id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17534v2 | Retrieval-style In-Context Learning for Few-shot Hierarchical Text Classification | 2024-06-25T13:19:41 | 2024-06-29T09:24:33 | Huiyao Chen, Yu Zhao, Zulong Chen, Mengjia Wang, Liangyue Li, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is an important task with broad
applications, while few-shot HTC has gained increasing interest recently. While
in-context learning (ICL) with large language models (LLMs) has achieved
significant success in few-shot learning, it is not as effective for HTC
because of the expansive hierarchical label sets and extremely-ambiguous
labels. In this work, we introduce the first ICL-based framework with LLM for
few-shot HTC. We exploit a retrieval database to identify relevant
demonstrations, and an iterative policy to manage multi-layer hierarchical
labels. Particularly, we equip the retrieval database with HTC label-aware
representations for the input texts, which is achieved by continual training on
a pretrained language model with masked language modeling (MLM), layer-wise
classification (CLS, specifically for HTC), and a novel divergent contrastive
learning (DCL, mainly for adjacent semantically-similar labels) objective.
Experimental results on three benchmark datasets demonstrate superior
performance of our method, and we can achieve state-of-the-art results in
few-shot HTC. | [
-0.10176407545804977,
-0.7027395367622375,
0.3446475863456726,
0.018375473096966743,
-0.24530267715454102,
0.33549487590789795,
-0.04147060588002205,
-0.4164979159832001,
-0.1877732276916504,
0.19440658390522003,
-0.4752039313316345,
-0.9088472127914429,
-0.4681905210018158,
0.07020767778158188,
-0.26577016711235046,
1.0394511222839355,
-0.007486242335289717,
-0.29064491391181946,
0.07538849860429764,
-0.2331629991531372,
-0.019472366198897362,
-0.5585542321205139,
-0.3831336498260498,
-0.6206298470497131,
0.5523210167884827,
0.7776365280151367,
0.2600441575050354,
0.603855550289154,
0.4660108983516693,
0.16514544188976288,
-0.2934105694293976,
0.11857452988624573,
-0.6724774241447449,
-0.11219105124473572,
0.06473061442375183,
-0.1305074542760849,
-0.05233019217848778,
-0.19683058559894562,
0.8101162314414978,
0.5190103650093079,
0.018932722508907318,
-0.013231483288109303,
0.40822964906692505,
0.3553587794303894,
-0.9622533321380615,
0.06209111213684082,
-0.8242038488388062,
0.2999515235424042,
-0.43614012002944946,
-0.47998836636543274,
-0.7350974678993225,
-0.0038974888157099485,
0.43987616896629333,
-0.5142768025398254,
-0.3126791715621948,
0.30865803360939026,
0.8420254588127136,
0.10857842117547989,
-0.5349319577217102,
-0.16315917670726776,
-0.48245126008987427,
0.9212972521781921,
-0.5850265026092529,
0.3639834225177765,
0.6048583388328552,
0.526726245880127,
0.0729861781001091,
-0.8272322416305542,
-0.3607754707336426,
-0.15614189207553864,
-0.2820322811603546,
0.13131704926490784,
-0.09315823763608932,
0.059956952929496765,
0.01511349342763424,
0.03831767663359642,
-0.4637531340122223,
0.5044491291046143,
0.09842626005411148,
-0.048643458634614944,
0.07497696578502655,
0.2104998081922531,
-0.06670498847961426,
-0.31142887473106384,
-0.7579644918441772,
0.06004584580659866,
-0.9288845658302307,
-0.09695053100585938,
-0.24314136803150177,
0.5152328014373779,
-0.28967273235321045,
0.29524755477905273,
-0.18089070916175842,
0.5808002948760986,
0.20284366607666016,
-0.5841789841651917,
0.19246906042099,
-0.23920154571533203,
-0.45285889506340027,
0.3173038363456726,
0.656207799911499,
-0.06360305845737457,
-0.3605327308177948,
-0.13172394037246704,
-0.2743411362171173,
-0.5545809268951416,
-0.061403144150972366,
-1.0797468423843384,
0.021986614912748337,
-0.1321994662284851,
-0.4337688982486725,
-0.2716900110244751,
-0.058181680738925934,
-0.5338438749313354,
-0.32872045040130615,
-0.04369187727570534,
0.7070525288581848,
-0.3080776035785675,
0.18295183777809143,
-0.10308180749416351,
0.18311558663845062,
0.3025299310684204,
0.2063552737236023,
-0.8569491505622864,
0.33040928840637207,
0.4379218816757202,
0.9378288984298706,
-0.4400155246257782,
-0.3128840923309326,
-0.6321132779121399,
0.37861937284469604,
-0.25069934129714966,
0.6369378566741943,
-0.5748355388641357,
-0.2638404667377472,
0.22108197212219238,
-0.28078049421310425,
0.08888332545757294,
-0.6541541814804077,
0.22396960854530334,
-0.7116998434066772,
0.15812794864177704,
0.05475231260061264,
-0.5072554349899292,
0.08428797125816345,
0.8146674036979675,
-0.23014411330223083,
1.093214511871338,
-0.005868448875844479,
-1.0747861862182617,
0.5194790959358215,
-0.305488258600235,
-0.3449285626411438,
0.3149770200252533,
-0.4149756133556366,
-0.726349413394928,
-0.4860492944717407,
0.0307709239423275,
0.5739697813987732,
-0.07722683250904083,
-0.0307416133582592,
-0.18144665658473969,
-0.7987499237060547,
-0.20781904458999634,
-0.4085196852684021,
0.6731558442115784,
0.04324911907315254,
-0.3753657937049866,
-0.03441276028752327,
-0.6980094909667969,
-0.04396849125623703,
-0.2855481803417206,
-0.6246110200881958,
-0.47935235500335693,
-0.2798672020435333,
0.2487362027168274,
0.40455153584480286,
0.12564361095428467,
-0.5201526880264282,
0.26587560772895813,
-0.414572536945343,
0.07317602634429932,
0.4264914393424988,
0.19856412708759308,
0.6498845815658569,
-0.28244560956954956,
0.32113879919052124,
0.36284130811691284,
-0.003024145495146513,
-0.3599740266799927,
-0.11928915977478027,
-0.48909589648246765,
-0.5134795904159546,
0.1410132199525833,
0.6024389266967773,
-1.0869508981704712,
0.31280088424682617,
-0.055800508707761765,
-0.33073291182518005,
-0.1692526489496231,
0.25464633107185364,
0.5484548211097717,
0.7735987901687622,
0.5705543756484985,
0.027758531272411346,
-0.42674797773361206,
-0.8899977803230286,
0.010554266162216663,
-0.26711732149124146,
0.11279702186584473,
0.6175693273544312,
0.7126824259757996,
-0.4784320294857025,
0.9227496385574341,
-0.3224315941333771,
-0.6776189208030701,
-0.32484135031700134,
0.4275742471218109,
0.04683418944478035,
0.43020063638687134,
0.4216318130493164,
-0.610171914100647,
-0.7172949314117432,
0.212050661444664,
-0.7602460980415344,
0.046968232840299606,
-0.0708293467760086,
-0.2425813376903534,
0.28111013770103455,
0.6356250047683716,
-0.16784904897212982,
0.411091148853302,
0.1703805923461914,
0.24607114493846893,
0.41097787022590637,
-0.022801928222179413,
-0.004637569189071655,
-1.018564224243164,
-0.17095471918582916,
0.21463704109191895,
-0.312034547328949,
-0.5174727439880371,
-0.0038325306959450245,
0.2934652864933014,
0.2849062383174896,
-0.8895584940910339,
0.8158153295516968,
-0.2397514432668686,
0.006617987062782049,
-0.3824373483657837,
0.21452532708644867,
-0.03595123812556267,
0.5405411720275879,
0.21449606120586395,
0.4581214189529419,
0.7371906638145447,
-0.683087170124054,
-0.19649985432624817,
0.17295055091381073,
-0.5230038166046143,
0.5845104455947876,
-0.16134867072105408,
0.17686383426189423,
-0.3429049551486969,
0.44566547870635986,
-0.8401517271995544,
-0.2108839899301529,
0.22003096342086792,
-0.012391417287290096,
0.4895175099372864,
-0.36067619919776917,
-0.7285687327384949,
-0.11162994056940079,
-0.29382002353668213,
0.578924298286438,
0.4246194660663605,
-1.037404179573059,
0.30650803446769714,
0.03718896210193634,
0.15955249965190887,
-0.8503894209861755,
-0.8537977337837219,
0.038867633789777756,
-0.3599620461463928,
-0.07510798424482346,
0.8161368370056152,
-0.05957532301545143,
-0.05651051178574562,
-0.30467358231544495,
-0.24449847638607025,
-0.521552562713623,
-0.04579794406890869,
0.027138125151395798,
0.10312218219041824,
-0.20478379726409912,
0.3093615174293518,
0.2247491180896759,
0.06311190873384476,
-0.5213342308998108,
-0.34683576226234436,
0.2268446534872055,
-0.22227221727371216,
-0.10592338442802429,
-0.6862960457801819,
0.21597693860530853,
0.1361619532108307,
0.15587882697582245,
0.5374445915222168,
0.5289314985275269,
-0.5275870561599731,
-0.33447614312171936,
-0.2046971470117569,
-0.18709033727645874,
-0.46708786487579346,
0.3439399003982544,
-0.5461000800132751,
-1.0915740728378296,
0.1563410758972168,
-0.13402390480041504,
-0.02250540256500244,
0.09091171622276306,
0.5092185735702515,
-0.402151495218277,
0.8447052240371704,
0.8349617719650269,
-0.21628883481025696,
0.7688353657722473,
-0.33305689692497253,
-0.257205605506897,
-0.6070072650909424,
-0.3348890542984009,
-0.44547247886657715,
-0.23812688887119293,
-0.6209063529968262,
-0.06867190450429916,
0.5646296143531799,
0.24027450382709503,
-0.6365047693252563,
0.22473639249801636,
-0.15737541019916534,
0.7965801358222961,
0.33334192633628845,
0.41883930563926697,
0.5679218769073486,
0.13232024013996124,
-0.3058684766292572,
-0.0594034381210804,
-0.8114978671073914,
-0.40521377325057983,
0.5746326446533203,
0.398184597492218,
1.0391274690628052,
0.13737249374389648,
1.1795859336853027,
-0.06416438519954681,
0.5226808786392212,
-0.9749955534934998,
0.26934534311294556,
-0.20096564292907715,
-0.4913425147533417,
-0.114298515021801,
-0.41461312770843506,
-0.6952683925628662,
0.4309176206588745,
-0.16547083854675293,
-0.8280525803565979,
0.32066747546195984,
0.07870535552501678,
-0.41437920928001404,
0.2591363489627838,
-0.3975936472415924,
0.6444758176803589,
-0.14758649468421936,
-0.617101788520813,
0.0927133858203888,
-0.9494335651397705,
0.37072643637657166,
-0.08786383271217346,
-0.03558184579014778,
0.21644887328147888,
-0.2397371530532837,
0.4613218307495117,
-0.18384073674678802,
1.0438116788864136,
0.015032922849059105,
0.04224903881549835,
0.3124721944332123,
0.1897263526916504,
0.45943328738212585,
-0.13151134550571442,
-0.1700771152973175,
-0.1602010279893875,
-0.023897791281342506,
-0.3723592758178711,
-0.5061303377151489,
0.6137968301773071,
-0.5150270462036133,
-0.27286842465400696,
-0.4027725160121918,
-0.2554120719432831,
-0.2365800440311432,
0.3802279233932495,
0.5544113516807556,
0.559890627861023,
-0.1639963984489441,
0.47107449173927307,
0.6513490080833435,
-0.1596076339483261,
0.6197635531425476,
0.4873967170715332,
-0.21379593014717102,
-0.0917973741889,
0.7758534550666809,
-0.019161056727170944,
0.15996494889259338,
0.9226223230361938,
0.3672564625740051,
-0.24995367228984833,
-0.4815184473991394,
-0.44895318150520325,
-0.17021748423576355,
-0.9294924736022949,
-0.5106487274169922,
-0.5828407406806946,
-0.33216947317123413,
0.0367603674530983,
-0.2095046192407608,
-0.14635637402534485,
-0.03286493569612503,
-0.5624433159828186,
0.008979939855635166,
0.009021962992846966,
0.6467347145080566,
0.3304079473018646,
0.6680400371551514,
-0.5931425094604492,
0.3346233665943146,
0.25577637553215027,
0.4352799355983734,
0.0007651978521607816,
-0.7795796990394592,
-0.38415130972862244,
-0.32903945446014404,
-0.4352351427078247,
-0.6955311894416809,
0.3165438771247864,
0.46748441457748413,
0.4165503978729248,
0.3740016222000122,
0.030589722096920013,
0.7346851825714111,
-0.5653297305107117,
0.48631832003593445,
0.10020474344491959,
-0.7162110805511475,
0.48141637444496155,
-0.18650972843170166,
0.6112770438194275,
0.8746375441551208,
0.7257503867149353,
-0.3722206652164459,
-0.17873622477054596,
-0.2421071082353592,
-0.6848428249359131,
0.8022013306617737,
0.09622630476951599,
0.06327361613512039,
-0.07823895663022995,
0.3775770366191864,
0.20800362527370453,
0.15253953635692596,
-0.8765974044799805,
-0.34318241477012634,
-0.13280369341373444,
-0.3181551694869995,
0.42146944999694824,
-0.06973627209663391,
0.1262751966714859,
-0.255608469247818,
0.5144314169883728,
-0.47375380992889404,
-0.1462145745754242,
0.12148753553628922,
-0.4821702837944031,
0.11024754494428635,
0.5720032453536987,
0.2675854563713074,
0.5015991926193237,
-0.3903249204158783,
0.37754684686660767,
0.18225885927677155,
-0.18399477005004883,
0.2919151782989502,
-0.054573625326156616,
-0.34300991892814636,
-0.15813258290290833,
0.34303146600723267,
0.664374589920044,
0.6520267724990845,
-0.5912616848945618,
0.6247465014457703,
0.2559739649295807,
-0.0904407724738121,
0.0899830088019371,
-0.29767999053001404,
-0.35377776622772217,
0.22955556213855743,
0.5745530128479004,
-0.2315637320280075,
0.4375349283218384,
-0.6526781916618347,
0.47567689418792725,
0.30664053559303284,
-0.6429793238639832,
0.06630314886569977,
0.2525515556335449,
-0.06895653158426285,
-0.05499045550823212,
0.5422942638397217,
-0.4226061701774597,
-0.45561838150024414,
0.3581484854221344,
0.8555746078491211,
0.7692716717720032,
0.12865762412548065,
0.32800307869911194,
0.3929368555545807,
0.13976246118545532,
-0.11728033423423767,
-0.12430386990308762,
-0.47720471024513245,
-0.630988359451294,
-0.15833254158496857,
-0.39237889647483826,
-0.6032951474189758,
0.018915070220828056,
-0.4239775240421295,
0.38005104660987854,
-0.5853210091590881,
-0.00744739780202508,
-0.2113151252269745,
0.09213569760322571,
-0.5120582580566406,
0.08391579985618591,
0.2526945471763611,
0.9348853826522827,
-0.5139899253845215,
1.1071306467056274,
0.5629835724830627,
-0.4043990671634674,
-0.37552809715270996,
0.3361288011074066,
0.3280879259109497,
-0.4353427290916443,
1.142836332321167,
0.3527221083641052,
-0.4692094027996063,
0.23974597454071045,
-0.8237143754959106,
-0.6168394088745117,
1.1934077739715576,
0.06339923292398453,
-0.6518243551254272,
-0.07085990160703659,
-0.09152378141880035,
0.6304485201835632,
-0.6645549535751343,
0.30733031034469604,
0.5900179743766785,
0.2119741290807724,
0.43405547738075256,
-0.7568405866622925,
-0.33279502391815186,
0.14120155572891235,
0.09122630953788757,
-0.19830237329006195,
-0.578682005405426,
0.4437343180179596,
-0.192683607339859,
-0.37905585765838623,
0.17656733095645905,
0.6156659126281738,
0.6173962950706482,
0.6348209977149963,
0.28760388493537903,
0.19523528218269348,
0.6409828066825867,
0.12482623010873795,
1.131528615951538,
0.07707066833972931,
0.48008352518081665,
1.3851404190063477,
-0.38391900062561035,
1.1182291507720947,
0.3549114167690277,
0.17210209369659424,
0.6857059597969055,
0.8176725506782532,
0.39429396390914917,
0.7407699823379517,
0.14146111905574799,
-0.4067796468734741,
-0.25882813334465027,
-0.37091875076293945,
0.02730480581521988,
0.4303153157234192,
0.31234386563301086,
-0.17251361906528473,
-0.5425412058830261,
0.185339093208313,
-0.0583866722881794,
-0.05124574154615402,
-0.3541652262210846,
1.0067596435546875,
0.3219205439090729,
-0.011338596232235432,
0.6819754838943481,
0.09641832113265991,
1.1421679258346558,
-0.3695298433303833,
-0.05477983504533768,
-0.2729479968547821,
0.1256157010793686,
-0.29207974672317505,
-0.7157453894615173,
-0.12658432126045227,
-0.03645721822977066,
-0.1678275167942047,
-0.2372073084115982,
0.6616027355194092,
-0.7398979067802429,
-0.17709487676620483,
0.23480628430843353,
0.3751073479652405,
0.03379492461681366,
0.13018354773521423,
-0.7385812401771545,
-0.07748942822217941,
-0.4704493582248688,
-0.09671030938625336,
0.5055612325668335,
0.36185216903686523,
-0.21882615983486176,
0.6777577996253967,
-0.07977230101823807,
-0.36192914843559265,
0.0653710663318634,
0.3172266185283661,
0.6604222655296326,
-0.6456860899925232,
-0.49084195494651794,
-0.889115571975708,
0.2195180058479309,
0.12020225822925568,
-0.29960939288139343,
0.5866923332214355,
0.6683656573295593,
0.9270569086074829,
0.15616042912006378,
0.5761666893959045,
0.2564955949783325,
0.17621555924415588,
-0.6077529191970825,
0.5544103980064392,
-0.7372541427612305,
0.33556637167930603,
-0.3339661955833435,
-0.763558030128479,
-0.6774842143058777,
0.46943655610084534,
-0.036711517721414566,
0.22403933107852936,
0.8328432440757751,
0.7235106229782104,
-0.23875996470451355,
-0.26846298575401306,
0.4685363471508026,
0.29596057534217834,
0.229238823056221,
0.6685303449630737,
0.931972086429596,
-0.6223644018173218,
0.7078136205673218,
-0.4740602970123291,
-0.18515853583812714,
-0.42912450432777405,
-0.9316903352737427,
-0.9159234166145325,
-0.45345595479011536,
-0.42522138357162476,
-0.11746009439229965,
0.12714457511901855,
1.2099741697311401,
0.9805042147636414,
-0.5945830345153809,
-0.2552691102027893,
0.2448507696390152,
0.3242354989051819,
-0.07874934375286102,
-0.2018139362335205,
0.4538407325744629,
-0.398740291595459,
-0.6924217939376831,
0.46241527795791626,
0.5524570345878601,
0.22391678392887115,
-0.051622532308101654,
-0.12373214960098267,
-0.37514832615852356,
-0.353760689496994,
1.0720546245574951,
0.33747515082359314,
-0.5824044942855835,
-0.26223841309547424,
-0.1301155537366867,
-0.6546518206596375,
0.3831474483013153,
0.7410411238670349,
-0.9821394681930542,
0.34598803520202637,
0.5238564014434814,
0.9032993912696838,
0.8159562945365906,
-0.01278787013143301,
-0.14626926183700562,
-1.3564356565475464,
0.21358579397201538,
0.41117966175079346,
0.12241681665182114,
0.28496062755584717,
-0.20306245982646942,
0.1099134311079979,
-0.04826739430427551,
-0.2534014880657196,
-0.6361061334609985,
0.21758855879306793,
-0.8615849018096924,
-0.23767299950122833,
1.1207363605499268,
-0.01697937771677971,
-0.09590601176023483,
-0.18305781483650208,
-0.24669493734836578,
-0.10654867440462112,
-0.4278024137020111,
0.5986155867576599,
0.4673776626586914,
-0.24035920202732086,
-0.532615602016449,
-0.2210479974746704,
0.5272886157035828,
0.11408881843090057,
-0.9098926186561584,
-0.18081854283809662,
0.42061156034469604,
0.0790235623717308,
-0.08557551354169846,
0.7562655210494995,
-0.18447676301002502,
0.15029701590538025,
-0.26493197679519653,
-0.30093175172805786,
0.15989528596401215,
-0.819707989692688,
-0.4136286973953247,
0.2130933552980423,
0.09320531040430069,
0.012744027189910412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17532v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand DL-Lite Ontologies? An Empirical Study | 2024-06-25T13:16:34 | 2024-06-25T13:16:34 | Keyu Wang, Guilin Qi, Jiaqi Li, Songlin Zhai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LO | Large language models (LLMs) have shown significant achievements in solving a
wide range of tasks. Recently, LLMs' capability to store, retrieve and infer
with symbolic knowledge has drawn a great deal of attention, showing their
potential to understand structured information. However, it is not yet known
whether LLMs can understand Description Logic (DL) ontologies. In this work, we
empirically analyze the LLMs' capability of understanding DL-Lite ontologies
covering 6 representative tasks from syntactic and semantic aspects. With
extensive experiments, we demonstrate both the effectiveness and limitations of
LLMs in understanding DL-Lite ontologies. We find that LLMs can understand
formal syntax and model-theoretic semantics of concepts and roles. However,
LLMs struggle with understanding TBox NI transitivity and handling ontologies
with large ABoxes. We hope that our experiments and analyses provide more
insights into LLMs and inspire to build more faithful knowledge engineering
solutions. | [
-0.062141481786966324,
-0.5917667746543884,
1.3321583271026611,
-0.05857505649328232,
-0.010635681450366974,
0.06552326679229736,
-0.31561487913131714,
-0.7326476573944092,
-0.10939957201480865,
0.914659857749939,
-0.7496602535247803,
-0.5011628270149231,
-0.7076802849769592,
0.364554226398468,
-0.5615764260292053,
0.5911509990692139,
0.002056568395346403,
0.004740460775792599,
0.006784359458833933,
0.004856012295931578,
-0.3701624572277069,
-0.3836327791213989,
-0.39524996280670166,
-0.39548197388648987,
0.5578942894935608,
-0.009228941984474659,
0.6555225253105164,
0.5818917751312256,
0.39431512355804443,
0.3000509738922119,
-0.3901168406009674,
0.057797871530056,
-0.4628189504146576,
0.0092034712433815,
-0.3935829997062683,
-0.8531662821769714,
-0.40519845485687256,
-0.13098111748695374,
0.7133691906929016,
0.9830829501152039,
-0.044951289892196655,
0.04248642176389694,
-0.06367690861225128,
0.35250645875930786,
-0.48983410000801086,
0.47391805052757263,
-0.9734743237495422,
0.09361778944730759,
0.07477430254220963,
-0.11006992310285568,
-0.6266605257987976,
0.11287768930196762,
0.3441670536994934,
-0.7840757966041565,
-0.22217567265033722,
0.33362695574760437,
0.6933803558349609,
0.14573858678340912,
-0.6423627734184265,
-0.3945799469947815,
-0.7288792133331299,
0.9901373982429504,
-0.8877018690109253,
0.5424481630325317,
0.07279179245233536,
0.32174327969551086,
-0.2384931445121765,
-0.6744102239608765,
-0.7543355226516724,
-0.1334705948829651,
-0.32700806856155396,
-0.017856674268841743,
0.05159316584467888,
0.2377263456583023,
0.5362403988838196,
0.2439664900302887,
-0.39920178055763245,
0.4392071068286896,
-0.13569597899913788,
-0.17387154698371887,
0.5411686897277832,
0.36167484521865845,
0.36139222979545593,
-0.42378732562065125,
-0.6980210542678833,
0.19128797948360443,
-0.7298866510391235,
-0.14141666889190674,
-0.10716332495212555,
0.21748299896717072,
-0.0309725534170866,
0.7443288564682007,
-0.024151809513568878,
0.7117472290992737,
-0.6098449230194092,
-0.2552720606327057,
-0.04586518183350563,
-0.5080813765525818,
-0.37594467401504517,
-0.14620144665241241,
0.6244964003562927,
-0.0014609541976824403,
0.37575414776802063,
-0.698381245136261,
-0.47964906692504883,
-0.1643734574317932,
0.012105773203074932,
-0.5551749467849731,
0.3243773877620697,
0.3134118616580963,
-0.512515664100647,
0.04666534811258316,
-0.05326014757156372,
-0.2616344094276428,
-0.6350259780883789,
-0.36273521184921265,
0.729072630405426,
-0.38694456219673157,
-0.26768532395362854,
0.4200695753097534,
-0.29327818751335144,
0.4657242000102997,
0.446219265460968,
-0.7273663878440857,
0.32649821043014526,
0.8338576555252075,
0.6309051513671875,
-0.08164584636688232,
-0.17647355794906616,
-0.19114463031291962,
0.31596794724464417,
-0.08789628744125366,
0.5846008658409119,
-0.4930081069469452,
-0.045945413410663605,
0.05034972354769707,
-0.022171230986714363,
-0.3118336796760559,
-0.6052218079566956,
0.381709486246109,
-0.8360106348991394,
-0.1733250916004181,
-0.35559630393981934,
-0.9646051526069641,
-0.3067679703235626,
0.3967387080192566,
-0.7181888818740845,
0.3245982527732849,
0.071111299097538,
-0.6551336050033569,
0.2176319658756256,
-0.5245581269264221,
-0.05476253107190132,
-0.024401886388659477,
-0.38667768239974976,
0.17383959889411926,
0.4928363263607025,
-0.25824174284935,
0.6026570200920105,
-0.6460385918617249,
0.11873836070299149,
-0.2682015001773834,
-0.23749108612537384,
0.7372989654541016,
-0.16559578478336334,
0.9532883763313293,
0.035051167011260986,
-0.11037904024124146,
-0.008565817959606647,
-0.7711519598960876,
0.008192440494894981,
0.23291441798210144,
-0.06611473858356476,
-0.3420703113079071,
0.08847393095493317,
-0.016002532094717026,
0.45653635263442993,
0.23621681332588196,
-0.6320030689239502,
0.35856136679649353,
-0.5232354402542114,
0.654224693775177,
0.7636935710906982,
-0.39488136768341064,
0.3430984616279602,
0.009505738504230976,
0.5511197447776794,
-0.12532542645931244,
-0.09566710889339447,
-0.05625031143426895,
-0.20563103258609772,
-0.5814262628555298,
-0.08683239668607712,
0.38584813475608826,
0.5243969559669495,
-0.9020878076553345,
0.48783794045448303,
-0.3901570737361908,
-0.03366720676422119,
-0.1926800161600113,
0.26986825466156006,
0.3261166214942932,
0.25381648540496826,
0.2335786372423172,
0.06472446024417877,
-0.283743292093277,
-0.8669254183769226,
-0.0912935808300972,
-0.14277946949005127,
-0.050069328397512436,
0.3716590106487274,
0.7311391234397888,
-0.32723772525787354,
0.964503288269043,
-0.4824300706386566,
-0.38706839084625244,
-0.6084584593772888,
-0.13150306046009064,
0.2389087975025177,
-0.19779036939144135,
0.4873620569705963,
-0.7781995534896851,
-0.08101801574230194,
0.05515868216753006,
-0.9854341745376587,
-0.3609183430671692,
-0.04591164365410805,
0.1377120465040207,
0.1305321305990219,
0.49180179834365845,
-0.7383224964141846,
0.3191105127334595,
0.583108127117157,
-0.5343590974807739,
0.47327762842178345,
-0.20762912929058075,
-0.21049009263515472,
-0.8250740170478821,
-0.053259462118148804,
-0.21490326523780823,
-0.2808360755443573,
-0.6686681509017944,
0.14306336641311646,
0.045171335339546204,
0.3097299635410309,
-0.4154372811317444,
0.794403076171875,
-0.43109601736068726,
-0.6194474101066589,
-0.3289058804512024,
0.6153350472450256,
0.19411471486091614,
0.14666545391082764,
0.26085931062698364,
0.3890379071235657,
0.5237762928009033,
-0.46281853318214417,
0.36187639832496643,
0.18241965770721436,
-0.6539314389228821,
0.017215583473443985,
-0.6131652593612671,
-0.27256882190704346,
-0.013707793317735195,
0.2741462290287018,
-0.9576230645179749,
-0.1320655792951584,
-0.14258356392383575,
-0.0001284982863580808,
0.05774829909205437,
-0.07870660722255707,
-1.063797116279602,
-0.05177726224064827,
-0.03904968127608299,
0.22893385589122772,
0.4650161564350128,
-0.4799843728542328,
0.9271615743637085,
0.1957191377878189,
0.11768040806055069,
-0.34622037410736084,
-0.6741939783096313,
0.0383063443005085,
-0.24065595865249634,
-0.7407033443450928,
0.22454862296581268,
0.11857402324676514,
-0.6946336030960083,
0.07234260439872742,
-0.13308806717395782,
-0.1011105552315712,
0.25805342197418213,
0.0011416217312216759,
0.22631923854351044,
-0.15794309973716736,
0.45387810468673706,
-0.25080233812332153,
-0.021976012736558914,
0.40538129210472107,
-0.26140064001083374,
0.6971092820167542,
0.11740366369485855,
-0.1704292893409729,
-0.2553914785385132,
0.004192772787064314,
0.5352191925048828,
-0.16486333310604095,
1.1751351356506348,
0.3573005199432373,
-0.29502594470977783,
-0.5482480525970459,
-0.441135048866272,
-0.36001789569854736,
-0.44760194420814514,
0.44567346572875977,
-0.35960525274276733,
-0.9291930198669434,
0.7526973485946655,
-0.14253360033035278,
0.1375081092119217,
0.6162551045417786,
0.2607867419719696,
-0.15504398941993713,
0.8195827603340149,
0.6778902411460876,
0.2512909173965454,
0.1203768327832222,
-0.3443529009819031,
0.16971752047538757,
-0.8196506500244141,
-0.21650533378124237,
-0.42105284333229065,
-0.14515374600887299,
-0.48475781083106995,
-0.14433304965496063,
0.38728249073028564,
0.08347725868225098,
-0.06145347282290459,
0.03453102707862854,
0.1411440670490265,
0.32519254088401794,
-0.2088363766670227,
-0.01117781363427639,
0.700860857963562,
-0.006104873958975077,
0.07996219396591187,
0.08502423018217087,
-0.6646564602851868,
-0.6426499485969543,
0.8566733002662659,
0.484120637178421,
0.9786151051521301,
0.29520416259765625,
0.4569367468357086,
-0.012690197676420212,
-0.042062122374773026,
-0.7988375425338745,
0.8082031607627869,
-0.4458736777305603,
-0.6916459798812866,
-0.1969185471534729,
-0.6472614407539368,
-0.8198094367980957,
0.23042795062065125,
-0.3704696297645569,
-0.8560184240341187,
-0.10552974790334702,
-0.012571781873703003,
-0.16304881870746613,
0.41283124685287476,
-0.5984982848167419,
0.877672016620636,
-0.39428067207336426,
-0.10244375467300415,
-0.3103469908237457,
-0.7517784833908081,
0.454406201839447,
-0.29547932744026184,
0.5800579786300659,
-0.2632655203342438,
-0.2751029431819916,
0.7241087555885315,
-0.4516417384147644,
0.8593509197235107,
0.031440649181604385,
-0.6989482045173645,
0.07947119325399399,
0.021951984614133835,
0.357930451631546,
-0.049491818994283676,
-0.3159632682800293,
0.060700833797454834,
0.13241690397262573,
-0.29979923367500305,
-1.0084532499313354,
0.5620004534721375,
-0.7129461169242859,
-0.6707712411880493,
-0.3076275587081909,
-0.7040340900421143,
-0.238236665725708,
0.12084795534610748,
0.033160414546728134,
0.4445223808288574,
0.2078593671321869,
0.11050731688737869,
0.8457174897193909,
-0.38030925393104553,
0.3484903872013092,
0.7577943205833435,
-0.6182600855827332,
0.3770178258419037,
0.5323418974876404,
0.32560786604881287,
0.8084895610809326,
0.5919663310050964,
0.3844147026538849,
-0.43433380126953125,
-0.6062549948692322,
-0.20484362542629242,
0.36107137799263,
-0.9481594562530518,
0.07792296260595322,
-0.7435010671615601,
-0.40024858713150024,
-0.15263797342777252,
-0.002229571808129549,
-0.16708363592624664,
-0.5767872333526611,
-0.03566742688417435,
0.027964932844042778,
0.5174052715301514,
1.1000839471817017,
0.45739105343818665,
0.4730682075023651,
-0.8941833972930908,
0.264291912317276,
0.10489293187856674,
0.29428771138191223,
0.07632189244031906,
-0.8475375175476074,
-0.11778213083744049,
-0.009846717119216919,
0.1836933046579361,
-0.7951910495758057,
0.11472342163324356,
-0.03728124499320984,
0.49162161350250244,
0.36594218015670776,
0.06574292480945587,
0.34522926807403564,
-0.346676766872406,
0.6916496157646179,
-0.17321394383907318,
-1.0185213088989258,
0.40040555596351624,
-0.20992708206176758,
0.09213080257177353,
0.09114189445972443,
0.27565914392471313,
-0.10981151461601257,
-0.36608126759529114,
-0.44281819462776184,
-0.6209568381309509,
0.8232471346855164,
0.22008536756038666,
0.08937754482030869,
0.24726536870002747,
0.7853510975837708,
0.18681590259075165,
0.17701447010040283,
-1.036687970161438,
-0.18868227303028107,
0.3806963264942169,
-0.1488199234008789,
0.0007588253356516361,
-0.3321070671081543,
0.012497211806476116,
0.27093878388404846,
0.411030113697052,
0.15220122039318085,
0.03822823986411095,
-0.12432576715946198,
-0.2555766701698303,
0.26235559582710266,
0.6888211369514465,
0.28342655301094055,
0.8177134394645691,
-0.2308853715658188,
0.44464075565338135,
0.22922736406326294,
-0.19289039075374603,
-0.023813843727111816,
-0.05396560579538345,
-0.05834704264998436,
-0.2973996698856354,
0.8812357783317566,
0.6667996644973755,
0.0657503604888916,
-1.0569534301757812,
0.3752788305282593,
-0.004895538091659546,
-0.10420583188533783,
-0.4060436189174652,
0.3159639537334442,
0.11052192002534866,
0.32064008712768555,
0.219324991106987,
-0.4631330370903015,
0.10519569367170334,
-0.9165033102035522,
-0.16688112914562225,
0.6111876964569092,
-0.05309288576245308,
-0.37137481570243835,
0.3978225588798523,
-0.0627930536866188,
0.102757528424263,
0.44554728269577026,
-0.2370726764202118,
-0.6072589755058289,
0.7240661978721619,
0.7048718929290771,
0.5194858908653259,
0.1838260143995285,
-0.07420435547828674,
-0.20797324180603027,
0.36743345856666565,
-0.08856237679719925,
0.401309996843338,
0.31277331709861755,
-1.1144145727157593,
-0.7184779644012451,
-0.7485396265983582,
-0.3576115667819977,
0.09529725462198257,
-0.3625468313694,
0.04662364721298218,
-0.3449137806892395,
0.04750635474920273,
0.21686944365501404,
0.052958957850933075,
-0.6970916986465454,
0.1529702991247177,
0.026591205969452858,
0.8956252336502075,
-0.9495912790298462,
0.8555969595909119,
0.724605917930603,
-0.4310652017593384,
-1.0220718383789062,
-0.008419795893132687,
-0.03994821384549141,
-0.9281215071678162,
1.3583502769470215,
0.13193798065185547,
-0.2107156366109848,
0.03253479301929474,
-0.41318371891975403,
-0.6922460794448853,
1.2273157835006714,
0.41945111751556396,
-0.5459668040275574,
-0.15438106656074524,
0.37536588311195374,
0.5999364852905273,
-0.4037425220012665,
0.37569552659988403,
0.5455957055091858,
0.6936488747596741,
0.012745597399771214,
-1.0307196378707886,
0.08411028981208801,
0.1857755184173584,
-0.02132849209010601,
0.07914097607135773,
-0.591517984867096,
0.79853755235672,
-0.1599394679069519,
-0.1930435299873352,
0.11039383709430695,
0.4292774796485901,
0.10251912474632263,
0.09295210242271423,
0.7215549349784851,
0.37975138425827026,
0.41030392050743103,
-0.06720942258834839,
1.2913841009140015,
-0.18423473834991455,
0.2649426758289337,
0.8014139533042908,
-0.7594281435012817,
0.8073927164077759,
0.3088502883911133,
-0.21423090994358063,
0.4993530213832855,
0.21404273808002472,
0.19265586137771606,
0.1695573329925537,
0.1820676475763321,
-0.2737090587615967,
-0.5172783136367798,
-0.40432342886924744,
-0.0032044718973338604,
0.6943180561065674,
0.6087838411331177,
-0.47133538126945496,
-0.1096382886171341,
0.08711142092943192,
-0.1749388873577118,
0.041453804820775986,
-0.5124064683914185,
0.7853642106056213,
0.32890740036964417,
-0.2568792402744293,
0.274282306432724,
-0.008127589710056782,
0.3259827196598053,
-0.6717653870582581,
0.04677276313304901,
0.2096329778432846,
0.2868431806564331,
-0.3864470422267914,
-1.0842809677124023,
0.378493070602417,
-0.17697471380233765,
-0.15168939530849457,
-0.2505969703197479,
0.7537359595298767,
-0.28599628806114197,
-0.4842718541622162,
0.7356496453285217,
0.7109097242355347,
0.06571640074253082,
0.09719649702310562,
-0.2698987126350403,
0.3213624060153961,
-0.14719842374324799,
-0.21834751963615417,
0.3837732672691345,
0.8217020630836487,
0.0313011072576046,
0.7915337085723877,
0.10899967700242996,
0.19876457750797272,
0.06257814913988113,
0.03718002513051033,
0.6482635736465454,
-0.7880414724349976,
-0.14095404744148254,
-0.9247933626174927,
0.1634199470281601,
0.09435175359249115,
0.14113907516002655,
0.796019434928894,
0.38849472999572754,
0.7635295391082764,
-0.12768739461898804,
0.8057330250740051,
-0.039838433265686035,
0.3975867033004761,
-1.0834710597991943,
0.4669933617115021,
-0.8242603540420532,
0.7236385345458984,
-0.009497927501797676,
-0.9157876968383789,
-0.3049074113368988,
0.5085766315460205,
-0.44514819979667664,
0.1091928780078888,
0.6789485812187195,
0.585946261882782,
-0.05423701927065849,
0.028958164155483246,
0.4703828692436218,
0.6565253734588623,
0.2826918065547943,
0.5925790071487427,
1.1039601564407349,
-0.11818423122167587,
0.5433515906333923,
0.13779650628566742,
-0.09047283232212067,
0.06396181136369705,
-0.7828498482704163,
-1.1039680242538452,
-0.26702868938446045,
-0.07332687824964523,
-0.20002779364585876,
-0.06477773189544678,
0.9317192435264587,
0.2951633632183075,
-0.5270481109619141,
-0.3238135278224945,
0.018083177506923676,
0.32151278853416443,
0.17211408913135529,
-0.20337043702602386,
0.3895549774169922,
-0.4202782213687897,
-0.4515312612056732,
0.22332815825939178,
0.42192378640174866,
-0.11621524393558502,
-0.4056810736656189,
-0.0028921645134687424,
-0.06228167563676834,
0.13528001308441162,
0.8585247993469238,
-0.0771915391087532,
-1.1544444561004639,
-0.4073599576950073,
0.12900105118751526,
-0.08532430976629257,
-0.27916577458381653,
0.8366575837135315,
-0.7234508395195007,
0.1588328778743744,
0.5917096138000488,
0.6600816249847412,
0.17190447449684143,
-0.3401210606098175,
0.4468483328819275,
-0.5167593955993652,
-0.10336790978908539,
-0.17711274325847626,
0.7722084522247314,
-0.08593685179948807,
-0.10066007822751999,
0.5775806307792664,
0.09493191540241241,
-0.5378104448318481,
-0.5591382384300232,
0.41259461641311646,
-1.1740691661834717,
-0.4613197147846222,
1.4622516632080078,
-0.2643977105617523,
-0.13197609782218933,
-0.2291647344827652,
-0.0636487677693367,
-0.030041225254535675,
0.10246162861585617,
0.4854156970977783,
0.6715283393859863,
-0.19928696751594543,
-0.36773568391799927,
-0.9260451197624207,
0.11813515424728394,
0.39090555906295776,
-0.902414858341217,
0.3288596272468567,
0.39535537362098694,
0.31889185309410095,
0.15346983075141907,
0.46612441539764404,
0.0459258109331131,
-0.03550161048769951,
-0.39656445384025574,
-0.19260816276073456,
0.11306776851415634,
-0.15312518179416656,
-0.21915386617183685,
0.09783974289894104,
0.3819800615310669,
0.4647766351699829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17526v1 | LumberChunker: Long-Form Narrative Document Segmentation | 2024-06-25T13:08:35 | 2024-06-25T13:08:35 | André V. Duarte, João Marques, Miguel Graça, Miguel Freire, Lei Li, Arlindo L. Oliveira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2 | Modern NLP tasks increasingly rely on dense retrieval methods to access
up-to-date and relevant contextual information. We are motivated by the premise
that retrieval benefits from segments that can vary in size such that a
content's semantic independence is better captured. We propose LumberChunker, a
method leveraging an LLM to dynamically segment documents, which iteratively
prompts the LLM to identify the point within a group of sequential passages
where the content begins to shift. To evaluate our method, we introduce
GutenQA, a benchmark with 3000 "needle in a haystack" type of question-answer
pairs derived from 100 public domain narrative books available on Project
Gutenberg. Our experiments show that LumberChunker not only outperforms the
most competitive baseline by 7.37% in retrieval performance (DCG@20) but also
that, when integrated into a RAG pipeline, LumberChunker proves to be more
effective than other chunking methods and competitive baselines, such as the
Gemini 1.5M Pro. Our Code and Data are available at
https://github.com/joaodsmarques/LumberChunker | [
0.09808225184679031,
-0.8896210193634033,
0.6774218678474426,
0.4624839425086975,
-0.6381547451019287,
0.6339852809906006,
0.16044558584690094,
-0.6818853616714478,
0.4094943106174469,
0.4584082365036011,
-0.4707193970680237,
-0.4669759273529053,
-0.6088883280754089,
-0.035038623958826065,
-0.7970273494720459,
0.7380573749542236,
-0.1488366574048996,
-0.3009755611419678,
-0.1817328929901123,
-0.10640911757946014,
-0.5869846940040588,
-0.22016586363315582,
-0.47580334544181824,
-0.22799783945083618,
0.8613640069961548,
0.15855129063129425,
0.4508029818534851,
1.1065382957458496,
0.5556480884552002,
0.31769582629203796,
-0.3178755044937134,
-0.15360786020755768,
-0.4189695715904236,
0.5745967626571655,
-0.19508327543735504,
-0.6198140382766724,
-0.08678831160068512,
-0.16238844394683838,
0.739975094795227,
0.513721227645874,
-0.13720975816249847,
0.11157285422086716,
-0.07879840582609177,
0.652582585811615,
-0.4251181483268738,
-0.19478023052215576,
-0.7410088777542114,
-0.053776394575834274,
-0.7703088521957397,
-0.25188493728637695,
-0.31884050369262695,
-0.4756152033805847,
0.2805343568325043,
-0.48878586292266846,
0.39071211218833923,
0.3035937547683716,
0.9704133868217468,
0.17583176493644714,
-0.43135562539100647,
-0.5350911021232605,
-0.31729942560195923,
0.8351964950561523,
-0.4440332353115082,
0.3648328185081482,
0.337213397026062,
0.11680067330598831,
0.00710275350138545,
-0.9884016513824463,
-0.21540123224258423,
0.0835387334227562,
-0.06952131539583206,
0.07792443782091141,
-0.22203512489795685,
-0.23123475909233093,
0.13819603621959686,
0.5332697033882141,
-0.7718515992164612,
0.22925859689712524,
-0.5139230489730835,
-0.045044492930173874,
0.630176305770874,
0.2251528799533844,
0.11854735016822815,
-0.8639669418334961,
-0.5061793923377991,
-0.15474118292331696,
-0.2738562226295471,
0.23744350671768188,
0.4485014081001282,
-0.1698218435049057,
0.27107512950897217,
0.5560149550437927,
0.23636169731616974,
0.5287250280380249,
0.3495209217071533,
-0.5516406297683716,
0.18143916130065918,
0.028288723900914192,
-0.19706501066684723,
0.29072245955467224,
0.5152922868728638,
0.44191840291023254,
-0.31316038966178894,
-0.03168393671512604,
-0.28899022936820984,
-0.3987613022327423,
0.46717724204063416,
-0.7855893969535828,
-0.2662796378135681,
0.33358877897262573,
-0.5880861282348633,
-0.17256762087345123,
-0.0526689812541008,
-0.7911880612373352,
-0.5102380514144897,
-0.22368666529655457,
0.001098406733945012,
-0.7267926931381226,
0.13153114914894104,
0.041775792837142944,
-0.771535336971283,
0.5107443928718567,
0.5145887732505798,
-0.9765015840530396,
0.07009588181972504,
1.0533055067062378,
1.218113899230957,
-0.6442631483078003,
0.027277935296297073,
-0.5115745067596436,
0.326423317193985,
-0.29195815324783325,
1.1917588710784912,
-0.41782811284065247,
-0.5427031517028809,
-0.23200540244579315,
0.14114271104335785,
-0.033420901745557785,
-0.7853354811668396,
0.5760132074356079,
-0.388541579246521,
0.3266473710536957,
0.03700782358646393,
-0.4330832064151764,
-0.05120784416794777,
0.5989240407943726,
-0.8137262463569641,
1.3973017930984497,
0.3036203980445862,
-0.7368932366371155,
0.32098478078842163,
-0.027312595397233963,
-0.3055656850337982,
0.30038338899612427,
-0.17152273654937744,
-0.2501758337020874,
0.3633563816547394,
0.20732320845127106,
0.1959466189146042,
-0.19930674135684967,
0.4620247781276703,
0.00832473486661911,
-0.09102889895439148,
0.06627925485372543,
-0.5449727773666382,
0.6675475239753723,
-0.11932957172393799,
-0.08781830221414566,
0.2196601927280426,
-0.793839156627655,
-0.029216062277555466,
0.071701779961586,
-0.5892715454101562,
-0.59820955991745,
0.06742459535598755,
0.2781963050365448,
-0.1648150235414505,
0.16464126110076904,
-0.5601091980934143,
0.2661309242248535,
-0.45746418833732605,
-0.04102550819516182,
0.8335831761360168,
0.11133269965648651,
0.347809374332428,
-0.5616837739944458,
0.6176562905311584,
-0.3982418179512024,
-0.07916189730167389,
-0.4937288761138916,
-0.171658456325531,
-0.6560311913490295,
-0.535481870174408,
0.49415552616119385,
0.4928172826766968,
-0.4585375189781189,
0.6312679648399353,
-0.17762714624404907,
-0.5896292924880981,
-0.28843703866004944,
-0.12500666081905365,
-0.03669033944606781,
0.500461757183075,
0.3593316674232483,
-0.5056242346763611,
-0.5345509648323059,
-0.9118660688400269,
-0.16454476118087769,
-0.13974274694919586,
-0.5811830163002014,
-0.06389481574296951,
0.27412766218185425,
0.09737188369035721,
0.9716287851333618,
-0.8030471205711365,
-0.2701897621154785,
-0.048570383340120316,
0.33173826336860657,
0.46504682302474976,
0.30661070346832275,
0.35319793224334717,
-0.9352746605873108,
-0.6873371005058289,
-0.15554417669773102,
-0.527216374874115,
-0.09053471684455872,
-0.45056501030921936,
-0.21339334547519684,
-0.06576517224311829,
0.6026389598846436,
-0.5187138915061951,
0.43629133701324463,
0.4254903197288513,
-0.312578409910202,
0.7493429183959961,
-0.1482849270105362,
-0.2461121529340744,
-0.9494590163230896,
0.18422599136829376,
-0.172514870762825,
-0.2700824439525604,
-0.15230318903923035,
-0.07638829946517944,
0.059835873544216156,
0.20870813727378845,
-0.17711219191551208,
0.6504850387573242,
-0.5932794809341431,
0.09825499355792999,
-0.22611744701862335,
0.4747106730937958,
0.2569096088409424,
0.3275284469127655,
0.0971306562423706,
0.29847586154937744,
0.1538364440202713,
-0.09242315590381622,
0.29546651244163513,
0.4186972379684448,
-0.5878239870071411,
0.9536103010177612,
-0.670608639717102,
0.09582747519016266,
-0.27897965908050537,
0.5632466077804565,
-0.8175429701805115,
-0.1606486737728119,
0.14169536530971527,
-0.0598510205745697,
0.3852965533733368,
-0.19750268757343292,
-0.36817851662635803,
-0.20937266945838928,
-0.7112547755241394,
0.26369404792785645,
0.20581656694412231,
-0.47719648480415344,
0.7629856467247009,
0.5084559321403503,
-0.452156662940979,
-0.5272128582000732,
-0.4352667033672333,
0.17987528443336487,
-0.3968978822231293,
-0.7233622670173645,
0.7328370213508606,
-0.24491924047470093,
-0.29875287413597107,
-0.15465420484542847,
-0.6831839084625244,
-0.14778001606464386,
-0.057051897048950195,
0.3575303256511688,
0.22530469298362732,
-0.22280798852443695,
0.21242813766002655,
0.15315976738929749,
-0.29609811305999756,
-0.0028376332484185696,
-0.3737221658229828,
0.38465335965156555,
0.21645259857177734,
-0.24738162755966187,
0.3944728672504425,
0.5355677008628845,
0.12985670566558838,
-0.35578814148902893,
0.2856384813785553,
0.5033084154129028,
-0.27066272497177124,
-0.31744033098220825,
-0.7053461074829102,
0.2923688292503357,
-0.4816072881221771,
0.34942036867141724,
-0.19343313574790955,
-1.0335038900375366,
0.20312048494815826,
-0.20640337467193604,
0.1913488209247589,
0.48830798268318176,
0.269387423992157,
-0.3335675895214081,
0.5891822576522827,
0.47566843032836914,
0.04562390595674515,
0.5462539196014404,
-0.15162383019924164,
0.0574883297085762,
-0.9711803793907166,
-0.5761375427246094,
-0.6320278644561768,
-0.7932407855987549,
-0.2862968444824219,
-0.8768861889839172,
0.24895036220550537,
0.4707373082637787,
0.3093055784702301,
0.3188546299934387,
-0.6471801400184631,
0.8338785767555237,
0.434221088886261,
-0.16479206085205078,
0.4372361898422241,
-0.10551658272743225,
-0.3366565406322479,
-0.10295874625444412,
-0.5833296179771423,
-0.5247703194618225,
0.4952690005302429,
0.43545621633529663,
0.7692351937294006,
-0.0906141921877861,
0.7460330724716187,
0.0783102884888649,
0.3510397672653198,
-1.1766273975372314,
0.447208046913147,
-0.15681962668895721,
-0.6696023941040039,
-0.5638905763626099,
0.036328982561826706,
-1.3883856534957886,
0.40013134479522705,
0.0004395867872517556,
-1.0873053073883057,
0.3074182868003845,
-0.3037298619747162,
-0.17566898465156555,
0.2390095442533493,
-0.20912839472293854,
0.6707712411880493,
-0.7441431283950806,
-0.25773707032203674,
-0.1567152887582779,
-0.7267147302627563,
0.0010060271015390754,
-0.5599619150161743,
0.023530369624495506,
-0.4840308725833893,
-0.23721732199192047,
0.9477395415306091,
-0.09958971291780472,
0.5765731930732727,
0.02754969149827957,
-0.0686885342001915,
0.30576658248901367,
0.19720104336738586,
0.4524919092655182,
0.090467169880867,
-0.18802671134471893,
0.03589179739356041,
0.2924811542034149,
-0.2759348452091217,
-0.5675528645515442,
0.4225943982601166,
-0.2891194522380829,
-0.6728663444519043,
-0.6158658862113953,
-0.4213615953922272,
0.05874603986740112,
0.5921515226364136,
0.11242633312940598,
0.4889179766178131,
-0.4755961000919342,
0.952694833278656,
0.43276581168174744,
-0.022352049127221107,
0.5647923350334167,
0.39554837346076965,
-0.43420282006263733,
-0.40879207849502563,
0.4915447533130646,
0.1480294167995453,
-0.3912329375743866,
0.8196179270744324,
0.331206351518631,
-0.3721145987510681,
-1.0035768747329712,
-0.263146311044693,
0.3525065779685974,
-0.6280367970466614,
-0.3371414542198181,
-0.5956869721412659,
-0.2023063451051712,
0.2131451964378357,
-0.5519641637802124,
-0.2447964996099472,
-0.35171443223953247,
-0.11188565194606781,
-0.3324234187602997,
-0.061772432178258896,
0.6386772394180298,
0.34657934308052063,
0.36527734994888306,
-0.9689462184906006,
0.22703240811824799,
0.16114696860313416,
0.34133630990982056,
-0.042121075093746185,
-0.32866379618644714,
-0.36276307702064514,
-0.5924351811408997,
-0.49421536922454834,
-0.7805473208427429,
0.47675150632858276,
-0.11187185347080231,
0.7561628222465515,
0.21865253150463104,
0.04518764093518257,
0.7103094458580017,
-0.6057721972465515,
0.5937055945396423,
0.31404784321784973,
-0.7793461084365845,
0.39072751998901367,
-0.5604650974273682,
0.8563481569290161,
0.7789653539657593,
0.7630223035812378,
-0.9514164328575134,
-0.42055097222328186,
-0.5883647799491882,
-1.2079769372940063,
0.5558323264122009,
0.027687134221196175,
-0.08407854288816452,
-0.10646186023950577,
0.03332255035638809,
0.30429184436798096,
0.02988980896770954,
-0.5069032311439514,
0.3231089413166046,
-0.10387420654296875,
-0.21067854762077332,
0.2756928503513336,
-0.3775559961795807,
-0.050547994673252106,
-0.03135346621274948,
0.38206711411476135,
-0.32299181818962097,
-0.18116621673107147,
0.24546638131141663,
-0.2635418772697449,
-0.11363199353218079,
0.13904376327991486,
0.05789294093847275,
1.1199432611465454,
-0.41614580154418945,
0.1414652168750763,
0.07969429343938828,
-0.5731121301651001,
0.08368305116891861,
0.23591910302639008,
-0.19822463393211365,
0.30609196424484253,
0.7709096670150757,
0.682518482208252,
0.4829739034175873,
-0.7158907055854797,
0.3462306559085846,
0.008782882243394852,
-0.47260332107543945,
-0.2742963433265686,
-0.07743772864341736,
0.347718745470047,
0.579545259475708,
0.8243646621704102,
-0.15570949018001556,
-0.038021739572286606,
-0.35025814175605774,
0.31717780232429504,
0.2848503589630127,
-0.4309362471103668,
-0.14962683618068695,
0.3156280219554901,
0.2880399227142334,
-0.6973261833190918,
0.8247545957565308,
0.25039005279541016,
-0.4261062443256378,
0.47948700189590454,
0.3827587068080902,
0.919377326965332,
-0.11280499398708344,
0.32522323727607727,
0.22834132611751556,
0.14654722809791565,
-0.10349307954311371,
-0.24490739405155182,
-0.21783243119716644,
-0.32757940888404846,
-0.3312259018421173,
-0.9057461619377136,
-0.319947749376297,
0.059688717126846313,
-0.4541909992694855,
0.45036837458610535,
-0.41684490442276,
-0.09463703632354736,
-0.007438821718096733,
-0.0736258253455162,
-0.25220707058906555,
0.15558567643165588,
0.1449602246284485,
1.129543662071228,
-0.06071004644036293,
0.7935932874679565,
0.24949172139167786,
0.0890422835946083,
-0.693468451499939,
0.3503708243370056,
0.2120949923992157,
-0.5189099311828613,
0.3697952926158905,
0.3896643817424774,
0.028123924508690834,
-0.24124078452587128,
-0.26825636625289917,
-0.9942169189453125,
1.447575569152832,
0.1295670121908188,
-0.7400839924812317,
-0.627517819404602,
-0.11144624650478363,
0.5362938642501831,
-0.06338215619325638,
0.35013440251350403,
0.5146917700767517,
0.6006261706352234,
0.46800658106803894,
-0.7945467829704285,
-0.20195619761943817,
-0.10998333990573883,
-0.08056128025054932,
0.5647523999214172,
-0.6225171685218811,
0.530186116695404,
0.3515218198299408,
-0.38274946808815,
0.13701856136322021,
0.569288432598114,
0.32585349678993225,
0.4651142954826355,
0.7578426599502563,
0.20515744388103485,
1.1477471590042114,
0.0038090951275080442,
0.7907496094703674,
-0.08683156967163086,
0.17368103563785553,
1.202194094657898,
-0.05995214357972145,
1.054707407951355,
0.5865233540534973,
-0.11743170022964478,
0.8549816608428955,
0.5230107307434082,
-0.2675006091594696,
0.26235565543174744,
0.39969953894615173,
-0.08972262591123581,
0.004414836410433054,
-0.08589134365320206,
-0.08868706226348877,
0.6890158653259277,
0.1731218844652176,
-0.33461031317710876,
-0.46848565340042114,
-0.2887097895145416,
0.07025308161973953,
-0.015647873282432556,
0.03070330061018467,
0.6591049432754517,
0.26786094903945923,
-0.8103843927383423,
0.3898913860321045,
0.20804597437381744,
0.6358326077461243,
-1.1934659481048584,
0.08127850294113159,
-0.28429365158081055,
0.11191335320472717,
-0.1855347752571106,
-0.8780591487884521,
0.567815899848938,
-0.022934557870030403,
-0.1862725466489792,
-0.6177759766578674,
0.9935736656188965,
-0.3436209559440613,
-0.48295265436172485,
0.29975491762161255,
0.4585511088371277,
-0.03343598172068596,
-0.1864699125289917,
-0.7004002928733826,
0.26422449946403503,
0.07901973277330399,
-0.4156060516834259,
0.39677363634109497,
0.6356788873672485,
-0.2649310529232025,
0.40310969948768616,
0.6757850646972656,
-0.1454940289258957,
-0.1475437730550766,
-0.29895010590553284,
0.8349122405052185,
-0.8137677907943726,
-0.6579671502113342,
-0.8015084862709045,
0.746222734451294,
-0.4084405303001404,
-0.39621543884277344,
1.0802226066589355,
1.0427414178848267,
0.6594382524490356,
0.05065983906388283,
0.3855653703212738,
-0.08017409592866898,
0.5254631042480469,
-0.501200258731842,
0.4260534942150116,
-0.3564377725124359,
0.14724096655845642,
-0.13715243339538574,
-1.1999201774597168,
-0.2768349051475525,
0.4463292956352234,
-0.29468414187431335,
-0.4982309937477112,
1.1502505540847778,
0.486723393201828,
-0.038457177579402924,
0.051214247941970825,
0.10690656304359436,
-0.024672051891684532,
0.46525686979293823,
0.19983023405075073,
0.9045002460479736,
-0.025033967569470406,
0.769003689289093,
-0.0018615692388266325,
-0.11074862629175186,
-0.05458225682377815,
-1.1091126203536987,
-0.7657132744789124,
-0.5267170667648315,
-0.18862150609493256,
-0.030302077531814575,
0.028532788157463074,
0.649181604385376,
0.7994853258132935,
-0.32676881551742554,
-0.6438586115837097,
0.3786965608596802,
0.32285723090171814,
-0.01597248949110508,
-0.21009963750839233,
0.434573233127594,
-0.0995275229215622,
-0.6055518388748169,
0.7089918255805969,
0.7245978713035583,
-0.2784847021102905,
-0.10983540862798691,
0.09375954419374466,
-0.4309288561344147,
0.17348866164684296,
0.5723170638084412,
-0.007168887183070183,
-0.4746110737323761,
-0.29504844546318054,
0.1317492127418518,
0.05192941054701805,
0.5241937637329102,
1.2120082378387451,
-0.8214386105537415,
0.39928677678108215,
0.713485836982727,
0.6363151669502258,
1.2469667196273804,
0.32344329357147217,
0.38026854395866394,
-0.9159761667251587,
-0.05792425200343132,
0.5909941792488098,
0.06559942662715912,
0.3065378665924072,
-0.2383774071931839,
0.6213232278823853,
0.32634758949279785,
-0.5628816485404968,
-0.5692960619926453,
-0.09171902388334274,
-1.1363734006881714,
-0.5384984016418457,
0.8739136457443237,
0.026710880920290947,
-0.5575764179229736,
-0.21431390941143036,
-0.559990406036377,
-0.19172228872776031,
-0.3128422498703003,
0.6362327933311462,
0.8208809494972229,
-0.18085771799087524,
-0.27641719579696655,
-0.19789618253707886,
0.15339143574237823,
0.0315135195851326,
-0.9276124238967896,
-0.03445761650800705,
0.7460569739341736,
0.14366796612739563,
0.3657168447971344,
0.8542132377624512,
-0.03205984830856323,
-0.1644030064344406,
0.22374366223812103,
-0.4491560459136963,
0.082478366792202,
-0.27136000990867615,
-0.1587507575750351,
0.6266415119171143,
-0.06967594474554062,
0.2342197746038437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17519v1 | Entropy-Based Decoding for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T12:59:38 | 2024-06-25T12:59:38 | Zexuan Qiu, Zijing Ou, Bin Wu, Jingjing Li, Aiwei Liu, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) with retrieved external knowledge has
proven effective for improving the factual accuracy of generated responses.
Despite their success, retrieval-augmented LLMs still face the distractibility
issue, where the generated responses are negatively influenced by noise from
both external and internal knowledge sources. In this paper, we introduce a
novel, training-free decoding method guided by entropy considerations to
mitigate this issue. Our approach utilizes entropy-based document-parallel
ensemble decoding to prioritize low-entropy distributions from retrieved
documents, thereby enhancing the extraction of relevant information of context.
Additionally, it incorporates a contrastive decoding mechanism that contrasts
the obtained low-entropy ensemble distribution with the high-entropy
distribution derived from the model's internal knowledge across layers, which
ensures a greater emphasis on reliable external information. Extensive
experiments on open-domain question answering datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method. | [
-0.07743330299854279,
-0.35657182335853577,
0.6133309006690979,
0.15285813808441162,
-0.441909521818161,
-0.04970574751496315,
-0.4794231653213501,
-0.46075648069381714,
0.22801466286182404,
0.3807986080646515,
-0.29858970642089844,
-0.3606177270412445,
-0.578428328037262,
0.07496682554483414,
-0.3028319776058197,
0.7806089520454407,
0.009374625980854034,
0.1691698431968689,
-0.6278506517410278,
0.14540790021419525,
-0.026816193014383316,
-0.4469229578971863,
-0.6420032978057861,
-0.36350345611572266,
0.4554682672023773,
0.13597799837589264,
0.14672845602035522,
0.48241037130355835,
0.5222252607345581,
0.2729610204696655,
-0.15101327002048492,
0.32352736592292786,
-0.6432292461395264,
0.3740483522415161,
-0.2543777823448181,
-0.5873926281929016,
0.04001934453845024,
-0.43178650736808777,
0.6863254308700562,
0.4074709713459015,
-0.14345872402191162,
-0.005819524172693491,
0.3182397484779358,
0.5046699047088623,
-1.1047730445861816,
0.33523884415626526,
-0.8752316832542419,
-0.24744831025600433,
-0.043564993888139725,
-0.6019752025604248,
-0.6561814546585083,
-0.04513904079794884,
-0.10164137929677963,
-0.5922536849975586,
0.2179962396621704,
0.03293076530098915,
0.47646215558052063,
0.30238643288612366,
-0.14383159577846527,
-0.40508267283439636,
-0.5545448064804077,
0.8702843189239502,
-0.5634905695915222,
0.49904343485832214,
0.8711335062980652,
-0.2205028384923935,
0.18969778716564178,
-0.41212791204452515,
-0.337881475687027,
0.091734379529953,
-0.04530458524823189,
0.16688326001167297,
0.03102828562259674,
0.00510982982814312,
-0.09702067077159882,
0.4057565927505493,
-0.42743802070617676,
0.06137903407216072,
-0.30169180035591125,
-0.24358874559402466,
0.42241010069847107,
0.037551842629909515,
0.14053188264369965,
0.037348199635744095,
-0.20590198040008545,
-0.24665692448616028,
-0.40186765789985657,
-0.1432129591703415,
0.26029953360557556,
0.39943328499794006,
-0.12680232524871826,
0.35438433289527893,
-0.43355369567871094,
0.46172139048576355,
0.22008371353149414,
-0.08985214680433273,
0.402223140001297,
-0.18025875091552734,
-0.4078918397426605,
0.18817511200904846,
0.5251576900482178,
0.15046021342277527,
-0.20573069155216217,
-0.6497586369514465,
-0.34986889362335205,
-0.38952675461769104,
0.17786696553230286,
-0.8614429235458374,
-0.1186550185084343,
0.3866005837917328,
-0.3881542682647705,
-0.2696962058544159,
-0.0023298405576497316,
-0.622413694858551,
-0.5192096829414368,
-0.2461487203836441,
0.4068060517311096,
-0.6563946604728699,
-0.1693381369113922,
0.0707520991563797,
-0.35902729630470276,
0.20867814123630524,
0.48518162965774536,
-1.0087659358978271,
0.029906585812568665,
0.6308808922767639,
0.692352831363678,
-0.10418213903903961,
-0.09974388778209686,
-0.7283922433853149,
0.4538792371749878,
-0.30653461813926697,
0.7197410464286804,
-0.6031192541122437,
-0.15988273918628693,
-0.026631848886609077,
-0.2102748602628708,
-0.16651830077171326,
-0.6660047769546509,
0.5230194330215454,
-0.9826189875602722,
0.09667979180812836,
-0.35085758566856384,
-0.6396007537841797,
0.03453170880675316,
0.4117852747440338,
-0.4791933000087738,
0.6520876288414001,
-0.07503020018339157,
-1.1305522918701172,
0.06254131346940994,
-0.2947651743888855,
-0.2920525372028351,
0.11881329864263535,
-0.011358912102878094,
-0.04519155994057655,
0.17504218220710754,
0.4164201319217682,
0.23283037543296814,
-0.42999371886253357,
-0.019291458651423454,
-0.27637359499931335,
-0.4258134067058563,
-0.02184693142771721,
-0.5760157108306885,
0.6414992213249207,
0.36743876338005066,
0.1183224767446518,
-0.03135169297456741,
-0.8690623044967651,
0.17814598977565765,
0.036570992320775986,
-0.7430334687232971,
-0.7751415967941284,
-0.0538916140794754,
-0.2731121778488159,
-0.051073428243398666,
0.36669376492500305,
-0.4916161894798279,
-0.13273946940898895,
-0.4867396950721741,
0.0649934634566307,
0.7586303353309631,
0.20739689469337463,
0.5705763697624207,
-0.37198665738105774,
0.2108008861541748,
0.3774190843105316,
-0.4282648265361786,
-0.1281796395778656,
-0.08409778028726578,
-0.6255577206611633,
-0.7434443831443787,
0.06851886957883835,
0.7915921807289124,
-1.112025499343872,
0.4631560742855072,
-0.34135425090789795,
-0.22690284252166748,
-0.6153952479362488,
0.43546026945114136,
0.3978472352027893,
0.637932300567627,
0.4943324327468872,
-0.13785876333713531,
-0.5458944439888,
-0.45939114689826965,
-0.1676831841468811,
-0.17172740399837494,
-0.26762983202934265,
0.25818124413490295,
0.356671005487442,
-0.1140434518456459,
0.44081759452819824,
-0.4757062792778015,
-0.0318061038851738,
-0.029789745807647705,
0.13319732248783112,
0.049670085310935974,
0.5786914229393005,
0.04437883570790291,
-0.5488336086273193,
-0.3753693401813507,
-0.04646630585193634,
-0.8575547337532043,
0.11923643946647644,
-0.028476126492023468,
-0.37522655725479126,
0.21388058364391327,
0.7246461510658264,
-0.7942644357681274,
0.14185158908367157,
-0.008025132119655609,
-0.040691714733839035,
0.3740101158618927,
-0.3144936263561249,
0.140811488032341,
-1.0063974857330322,
0.15282370150089264,
-0.1055973619222641,
0.06237078085541725,
-0.41318368911743164,
0.31982648372650146,
0.2265862077474594,
0.15653876960277557,
-0.3114160895347595,
0.6604042649269104,
-0.5295366644859314,
0.2928048074245453,
-0.21272020041942596,
-0.1024685651063919,
0.08055031299591064,
0.3850882649421692,
0.2897198796272278,
0.7635146975517273,
0.5196938514709473,
-0.6214401721954346,
0.21140669286251068,
0.220937117934227,
-0.6135400533676147,
0.6106487512588501,
-0.18916012346744537,
0.3630259931087494,
-0.6612468957901001,
0.07224429398775101,
-0.7947812676429749,
-0.4873935282230377,
0.21433718502521515,
-0.29738715291023254,
0.48500147461891174,
-0.19518546760082245,
-0.569835901260376,
-0.15276731550693512,
-0.4624966084957123,
0.4685337543487549,
0.365314781665802,
-0.6701539158821106,
0.2648189663887024,
0.060432154685258865,
-0.2105346918106079,
-0.7299854159355164,
-0.8067668676376343,
-0.0746605396270752,
-0.307153582572937,
-0.5457924008369446,
0.17454296350479126,
-0.25952422618865967,
-0.4430980086326599,
-0.12571465969085693,
-0.14922435581684113,
-0.28715991973876953,
0.07142555713653564,
-0.1680271178483963,
-0.015277376398444176,
-0.23446150124073029,
0.3871214687824249,
-0.06583156436681747,
0.3285644054412842,
0.013047631829977036,
-0.43914949893951416,
0.4763185381889343,
0.2067682147026062,
-0.2645331919193268,
-0.23444610834121704,
0.3955546021461487,
0.46152132749557495,
-0.3632350564002991,
1.1367076635360718,
0.6361736059188843,
-0.3599366247653961,
-0.27156224846839905,
-0.5451236963272095,
-0.3084256649017334,
-0.5125488638877869,
0.28530505299568176,
-0.38466519117355347,
-0.7338179349899292,
0.6596147418022156,
0.2970534861087799,
-0.24411903321743011,
0.26778504252433777,
0.5681045651435852,
-0.09057006984949112,
0.5351264476776123,
0.4508061707019806,
-0.22290001809597015,
0.6072193384170532,
-0.01861684024333954,
0.042033422738313675,
-0.8713931441307068,
-0.44148677587509155,
-0.49533531069755554,
-0.03521936759352684,
-0.14796596765518188,
-0.6479000449180603,
0.18192020058631897,
0.26913902163505554,
-0.30923447012901306,
-0.14203821122646332,
-0.453882098197937,
0.48312392830848694,
0.8139925599098206,
0.4405446946620941,
0.25533440709114075,
0.4304679036140442,
-0.23780164122581482,
0.20346228778362274,
-0.6003850102424622,
0.02275506779551506,
1.0573389530181885,
0.07626217603683472,
1.0761324167251587,
0.14107759296894073,
1.0916475057601929,
0.16784918308258057,
0.07542377710342407,
-0.5755192637443542,
0.35467880964279175,
0.03333453834056854,
-0.44431594014167786,
-0.47968190908432007,
-0.7727105617523193,
-0.9240560531616211,
0.46557721495628357,
-0.035916753113269806,
-0.9198833107948303,
0.3995358347892761,
-0.04388308525085449,
-0.27683117985725403,
0.4206623435020447,
-0.7600387334823608,
0.3675086200237274,
0.06832868605852127,
-0.6105822324752808,
-0.09211374819278717,
-0.5624322295188904,
0.4899299740791321,
-0.11492800712585449,
0.15967531502246857,
0.20247158408164978,
0.0341644249856472,
0.5350992679595947,
-0.27162763476371765,
0.7521331310272217,
-0.1566149890422821,
-0.38389483094215393,
0.43791911005973816,
0.04702668637037277,
0.7955683469772339,
-0.004740837030112743,
-0.5932809114456177,
-0.24027511477470398,
0.043999139219522476,
-0.39395591616630554,
-0.4615161418914795,
0.7995685935020447,
-0.7470079660415649,
-0.6893270015716553,
-0.21935467422008514,
-0.9631327390670776,
-0.3787371516227722,
0.2360360026359558,
0.40794795751571655,
0.35423946380615234,
0.01641303114593029,
0.4879049062728882,
0.925102710723877,
-0.2727220356464386,
0.45680713653564453,
0.5501073598861694,
0.41155296564102173,
-0.6649082899093628,
1.133525013923645,
0.028830885887145996,
0.08301207423210144,
0.8345993161201477,
-0.05924490466713905,
-0.34459298849105835,
-0.6381909251213074,
-0.08510562777519226,
0.10013658553361893,
-0.9387893080711365,
-0.39289698004722595,
-0.6072207093238831,
-0.29469335079193115,
-0.6943010091781616,
0.038835082203149796,
0.06402066349983215,
-0.1490754634141922,
-0.6786827445030212,
-0.10081486403942108,
0.15747566521167755,
0.31623318791389465,
-0.11404267698526382,
0.11836539953947067,
-0.864178478717804,
0.2526131570339203,
0.2441246658563614,
0.4926152229309082,
0.19624537229537964,
-0.6502659320831299,
-0.5830522179603577,
-0.02465691603720188,
-0.060715533792972565,
-0.6820414662361145,
0.46144288778305054,
0.055869296193122864,
0.5892637968063354,
0.2846032679080963,
0.5204722285270691,
0.5443627238273621,
-0.36583247780799866,
0.5165030360221863,
0.03980683162808418,
-0.6726346015930176,
0.3751399517059326,
-0.40818580985069275,
0.4882940351963043,
0.5656309127807617,
0.1860089898109436,
-0.12750256061553955,
-0.505057156085968,
-0.3835385739803314,
-1.0566924810409546,
0.9064242243766785,
0.061021529138088226,
0.1666257083415985,
-0.3418571352958679,
0.21660642325878143,
0.011248971335589886,
0.2958429157733917,
-0.6044163107872009,
0.21177123486995697,
-0.05013404041528702,
-0.5405038595199585,
-0.029814183712005615,
-0.3997437655925751,
-0.1940082609653473,
-0.07339908182621002,
0.7966896295547485,
-0.04447295889258385,
0.4318273067474365,
0.34104660153388977,
-0.42848384380340576,
-0.19637039303779602,
0.4862399101257324,
0.57596755027771,
0.3654125928878784,
-0.5904787182807922,
0.42522913217544556,
0.1392984688282013,
-0.40942463278770447,
0.03527110069990158,
0.14742426574230194,
-0.20721331238746643,
-0.19638772308826447,
0.4323495030403137,
0.7413453459739685,
-0.14429612457752228,
-0.5949234366416931,
0.28530749678611755,
0.16645547747612,
-0.16247016191482544,
0.0005771000287495553,
-0.038024112582206726,
0.1312570571899414,
0.3975713849067688,
0.5985530018806458,
0.050353359431028366,
0.17860278487205505,
-0.3425203263759613,
0.22815096378326416,
0.6045010089874268,
-0.09772640466690063,
-0.13671556115150452,
0.4697244465351105,
0.14030735194683075,
0.02236606925725937,
0.6369210481643677,
-0.176723912358284,
-0.00004651643394026905,
0.5053791999816895,
0.7127627730369568,
0.7724665999412537,
-0.08080647885799408,
-0.06373149156570435,
0.4137253761291504,
0.39032813906669617,
-0.3230161964893341,
0.3346315622329712,
-0.3397614061832428,
-0.7023048400878906,
-0.2937721908092499,
-0.7155314683914185,
-0.2181587666273117,
0.38016238808631897,
-0.7497904896736145,
-0.17267732322216034,
-0.2843002676963806,
0.2557249069213867,
-0.4260368049144745,
-0.16356347501277924,
-0.5700708627700806,
0.29633668065071106,
0.3664033114910126,
0.978082001209259,
-0.33045023679733276,
1.0231910943984985,
0.30814558267593384,
-0.3945974111557007,
-0.393914133310318,
0.5430362820625305,
-0.23981203138828278,
-0.8613394498825073,
0.556925356388092,
0.029575342312455177,
-0.26553741097450256,
0.09454983472824097,
-0.5999479293823242,
-1.057508945465088,
1.0437742471694946,
0.7475507855415344,
-0.2757173478603363,
-0.13533160090446472,
-0.2111331671476364,
0.4895355999469757,
-0.12547919154167175,
0.28234297037124634,
0.15586431324481964,
0.17672960460186005,
0.16735398769378662,
-0.6558325290679932,
0.1652136743068695,
-0.3098803460597992,
-0.17071741819381714,
-0.060543786734342575,
-0.5760805606842041,
0.5814110040664673,
-0.15996809303760529,
-0.26626795530319214,
0.21931374073028564,
0.6324983239173889,
0.16492176055908203,
0.3604680895805359,
0.21188807487487793,
0.6290495991706848,
1.146451473236084,
0.3165367543697357,
1.2094610929489136,
-0.607010543346405,
0.2019130438566208,
1.2993905544281006,
-0.22206982970237732,
1.1566979885101318,
0.6316100358963013,
0.07395239919424057,
0.40355968475341797,
0.43939104676246643,
0.2839221954345703,
1.0393686294555664,
0.22348076105117798,
-0.6358676552772522,
-0.35060057044029236,
-0.08219596743583679,
-0.44925469160079956,
0.131705179810524,
0.5070172548294067,
-0.5864943861961365,
-0.28091803193092346,
-0.08521894365549088,
-0.3036528527736664,
-0.0925569012761116,
-0.5237434506416321,
0.9167478084564209,
0.08114658296108246,
-0.7081301808357239,
0.9114311933517456,
0.13396891951560974,
0.7787848114967346,
-0.5689524412155151,
0.3629634380340576,
-0.30204281210899353,
0.219695582985878,
-0.1609984040260315,
-0.7208554744720459,
0.2114361971616745,
-0.14456723630428314,
-0.5063072443008423,
-0.1839665323495865,
0.9027764201164246,
-0.817345142364502,
-0.3950203061103821,
0.2313893735408783,
0.5174845457077026,
0.19028526544570923,
-0.2431795299053192,
-0.27926334738731384,
0.01333387941122055,
-0.07976961880922318,
-0.16518546640872955,
0.5394598841667175,
0.547097384929657,
0.22213460505008698,
0.5707531571388245,
0.5037781000137329,
-0.13229505717754364,
0.04052920266985893,
-0.00985025241971016,
0.8280197381973267,
-0.3627074956893921,
-0.6777382493019104,
-0.7923534512519836,
0.291260302066803,
0.012415348552167416,
0.23621658980846405,
0.6881667971611023,
0.509636640548706,
0.6694579720497131,
-0.29705676436424255,
0.8309332132339478,
0.2532239854335785,
0.4356733560562134,
-0.7566747665405273,
0.6883925795555115,
-0.5769097208976746,
0.5055775046348572,
-0.0077080619521439075,
-0.5848510265350342,
-0.20125630497932434,
0.3416846692562103,
-0.42218446731567383,
0.02532263845205307,
0.5777803659439087,
0.9504947066307068,
-0.17398318648338318,
-0.28076496720314026,
0.3799431025981903,
0.09967701137065887,
-0.13697102665901184,
0.5821905136108398,
0.7195282578468323,
-0.19106228649616241,
0.8401578068733215,
-0.10602202266454697,
0.06329790502786636,
-0.1991778165102005,
-0.526332676410675,
-0.853869616985321,
-0.4727630615234375,
-0.1801494061946869,
-0.45768195390701294,
0.22205348312854767,
0.8448461294174194,
0.5973965525627136,
-0.7970609068870544,
-0.04481978341937065,
-0.042587921023368835,
0.3125652074813843,
-0.0792754516005516,
-0.2281457930803299,
0.4261857569217682,
-0.8263652324676514,
-0.5837836265563965,
0.6750943660736084,
0.05288964882493019,
-0.03565039858222008,
0.2174203097820282,
-0.1608836054801941,
-0.2763667702674866,
0.4042317271232605,
0.6382705569267273,
0.24942843616008759,
-0.4949199855327606,
-0.20360146462917328,
-0.09394145011901855,
-0.3173782527446747,
0.3038557171821594,
0.5717926621437073,
-0.6602710485458374,
0.37775716185569763,
0.9150168895721436,
0.8860112428665161,
0.45852962136268616,
0.07650487869977951,
0.48060840368270874,
-1.091850757598877,
0.3234908878803253,
0.07558330148458481,
0.2414182722568512,
0.5012255907058716,
-0.7192226648330688,
0.32697823643684387,
0.2786714434623718,
-0.2448892891407013,
-0.9134723544120789,
-0.05071123316884041,
-0.6843129396438599,
-0.47594454884529114,
1.2761287689208984,
-0.28222936391830444,
-0.2309027910232544,
-0.02049589715898037,
0.06067540869116783,
0.13274824619293213,
-0.5322154760360718,
0.8628877997398376,
0.7743597030639648,
0.18083053827285767,
-0.4415731728076935,
-0.22099217772483826,
0.49508264660835266,
0.4637930989265442,
-0.7924739718437195,
0.19322355091571808,
0.47344401478767395,
0.37733733654022217,
0.18028447031974792,
0.6945907473564148,
0.02980838343501091,
0.14156542718410492,
0.20538634061813354,
0.0006956422002986073,
-0.01041643787175417,
-0.1671532243490219,
-0.46946457028388977,
0.4808553457260132,
0.11013204604387283,
-0.2541073262691498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17513v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17513v2 | Benchmarking Mental State Representations in Language Models | 2024-06-25T12:51:06 | 2024-07-01T06:48:34 | Matteo Bortoletto, Constantin Ruhdorfer, Lei Shi, Andreas Bulling | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While numerous works have assessed the generative performance of language
models (LMs) on tasks requiring Theory of Mind reasoning, research into the
models' internal representation of mental states remains limited. Recent work
has used probing to demonstrate that LMs can represent beliefs of themselves
and others. However, these claims are accompanied by limited evaluation, making
it difficult to assess how mental state representations are affected by model
design and training choices. We report an extensive benchmark with various LM
types with different model sizes, fine-tuning approaches, and prompt designs to
study the robustness of mental state representations and memorisation issues
within the probes. Our results show that the quality of models' internal
representations of the beliefs of others increases with model size and, more
crucially, with fine-tuning. We are the first to study how prompt variations
impact probing performance on theory of mind tasks. We demonstrate that models'
representations are sensitive to prompt variations, even when such variations
should be beneficial. Finally, we complement previous activation editing
experiments on Theory of Mind tasks and show that it is possible to improve
models' reasoning performance by steering their activations without the need to
train any probe. | [
-0.6371397972106934,
-0.5667369365692139,
0.8887413144111633,
-0.011495116166770458,
-0.14541348814964294,
-0.19379737973213196,
-0.48741066455841064,
-0.33102595806121826,
0.08053083717823029,
0.17809723317623138,
-0.5050364136695862,
-0.07567717880010605,
-0.5661301612854004,
0.25266313552856445,
-0.12773233652114868,
0.5045832395553589,
-0.201781764626503,
0.20288611948490143,
-0.30377939343452454,
-0.3243076205253601,
-0.5630858540534973,
-0.5892975330352783,
-0.610173761844635,
-0.5689939260482788,
0.4546632468700409,
0.003738311817869544,
0.6814754009246826,
0.4451577365398407,
0.42471057176589966,
0.19179081916809082,
-0.1638309806585312,
0.2547432780265808,
-0.48768576979637146,
0.34313613176345825,
-0.4253939986228943,
-0.7411904335021973,
-0.16191938519477844,
0.24715138971805573,
0.9104869961738586,
0.6136860251426697,
-0.16112126410007477,
0.22874067723751068,
0.11938827484846115,
0.4225093722343445,
-0.7756178379058838,
0.30520159006118774,
-0.7634723782539368,
-0.07888452708721161,
-0.08722938597202301,
-0.000031107785616768524,
-0.6332943439483643,
-0.275960236787796,
0.10581117123365402,
-0.39733779430389404,
0.27844443917274475,
0.2305297553539276,
0.7345035672187805,
0.2877092957496643,
-0.37887638807296753,
-0.0072455327026546,
-0.7083547711372375,
0.7147375345230103,
-0.8678610324859619,
0.5461335182189941,
0.4303499460220337,
0.20922242105007172,
-0.1770360916852951,
-0.4144741892814636,
-0.5022673606872559,
-0.5237904191017151,
-0.17926809191703796,
-0.10639888793230057,
-0.16882546246051788,
0.16695985198020935,
0.8352310061454773,
0.4477488696575165,
-0.24292370676994324,
-0.045090481638908386,
0.08407216519117355,
-0.19730034470558167,
0.4307618737220764,
0.4826805293560028,
0.08829893171787262,
0.10997264832258224,
0.09259714931249619,
-0.5055521130561829,
-0.6153330206871033,
0.1739916056394577,
0.10151108354330063,
0.32395046949386597,
0.11559045314788818,
0.6237232089042664,
-0.3366011679172516,
0.6158245205879211,
0.24905717372894287,
0.17628473043441772,
-0.1514723002910614,
-0.042265795171260834,
-0.3714297115802765,
-0.34729477763175964,
0.610949695110321,
0.48531702160835266,
0.20338940620422363,
-0.025699350982904434,
-0.4109456539154053,
0.42240825295448303,
0.3503839671611786,
-0.7667373418807983,
-0.23827297985553741,
-0.0644657090306282,
-0.3447611927986145,
0.22549988329410553,
-0.08758295327425003,
-0.350159615278244,
-0.6578161716461182,
-0.2897944748401642,
0.564768373966217,
-0.6487241387367249,
-0.38181832432746887,
0.25821733474731445,
-0.11748243868350983,
0.10949620604515076,
0.3591385781764984,
-1.0327528715133667,
0.49014225602149963,
0.6058762669563293,
0.6410037279129028,
-0.04416881874203682,
-0.3566342294216156,
-0.2888389229774475,
-0.044538140296936035,
-0.7707364559173584,
0.7872447371482849,
-0.6252937912940979,
-0.49998968839645386,
-0.047976817935705185,
-0.13669566810131073,
-0.24941304326057434,
-0.5753964185714722,
0.3528541326522827,
-0.3889910578727722,
0.07996080070734024,
-0.9415306448936462,
-1.123721957206726,
-0.19304272532463074,
0.2598007917404175,
-0.7650651335716248,
1.0225690603256226,
0.0694756954908371,
-0.7188268899917603,
0.4124968945980072,
-0.401199609041214,
-0.15214954316616058,
-0.14881710708141327,
-0.5008803009986877,
-0.04036075621843338,
0.6615396738052368,
0.1532997339963913,
0.5056357383728027,
-0.4932858645915985,
0.1127738505601883,
-0.34285974502563477,
-0.5032884478569031,
0.6293460726737976,
-0.23951999843120575,
0.565916121006012,
0.07378342002630234,
-0.25019267201423645,
0.15213364362716675,
-0.47076573967933655,
0.15051424503326416,
0.2982461154460907,
-0.18930326402187347,
-0.40171128511428833,
0.17959852516651154,
-0.41815313696861267,
-0.009571016766130924,
0.1550971269607544,
-0.4961756765842438,
0.30101802945137024,
-0.32180675864219666,
0.15049639344215393,
0.5287957191467285,
0.1544927954673767,
0.3882955312728882,
-0.452203631401062,
0.43610626459121704,
0.13322868943214417,
-0.09204200655221939,
-0.28238028287887573,
-0.4691362977027893,
-0.9227809309959412,
-0.007379496935755014,
0.2564784586429596,
0.2306223064661026,
-0.30943024158477783,
0.11885001510381699,
-0.08087465912103653,
-0.5172264575958252,
-0.685896098613739,
-0.08125752955675125,
0.33576348423957825,
0.32026785612106323,
0.2913109064102173,
-0.31094127893447876,
-0.17184355854988098,
-1.1293121576309204,
-0.6965964436531067,
-0.20720428228378296,
-0.056241583079099655,
0.1683381050825119,
0.5237852334976196,
0.05416056886315346,
0.9032303690910339,
-0.5620495676994324,
0.10460200905799866,
-0.17608609795570374,
0.2549576759338379,
0.09907899796962738,
0.3876940608024597,
0.5858363509178162,
-0.31142985820770264,
-0.22322571277618408,
-0.2628287374973297,
-0.574319064617157,
0.19463910162448883,
-0.13412617146968842,
0.018617093563079834,
0.10301750153303146,
0.45233407616615295,
-0.8140951991081238,
0.34162676334381104,
0.2425292730331421,
-0.35402119159698486,
0.5239774584770203,
-0.280774861574173,
0.30963826179504395,
-0.7572973966598511,
-0.02012547478079796,
0.2541053295135498,
-0.19274553656578064,
-0.6321190595626831,
0.34721675515174866,
0.6312437057495117,
-0.08947383612394333,
-0.07216686010360718,
0.6038745045661926,
-0.5587006211280823,
0.11472130566835403,
-0.27279844880104065,
-0.05833197757601738,
-0.09784621745347977,
0.5418119430541992,
-0.001723627676256001,
0.8585653305053711,
0.5319797992706299,
-0.6190195083618164,
0.03343905881047249,
-0.16040268540382385,
-0.6714631915092468,
0.4851367771625519,
-0.5874375700950623,
0.4473647475242615,
-0.1758139282464981,
0.059166036546230316,
-0.8734049797058105,
-0.06466981023550034,
0.04232053458690643,
-0.2402089238166809,
0.3226199448108673,
0.003511667251586914,
-0.7651901841163635,
-0.15906110405921936,
-0.07732249051332474,
0.281245619058609,
0.5734711289405823,
-0.2772572338581085,
0.5692489147186279,
0.19441534578800201,
0.19811493158340454,
-0.13434450328350067,
-0.4108434021472931,
-0.134015291929245,
-0.4052025377750397,
-0.2100428342819214,
0.34773367643356323,
-0.20461103320121765,
-0.5350884199142456,
-0.09616990387439728,
-0.35270392894744873,
0.0651557520031929,
0.17773696780204773,
0.14390434324741364,
0.09540030360221863,
-0.30185678601264954,
0.17495080828666687,
0.08919525891542435,
0.04592134431004524,
0.46502622961997986,
-0.08932559192180634,
0.48752233386039734,
-0.2314731627702713,
-0.468265175819397,
-0.3541076183319092,
0.47238314151763916,
0.4723743796348572,
-0.44001448154449463,
0.778265118598938,
0.2074209302663803,
-0.7583850622177124,
-0.42699742317199707,
-0.7398662567138672,
-0.4905397295951843,
-0.48717981576919556,
0.1896074265241623,
-0.6880508661270142,
-0.9449646472930908,
0.5805733799934387,
-0.09267067164182663,
-0.00622840691357851,
0.47709694504737854,
0.44464200735092163,
-0.14733049273490906,
1.3051618337631226,
0.6706726551055908,
-0.13617317378520966,
0.42026928067207336,
-0.04896086826920509,
-0.008813902735710144,
-0.8711535334587097,
0.06959612667560577,
-0.4545949697494507,
-0.20828761160373688,
-0.3643514811992645,
-0.5439398884773254,
0.2223595827817917,
0.22103473544120789,
-0.2762567400932312,
0.21730153262615204,
-0.3180694580078125,
0.5318019390106201,
0.5234798789024353,
0.16994382441043854,
0.12065868824720383,
-0.22779430449008942,
-0.5304677486419678,
-0.297444224357605,
-0.5714331269264221,
-0.6276624798774719,
1.0248620510101318,
0.3316471576690674,
0.7915533781051636,
0.036881670355796814,
0.49507027864456177,
0.16067379713058472,
0.2770175635814667,
-0.6868411302566528,
0.7892848253250122,
0.10554255545139313,
-0.8029854893684387,
-0.17191916704177856,
-0.2562529146671295,
-0.6237310171127319,
0.34165847301483154,
-0.15165939927101135,
-0.9416720271110535,
0.21193863451480865,
0.22123143076896667,
-0.3772328197956085,
0.34068596363067627,
-0.6510132551193237,
0.7380552887916565,
0.009853754192590714,
-0.060077767819166183,
-0.6002418994903564,
-0.17826908826828003,
0.15361851453781128,
0.15973664820194244,
-0.3072282671928406,
-0.273342490196228,
0.12548576295375824,
0.6448625922203064,
-0.07950475066900253,
0.8974984288215637,
-0.24185143411159515,
-0.3577979505062103,
0.21884828805923462,
0.5402439832687378,
0.605972409248352,
0.061246708035469055,
-0.20587246119976044,
-0.11788424849510193,
0.14675766229629517,
-0.27690431475639343,
-0.8887676000595093,
0.5094549059867859,
-0.5359084606170654,
-0.9398022890090942,
-0.28316763043403625,
-0.7339032292366028,
-0.6597171425819397,
0.18986669182777405,
0.17153730988502502,
0.49126577377319336,
-0.36140120029449463,
-0.016517797484993935,
0.969072699546814,
0.08605457842350006,
0.1945173591375351,
0.4796591103076935,
-0.2845923602581024,
-0.023796867579221725,
0.6258541941642761,
0.16332882642745972,
0.3914303779602051,
0.35762232542037964,
-0.03478822484612465,
-0.23781374096870422,
-0.5318257212638855,
-0.27513059973716736,
0.3180110454559326,
-1.0163037776947021,
0.04153282567858696,
-0.3396611511707306,
0.027314001694321632,
-0.336352676153183,
0.31940749287605286,
-0.559680163860321,
-0.2381216287612915,
-0.35235872864723206,
-0.0454181432723999,
0.3973832130432129,
0.8368861675262451,
0.1832372099161148,
0.04603785648941994,
-0.18101127445697784,
0.2408871054649353,
0.378025621175766,
0.6028604507446289,
0.11540326476097107,
-0.5167720317840576,
-0.4775128662586212,
0.04556803032755852,
-0.15977847576141357,
-1.1043914556503296,
-0.06754699349403381,
-0.0074357278645038605,
0.8055633306503296,
0.46473222970962524,
0.03290629759430885,
0.7279165983200073,
-0.4993557929992676,
0.7094144821166992,
-0.09651215374469757,
-1.0362910032272339,
0.6193771958351135,
-0.41940250992774963,
0.4479146897792816,
0.5502378344535828,
0.45075809955596924,
-0.6089391112327576,
-0.5671602487564087,
-0.40366843342781067,
-0.1747811883687973,
0.5343451499938965,
-0.07793696224689484,
0.10363566130399704,
-0.17198120057582855,
0.5908673405647278,
0.0738869160413742,
-0.027146682143211365,
-0.4627442955970764,
-0.3917846083641052,
-0.06505706906318665,
-0.027275634929537773,
-0.2751075029373169,
-0.33258962631225586,
-0.2819715440273285,
-0.41898059844970703,
0.4184638261795044,
-0.26641371846199036,
0.5168048739433289,
0.27207791805267334,
-0.18231579661369324,
-0.07308769226074219,
0.2247452735900879,
0.6702105402946472,
0.6916735172271729,
-0.19540564715862274,
0.2104363888502121,
0.43694862723350525,
-0.08987250924110413,
0.1315244734287262,
0.06506712734699249,
-0.129986971616745,
0.03732774779200554,
0.23255334794521332,
1.0073482990264893,
0.24556031823158264,
-0.5245610475540161,
0.017801200971007347,
-0.17552067339420319,
0.013093490153551102,
0.020037580281496048,
0.5216538310050964,
0.20365719497203827,
0.4352448880672455,
0.21851907670497894,
0.09779532998800278,
0.012334764003753662,
-0.5021031498908997,
-0.23850002884864807,
0.49854859709739685,
-0.3190857768058777,
-0.448514848947525,
0.6670634150505066,
-0.28401681780815125,
-0.33775120973587036,
0.5058101415634155,
-0.37480154633522034,
-0.3099788427352905,
0.43782585859298706,
0.6122903227806091,
0.7783110737800598,
-0.35184869170188904,
-0.027130644768476486,
0.49098557233810425,
0.4703441262245178,
-0.4300088584423065,
0.43855488300323486,
-0.08331389725208282,
-1.0432995557785034,
-0.19342495501041412,
-0.0813174843788147,
-0.6693428754806519,
0.3355104625225067,
-1.0120781660079956,
-0.04895278438925743,
-0.5294348001480103,
-0.5934123992919922,
-0.1926078349351883,
0.05881216749548912,
-0.9357991814613342,
0.2923021614551544,
0.3595234453678131,
1.086103916168213,
-0.7038381695747375,
0.9345259070396423,
0.976989209651947,
-0.2676246166229248,
-0.8661805391311646,
0.13508528470993042,
-0.017060009762644768,
-0.5417366027832031,
0.25400805473327637,
0.169484943151474,
-0.28638312220573425,
-0.0034272647462785244,
-0.3674718737602234,
-0.9832862019538879,
0.8121764659881592,
0.7003699541091919,
-0.5602989792823792,
0.05682060122489929,
-0.036784589290618896,
0.6145985126495361,
-0.405114084482193,
0.2915935814380646,
0.6899347901344299,
0.32930052280426025,
-0.6537025570869446,
-0.9354223012924194,
0.32559528946876526,
-0.3245619833469391,
0.1988571137189865,
0.07295967638492584,
-0.5277156829833984,
0.9781349301338196,
-0.16330471634864807,
-0.5516849160194397,
0.16140425205230713,
0.7984825968742371,
0.3520083427429199,
-0.015344918705523014,
0.5442819595336914,
0.5555550456047058,
1.0231207609176636,
-0.200889453291893,
1.2286242246627808,
-0.32983916997909546,
0.3909986615180969,
1.2009236812591553,
-0.335550457239151,
0.8407754302024841,
0.4447264075279236,
-0.2696874439716339,
0.4309863746166229,
0.6917440891265869,
-0.015407942235469818,
0.4774218499660492,
0.36181917786598206,
-0.16610756516456604,
-0.4230360984802246,
-0.007799494545906782,
-0.3607279360294342,
0.16783738136291504,
0.6111308336257935,
-0.2863607406616211,
0.048394929617643356,
-0.03995129093527794,
-0.13713571429252625,
0.12107401341199875,
-0.24762384593486786,
0.5661765336990356,
0.10056672245264053,
-0.9720733761787415,
0.6391942501068115,
0.06589669734239578,
0.5215004086494446,
-0.5261055827140808,
0.16963033378124237,
-0.4688794016838074,
0.18190152943134308,
0.33940058946609497,
-0.7266825437545776,
-0.10326773673295975,
-0.06448472291231155,
-0.2852793037891388,
-0.2546934485435486,
0.6777995228767395,
-0.21581968665122986,
-0.3290853500366211,
0.3232839107513428,
0.5007126331329346,
0.1015620306134224,
-0.24992704391479492,
-0.47634008526802063,
0.2759488523006439,
-0.16146032512187958,
-0.47047990560531616,
0.3602139949798584,
0.48460566997528076,
-0.06794220209121704,
0.757979154586792,
0.15211789309978485,
0.2529698312282562,
0.16244763135910034,
0.22050489485263824,
0.8198494911193848,
-1.0015614032745361,
-0.2696512043476105,
-0.9079256653785706,
0.28433603048324585,
0.011877941899001598,
-0.4963873326778412,
0.8478198647499084,
0.40309858322143555,
0.9654082655906677,
-0.17001092433929443,
0.5733248591423035,
0.2547248899936676,
0.42493849992752075,
-0.5967791676521301,
0.7349743247032166,
-0.4073183834552765,
-0.013179352506995201,
-0.23247067630290985,
-0.8725689649581909,
0.0463891327381134,
0.7142216563224792,
-0.2717569172382355,
0.024908188730478287,
0.8653749227523804,
0.7822978496551514,
-0.08807934820652008,
0.26500725746154785,
0.3561117947101593,
0.2983675003051758,
0.1978830248117447,
0.4397011399269104,
1.1367182731628418,
-0.26187384128570557,
-0.016441473737359047,
-0.47098761796951294,
0.018168648704886436,
-0.05573015660047531,
-0.8005026578903198,
-1.1735472679138184,
-0.8787269592285156,
-0.3458347022533417,
-0.12523727118968964,
-0.11876551061868668,
0.9282029867172241,
0.744769275188446,
-0.7040172815322876,
-0.3558371067047119,
0.12340282648801804,
-0.15125006437301636,
-0.5090035796165466,
-0.16616341471672058,
0.20261695981025696,
-0.40080294013023376,
-0.562825620174408,
0.7564736604690552,
0.10239469259977341,
0.04406890273094177,
-0.5183743238449097,
0.10961762815713882,
0.1071741133928299,
0.2955186367034912,
0.46810340881347656,
0.1930144727230072,
-1.0196638107299805,
-0.48504161834716797,
0.10345141589641571,
-0.161164328455925,
0.05055046081542969,
1.1361497640609741,
-0.8424783945083618,
0.47785240411758423,
0.3267380893230438,
0.5475088357925415,
0.5165548324584961,
-0.33319327235221863,
0.7282606959342957,
-0.5177904963493347,
-0.10608698427677155,
0.22123296558856964,
0.6796750426292419,
0.2941563129425049,
-0.19265606999397278,
0.24293109774589539,
-0.04940900579094887,
-0.4065294861793518,
-0.9259980320930481,
0.35221511125564575,
-0.7874650955200195,
-0.24513673782348633,
0.8814262747764587,
-0.20547863841056824,
0.021033039316534996,
0.2623291611671448,
-0.11592153459787369,
0.34308454394340515,
-0.36217954754829407,
0.8490946888923645,
1.144501805305481,
-0.26646772027015686,
-0.29220718145370483,
-0.65909343957901,
0.4699461758136749,
0.8917874097824097,
-0.5309948325157166,
0.2754347622394562,
0.3892614245414734,
0.37115585803985596,
0.05724627897143364,
0.6442541480064392,
0.13771472871303558,
0.20749372243881226,
0.0789136067032814,
-0.15342523157596588,
0.11497318744659424,
-0.20501022040843964,
-0.48302116990089417,
-0.04406103491783142,
0.35427868366241455,
0.08737096935510635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17825v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17825v1 | Automatic speech recognition for the Nepali language using CNN, bidirectional LSTM and ResNet | 2024-06-25T12:14:01 | 2024-06-25T12:14:01 | Manish Dhakal, Arman Chhetri, Aman Kumar Gupta, Prabin Lamichhane, Suraj Pandey, Subarna Shakya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents an end-to-end deep learning model for Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) that transcribes Nepali speech to text. The model was trained
and tested on the OpenSLR (audio, text) dataset. The majority of the audio
dataset have silent gaps at both ends which are clipped during dataset
preprocessing for a more uniform mapping of audio frames and their
corresponding texts. Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs) are used as
audio features to feed into the model. The model having Bidirectional LSTM
paired with ResNet and one-dimensional CNN produces the best results for this
dataset out of all the models (neural networks with variations of LSTM, GRU,
CNN, and ResNet) that have been trained so far. This novel model uses
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) function for loss calculation
during training and CTC beam search decoding for predicting characters as the
most likely sequence of Nepali text. On the test dataset, the character error
rate (CER) of 17.06 percent has been achieved. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/manishdhakal/ASR-Nepali-using-CNN-BiLSTM-ResNet. | [
0.16912882030010223,
-0.5059069991111755,
-0.16084995865821838,
0.44139304757118225,
-0.5537583231925964,
0.3359057903289795,
-0.3142617642879486,
-0.43274691700935364,
-0.14023910462856293,
0.45045745372772217,
-0.06021520867943764,
-0.45618394017219543,
-0.5776647329330444,
0.5657002925872803,
-0.8797401785850525,
0.5855808258056641,
0.023038826882839203,
0.30383551120758057,
0.2610510587692261,
-0.1645864099264145,
-0.4429243206977844,
-0.6397853493690491,
-0.7888893485069275,
-0.1924125850200653,
0.23254351317882538,
0.37917304039001465,
0.1651596575975418,
0.4993973672389984,
0.3789052665233612,
0.35446006059646606,
-0.4041403830051422,
0.12999822199344635,
-0.10101916640996933,
0.04205054044723511,
0.26616331934928894,
-0.2949473261833191,
-0.19336572289466858,
-0.17118164896965027,
1.1037888526916504,
0.3690715432167053,
-0.563510000705719,
0.07165572047233582,
0.12794041633605957,
0.6917681694030762,
-0.20873886346817017,
0.16359148919582367,
-0.5406896471977234,
0.21857020258903503,
-0.2398391216993332,
-0.27910685539245605,
-0.47228965163230896,
-0.41132262349128723,
0.02657298371195793,
-0.21053446829319,
0.11788202822208405,
0.07202588766813278,
0.7203070521354675,
0.5055106282234192,
-0.5821818709373474,
-0.3269543945789337,
-0.6859316229820251,
0.47365713119506836,
-0.7074711322784424,
0.6375025510787964,
0.7418741583824158,
0.64703768491745,
0.19161954522132874,
-0.580084502696991,
-0.6801971793174744,
-0.2885889410972595,
-0.055815018713474274,
0.10813882201910019,
0.08804021775722504,
-0.10877522826194763,
-0.10982226580381393,
0.46951261162757874,
-0.8048549890518188,
0.2484368532896042,
-0.8889510035514832,
-0.159568190574646,
0.5081467032432556,
0.28973180055618286,
0.09994490444660187,
-0.012639863416552544,
-0.28424036502838135,
0.18259383738040924,
-0.5366342067718506,
0.24057649075984955,
0.46577978134155273,
0.4786839485168457,
-0.4875711500644684,
0.732235312461853,
-0.3068869113922119,
1.0663846731185913,
-0.13224664330482483,
0.21662184596061707,
0.30202004313468933,
-0.36659112572669983,
-0.2903839647769928,
0.7840988039970398,
0.8351985216140747,
-0.07620766758918762,
0.6251714825630188,
0.09900588542222977,
-0.05586808919906616,
-0.07394061237573624,
0.038346100598573685,
-0.6951148509979248,
-0.2373359501361847,
-0.11355824023485184,
-0.47572851181030273,
-0.29687702655792236,
-0.3433326482772827,
-0.2851293087005615,
-0.32160821557044983,
-0.6344409584999084,
-0.13603220880031586,
-0.31472644209861755,
-0.22796408832073212,
0.16574062407016754,
0.31189581751823425,
0.2819385826587677,
0.36582380533218384,
-0.4390394687652588,
0.5430740714073181,
0.19782060384750366,
1.0119638442993164,
-0.20252880454063416,
-0.2889603078365326,
-0.6722855567932129,
0.08197186142206192,
-0.2026560753583908,
0.8835338950157166,
-0.3241051733493805,
-0.40674206614494324,
-0.1243823915719986,
0.05010189861059189,
-0.1569662243127823,
-0.34408602118492126,
0.4311843812465668,
-0.7202247977256775,
0.19638372957706451,
0.41902947425842285,
-0.2845662832260132,
-0.3139611780643463,
0.18389859795570374,
-0.7867711782455444,
0.6911563873291016,
-0.13447406888008118,
-0.6357166767120361,
-0.07830873131752014,
-0.5090382099151611,
-0.8872859477996826,
0.06378669291734695,
0.010239590890705585,
-0.41840824484825134,
-0.1746632158756256,
-0.0832117572426796,
0.4003394544124603,
-0.5340690612792969,
0.41511303186416626,
0.1767655462026596,
-0.37724000215530396,
0.48133304715156555,
-0.9085204005241394,
1.1363617181777954,
0.26400840282440186,
0.022917797788977623,
0.2906076908111572,
-1.1726022958755493,
-0.08533891290426254,
0.055353038012981415,
-1.058796763420105,
0.24082058668136597,
-0.03040059469640255,
0.6205722689628601,
0.20504377782344818,
0.10759784281253815,
-0.6468007564544678,
-0.3075058162212372,
-0.5710964202880859,
0.6455746293067932,
0.703803300857544,
-0.3468523323535919,
0.16403943300247192,
0.11637420952320099,
0.13453446328639984,
0.12206609547138214,
-0.0320240817964077,
0.09223228693008423,
-0.4550390839576721,
-0.6161782145500183,
-0.07155358791351318,
0.7830747365951538,
0.8538073897361755,
-0.3506421446800232,
0.6261880397796631,
-0.13746781647205353,
-0.3206610679626465,
-0.6558211445808411,
-0.12754836678504944,
0.4344273507595062,
0.6819387078285217,
0.384381502866745,
-0.4300541877746582,
-0.7572399377822876,
-0.7038272023200989,
0.05651206150650978,
-0.30632326006889343,
0.21357601881027222,
0.028217198327183723,
0.045174550265073776,
-0.06506265699863434,
0.6838375926017761,
-0.3266479969024658,
-0.555129885673523,
-0.11266133934259415,
0.08930669724941254,
0.24724841117858887,
0.6033400893211365,
-0.1010034829378128,
-1.1200006008148193,
-0.9426348805427551,
0.22346290946006775,
-0.4524238407611847,
0.0902835801243782,
0.2877790033817291,
0.41235363483428955,
0.5446769595146179,
0.5759202837944031,
-0.18527235090732574,
0.7157205939292908,
0.42580047249794006,
-0.2209702581167221,
0.6657102108001709,
-0.21411563456058502,
0.07328353822231293,
-0.9993035793304443,
0.2845277786254883,
-0.12114734202623367,
-0.4382743537425995,
-0.6209436655044556,
-0.4864456355571747,
-0.03292200341820717,
-0.294567346572876,
-0.39257341623306274,
0.437595397233963,
-0.543495237827301,
-0.0528278686106205,
-0.2999449074268341,
-0.07145804166793823,
-0.2936383783817291,
0.30986660718917847,
0.3698793053627014,
0.8033384084701538,
0.4028238356113434,
-0.49262145161628723,
0.6180159449577332,
0.46786150336265564,
-0.44444751739501953,
0.3825633227825165,
-0.8931109309196472,
0.07545691728591919,
0.08615473657846451,
0.10794882476329803,
-1.0501083135604858,
0.11312165856361389,
0.25626713037490845,
-0.6428931951522827,
0.7575196623802185,
0.023110458627343178,
-0.6526244878768921,
-0.22656482458114624,
0.3299074172973633,
0.5103078484535217,
0.43379688262939453,
-0.34654542803764343,
0.2554994821548462,
0.39706048369407654,
-0.1768171638250351,
-0.5061593651771545,
-0.9199272394180298,
0.41200658679008484,
-0.03403113782405853,
-0.23077909648418427,
0.09252247959375381,
-0.188970685005188,
0.3089577257633209,
-0.09482415020465851,
0.26235097646713257,
-0.4014141857624054,
-0.16623535752296448,
0.15195830166339874,
-0.04780936241149902,
-0.18293020129203796,
-0.04842235893011093,
-0.14424148201942444,
-0.48010340332984924,
-0.24558119475841522,
-0.061590541154146194,
0.6631117463111877,
-0.46943894028663635,
-0.20134705305099487,
-0.9034460186958313,
0.5278140306472778,
0.43506526947021484,
-0.4582287073135376,
0.4096633195877075,
0.705116331577301,
-0.5120503902435303,
0.18098516762256622,
-0.47858136892318726,
0.12279574573040009,
-0.39228013157844543,
0.5005111694335938,
-0.2646780014038086,
-0.6824612617492676,
0.4271402657032013,
0.09416873008012772,
-0.39542555809020996,
0.27929621934890747,
0.39517197012901306,
0.0605505146086216,
0.9143818020820618,
0.658329427242279,
-0.15313665568828583,
0.35046878457069397,
-0.22009220719337463,
0.14589175581932068,
-1.1717931032180786,
-0.3036171495914459,
-0.7163669466972351,
-0.05874431133270264,
-0.41546446084976196,
-0.2360965609550476,
0.17775274813175201,
-0.07613313943147659,
-0.4583919048309326,
0.4722497761249542,
-0.7969567179679871,
0.14384648203849792,
0.576793909072876,
0.09151618927717209,
0.4358501732349396,
0.11532841622829437,
-0.11093780398368835,
0.18605758249759674,
-0.6677536368370056,
-0.2827187180519104,
0.7671990394592285,
0.14307089149951935,
0.6808202862739563,
-0.030207496136426926,
0.2586556077003479,
0.39831608533859253,
0.08105636388063431,
-0.7066424489021301,
0.4528801143169403,
-0.42951056361198425,
-0.4308546185493469,
-0.46379581093788147,
-0.28012633323669434,
-0.6858897805213928,
-0.07576636970043182,
0.19291524589061737,
-0.38062185049057007,
0.3585968613624573,
-0.05341548100113869,
-0.27317747473716736,
0.21352587640285492,
-0.45950499176979065,
0.4953038692474365,
-0.28966596722602844,
0.14168551564216614,
-0.3169652819633484,
-1.338679552078247,
0.10818380862474442,
0.039783328771591187,
-0.28436464071273804,
-0.011558658443391323,
0.057366881519556046,
0.8785799145698547,
-0.18181486427783966,
1.108098030090332,
0.08542810380458832,
0.20317216217517853,
0.41504934430122375,
-0.1220281794667244,
0.35932645201683044,
-0.32033446431159973,
-0.50948166847229,
0.4414936304092407,
-0.17288832366466522,
-0.08602933585643768,
-0.04805487021803856,
0.373320609331131,
-0.7691314220428467,
-0.12728281319141388,
-0.6395577192306519,
-0.2084154635667801,
0.11633801460266113,
0.2389240264892578,
0.25026389956474304,
0.6249631643295288,
-0.2874406576156616,
0.4525817334651947,
0.35674139857292175,
-0.11373762041330338,
0.5400221943855286,
0.6401629447937012,
0.2069377899169922,
-0.8267523050308228,
0.8855025172233582,
0.39188772439956665,
0.0758184865117073,
0.33921417593955994,
0.24206724762916565,
-0.48585858941078186,
-0.713013768196106,
-0.7847456336021423,
0.10103567689657211,
-0.7452136278152466,
-0.5526842474937439,
-0.5361542701721191,
-0.8460659384727478,
-0.20689646899700165,
0.020311003550887108,
-0.2691086530685425,
-0.3916513919830322,
-0.8723470568656921,
-0.0010375144192948937,
0.5310171842575073,
0.6115574836730957,
-0.009744795970618725,
0.5546178221702576,
-0.6347731947898865,
0.31350767612457275,
0.14013797044754028,
0.28720954060554504,
0.16603367030620575,
-0.7095206379890442,
-0.4241398870944977,
0.028074966743588448,
-0.13429543375968933,
-0.8097768425941467,
0.6499179601669312,
0.5354768633842468,
0.16786181926727295,
0.18390709161758423,
-0.04623141512274742,
0.4834590554237366,
-0.8551607728004456,
0.6006523966789246,
0.5460123419761658,
-0.8311043977737427,
0.45444485545158386,
-0.1343824714422226,
0.21367311477661133,
0.4350804388523102,
0.1960894912481308,
-0.6522465944290161,
0.04589129611849785,
-0.25210756063461304,
-0.4870296120643616,
0.6735461950302124,
0.07943905144929886,
-0.2995162606239319,
0.14107605814933777,
0.14132487773895264,
0.07699330151081085,
0.4454152286052704,
-0.5939390063285828,
-0.06929168850183487,
-0.32676783204078674,
-0.5322269797325134,
-0.1829313039779663,
-0.27046242356300354,
0.1244375929236412,
-0.5232695937156677,
0.6335306167602539,
-0.18888935446739197,
0.19890610873699188,
0.337904691696167,
-0.02404959499835968,
-0.26666441559791565,
0.20587772130966187,
0.8114245533943176,
0.21763403713703156,
0.003872309345752001,
0.26401978731155396,
0.3461184501647949,
-0.527353823184967,
0.37521299719810486,
0.36018699407577515,
-0.04259681701660156,
-0.027069561183452606,
0.13283102214336395,
0.7672681212425232,
0.01763622649013996,
-0.4718255400657654,
0.45013856887817383,
-0.2164284735918045,
0.11205654591321945,
-0.5993398427963257,
-0.29591676592826843,
0.06300291419029236,
0.19368790090084076,
0.3303055465221405,
0.28557050228118896,
0.316056489944458,
-0.2840963900089264,
0.0760817602276802,
0.1719488799571991,
-0.7209043502807617,
-0.394547700881958,
0.6623104214668274,
0.1411079615354538,
-0.8595232963562012,
1.0478744506835938,
0.08562256395816803,
-0.8107309937477112,
0.7407649755477905,
0.836635410785675,
1.0184768438339233,
-0.731499433517456,
0.0682259052991867,
0.3289916217327118,
0.1692408174276352,
0.04218414053320885,
0.30444204807281494,
-0.3151130676269531,
-0.2545315623283386,
-0.31873610615730286,
-0.9462910890579224,
-0.13765601813793182,
-0.12600325047969818,
-0.4629427194595337,
0.5560797452926636,
-0.29194480180740356,
0.14521284401416779,
-0.3702425956726074,
-0.005434014368802309,
-0.5516059994697571,
0.4795398414134979,
-0.15052711963653564,
0.8350780010223389,
-0.6365396976470947,
1.0243462324142456,
0.34911462664604187,
-0.4441533088684082,
-0.5197158455848694,
-0.18199148774147034,
-0.2039153128862381,
-0.9283167719841003,
0.9713477492332458,
0.16358071565628052,
-0.29800185561180115,
0.28787440061569214,
-0.3261902630329132,
-0.7611343264579773,
0.878889262676239,
0.10280241072177887,
-0.5927847027778625,
-0.011758636683225632,
0.2508707046508789,
0.6940532326698303,
-0.41096335649490356,
-0.0002151087683159858,
0.2215726524591446,
0.40674835443496704,
0.19377774000167847,
-1.1545575857162476,
0.03852146118879318,
-0.4814215302467346,
-0.022710217162966728,
0.011590869165956974,
-0.762022852897644,
0.5369321703910828,
-0.23288649320602417,
-0.23647405207157135,
0.2575855851173401,
0.76304030418396,
0.11085747182369232,
0.32554903626441956,
0.4633435606956482,
0.4438021779060364,
0.46212098002433777,
0.24615764617919922,
0.6234912276268005,
-0.09057022631168365,
-0.06156393885612488,
1.0722582340240479,
-0.36319687962532043,
1.1887807846069336,
0.3166108727455139,
-0.21167011559009552,
0.3142412006855011,
0.8544989228248596,
0.09348886460065842,
0.7281400561332703,
0.48358234763145447,
-0.2432464063167572,
0.003646208206191659,
-0.2928209900856018,
-0.4773118495941162,
0.6181689500808716,
0.3609791696071625,
-0.24754951894283295,
-0.12549711763858795,
0.1562289297580719,
-0.5356111526489258,
0.07270269840955734,
-0.06619575619697571,
0.9244948029518127,
0.3290145993232727,
-0.09445656836032867,
0.8489978313446045,
-0.01749986596405506,
0.5727712512016296,
-0.5599108934402466,
-0.18626202642917633,
0.31800466775894165,
0.08821885287761688,
-0.2449740171432495,
-0.7257305979728699,
0.6235765814781189,
0.018946373835206032,
-0.38235169649124146,
-0.006307872012257576,
0.7130494117736816,
-0.7858617305755615,
-0.6142194271087646,
0.23137423396110535,
-0.06979761272668839,
0.42519083619117737,
-0.024249857291579247,
-0.5878381133079529,
0.06673184782266617,
-0.1673455834388733,
-0.002609489718452096,
0.11109685897827148,
0.1951751857995987,
-0.019995877519249916,
0.6954400539398193,
0.7919571995735168,
0.4235965311527252,
0.14325128495693207,
0.18075060844421387,
0.7075156569480896,
-0.5577048659324646,
-0.8521666526794434,
-0.6326569318771362,
0.5798551440238953,
-0.026548778638243675,
-0.304557740688324,
0.32365840673446655,
0.7150492072105408,
0.48083677887916565,
0.03507184982299805,
0.5633823871612549,
0.2869289517402649,
0.5366612672805786,
-0.3335036635398865,
1.1162312030792236,
-0.5131847858428955,
0.06134176254272461,
0.22392283380031586,
-0.5375500917434692,
-0.462488055229187,
0.6066471338272095,
0.025543179363012314,
0.006244555115699768,
0.5708005428314209,
0.5154114365577698,
-0.09936518967151642,
0.32500147819519043,
0.31142979860305786,
0.18236829340457916,
0.20378193259239197,
0.34906408190727234,
0.7919265627861023,
-0.7670669555664062,
0.5713173151016235,
-0.09193721413612366,
-0.09229575842618942,
-0.4018900394439697,
-0.6959848403930664,
-0.685483992099762,
-1.1241295337677002,
-0.34601953625679016,
-0.2800788879394531,
0.23698747158050537,
0.62309330701828,
0.7364266514778137,
-0.7839595079421997,
-0.5088216066360474,
-0.26191645860671997,
0.04746777564287186,
-0.16027510166168213,
-0.1717081069946289,
0.7968131899833679,
0.04520628601312637,
-0.49923059344291687,
0.5487328767776489,
0.1691552698612213,
0.2173735648393631,
-0.15803980827331543,
-0.27993160486221313,
-0.6605983972549438,
-0.2570488452911377,
0.46696510910987854,
0.4125640094280243,
-0.63552325963974,
-0.07398747652769089,
-0.04322155565023422,
-0.10177963227033615,
0.3169623613357544,
0.5339135527610779,
-0.7477583289146423,
0.48161908984184265,
0.5750245451927185,
0.5811172127723694,
0.5657120943069458,
-0.12243858724832535,
0.49867013096809387,
-0.5395123958587646,
0.04668504744768143,
0.4471350908279419,
0.20813506841659546,
0.7954373359680176,
-0.5508911609649658,
0.43774667382240295,
0.17949648201465607,
-0.7098857760429382,
-1.124781608581543,
0.09077117592096329,
-0.9994233846664429,
0.03640107437968254,
0.9199476838111877,
0.1099846288561821,
-0.3157285749912262,
-0.30874747037887573,
-0.4266282916069031,
0.7479615211486816,
-0.3066481053829193,
0.5455795526504517,
0.32788535952568054,
-0.035001110285520554,
-0.2612454295158386,
-0.3909153938293457,
0.3186233341693878,
0.09981109946966171,
-0.510909378528595,
0.23667195439338684,
0.21433937549591064,
0.2871127426624298,
0.05747980996966362,
0.563728392124176,
-0.1726686805486679,
0.3177452087402344,
-0.095904141664505,
0.08607487380504608,
-0.43867918848991394,
-0.6505409479141235,
-0.8922721147537231,
0.10985533893108368,
-0.13401103019714355,
-0.4011249244213104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17484v1 | MedCare: Advancing Medical LLMs through Decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge Aggregation | 2024-06-25T12:05:56 | 2024-06-25T12:05:56 | Yusheng Liao, Shuyang Jiang, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown substantial progress in natural
language understanding and generation, proving valuable especially in the
medical field. Despite advancements, challenges persist due to the complexity
and diversity inherent in medical tasks, which can be categorized as
knowledge-intensive tasks and alignment-required tasks. Previous approaches
either ignore the latter task or focus on a minority of tasks and hence lose
generalization. To address these drawbacks, we propose a progressive
fine-tuning pipeline. This pipeline employs a Knowledge Aggregator and a Noise
aggregator to encode diverse knowledge in the first stage and filter out
detrimental information. In the second stage, we drop the Noise Aggregator to
avoid the interference of suboptimal representation and leverage an additional
alignment module optimized towards an orthogonal direction to the knowledge
space to mitigate knowledge forgetting. Based on this two-stage paradigm, we
proposed a Medical LLM through decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge
Aggregation (MedCare), which is designed to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on over 20 medical tasks, as well as SOTA results on specific
medical alignment tasks. Various model sizes of MedCare (1.8B, 7B, 14B) all
demonstrate significant improvements over existing models with similar model
sizes. | [
-0.016591867431998253,
-0.5601757764816284,
0.7401204109191895,
-0.2885434627532959,
-0.24055445194244385,
0.04998503997921944,
-0.07781121879816055,
-0.3828034996986389,
0.09443081170320511,
0.5857364535331726,
-0.9291052222251892,
-0.7027906179428101,
-0.7947977781295776,
0.00713725620880723,
-0.22331731021404266,
1.0208195447921753,
0.00705906143411994,
0.2185276746749878,
-0.3436053395271301,
-0.25380027294158936,
-0.45920437574386597,
-0.040092285722494125,
-0.9840402007102966,
-0.4813152551651001,
0.5900111794471741,
0.16145142912864685,
0.7026546597480774,
0.9951081275939941,
0.7565363049507141,
0.31644901633262634,
-0.2052335888147354,
0.7101383805274963,
-0.4880983233451843,
0.197211354970932,
-0.22264160215854645,
-0.46819406747817993,
-0.9345008134841919,
-0.3035121262073517,
0.664706826210022,
0.9304584860801697,
-0.5663032531738281,
0.02027769759297371,
0.009100639261305332,
0.908439576625824,
-0.42224639654159546,
0.2433798909187317,
-0.4969993829727173,
-0.03826012462377548,
-0.04169900342822075,
-0.13810676336288452,
0.02528073638677597,
-0.2539291977882385,
0.0014123305445536971,
-0.6455564498901367,
-0.030960286036133766,
-0.05454735830426216,
0.7967390418052673,
0.7722017168998718,
-0.26937922835350037,
-0.2710210978984833,
-0.5513063073158264,
0.8402665257453918,
-0.8978434205055237,
0.37603822350502014,
0.21262948215007782,
0.2100406289100647,
-0.2729147970676422,
-0.9669360518455505,
-0.22504441440105438,
0.2441737949848175,
0.12614765763282776,
0.4105783700942993,
-0.34666723012924194,
0.2734176218509674,
-0.15318900346755981,
0.5375583171844482,
-0.3913670778274536,
0.6589819192886353,
-0.5392098426818848,
-0.07014524936676025,
0.4559212625026703,
0.6430420279502869,
0.37309974431991577,
0.23626655340194702,
-0.27052438259124756,
0.5278934836387634,
-0.8681743741035461,
-0.3278943598270416,
-0.27683424949645996,
0.18411460518836975,
-0.22144019603729248,
0.519323468208313,
-0.22771963477134705,
0.804684042930603,
-0.027686433866620064,
-0.5961843132972717,
0.2448519468307495,
-0.29396361112594604,
-0.5795418620109558,
0.039170198142528534,
0.671348512172699,
0.4885905086994171,
-0.02846948802471161,
-0.22401900589466095,
-0.06088536977767944,
0.527370810508728,
0.3595612645149231,
-0.5426505208015442,
-0.08578675985336304,
0.5622841119766235,
-0.7215004563331604,
-0.4013880491256714,
-0.4991879165172577,
-0.3256199359893799,
-0.641198992729187,
-0.7213944792747498,
0.15949329733848572,
-0.5644329786300659,
-0.19430209696292877,
0.5948812365531921,
0.3165164291858673,
0.04374712333083153,
0.39240407943725586,
-0.7275416851043701,
0.3490641415119171,
1.0280424356460571,
0.7333391308784485,
-0.27685385942459106,
-0.01429854054003954,
-0.4713040888309479,
0.22603178024291992,
-0.15697601437568665,
0.8108713626861572,
-0.3526056408882141,
-0.10081122070550919,
0.03358428180217743,
0.01117150578647852,
-0.2599536180496216,
-0.8318758606910706,
0.4677104353904724,
-0.34114232659339905,
0.3262571096420288,
0.11671999841928482,
-0.8923813700675964,
-0.07671402394771576,
0.3933389186859131,
-0.38719743490219116,
0.6346392631530762,
0.3537410497665405,
-0.6083769798278809,
0.4665966033935547,
-0.6099653244018555,
-0.31181371212005615,
0.18284159898757935,
-0.3813594579696655,
-0.568157434463501,
0.25869232416152954,
0.2832629084587097,
0.3969973921775818,
-0.6017183661460876,
0.6174505949020386,
0.04216255247592926,
-0.30778712034225464,
-0.05241826921701431,
-0.15199986100196838,
0.5157088041305542,
0.3126177191734314,
0.03523806482553482,
0.2280901074409485,
-0.8720169067382812,
-0.2577625811100006,
-0.13573504984378815,
-0.5292852520942688,
-0.26302680373191833,
0.14032521843910217,
-0.3944554626941681,
0.305400013923645,
0.2738606333732605,
-0.4052188992500305,
0.31114625930786133,
-0.7151248455047607,
0.5265293717384338,
0.4771849811077118,
0.08710947632789612,
0.37027600407600403,
-0.7738608717918396,
0.6551019549369812,
0.3848332464694977,
0.40609660744667053,
-0.03467278182506561,
-0.5512794852256775,
-0.5471792817115784,
-0.6716893315315247,
0.1574321687221527,
0.5249408483505249,
-0.45938724279403687,
0.37750890851020813,
-0.4565400183200836,
-0.2830594778060913,
-1.1917603015899658,
0.31315693259239197,
0.33634868264198303,
0.9622341990470886,
0.5614492893218994,
-0.3840157091617584,
-0.488162636756897,
-0.8771474361419678,
-0.29217997193336487,
0.07142472267150879,
-0.11561083048582077,
0.2625080943107605,
-0.07319114357233047,
-0.9097511768341064,
0.7048882842063904,
-0.4213356077671051,
-0.7825843691825867,
-0.2857540249824524,
-0.22764764726161957,
0.519487738609314,
0.44983863830566406,
0.07705752551555634,
-0.45926761627197266,
-0.01231348980218172,
0.11023753881454468,
-0.7162303924560547,
-0.18976546823978424,
0.15371501445770264,
-0.09068790078163147,
0.057379286736249924,
0.6585372686386108,
-0.5620891451835632,
0.12309008091688156,
0.8695793747901917,
-0.45352163910865784,
0.18496087193489075,
-0.34689217805862427,
-0.17304128408432007,
-1.4520759582519531,
0.0029299433808773756,
-0.24564917385578156,
-0.296191543340683,
-0.6428980827331543,
-0.05865954980254173,
0.004346526227891445,
0.23042340576648712,
-0.37767067551612854,
0.45431461930274963,
-0.3591066300868988,
0.45011723041534424,
-0.275147944688797,
0.05085065960884094,
0.027090150862932205,
0.10855989903211594,
-0.20197845995426178,
0.33102402091026306,
0.5906865000724792,
-0.6974431276321411,
0.09112272411584854,
0.32353585958480835,
-0.2919606566429138,
0.5911473035812378,
-0.38269588351249695,
-0.2560141384601593,
-0.28295472264289856,
0.0455114021897316,
-0.6576683521270752,
-0.29168975353240967,
0.03126680478453636,
-0.1797470897436142,
0.49755042791366577,
-0.1629323661327362,
-0.2703653573989868,
-0.11828037351369858,
0.06204734370112419,
0.4823271334171295,
0.6478556990623474,
-0.17567318677902222,
0.6777782440185547,
0.6182300448417664,
-0.38608458638191223,
-0.4084543287754059,
-0.6847600340843201,
-0.0036528268828988075,
-0.2125181257724762,
-0.5899252891540527,
0.350507915019989,
0.2656107544898987,
-0.20896248519420624,
-0.0005994969396851957,
-0.19233247637748718,
0.008129304274916649,
-0.13875658810138702,
0.20902298390865326,
0.44098347425460815,
-0.36901232600212097,
0.42634594440460205,
0.4983997941017151,
-0.33394575119018555,
-0.01115484070032835,
-0.5954130291938782,
0.4490063190460205,
0.31578296422958374,
-0.4282379746437073,
-0.4695907533168793,
0.3597147464752197,
0.771062970161438,
-0.21587955951690674,
0.8979130387306213,
0.5802420377731323,
-0.5383555889129639,
0.13529205322265625,
-0.7833957672119141,
-0.1322508305311203,
-0.4188934862613678,
0.5969828367233276,
0.17525440454483032,
-1.2674986124038696,
0.4557516276836395,
-0.6372014284133911,
0.4368036985397339,
0.5254467725753784,
0.757007360458374,
-0.27972137928009033,
0.9922446012496948,
0.5234817862510681,
-0.11967071145772934,
0.06200239807367325,
-0.16290317475795746,
0.11426052451133728,
-0.9370220303535461,
-0.40776297450065613,
-0.20172467827796936,
-0.4850034713745117,
-0.42429935932159424,
-0.5299022197723389,
0.5425254106521606,
0.020776987075805664,
-0.36686721444129944,
-0.15868468582630157,
-0.560288667678833,
0.10389761626720428,
0.4130210876464844,
0.4432685375213623,
0.6078269481658936,
0.04369413107633591,
-0.2149515450000763,
-0.03855856508016586,
-0.9607909321784973,
-0.22409716248512268,
1.0839985609054565,
0.5174724459648132,
0.7506705522537231,
0.0960782915353775,
0.8295650482177734,
-0.15635797381401062,
0.4915864169597626,
-0.8678480386734009,
0.2583256959915161,
-0.710622251033783,
-0.26220595836639404,
-0.15501314401626587,
-0.44285979866981506,
-1.146000623703003,
0.06591587513685226,
-0.16368676722049713,
-0.509096086025238,
0.034718986600637436,
0.35075804591178894,
-0.6760252714157104,
0.21047133207321167,
-0.2912781834602356,
0.6761190891265869,
0.04275010526180267,
-0.19744044542312622,
-0.24429672956466675,
-0.7879909873008728,
0.4063100218772888,
-0.10885778069496155,
0.6220359802246094,
-0.26843464374542236,
-0.3596089780330658,
0.5738486051559448,
-0.48724889755249023,
0.91911381483078,
-0.10553144663572311,
-0.29544922709465027,
0.01852979138493538,
-0.022714193910360336,
0.37086865305900574,
-0.1296367645263672,
0.08679059147834778,
0.11890464276075363,
-0.009677783586084843,
-0.24131464958190918,
-0.36428502202033997,
0.6110349893569946,
-0.5525938868522644,
-0.3882574439048767,
-0.03298645466566086,
-1.0045166015625,
-0.48238393664360046,
0.35844725370407104,
0.2729589343070984,
0.5742779970169067,
0.07551181316375732,
0.02193603850901127,
0.7443995475769043,
-0.19352790713310242,
0.037993963807821274,
0.6878483891487122,
-0.058068521320819855,
-0.411188006401062,
0.6964312195777893,
-0.07098431885242462,
0.359291672706604,
0.35792839527130127,
0.2166191190481186,
-0.3377628028392792,
-0.8323637843132019,
-0.08197035640478134,
0.4056352376937866,
-0.4789641797542572,
-0.5239831805229187,
-0.7151303887367249,
-0.33879920840263367,
-0.2932579219341278,
-0.06110734865069389,
-0.49224820733070374,
-0.2578509449958801,
-0.4856278896331787,
0.11980235576629639,
0.27367058396339417,
0.6929178833961487,
0.1721469610929489,
0.3168379068374634,
-1.0795104503631592,
0.45250311493873596,
0.07376796007156372,
0.4525013566017151,
-0.2566147744655609,
-0.4842884838581085,
-0.3408629596233368,
-0.09153148531913757,
-0.21918267011642456,
-0.41977518796920776,
0.4300273656845093,
0.20801186561584473,
0.34460413455963135,
0.6767840385437012,
-0.10117883235216141,
0.9329434633255005,
-0.6742632389068604,
0.5085069537162781,
0.5395507216453552,
-0.4292707145214081,
0.49096813797950745,
-0.3506137728691101,
0.6104443073272705,
0.6039701700210571,
-0.01609937846660614,
-0.463256299495697,
-0.7382691502571106,
-0.5535954236984253,
-0.903954029083252,
0.29891833662986755,
-0.15136666595935822,
-0.11693139374256134,
0.009586541913449764,
0.4038660526275635,
0.05371876060962677,
0.2541752755641937,
-0.1446821391582489,
-0.07213417440652847,
0.5188659429550171,
-0.8889972567558289,
-0.015794476494193077,
-0.19054019451141357,
-0.6463390588760376,
-0.3709663152694702,
0.36110028624534607,
-0.15644171833992004,
0.12248922884464264,
0.27544236183166504,
0.02614172361791134,
-0.20188212394714355,
0.3648851811885834,
0.531650960445404,
0.6088609099388123,
0.11039263010025024,
-0.0749799981713295,
0.08676410466432571,
-0.7946695685386658,
-0.06032104790210724,
0.21184831857681274,
-0.06346781551837921,
-0.1597042679786682,
0.5064191818237305,
0.6610047221183777,
0.5103200078010559,
-0.7845585346221924,
0.35955220460891724,
0.05951637402176857,
-0.3920424282550812,
-0.007363373413681984,
0.22223319113254547,
0.488955557346344,
0.4107893407344818,
-0.07200825959444046,
0.3418995440006256,
0.1618427336215973,
-0.33103683590888977,
0.2411104142665863,
0.32284775376319885,
-0.5832622647285461,
0.04997244477272034,
0.8091298937797546,
0.08677775412797928,
-0.07636088877916336,
0.628199577331543,
0.26129648089408875,
-0.09739511460065842,
0.3825626075267792,
0.5146027207374573,
0.625618040561676,
-0.2633267939090729,
-0.24359972774982452,
0.089195616543293,
0.17558568716049194,
-0.3265842795372009,
0.5333603620529175,
0.2520523965358734,
-0.6868063807487488,
-0.7246761322021484,
-0.7633563280105591,
-0.11412150412797928,
0.059924375265836716,
-0.7484465837478638,
0.1519111692905426,
-0.19833026826381683,
-0.2591831386089325,
-0.28045856952667236,
-0.16113947331905365,
-0.807674765586853,
0.3859046995639801,
-0.04183250293135643,
0.9197115898132324,
-0.5904878973960876,
0.7987410426139832,
0.8668908476829529,
-0.029669493436813354,
-0.9010288119316101,
-0.2781051993370056,
0.2135399580001831,
-1.0861525535583496,
0.1293552666902542,
-0.10152889043092728,
0.013097230345010757,
0.08715538680553436,
-0.2677503526210785,
-0.711290717124939,
1.4490348100662231,
0.42860859632492065,
-1.047162413597107,
-0.2891483008861542,
0.05695480480790138,
0.5277416110038757,
-0.5737879276275635,
-0.291767954826355,
0.9176539778709412,
0.16995356976985931,
0.07545667141675949,
-1.007755994796753,
0.14538943767547607,
0.06218421831727028,
-0.23595485091209412,
0.2950355112552643,
-0.47956204414367676,
0.7008959650993347,
-0.3083954155445099,
-0.14244605600833893,
0.2430962324142456,
0.15741021931171417,
0.4815160036087036,
0.372836709022522,
0.31111302971839905,
0.9984963536262512,
0.9284034967422485,
-0.1664215475320816,
0.9735527634620667,
-0.44811782240867615,
0.2703629732131958,
1.1122668981552124,
-0.11164749413728714,
0.5845734477043152,
0.6289255619049072,
-0.22436897456645966,
0.40712836384773254,
0.4159946143627167,
0.24929837882518768,
0.435639888048172,
-0.007634333334863186,
-0.46221858263015747,
-0.38315823674201965,
-0.1602761298418045,
-0.39398300647735596,
0.43036627769470215,
0.632668137550354,
-0.8428612351417542,
-0.28125616908073425,
-0.19783245027065277,
0.16912467777729034,
0.02913576364517212,
-0.6364603042602539,
1.2806862592697144,
0.37896692752838135,
-0.7051035761833191,
0.5244483947753906,
-0.19943176209926605,
0.45513078570365906,
-0.7216584086418152,
-0.05621218681335449,
-0.31432509422302246,
0.5248643159866333,
-0.3973267078399658,
-0.41322702169418335,
0.298247754573822,
-0.2736414074897766,
-0.2512402832508087,
-0.07042457163333893,
0.760214626789093,
-0.6283296346664429,
-0.6654286980628967,
0.15247610211372375,
0.6111552715301514,
0.014651506207883358,
0.2353612333536148,
-0.6107566356658936,
0.12039469927549362,
-0.10140124708414078,
0.15325602889060974,
0.40379098057746887,
0.48398056626319885,
0.24009397625923157,
0.8339000344276428,
0.5498088598251343,
0.6637389063835144,
0.022275123745203018,
0.389618843793869,
1.126242995262146,
-0.40450841188430786,
-0.42577025294303894,
-0.8943695425987244,
0.632535457611084,
0.008624952286481857,
-0.28384312987327576,
0.18672436475753784,
0.47013917565345764,
0.23265551030635834,
0.024412330240011215,
0.6635458469390869,
0.312686562538147,
0.7865856289863586,
-0.6482108235359192,
0.8324941992759705,
-0.7350326180458069,
0.37620285153388977,
-0.07901810109615326,
-0.43568873405456543,
-0.7319524884223938,
0.3157346248626709,
0.06259451806545258,
-0.2742707431316376,
0.5614951848983765,
0.695956289768219,
-0.10793188214302063,
-0.12603719532489777,
0.4250560998916626,
0.4404527544975281,
0.3407432734966278,
0.7767297029495239,
0.5009649395942688,
-0.3143196403980255,
0.2878798842430115,
0.10775298625230789,
-0.5352250337600708,
-0.036606334149837494,
-0.6991356611251831,
-0.608239471912384,
-0.15829798579216003,
-0.475111186504364,
-0.3331410884857178,
0.10520699620246887,
0.8033151030540466,
0.7173557281494141,
-0.7763938307762146,
0.12731273472309113,
-0.2940084636211395,
-0.10210374742746353,
-0.4602523148059845,
-0.12549230456352234,
0.42613914608955383,
-0.6311773061752319,
-0.5127698183059692,
0.44555020332336426,
0.8406378626823425,
-0.25479137897491455,
-0.18111571669578552,
-0.14118412137031555,
0.06443621963262558,
-0.09711305052042007,
0.5334306359291077,
0.12886850535869598,
-0.8021906614303589,
0.1347426027059555,
-0.11112937331199646,
-0.12122512608766556,
0.08080001920461655,
0.7782440185546875,
-0.8036882281303406,
0.4777708947658539,
0.020496532320976257,
0.7650412917137146,
0.12130662053823471,
0.09919363260269165,
0.6851006150245667,
-0.4672870337963104,
0.05276228487491608,
0.49144747853279114,
0.4735366106033325,
0.07584282755851746,
-0.31873568892478943,
0.3985823094844818,
0.04143428057432175,
-0.6463986039161682,
-0.6924574971199036,
0.33155110478401184,
-0.942060112953186,
-0.19786590337753296,
0.969536304473877,
-0.14314840734004974,
0.09460017085075378,
-0.28269994258880615,
-0.21648432314395905,
0.4543226957321167,
-0.04344504326581955,
0.9348370432853699,
0.3136569559574127,
-0.3374260365962982,
-0.16640456020832062,
-0.46140924096107483,
0.5915798544883728,
0.4909251630306244,
-0.7857093214988708,
-0.13992518186569214,
0.37056881189346313,
0.4509456157684326,
-0.14900724589824677,
0.8951817154884338,
-0.7112252712249756,
0.24525544047355652,
-0.428762286901474,
-0.2298652082681656,
-0.053109683096408844,
-0.11249378323554993,
-0.37857794761657715,
0.11408881098031998,
0.038105711340904236,
-0.2927052974700928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17474v1 | Transformer-based Named Entity Recognition with Combined Data Representation | 2024-06-25T11:41:16 | 2024-06-25T11:41:16 | Michał Marcińczuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study examines transformer-based models and their effectiveness in named
entity recognition tasks. The study investigates data representation
strategies, including single, merged, and context, which respectively use one
sentence, multiple sentences, and sentences joined with attention to context
per vector. Analysis shows that training models with a single strategy may lead
to poor performance on different data representations. To address this
limitation, the study proposes a combined training procedure that utilizes all
three strategies to improve model stability and adaptability. The results of
this approach are presented and discussed for four languages (English, Polish,
Czech, and German) across various datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of
the combined strategy. | [
-0.5203962922096252,
-0.1981223076581955,
0.510829508304596,
0.1414627730846405,
-0.3839021623134613,
0.0461881123483181,
-0.3861651122570038,
-0.515902578830719,
0.3001936972141266,
0.5775629878044128,
-0.4574242830276489,
-0.28947535157203674,
-0.7184625267982483,
0.47613731026649475,
-0.44136643409729004,
0.952319860458374,
-0.3595529794692993,
0.589683473110199,
-0.21996670961380005,
-0.5511636734008789,
-0.8830851316452026,
-0.6870537400245667,
-0.6664431095123291,
-0.4861550033092499,
0.5280357599258423,
0.3352334499359131,
0.4136338531970978,
0.5760312080383301,
0.8376421332359314,
0.19792440533638,
0.17213034629821777,
0.041490279138088226,
-0.42501649260520935,
0.20471903681755066,
-0.15579882264137268,
-0.5276570916175842,
-0.035362470895051956,
-0.06884370744228363,
0.8115928173065186,
0.7595750689506531,
0.014230417087674141,
-0.06623408943414688,
-0.1368492692708969,
0.32718417048454285,
-0.4560786187648773,
0.2057182937860489,
-0.617760181427002,
0.22128571569919586,
-0.26533302664756775,
-0.18669138848781586,
-0.6793949007987976,
0.04105581343173981,
0.27625951170921326,
-0.569705069065094,
0.35536983609199524,
0.028828324750065804,
0.8723239898681641,
0.3265884816646576,
-0.610714852809906,
-0.29292821884155273,
-1.2944165468215942,
0.834476113319397,
-0.3198438584804535,
0.7951104044914246,
-0.06425216048955917,
0.45511317253112793,
-0.04111066460609436,
-0.7911840677261353,
-0.6131612658500671,
0.0816139280796051,
-0.42616140842437744,
0.0850479006767273,
-0.28286904096603394,
-0.15925820171833038,
0.4420044422149658,
0.16448581218719482,
-0.2785812318325043,
0.12362753599882126,
-0.42039754986763,
-0.1458008885383606,
0.5784806609153748,
0.013208989053964615,
0.31268900632858276,
-0.06456837803125381,
-0.6933587193489075,
-0.2721497416496277,
-0.6954529285430908,
0.16679659485816956,
0.11330579221248627,
0.6949119567871094,
0.14398296177387238,
0.5375229120254517,
0.028459759429097176,
0.5777950882911682,
0.14508475363254547,
-0.17325465381145477,
0.27364495396614075,
0.013588604517281055,
-0.3193684220314026,
0.22030586004257202,
0.5854538679122925,
0.10722995549440384,
0.10037887841463089,
-0.8151198029518127,
-0.33389654755592346,
0.16770604252815247,
0.5898508429527283,
-0.46603289246559143,
-0.21484404802322388,
0.11885029077529907,
-0.46639057993888855,
-0.17137427628040314,
0.45597466826438904,
-0.7741872668266296,
-0.17428120970726013,
-0.49319806694984436,
0.5308576226234436,
-0.472553014755249,
-0.22142520546913147,
0.07519949227571487,
-0.36061176657676697,
0.3140168786048889,
0.19906798005104065,
-0.8818386793136597,
0.5638250112533569,
0.3483799397945404,
0.4833618104457855,
-0.4872276484966278,
-0.2205396443605423,
-0.3658261299133301,
0.3239000737667084,
-0.02070663869380951,
1.00583016872406,
-0.565737783908844,
-0.4280318319797516,
-0.3385585844516754,
0.3045954406261444,
-0.45712870359420776,
-0.4945526123046875,
0.7185882329940796,
-0.6765162944793701,
0.36029356718063354,
-0.1315322369337082,
-0.7800998687744141,
-0.4456535577774048,
0.08614510297775269,
-1.3926337957382202,
0.9302002787590027,
0.030006177723407745,
-1.1448456048965454,
0.6110227704048157,
-0.7917855978012085,
-0.4336860477924347,
0.2538681924343109,
-0.3194146454334259,
-0.6564618349075317,
0.068088598549366,
0.3334718644618988,
0.6642720699310303,
-0.08077162504196167,
0.31580257415771484,
0.1964476853609085,
-0.33294686675071716,
0.061026107519865036,
-0.33923375606536865,
0.5688340663909912,
-0.2657228410243988,
-0.1844981610774994,
-0.03901633247733116,
-0.9832352995872498,
-0.10540895909070969,
0.5740506052970886,
-0.5947303175926208,
-0.515826404094696,
0.1512015163898468,
0.43018651008605957,
-0.003962669521570206,
-0.19017797708511353,
-0.490326464176178,
0.39868342876434326,
-0.24159882962703705,
0.26326045393943787,
0.14449454843997955,
0.053753163665533066,
0.5260496139526367,
0.008536772802472115,
0.48082679510116577,
0.38605937361717224,
-0.3674752116203308,
-0.050792284309864044,
-0.30620163679122925,
-1.033232569694519,
-0.10010300576686859,
0.8177247047424316,
0.6784293055534363,
-1.0080125331878662,
0.15903456509113312,
-0.6560313701629639,
-0.4768833518028259,
-0.36904600262641907,
-0.3108656108379364,
-0.028303366154432297,
0.410525918006897,
0.7112573385238647,
-0.12498891353607178,
-0.8888986706733704,
-1.0413647890090942,
-0.2529076039791107,
0.13382749259471893,
0.12540467083454132,
0.1813712865114212,
0.6964277625083923,
-0.28035616874694824,
1.0069358348846436,
-0.28042128682136536,
-0.10913359373807907,
-0.5338101387023926,
0.11099424958229065,
0.1786523163318634,
0.3443911075592041,
0.555560827255249,
-1.268775463104248,
-0.19638021290302277,
-0.09838151931762695,
-0.4948996305465698,
0.6415178775787354,
-0.17363852262496948,
0.17624381184577942,
-0.0773533433675766,
0.2318454086780548,
-0.5644469261169434,
0.42606422305107117,
0.33515867590904236,
-0.07079648226499557,
0.18699178099632263,
-0.01124558411538601,
0.10657507926225662,
-1.1999346017837524,
-0.08329284936189651,
0.10782846063375473,
-0.3648994565010071,
-1.007966160774231,
-0.1233704686164856,
0.34238162636756897,
-0.2558821439743042,
-0.49660229682922363,
0.4195554256439209,
-0.6889505982398987,
0.08444336801767349,
-0.14834196865558624,
-0.13455615937709808,
-0.17885760962963104,
0.45863863825798035,
0.4602620005607605,
0.7220958471298218,
0.7378488183021545,
-0.6689499020576477,
0.6419926285743713,
0.34287163615226746,
-0.08403398096561432,
0.6505799889564514,
-0.5646941065788269,
0.22238007187843323,
-0.49115025997161865,
0.2767149806022644,
-0.7337385416030884,
-0.4058203399181366,
0.16944006085395813,
-0.26460975408554077,
0.725848376750946,
-0.0022140571381896734,
-0.3760988414287567,
-0.6414925456047058,
0.047353729605674744,
0.37878307700157166,
-0.05289402976632118,
-0.865976870059967,
1.0538971424102783,
0.44842296838760376,
0.1855889856815338,
-0.5077974796295166,
-0.8521376252174377,
0.18510694801807404,
-0.770696222782135,
-0.4388713538646698,
0.8604065179824829,
0.332304447889328,
0.22516515851020813,
-0.015230189077556133,
-0.1357310712337494,
-0.26233747601509094,
-0.0496659129858017,
0.16849198937416077,
0.4098491966724396,
-0.15553034842014313,
0.4151632785797119,
-0.22967752814292908,
-0.28536567091941833,
-0.2596323490142822,
-0.07634098082780838,
0.4648059606552124,
0.22190149128437042,
-0.08785925060510635,
-0.42968904972076416,
0.5686043500900269,
0.5178914070129395,
-0.3269992768764496,
1.0087817907333374,
0.4394478499889374,
-0.7275766134262085,
-0.2238570898771286,
-0.37953129410743713,
-0.059741683304309845,
-0.3189813792705536,
0.06469704210758209,
-0.6534901261329651,
-0.676605761051178,
0.5883319973945618,
-0.33610212802886963,
-0.1092769131064415,
0.5329884886741638,
0.33139628171920776,
-0.06046314910054207,
0.8003929853439331,
0.8721442818641663,
-0.1945543885231018,
0.2600630819797516,
-0.21808010339736938,
0.6740913987159729,
-0.8264116644859314,
-0.4376640319824219,
-0.5544172525405884,
-0.4277219772338867,
-0.6106578707695007,
-0.23580782115459442,
0.10452215373516083,
0.07846026867628098,
0.09833908081054688,
1.1302891969680786,
-0.623070478439331,
0.23525795340538025,
0.4931235611438751,
0.21614935994148254,
0.30812546610832214,
0.028919745236635208,
-0.12260615825653076,
-0.15491867065429688,
-0.6614312529563904,
-0.7237815260887146,
1.1034774780273438,
0.4590119421482086,
0.6111887693405151,
0.001271948218345642,
0.8150124549865723,
-0.060044459998607635,
0.07654308527708054,
-0.9270184636116028,
0.3646408021450043,
-0.06040450185537338,
-0.5018327236175537,
-0.22710704803466797,
-0.3636869192123413,
-1.053045630455017,
0.1758662313222885,
-0.3863018751144409,
-0.7470388412475586,
0.31350138783454895,
-0.147307887673378,
-0.2261246293783188,
0.2595846354961395,
-0.7360022664070129,
0.8053021430969238,
-0.30534178018569946,
0.3688676655292511,
0.2416914850473404,
-0.5230419039726257,
-0.02942880429327488,
-0.19435326755046844,
-0.047321613878011703,
0.22610773146152496,
0.025779636576771736,
1.058472990989685,
0.13421858847141266,
0.3891262710094452,
-0.11478888243436813,
0.15175022184848785,
-0.0572129487991333,
-0.45969074964523315,
0.6343640089035034,
0.07647246867418289,
0.2054944783449173,
0.36801236867904663,
-0.08793085813522339,
-0.08353595435619354,
-0.5966237187385559,
0.4056348204612732,
-0.578965961933136,
-0.25733765959739685,
-0.26229536533355713,
-0.5920777320861816,
-0.29473358392715454,
0.44808870553970337,
0.50389564037323,
0.3003341555595398,
-0.4045560657978058,
0.3232927918434143,
0.8212215304374695,
0.11612799763679504,
0.5479176044464111,
0.45003777742385864,
0.011270498856902122,
-0.44755733013153076,
0.49182844161987305,
0.27336615324020386,
-0.18722862005233765,
0.5409910082817078,
-0.35069769620895386,
-0.11076289415359497,
-0.471748411655426,
-0.40755388140678406,
0.17406591773033142,
-0.7366667985916138,
-0.4856930375099182,
-0.8352311253547668,
-0.38751015067100525,
-0.20180809497833252,
0.28401046991348267,
-0.3907625079154968,
-0.4436783790588379,
-0.31391021609306335,
-0.09721753001213074,
0.2879991829395294,
0.6440338492393494,
0.48080939054489136,
0.29878348112106323,
-0.6071155667304993,
0.41781070828437805,
0.17720289528369904,
0.5276956558227539,
-0.19822871685028076,
-0.1004306823015213,
-0.23098325729370117,
-0.16359679400920868,
-0.16711828112602234,
-1.3824489116668701,
0.13828451931476593,
0.0428064726293087,
0.9023109078407288,
0.14130014181137085,
-0.14384037256240845,
0.44866943359375,
-0.7531481385231018,
0.4998287260532379,
0.1110110729932785,
-0.7818516492843628,
0.6958355903625488,
-0.02680014818906784,
-0.04404692351818085,
0.47638559341430664,
0.6802484393119812,
-0.48106124997138977,
-0.10319209843873978,
-0.5933305025100708,
-0.6845471858978271,
0.9555270671844482,
0.43563589453697205,
0.13187438249588013,
0.14162686467170715,
0.19218429923057556,
0.08191297948360443,
-0.01570940762758255,
-1.0034551620483398,
-0.5788060426712036,
-0.03205637261271477,
-0.32092759013175964,
0.26350539922714233,
0.007341642864048481,
-0.10944189876317978,
-0.2736397981643677,
0.7217257022857666,
-0.006083718501031399,
0.6320611834526062,
0.028596676886081696,
-0.20192736387252808,
0.06327400356531143,
0.2783412039279938,
0.23008565604686737,
0.2697337567806244,
0.04575240984559059,
0.04142557457089424,
0.3551104962825775,
-0.5265231132507324,
0.19198215007781982,
0.4422927796840668,
-0.2173389494419098,
0.3998190760612488,
0.4058566391468048,
1.1460189819335938,
0.5521593689918518,
-0.29318371415138245,
0.38199785351753235,
-0.379692405462265,
0.0545000322163105,
-0.2175375074148178,
0.13570517301559448,
0.19393110275268555,
0.2934304475784302,
0.4392675757408142,
0.19191448390483856,
0.10996690392494202,
-0.21709975600242615,
0.2640180289745331,
0.4296438694000244,
-0.20513077080249786,
-0.07079256325960159,
0.5849674344062805,
-0.08834944665431976,
-0.3206770420074463,
0.5433248281478882,
0.07773050665855408,
-0.6465400457382202,
0.7122560739517212,
0.6192519068717957,
0.6908106803894043,
-0.5243978500366211,
0.08566365391016006,
0.4768013656139374,
0.12748980522155762,
-0.5238162875175476,
0.10175818204879761,
-0.08364685624837875,
-1.0584142208099365,
0.034615907818078995,
-0.3727210760116577,
-0.3890761733055115,
0.1400071531534195,
-0.9610719680786133,
0.8879958391189575,
0.055690567940473557,
-0.4343196153640747,
0.5279025435447693,
-0.092417411506176,
-1.1572339534759521,
0.3744449019432068,
0.34064972400665283,
0.8604159951210022,
-0.8207805156707764,
0.7805095911026001,
1.211847186088562,
-0.5950301885604858,
-1.0707648992538452,
-0.020610958337783813,
-0.3952677547931671,
-0.43534842133522034,
0.59035724401474,
0.4522000551223755,
0.18086011707782745,
0.09638412296772003,
-0.26927605271339417,
-1.3148837089538574,
1.3390811681747437,
0.3097783625125885,
-0.7093336582183838,
-0.3463330566883087,
0.12671653926372528,
0.5125613212585449,
-0.6870884895324707,
-0.03939029201865196,
0.6479595899581909,
0.49317264556884766,
0.1650659143924713,
-0.998447060585022,
-0.1940051168203354,
-0.08608512580394745,
0.24860668182373047,
0.3395887017250061,
-0.3527160584926605,
0.5666162967681885,
-0.008223747834563255,
-0.954258382320404,
-0.21265123784542084,
0.7381467819213867,
0.029910791665315628,
0.23343788087368011,
0.5257870554924011,
0.7907595634460449,
0.9111343622207642,
-0.4075450599193573,
0.8710609078407288,
-0.3590623140335083,
0.8461170792579651,
1.088985800743103,
-0.2598586976528168,
0.8488134145736694,
0.5649676322937012,
-0.2343287169933319,
0.476085364818573,
0.39294466376304626,
-0.5097724199295044,
0.7898270487785339,
-0.12636534869670868,
-0.022435899823904037,
0.05434447526931763,
0.0381508506834507,
-0.16956587135791779,
0.7593090534210205,
0.13835646212100983,
-0.5900693535804749,
-0.4924757480621338,
0.5967581868171692,
-0.09028467535972595,
-0.2542860507965088,
-0.23196305334568024,
0.8497452735900879,
-0.18617096543312073,
-0.4901072084903717,
0.25998690724372864,
0.1181316077709198,
0.5682972073554993,
-0.23954229056835175,
-0.07811722904443741,
0.16393107175827026,
0.057663384824991226,
-0.2672072947025299,
-0.6662980914115906,
0.33374089002609253,
0.05094209313392639,
-0.5845020413398743,
-0.12402486056089401,
0.9187872409820557,
-0.6460497379302979,
-0.8108291029930115,
0.4187459349632263,
0.2995305061340332,
0.014940406195819378,
0.08898492902517319,
-0.3961133360862732,
0.12128439545631409,
-0.0902310237288475,
-0.16048379242420197,
-0.08637075126171112,
0.28960487246513367,
-0.029753681272268295,
0.49282369017601013,
0.15707463026046753,
0.05420401319861412,
0.061549145728349686,
0.23003774881362915,
1.0152130126953125,
-0.7587511539459229,
-0.3507498502731323,
-0.6205498576164246,
0.5621035099029541,
-0.07316091656684875,
0.07798776775598526,
0.6030649542808533,
0.547936201095581,
1.0126733779907227,
-0.16337372362613678,
0.7347551584243774,
0.08707302808761597,
0.7083224654197693,
-0.48961564898490906,
0.4575887620449066,
-0.22540658712387085,
0.05244261398911476,
-0.06363719701766968,
-1.2435144186019897,
-0.44898930191993713,
0.5527116060256958,
-0.1858224868774414,
0.04809599369764328,
0.7506417036056519,
0.30935126543045044,
-0.3389904499053955,
0.13627438247203827,
0.18153899908065796,
-0.20792338252067566,
0.21529579162597656,
0.7075455784797668,
0.5244174003601074,
-0.8585144281387329,
0.2779930531978607,
-0.27794212102890015,
0.1620563417673111,
-0.02188297174870968,
-0.6967140436172485,
-0.9620797038078308,
-0.6797269582748413,
-0.3568623661994934,
0.017574282363057137,
-0.27285271883010864,
0.7383999824523926,
0.7130500674247742,
-0.96934974193573,
0.38005998730659485,
-0.052098002284765244,
-0.13506539165973663,
-0.15373985469341278,
-0.24613963067531586,
0.4032854735851288,
-0.17224591970443726,
-0.7683783173561096,
0.49914324283599854,
0.32372552156448364,
0.20691582560539246,
-0.21801583468914032,
0.27621719241142273,
-0.03553976118564606,
0.016269125044345856,
0.40365365147590637,
0.07434450089931488,
-0.7438033819198608,
-0.2457810789346695,
0.061920542269945145,
-0.17992612719535828,
0.38746193051338196,
1.0877677202224731,
-0.9624040126800537,
0.6215338110923767,
0.23688265681266785,
0.746882438659668,
0.394130140542984,
0.11968094110488892,
0.4246933162212372,
-0.6682594418525696,
0.1193455383181572,
0.2725566327571869,
0.5803348422050476,
0.7610841989517212,
-0.7345789670944214,
0.5248580574989319,
0.1663362979888916,
-0.318464457988739,
-0.5727118849754333,
-0.0038254638202488422,
-1.0998775959014893,
-0.023462504148483276,
0.8744495511054993,
-0.11913024634122849,
0.04978935047984123,
0.0011250762036070228,
-0.1219935193657875,
0.4544272720813751,
-0.22356854379177094,
0.48537254333496094,
1.0082237720489502,
-0.31940674781799316,
-0.29876112937927246,
-0.462575763463974,
0.21038173139095306,
-0.12019394338130951,
-0.7265399694442749,
-0.2141508013010025,
0.17387619614601135,
0.33633488416671753,
0.4777028560638428,
0.12915067374706268,
-0.029740840196609497,
0.017317282035946846,
-0.12485527992248535,
0.059837356209754944,
0.1429457813501358,
-0.6458082795143127,
-0.5784563422203064,
0.16740822792053223,
-0.35653749108314514,
-0.1640787124633789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17465v1 | Enhancing Tool Retrieval with Iterative Feedback from Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T11:12:01 | 2024-06-25T11:12:01 | Qiancheng Xu, Yongqi Li, Heming Xia, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool learning aims to enhance and expand large language models' (LLMs)
capabilities with external tools, which has gained significant attention
recently. Current methods have shown that LLMs can effectively handle a certain
amount of tools through in-context learning or fine-tuning. However, in
real-world scenarios, the number of tools is typically extensive and
irregularly updated, emphasizing the necessity for a dedicated tool retrieval
component. Tool retrieval is nontrivial due to the following challenges: 1)
complex user instructions and tool descriptions; 2) misalignment between tool
retrieval and tool usage models. To address the above issues, we propose to
enhance tool retrieval with iterative feedback from the large language model.
Specifically, we prompt the tool usage model, i.e., the LLM, to provide
feedback for the tool retriever model in multi-round, which could progressively
improve the tool retriever's understanding of instructions and tools and reduce
the gap between the two standalone components. We build a unified and
comprehensive benchmark to evaluate tool retrieval models. The extensive
experiments indicate that our proposed approach achieves advanced performance
in both in-domain evaluation and out-of-domain evaluation. | [
-0.1824498027563095,
-0.726473867893219,
0.6172844767570496,
0.0658593401312828,
-0.482021301984787,
0.21758486330509186,
-0.47561997175216675,
-0.4444059133529663,
0.009024964645504951,
0.4146605134010315,
-0.46236667037010193,
-0.6140264272689819,
-0.5537362694740295,
0.0060224514454603195,
-0.534633219242096,
0.7010889649391174,
0.06526488065719604,
0.2477361559867859,
-0.17060202360153198,
-0.10524272173643112,
-0.7084801197052002,
-0.6380020976066589,
-0.5122092962265015,
-0.5035207867622375,
0.4676816463470459,
0.46563521027565,
0.39097025990486145,
0.3312397301197052,
0.5136839747428894,
0.35045427083969116,
-0.09144194424152374,
0.11518064141273499,
-0.5606995820999146,
0.10552769154310226,
-0.2953375577926636,
-0.32072144746780396,
-0.22903548181056976,
-0.21577119827270508,
0.6316706538200378,
0.8037766814231873,
-0.3895057737827301,
0.26455867290496826,
0.18374699354171753,
0.2124553918838501,
-0.5664021372795105,
0.08089303225278854,
-0.8402643203735352,
-0.22267700731754303,
-0.20550961792469025,
-0.3273434638977051,
-0.7900397181510925,
-0.3405645489692688,
0.19743038713932037,
-0.6294220685958862,
0.26538631319999695,
0.06406351178884506,
0.44894275069236755,
0.023086221888661385,
-0.3235227167606354,
-0.24749253690242767,
-0.7167165279388428,
0.8705065250396729,
-0.8528692722320557,
0.656551718711853,
0.44323480129241943,
0.44521376490592957,
-0.33857619762420654,
-0.7561225295066833,
-0.2455815225839615,
-0.6407794952392578,
0.09957341849803925,
-0.12935465574264526,
0.2208600789308548,
-0.30961647629737854,
0.3759978115558624,
0.26535165309906006,
-0.08520779758691788,
0.3288450837135315,
-0.45631036162376404,
-0.2654746174812317,
0.664430558681488,
0.23610876500606537,
-0.11268117278814316,
0.13197851181030273,
-0.3106623888015747,
-0.19821050763130188,
-0.848263680934906,
-0.12171871215105057,
0.31247594952583313,
0.5203984379768372,
0.1315675526857376,
0.6470919847488403,
-0.06490948051214218,
0.678654134273529,
-0.005367042031139135,
-0.20263423025608063,
0.4149172902107239,
-0.366070955991745,
-0.047853734344244,
-0.31706181168556213,
0.4938155710697174,
0.316905677318573,
-0.08785095065832138,
-0.5200384855270386,
-0.5333729386329651,
-0.4666749835014343,
0.5556163191795349,
-0.9541835784912109,
-0.0864250510931015,
-0.11249040067195892,
-0.376524955034256,
0.012291714549064636,
0.20547522604465485,
-0.5638954043388367,
-0.7054310441017151,
-0.3674035370349884,
0.6014325618743896,
-0.3035791516304016,
-0.3730413317680359,
0.07845013588666916,
-0.13135184347629547,
0.18429914116859436,
0.6699879169464111,
-0.3504333198070526,
0.15436416864395142,
0.6005571484565735,
0.9788743853569031,
-0.2818205952644348,
-0.150438591837883,
-1.0741263628005981,
0.07075291126966476,
-0.14544276893138885,
0.7547245621681213,
-0.9339125752449036,
-0.7370266914367676,
0.03755684569478035,
0.21825018525123596,
0.17620381712913513,
-0.8332446217536926,
0.20748917758464813,
-0.766157329082489,
0.15895015001296997,
-0.2850598096847534,
-0.5636230707168579,
-0.45664218068122864,
0.2276257425546646,
-0.6825589537620544,
1.2968018054962158,
0.1250564157962799,
-0.536361575126648,
0.34542614221572876,
-0.5653588175773621,
-0.36981338262557983,
0.19166715443134308,
-0.12007521092891693,
-0.4583800435066223,
0.36112353205680847,
0.11110909283161163,
0.3545290529727936,
-0.5387834906578064,
0.3238333463668823,
-0.8686060905456543,
-0.6052790284156799,
0.01904633268713951,
-0.3025418817996979,
0.47434696555137634,
0.01381414383649826,
-0.25034359097480774,
0.46355897188186646,
-0.5585740208625793,
-0.0638924315571785,
0.08697756379842758,
-0.5232507586479187,
-0.21193204820156097,
-0.12348292022943497,
0.10947834700345993,
0.2762763798236847,
0.20942504703998566,
-0.6497167944908142,
0.4861840605735779,
-0.4974968433380127,
0.21749256551265717,
0.8353801369667053,
0.05133093148469925,
0.41065552830696106,
-0.09755478799343109,
0.4672597348690033,
0.007181891240179539,
-0.017021216452121735,
-0.12413132935762405,
0.007179907988756895,
-0.6021293997764587,
-0.08478087931871414,
0.41277050971984863,
0.2992677688598633,
-0.8554772734642029,
0.3112167418003082,
-0.15724678337574005,
-0.455973744392395,
-0.5328534841537476,
0.5190527439117432,
0.33733078837394714,
0.2996174097061157,
0.43005913496017456,
-0.7936801910400391,
-0.3259830176830292,
-0.5621215105056763,
-0.11652051657438278,
0.012565848417580128,
-0.32007938623428345,
0.46383562684059143,
0.43265634775161743,
-0.13824984431266785,
0.5905532836914062,
-0.2513425648212433,
-0.34116625785827637,
-0.32887908816337585,
0.13077959418296814,
0.09841552376747131,
0.22654053568840027,
0.05877399817109108,
-0.5097858905792236,
-0.39436495304107666,
0.055187616497278214,
-0.4080924093723297,
-0.061671141535043716,
0.18238137662410736,
0.031897589564323425,
0.049588676542043686,
0.7470493316650391,
-0.36971521377563477,
0.4148910939693451,
0.10023988783359528,
-0.07879472523927689,
0.5696761012077332,
-0.29597318172454834,
-0.17508377134799957,
-0.9330776929855347,
0.42866671085357666,
-0.07808692008256912,
-0.3497745394706726,
-0.2509818375110626,
0.1991020143032074,
0.20404678583145142,
0.14953431487083435,
-0.5532941222190857,
0.8872982859611511,
-0.5669956803321838,
-0.2511915862560272,
-0.39176371693611145,
0.39949458837509155,
-0.15530945360660553,
0.30945947766304016,
-0.14818145334720612,
0.9271351099014282,
0.484772264957428,
-0.6478186845779419,
0.3746810853481293,
-0.04495537653565407,
-0.2975395917892456,
0.5147022008895874,
-0.6764200329780579,
0.504125714302063,
-0.003960351925343275,
0.21707607805728912,
-0.7783612608909607,
-0.0727788507938385,
-0.12912514805793762,
-0.14113155007362366,
0.4531944990158081,
-0.21363714337348938,
-0.9939538240432739,
-0.37234359979629517,
-0.5413956642150879,
0.0161840058863163,
0.2051904797554016,
-0.7512176036834717,
0.7727392315864563,
0.3943881094455719,
-0.12114161252975464,
-0.5592477917671204,
0.1500377357006073,
-0.04174332320690155,
-0.1669485718011856,
-0.22647470235824585,
-0.00043378924601711333,
-0.30574730038642883,
-0.10252557694911957,
-0.3466484248638153,
-0.49213212728500366,
0.05747126042842865,
0.26621177792549133,
0.09170281141996384,
0.20015302300453186,
0.08790615200996399,
0.5031528472900391,
-0.2871992588043213,
-0.07566321641206741,
-0.02895088866353035,
-0.17836546897888184,
0.6413238644599915,
-0.01619761437177658,
-0.6897402405738831,
-0.031236587092280388,
0.2846687138080597,
0.3678624927997589,
-0.43653470277786255,
0.4272208511829376,
0.8584451079368591,
-0.16838370263576508,
-0.2047380656003952,
-0.9141384363174438,
-0.5962464213371277,
-0.5215398073196411,
0.523554265499115,
-0.5270191431045532,
-0.9507412314414978,
0.38358011841773987,
-0.5956737399101257,
0.32536423206329346,
0.20121897757053375,
0.7908027768135071,
0.13054241240024567,
1.3799253702163696,
0.9767541289329529,
-0.25360843539237976,
0.5697048306465149,
-0.36692649126052856,
-0.01601950265467167,
-1.105776309967041,
-0.35791653394699097,
-0.5918282270431519,
-0.186719611287117,
-0.13038472831249237,
-0.4078318774700165,
0.25379496812820435,
0.3017987906932831,
-0.1485765129327774,
0.3714550733566284,
-0.30268144607543945,
0.47289735078811646,
0.616989254951477,
0.2412407100200653,
0.49149027466773987,
0.052543506026268005,
-0.5435584783554077,
0.13343381881713867,
-0.6982450485229492,
-0.5140711069107056,
1.1390626430511475,
0.30846986174583435,
0.8427520394325256,
0.2861454486846924,
0.5729601979255676,
0.09744686633348465,
0.5822656750679016,
-0.9485899209976196,
0.49744221568107605,
-0.07762741297483444,
-0.4129408895969391,
-0.1257227063179016,
-0.3923516273498535,
-0.930270791053772,
0.41721054911613464,
0.09682709723711014,
-1.1086759567260742,
-0.1490493267774582,
0.01728864200413227,
-0.31227847933769226,
0.17652925848960876,
-0.6808225512504578,
0.6883083581924438,
-0.13789740204811096,
-0.5203571319580078,
-0.429164856672287,
-0.6083241105079651,
-0.010817726142704487,
-0.2010725438594818,
0.20422343909740448,
-0.04334723576903343,
0.04790542647242546,
0.44787395000457764,
-0.379608690738678,
0.9724910259246826,
-0.36136114597320557,
-0.4243256747722626,
0.02276531234383583,
0.2690960764884949,
0.7945226430892944,
0.1646694391965866,
-0.43966972827911377,
-0.2193734049797058,
-0.049229539930820465,
-0.09102323651313782,
-0.6596150398254395,
0.7998712062835693,
-0.6161956787109375,
-0.8410581946372986,
-0.022819381207227707,
-0.602485179901123,
-0.35082167387008667,
0.43402233719825745,
-0.08541352301836014,
0.644346296787262,
0.04003968462347984,
0.42610880732536316,
0.4785570204257965,
-0.26747119426727295,
0.39519861340522766,
0.7618807554244995,
-0.46464622020721436,
0.04457811266183853,
0.8193144798278809,
0.0361395962536335,
0.2012261301279068,
0.18841879069805145,
0.03841785714030266,
-0.5629979968070984,
-0.5320913791656494,
-0.5515215396881104,
0.330276757478714,
-0.9644811153411865,
-0.4017171263694763,
-0.513540506362915,
0.13491716980934143,
-0.00973586831241846,
0.1388731449842453,
-0.33901911973953247,
-0.18831297755241394,
-0.3304615914821625,
-0.020925533026456833,
0.44227197766304016,
0.9176529049873352,
0.2898994982242584,
0.3222644031047821,
-0.8076473474502563,
0.02909708209335804,
-0.016191188246011734,
0.7835974097251892,
0.3667234182357788,
-0.8148506879806519,
-0.28849324584007263,
-0.11078771203756332,
-0.49165046215057373,
-0.7036252021789551,
0.14121653139591217,
0.08388286828994751,
0.6441325545310974,
0.1650976836681366,
0.08611611276865005,
0.7965872287750244,
-0.6176332235336304,
0.591686487197876,
-0.12088093161582947,
-0.8371016383171082,
0.32139134407043457,
-0.01329804863780737,
0.5942450165748596,
0.4780011475086212,
0.23974236845970154,
-0.3556157052516937,
-0.5035485625267029,
-0.4415052533149719,
-1.0641356706619263,
0.8011268973350525,
-0.18888351321220398,
0.21016737818717957,
0.2157842069864273,
0.35144609212875366,
0.37883460521698,
0.29685306549072266,
-0.6466217041015625,
0.1498526930809021,
0.06324899941682816,
0.05058122053742409,
0.053008150309324265,
-0.001349269412457943,
-0.1759016513824463,
-0.17157110571861267,
0.8135225176811218,
-0.41139858961105347,
0.17161035537719727,
-0.17702846229076385,
-0.4851313531398773,
-0.247085839509964,
0.37225019931793213,
0.3210236430168152,
1.023067831993103,
-0.10231060534715652,
0.10669741034507751,
0.5766342282295227,
-0.20675192773342133,
0.0018111285753548145,
0.20616541802883148,
0.10210812836885452,
0.10860183835029602,
0.21563208103179932,
0.6000962257385254,
0.3208617866039276,
-0.787303626537323,
0.47739511728286743,
0.025742998346686363,
0.13089969754219055,
-0.26951897144317627,
0.028970126062631607,
0.25422561168670654,
0.5123776793479919,
0.42584505677223206,
-0.3886948227882385,
0.34750446677207947,
-0.3994450271129608,
0.36833250522613525,
0.7100210785865784,
-0.5100113153457642,
-0.3036007881164551,
0.42701590061187744,
0.16655561327934265,
-0.3941907286643982,
0.6150651574134827,
-0.27614477276802063,
-0.4008495807647705,
0.3111412525177002,
0.6040915250778198,
0.6752253174781799,
-0.03328976407647133,
0.01743919402360916,
0.4638254940509796,
0.21032287180423737,
-0.23983874917030334,
0.2701619863510132,
-0.20992353558540344,
-0.242157980799675,
-0.6505248546600342,
-0.4844767153263092,
-0.32525116205215454,
0.2506370544433594,
-0.6027419567108154,
0.5197548270225525,
-0.36765244603157043,
-0.22873495519161224,
-0.24267688393592834,
0.07516363263130188,
-0.7903605699539185,
-0.20751804113388062,
-0.20044328272342682,
1.060826063156128,
-0.25992029905319214,
1.032351016998291,
0.749558687210083,
-0.48020821809768677,
-0.977348804473877,
-0.030134545639157295,
0.1363844871520996,
-0.7052915692329407,
0.6408655643463135,
0.5122169852256775,
-0.38203656673431396,
0.07223711907863617,
-0.5392123460769653,
-0.8930737376213074,
1.1256262063980103,
0.4000614285469055,
-0.7428833246231079,
0.017956947907805443,
-0.2720971405506134,
0.49887970089912415,
-0.19612650573253632,
0.5893877744674683,
0.34381288290023804,
0.2581516206264496,
0.3638097643852234,
-1.409128189086914,
0.1990414708852768,
-0.2644788324832916,
0.2914857864379883,
0.4463743567466736,
-0.41724881529808044,
0.4610711634159088,
-0.3174481987953186,
-0.30194076895713806,
0.15791559219360352,
0.391385942697525,
0.3023921251296997,
-0.019592242315411568,
0.5149272680282593,
0.44188863039016724,
0.48318392038345337,
0.1530659794807434,
1.077362060546875,
-0.07056315243244171,
0.4510546028614044,
1.3881161212921143,
-0.49873045086860657,
1.0340725183486938,
0.4656537175178528,
0.028379619121551514,
0.2997111976146698,
0.5200077891349792,
0.0036702752113342285,
0.4123442471027374,
0.3724268674850464,
-0.20581303536891937,
-0.3907172381877899,
-0.26960185170173645,
-0.3480682373046875,
0.3547767698764801,
0.2854021489620209,
-0.3622928857803345,
-0.49556705355644226,
0.09859182685613632,
-0.059533149003982544,
-0.15340711176395416,
-0.23115332424640656,
1.147983193397522,
0.16355063021183014,
-0.519614577293396,
0.5187825560569763,
0.20993727445602417,
0.6417627334594727,
-0.5629953145980835,
-0.35835981369018555,
-0.001169025432318449,
0.4788793921470642,
0.026543591171503067,
-0.5290332436561584,
0.15929296612739563,
-0.12248345464468002,
0.062183678150177,
-0.0004446611274033785,
0.6600067019462585,
-0.47583290934562683,
-0.4588274359703064,
0.6385149359703064,
0.45669686794281006,
0.0070859878323972225,
-0.1262800097465515,
-0.7443826198577881,
0.27214935421943665,
-0.1530553549528122,
-0.21167539060115814,
0.4027952253818512,
0.2924056649208069,
-0.1708528995513916,
0.8933621644973755,
0.6050985455513,
-0.02092805877327919,
-0.014846635051071644,
0.5209865570068359,
1.0338783264160156,
-0.5219905376434326,
-0.22235572338104248,
-0.7830309867858887,
0.4339333474636078,
-0.20147587358951569,
0.02422371320426464,
0.9175782203674316,
0.43560856580734253,
1.1798303127288818,
0.047480955719947815,
0.5613160133361816,
0.04015364870429039,
0.8057927489280701,
-0.3910810649394989,
0.3064470589160919,
-0.74057936668396,
0.7444995641708374,
-0.24882002174854279,
-1.0486541986465454,
-0.2550869882106781,
0.5480325818061829,
-0.3362744152545929,
0.3023715019226074,
0.48183685541152954,
0.8360563516616821,
-0.32665812969207764,
-0.1483190804719925,
0.14459487795829773,
0.2002653181552887,
0.3660982847213745,
0.22567534446716309,
0.720371425151825,
-0.14587488770484924,
0.5959232449531555,
-0.15983374416828156,
-0.019129229709506035,
-0.4241788983345032,
-0.8038822412490845,
-0.8677689433097839,
-0.5071244239807129,
-0.1437087208032608,
-0.31940758228302,
-0.07622355222702026,
1.2719472646713257,
0.843562126159668,
-0.6738804578781128,
-0.5927345156669617,
0.2908565104007721,
0.04554804414510727,
-0.10976008325815201,
-0.22062690556049347,
0.14610323309898376,
-0.5183047652244568,
-0.5832078456878662,
0.4887636601924896,
0.36327117681503296,
-0.3344082832336426,
-0.4512587785720825,
-0.06718512624502182,
-0.24227331578731537,
-0.17647790908813477,
0.9068220853805542,
-0.0111997090280056,
-0.8764818906784058,
-0.4459552466869354,
0.2538694143295288,
0.24647726118564606,
0.07944581657648087,
0.9886146187782288,
-0.8504400849342346,
0.7458552122116089,
0.23498164117336273,
0.7624439001083374,
0.611555278301239,
-0.17726989090442657,
0.7829581499099731,
-1.1411068439483643,
-0.026456458494067192,
0.1258295774459839,
0.3692627251148224,
0.6169484257698059,
-0.21024523675441742,
0.5345454812049866,
-0.09337860345840454,
-0.281978964805603,
-0.9575344324111938,
0.3102230131626129,
-0.4463289678096771,
-0.2778576910495758,
1.1498380899429321,
-0.16905918717384338,
0.26279792189598083,
-0.34092772006988525,
-0.4987712800502777,
0.32908785343170166,
-0.6075083017349243,
1.0299288034439087,
0.7170087099075317,
0.08249638974666595,
-0.276498407125473,
-0.6668345928192139,
0.08232297003269196,
0.3398088216781616,
-0.7062562108039856,
0.319460391998291,
0.5058931708335876,
0.40761855244636536,
0.1436048299074173,
0.47651341557502747,
-0.32882159948349,
0.29452764987945557,
-0.5262534022331238,
0.004707615356892347,
-0.03581356257200241,
-0.453902930021286,
-0.4127039313316345,
0.10471061617136002,
0.561511218547821,
0.2569441795349121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00875v1 | MoE-CT: A Novel Approach For Large Language Models Training With Resistance To Catastrophic Forgetting | 2024-06-25T11:03:45 | 2024-06-25T11:03:45 | Tianhao Li, Shangjie Li, Binbin Xie, Deyi Xiong, Baosong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has predominantly catered to
high-resource languages, leaving a disparity in performance for low-resource
languages. Conventional Continual Training (CT) approaches to bridge this gap
often undermine a model's original linguistic proficiency when expanding to
multilingual contexts. Addressing this issue, we introduce a novel MoE-CT
architecture, a paradigm that innovatively separates the base model's learning
from the multilingual expansion process. Our design freezes the original LLM
parameters, thus safeguarding its performance in high-resource languages, while
an appended MoE module, trained on diverse language datasets, augments
low-resource language proficiency. Our approach significantly outperforms
conventional CT methods, as evidenced by our experiments, which show marked
improvements in multilingual benchmarks without sacrificing the model's
original language performance. Moreover, our MoE-CT framework demonstrates
enhanced resistance to forgetting and superior transfer learning capabilities.
By preserving the base model's integrity and focusing on strategic parameter
expansion, our methodology advances multilingual language modeling and
represents a significant step forward for low-resource language inclusion in
LLMs, indicating a fruitful direction for future research in language
technologies. | [
-0.314682275056839,
-0.7534753680229187,
0.341305673122406,
0.14343909919261932,
-0.17955783009529114,
0.24383755028247833,
-0.5699663162231445,
-0.15717212855815887,
-0.12873657047748566,
0.3494778573513031,
-0.5345331430435181,
-0.3670361340045929,
-0.6721271276473999,
-0.006599336862564087,
0.1316411793231964,
0.6914941668510437,
-0.06463614851236343,
0.22681915760040283,
-0.11777139455080032,
-0.4772730767726898,
-0.8408304452896118,
-0.6871557235717773,
-0.790949285030365,
-0.39988207817077637,
0.6185872554779053,
0.33257514238357544,
0.3997209072113037,
0.592115044593811,
0.3081044852733612,
0.21712476015090942,
0.042365215718746185,
0.09558431804180145,
-0.7762961387634277,
0.0986323207616806,
-0.18365360796451569,
-0.5662593841552734,
-0.6226828098297119,
-0.3777307868003845,
0.9991785287857056,
0.8050909042358398,
-0.28773263096809387,
-0.13007764518260956,
0.2877190113067627,
0.7202773690223694,
-0.8723302483558655,
0.2150307148694992,
-0.9574964046478271,
0.010392262600362301,
-0.36786678433418274,
-0.07162940502166748,
-0.8072989583015442,
0.033957209438085556,
0.023904379457235336,
-0.46832841634750366,
-0.04574306681752205,
-0.265837699174881,
0.6092655062675476,
0.020276114344596863,
-0.3987739682197571,
-0.20763252675533295,
-0.7349995374679565,
1.0560917854309082,
-0.3015162944793701,
0.6224150657653809,
0.24072551727294922,
0.15916377305984497,
0.10922165215015411,
-0.2762106657028198,
-0.14554591476917267,
-0.44872698187828064,
0.39826035499572754,
0.20498336851596832,
0.05562913045287132,
-0.19305433332920074,
-0.07755618542432785,
0.2093057930469513,
-0.6237987279891968,
0.28310608863830566,
-0.4682098627090454,
-0.21782487630844116,
0.3381922245025635,
0.15056781470775604,
0.29765912890434265,
0.3461366593837738,
-0.6838973760604858,
0.05856771394610405,
-1.1537429094314575,
-0.22947952151298523,
0.10905001312494278,
0.4543083608150482,
-0.17885231971740723,
0.1740468144416809,
0.09161664545536041,
0.28806668519973755,
-0.15400856733322144,
-0.04784155264496803,
0.1801002323627472,
0.058605797588825226,
0.012642552144825459,
0.08234027773141861,
0.7199315428733826,
-0.09340778738260269,
0.30521655082702637,
-0.28501516580581665,
-0.2585518956184387,
-0.13270622491836548,
0.19850358366966248,
-0.5234892964363098,
-0.17429004609584808,
-0.18658116459846497,
-0.2712966799736023,
0.014309130609035492,
-0.2632518410682678,
-0.5532779097557068,
-0.09159353375434875,
-0.08700985461473465,
0.41602542996406555,
-0.9433037042617798,
-0.5275340676307678,
-0.05239768698811531,
0.21198596060276031,
-0.11311118304729462,
0.28084149956703186,
-0.9593170881271362,
0.08132583647966385,
0.5860790610313416,
1.068199634552002,
-0.32282012701034546,
-0.6029334664344788,
-0.39332637190818787,
0.5720728635787964,
-0.4719941020011902,
0.5505973100662231,
-0.716175377368927,
-0.6021552085876465,
0.10578489303588867,
-0.21777474880218506,
-0.1460588574409485,
-0.6569039225578308,
0.1810368299484253,
-0.7442200183868408,
-0.03319850564002991,
-0.12520761787891388,
-0.37120547890663147,
-0.2404126226902008,
0.5990907549858093,
-0.6996483206748962,
0.8900001049041748,
0.11069543659687042,
-0.33639153838157654,
0.1861584484577179,
-0.7485580444335938,
-0.3044258952140808,
0.04685908928513527,
0.08808808773756027,
-0.33484166860580444,
0.23493152856826782,
0.11551827937364578,
0.3313141167163849,
-0.27577751874923706,
0.307843953371048,
-0.5624969005584717,
-0.29111555218696594,
0.10725205391645432,
-1.000447392463684,
0.8332099318504333,
0.15526098012924194,
0.10954909771680832,
-0.09944287687540054,
-0.688950777053833,
-0.04148899391293526,
0.37835484743118286,
-0.7817074656486511,
-0.5221508741378784,
-0.2799395024776459,
0.0025080470368266106,
0.3009403645992279,
0.4982271194458008,
-0.3605777621269226,
0.37129464745521545,
-0.4265647530555725,
0.4265652596950531,
0.9999679923057556,
-0.27683883905410767,
0.6095544099807739,
-0.43650680780410767,
0.5332604646682739,
0.26009446382522583,
0.11255183070898056,
-0.6667495369911194,
-0.24026450514793396,
-0.8532215356826782,
-0.3054370880126953,
0.1872975081205368,
0.49050793051719666,
-0.8517864346504211,
0.008409234695136547,
-0.7117536664009094,
-0.4652778208255768,
-0.3111494779586792,
0.46422505378723145,
0.6118867993354797,
0.22796662151813507,
0.4096251428127289,
-0.45763757824897766,
-0.44583192467689514,
-0.7795822024345398,
-0.05508903041481972,
-0.24245139956474304,
0.0918252021074295,
-0.050624676048755646,
0.32194358110427856,
-0.07605460286140442,
0.6461015343666077,
-0.08516121655702591,
-0.2528834044933319,
-0.5145515203475952,
0.006207877304404974,
0.033441439270973206,
0.6870020627975464,
0.5228704810142517,
-0.635046660900116,
-0.5346530079841614,
0.11861463636159897,
-0.7227411270141602,
0.264717698097229,
-0.17520220577716827,
-0.11371997743844986,
0.4248955547809601,
0.4435354769229889,
-0.4462294578552246,
0.008270397782325745,
0.630388081073761,
0.2676980495452881,
0.49321070313453674,
-0.33842724561691284,
-0.18886367976665497,
-1.2522796392440796,
0.0574084147810936,
-0.3584277033805847,
0.1383167803287506,
-0.5427119135856628,
0.20569488406181335,
0.22984127700328827,
-0.13625605404376984,
-0.5478395223617554,
0.8982132077217102,
-0.7036662101745605,
0.3043394684791565,
-0.22358959913253784,
-0.13031399250030518,
-0.2724974751472473,
0.640591025352478,
0.05082456395030022,
0.7410460710525513,
0.6810756325721741,
-0.7645999193191528,
0.2512768805027008,
0.07414387911558151,
-0.040702469646930695,
0.6145675182342529,
-0.22275733947753906,
0.24404777586460114,
-0.06653665006160736,
0.18319793045520782,
-0.8449243307113647,
-0.035247452557086945,
0.1551511287689209,
-0.2994987666606903,
0.6178591847419739,
-0.39791592955589294,
-0.33144044876098633,
-0.22272710502147675,
-0.10074857622385025,
0.6893484592437744,
0.44090303778648376,
-0.3424384593963623,
0.8494959473609924,
0.15551847219467163,
-0.44171255826950073,
-0.5161599516868591,
-0.8218152523040771,
0.409894734621048,
-0.3032863438129425,
-0.45655572414398193,
0.18175368010997772,
-0.27131158113479614,
-0.05211644992232323,
-0.21610470116138458,
0.11953391879796982,
-0.5051550269126892,
0.23732593655586243,
0.0114746680483222,
0.22643880546092987,
-0.656576931476593,
0.38575589656829834,
0.019339339807629585,
-0.33690598607063293,
-0.08091939985752106,
-0.5272387862205505,
0.8836060166358948,
-0.11978649348020554,
-0.4728050231933594,
-0.5326758027076721,
0.567221462726593,
0.7990057468414307,
-0.34587806463241577,
0.8075852394104004,
0.44388794898986816,
-0.3945862352848053,
-0.18267664313316345,
-0.6568247675895691,
-0.09154948592185974,
-0.46448367834091187,
0.6875901818275452,
-0.4981010854244232,
-0.6834875345230103,
0.4333384931087494,
-0.16086386144161224,
0.22866389155387878,
0.2533615231513977,
0.7613993287086487,
0.08275198191404343,
0.6948021650314331,
0.8811488151550293,
-0.3258206248283386,
0.7231425046920776,
0.004746191203594208,
0.016505166888237,
-0.8418136835098267,
-0.05318941920995712,
-0.06711282581090927,
-0.20394231379032135,
-0.22967314720153809,
-0.29678457975387573,
0.29929742217063904,
0.10852369666099548,
-0.36044082045555115,
0.18988652527332306,
0.09216534346342087,
0.3168824017047882,
0.5899745225906372,
0.06957101821899414,
0.31459948420524597,
0.02161327935755253,
-0.3324146270751953,
-0.03184392303228378,
-1.0904603004455566,
-0.4667345881462097,
1.3950793743133545,
0.3178751468658447,
0.629753828048706,
0.2383587658405304,
0.7704639434814453,
0.12647750973701477,
0.7072830200195312,
-0.6678356528282166,
0.4919531047344208,
-0.07289869338274002,
-0.676609456539154,
-0.32549309730529785,
-0.412452757358551,
-0.7980659008026123,
0.2617197632789612,
0.07224215567111969,
-0.5536306500434875,
-0.15340575575828552,
0.40879377722740173,
-0.41801849007606506,
0.5969005227088928,
-0.8164798021316528,
0.6250452995300293,
-0.4352608323097229,
-0.5659030079841614,
-0.3475812077522278,
-0.28284844756126404,
0.4111117124557495,
-0.39363157749176025,
0.24609504640102386,
-0.054565656930208206,
-0.11720120161771774,
0.4220111668109894,
-0.07964334636926651,
0.9644228219985962,
-0.017434624955058098,
-0.3299500048160553,
0.22981509566307068,
0.3545389771461487,
0.476741224527359,
0.029252560809254646,
-0.2656141519546509,
0.4259319007396698,
-0.46484652161598206,
-0.6661079525947571,
-0.256475031375885,
0.7251625061035156,
-0.3993210792541504,
-0.6525312066078186,
-0.16817784309387207,
-0.7777553200721741,
-0.49874159693717957,
0.418573796749115,
0.23636670410633087,
0.30590102076530457,
-0.4278999865055084,
0.3923121690750122,
0.7883358597755432,
-0.1951020061969757,
0.5517939925193787,
0.4666563868522644,
0.10899326205253601,
-0.515893280506134,
1.0209859609603882,
0.32802870869636536,
0.6459521055221558,
0.5575768947601318,
0.22255058586597443,
-0.057171400636434555,
-0.599161684513092,
-0.4017566740512848,
0.1460370421409607,
-0.5506119132041931,
-0.07158201932907104,
-0.5923362374305725,
-0.19804950058460236,
-0.20747730135917664,
-0.30271992087364197,
-0.8562711477279663,
-0.06076617166399956,
-0.083554707467556,
0.1962410807609558,
-0.056185267865657806,
0.5224493145942688,
-0.04299897328019142,
0.30344417691230774,
-1.1048310995101929,
0.00050074711907655,
0.2315131276845932,
0.43051373958587646,
0.4311455190181732,
-0.6026899814605713,
-0.5350468158721924,
0.2353125959634781,
-0.682252824306488,
-0.45957380533218384,
0.332531213760376,
0.4044985771179199,
0.6054232120513916,
0.5702102184295654,
0.005821483209729195,
0.7618598341941833,
-0.7680209279060364,
0.6941235065460205,
0.4610805809497833,
-0.8021193742752075,
0.3929857313632965,
-0.5059903860092163,
0.5824468731880188,
0.2689400613307953,
0.2436254471540451,
-0.5498116612434387,
-0.45157402753829956,
-0.45499125123023987,
-0.8849220275878906,
0.6213992238044739,
-0.022182166576385498,
0.4816899001598358,
-0.16044944524765015,
0.1936611384153366,
0.31807947158813477,
-0.0008394771721214056,
-0.9399736523628235,
0.029440101236104965,
0.009255994111299515,
-0.10917460918426514,
0.0035289637744426727,
-0.48214974999427795,
-0.07343851029872894,
0.19391897320747375,
0.71332186460495,
-0.15876787900924683,
0.24276652932167053,
-0.2539081275463104,
-0.4580276310443878,
0.10544095188379288,
0.2394280582666397,
0.6268255710601807,
0.7136348485946655,
0.07963167130947113,
0.04436975345015526,
0.5871104598045349,
-0.4627286493778229,
0.101654052734375,
-0.47403135895729065,
0.08651532232761383,
-0.10598304867744446,
0.6758604645729065,
0.5361284613609314,
0.5442460775375366,
-0.6308462619781494,
0.21897827088832855,
0.2673034965991974,
-0.13223977386951447,
-0.3777238130569458,
0.08015946298837662,
0.27406883239746094,
0.07020941376686096,
0.2963823676109314,
0.15736407041549683,
-0.3639300763607025,
-0.661902904510498,
0.2704261839389801,
0.3398410677909851,
-0.5214572548866272,
-0.42499297857284546,
0.7008055448532104,
0.28715014457702637,
-0.20381107926368713,
0.7371877431869507,
0.14199699461460114,
-0.40168529748916626,
0.4593859910964966,
0.6486431360244751,
0.8846656084060669,
-0.6337836384773254,
-0.16940882802009583,
0.42669329047203064,
0.48429757356643677,
-0.2867611348628998,
0.02620667591691017,
-0.040459826588630676,
-0.6120604872703552,
-0.14870966970920563,
-0.37770771980285645,
-0.15248224139213562,
0.09884563833475113,
-0.7977662086486816,
0.33336496353149414,
-0.681296706199646,
0.046550117433071136,
-0.671842098236084,
-0.44480782747268677,
-0.5332919359207153,
-0.00535947922617197,
0.3737923800945282,
1.0274379253387451,
-0.6073616743087769,
1.156401515007019,
0.4936050772666931,
-0.3365638852119446,
-0.3302249610424042,
0.20393867790699005,
0.16950291395187378,
-1.032734990119934,
0.6418420672416687,
0.2449619621038437,
-0.18232488632202148,
-0.04290127754211426,
-0.20153357088565826,
-0.9354088306427002,
1.0413762331008911,
0.7360209822654724,
-0.6357670426368713,
-0.0047602104023098946,
0.06328601390123367,
0.28312259912490845,
-0.2338505983352661,
-0.11986089497804642,
0.1927746832370758,
0.22167491912841797,
0.08379481732845306,
-0.8905971646308899,
-0.20244503021240234,
-0.12040189653635025,
0.2218141257762909,
0.18900330364704132,
-0.896699070930481,
0.7922520041465759,
-0.21287190914154053,
-0.27769526839256287,
0.39947009086608887,
0.6159325242042542,
0.2580134868621826,
0.1579248160123825,
0.33007001876831055,
0.4035452902317047,
0.652410626411438,
-0.1628831923007965,
0.8403570055961609,
-0.3246738314628601,
0.465375691652298,
1.2712390422821045,
-0.41879984736442566,
1.051893711090088,
0.518598735332489,
0.11227233707904816,
0.2342132180929184,
0.4231753647327423,
0.2480609267950058,
0.5596712231636047,
-0.0325782373547554,
-0.39550650119781494,
-0.556816816329956,
-0.023691346868872643,
-0.49465203285217285,
0.4287096858024597,
0.48727455735206604,
-0.1322426050901413,
-0.351969450712204,
0.3109823763370514,
0.20257627964019775,
0.14165858924388885,
-0.36798128485679626,
0.6490108370780945,
0.18635939061641693,
-0.35420548915863037,
0.8096885085105896,
-0.12375781685113907,
0.6923488974571228,
-0.9346718788146973,
0.06943321973085403,
-0.39053237438201904,
0.378518283367157,
0.4246504008769989,
-0.5113906264305115,
0.36689016222953796,
-0.09398982673883438,
-0.28758305311203003,
-0.4746197760105133,
0.03830482065677643,
-0.5266978740692139,
-0.5499193668365479,
0.4795554578304291,
0.3982705771923065,
-0.2758978605270386,
-0.0006149413529783487,
-0.6805208325386047,
0.21104483306407928,
-0.2095908671617508,
-0.21917980909347534,
0.32852286100387573,
0.7443304657936096,
-0.25096747279167175,
1.0895262956619263,
0.6162902116775513,
0.02541554719209671,
0.19413022696971893,
-0.061655666679143906,
0.7958709597587585,
-0.5556852221488953,
-0.7082811594009399,
-1.0056498050689697,
0.4355088472366333,
0.09799163043498993,
-0.4851292669773102,
0.42587077617645264,
0.6183652877807617,
1.175213098526001,
-0.19815494120121002,
0.9085594415664673,
0.27505314350128174,
0.13098710775375366,
-0.8846811652183533,
0.983828067779541,
-0.7493056654930115,
0.34312552213668823,
-0.05117679759860039,
-0.8024225234985352,
-0.4763268828392029,
0.2438449114561081,
-0.25696349143981934,
0.2748217284679413,
0.7645463943481445,
0.700356125831604,
-0.16156534850597382,
-0.518977701663971,
0.6234686970710754,
0.4595851004123688,
0.3839503228664398,
1.0888190269470215,
0.886396586894989,
-0.19579999148845673,
0.8377636671066284,
-0.00018693339370656759,
-0.17075395584106445,
-0.42900925874710083,
-0.6614487171173096,
-0.9593744277954102,
-0.5284905433654785,
-0.17036688327789307,
-0.03476369380950928,
0.21634462475776672,
0.8960901498794556,
0.7688630819320679,
-0.7850959897041321,
-0.32143667340278625,
-0.013876746408641338,
0.13790078461170197,
-0.37991786003112793,
-0.14835907518863678,
0.20907706022262573,
-0.5294190049171448,
-0.9231215715408325,
0.4947483241558075,
0.6807352900505066,
-0.03876063972711563,
-0.2982499599456787,
-0.2969253361225128,
-0.19382750988006592,
0.04471801221370697,
0.5498199462890625,
0.40938469767570496,
-0.8742424249649048,
-0.08573005348443985,
-0.15790317952632904,
-0.1295659840106964,
0.3040107488632202,
0.762738823890686,
-0.504777729511261,
0.6726307272911072,
0.09464893490076065,
0.8763027191162109,
-0.11970706284046173,
-0.5831106901168823,
0.9054548144340515,
-0.6885247826576233,
0.46583741903305054,
0.21904194355010986,
0.49891313910484314,
0.22147031128406525,
-0.27136266231536865,
0.1831185221672058,
0.40358367562294006,
0.06743397563695908,
-0.8129217624664307,
0.42441293597221375,
-0.8081847429275513,
-0.28113478422164917,
0.9524151086807251,
-0.2559434771537781,
-0.037970054894685745,
-0.17610369622707367,
-0.19338057935237885,
0.04323068633675575,
-0.3089313805103302,
1.1191834211349487,
1.0266379117965698,
0.3863765597343445,
-0.31681007146835327,
-0.47668731212615967,
-0.10863387584686279,
0.4213921129703522,
-0.37663453817367554,
0.32112395763397217,
0.23952777683734894,
0.4053741693496704,
0.10038326680660248,
0.5778710246086121,
-0.30008664727211,
0.3993656635284424,
-0.010965319350361824,
0.1143796369433403,
-0.32412129640579224,
-0.629276692867279,
-0.41381680965423584,
0.39285025000572205,
0.10502062737941742,
-0.20093098282814026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17456v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17456v1 | Improving Grammatical Error Correction via Contextual Data Augmentation | 2024-06-25T10:49:56 | 2024-06-25T10:49:56 | Yixuan Wang, Baoxin Wang, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Dayong Wu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, data augmentation through synthetic data has been widely used in
the field of Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) to alleviate the problem of
data scarcity. However, these synthetic data are mainly used in the
pre-training phase rather than the data-limited fine-tuning phase due to
inconsistent error distribution and noisy labels. In this paper, we propose a
synthetic data construction method based on contextual augmentation, which can
ensure an efficient augmentation of the original data with a more consistent
error distribution. Specifically, we combine rule-based substitution with
model-based generation, using the generative model to generate a richer context
for the extracted error patterns. Besides, we also propose a relabeling-based
data cleaning method to mitigate the effects of noisy labels in synthetic data.
Experiments on CoNLL14 and BEA19-Test show that our proposed augmentation
method consistently and substantially outperforms strong baselines and achieves
the state-of-the-art level with only a few synthetic data. | [
-0.18807655572891235,
-1.2080068588256836,
0.41304710507392883,
0.1523228883743286,
-0.1383242905139923,
-0.12726950645446777,
-0.3532697856426239,
-0.3022788166999817,
0.2049841433763504,
0.22826288640499115,
-0.8688497543334961,
-0.6411323547363281,
-0.21241728961467743,
0.34817251563072205,
-0.3929811120033264,
0.7458353638648987,
-0.08544862270355225,
0.2666895389556885,
-0.40576887130737305,
0.11653541028499603,
-0.8116006255149841,
-0.6344913244247437,
-0.4175446331501007,
0.10469155013561249,
0.2475465089082718,
0.5125047564506531,
0.5694308876991272,
0.7212076783180237,
0.052140481770038605,
0.35309597849845886,
-0.20011988282203674,
1.0053751468658447,
-0.34994590282440186,
0.11028509587049484,
-0.33122310042381287,
-0.17490193247795105,
-0.7519795894622803,
-0.14747892320156097,
0.7552430629730225,
0.9061384797096252,
-0.11751134693622589,
-0.21723710000514984,
0.1385771483182907,
0.3892628252506256,
-0.550581693649292,
0.2429497092962265,
-0.6192464232444763,
0.022483589127659798,
-0.190721333026886,
-0.25336992740631104,
-0.498928040266037,
-0.44352129101753235,
-0.3310416340827942,
-0.9821436405181885,
0.5598962306976318,
-0.10522889345884323,
0.7066521048545837,
0.25673457980155945,
-0.24263674020767212,
-0.05188135430216789,
-0.659392774105072,
0.5997874140739441,
-1.0312248468399048,
0.32250192761421204,
0.2779919505119324,
-0.11608251184225082,
-0.4985111355781555,
-0.5645703673362732,
-0.7894535064697266,
-0.05330298840999603,
-0.2308950126171112,
0.0880039632320404,
0.023094244301319122,
-0.02788703329861164,
0.2586582899093628,
0.4317730963230133,
-0.3272727429866791,
-0.10481832176446915,
-0.34716060757637024,
-0.20491334795951843,
0.6966827511787415,
0.026110390201210976,
0.4339558482170105,
-0.2176305651664734,
0.0719657838344574,
-0.2593311369419098,
-0.7370822429656982,
-0.2477159947156906,
0.457353413105011,
0.6063485145568848,
0.14017221331596375,
0.5023465752601624,
-0.45057544112205505,
0.8243566155433655,
0.21744801104068756,
0.1048005074262619,
0.6877954602241516,
-0.7111257910728455,
-0.30707427859306335,
0.10745161026716232,
0.4405244290828705,
0.41207197308540344,
0.174261212348938,
-0.09649322181940079,
-0.24741463363170624,
0.2707759141921997,
0.31592369079589844,
-0.36573371291160583,
-0.20670343935489655,
-0.1119687408208847,
0.0890008807182312,
-0.36778178811073303,
0.3430822789669037,
-0.89191734790802,
-0.04140245541930199,
-0.8444918990135193,
0.31733134388923645,
-0.4857715368270874,
0.11810623854398727,
0.013099931180477142,
0.22380220890045166,
-0.1953023374080658,
0.4400634169578552,
-0.8793249130249023,
0.12638409435749054,
0.5213013291358948,
0.5230963826179504,
0.11763342469930649,
-0.16387178003787994,
-0.6539316773414612,
0.0963062196969986,
-0.6172845363616943,
0.6935699582099915,
-0.38287243247032166,
-0.5936040878295898,
0.07012199610471725,
0.1970592588186264,
-0.11759321391582489,
-0.6903345584869385,
0.8071942329406738,
-0.18701337277889252,
0.4195480942726135,
-0.18235796689987183,
-0.640421986579895,
0.07542132586240768,
0.17678728699684143,
-0.5920164585113525,
1.2618484497070312,
0.2604702115058899,
-0.34264281392097473,
0.43619126081466675,
-0.4788869321346283,
-0.7427853941917419,
-0.01996142603456974,
0.042341262102127075,
-0.4587215483188629,
0.10110145062208176,
0.7050779461860657,
0.21113424003124237,
0.08050898462533951,
0.5756839513778687,
-0.07882752269506454,
-0.3681895434856415,
0.1729099005460739,
-0.4729436933994293,
0.4675118625164032,
0.06923316419124603,
-0.24151089787483215,
0.00038137100636959076,
-1.0874910354614258,
0.20659585297107697,
-0.2316245585680008,
-0.4621083438396454,
-0.33167821168899536,
0.03762884438037872,
0.03666999191045761,
0.020537657663226128,
-0.09150727838277817,
-0.5432115793228149,
0.33950477838516235,
-0.6110379099845886,
0.19485963881015778,
0.780036449432373,
0.001055197324603796,
0.5500985980033875,
-0.2999633550643921,
0.39433589577674866,
-0.055716075003147125,
-0.0203325804322958,
-0.3023875057697296,
-0.1978256106376648,
-0.8227019906044006,
-0.09741368144750595,
0.48359739780426025,
0.632986307144165,
-0.8694924712181091,
0.7466793656349182,
-0.5190379023551941,
-0.2603495717048645,
-0.40727734565734863,
0.3946962356567383,
0.3444400727748871,
0.8751262426376343,
0.6082932353019714,
0.048474907875061035,
-1.1712357997894287,
-0.6210915446281433,
-0.09618605673313141,
0.05955703184008598,
0.15525422990322113,
0.19469845294952393,
0.11691240966320038,
-0.5852024555206299,
1.014679193496704,
-0.5669471025466919,
-0.21910080313682556,
-0.16070088744163513,
0.016328465193510056,
0.1215406283736229,
0.962921142578125,
0.2109043002128601,
-0.5525680780410767,
-0.26975753903388977,
0.057557396590709686,
-0.6260392665863037,
-0.5300490856170654,
-0.20591039955615997,
-0.26817065477371216,
0.24723052978515625,
0.7150017023086548,
-0.49039027094841003,
0.25923630595207214,
0.2985630929470062,
-0.3140457272529602,
0.5992913842201233,
-0.39930349588394165,
0.1416608840227127,
-1.1520097255706787,
-0.16610737144947052,
-0.017316965386271477,
-0.34457847476005554,
-0.7400121092796326,
-0.010062672197818756,
0.18129950761795044,
0.0906125083565712,
-0.34405937790870667,
0.2738829553127289,
-0.26937052607536316,
0.39513251185417175,
-0.11815401911735535,
-0.0996374562382698,
0.05073835328221321,
0.19770871102809906,
-0.2162834107875824,
0.8763692378997803,
0.3104884624481201,
-0.4936494827270508,
0.466389000415802,
0.41215741634368896,
-0.14899247884750366,
0.5502458810806274,
-0.41887223720550537,
0.025830386206507683,
-0.2866213321685791,
0.42656558752059937,
-0.7994537949562073,
-0.7217075824737549,
0.4169285297393799,
-0.30804407596588135,
0.34309443831443787,
0.10407930612564087,
-0.4879153072834015,
0.00396498991176486,
-0.046554479748010635,
0.3878743052482605,
0.5593423843383789,
-0.8305432200431824,
0.5176950097084045,
0.053470198065042496,
-0.238211527466774,
-0.3693881928920746,
-0.7821738123893738,
0.15170450508594513,
-0.22211694717407227,
-0.8180277347564697,
0.6986145377159119,
0.09882674366235733,
-0.19340719282627106,
-0.1265590637922287,
-0.06793064624071121,
0.14636434614658356,
-0.15829969942569733,
0.04735434055328369,
0.38430255651474,
-0.12047205120325089,
0.3856455385684967,
0.2539881467819214,
0.011636963114142418,
-0.009451785124838352,
-0.1426621824502945,
0.3029315173625946,
0.2058330625295639,
-0.199478879570961,
-0.2781291902065277,
0.2502141296863556,
0.27586743235588074,
0.20430916547775269,
0.5313078165054321,
0.2797129154205322,
-0.5316620469093323,
-0.5115196108818054,
-0.5613705515861511,
-0.17655237019062042,
-0.4704102873802185,
0.15765191614627838,
-0.2220919132232666,
-0.38173237442970276,
0.3545176088809967,
-0.021770652383565903,
-0.316386342048645,
0.34399375319480896,
0.1327521800994873,
-0.21733525395393372,
0.7915899157524109,
0.15709444880485535,
0.15479083359241486,
0.5704813599586487,
-0.16506101191043854,
0.1756218820810318,
-0.6667519807815552,
-0.23680198192596436,
-0.2031441181898117,
-0.09091304242610931,
-0.4419996738433838,
-0.47192299365997314,
0.34257224202156067,
0.10856373608112335,
0.030096951872110367,
0.3451274335384369,
-0.2221066951751709,
0.3761519491672516,
0.6791653633117676,
0.38370731472969055,
0.27885228395462036,
0.4118128716945648,
-0.08656033873558044,
-0.3315674662590027,
-0.639549195766449,
-0.3434368968009949,
0.9528230428695679,
-0.16532373428344727,
0.6568346619606018,
0.05166403576731682,
0.5398581027984619,
0.27234509587287903,
0.1013687252998352,
-0.31808164715766907,
0.43823540210723877,
-0.34586969017982483,
-0.30129390954971313,
-0.2741161286830902,
-0.4074811041355133,
-0.5088523030281067,
0.2886027991771698,
-0.5098022818565369,
-0.40253791213035583,
0.4196130335330963,
0.4986323118209839,
-0.31282827258110046,
0.05584839731454849,
-0.9736389517784119,
0.8126549124717712,
0.1516517847776413,
-0.5969355702400208,
0.17844492197036743,
-0.40852099657058716,
0.28084027767181396,
-0.297471821308136,
0.2832579016685486,
0.34492623805999756,
0.30439549684524536,
0.36013320088386536,
-1.038111686706543,
0.8195832967758179,
-0.15699656307697296,
-0.24071376025676727,
0.36472564935684204,
-0.2539912164211273,
0.9756426811218262,
0.104859359562397,
-0.024894677102565765,
-0.16335900127887726,
-0.5197799801826477,
-0.24657680094242096,
-0.8460401892662048,
0.617159903049469,
-0.3758993148803711,
-0.5201023817062378,
-0.22122910618782043,
-0.6503326892852783,
-0.4509013891220093,
-0.20354099571704865,
0.3351501524448395,
0.5966491103172302,
-0.2104531079530716,
0.34677666425704956,
0.32042062282562256,
-0.09012409299612045,
0.23992757499217987,
0.1835765391588211,
0.18522195518016815,
-0.4823938310146332,
0.81829434633255,
0.1107262670993805,
0.17352421581745148,
0.1560516506433487,
-0.05852232873439789,
-0.46255695819854736,
-0.42260441184043884,
-0.6279802918434143,
-0.06133722513914108,
-0.6225550174713135,
-0.3000866770744324,
-0.6576648354530334,
-0.12078995257616043,
-0.7535859942436218,
-0.30057546496391296,
-0.24569757282733917,
-0.435992568731308,
-0.4277144968509674,
-0.3954732418060303,
0.4551507532596588,
0.14384408295154572,
-0.3438664376735687,
0.6089980602264404,
-0.5983530282974243,
0.09176849573850632,
0.1209825649857521,
0.03834347426891327,
-0.28792285919189453,
-0.5273802876472473,
-0.1489427536725998,
0.41947492957115173,
-0.15747930109500885,
-0.7477257251739502,
0.7373740077018738,
0.43272900581359863,
0.3182087540626526,
0.011611558496952057,
-0.24698226153850555,
1.2100237607955933,
-0.5084964632987976,
0.6772281527519226,
-0.11194741725921631,
-1.1704505681991577,
0.7303662896156311,
-0.5894722938537598,
0.07464123517274857,
0.4949935972690582,
-0.46459004282951355,
-0.5677481889724731,
-0.2655770778656006,
-0.8227015137672424,
-1.0156861543655396,
0.5770467519760132,
0.36532026529312134,
0.37463220953941345,
-0.014430259354412556,
0.5956425666809082,
0.06936261057853699,
0.10017726570367813,
-0.6843523383140564,
-0.04207857325673103,
-0.22808997333049774,
-0.45156559348106384,
-0.22325998544692993,
-0.21053364872932434,
0.12435607612133026,
-0.4791482388973236,
1.1066374778747559,
-0.1544223576784134,
-0.23177802562713623,
0.4204070270061493,
-0.22469066083431244,
-0.09989243000745773,
0.46951138973236084,
0.5114846229553223,
0.5028170943260193,
-0.05600791051983833,
0.10804792493581772,
0.5838473439216614,
-0.42670178413391113,
0.3768552243709564,
0.24192273616790771,
-0.5946558713912964,
0.2341071367263794,
0.33428919315338135,
0.6355202198028564,
0.23859930038452148,
-0.7223719954490662,
0.17883944511413574,
0.4729432761669159,
-0.09499777108430862,
-0.3652697801589966,
0.24603678286075592,
-0.11871383339166641,
-0.11242637038230896,
0.27182382345199585,
0.24041005969047546,
0.12430957704782486,
-0.44499635696411133,
0.3874191641807556,
0.19984041154384613,
0.13110528886318207,
-0.17542517185211182,
0.5838185548782349,
0.1377081573009491,
-0.0001331594685325399,
0.5507349967956543,
-0.40408021211624146,
-0.2763771414756775,
0.5362772345542908,
0.7452753782272339,
0.4291447103023529,
-0.4326176941394806,
0.2931668758392334,
0.5957444310188293,
0.06732793897390366,
-0.27226850390434265,
0.26062318682670593,
0.2341300994157791,
-0.8309610486030579,
-0.7523142695426941,
-0.3952297568321228,
-0.03969154506921768,
0.1978985071182251,
-0.45688119530677795,
0.32753312587738037,
-0.3427309989929199,
0.05509345605969429,
-0.08195792138576508,
-0.3459615111351013,
-0.3196147084236145,
0.7014997005462646,
-0.16012650728225708,
0.46681228280067444,
-0.9053585529327393,
0.5718705654144287,
0.7011436820030212,
-0.3375414311885834,
-0.7696294188499451,
-0.20220030844211578,
0.06586187332868576,
-0.323954313993454,
0.5879367589950562,
-0.05522546544671059,
0.136274516582489,
-0.055928755551576614,
-0.41311249136924744,
-0.742733359336853,
0.833630383014679,
0.3776070475578308,
-0.7566114664077759,
-0.040943145751953125,
0.25930026173591614,
0.7601986527442932,
-0.45254358649253845,
-0.20982232689857483,
0.6262802481651306,
0.5603213906288147,
0.2336675226688385,
-0.4579767882823944,
0.14237532019615173,
-0.6176644563674927,
0.1842459887266159,
-0.03458987921476364,
0.029937738552689552,
0.8379390239715576,
0.06295964866876602,
-0.3980133533477783,
0.1963730752468109,
0.6218166351318359,
0.19523541629314423,
0.20071883499622345,
0.43201202154159546,
0.7085400819778442,
0.8147791028022766,
-0.34551844000816345,
0.8742727637290955,
0.059316765516996384,
0.3034055233001709,
1.3794763088226318,
-0.09415316581726074,
0.5302671790122986,
0.5312404036521912,
-0.06915006786584854,
0.545775830745697,
0.5702729821205139,
-0.17254072427749634,
0.46731650829315186,
0.16621659696102142,
-0.4258745312690735,
-0.1337759792804718,
-0.07327068597078323,
-0.3933102786540985,
0.30697280168533325,
0.3736821413040161,
-0.49224740266799927,
-0.15178892016410828,
0.011648548766970634,
0.10359125584363937,
0.4042823016643524,
-0.21985219419002533,
0.6802567839622498,
-0.349641352891922,
-0.7186439037322998,
0.6131041049957275,
0.15298393368721008,
0.6390469074249268,
-0.08862725645303726,
-0.1747162640094757,
-0.46230730414390564,
0.39320987462997437,
-0.37997934222221375,
-0.2651573717594147,
0.38028132915496826,
0.167650505900383,
-0.31384700536727905,
-0.24500347673892975,
0.6620954871177673,
-0.7903982400894165,
-0.7752300500869751,
-0.17484131455421448,
0.4017559885978699,
-0.22139482200145721,
0.0312282033264637,
-0.16387630999088287,
0.01307067833840847,
0.05894167721271515,
0.2427045702934265,
-0.17277731001377106,
0.16431985795497894,
-0.11559415608644485,
0.2447095811367035,
1.0237725973129272,
0.22816284000873566,
0.27250149846076965,
0.22526110708713531,
0.7857651114463806,
-0.4738624095916748,
-0.6261248588562012,
-0.7896310687065125,
0.7543715834617615,
-0.39863207936286926,
-0.21359369158744812,
0.9017967581748962,
0.491310715675354,
1.1280810832977295,
-0.4403029680252075,
0.8569270372390747,
-0.02944357320666313,
0.5243865847587585,
-0.8109681010246277,
0.25615960359573364,
-0.3390491306781769,
0.33585140109062195,
-0.4345901906490326,
-1.045007348060608,
-0.5555595755577087,
0.6512194275856018,
-0.32218611240386963,
0.10991814732551575,
0.4939188063144684,
1.2873241901397705,
-0.3378311097621918,
0.07144919037818909,
0.09758621454238892,
0.12449812889099121,
0.17616596817970276,
0.24671770632266998,
0.7359421253204346,
-0.722057580947876,
0.09577085077762604,
-0.3036949634552002,
0.048386842012405396,
-0.28497204184532166,
-0.6309946179389954,
-0.38108429312705994,
-0.5010876059532166,
-0.4886043667793274,
-0.4969717264175415,
0.45401903986930847,
1.1620676517486572,
0.6662108898162842,
-1.0360522270202637,
0.29821401834487915,
-0.6528880000114441,
-0.11315009742975235,
-0.24501022696495056,
-0.28847599029541016,
0.38070279359817505,
-0.6460932493209839,
-1.1436408758163452,
0.8614866733551025,
-0.2745588421821594,
0.4662989675998688,
0.19196100533008575,
-0.12615111470222473,
-0.14683251082897186,
-0.07084184885025024,
0.5836628079414368,
0.1398162990808487,
-0.6677877902984619,
-0.29202887415885925,
0.005637120455503464,
0.012766484171152115,
0.20050804316997528,
0.7081415057182312,
-0.7287676334381104,
0.713476836681366,
0.5790227055549622,
0.5829538106918335,
0.15359914302825928,
0.5916702747344971,
0.8284422159194946,
-1.3186582326889038,
0.20527900755405426,
-0.1709064096212387,
0.5032715201377869,
0.63949054479599,
-0.5527153611183167,
0.6743919253349304,
0.5285893082618713,
-0.08701854199171066,
-0.8477733731269836,
-0.14595842361450195,
-0.8019971251487732,
-0.19852715730667114,
1.2419536113739014,
0.07512471824884415,
-0.09806036949157715,
0.14353054761886597,
-0.4533165991306305,
0.32593074440956116,
-0.3284500241279602,
0.7978259325027466,
0.7962110042572021,
0.16691498458385468,
0.14241525530815125,
-0.28354179859161377,
0.6938678622245789,
0.614154040813446,
-1.140995740890503,
0.02468191459774971,
1.0909900665283203,
0.26618003845214844,
0.1382511854171753,
0.16204601526260376,
-0.12816685438156128,
0.2966420352458954,
0.06641913205385208,
-0.03705038130283356,
-0.183439701795578,
-0.27008816599845886,
-0.348710834980011,
-0.03099159337580204,
-0.5789822340011597,
-0.11573495715856552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17453v1 | Learning to Ask Informative Questions: Enhancing LLMs with Preference Optimization and Expected Information Gain | 2024-06-25T10:44:01 | 2024-06-25T10:44:01 | Davide Mazzaccara, Alberto Testoni, Raffaella Bernardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Questions are essential tools for acquiring the necessary information to
complete information-seeking tasks. However, large language models (LLMs),
especially open-source models, often perform poorly in generating informative
questions, as measured by expected information gain (EIG). In this paper, we
propose a method to enhance the informativeness of LLM-generated questions in
20-question game dialogues. We sample multiple questions from the same model
(LLAMA 2-CHAT 7B) for each game and create pairs of low-EIG and high-EIG
questions to apply a Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) algorithm. Our
results show that this method produces more effective questions (in terms of
EIG), even in domains different from those used to train the DPO model. | [
-0.5069375038146973,
-0.9007973670959473,
0.6752732992172241,
-0.04948267340660095,
-0.3142211139202118,
-0.17300160229206085,
-0.45464903116226196,
-0.3906770348548889,
0.08963644504547119,
0.6250287294387817,
-0.6057896018028259,
-0.4528299570083618,
-0.3740963339805603,
0.11351187527179718,
0.2313752919435501,
0.8205345869064331,
-0.01574820652604103,
0.14050190150737762,
-0.4347626566886902,
0.17929008603096008,
-0.2088545262813568,
-0.3881061375141144,
-0.9004262089729309,
-0.07461054623126984,
0.5015588998794556,
0.6895833611488342,
0.4196287989616394,
0.4616438150405884,
0.5358576774597168,
0.25461721420288086,
-0.12049660086631775,
0.6630541086196899,
-0.9994097948074341,
0.5324589014053345,
-0.0132773881778121,
-1.023998498916626,
0.033606406301259995,
-0.13539662957191467,
0.4227195382118225,
0.5042697191238403,
-0.07596184313297272,
0.22783152759075165,
0.018975289538502693,
0.5642861127853394,
-0.5076779723167419,
0.2967376112937927,
-0.77911376953125,
0.013690409250557423,
0.16975870728492737,
-0.7792895436286926,
-0.45997926592826843,
-0.511881947517395,
0.15426793694496155,
-0.876264214515686,
-0.4365725815296173,
0.09110412001609802,
0.8012795448303223,
0.20505864918231964,
-0.07132024317979813,
-0.5645225048065186,
-0.8890973329544067,
0.7744771838188171,
-0.6818640232086182,
0.16498546302318573,
0.26922664046287537,
0.04752884432673454,
-0.3762708306312561,
-0.20650389790534973,
-0.4532359540462494,
-0.24644339084625244,
0.2259865403175354,
0.23691263794898987,
-0.5181235671043396,
0.010891038924455643,
0.36269164085388184,
0.10245869308710098,
-0.25598376989364624,
0.005298919044435024,
-0.29137301445007324,
0.23437650501728058,
0.6758246421813965,
0.19488279521465302,
0.0839342325925827,
-0.12068437784910202,
-0.2641003429889679,
-0.24560001492500305,
-0.807077169418335,
0.3731040358543396,
0.9346577525138855,
-0.04116875305771828,
0.1914282590150833,
0.6217304468154907,
-0.25525808334350586,
0.8605217337608337,
0.41650187969207764,
-0.3086746037006378,
0.04053843393921852,
-0.3525397479534149,
0.22503025829792023,
-0.2377626597881317,
0.46853509545326233,
0.9201329350471497,
0.2877572178840637,
-0.0196321252733469,
-0.05806946009397507,
-0.3448745310306549,
0.05853381007909775,
-0.9619309306144714,
-0.15421728789806366,
0.4916149973869324,
-0.40493205189704895,
-0.5528859496116638,
0.05955060198903084,
-0.7564888596534729,
-0.24910391867160797,
-0.25128161907196045,
0.3715098202228546,
-0.3636743724346161,
-0.2762567102909088,
0.19251856207847595,
-0.34054479002952576,
0.47356143593788147,
0.5801887512207031,
-0.8232048749923706,
-0.0394948348402977,
0.34069642424583435,
0.2808937728404999,
-0.19932812452316284,
0.23086702823638916,
-0.6177098155021667,
0.2778749167919159,
-0.47729089856147766,
0.7222704291343689,
-0.6591864228248596,
-0.43980443477630615,
-0.011693121865391731,
-0.30222320556640625,
0.2606687843799591,
-0.7544094324111938,
0.33890584111213684,
-0.5802813768386841,
0.3966675102710724,
-0.4757952094078064,
-0.6542016267776489,
0.07399403303861618,
0.6306201219558716,
-0.3066474497318268,
0.8691815733909607,
-0.27658528089523315,
-0.7289525866508484,
0.42074283957481384,
-0.7123974561691284,
0.0029140913393348455,
0.21903961896896362,
-0.3265730142593384,
-0.03979337587952614,
0.12384180724620819,
0.5123295187950134,
0.3958960175514221,
-0.3273453712463379,
0.2945324182510376,
-0.09788424521684647,
-0.33244195580482483,
0.2655511498451233,
-0.22270959615707397,
0.31496089696884155,
0.18059347569942474,
-0.3094053268432617,
0.019206292927265167,
-0.5862979292869568,
0.3771415650844574,
0.38500475883483887,
-0.7361531257629395,
-0.5551305413246155,
0.17973637580871582,
-0.6887558698654175,
-0.09156227111816406,
0.4194890260696411,
-0.6012141108512878,
0.15491053462028503,
-0.48911336064338684,
0.0019441164331510663,
0.795177161693573,
0.28913813829421997,
0.2971336543560028,
-0.5192760825157166,
0.4764440953731537,
0.24721942842006683,
0.3464025855064392,
0.021404124796390533,
-0.5912923216819763,
-0.9376083016395569,
0.19223356246948242,
-0.043241437524557114,
0.5424581170082092,
-1.0147079229354858,
0.3575010895729065,
-0.030261201784014702,
-0.5457281470298767,
-0.5149747729301453,
0.12875965237617493,
0.07819613814353943,
0.5456504225730896,
0.19364428520202637,
0.0597621314227581,
-0.6167328953742981,
-0.7240683436393738,
-0.15291830897331238,
-0.5404808521270752,
0.057337503880262375,
1.170141577720642,
0.11883126944303513,
0.16838130354881287,
0.7211718559265137,
-0.8108153939247131,
0.28906625509262085,
-0.44212624430656433,
-0.010864357464015484,
0.28127264976501465,
0.09451606124639511,
0.39892280101776123,
-0.9424034357070923,
-0.4285065829753876,
-0.27021247148513794,
-0.6343365907669067,
-0.07920489460229874,
0.024655986577272415,
-0.33483800292015076,
-0.2376568466424942,
0.16839317977428436,
-0.45032522082328796,
0.07041682302951813,
0.35893628001213074,
0.14355143904685974,
0.2763175070285797,
-0.2236439287662506,
0.44677895307540894,
-1.0914678573608398,
-0.045020073652267456,
-0.15049099922180176,
-0.04051000997424126,
-0.8522178530693054,
0.08680068701505661,
-0.26432323455810547,
-0.10630455613136292,
-0.4394695460796356,
0.6845303177833557,
-0.4706195592880249,
0.22748887538909912,
-0.19755332171916962,
0.43361905217170715,
0.10582723468542099,
0.5169191956520081,
0.06615711003541946,
0.8988919854164124,
0.38750794529914856,
-0.9957489371299744,
0.3965863287448883,
0.3261428475379944,
-0.5453033447265625,
0.3165145814418793,
-0.6381967067718506,
0.40819770097732544,
-0.6523488759994507,
-0.09244196861982346,
-1.1589645147323608,
-0.29080730676651,
0.22436368465423584,
-0.46535131335258484,
0.14980310201644897,
-0.023742349818348885,
-0.2587985098361969,
-0.30786821246147156,
-0.5196965336799622,
0.32848119735717773,
0.5422110557556152,
-0.7544525265693665,
0.09382963180541992,
0.5845063924789429,
-0.2101006656885147,
-0.7363053560256958,
-0.20564313232898712,
-0.16134652495384216,
-0.25139638781547546,
-0.6912286877632141,
0.08019546419382095,
-0.39429664611816406,
-0.4600125253200531,
-0.2084372341632843,
0.11685734242200851,
0.14266915619373322,
0.20092107355594635,
0.07356438040733337,
0.25277963280677795,
-0.20524944365024567,
0.42212438583374023,
0.06429001688957214,
0.4043636918067932,
0.07417573779821396,
-0.27590277791023254,
0.861048698425293,
0.06738857179880142,
-0.17165832221508026,
0.005223539192229509,
0.49746403098106384,
-0.14671950042247772,
-0.29217976331710815,
0.4506657123565674,
0.0602983757853508,
0.031003549695014954,
-0.396450400352478,
-0.6750391125679016,
-0.3499942123889923,
-0.49441152811050415,
0.40026527643203735,
-0.5333165526390076,
-1.084820032119751,
0.3104204535484314,
-0.2885621190071106,
0.011746120639145374,
0.3343067169189453,
0.48854711651802063,
-0.1342684030532837,
1.3259912729263306,
0.41565048694610596,
0.21601328253746033,
0.5441789031028748,
-0.20971958339214325,
-0.09061428904533386,
-0.6601663827896118,
-0.3727094233036041,
-0.40911903977394104,
-0.22425372898578644,
-0.2988385260105133,
-0.6475090980529785,
0.5143081545829773,
0.21572983264923096,
-0.03855397179722786,
0.13145136833190918,
-0.5619232058525085,
0.524573802947998,
0.6704111099243164,
0.39287567138671875,
0.2938027083873749,
0.13234995305538177,
-0.18085214495658875,
-0.08003143221139908,
-0.8033605813980103,
-0.5499991178512573,
1.2375974655151367,
0.27567505836486816,
0.9948570132255554,
0.16670088469982147,
1.0793081521987915,
-0.2563227713108063,
0.03285543993115425,
-0.8792309761047363,
0.5534784197807312,
0.19891196489334106,
-0.6245356202125549,
-0.4744895100593567,
-0.6716276407241821,
-0.8356539607048035,
-0.01892356388270855,
-0.20529071986675262,
-0.6755610108375549,
0.35881170630455017,
0.1216854602098465,
-0.5041894912719727,
0.32705509662628174,
-0.46694356203079224,
0.2889041602611542,
-0.47294682264328003,
-0.36566606163978577,
0.1005006805062294,
-0.4300512671470642,
0.3061513900756836,
0.16163355112075806,
-0.033297210931777954,
-0.11594192683696747,
-0.19720250368118286,
0.715979814529419,
-0.08937685936689377,
0.3445329964160919,
-0.3009885549545288,
-0.13674387335777283,
0.6272584795951843,
-0.11118590086698532,
0.6502619981765747,
0.1453017145395279,
-0.23919297754764557,
-0.174722358584404,
-0.24849702417850494,
-0.0952409952878952,
-0.8713270425796509,
0.4529320299625397,
-0.9197648763656616,
-1.1096162796020508,
0.12624146044254303,
-0.48889246582984924,
-0.3993634283542633,
-0.008091306313872337,
0.16415497660636902,
0.2852995693683624,
-0.22789844870567322,
0.15399760007858276,
0.8913173079490662,
-0.5425649285316467,
0.11178548634052277,
0.376229852437973,
-0.14823591709136963,
-0.3138597309589386,
0.5916298031806946,
-0.2264421284198761,
0.5997499227523804,
0.644238293170929,
0.485272079706192,
-0.26237162947654724,
-0.6607191562652588,
-0.46566277742385864,
0.3058280646800995,
-0.7427862286567688,
-0.2239614725112915,
-0.7516394257545471,
-0.10248681157827377,
-0.2249757945537567,
0.37754935026168823,
0.0037234772462397814,
-0.2631562352180481,
-0.4426113963127136,
-0.24489936232566833,
0.4083770513534546,
0.7543547749519348,
0.00306162447668612,
0.1548013538122177,
-0.6724736094474792,
-0.12511737644672394,
0.44482100009918213,
0.09217768907546997,
-0.18308234214782715,
-0.48615971207618713,
-0.022847875952720642,
0.31190353631973267,
-0.29161494970321655,
-0.8683968186378479,
0.22211094200611115,
0.0867132768034935,
0.8313934206962585,
0.5244817137718201,
0.15863974392414093,
0.5872063040733337,
-0.36548733711242676,
0.7087088227272034,
0.14528316259384155,
-0.378214031457901,
0.9136296510696411,
-0.3823367953300476,
0.19370800256729126,
0.6370435357093811,
0.7667578458786011,
-0.16318421065807343,
-0.214261993765831,
-0.459894597530365,
-0.625557005405426,
0.7238906025886536,
0.0241526048630476,
0.495126336812973,
-0.48378559947013855,
0.47050708532333374,
0.17052699625492096,
0.4844691753387451,
-0.5772100687026978,
-0.2980884611606598,
0.29162904620170593,
0.01973961479961872,
0.16674447059631348,
-0.46976006031036377,
-0.3172708749771118,
-0.016419723629951477,
0.7067314386367798,
-0.1983983814716339,
0.4285520911216736,
0.27927079796791077,
0.2783375382423401,
-0.29289117455482483,
0.30340060591697693,
0.5617530941963196,
0.5887821912765503,
-0.4259278178215027,
-0.005591473542153835,
0.10795345157384872,
-0.22160695493221283,
0.20432768762111664,
-0.15908806025981903,
-0.38711681962013245,
-0.10196270048618317,
-0.13854600489139557,
1.1350082159042358,
-0.09966517239809036,
-0.8098401427268982,
0.5496529936790466,
-0.19712862372398376,
-0.3292666971683502,
0.0377638041973114,
0.33600857853889465,
0.15653318166732788,
0.3321897089481354,
0.2051851898431778,
-0.3364127278327942,
0.08418592810630798,
-0.8213649392127991,
0.16399626433849335,
0.6177177429199219,
-0.3869364559650421,
0.15712736546993256,
0.5697923898696899,
0.25510290265083313,
-0.24161380529403687,
0.28538867831230164,
-0.10605121403932571,
-0.47465479373931885,
0.42131033539772034,
0.5152296423912048,
0.33568906784057617,
-0.19993768632411957,
0.4383070468902588,
0.5301269292831421,
0.11568482220172882,
-0.019641496241092682,
0.7463003993034363,
-0.21493485569953918,
-0.8165323138237,
-0.31079360842704773,
-0.35074323415756226,
-0.7341136932373047,
0.28243085741996765,
-0.3157115578651428,
0.4019262492656708,
-0.41245079040527344,
-0.36176958680152893,
-0.18434089422225952,
0.1547372043132782,
-0.6240704655647278,
0.22335486114025116,
-0.07688304036855698,
0.5367305278778076,
-0.10012006759643555,
0.2849232852458954,
0.6495833396911621,
-0.5489314794540405,
-1.0795096158981323,
-0.08923312276601791,
-0.6521972417831421,
-0.9983029365539551,
0.9054140448570251,
-0.008299174718558788,
0.018728401511907578,
0.04672824218869209,
-0.9243085384368896,
-1.0802769660949707,
1.0360937118530273,
0.4045393764972687,
-0.589381217956543,
-0.2764360010623932,
0.2122570127248764,
0.2818874716758728,
-0.6128773093223572,
0.5769690275192261,
0.05732588469982147,
0.48395034670829773,
0.34459152817726135,
-0.5081189274787903,
-0.14744991064071655,
-0.28966882824897766,
-0.30173182487487793,
0.16207793354988098,
-0.6310059428215027,
0.7123167514801025,
-0.5907456278800964,
-0.1239842027425766,
-0.016212986782193184,
0.4790400564670563,
0.37053999304771423,
0.061915624886751175,
0.6902730464935303,
0.24496321380138397,
0.9799383878707886,
-0.13096289336681366,
1.145047903060913,
-0.5251089930534363,
0.08257021754980087,
1.0011870861053467,
-0.13660387694835663,
0.8136013150215149,
0.5412342548370361,
0.05124824866652489,
0.20668140053749084,
0.7284483909606934,
-0.10556895285844803,
0.6175129413604736,
0.8232135772705078,
-0.15558835864067078,
-0.5363596081733704,
-0.2666190266609192,
-0.2613442540168762,
0.538320779800415,
0.12409988045692444,
-0.4969998300075531,
0.02908170223236084,
-0.12340546399354935,
0.10099487751722336,
0.02919975109398365,
-0.16246727108955383,
1.1265901327133179,
-0.10650733858346939,
-1.0103079080581665,
0.3817392587661743,
-0.09868380427360535,
0.6114351749420166,
-0.6716993451118469,
-0.24868078529834747,
-0.36883237957954407,
-0.0071662478148937225,
0.048461176455020905,
-0.6030967831611633,
-0.2907524108886719,
0.22016698122024536,
-0.09169968962669373,
0.18179793655872345,
0.8003790974617004,
-0.6252776384353638,
-0.34532836079597473,
0.2423309087753296,
0.853905975818634,
0.5407410264015198,
-0.04789069667458534,
-0.5832447409629822,
-0.13844221830368042,
0.1748363971710205,
-0.3321281671524048,
0.18320883810520172,
0.3695893883705139,
0.2798437774181366,
0.6447575688362122,
0.6739198565483093,
0.316363662481308,
0.10195571184158325,
-0.10040842741727829,
1.025417447090149,
-0.3001841902732849,
-0.2642686367034912,
-0.7291197776794434,
0.3832632899284363,
-0.4876921474933624,
-0.2741982936859131,
0.7969986796379089,
0.7032092213630676,
0.8937757015228271,
-0.11019358783960342,
0.8543071150779724,
0.20793373882770538,
0.5359222888946533,
-0.4914364516735077,
0.4592651128768921,
-0.6582015752792358,
0.3405596911907196,
-0.22882795333862305,
-1.0545235872268677,
0.22870154678821564,
0.5236569046974182,
-0.3144056797027588,
0.03173323720693588,
0.33797332644462585,
0.8447445034980774,
0.26066574454307556,
0.017107022926211357,
0.6084603071212769,
-0.1155078187584877,
0.313083291053772,
0.8221532702445984,
1.2232489585876465,
-0.33123844861984253,
0.7023607492446899,
-0.21310767531394958,
-0.36090999841690063,
-0.027888093143701553,
-0.7500472664833069,
-1.1645667552947998,
-0.41417258977890015,
-0.12786421179771423,
-0.18417339026927948,
0.19592520594596863,
1.1690263748168945,
0.5982548594474792,
-0.4458438754081726,
-0.3696316182613373,
0.17886397242546082,
0.06363119184970856,
0.31212207674980164,
-0.16707971692085266,
0.06238057091832161,
-0.36767256259918213,
-0.9358678460121155,
0.5562583804130554,
0.19911183416843414,
0.11517413705587387,
-0.2603868246078491,
-0.008929328992962837,
-0.2608998119831085,
0.5562631487846375,
0.3660734295845032,
-0.15166139602661133,
-0.3779149353504181,
-0.4541974365711212,
0.4829491078853607,
0.05019735172390938,
0.2623465061187744,
0.6686606407165527,
-0.27359914779663086,
0.688159167766571,
0.564506471157074,
0.6696231365203857,
0.5694057941436768,
0.37098512053489685,
0.8117231130599976,
-0.6186889410018921,
-0.13490788638591766,
0.3467811942100525,
-0.010504762642085552,
0.38517364859580994,
-0.68349289894104,
0.5009240508079529,
-0.12722785770893097,
-0.4309083819389343,
-0.5929722785949707,
0.3097410500049591,
-0.6025401949882507,
-0.10111556947231293,
1.5981525182724,
-0.17317411303520203,
-0.05469038709998131,
0.269767701625824,
-0.4188635051250458,
0.1739809811115265,
-0.5122866630554199,
0.42991021275520325,
0.8752925992012024,
-0.35755789279937744,
-0.11868689954280853,
-0.45115312933921814,
0.7159759998321533,
0.3912501931190491,
-1.1393686532974243,
-0.18936105072498322,
0.37359070777893066,
0.11511501669883728,
0.11762997508049011,
0.6185764670372009,
-0.0889541357755661,
0.12260216474533081,
-0.06933946907520294,
-0.08623722940683365,
-0.271952748298645,
-0.25377437472343445,
0.09226594120264053,
0.19015216827392578,
0.2961331605911255,
-0.19692012667655945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17430v1 | Towards Probing Speech-Specific Risks in Large Multimodal Models: A Taxonomy, Benchmark, and Insights | 2024-06-25T10:08:45 | 2024-06-25T10:08:45 | Hao Yang, Lizhen Qu, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have achieved great success recently,
demonstrating a strong capability to understand multimodal information and to
interact with human users. Despite the progress made, the challenge of
detecting high-risk interactions in multimodal settings, and in particular in
speech modality, remains largely unexplored. Conventional research on risk for
speech modality primarily emphasises the content (e.g., what is captured as
transcription). However, in speech-based interactions, paralinguistic cues in
audio can significantly alter the intended meaning behind utterances. In this
work, we propose a speech-specific risk taxonomy, covering 8 risk categories
under hostility (malicious sarcasm and threats), malicious imitation (age,
gender, ethnicity), and stereotypical biases (age, gender, ethnicity). Based on
the taxonomy, we create a small-scale dataset for evaluating current LMMs
capability in detecting these categories of risk. We observe even the latest
models remain ineffective to detect various paralinguistic-specific risks in
speech (e.g., Gemini 1.5 Pro is performing only slightly above random
baseline). Warning: this paper contains biased and offensive examples. | [
-0.25214684009552,
-0.8280624747276306,
0.3340564966201782,
0.05768387392163277,
0.13908758759498596,
-0.3457249402999878,
-0.1840122938156128,
-0.41738632321357727,
0.13450098037719727,
0.5306857228279114,
-0.5178518891334534,
-0.339708536863327,
-0.7462772727012634,
-0.33243197202682495,
-0.27298861742019653,
1.0233478546142578,
0.3041207492351532,
-0.06254883855581284,
-0.14333802461624146,
-0.2630802392959595,
-0.43521252274513245,
-0.7404615879058838,
-0.5065621733665466,
0.200839564204216,
1.0436787605285645,
0.12657925486564636,
0.7647422552108765,
0.16200441122055054,
0.6218209862709045,
0.27124249935150146,
-0.21696989238262177,
-0.1556650549173355,
-0.2889403700828552,
0.42513659596443176,
-0.23915472626686096,
-0.231049582362175,
-0.5839198231697083,
0.1591363549232483,
0.7716599702835083,
0.7791449427604675,
-0.2785130739212036,
0.39868003129959106,
-0.03054826706647873,
0.024269742891192436,
-0.8767176270484924,
0.20675323903560638,
-0.763136625289917,
-0.03682231903076172,
-0.6848159432411194,
-0.31717804074287415,
-0.547917902469635,
0.04758261889219284,
0.20548716187477112,
-0.2028186023235321,
-0.34924033284187317,
-0.07080192118883133,
0.3180597126483917,
0.18754267692565918,
-0.949074387550354,
-0.2548495829105377,
-0.7535231709480286,
0.7042188048362732,
-0.6567575335502625,
0.4557522237300873,
0.40726977586746216,
0.6058716773986816,
0.05249512940645218,
-0.6569235324859619,
-0.4427657127380371,
-0.31048503518104553,
0.13235917687416077,
-0.11486294865608215,
-0.5678443908691406,
0.19033381342887878,
0.26407507061958313,
0.0049004945904016495,
-0.5735619068145752,
0.1701233834028244,
-0.2205737978219986,
-0.6028256416320801,
0.4894506633281708,
0.20275139808654785,
0.3497249186038971,
-0.3826969265937805,
-0.35239964723587036,
-0.19299526512622833,
-0.5696820020675659,
0.3681682050228119,
0.6788841485977173,
0.46495378017425537,
-0.14894743263721466,
0.5398228168487549,
-0.023150315508246422,
0.5194575786590576,
-0.321770042181015,
-0.39907726645469666,
0.4858943819999695,
-0.44442716240882874,
-0.0486643984913826,
0.029532140120863914,
0.8165653347969055,
0.32961568236351013,
0.13543635606765747,
-0.022778503596782684,
-0.08047585189342499,
-0.0432031974196434,
0.06623054295778275,
-0.3632275462150574,
0.14131246507167816,
0.07065097242593765,
-0.38704365491867065,
-0.4022611975669861,
-0.23133738338947296,
-0.8702368140220642,
-0.7265406250953674,
-0.062483660876750946,
0.7373606562614441,
-0.5323969125747681,
-0.4968560039997101,
0.07003570348024368,
-0.09602568298578262,
0.22054128348827362,
0.023504843935370445,
-0.45216646790504456,
-0.1741134375333786,
0.4305039942264557,
0.5317350625991821,
0.02335771918296814,
-0.18153338134288788,
-0.7410182952880859,
0.31356385350227356,
-0.09484444558620453,
0.551800012588501,
-0.6984020471572876,
-0.37152716517448425,
0.007485545240342617,
-0.251550555229187,
-0.15558072924613953,
-0.3681851029396057,
1.0337492227554321,
-0.0788809061050415,
0.07575353235006332,
-0.11625227332115173,
-0.09101632982492447,
-0.27586016058921814,
0.2982308864593506,
-0.6049789786338806,
0.752056360244751,
-0.17834097146987915,
-0.9758408069610596,
0.26976248621940613,
-0.31039464473724365,
-0.36485040187835693,
-0.12576302886009216,
-0.3214510977268219,
-0.3843749463558197,
0.06843842566013336,
-0.010584399104118347,
0.5057815909385681,
-0.2678074538707733,
0.5831416249275208,
-0.4288727641105652,
0.09291647374629974,
0.595826268196106,
-0.9553470611572266,
0.5062311887741089,
0.18003423511981964,
-0.23247815668582916,
0.4949330687522888,
-0.7199414372444153,
-0.09718877822160721,
-0.17275622487068176,
-0.051003456115722656,
-0.537257194519043,
0.0257926806807518,
0.26571813225746155,
0.6538428664207458,
0.0308237187564373,
-0.4268573224544525,
-0.29789695143699646,
0.1280028373003006,
0.6186156868934631,
0.7191649675369263,
0.050639715045690536,
0.13687686622142792,
-0.4769173264503479,
0.6151846051216125,
0.2620384097099304,
0.44383129477500916,
-0.3916431963443756,
-0.5630962252616882,
-0.3075058162212372,
-0.5736024975776672,
0.27131563425064087,
0.5709550976753235,
-0.7875528335571289,
0.1573270857334137,
-0.38606488704681396,
-0.7527468204498291,
-0.4268735647201538,
-0.2667117118835449,
0.5372393131256104,
0.4400446116924286,
0.14288003742694855,
-0.2806972563266754,
-0.4530235826969147,
-1.1018669605255127,
-0.4848964214324951,
-0.327560693025589,
0.0913432389497757,
0.5179426074028015,
0.18860244750976562,
-0.4289938509464264,
0.6808291077613831,
-0.14227767288684845,
-0.36143016815185547,
0.03573654219508171,
0.38811758160591125,
-0.07386824488639832,
0.43562960624694824,
0.4984672963619232,
-0.9807147979736328,
-0.07107573747634888,
-0.20896852016448975,
-0.4433034658432007,
-0.14557385444641113,
-0.1827528029680252,
0.30373600125312805,
-0.16945874691009521,
0.5773851275444031,
-0.7052759528160095,
0.19446583092212677,
0.8462734222412109,
-0.1765284389257431,
0.6785447001457214,
0.1864437460899353,
0.12454725801944733,
-0.8490506410598755,
0.11705944687128067,
0.25813397765159607,
-0.033094167709350586,
-0.955211877822876,
0.014669960364699364,
-0.05004710704088211,
-0.30110594630241394,
-0.8418977856636047,
0.30141720175743103,
-0.12471538037061691,
0.016663163900375366,
0.17056672275066376,
0.0016949328128248453,
-0.37064066529273987,
0.2669340670108795,
-0.218253955245018,
0.6710244417190552,
0.7205156683921814,
-0.49384695291519165,
0.19724729657173157,
-0.02499370649456978,
-0.467290461063385,
0.6155650615692139,
-0.5143883228302002,
0.1829473227262497,
-0.2224298119544983,
0.34483715891838074,
-1.1079416275024414,
-0.21465200185775757,
0.20391924679279327,
-0.5833103656768799,
0.2578693926334381,
0.048281703144311905,
-0.4073250889778137,
-0.14738066494464874,
-0.4100929796695709,
0.8238847851753235,
0.25987887382507324,
-0.02919517457485199,
0.9955044388771057,
0.6566805243492126,
-0.6368501782417297,
-0.6286173462867737,
-0.5736786723136902,
0.33861351013183594,
-0.6961447596549988,
-0.8191226720809937,
0.23987500369548798,
-0.039774976670742035,
-0.4092405438423157,
-0.33962783217430115,
-0.14452990889549255,
0.10229207575321198,
0.001430761069059372,
0.46445003151893616,
-0.015426473692059517,
-0.04217616096138954,
0.1321520209312439,
-0.052793122828006744,
0.0033334209583699703,
0.14015810191631317,
0.14277531206607819,
0.6517231464385986,
-0.03672835975885391,
-0.3201906979084015,
-0.5200099945068359,
0.4345318377017975,
0.8462160229682922,
-0.4742374122142792,
0.5481266975402832,
0.9303646683692932,
-0.30974453687667847,
0.17674046754837036,
-0.6122469902038574,
-0.17953623831272125,
-0.476358026266098,
0.4392906129360199,
-0.48722031712532043,
-0.782900333404541,
0.6073750257492065,
0.07236075401306152,
-0.24782852828502655,
0.3824150562286377,
0.6803786754608154,
-0.045941635966300964,
1.021583080291748,
0.3451964855194092,
-0.20066778361797333,
0.392578125,
0.18911343812942505,
0.041531410068273544,
-0.633225679397583,
-0.4961738586425781,
-0.6511370539665222,
-0.12458866834640503,
-0.6611739993095398,
-0.7126349806785583,
0.716454803943634,
-0.6488553881645203,
-0.18471738696098328,
0.30792611837387085,
0.07222966104745865,
-0.04715253412723541,
0.5686591267585754,
-0.0004639394173864275,
0.17447373270988464,
-0.41699516773223877,
0.06992079317569733,
-0.03173770383000374,
-0.5946184396743774,
-0.2994821071624756,
1.149753212928772,
0.7749142050743103,
0.9307088255882263,
0.42463648319244385,
0.3429296612739563,
0.4017181098461151,
-0.06042279675602913,
-0.602027952671051,
0.5154199004173279,
-0.038680944591760635,
-0.9451057314872742,
-0.2711275815963745,
-0.7482584118843079,
-0.7614414095878601,
0.21829788386821747,
-0.2935444414615631,
-0.7137507796287537,
0.38756436109542847,
0.1725894957780838,
-0.44421473145484924,
0.1796995848417282,
-0.48845523595809937,
0.7916573882102966,
-0.24286417663097382,
-0.23196154832839966,
-0.11479522287845612,
-0.9093776345252991,
0.594968318939209,
-0.20174908638000488,
0.7582415342330933,
-0.33197999000549316,
-0.039706215262413025,
0.6880214810371399,
0.42994800209999084,
1.073176383972168,
-0.1781514286994934,
-0.5306738018989563,
0.13425932824611664,
0.23422811925411224,
0.3880215287208557,
-0.020034879446029663,
-0.017173614352941513,
0.1917169839143753,
0.18522676825523376,
-0.21763400733470917,
-0.22449250519275665,
0.6090971231460571,
-0.514764666557312,
-0.4532693326473236,
-0.5588883757591248,
-0.9877215623855591,
-0.6161278486251831,
-0.06315668672323227,
0.18245074152946472,
0.5857945680618286,
-0.25160127878189087,
0.4211976230144501,
0.7145446538925171,
-0.5041126012802124,
0.2806472182273865,
0.4020081162452698,
0.012779534794390202,
-0.4111480116844177,
1.0019199848175049,
0.03094843216240406,
0.4682663679122925,
0.26223254203796387,
0.2986166477203369,
-0.3202064037322998,
-0.48219868540763855,
-0.034221965819597244,
-0.022784249857068062,
-0.8149633407592773,
-0.04996950179338455,
-0.45152994990348816,
0.008000504225492477,
-0.6253673434257507,
0.4275169372558594,
-0.14933335781097412,
-0.33848026394844055,
-0.08381174504756927,
0.03628724440932274,
-0.03234158828854561,
0.13115505874156952,
-0.09652382135391235,
0.16983242332935333,
-0.8061605095863342,
0.15814410150051117,
0.5263777375221252,
0.0778331533074379,
-0.18206621706485748,
-0.6743488311767578,
0.1756298691034317,
0.021345481276512146,
-0.23979824781417847,
-0.890646755695343,
0.2841789722442627,
0.5054978132247925,
0.8803035020828247,
0.7141976356506348,
0.09424743056297302,
0.4040141999721527,
-0.6319303512573242,
0.8679912686347961,
0.40738674998283386,
-0.9567506909370422,
0.38842231035232544,
-0.8110923171043396,
0.01573285274207592,
0.4227577745914459,
0.666315495967865,
-1.0317277908325195,
-0.2372017800807953,
-0.6161749362945557,
-0.8558701276779175,
0.26866260170936584,
0.18435971438884735,
0.5132922530174255,
0.00971879344433546,
0.013441032730042934,
0.0712418258190155,
0.2958970069885254,
-0.7407083511352539,
-0.12111754715442657,
-0.06428369134664536,
-0.18342891335487366,
-0.34220075607299805,
-0.3086898922920227,
-0.5937338471412659,
-0.08285079896450043,
0.3879282474517822,
-0.08643751591444016,
0.21701839566230774,
-0.09408827871084213,
-0.15981365740299225,
-0.01846575178205967,
0.5227804183959961,
0.8330609798431396,
0.33234408497810364,
-0.2554807960987091,
0.5905323028564453,
0.04564960300922394,
-0.2872649133205414,
0.20747950673103333,
0.1804099828004837,
0.1857166886329651,
-0.11005187034606934,
0.684911847114563,
0.8719998598098755,
0.4687628746032715,
-1.1890772581100464,
0.6999340057373047,
0.22386367619037628,
-0.022717252373695374,
-0.08540093153715134,
-0.1625954508781433,
-0.0810294970870018,
0.16818219423294067,
0.2076582908630371,
0.039765115827322006,
0.35996749997138977,
-1.0285776853561401,
0.36527031660079956,
0.5458081960678101,
-0.5924854278564453,
-0.3586418032646179,
0.5056373476982117,
0.3391401171684265,
-0.00608776556327939,
0.004259852226823568,
-0.050667401403188705,
-0.37275949120521545,
0.4672355651855469,
0.26709720492362976,
0.6555472016334534,
-0.4822622239589691,
0.17947199940681458,
-0.06424321979284286,
0.45534855127334595,
0.2535456418991089,
0.2840758264064789,
0.30620431900024414,
-0.6675699353218079,
-0.2244693487882614,
-0.31315723061561584,
-0.5045819878578186,
0.15728288888931274,
-0.8351650238037109,
0.23362353444099426,
-0.27112525701522827,
-0.5649811029434204,
0.4583435356616974,
-0.6980313062667847,
-0.34618398547172546,
0.06304030120372772,
0.5989022850990295,
0.8051175475120544,
-0.9234734177589417,
0.6831790804862976,
0.5717830657958984,
-0.2848037779331207,
-0.5289503931999207,
0.10419218242168427,
0.5412719249725342,
-0.6537435054779053,
0.638465166091919,
0.1509624421596527,
-0.2204807847738266,
-0.28901204466819763,
-0.06871237605810165,
-0.8079527616500854,
0.9461142420768738,
0.4366370737552643,
-0.6069424152374268,
-0.3180842399597168,
0.43470239639282227,
0.24886997044086456,
-0.16034743189811707,
0.12090828269720078,
0.5598392486572266,
0.5134755373001099,
-0.04514378309249878,
-1.3115952014923096,
-0.17001104354858398,
0.006611061282455921,
-0.01535889133810997,
0.20662258565425873,
-0.456594318151474,
1.0958584547042847,
0.1051720455288887,
0.00559254502877593,
-0.030024785548448563,
0.3691645562648773,
-0.002014353172853589,
0.6028779149055481,
0.7412288188934326,
0.5280282497406006,
0.5591457486152649,
-0.03396885469555855,
0.9601966738700867,
-0.08298920094966888,
0.1807761788368225,
1.0796451568603516,
-0.31637856364250183,
0.8422605991363525,
0.46964433789253235,
-0.0557858981192112,
0.1505635380744934,
0.5164432525634766,
0.32982274889945984,
0.45088815689086914,
0.2878980040550232,
-0.5143912434577942,
-0.3583802878856659,
-0.33672481775283813,
-0.36783567070961,
0.9256165027618408,
0.5792279839515686,
-0.4550761878490448,
-0.1520916223526001,
0.648490309715271,
0.15089568495750427,
-0.061724867671728134,
-0.5042133331298828,
0.6335300207138062,
0.0799781009554863,
-0.2830515503883362,
0.33042705059051514,
-0.04590284824371338,
0.9084163308143616,
-0.7696400284767151,
0.390491247177124,
0.13322608172893524,
0.07314710319042206,
0.021915823221206665,
-0.6464008688926697,
0.28323620557785034,
-0.2043793499469757,
0.10104802995920181,
0.025747688487172127,
0.5734424591064453,
-0.47429078817367554,
-0.4255654215812683,
0.26938697695732117,
0.419294536113739,
-0.055672526359558105,
-0.2974857687950134,
-0.529506266117096,
0.2801114618778229,
-0.30744436383247375,
-0.10776462405920029,
0.5621881484985352,
0.44566670060157776,
-0.11225654184818268,
0.828545868396759,
0.47361451387405396,
-0.047674763947725296,
0.18232135474681854,
0.08711212128400803,
0.7579126358032227,
-0.579101026058197,
-0.3081062436103821,
-0.6898297071456909,
0.5245500206947327,
0.2243286669254303,
-0.5173244476318359,
0.8744547367095947,
0.403397798538208,
0.5166531801223755,
0.060870904475450516,
0.5799282789230347,
-0.03168054297566414,
0.2629460096359253,
-0.5742515325546265,
0.7371605038642883,
-0.5040889382362366,
-0.006615737918764353,
-0.6436635851860046,
-0.47091391682624817,
-0.28443431854248047,
0.25788912177085876,
-0.36293697357177734,
-0.0799776017665863,
0.4548066258430481,
0.8456876277923584,
0.07454416900873184,
-0.1083587184548378,
0.5887963771820068,
0.17352229356765747,
0.3804945647716522,
0.47658565640449524,
1.0351829528808594,
-0.046036750078201294,
0.8319538235664368,
-0.15287180244922638,
-0.33698344230651855,
-0.11724929511547089,
-1.0582501888275146,
-0.6890828609466553,
-0.89522385597229,
-0.3720843195915222,
-0.32225194573402405,
-0.08357027918100357,
0.743637204170227,
0.7202385663986206,
-0.526353657245636,
-0.012286590412259102,
0.47873449325561523,
-0.33369284868240356,
-0.25568336248397827,
-0.15520694851875305,
0.13214340806007385,
0.01716909185051918,
-0.5387614369392395,
0.462581068277359,
0.13291260600090027,
-0.08043590933084488,
-0.311210572719574,
0.1627287119626999,
-0.147442027926445,
0.40098053216934204,
0.7741749882698059,
0.16333448886871338,
-0.8244884610176086,
-0.6702876687049866,
-0.11959338933229446,
0.03912966325879097,
-0.3592376410961151,
0.917252242565155,
-0.27331432700157166,
0.2893037796020508,
0.35054779052734375,
0.5532349348068237,
0.18063853681087494,
-0.4039326310157776,
0.2521516978740692,
-0.9419329166412354,
0.3205851912498474,
0.5473020672798157,
0.39607927203178406,
0.23085327446460724,
-0.24194157123565674,
0.1714312583208084,
0.24840116500854492,
-0.3883652687072754,
-1.0633405447006226,
0.5881703495979309,
-1.433173656463623,
-0.21059207618236542,
1.3896547555923462,
-0.11365380883216858,
0.24507072567939758,
-0.01640699803829193,
-0.3918401300907135,
0.15300513803958893,
-0.2868540585041046,
0.7453719973564148,
0.6642341613769531,
-0.01504733320325613,
-0.2900375723838806,
-0.8285694718360901,
0.5203956961631775,
0.3478161692619324,
-0.742102324962616,
0.27639925479888916,
0.5150739550590515,
0.2133740782737732,
0.4121251702308655,
0.19057540595531464,
-0.28881195187568665,
0.4313279688358307,
-0.016143230721354485,
-0.06529168784618378,
-0.07963912189006805,
-0.48905274271965027,
-0.5698720216751099,
0.42616069316864014,
-0.06846509873867035,
-0.09749076515436172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17419v1 | Leave No Document Behind: Benchmarking Long-Context LLMs with Extended Multi-Doc QA | 2024-06-25T09:42:56 | 2024-06-25T09:42:56 | Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi Liao, Xinghua Zhang, Bingli Wu, Haiyang Yu, Nan Xu, Lei Zhang, Run Luo, Yunshui Li, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context modeling capabilities have garnered widespread attention,
leading to the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) with ultra-context
windows. Meanwhile, benchmarks for evaluating long-context LLMs are gradually
catching up. However, existing benchmarks employ irrelevant noise texts to
artificially extend the length of test cases, diverging from the real-world
scenarios of long-context applications. To bridge this gap, we propose a novel
long-context benchmark, Loong, aligning with realistic scenarios through
extended multi-document question answering (QA). Unlike typical document QA, in
Loong's test cases, each document is relevant to the final answer, ignoring any
document will lead to the failure of the answer. Furthermore, Loong introduces
four types of tasks with a range of context lengths: Spotlight Locating,
Comparison, Clustering, and Chain of Reasoning, to facilitate a more realistic
and comprehensive evaluation of long-context understanding. Extensive
experiments indicate that existing long-context language models still exhibit
considerable potential for enhancement. Retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
achieves poor performance, demonstrating that Loong can reliably assess the
model's long-context modeling capabilities. | [
-0.4958092272281647,
-0.9656378030776978,
0.8033941984176636,
0.23403315246105194,
-0.3401069939136505,
0.025845644995570183,
-0.39779824018478394,
-0.6474803686141968,
0.03613768145442009,
0.7577371001243591,
-0.5414946675300598,
-0.48911333084106445,
-0.36127030849456787,
0.0444975420832634,
-0.7175783514976501,
0.7869351506233215,
-0.25750991702079773,
-0.4032166600227356,
-0.5387116074562073,
-0.46918797492980957,
-0.30045920610427856,
-0.3676091730594635,
-0.580008327960968,
-0.17047497630119324,
0.6082329154014587,
0.1534273773431778,
0.32505980134010315,
0.4291810989379883,
0.2584853768348694,
0.22507375478744507,
-0.23116610944271088,
0.24022817611694336,
-0.47942230105400085,
0.2575339674949646,
0.09609706699848175,
-0.22643612325191498,
-0.5489788055419922,
0.08785323798656464,
0.8142176270484924,
0.6789782643318176,
-0.11776423454284668,
0.23978467285633087,
-0.012959188781678677,
0.5758763551712036,
-0.6013016700744629,
0.13479703664779663,
-0.5854912996292114,
-0.1352270245552063,
-0.04297046735882759,
-0.222046360373497,
-0.27743104100227356,
-0.38757964968681335,
-0.025107618421316147,
-0.6511742472648621,
0.14133848249912262,
-0.18879814445972443,
0.6846621036529541,
0.26876166462898254,
-0.6807749271392822,
-0.27471956610679626,
-0.4503251016139984,
0.7393777370452881,
-0.7529048323631287,
0.4253003001213074,
0.43729859590530396,
0.3858322203159332,
-0.10503189265727997,
-0.7255457043647766,
-0.6379330158233643,
-0.2558750510215759,
0.22945177555084229,
0.4842822253704071,
0.26771023869514465,
-0.15749336779117584,
0.2624337375164032,
0.3116563856601715,
-0.23976558446884155,
0.054642174392938614,
-0.34364739060401917,
0.09597256034612656,
0.3884589672088623,
-0.24035994708538055,
-0.03094983845949173,
0.014718743041157722,
-0.6239889860153198,
0.0007522156811319292,
-0.770117998123169,
0.095040462911129,
0.12839698791503906,
0.11376078426837921,
0.03174454718828201,
0.4732937812805176,
-0.18295401334762573,
0.5856209397315979,
-0.18357758224010468,
-0.19425103068351746,
0.33353284001350403,
-0.31016916036605835,
-0.25063812732696533,
-0.14522987604141235,
0.5466728806495667,
0.4327749013900757,
-0.058337338268756866,
-0.3275432586669922,
-0.31985732913017273,
-0.10954642295837402,
0.1774439811706543,
-0.7551576495170593,
0.4813905358314514,
0.3603646159172058,
-0.2589215636253357,
-0.21440264582633972,
-0.45300596952438354,
-0.7805913686752319,
-0.5309810042381287,
-0.10966936498880386,
0.34601110219955444,
-0.45612195134162903,
-0.14878788590431213,
-0.10967472195625305,
-0.18636001646518707,
0.5190837979316711,
0.4197498559951782,
-0.48116323351860046,
0.5382332801818848,
0.9876184463500977,
0.6770778298377991,
-0.3084789514541626,
-0.6550549864768982,
-0.9938199520111084,
0.24160994589328766,
-0.4833013713359833,
0.8240075707435608,
-0.5007367134094238,
-0.5330837965011597,
0.11533038318157196,
0.09094259887933731,
-0.11245660483837128,
-0.6256090998649597,
0.8782640099525452,
-0.5614038109779358,
0.5256969928741455,
-0.28403422236442566,
-0.7186354398727417,
-0.045151595026254654,
0.5742073059082031,
-0.6210452914237976,
1.3737890720367432,
0.4887774586677551,
-0.4650120139122009,
0.15391959249973297,
-0.6347075700759888,
-0.5122897624969482,
-0.11015273630619049,
-0.2851662337779999,
-0.32402658462524414,
0.14192324876785278,
0.08969135582447052,
0.11517874896526337,
-0.5129801630973816,
0.16835036873817444,
-0.38862845301628113,
-0.7842461466789246,
0.0004392437112983316,
-0.47953328490257263,
0.42343756556510925,
0.0028621861711144447,
-0.47410085797309875,
-0.00914002675563097,
-0.9275005459785461,
0.30415472388267517,
0.045927658677101135,
-0.6133202910423279,
-0.3307725191116333,
-0.1827383190393448,
0.18889962136745453,
0.3683732748031616,
0.3674257695674896,
-0.6720009446144104,
0.09587620943784714,
-0.23480111360549927,
0.37091535329818726,
0.6432546973228455,
-0.12048853933811188,
0.3452623784542084,
-0.5296619534492493,
0.6963568925857544,
-0.12428753077983856,
0.07359088212251663,
-0.31934428215026855,
-0.36821386218070984,
-0.5488672852516174,
-0.3233342170715332,
0.23398970067501068,
0.34695062041282654,
-0.510148823261261,
0.148514062166214,
-0.47567108273506165,
-0.3262036144733429,
-0.5996426939964294,
0.2733311653137207,
0.5072965621948242,
0.6043338775634766,
0.3915163278579712,
-0.161505326628685,
-0.24821732938289642,
-0.6489941477775574,
-0.27270641922950745,
-0.14694862067699432,
0.02460385300219059,
0.520384669303894,
0.34398484230041504,
-0.300988107919693,
0.7783838510513306,
-0.31450021266937256,
-0.2780778706073761,
-0.037966854870319366,
-0.05910823866724968,
0.28065943717956543,
0.10526728630065918,
0.37182533740997314,
-0.8508161306381226,
-0.36328792572021484,
-0.1273234337568283,
-0.7064293026924133,
-0.21981972455978394,
-0.014934547245502472,
-0.005567452870309353,
0.49927273392677307,
0.7448524832725525,
-0.9553239941596985,
0.26129910349845886,
0.717284619808197,
-0.08474858105182648,
0.6867974996566772,
-0.31499430537223816,
0.1651972383260727,
-1.0973422527313232,
0.2590060830116272,
-0.2958376705646515,
-0.14258432388305664,
-0.40308234095573425,
0.4632403552532196,
0.3962101340293884,
-0.5014033913612366,
-0.4080955982208252,
1.1441516876220703,
-0.5721526145935059,
-0.3414216637611389,
-0.35164332389831543,
0.5825870633125305,
0.6009548306465149,
0.3221910893917084,
-0.14555051922798157,
0.9956920742988586,
0.1986013650894165,
-0.3556864857673645,
0.13733355700969696,
0.18243983387947083,
-0.28424495458602905,
0.6980083584785461,
-0.6632784605026245,
0.13624611496925354,
-0.04229772090911865,
0.5557020902633667,
-0.8610510230064392,
0.02699560672044754,
-0.24570232629776,
-0.30043235421180725,
0.2958025336265564,
-0.15962304174900055,
-0.6188112497329712,
-0.4862643778324127,
-0.49737682938575745,
0.3605841100215912,
0.530460000038147,
-0.6257417798042297,
0.65167236328125,
0.07854188233613968,
-0.04390008747577667,
-0.6896489858627319,
-0.4366925060749054,
0.17900998890399933,
-0.453913152217865,
-0.5046290755271912,
0.47926774621009827,
-0.33813366293907166,
-0.18958419561386108,
-0.26202869415283203,
-0.2905241847038269,
-0.33576059341430664,
0.16402804851531982,
0.36592110991477966,
-0.10571986436843872,
-0.30201274156570435,
0.39234659075737,
-0.042592521756887436,
0.03611002489924431,
0.07346731424331665,
-0.04840051755309105,
0.46805018186569214,
-0.15411192178726196,
-0.45765843987464905,
0.02826901711523533,
0.7764942049980164,
0.844109058380127,
-0.48141998052597046,
0.4384700357913971,
0.7206137776374817,
-0.23503051698207855,
-0.2407834380865097,
-0.7127388715744019,
0.1242862269282341,
-0.5128618478775024,
0.336935818195343,
-0.6495705842971802,
-0.6773359775543213,
0.5952106714248657,
-0.2136227786540985,
0.19480319321155548,
0.11314135789871216,
0.13869765400886536,
-0.17265662550926208,
0.47385990619659424,
0.5185359716415405,
-0.10850418359041214,
0.32494983077049255,
0.03731664642691612,
0.16125059127807617,
-1.105186939239502,
0.1530972719192505,
-0.4477699100971222,
0.2241378277540207,
-0.5278534293174744,
-0.6343931555747986,
0.41181468963623047,
0.4640679955482483,
-0.17057955265045166,
0.31487905979156494,
-0.19941389560699463,
0.48998382687568665,
0.6354895234107971,
-0.005100306123495102,
0.2739091217517853,
-0.3746909201145172,
-0.0576261542737484,
0.3902551233768463,
-0.36466750502586365,
-0.32074716687202454,
1.1407272815704346,
0.17525555193424225,
0.5048906207084656,
0.15363037586212158,
1.0883299112319946,
0.11595474183559418,
0.3012503981590271,
-0.651555061340332,
0.7023589015007019,
-0.03855065628886223,
-0.47276437282562256,
-0.5837934017181396,
-0.41096946597099304,
-1.0798780918121338,
0.4075808525085449,
0.22804634273052216,
-0.6111756563186646,
-0.2558715045452118,
-0.23759543895721436,
-0.2760150730609894,
0.16310252249240875,
-0.5868249535560608,
0.8111567497253418,
-0.16616037487983704,
-0.4376077651977539,
-0.03289056569337845,
-0.4651886522769928,
0.2993435263633728,
-0.43014079332351685,
0.38971179723739624,
-0.232323557138443,
-0.20200969278812408,
0.5071503520011902,
-0.25164172053337097,
0.6007653474807739,
-0.070623017847538,
-0.5540031790733337,
0.4336523413658142,
-0.04430503025650978,
0.731925904750824,
-0.10384824126958847,
-0.41777148842811584,
-0.14703302085399628,
0.3443657457828522,
-0.51509690284729,
-0.5635036826133728,
1.1609364748001099,
-0.4888976812362671,
-0.7529420852661133,
-0.19504132866859436,
-0.5562401413917542,
-0.5465400218963623,
0.620448648929596,
0.05991436168551445,
0.4875379204750061,
-0.2559959292411804,
0.14204660058021545,
0.6911096572875977,
-0.37074926495552063,
0.5464240908622742,
0.6069302558898926,
-0.2530452311038971,
-0.2787569463253021,
0.660010039806366,
0.1069013848900795,
0.3055231273174286,
0.30053070187568665,
0.18174730241298676,
-0.5547350645065308,
-0.5100181102752686,
-0.41258513927459717,
0.20654337108135223,
-0.9231875538825989,
0.13641570508480072,
-0.7213264107704163,
-0.0911559984087944,
-0.5585541725158691,
-0.09210502356290817,
-0.32645049691200256,
-0.2775803506374359,
-0.0732259452342987,
0.10205700248479843,
0.007213423028588295,
0.36132314801216125,
0.3330267369747162,
0.08011966198682785,
-0.8663008809089661,
0.5981882810592651,
0.41874054074287415,
0.6587327718734741,
-0.07701443880796432,
-0.49154824018478394,
-0.14987194538116455,
-0.1829724758863449,
-0.2028171867132187,
-0.5254935622215271,
-0.026295363903045654,
0.18076366186141968,
0.6182119250297546,
0.1203291118144989,
0.31359925866127014,
0.6751500964164734,
-0.6223741173744202,
0.7249289751052856,
0.025836968794465065,
-0.7999468445777893,
0.2632407248020172,
-0.7620860934257507,
0.6596617102622986,
0.7094290256500244,
0.02336573414504528,
-0.6057741045951843,
-0.34878820180892944,
-0.518279492855072,
-1.0155012607574463,
0.17134162783622742,
-0.043775524944067,
0.1587972193956375,
-0.31584814190864563,
0.2512591481208801,
0.17848916351795197,
0.2929920256137848,
-0.7177687287330627,
0.03259687498211861,
-0.07662367820739746,
0.09128306061029434,
-0.19222599267959595,
-0.2479327917098999,
-0.3520534038543701,
0.13700860738754272,
0.5260853171348572,
-0.43283265829086304,
0.17217297852039337,
0.25518059730529785,
-0.12037340551614761,
0.031173067167401314,
0.6666844487190247,
0.6494188904762268,
0.8947571516036987,
-0.5357544422149658,
0.04239340126514435,
0.2482253462076187,
-0.0581195205450058,
0.012187979184091091,
0.4180905222892761,
0.0120112719014287,
0.10568889230489731,
0.4209936559200287,
0.2883264720439911,
0.35320845246315,
-0.9079089164733887,
0.6443807482719421,
-0.07662387937307358,
-0.14086128771305084,
-0.6523083448410034,
-0.10835444182157516,
0.3468407690525055,
0.09354715794324875,
0.5825254917144775,
-0.37245413661003113,
-0.09786339849233627,
-0.7834882140159607,
0.25608953833580017,
0.4122623801231384,
-0.535886287689209,
0.024393077939748764,
0.6385022401809692,
0.25726041197776794,
-0.13414005935192108,
0.43791666626930237,
-0.0064804768189787865,
-0.23575502634048462,
0.8140569925308228,
0.5627992153167725,
0.7290993332862854,
0.2277628779411316,
0.15575851500034332,
0.03356786072254181,
0.15247689187526703,
-0.033175449818372726,
0.2520942986011505,
-0.23497918248176575,
-0.2656274735927582,
-0.3870232403278351,
-0.5512083172798157,
-0.5411089658737183,
0.43711942434310913,
-0.8501846790313721,
-0.011738932691514492,
-0.3407137989997864,
-0.05664949119091034,
0.05393243208527565,
0.3788239359855652,
-0.5599073767662048,
0.38306373357772827,
0.21419399976730347,
1.1784943342208862,
-0.32691389322280884,
1.0378555059432983,
0.3950985074043274,
-0.08474665135145187,
-0.2867642045021057,
0.13727454841136932,
-0.10858498513698578,
-0.6438668370246887,
0.29564350843429565,
0.6319080591201782,
-0.11416707187891006,
-0.19630853831768036,
-0.27047714591026306,
-0.835623025894165,
1.226172924041748,
0.22535571455955505,
-0.5265897512435913,
-0.09010287374258041,
-0.07476108521223068,
0.6902986764907837,
-0.24409514665603638,
0.23198623955249786,
0.48188427090644836,
0.46318191289901733,
-0.10226844996213913,
-0.9514615535736084,
0.19475391507148743,
-0.25318142771720886,
-0.2612125873565674,
0.22255633771419525,
-1.017578363418579,
0.7950055599212646,
-0.18891866505146027,
-0.20867711305618286,
0.4577163755893707,
0.3984829783439636,
0.4271582067012787,
0.6381142139434814,
0.5281607508659363,
0.5059363842010498,
0.765699565410614,
0.06068781018257141,
1.2703924179077148,
-0.4683668315410614,
0.18148909509181976,
1.6942754983901978,
-0.9010134339332581,
0.9852162003517151,
0.637004017829895,
0.013463304378092289,
0.28619539737701416,
0.4821408689022064,
0.23043392598628998,
0.4005531072616577,
0.24965767562389374,
-0.46528807282447815,
-0.08864796161651611,
-0.17082525789737701,
-0.7056354880332947,
0.3834210932254791,
0.004173578694462776,
-0.2098711133003235,
-0.3004814088344574,
-0.2351451963186264,
-0.07309523969888687,
0.27388519048690796,
-0.08734425902366638,
0.6101987957954407,
0.19540920853614807,
-1.0718892812728882,
0.842606782913208,
-0.04186427220702171,
0.4615907073020935,
-0.7335308194160461,
0.10588904470205307,
-0.6705589890480042,
0.1268981397151947,
0.21770335733890533,
-0.6834366917610168,
0.08070201426744461,
-0.31199124455451965,
-0.3154098391532898,
-0.1602998524904251,
0.5304214358329773,
-0.4067213237285614,
-0.2512901723384857,
0.690589189529419,
0.6954465508460999,
0.08453954756259918,
-0.28794586658477783,
-0.5309996008872986,
-0.09836000949144363,
-0.34710150957107544,
-0.42010435461997986,
0.5973716974258423,
0.6308284401893616,
-0.1839102953672409,
0.8379316926002502,
0.6778274774551392,
-0.09817284345626831,
-0.0005771847791038454,
0.35130250453948975,
0.9132084846496582,
-0.9246771931648254,
-0.45043525099754333,
-0.410045862197876,
-0.17848587036132812,
-0.20429587364196777,
-0.5103356242179871,
0.9004275798797607,
0.6778690814971924,
0.5378011465072632,
0.17145489156246185,
0.6879549026489258,
0.2640072703361511,
0.7954618334770203,
-0.3964751660823822,
0.5815964341163635,
-0.7181491255760193,
0.34185996651649475,
-0.31360965967178345,
-0.9519297480583191,
0.09692655503749847,
-0.21075302362442017,
-0.21447217464447021,
0.0789254680275917,
0.8253790140151978,
0.5439149737358093,
-0.08202420920133591,
-0.11309625208377838,
0.6332245469093323,
0.022143635898828506,
0.4162988066673279,
0.6281436085700989,
0.8435539603233337,
-0.6406257748603821,
0.7585864067077637,
-0.056640882045030594,
-0.08018169552087784,
-0.14467427134513855,
-0.8943718075752258,
-0.8458852171897888,
-0.39483943581581116,
-0.13405628502368927,
-0.38919156789779663,
0.07847857475280762,
0.45749425888061523,
0.7312219738960266,
-0.4142240881919861,
-0.05865250155329704,
0.2387477457523346,
0.1388566941022873,
-0.3545702397823334,
-0.23245729506015778,
0.582679808139801,
-0.3195453882217407,
-0.6479266285896301,
0.8603014945983887,
0.2653232514858246,
0.07635705918073654,
-0.06116841733455658,
-0.023048823699355125,
-0.1925024539232254,
0.29938220977783203,
0.732306718826294,
0.44371193647384644,
-0.6517878770828247,
-0.32038208842277527,
-0.028105225414037704,
-0.26393258571624756,
0.09974993765354156,
0.6669397354125977,
-0.8077479600906372,
0.3306003212928772,
0.1763235330581665,
0.8046228289604187,
0.6483867764472961,
0.23764467239379883,
0.4478994607925415,
-0.8324528932571411,
0.07695706188678741,
0.10805997252464294,
0.2627120614051819,
0.29785048961639404,
-0.17122292518615723,
0.7519269585609436,
-0.13875457644462585,
-0.5435422658920288,
-0.9880172610282898,
0.08856823295354843,
-0.9874345064163208,
-0.4847085475921631,
1.3561145067214966,
-0.4663154184818268,
-0.4325084388256073,
0.020436495542526245,
0.03557959944009781,
0.0038902948144823313,
-0.2550843060016632,
0.9071719646453857,
0.678253710269928,
0.13479870557785034,
-0.3519400358200073,
-0.7058899998664856,
0.3539842665195465,
0.587481677532196,
-1.0646116733551025,
0.281612753868103,
0.5294057726860046,
0.3046824336051941,
0.22237667441368103,
0.9084576964378357,
-0.20939403772354126,
0.39139044284820557,
0.018114730715751648,
-0.3001158833503723,
-0.09603101015090942,
-0.27456045150756836,
-0.2316340059041977,
0.3651304244995117,
0.0020890028681606054,
-0.18206365406513214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17415v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17415v2 | Layer-Wise Quantization: A Pragmatic and Effective Method for Quantizing LLMs Beyond Integer Bit-Levels | 2024-06-25T09:37:15 | 2024-06-26T08:00:18 | Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Vikas Yadav, Rishabh Maheshwary, Paul-Ioan Clotan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0 | We present a simple variable quantization approach that quantizes different
layers of a large language model (LLM) at different bit levels. Specifically,
we quantize the most important layers to higher bit precision and less
important layers to lower bits to achieve floating point quantization levels.
We propose two effective strategies to measure the importance of layers within
LLMs: the first measures the importance of a layer based on how different its
output embeddings are from the input embeddings (the higher the better); the
second estimates the importance of a layer using the number of layer weights
that are much larger than average (the smaller the better). We show that
quantizing different layers at varying bits according to our importance scores
results in minimal performance drop with a far more compressed model size.
Finally, we present several practical key takeaways from our variable
layer-wise quantization experiments: (a) LLM performance under variable
quantization remains close to the original model until 25-50% of layers are
moved in lower quantization using our proposed ordering but only until 5-10% if
moved using no specific ordering; (b) Quantizing LLMs to lower bits performs
substantially better than pruning unless extreme quantization (2-bit) is used;
and (c) Layer-wise quantization to lower bits works better in the case of
larger LLMs with more layers compared to smaller LLMs with fewer layers. The
code used to run the experiments is available at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/LayerwiseQuant. | [
-0.3291793763637543,
-0.8789077997207642,
0.6312847137451172,
0.28834450244903564,
-0.3883216977119446,
0.14035198092460632,
-0.19026783108711243,
-0.3128812909126282,
-0.05369417369365692,
0.34639790654182434,
-0.1496923267841339,
-0.5059936046600342,
-0.3622950613498688,
-0.38171905279159546,
-0.3046635091304779,
0.7455751895904541,
0.19925203919410706,
0.16867120563983917,
-0.36763957142829895,
0.06335119903087616,
-0.0050065405666828156,
-0.6307973265647888,
-0.7216792702674866,
-0.32505643367767334,
0.5780287384986877,
0.2645322382450104,
0.7736256718635559,
0.8381414413452148,
0.772255539894104,
0.26530635356903076,
-0.2767305076122284,
-0.0636707991361618,
-0.2436417043209076,
-0.11245577037334442,
0.07611551880836487,
-0.5127094388008118,
-0.7396320700645447,
0.04732485115528107,
0.7915210127830505,
0.6871234774589539,
-0.25732970237731934,
0.3854873478412628,
-0.3398241698741913,
0.8957832455635071,
-0.6804136037826538,
-0.12715521454811096,
-0.25480759143829346,
0.23041437566280365,
-0.20068930089473724,
-0.2685701549053192,
-0.24150758981704712,
-0.4842669367790222,
-0.08975207805633545,
-0.2647820711135864,
0.06570245325565338,
-0.027378443628549576,
0.6189496517181396,
0.25940486788749695,
-0.5129272937774658,
0.24108122289180756,
-0.894035816192627,
0.9614086747169495,
-1.034051775932312,
0.4377746284008026,
0.36194753646850586,
0.19506467878818512,
0.3948177397251129,
-0.7388805150985718,
-0.3504202663898468,
-0.241029754281044,
0.2718404233455658,
0.16296619176864624,
0.009012671187520027,
0.3721410930156708,
0.2273188829421997,
0.7075189352035522,
-0.2745991349220276,
0.0310067068785429,
-0.2052042931318283,
-0.27761396765708923,
0.44368603825569153,
0.07387226074934006,
0.18893171846866608,
-0.04939290136098862,
-0.5401074290275574,
-0.24609892070293427,
-0.8319753408432007,
0.4208011031150818,
0.552781879901886,
0.08790069073438644,
0.09905330836772919,
0.5011782050132751,
-0.09936744719743729,
0.6043023467063904,
0.035337887704372406,
-0.3206599950790405,
0.12225667387247086,
-0.3615967035293579,
-0.27362969517707825,
-0.040868744254112244,
0.5977767109870911,
0.006140492390841246,
0.07957124710083008,
-0.05579201877117157,
-0.6484572291374207,
-0.1954580843448639,
0.3165610730648041,
-0.9562857747077942,
-0.229831263422966,
0.48436635732650757,
-0.43048930168151855,
-0.4960627257823944,
-0.0339726023375988,
-0.14296717941761017,
-0.16363023221492767,
-0.28551894426345825,
0.7153190970420837,
-0.5693988800048828,
-0.30242040753364563,
0.2015036642551422,
0.11599180102348328,
0.27080678939819336,
0.3521145284175873,
-0.8032175302505493,
0.4383879601955414,
0.9184581637382507,
0.8290205001831055,
0.07402124255895615,
-0.0140061154961586,
-0.5778385996818542,
0.09837179630994797,
-0.7502983212471008,
0.4576605260372162,
-0.49031540751457214,
-0.060969334095716476,
-0.1911696344614029,
-0.5445920825004578,
0.25457245111465454,
-0.568156361579895,
0.4291902780532837,
-0.701853334903717,
0.04823416471481323,
-0.18078599870204926,
-0.5695371031761169,
-0.07054554671049118,
0.10919482260942459,
-0.7359270453453064,
0.9818049669265747,
0.11283125728368759,
-0.6635385751724243,
-0.04368450865149498,
-0.1928219050168991,
-0.32209110260009766,
0.14990055561065674,
-0.09824779629707336,
-0.5917108654975891,
0.6748319864273071,
0.042097337543964386,
0.44268718361854553,
-0.35764890909194946,
0.27422136068344116,
-0.20087704062461853,
-0.49144402146339417,
0.42537298798561096,
-0.4886266887187958,
0.8774735331535339,
0.07674062252044678,
-0.17499586939811707,
0.10278858989477158,
-0.8502774238586426,
0.6530210971832275,
-0.023808764293789864,
-0.6081028580665588,
-0.30117321014404297,
-0.0006532181287184358,
-0.059597503393888474,
0.10493849962949753,
0.31785815954208374,
-0.32507196068763733,
0.13856281340122223,
-0.36306318640708923,
0.9740825295448303,
0.7615392208099365,
0.19752848148345947,
0.5580592751502991,
-0.09154824912548065,
0.6264950037002563,
0.0774323046207428,
0.39129793643951416,
0.2471638321876526,
-0.2332594394683838,
-0.868256151676178,
-0.4740740656852722,
0.6712660789489746,
0.5090533494949341,
-0.6966843605041504,
0.5017805099487305,
-0.2017965465784073,
-0.19925443828105927,
-0.4443764090538025,
-0.1349021941423416,
0.60478276014328,
0.13201558589935303,
0.0927267000079155,
-0.5588492155075073,
-0.10589490830898285,
-1.005391001701355,
-0.07900484651327133,
-0.4257221817970276,
-0.13468140363693237,
-0.04362168163061142,
0.2308480143547058,
0.18627893924713135,
0.7493801712989807,
-0.3100056052207947,
-0.04959387332201004,
0.05366259813308716,
0.09274189174175262,
0.08198212087154388,
0.5379099249839783,
0.26049864292144775,
-0.8193666934967041,
-0.3348815441131592,
0.19554153084754944,
-0.3127957880496979,
-0.0430128313601017,
0.07794123888015747,
-0.19470897316932678,
0.06918279081583023,
0.4779364764690399,
-0.6617666482925415,
0.18497401475906372,
0.5424399375915527,
0.04436366260051727,
0.36662715673446655,
-0.1612064093351364,
-0.06441349536180496,
-0.7853561043739319,
-0.18418653309345245,
0.10548394173383713,
-0.6378722190856934,
-0.9437273740768433,
0.2241288721561432,
0.4487486779689789,
0.03576967120170593,
-0.5262323617935181,
0.08707231283187866,
-0.4297672212123871,
-0.20897245407104492,
-0.050820667296648026,
-0.023102127015590668,
0.26070547103881836,
0.5934123992919922,
-0.12356864660978317,
0.6837337017059326,
0.4784262180328369,
-0.39255058765411377,
0.2684919834136963,
-0.46962612867355347,
-0.6337600946426392,
0.5983699560165405,
-0.7792760133743286,
0.4038372337818146,
-0.0008919232641346753,
0.0024331463500857353,
-0.8306097388267517,
0.17307642102241516,
0.06537861377000809,
-0.31973832845687866,
0.4044119715690613,
-0.2582961618900299,
-0.5994386672973633,
-0.01603039912879467,
-0.6429465413093567,
0.6224548816680908,
0.42343658208847046,
-0.1314210444688797,
0.5408351421356201,
0.38445815443992615,
0.038873158395290375,
-0.36079975962638855,
-0.875411868095398,
-0.09117958694696426,
-0.5724583268165588,
-0.7879742980003357,
0.5651320219039917,
-0.37186890840530396,
-0.25290849804878235,
-0.09724723547697067,
-0.4767152667045593,
-0.2573411464691162,
0.14991424977779388,
-0.05447186902165413,
-0.07521812617778778,
-0.4355890154838562,
0.21724525094032288,
-0.06541359424591064,
-0.11933943629264832,
0.23649601638317108,
-0.7631198167800903,
0.42898744344711304,
-0.48904263973236084,
-0.19493281841278076,
-0.20205965638160706,
0.2957586348056793,
0.17769663035869598,
-0.386569082736969,
0.6643204689025879,
0.9653756022453308,
-0.45059964060783386,
-0.34871774911880493,
-0.5078477263450623,
0.12429681420326233,
-0.5262109041213989,
0.3523685336112976,
-0.47814813256263733,
-1.0423167943954468,
0.7184089422225952,
-0.009863252751529217,
-0.2997843325138092,
0.22615833580493927,
0.44837281107902527,
-0.22737209498882294,
1.0937581062316895,
0.8111241459846497,
0.01721058040857315,
0.7062305808067322,
-0.45075222849845886,
0.49409985542297363,
-0.9101194739341736,
0.145303413271904,
-0.26452717185020447,
-0.2624816596508026,
-0.7586910724639893,
-0.6484548449516296,
0.4749852120876312,
0.7107744812965393,
-0.39322975277900696,
0.053803130984306335,
-0.41392794251441956,
0.8376523852348328,
0.5529618263244629,
0.33632925152778625,
0.23377105593681335,
0.13946330547332764,
0.09049314260482788,
-0.009868375957012177,
-0.7089928388595581,
-0.3698645532131195,
0.6708208322525024,
0.5733899474143982,
0.6135760545730591,
0.4726266860961914,
0.8142713904380798,
0.2314920276403427,
-0.14097045361995697,
-0.9343171119689941,
0.48003941774368286,
-0.24980837106704712,
-0.3407435119152069,
-0.5224392414093018,
-0.6818301677703857,
-0.4825885593891144,
0.3104378581047058,
0.16187885403633118,
-0.638055682182312,
0.257987916469574,
0.11753138154745102,
-0.6400156021118164,
0.17519837617874146,
-0.9725551009178162,
0.6579557061195374,
-0.21233657002449036,
-0.18291522562503815,
-0.18807780742645264,
-0.7196664810180664,
0.30038824677467346,
-0.03992639109492302,
0.244862899184227,
-0.012990646995604038,
-0.488658607006073,
0.5756859183311462,
-0.5487814545631409,
0.8490580320358276,
-0.011885492131114006,
-0.4321792423725128,
0.3388500511646271,
0.3414509892463684,
0.5121700167655945,
0.1535387933254242,
0.07584995776414871,
0.26534155011177063,
0.09573665261268616,
-0.5594564080238342,
-0.6886627674102783,
0.8391002416610718,
-0.9923771619796753,
-0.7822906970977783,
-0.0358160063624382,
-0.5979938507080078,
-0.1471821367740631,
0.06233622878789902,
0.026504579931497574,
0.6856883764266968,
0.2815302908420563,
0.2837105989456177,
0.9065024256706238,
-0.119426429271698,
0.350674569606781,
0.30132538080215454,
-0.03505389764904976,
-0.5277434587478638,
1.4469751119613647,
0.3289420008659363,
0.7046201229095459,
0.9370743036270142,
0.6389689445495605,
0.0986269861459732,
-0.7939514517784119,
-0.04816487058997154,
-0.05577928200364113,
-0.9485838413238525,
-0.3514399528503418,
-0.4271935522556305,
-0.5261905193328857,
-0.308020681142807,
0.10116315633058548,
-0.5674574971199036,
-0.9074360132217407,
-0.0696185976266861,
-0.17536459863185883,
0.2256188839673996,
0.44896888732910156,
-0.23216170072555542,
0.31420812010765076,
-0.5669252276420593,
0.24067559838294983,
0.5655637979507446,
0.4172540307044983,
0.054099373519420624,
-0.5166463851928711,
-0.6378481984138489,
-0.17618517577648163,
-0.12547360360622406,
-0.5744431614875793,
0.36238205432891846,
0.28789764642715454,
0.396183043718338,
0.2799340486526489,
-0.1015816256403923,
0.7018865346908569,
-0.3754080832004547,
0.7191295623779297,
0.11426495015621185,
-1.373958945274353,
0.5509184002876282,
-0.23420925438404083,
0.4116356372833252,
0.37650689482688904,
0.23836582899093628,
-0.3725692331790924,
-0.26547175645828247,
-0.584496021270752,
-1.312584638595581,
0.7476515173912048,
0.3594239354133606,
0.038255032151937485,
0.1803102046251297,
0.39890167117118835,
-0.23758092522621155,
0.47569313645362854,
-0.9315298199653625,
-0.42365989089012146,
-0.010531539097428322,
-0.12118490785360336,
0.08872941136360168,
-0.40737384557724,
-0.2019479125738144,
-0.11039884388446808,
0.4382305443286896,
-0.020679231733083725,
0.3762328326702118,
0.051132190972566605,
-0.19839781522750854,
-0.2795778512954712,
0.1186804249882698,
0.5243142247200012,
0.9695129990577698,
-0.48378077149391174,
0.6384689211845398,
-0.008292168378829956,
-0.5379988551139832,
0.07649952918291092,
-0.29782024025917053,
-0.27387866377830505,
-0.27592962980270386,
0.5045772790908813,
0.9376091361045837,
0.07550042122602463,
-0.16968196630477905,
0.5557472109794617,
0.02328401431441307,
-0.09692919254302979,
-0.2042776644229889,
0.09858036786317825,
0.16870853304862976,
0.5835350155830383,
0.1949324607849121,
-0.0993550717830658,
0.1322283297777176,
-0.4530926048755646,
-0.10190830379724503,
0.41424626111984253,
-0.2823808491230011,
-0.4181070923805237,
0.2676224112510681,
0.05488842725753784,
-0.5369617342948914,
0.30225375294685364,
-0.042939748615026474,
-0.4891696274280548,
0.8518358469009399,
0.33808600902557373,
0.8183987736701965,
-0.19686932861804962,
0.35989508032798767,
0.1307668536901474,
0.518539547920227,
-0.131343275308609,
0.11936464160680771,
-0.2563769519329071,
-0.6614938378334045,
-0.6995540857315063,
-0.44816917181015015,
-0.41910871863365173,
0.09275214374065399,
-0.768197774887085,
-0.005506080109626055,
-0.7090545296669006,
-0.2556658387184143,
0.1291252225637436,
0.3673638105392456,
-0.6026850342750549,
0.22200140357017517,
0.27653947472572327,
0.6690371036529541,
-0.6067036390304565,
1.0581640005111694,
0.6268101334571838,
-0.40690964460372925,
-0.7585632801055908,
0.021019773557782173,
-0.2357245534658432,
-0.8476846218109131,
0.509607195854187,
-0.1010783240199089,
-0.09034515172243118,
0.29653653502464294,
-0.7710700631141663,
-1.1789482831954956,
1.3229764699935913,
0.4736592173576355,
-0.638759434223175,
0.22264821827411652,
0.31676629185676575,
0.6020169258117676,
-0.24921831488609314,
0.45132821798324585,
0.5163834095001221,
0.202610045671463,
-0.02276652492582798,
-0.5277062654495239,
-0.05893006920814514,
-0.09909944236278534,
0.6893986463546753,
0.43935441970825195,
-0.9059241414070129,
0.9682125449180603,
-0.10477393865585327,
-0.33586108684539795,
-0.11630937457084656,
0.5923934578895569,
0.19681872427463531,
0.0410115122795105,
0.5674190521240234,
0.507756233215332,
0.6548094749450684,
0.08410611748695374,
1.1425511837005615,
-0.26385200023651123,
0.5324525833129883,
0.7489506006240845,
0.07631030678749084,
0.8330296874046326,
0.7111254930496216,
-0.4585171639919281,
0.13747729361057281,
0.6742404103279114,
0.5355766415596008,
0.6817793846130371,
0.5835157632827759,
-0.21170826256275177,
-0.5299516916275024,
-0.08335839956998825,
-0.265142560005188,
-0.10083084553480148,
0.24645572900772095,
-0.038815248757600784,
0.2246415615081787,
-0.13762295246124268,
-0.18359462916851044,
-0.24825625121593475,
-0.2874195873737335,
0.6161221265792847,
0.31529906392097473,
-0.1649189591407776,
0.6516636610031128,
0.2864076495170593,
0.4562446177005768,
-0.6644648909568787,
0.12268688529729843,
-0.5828465819358826,
0.12511540949344635,
-0.22639550268650055,
-0.720375657081604,
-0.016709083691239357,
-0.09714965522289276,
-0.4026268422603607,
-0.4844568073749542,
0.6408420205116272,
-0.5457268357276917,
-0.7943875193595886,
0.05266893655061722,
0.5326624512672424,
0.1357031911611557,
-0.16647061705589294,
-0.5767001509666443,
0.3503459692001343,
-0.05830676108598709,
-0.6833388209342957,
0.5801733136177063,
1.016175389289856,
-0.24653153121471405,
0.6030673384666443,
0.44983747601509094,
0.3049798607826233,
0.17148245871067047,
0.5695260167121887,
0.8899004459381104,
-0.9102272987365723,
-0.345951646566391,
-0.7604665756225586,
0.4256848990917206,
0.2708047926425934,
-0.14017073810100555,
0.5205754041671753,
0.2532077729701996,
1.036643147468567,
0.20623202621936798,
0.3666051924228668,
0.11022470146417618,
0.0064070019870996475,
-0.7730336785316467,
0.15036049485206604,
-0.5128746032714844,
0.7025233507156372,
-0.11510410159826279,
-1.29112708568573,
-0.4091630280017853,
0.8377814888954163,
-0.16312073171138763,
0.19612672924995422,
0.7331562638282776,
0.6128033399581909,
0.06887101382017136,
-0.31304821372032166,
0.5996275544166565,
0.24431926012039185,
0.42525920271873474,
0.6459384560585022,
1.0467358827590942,
-0.546043336391449,
0.46282389760017395,
-0.8582190275192261,
-0.16767171025276184,
0.15457786619663239,
-1.0089508295059204,
-0.6764981746673584,
-0.45998328924179077,
-0.7748015522956848,
-0.060895055532455444,
-0.006387705449014902,
0.64760822057724,
0.8459348678588867,
-0.5590863227844238,
-0.3302951753139496,
-0.06007891893386841,
0.1769549697637558,
-0.3622053563594818,
-0.3103823661804199,
0.4687213599681854,
-0.06830652058124542,
-0.534622848033905,
0.17407289147377014,
0.44874945282936096,
-0.05842975527048111,
-0.652928352355957,
-0.052322868257761,
0.01775994896888733,
0.1915072649717331,
0.795712411403656,
-0.23808583617210388,
-0.7051678895950317,
-0.4465101957321167,
-0.11616260558366776,
-0.3935621380805969,
0.020504774525761604,
0.9804789423942566,
-0.6159325838088989,
0.2499217391014099,
0.7443698644638062,
0.4553440511226654,
0.675082266330719,
0.10351500660181046,
0.3469296097755432,
-1.2109627723693848,
0.044341977685689926,
0.35911276936531067,
-0.053323894739151,
0.47704851627349854,
-0.48474979400634766,
0.5709553956985474,
-0.01971251890063286,
-0.6118911504745483,
-0.8038021326065063,
0.1698068529367447,
-1.130630373954773,
-0.24640075862407684,
1.140868067741394,
-0.25960439443588257,
-0.48049280047416687,
0.47731244564056396,
0.1843833029270172,
0.0028227651491761208,
-0.2879999279975891,
0.6207153797149658,
0.6533977389335632,
0.011254689656198025,
-0.47230979800224304,
-0.6703323721885681,
0.35134267807006836,
0.4382024109363556,
-0.6110350489616394,
-0.09540971368551254,
0.3013768196105957,
0.09986493736505508,
0.20016413927078247,
0.7124535441398621,
-0.0935024693608284,
-0.06776534765958786,
-0.24461901187896729,
0.0659959614276886,
-0.007035124581307173,
-0.3736581802368164,
-0.5672807097434998,
0.13601569831371307,
0.2280169576406479,
-0.1524854600429535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17404v1 | Make Some Noise: Unlocking Language Model Parallel Inference Capability through Noisy Training | 2024-06-25T09:25:39 | 2024-06-25T09:25:39 | Yixuan Wang, Xianzhen Luo, Fuxuan Wei, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Xuanyu Zhang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Existing speculative decoding methods typically require additional model
structure and training processes to assist the model for draft token
generation. This makes the migration of acceleration methods to the new model
more costly and more demanding on device memory. To address this problem, we
propose the Make Some Noise (MSN) training framework as a replacement for the
supervised fine-tuning stage of the large language model. The training method
simply introduces some noise at the input for the model to learn the denoising
task. It significantly enhances the parallel decoding capability of the model
without affecting the original task capability. In addition, we propose a
tree-based retrieval-augmented Jacobi (TR-Jacobi) decoding strategy to further
improve the inference speed of MSN models. Experiments in both the general and
code domains have shown that MSN can improve inference speed by 2.3-2.7x times
without compromising model performance. The MSN model also achieves comparable
acceleration ratios to the SOTA model with additional model structure on
Spec-Bench. | [
-0.2866462767124176,
-0.734490692615509,
0.4528977572917938,
0.08809798210859299,
-0.046074386686086655,
0.07015322148799896,
-0.201389878988266,
-0.6112003922462463,
0.2526443600654602,
0.4970187842845917,
-0.6157690286636353,
-0.2812085747718811,
-0.6522809863090515,
-0.008007939904928207,
-0.44216299057006836,
0.7841026186943054,
0.2903655767440796,
0.286124587059021,
0.1772739440202713,
0.26314789056777954,
-0.1152535229921341,
-0.5145214796066284,
-1.0465164184570312,
0.0033998810686171055,
0.4042530059814453,
0.12653186917304993,
0.678062379360199,
0.8458109498023987,
0.2814747393131256,
0.31475210189819336,
-0.4147695004940033,
0.20730812847614288,
-0.5070821046829224,
0.1371275931596756,
0.08615648001432419,
-0.738403856754303,
-0.4806627929210663,
-0.2331882119178772,
0.6604629158973694,
0.6609376668930054,
0.013923580758273602,
0.025935109704732895,
-0.14302250742912292,
0.674315869808197,
-0.7705417275428772,
0.3714517056941986,
-0.6964218020439148,
-0.0609956756234169,
-0.27762219309806824,
0.044063422828912735,
-0.5684980154037476,
-0.09465496987104416,
-0.04362143203616142,
-0.575543999671936,
0.28863200545310974,
0.22495467960834503,
0.9277037382125854,
0.2678374648094177,
0.03851788863539696,
-0.00021513695537578315,
-0.8371868133544922,
0.9360896348953247,
-1.0297709703445435,
0.4411751329898834,
0.5210602879524231,
0.23384709656238556,
-0.03320593014359474,
-0.7978534698486328,
-0.46066609025001526,
-0.12130796909332275,
-0.011197799816727638,
0.05268435552716255,
-0.2902078330516815,
0.2642894685268402,
0.5639785528182983,
0.22803044319152832,
-0.39069029688835144,
-0.0037856558337807655,
-0.4980716109275818,
-0.13231903314590454,
0.41676419973373413,
0.11433883011341095,
0.19557112455368042,
0.05596499517560005,
0.31105825304985046,
-0.016409020870923996,
-0.5803811550140381,
-0.07371124625205994,
0.4978666305541992,
0.6552670001983643,
0.007475352380424738,
0.191701278090477,
-0.36112114787101746,
0.663542628288269,
-0.07488096505403519,
-0.07563444972038269,
0.24541634321212769,
-0.2823657989501953,
-0.32528865337371826,
0.24045850336551666,
0.5067830681800842,
0.2328476458787918,
0.15871693193912506,
-0.1841256022453308,
-0.3650721609592438,
0.24708744883537292,
0.21048559248447418,
-1.1754459142684937,
-0.35654938220977783,
0.06633563339710236,
-0.7683889865875244,
-0.4128633439540863,
-0.24509687721729279,
-0.4856284558773041,
-0.24861282110214233,
-0.635208785533905,
0.13317559659481049,
-0.45180097222328186,
-0.6473464369773865,
0.29529044032096863,
-0.11433342099189758,
-0.16636043787002563,
0.1666330099105835,
-1.1308865547180176,
0.44477352499961853,
0.6194377541542053,
0.921888530254364,
0.004215207416564226,
-0.2786148488521576,
-0.5804384350776672,
-0.08329014480113983,
-0.6100960373878479,
0.7506182789802551,
-0.7952486872673035,
-0.19009889662265778,
-0.15467555820941925,
0.08279923349618912,
-0.3601745367050171,
-0.5371052026748657,
0.20824049413204193,
-0.4981893301010132,
-0.31013351678848267,
-0.41859543323516846,
-0.3464900255203247,
-0.18574661016464233,
0.12061125785112381,
-0.49485477805137634,
1.0293171405792236,
0.1514638513326645,
-0.8092800378799438,
0.29466649889945984,
-0.634951114654541,
-0.37837332487106323,
-0.31897106766700745,
-0.08041371405124664,
-0.493425577878952,
0.28711676597595215,
0.3443044126033783,
0.252750426530838,
-0.25919950008392334,
0.2768498659133911,
-0.33138614892959595,
-0.5716290473937988,
-0.032854802906513214,
-0.41836363077163696,
0.8304699063301086,
0.6008771657943726,
-0.18743932247161865,
0.14635759592056274,
-0.8482837080955505,
-0.12923814356327057,
-0.12582837045192719,
-0.10402967035770416,
-0.29994162917137146,
0.045625511556863785,
-0.16098922491073608,
0.09834840148687363,
-0.21182100474834442,
-0.5514559745788574,
0.03294987604022026,
-0.7239189147949219,
0.47558608651161194,
0.40606117248535156,
0.03511013463139534,
0.43221592903137207,
-0.5233721137046814,
0.5052143931388855,
0.35725632309913635,
0.0026464920956641436,
-0.21535201370716095,
-0.48747220635414124,
-0.8715943694114685,
-0.2978954017162323,
0.6115952730178833,
0.2269074022769928,
-0.7264332175254822,
-0.11592061817646027,
-0.2731938064098358,
-0.26795899868011475,
-0.8091909885406494,
0.15748362243175507,
0.3387893736362457,
0.2786753177642822,
0.12444943189620972,
-0.22222387790679932,
-1.1069526672363281,
-0.6949084997177124,
-0.23594467341899872,
-0.2079216092824936,
-0.1579706221818924,
0.13497881591320038,
0.32918885350227356,
0.19681687653064728,
0.711996853351593,
-0.09919801354408264,
-0.054054394364356995,
-0.3082340657711029,
0.33312395215034485,
0.12356910854578018,
0.710563600063324,
0.6375657916069031,
-0.5242248177528381,
-0.45181363821029663,
-0.0499119907617569,
-0.67833012342453,
-0.08100557327270508,
-0.18882210552692413,
-0.0598696768283844,
0.04444330930709839,
0.9334141612052917,
-0.4123796224594116,
0.3722324073314667,
0.43616437911987305,
0.02471120096743107,
0.36265426874160767,
-0.08643628656864166,
0.110966257750988,
-1.1816973686218262,
-0.22768738865852356,
-0.36255937814712524,
-0.15801797807216644,
-0.602445662021637,
-0.018963968381285667,
-0.1694500744342804,
-0.14754410088062286,
-0.436532199382782,
0.10681198537349701,
-0.5483977198600769,
-0.11028541624546051,
-0.4309449791908264,
-0.11945660412311554,
-0.10954007506370544,
0.39080527424812317,
0.09439004212617874,
1.0746040344238281,
1.1274305582046509,
-0.5912021994590759,
-0.2799166440963745,
-0.02685697376728058,
-0.24791091680526733,
0.038381192833185196,
-0.43401622772216797,
-0.004832599312067032,
-0.3655630648136139,
-0.005764518398791552,
-0.7800463438034058,
-0.008666041307151318,
0.04180742800235748,
-0.22415833175182343,
0.40782463550567627,
-0.45462659001350403,
-0.5853996872901917,
-0.2504015266895294,
-0.09672373533248901,
0.36076223850250244,
0.6305538415908813,
-0.48638346791267395,
0.5196263790130615,
0.45440196990966797,
0.01708325184881687,
-0.3270244598388672,
-1.050420880317688,
0.23745912313461304,
0.19067667424678802,
-0.587760329246521,
0.2975420653820038,
0.03442846238613129,
-0.10812227427959442,
0.01784907653927803,
-0.16180792450904846,
-0.14767035841941833,
0.056835900992155075,
0.3554171621799469,
-0.01992819458246231,
-0.7556824684143066,
-0.0012339347740635276,
0.23111972212791443,
-0.31158387660980225,
0.0724489763379097,
-0.44512179493904114,
0.23070548474788666,
-0.3492079973220825,
-0.1999133825302124,
-0.5145753026008606,
0.22825436294078827,
0.6634179949760437,
-0.21961292624473572,
0.8255398869514465,
0.5981228351593018,
-0.2637268006801605,
-0.33188357949256897,
-0.45245829224586487,
-0.5548505187034607,
-0.48235994577407837,
0.48213329911231995,
-0.6559494137763977,
-0.9060196280479431,
0.44117435812950134,
-0.48359495401382446,
0.021603964269161224,
0.03950963169336319,
0.5182443857192993,
0.22113190591335297,
1.2850033044815063,
0.5966339111328125,
-0.021077636629343033,
0.6663451790809631,
-0.28518369793891907,
0.2490769624710083,
-0.5371145009994507,
0.10054727643728256,
-0.6528221368789673,
-0.4754696488380432,
-0.5490787029266357,
-0.44963282346725464,
-0.09700600802898407,
0.2029571235179901,
-0.22944097220897675,
0.49957209825515747,
-0.46231457591056824,
0.66673344373703,
0.6685656905174255,
0.15131822228431702,
0.2822269797325134,
0.30594488978385925,
-0.17374730110168457,
-0.13452771306037903,
-0.9463698267936707,
-0.1442623734474182,
1.0192323923110962,
0.31820327043533325,
0.6832322478294373,
-0.00609164172783494,
0.6275100111961365,
-0.05632300302386284,
0.311993271112442,
-0.5295359492301941,
0.4184125065803528,
-0.36248067021369934,
-0.6100704073905945,
-0.1840192824602127,
-0.4722815454006195,
-0.7122575640678406,
0.18844804167747498,
-0.22033289074897766,
-1.030451774597168,
0.43142783641815186,
0.14746974408626556,
-0.3561805188655853,
0.6880545616149902,
-0.7820302248001099,
0.6338047981262207,
0.49338871240615845,
-0.19385896623134613,
-0.2472001165151596,
-0.43162134289741516,
0.6095007061958313,
0.0666201114654541,
0.14029404520988464,
-0.09944158047437668,
0.4017706513404846,
0.7782224416732788,
-0.448650062084198,
1.1698315143585205,
-0.20025765895843506,
0.1996650993824005,
0.542182981967926,
0.32908228039741516,
0.8190904855728149,
-0.23828795552253723,
-0.5343738794326782,
0.363894522190094,
0.12331041693687439,
-0.41961538791656494,
-0.6139069199562073,
0.5492106676101685,
-0.5985759496688843,
-0.4647405743598938,
0.024563465267419815,
-0.9559155106544495,
-0.1835474669933319,
0.0667099580168724,
0.175013467669487,
0.20403726398944855,
0.055472876876592636,
0.16787566244602203,
0.4324982762336731,
0.23555612564086914,
0.7913990020751953,
0.5294787287712097,
-0.19144558906555176,
-0.061716992408037186,
1.1422699689865112,
0.27753588557243347,
0.10796371847391129,
0.20158633589744568,
0.16997583210468292,
-0.05623332038521767,
-0.7975684404373169,
-0.4539608657360077,
-0.04527653753757477,
-0.3688358962535858,
-0.07446322590112686,
-0.8309256434440613,
-0.5245104432106018,
-0.329926073551178,
0.08205007761716843,
-0.690357506275177,
-0.5698204636573792,
0.03461635112762451,
-0.10432091355323792,
0.4124032258987427,
0.7526485919952393,
-0.12140568345785141,
0.9260047674179077,
-0.7508512139320374,
0.2931545674800873,
0.08365071564912796,
0.3002666234970093,
0.1843252182006836,
-0.7513144016265869,
-0.42806679010391235,
0.009934752248227596,
-0.04689417779445648,
-0.5675719380378723,
0.34588387608528137,
0.19135010242462158,
0.295342355966568,
0.5488891005516052,
0.3132352828979492,
0.8238974213600159,
-0.3500420153141022,
0.505618691444397,
0.1132240742444992,
-0.8743979930877686,
0.33172309398651123,
-0.21541596949100494,
0.2632811963558197,
0.5304108262062073,
-0.0146120460703969,
-0.03915278613567352,
-0.8135194182395935,
-0.6183582544326782,
-0.38626518845558167,
1.1569899320602417,
0.4999810457229614,
0.1804644763469696,
-0.0045533981174230576,
0.20048795640468597,
-0.12131741642951965,
0.21961107850074768,
-0.6101404428482056,
-0.28755465149879456,
-0.06719079613685608,
-0.12087155133485794,
0.32939839363098145,
-0.5668123960494995,
0.0415007509291172,
-0.40156090259552,
0.6348274946212769,
-0.03386465460062027,
0.12631650269031525,
0.028553515672683716,
-0.030385367572307587,
-0.2941761910915375,
0.19385093450546265,
0.5095750689506531,
0.5719568133354187,
-0.2848481237888336,
0.2851864695549011,
0.29995208978652954,
-0.3910507261753082,
-0.11574593931436539,
0.002793142106384039,
-0.5971702933311462,
0.2570512294769287,
0.17900069057941437,
1.0938767194747925,
0.24573849141597748,
-0.3569619953632355,
0.3811319172382355,
-0.10701747238636017,
-0.5528243780136108,
0.2289879471063614,
0.19386568665504456,
0.2143966257572174,
0.2700340151786804,
-0.07727939635515213,
0.7781733274459839,
0.24097542464733124,
-0.13841353356838226,
0.33989328145980835,
0.12180472165346146,
-0.5428835153579712,
-0.4453064501285553,
0.7298657894134521,
-0.07283160090446472,
-0.22559908032417297,
0.268928587436676,
-0.5036130547523499,
-0.3183242082595825,
0.5003395676612854,
0.8550116419792175,
0.9069797992706299,
-0.13050630688667297,
0.11114439368247986,
0.6164186596870422,
0.5345534086227417,
-0.4357937276363373,
0.5515275001525879,
-0.0696108266711235,
-0.7618409395217896,
-0.8771402835845947,
-0.7827609181404114,
-0.15458843111991882,
0.20807543396949768,
-0.5721033811569214,
-0.019573930650949478,
-0.6943610906600952,
-0.10329782217741013,
0.08410812169313431,
-0.4393554627895355,
-0.3475130796432495,
0.12209691852331161,
0.08609947562217712,
0.6679860353469849,
-0.8530943393707275,
1.0506844520568848,
0.43339982628822327,
-0.3017510771751404,
-0.7847837209701538,
-0.03397735580801964,
0.011104568839073181,
-0.7308929562568665,
0.8828251361846924,
0.1802091747522354,
-0.1537971943616867,
0.1378972977399826,
-0.5641034841537476,
-0.7774518728256226,
0.4563930928707123,
0.8016899824142456,
-0.9131476283073425,
0.031557608395814896,
0.10809008032083511,
0.4171568751335144,
-0.5429477691650391,
0.44600892066955566,
0.6956804990768433,
0.42590904235839844,
0.13161517679691315,
-0.6866362690925598,
0.225251704454422,
-0.1100415363907814,
0.21822814643383026,
-0.017814254388213158,
-0.4291023313999176,
0.9586756229400635,
-0.3182827830314636,
-0.2699337899684906,
0.11430630087852478,
0.66874098777771,
0.168672576546669,
0.32598596811294556,
0.7088701128959656,
0.45024967193603516,
0.8504207730293274,
0.0745745375752449,
0.8534919619560242,
-0.6542562246322632,
0.10567734390497208,
1.2463685274124146,
-0.09495750069618225,
0.8523054718971252,
0.4709728956222534,
-0.22669795155525208,
0.31764495372772217,
0.5577016472816467,
-0.014730098657310009,
0.40294137597084045,
0.38636550307273865,
-0.3145236372947693,
-0.6909251809120178,
-0.28305935859680176,
-0.40872183442115784,
0.237186998128891,
0.35172003507614136,
-0.40938737988471985,
-0.4921267032623291,
0.06747446954250336,
-0.1369992196559906,
0.03836735710501671,
-0.17758210003376007,
0.6553441882133484,
0.24785679578781128,
-0.27781611680984497,
0.7894106507301331,
0.013150093145668507,
0.5545547008514404,
-0.587167501449585,
-0.09986609220504761,
-0.12544390559196472,
0.13455259799957275,
-0.06918089836835861,
-0.07946770638227463,
0.6669201254844666,
-0.20422396063804626,
-0.4506998360157013,
-0.1781148463487625,
0.5105301141738892,
-0.4753682017326355,
-0.7919789552688599,
0.40870732069015503,
0.5118431448936462,
0.5875886678695679,
-0.38014042377471924,
-0.732384443283081,
0.18726390600204468,
0.0833706185221672,
-0.2208849936723709,
0.4809828996658325,
0.5314440727233887,
-0.07900267839431763,
0.6389197111129761,
1.0167666673660278,
0.22446298599243164,
0.12594354152679443,
0.5136770009994507,
0.9626957774162292,
-0.4877510666847229,
-0.5079479813575745,
-0.7440088987350464,
0.1993902623653412,
0.010670939460396767,
-0.14431452751159668,
0.5925330519676208,
0.5858954787254333,
0.7361499667167664,
-0.18398259580135345,
0.6721789240837097,
-0.08442746847867966,
0.3871783912181854,
-0.6630995273590088,
0.9033011794090271,
-0.47496652603149414,
0.6639449000358582,
-0.06644131243228912,
-0.6819692254066467,
-0.33768942952156067,
0.2954537868499756,
-0.27323466539382935,
0.00684455968439579,
0.7918395400047302,
1.5410486459732056,
-0.30077287554740906,
0.2465023547410965,
0.8116828799247742,
0.6209182143211365,
-0.021527228876948357,
0.32037657499313354,
0.6398073434829712,
-0.8300082087516785,
0.8439448475837708,
-0.3743334710597992,
0.03228020295500755,
0.03186086192727089,
-0.657708466053009,
-1.0516036748886108,
-0.22943033277988434,
-0.47847986221313477,
-0.6847859025001526,
0.38778358697891235,
0.5649043321609497,
1.23031485080719,
-1.3638148307800293,
-0.2569712698459625,
-0.6068696975708008,
0.18977750837802887,
-0.5721138715744019,
-0.21299655735492706,
0.4692983031272888,
-0.8507320880889893,
-1.063718557357788,
0.7804173827171326,
0.15001341700553894,
0.0059754569083452225,
0.27987736463546753,
-0.15124674141407013,
-0.09091823548078537,
-0.010422389954328537,
0.3915769159793854,
0.34962040185928345,
-0.6230087876319885,
-0.013288374058902264,
-0.08831977844238281,
0.011625576764345169,
0.037913303822278976,
1.0158179998397827,
-0.6828674674034119,
0.6441417932510376,
0.5205700397491455,
0.8647794723510742,
0.8642998337745667,
-0.22651706635951996,
0.7298232316970825,
-0.8925442695617676,
0.6328182220458984,
-0.17220211029052734,
0.3800431787967682,
-0.033216074109077454,
-0.28091976046562195,
0.3276069462299347,
0.36798784136772156,
-0.18377220630645752,
-0.9297060966491699,
0.05125560611486435,
-0.709793746471405,
-0.5564879179000854,
1.0259573459625244,
-0.16115427017211914,
-0.48620009422302246,
-0.4751346707344055,
-0.23777785897254944,
0.26920026540756226,
-0.5078365802764893,
0.6279372572898865,
0.3509518504142761,
0.14925837516784668,
-0.4141417443752289,
-0.7042069435119629,
0.6657653450965881,
0.7441858649253845,
-0.312166303396225,
0.2574395537376404,
0.008850349113345146,
0.0964801013469696,
0.14838425815105438,
0.5014280080795288,
-0.06456881761550903,
0.23912449181079865,
0.8427025079727173,
0.17108744382858276,
-0.45313140749931335,
-0.316158264875412,
-0.1397830694913864,
0.15767696499824524,
0.06583762913942337,
-0.4162677228450775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17385v1 | Native Design Bias: Studying the Impact of English Nativeness on Language Model Performance | 2024-06-25T09:04:21 | 2024-06-25T09:04:21 | Manon Reusens, Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Bart Baesens | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at providing information acquired during
pretraining on large-scale corpora and following instructions through user
prompts. This study investigates whether the quality of LLM responses varies
depending on the demographic profile of users. Considering English as the
global lingua franca, along with the diversity of its dialects among speakers
of different native languages, we explore whether non-native English speakers
receive lower-quality or even factually incorrect responses from LLMs more
frequently. Our results show that performance discrepancies occur when LLMs are
prompted by native versus non-native English speakers and persist when
comparing native speakers from Western countries with others. Additionally, we
find a strong anchoring effect when the model recognizes or is made aware of
the user's nativeness, which further degrades the response quality when
interacting with non-native speakers. Our analysis is based on a newly
collected dataset with over 12,000 unique annotations from 124 annotators,
including information on their native language and English proficiency. | [
-0.40845388174057007,
-0.6137173175811768,
0.21729736030101776,
0.24847351014614105,
-0.049603044986724854,
0.32079386711120605,
-0.3693421185016632,
-0.9635783433914185,
0.1660332977771759,
0.20331119000911713,
-0.26159214973449707,
-0.4420207440853119,
-0.4328593909740448,
0.4070047438144684,
-0.011526218615472317,
0.6280292272567749,
0.03856103867292404,
0.17169848084449768,
-0.5905122756958008,
-0.11117298156023026,
-0.6888557076454163,
-0.679635226726532,
-0.5121893286705017,
-0.3004583418369293,
0.4538376033306122,
0.3900625705718994,
0.6992518901824951,
0.281242311000824,
0.36235976219177246,
0.23399291932582855,
-0.2630913555622101,
-0.011253290809690952,
-0.6273261308670044,
0.0912117063999176,
-0.3376176357269287,
-0.728710412979126,
-0.5719915628433228,
0.10922300815582275,
0.38036423921585083,
0.7107105255126953,
0.18481895327568054,
0.31667426228523254,
0.2644582986831665,
0.40531623363494873,
-0.5747067332267761,
0.08220241218805313,
-0.5676376223564148,
-0.07020571082830429,
-0.3189097046852112,
-0.1961134523153305,
-0.6309013962745667,
-0.2902911305427551,
0.19422832131385803,
-0.6746704578399658,
0.37357574701309204,
0.17995986342430115,
0.8076509237289429,
0.07122921943664551,
-0.6632775068283081,
-0.07378916442394257,
-0.7640441060066223,
0.8038284182548523,
-0.9633321166038513,
0.5413471460342407,
0.4708593189716339,
-0.0904456302523613,
-0.16044798493385315,
-0.035921551287174225,
-0.3019407391548157,
-0.4645090103149414,
-0.2999570369720459,
-0.031904932111501694,
-0.07821626216173172,
0.018558690324425697,
0.43323782086372375,
0.4395431578159332,
-0.7883168458938599,
0.7343527674674988,
-0.5384238362312317,
-0.32591021060943604,
0.9057893753051758,
0.08094441890716553,
0.2140580713748932,
-0.09051865339279175,
-0.05188370123505592,
0.156625896692276,
-0.8722474575042725,
0.3413696587085724,
0.6058217883110046,
0.46656906604766846,
-0.42639490962028503,
0.37131720781326294,
-0.07352887094020844,
0.7628222703933716,
-0.15072257816791534,
-0.4983798563480377,
0.5585117936134338,
-0.11357107758522034,
0.12157898396253586,
-0.13132432103157043,
0.7531201243400574,
0.5483132600784302,
0.7756968140602112,
-0.16045880317687988,
-0.4395221471786499,
0.13296787440776825,
-0.0405748151242733,
-0.6264491677284241,
0.022317711263895035,
-0.1035216748714447,
-0.544367253780365,
-0.022086890414357185,
0.05270656198263168,
-0.7204364538192749,
-0.32877087593078613,
-0.37489059567451477,
0.2035394310951233,
0.17661415040493011,
-0.4179335832595825,
0.09385260194540024,
0.15093331038951874,
0.03459055721759796,
0.10088768601417542,
-0.9499168992042542,
0.3366050124168396,
0.4065535068511963,
0.6026250720024109,
-0.5837833285331726,
-0.11333338916301727,
-0.26213574409484863,
-0.11971437186002731,
-0.3794333338737488,
0.6041359305381775,
-0.6129618287086487,
-0.804912269115448,
0.17261356115341187,
-0.01863911747932434,
0.007515034172683954,
-0.7736092805862427,
0.4966268837451935,
-0.605043888092041,
0.2282503843307495,
-0.507548451423645,
-0.21746008098125458,
0.010136375203728676,
-0.051081519573926926,
-0.7458943128585815,
0.8761233687400818,
-0.2559129595756531,
-0.8280348777770996,
0.6353975534439087,
-0.45475849509239197,
-0.6989439725875854,
0.05591120943427086,
-0.32451575994491577,
-0.019130434840917587,
0.49989384412765503,
0.2849404811859131,
0.29220345616340637,
-0.15846750140190125,
0.010894039645791054,
-0.31627893447875977,
-0.49434441328048706,
0.11365417391061783,
-0.33717676997184753,
0.43426164984703064,
0.30480197072029114,
-0.27649012207984924,
-0.07864772528409958,
-0.8855844736099243,
-0.3893163204193115,
0.39519378542900085,
-0.6033827662467957,
-0.5748425126075745,
0.09182503819465637,
0.14148129522800446,
0.373744934797287,
0.264703631401062,
-0.7517750859260559,
0.06314209848642349,
-0.45446300506591797,
0.24736936390399933,
0.8093758821487427,
-0.05539215728640556,
0.37698057293891907,
-0.37311023473739624,
0.7004103064537048,
-0.14418844878673553,
-0.05439271032810211,
-0.23255737125873566,
-0.6474624872207642,
-0.42748719453811646,
0.08805243670940399,
0.16478323936462402,
0.3749562203884125,
-0.22736607491970062,
-0.029392851516604424,
-0.23167115449905396,
-0.20975400507450104,
-0.5240312218666077,
0.4637695550918579,
0.299381822347641,
0.4832192063331604,
0.08235758543014526,
-0.41235488653182983,
-0.5220741033554077,
-1.2099641561508179,
-0.2506890594959259,
-0.44579797983169556,
-0.3383312523365021,
0.44140657782554626,
0.305974543094635,
0.07368533313274384,
0.9878572225570679,
-0.23802438378334045,
-0.06996884196996689,
-0.2803247570991516,
-0.021923024207353592,
0.12438435852527618,
0.13035687804222107,
0.6776663661003113,
-0.5338149070739746,
-0.3392936885356903,
-0.08663202077150345,
-0.511803388595581,
-0.33634474873542786,
-0.04129382222890854,
0.05600399523973465,
0.5597431659698486,
0.37769776582717896,
-0.43622636795043945,
0.27475807070732117,
0.82524573802948,
-0.15596231818199158,
0.5725050568580627,
-0.08879433572292328,
0.12595902383327484,
-1.1353356838226318,
0.1252838522195816,
0.34449535608291626,
0.18252934515476227,
-0.31486234068870544,
-0.1522182822227478,
0.10538545995950699,
0.12230891734361649,
-0.38124001026153564,
0.685319185256958,
-0.5977147221565247,
-0.13139882683753967,
-0.2330557107925415,
0.11477086693048477,
0.19074469804763794,
0.1558462381362915,
0.2579523026943207,
1.0686184167861938,
0.02915898896753788,
-0.5180924534797668,
-0.08421473205089569,
0.1951141655445099,
-0.4654685854911804,
0.49314406514167786,
-0.9426087737083435,
0.1913043111562729,
-0.3597676157951355,
0.1590988039970398,
-1.2847775220870972,
-0.12495644390583038,
-0.41617879271507263,
-0.5817204117774963,
0.3894391357898712,
-0.03441636636853218,
-0.4971906840801239,
-0.5766453742980957,
-0.08236652612686157,
0.3757772147655487,
0.40948158502578735,
-0.40547844767570496,
0.39165258407592773,
0.2888384461402893,
-0.3003811836242676,
-0.37844741344451904,
-0.7411709427833557,
0.08442844450473785,
-0.054973043501377106,
-0.8638863563537598,
0.1988813728094101,
-0.18640531599521637,
-0.5785844326019287,
-0.3141856789588928,
0.05891396105289459,
0.22940067946910858,
0.3415500223636627,
0.19001753628253937,
0.3046548366546631,
-0.37559041380882263,
0.20679990947246552,
-0.38438647985458374,
0.22623510658740997,
0.4628290832042694,
-0.03246919438242912,
0.4194093644618988,
0.24759995937347412,
-0.3947136104106903,
-0.33872371912002563,
0.30245739221572876,
0.6381932497024536,
-0.6305052638053894,
0.7923233509063721,
0.08142349123954773,
-0.34719935059547424,
-0.06674252450466156,
-0.7831733226776123,
-0.21123330295085907,
-0.4767402410507202,
0.4769899845123291,
-0.47591105103492737,
-0.9708419442176819,
0.7537508010864258,
0.47523006796836853,
0.4969675838947296,
0.32579973340034485,
0.5469382405281067,
-0.14401701092720032,
1.0674080848693848,
0.7429898977279663,
-0.24736130237579346,
0.3831980228424072,
0.045515276491642,
0.13877885043621063,
-0.4912465214729309,
-0.3959113359451294,
-0.565930962562561,
-0.5494300127029419,
-0.7223566770553589,
-0.02993938699364662,
-0.04700437933206558,
-0.3521427810192108,
-0.14792221784591675,
-0.011969849467277527,
-0.20119412243366241,
0.306632936000824,
0.5392410755157471,
-0.15628784894943237,
0.401163786649704,
0.15647712349891663,
-0.20146304368972778,
-0.4413963556289673,
-0.4880845546722412,
-0.6484000086784363,
1.1459938287734985,
0.581870436668396,
1.190697193145752,
0.2528977394104004,
0.4081830084323883,
0.21431320905685425,
0.27234241366386414,
-0.5980859398841858,
0.2965971827507019,
0.10322736203670502,
-0.8247426152229309,
0.12786632776260376,
-0.4910777509212494,
-0.9547017216682434,
0.04765291139483452,
-0.32344770431518555,
-0.7383342981338501,
0.10028105229139328,
0.26572608947753906,
-0.33047109842300415,
0.34056055545806885,
-0.8561442494392395,
0.5586608052253723,
-0.5558251738548279,
-0.5438055992126465,
0.0712461993098259,
-0.45901358127593994,
0.4588102400302887,
-0.31537550687789917,
0.5059802532196045,
-0.11593812704086304,
-0.008277916349470615,
0.8357433676719666,
0.015886303037405014,
1.0033199787139893,
-0.1483587771654129,
-0.38270118832588196,
-0.03143724054098129,
0.12121906876564026,
0.5089675784111023,
0.03544486314058304,
-0.24945268034934998,
0.15854863822460175,
-0.32402729988098145,
-0.523676335811615,
-0.26654794812202454,
0.8498337268829346,
-1.0644906759262085,
-0.9308359622955322,
-0.12519049644470215,
-0.6193453073501587,
-0.5049887299537659,
-0.12357301265001297,
0.446359783411026,
0.32932209968566895,
-0.12922659516334534,
0.04954569786787033,
0.5860663652420044,
-0.5063724517822266,
0.3276035487651825,
0.8157487511634827,
-0.18720878660678864,
-0.035253457725048065,
0.5416523814201355,
0.4160567820072174,
0.5353922843933105,
0.36660340428352356,
0.1824706494808197,
-0.3741396367549896,
-0.5793992877006531,
-0.2960943281650543,
0.39583098888397217,
-0.5375955700874329,
0.1501777321100235,
-0.44878554344177246,
0.02664218842983246,
-0.4509972035884857,
-0.05036639794707298,
-0.34005579352378845,
-0.0608375109732151,
-0.13597117364406586,
-0.3665944039821625,
0.2654634118080139,
1.110486388206482,
0.1755276769399643,
0.1637498289346695,
-0.43370702862739563,
-0.07385783642530441,
0.24064521491527557,
0.29892048239707947,
0.156496062874794,
-0.9634653329849243,
-0.3360711932182312,
-0.015334103256464005,
-0.15602853894233704,
-0.6875197887420654,
0.08485737442970276,
0.07682736963033676,
0.9689788818359375,
0.5380883812904358,
-0.03125810995697975,
0.2380397468805313,
-0.37285494804382324,
0.9701847434043884,
-0.09625090658664703,
-0.4649266302585602,
0.4886492192745209,
-0.467642217874527,
0.5558950901031494,
0.5454114675521851,
0.4674469828605652,
-0.6563957929611206,
-0.35759276151657104,
-0.2553795576095581,
-0.8440937399864197,
0.3293464779853821,
-0.2478017657995224,
0.5367094874382019,
-0.13182593882083893,
0.21081973612308502,
0.20487408339977264,
0.12930041551589966,
-0.787128746509552,
-0.38535255193710327,
0.17873750627040863,
0.20797047019004822,
-0.23640693724155426,
-0.6633331179618835,
0.13086555898189545,
-0.0349467471241951,
0.4444223642349243,
-0.01838451810181141,
-0.07422720640897751,
-0.08145677298307419,
-0.27996301651000977,
-0.2676815986633301,
0.13844545185565948,
0.8937179446220398,
1.0314886569976807,
-0.2008843868970871,
0.17015472054481506,
0.3266754746437073,
-0.37218278646469116,
0.21930678188800812,
-0.2547810673713684,
-0.15429852902889252,
0.2434019297361374,
0.621912956237793,
0.5993112921714783,
0.30398720502853394,
-0.45359116792678833,
0.4800410866737366,
-0.18619966506958008,
-0.09330005198717117,
-0.11278308928012848,
-0.14356528222560883,
0.21749523282051086,
-0.3770214319229126,
0.5897948741912842,
0.004726011771708727,
-0.1780232936143875,
-0.3805742561817169,
0.07832132279872894,
0.5204501748085022,
0.00010685299639590085,
-0.6124533414840698,
0.979289710521698,
0.5891823172569275,
-0.5649896860122681,
0.4511008858680725,
-0.02884969674050808,
-0.37009891867637634,
0.34773120284080505,
0.5563662648200989,
0.44654399156570435,
-0.40584319829940796,
-0.10848932713270187,
0.5432655811309814,
0.5142143964767456,
0.22821800410747528,
0.14478527009487152,
0.2938968241214752,
-0.6771917343139648,
-0.9104783535003662,
-0.5164633989334106,
-0.31724071502685547,
0.3255821466445923,
-0.5925793051719666,
0.25146278738975525,
-0.44773921370506287,
-0.3611106276512146,
-0.33957281708717346,
-0.06468700617551804,
-0.941013753414154,
0.20663809776306152,
0.5644491910934448,
1.142473578453064,
-1.1553120613098145,
0.4297439754009247,
0.9113165140151978,
-0.45084547996520996,
-0.7278366684913635,
-0.0016764589818194509,
0.2599693238735199,
-0.7873737812042236,
0.9364222288131714,
0.19170887768268585,
0.017186563462018967,
-0.38294482231140137,
-0.14863868057727814,
-1.0113061666488647,
0.632735550403595,
0.55496746301651,
-0.6228463649749756,
0.00006511253741336986,
0.5300316214561462,
0.5898048877716064,
-0.1255611926317215,
0.5323205590248108,
0.4256928265094757,
0.11812055855989456,
-0.025363050401210785,
-1.3442403078079224,
-0.24289648234844208,
-0.35410693287849426,
0.22028855979442596,
-0.09135177731513977,
-0.7527881860733032,
0.7480692863464355,
-0.23088620603084564,
-0.16670146584510803,
-0.2454233467578888,
0.6938406229019165,
0.34562793374061584,
0.030454711988568306,
0.3676246404647827,
0.42125463485717773,
0.7869594693183899,
0.030944980680942535,
0.8674353361129761,
-0.5108493566513062,
-0.13863004744052887,
1.0223782062530518,
-0.24774625897407532,
1.0686827898025513,
0.518276572227478,
-0.33584466576576233,
0.5155882835388184,
0.8493165969848633,
0.4076915383338928,
0.144473597407341,
0.41377028822898865,
-0.3283405601978302,
-0.11478672921657562,
-0.26000282168388367,
-0.5417987108230591,
0.4637734889984131,
0.09303046017885208,
-0.45046308636665344,
0.017512978985905647,
-0.029293473809957504,
0.21351410448551178,
0.3396150469779968,
-0.233317568898201,
0.4853362739086151,
0.12392017990350723,
-0.6143162846565247,
0.7003141641616821,
-0.0013769243378192186,
1.3264237642288208,
-0.4490234851837158,
0.20686174929141998,
-0.7585761547088623,
-0.059775158762931824,
-0.5356233716011047,
-0.6419501900672913,
0.0003452860109973699,
0.06738334149122238,
-0.5243651866912842,
-0.08403480052947998,
0.2959659993648529,
-0.03881645202636719,
-0.6076483726501465,
0.5707291960716248,
0.5894774794578552,
0.10397014021873474,
0.11891338974237442,
-0.2654534876346588,
0.3069632947444916,
-0.110956110060215,
-0.5197572708129883,
0.3659890294075012,
0.030013296753168106,
-0.3092106878757477,
0.6270634531974792,
0.6328070163726807,
0.152632936835289,
0.21655994653701782,
0.1535460650920868,
0.5202422738075256,
-0.274057537317276,
-0.37106746435165405,
-0.8535813093185425,
0.5500925183296204,
-0.10029322654008865,
-0.5149757862091064,
0.9550287127494812,
0.8492028713226318,
1.2703570127487183,
-0.019747210666537285,
0.8625988960266113,
0.4585709273815155,
0.49715933203697205,
-0.31228914856910706,
0.6300323605537415,
-0.5523301959037781,
0.43830054998397827,
-0.3532574772834778,
-1.0638997554779053,
-0.13514570891857147,
0.5832441449165344,
-0.6543305516242981,
0.32974591851234436,
0.2857693135738373,
0.8839662075042725,
-0.008504042401909828,
-0.12254626303911209,
0.5310071110725403,
0.06286760419607162,
0.5003374814987183,
0.4560633599758148,
0.8166890144348145,
0.009267469868063927,
0.40975919365882874,
-0.029925208538770676,
-0.14333462715148926,
-0.1474538892507553,
-0.6914356350898743,
-0.9470518827438354,
-0.26081177592277527,
-0.20702071487903595,
-0.21608203649520874,
-0.15925432741641998,
1.0970807075500488,
0.7603527307510376,
-0.8482298254966736,
-0.4812738299369812,
0.49750638008117676,
-0.0943511351943016,
0.3733592629432678,
-0.23991292715072632,
0.04655155539512634,
-0.28657886385917664,
-0.719077467918396,
0.3416200876235962,
-0.10247240960597992,
0.04497572407126427,
-0.5532423257827759,
-0.21724346280097961,
0.06994695216417313,
0.057769160717725754,
0.6095179915428162,
0.3554263710975647,
-0.7689083218574524,
-0.17972664535045624,
0.3977700173854828,
-0.25219741463661194,
0.22155651450157166,
0.5602944493293762,
-0.723658561706543,
0.4549148976802826,
0.40291064977645874,
0.5416878461837769,
0.21545559167861938,
-0.06360125541687012,
0.7979639172554016,
-0.8324760794639587,
0.2754744291305542,
0.0769607275724411,
0.42131951451301575,
0.6370254158973694,
-0.26822686195373535,
0.1835247427225113,
0.33374133706092834,
-0.5399222373962402,
-0.7192258834838867,
0.11227945238351822,
-0.3992787301540375,
-0.06937973201274872,
1.4486258029937744,
-0.04958565905690193,
-0.16393215954303741,
-0.10932125151157379,
-0.20850931107997894,
-0.331516295671463,
-0.4522101581096649,
0.612516462802887,
0.911258339881897,
0.003144897287711501,
-0.20112471282482147,
-0.9506640434265137,
0.4539015293121338,
0.45136573910713196,
-0.5119116306304932,
-0.056344710290431976,
0.5155372023582458,
0.6367701888084412,
0.12667430937290192,
0.5088096261024475,
0.10740115493535995,
0.1810794472694397,
-0.2656886577606201,
0.2529103457927704,
0.012297548353672028,
-0.0020132013596594334,
-0.3066018223762512,
-0.012930402532219887,
0.8566232323646545,
-0.12569448351860046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17378v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17378v1 | A Text is Worth Several Tokens: Text Embedding from LLMs Secretly Aligns Well with The Key Tokens | 2024-06-25T08:55:12 | 2024-06-25T08:55:12 | Zhijie Nie, Richong Zhang, Zhanyu Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Text embeddings from large language models (LLMs) have achieved excellent
results in tasks such as information retrieval, semantic textual similarity,
etc. In this work, we show an interesting finding: when feeding a text into the
embedding LLMs, the obtained text embedding will be able to be aligned with the
key tokens in the input text. We first fully analyze this phenomenon on eight
embedding LLMs and show that this phenomenon is universal and is not affected
by model architecture, training strategy, and embedding method. With a deeper
analysis, we then find that the main change in embedding space between the
embedding LLMs and their original generative LLMs is in the first principal
component. By adjusting the first principal component, we can align text
embedding with the key tokens. Finally, we give several examples to demonstrate
the vast application potential of this finding: (1) we propose a simple and
practical sparse retrieval method based on the aligned tokens, which can
achieve 80\% of the dense retrieval effect of the same model while reducing the
computation significantly; (2) we show that our findings provide a fresh
perspective to help understand fuzzy concepts (e.g., semantic relatedness vs.
semantic similarity) and emerging technologies (e.g., instruction-following
embedding) in this field. | [
0.06268256157636642,
-0.7668725252151489,
1.0247539281845093,
-0.07274467498064041,
-0.5462211966514587,
0.12168451398611069,
-0.19242194294929504,
-0.22833693027496338,
0.4066962003707886,
0.3084907829761505,
-0.3076344132423401,
-0.4986140727996826,
-0.6779910326004028,
-0.10906856507062912,
-0.5878957509994507,
0.7118815183639526,
0.043667543679475784,
0.2643280029296875,
-0.4450436234474182,
-0.227065309882164,
-0.5386908650398254,
-0.6555253267288208,
-0.28385624289512634,
-0.1973113715648651,
0.41820549964904785,
0.2801305651664734,
0.9427398443222046,
1.1553226709365845,
0.7538551092147827,
0.3190782368183136,
-0.1917295753955841,
-0.0776081532239914,
-0.5546061992645264,
0.21284382045269012,
0.0037921422626823187,
-0.6659272909164429,
-0.1603906899690628,
-0.05774359405040741,
0.9922513365745544,
0.6166755557060242,
0.12596945464611053,
-0.1265871226787567,
0.4856395125389099,
0.5308570265769958,
-0.42800188064575195,
0.0034745424054563046,
-0.8491274118423462,
0.030410416424274445,
-0.3030623495578766,
-0.02759828045964241,
-0.34311845898628235,
-0.04405149817466736,
-0.055565472692251205,
-0.6002734303474426,
0.0450613759458065,
0.2775825262069702,
1.0695685148239136,
0.3729245662689209,
-0.3887510597705841,
-0.29453641176223755,
-0.18082423508167267,
0.764801561832428,
-0.6720749139785767,
0.37328651547431946,
-0.028113575652241707,
-0.05319816991686821,
-0.13813000917434692,
-0.578037679195404,
-0.7869237661361694,
0.06209013983607292,
-0.16602101922035217,
-0.25569257140159607,
0.1241251602768898,
0.19355271756649017,
-0.05409073457121849,
0.3512097895145416,
-0.32549285888671875,
0.27549588680267334,
0.10273787379264832,
-0.13079676032066345,
0.3583761751651764,
0.08196771889925003,
0.4031142294406891,
-0.3360256552696228,
-0.7669918537139893,
-0.16412249207496643,
-0.8044991493225098,
-0.336568683385849,
0.1996060460805893,
0.5396469235420227,
-0.05540217086672783,
0.9194690585136414,
0.44038689136505127,
0.5888726115226746,
0.03296802565455437,
-0.15795278549194336,
0.22172948718070984,
-0.7326204180717468,
-0.22534368932247162,
0.15631316602230072,
0.680837094783783,
0.32209742069244385,
0.3756328225135803,
-0.2170676589012146,
-0.20061935484409332,
-0.07702910155057907,
0.24391068518161774,
-0.5117539167404175,
0.16961263120174408,
-0.09610947966575623,
-0.6211628317832947,
-0.3590329885482788,
0.37291428446769714,
-0.3941628336906433,
-0.4602985084056854,
-0.23817242681980133,
0.698704719543457,
-0.4336790144443512,
0.0201133880764246,
0.040794555097818375,
-0.25636494159698486,
0.5183771252632141,
0.17080490291118622,
-1.0707275867462158,
0.38997960090637207,
1.3552005290985107,
1.0353217124938965,
-0.22998109459877014,
-0.12149082124233246,
-0.23995372653007507,
0.19327284395694733,
-0.3743201196193695,
0.7314993739128113,
-0.822339653968811,
-0.13841600716114044,
0.26751193404197693,
-0.18142735958099365,
0.0009925710037350655,
-0.44737112522125244,
0.4024171233177185,
-0.541583776473999,
-0.05970783159136772,
-0.3868356943130493,
-0.9439997673034668,
0.05037800222635269,
0.15929311513900757,
-0.6521328091621399,
1.037307858467102,
-0.27233588695526123,
-0.7244066596031189,
0.3536626100540161,
-0.022496633231639862,
-0.19384396076202393,
-0.09867651015520096,
-0.4661238193511963,
-0.41682398319244385,
0.376444548368454,
0.01673489436507225,
0.5048797130584717,
-0.22284483909606934,
0.20592954754829407,
-0.40050554275512695,
-0.6197410821914673,
0.6122983694076538,
-0.45566824078559875,
0.47939348220825195,
0.067656010389328,
-0.21726351976394653,
-0.10943485051393509,
-0.3809804618358612,
-0.06057851389050484,
0.012636462226510048,
-0.2476392388343811,
-0.7063515782356262,
0.0822407677769661,
-0.02929581142961979,
-0.05562359839677811,
0.40376603603363037,
-0.6845114231109619,
0.46967369318008423,
-0.48177245259284973,
0.483973890542984,
0.9527096152305603,
-0.03508904203772545,
0.734337329864502,
-0.4289080500602722,
0.15485930442810059,
0.01724102348089218,
-0.2023848593235016,
-0.32154613733291626,
-0.45373624563217163,
-0.6340829730033875,
-0.49922043085098267,
0.6550377607345581,
0.3360014855861664,
-0.29859456419944763,
0.5488878488540649,
-0.4920794665813446,
-0.007378159556537867,
-0.6956369876861572,
0.28523385524749756,
0.24699024856090546,
0.12331318855285645,
-0.018236976116895676,
-0.09815895557403564,
-0.2697353959083557,
-0.891377866268158,
-0.5549067258834839,
-0.024412844330072403,
0.1171635165810585,
0.13506737351417542,
0.2997325360774994,
0.0034591194707900286,
0.9804714918136597,
-0.6421334147453308,
-0.4319595992565155,
0.05668773129582405,
-0.21363778412342072,
0.07813037186861038,
0.6634612083435059,
0.43363383412361145,
-0.7693791389465332,
-0.5428194999694824,
-0.06553667038679123,
-0.5844553112983704,
0.09088322520256042,
-0.2282056361436844,
-0.3729073703289032,
0.016196124255657196,
0.7836650013923645,
-0.5918081402778625,
0.12909987568855286,
0.4034436345100403,
-0.4587785005569458,
-0.20408686995506287,
-0.1814156472682953,
-0.04412747547030449,
-1.3013098239898682,
-0.11892696470022202,
-0.2042631208896637,
-0.3193780779838562,
-0.3746037185192108,
0.1686779111623764,
0.23279891908168793,
-0.037909768521785736,
-0.24344849586486816,
0.6236405968666077,
-0.4939562678337097,
-0.10519155114889145,
-0.31707873940467834,
0.6544097661972046,
0.07272771745920181,
0.31034642457962036,
-0.40732401609420776,
0.8137526512145996,
0.2734878957271576,
-0.25550875067710876,
0.10986088961362839,
0.3073233962059021,
-0.40746602416038513,
0.4611055850982666,
-0.38783395290374756,
0.17393378913402557,
-0.29687386751174927,
-0.009207778610289097,
-1.4393391609191895,
0.08003192394971848,
0.11278172582387924,
-0.48205143213272095,
0.5962552428245544,
0.08815998584032059,
-0.8492569327354431,
0.09167981892824173,
-0.7195863723754883,
0.5020993947982788,
0.4480551481246948,
-0.6162825226783752,
0.4586153030395508,
0.44958561658859253,
-0.18099351227283478,
-0.5863544940948486,
-0.7398619055747986,
0.21896140277385712,
-0.24121013283729553,
-0.37423932552337646,
0.6580631136894226,
0.13868717849254608,
-0.23985667526721954,
0.5366771221160889,
-0.1633034646511078,
0.029592998325824738,
0.34720996022224426,
0.1406911462545395,
0.2833627760410309,
-0.32909807562828064,
0.6047400832176208,
0.07625492662191391,
-0.10226163268089294,
-0.14183682203292847,
-0.4481849670410156,
0.5275510549545288,
0.13478505611419678,
-0.6355620622634888,
-0.32960274815559387,
0.3559972047805786,
0.4147127866744995,
-0.009286773391067982,
1.0109188556671143,
0.3939734995365143,
-0.6014854311943054,
0.05598829314112663,
-0.5875612497329712,
-0.05446165055036545,
-0.5337573885917664,
0.5087711215019226,
-0.2410580962896347,
-1.1039760112762451,
0.31728342175483704,
0.0010933467419818044,
-0.010470066219568253,
0.6132057905197144,
0.3566093444824219,
-0.1745818555355072,
1.2266607284545898,
0.8765224814414978,
-0.18619617819786072,
0.582088828086853,
0.01923312060534954,
0.44766244292259216,
-0.8936604261398315,
-0.5027045607566833,
-0.6996561884880066,
-0.5433191657066345,
-0.7755183577537537,
-0.5639409422874451,
0.12412244081497192,
0.26436150074005127,
-0.32634323835372925,
0.001050669001415372,
-0.4270801246166229,
0.5253670811653137,
0.33571305871009827,
0.041105691343545914,
0.21946726739406586,
0.16321030259132385,
-0.4964693784713745,
-0.3052692115306854,
-0.5910707712173462,
-0.6216278672218323,
0.9532414078712463,
0.39246246218681335,
0.8748132586479187,
0.2589658498764038,
0.8658369779586792,
0.21051611006259918,
0.19852297008037567,
-0.9814644455909729,
0.3494167625904083,
-0.36629000306129456,
-0.32039931416511536,
-0.17874953150749207,
-0.1650475561618805,
-0.8269465565681458,
0.19500458240509033,
-0.36041274666786194,
-0.741524338722229,
0.011829149909317493,
-0.1637434959411621,
-0.2882384955883026,
0.26470309495925903,
-0.6467266082763672,
0.7030707597732544,
-0.3473581075668335,
-0.2810062766075134,
-0.2776913642883301,
-0.36197584867477417,
-0.010241773910820484,
-0.1666577309370041,
0.09179437905550003,
-0.03685838729143143,
-0.6363053917884827,
0.8318556547164917,
-0.46884211897850037,
0.9186751842498779,
0.09451422840356827,
-0.2644350230693817,
0.2063336968421936,
-0.21197247505187988,
0.40981000661849976,
-0.0983729436993599,
-0.06821374595165253,
-0.0862477496266365,
-0.09630199521780014,
-0.49925127625465393,
-0.9424887895584106,
1.1184426546096802,
-0.742802083492279,
-1.0173728466033936,
-0.5832748413085938,
-0.3504093885421753,
-0.13023529946804047,
0.35164740681648254,
-0.07266337424516678,
0.3896086812019348,
-0.1677510291337967,
0.4022747278213501,
0.8207224607467651,
-0.10622827708721161,
0.3540204167366028,
0.07960774004459381,
-0.1881738305091858,
-0.38025182485580444,
0.7850375175476074,
0.0737202987074852,
0.21000711619853973,
0.8763522505760193,
0.16406749188899994,
-0.4174121618270874,
-0.21813037991523743,
-0.30625078082084656,
0.5601525902748108,
-0.712080180644989,
-0.4916529953479767,
-0.5750276446342468,
-0.1797749251127243,
-0.40330660343170166,
-0.4465728998184204,
-0.22162072360515594,
-0.5864486694335938,
-0.6403495073318481,
-0.2852918803691864,
0.40535035729408264,
1.0486419200897217,
0.053599122911691666,
0.46023207902908325,
-0.9397269487380981,
-0.04560046270489693,
0.3022521734237671,
0.5123302340507507,
0.3091731071472168,
-0.4452694058418274,
-0.2804446220397949,
0.03341608867049217,
-0.3470381796360016,
-0.8712206482887268,
0.08578497171401978,
0.23968495428562164,
0.5784871578216553,
0.7302945852279663,
-0.1768517643213272,
0.7332069277763367,
-0.6902633309364319,
0.9180474877357483,
0.0837249755859375,
-1.1844185590744019,
-0.028598293662071228,
-0.08892383426427841,
0.15693733096122742,
0.6142534017562866,
0.31582510471343994,
-0.4959072768688202,
-0.2387622594833374,
-0.5205531716346741,
-0.6771956086158752,
0.5317829847335815,
0.020569227635860443,
0.7988780736923218,
-0.2294493317604065,
0.650174617767334,
-0.03967894986271858,
0.24376419186592102,
-0.5952648520469666,
-0.3311643898487091,
0.07527653127908707,
-0.7753573656082153,
-0.1089387908577919,
-0.6089405417442322,
0.04764446243643761,
-0.015093785710632801,
0.4462302029132843,
0.04520249366760254,
0.736721932888031,
0.08803398907184601,
-0.11597340553998947,
0.08454273641109467,
0.1353200525045395,
0.44615480303764343,
0.2305767685174942,
0.10066933184862137,
0.4347764849662781,
0.07202981412410736,
-0.35452505946159363,
0.22912105917930603,
-0.09067515283823013,
0.02764580398797989,
-0.006355850026011467,
0.4267207086086273,
0.5438336730003357,
0.6858465075492859,
-0.5350930094718933,
0.7974978089332581,
0.1380188912153244,
0.01044456847012043,
0.06669493019580841,
-0.0512414313852787,
0.2671251595020294,
0.26091504096984863,
0.4459758698940277,
-0.2493792176246643,
-0.10269785672426224,
-0.5636433362960815,
0.30081015825271606,
0.8781294226646423,
-0.4438543915748596,
-0.2235221415758133,
0.48293498158454895,
0.07075842469930649,
-0.46398529410362244,
0.5585126876831055,
0.06763671338558197,
-0.9242897033691406,
0.42292559146881104,
0.8804513812065125,
0.7430288791656494,
0.16826994717121124,
0.13050618767738342,
0.1326412558555603,
0.27565526962280273,
-0.03227194771170616,
0.17339053750038147,
-0.17726218700408936,
-0.7438125610351562,
-0.3285425901412964,
-0.5436020493507385,
0.0360497310757637,
-0.24952062964439392,
-0.4552709460258484,
0.29751765727996826,
-0.3495540916919708,
-0.12354031950235367,
-0.1775793731212616,
0.09690391272306442,
-0.5905495882034302,
-0.24975243210792542,
0.21169857680797577,
0.9052398800849915,
-0.7838960886001587,
0.7236871719360352,
0.5480183362960815,
-0.1405157893896103,
-0.8289299607276917,
0.2962852120399475,
0.04209963604807854,
-1.1252989768981934,
0.6838912963867188,
0.24302615225315094,
0.1476755440235138,
0.06846828013658524,
-0.6012542247772217,
-1.254889965057373,
0.9481045007705688,
0.29250481724739075,
-0.4676690995693207,
-0.16918648779392242,
0.3738787770271301,
0.4352515637874603,
-0.34034469723701477,
-0.1586781144142151,
0.13182929158210754,
0.374813050031662,
-0.06743408739566803,
-0.6019123196601868,
0.3331899046897888,
-0.12310758233070374,
0.1638510525226593,
0.5378999710083008,
-0.820271909236908,
0.8141061663627625,
-0.05942676588892937,
-0.5190212726593018,
0.4364188015460968,
0.6663380861282349,
-0.11961159855127335,
-0.043251149356365204,
0.2441663146018982,
0.8229576349258423,
0.7378398180007935,
-0.059131231158971786,
0.9379734992980957,
-0.4042080044746399,
0.41000229120254517,
0.6016554236412048,
-0.25556546449661255,
0.9334487318992615,
0.7281625270843506,
0.08933807909488678,
0.45301663875579834,
0.3154653012752533,
0.020057382062077522,
0.7674465179443359,
0.18687419593334198,
-0.20229797065258026,
-0.2220308482646942,
-0.2820398211479187,
-0.28718456625938416,
0.31820523738861084,
0.46299153566360474,
-0.4898075759410858,
-0.10241834819316864,
0.005932040978223085,
0.1995677351951599,
0.24886684119701385,
-0.1191692054271698,
0.976277768611908,
0.3346782624721527,
-0.5029551386833191,
0.29343876242637634,
0.12110306322574615,
0.7899937629699707,
-0.44175171852111816,
-0.1358928680419922,
0.04763827472925186,
0.3149644136428833,
-0.030394604429602623,
-0.7763093709945679,
0.11616256833076477,
-0.14515656232833862,
0.008931235410273075,
-0.30212053656578064,
0.7023926973342896,
-0.456256628036499,
-0.4567359387874603,
0.17545312643051147,
0.4275943636894226,
-0.18313796818256378,
0.2322189062833786,
-0.4847434163093567,
0.28752484917640686,
-0.07298307865858078,
0.09853911399841309,
0.6005741357803345,
0.7062366604804993,
0.16044916212558746,
0.29741141200065613,
0.5062049627304077,
-0.0015355761861428618,
0.06609945744276047,
-0.2006758153438568,
0.8807932138442993,
-0.7592189311981201,
-0.42498326301574707,
-1.1883898973464966,
0.15652188658714294,
-0.06661827862262726,
-0.11595861613750458,
0.8708584904670715,
0.5924738645553589,
0.7206133008003235,
0.2690938711166382,
0.47913920879364014,
0.2995149791240692,
0.16588205099105835,
-0.7674973607063293,
0.5720773935317993,
-0.5921410322189331,
0.29263773560523987,
-0.343588650226593,
-0.9753641486167908,
-0.43528833985328674,
0.7139881253242493,
-0.030784305185079575,
-0.10566380620002747,
0.7474642395973206,
0.7281414866447449,
0.06265366077423096,
-0.1342504918575287,
0.24486513435840607,
0.14495086669921875,
0.1218646988272667,
0.25385990738868713,
0.7595956921577454,
-0.4474702477455139,
0.25853100419044495,
0.04318792745471001,
-0.06774657964706421,
-0.21663691103458405,
-0.9191341400146484,
-0.6541736721992493,
-0.7123529314994812,
-0.06926004588603973,
-0.18090131878852844,
0.22732701897621155,
0.9058643579483032,
0.26188087463378906,
-0.4705142378807068,
-0.03292149677872658,
-0.003930641338229179,
0.4800351560115814,
0.02674883045256138,
-0.24112120270729065,
0.541304886341095,
-0.4916275143623352,
-0.7114958763122559,
-0.0761747658252716,
0.29511016607284546,
0.2546274662017822,
-0.1738317459821701,
0.05165162310004234,
-0.48306944966316223,
0.1692514419555664,
0.4228394329547882,
-0.26914969086647034,
-0.675943911075592,
-0.7252636551856995,
0.31457364559173584,
-0.45464301109313965,
0.12534630298614502,
0.9645475149154663,
-0.777644693851471,
0.2524205446243286,
0.6320269703865051,
1.0885168313980103,
0.1263754814863205,
0.13038106262683868,
0.581547737121582,
-0.7808440327644348,
0.05325711518526077,
0.049278419464826584,
0.4187639057636261,
0.3752782344818115,
-0.4781925678253174,
0.012563301250338554,
0.07000807672739029,
-0.3870990574359894,
-0.8746337890625,
-0.025322668254375458,
-0.8415074348449707,
-0.28855785727500916,
1.1906102895736694,
0.03760380670428276,
-0.2545519769191742,
0.2669563591480255,
-0.1885884404182434,
0.3326420187950134,
-0.25445684790611267,
0.6432249546051025,
0.9943413734436035,
0.15957295894622803,
0.16729560494422913,
-0.0851718857884407,
0.27887746691703796,
0.6450221538543701,
-0.3238331079483032,
-0.17058469355106354,
0.0644240453839302,
0.14399804174900055,
0.1743885576725006,
0.3581131398677826,
-0.1998693197965622,
-0.1508076786994934,
-0.0388592965900898,
-0.3982621133327484,
0.10649131238460541,
-0.13443513214588165,
-0.5205907225608826,
0.04096382111310959,
0.3400217592716217,
-0.4349811375141144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17377v1 | A Three-Pronged Approach to Cross-Lingual Adaptation with Multilingual LLMs | 2024-06-25T08:53:46 | 2024-06-25T08:53:46 | Vaibhav Singh, Amrith Krishna, Karthika NJ, Ganesh Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-resource languages, by its very definition, tend to be under represented
in the pre-training corpora of Large Language Models. In this work, we
investigate three low-resource cross-lingual approaches that enable an LLM
adapt to tasks in previously unseen languages. Llama-2 is an LLM where Indic
languages, among many other language families, contribute to less than
$0.005\%$ of the total $2$ trillion token pre-training corpora. In this work,
we experiment with the English-dominated Llama-2 for cross-lingual transfer to
three Indic languages, Bengali, Hindi, and Tamil as target languages. We study
three approaches for cross-lingual transfer, under ICL and fine-tuning. One, we
find that adding additional supervisory signals via a dominant language in the
LLM, leads to improvements, both under in-context learning and fine-tuning.
Two, adapting the target languages to word reordering may be beneficial under
ICL, but its impact diminishes with fine tuning. Finally, continued
pre-training in one low-resource language can improve model performance for
other related low-resource languages. | [
-0.25367841124534607,
-0.3369271159172058,
0.1889188438653946,
0.5293280482292175,
-0.3906203806400299,
0.5343950390815735,
-0.530218780040741,
-0.677016019821167,
0.1336626410484314,
0.4605657458305359,
-0.43398165702819824,
-0.07637865841388702,
-0.5891413688659668,
0.315216600894928,
0.13494521379470825,
1.0335561037063599,
-0.4418257176876068,
0.06512336432933807,
0.29247188568115234,
-0.35652464628219604,
-0.7061879634857178,
-0.3694482743740082,
-0.5816515684127808,
-0.33532974123954773,
0.6320171356201172,
0.824695348739624,
0.5486913919448853,
0.2841203510761261,
0.34470847249031067,
0.12788860499858856,
0.16178302466869354,
0.26829075813293457,
-0.6865139603614807,
-0.42624443769454956,
-0.476880818605423,
-0.9287371635437012,
-0.4522879719734192,
-0.09533290565013885,
0.7098485827445984,
0.6988762021064758,
0.07584494352340698,
0.27134108543395996,
0.37717461585998535,
0.5150935053825378,
-0.8284714818000793,
0.07060449570417404,
-0.8825411200523376,
0.2249254584312439,
-0.3365117311477661,
-0.3913153409957886,
-0.38744449615478516,
0.05833948403596878,
-0.13589170575141907,
-0.9183889031410217,
-0.32700973749160767,
0.36751142144203186,
0.4652857482433319,
0.3460333049297333,
-0.30976641178131104,
-0.3872436583042145,
-0.6525291800498962,
1.0237940549850464,
-0.5624309778213501,
0.4564191699028015,
0.5116953253746033,
-0.016102664172649384,
0.10367950797080994,
-0.24495723843574524,
-0.38077905774116516,
-0.06183326989412308,
-0.28479963541030884,
0.15819229185581207,
-0.29776033759117126,
-0.2375800758600235,
-0.04604874923825264,
0.051058415323495865,
-0.30407145619392395,
0.7916948795318604,
-0.34394577145576477,
-0.16136549413204193,
0.3869132101535797,
0.05613451078534126,
0.23822125792503357,
0.10383406281471252,
-0.6791922450065613,
-0.1649572104215622,
-1.122494101524353,
0.045339129865169525,
0.2925484776496887,
0.6057312488555908,
-0.5577031970024109,
0.4172613322734833,
0.1867278665304184,
0.5378777384757996,
0.13597926497459412,
-0.43156489729881287,
0.06160735338926315,
-0.75944983959198,
-0.16970384120941162,
0.3461607098579407,
0.4104500710964203,
0.21545402705669403,
0.5024490356445312,
-0.171378031373024,
-0.03148326650261879,
-0.1366369128227234,
-0.15012167394161224,
-0.538399338722229,
0.18492312729358673,
-0.3212977945804596,
-0.40020397305488586,
0.18567731976509094,
-0.6561555862426758,
-0.6524593234062195,
-0.40487048029899597,
-0.49860459566116333,
0.4251922369003296,
-0.33233919739723206,
-0.417335569858551,
0.02371937595307827,
0.2570714056491852,
0.4522940516471863,
0.3692314624786377,
-1.2167414426803589,
0.44447585940361023,
0.5048765540122986,
0.9746200442314148,
-0.4731146991252899,
-0.6395518183708191,
-0.6618668437004089,
0.5289788842201233,
-0.5988810062408447,
0.72081458568573,
-0.4554689824581146,
-0.3813919723033905,
-0.028118714690208435,
0.14199209213256836,
-0.35032206773757935,
-0.6282286047935486,
0.19898036122322083,
-0.5060487389564514,
0.11318108439445496,
-0.3709700405597687,
0.12498723715543747,
-0.19447728991508484,
0.22797521948814392,
-0.4846058785915375,
0.9831230640411377,
0.2576676905155182,
-0.6543855667114258,
0.3726818263530731,
-0.6696483492851257,
-0.7334418892860413,
-0.14222250878810883,
0.13336776196956635,
0.17030645906925201,
0.09858482331037521,
0.18607255816459656,
0.3486233949661255,
-0.5652685761451721,
-0.3666849732398987,
-0.19972659647464752,
-0.5537735223770142,
0.07039232552051544,
-0.3136628270149231,
0.9295998811721802,
0.12753456830978394,
-0.25747543573379517,
-0.07595627009868622,
-0.7255734801292419,
-0.09099192917346954,
-0.0076223560608923435,
-0.6095897555351257,
-0.5537205934524536,
-0.38611501455307007,
0.17615842819213867,
0.17880304157733917,
0.31020572781562805,
-0.24658727645874023,
0.12883742153644562,
-0.30562901496887207,
0.23593410849571228,
0.7866171002388,
-0.2996829152107239,
0.7417830228805542,
-0.19331705570220947,
0.7797248959541321,
0.2595195174217224,
0.005171401426196098,
0.20216155052185059,
-0.020806293934583664,
-1.1850155591964722,
-0.3171433210372925,
0.23127250373363495,
0.9356374740600586,
-1.1173391342163086,
-0.2446800172328949,
-0.14448007941246033,
-0.25181248784065247,
-0.8356301188468933,
0.6888725757598877,
0.5099012851715088,
0.30005818605422974,
0.4761653244495392,
-0.4396773874759674,
-0.5298627614974976,
-0.9232088923454285,
-0.31138062477111816,
-0.3746166527271271,
0.08857233077287674,
0.07344039529561996,
0.2687147557735443,
-0.21481941640377045,
0.4331929087638855,
0.051550041884183884,
-0.4325934052467346,
-0.4441887140274048,
0.00891133677214384,
0.1922975331544876,
0.30174803733825684,
0.7976568341255188,
-0.4263335168361664,
-0.6740255355834961,
0.49186375737190247,
-0.44924837350845337,
-0.2855236828327179,
-0.2927050292491913,
-0.24537134170532227,
0.587070882320404,
0.5716089010238647,
-0.18424497544765472,
0.08637525141239166,
0.9207028746604919,
0.0007421349291689694,
0.3091229796409607,
-0.3187342584133148,
-0.18826648592948914,
-1.0431039333343506,
-0.2210996448993683,
-0.2779339849948883,
-0.10796666890382767,
-0.6588361263275146,
-0.17530570924282074,
0.050189316272735596,
0.20803675055503845,
-0.6629050374031067,
0.8417585492134094,
-0.7929350733757019,
-0.5759023427963257,
-0.3665069341659546,
0.1125006452202797,
-0.2138846516609192,
0.734427809715271,
0.1296415776014328,
0.9521812200546265,
0.5534641742706299,
-0.587498664855957,
-0.020150763913989067,
0.06716498732566833,
-0.3129219710826874,
0.763151228427887,
-0.2869253158569336,
0.16088558733463287,
-0.018906518816947937,
0.04890413209795952,
-0.749934732913971,
0.16833315789699554,
0.5507664680480957,
0.1120726615190506,
0.46935930848121643,
-0.15979419648647308,
-0.47880035638809204,
0.2606145441532135,
-0.2668256461620331,
0.6144676208496094,
0.1240130066871643,
-0.6680721044540405,
0.5097184777259827,
0.2733208239078522,
-0.4904438853263855,
-0.608461320400238,
-1.0315498113632202,
0.20295068621635437,
-0.3334615230560303,
-0.152443990111351,
0.42351192235946655,
-0.12512895464897156,
-0.38398462533950806,
0.005000374745577574,
0.17215968668460846,
0.1174413338303566,
0.24267326295375824,
0.04558342695236206,
0.338094562292099,
-0.38577979803085327,
-0.1348637342453003,
0.07559961080551147,
-0.10475011169910431,
-0.20530715584754944,
-0.2200789451599121,
0.37945225834846497,
-0.3085305690765381,
-0.4740474820137024,
-0.1485634595155716,
0.29913628101348877,
0.50175940990448,
-0.26560693979263306,
0.5450361371040344,
0.9020974040031433,
-0.2633434236049652,
-0.20538641512393951,
-0.33180850744247437,
0.19915543496608734,
-0.4052707254886627,
0.5384212732315063,
-0.43004927039146423,
-0.9009783864021301,
0.48197177052497864,
-0.23275135457515717,
0.008347299881279469,
0.2107241004705429,
0.9224081039428711,
0.17621998488903046,
0.4487324655056,
1.057373285293579,
-0.3698221445083618,
0.5831234455108643,
0.001407498144544661,
0.4016645848751068,
-1.0521715879440308,
-0.17410774528980255,
-0.23715119063854218,
-0.4051457345485687,
-0.8673689961433411,
-0.674401044845581,
0.3482346832752228,
0.4026038646697998,
-0.19923515617847443,
0.5453693866729736,
0.11324195563793182,
0.24097158014774323,
0.6009638905525208,
-0.216570645570755,
0.38904282450675964,
0.2724663019180298,
-0.10626470297574997,
0.06558169424533844,
-1.0646089315414429,
-0.35861846804618835,
0.8397156596183777,
0.29698503017425537,
0.9997378587722778,
0.2999298572540283,
0.5152534246444702,
0.0129845654591918,
0.6183477640151978,
-0.6065006256103516,
0.39451080560684204,
-0.3522813320159912,
-0.33200472593307495,
-0.24035845696926117,
0.020054230466485023,
-0.7095248103141785,
0.5179520845413208,
-0.26219817996025085,
-0.6744855642318726,
0.39127835631370544,
-0.16757959127426147,
-0.3985179662704468,
0.29204973578453064,
-0.784127950668335,
0.5957581400871277,
-0.8363990187644958,
-0.6144051551818848,
-0.46136659383773804,
-0.48863276839256287,
0.40444415807724,
-0.6495062708854675,
0.6028257012367249,
-0.18619532883167267,
-0.3706878423690796,
0.6838629841804504,
0.1440717577934265,
1.1123369932174683,
0.020996784791350365,
-0.36313724517822266,
0.18178977072238922,
0.2485327124595642,
0.4769740104675293,
0.10945340991020203,
-0.09193025529384613,
0.3743305802345276,
0.02171056531369686,
-0.44049227237701416,
-0.25637853145599365,
0.5957979559898376,
-1.0696502923965454,
-0.7028771638870239,
-0.2776915431022644,
-0.9883129000663757,
-0.4363238513469696,
0.14209598302841187,
-0.06061834096908569,
-0.1156068742275238,
0.019489116966724396,
-0.07594417780637741,
0.15684418380260468,
-0.4951228201389313,
0.6797608137130737,
0.8708409070968628,
-0.062003906816244125,
-0.3164776563644409,
0.7605300545692444,
0.09398848563432693,
0.4377116560935974,
0.5110781788825989,
0.025058001279830933,
-0.17253854870796204,
-0.47924259305000305,
-0.6984089016914368,
0.3706958293914795,
-0.739101767539978,
-0.07316134124994278,
-0.27421486377716064,
0.08527211844921112,
-0.3195149004459381,
-0.3495798707008362,
-0.241653174161911,
-0.31108373403549194,
-0.6804444193840027,
0.03428932651877403,
0.40516990423202515,
0.5270688533782959,
-0.4126816391944885,
0.4246987998485565,
-0.6599807143211365,
0.31985509395599365,
0.2277717888355255,
0.2653762698173523,
-0.08381696790456772,
-0.9146620631217957,
-0.5452443957328796,
-0.05126055330038071,
0.13048945367336273,
-0.46342411637306213,
0.24964341521263123,
0.4491055905818939,
0.5912459492683411,
0.09430991858243942,
-0.1267593950033188,
1.0526654720306396,
-0.5058342814445496,
0.47853007912635803,
0.3283887803554535,
-0.8283206820487976,
0.1341252624988556,
0.06509146839380264,
0.1508229523897171,
0.5808928608894348,
0.48432961106300354,
-0.563724935054779,
-0.0493689589202404,
0.07699940353631973,
-0.6032282114028931,
0.8834002614021301,
-0.20506401360034943,
0.12122321128845215,
0.3314703106880188,
0.0752926766872406,
0.28312966227531433,
-0.08183053135871887,
-0.8870991468429565,
0.09062907844781876,
-0.20551681518554688,
0.0810774564743042,
-0.2952476441860199,
-0.2982786297798157,
-0.20537656545639038,
-0.09117378294467926,
0.5650278329849243,
-0.4680593013763428,
-0.15434443950653076,
-0.11462859064340591,
-0.5414563417434692,
-0.22402429580688477,
0.4616931974887848,
0.5326112508773804,
0.6409469246864319,
0.10778969526290894,
0.30610162019729614,
0.8375325202941895,
-0.23578684031963348,
0.26894503831863403,
0.08612003922462463,
0.09706157445907593,
-0.28596702218055725,
0.8212498426437378,
1.0135186910629272,
0.6272234916687012,
-0.5084251761436462,
0.0853218361735344,
0.2734774947166443,
0.13120785355567932,
-0.07710737735033035,
-0.06623367965221405,
0.24201084673404694,
0.4713766276836395,
0.2917240560054779,
-0.13976357877254486,
-0.42128562927246094,
-0.8749619126319885,
-0.30020710825920105,
0.3392712473869324,
-0.13537238538265228,
-0.5228741765022278,
0.49301204085350037,
0.08884898573160172,
-0.16343404352664948,
0.23813071846961975,
-0.04319547489285469,
-0.4392291307449341,
0.351488322019577,
0.9987433552742004,
0.5374212265014648,
-0.13581238687038422,
0.06088174879550934,
0.10991687327623367,
0.6245110034942627,
0.017534026876091957,
0.16952091455459595,
-0.027972441166639328,
-0.8221104741096497,
-0.5492066740989685,
-0.6639235019683838,
-0.4824029207229614,
-0.06121662259101868,
-0.552338719367981,
0.3782854974269867,
-0.4818522036075592,
0.2462974488735199,
-0.23491676151752472,
0.22705551981925964,
-0.8949707746505737,
-0.1300855427980423,
0.31787246465682983,
0.8421251773834229,
-0.9968680739402771,
0.9747703075408936,
0.7319447994232178,
-0.2914890944957733,
-0.6200399398803711,
-0.07794304192066193,
-0.10574474930763245,
-1.357506275177002,
0.9465347528457642,
-0.23388464748859406,
-0.39158833026885986,
0.05180402100086212,
-0.09072153270244598,
-1.1242529153823853,
1.1588215827941895,
0.6736120581626892,
-0.7614663243293762,
0.15389521420001984,
0.46056124567985535,
0.6009925007820129,
-0.4022444188594818,
0.026772286742925644,
0.6379086971282959,
0.5820358991622925,
-0.2857520580291748,
-1.234373927116394,
0.10502869635820389,
0.07882804423570633,
0.09984336793422699,
-0.17683792114257812,
-0.8586643934249878,
0.8888329863548279,
-0.40495890378952026,
-0.1743980348110199,
-0.05787579342722893,
0.5536879897117615,
0.3554759919643402,
0.11176767200231552,
0.7476610541343689,
0.2099863737821579,
0.6869750022888184,
0.41082870960235596,
0.8819125890731812,
-0.4489135146141052,
-0.151736781001091,
1.119796633720398,
-0.7969917058944702,
0.8814138174057007,
0.9139065146446228,
-0.21949239075183868,
0.4422335624694824,
0.7690687775611877,
0.24747583270072937,
0.6388320326805115,
0.10115813463926315,
-0.12174206227064133,
-0.19449448585510254,
-0.6902213096618652,
-0.35016578435897827,
0.7067376375198364,
0.46399277448654175,
0.11214737594127655,
-0.1986355185508728,
0.17991206049919128,
0.075653076171875,
-0.20915204286575317,
-0.6060240268707275,
0.6552188396453857,
0.3427214026451111,
-0.6698216199874878,
0.8687626719474792,
0.037766069173812866,
0.8282217383384705,
-0.4909058213233948,
0.013034981675446033,
-0.5212253928184509,
0.2838040292263031,
-0.2241104543209076,
-0.6204764246940613,
0.20928925275802612,
0.20453350245952606,
-0.08247344940900803,
-0.516022801399231,
0.8552569150924683,
-0.7105737924575806,
-0.6939367055892944,
0.83237624168396,
0.7151055932044983,
0.17609380185604095,
0.3114356994628906,
-0.4759250581264496,
0.2010209709405899,
-0.0771482065320015,
-0.05986683815717697,
0.6772899031639099,
0.5665379166603088,
-0.5368571877479553,
0.5050948858261108,
0.6536742448806763,
0.38709700107574463,
0.10229041427373886,
0.05676957219839096,
0.7878178954124451,
-0.38197994232177734,
-0.35207492113113403,
-0.6608278751373291,
-0.025850072503089905,
0.6236263513565063,
-0.28071436285972595,
0.6919465661048889,
0.3811253607273102,
1.3334580659866333,
-0.10181252658367157,
0.7040009498596191,
0.10666404664516449,
0.2202269285917282,
-0.7901872396469116,
0.41465431451797485,
-0.819617748260498,
0.20897918939590454,
-0.10528887063264847,
-0.880750298500061,
-0.1622113585472107,
0.3409363031387329,
-0.1479158252477646,
-0.31860190629959106,
0.586107611656189,
0.8606505990028381,
-0.08948198705911636,
-0.3688904643058777,
0.2554185092449188,
0.11388599872589111,
-0.07344193756580353,
0.8255600333213806,
0.8808209896087646,
-0.214122012257576,
0.7426419854164124,
-0.25565269589424133,
-0.11523845791816711,
-0.375446081161499,
-0.9898289442062378,
-0.7650116086006165,
-0.2608347535133362,
-0.0676964819431305,
0.05134639889001846,
0.08589138090610504,
0.9098174571990967,
0.6033050417900085,
-0.7845094203948975,
-0.5472612977027893,
0.43049341440200806,
0.290261447429657,
-0.2574423551559448,
-0.1031143069267273,
0.2802276015281677,
-0.33214765787124634,
-0.630024790763855,
0.721284031867981,
0.48079970479011536,
0.0383211113512516,
-0.3320271670818329,
-0.25871315598487854,
-0.32966989278793335,
-0.23297365009784698,
0.8354242444038391,
0.3859270513057709,
-0.7613311409950256,
-0.33755671977996826,
-0.012047088705003262,
-0.14738352596759796,
0.06516224145889282,
0.8205986022949219,
-0.5827972292900085,
0.04095973074436188,
0.18791499733924866,
0.8637110590934753,
0.44775450229644775,
-0.3226419687271118,
0.41846537590026855,
-0.6739870309829712,
0.6749228835105896,
-0.04291005805134773,
0.2958873510360718,
0.46530723571777344,
-0.2775452435016632,
0.6371928453445435,
0.16339479386806488,
0.03041275404393673,
-0.8022089600563049,
0.14745855331420898,
-0.8640851974487305,
-0.294721394777298,
1.339231014251709,
-0.0587417297065258,
-0.1651497483253479,
-0.10275580734014511,
-0.13581770658493042,
0.380353718996048,
0.1484726071357727,
0.4677264988422394,
0.6921653747558594,
-0.0963204950094223,
-0.23590338230133057,
-0.6365410685539246,
0.2613488435745239,
0.6939325332641602,
-0.8577932119369507,
0.08358197659254074,
0.0257756095379591,
0.30386802554130554,
0.14102891087532043,
0.7253141403198242,
0.02172437310218811,
0.146206796169281,
-0.20987766981124878,
-0.005901019088923931,
0.06648971140384674,
-0.4196449816226959,
-0.48868098855018616,
-0.21985438466072083,
0.3115711510181427,
-0.1776304543018341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17375v1 | An Empirical Study on the Characteristics of Bias upon Context Length Variation for Bangla | 2024-06-25T08:49:11 | 2024-06-25T08:49:11 | Jayanta Sadhu, Ayan Antik Khan, Abhik Bhattacharjee, Rifat Shahriyar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models inherently exhibit various social biases,
prompting a crucial examination of their social impact across various
linguistic contexts due to their widespread usage. Previous studies have
provided numerous methods for intrinsic bias measurements, predominantly
focused on high-resource languages. In this work, we aim to extend these
investigations to Bangla, a low-resource language. Specifically, in this study,
we (1) create a dataset for intrinsic gender bias measurement in Bangla, (2)
discuss necessary adaptations to apply existing bias measurement methods for
Bangla, and (3) examine the impact of context length variation on bias
measurement, a factor that has been overlooked in previous studies. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate a clear dependency of bias metrics on context
length, highlighting the need for nuanced considerations in Bangla bias
analysis. We consider our work as a stepping stone for bias measurement in the
Bangla Language and make all of our resources publicly available to support
future research. | [
-0.3282510042190552,
-0.8651454448699951,
0.3359961211681366,
0.6147141456604004,
-0.10354115068912506,
-0.12344114482402802,
-0.3065735399723053,
-0.4738914966583252,
0.06475608050823212,
0.17446263134479523,
-0.5294029712677002,
0.048153072595596313,
-0.6962636709213257,
0.13227227330207825,
-0.17603564262390137,
1.010858416557312,
-0.035040613263845444,
0.20122355222702026,
0.11353696137666702,
-0.254795104265213,
-0.9604206085205078,
-0.23062708973884583,
0.17678773403167725,
-0.3520796000957489,
0.49997860193252563,
0.2865832448005676,
0.4502969980239868,
0.3774663507938385,
0.1840224713087082,
0.11605549603700638,
-0.40296074748039246,
-0.09339680522680283,
-0.6216861009597778,
-0.06675418466329575,
-0.46206972002983093,
-0.4410950243473053,
-0.25089821219444275,
0.14744596183300018,
0.9725515842437744,
1.082053780555725,
0.1900358498096466,
0.519950807094574,
0.1595238894224167,
0.967062771320343,
-1.1475590467453003,
-0.01734008640050888,
-0.4795595109462738,
-0.05158485472202301,
-0.577360212802887,
-0.14984013140201569,
-0.16262885928153992,
-0.5936263799667358,
0.4142022132873535,
-0.014831497333943844,
0.1537640541791916,
-0.05399977043271065,
0.8104819059371948,
0.25108909606933594,
-0.6483261585235596,
-0.3310236930847168,
-0.6573274731636047,
1.0306246280670166,
-0.6683566570281982,
0.44243523478507996,
0.5299863219261169,
0.312457799911499,
0.19995778799057007,
0.03176990523934364,
-0.31813156604766846,
-0.08233825117349625,
-0.17177307605743408,
-0.32463338971138,
0.342924565076828,
-0.37513279914855957,
0.38208600878715515,
0.36066198348999023,
-0.00722935376688838,
-0.2127213031053543,
-0.649174690246582,
0.09755801409482956,
0.5955087542533875,
0.09595413506031036,
0.3086593449115753,
-0.33104410767555237,
0.09100853651762009,
0.16929861903190613,
-1.2019591331481934,
0.19472265243530273,
0.9661669731140137,
0.4987284243106842,
-0.5051288604736328,
0.375582218170166,
-0.3353675305843353,
0.8669179081916809,
0.05784445255994797,
-0.1298760026693344,
0.2017858773469925,
-0.7264177799224854,
-0.006042017135769129,
0.34535571932792664,
0.3625825047492981,
0.007077401503920555,
0.05049022287130356,
0.07840410619974136,
0.10301902890205383,
-0.18733511865139008,
0.12283693999052048,
-0.9279489517211914,
0.19334273040294647,
-0.29520487785339355,
-0.4517867863178253,
0.02391054295003414,
-0.15323950350284576,
-0.8480290174484253,
-0.506106436252594,
-0.13658852875232697,
0.13543367385864258,
-0.2402331829071045,
-0.3335055410861969,
-0.13154812157154083,
0.023304380476474762,
0.47724032402038574,
0.1656097173690796,
-0.9953639507293701,
-0.03855043649673462,
0.33782681822776794,
0.8710601329803467,
-0.019824715331196785,
-0.17703460156917572,
-0.2188083380460739,
-0.06135125085711479,
-0.5435609221458435,
0.46149376034736633,
-0.85450679063797,
-0.6534423232078552,
0.01128409057855606,
-0.1620102971792221,
0.04895869642496109,
-0.2802475392818451,
0.5074958801269531,
-0.21334876120090485,
0.05436653271317482,
-0.739555299282074,
-0.23723268508911133,
-0.1487567275762558,
-0.17011500895023346,
-0.31823641061782837,
0.6715112924575806,
0.2537824213504791,
-1.1861809492111206,
0.943168044090271,
-0.5807444453239441,
-0.5812693238258362,
-0.015095970593392849,
-0.48380395770072937,
-0.17955222725868225,
0.2860994040966034,
0.1094091609120369,
0.08462563902139664,
-0.41636741161346436,
0.280020534992218,
-0.32659900188446045,
-0.7498541474342346,
0.3572928309440613,
-0.5491420030593872,
0.9311833381652832,
0.11815746128559113,
-0.6553294658660889,
0.01208936795592308,
-0.7002437114715576,
-0.1559908241033554,
-0.013778417371213436,
-0.30696722865104675,
-0.6117846369743347,
0.023450132459402084,
0.15560351312160492,
0.0616251640021801,
0.3642190098762512,
-0.591789960861206,
0.07175260782241821,
-0.3949911594390869,
0.09580803662538528,
0.9516173005104065,
-0.2561551034450531,
0.6054570078849792,
-0.0015039152931421995,
0.417218416929245,
-0.2145088165998459,
0.09799698740243912,
-0.03778810799121857,
-0.15888731181621552,
-0.4709542393684387,
-0.32140761613845825,
0.5182943940162659,
-0.022204525768756866,
-0.1317107230424881,
0.3530745208263397,
-0.20390287041664124,
-0.3154117166996002,
-0.7948625683784485,
0.20884288847446442,
0.5906774401664734,
0.31803810596466064,
-0.06014115363359451,
-0.3902718424797058,
-0.5763055682182312,
-1.2817554473876953,
-0.37306979298591614,
-0.10190515220165253,
0.09509649872779846,
0.6846550107002258,
0.5658245086669922,
-0.5429706573486328,
1.5080054998397827,
-0.4070085287094116,
-0.031545430421829224,
-0.23348428308963776,
0.0724293440580368,
0.3394277095794678,
0.37298092246055603,
0.7388840913772583,
-0.5468803644180298,
-0.43220075964927673,
-0.007533689960837364,
-0.6374281048774719,
-0.7271787524223328,
0.3123242259025574,
-0.36922499537467957,
0.13710521161556244,
0.0040558744221925735,
-0.014294561930000782,
0.7954372763633728,
0.6214344501495361,
-0.6232969164848328,
0.8100613951683044,
0.19135361909866333,
0.17062096297740936,
-0.6249182224273682,
0.08132396638393402,
-0.09870835393667221,
0.06486430764198303,
-0.4641191065311432,
-0.23665361106395721,
0.0011022049002349377,
0.4404808282852173,
-0.5768901705741882,
0.8807111382484436,
-0.5082865953445435,
-0.43622809648513794,
-0.47423142194747925,
-0.25404593348503113,
-0.21042770147323608,
0.10452127456665039,
0.06908101588487625,
1.0467455387115479,
0.278770387172699,
-0.646469235420227,
-0.31609541177749634,
0.23874741792678833,
-0.5865345597267151,
0.7030013203620911,
-0.8151890635490417,
0.09315663576126099,
-0.1145525723695755,
0.29406702518463135,
-0.7417768836021423,
-0.4035547971725464,
0.19922347366809845,
-0.2266390472650528,
0.21327729523181915,
-0.3495815694332123,
-0.16378459334373474,
-0.0185173861682415,
-0.16958561539649963,
0.7779103517532349,
0.40966829657554626,
-0.3429974317550659,
0.09072273969650269,
0.5172587633132935,
-0.06748426705598831,
-0.9183362722396851,
-0.6029725670814514,
-0.36900633573532104,
-0.3842312693595886,
-0.5537082552909851,
0.04569433629512787,
-0.24241846799850464,
-0.4534938931465149,
-0.3631082773208618,
-0.1621161252260208,
-0.17908139526844025,
0.08050719648599625,
0.523285984992981,
-0.05724624916911125,
-0.07939580827951431,
-0.1755882352590561,
0.3871884346008301,
0.48869559168815613,
0.09897155314683914,
0.1443682163953781,
0.7655467391014099,
-0.3949222266674042,
-0.29410481452941895,
-0.18556100130081177,
0.16507308185100555,
0.30874788761138916,
0.1674458086490631,
0.9097281098365784,
0.5792768001556396,
-0.2860729396343231,
0.019107678905129433,
-0.6356746554374695,
-0.17671442031860352,
-0.43835872411727905,
0.3650248348712921,
-0.17827729880809784,
-0.9411240220069885,
0.6561470031738281,
0.16780897974967957,
-0.321532666683197,
-0.0399918295443058,
0.774452269077301,
0.26960980892181396,
0.6871436238288879,
0.817428708076477,
0.011226218193769455,
0.5755538940429688,
0.19456517696380615,
0.31051740050315857,
-1.2517952919006348,
0.06255635619163513,
-0.45080476999282837,
-0.20474320650100708,
-0.6667987704277039,
-0.07034952938556671,
0.14130648970603943,
0.07453151792287827,
-0.4376645088195801,
-0.1350618451833725,
-0.05848710983991623,
0.490882933139801,
0.38754650950431824,
0.15421202778816223,
-0.21030297875404358,
-0.3327582776546478,
0.2587624788284302,
-0.3181779086589813,
-0.5007624626159668,
-0.637438952922821,
1.2046490907669067,
0.39274081587791443,
0.773210346698761,
0.10689396411180496,
0.45307475328445435,
0.4434262216091156,
0.19521769881248474,
-0.17000792920589447,
0.30054113268852234,
0.46866777539253235,
-1.1840312480926514,
-0.5213744044303894,
-0.41235339641571045,
-0.8663764595985413,
0.26256415247917175,
0.14731968939304352,
-0.7064960598945618,
0.41249802708625793,
0.23370911180973053,
-0.09925627708435059,
-0.049752652645111084,
-0.6816439628601074,
0.7397295236587524,
-0.1939036101102829,
-0.8981446027755737,
0.13933750987052917,
-0.6731582283973694,
0.6340708136558533,
-0.31549543142318726,
0.20037448406219482,
-0.37090474367141724,
0.3589969873428345,
0.8757674694061279,
-0.36014601588249207,
0.9739367365837097,
-0.27630043029785156,
-0.30034568905830383,
0.22624774277210236,
-0.06253770738840103,
0.08474799990653992,
0.2603236138820648,
0.01672709919512272,
0.4606473445892334,
-0.12762731313705444,
-0.9104712009429932,
-0.15408171713352203,
0.5488182902336121,
-0.8149449229240417,
-0.3907336890697479,
-0.48562654852867126,
-0.7907202243804932,
-0.32569223642349243,
0.23328255116939545,
0.26003602147102356,
0.13559666275978088,
-0.30510979890823364,
0.34190723299980164,
0.38986968994140625,
-0.6168323755264282,
0.4833354949951172,
0.5590828061103821,
-0.2766377329826355,
0.3838181793689728,
0.445882111787796,
0.45172953605651855,
0.18775726854801178,
0.0215691477060318,
0.5364996194839478,
-0.270353227853775,
-0.10297266393899918,
-0.4270428419113159,
0.07409075647592545,
-0.5107468366622925,
0.2467954009771347,
-0.5613664984703064,
0.018499501049518585,
-0.6226271390914917,
-0.39310386776924133,
-0.5755574107170105,
-0.11171284317970276,
0.16410791873931885,
-0.09395519644021988,
0.17542003095149994,
0.8619706630706787,
-0.05656395107507706,
0.5611799955368042,
-0.2799563407897949,
-0.07060105353593826,
0.4699958264827728,
0.30483919382095337,
0.18453827500343323,
-0.8206971287727356,
-0.3355799913406372,
0.1735127568244934,
-0.09352883696556091,
-1.004551649093628,
0.38146060705184937,
0.039213184267282486,
0.3495177626609802,
0.47366389632225037,
-0.027117736637592316,
0.336056113243103,
-0.5173649191856384,
0.9110803604125977,
0.03842737525701523,
-1.1643586158752441,
0.8815138339996338,
-0.6890785098075867,
0.40263837575912476,
0.6682646870613098,
0.2585494816303253,
-0.23313024640083313,
-0.04811704531311989,
-0.3003700077533722,
-0.953201174736023,
0.7289068698883057,
0.4106535017490387,
0.24810194969177246,
-0.024921374395489693,
0.17250551283359528,
0.5224357843399048,
0.47243884205818176,
-0.7730557322502136,
-0.48172637820243835,
-0.16492867469787598,
0.23942309617996216,
0.1776314079761505,
-0.6516477465629578,
-0.04882560670375824,
-0.3559610843658447,
0.5450783371925354,
0.026437120512127876,
0.27296069264411926,
-0.09639476984739304,
-0.4939471483230591,
0.12825964391231537,
0.6425006985664368,
0.7630452513694763,
1.3839157819747925,
-0.5901203155517578,
0.0017021337989717722,
0.31089022755622864,
-0.7015669345855713,
0.34662678837776184,
-0.22667618095874786,
-0.5425524115562439,
0.055153463035821915,
0.3004131317138672,
0.8870710134506226,
0.04130656644701958,
-0.6686346530914307,
0.48235073685646057,
0.12727762758731842,
0.39945927262306213,
-0.1705939918756485,
-0.1704445779323578,
-0.17027994990348816,
-0.0077448682859539986,
0.4709855914115906,
-0.14959223568439484,
0.24803197383880615,
-0.576767086982727,
-0.021744750440120697,
0.1612294614315033,
-0.7592322826385498,
-0.4968899190425873,
0.3149620592594147,
0.3031216561794281,
-0.04744207113981247,
0.17987188696861267,
-0.44401904940605164,
-0.4462147355079651,
0.4221265912055969,
0.620992124080658,
0.6468930244445801,
-0.4529950022697449,
0.14835843443870544,
0.29887062311172485,
0.5451613068580627,
0.1677035242319107,
0.14020264148712158,
-0.05701003223657608,
-0.6004323959350586,
-0.41631171107292175,
-0.8755459189414978,
-0.18597258627414703,
-0.09330151975154877,
-0.6109009981155396,
0.09853222221136093,
-0.35480019450187683,
-0.15666046738624573,
-0.35176053643226624,
-0.0800754576921463,
-0.7453653812408447,
0.18436753749847412,
-0.08790896087884903,
0.25286608934402466,
-0.9795743227005005,
0.514350414276123,
0.5464869737625122,
-0.3753921091556549,
-0.4161766469478607,
0.0725574642419815,
-0.02615908905863762,
-0.7153136134147644,
1.2909010648727417,
0.38312771916389465,
-0.20511901378631592,
-0.6345875263214111,
-0.4802806079387665,
-0.834360659122467,
0.5879241228103638,
0.4148964285850525,
-0.4309805929660797,
0.19570642709732056,
0.2175426036119461,
0.4224770963191986,
-0.2799230217933655,
0.5716812014579773,
0.8886150121688843,
0.5119653344154358,
-0.45231521129608154,
-0.9392510056495667,
-0.0009106199722737074,
-0.2036382108926773,
0.23992948234081268,
-0.059928081929683685,
-0.6462488174438477,
0.9118938446044922,
0.06657072901725769,
-0.0513172522187233,
-0.49077001214027405,
0.6944286227226257,
0.2968480587005615,
0.45427584648132324,
0.3008541762828827,
0.07990337908267975,
0.631660521030426,
-0.032789185643196106,
1.0770695209503174,
-0.3447844982147217,
0.14552877843379974,
1.161780595779419,
-0.6894107460975647,
0.23084351420402527,
0.4770229458808899,
-0.4225119650363922,
0.43683791160583496,
0.6548753976821899,
0.6296908855438232,
0.45611119270324707,
0.48642614483833313,
-0.23505546152591705,
0.1190004050731659,
-0.6768066883087158,
-0.8099247217178345,
0.36722245812416077,
0.27992191910743713,
-0.236301451921463,
0.29780712723731995,
-0.05635442957282066,
0.30708402395248413,
0.09345540404319763,
-0.3257215619087219,
0.21148869395256042,
0.07909426838159561,
-0.37896010279655457,
0.4204576909542084,
-0.18290750682353973,
1.1443519592285156,
-0.6058129072189331,
0.2602195739746094,
-0.4617244005203247,
0.0634005069732666,
-0.18449272215366364,
-0.4322807490825653,
0.39258304238319397,
0.1285995990037918,
-0.43289557099342346,
0.11044561117887497,
0.6191505789756775,
-0.22717814147472382,
-0.44893139600753784,
0.25543349981307983,
0.4987516701221466,
-0.018537171185016632,
0.03999059647321701,
-0.14927975833415985,
0.3867919445037842,
-0.050739835947752,
-0.012818939983844757,
0.4984572231769562,
0.28840380907058716,
-0.14836673438549042,
0.4817214906215668,
0.37010589241981506,
0.29127371311187744,
0.5736286640167236,
0.028302408754825592,
0.41933682560920715,
-0.5565506815910339,
-0.6623703837394714,
-0.9288575053215027,
0.0590067133307457,
-0.2336735725402832,
-0.5431739687919617,
1.0377358198165894,
0.41455212235450745,
0.908377468585968,
-0.08934271335601807,
0.9519006013870239,
-0.17385056614875793,
0.4805348217487335,
-0.36614611744880676,
0.8734763860702515,
-0.42839014530181885,
0.20620661973953247,
-0.8255248069763184,
-1.3212151527404785,
0.28681203722953796,
0.9153838157653809,
-0.7034429907798767,
0.2800861597061157,
0.5849829316139221,
0.465555340051651,
0.020937062799930573,
-0.051153916865587234,
0.09842545539140701,
0.0936918631196022,
0.16999046504497528,
0.19205912947654724,
0.9858307838439941,
-0.3569369912147522,
0.003546700347214937,
-0.03275343030691147,
-0.4481278955936432,
-0.4111086130142212,
-0.9566617012023926,
-1.0680700540542603,
-0.5009922385215759,
-0.27283912897109985,
-0.17737215757369995,
0.4390268921852112,
0.8550892472267151,
1.051222801208496,
-0.5260029435157776,
-0.5425045490264893,
0.2896111309528351,
0.41485831141471863,
0.07466460019350052,
-0.23055399954319,
0.3499414622783661,
-0.17659860849380493,
-0.6510977149009705,
0.20672865211963654,
0.19952450692653656,
-0.2692716419696808,
-0.34046027064323425,
-0.17654135823249817,
-0.4585460424423218,
0.4383394122123718,
0.6793215870857239,
0.3105615973472595,
-0.6013467907905579,
-0.4737500250339508,
-0.3013049066066742,
-0.07500376552343369,
-0.042427849024534225,
0.755614161491394,
-0.23739875853061676,
0.4428325891494751,
0.7912405133247375,
0.6499562859535217,
0.3274911344051361,
-0.09921321272850037,
0.6835151314735413,
-1.1762731075286865,
0.5003723502159119,
-0.06749136000871658,
0.4883207082748413,
0.46888110041618347,
-0.24651913344860077,
0.7683824896812439,
0.20107388496398926,
-0.5922644138336182,
-1.1392313241958618,
0.43016940355300903,
-0.7016986012458801,
-0.2774953544139862,
1.4629864692687988,
0.11127777397632599,
-0.21612244844436646,
-0.09817950427532196,
-0.36368051171302795,
0.17690208554267883,
-0.44397348165512085,
0.9693771004676819,
0.8918136954307556,
0.18035905063152313,
0.10732652246952057,
-0.5627591013908386,
0.3661161959171295,
0.4658341705799103,
-0.4794176518917084,
0.08069860190153122,
0.5372586250305176,
0.10687702149152756,
0.21526099741458893,
0.7952699065208435,
-0.07436804473400116,
0.13409878313541412,
-0.05910710617899895,
0.14186044037342072,
0.2898230254650116,
-0.16956886649131775,
-0.18320032954216003,
-0.1239590123295784,
-0.17488563060760498,
0.19789600372314453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17363v2 | Leveraging Synthetic Audio Data for End-to-End Low-Resource Speech Translation | 2024-06-25T08:26:41 | 2024-06-27T09:08:03 | Yasmin Moslem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes our system submission to the International Conference on
Spoken Language Translation (IWSLT 2024) for Irish-to-English speech
translation. We built end-to-end systems based on Whisper, and employed a
number of data augmentation techniques, such as speech back-translation and
noise augmentation. We investigate the effect of using synthetic audio data and
discuss several methods for enriching signal diversity. | [
-0.30488401651382446,
-0.4996746778488159,
0.18807196617126465,
0.3851028084754944,
-0.29666975140571594,
0.6604107618331909,
-0.12403970211744308,
-0.8938571214675903,
0.5228816270828247,
0.45949792861938477,
-0.7965093851089478,
-0.4415134787559509,
-0.5743900537490845,
0.3421913683414459,
-0.912458062171936,
0.8055652976036072,
0.21788325905799866,
0.23679476976394653,
0.18136484920978546,
-0.2989336848258972,
-0.334991991519928,
-0.5227074027061462,
-0.6001836657524109,
-0.22774623334407806,
0.1778331696987152,
0.6165028810501099,
0.5304778814315796,
0.28958413004875183,
0.38599056005477905,
0.18259528279304504,
-0.08370660245418549,
0.3347617983818054,
-0.5681832432746887,
0.04957643896341324,
-0.30484455823898315,
-0.3819279670715332,
-0.5422161817550659,
-0.0034367693588137627,
0.8096600770950317,
0.779202401638031,
0.007891546934843063,
0.37381383776664734,
-0.06281814724206924,
0.3940216898918152,
-0.31418702006340027,
0.004422416910529137,
-0.7926307320594788,
0.16042423248291016,
-0.3887960612773895,
-0.46515920758247375,
-0.39109116792678833,
0.06298161298036575,
0.14894631505012512,
-0.6442026495933533,
0.1254018098115921,
0.34691327810287476,
0.4008347690105438,
0.4559921622276306,
-0.47311368584632874,
-0.2556236684322357,
-1.0113743543624878,
0.8265751600265503,
-0.8372180461883545,
0.7479633688926697,
0.30223995447158813,
0.13035660982131958,
-0.3585985004901886,
-0.9746786952018738,
-0.7081359624862671,
0.017084287479519844,
0.11110365390777588,
0.5930140018463135,
-0.40146714448928833,
0.24945512413978577,
0.0023845508694648743,
0.4396993815898895,
-0.5359547138214111,
0.16129037737846375,
-1.0425175428390503,
-0.2973523437976837,
0.9096888899803162,
0.022489069029688835,
0.40336868166923523,
0.15957601368427277,
-0.2778763473033905,
-0.16491533815860748,
-0.6126560568809509,
-0.1011248528957367,
0.8829326033592224,
0.49961569905281067,
-0.3321935832500458,
0.7251245975494385,
-0.5551366209983826,
0.620686948299408,
-0.20568349957466125,
-0.31990179419517517,
0.43795016407966614,
-0.627946138381958,
0.18752357363700867,
0.7969968318939209,
0.6100503206253052,
0.5291735529899597,
-0.07068473845720291,
-0.23625555634498596,
-0.31963905692100525,
0.0781073048710823,
-0.07120691239833832,
-0.5587059259414673,
0.20528696477413177,
0.2385508269071579,
-0.322182297706604,
-0.2513370215892792,
-0.24739426374435425,
-0.6651350259780884,
0.4062994420528412,
-0.4370121955871582,
0.4733373820781708,
-0.289345920085907,
-0.14649005234241486,
0.286363810300827,
-0.44235336780548096,
0.28557127714157104,
0.19030626118183136,
-0.6823779344558716,
0.7158549427986145,
0.3528950810432434,
1.0031338930130005,
-0.49023693799972534,
-0.05030626058578491,
-0.7893658876419067,
0.3721763789653778,
-0.4761297106742859,
0.6455678343772888,
-0.2443404346704483,
-0.7776169180870056,
-0.14295841753482819,
-0.0796467512845993,
0.3219255805015564,
-0.7460273504257202,
1.004830241203308,
-0.09058421105146408,
0.32570940256118774,
0.1909589022397995,
-0.4273901581764221,
0.11592774093151093,
-0.26932433247566223,
-0.46957799792289734,
0.8855385184288025,
0.11926377564668655,
-0.2704117000102997,
0.06803449243307114,
-0.6412074565887451,
-0.6912063360214233,
0.05536476895213127,
0.07001638412475586,
-0.1885441690683365,
0.22148212790489197,
0.20113295316696167,
-0.03647475689649582,
-0.23459848761558533,
-0.016706574708223343,
0.10652391612529755,
-0.3505425751209259,
0.334155410528183,
-0.7805896997451782,
0.6570438146591187,
0.5908661484718323,
-0.05073247104883194,
-0.0808127224445343,
-0.9286810755729675,
-0.04302012920379639,
-0.15697693824768066,
-0.3131033778190613,
-0.01490482036024332,
-0.041825585067272186,
0.4259631335735321,
0.08881957083940506,
0.15766200423240662,
-1.0160776376724243,
-0.15643975138664246,
-0.5578013062477112,
0.7721185684204102,
0.3594297766685486,
-0.18112164735794067,
0.3703099489212036,
-0.3205438256263733,
0.5606266260147095,
-0.01564071886241436,
0.06203766539692879,
-0.25068992376327515,
-0.8890276551246643,
-0.3880150020122528,
-0.17264357209205627,
0.3269496262073517,
0.8844054937362671,
-0.45926883816719055,
0.17678822576999664,
-0.22607479989528656,
-0.2316817194223404,
-1.1256788969039917,
-0.003904038807377219,
0.11251838505268097,
0.6191023588180542,
0.6780453324317932,
-0.25105249881744385,
-0.8919414281845093,
-1.0227800607681274,
-0.08281596750020981,
-0.33566686511039734,
-0.016573572531342506,
-0.012273507192730904,
0.014782076701521873,
-0.3843283951282501,
0.8635861277580261,
-0.20430150628089905,
-0.3980373740196228,
-0.1113431379199028,
-0.0019981127697974443,
0.23112383484840393,
0.7657738327980042,
0.3401898741722107,
-0.7282397747039795,
-0.3524627089500427,
0.22904404997825623,
-0.3762645125389099,
-0.3827877342700958,
-0.03563174605369568,
-0.08174554258584976,
-0.12290643155574799,
0.6712446808815002,
-0.49261316657066345,
0.547717273235321,
0.9353997707366943,
-0.09554725140333176,
0.4767199754714966,
0.10011158883571625,
0.34061771631240845,
-1.0388598442077637,
-0.27552011609077454,
-0.3754187822341919,
-0.485615074634552,
-0.7709597945213318,
-0.06965242326259613,
-0.26291945576667786,
-0.32044029235839844,
-0.5344215035438538,
0.6875039339065552,
-0.19412612915039062,
-0.2932325601577759,
-0.15771037340164185,
0.10029053688049316,
-0.009787117131054401,
0.1217908039689064,
-0.03031027503311634,
1.3145009279251099,
0.1784866452217102,
-0.19162105023860931,
0.49571624398231506,
0.5912734866142273,
-0.20323961973190308,
0.5475040078163147,
-0.5081596970558167,
0.18639709055423737,
0.11772838234901428,
0.309723824262619,
-1.1712936162948608,
-0.35394737124443054,
-0.05797569453716278,
-0.975318968296051,
0.17478393018245697,
-0.1762523502111435,
-0.35134217143058777,
-0.1247524693608284,
-0.025548646226525307,
0.39166051149368286,
0.7889078855514526,
-0.6569823622703552,
0.11746406555175781,
0.46998798847198486,
-0.4320753514766693,
-0.14188721776008606,
-0.992629885673523,
0.6605081558227539,
-0.19201788306236267,
-0.7599322199821472,
0.8610038161277771,
-0.26472795009613037,
-0.37175196409225464,
-0.02105458825826645,
0.0031244067940860987,
-0.009024064987897873,
-0.30216217041015625,
-0.08660948276519775,
0.014451907016336918,
-0.25100255012512207,
0.0004970150766894221,
0.3907489776611328,
-0.03738095611333847,
-0.03203168883919716,
-0.8548058271408081,
0.39224565029144287,
0.15307508409023285,
-0.380612850189209,
-0.4523124396800995,
1.007557988166809,
0.4840957820415497,
0.05136457830667496,
0.35498538613319397,
0.6193453073501587,
-0.22958485782146454,
-0.2126784324645996,
-0.4692785143852234,
-0.2651067078113556,
-0.4798513650894165,
0.298359215259552,
-0.22922243177890778,
-0.8431082963943481,
0.6129311919212341,
-0.3565358817577362,
0.05083215609192848,
0.3676369786262512,
0.4106850326061249,
-0.5530948638916016,
1.3408726453781128,
0.39513227343559265,
0.1652039736509323,
0.4202018976211548,
-0.19723811745643616,
0.3361250162124634,
-0.9512767195701599,
-0.08473977446556091,
-0.35043761134147644,
-0.5357279181480408,
-0.787216305732727,
-0.29440373182296753,
0.47334468364715576,
0.07634792476892471,
0.3021467924118042,
0.3264263868331909,
-0.6868183612823486,
0.03650466725230217,
0.6529567241668701,
-0.01503690890967846,
0.5702329874038696,
0.22232475876808167,
0.17027093470096588,
-0.1796993911266327,
-0.5592725276947021,
-0.20423763990402222,
0.9056904911994934,
0.3256836235523224,
0.614910900592804,
0.12125027924776077,
0.700566828250885,
0.4467177987098694,
-0.18202923238277435,
-0.7586783170700073,
0.36087337136268616,
-0.3002403974533081,
-0.486103892326355,
-0.43109309673309326,
-0.14648661017417908,
-0.7468315362930298,
0.0929853767156601,
-0.11321534216403961,
-0.4718807339668274,
0.36427217721939087,
0.01846763864159584,
0.0722041204571724,
0.1533624231815338,
-0.7064763307571411,
0.017587866634130478,
-0.09506383538246155,
-0.055133555084466934,
-0.2449626624584198,
-0.47760945558547974,
0.17540667951107025,
-0.2113567441701889,
0.41210275888442993,
-0.0010901346104219556,
-0.1132940948009491,
0.8389844298362732,
-0.4646274149417877,
0.608085036277771,
0.10562426596879959,
-0.28017812967300415,
0.45622125267982483,
-0.22819747030735016,
0.6537001729011536,
0.0633106529712677,
-0.17196495831012726,
0.3832542598247528,
0.06714366376399994,
-0.41039353609085083,
-0.44962355494499207,
0.4583570659160614,
-0.876784086227417,
-0.5588787794113159,
-0.08630891144275665,
-0.5520094633102417,
-0.47947198152542114,
-0.09333619475364685,
0.6811911463737488,
0.5632579922676086,
-0.07662833482027054,
0.32860252261161804,
0.40700429677963257,
-0.17375390231609344,
0.3776979148387909,
0.4339185357093811,
-0.23672249913215637,
-0.7944393754005432,
1.0048530101776123,
0.49562767148017883,
0.6261650323867798,
0.15132968127727509,
0.07561961561441422,
-0.38294872641563416,
-0.9406829476356506,
-0.7157749533653259,
-0.05269825458526611,
-0.5626877546310425,
-0.09953895211219788,
-0.7764386534690857,
-0.515926718711853,
-0.6257284879684448,
-0.3538671135902405,
-0.5537644028663635,
-0.874730110168457,
-0.1948937028646469,
-0.4181458353996277,
0.5824292898178101,
0.5557276010513306,
-0.38364270329475403,
0.8313984274864197,
-0.6998487114906311,
0.3449910283088684,
0.10859261453151703,
-0.044782813638448715,
-0.6392364501953125,
-0.794463574886322,
-0.45859530568122864,
0.1926560252904892,
-0.0032073205802589655,
-0.8858744502067566,
0.8117175698280334,
0.5163331627845764,
0.6662143468856812,
-0.2247401922941208,
0.2034001499414444,
0.7845354676246643,
-0.561751663684845,
0.9247904419898987,
0.44514578580856323,
-0.8959271311759949,
0.6700096726417542,
-0.41006505489349365,
0.353346049785614,
0.30682992935180664,
-0.04574825242161751,
-0.5468983054161072,
-0.6077847480773926,
-0.4947448968887329,
-0.9481080770492554,
0.3836997151374817,
0.38895541429519653,
0.3044186234474182,
0.16585777699947357,
0.15380094945430756,
0.24317289888858795,
0.21093973517417908,
-0.1484011858701706,
-0.14512309432029724,
-0.27213403582572937,
-0.3094523251056671,
0.0004987490247003734,
0.10778956115245819,
-0.05953463166952133,
-0.3187454640865326,
0.6128960847854614,
-0.2800414264202118,
0.28159821033477783,
0.49366429448127747,
0.050576385110616684,
-0.3063722550868988,
0.35778921842575073,
0.5100396871566772,
0.23203955590724945,
-0.12809592485427856,
-0.13620759546756744,
0.6118796467781067,
-0.7747182250022888,
0.25377559661865234,
-0.01784771867096424,
-0.3670942187309265,
0.22553467750549316,
0.6983712315559387,
0.8864701390266418,
0.11263071745634079,
-0.6709730625152588,
0.2515980005264282,
0.034040264785289764,
-0.4638553857803345,
-0.4596264660358429,
-0.03658769279718399,
0.04194527119398117,
0.1622932255268097,
0.6289549469947815,
0.12143246829509735,
0.6081628203392029,
-0.7890189290046692,
0.4071819484233856,
0.24111858010292053,
-0.5496983528137207,
-0.4921233057975769,
0.7886901497840881,
0.365639865398407,
-0.4793882966041565,
0.43713152408599854,
0.12075185030698776,
-0.1597733497619629,
0.20404306054115295,
0.8633957505226135,
0.9616572260856628,
-0.36544498801231384,
-0.0845600888133049,
0.17882157862186432,
0.2662901282310486,
0.2833060920238495,
0.6088289022445679,
-0.15658679604530334,
-0.23237687349319458,
-0.9425274729728699,
-0.7890717387199402,
-0.6752535700798035,
0.08766960352659225,
-0.7347439527511597,
0.3490294814109802,
-0.03067680075764656,
-0.359482079744339,
-0.2885780334472656,
-0.24204730987548828,
-0.6330236196517944,
0.20547321438789368,
0.14513549208641052,
0.9879125356674194,
-0.6248410940170288,
0.8492856621742249,
0.3742837607860565,
-0.0653689056634903,
-0.4345666468143463,
-0.1412973254919052,
0.012702341191470623,
-0.6443706154823303,
0.6987282037734985,
-0.41760966181755066,
-0.4961480498313904,
0.40285396575927734,
-0.8450961709022522,
-1.0979511737823486,
0.849750280380249,
0.4537019431591034,
-0.776587724685669,
0.014747312292456627,
0.6499059200286865,
0.4528953433036804,
-0.24419869482517242,
-0.004770886618643999,
0.5783743262290955,
0.4840608835220337,
0.44362515211105347,
-1.35177743434906,
-0.6388210654258728,
-0.2736963629722595,
-0.29576364159584045,
-0.16442625224590302,
-0.5234923958778381,
0.718329131603241,
0.028511909767985344,
-0.23488964140415192,
0.008487213402986526,
0.8293675184249878,
0.0743277370929718,
0.2783931493759155,
0.3574153780937195,
0.31641292572021484,
0.5187997817993164,
-0.030320553109049797,
0.6222648620605469,
-0.2405821681022644,
-0.19782644510269165,
1.068730354309082,
-0.12357071787118912,
0.9109558463096619,
0.7280282378196716,
-0.28898632526397705,
0.032916635274887085,
0.4458467364311218,
0.5440968871116638,
0.6869062781333923,
0.0035061875823885202,
-0.5271464586257935,
0.02251542918384075,
-0.550385594367981,
-0.4580743908882141,
0.712440550327301,
0.8490390777587891,
0.04111955687403679,
-0.02288796752691269,
0.38872432708740234,
-0.569173276424408,
0.07431014627218246,
-0.05510687083005905,
0.9753334522247314,
0.3389568626880646,
-0.4016505777835846,
0.5814779996871948,
-0.22820226848125458,
0.8920015692710876,
-0.5720869898796082,
-0.32136619091033936,
-0.19519391655921936,
-0.1134413555264473,
-0.3592538833618164,
-1.111901044845581,
0.5611568689346313,
-0.08556850254535675,
-0.12188252061605453,
-0.35959392786026,
0.5630156397819519,
-0.6021875739097595,
-0.3799462914466858,
0.6547327637672424,
0.40631625056266785,
0.20241068303585052,
0.31373676657676697,
-0.24610154330730438,
0.37877514958381653,
0.16087767481803894,
0.035299427807331085,
0.2779978811740875,
0.32077884674072266,
-0.1856250911951065,
0.5051910877227783,
1.1179187297821045,
0.7028197646141052,
0.5317078828811646,
0.037914250046014786,
0.6552027463912964,
-0.5031780004501343,
-0.8345986008644104,
-0.4483771026134491,
0.5319482684135437,
-0.13330933451652527,
-0.2988068759441376,
0.5836904048919678,
0.7027472853660583,
1.0831607580184937,
0.20074693858623505,
1.112494707107544,
0.3390592038631439,
0.7774770259857178,
-0.5870168209075928,
0.25365006923675537,
-0.35045289993286133,
0.031380508095026016,
-0.04969099909067154,
-0.8332692384719849,
0.04296493157744408,
0.20096470415592194,
0.06566155701875687,
-0.6353027820587158,
0.19809383153915405,
0.7958343029022217,
-0.17881430685520172,
0.32737842202186584,
0.7211576700210571,
0.09774159640073776,
0.47342202067375183,
-0.0030674352310597897,
0.8886359333992004,
-0.6970342397689819,
0.6391879320144653,
-0.19562476873397827,
-0.1187266930937767,
-0.2547091245651245,
-0.5005595088005066,
-0.141013965010643,
-0.9620600938796997,
-0.2618955373764038,
-0.3022973835468292,
0.29427585005760193,
0.8902407884597778,
1.002871036529541,
-0.9252203702926636,
-0.3507213890552521,
0.11115871369838715,
-0.36755606532096863,
-0.09251052886247635,
-0.1516246348619461,
0.015104064717888832,
-0.25986072421073914,
-1.0120277404785156,
1.207524299621582,
0.515640377998352,
0.2490144670009613,
-0.3399251103401184,
-0.3535206615924835,
0.025341492146253586,
0.31732064485549927,
0.9001745581626892,
0.23711708188056946,
-0.7865695953369141,
-0.297902911901474,
0.03479798883199692,
0.24832023680210114,
0.13745024800300598,
0.4848383665084839,
-0.9011843204498291,
0.5197558999061584,
0.5517945885658264,
0.5205767154693604,
0.7287571430206299,
-0.08683981001377106,
0.8712072968482971,
-0.8894554376602173,
0.5706438422203064,
0.3802421987056732,
0.26631098985671997,
0.4317929148674011,
-0.5443034172058105,
0.6452541351318359,
0.20246292650699615,
-0.4579010605812073,
-1.063283085823059,
0.11216223984956741,
-1.078856348991394,
0.10206714272499084,
1.0161174535751343,
0.3614042103290558,
-0.028271328657865524,
-0.3558308780193329,
-0.4899347424507141,
0.42496392130851746,
-0.5594186186790466,
0.18387572467327118,
0.49410730600357056,
-0.360305517911911,
-0.1920715719461441,
-1.0817433595657349,
0.4669466018676758,
0.09312020987272263,
-0.5788642168045044,
-0.2266179472208023,
0.2345789074897766,
-0.04656825587153435,
0.2885006070137024,
0.562993049621582,
-0.21308967471122742,
0.04448230564594269,
0.15751053392887115,
-0.28342944383621216,
0.1469038724899292,
-0.06600009649991989,
-0.0561872161924839,
-0.28613895177841187,
-0.11876942217350006,
-0.36538559198379517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17328v1 | Dual-Space Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T07:25:15 | 2024-06-25T07:25:15 | Songming Zhang, Xue Zhang, Zengkui Sun, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge distillation (KD) is known as a promising solution to compress
large language models (LLMs) via transferring their knowledge to smaller
models. During this process, white-box KD methods usually minimize the distance
between the output distributions of the two models so that more knowledge can
be transferred. However, in the current white-box KD framework, the output
distributions are from the respective output spaces of the two models, using
their own prediction heads. We argue that the space discrepancy will lead to
low similarity between the teacher model and the student model on both
representation and distribution levels. Furthermore, this discrepancy also
hinders the KD process between models with different vocabularies, which is
common for current LLMs. To address these issues, we propose a dual-space
knowledge distillation (DSKD) framework that unifies the output spaces of the
two models for KD. On the basis of DSKD, we further develop a cross-model
attention mechanism, which can automatically align the representations of the
two models with different vocabularies. Thus, our framework is not only
compatible with various distance functions for KD (e.g., KL divergence) like
the current framework, but also supports KD between any two LLMs regardless of
their vocabularies. Experiments on task-agnostic instruction-following
benchmarks show that DSKD significantly outperforms the current white-box KD
framework with various distance functions, and also surpasses existing KD
methods for LLMs with different vocabularies. | [
-0.4094465672969818,
-0.6288223266601562,
0.8842263221740723,
-0.038289207965135574,
-0.29953062534332275,
0.28568193316459656,
-0.46920448541641235,
-0.1387539505958557,
-0.0626479834318161,
0.2667279541492462,
-0.49304041266441345,
-0.556066632270813,
-0.8903969526290894,
-0.38388967514038086,
-0.2961044907569885,
0.7249740958213806,
-0.11465510725975037,
0.04114992544054985,
-0.6660031080245972,
-0.1402435153722763,
-0.5743017792701721,
-0.5237137079238892,
-0.33826744556427,
-0.47174450755119324,
0.483690470457077,
0.28622788190841675,
0.5502660274505615,
0.4278270900249481,
0.3549728989601135,
0.24414703249931335,
-0.20701850950717926,
0.010138582438230515,
-0.37262049317359924,
0.2313879281282425,
-0.2804306149482727,
-0.376526415348053,
0.07538940012454987,
-0.24616558849811554,
0.496808260679245,
0.9522018432617188,
-0.22575202584266663,
0.0847877487540245,
0.4642643630504608,
0.8973388671875,
-0.7711763381958008,
0.22060483694076538,
-0.3052617907524109,
0.23223595321178436,
0.022310925647616386,
0.16310662031173706,
-0.213095024228096,
-0.23799623548984528,
0.3205493092536926,
-0.47869667410850525,
0.13847464323043823,
-0.38325297832489014,
0.5142859816551208,
0.6493391394615173,
-0.6825041174888611,
-0.3484763503074646,
-1.0154027938842773,
0.6501303911209106,
-0.6859003305435181,
0.660408079624176,
0.11774680763483047,
0.6225651502609253,
0.034700118005275726,
-0.5209489464759827,
-0.7210079431533813,
-0.08242131024599075,
-0.13017073273658752,
-0.0481758788228035,
-0.06751424819231033,
-0.08870911598205566,
0.2948703467845917,
0.28931236267089844,
-0.34691429138183594,
0.1967242956161499,
-0.55405592918396,
0.07313688099384308,
0.3863210678100586,
-0.07927227020263672,
0.07048258930444717,
0.11423990875482559,
-0.49649709463119507,
-0.4330886900424957,
-0.6730624437332153,
0.0010608234442770481,
0.27614399790763855,
0.18729224801063538,
-0.05717657133936882,
0.3888660967350006,
-0.3325050473213196,
0.4877499043941498,
0.2194630652666092,
-0.3011189103126526,
0.10467585921287537,
-0.19763562083244324,
-0.1677306443452835,
0.05858631804585457,
0.6799766421318054,
0.5108966827392578,
0.17058776319026947,
-0.2213393598794937,
0.13449470698833466,
0.3157496154308319,
0.11386051774024963,
-0.7330623865127563,
-0.5515672564506531,
-0.006824093870818615,
-0.3024507761001587,
-0.22728227078914642,
-0.16705402731895447,
-0.8317786455154419,
-0.5026094317436218,
-0.526465117931366,
0.34574994444847107,
-0.230755016207695,
-0.46378445625305176,
0.11430477350950241,
-0.05406501144170761,
-0.3124748468399048,
0.1654811054468155,
-0.9151458144187927,
0.4214307367801666,
0.5168664455413818,
0.7324734330177307,
-0.3249572217464447,
-0.20016029477119446,
-0.18007026612758636,
0.28588518500328064,
-0.0824635699391365,
0.5829454064369202,
-0.5303409099578857,
-0.3142365515232086,
-0.09564559161663055,
-0.24615271389484406,
0.14455313980579376,
-0.645378828048706,
0.09692133963108063,
-0.5772587060928345,
-0.016665799543261528,
-0.481536328792572,
-0.6420100927352905,
-0.26673558354377747,
0.09246262162923813,
-0.5881322622299194,
1.1667829751968384,
0.15915898978710175,
-0.7103986144065857,
0.59454745054245,
-0.5494386553764343,
-0.3680088222026825,
-0.038340210914611816,
-0.31910422444343567,
-0.2166614830493927,
0.09954313933849335,
0.22621497511863708,
0.5709996819496155,
-0.24527113139629364,
0.34179994463920593,
-0.7061813473701477,
-0.0554373525083065,
0.01936429552733898,
-0.351947158575058,
0.674010694026947,
0.23277123272418976,
-0.18135592341423035,
-0.3419870436191559,
-0.6767758131027222,
0.01562108937650919,
0.04637400060892105,
-0.34375858306884766,
-0.9084993004798889,
-0.07482206076383591,
-0.1850186139345169,
0.46659964323043823,
0.37445351481437683,
-0.38057446479797363,
0.36891859769821167,
-0.21295307576656342,
0.3228852450847626,
0.720543622970581,
-0.011566950008273125,
0.7572540044784546,
-0.008767100982367992,
0.5327608585357666,
0.4416762590408325,
-0.27134764194488525,
0.17263488471508026,
-0.16059954464435577,
-0.42806434631347656,
-0.2236892580986023,
0.2126908153295517,
0.2399141639471054,
-0.7643402218818665,
0.38983649015426636,
-0.32603919506073,
-0.4948946535587311,
-0.5347148776054382,
0.32709380984306335,
0.4035849869251251,
0.43216973543167114,
0.23335975408554077,
0.028240477666258812,
-0.33971548080444336,
-0.8592559695243835,
-0.07327651977539062,
-0.10514543205499649,
0.10448211431503296,
0.2057676464319229,
0.3323722183704376,
-0.07942802459001541,
0.8796738982200623,
-0.9346952438354492,
-0.3732781410217285,
-0.05441731587052345,
-0.1937195360660553,
0.05757954716682434,
0.2594791352748871,
0.7251140475273132,
-0.8625759482383728,
-1.0110268592834473,
0.1933937668800354,
-0.47139063477516174,
-0.3075520992279053,
0.28643786907196045,
-0.2534027397632599,
0.1819021850824356,
0.6788643002510071,
-0.7031815052032471,
0.3629343509674072,
0.5616057515144348,
-0.37576720118522644,
0.4630680978298187,
-0.18497514724731445,
0.2308981567621231,
-1.4352738857269287,
-0.03495652973651886,
-0.04901989921927452,
-0.15456271171569824,
-0.44250723719596863,
0.06305203586816788,
0.18968036770820618,
0.11179041117429733,
-0.2617103159427643,
0.6128758192062378,
-0.36239251494407654,
-0.16269175708293915,
-0.3825173079967499,
0.3223874568939209,
0.07062217593193054,
0.5811349153518677,
0.254825234413147,
0.3982555568218231,
0.6196456551551819,
-0.6102116703987122,
0.6242084503173828,
0.035657864063978195,
-0.4480263590812683,
0.6540963649749756,
-0.44330644607543945,
0.01598147675395012,
-0.07304501533508301,
0.196699321269989,
-1.3459223508834839,
0.09192420542240143,
0.05629469081759453,
-0.22026211023330688,
0.3481460511684418,
-0.19468362629413605,
-0.4905543029308319,
-0.5605322122573853,
-0.12155835330486298,
0.5821967124938965,
0.8143973350524902,
-0.703838586807251,
0.20503918826580048,
0.3389948308467865,
-0.33749088644981384,
-0.705221951007843,
-0.7286927103996277,
-0.27776432037353516,
-0.3799518942832947,
-0.6099560260772705,
0.23799538612365723,
-0.2281392216682434,
-0.21202626824378967,
0.39687538146972656,
-0.36805859208106995,
-0.12379381060600281,
-0.06911591440439224,
0.1404721885919571,
0.2144681066274643,
-0.21888534724712372,
0.32155171036720276,
0.39835017919540405,
0.11979483813047409,
0.0017075841315090656,
-0.5550078749656677,
0.47545644640922546,
0.48693281412124634,
-0.5282476544380188,
-0.24506811797618866,
0.36940816044807434,
0.815852701663971,
0.1258695423603058,
0.8735556602478027,
0.4798016846179962,
-0.3655053973197937,
-0.5261821746826172,
-0.5665709376335144,
-0.2827099859714508,
-0.47250398993492126,
0.6483644247055054,
-0.44818440079689026,
-0.8970855474472046,
0.48183807730674744,
-0.20974472165107727,
-0.02962050586938858,
0.21284766495227814,
0.6930637359619141,
-0.0368383564054966,
0.8624759316444397,
0.9127512574195862,
-0.14377157390117645,
0.32076478004455566,
-0.25992172956466675,
0.4662652611732483,
-0.829615592956543,
-0.18928198516368866,
-0.47272294759750366,
-0.6641653180122375,
-0.16206473112106323,
-0.47236332297325134,
0.3631094992160797,
0.357303261756897,
0.1474056839942932,
0.27987250685691833,
-0.5638594031333923,
0.6668078303337097,
0.5842378735542297,
-0.3746790587902069,
0.3170263171195984,
0.2768597900867462,
-0.44136887788772583,
-0.32104456424713135,
-0.737291693687439,
-0.2723897397518158,
1.192065715789795,
0.1537308543920517,
0.77689528465271,
0.16346710920333862,
0.9374528527259827,
0.20902782678604126,
0.09965911507606506,
-0.5596489906311035,
0.396371454000473,
-0.43824875354766846,
-0.2880955636501312,
-0.3100898563861847,
-0.49362632632255554,
-0.6282621622085571,
0.5426612496376038,
0.2653886079788208,
-0.8503772020339966,
0.14187172055244446,
0.12484855949878693,
-0.4868759512901306,
0.37134620547294617,
-1.0983036756515503,
0.8995378613471985,
0.12194007635116577,
-0.17082256078720093,
-0.3201724588871002,
-0.41787225008010864,
0.5915989875793457,
-0.2187272012233734,
0.21482054889202118,
-0.05397983267903328,
0.19991178810596466,
0.6678285002708435,
-0.45817863941192627,
0.7194794416427612,
-0.5461060404777527,
-0.4664372503757477,
0.10319457203149796,
0.17229299247264862,
0.31048858165740967,
0.06871559470891953,
0.298907607793808,
-0.015827935189008713,
0.49546948075294495,
-0.11537674814462662,
-0.8518934845924377,
1.0060237646102905,
-0.8800510764122009,
-0.6664829254150391,
-0.2019074410200119,
-0.7946724891662598,
-0.25797536969184875,
0.16184747219085693,
0.09951101243495941,
0.15480363368988037,
0.0373271182179451,
0.18268978595733643,
0.6430683135986328,
-0.07936566323041916,
0.301568865776062,
0.620274007320404,
-0.2597294747829437,
-0.04901912435889244,
0.5809682011604309,
0.3086443543434143,
0.5751575827598572,
0.42159417271614075,
0.101533904671669,
-0.7289193868637085,
-0.2614805996417999,
-0.29005926847457886,
0.03839953988790512,
-0.9033642411231995,
-0.1898469477891922,
-0.6641937494277954,
-0.28256386518478394,
-0.7248654961585999,
-0.16572485864162445,
-0.5997518301010132,
-0.46828633546829224,
-0.06868596374988556,
-0.03760949522256851,
0.21118640899658203,
0.6602407693862915,
-0.017167257145047188,
-0.029583826661109924,
-0.6526152491569519,
0.5682467818260193,
0.4314604103565216,
0.28619763255119324,
0.29997414350509644,
-0.5496844053268433,
-0.27056899666786194,
0.37603071331977844,
-0.41605162620544434,
-0.6736490726470947,
0.25852811336517334,
0.040271151810884476,
0.321731835603714,
0.3634343445301056,
0.3654150068759918,
0.8359670042991638,
-0.5720618963241577,
0.6135179996490479,
0.47009870409965515,
-0.642692506313324,
0.3121589124202728,
0.16952082514762878,
0.6520311832427979,
0.366985023021698,
0.327132910490036,
-0.8597186803817749,
-0.6026602983474731,
-0.3800886869430542,
-0.6739923357963562,
0.9675078988075256,
-0.19798949360847473,
0.0033792140893638134,
0.2684897780418396,
0.14142192900180817,
0.4079989492893219,
0.14069722592830658,
-0.6966584324836731,
-0.3163778781890869,
0.17628604173660278,
-0.4866889715194702,
-0.050065308809280396,
-0.11168260872364044,
-0.03791581466794014,
-0.1174648329615593,
0.6610803604125977,
-0.0004388674278743565,
-0.0044352044351398945,
-0.04740000516176224,
-0.05731019005179405,
-0.1837393045425415,
0.19964556396007538,
0.24165427684783936,
0.5684394836425781,
0.10086392611265182,
0.43441537022590637,
0.08607077598571777,
-0.6486495733261108,
0.4988107979297638,
0.13017183542251587,
-0.006011458113789558,
-0.11328400671482086,
0.12111722677946091,
0.5778918266296387,
0.15020106732845306,
-0.4888066351413727,
0.42672863602638245,
0.055837299674749374,
-0.310249388217926,
-0.027502037584781647,
0.11186382919549942,
0.6002464890480042,
0.685075044631958,
0.2426406443119049,
0.16514606773853302,
0.06924696266651154,
-0.3322295546531677,
0.10698271542787552,
0.31666284799575806,
-0.0878010243177414,
-0.28630760312080383,
0.6625524759292603,
-0.018131855875253677,
-0.044148363173007965,
0.3874295651912689,
-0.36930015683174133,
-0.4483594298362732,
0.6690405011177063,
0.4113383889198303,
0.8434319496154785,
-0.22880493104457855,
0.23789334297180176,
0.2265615612268448,
-0.10380982607603073,
-0.16220588982105255,
0.03152007237076759,
-0.509551465511322,
-0.7491171360015869,
-0.4081434905529022,
-0.8251649737358093,
0.12778593599796295,
0.3131098449230194,
-0.6857010126113892,
0.3445007801055908,
-0.23311954736709595,
-0.008135845884680748,
0.2350223958492279,
0.1415380984544754,
-0.5903164744377136,
-0.2233056277036667,
0.3670411705970764,
0.49241188168525696,
-0.9039703011512756,
1.1489660739898682,
0.7367075085639954,
-0.007888473570346832,
-0.7313423752784729,
0.09517783671617508,
0.03741549700498581,
-0.4750274419784546,
0.9407133460044861,
-0.11384610831737518,
-0.09674305468797684,
-0.15588049590587616,
-0.08089940994977951,
-0.9592151045799255,
1.311240315437317,
0.5223502516746521,
-1.1411839723587036,
-0.08327978104352951,
0.21358731389045715,
0.5728402733802795,
-0.25179752707481384,
-0.2955547869205475,
0.5296099185943604,
0.21516337990760803,
0.4074017405509949,
-0.9431067705154419,
0.03695640340447426,
-0.01688498444855213,
0.24463292956352234,
0.43413761258125305,
-0.5859858989715576,
0.6585904955863953,
-0.2322579026222229,
-0.42085692286491394,
-0.19636689126491547,
0.4426422715187073,
0.34019050002098083,
0.2879190444946289,
0.49294471740722656,
0.9318615198135376,
0.6073562502861023,
0.017203867435455322,
0.5835062265396118,
-0.32357922196388245,
0.551020085811615,
1.221062183380127,
-0.6676349639892578,
0.6604700684547424,
0.8514277338981628,
-0.6319184303283691,
0.26433107256889343,
0.2259601652622223,
0.06356720626354218,
1.018337607383728,
0.13171197474002838,
-0.16859309375286102,
0.06881482899188995,
0.24308568239212036,
-0.45253390073776245,
-0.014013412408530712,
0.15683197975158691,
-0.14334136247634888,
-0.4613538682460785,
0.2177298665046692,
-0.19268397986888885,
0.4303317368030548,
-0.018121279776096344,
0.8056976199150085,
0.20228981971740723,
-0.8643874526023865,
0.6438033580780029,
0.03719419986009598,
0.592801034450531,
-0.5213758945465088,
0.001978484680876136,
-0.14411766827106476,
0.4950059652328491,
0.09238214045763016,
-0.7361761331558228,
0.34264299273490906,
-0.1030547097325325,
-0.5198719501495361,
-0.28241488337516785,
0.6882269978523254,
-1.0885626077651978,
-0.4236220717430115,
0.5475358366966248,
0.3746272027492523,
-0.07497605681419373,
0.1120334267616272,
-0.48944082856178284,
0.10544383525848389,
0.10044922679662704,
-0.10367897152900696,
0.5468485355377197,
0.7038909792900085,
0.04756755754351616,
0.5085389018058777,
0.44208070635795593,
0.22110319137573242,
0.30284714698791504,
0.03699114918708801,
0.8790000677108765,
-0.19048050045967102,
-0.8562222123146057,
-1.0194092988967896,
0.290378212928772,
-0.03291619196534157,
-0.025556422770023346,
0.6618977189064026,
0.3227079212665558,
1.0431417226791382,
-0.30992966890335083,
0.9183756709098816,
-0.235725536942482,
0.6043274402618408,
-0.5301082730293274,
0.7733628749847412,
-0.6442824006080627,
0.34848785400390625,
-0.23515602946281433,
-1.362830638885498,
0.06453356891870499,
0.41380372643470764,
-0.3719046711921692,
0.0388023667037487,
0.8904469609260559,
0.7895027995109558,
-0.41352811455726624,
-0.314614474773407,
0.4926246404647827,
0.20854631066322327,
0.25831297039985657,
0.9405025243759155,
0.8481452465057373,
-0.22007869184017181,
0.5643228888511658,
-0.4765174984931946,
0.027974959462881088,
-0.17309896647930145,
-0.5951540470123291,
-1.0274757146835327,
-1.0030921697616577,
-0.6376467347145081,
-0.017809437587857246,
-0.07851899415254593,
0.5392187237739563,
0.8746368288993835,
-0.5482636094093323,
-0.029658224433660507,
-0.0963703915476799,
0.15421278774738312,
-0.2723590135574341,
-0.3018539547920227,
0.5298150181770325,
-0.25083276629447937,
-0.87388676404953,
0.008170066401362419,
0.29180654883384705,
0.042585209012031555,
-0.5186861157417297,
-0.27185913920402527,
-0.20451156795024872,
-0.08898701518774033,
0.39187857508659363,
-0.04606705904006958,
-0.827932596206665,
-0.21629376709461212,
-0.23121461272239685,
-0.20715349912643433,
-0.23628133535385132,
0.6434609889984131,
-0.8109210133552551,
0.3554937243461609,
0.4334399998188019,
0.6798559427261353,
0.5694137215614319,
-0.3130241334438324,
0.4777688980102539,
-1.1373252868652344,
0.33482566475868225,
0.003174120793119073,
0.0949326604604721,
0.21745838224887848,
-0.4863421320915222,
0.21422524750232697,
0.1571549028158188,
-0.43044930696487427,
-0.9597691893577576,
0.2718384861946106,
-0.6472862958908081,
-0.517196536064148,
1.2621607780456543,
-0.32484620809555054,
-0.0856861025094986,
0.1166924312710762,
-0.24308548867702484,
0.32749441266059875,
-0.32216671109199524,
0.9938532114028931,
1.2507591247558594,
0.3151876926422119,
-0.04728182405233383,
-0.5155738592147827,
0.6021556854248047,
0.41967666149139404,
-0.49231815338134766,
0.41859540343284607,
0.47416049242019653,
0.5044968128204346,
0.27492058277130127,
0.5106691718101501,
-0.09793112426996231,
0.2907051742076874,
0.020152047276496887,
0.13791880011558533,
-0.10122630000114441,
-0.3625142276287079,
-0.28209516406059265,
0.11552377790212631,
-0.08678989112377167,
-0.2007656991481781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00087v1 | ARES: Alternating Reinforcement Learning and Supervised Fine-Tuning for Enhanced Multi-Modal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Through Diverse AI Feedback | 2024-06-25T07:20:11 | 2024-06-25T07:20:11 | Ju-Seung Byun, Jiyun Chun, Jihyung Kil, Andrew Perrault | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) excel at comprehending human instructions and
demonstrate remarkable results across a broad spectrum of tasks. Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) and AI Feedback (RLAIF) further refine LLMs
by aligning them with specific preferences. These methods primarily use
ranking-based feedback for entire generations. With advanced AI models
(Teacher), such as GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus, we can request various types of
detailed feedback that are expensive for humans to provide. We propose a
two-stage algorithm ARES that Alternates REinforcement Learning (RL) and
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT). First, we request the Teacher to score how much
each sentence contributes to solving the problem in a Chain-of-Thought (CoT).
This sentence-level feedback allows us to consider individual valuable
segments, providing more granular rewards for the RL procedure. Second, we ask
the Teacher to correct the wrong reasoning after the RL stage. The RL procedure
requires massive efforts for hyperparameter tuning and often generates errors
like repetitive words and incomplete sentences. With the correction feedback,
we stabilize the RL fine-tuned model through SFT. We conduct experiments on
multi-model dataset ScienceQA and A-OKVQA to demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposal. ARES rationale reasoning achieves around 70% win rate against
baseline models judged by GPT-4o. Additionally, we observe that the improved
rationale reasoning leads to a 2.5% increase in inference answer accuracy on
average for the multi-modal datasets. | [
-0.6942693591117859,
-1.1449300050735474,
0.7140749096870422,
-0.06770003587007523,
-0.17170003056526184,
0.11361140757799149,
-0.2944120168685913,
-0.3034336268901825,
-0.06217603757977486,
0.5495903491973877,
-0.872252881526947,
-0.296741247177124,
-0.5409695506095886,
0.13540096580982208,
-0.022703006863594055,
1.0349968671798706,
-0.14398568868637085,
0.18286684155464172,
0.20999348163604736,
-0.2961246371269226,
-0.4685802459716797,
-0.2618617117404938,
-1.0506324768066406,
-0.3123719096183777,
0.651222288608551,
0.770216703414917,
0.5276104211807251,
0.6124544143676758,
0.21966023743152618,
0.3474292755126953,
0.19013257324695587,
0.9539048075675964,
-0.191054105758667,
0.36041805148124695,
-0.5008555054664612,
-0.3532871901988983,
-0.41387566924095154,
0.07251417636871338,
0.3721890151500702,
0.314287394285202,
-0.2934756875038147,
0.0035860633943229914,
0.038422681391239166,
0.8815643787384033,
-0.6989648938179016,
0.0032716391142457724,
-0.5496652126312256,
0.013055321760475636,
0.06233504042029381,
-0.5023362636566162,
-0.697699248790741,
-0.2354266196489334,
-0.0660599023103714,
-0.8554413318634033,
-0.11327753216028214,
0.47011464834213257,
0.6535308957099915,
0.6627816557884216,
-0.5972469449043274,
-0.39380592107772827,
-0.9587787985801697,
0.8053084015846252,
-0.49812328815460205,
0.5303200483322144,
0.4868329167366028,
0.3334055542945862,
-0.11643140017986298,
-0.6490466594696045,
-0.5774036645889282,
-0.4714421033859253,
0.29216837882995605,
0.2732604444026947,
-0.09521103650331497,
0.4013183116912842,
0.19099268317222595,
0.17171353101730347,
-0.10241511464118958,
0.016837220638990402,
-0.38483843207359314,
0.0429132804274559,
0.6140984892845154,
0.20900879800319672,
-0.15887244045734406,
0.2091703563928604,
-0.4425930678844452,
-0.29648876190185547,
-0.5168976783752441,
0.27043116092681885,
0.35971614718437195,
0.21749459207057953,
0.19808493554592133,
0.5485886335372925,
-0.4498518407344818,
0.6475362181663513,
0.5180628895759583,
0.05139214172959328,
-0.028478682041168213,
-0.24125780165195465,
-0.2978784143924713,
-0.2483658641576767,
0.5981723070144653,
0.13496609032154083,
0.07259751111268997,
-0.04710335284471512,
-0.4236938953399658,
0.1161596029996872,
0.5023868083953857,
-0.3595985174179077,
-0.2502567768096924,
-0.04666073992848396,
-0.41398322582244873,
-0.20224905014038086,
-0.025046534836292267,
-0.5413150191307068,
-0.44503700733184814,
-0.7391244769096375,
0.9164089560508728,
-0.531326174736023,
0.20787553489208221,
0.08303739875555038,
0.01801341027021408,
-0.23348763585090637,
0.6213632225990295,
-0.8165866136550903,
0.4403088688850403,
0.42814892530441284,
0.3505176305770874,
0.10650268197059631,
-0.5324448347091675,
-0.88177889585495,
-0.004213276319205761,
-0.3860529959201813,
0.9244346022605896,
-0.6416140198707581,
0.13138248026371002,
-0.3881063163280487,
-0.20084135234355927,
-0.14729206264019012,
-0.2668831944465637,
0.6610336303710938,
-0.6586463451385498,
0.3594399690628052,
-0.30593690276145935,
-0.5329975485801697,
-0.5290652513504028,
0.412154883146286,
-0.40248018503189087,
1.004258632659912,
-0.16032767295837402,
-0.4378533363342285,
0.43402618169784546,
-0.6371342539787292,
-0.2610275149345398,
-0.44485384225845337,
-0.136915922164917,
-0.36192378401756287,
0.04925891011953354,
0.8024186491966248,
0.33455944061279297,
-0.24316400289535522,
0.2510514259338379,
-0.43062838912010193,
-0.43252307176589966,
0.2662327289581299,
-0.784441351890564,
0.03304363787174225,
0.3312074542045593,
-0.5690523982048035,
0.7772942781448364,
-0.6409198641777039,
0.07773136347532272,
-0.3547006845474243,
-0.35566362738609314,
-0.16961227357387543,
0.25998881459236145,
-0.05616180598735809,
0.4210483133792877,
-0.17462478578090668,
-0.24847646057605743,
0.3783700168132782,
-0.22509437799453735,
0.40250715613365173,
1.038543701171875,
0.20149165391921997,
0.3466917872428894,
-0.5938432812690735,
0.5663796067237854,
-0.12843875586986542,
0.30185651779174805,
-0.12119697034358978,
-0.3950924575328827,
-1.0135647058486938,
-0.30111345648765564,
0.24245770275592804,
0.4123368263244629,
-0.8222794532775879,
0.2804189920425415,
0.19978436827659607,
-0.1656174659729004,
-0.7676491737365723,
0.13027018308639526,
0.4392443001270294,
0.4164426624774933,
0.692981481552124,
-0.2635825574398041,
-0.6130120158195496,
-0.9768434762954712,
-0.14991070330142975,
0.014415263198316097,
0.26982584595680237,
0.599390983581543,
0.5249226689338684,
-0.2211829572916031,
0.6384469270706177,
-0.22078287601470947,
-0.20644955337047577,
-0.22422809898853302,
0.44392263889312744,
-0.14738309383392334,
0.28390708565711975,
-0.01385511551052332,
-0.47268491983413696,
-0.19959504902362823,
-0.024343792349100113,
-0.36098340153694153,
0.03859268128871918,
-0.3310849964618683,
-0.11161086708307266,
0.06558346003293991,
0.41468021273612976,
-0.3659726679325104,
0.152709499001503,
0.37312883138656616,
-0.3878338932991028,
0.489761084318161,
-0.42439231276512146,
0.5607358813285828,
-0.8451181650161743,
-0.07622302323579788,
-0.07644135504961014,
-0.3573884069919586,
-0.11028294265270233,
0.23425744473934174,
-0.0080639086663723,
0.1370934695005417,
-0.14237390458583832,
0.4210249185562134,
-0.21875791251659393,
-0.06389322131872177,
-0.5380970239639282,
0.03865979611873627,
-0.09328441321849823,
0.9426817893981934,
-0.06573687493801117,
0.9738457202911377,
0.3648710250854492,
-0.7695300579071045,
0.45091527700424194,
0.0371890664100647,
-0.18470624089241028,
0.42779237031936646,
-0.4747537076473236,
0.22775761783123016,
-0.1006498709321022,
0.7152953147888184,
-0.7453001141548157,
-0.2516680061817169,
0.31730929017066956,
-0.3164786398410797,
0.01564391702413559,
0.10705040395259857,
-0.23301725089550018,
-0.21380586922168732,
-0.3300451636314392,
0.3293401300907135,
0.20909340679645538,
-0.6316254734992981,
0.6400188207626343,
0.13063935935497284,
-0.019651219248771667,
-0.7643213868141174,
-0.1574244648218155,
-0.14078928530216217,
-0.09631311148405075,
-0.41659268736839294,
0.14570002257823944,
0.006291874218732119,
-0.112248994410038,
0.21607136726379395,
-0.29574495553970337,
0.05288291722536087,
0.07524315267801285,
0.22354474663734436,
0.1011725589632988,
-0.0580357126891613,
0.3438263535499573,
0.4217575192451477,
-0.14488887786865234,
-0.2355925738811493,
-0.46201780438423157,
0.4570388197898865,
-0.38681337237358093,
-0.5631786584854126,
-0.623436450958252,
0.23002417385578156,
0.7223724126815796,
-0.3645825684070587,
0.5070081353187561,
0.6542544960975647,
-0.15349790453910828,
-0.4957207441329956,
-0.5044821500778198,
-0.5551548004150391,
-0.41526830196380615,
0.30985891819000244,
-0.4284968674182892,
-0.929151177406311,
0.30396708846092224,
-0.30484554171562195,
0.14468063414096832,
0.45311838388442993,
0.6695200204849243,
-0.258352667093277,
1.4446794986724854,
0.4980284571647644,
0.06618162244558334,
0.5477634072303772,
-0.36118587851524353,
-0.015971669927239418,
-0.922339141368866,
-0.27490076422691345,
-0.12319029867649078,
-0.5904280543327332,
-0.38050776720046997,
-0.3672312796115875,
0.6187974810600281,
0.25077876448631287,
-0.5443432331085205,
-0.10356171429157257,
-0.35354918241500854,
0.4480935037136078,
0.8548734188079834,
0.5107157826423645,
0.34582194685935974,
-0.2097494751214981,
-0.4379402697086334,
0.2655601501464844,
-0.6609582901000977,
-0.3296719789505005,
1.2479740381240845,
0.38998785614967346,
0.8353037238121033,
-0.005856349132955074,
0.6080875396728516,
0.4958707094192505,
0.23575040698051453,
-0.6900936365127563,
0.3425517678260803,
0.0723644271492958,
-0.681918203830719,
-0.36572396755218506,
-0.2970406115055084,
-0.7277783751487732,
0.5196312665939331,
-0.5100395679473877,
-0.44906699657440186,
-0.003269163193181157,
0.4006517827510834,
-0.6590076088905334,
0.21825525164604187,
-0.5047295093536377,
0.5364301800727844,
-0.2682580351829529,
-0.6083154678344727,
-0.9312987327575684,
-0.7019615173339844,
0.4991791248321533,
0.22220110893249512,
0.2867263853549957,
0.0667666345834732,
0.0904259979724884,
0.6080718040466309,
-0.4218302071094513,
0.6860832571983337,
0.016389600932598114,
0.17942112684249878,
0.12111055105924606,
-0.16197235882282257,
0.7709577083587646,
0.378864049911499,
0.17393645644187927,
-0.5227171182632446,
-0.25205299258232117,
-0.28798824548721313,
-0.7599601149559021,
0.6857448220252991,
-0.9694728851318359,
-0.548416793346405,
-0.4768792688846588,
-0.6933967471122742,
-0.5728241205215454,
-0.05456353724002838,
0.19212235510349274,
0.5205731987953186,
0.1889522820711136,
0.11322659254074097,
0.694571316242218,
-0.01530286855995655,
0.10578915476799011,
0.5163328051567078,
-0.1431402862071991,
-0.8095139265060425,
0.6816096901893616,
-0.3868705928325653,
0.14491534233093262,
0.30494698882102966,
0.03161519020795822,
-0.35351184010505676,
-0.4312230944633484,
-0.756309986114502,
-0.062352798879146576,
-0.5756894946098328,
-0.19098621606826782,
-0.5216098427772522,
0.07185599952936172,
0.0888519212603569,
-0.15242671966552734,
-0.5264790058135986,
-0.5577762722969055,
0.10824094712734222,
-0.09502553194761276,
0.30587828159332275,
0.766766369342804,
-0.2577231228351593,
0.17070068418979645,
-0.6504483819007874,
0.516667366027832,
0.5834763050079346,
0.23708032071590424,
0.11754263192415237,
-0.44089093804359436,
-0.25426504015922546,
0.21133923530578613,
-0.7058650255203247,
-0.9046438932418823,
0.0592467337846756,
0.20467159152030945,
0.438820481300354,
0.43762823939323425,
-0.09559676796197891,
0.8741679787635803,
-0.44164031744003296,
0.4734465181827545,
0.03912562131881714,
-0.935265839099884,
0.6541239023208618,
-0.2402353286743164,
0.0011770387645810843,
0.6600766181945801,
0.007073267828673124,
-0.46256211400032043,
-0.532863438129425,
-0.5502699017524719,
-0.9006585478782654,
1.0030858516693115,
0.12591181695461273,
-0.2626000940799713,
0.0947057455778122,
0.31016960740089417,
0.23340381681919098,
0.11715620756149292,
-0.6273616552352905,
-0.2960774302482605,
0.04931433126330376,
-0.16235743463039398,
-0.04865940287709236,
0.13709813356399536,
-0.3712332844734192,
-0.48716360330581665,
1.0313318967819214,
-0.10075110197067261,
0.0900784358382225,
0.29066118597984314,
-0.025122370570898056,
-0.35912424325942993,
0.6504489183425903,
0.8148955702781677,
0.43643608689308167,
-0.1461976170539856,
0.22201456129550934,
0.3889869153499603,
-0.08173442631959915,
0.3504261374473572,
0.2177087664604187,
-0.04908629134297371,
-0.46745792031288147,
0.3186887502670288,
1.1696962118148804,
0.3921237289905548,
-0.6092962622642517,
0.13519501686096191,
-0.1108705997467041,
-0.2145824432373047,
-0.16482661664485931,
0.32377690076828003,
-0.21474409103393555,
0.6565187573432922,
0.33905652165412903,
0.8037391304969788,
0.2664991021156311,
-0.6437187194824219,
0.4313177168369293,
0.3344291150569916,
-0.42590129375457764,
-0.1944521963596344,
0.7836230993270874,
0.39785298705101013,
-0.10425739735364914,
0.5523015856742859,
-0.18564364314079285,
-0.419137179851532,
0.4657868444919586,
0.3973020017147064,
0.7832309603691101,
-0.05105694383382797,
0.2692314386367798,
0.29483896493911743,
0.2343757301568985,
-0.42530927062034607,
0.33141204714775085,
-0.4115995764732361,
-0.6609784364700317,
-0.6271352767944336,
-0.38464751839637756,
-0.5703215599060059,
0.23395466804504395,
-0.6662537455558777,
0.17109398543834686,
-0.5608937740325928,
-0.19574004411697388,
-0.11719091236591339,
0.11464259028434753,
-0.4774756133556366,
0.27389001846313477,
0.17845328152179718,
0.6132415533065796,
-0.8823773264884949,
0.8953177332878113,
0.9847723245620728,
-0.5048164129257202,
-1.109290599822998,
0.06714503467082977,
0.033544715493917465,
-0.6382953524589539,
0.41565045714378357,
-0.0327313132584095,
-0.3736362159252167,
0.10293696820735931,
-0.3373268246650696,
-0.8242511749267578,
1.0498560667037964,
0.10468778759241104,
-0.6047595739364624,
0.03138752654194832,
-0.5347388386726379,
0.4605380594730377,
-0.3132816255092621,
0.5492492318153381,
0.39450687170028687,
0.5089972615242004,
0.013137595728039742,
-0.9412883520126343,
-0.12877283990383148,
-0.20920002460479736,
-0.31713902950286865,
0.34389129281044006,
-0.600417971611023,
0.8323675394058228,
-0.4456995129585266,
0.10896661877632141,
-0.04283514246344566,
0.6644025444984436,
0.7040673494338989,
0.5482690334320068,
0.6689820885658264,
0.8264544010162354,
0.8133199214935303,
0.14787793159484863,
0.9265254139900208,
-0.2256888747215271,
0.3307071328163147,
1.0611703395843506,
0.08624936640262604,
0.875491201877594,
0.47830259799957275,
-0.016081100329756737,
0.5458895564079285,
0.6593922972679138,
0.15105706453323364,
0.7902460098266602,
-0.07668221741914749,
-0.2459714263677597,
-0.6068271398544312,
0.17293578386306763,
-0.27894315123558044,
0.38306334614753723,
0.4139874577522278,
-0.3398919403553009,
-0.1608881801366806,
0.30090421438217163,
-0.2929658889770508,
0.16881024837493896,
-0.33874648809432983,
0.6715990304946899,
-0.04945022985339165,
-1.0429434776306152,
0.370932400226593,
0.3859143555164337,
0.632485568523407,
-0.47226741909980774,
-0.1565100997686386,
-0.19033396244049072,
0.5332362055778503,
-0.04686722531914711,
-0.45411452651023865,
0.02694072760641575,
-0.0642768070101738,
-0.25529223680496216,
-0.21795500814914703,
0.3150915801525116,
-0.47724124789237976,
-0.27425602078437805,
-0.0032982651609927416,
0.46700581908226013,
-0.32409340143203735,
0.12113755941390991,
-0.787327766418457,
-0.07554473727941513,
-0.001996966078877449,
-0.43892523646354675,
0.15251418948173523,
0.3671274185180664,
-0.2799053490161896,
0.906844973564148,
0.6776812672615051,
-0.03065286949276924,
0.024857738986611366,
0.06653588265180588,
0.9616223573684692,
-0.5048187375068665,
-0.5762360095977783,
-0.6484384536743164,
0.3755367696285248,
0.08760028332471848,
-0.6790136694908142,
0.5120545029640198,
0.44637560844421387,
0.6287445425987244,
0.012814585119485855,
0.6870207786560059,
0.03728977218270302,
0.3780118227005005,
-0.8267724514007568,
0.27279722690582275,
-0.7219452857971191,
0.437643438577652,
-0.06284203380346298,
-0.7685698866844177,
-0.02429342456161976,
0.7347314357757568,
-0.2770286202430725,
0.06555813550949097,
0.8989612460136414,
0.5733668804168701,
-0.3154098689556122,
0.1778426170349121,
0.04607398435473442,
0.13054318726062775,
0.24320672452449799,
0.71513831615448,
1.0947576761245728,
-0.4360624849796295,
0.3823436200618744,
-0.23407596349716187,
-0.2432938516139984,
-0.2075713574886322,
-0.301846981048584,
-0.6796796917915344,
-0.6353861093521118,
-0.10565260052680969,
-0.15331195294857025,
0.450492799282074,
1.2654950618743896,
0.823035717010498,
-0.8833170533180237,
0.006017641630023718,
-0.5336266756057739,
0.13077493011951447,
-0.7586076259613037,
-0.18696609139442444,
0.2992839813232422,
-0.690938413143158,
-0.5985228419303894,
0.741592526435852,
0.2349623590707779,
-0.5243467688560486,
-0.08646456152200699,
-0.458956241607666,
-0.24325492978096008,
0.44215837121009827,
0.48649463057518005,
0.12927278876304626,
-1.1186025142669678,
-0.42912909388542175,
0.013130431063473225,
-0.07081404328346252,
-0.20335586369037628,
0.8279202580451965,
-0.9724504947662354,
0.46739357709884644,
0.33323562145233154,
0.4472058117389679,
0.6255712509155273,
0.24918673932552338,
0.5864952206611633,
-0.6384166479110718,
0.06591213494539261,
0.3615652322769165,
0.2822207510471344,
-0.13252580165863037,
-0.14876927435398102,
0.3084334135055542,
0.054324910044670105,
-0.8029820322990417,
-0.5753092765808105,
0.4742101728916168,
-1.0101361274719238,
-0.4523490071296692,
1.025610327720642,
0.06328573077917099,
0.2813459038734436,
-0.11921367794275284,
-0.63739413022995,
0.3609952926635742,
-0.6880754232406616,
1.0250952243804932,
0.6454953551292419,
-0.6343935132026672,
-0.4630257785320282,
-0.45780351758003235,
0.5836305022239685,
0.7569807171821594,
-0.8190359473228455,
-0.17664366960525513,
0.7704037427902222,
0.15880225598812103,
-0.18848660588264465,
0.5762238502502441,
0.21006301045417786,
0.588661253452301,
-0.1188514307141304,
-0.09549430012702942,
-0.4611237645149231,
-0.7046805024147034,
-0.2920055389404297,
0.1937999278306961,
0.19841928780078888,
-0.32017308473587036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17324v1 | Delving into the Utilisation of ChatGPT in Scientific Publications in Astronomy | 2024-06-25T07:15:10 | 2024-06-25T07:15:10 | Simone Astarita, Sandor Kruk, Jan Reerink, Pablo Gómez | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM, cs.DL | Rapid progress in the capabilities of machine learning approaches in natural
language processing has culminated in the rise of large language models over
the last two years. Recent works have shown unprecedented adoption of these for
academic writing, especially in some fields, but their pervasiveness in
astronomy has not been studied sufficiently. To remedy this, we extract words
that ChatGPT uses more often than humans when generating academic text and
search a total of 1 million articles for them. This way, we assess the
frequency of word occurrence in published works in astronomy tracked by the
NASA Astrophysics Data System since 2000. We then perform a statistical
analysis of the occurrences. We identify a list of words favoured by ChatGPT
and find a statistically significant increase for these words against a control
group in 2024, which matches the trend in other disciplines. These results
suggest a widespread adoption of these models in the writing of astronomy
papers. We encourage organisations, publishers, and researchers to work
together to identify ethical and pragmatic guidelines to maximise the benefits
of these systems while maintaining scientific rigour. | [
-0.2780779302120209,
-0.5243909358978271,
0.4851318597793579,
0.29932060837745667,
-0.3010268211364746,
0.008036782033741474,
-0.22619274258613586,
-0.7749964594841003,
0.07650832831859589,
0.6579829454421997,
-0.2900322675704956,
-0.34179753065109253,
-0.9611102938652039,
0.4101516306400299,
-0.6496400237083435,
1.076338291168213,
0.03278302028775215,
0.021520555019378662,
-0.16847680509090424,
0.1944667100906372,
-0.15418589115142822,
-0.3914264440536499,
-0.3919263184070587,
-0.20135116577148438,
0.7151440978050232,
0.20412695407867432,
0.645285427570343,
0.4998456835746765,
1.1691203117370605,
0.2288249135017395,
-0.28194671869277954,
0.35326316952705383,
-0.5467193126678467,
-0.12337927520275116,
0.14652390778064728,
-0.4065858721733093,
-0.15247243642807007,
0.192286878824234,
0.6977224349975586,
0.7824425101280212,
-0.23742783069610596,
-0.009586705826222897,
0.16848787665367126,
0.5360549092292786,
-0.40138280391693115,
0.6669747233390808,
-0.6691604256629944,
0.030244266614317894,
-0.5389136075973511,
-0.25615087151527405,
-0.36547231674194336,
-0.4046933650970459,
0.3375478684902191,
-0.9392848610877991,
0.08707074075937271,
0.2886229455471039,
0.7194592356681824,
0.033716313540935516,
-0.06275349110364914,
-0.9021059274673462,
-0.5583806037902832,
0.7615901827812195,
-0.3996050953865051,
0.4067707061767578,
0.3747973144054413,
0.02858615107834339,
-0.3720090091228485,
-1.0444380044937134,
-0.5890477299690247,
-0.6270754337310791,
-0.12067103385925293,
0.1947467029094696,
-0.20850594341754913,
0.03963535651564598,
0.08526510745286942,
0.10967420041561127,
-0.6716623306274414,
-0.2122335135936737,
-0.6546803116798401,
0.011723251082003117,
0.32976680994033813,
0.00016407326620537788,
0.1691271811723709,
-0.28227698802948,
-0.014783496037125587,
-0.13450220227241516,
-0.7924548983573914,
-0.24222305417060852,
0.3049893081188202,
0.2868574261665344,
0.3931640088558197,
0.9150745868682861,
0.17739903926849365,
0.46129369735717773,
-0.2627379894256592,
0.3773649036884308,
-0.27078157663345337,
-0.43759241700172424,
-0.048072993755340576,
-0.15144747495651245,
0.9350942373275757,
0.27251121401786804,
0.28229624032974243,
-0.29932212829589844,
0.31181058287620544,
0.4418308138847351,
0.36807170510292053,
-0.6047690510749817,
-0.5182183384895325,
-0.1199946254491806,
-0.013239963911473751,
-0.2832511365413666,
0.059647344052791595,
-0.6347184777259827,
-0.5041636824607849,
-0.1850365698337555,
0.004748919978737831,
-0.5611650347709656,
0.020000940188765526,
0.2863016724586487,
-0.3293409049510956,
0.1086781844496727,
0.07878678292036057,
-0.861885130405426,
0.08167783170938492,
1.0715595483779907,
0.8341432809829712,
0.24054782092571259,
-0.3261483907699585,
0.01828785240650177,
-0.1058819591999054,
-0.5070656538009644,
0.9958873391151428,
-0.8412932753562927,
-0.9048982262611389,
-0.1504071205854416,
-0.034405216574668884,
-0.22152617573738098,
-0.33331769704818726,
0.8481312394142151,
-0.5551923513412476,
0.5446749329566956,
-0.2518424689769745,
-0.6496691703796387,
-0.4295775294303894,
-0.15539699792861938,
-0.3046448230743408,
1.0624289512634277,
-0.1260523945093155,
-0.6171026825904846,
0.956545889377594,
-0.9717194437980652,
-0.03872767463326454,
0.3975861072540283,
0.08362898975610733,
-0.5939939022064209,
-0.014109918847680092,
0.06769481301307678,
0.3260592818260193,
0.012279095128178596,
0.1624642312526703,
-0.0924324095249176,
-0.1527579128742218,
0.296387255191803,
-0.1955070197582245,
0.24709118902683258,
0.6323596239089966,
0.0850888043642044,
-0.4004799723625183,
-0.44666537642478943,
-0.21663594245910645,
-0.17722348868846893,
-0.22088901698589325,
-0.5094766616821289,
0.4836462736129761,
0.3257678151130676,
-0.2984255254268646,
0.1398545801639557,
-0.6992701888084412,
0.3114856481552124,
-0.5001832246780396,
0.5149059891700745,
0.18382181227207184,
0.05881679803133011,
0.32054463028907776,
-0.3341376781463623,
0.20836377143859863,
-0.2216319739818573,
-0.05173657089471817,
-0.07509803026914597,
-0.7179476022720337,
-0.4175029397010803,
-0.22354573011398315,
0.06094752252101898,
0.224328875541687,
-0.14564982056617737,
0.2344847023487091,
-0.050665467977523804,
-1.0295510292053223,
-0.5451689958572388,
0.04617408290505409,
0.20248982310295105,
0.345944344997406,
0.08645029366016388,
-0.20018532872200012,
-0.5934382081031799,
-0.5092158913612366,
-0.656458854675293,
-0.15999749302864075,
0.11653511226177216,
0.5579579472541809,
0.6017955541610718,
-0.35051268339157104,
0.890426754951477,
-0.42010194063186646,
0.0676993578672409,
0.23849432170391083,
0.6556813716888428,
0.20576058328151703,
0.19333074986934662,
0.20123302936553955,
-1.0155020952224731,
-0.5336052775382996,
0.2754085958003998,
-0.8550971150398254,
-0.16013723611831665,
0.031618330627679825,
-0.18320627510547638,
0.059827011078596115,
0.38496914505958557,
-0.5352274775505066,
0.15716196596622467,
0.4284345507621765,
-0.5517640709877014,
0.49220630526542664,
-0.08389510214328766,
0.22637684643268585,
-0.8507893681526184,
0.47974488139152527,
0.2678675353527069,
-0.152024045586586,
-0.389443576335907,
0.1353464126586914,
-0.00033136570709757507,
-0.13876095414161682,
-0.1474563479423523,
0.25353294610977173,
-0.5781608819961548,
0.13876844942569733,
-0.3999021649360657,
0.3986583650112152,
-0.17817553877830505,
-0.32734403014183044,
0.18299557268619537,
0.8866578340530396,
0.4142635464668274,
-0.5432237982749939,
0.1902688592672348,
0.5555715560913086,
-0.47472697496414185,
0.23493778705596924,
-0.5423311591148376,
-0.08235762268304825,
-0.4996904730796814,
0.2467757910490036,
-0.9430829882621765,
-0.2590411901473999,
0.12867148220539093,
-0.44636860489845276,
0.08740083873271942,
-0.21197569370269775,
-0.31744110584259033,
-0.4171341359615326,
0.19920696318149567,
-0.22211523354053497,
0.3979058563709259,
-0.24186870455741882,
0.24754928052425385,
0.5661869645118713,
-0.3770352602005005,
-0.5727717876434326,
-0.24541927874088287,
0.4847797155380249,
-0.4088762104511261,
-0.6779400110244751,
0.06306984275579453,
0.14869479835033417,
-0.38924872875213623,
0.04615168645977974,
0.019303031265735626,
0.2842726409435272,
0.09372396022081375,
0.26358234882354736,
0.306233286857605,
-0.07237028330564499,
0.1485634744167328,
-0.6680744886398315,
-0.1712234616279602,
0.035234492272138596,
-0.46640297770500183,
0.6426514387130737,
-0.17701996862888336,
-0.05859199911355972,
-0.14368021488189697,
0.3454551100730896,
0.426090806722641,
-0.017641017213463783,
0.5779749751091003,
0.6479502320289612,
-0.03136756643652916,
0.06651727110147476,
-0.4570174813270569,
-0.321794331073761,
-0.4365572929382324,
0.614270806312561,
0.22546570003032684,
-0.7621423006057739,
0.3244965374469757,
0.029347935691475868,
0.4968768060207367,
0.5096192359924316,
0.3798257112503052,
-0.34959936141967773,
0.6655914783477783,
0.6818965077400208,
-0.006572536658495665,
0.5335585474967957,
-0.18966029584407806,
0.2515656352043152,
-0.6667982339859009,
-0.1628659963607788,
-0.8804463744163513,
0.17231212556362152,
-0.9475908875465393,
-0.47067689895629883,
0.49750590324401855,
-0.1943412721157074,
0.07852914929389954,
0.5460377335548401,
-0.8352416753768921,
0.5843409299850464,
0.3458021879196167,
-0.1801391988992691,
0.41206085681915283,
0.0625695213675499,
0.3224000334739685,
-0.17327935993671417,
-0.4347824454307556,
-0.8176279067993164,
1.150888204574585,
0.0747479796409607,
0.8039872646331787,
-0.17606700956821442,
0.590528666973114,
0.15674707293510437,
0.6173929572105408,
-0.7775634527206421,
0.4513535499572754,
-0.49723389744758606,
-0.5694310665130615,
-0.10212542861700058,
-0.4991954267024994,
-1.269030213356018,
0.09036826342344284,
-0.081889808177948,
-0.6471045017242432,
0.050207655876874924,
-0.149762824177742,
-0.11056715995073318,
0.053138215094804764,
-0.755441427230835,
0.5012121200561523,
0.14582005143165588,
-0.21588632464408875,
-0.3759061396121979,
-0.32042428851127625,
0.16967642307281494,
-0.12168305367231369,
0.3011429011821747,
-0.12640753388404846,
0.07335866987705231,
1.023282766342163,
0.013221027329564095,
0.7624439001083374,
0.12881246209144592,
0.036627721041440964,
0.46298423409461975,
0.07828807085752487,
0.5323809385299683,
0.03886602073907852,
-0.01747792400419712,
0.21607886254787445,
0.41446346044540405,
-0.2500876188278198,
0.0361889973282814,
0.6592933535575867,
-0.6709272861480713,
-0.3721299171447754,
-0.8028279542922974,
-0.5277508497238159,
-0.012715517543256283,
0.037140537053346634,
0.41097360849380493,
0.3678978681564331,
-0.42844074964523315,
0.39182060956954956,
0.2510533034801483,
-0.027521401643753052,
0.37682610750198364,
0.47483372688293457,
-0.4097900390625,
-0.043097008019685745,
0.7821922302246094,
0.2340659499168396,
0.05229716747999191,
0.1507224589586258,
0.2850119471549988,
-0.40878674387931824,
-0.45488402247428894,
0.0008605764014646411,
0.3845984935760498,
-0.21040743589401245,
0.29730674624443054,
-0.8663768172264099,
-0.18631017208099365,
-0.32142144441604614,
-0.3505682647228241,
-0.19151072204113007,
-0.3857742249965668,
-0.3351776599884033,
0.19769465923309326,
0.4930265545845032,
0.801371693611145,
0.0009402502328157425,
0.681209146976471,
-0.7338197827339172,
-0.043170906603336334,
-0.18411971628665924,
0.3002930283546448,
-0.5412236452102661,
-0.28631308674812317,
-0.2634468376636505,
-0.1351614147424698,
-0.6076544523239136,
-0.6626394987106323,
0.7850954532623291,
0.36791878938674927,
0.4342314600944519,
0.11037338525056839,
-0.5128902792930603,
0.39791497588157654,
-0.2919413149356842,
0.8642280697822571,
0.01898828148841858,
-0.37975260615348816,
0.25379982590675354,
-0.8341020345687866,
0.1612847000360489,
0.331977516412735,
0.71974778175354,
-1.1697189807891846,
-0.6033423542976379,
-0.7485023736953735,
-0.8712810277938843,
0.38468286395072937,
0.2797263264656067,
0.13253477215766907,
-0.06992429494857788,
0.29773691296577454,
0.23017606139183044,
0.3670896589756012,
-0.6093662977218628,
0.21564608812332153,
0.1475190967321396,
-0.16471825540065765,
-0.15501190721988678,
-0.0757569745182991,
-0.1899697631597519,
0.3072962760925293,
0.7549213171005249,
-0.10153798013925552,
0.29132258892059326,
0.3000927269458771,
0.0933494046330452,
-0.0694732740521431,
0.22581589221954346,
0.09943509101867676,
0.7360599637031555,
-0.25530803203582764,
-0.21582624316215515,
-0.3114704489707947,
-1.185248851776123,
-0.6474283337593079,
0.32674694061279297,
-0.39592233300209045,
0.0702655166387558,
0.059860531240701675,
0.31562164425849915,
0.2868899703025818,
-0.4584627151489258,
-0.08482442796230316,
0.10608965903520584,
-0.34383368492126465,
-0.5402975082397461,
0.08496697247028351,
0.14530038833618164,
-0.024608314037322998,
0.30295804142951965,
0.4060286283493042,
0.3786427676677704,
-0.573758065700531,
0.16009637713432312,
0.6534233093261719,
-0.3397543728351593,
-0.22914870083332062,
0.6452897191047668,
-0.006342068314552307,
-0.06761683523654938,
0.20334692299365997,
-0.022490179166197777,
-0.4828552305698395,
0.5657262802124023,
0.27136173844337463,
0.6326383948326111,
0.2621423900127411,
0.39378592371940613,
0.3360219895839691,
0.22864818572998047,
-0.3286682963371277,
0.39292657375335693,
0.21373026072978973,
-0.5414332151412964,
-0.5307931303977966,
-0.8257483839988708,
-0.7619208693504333,
-0.27902960777282715,
-0.04643126204609871,
0.48893216252326965,
-0.26725155115127563,
-0.3198089599609375,
0.6259361505508423,
0.25734463334083557,
-0.5312700867652893,
-0.17152294516563416,
0.3631386160850525,
0.566709041595459,
-0.5806427001953125,
0.24918590486049652,
0.6304637789726257,
-0.3837628960609436,
-0.6191986203193665,
-0.45002710819244385,
0.3611316680908203,
-0.685331404209137,
0.5120635032653809,
0.011751563288271427,
0.0893569216132164,
0.03358539938926697,
-0.785641074180603,
-0.7617362141609192,
0.7336996793746948,
-0.2632552683353424,
-0.6104357838630676,
-0.025143863633275032,
0.10604491829872131,
0.7486263513565063,
-0.11037462204694748,
0.4574125409126282,
0.5229961276054382,
0.7252687215805054,
0.3663913905620575,
-1.042269229888916,
-0.5790266990661621,
-0.1299433559179306,
-0.4509723484516144,
0.6239713430404663,
-0.7085896134376526,
0.6186296343803406,
0.1517118662595749,
-0.3543683886528015,
0.05079590901732445,
0.39828282594680786,
0.18182983994483948,
0.5621334314346313,
0.0021543269976973534,
0.1430041640996933,
0.9881013035774231,
-0.2613457143306732,
0.8067140579223633,
-0.26461178064346313,
0.4198635518550873,
0.38388609886169434,
-0.24451129138469696,
0.7352948188781738,
0.6073431372642517,
-0.5058103799819946,
0.23740693926811218,
0.497372031211853,
-0.35823678970336914,
0.23124203085899353,
0.12653429806232452,
-0.42747852206230164,
0.08590569347143173,
-0.35022157430648804,
-0.2151847928762436,
0.8240700364112854,
0.7579278349876404,
-0.3590887784957886,
-0.21226434409618378,
-0.044094834476709366,
0.49484872817993164,
0.11096438765525818,
-0.09077418595552444,
0.9229732751846313,
0.35686901211738586,
-1.0554144382476807,
0.3023156523704529,
-0.3514207899570465,
0.6896925568580627,
-0.8503367304801941,
0.15427805483341217,
-0.07790710777044296,
0.2010456770658493,
-0.24203991889953613,
-0.9723567962646484,
0.5980370044708252,
0.2671170234680176,
0.09300196915864944,
-0.20554319024085999,
0.5753928422927856,
-0.27086320519447327,
-0.7649112343788147,
-0.10796693712472916,
0.46705126762390137,
0.3717327117919922,
-0.056643903255462646,
-0.1413765549659729,
-0.4745231866836548,
0.058139510452747345,
-0.3784012198448181,
0.27378156781196594,
0.4746045470237732,
0.11269434541463852,
0.7130073308944702,
0.9343006610870361,
0.6495998501777649,
0.19894595444202423,
-0.31699827313423157,
0.786177396774292,
-0.6843210458755493,
-0.4791063964366913,
-0.6135416626930237,
0.21407175064086914,
-0.1615554541349411,
-0.5949856042861938,
0.9170835018157959,
0.42618101835250854,
0.2109372317790985,
0.11124364286661148,
0.8866522312164307,
-0.31486988067626953,
0.638665497303009,
-0.32842156291007996,
0.8537366390228271,
-0.2505388557910919,
0.2957472503185272,
-0.395633727312088,
-0.9391292929649353,
-0.47712767124176025,
0.38217097520828247,
-0.6893316507339478,
-0.11752732843160629,
0.5709168910980225,
0.9503068923950195,
-0.008333304896950722,
0.7247452735900879,
0.1645818054676056,
0.12810687720775604,
0.5596318244934082,
0.15076562762260437,
0.7903620004653931,
-0.25582194328308105,
0.7507335543632507,
0.05032834783196449,
-0.30018359422683716,
-0.43464386463165283,
-1.0687106847763062,
-0.40555253624916077,
-0.7212215065956116,
-0.23022572696208954,
-0.1379385143518448,
0.20358295738697052,
0.7678248882293701,
0.6064937710762024,
-0.7280853390693665,
-0.0842227041721344,
-0.24705475568771362,
-0.38952016830444336,
-0.09957151114940643,
-0.19926294684410095,
0.40267452597618103,
-0.5457375049591064,
-0.6911688446998596,
0.3646826446056366,
0.12989293038845062,
-0.3353128135204315,
-0.14407634735107422,
0.27198848128318787,
-0.09713761508464813,
0.1785351186990738,
0.4550832509994507,
0.45330026745796204,
-0.20325881242752075,
-0.16205869615077972,
0.40255802869796753,
-0.14726336300373077,
-0.009694050997495651,
0.627406656742096,
-0.4459470212459564,
0.5959751009941101,
0.4356617033481598,
0.3630049526691437,
0.5485830307006836,
-0.05489873141050339,
0.4700322449207306,
-0.4225558936595917,
0.005116770509630442,
0.5524253845214844,
0.2929327189922333,
0.3605334460735321,
-0.3617640435695648,
0.7586912512779236,
0.42607414722442627,
-1.3022737503051758,
-0.6189360022544861,
-0.16517314314842224,
-1.0218714475631714,
-0.0313255675137043,
1.0990610122680664,
0.12888547778129578,
-0.27532196044921875,
-0.1762750744819641,
-0.5534096956253052,
-0.025702957063913345,
-0.6121691465377808,
1.2317994832992554,
1.029692530632019,
-0.25565728545188904,
-0.059691619127988815,
-0.9128312468528748,
0.5730475783348083,
0.34679654240608215,
-0.5895684361457825,
0.32041704654693604,
0.5345115661621094,
0.036658428609371185,
0.43534427881240845,
0.24928918480873108,
-0.4117808938026428,
0.13625091314315796,
0.32319140434265137,
-0.07589951902627945,
0.05647450312972069,
0.0442495197057724,
0.26438015699386597,
0.11928586661815643,
0.1261224001646042,
0.241774320602417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17312v1 | Not All Preference Pairs Are Created Equal: A Recipe for Annotation-Efficient Iterative Preference Learning | 2024-06-25T06:49:16 | 2024-06-25T06:49:16 | Sen Yang, Leyang Cui, Deng Cai, Xinting Huang, Shuming Shi, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Iterative preference learning, though yielding superior performances,
requires online annotated preference labels. In this work, we study strategies
to select worth-annotating response pairs for cost-efficient annotation while
achieving competitive or even better performances compared with the random
selection baseline for iterative preference learning. Built on assumptions
regarding uncertainty and distribution shifts, we propose a comparative view to
rank the implicit reward margins as predicted by DPO to select the response
pairs that yield more benefits. Through extensive experiments, we show that
annotating those response pairs with small margins is generally better than
large or random, under both single- and multi-iteration scenarios. Besides, our
empirical results suggest allocating more annotation budgets in the earlier
iterations rather than later across multiple iterations. | [
-0.4896276295185089,
0.21249747276306152,
0.420381098985672,
0.24017366766929626,
-0.3638277053833008,
-0.003777763107791543,
-0.41791868209838867,
-0.5660484433174133,
0.3505030572414398,
0.16662448644638062,
-0.2566564679145813,
-0.09227299690246582,
-0.7784227728843689,
0.007506397552788258,
0.35353201627731323,
1.1515312194824219,
0.14883024990558624,
-0.03793442249298096,
-0.4295872151851654,
-0.4960729479789734,
-0.20262008905410767,
-0.6252636909484863,
-0.8779337406158447,
-0.3925064206123352,
0.8845087885856628,
0.5955997109413147,
0.5580849647521973,
0.7535189390182495,
0.5916681289672852,
0.21889735758304596,
0.04093214496970177,
0.13277845084667206,
-0.5584582090377808,
0.23633451759815216,
0.040025386959314346,
-0.1635061800479889,
-0.1857631355524063,
0.5094561576843262,
0.11745787411928177,
0.671324610710144,
0.0960579439997673,
0.3875918984413147,
-0.10117083042860031,
1.0928332805633545,
-0.996673047542572,
0.19891084730625153,
-0.5606977343559265,
0.04351988062262535,
-0.14845147728919983,
-0.3568355143070221,
-0.5952163934707642,
-0.8065817356109619,
0.47091779112815857,
-1.0889577865600586,
-0.22719235718250275,
0.2893974483013153,
0.7237001657485962,
0.4161047041416168,
0.06924547255039215,
-0.36690637469291687,
-0.5039700269699097,
0.6842000484466553,
-0.19051288068294525,
0.33175206184387207,
0.5877329111099243,
0.3569148778915405,
0.27438390254974365,
-0.5913562178611755,
-0.08790207654237747,
-0.4285363554954529,
-0.0799708291888237,
0.34899210929870605,
0.2878879904747009,
0.11064137518405914,
0.16955822706222534,
0.3732960820198059,
0.045973390340805054,
0.32712844014167786,
-0.32551273703575134,
0.05815035104751587,
0.9348105788230896,
-0.25872623920440674,
-0.31455570459365845,
-0.05071739852428436,
-0.49902841448783875,
-0.44934695959091187,
-0.43001195788383484,
0.6368269324302673,
0.5406292676925659,
0.3742651045322418,
0.10702905058860779,
0.5038161873817444,
-0.34677788615226746,
0.6846604347229004,
0.33496803045272827,
-0.344600111246109,
0.3723069131374359,
0.02984723076224327,
0.013720354065299034,
0.20239831507205963,
0.649476170539856,
0.7022799253463745,
0.5761521458625793,
-0.43384435772895813,
-0.1680927872657776,
-0.16558940708637238,
0.22647446393966675,
-0.5755648612976074,
-0.4067552089691162,
0.2253088355064392,
-0.48976367712020874,
-0.4984303116798401,
-0.1358325034379959,
-0.6940826177597046,
-0.4928259253501892,
-0.507230281829834,
0.6101438403129578,
-0.12670521438121796,
-0.15397843718528748,
-0.0677410438656807,
-0.6903262734413147,
-0.1632024198770523,
0.3183833360671997,
-1.184789776802063,
0.3120182454586029,
0.5806870460510254,
0.7974379658699036,
-0.2659836411476135,
0.005672156810760498,
-0.7594645619392395,
-0.04998607188463211,
-0.3612714111804962,
0.9528098702430725,
-0.7470479607582092,
-0.5168073177337646,
-0.16225065290927887,
-0.6651264429092407,
0.1277875453233719,
-0.5680227279663086,
0.5051563382148743,
-0.6062632203102112,
-0.06829299032688141,
-0.9126583337783813,
-0.6032042503356934,
0.14739400148391724,
0.048409536480903625,
-0.9970428943634033,
1.017196536064148,
0.0772651955485344,
-1.0983405113220215,
1.0770069360733032,
-0.5539407730102539,
-0.22359569370746613,
0.04760025814175606,
0.0024129380472004414,
-0.3317866921424866,
0.1335698962211609,
0.14194165170192719,
0.3935822546482086,
-0.09851822257041931,
-0.17136810719966888,
-0.7056998610496521,
-0.32416918873786926,
0.4762550890445709,
0.1104152575135231,
0.5146910548210144,
0.23443152010440826,
-0.5348536372184753,
0.16830630600452423,
-0.9178435802459717,
0.04761814326047897,
0.13173270225524902,
-0.495708167552948,
-0.6679192185401917,
-0.015269466675817966,
-0.19118615984916687,
-0.05793844535946846,
-0.08712370693683624,
-0.5901670455932617,
0.3763503134250641,
-0.08063901215791702,
0.28616753220558167,
1.4131927490234375,
-0.2765747606754303,
0.8337594270706177,
-0.34941983222961426,
-0.007291181478649378,
-0.3823457360267639,
0.32935404777526855,
0.43856537342071533,
-0.3836653530597687,
-0.7330048680305481,
-0.6016785502433777,
0.598472535610199,
0.0649615004658699,
-0.5644375681877136,
0.008545410819351673,
-0.25259557366371155,
-0.2650023102760315,
-0.8344215750694275,
-0.0657326877117157,
0.30121922492980957,
0.6462887525558472,
0.4886591136455536,
0.0027904680464416742,
-0.27483081817626953,
-0.9591219425201416,
-0.22980400919914246,
-0.3974969983100891,
0.19810102880001068,
0.5135881900787354,
0.10601447522640228,
0.35548070073127747,
0.8601480722427368,
-0.500118613243103,
-0.2457202672958374,
0.013822201639413834,
0.06840045005083084,
-0.3503493368625641,
0.1643480658531189,
0.824832022190094,
-0.9176531434059143,
-0.5733941793441772,
-0.21659913659095764,
-0.3014981150627136,
-0.0832877904176712,
0.013035459443926811,
-0.20749488472938538,
0.2833758592605591,
-0.22123415768146515,
0.10177996754646301,
0.198820561170578,
0.35742896795272827,
0.1480719894170761,
-0.12428078800439835,
-0.22711972892284393,
0.3316669762134552,
-0.6264575719833374,
0.1517767757177353,
0.24804140627384186,
-0.1019308939576149,
-0.23235593736171722,
-0.33187374472618103,
0.05707259103655815,
0.4800294041633606,
-0.07688488811254501,
0.5248621702194214,
-0.3223364055156708,
-0.3316989541053772,
-0.023150136694312096,
0.2543001174926758,
-0.22812578082084656,
0.44293516874313354,
0.5024527907371521,
0.7482579946517944,
0.13867051899433136,
-0.5625975728034973,
0.19574066996574402,
0.28336647152900696,
0.026022573933005333,
0.6392486691474915,
-0.45577672123908997,
0.36192214488983154,
-0.1991393119096756,
0.20710645616054535,
-1.1779710054397583,
-0.220472514629364,
0.3546842634677887,
-0.4671895205974579,
0.15055066347122192,
-0.22999435663223267,
-0.22907105088233948,
-0.22806289792060852,
-0.921538770198822,
0.22244635224342346,
0.5087143182754517,
-1.196739673614502,
0.008248570375144482,
0.43796029686927795,
0.1011163741350174,
-0.8962629437446594,
-0.3936653137207031,
-0.43514466285705566,
-0.40302979946136475,
-0.13216142356395721,
0.12859928607940674,
-0.18372251093387604,
-0.5295758843421936,
-0.11550142616033554,
-0.2187550961971283,
0.26074162125587463,
0.37970906496047974,
0.5850486755371094,
0.2042449563741684,
0.30849212408065796,
0.41429489850997925,
-0.17366041243076324,
-0.6890668272972107,
-0.18986257910728455,
-0.3819175958633423,
0.1291559785604477,
0.06581149250268936,
-0.047390200197696686,
0.03639157488942146,
0.5109223127365112,
0.04949014633893967,
-0.3414328694343567,
0.5727185606956482,
0.31712353229522705,
-0.10600718855857849,
-0.06980719417333603,
-0.7255483269691467,
-0.11691518872976303,
-0.45415937900543213,
-0.3925395905971527,
-0.6008744239807129,
-0.8148455023765564,
0.20346693694591522,
0.051962316036224365,
0.44537389278411865,
0.5585305094718933,
0.263058602809906,
-0.2359071522951126,
0.8334259986877441,
0.5050252079963684,
-0.049923576414585114,
0.5414409637451172,
-0.22784650325775146,
-0.0025027082301676273,
-0.7177817821502686,
-0.30420660972595215,
-0.576991617679596,
-0.5556495785713196,
-0.7002384066581726,
0.04202965646982193,
0.5327970385551453,
-0.01333882287144661,
-0.29151761531829834,
-0.12752878665924072,
-0.8894864916801453,
0.35113048553466797,
1.1585506200790405,
0.2791212499141693,
0.36583682894706726,
0.16612066328525543,
-0.04360569640994072,
-0.21712885797023773,
-0.45415380597114563,
-0.2931489050388336,
1.4122898578643799,
0.054557692259550095,
0.48070842027664185,
-0.04571302980184555,
0.8952662348747253,
0.059366773813962936,
0.4616854786872864,
-0.7287753820419312,
0.13787591457366943,
-0.09193053096532822,
-0.3295848071575165,
-0.18228872120380402,
-0.25135475397109985,
-0.7133110165596008,
0.14432761073112488,
-0.5453875660896301,
-0.8745216727256775,
0.24698179960250854,
0.5588564276695251,
-0.7427123785018921,
0.3212914764881134,
-0.6159073114395142,
0.4596139192581177,
-0.36218106746673584,
-0.5710881948471069,
-0.12114247679710388,
-0.896493136882782,
-0.22599783539772034,
0.2564447522163391,
-0.1931564211845398,
-0.25074368715286255,
-0.13852357864379883,
0.8550140857696533,
-0.07255152612924576,
0.26685017347335815,
-0.2636445164680481,
0.39202770590782166,
0.026266885921359062,
-0.3041081726551056,
0.2445569634437561,
0.3540302515029907,
-0.45785611867904663,
-0.056714463979005814,
-0.32653751969337463,
-0.32910099625587463,
-0.21550819277763367,
0.7953748106956482,
-0.8355730175971985,
-0.5692136287689209,
-0.5244788527488708,
-0.3113085627555847,
-0.2464061677455902,
-0.17201285064220428,
0.5003367066383362,
0.34348446130752563,
0.31730204820632935,
0.07607825845479965,
0.5986992716789246,
0.05326128378510475,
0.6998822689056396,
-0.062192339450120926,
0.1996912956237793,
-0.7959240078926086,
0.7010443806648254,
0.4239225387573242,
0.5145772695541382,
0.4761500954627991,
0.4233047366142273,
-0.495416522026062,
-0.5373703837394714,
-0.569932758808136,
0.0390431210398674,
-0.7901537418365479,
-0.03628041595220566,
-0.7271634936332703,
0.40746989846229553,
-0.31244030594825745,
-0.5310805439949036,
-0.5609002113342285,
-0.8575649261474609,
0.07439953088760376,
-0.5252106189727783,
0.8613163828849792,
0.5197349190711975,
-0.7165070176124573,
0.02000710926949978,
-0.18198904395103455,
0.2169780731201172,
0.6968972086906433,
0.5519564747810364,
-0.07915899157524109,
0.05721908062696457,
0.06745357811450958,
-0.11745574325323105,
-0.11123476922512054,
-0.7869616746902466,
-0.08053740113973618,
-0.142381489276886,
0.7150300145149231,
0.25808101892471313,
0.47843924164772034,
0.8188573718070984,
-0.07370846718549728,
0.5787404775619507,
0.04385164752602577,
-0.5959276556968689,
0.4618862569332123,
0.0460549034178257,
-0.259491890668869,
1.0366954803466797,
0.8333191871643066,
-0.22523576021194458,
0.25597748160362244,
-0.70449298620224,
-1.2295217514038086,
0.7550275325775146,
0.13018430769443512,
-0.23114576935768127,
0.061806436628103256,
0.5994787812232971,
0.5754714608192444,
0.4703485369682312,
-0.6919968724250793,
-0.6606664061546326,
-0.24116282165050507,
0.07956304401159286,
-0.25943711400032043,
-0.25625118613243103,
-0.4670514762401581,
-0.1938362568616867,
0.6061989665031433,
-0.2917173206806183,
0.3306039273738861,
0.31010201573371887,
0.019979087635874748,
-0.151096910238266,
0.046763014048337936,
0.3105064034461975,
0.4883955121040344,
-0.5374543070793152,
0.18604537844657898,
0.036522574722766876,
0.12275765091180801,
0.16914385557174683,
0.1672830879688263,
-0.0129132941365242,
-0.16116857528686523,
0.06732568144798279,
1.173269271850586,
0.06523119658231735,
-0.3471762537956238,
0.5716318488121033,
-0.09861966222524643,
-0.04469478502869606,
-0.15794047713279724,
-0.16331063210964203,
0.036250922828912735,
0.19681113958358765,
0.29963982105255127,
0.08918029069900513,
0.4742336571216583,
-0.4255409240722656,
-0.01386828999966383,
0.47070929408073425,
-0.37052059173583984,
0.09404465556144714,
0.6500347256660461,
0.40912100672721863,
-0.22076542675495148,
0.40224045515060425,
-0.19833028316497803,
-0.5506286025047302,
0.3883167505264282,
0.19807180762290955,
0.6811267733573914,
0.20306505262851715,
0.4677616059780121,
0.6516354084014893,
-0.09165191650390625,
-0.34142810106277466,
-0.08050128072500229,
-0.7248896956443787,
-0.3392820358276367,
0.1424560695886612,
-0.2672770619392395,
-0.6887645721435547,
-0.22924384474754333,
-0.9732066988945007,
0.15459062159061432,
-0.5755296945571899,
-0.22924752533435822,
0.2933804392814636,
-0.02227257378399372,
-0.7113727927207947,
0.2721844017505646,
0.22697938978672028,
0.5443825721740723,
-0.6553073525428772,
0.3535838723182678,
0.8529424667358398,
-0.5944612622261047,
-0.847786545753479,
-0.16995683312416077,
-0.09977341443300247,
-0.9561684131622314,
0.9898511171340942,
0.37445586919784546,
-0.019003834575414658,
-0.15709306299686432,
-0.22625449299812317,
-0.7497864365577698,
0.9284093379974365,
0.26189124584198,
-0.3946719765663147,
0.13242973387241364,
-0.017304066568613052,
0.25611233711242676,
-0.257259726524353,
0.8537604808807373,
0.5489975810050964,
0.4742073714733124,
0.33269116282463074,
-0.9878215789794922,
-0.11384924501180649,
-0.10597260296344757,
-0.005458313971757889,
0.24853335320949554,
-1.0984416007995605,
0.5966797471046448,
-0.5089429616928101,
0.04045037552714348,
-0.20283132791519165,
0.23544877767562866,
0.2927999496459961,
0.5424644351005554,
0.6737334728240967,
0.5658637285232544,
0.7405073046684265,
-0.26773717999458313,
1.0683715343475342,
0.07803502678871155,
0.24639564752578735,
1.0361809730529785,
-0.026333831250667572,
0.9465023279190063,
0.6975522637367249,
-0.09411083161830902,
0.08872893452644348,
1.2041113376617432,
0.374019593000412,
1.0372446775436401,
0.27880752086639404,
-0.043392881751060486,
-0.543813943862915,
-0.15366072952747345,
-0.4675378203392029,
-0.07337583601474762,
-0.025923840701580048,
-0.20392051339149475,
0.020926060155034065,
-0.13501104712486267,
0.04851311072707176,
0.1545058786869049,
-0.2547053098678589,
1.1362074613571167,
-0.01389401126652956,
-0.955266535282135,
0.33090052008628845,
-0.4931945502758026,
0.8104201555252075,
-0.2515206038951874,
0.11241133511066437,
-0.33472752571105957,
0.2520582973957062,
-0.24276703596115112,
-0.7433027029037476,
-0.21816469728946686,
-0.24475404620170593,
-0.08439638465642929,
-0.3138478100299835,
0.4741390645503998,
-0.15472100675106049,
-0.043380625545978546,
0.5132056474685669,
-0.12895381450653076,
-0.3687328100204468,
-0.0010339651489630342,
-0.49798503518104553,
0.10750628262758255,
-0.05471806973218918,
-0.553224503993988,
0.28371596336364746,
-0.0015212170546874404,
-0.12161393463611603,
0.7103676795959473,
0.5792840123176575,
0.15314215421676636,
0.20058338344097137,
-0.14721356332302094,
0.7755001187324524,
-0.25139522552490234,
-0.6333260536193848,
-0.7250139117240906,
0.8384723663330078,
-0.7592930197715759,
-0.47320929169654846,
0.5359522700309753,
0.3595768213272095,
1.074478268623352,
0.1328909546136856,
0.8616657853126526,
0.15512675046920776,
0.34815770387649536,
-0.3343797028064728,
0.031096652150154114,
-0.619788646697998,
0.1730787456035614,
-0.20420633256435394,
-0.7087714672088623,
-0.15450261533260345,
0.9135870933532715,
-0.4753609895706177,
0.0183469969779253,
0.47912704944610596,
0.04280567914247513,
0.28717106580734253,
0.17770425975322723,
-0.08616186678409576,
-0.4745766818523407,
0.2862350344657898,
0.6931134462356567,
0.6272793412208557,
-0.2672164738178253,
0.20500120520591736,
-0.8614815473556519,
-0.5054309964179993,
-0.3160824179649353,
-0.9934848546981812,
-0.9642392992973328,
-0.7362821698188782,
-0.43861836194992065,
-0.37716007232666016,
0.38846343755722046,
1.5049861669540405,
0.8838803768157959,
-0.5535863041877747,
-0.04261857643723488,
0.39117610454559326,
-0.1705234795808792,
-0.3518185019493103,
-0.11897482722997665,
0.29208627343177795,
-0.5750585198402405,
-0.7395564913749695,
-0.21492591500282288,
0.37540364265441895,
-0.03675131872296333,
0.09830078482627869,
-0.10902157425880432,
0.021019676700234413,
-0.011420032009482384,
0.3027641177177429,
0.31127697229385376,
-0.5382018685340881,
-0.5595144629478455,
-0.06860556453466415,
-0.060048796236515045,
0.34219419956207275,
0.7411007881164551,
-0.7293331027030945,
0.7216094732284546,
0.5432639122009277,
1.0113227367401123,
0.7379375100135803,
0.007951478473842144,
0.4479295611381531,
-0.503825306892395,
0.2656739056110382,
0.08490640670061111,
0.23106004297733307,
0.47709110379219055,
-0.37964171171188354,
0.9325196146965027,
0.21220189332962036,
-0.626781165599823,
-0.8154363632202148,
0.034472379833459854,
-1.3152194023132324,
-0.016245733946561813,
1.5008049011230469,
-0.2377040982246399,
0.22046919167041779,
0.3345464766025543,
-0.356388658285141,
0.09940015524625778,
-0.7190876007080078,
1.1150307655334473,
0.5126239657402039,
-0.36306384205818176,
0.14099645614624023,
-0.2700672745704651,
0.9099085927009583,
0.5242365002632141,
-0.669090211391449,
-0.04906085878610611,
0.31812936067581177,
0.1652112752199173,
0.3472349941730499,
0.8194276690483093,
0.326498806476593,
0.26380062103271484,
-0.10287709534168243,
-0.10601344704627991,
-0.25657156109809875,
-0.3457315266132355,
-0.07914411276578903,
0.3993072509765625,
0.6137421131134033,
-0.7260231375694275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17305v1 | Retrieval Augmented Instruction Tuning for Open NER with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T06:24:50 | 2024-06-25T06:24:50 | Tingyu Xie, Jian Zhang, Yan Zhang, Yuanyuan Liang, Qi Li, Hongwei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The strong capability of large language models (LLMs) has been applied to
information extraction (IE) through either retrieval augmented prompting or
instruction tuning (IT). However, the best way to incorporate information with
LLMs for IE remains an open question. In this paper, we explore Retrieval
Augmented Instruction Tuning (RA-IT) for IE, focusing on the task of open named
entity recognition (NER). Specifically, for each training sample, we retrieve
semantically similar examples from the training dataset as the context and
prepend them to the input of the original instruction. To evaluate our RA-IT
approach more thoroughly, we construct a Chinese IT dataset for open NER and
evaluate RA-IT in both English and Chinese scenarios. Experimental results
verify the effectiveness of RA-IT across various data sizes and in both English
and Chinese scenarios. We also conduct thorough studies to explore the impacts
of various retrieval strategies in the proposed RA-IT framework. Code and data
are available at: https://github.com/Emma1066/Retrieval-Augmented-IT-OpenNER | [
-0.2956942915916443,
-0.7168933749198914,
0.26489460468292236,
0.015059079974889755,
-0.2323046326637268,
-0.23111788928508759,
-0.8021825551986694,
-0.5874453186988831,
0.2758098840713501,
0.5801878571510315,
-0.29071667790412903,
-0.5214646458625793,
-0.46816807985305786,
0.29872754216194153,
-0.29155442118644714,
0.9810969829559326,
-0.07313619554042816,
0.2462577223777771,
0.16101956367492676,
-0.0012091362150385976,
-0.5685566067695618,
-0.17750579118728638,
-0.8447386622428894,
-0.19775845110416412,
0.5208704471588135,
0.7683935761451721,
0.32084426283836365,
0.9632899761199951,
0.6265625357627869,
0.19169601798057556,
0.1289484053850174,
0.43755945563316345,
-0.3806565999984741,
0.03577978536486626,
-0.3696202337741852,
-0.3376023471355438,
-0.23769181966781616,
-0.11104456335306168,
0.9706717729568481,
0.3675785958766937,
-0.19304974377155304,
0.2846514582633972,
0.01968548260629177,
0.4997056722640991,
-0.8627018928527832,
0.1482279896736145,
-0.8822942972183228,
-0.010770310647785664,
-0.38975805044174194,
-0.5228250026702881,
-0.8602056503295898,
-0.24417231976985931,
0.14176416397094727,
-0.7234436869621277,
0.21748675405979156,
0.4401136338710785,
1.3505065441131592,
0.09307180345058441,
-0.15364903211593628,
-0.2876757085323334,
-0.8468590378761292,
0.8738210201263428,
-0.6321035623550415,
0.45702069997787476,
0.532413899898529,
0.24063582718372345,
-0.14357705414295197,
-0.6150760054588318,
-0.4787003993988037,
-0.17351000010967255,
-0.11932971328496933,
0.06335476785898209,
-0.06848033517599106,
0.06092153862118721,
0.43970099091529846,
0.6589396595954895,
-0.3561929166316986,
0.414095401763916,
-0.33226442337036133,
-0.082392118871212,
0.47225165367126465,
-0.032392606139183044,
0.5032548904418945,
0.005356904584914446,
-0.35837867856025696,
-0.15407399833202362,
-0.8553791642189026,
-0.10427596420049667,
0.18038339912891388,
0.6981983184814453,
0.1844540685415268,
0.7568891644477844,
-0.13995441794395447,
0.869602382183075,
0.230636328458786,
-0.0006450241198763251,
0.2125101238489151,
-0.10244110971689224,
-0.21036702394485474,
0.4331214129924774,
0.6130275130271912,
0.0594937726855278,
0.41528868675231934,
-0.3046911954879761,
-0.5606667399406433,
-0.5626656413078308,
0.21687154471874237,
-0.9154307842254639,
-0.2251073569059372,
-0.21625609695911407,
-0.28654804825782776,
0.21979832649230957,
0.5319015383720398,
-0.7124312520027161,
-0.06199532747268677,
-0.4786422848701477,
0.6763102412223816,
-0.6468331217765808,
-0.27887773513793945,
0.13730746507644653,
0.04763811081647873,
0.5949233770370483,
0.3178635239601135,
-0.9991562962532043,
0.13153499364852905,
0.6851370930671692,
0.611365020275116,
-0.3005443811416626,
-0.03885214030742645,
-1.1390950679779053,
0.33660027384757996,
-0.20174743235111237,
0.7302758693695068,
-0.9846670627593994,
-0.13833573460578918,
-0.11391047388315201,
0.1871277242898941,
-0.46511733531951904,
-0.7761154770851135,
0.39788302779197693,
-1.0292943716049194,
0.27790480852127075,
-0.15035924315452576,
-0.6955301761627197,
-0.1545947790145874,
0.28926098346710205,
-0.9798597693443298,
1.0944448709487915,
-0.104474738240242,
-0.726561963558197,
0.3446377217769623,
-0.7450045347213745,
-0.5662164688110352,
0.17590589821338654,
-0.24083974957466125,
-0.33266353607177734,
0.15733855962753296,
0.4609663486480713,
0.2500592768192291,
-0.35363343358039856,
-0.13619470596313477,
-0.018753865733742714,
-0.6305409669876099,
-0.15515807271003723,
-0.3207387328147888,
0.5336824059486389,
0.13390196859836578,
-0.27562758326530457,
-0.11417010426521301,
-0.8244504332542419,
0.3473406732082367,
0.05449870228767395,
-0.6015695929527283,
-0.7417140007019043,
-0.1821502447128296,
-0.22375836968421936,
-0.2618182897567749,
0.25805777311325073,
-0.7121695876121521,
0.4223105013370514,
-0.5224315524101257,
0.23803971707820892,
0.7290105819702148,
0.215580552816391,
0.441967248916626,
0.15274348855018616,
0.3987922668457031,
-0.0908941999077797,
-0.158793643116951,
-0.1780604124069214,
-0.15597748756408691,
-0.7630141377449036,
-0.4559996426105499,
0.8568609952926636,
0.6537588238716125,
-0.9940184950828552,
0.33393001556396484,
-0.41443610191345215,
-0.07281163334846497,
-0.7921358346939087,
-0.029536418616771698,
0.4224582612514496,
0.5334457755088806,
0.4859547019004822,
0.07355896383523941,
-0.5716456770896912,
-0.7200852632522583,
-0.24792850017547607,
0.12814795970916748,
-0.07311274111270905,
0.49468427896499634,
0.36406630277633667,
0.05368923768401146,
0.7130730748176575,
-0.39018189907073975,
-0.3837980628013611,
-0.12302179634571075,
0.11940368264913559,
0.2053116410970688,
0.3659224808216095,
0.12314842641353607,
-0.7745153903961182,
-0.5157825350761414,
0.34827154874801636,
-0.6781316995620728,
0.08247719705104828,
0.11163084954023361,
-0.1967838555574417,
0.11708027869462967,
0.5032836198806763,
-0.35971003770828247,
0.4782992899417877,
0.1306672990322113,
0.15289178490638733,
0.34142088890075684,
-0.25036099553108215,
0.3838699460029602,
-1.1876955032348633,
0.12909618020057678,
0.08315295726060867,
0.10480660200119019,
-0.28327634930610657,
0.2643801271915436,
0.31436172127723694,
0.03557036817073822,
-0.25599583983421326,
0.6876403093338013,
-1.0171854496002197,
-0.1817946434020996,
-0.31037837266921997,
0.30024221539497375,
-0.06324352324008942,
0.15542452037334442,
0.23084621131420135,
1.1632651090621948,
0.48053422570228577,
-0.8566354513168335,
0.09378491342067719,
0.1465771347284317,
-0.695220947265625,
0.319619357585907,
-0.5467520356178284,
0.3814433217048645,
-0.1954255849123001,
-0.3019355833530426,
-0.45060479640960693,
-0.34292346239089966,
0.07999828457832336,
-0.29308944940567017,
0.7608979344367981,
-0.07476811856031418,
-0.635369598865509,
-0.22272078692913055,
-0.08234833925962448,
0.29444143176078796,
0.16894219815731049,
-1.0594518184661865,
0.7307698130607605,
0.22049103677272797,
0.08744848519563675,
-0.8503642678260803,
-0.4133266806602478,
0.0017517519881948829,
-0.2423778474330902,
-0.4329993426799774,
0.674949049949646,
0.11077926307916641,
-0.1923826038837433,
0.14666934311389923,
-0.2189479023218155,
-0.1969999521970749,
-0.010463484562933445,
-0.08292032033205032,
0.3517298102378845,
-0.6404991745948792,
0.3484986126422882,
0.031374428421258926,
-0.09688431024551392,
-0.29871147871017456,
-0.1289796680212021,
0.3552355170249939,
-0.019426152110099792,
-0.31137871742248535,
-0.3449551463127136,
0.18598896265029907,
0.0034524884540587664,
-0.7370063662528992,
0.8788791298866272,
0.7477115988731384,
-0.5108354687690735,
-0.39234262704849243,
-0.4905877113342285,
-0.30861175060272217,
-0.4690703749656677,
0.37800782918930054,
-0.5866193771362305,
-0.8845396637916565,
0.275178998708725,
-0.154809832572937,
0.2378564476966858,
0.24571457505226135,
0.18255764245986938,
0.1304856389760971,
1.0707250833511353,
0.8005889654159546,
-0.254955530166626,
0.8824012279510498,
-0.22047516703605652,
0.2534860372543335,
-1.0901883840560913,
-0.13117468357086182,
-0.643388032913208,
-0.25586453080177307,
-0.3210884630680084,
-0.11201648414134979,
0.3694024085998535,
0.3509484529495239,
-0.1109325960278511,
0.41403815150260925,
-0.4172472357749939,
0.8125808835029602,
0.6146982908248901,
0.3171060085296631,
0.3667762577533722,
0.33638009428977966,
-0.012106640264391899,
-0.146364226937294,
-0.4934161603450775,
-0.3976662755012512,
0.8427961468696594,
-0.02728305570781231,
0.7994198203086853,
0.13821102678775787,
0.8184142112731934,
0.002266921103000641,
0.1933799833059311,
-0.8447092771530151,
0.5233957767486572,
-0.3672598600387573,
-0.3729819059371948,
-0.20329943299293518,
-0.47778263688087463,
-1.1102420091629028,
-0.097110316157341,
-0.256155788898468,
-0.8910700082778931,
-0.11017738282680511,
-0.007728966884315014,
-0.32332170009613037,
0.36323732137680054,
-0.6718912124633789,
0.5513136386871338,
-0.19036591053009033,
-0.30654871463775635,
-0.09950990974903107,
-0.3469972610473633,
0.27406370639801025,
0.145058274269104,
-0.14815503358840942,
0.26047876477241516,
-0.08398937433958054,
0.633722722530365,
-0.147525817155838,
0.29538261890411377,
-0.10258126258850098,
-0.04863540083169937,
0.1205873191356659,
-0.22896920144557953,
0.6753461360931396,
0.0007930637220852077,
-0.5069968700408936,
0.10318039357662201,
-0.29480352997779846,
-0.11945115774869919,
-0.7460998296737671,
0.8437393307685852,
-0.7707114219665527,
-0.6441107392311096,
-0.11859778314828873,
-0.40420001745224,
0.017753511667251587,
0.48988211154937744,
0.4187253713607788,
0.5256868600845337,
-0.016366582363843918,
0.3587726056575775,
1.1274151802062988,
-0.3357662260532379,
0.4125930964946747,
0.8998509645462036,
-0.14630402624607086,
-0.3659525513648987,
1.1863749027252197,
0.22657127678394318,
0.0612458735704422,
0.8257811069488525,
0.00021688755077775568,
-0.046288181096315384,
-0.5450596809387207,
-0.7028490900993347,
0.35357534885406494,
-0.5574092268943787,
-0.3353695571422577,
-0.38585183024406433,
-0.5154265761375427,
-0.1999989151954651,
0.3960093557834625,
-0.2666299343109131,
-0.11656494438648224,
-0.662194013595581,
-0.09591031074523926,
0.5110333561897278,
0.6377720832824707,
0.17268677055835724,
0.11242401599884033,
-0.8950484395027161,
0.21853207051753998,
-0.19233335554599762,
0.5665627717971802,
-0.04587775468826294,
-0.6607760787010193,
-0.5372136831283569,
0.00032107136212289333,
0.08916909992694855,
-0.7797358632087708,
0.2659507393836975,
0.5608397126197815,
0.7147376537322998,
0.42274758219718933,
0.25085869431495667,
0.8525559902191162,
-0.6928972005844116,
0.4782383441925049,
-0.4326998293399811,
-0.5813779234886169,
0.7126786112785339,
-0.005036074668169022,
0.08028464764356613,
0.6861458420753479,
0.5228673219680786,
-0.05807054042816162,
0.05291839689016342,
-0.131118044257164,
-0.8935272097587585,
0.9666845202445984,
-0.1614764779806137,
-0.036063797771930695,
-0.3119543492794037,
0.6971824765205383,
0.12461075186729431,
-0.038371581584215164,
-0.5920909643173218,
-0.270058810710907,
0.379556804895401,
-0.2531306743621826,
0.27832701802253723,
-0.1591869294643402,
0.17376528680324554,
-0.13315680623054504,
0.941742479801178,
0.0017607772024348378,
0.2579011917114258,
0.07862141728401184,
-0.3468147814273834,
-0.2296382039785385,
0.3313203454017639,
0.18365956842899323,
0.3174179792404175,
-0.13189390301704407,
-0.07636882364749908,
0.012945153750479221,
-0.5075522065162659,
-0.3084021806716919,
0.23222438991069794,
-0.30168822407722473,
0.025998555123806,
0.2306751161813736,
0.9448064565658569,
0.23801444470882416,
-0.6309685111045837,
0.2959081530570984,
-0.22308553755283356,
0.06707543879747391,
-0.3580998182296753,
0.304913192987442,
-0.3938904106616974,
0.23667991161346436,
0.32519224286079407,
-0.2995915412902832,
0.1266714632511139,
-0.3040357828140259,
0.24080054461956024,
0.5884644985198975,
-0.27957889437675476,
-0.14921869337558746,
0.351767897605896,
-0.15092796087265015,
-0.5373411178588867,
1.1682331562042236,
-0.18329687416553497,
-0.20550647377967834,
0.46262630820274353,
0.7947827577590942,
0.8784454464912415,
-0.2884712815284729,
-0.09055814892053604,
0.803834080696106,
0.44222259521484375,
-0.14996148645877838,
0.36000582575798035,
-0.1727762520313263,
-0.6936129927635193,
-0.5757244229316711,
-0.5734254121780396,
-0.32834309339523315,
0.3192058205604553,
-1.2307432889938354,
0.6566089987754822,
-0.28986266255378723,
0.12714795768260956,
-0.01580071821808815,
-0.04561378434300423,
-0.6069649457931519,
0.018403327092528343,
0.03874668478965759,
1.079844355583191,
-0.3806571662425995,
0.9531261920928955,
0.9354777336120605,
-0.4825180470943451,
-1.0683284997940063,
0.13665960729122162,
-0.33206722140312195,
-0.9240188002586365,
0.7849681973457336,
0.35851752758026123,
0.007789980620145798,
0.33570700883865356,
-0.523909330368042,
-1.091723918914795,
1.1898202896118164,
0.36112311482429504,
-0.7657608985900879,
-0.2594030201435089,
-0.14214590191841125,
0.3129008710384369,
-0.3344968259334564,
0.49311521649360657,
0.4791505038738251,
0.4473901093006134,
0.04581557959318161,
-0.9686135053634644,
-0.19761066138744354,
-0.3944862186908722,
-0.16136184334754944,
0.5362235903739929,
-0.4529803395271301,
0.8030698895454407,
-0.4180910885334015,
-0.6612194776535034,
0.2039773017168045,
0.6852040886878967,
0.053660403937101364,
0.13255268335342407,
0.4209783971309662,
0.6632711887359619,
0.7609896063804626,
-0.04854594171047211,
0.8572816252708435,
-0.41924917697906494,
0.021035466343164444,
1.3989808559417725,
-0.3673489987850189,
1.1806658506393433,
0.2357134371995926,
0.268954336643219,
0.5123839378356934,
0.5804436802864075,
-0.09319615364074707,
0.5266398787498474,
0.02353890985250473,
-0.2633867859840393,
-0.17106057703495026,
-0.2460249364376068,
-0.37662747502326965,
0.5967679023742676,
0.487202525138855,
-0.5158183574676514,
-0.29650434851646423,
0.38403576612472534,
-0.12747016549110413,
0.10321322083473206,
-0.572891891002655,
1.1585828065872192,
-0.04740897938609123,
-0.7135663032531738,
0.48998260498046875,
0.1772608906030655,
0.4883403182029724,
-0.5762233138084412,
-0.5523911714553833,
0.0684947744011879,
0.2367715984582901,
-0.20634043216705322,
-0.606727659702301,
0.029535531997680664,
0.11185342073440552,
-0.412654846906662,
-0.05032254755496979,
0.7196311354637146,
-0.573765218257904,
-0.19678330421447754,
0.29183229804039,
0.16459080576896667,
0.3102319538593292,
-0.01667589135468006,
-0.5104572772979736,
0.07620682567358017,
0.12529048323631287,
-0.43421876430511475,
0.5784511566162109,
0.6373423933982849,
-0.07592212408781052,
0.42092621326446533,
0.3607795834541321,
0.18129298090934753,
0.1277826577425003,
0.1410379558801651,
0.8051670789718628,
-0.7992962598800659,
-0.20559290051460266,
-0.8123455047607422,
0.22748593986034393,
-0.0873546376824379,
-0.17718245089054108,
0.9427127838134766,
0.6061267852783203,
1.0316965579986572,
0.1717473566532135,
0.45640069246292114,
-0.052563220262527466,
0.6288038492202759,
-0.8936933875083923,
0.37062495946884155,
-0.5323816537857056,
0.5572834014892578,
-0.14133873581886292,
-1.051482081413269,
-0.00575464079156518,
0.6031501293182373,
-0.5562589168548584,
-0.03910406678915024,
0.48793163895606995,
0.9197400212287903,
-0.10645245760679245,
0.35889482498168945,
0.07577071338891983,
0.07383763790130615,
0.09799227118492126,
0.5297825932502747,
0.5882450342178345,
-0.4913693368434906,
0.42709052562713623,
-0.26921263337135315,
-0.20753909647464752,
-0.08398023247718811,
-0.8839277625083923,
-0.7940317392349243,
-0.33891063928604126,
-0.2938348054885864,
-0.22117291390895844,
0.08721083402633667,
1.0929008722305298,
0.45093902945518494,
-0.8638282418251038,
0.08046422898769379,
0.12737175822257996,
0.09262966364622116,
-0.23386991024017334,
-0.348402202129364,
0.49252739548683167,
-0.32899680733680725,
-0.8948037028312683,
0.6440434455871582,
0.2630460560321808,
-0.28267401456832886,
0.20882104337215424,
0.11740829795598984,
-0.3666846454143524,
-0.22914426028728485,
0.44665390253067017,
0.4860275983810425,
-0.5994312763214111,
-0.5613338351249695,
0.3455416262149811,
0.0060143377631902695,
0.0567738376557827,
0.6683337092399597,
-0.6791518330574036,
0.7503234148025513,
0.18133200705051422,
1.0598543882369995,
0.36875954270362854,
0.04065381735563278,
0.5475225448608398,
-0.9024370908737183,
-0.17178194224834442,
0.12799562513828278,
0.31596699357032776,
0.2643669843673706,
-0.5148225426673889,
0.5515242218971252,
-0.19100485742092133,
-0.5549095273017883,
-0.9586642384529114,
-0.1094854399561882,
-0.7773022055625916,
0.0690191462635994,
1.1081193685531616,
-0.25727933645248413,
-0.28668901324272156,
0.26387616991996765,
-0.2500896751880646,
0.307289183139801,
-0.4363105595111847,
0.5815260410308838,
0.5904383063316345,
-0.04687345772981644,
-0.238900288939476,
-0.6150054335594177,
0.1002909243106842,
0.22762329876422882,
-0.6039607524871826,
-0.022434303537011147,
0.3857482075691223,
0.21060296893119812,
0.06111420691013336,
0.3366575837135315,
-0.1115524172782898,
0.3157108426094055,
-0.2829534709453583,
0.15973205864429474,
-0.27679991722106934,
-0.49488380551338196,
-0.34025976061820984,
-0.047743067145347595,
0.17029273509979248,
-0.34623298048973083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17304v1 | Leveraging LLMs for Dialogue Quality Measurement | 2024-06-25T06:19:47 | 2024-06-25T06:19:47 | Jinghan Jia, Abi Komma, Timothy Leffel, Xujun Peng, Ajay Nagesh, Tamer Soliman, Aram Galstyan, Anoop Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In task-oriented conversational AI evaluation, unsupervised methods poorly
correlate with human judgments, and supervised approaches lack generalization.
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) show robust zeroshot and
few-shot capabilities across NLP tasks. This paper explores using LLMs for
automated dialogue quality evaluation, experimenting with various
configurations on public and proprietary datasets. Manipulating factors such as
model size, in-context examples, and selection techniques, we examine
"chain-of-thought" (CoT) reasoning and label extraction procedures. Our results
show that (1) larger models yield more accurate dialogue labels; (2)
algorithmic selection of in-context examples outperforms random selection; (3)
CoT reasoning where an LLM is asked to provide justifications before outputting
final labels improves performance; and (4) fine-tuned LLMs outperform
out-of-the-box ones. Our results indicate that LLMs that are suitably
fine-tuned and have sufficient reasoning capabilities can be leveraged for
automated dialogue evaluation. | [
-0.6022664308547974,
-0.7505126595497131,
0.8363733291625977,
-0.07924312353134155,
-0.35187432169914246,
0.32676172256469727,
-0.23815719783306122,
-0.4416937232017517,
-0.03429020941257477,
0.756767988204956,
-0.3822305500507355,
-0.6328286528587341,
-0.6338348984718323,
0.22864139080047607,
-0.45233047008514404,
0.9575241208076477,
0.02069723978638649,
0.1759813129901886,
-0.36943596601486206,
-0.1652246117591858,
-0.35216933488845825,
-0.5195367932319641,
-0.5557937026023865,
-0.5385987758636475,
0.3825131356716156,
0.2874203622341156,
0.91404789686203,
0.48410388827323914,
0.4182322323322296,
0.3750521242618561,
-0.14437435567378998,
0.4524655342102051,
-0.4001351296901703,
0.14856520295143127,
-0.16171452403068542,
-0.4473983645439148,
-0.5946095585823059,
0.258469820022583,
0.5466495156288147,
0.815797746181488,
0.12393215298652649,
0.3112742602825165,
0.21273577213287354,
0.35406768321990967,
-0.6166383028030396,
0.21132217347621918,
-0.6870077252388,
0.049892619252204895,
0.3657435476779938,
-0.2627606689929962,
-0.3637361526489258,
-0.34237900376319885,
0.37155017256736755,
-0.30288246273994446,
-0.14171993732452393,
0.18270637094974518,
0.8597080707550049,
0.46990862488746643,
-0.3706403374671936,
-0.5058783888816833,
-0.8560110330581665,
0.9577187895774841,
-1.0616408586502075,
0.14998045563697815,
0.5067228674888611,
0.30962809920310974,
-0.26854223012924194,
-0.5415909290313721,
-0.48197829723358154,
-0.5797907114028931,
-0.04278984293341637,
0.0809924528002739,
-0.26978203654289246,
0.33411791920661926,
0.18088287115097046,
0.491770476102829,
-0.21198652684688568,
0.38219740986824036,
-0.06431266665458679,
-0.24481719732284546,
0.674836277961731,
0.37540289759635925,
0.17095929384231567,
-0.2093224674463272,
-0.2607628107070923,
-0.04114745929837227,
-0.5358173251152039,
0.07324546575546265,
0.31290608644485474,
0.13902825117111206,
0.1678560972213745,
0.6041706800460815,
-0.09735926985740662,
0.913363516330719,
0.006781110540032387,
-0.29875415563583374,
-0.12473707646131516,
-0.5017332434654236,
-0.5291938185691833,
-0.21908198297023773,
0.9981471300125122,
0.5202690958976746,
0.1391461342573166,
-0.12170346826314926,
-0.37016797065734863,
-0.07177670300006866,
0.16210462152957916,
-0.6005376577377319,
-0.07944677025079727,
0.35015302896499634,
-0.37181827425956726,
-0.2936577796936035,
-0.19989097118377686,
-0.5365079641342163,
-0.20700593292713165,
-0.6063297390937805,
0.31196069717407227,
-0.16672100126743317,
0.12643346190452576,
-0.09234797954559326,
-0.05658222362399101,
0.060040105134248734,
0.5344765186309814,
-0.5404698252677917,
0.29029151797294617,
0.7864875197410583,
0.6585982441902161,
-0.5145567655563354,
0.0788140818476677,
-0.7777281999588013,
-0.23397432267665863,
-0.6339513063430786,
0.8412735462188721,
-0.41000908613204956,
-0.35397017002105713,
-0.0496145598590374,
-0.2770807445049286,
-0.056924279779195786,
-0.7421197891235352,
0.5161078572273254,
-0.35171911120414734,
0.28855395317077637,
0.1145140528678894,
-0.7276336550712585,
-0.0795210674405098,
0.5788316130638123,
-0.42946505546569824,
0.8468343615531921,
0.20717179775238037,
-0.34186819195747375,
0.33743318915367126,
-0.33660244941711426,
-0.07707741111516953,
0.13850539922714233,
-0.22650909423828125,
-0.2178131341934204,
0.1575605720281601,
0.4389629065990448,
0.4921426475048065,
-0.5099676251411438,
0.4574076533317566,
-0.2696387469768524,
-0.47050940990448,
0.6352531909942627,
-0.8106657266616821,
0.5425275564193726,
0.31672659516334534,
-0.17609915137290955,
0.2901441156864166,
-0.6182108521461487,
0.36158502101898193,
-0.3499261438846588,
-0.2541010081768036,
-0.025605039671063423,
-0.13002228736877441,
-0.3450927734375,
0.18950255215168,
0.04581007361412048,
-0.4403972327709198,
-0.10100235044956207,
-0.6044825911521912,
0.4417894184589386,
0.6039425134658813,
0.21062147617340088,
0.35005369782447815,
-0.373185932636261,
0.5059234499931335,
-0.15694820880889893,
0.21131767332553864,
-0.0951530858874321,
-0.46869146823883057,
-1.1182600259780884,
-0.4900553226470947,
0.3331122398376465,
0.37679389119148254,
-0.7158828377723694,
0.8274483680725098,
-0.03893977403640747,
-0.4123828709125519,
-0.5719617605209351,
0.3316701352596283,
0.40074822306632996,
0.31352508068084717,
0.160776749253273,
-0.6538197994232178,
-0.07610026746988297,
-0.7233774065971375,
-0.12658242881298065,
-0.3825452923774719,
-0.3795170187950134,
0.5672626495361328,
0.37031692266464233,
-0.31951144337654114,
1.1502561569213867,
-0.3693672716617584,
-0.22599227726459503,
-0.4508783221244812,
0.3891068398952484,
0.3178408145904541,
0.060333430767059326,
0.03650963306427002,
-0.1352134495973587,
-0.18975791335105896,
-0.19638152420520782,
-0.7819896936416626,
-0.23592537641525269,
-0.30658960342407227,
-0.05693213269114494,
0.16531571745872498,
0.3523889183998108,
-0.4862825572490692,
0.4094865918159485,
0.5562509894371033,
-0.044218845665454865,
0.6302409172058105,
-0.13377776741981506,
0.19644057750701904,
-0.7506715059280396,
-0.10886549949645996,
0.18337905406951904,
-0.47478005290031433,
-0.5552313327789307,
-0.1909787654876709,
-0.4303775131702423,
-0.05293998867273331,
-0.5149652361869812,
0.4813224673271179,
-0.3695977032184601,
-0.4734736680984497,
-0.41317057609558105,
0.5037618279457092,
0.25548163056373596,
0.5670233964920044,
-0.0030510001815855503,
0.8016002178192139,
0.31586650013923645,
-0.5256985425949097,
0.641177773475647,
0.16349954903125763,
-0.8576261401176453,
0.6005248427391052,
-0.6817372441291809,
0.3803141117095947,
0.08246050775051117,
0.5410934090614319,
-1.0673919916152954,
-0.15544737875461578,
0.14044266939163208,
-0.23375774919986725,
0.03929656744003296,
-0.1379331797361374,
-0.5834527611732483,
-0.25694695115089417,
-0.1292889416217804,
0.22929450869560242,
0.3973604440689087,
-0.6023386716842651,
0.40821006894111633,
0.45974138379096985,
-0.22118110954761505,
-0.21871323883533478,
-0.4020368158817291,
0.28962042927742004,
-0.21509048342704773,
-0.38997581601142883,
-0.06274199485778809,
0.02298952266573906,
-0.41480112075805664,
-0.3436654210090637,
-0.2436288744211197,
-0.15406468510627747,
0.05108004808425903,
0.29745814204216003,
0.3614151179790497,
-0.12831440567970276,
0.07796008139848709,
-0.04665011167526245,
-0.11119281500577927,
0.15251770615577698,
-0.11095638573169708,
0.438626766204834,
-0.28499266505241394,
-0.6519163846969604,
-0.7993231415748596,
0.034620366990566254,
0.566955029964447,
-0.0671221911907196,
0.26724889874458313,
0.5095546245574951,
0.010869561694562435,
-0.17483338713645935,
-0.7615696787834167,
-0.1810878962278366,
-0.4461252689361572,
0.21545277535915375,
-0.053615763783454895,
-0.9553470611572266,
0.2527740001678467,
-0.37477928400039673,
0.040799692273139954,
0.16366975009441376,
0.49335265159606934,
-0.3789221942424774,
1.1579012870788574,
0.21223130822181702,
-0.14628687500953674,
0.32547813653945923,
-0.28363871574401855,
0.5050294399261475,
-0.9789657592773438,
-0.11833750456571579,
-0.460692435503006,
-0.0981026440858841,
-0.45382121205329895,
-0.673772394657135,
0.6001619100570679,
0.19172123074531555,
-0.20777203142642975,
0.29557546973228455,
-0.4108375012874603,
0.4718160331249237,
0.47589704394340515,
0.08465225249528885,
0.6000549793243408,
-0.10154738277196884,
0.07901310920715332,
0.1312331259250641,
-0.5935388803482056,
-1.0357201099395752,
0.8386227488517761,
0.6089015007019043,
0.8462548851966858,
-0.2475017011165619,
0.48397400975227356,
0.23430751264095306,
0.32802507281303406,
-0.9811574220657349,
0.7052554488182068,
0.026348812505602837,
-0.3695269823074341,
-0.5314107537269592,
-0.48251429200172424,
-0.7735787630081177,
0.34036174416542053,
-0.08601824194192886,
-1.0007586479187012,
-0.05923137441277504,
0.09898462891578674,
-0.5138902068138123,
0.1516781896352768,
-0.44803112745285034,
0.5682829022407532,
-0.4183708429336548,
-0.04360513016581535,
-0.22109967470169067,
-0.4470243453979492,
0.20051002502441406,
0.06404588371515274,
0.0020729757379740477,
-0.5463471412658691,
0.24374066293239594,
0.655110239982605,
-0.5132760405540466,
0.8650322556495667,
0.24363520741462708,
-0.30629199743270874,
0.7204549312591553,
0.1789061278104782,
0.32811346650123596,
0.02340146154165268,
-0.08470000326633453,
0.4373117983341217,
0.17103591561317444,
-0.15168963372707367,
-0.8765788078308105,
0.6491774916648865,
-0.8480093479156494,
-0.6697861552238464,
-0.18075019121170044,
-0.5086991786956787,
-0.6247329711914062,
-0.13950879871845245,
0.0695587769150734,
0.41545289754867554,
-0.23573772609233856,
0.24220414459705353,
0.31899088621139526,
-0.479302316904068,
0.33673804998397827,
0.3463774025440216,
-0.09175670146942139,
-0.4528011083602905,
0.8143411874771118,
-0.08164810389280319,
0.6136863231658936,
0.24418653547763824,
0.18996363878250122,
-0.4256938695907593,
-0.40287473797798157,
-0.4933514893054962,
0.01093287393450737,
-0.7900292277336121,
-0.3359738886356354,
-0.5122315287590027,
-0.3607936501502991,
-0.17459836602210999,
0.08395103365182877,
-0.40521830320358276,
-0.41944536566734314,
-0.2944399416446686,
-0.12799489498138428,
-0.013082844205200672,
0.653087854385376,
0.2103116810321808,
0.33430448174476624,
-0.7449584007263184,
0.2738937735557556,
0.4533017873764038,
0.31519579887390137,
-0.010001073591411114,
-0.6618362665176392,
-0.10257454216480255,
0.2571900188922882,
-0.5404574871063232,
-0.5889327526092529,
0.528484046459198,
0.014708749018609524,
0.5915959477424622,
0.2791014015674591,
0.038868553936481476,
0.5386974215507507,
-0.10009302198886871,
0.9936801195144653,
0.23975364863872528,
-1.0201616287231445,
0.603924036026001,
-0.16637735068798065,
0.49106746912002563,
0.6528169512748718,
0.12564876675605774,
-0.27253055572509766,
-0.7694370746612549,
-0.31705448031425476,
-0.6641377806663513,
0.5213505029678345,
0.3449706733226776,
0.026046965271234512,
-0.1797255575656891,
0.06795182079076767,
0.02262905053794384,
0.25449538230895996,
-0.38652053475379944,
-0.07402339577674866,
-0.020720014348626137,
-0.08754071593284607,
-0.21776992082595825,
-0.1831289678812027,
-0.23048709332942963,
-0.23583652079105377,
0.44691020250320435,
-0.2913304567337036,
0.22299852967262268,
0.15590441226959229,
-0.11817342787981033,
-0.0464954748749733,
0.4537704885005951,
0.2751116156578064,
0.8415526151657104,
-0.20040112733840942,
-0.01881049945950508,
0.3685291111469269,
0.17115017771720886,
0.17500419914722443,
-0.30504310131073,
0.08133327960968018,
0.1692313402891159,
0.4394134283065796,
0.940902829170227,
0.12135785073041916,
-0.8919224143028259,
0.5202282667160034,
-0.08678845316171646,
-0.05047601833939552,
-0.20268744230270386,
0.28816401958465576,
-0.2366231381893158,
0.3249887526035309,
0.14495496451854706,
-0.1352844387292862,
0.26111313700675964,
-0.7021467089653015,
0.036811068654060364,
0.5638227462768555,
-0.5152333974838257,
0.050079282373189926,
0.16772910952568054,
0.5117862224578857,
-0.4468086361885071,
0.8422285318374634,
0.011043550446629524,
-0.2804986536502838,
0.5465342998504639,
0.23844970762729645,
0.8679556846618652,
0.08784950524568558,
0.3216122090816498,
0.22988927364349365,
0.15189972519874573,
0.001001713564619422,
-0.2724760174751282,
-0.2619483768939972,
-0.8172814249992371,
-0.7370802760124207,
-0.6046578884124756,
-1.0064003467559814,
0.3027026951313019,
-0.6980119943618774,
0.15950165688991547,
-0.5318124294281006,
-0.45868369936943054,
-0.11116649955511093,
-0.033303290605545044,
-0.7814133167266846,
0.29804348945617676,
0.29760104417800903,
0.6639586687088013,
-0.568596363067627,
0.532826840877533,
0.18454013764858246,
-0.19682934880256653,
-0.7256308197975159,
-0.044101644307374954,
0.00833396427333355,
-0.7600745558738708,
0.533677339553833,
0.12151888012886047,
-0.3669617176055908,
-0.3249508738517761,
-0.5717993378639221,
-0.7568607926368713,
0.9533309936523438,
0.339844673871994,
-0.7411906719207764,
0.10268866270780563,
0.3019101321697235,
0.9036272168159485,
-0.5519501566886902,
0.7167348265647888,
0.9041757583618164,
0.23057518899440765,
0.23979970812797546,
-1.1113847494125366,
-0.2572609782218933,
0.15447258949279785,
0.08369561284780502,
-0.034413501620292664,
-0.29772302508354187,
0.23659482598304749,
-0.0641990453004837,
-0.09208120405673981,
0.2983998954296112,
0.5217550992965698,
0.33854225277900696,
0.4473367929458618,
0.5604018568992615,
0.34318843483924866,
0.6264720559120178,
-0.14325129985809326,
1.0113507509231567,
-0.24769935011863708,
0.24808968603610992,
1.3419945240020752,
-0.42437466979026794,
0.8463314771652222,
0.28965428471565247,
-0.09606608748435974,
0.34608909487724304,
0.5184657573699951,
-0.03529617562890053,
0.24169768393039703,
0.4569535255432129,
-0.2962639331817627,
-0.4377305805683136,
-0.4213615357875824,
0.128495991230011,
0.7544276118278503,
0.5369603037834167,
-0.5119739770889282,
-0.19258379936218262,
0.020999234169721603,
-0.15513283014297485,
-0.002755369758233428,
-0.16949091851711273,
1.2201350927352905,
0.27317413687705994,
-1.0526132583618164,
0.7482777237892151,
-0.19401094317436218,
0.4377606511116028,
-0.09645368903875351,
-0.05348445102572441,
-0.2568685710430145,
-0.009744901210069656,
-0.05448664724826813,
-1.0255389213562012,
0.2654536962509155,
0.2507116496562958,
0.2531557083129883,
-0.35437822341918945,
0.5058119297027588,
-0.3752950429916382,
-0.38782551884651184,
0.3013719916343689,
0.6190809607505798,
0.5891631245613098,
-0.015694662928581238,
-0.6553488373756409,
0.2711223363876343,
-0.12543301284313202,
-0.06403941661119461,
0.347248375415802,
0.26918917894363403,
0.03623811900615692,
0.7877965569496155,
0.5414912104606628,
0.06894564628601074,
-0.3043356239795685,
0.48390305042266846,
0.8550969958305359,
-0.49642691016197205,
-0.03988990932703018,
-0.7531449198722839,
0.3119480609893799,
-0.22534194588661194,
-0.30895745754241943,
0.5607292056083679,
0.32540595531463623,
0.8065575361251831,
0.328372985124588,
0.6470440626144409,
0.4911032021045685,
0.4322760999202728,
-0.4962402284145355,
0.4784592390060425,
-0.21000857651233673,
0.41429245471954346,
-0.34304890036582947,
-1.1183465719223022,
-0.2141529619693756,
0.6896418333053589,
-0.43656453490257263,
-0.11792095750570297,
0.5639995336532593,
0.829988420009613,
0.15814104676246643,
0.08518814295530319,
0.6742838621139526,
0.11980924010276794,
0.5522356033325195,
0.4331206977367401,
1.1737585067749023,
-0.2820110023021698,
0.5464620590209961,
-0.01714775152504444,
-0.3264959156513214,
-0.15778806805610657,
-0.9093009233474731,
-1.0971466302871704,
-0.33011025190353394,
-0.5195960402488708,
-0.21655303239822388,
0.12062874436378479,
1.1224366426467896,
0.8358851671218872,
-0.7169851660728455,
-0.37609776854515076,
-0.011421610601246357,
0.15745000541210175,
0.042277462780475616,
-0.1977400928735733,
0.03311619535088539,
-0.5320615172386169,
-0.7913080453872681,
0.6102091073989868,
0.4987507462501526,
-0.05517292022705078,
-0.37212252616882324,
-0.07521259039640427,
0.11893583834171295,
0.32100850343704224,
0.742746114730835,
-0.04754798486828804,
-1.0307402610778809,
-0.3313981890678406,
-0.38911303877830505,
-0.25347742438316345,
0.11141540855169296,
0.6843348145484924,
-0.7103222608566284,
0.6210451126098633,
0.4025447368621826,
0.5855312943458557,
0.4252496361732483,
0.3309969902038574,
0.7812632918357849,
-0.6246961951255798,
-0.19440074265003204,
0.5057847499847412,
0.31425851583480835,
0.38244983553886414,
-0.12505047023296356,
0.42783626914024353,
-0.34177857637405396,
-0.8164218068122864,
-0.7771182656288147,
0.09522665292024612,
-0.8797988295555115,
-0.11968272924423218,
1.3663725852966309,
-0.39952850341796875,
-0.057131387293338776,
-0.14410875737667084,
-0.3755083978176117,
0.1167764812707901,
-0.39598289132118225,
0.7705432772636414,
0.8038679957389832,
-0.4708994925022125,
-0.1851295828819275,
-0.541340708732605,
0.3572686016559601,
0.40569743514060974,
-1.009671688079834,
-0.21786868572235107,
0.5742455720901489,
0.09067298471927643,
0.251492977142334,
0.6135581135749817,
-0.00014155879034660757,
0.048015348613262177,
-0.3195924460887909,
-0.25157177448272705,
0.11515197902917862,
-0.31318792700767517,
-0.3463164269924164,
-0.0728134885430336,
0.36657488346099854,
-0.19302646815776825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17300v1 | CausalScore: An Automatic Reference-Free Metric for Assessing Response Relevance in Open-Domain Dialogue Systems | 2024-06-25T06:08:16 | 2024-06-25T06:08:16 | Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Xiaoxi Kang, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatically evaluating the quality of responses in open-domain dialogue
systems is a challenging but crucial task. Current evaluation metrics often
fail to align with human judgments, especially when assessing responses that
are grammatically correct. To address this issue, we propose a novel metric,
called CausalScore, which assesses the relevance of responses by measuring the
causal strength between dialogue histories and responses. The causal strength
is estimated by utilizing both unconditional dependence and conditional
dependencies from the dialogue history to responses. We compare our metric with
the existing competitive metrics in terms of their alignment with human
judgements. Our experimental results demonstrate that CausalScore significantly
surpasses existing state-of-the-art metrics by aligning better with human
judgements. Additionally, we collect a new dialogue dataset CGDIALOG+ with
human-annotated causal relations and a set of pairwise human judgements to
facilitate the development of future automatic metrics. | [
-0.35506656765937805,
-0.424951434135437,
0.6184845566749573,
0.32019880414009094,
-0.0582706481218338,
-0.10835663974285126,
-0.1841222494840622,
-0.3199644982814789,
0.07168515771627426,
0.32419437170028687,
-0.32396167516708374,
-0.20751038193702698,
-0.5252573490142822,
0.08327556401491165,
-0.07558214664459229,
0.9513453841209412,
0.0921296775341034,
0.2436244934797287,
-0.6729477643966675,
-0.5972385406494141,
-0.8834301829338074,
-0.40663254261016846,
-0.45380523800849915,
-0.15874643623828888,
0.6935659646987915,
0.26780253648757935,
0.7786408066749573,
0.10059529542922974,
0.7156669497489929,
0.3093825876712799,
0.2239101380109787,
0.18700306117534637,
-0.4964575171470642,
0.07450729608535767,
-0.595902144908905,
-0.119717538356781,
-0.6132716536521912,
0.279615581035614,
0.5303151607513428,
0.8065422177314758,
0.02498718909919262,
0.4972783029079437,
0.2815071940422058,
0.331966370344162,
-0.836355447769165,
0.3099576532840729,
-0.35181209444999695,
-0.24801136553287506,
0.20209021866321564,
-0.6638847589492798,
-0.4805663228034973,
-0.7192896604537964,
0.4236654043197632,
-0.6811721324920654,
0.14431755244731903,
0.30289706587791443,
0.8628756403923035,
0.2827098071575165,
-0.7305890917778015,
-0.09353780001401901,
-0.9081839919090271,
0.6036313772201538,
-0.9084773063659668,
0.341295063495636,
0.33906620740890503,
0.6295396089553833,
-0.2551122307777405,
-0.5555446743965149,
-0.4458552300930023,
-0.3717808127403259,
-0.4865553379058838,
0.36004510521888733,
-0.33698606491088867,
0.02977140247821808,
0.13826826214790344,
0.2715277075767517,
-0.519629716873169,
-0.11795905977487564,
-0.2636888027191162,
-0.3547767400741577,
0.4937532842159271,
0.5908358097076416,
0.33433565497398376,
-0.12379542738199234,
-0.3665868639945984,
0.09896594285964966,
-0.39080458879470825,
0.24735911190509796,
0.195583775639534,
0.4532910883426666,
0.09914141893386841,
0.3846493363380432,
-0.28029656410217285,
0.7138493657112122,
0.2087099552154541,
-0.18918004631996155,
-0.19741448760032654,
-0.6530871391296387,
-0.3681730628013611,
0.07682226598262787,
1.1271252632141113,
0.588634192943573,
-0.04861026629805565,
-0.2868388593196869,
0.3108227252960205,
0.17948544025421143,
0.47423216700553894,
-0.7275319695472717,
-0.06654056161642075,
-0.06316082179546356,
-0.23019365966320038,
-0.09143369644880295,
0.3212902545928955,
-0.6546552181243896,
-0.2639429271221161,
-0.32681116461753845,
0.5750846862792969,
0.127208411693573,
-0.01865445449948311,
0.11465173959732056,
-0.08050651103258133,
-0.15776808559894562,
0.7274983525276184,
-0.47349435091018677,
0.39643222093582153,
0.5921825170516968,
0.6038699150085449,
-0.015483560971915722,
0.016109224408864975,
-0.8757021427154541,
-0.044479984790086746,
-0.3972528278827667,
0.7977136373519897,
-0.308127760887146,
-0.22122056782245636,
-0.13107475638389587,
0.039775144308805466,
-0.05773355811834335,
-0.461844801902771,
1.0752029418945312,
-0.5964778661727905,
0.6075627207756042,
-0.12829537689685822,
-0.42405474185943604,
-0.30360645055770874,
-0.003962146118283272,
-0.5061356425285339,
0.8085470199584961,
0.23220309615135193,
-0.8404834270477295,
0.6515910625457764,
-0.12054508924484253,
-0.21787038445472717,
0.006295861676335335,
-0.15030546486377716,
-0.2798478603363037,
0.04202652722597122,
-0.0905521810054779,
0.0713714063167572,
-1.086686611175537,
0.720826268196106,
-0.6875889301300049,
-0.19791485369205475,
0.256087064743042,
-0.5640091896057129,
0.704606831073761,
-0.023135848343372345,
-0.4216124713420868,
0.2142138034105301,
-0.9211508631706238,
0.07878516614437103,
-0.25111129879951477,
-0.053272344172000885,
-0.6141806840896606,
0.1433972865343094,
-0.4982709288597107,
0.5165249705314636,
0.05874299630522728,
-0.6910638809204102,
-0.16757680475711823,
-0.25780346989631653,
-0.13088370859622955,
0.6904078125953674,
0.23576770722866058,
0.2902369797229767,
-0.2318315953016281,
0.2081410437822342,
-0.05984142795205116,
0.31830546259880066,
-0.03327560797333717,
-0.5937977433204651,
-0.8070905804634094,
-0.29680898785591125,
0.07089608907699585,
0.5856199860572815,
-0.12199082225561142,
0.9360935688018799,
-0.49402597546577454,
-0.4660187363624573,
-0.38484829664230347,
-0.09913253784179688,
0.5325274467468262,
0.9582147598266602,
0.30088964104652405,
-0.9254644513130188,
-0.3770498037338257,
-0.9046417474746704,
-0.47260215878486633,
-0.844352662563324,
-0.2983463406562805,
0.7152730226516724,
0.05414747819304466,
0.12993425130844116,
1.3511037826538086,
-0.6011449098587036,
-0.35519981384277344,
0.3233737349510193,
0.4323962926864624,
0.19428750872612,
0.15209679305553436,
0.30781999230384827,
-0.3070260286331177,
-0.23220035433769226,
-0.12509872019290924,
-0.9689819812774658,
-0.629362165927887,
-0.03660355880856514,
-0.320812463760376,
-0.18228717148303986,
0.19495481252670288,
-0.4685457646846771,
0.5269119143486023,
0.26188409328460693,
-0.7939708232879639,
0.7137004733085632,
0.03490964323282242,
0.76897794008255,
-0.740131139755249,
0.5883835554122925,
0.029811589047312737,
-0.12410691380500793,
-0.4399968683719635,
-0.4195372462272644,
0.011149699799716473,
-0.05183485522866249,
-0.5254733562469482,
0.7788839340209961,
-0.04166097193956375,
-0.0095252376049757,
0.22823895514011383,
0.4189629852771759,
-0.011385503225028515,
0.6900216341018677,
-0.28942936658859253,
0.6825505495071411,
-0.06588207930326462,
-0.6331497430801392,
0.44414815306663513,
0.5429210066795349,
-0.47990885376930237,
1.129503607749939,
-0.7255200147628784,
-0.014722340740263462,
0.20935234427452087,
0.44255921244621277,
-1.3644589185714722,
-0.1990494579076767,
0.2700006365776062,
-0.6166427731513977,
-0.2259497344493866,
-0.07327444106340408,
-0.3652570843696594,
-0.466368168592453,
-0.00565263582393527,
0.6520095467567444,
0.10570388287305832,
-0.46393442153930664,
0.34843745827674866,
0.1530320942401886,
-0.22769398987293243,
-0.25265297293663025,
-0.07494323700666428,
0.06848778575658798,
-0.31130850315093994,
-0.7136300206184387,
-0.22188697755336761,
-0.20081685483455658,
-0.34640219807624817,
-0.15473368763923645,
-0.38398104906082153,
-0.023160511627793312,
0.07245183736085892,
0.370988667011261,
0.3785313367843628,
-0.30408158898353577,
-0.01506009604781866,
-0.10787612944841385,
-0.2568226456642151,
0.36143019795417786,
-0.3075415790081024,
0.029404621571302414,
0.122635118663311,
-0.48682671785354614,
-0.5612999200820923,
0.15178930759429932,
0.9014036059379578,
-0.06823792308568954,
0.40758442878723145,
0.11210913211107254,
-0.08948149532079697,
0.4186135530471802,
-0.5737848281860352,
0.03606785461306572,
-0.40432488918304443,
-0.024134935811161995,
-0.02406621165573597,
-0.9332917332649231,
0.30162233114242554,
-0.07102052867412567,
-0.08242824673652649,
0.6077660322189331,
0.452807754278183,
0.1496039181947708,
1.3318077325820923,
0.24105995893478394,
-0.24401362240314484,
0.14997930824756622,
0.5341558456420898,
0.4996166229248047,
-0.7946922183036804,
-0.3105787932872772,
-0.8560641407966614,
-0.022577758878469467,
-0.280516117811203,
-0.17347709834575653,
0.48966559767723083,
0.22119559347629547,
-0.6873067021369934,
0.4661075472831726,
-0.060600630939006805,
0.05249198153614998,
0.43050503730773926,
-0.11775356531143188,
0.5921517014503479,
-0.3969029188156128,
-0.25128525495529175,
-0.2014191746711731,
-0.3893948197364807,
-0.5845461487770081,
0.8904309272766113,
0.027624547481536865,
0.7811031341552734,
0.42095983028411865,
0.15825040638446808,
0.4391316771507263,
0.44739481806755066,
-0.670229434967041,
0.5574370622634888,
0.26885998249053955,
-0.46770933270454407,
-0.271123468875885,
-0.6448482275009155,
-0.8857834339141846,
0.32888534665107727,
-0.037759557366371155,
-1.044460415840149,
0.1767442524433136,
0.03039293736219406,
-0.5382345914840698,
-0.03199133276939392,
-0.519148588180542,
0.8043231964111328,
-0.18800674378871918,
-0.5424569249153137,
-0.10752757638692856,
-0.7290337681770325,
0.35488730669021606,
-0.04921232908964157,
-0.014990455470979214,
-0.3756456673145294,
0.27226147055625916,
0.8060405254364014,
-0.6701890230178833,
0.8457123041152954,
0.004675775300711393,
-0.21357014775276184,
0.19064192473888397,
0.2642342746257782,
0.1994270533323288,
0.24806278944015503,
0.26512712240219116,
0.1021055206656456,
-0.15909071266651154,
-0.17710629105567932,
-1.0570429563522339,
0.6927089095115662,
-0.6140428185462952,
-0.8714779615402222,
-0.4078389108181,
-0.17272919416427612,
-0.6006078720092773,
0.25700119137763977,
-0.1673748642206192,
0.5438923239707947,
-0.8933578133583069,
0.04759427532553673,
0.3148399889469147,
-0.2587772309780121,
0.09710028767585754,
1.073257327079773,
0.0035048718564212322,
-0.739453911781311,
0.5003070831298828,
-0.16981999576091766,
0.3887339234352112,
0.49740275740623474,
0.2358265370130539,
-0.1979064643383026,
0.29813408851623535,
-0.5085546374320984,
0.07034017145633698,
-0.4923384487628937,
-0.585506796836853,
-0.6845036149024963,
-0.012707636691629887,
-0.26998114585876465,
-0.005367174278944731,
-0.05283360183238983,
-0.5958635210990906,
-0.18351145088672638,
0.01584187150001526,
0.11844208836555481,
0.3505041301250458,
-0.054643407464027405,
-0.06828678399324417,
-0.7478892803192139,
0.2220408320426941,
0.6553629040718079,
0.42968523502349854,
0.11747755855321884,
-0.6621811985969543,
-0.2884432077407837,
-0.025912029668688774,
-0.5277656316757202,
-0.6076117753982544,
0.13850685954093933,
0.17915940284729004,
0.5482808351516724,
0.5261793732643127,
0.3281385898590088,
0.7017486095428467,
-0.5584375858306885,
1.0805784463882446,
0.46764516830444336,
-0.8631413578987122,
0.6328645944595337,
-0.5344700217247009,
0.37518641352653503,
0.7183479070663452,
0.2578381597995758,
-0.6560660600662231,
-0.915015697479248,
-0.6214333772659302,
-0.7513129115104675,
0.7500613927841187,
0.16251079738140106,
-0.1444806605577469,
-0.049722589552402496,
-0.06265516579151154,
-0.012728475034236908,
0.16308742761611938,
0.06910575181245804,
-0.15340280532836914,
0.025285139679908752,
-0.03298524022102356,
-0.361673504114151,
0.13092650473117828,
-0.45850783586502075,
-0.40421998500823975,
0.45762914419174194,
-0.10894826799631119,
0.483725905418396,
0.2945365905761719,
-0.21188685297966003,
-0.40661758184432983,
0.3080277144908905,
0.593562126159668,
0.6501225829124451,
-0.42146408557891846,
0.0730389952659607,
0.1623026728630066,
-0.2826407849788666,
0.39843428134918213,
-0.029258616268634796,
0.09497610479593277,
0.006428695749491453,
0.4329844117164612,
0.7819695472717285,
0.6670396327972412,
-0.5385663509368896,
0.857870876789093,
-0.40268149971961975,
0.07523389905691147,
-0.023929759860038757,
0.06651546061038971,
-0.3593652546405792,
0.22121776640415192,
0.2624070346355438,
0.23215745389461517,
0.3861010670661926,
-0.35045406222343445,
0.41457894444465637,
0.24592314660549164,
-0.8663180470466614,
-0.40867379307746887,
0.9163673520088196,
0.4085409641265869,
-0.2621718943119049,
0.47384950518608093,
0.12051736563444138,
-0.3094725012779236,
0.5266147255897522,
0.4349404573440552,
1.2017821073532104,
-0.2601810097694397,
0.2165869027376175,
0.7965248823165894,
-0.0019239047542214394,
0.199198380112648,
-0.37072518467903137,
-0.27465763688087463,
-0.5077202916145325,
-0.11826933175325394,
-0.46381857991218567,
-0.5234753489494324,
-0.18137820065021515,
-0.9199145436286926,
0.17619217932224274,
-0.417184978723526,
-0.46602097153663635,
-0.02588037960231304,
-0.08185447007417679,
-0.7289053797721863,
0.3183388113975525,
-0.3457278311252594,
0.7480208277702332,
-0.8242782950401306,
0.3275001049041748,
0.24520276486873627,
-0.7140718102455139,
-0.7213884592056274,
0.07217775285243988,
0.42770615220069885,
-0.4865061342716217,
0.9363458752632141,
-0.01846727915108204,
-0.5864079594612122,
-0.31061381101608276,
-0.12246741354465485,
-0.7761834859848022,
1.074771523475647,
0.3200264275074005,
-0.16825959086418152,
0.2624114155769348,
0.0899849683046341,
0.7430368065834045,
-0.2473820596933365,
0.7655203342437744,
0.6844599843025208,
0.3602076768875122,
-0.16440314054489136,
-1.4079188108444214,
0.28150883316993713,
-0.4933088719844818,
-0.1576281487941742,
0.49045315384864807,
-0.8217652440071106,
0.1526029407978058,
-0.02792869322001934,
-0.4156833589076996,
0.407264769077301,
0.5850862264633179,
-0.2297208607196808,
0.4095814526081085,
0.39053910970687866,
0.6722577810287476,
0.5861966609954834,
-0.21675463020801544,
0.7191194891929626,
-0.20589299499988556,
0.48941293358802795,
1.2965975999832153,
-0.3376215994358063,
0.709030270576477,
0.27702558040618896,
-0.12252268195152283,
0.6120296120643616,
0.25270766019821167,
0.2698409855365753,
0.5251567959785461,
0.21617861092090607,
-0.5722537040710449,
-0.21284104883670807,
-0.2980901598930359,
-0.12040980905294418,
0.25279170274734497,
0.14109843969345093,
-0.12224871665239334,
-0.4013817310333252,
-0.30227214097976685,
0.13680341839790344,
0.0244583897292614,
0.005124796647578478,
1.0949723720550537,
0.03706216439604759,
-1.1129573583602905,
0.6504427790641785,
-0.35187357664108276,
0.1820196956396103,
-0.6385297179222107,
0.05239478126168251,
-0.37213096022605896,
0.22757349908351898,
-0.13510525226593018,
-0.7036736011505127,
0.15235306322574615,
0.12400046736001968,
-0.1335260272026062,
0.07578875869512558,
0.36662203073501587,
-0.2982887625694275,
0.006103146355599165,
0.5848706960678101,
0.3836745619773865,
-0.18864643573760986,
0.3746166229248047,
-0.3247746229171753,
-0.3095962703227997,
-0.3719390630722046,
-0.0012668592389672995,
0.3609265685081482,
0.4309765100479126,
-0.2659616470336914,
0.5374727249145508,
0.5572735667228699,
-0.2301500290632248,
-0.31825393438339233,
0.21944962441921234,
0.749161958694458,
-0.6834414601325989,
-0.4174075722694397,
-0.49513158202171326,
0.5732701420783997,
-0.24076317250728607,
-0.5684627294540405,
0.9527547955513,
0.5059220790863037,
0.6321474313735962,
0.22525739669799805,
0.5953909158706665,
0.017617622390389442,
0.6396328806877136,
-0.16942240297794342,
0.5443697571754456,
-0.4962606728076935,
0.0981360599398613,
-0.8128240704536438,
-0.9567254185676575,
-0.4582608640193939,
0.1896113157272339,
-0.377631813287735,
-0.22900168597698212,
0.920742928981781,
0.8249390721321106,
-0.20798498392105103,
0.13935714960098267,
0.3900671601295471,
0.14789751172065735,
0.4172423183917999,
0.5164971947669983,
1.0144439935684204,
-0.3876228928565979,
0.5489640235900879,
0.44202446937561035,
-0.6583391427993774,
-0.3244935870170593,
-0.8254823684692383,
-0.7093484401702881,
-0.6538206934928894,
-0.18501447141170502,
-0.4115629494190216,
0.20794443786144257,
0.8069158792495728,
0.48239922523498535,
-0.8780518174171448,
-0.4784581959247589,
0.15856407582759857,
-0.09713253378868103,
-0.28165289759635925,
-0.27217498421669006,
0.3169304132461548,
-0.5129146575927734,
-0.24956096708774567,
0.30247876048088074,
0.631406307220459,
-0.33713334798812866,
-0.08755626529455185,
-0.20847338438034058,
0.060989297926425934,
0.5598764419555664,
0.7359153628349304,
0.5583757162094116,
-0.749034583568573,
-0.7623694539070129,
-0.2383788377046585,
-0.39758580923080444,
-0.01478948350995779,
1.27146315574646,
-0.756545901298523,
0.7609192132949829,
0.6553933620452881,
0.48206251859664917,
0.09402736276388168,
0.16140516102313995,
1.016310453414917,
-0.4925616383552551,
-0.0323273167014122,
0.149358332157135,
0.2184564620256424,
0.1220034584403038,
-0.16946320235729218,
0.5215024352073669,
0.3412421643733978,
-0.7726078033447266,
-0.5978360772132874,
0.16616849601268768,
-1.1415308713912964,
0.2107144147157669,
0.8722246289253235,
-0.3763921558856964,
0.22092008590698242,
-0.2973417639732361,
-0.3551827371120453,
0.2335297167301178,
-0.551821231842041,
0.8076359033584595,
0.6745920181274414,
-0.17612436413764954,
0.3484472334384918,
-0.3654923141002655,
0.452284574508667,
0.4899843633174896,
-0.8277652859687805,
0.19870546460151672,
0.9329128265380859,
0.004850985482335091,
0.29189714789390564,
0.7930299043655396,
-0.23734639585018158,
0.4599114656448364,
-0.19348284602165222,
-0.38921499252319336,
0.4505794942378998,
-0.3458496928215027,
-0.050918299704790115,
-0.007072783540934324,
0.00014317483874037862,
0.03892378881573677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17294v2 | Math-LLaVA: Bootstrapping Mathematical Reasoning for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T05:43:21 | 2024-06-26T16:43:27 | Wenhao Shi, Zhiqiang Hu, Yi Bin, Junhua Liu, Yang Yang, See-Kiong Ng, Lidong Bing, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive reasoning
capabilities, particularly in textual mathematical problem-solving. However,
existing open-source image instruction fine-tuning datasets, containing limited
question-answer pairs per image, do not fully exploit visual information to
enhance the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of Multimodal LLMs
(MLLMs). To bridge this gap, we address the lack of high-quality, diverse
multimodal mathematical datasets by collecting 40K high-quality images with
question-answer pairs from 24 existing datasets and synthesizing 320K new
pairs, creating the MathV360K dataset, which enhances both the breadth and
depth of multimodal mathematical questions. We introduce Math-LLaVA, a
LLaVA-1.5-based model fine-tuned with MathV360K. This novel approach
significantly improves the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of
LLaVA-1.5, achieving a 19-point increase and comparable performance to GPT-4V
on MathVista's minitest split. Furthermore, Math-LLaVA demonstrates enhanced
generalizability, showing substantial improvements on the MMMU benchmark. Our
research highlights the importance of dataset diversity and synthesis in
advancing MLLMs' mathematical reasoning abilities. The code and data are
available at: \url{https://github.com/HZQ950419/Math-LLaVA}. | [
-0.4220002591609955,
-0.6951005458831787,
0.533011257648468,
0.3528178036212921,
-0.1739012598991394,
0.2850598394870758,
-0.23272357881069183,
-0.22413180768489838,
0.07353583723306656,
0.27346959710121155,
-0.7763643860816956,
-0.5039398670196533,
-0.3223746120929718,
0.008722522296011448,
-0.04454422742128372,
0.7328962683677673,
-0.1846553385257721,
0.25010454654693604,
-0.8166275024414062,
-0.27103105187416077,
-0.4877249598503113,
-0.18250681459903717,
-0.12991245090961456,
-0.15969933569431305,
0.6477412581443787,
0.5383721590042114,
0.7049949765205383,
0.31106606125831604,
0.6055307984352112,
0.35685503482818604,
0.32076987624168396,
0.544862687587738,
-0.39489036798477173,
0.4938528835773468,
0.03454330936074257,
-0.6338143944740295,
-0.4154244363307953,
-0.23716601729393005,
0.6106966733932495,
0.5037391185760498,
-0.10817607492208481,
0.3633763790130615,
-0.3567364811897278,
0.7350937724113464,
-0.7267189621925354,
0.5223762392997742,
-0.670754611492157,
-0.14689725637435913,
-0.2345748096704483,
-0.06067376956343651,
-0.3201923668384552,
-0.36947277188301086,
-0.2540247142314911,
-0.9440366625785828,
-0.17305433750152588,
-0.011308625340461731,
0.6716282963752747,
0.3492790758609772,
-0.39202412962913513,
-0.09359073638916016,
-0.4680372178554535,
1.026021957397461,
-0.39882978796958923,
0.48502323031425476,
0.5989892482757568,
0.6421146392822266,
0.14165088534355164,
-0.4897441267967224,
-0.3495618402957916,
0.04503464326262474,
0.27607986330986023,
0.0023879222571849823,
-0.2274746149778366,
-0.29472312331199646,
0.35079580545425415,
0.25214096903800964,
-0.5457007884979248,
-0.11434847116470337,
-0.4403875172138214,
-0.31426116824150085,
0.6051090359687805,
0.3266820013523102,
0.07023696601390839,
-0.033325135707855225,
-0.12210714817047119,
-0.1014818400144577,
-0.8093375563621521,
0.03836885839700699,
0.36382225155830383,
-0.007449360564351082,
-0.11518429219722748,
0.8102858066558838,
-0.05510290339589119,
0.7335862517356873,
-0.4364008903503418,
-0.51849365234375,
0.3694688081741333,
-0.4009092450141907,
-0.3798874616622925,
-0.41648632287979126,
0.48337677121162415,
0.32187944650650024,
0.4513326585292816,
0.19981630146503448,
-0.31779277324676514,
0.3361601233482361,
-0.1389099657535553,
-0.8369040489196777,
-0.15189260244369507,
0.10253333300352097,
-0.0740903839468956,
-0.27581268548965454,
-0.4292645752429962,
-0.8724105358123779,
-0.22315794229507446,
-0.6436740756034851,
0.35335779190063477,
-0.46257510781288147,
-0.07001976668834686,
0.10224061459302902,
0.2373790591955185,
0.2444228231906891,
0.7936044931411743,
-0.8504104614257812,
0.11378120630979538,
0.6624488234519958,
0.5095232129096985,
0.10030348598957062,
-0.050657592713832855,
-0.7288503646850586,
-0.09115902334451675,
-0.43125760555267334,
0.7487761378288269,
-0.8127583861351013,
0.003441259963437915,
-0.015274026431143284,
-0.18204733729362488,
0.11831381171941757,
-0.4422757625579834,
0.27715635299682617,
-0.6494045257568359,
0.23407143354415894,
-0.29048219323158264,
-0.3942949175834656,
-0.10522834211587906,
0.5177143216133118,
-0.5436994433403015,
0.9619685411453247,
-0.043094784021377563,
-0.399421751499176,
0.07849062979221344,
-0.4108947515487671,
-0.2965388894081116,
0.05646564066410065,
-0.3472822308540344,
-0.43869075179100037,
0.04074793681502342,
0.7998260855674744,
0.2489338517189026,
-0.604233980178833,
0.22056449949741364,
-0.4425637125968933,
-0.08141902089118958,
0.4369697868824005,
-0.5963668823242188,
0.7319088578224182,
0.32310160994529724,
0.15158149600028992,
0.06148919463157654,
-0.9377297759056091,
0.09072805941104889,
0.29627081751823425,
-0.21117886900901794,
-0.2713353931903839,
-0.3734886944293976,
0.048805322498083115,
0.20437920093536377,
0.24133245646953583,
-0.4199538826942444,
0.3667805790901184,
-0.080290786921978,
0.26984670758247375,
0.9521427750587463,
-0.32313743233680725,
0.29471707344055176,
-0.40927359461784363,
0.8042612075805664,
-0.05539395287632942,
0.18724502623081207,
-0.615117073059082,
-0.8269268274307251,
-0.7396249175071716,
-0.6517012715339661,
0.43926945328712463,
0.5892317891120911,
-1.036963701248169,
-0.30851849913597107,
-0.2036728709936142,
-0.3148212730884552,
-0.6576680541038513,
0.42748379707336426,
0.4020184874534607,
0.48811259865760803,
0.31999900937080383,
0.0921487957239151,
-0.4993462860584259,
-0.9965333342552185,
-0.12066101282835007,
0.2092895805835724,
-0.09999295324087143,
0.36694255471229553,
0.6190988421440125,
-0.05096130445599556,
0.7104108333587646,
-0.5757445096969604,
-0.22808967530727386,
0.0038719463627785444,
-0.09021776169538498,
0.09626196324825287,
0.27250662446022034,
0.44973674416542053,
-0.8484678268432617,
-0.37286049127578735,
-0.12064836919307709,
-0.8862001299858093,
-0.1123744323849678,
-0.11203177273273468,
-0.3242269456386566,
-0.018471376970410347,
0.23791734874248505,
-0.6386892795562744,
0.3896830081939697,
0.5830321907997131,
-0.22807754576206207,
0.6282735466957092,
-0.029854847118258476,
0.2774905562400818,
-1.0911248922348022,
-0.21882499754428864,
0.09468071162700653,
-0.31991055607795715,
-0.3021080493927002,
0.2040402889251709,
0.11634010821580887,
-0.12229079753160477,
-0.4072535037994385,
0.38340070843696594,
-0.37228962779045105,
-0.21480529010295868,
0.11075574159622192,
0.08899910748004913,
0.1395529806613922,
0.5854735970497131,
-0.404706746339798,
0.8971764445304871,
0.7214192748069763,
-0.26179298758506775,
0.8418355584144592,
0.258581280708313,
-0.5376496911048889,
0.7745625972747803,
-0.544571578502655,
0.05986515060067177,
-0.17270003259181976,
0.12317361682653427,
-1.116347074508667,
-0.40319862961769104,
0.019853776320815086,
-0.45304250717163086,
0.12450907379388809,
-0.3458433747291565,
-0.753873884677887,
0.07771749794483185,
-0.24688145518302917,
0.9161741137504578,
0.5083342790603638,
-0.4738290011882782,
0.7411437630653381,
0.34561777114868164,
-0.30690810084342957,
-0.6405928134918213,
-0.6527172923088074,
0.07066812366247177,
-0.02205612137913704,
-0.8967341184616089,
-0.005955155938863754,
-0.34516751766204834,
-0.635986328125,
-0.11101450026035309,
0.014132514595985413,
-0.09607861191034317,
-0.21045927703380585,
0.21214787662029266,
0.6744551658630371,
-0.380840003490448,
0.5077798962593079,
0.30470389127731323,
-0.17342153191566467,
0.08163421601057053,
-0.24397443234920502,
0.4201526343822479,
-0.4577398896217346,
-0.6403922438621521,
-0.17048989236354828,
0.19398976862430573,
0.7079662680625916,
-0.514472484588623,
0.5088896751403809,
0.4266209304332733,
-0.4347527325153351,
0.03507663309574127,
-0.5867671966552734,
0.0209803506731987,
-0.46510735154151917,
0.11142748594284058,
-0.5438801050186157,
-0.8207636475563049,
0.36725008487701416,
-0.08831296861171722,
0.29529696702957153,
0.2953159809112549,
0.8398764729499817,
-0.24224814772605896,
0.8636078834533691,
0.16801460087299347,
0.30970498919487,
0.16681155562400818,
-0.1807066649198532,
-0.20613901317119598,
-0.512246310710907,
-0.43019893765449524,
-0.10453726351261139,
-0.42938512563705444,
-0.2834784686565399,
-0.8152558207511902,
0.4701656401157379,
-0.3667600750923157,
-0.10192421078681946,
-0.11775477230548859,
-0.17584189772605896,
0.7970216870307922,
0.3501439392566681,
0.12816773355007172,
0.4674034118652344,
0.4577285349369049,
-0.3145986497402191,
-0.43716511130332947,
-0.4256933629512787,
-0.11842510104179382,
1.2591776847839355,
0.2635725140571594,
1.025887131690979,
0.28012561798095703,
0.3813951313495636,
0.06519044190645218,
0.30105286836624146,
-0.7128309011459351,
0.5725307464599609,
0.10215726494789124,
-0.6324807405471802,
-0.20447243750095367,
-0.6264809966087341,
-0.8498885631561279,
0.488425076007843,
-0.31484606862068176,
-0.39342373609542847,
-0.12954488396644592,
0.10863011330366135,
-0.15202562510967255,
0.24379920959472656,
-0.6454133987426758,
0.6495116949081421,
-0.3471745550632477,
-0.696027398109436,
-0.25890928506851196,
-0.40419983863830566,
0.6913817524909973,
-0.14610275626182556,
0.6585240364074707,
-0.37941157817840576,
-0.07939571142196655,
0.4421226382255554,
-0.39322134852409363,
0.7784932255744934,
0.019823096692562103,
-0.5211426615715027,
0.22894051671028137,
0.35473501682281494,
0.2986857295036316,
0.28692713379859924,
0.27952900528907776,
0.10194770991802216,
-0.021731460466980934,
-0.5398871302604675,
-0.882326602935791,
0.8511183261871338,
-0.6138759255409241,
-0.49850520491600037,
-0.22715485095977783,
-1.0869334936141968,
-0.43344154953956604,
0.04030938819050789,
-0.1733078807592392,
0.7382592558860779,
0.422306090593338,
0.43448784947395325,
0.7414547801017761,
-0.15070854127407074,
0.14931465685367584,
0.09638502448797226,
-0.6437767148017883,
-0.8097074031829834,
0.9682360887527466,
-0.08309603482484818,
0.32711556553840637,
0.5621543526649475,
0.1307600736618042,
-0.3334610164165497,
-0.0891701877117157,
-0.6129544973373413,
0.3382723927497864,
-1.0935380458831787,
-0.4654347598552704,
-0.14306733012199402,
0.028562653809785843,
-0.21983246505260468,
-0.047261543571949005,
-0.48991361260414124,
-0.7501620650291443,
-0.016544118523597717,
0.110710009932518,
0.6143059730529785,
0.4236989915370941,
0.10714250802993774,
-0.1327848583459854,
-0.5641623139381409,
0.5041207075119019,
0.6550954580307007,
0.2962072193622589,
-0.27432477474212646,
-0.5017609000205994,
-0.03454422205686569,
0.15405964851379395,
-0.14384719729423523,
-0.647031307220459,
0.27815672755241394,
0.08944125473499298,
0.2200167179107666,
0.15773507952690125,
-0.27908211946487427,
0.9143863320350647,
-0.49231505393981934,
0.43045851588249207,
0.45418718457221985,
-0.8533434867858887,
0.5676117539405823,
-0.38683661818504333,
0.4341421127319336,
0.25800421833992004,
0.2316405475139618,
-0.12922529876232147,
-0.0024694809690117836,
-0.27826905250549316,
-0.5169103145599365,
0.26250532269477844,
0.553684413433075,
0.04838038980960846,
0.46563172340393066,
0.11681409180164337,
0.2794612646102905,
0.2631121575832367,
-0.6135778427124023,
-0.27444714307785034,
-0.3254474997520447,
-0.3948519229888916,
-0.01632794179022312,
-0.02741861715912819,
-0.41230514645576477,
-0.6479882597923279,
0.37560558319091797,
-0.33513373136520386,
0.09862125664949417,
-0.28211554884910583,
-0.37046340107917786,
-0.03331342712044716,
0.35536545515060425,
0.9227944612503052,
0.9784455299377441,
0.05002831667661667,
0.31344372034072876,
0.14353018999099731,
-0.4378148913383484,
0.23723997175693512,
0.21850715577602386,
0.020407164469361305,
-0.10513979196548462,
0.4352794885635376,
0.7233567833900452,
0.37815338373184204,
-0.9849795699119568,
0.4732334017753601,
-0.1640806496143341,
-0.537782609462738,
-0.2082577347755432,
-0.17545989155769348,
0.15688203275203705,
0.39143842458724976,
0.4047917127609253,
0.209627166390419,
-0.24523264169692993,
-0.2609020471572876,
0.10413280874490738,
0.46352577209472656,
0.17268599569797516,
-0.23952794075012207,
0.579089343547821,
-0.02764163911342621,
-0.12044540792703629,
0.6745081543922424,
0.06438757479190826,
-0.12595920264720917,
0.5676559209823608,
0.46956074237823486,
0.33092591166496277,
-0.020365850999951363,
0.2326764315366745,
0.2722492814064026,
0.3696431815624237,
0.3072599172592163,
0.41463449597358704,
-0.13930295407772064,
-0.5817356705665588,
-0.7652921676635742,
-0.5444582104682922,
-0.3790806829929352,
0.019247500225901604,
-0.48785117268562317,
0.28631120920181274,
-0.5285226106643677,
0.10010553896427155,
0.017731765285134315,
-0.2953876256942749,
-0.7963996529579163,
0.10296996682882309,
0.3240581452846527,
0.6711806654930115,
-0.6167656183242798,
0.7210153341293335,
0.6661927103996277,
-0.4989604651927948,
-0.4681459963321686,
-0.387322336435318,
-0.04224170744419098,
-1.3086808919906616,
0.8408019542694092,
0.07970944792032242,
-0.11551564186811447,
-0.18272873759269714,
-0.8670440316200256,
-0.8284912109375,
1.135346531867981,
0.8132923245429993,
-0.7289648056030273,
0.0027999591547995806,
0.2749323546886444,
0.3089445233345032,
-0.3300505578517914,
0.26909229159355164,
0.19130250811576843,
0.4499519467353821,
0.609086275100708,
-0.8763909935951233,
-0.12375568598508835,
-0.40609607100486755,
-0.026989765465259552,
0.2201765775680542,
-0.48625174164772034,
0.8726353049278259,
-0.4134743809700012,
0.19233308732509613,
-0.016286753118038177,
0.625264048576355,
0.699822187423706,
0.4585234224796295,
0.42760276794433594,
0.766187310218811,
0.6819621920585632,
-0.08371100574731827,
0.8458953499794006,
0.02881430648267269,
0.33066239953041077,
0.7676423192024231,
-0.013929689303040504,
0.7694135904312134,
0.5838332176208496,
-0.3131871819496155,
0.6557729840278625,
0.42688292264938354,
-0.05397350341081619,
0.38220834732055664,
0.1976788192987442,
-0.26615551114082336,
-0.8808438777923584,
0.10757248848676682,
-0.4061751067638397,
0.504595160484314,
0.6000295281410217,
-0.10339075326919556,
-0.42035719752311707,
0.09437503665685654,
-0.12704619765281677,
0.04740578308701515,
-0.2787894010543823,
0.29179826378822327,
0.06570687144994736,
-0.5351659059524536,
0.8213327527046204,
-0.12089043110609055,
0.3362332880496979,
-0.6184532046318054,
-0.36891448497772217,
-0.39795175194740295,
0.1758839637041092,
-0.19807875156402588,
-0.8415278196334839,
-0.0511811189353466,
0.06767956167459488,
-0.012140010483562946,
-0.1955077052116394,
0.5791600942611694,
-0.45770421624183655,
-0.9233847856521606,
-0.2540007531642914,
0.5970365405082703,
0.05620608106255531,
0.06290645897388458,
-0.7699780464172363,
0.3374820947647095,
-0.09243802726268768,
0.0145677225664258,
0.46272745728492737,
0.5380958914756775,
-0.1342848390340805,
0.9602414965629578,
0.9883544445037842,
-0.28902682662010193,
0.15857891738414764,
0.21898354589939117,
1.1661014556884766,
-0.32956984639167786,
-0.20752884447574615,
-0.897581934928894,
0.5914394855499268,
0.07291607558727264,
-0.35408398509025574,
0.8351033329963684,
0.6008703112602234,
0.6298487186431885,
-0.21717631816864014,
0.5539742708206177,
0.3313038945198059,
0.07784191519021988,
-0.7549430727958679,
0.21617716550827026,
-0.8794260025024414,
0.42273083329200745,
-0.2526499927043915,
-0.7928623557090759,
-0.5979092121124268,
0.6758009195327759,
-0.330608993768692,
0.010723245330154896,
0.5355021357536316,
0.7005677819252014,
-0.30765488743782043,
-0.07404866069555283,
0.43027639389038086,
-0.03697342425584793,
0.35961106419563293,
0.7794286012649536,
0.9763650298118591,
-0.47896283864974976,
0.9262422919273376,
-0.15489274263381958,
-0.34729549288749695,
-0.030976613983511925,
-0.7956580519676208,
-0.9439863562583923,
-0.4804146885871887,
-0.35881879925727844,
-0.3041278123855591,
-0.18640537559986115,
0.8941386342048645,
0.4630204439163208,
-0.6597617268562317,
-0.10570812225341797,
0.15127204358577728,
0.28032103180885315,
-0.016856178641319275,
-0.16856598854064941,
0.08139235526323318,
-0.39132359623908997,
-0.5729697346687317,
0.31877079606056213,
0.4765300452709198,
-0.19658908247947693,
-0.5326680541038513,
-0.06419619172811508,
-0.2200823724269867,
0.09251004457473755,
0.7786144018173218,
0.17070722579956055,
-0.7747673988342285,
0.25904181599617004,
0.2487064003944397,
0.10483945906162262,
0.2327202707529068,
0.7906890511512756,
-0.7161715030670166,
0.6047399640083313,
0.3660687208175659,
0.8552959561347961,
0.6717278361320496,
-0.2878369390964508,
0.33080223202705383,
-0.794214129447937,
0.22579830884933472,
0.23678617179393768,
0.5389016270637512,
0.3836219012737274,
-0.01182776503264904,
0.3110198974609375,
0.52573162317276,
-0.38532528281211853,
-0.8863232731819153,
0.37859344482421875,
-0.8548716902732849,
-0.13370220363140106,
1.187848448753357,
-0.026660585775971413,
-0.25530537962913513,
0.1868307739496231,
-0.27730345726013184,
-0.28919553756713867,
-0.35769015550613403,
0.5219272375106812,
0.8040582537651062,
-0.05846242606639862,
-0.6072588562965393,
-0.6092843413352966,
0.11459757387638092,
0.43852633237838745,
-1.0876402854919434,
-0.06528265029191971,
0.75026935338974,
0.25334247946739197,
0.13756710290908813,
0.32681289315223694,
-0.24941672384738922,
0.4005982577800751,
0.12283148616552353,
-0.1534252166748047,
-0.36965030431747437,
-0.38544750213623047,
-0.08501279354095459,
0.2583561837673187,
-0.20795929431915283,
-0.28007930517196655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17287v1 | Predicting the Big Five Personality Traits in Chinese Counselling Dialogues Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T05:30:55 | 2024-06-25T05:30:55 | Yang Yan, Lizhi Ma, Anqi Li, Jingsong Ma, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurate assessment of personality traits is crucial for effective
psycho-counseling, yet traditional methods like self-report questionnaires are
time-consuming and biased. This study exams whether Large Language Models
(LLMs) can predict the Big Five personality traits directly from counseling
dialogues and introduces an innovative framework to perform the task. Our
framework applies role-play and questionnaire-based prompting to condition LLMs
on counseling sessions, simulating client responses to the Big Five Inventory.
We evaluated our framework on 853 real-world counseling sessions, finding a
significant correlation between LLM-predicted and actual Big Five traits,
proving the validity of framework. Moreover, ablation studies highlight the
importance of role-play simulations and task simplification via questionnaires
in enhancing prediction accuracy. Meanwhile, our fine-tuned Llama3-8B model,
utilizing Direct Preference Optimization with Supervised Fine-Tuning, achieves
a 130.95\% improvement, surpassing the state-of-the-art Qwen1.5-110B by 36.94\%
in personality prediction validity. In conclusion, LLMs can predict personality
based on counseling dialogues. Our code and model are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/kuri-leo/BigFive-LLM-Predictor}, providing a valuable
tool for future research in computational psychometrics. | [
-0.3629539906978607,
-0.6000155806541443,
0.7008504867553711,
0.6568459272384644,
-0.14119186997413635,
-0.11838272213935852,
-0.5096471905708313,
-0.5927566885948181,
0.11990512907505035,
0.5035409927368164,
-0.6697844862937927,
-0.5141997933387756,
-0.49770230054855347,
0.21368376910686493,
0.057678479701280594,
0.7750695943832397,
0.3400461673736572,
0.7908268570899963,
-0.0010878341272473335,
0.14367014169692993,
-0.6936332583427429,
-0.533183217048645,
-0.7947000861167908,
-0.4808201193809509,
0.6759235858917236,
0.3794066607952118,
0.4651840031147003,
0.3893439769744873,
0.4106636941432953,
0.28821516036987305,
-0.36203891038894653,
0.014782586134970188,
-0.4760074317455292,
-0.01007948350161314,
0.07363370060920715,
-0.36618807911872864,
-0.7918156385421753,
0.13134026527404785,
0.48493367433547974,
0.4946649670600891,
-0.23529744148254395,
0.26190847158432007,
-0.00950517226010561,
0.501160204410553,
-0.29089459776878357,
0.3708721697330475,
-0.5869240760803223,
0.1643197238445282,
-0.004317163024097681,
0.07023012638092041,
-0.4527333676815033,
-0.36299267411231995,
0.15399396419525146,
-0.19056642055511475,
0.12066543847322464,
0.09227155148983002,
0.4729526937007904,
0.1321922391653061,
-0.6821800470352173,
0.06798568367958069,
-1.0234366655349731,
0.8203909993171692,
-0.8727920651435852,
0.09854035824537277,
0.6804463863372803,
0.6165863871574402,
-0.2751249372959137,
-0.2999735474586487,
-0.5298155546188354,
-0.42251595854759216,
-0.08612329512834549,
0.18238072097301483,
0.26860660314559937,
0.26213857531547546,
0.6219395995140076,
0.5951154828071594,
-0.4270571768283844,
0.3732106685638428,
-0.41445860266685486,
-0.09015680104494095,
1.050947904586792,
0.3497348427772522,
0.06095241382718086,
0.12465256452560425,
-0.1512930542230606,
0.14252160489559174,
-0.7899394631385803,
0.05116286873817444,
0.308784157037735,
0.0670720636844635,
-0.06731458753347397,
0.21656692028045654,
-0.02277420088648796,
0.3630937337875366,
0.49452075362205505,
-0.6906047463417053,
-0.0005304612568579614,
-0.1520063281059265,
-0.12317048758268356,
0.2758801579475403,
0.7298534512519836,
0.5372530221939087,
0.4218583405017853,
0.12495468556880951,
0.1448121964931488,
-0.2237945944070816,
0.10222544521093369,
-1.060683012008667,
-0.222556933760643,
0.5941727161407471,
-0.38754814863204956,
-0.36536088585853577,
-0.14975081384181976,
-0.7163857221603394,
-0.774455726146698,
-0.11054164171218872,
-0.20283940434455872,
-0.5370340347290039,
-0.3023017644882202,
-0.04390193894505501,
0.2755487263202667,
0.4287741184234619,
0.4305993914604187,
-0.9981269240379333,
-0.03219860792160034,
0.6396819353103638,
0.6537060141563416,
-0.1880546659231186,
-0.3563218116760254,
-0.6022866368293762,
0.09460758417844772,
-0.4303324818611145,
0.4684140980243683,
-0.5629091858863831,
-0.6217209696769714,
0.08087442070245743,
-0.013386772014200687,
0.26886871457099915,
-0.43319171667099,
0.7724639773368835,
-0.12903054058551788,
0.09946327656507492,
-0.5534222722053528,
-0.5431569218635559,
0.03429616242647171,
0.41954129934310913,
-0.6410104036331177,
0.6474565267562866,
0.0073404256254434586,
-0.5607852339744568,
0.5102235674858093,
-0.5647902488708496,
-0.23861558735370636,
0.06505948305130005,
0.06758712977170944,
-0.6540902853012085,
-0.16279587149620056,
0.28188371658325195,
0.8104897737503052,
-0.2701832056045532,
0.5598763227462769,
-0.8459827303886414,
-0.586482048034668,
0.7235246300697327,
-0.0719900131225586,
0.508230984210968,
0.05262827128171921,
-0.1230400949716568,
0.27979835867881775,
-0.5640912055969238,
-0.03634817525744438,
0.07014293223619461,
-0.24057993292808533,
-0.012383092194795609,
-0.009821838699281216,
-0.13440141081809998,
0.30455806851387024,
0.22709350287914276,
-0.8449267148971558,
0.4974748492240906,
-0.41665372252464294,
0.19445189833641052,
0.7364682555198669,
-0.009707302786409855,
0.03703834116458893,
-0.21236760914325714,
0.5677692890167236,
0.14115753769874573,
0.13848631083965302,
-0.052388351410627365,
-0.37521353363990784,
-0.41979914903640747,
-0.5130338072776794,
0.25195637345314026,
0.28821760416030884,
-0.24257387220859528,
0.8236549496650696,
-0.12602172791957855,
-0.9579216241836548,
-0.23812223970890045,
0.2155011147260666,
0.4891142249107361,
0.03969649598002434,
0.23996922373771667,
-0.08932574093341827,
-0.5868726372718811,
-0.5875678658485413,
-0.1799609214067459,
-0.10281204432249069,
-0.05335680767893791,
0.3009299635887146,
0.45296749472618103,
-0.04065147414803505,
0.5745841264724731,
-0.6497848033905029,
-0.2673485577106476,
-0.652064859867096,
-0.13132871687412262,
0.32429128885269165,
0.3406994640827179,
0.7896884679794312,
-0.7481478452682495,
-0.600380003452301,
-0.14615079760551453,
-0.37751907110214233,
0.0037829570937901735,
0.1570458561182022,
0.1063629686832428,
0.11802651733160019,
0.32828080654144287,
-0.3870234489440918,
0.27665072679519653,
0.7018981575965881,
-0.4510941505432129,
0.9160678386688232,
-0.07335160672664642,
-0.23334822058677673,
-1.0297478437423706,
0.17705367505550385,
0.12903079390525818,
0.09819140285253525,
-0.5434087514877319,
-0.18192245066165924,
-0.08276769518852234,
-0.0985453873872757,
-0.07361140102148056,
0.771468997001648,
-0.21141789853572845,
-0.1839393526315689,
-0.11015300452709198,
-0.12703804671764374,
-0.26582634449005127,
0.7203163504600525,
0.0031658150255680084,
0.6821937561035156,
0.38412612676620483,
-0.4948253631591797,
0.6692667007446289,
0.37033817172050476,
-0.3485296368598938,
0.6901195645332336,
-0.685016393661499,
0.12116429954767227,
0.11251114308834076,
0.7624222040176392,
-1.0745209455490112,
-0.5015837550163269,
-0.1402871161699295,
-0.40422362089157104,
0.12143690884113312,
-0.09207754582166672,
-0.25434327125549316,
-0.5045592188835144,
-0.33148157596588135,
-0.08404182642698288,
0.44074222445487976,
-0.4213767647743225,
0.4876234233379364,
-0.09134840965270996,
-0.4090147018432617,
-0.5908186435699463,
-0.35610154271125793,
-0.14436520636081696,
-0.40504589676856995,
-0.36179718375205994,
0.3260895609855652,
-0.436549574136734,
-0.05463168025016785,
-0.5256062746047974,
0.1404818445444107,
0.029321972280740738,
0.22935333847999573,
0.3753298819065094,
0.5603929758071899,
-0.0580507330596447,
0.12121100723743439,
-0.06974782794713974,
-0.18471239507198334,
0.1597585678100586,
-0.04117123782634735,
0.5497213006019592,
-0.2700589895248413,
-0.39616766571998596,
-0.2684018313884735,
0.03963936120271683,
0.8002489805221558,
-0.4656117856502533,
0.7544978260993958,
1.0089118480682373,
0.010288641788065434,
-0.0485832579433918,
-0.6872269511222839,
-0.23824842274188995,
-0.43745890259742737,
0.49949127435684204,
-0.3082462549209595,
-0.8729838728904724,
0.6729400753974915,
-0.021485362201929092,
0.18425258994102478,
0.04796295613050461,
0.7415632009506226,
0.022252732887864113,
1.5639971494674683,
0.6556470990180969,
-0.24279919266700745,
0.5333296656608582,
-0.16423571109771729,
0.47542425990104675,
-0.9290831089019775,
0.05105595290660858,
-0.19144216179847717,
-0.46529972553253174,
-0.7812780737876892,
0.11602125316858292,
0.4761022627353668,
-0.09500949084758759,
-0.5656241774559021,
-0.28107181191444397,
-0.248553067445755,
0.327412873506546,
0.2798006236553192,
-0.09847941994667053,
0.33710452914237976,
-0.27664491534233093,
-0.22447535395622253,
-0.21064522862434387,
-0.06260249763727188,
-0.39354467391967773,
1.122357726097107,
0.4834405779838562,
0.53593909740448,
0.21259890496730804,
0.41797924041748047,
-0.03864182531833649,
0.5238918662071228,
-1.1461608409881592,
0.6483944654464722,
-0.02642028033733368,
-0.6837171912193298,
-0.5211359858512878,
-0.23840825259685516,
-0.6726242899894714,
0.22060848772525787,
-0.28527340292930603,
-0.8968931436538696,
-0.06222290173172951,
0.2534390091896057,
-0.42289549112319946,
0.0652298554778099,
-0.5124044418334961,
0.8061497807502747,
-0.29065200686454773,
-0.3134556710720062,
-0.22395794093608856,
-0.5863953828811646,
0.600567638874054,
-0.1528877466917038,
-0.18833358585834503,
-0.26047283411026,
0.35677990317344666,
0.363155722618103,
-0.17449341714382172,
0.7978976964950562,
-0.251426100730896,
-0.21577531099319458,
-0.22121313214302063,
0.21150678396224976,
0.41026851534843445,
-0.0007553951581940055,
-0.40063586831092834,
-0.031992800533771515,
0.4604025185108185,
-0.3609444797039032,
-0.9161175489425659,
0.5967371463775635,
-0.982128918170929,
-0.5172571539878845,
-0.31361737847328186,
-0.2867415249347687,
-0.6793597340583801,
0.20958112180233002,
0.12368886172771454,
0.26650846004486084,
-0.5472964644432068,
0.2523631751537323,
0.34847480058670044,
-0.24755799770355225,
0.23072300851345062,
0.6459866762161255,
-0.6312979459762573,
-0.32608264684677124,
0.8656007647514343,
0.047728195786476135,
0.23471754789352417,
-0.16967281699180603,
0.5254144668579102,
-0.13021333515644073,
-0.48462602496147156,
-0.18295593559741974,
0.5067209601402283,
-0.4398844838142395,
0.06208007410168648,
-0.28066810965538025,
-0.33217981457710266,
-0.6104230880737305,
-0.03838863596320152,
-0.24811965227127075,
0.17789702117443085,
0.2278738021850586,
-0.2852141559123993,
0.21583212912082672,
0.5738815069198608,
0.28352585434913635,
0.3709769546985626,
-0.7514771223068237,
-0.12022958695888519,
0.3074836730957031,
0.3865705728530884,
0.276139497756958,
-0.30925703048706055,
-0.22759968042373657,
0.07775817066431046,
-0.5946300029754639,
-0.5567948818206787,
0.636458694934845,
0.04133369028568268,
0.27804985642433167,
0.9477919340133667,
-0.0035271723754704,
0.5750475525856018,
-0.08898912370204926,
0.9742637276649475,
0.0665370374917984,
-0.6427229642868042,
0.28736740350723267,
-0.6121162176132202,
0.16715788841247559,
0.3271065652370453,
0.39601778984069824,
-0.7688300013542175,
-0.16758908331394196,
-0.6680095195770264,
-0.41638338565826416,
0.7399227023124695,
-0.12907782196998596,
0.017797064036130905,
0.2681882083415985,
0.3610653877258301,
-0.061060626059770584,
0.3139553368091583,
-0.7193230390548706,
-0.06795869022607803,
-0.12537482380867004,
-0.22822752594947815,
-0.272009938955307,
-0.44794976711273193,
-0.10989897698163986,
-0.46312665939331055,
0.7218695282936096,
-0.48919421434402466,
0.3924538195133209,
0.018159348517656326,
0.47054243087768555,
-0.21889878809452057,
0.36885419487953186,
0.6095777153968811,
0.6486309170722961,
-0.440860778093338,
-0.29953956604003906,
0.48693355917930603,
-0.620622992515564,
-0.003398015396669507,
-0.14697465300559998,
0.34673061966896057,
-0.26053643226623535,
0.44392523169517517,
0.8690645098686218,
-0.04758860170841217,
-0.6536834836006165,
0.7226030230522156,
-0.12380704283714294,
-0.2496311217546463,
-1.0499006509780884,
0.23000960052013397,
0.2564693093299866,
0.2315351366996765,
0.025061363354325294,
-0.5093095302581787,
-0.0023474234621971846,
-0.6340736150741577,
-0.4385233521461487,
0.30442339181900024,
-0.5209782123565674,
-0.3821237087249756,
0.23917345702648163,
0.36441418528556824,
-0.10408218950033188,
0.6196994185447693,
-0.12060124427080154,
-0.4856540560722351,
0.6193417906761169,
0.5864107608795166,
0.8117546439170837,
-0.5462801456451416,
0.15201127529144287,
0.4543050229549408,
-0.3814201056957245,
-0.13055002689361572,
0.31327930092811584,
0.1230904683470726,
-0.9296137094497681,
-0.6825522184371948,
-0.8119007349014282,
-0.6940650939941406,
0.49959796667099,
-0.5544975996017456,
0.4394044280052185,
-0.6933866739273071,
-0.086293064057827,
-0.07568485289812088,
0.4952888488769531,
-0.3177933990955353,
0.24917784333229065,
0.4369000792503357,
0.5913205146789551,
-0.6447324156761169,
0.9394382238388062,
0.802802324295044,
-0.21556183695793152,
-1.1166493892669678,
0.023420967161655426,
0.27099549770355225,
-0.712284505367279,
0.6505903005599976,
0.2910173237323761,
0.010020134970545769,
-0.07541994005441666,
-0.7806150913238525,
-0.771668016910553,
1.1723335981369019,
0.4182637929916382,
-0.34571442008018494,
-0.29653412103652954,
0.03775494545698166,
0.6907406449317932,
-0.45027869939804077,
0.5475581288337708,
0.7105256915092468,
0.7284206748008728,
0.6387638449668884,
-1.0980545282363892,
0.005157128907740116,
-0.3084668815135956,
0.17771083116531372,
-0.07605857402086258,
-0.8495926260948181,
0.6281036734580994,
-0.33236730098724365,
0.23487748205661774,
0.29839903116226196,
0.5953556895256042,
0.4317466616630554,
0.09315931051969528,
0.479657918214798,
0.09471409767866135,
0.7871356010437012,
0.052009791135787964,
0.8395843505859375,
-0.6566367149353027,
0.22718343138694763,
0.8608167767524719,
-0.5178012251853943,
0.6595141291618347,
0.09901735931634903,
-0.17716912925243378,
0.5947157144546509,
0.6112025380134583,
-0.44569480419158936,
-0.031286776065826416,
0.18536338210105896,
-0.051797982305288315,
-0.42186859250068665,
-0.2370869517326355,
-0.14703139662742615,
0.8780409693717957,
0.5147060751914978,
-0.3621276319026947,
0.3651482164859772,
-0.021384479478001595,
0.32400181889533997,
-0.22338399291038513,
-0.2269277125597,
0.6307641863822937,
0.14806808531284332,
-0.8588044047355652,
0.44548842310905457,
0.09832689166069031,
0.6170447468757629,
-0.6485575437545776,
-0.18686333298683167,
-0.3130548894405365,
0.44079241156578064,
-0.3024453818798065,
-0.7874401211738586,
-0.004231212195008993,
-0.2374589443206787,
0.14752197265625,
-0.2752731740474701,
0.7354030609130859,
-0.4884243309497833,
-0.36426958441734314,
0.10936097055673599,
0.36938995122909546,
0.09717603027820587,
-0.1351911425590515,
-0.45204368233680725,
-0.31586259603500366,
-0.16021201014518738,
-0.29617083072662354,
0.6350866556167603,
0.23632575571537018,
-0.09144613146781921,
0.8633474111557007,
0.7351600527763367,
0.34804078936576843,
-0.552375078201294,
0.00847300048917532,
0.6459815502166748,
-0.9296372532844543,
-0.7152905464172363,
-0.8901371359825134,
0.2786272168159485,
-0.246336430311203,
-0.49647700786590576,
0.6409654021263123,
0.11073791235685349,
0.4775322675704956,
0.03402040898799896,
0.7264921069145203,
0.17988057434558868,
0.7510347962379456,
-0.45645397901535034,
0.6627447009086609,
-0.26028549671173096,
0.004523386247456074,
-0.40990549325942993,
-0.9686547517776489,
-0.0014752313727512956,
0.4526124596595764,
-0.8178597688674927,
0.2613581418991089,
0.6517630815505981,
0.7323449850082397,
0.17035090923309326,
0.11694049835205078,
0.5648753046989441,
0.5559884309768677,
0.4819808602333069,
0.5292372703552246,
0.672360360622406,
0.24612514674663544,
0.38399142026901245,
-0.22861140966415405,
0.04705129191279411,
-0.565850019454956,
-0.6226602792739868,
-1.0708911418914795,
-0.4412901997566223,
0.04590144380927086,
-0.2651185095310211,
-0.4249817132949829,
1.0511448383331299,
0.48932042717933655,
-0.5695106983184814,
-0.31732162833213806,
0.34420400857925415,
0.07391838729381561,
-0.3783569931983948,
-0.21250396966934204,
0.16919293999671936,
0.08350764214992523,
-0.6942417025566101,
-0.029365232214331627,
0.1121380478143692,
-0.060815420001745224,
-0.8188567161560059,
-0.0174428541213274,
0.20292514562606812,
-0.04008110240101814,
0.6146190166473389,
0.002597598824650049,
-0.8556003570556641,
-0.5053867697715759,
0.0817924365401268,
-0.1898948699235916,
0.06103580445051193,
0.6795544624328613,
-0.2887430787086487,
0.1601414978504181,
0.09563512355089188,
0.23191247880458832,
0.4110584259033203,
0.0501934252679348,
0.9287534952163696,
-0.3903491497039795,
0.011580085381865501,
0.17790505290031433,
0.45100224018096924,
0.28502893447875977,
-0.622006356716156,
0.4811677634716034,
-0.02741456963121891,
-0.6481801271438599,
-0.5872384309768677,
0.295486718416214,
-0.9572635889053345,
-0.04860465228557587,
1.2634661197662354,
-0.4951895773410797,
-0.2308194935321808,
-0.07313764840364456,
-0.7011940479278564,
0.08408913016319275,
-0.3691396713256836,
0.8610466718673706,
0.8691865801811218,
-0.31800445914268494,
-0.20380666851997375,
-0.4201350212097168,
0.634564995765686,
0.5005570650100708,
-0.47160056233406067,
0.19181367754936218,
0.6079286336898804,
0.3060277998447418,
0.1364661157131195,
0.4289146065711975,
0.047221601009368896,
0.24906384944915771,
-0.4007616341114044,
0.20786258578300476,
-0.19145725667476654,
0.0011964502045884728,
-0.16534452140331268,
-0.12825140357017517,
0.39805668592453003,
0.4320560693740845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17283v1 | A Recursive Encoding for Cuneiform Signs | 2024-06-25T05:18:12 | 2024-06-25T05:18:12 | Daniel M. Stelzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the most significant problems in cuneiform pedagogy is the process of
looking up unknown signs, which often involves a tedious page-by-page search
through a sign list. This paper proposes a new "recursive encoding" for signs,
which represents the arrangement of strokes in a way a computer can process. A
series of new algorithms then offers students a new way to look up signs by any
distinctive component, as well as providing new ways to render signs and
tablets electronically. | [
-0.2514273226261139,
-0.274883896112442,
0.679715096950531,
0.030158178880810738,
-0.12401074171066284,
0.4395830035209656,
0.08025673776865005,
-0.2763133943080902,
0.2746502161026001,
0.2358497828245163,
-0.9437735676765442,
-0.44681206345558167,
-1.0225468873977661,
0.3393046259880066,
-0.37884441018104553,
0.342187762260437,
-0.2571675777435303,
-0.2564805746078491,
0.47898799180984497,
-0.01669405773282051,
-0.2053728997707367,
-0.6078242659568787,
-0.8698686957359314,
-0.44229161739349365,
0.5378650426864624,
0.4429098963737488,
0.8751868605613708,
0.5831050276756287,
0.4598662853240967,
0.3592693507671356,
0.00902711320668459,
0.3424776792526245,
-0.29534175992012024,
0.21853134036064148,
0.00780911510810256,
-0.3276130259037018,
-0.054198816418647766,
0.22270266711711884,
0.5964610576629639,
0.9768936634063721,
0.03392760828137398,
-0.03296634927392006,
-0.4646564722061157,
0.8843885064125061,
-0.5324190855026245,
0.1887451708316803,
-0.18963447213172913,
0.24833820760250092,
-0.26519450545310974,
-0.36247962713241577,
-0.7127594351768494,
-0.6019837260246277,
-0.0999513491988182,
-0.8166248798370361,
0.22317013144493103,
0.07453170418739319,
0.6543878316879272,
-0.20795731246471405,
-0.20493793487548828,
-0.5456253290176392,
-0.5831663012504578,
0.5738831162452698,
-0.33581215143203735,
0.8657360672950745,
0.17396433651447296,
0.25739938020706177,
-0.8026484251022339,
-0.968242883682251,
-0.6082198023796082,
0.024926744401454926,
-0.036280762404203415,
-0.03389755263924599,
-0.15899154543876648,
0.12307044118642807,
0.5203490257263184,
0.4942888617515564,
-0.39874163269996643,
-0.05091947689652443,
-0.42104771733283997,
-0.18078410625457764,
0.5704069137573242,
0.38032329082489014,
0.9085419774055481,
0.159733384847641,
0.07353539019823074,
-0.2541961967945099,
-0.7544675469398499,
0.3526322841644287,
0.4961550235748291,
0.27265429496765137,
0.13602980971336365,
0.6206639409065247,
-0.1833709180355072,
1.000388741493225,
0.675935685634613,
0.011899415403604507,
0.19389060139656067,
0.07351276278495789,
-0.0023151771165430546,
0.15497493743896484,
0.39162227511405945,
0.37733137607574463,
0.33546847105026245,
-0.03442518785595894,
-0.2436407506465912,
0.035039447247982025,
0.053271662443876266,
-0.6183095574378967,
-0.664962887763977,
0.11084210127592087,
-0.5600608587265015,
-0.24121159315109253,
0.1164545789361,
-0.1727534979581833,
-0.7610098123550415,
-0.23143252730369568,
0.43459445238113403,
-0.48736661672592163,
-0.2819814085960388,
0.4268183708190918,
-0.3513565957546234,
0.1784895807504654,
0.4670208692550659,
-1.304750919342041,
0.3109721541404724,
0.6023274660110474,
0.6970078945159912,
0.1975630223751068,
-0.1157432571053505,
-0.5683493614196777,
-0.18408311903476715,
-0.06250419467687607,
0.784397542476654,
-1.0311980247497559,
-0.3865722119808197,
0.011120550334453583,
0.27836886048316956,
-0.19470730423927307,
-0.10724388062953949,
0.1531933695077896,
-0.3847741186618805,
0.19393257796764374,
-0.12417095899581909,
-0.6500958800315857,
-0.4562034606933594,
0.04612383991479874,
-1.2027831077575684,
1.0237798690795898,
0.41626864671707153,
-0.6385610103607178,
0.06777193397283554,
-0.47402283549308777,
-0.7632972598075867,
0.18775704503059387,
-0.49936991930007935,
-0.2724483609199524,
0.27131614089012146,
0.2975527048110962,
0.34730103611946106,
0.2131405770778656,
-0.47771498560905457,
0.3811303973197937,
-0.7234621047973633,
0.49694088101387024,
-0.14439016580581665,
1.3133395910263062,
0.00637280847877264,
-0.646317183971405,
-0.1012350395321846,
-0.6622710824012756,
0.031264156103134155,
0.20340579748153687,
-0.5395134091377258,
-0.31673353910446167,
0.056296881288290024,
-0.19635646045207977,
0.05152711644768715,
0.3595639169216156,
-0.6629225611686707,
0.44077974557876587,
-0.6060742139816284,
0.5903291702270508,
0.6261029839515686,
0.11477047950029373,
0.3488830029964447,
-0.23005756735801697,
0.3188343346118927,
0.047831159085035324,
0.2190861850976944,
-0.3982611298561096,
-1.0130022764205933,
-0.7762091755867004,
0.5503185987472534,
-0.2404794692993164,
0.3125176429748535,
-0.6810542941093445,
-0.16817207634449005,
0.20879046618938446,
-0.4911239445209503,
-0.4274303615093231,
-0.05257172882556915,
0.3987489640712738,
0.2080049216747284,
0.042811594903469086,
-0.3592154383659363,
-0.6180986762046814,
-0.37667444348335266,
-0.10688520967960358,
-0.0221603624522686,
0.18183688819408417,
-0.0951075553894043,
0.26659682393074036,
-0.02423013001680374,
-0.0832204669713974,
-0.46811097860336304,
0.1550946682691574,
-0.1928127557039261,
0.45790213346481323,
0.5789565443992615,
0.3626430928707123,
0.09024312347173691,
-0.9421002864837646,
-0.5604283809661865,
0.2520790994167328,
-0.2158965766429901,
0.11545208841562271,
-0.5043044090270996,
-0.04925849288702011,
0.2399829626083374,
0.5503254532814026,
-0.47644224762916565,
0.5565453767776489,
0.4185739755630493,
-0.604102611541748,
0.6547093391418457,
-0.2672457695007324,
0.3232530355453491,
-0.36458516120910645,
-0.29166269302368164,
-0.15809443593025208,
0.03376421704888344,
-0.7725447416305542,
0.2825150191783905,
0.15194517374038696,
-0.230730339884758,
-0.46186918020248413,
0.2277456521987915,
-1.0719780921936035,
0.04205001890659332,
-0.15918251872062683,
0.3607932925224304,
0.06625329703092575,
0.40711021423339844,
0.4019801914691925,
0.7066330313682556,
0.5165756344795227,
-0.5624598264694214,
0.6657754778862,
0.0985746681690216,
-0.1969180405139923,
0.5087893009185791,
-0.03646419942378998,
0.2943934500217438,
-0.36896857619285583,
-0.17012427747249603,
-1.0368764400482178,
-0.15029938519001007,
0.5323051810264587,
-0.5831802487373352,
0.6080445647239685,
0.03886418044567108,
0.02043144404888153,
-0.6762083172798157,
-0.3616676926612854,
0.6783158779144287,
0.2867196500301361,
-0.6454914212226868,
0.6699126958847046,
0.29259541630744934,
0.2744016945362091,
-0.6229333281517029,
-0.3235301375389099,
-0.12738162279129028,
0.2553919553756714,
-0.7243243455886841,
0.3614949584007263,
0.04014947637915611,
0.00037525934749282897,
-0.08867146819829941,
-0.26536324620246887,
-0.013241991400718689,
0.0057651689276099205,
0.49462100863456726,
0.11296255886554718,
-0.12434806674718857,
-0.15454420447349548,
-0.06189345195889473,
-0.34139150381088257,
0.1618528515100479,
-0.41501688957214355,
0.5367523431777954,
-0.12750788033008575,
-0.3375854194164276,
-0.7394680380821228,
0.5579835772514343,
0.607941210269928,
0.004089435562491417,
0.09195980429649353,
0.2652709484100342,
-0.8567301034927368,
-0.19931462407112122,
-0.3047493100166321,
-0.007366444915533066,
-0.5891878604888916,
0.16435639560222626,
-0.40026822686195374,
-0.457859069108963,
0.3516716957092285,
-0.3139784038066864,
0.06879425793886185,
0.08712409436702728,
0.4186939299106598,
-0.2211177498102188,
1.0531405210494995,
0.5888209342956543,
0.48236924409866333,
0.44438570737838745,
-0.3280200958251953,
0.5163553953170776,
-0.765062689781189,
-0.803117036819458,
-0.4268293082714081,
-0.42777159810066223,
-0.7659160494804382,
-0.18667072057724,
-0.14201317727565765,
-0.3716863691806793,
-0.3644562065601349,
0.8542795777320862,
-1.3080638647079468,
0.715893030166626,
0.7500250935554504,
0.19661954045295715,
0.3980301320552826,
0.17824435234069824,
-0.09930291026830673,
-0.06306033581495285,
-0.3939739465713501,
-0.37101754546165466,
0.9508921504020691,
-0.0937730148434639,
0.7844233512878418,
0.005526533350348473,
0.9692718982696533,
0.3300173282623291,
0.3012104332447052,
-0.8821061253547668,
0.47918522357940674,
-0.4684721529483795,
-0.4639805555343628,
-0.41342031955718994,
-0.014240642078220844,
-1.2595856189727783,
-0.29084333777427673,
-0.3957211971282959,
-1.0440857410430908,
0.25158271193504333,
0.01377010252326727,
-0.3408886790275574,
0.7600094079971313,
-0.621100664138794,
0.6861683130264282,
-0.3981482982635498,
0.10288982838392258,
0.13164839148521423,
-0.1745404601097107,
0.09435489773750305,
0.4177420735359192,
0.0825442299246788,
-0.01594732329249382,
0.3866276741027832,
0.776232898235321,
-0.5012747049331665,
0.6122905611991882,
-0.2120707631111145,
-0.05321090668439865,
0.3687104880809784,
0.4674549996852875,
0.7696963548660278,
-0.44953373074531555,
0.11309139430522919,
-0.19617190957069397,
0.10903472453355789,
-0.24103230237960815,
-0.5782861113548279,
0.6972463130950928,
-0.7743138670921326,
-0.8365285396575928,
-0.7156471610069275,
-0.42099761962890625,
0.1934284120798111,
0.5966083407402039,
0.5438233017921448,
0.49361103773117065,
0.1563577502965927,
-0.5539246797561646,
0.6608772277832031,
-0.2504611313343048,
0.3535301089286804,
0.16969481110572815,
-0.256065309047699,
-0.11331191658973694,
1.1150224208831787,
0.25329259037971497,
-0.0962323546409607,
0.4798606336116791,
0.07296331226825714,
-0.3500269651412964,
-0.8240436315536499,
-0.339510440826416,
0.34937193989753723,
-0.9390960931777954,
0.04373567923903465,
-0.005607000086456537,
-0.47433552145957947,
-0.1997881382703781,
-0.5340080261230469,
-0.07284707576036453,
-0.7130595445632935,
-0.262431800365448,
-0.06680060923099518,
0.17372842133045197,
1.0538805723190308,
-0.05557656288146973,
0.3985133171081543,
-0.45267900824546814,
0.5292271375656128,
0.42954668402671814,
0.6146116256713867,
0.14079229533672333,
-0.22494736313819885,
-0.0779246985912323,
-0.06376154720783234,
-0.42565539479255676,
-0.9990010857582092,
0.026166314259171486,
0.033954959362745285,
0.45528095960617065,
0.5560348629951477,
0.02703445963561535,
0.53605717420578,
-0.44326573610305786,
0.3329111933708191,
0.6757197380065918,
-0.7791086435317993,
0.4936472177505493,
-0.07886337488889694,
0.15713554620742798,
0.2874985337257385,
0.6067826747894287,
-1.1188764572143555,
-0.33418598771095276,
-0.4244726300239563,
-0.7327821254730225,
0.55878084897995,
0.4910725951194763,
0.22242522239685059,
-0.30843082070350647,
0.5036783814430237,
0.3452628552913666,
-0.2183365523815155,
-0.5260441303253174,
-0.6462407112121582,
-0.571607232093811,
-0.22683210670948029,
0.6758043766021729,
-0.13292087614536285,
0.24234811961650848,
-0.4483858644962311,
0.4927786588668823,
0.5192925930023193,
0.4669307470321655,
0.05210081860423088,
-0.09888429939746857,
-0.2553021013736725,
0.05377821996808052,
0.5463905930519104,
0.5482205748558044,
-0.1651318073272705,
0.48563772439956665,
-0.2987002432346344,
-1.1916481256484985,
0.43538370728492737,
-0.06537085771560669,
-0.41850459575653076,
0.13824044167995453,
0.11895325034856796,
0.5937221050262451,
0.23808178305625916,
-0.35111135244369507,
0.36983752250671387,
-0.12769560515880585,
-0.1216360405087471,
-0.6641358733177185,
0.29528889060020447,
-0.055566295981407166,
0.1720041036605835,
0.47845321893692017,
-0.34598150849342346,
0.19406427443027496,
-0.4056624174118042,
0.24391527473926544,
0.13173997402191162,
-0.09528396278619766,
-0.2440667301416397,
0.7135476469993591,
0.5158863663673401,
-0.9765090942382812,
1.2386482954025269,
-0.3442328870296478,
-0.5445479154586792,
0.7081664204597473,
0.7824354767799377,
0.7543478012084961,
-0.2786332070827484,
0.5485231876373291,
0.7981511354446411,
0.3955584764480591,
-0.11839809268712997,
0.8331025242805481,
-0.051411449909210205,
-0.4653063118457794,
-0.33926746249198914,
-0.2596581280231476,
-0.8790022134780884,
-0.013000310398638248,
-0.4548432528972626,
0.27351677417755127,
-0.8906353116035461,
-0.2562571167945862,
0.45362287759780884,
-0.06912150979042053,
-0.730290949344635,
0.39237383008003235,
0.7027552127838135,
0.9393332600593567,
-0.5607557892799377,
0.515307605266571,
0.6978437304496765,
-0.40359634160995483,
-0.8565046787261963,
-0.590461015701294,
-0.0658888891339302,
-1.102327585220337,
0.7863268256187439,
0.5857033729553223,
-0.4810762107372284,
0.14635995030403137,
-0.30109262466430664,
-0.915876030921936,
0.9646620750427246,
0.06611596047878265,
-0.8380094170570374,
-0.4301145672798157,
0.42223718762397766,
0.09579160809516907,
-0.4306219816207886,
0.11324377357959747,
0.7542915940284729,
0.7618148922920227,
-0.17391905188560486,
-0.2974795997142792,
0.6333066821098328,
-0.489988774061203,
-0.11613325774669647,
0.6860548853874207,
-0.09488318860530853,
0.8278411030769348,
-0.494343638420105,
-0.9779506921768188,
0.07409294694662094,
0.47554200887680054,
0.05532197654247284,
0.6061676144599915,
-0.12190283089876175,
0.3910105228424072,
1.0858395099639893,
-0.5015595555305481,
0.8770366907119751,
-0.2764478325843811,
0.1533612608909607,
0.8951008319854736,
0.4230233132839203,
0.3564804494380951,
0.5344537496566772,
-0.3499910235404968,
1.0062357187271118,
0.6849860548973083,
-0.2636907696723938,
0.15757325291633606,
0.40970927476882935,
-0.37063077092170715,
-0.4405757784843445,
0.35977843403816223,
-0.05697614699602127,
-0.026842599734663963,
0.6434602737426758,
-0.4628484547138214,
-0.3439532518386841,
-0.11530118435621262,
-0.03928947076201439,
0.5234534740447998,
-0.7392935752868652,
0.08077450841665268,
0.0564308799803257,
-0.4120701253414154,
0.5621873736381531,
-0.03223555535078049,
0.4083714187145233,
-0.25486528873443604,
-0.4506571292877197,
-0.23467335104942322,
-0.24745820462703705,
-0.6736206412315369,
-1.267180323600769,
0.0726512223482132,
-0.41399624943733215,
-0.0032478393986821175,
-0.07587262243032455,
0.6675262451171875,
-0.02392168901860714,
-0.7491614818572998,
0.04206196591258049,
-0.0062312595546245575,
0.4446251094341278,
0.09984689205884933,
-0.4538447856903076,
0.19977417588233948,
-0.15400151908397675,
-0.17820675671100616,
-0.21216638386249542,
0.4942857623100281,
-0.301539808511734,
0.6676069498062134,
0.5144487619400024,
0.03110787272453308,
0.42854809761047363,
0.10625697672367096,
0.541621208190918,
-1.0997780561447144,
-0.33120325207710266,
-0.45160111784935,
0.500876247882843,
-0.03689024597406387,
-0.16845625638961792,
0.6361247897148132,
0.20117585361003876,
1.0138014554977417,
-0.10736653953790665,
0.7014126777648926,
-0.04578819498419762,
-0.16134223341941833,
-0.2920764088630676,
0.7646726369857788,
-0.020035097375512123,
-0.09948942810297012,
-0.23137116432189941,
-0.7943791747093201,
-0.6500062942504883,
0.8618568778038025,
-0.25496628880500793,
-0.04837428405880928,
0.8015333414077759,
0.5448395013809204,
-0.043303679674863815,
0.10541415959596634,
0.32757747173309326,
-0.21183526515960693,
-0.05492311343550682,
1.1435154676437378,
0.7826617956161499,
-0.6894962787628174,
0.582270622253418,
-0.6071479916572571,
-0.14907099306583405,
-0.2212027907371521,
-0.695595920085907,
-0.9365720152854919,
-0.8976821899414062,
-0.4860091209411621,
-0.42124295234680176,
0.02683141827583313,
0.5636328458786011,
0.10302576422691345,
-0.9045459628105164,
-0.06364929676055908,
-0.2617320120334625,
0.5294227004051208,
-0.6103977560997009,
-0.07405344396829605,
0.7824907302856445,
0.02845749445259571,
-0.807433009147644,
-0.004410650581121445,
0.39559313654899597,
0.3309735953807831,
-0.1731080859899521,
-0.33411234617233276,
-0.08687788993120193,
0.05157988518476486,
0.534712553024292,
0.931225597858429,
-0.5329986214637756,
-0.5204480886459351,
0.1496792435646057,
-0.021102825179696083,
0.2807231843471527,
1.186347246170044,
-0.6051719188690186,
0.7800101637840271,
0.5949140191078186,
0.3123129904270172,
0.5914263129234314,
-0.32202932238578796,
0.15336677432060242,
-0.2526928782463074,
-0.19285166263580322,
-0.05833809822797775,
0.48677781224250793,
0.4295896291732788,
-0.6681129336357117,
0.28818807005882263,
0.12836168706417084,
-0.07406412065029144,
-0.5521835088729858,
0.5835210680961609,
-1.0672755241394043,
-0.09485621750354767,
0.6829622983932495,
-0.07241841405630112,
-0.46034368872642517,
-0.4629952907562256,
-0.4200434982776642,
0.3433799147605896,
-0.2993544936180115,
1.0306973457336426,
0.6969570517539978,
-0.7375879883766174,
-0.4221489429473877,
0.09225451946258545,
0.41276511549949646,
-0.22767314314842224,
-0.23492461442947388,
0.13738249242305756,
0.4277014434337616,
0.3113357424736023,
0.2755068838596344,
0.6189932823181152,
-0.2821711599826813,
0.9502515196800232,
0.39651036262512207,
-0.06177210807800293,
-0.6729841828346252,
-0.36028802394866943,
-0.04672333225607872,
0.1508631408214569,
0.3294581472873688,
-0.21813420951366425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17282v2 | SetBERT: Enhancing Retrieval Performance for Boolean Logic and Set Operation Queries | 2024-06-25T05:14:54 | 2024-06-26T14:38:31 | Quan Mai, Susan Gauch, Douglas Adams | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce SetBERT, a fine-tuned BERT-based model designed to enhance query
embeddings for set operations and Boolean logic queries, such as Intersection
(AND), Difference (NOT), and Union (OR). SetBERT significantly improves
retrieval performance for logic-structured queries, an area where both
traditional and neural retrieval methods typically underperform. We propose an
innovative use of inversed-contrastive loss, focusing on identifying the
negative sentence, and fine-tuning BERT with a dataset generated via prompt
GPT. Furthermore, we demonstrate that, unlike other BERT-based models,
fine-tuning with triplet loss actually degrades performance for this specific
task. Our experiments reveal that SetBERT-base not only significantly
outperforms BERT-base (up to a 63% improvement in Recall) but also achieves
performance comparable to the much larger BERT-large model, despite being only
one-third the size. | [
-0.2739039659500122,
-0.7309306263923645,
0.44605639576911926,
0.24606412649154663,
-0.0927940309047699,
-0.08182520419359207,
-0.16710466146469116,
-0.34987884759902954,
0.1963166743516922,
0.8729149699211121,
-0.434135764837265,
-0.4540976285934448,
-0.34575775265693665,
-0.30201032757759094,
-0.39157480001449585,
0.9951567053794861,
0.25612160563468933,
0.13856510818004608,
0.18895408511161804,
-0.38851678371429443,
-0.5775010585784912,
-0.498321533203125,
-0.46167659759521484,
-0.36122849583625793,
0.3686453402042389,
0.13491171598434448,
0.9430551528930664,
0.14059361815452576,
0.697803795337677,
0.08187497407197952,
-0.15267561376094818,
0.33974650502204895,
-0.6940897107124329,
0.18128426373004913,
-0.40030601620674133,
-0.6031541228294373,
0.049462009221315384,
0.02525910921394825,
0.47166791558265686,
0.8392417430877686,
0.03652835637331009,
-0.16640977561473846,
-0.1557445228099823,
1.02872896194458,
-1.0808087587356567,
-0.09562116116285324,
-0.8712367415428162,
0.30101820826530457,
0.20152322947978973,
-0.2764873802661896,
-0.48315244913101196,
-0.8975464105606079,
0.17117342352867126,
-0.5330937504768372,
0.4722417891025543,
0.19169260561466217,
0.8574181199073792,
0.5060210227966309,
-0.459264874458313,
-0.12091034650802612,
-0.5441948771476746,
0.5871184468269348,
-0.6680428385734558,
0.5703524351119995,
0.2797904312610626,
0.07059349864721298,
-0.19531208276748657,
-0.7363476157188416,
-0.6058995127677917,
-0.211703822016716,
-0.22385695576667786,
0.3351231813430786,
-0.011952745728194714,
0.1949206441640854,
0.375082403421402,
0.3251386880874634,
-0.5080965161323547,
-0.2440284788608551,
-0.5565665364265442,
-0.03454860299825668,
0.305207759141922,
0.10506477952003479,
0.009005566127598286,
0.03705188259482384,
-0.1747443825006485,
0.1907203197479248,
-1.0945683717727661,
0.09016585350036621,
0.3829735219478607,
0.5310338735580444,
0.5876582264900208,
0.6060802936553955,
-0.290283203125,
1.1543720960617065,
-0.058811359107494354,
0.6780465841293335,
0.05431300029158592,
-0.13187487423419952,
-0.24643093347549438,
0.10325323790311813,
0.2805989682674408,
0.25933948159217834,
0.20414550602436066,
-0.1901368945837021,
-0.5161134600639343,
-0.021338095888495445,
0.2118128389120102,
-0.8490752577781677,
-1.1224733591079712,
0.017235368490219116,
-0.513751745223999,
-0.33093175292015076,
0.1362195909023285,
-0.02824459969997406,
-0.3999145030975342,
-0.5314371585845947,
1.141627311706543,
-0.9014788866043091,
0.26821526885032654,
0.28235316276550293,
-0.4222168028354645,
0.2620842754840851,
0.423126757144928,
-0.6621870994567871,
0.3915143609046936,
0.7863808870315552,
0.5591539740562439,
0.2808665633201599,
0.18554311990737915,
-1.0787709951400757,
-0.048142209649086,
-0.7825812697410583,
0.3844161331653595,
-1.1239269971847534,
-0.04622923210263252,
0.11429376900196075,
-0.1435714215040207,
0.018220875412225723,
-0.6959750652313232,
0.5854916572570801,
-1.003417730331421,
0.2693478465080261,
-0.6617525219917297,
-0.6330121755599976,
-0.1172930970788002,
0.3677998185157776,
-0.7232504487037659,
0.9600675106048584,
-0.12930701673030853,
-0.5434505343437195,
0.49100348353385925,
-0.6485341191291809,
-0.9331095218658447,
-0.049662720412015915,
-0.11583510786294937,
-0.23315761983394623,
0.29153791069984436,
0.5327095985412598,
0.3337588608264923,
0.05068005248904228,
-0.2760254144668579,
-0.23916061222553253,
-0.9153105020523071,
0.0028608106076717377,
0.16487160325050354,
1.1158714294433594,
-0.1656465381383896,
-0.11838286370038986,
0.11746526509523392,
-0.484073281288147,
0.42949745059013367,
-0.2726116180419922,
-0.22404874861240387,
-0.5193583965301514,
0.35978853702545166,
-0.39378708600997925,
0.1918003112077713,
0.20308245718479156,
-0.8065441846847534,
0.29931119084358215,
-0.5479813814163208,
0.4555805027484894,
0.6400688290596008,
-0.07104511559009552,
0.10922589898109436,
-0.2781832814216614,
-0.016385678201913834,
0.04000107944011688,
-0.026019809767603874,
0.15988579392433167,
-0.29091763496398926,
-0.898698091506958,
-0.30216288566589355,
0.5980305671691895,
0.7015756368637085,
-0.848189651966095,
0.5581909418106079,
0.07031489163637161,
-0.2508388161659241,
-0.9954168200492859,
-0.2039458006620407,
0.3824482858181,
0.8956232070922852,
0.550713837146759,
0.18279002606868744,
-0.4337647557258606,
-1.3688592910766602,
-0.10695232450962067,
0.056723423302173615,
0.10075826197862625,
0.34155553579330444,
0.39453163743019104,
0.09550061821937561,
0.7404526472091675,
-0.9448030591011047,
-0.2471827119588852,
0.17589028179645538,
0.1578369140625,
0.5285519361495972,
0.45003390312194824,
0.31861066818237305,
-0.932212233543396,
-0.3970547914505005,
-0.22631238400936127,
-0.7204459309577942,
-0.026752814650535583,
0.3533821702003479,
-0.35968494415283203,
0.29595044255256653,
0.5113464593887329,
-0.4120468199253082,
0.8048692345619202,
0.14708246290683746,
-0.18811970949172974,
0.6515413522720337,
-0.3709927797317505,
0.3666759431362152,
-0.5832439064979553,
0.03428717330098152,
-0.42516055703163147,
-0.24048694968223572,
-0.3544120788574219,
0.1053437739610672,
0.6213707327842712,
-0.28020551800727844,
-0.2760990858078003,
0.02691459469497204,
-0.12935325503349304,
-0.1723843216896057,
-0.026801086962223053,
0.3421204388141632,
0.34304317831993103,
0.3872186839580536,
-0.06998247653245926,
1.1323522329330444,
0.4464873969554901,
-0.7848828434944153,
0.285164475440979,
0.5657992959022522,
-0.2627811133861542,
0.585284411907196,
-0.9449861645698547,
-0.07207459211349487,
-0.1607452630996704,
0.2648504674434662,
-0.9648805856704712,
0.3024024963378906,
-0.00026695572887547314,
-0.4103718400001526,
0.11016813665628433,
-0.1467692106962204,
-0.7616125345230103,
-0.11805730313062668,
-0.753131628036499,
0.10754373669624329,
0.644747793674469,
-1.1962933540344238,
0.16241969168186188,
-0.1681148111820221,
0.2071087807416916,
-0.7979639172554016,
-0.5925971269607544,
-0.13574329018592834,
0.21694433689117432,
-0.8505975008010864,
0.5939303040504456,
0.02351219952106476,
-0.13978515565395355,
0.058360755443573,
-0.18012911081314087,
0.03853021189570427,
-0.03845106437802315,
-0.1626567840576172,
0.26983705163002014,
-0.15874753892421722,
0.9981848001480103,
0.196913480758667,
0.2532649040222168,
-0.0894598588347435,
-0.48175856471061707,
0.5338656902313232,
-0.4176464378833771,
-0.08498334139585495,
-0.1223907619714737,
0.29414254426956177,
-0.03342396765947342,
-0.7824968695640564,
0.933443546295166,
0.6871345043182373,
-0.5141650438308716,
-0.23185524344444275,
-0.5861345529556274,
-0.48341354727745056,
-0.44409239292144775,
0.17964395880699158,
-0.5144456028938293,
-0.8273709416389465,
0.6409142017364502,
0.3698289096355438,
0.08612103015184402,
0.4441896080970764,
0.38892337679862976,
-0.5075997710227966,
0.8263985514640808,
0.35803350806236267,
0.14458245038986206,
0.4582303464412689,
-0.18989114463329315,
0.4407466650009155,
-1.1394891738891602,
-0.17035920917987823,
-0.44580602645874023,
-0.5011481642723083,
-0.6901142001152039,
0.013506930321455002,
0.5343586802482605,
0.17831481993198395,
-0.5258869528770447,
0.30862873792648315,
-0.7741849422454834,
0.5370661020278931,
1.035013198852539,
0.7375956177711487,
0.41897663474082947,
-0.3408007025718689,
0.06724830716848373,
-0.15756189823150635,
-0.5373393893241882,
-0.3458980321884155,
1.251953125,
-0.40431779623031616,
0.9287110567092896,
0.523138701915741,
0.8919022083282471,
0.592585563659668,
0.03358951956033707,
-0.45235520601272583,
0.540262758731842,
-0.42286089062690735,
-0.8307722806930542,
-0.19571048021316528,
-0.5159240365028381,
-0.9144489169120789,
0.45954325795173645,
-0.2635761499404907,
-1.0069959163665771,
0.1828324794769287,
0.43406441807746887,
-0.40832042694091797,
0.17705301940441132,
-0.911365270614624,
0.6321275234222412,
-0.16345436871051788,
-0.48968055844306946,
-0.29822099208831787,
-0.7987487316131592,
0.35213133692741394,
0.0611015148460865,
-0.7581162452697754,
-0.21232692897319794,
-0.20096400380134583,
0.6156284213066101,
-0.3900196850299835,
0.3018198609352112,
-0.1262430101633072,
0.0887434184551239,
0.06892545521259308,
0.33709150552749634,
0.6126267910003662,
0.33590033650398254,
-0.45226916670799255,
-0.2574204206466675,
0.18870456516742706,
-0.4030435085296631,
-0.9273033738136292,
1.035265564918518,
-0.6023581624031067,
-0.557809591293335,
-0.01966123655438423,
-0.6021371483802795,
-0.34065285325050354,
0.19513261318206787,
0.21719293296337128,
0.6849803328514099,
-0.0794636607170105,
0.36495882272720337,
1.0640767812728882,
-0.26024848222732544,
0.2526746690273285,
0.4542385935783386,
-0.1204952523112297,
0.030893556773662567,
1.085379958152771,
0.07787024229764938,
0.19538594782352448,
0.7541077136993408,
-0.023790448904037476,
-0.19721223413944244,
-0.30134618282318115,
-0.04997209832072258,
0.11191611737012863,
-0.7763272523880005,
-0.3143986165523529,
-0.5098426342010498,
-0.1460871696472168,
-0.48220571875572205,
-0.1527186632156372,
-0.3036726415157318,
-0.9351510405540466,
-0.25228410959243774,
0.09566331654787064,
0.2144159972667694,
0.2986027002334595,
-0.08976604789495468,
0.17817382514476776,
-0.4389747679233551,
0.37884053587913513,
0.22223961353302002,
0.701560378074646,
-0.427513062953949,
-0.33587387204170227,
-0.03935229033231735,
-0.06393615901470184,
-0.43066224455833435,
-0.717343270778656,
0.23663058876991272,
0.3081299066543579,
0.2808738648891449,
0.09669192880392075,
0.38794806599617004,
0.49635976552963257,
-0.4289659857749939,
0.45139092206954956,
-0.15396538376808167,
-0.82798832654953,
0.8026488423347473,
-0.4300936162471771,
0.20492024719715118,
0.7264710068702698,
0.09457433223724365,
-0.27335625886917114,
0.06727985292673111,
-0.703374981880188,
-0.7883323431015015,
0.8839603066444397,
0.7845283150672913,
-0.12383481115102768,
0.04029420390725136,
0.1535455584526062,
0.010309108532965183,
0.5042693614959717,
-0.41300398111343384,
-0.07706756889820099,
-0.11400061845779419,
-0.20470134913921356,
0.306325227022171,
-0.014323225244879723,
-0.5134463906288147,
-0.40636029839515686,
0.8703390955924988,
0.008419022895395756,
0.7106518149375916,
0.3134981691837311,
-0.21452830731868744,
0.2141810655593872,
0.20188495516777039,
0.2756171226501465,
0.7290158867835999,
-0.9415168166160583,
-0.03016449324786663,
0.08027976006269455,
0.07195413112640381,
-0.3911891281604767,
0.6803397536277771,
-0.07453794032335281,
-0.05910058692097664,
0.2873903214931488,
0.5115942358970642,
-0.13001306354999542,
-0.836927056312561,
0.38537514209747314,
0.03224494680762291,
-0.23624862730503082,
-0.26974955201148987,
0.35283195972442627,
-0.12331092357635498,
0.45536303520202637,
0.20784400403499603,
-0.15138308703899384,
0.6388864517211914,
-0.5742888450622559,
0.18080174922943115,
0.5850099921226501,
-0.5567246675491333,
0.27109599113464355,
0.4421074390411377,
0.28970015048980713,
-0.3701022267341614,
1.2203012704849243,
-0.1423788219690323,
-0.7008254528045654,
0.6743694543838501,
0.49977970123291016,
0.4861648678779602,
0.3705769181251526,
-0.128307044506073,
0.07801549136638641,
0.5694419741630554,
0.20659959316253662,
0.7522702217102051,
-0.17929309606552124,
-0.7992209792137146,
-0.014962786808609962,
-0.13436201214790344,
-0.3931322395801544,
0.01699567213654518,
-0.7520565390586853,
-0.055111363530159,
-0.6378346681594849,
0.005987032316625118,
0.14057719707489014,
0.08330584317445755,
-0.6969159841537476,
0.2684408724308014,
-0.2896219491958618,
0.9263409376144409,
-0.4681154191493988,
0.5349986553192139,
0.6274554133415222,
-0.5402927994728088,
-0.4610915184020996,
0.04495660960674286,
-0.45661500096321106,
-0.652811586856842,
0.8460156917572021,
0.23870255053043365,
-0.16950160264968872,
-0.18022291362285614,
-0.7371653318405151,
-0.5654861330986023,
0.7509058713912964,
0.24565663933753967,
-0.4487990736961365,
0.21488159894943237,
-0.4561220705509186,
0.5938519835472107,
-0.2450115978717804,
0.06253734230995178,
0.8569405674934387,
0.2759724259376526,
-0.2571510076522827,
-0.6702806949615479,
-0.012437311932444572,
-0.02490440011024475,
0.0027491652872413397,
0.9124864935874939,
-0.7090092897415161,
0.8550627827644348,
-0.2844221889972687,
0.25301608443260193,
-0.09463352710008621,
0.5705571174621582,
0.12725497782230377,
0.1376146823167801,
0.11581801623106003,
0.5826833844184875,
0.9550907611846924,
-0.4328504800796509,
1.0580207109451294,
-0.24103206396102905,
0.35888540744781494,
1.4477880001068115,
-0.27390599250793457,
0.9565568566322327,
0.34435799717903137,
0.01364788319915533,
0.17621201276779175,
0.3747462034225464,
0.11118707060813904,
0.8132010102272034,
0.3196399509906769,
-0.33782610297203064,
-0.4853821396827698,
0.14749255776405334,
-0.29963621497154236,
0.07912199944257736,
0.6130194067955017,
-0.6237617135047913,
-0.06364397704601288,
-0.1153283640742302,
-0.1745789498090744,
0.1451983004808426,
-0.3120080232620239,
0.34283867478370667,
-0.2170790731906891,
-0.7286526560783386,
0.6212307810783386,
-0.11039131879806519,
0.39655157923698425,
-0.231443852186203,
-0.3558102548122406,
-0.22480320930480957,
0.544951856136322,
-0.2936766445636749,
-1.0025441646575928,
0.1522151380777359,
-0.6577520370483398,
-0.20302031934261322,
0.3394036889076233,
0.8247608542442322,
-0.37396302819252014,
-0.5884366631507874,
0.16491037607192993,
0.32307055592536926,
-0.0820649117231369,
-0.278442919254303,
-0.6818761229515076,
-0.117791548371315,
0.18397636711597443,
-0.07190166413784027,
-0.19928158819675446,
0.3969351351261139,
-0.05246741324663162,
0.7619497179985046,
0.37759634852409363,
-0.24372994899749756,
-0.06403966248035431,
0.23576432466506958,
1.1258090734481812,
-0.8294416666030884,
-0.15558335185050964,
-0.5313693881034851,
0.07672704011201859,
-0.3319575786590576,
-0.15962518751621246,
0.35759034752845764,
0.6781387329101562,
0.6557198166847229,
-0.07702656090259552,
0.79060959815979,
-0.24014487862586975,
0.5920303463935852,
-0.6716276407241821,
0.5179369449615479,
-0.6101405024528503,
0.3328127861022949,
-0.2078026384115219,
-0.9764471054077148,
-0.43084728717803955,
0.7216472625732422,
-0.5825415253639221,
0.1559472531080246,
0.5140032172203064,
1.0967074632644653,
-0.1924957036972046,
0.12243839353322983,
0.31502461433410645,
0.053874384611845016,
0.6564612984657288,
0.6320217251777649,
0.6794720888137817,
-0.6431184411048889,
0.7081072926521301,
-0.09585562348365784,
-0.14495673775672913,
-0.5673584342002869,
-0.4842183291912079,
-1.1629003286361694,
-0.44241103529930115,
-0.05889745429158211,
-0.4264001250267029,
0.712510883808136,
0.7469409704208374,
0.7278668880462646,
-0.588902473449707,
0.20532242953777313,
0.06187254562973976,
0.16568832099437714,
-0.1823967844247818,
-0.20468191802501678,
0.681585967540741,
-0.6588714122772217,
-0.46207040548324585,
0.35512208938598633,
0.15072402358055115,
-0.46290192008018494,
0.2695007026195526,
0.11852189898490906,
-0.6673682332038879,
0.14006873965263367,
0.74656081199646,
0.1788674294948578,
-0.4566360116004944,
-0.6217166185379028,
-0.16480818390846252,
0.014553701505064964,
0.01857348531484604,
0.6754425764083862,
-1.2104367017745972,
0.5328720808029175,
0.5497218370437622,
0.6635343432426453,
0.7583189010620117,
0.14919809997081757,
0.6900239586830139,
-0.9761466383934021,
-0.06447780132293701,
0.6809454560279846,
0.3892804682254791,
0.29984214901924133,
-0.30950385332107544,
1.0069160461425781,
-0.05427943542599678,
-0.526411771774292,
-0.467513769865036,
0.24350033700466156,
-0.9350974559783936,
-0.2957979142665863,
0.7242658138275146,
0.15086911618709564,
0.2055797427892685,
0.11882393807172775,
-0.37313875555992126,
0.07342878729104996,
-0.6489841938018799,
0.7350185513496399,
0.5414961576461792,
-0.6435577869415283,
-0.04521264135837555,
-0.36593079566955566,
0.2197822779417038,
0.761219322681427,
-0.5490874648094177,
-0.029999420046806335,
0.8037541508674622,
0.21192146837711334,
0.03806354105472565,
0.3088138997554779,
-0.04821164906024933,
0.5055806040763855,
-0.2973782420158386,
-0.020634423941373825,
-0.20971760153770447,
-0.28392550349235535,
0.05364393815398216,
0.10987934470176697,
-0.12406037002801895,
-0.5102289915084839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17276v1 | OPT-Tree: Speculative Decoding with Adaptive Draft Tree Structure | 2024-06-25T04:45:53 | 2024-06-25T04:45:53 | Jikai Wang, Yi Su, Juntao Li, Qinrong Xia, Zi Ye, Xinyu Duan, Zhefeng Wang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Autoregressive language models demonstrate excellent performance in various
scenarios. However, the inference efficiency is limited by its
one-step-one-word generation mode, which has become a pressing problem recently
as the models become increasingly larger. Speculative decoding employs a "draft
and then verify" mechanism to allow multiple tokens to be generated in one
step, realizing lossless acceleration. Existing methods mainly adopt fixed
heuristic draft structures, which fail to adapt to different situations to
maximize the acceptance length during verification. To alleviate this dilemma,
we proposed OPT-Tree, an algorithm to construct adaptive and scalable draft
trees. It searches the optimal tree structure that maximizes the mathematical
expectation of the acceptance length in each decoding step. Experimental
results reveal that OPT-Tree outperforms the existing draft structures and
achieves a speed-up ratio of up to 3.2 compared with autoregressive decoding.
If the draft model is powerful enough and the node budget is sufficient, it can
generate more than ten tokens in a single step. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Jikai0Wang/OPT-Tree. | [
-0.12146386504173279,
-0.8320068717002869,
0.31792378425598145,
0.4210575819015503,
-0.5836910605430603,
0.5247699022293091,
0.20994043350219727,
-0.503009557723999,
0.36940649151802063,
0.22931508719921112,
-0.5679527521133423,
-0.23559026420116425,
-0.46631744503974915,
0.273887038230896,
-0.6354900598526001,
0.5575476288795471,
-0.230656236410141,
-0.37168148159980774,
0.1435539871454239,
0.0031361940782517195,
-0.0008825788390822709,
-0.22819170355796814,
-0.9012601375579834,
0.20322124660015106,
-0.0436251126229763,
0.3235359191894531,
0.7103263139724731,
1.0463244915008545,
0.3417881429195404,
0.32284271717071533,
-0.12995438277721405,
0.16913527250289917,
-0.35963723063468933,
0.13728313148021698,
0.25809863209724426,
-0.44434404373168945,
-0.6056542992591858,
-0.3478420078754425,
0.9946175813674927,
0.2900351285934448,
-0.23550257086753845,
0.09058497101068497,
-0.30595076084136963,
0.8053247928619385,
-0.6877525448799133,
0.044593002647161484,
-1.1240798234939575,
-0.005388003308326006,
-0.34621116518974304,
-0.731277585029602,
-0.6085469126701355,
-0.4358266592025757,
-0.12262608110904694,
-0.673427402973175,
0.2868478000164032,
0.29059913754463196,
0.6303799152374268,
0.21765920519828796,
-0.22765091061592102,
-0.18971695005893707,
-0.44813647866249084,
0.23578757047653198,
-0.6683806777000427,
0.3654816448688507,
0.4631158113479614,
0.2997564673423767,
-0.17770251631736755,
-0.568104088306427,
-0.3823319375514984,
-0.1519230306148529,
0.11797481030225754,
0.20559777319431305,
-0.19904731214046478,
0.2252710610628128,
0.20520153641700745,
0.3504470884799957,
-0.6943328976631165,
0.009963109157979488,
-0.27356576919555664,
-0.40113919973373413,
0.4149753153324127,
0.31983017921447754,
0.16364456713199615,
-0.1916964203119278,
-0.03883243352174759,
-0.2295594960451126,
-0.3436468541622162,
0.12754306197166443,
0.5985133051872253,
0.18284836411476135,
-0.001170561765320599,
0.34317150712013245,
-0.5594792366027832,
0.7613376379013062,
0.2013862431049347,
0.09053968638181686,
0.13658049702644348,
-0.5218608379364014,
-0.23569433391094208,
0.27901721000671387,
0.6043758392333984,
0.08485288918018341,
-0.14628946781158447,
-0.06648410111665726,
-0.22872145473957062,
0.28916215896606445,
0.1867573857307434,
-0.925261378288269,
-0.2621604800224304,
0.3920973837375641,
-0.6445648670196533,
-0.48749154806137085,
-0.2856144905090332,
-0.6191537976264954,
0.0670720636844635,
0.3885464668273926,
0.05715422332286835,
-0.8039266467094421,
-0.5885147452354431,
0.6387729048728943,
-0.25808605551719666,
0.1382494568824768,
0.2900231182575226,
-0.8455719947814941,
0.37440499663352966,
0.3278736472129822,
0.8919138312339783,
-0.13239198923110962,
-0.3372826874256134,
-0.532325804233551,
-0.06665091961622238,
-0.7231574654579163,
0.945123553276062,
-0.5299702882766724,
-0.28216543793678284,
-0.10200729966163635,
-0.32037049531936646,
-0.14455007016658783,
-0.021735504269599915,
0.8983514308929443,
-0.737378716468811,
-0.05886266008019447,
-0.018115337938070297,
-0.5091897249221802,
-0.008213607594370842,
0.2528943121433258,
-0.5122972726821899,
0.7176206707954407,
0.2800380289554596,
-1.1202055215835571,
0.5356858372688293,
-0.8351002335548401,
-0.6102316975593567,
0.26837947964668274,
0.14084216952323914,
-0.341280072927475,
0.40676403045654297,
0.3923812210559845,
0.13519084453582764,
-0.10236317664384842,
0.025053471326828003,
-0.22750265896320343,
-0.3306909203529358,
-0.09927411377429962,
-0.7248626351356506,
0.8906100988388062,
0.5828090310096741,
-0.07964911311864853,
0.06962662935256958,
-0.8512954115867615,
0.40484383702278137,
0.4331946074962616,
-0.4672583043575287,
-0.22784017026424408,
0.3699057400226593,
-0.04362816363573074,
-0.2806808352470398,
0.02853810042142868,
-0.5440828800201416,
0.3044797480106354,
-0.7326368093490601,
0.6073196530342102,
0.604272723197937,
0.008500618860125542,
0.31181982159614563,
-0.15670257806777954,
0.6467074155807495,
0.15269657969474792,
0.16458645462989807,
-0.6361008882522583,
0.022154422476887703,
-0.6818549633026123,
0.05311570316553116,
0.4059717357158661,
0.19004851579666138,
-0.9500380158424377,
0.380415678024292,
-0.1559133678674698,
-0.3823917806148529,
-0.47261303663253784,
-0.4919617772102356,
0.06423834711313248,
0.15715831518173218,
0.19568772614002228,
-0.16260145604610443,
-0.8146207332611084,
-0.5717653632164001,
-0.3023056983947754,
-0.6871140599250793,
0.4828609526157379,
0.10526040941476822,
0.2381039410829544,
-0.06413567066192627,
0.7866469621658325,
-0.46988579630851746,
0.2946488857269287,
-0.028572119772434235,
0.06055480241775513,
0.2230154275894165,
0.5814291834831238,
0.6875199675559998,
-0.491997092962265,
-0.6052635908126831,
0.22680869698524475,
-0.2320445030927658,
0.046639274805784225,
-0.3550664484500885,
-0.16773492097854614,
0.2930871844291687,
0.41047972440719604,
-0.5084217190742493,
0.13625764846801758,
0.6236910223960876,
-0.6629095077514648,
0.6263779997825623,
-0.38780051469802856,
0.1375313103199005,
-1.0292701721191406,
-0.02075413428246975,
-0.5037594437599182,
-0.4204155206680298,
-0.2235328108072281,
0.2937038242816925,
0.14097918570041656,
0.2294604778289795,
-0.1220138669013977,
0.16376133263111115,
-0.5871588587760925,
-0.039788346737623215,
-0.4498855471611023,
-0.16733266413211823,
-0.09544999152421951,
0.16366222500801086,
-0.0033859864342957735,
0.9317506551742554,
0.8291405439376831,
-0.47469019889831543,
0.012045780196785927,
-0.08985450118780136,
-0.28084826469421387,
0.14396564662456512,
-0.2946486175060272,
0.21485339105129242,
-0.3350825011730194,
0.45537978410720825,
-0.9450245499610901,
-0.2733606696128845,
0.23744608461856842,
-0.5027914047241211,
0.10079667717218399,
-0.12470792979001999,
-0.2899622619152069,
-0.7122417092323303,
-0.26993584632873535,
0.6340389251708984,
0.4376225769519806,
-0.6039575338363647,
0.6366015672683716,
0.25532880425453186,
0.18585070967674255,
-0.48717963695526123,
-0.3098953366279602,
0.22785638272762299,
-0.01334073394536972,
-0.463981032371521,
0.4351876378059387,
-0.26226523518562317,
0.24314665794372559,
0.24908190965652466,
-0.39542245864868164,
-0.18030132353305817,
0.17092330753803253,
-0.08858360350131989,
0.03058624640107155,
-0.3809047341346741,
-0.2088661789894104,
0.4154244065284729,
-0.20420365035533905,
0.13720820844173431,
-0.9017825722694397,
0.24341341853141785,
-0.14308702945709229,
-0.2174319475889206,
-0.2902214527130127,
0.37386471033096313,
1.037471055984497,
-0.18078185617923737,
0.3051091432571411,
0.3991563022136688,
-0.43111303448677063,
-0.48420971632003784,
-0.4223569333553314,
0.03633702173829079,
-0.5051764249801636,
0.5382263660430908,
-0.8123383522033691,
-0.8165099024772644,
0.44279780983924866,
-0.15553344786167145,
0.3633025288581848,
0.5621994733810425,
0.3407287299633026,
0.26604512333869934,
1.2530057430267334,
0.5404238700866699,
-0.10000765323638916,
0.46661192178726196,
-0.12852562963962555,
-0.06035839766263962,
-0.5824915170669556,
-0.012569705955684185,
-0.7936100959777832,
0.11314229667186737,
-0.2663537263870239,
-0.47335055470466614,
0.0225044097751379,
0.2883560061454773,
0.045547403395175934,
0.4629797637462616,
-0.8090327978134155,
0.6489880084991455,
0.2553257942199707,
-0.07566820085048676,
0.3532135486602783,
0.3006691038608551,
-0.5540663003921509,
0.1746433675289154,
-1.106552004814148,
-0.19605880975723267,
0.8376867175102234,
0.47652551531791687,
0.6613145470619202,
-0.10605983436107635,
0.6665802001953125,
0.2594752311706543,
0.19394654035568237,
-0.7867143154144287,
0.529190719127655,
-0.16022765636444092,
-0.412945955991745,
-0.21593323349952698,
-0.4664618670940399,
-0.7128188610076904,
0.23145344853401184,
-0.15685908496379852,
-0.5225836634635925,
0.027677737176418304,
0.4891224801540375,
-0.30676326155662537,
0.37741994857788086,
-0.663523256778717,
0.58420330286026,
-0.3086366355419159,
-0.11813473701477051,
-0.41676005721092224,
-0.19090838730335236,
0.4503604471683502,
-0.17649856209754944,
-0.11802008748054504,
0.03026881255209446,
0.06909657269716263,
0.7397844791412354,
-0.5084237456321716,
0.4775836765766144,
-0.2681208550930023,
0.21948914229869843,
0.5299095511436462,
0.40720734000205994,
1.0277738571166992,
0.1693667322397232,
-0.30781155824661255,
-0.27986857295036316,
0.3502751290798187,
-0.4535389244556427,
-0.33958059549331665,
0.2986050844192505,
-0.755031406879425,
-0.42428895831108093,
-0.38650819659233093,
-0.43767452239990234,
-0.1853240579366684,
0.4608460068702698,
0.44135209918022156,
0.26330453157424927,
-0.30093422532081604,
0.06373123079538345,
0.2202315479516983,
0.14005036652088165,
0.6783243417739868,
0.547256350517273,
-0.26439398527145386,
-0.4701249301433563,
0.7593087553977966,
-0.02822984755039215,
0.18011197447776794,
0.4795466661453247,
0.2932363450527191,
-0.47547370195388794,
-1.3134950399398804,
-0.6639711260795593,
-0.20692755281925201,
-0.4937724471092224,
-0.39260920882225037,
-0.9792278409004211,
-0.30587446689605713,
-0.11061520129442215,
-0.2469155639410019,
-0.5507986545562744,
-0.4255996644496918,
0.04967336356639862,
-0.20679211616516113,
0.5451088547706604,
0.4651227295398712,
-0.059593554586172104,
0.3440783619880676,
-0.7752801179885864,
0.2925914525985718,
0.043662622570991516,
0.5576215982437134,
0.2082849144935608,
-0.4485158622264862,
-0.20855093002319336,
-0.13746033608913422,
0.06971380114555359,
-0.8438236713409424,
0.21283207833766937,
0.06596507877111435,
0.40481168031692505,
0.5524019002914429,
0.3045491576194763,
0.9844653606414795,
-0.4918210506439209,
0.413108229637146,
0.17609289288520813,
-1.0065088272094727,
0.44044917821884155,
-0.41975727677345276,
0.5437943935394287,
0.7147452235221863,
-0.02915526181459427,
-0.31116431951522827,
-0.47907692193984985,
-0.632840633392334,
-0.7493874430656433,
1.0378984212875366,
0.252612829208374,
0.06299414485692978,
-0.05678332597017288,
0.5068323016166687,
0.11040976643562317,
-0.182830348610878,
-0.4581867456436157,
-0.048341911286115646,
-0.40497976541519165,
-0.05546293035149574,
0.3011866509914398,
-0.5364391207695007,
0.30747151374816895,
-0.09343624860048294,
0.59618079662323,
-0.4544183909893036,
0.3210689127445221,
0.29847797751426697,
0.24200323224067688,
-0.6612386703491211,
0.20813028514385223,
0.3898659646511078,
0.3679567575454712,
-0.36512935161590576,
0.19298593699932098,
0.19443455338478088,
-0.5873295068740845,
0.15991055965423584,
0.04677135497331619,
-0.38662010431289673,
0.04386674985289574,
0.26083409786224365,
1.0955005884170532,
-0.19044651091098785,
-0.42048996686935425,
0.09660186618566513,
-0.4339396059513092,
-0.5338956117630005,
0.00868360884487629,
0.07751685380935669,
0.017264481633901596,
0.004964982625097036,
0.5069635510444641,
0.518619954586029,
0.22271589934825897,
-0.205522820353508,
0.2438349574804306,
0.5790318846702576,
-0.0051627070643007755,
-0.4355090856552124,
0.6779104471206665,
0.2793610095977783,
-0.39588072896003723,
0.5642423033714294,
-0.5219717025756836,
-0.5667210817337036,
0.6065766215324402,
0.9551060199737549,
1.2967445850372314,
-0.10803373903036118,
0.39409369230270386,
0.6203177571296692,
0.5643860101699829,
-0.21456694602966309,
0.4753663241863251,
-0.23014260828495026,
-0.7892074584960938,
-0.5356538891792297,
-0.9396840333938599,
-0.23674260079860687,
-0.04768235981464386,
-0.23195508122444153,
-0.10374047607183456,
-0.3707444965839386,
-0.12798234820365906,
-0.19799774885177612,
-0.08953908085823059,
-0.4282725751399994,
0.017561588436365128,
-0.199855238199234,
1.3529366254806519,
-0.6693971157073975,
0.8896389603614807,
0.6304263472557068,
0.35158687829971313,
-0.9978747367858887,
0.25804296135902405,
-0.24985316395759583,
-0.6074981689453125,
0.22579213976860046,
0.013869735412299633,
-0.2515886425971985,
0.4106673300266266,
-0.08314687758684158,
-1.0998868942260742,
0.7260070443153381,
0.31159982085227966,
-0.542494535446167,
-0.20738159120082855,
-0.20022107660770416,
0.3924531638622284,
-0.5668790340423584,
0.3405073881149292,
0.4438425898551941,
0.40778857469558716,
0.39526113867759705,
-0.595798909664154,
0.14317092299461365,
-0.25301989912986755,
0.0604189857840538,
0.2629023492336273,
-0.3717842698097229,
0.6312758326530457,
-0.2774289846420288,
-0.6420812606811523,
0.1243397518992424,
0.5666003227233887,
0.10696619749069214,
0.013966697268188,
0.8197160959243774,
0.3489750921726227,
0.7007070779800415,
0.1370953470468521,
0.9192597270011902,
-0.7336695790290833,
0.28352969884872437,
0.7476938366889954,
-0.062194302678108215,
0.8170347213745117,
0.18727880716323853,
-0.40125662088394165,
0.19517841935157776,
0.8227563500404358,
0.39932382106781006,
0.41576871275901794,
-0.0033802909310907125,
-0.08313483744859695,
-0.4872490167617798,
-0.006478902418166399,
-0.33230823278427124,
0.4799334704875946,
0.4056653380393982,
-0.2066986858844757,
-0.37256380915641785,
-0.271604061126709,
-0.334231436252594,
-0.1786809116601944,
-0.3009962737560272,
0.40347132086753845,
-0.2686397433280945,
-0.9371120929718018,
0.8417052030563354,
0.28031298518180847,
0.574704647064209,
-0.8549063801765442,
0.16393926739692688,
0.03423643857240677,
0.038599926978349686,
-0.15962961316108704,
-0.4338814616203308,
0.4117121398448944,
-0.17252503335475922,
-0.1192425787448883,
-0.2747010290622711,
0.7635215520858765,
-0.2757331430912018,
-0.6819329261779785,
0.13639797270298004,
0.5995136499404907,
-0.03661833703517914,
0.08008207380771637,
-0.8580933213233948,
0.5253213047981262,
0.16600006818771362,
-0.26875028014183044,
-0.0660300999879837,
0.47174271941185,
-0.09984158724546432,
0.39669129252433777,
0.9612831473350525,
0.29708331823349,
0.16562727093696594,
-0.1685924381017685,
0.8455618023872375,
-0.5105816721916199,
-0.9785926342010498,
-0.8558876514434814,
0.24980445206165314,
0.07559667527675629,
-0.24813230335712433,
0.587541401386261,
0.580308735370636,
0.7025455236434937,
0.051995739340782166,
0.759064793586731,
-0.22099345922470093,
0.02681879512965679,
-0.604918897151947,
0.4326888918876648,
-0.3564244210720062,
0.07479771971702576,
-0.2938738167285919,
-0.7633035778999329,
-0.20370134711265564,
0.5824924111366272,
0.17329441010951996,
-0.0944426879286766,
0.9752489328384399,
0.6656733155250549,
-0.039216071367263794,
0.2649097144603729,
0.22051706910133362,
0.39694517850875854,
0.22519908845424652,
0.7766199111938477,
0.7182922959327698,
-0.4907010793685913,
0.6070992946624756,
-0.08598411828279495,
-0.2393157035112381,
-0.1253613829612732,
-0.906464695930481,
-0.727067768573761,
-0.5707352757453918,
-0.35969170928001404,
-0.37792322039604187,
0.2445846050977707,
0.8672438859939575,
0.8240794539451599,
-0.49839162826538086,
-0.1604740470647812,
-0.8377751111984253,
0.1370764821767807,
-0.46245700120925903,
-0.2298804372549057,
0.6014912724494934,
-0.4330635368824005,
-0.5733145475387573,
0.6203938722610474,
0.5511171817779541,
0.1716288924217224,
-0.15915249288082123,
-0.1845903843641281,
0.016474781557917595,
0.214020773768425,
0.510317325592041,
0.3053540587425232,
-0.5710201859474182,
-0.08432312309741974,
0.10191261768341064,
0.06410601735115051,
0.004911139141768217,
1.1026802062988281,
-0.9900039434432983,
0.6934686899185181,
0.810645341873169,
0.8673855662345886,
0.4921257495880127,
0.049052055925130844,
0.41789859533309937,
-0.29474547505378723,
0.09757716208696365,
0.29659634828567505,
0.3899507522583008,
-0.1477845162153244,
-0.48361071944236755,
0.24483607709407806,
0.28261426091194153,
-0.17226897180080414,
-0.8885142803192139,
0.2262539118528366,
-0.8549389839172363,
-0.3766515254974365,
0.7503523230552673,
0.1135110855102539,
-0.35569503903388977,
-0.1059025377035141,
-0.38374054431915283,
-0.03790852054953575,
-0.5579283237457275,
0.6520206928253174,
0.4743061661720276,
-0.051974907517433167,
-0.2356860339641571,
-0.05851568654179573,
0.6157213449478149,
0.38260746002197266,
-0.7933846712112427,
0.5049563646316528,
0.42127668857574463,
0.1271396428346634,
0.17392311990261078,
1.2183725833892822,
-0.13151684403419495,
0.5545663833618164,
0.6796168088912964,
-0.5107457041740417,
-0.38358914852142334,
-0.2964214086532593,
-0.21864557266235352,
0.5257683992385864,
0.4926859438419342,
-0.18801312148571014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17274v1 | Can We Trust the Performance Evaluation of Uncertainty Estimation Methods in Text Summarization? | 2024-06-25T04:41:17 | 2024-06-25T04:41:17 | Jianfeng He, Runing Yang, Linlin Yu, Changbin Li, Ruoxi Jia, Feng Chen, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text summarization, a key natural language generation (NLG) task, is vital in
various domains. However, the high cost of inaccurate summaries in
risk-critical applications, particularly those involving human-in-the-loop
decision-making, raises concerns about the reliability of uncertainty
estimation on text summarization (UE-TS) evaluation methods. This concern stems
from the dependency of uncertainty model metrics on diverse and potentially
conflicting NLG metrics. To address this issue, we introduce a comprehensive
UE-TS benchmark incorporating 31 NLG metrics across four dimensions. The
benchmark evaluates the uncertainty estimation capabilities of two large
language models and one pre-trained language model on three datasets, with
human-annotation analysis incorporated where applicable. We also assess the
performance of 14 common uncertainty estimation methods within this benchmark.
Our findings emphasize the importance of considering multiple uncorrelated NLG
metrics and diverse uncertainty estimation methods to ensure reliable and
efficient evaluation of UE-TS techniques. | [
-0.2286500483751297,
-0.3912578225135803,
0.5987804532051086,
0.24135486781597137,
-0.40926724672317505,
0.3591955304145813,
-0.26392310857772827,
-0.4588378667831421,
-0.19671471416950226,
0.11438723653554916,
-0.14679057896137238,
-0.5368814468383789,
-0.7999378442764282,
0.30444109439849854,
-0.30323949456214905,
0.8320887088775635,
-0.03183035925030708,
-0.10098394006490707,
-0.1816435605287552,
-0.04133595526218414,
-0.30009451508522034,
-0.25245532393455505,
-0.3884304165840149,
-0.2208280712366104,
0.0619085319340229,
0.1429751068353653,
0.7407848834991455,
0.43957942724227905,
0.6534913182258606,
0.2678835391998291,
-0.11093313246965408,
0.21131855249404907,
-0.0353790745139122,
0.2611859440803528,
-0.05593938007950783,
-0.24790838360786438,
-0.49812790751457214,
0.014125608839094639,
0.7564642429351807,
0.6309126019477844,
-0.33502092957496643,
0.41217130422592163,
0.20806723833084106,
0.6611886620521545,
-0.9108384847640991,
-0.3300565481185913,
-0.6456729173660278,
0.14791017770767212,
-0.08703839033842087,
0.1295267641544342,
-0.26370155811309814,
-0.5379369258880615,
0.6027653217315674,
-0.6231548190116882,
0.12852752208709717,
0.10525322705507278,
0.8513345718383789,
0.4315275549888611,
-0.4390660226345062,
-0.2048351764678955,
-0.761864960193634,
1.0347429513931274,
-1.0586518049240112,
0.24644054472446442,
0.47367873787879944,
0.3393833041191101,
-0.024109505116939545,
-0.7277678847312927,
-0.11113521456718445,
0.09381375461816788,
-0.023090356960892677,
0.4452299177646637,
-0.24076567590236664,
0.09914238005876541,
-0.08108107000589371,
0.27798885107040405,
-0.5456081032752991,
0.15026302635669708,
-0.1425335705280304,
-0.5560896992683411,
0.6372668743133545,
0.02169313281774521,
0.02969270944595337,
-0.3459683954715729,
-0.5300351977348328,
-0.033878810703754425,
-0.07797341793775558,
-0.12920527160167694,
0.4607919454574585,
0.140425905585289,
-0.15662768483161926,
0.38488200306892395,
-0.23793308436870575,
0.6191053986549377,
-0.30510208010673523,
-0.33029940724372864,
0.11714817583560944,
-0.5353575944900513,
-0.3316039741039276,
-0.11799415946006775,
1.253241777420044,
0.7174545526504517,
0.33238455653190613,
-0.5003933906555176,
-0.06127160042524338,
-0.05631544068455696,
0.4384515583515167,
-0.5602263808250427,
0.05876300483942032,
0.30636459589004517,
-0.1234363242983818,
-0.2939390242099762,
0.27017074823379517,
-1.0180320739746094,
-0.2953307032585144,
0.16325120627880096,
0.34314966201782227,
-0.4527122676372528,
-0.11855150014162064,
0.0677526518702507,
-0.4020465612411499,
-0.23429816961288452,
0.18879717588424683,
-0.5708156824111938,
0.3530276119709015,
0.3838856518268585,
0.7354348301887512,
-0.3803921341896057,
-0.4619249105453491,
-0.16901876032352448,
0.10564243793487549,
-0.3936495780944824,
0.8233104944229126,
-0.16980555653572083,
-0.4756408631801605,
-0.1365736424922943,
-0.7236011624336243,
-0.2578074038028717,
-0.21250960230827332,
0.9987176060676575,
-0.05662969499826431,
0.18843285739421844,
-0.2396516054868698,
-0.6502714157104492,
-0.12993569672107697,
0.09390798956155777,
-0.584768533706665,
1.3023419380187988,
0.14632907509803772,
-1.0786250829696655,
0.5771405100822449,
-0.3018838167190552,
-0.2996841073036194,
-0.3029930889606476,
-0.06025797873735428,
-0.7212538123130798,
0.39105960726737976,
0.480072021484375,
0.45278874039649963,
-0.567376971244812,
0.3195977210998535,
-0.18018250167369843,
-0.40841832756996155,
0.45586058497428894,
-0.743998646736145,
0.37897220253944397,
0.2264057993888855,
-0.21352437138557434,
-0.06810706108808517,
-0.7565207481384277,
0.26833876967430115,
-0.25709837675094604,
-0.11325634270906448,
-0.3222506046295166,
-0.06202095374464989,
0.017436129972338676,
-0.0176082793623209,
0.25721824169158936,
-0.279914528131485,
-0.34287434816360474,
-0.1725076586008072,
0.14054477214813232,
0.4246634840965271,
0.2934950888156891,
0.37651118636131287,
-0.27808746695518494,
0.6785092949867249,
-0.1687740832567215,
-0.007042914628982544,
-0.023063810542225838,
-0.42903459072113037,
-0.19351695477962494,
-0.019014371559023857,
0.6328856945037842,
0.44562050700187683,
-0.3428961932659149,
0.3860248327255249,
-0.2966284155845642,
-0.821122407913208,
-0.17473523318767548,
-0.11026052385568619,
0.6976712346076965,
0.36088651418685913,
0.3206009268760681,
-0.07600804418325424,
-0.6371719837188721,
-0.5617362260818481,
-0.8956218957901001,
-0.4429837465286255,
-0.42212367057800293,
-0.16617195308208466,
0.45209604501724243,
0.022507891058921814,
1.0434036254882812,
-0.25767919421195984,
-0.015961911529302597,
-0.21756473183631897,
0.9727905988693237,
-0.23956282436847687,
0.26216864585876465,
0.6500892043113708,
-0.3093596398830414,
-0.3721095025539398,
-0.2454507201910019,
-0.8968045115470886,
-0.06456554681062698,
-0.2844615578651428,
0.0560525618493557,
0.3331071436405182,
0.20722989737987518,
-0.34691348671913147,
0.506756603717804,
0.7087572813034058,
-0.08675836771726608,
0.6940913200378418,
-0.4899405837059021,
0.4042004346847534,
-1.1923103332519531,
0.011512117460370064,
0.28750842809677124,
-0.1434127539396286,
-0.45071178674697876,
-0.029472284018993378,
0.08614330738782883,
0.4032374322414398,
-0.07210695743560791,
0.20995180308818817,
-0.5992191433906555,
-0.3291025161743164,
0.03644680976867676,
0.4908095896244049,
0.15456010401248932,
0.08105991035699844,
-0.1152285486459732,
0.8603833317756653,
0.4757356643676758,
-0.5312995314598083,
-0.22578169405460358,
0.001612303894944489,
-0.45885732769966125,
0.6434857845306396,
-0.7917802333831787,
-0.06797527521848679,
0.2188427746295929,
0.18057826161384583,
-0.8830122947692871,
-0.345926970243454,
-0.24364157021045685,
-0.5999007225036621,
0.1713809072971344,
0.34828847646713257,
-0.47846758365631104,
-0.27976101636886597,
-0.5755000114440918,
0.20202049612998962,
0.2081194669008255,
-0.0655151754617691,
0.6717997193336487,
0.38067153096199036,
-0.09856688976287842,
-0.9013127684593201,
-0.8280671834945679,
0.25964853167533875,
-0.3317926824092865,
-0.32238826155662537,
0.046875253319740295,
0.147163525223732,
-0.38671186566352844,
-0.199739009141922,
-0.6478843688964844,
-0.30601605772972107,
0.3776475489139557,
0.21669110655784607,
-0.11553439497947693,
-0.014664556831121445,
0.01909911446273327,
0.3168148696422577,
-0.06152498349547386,
0.027322329580783844,
-0.08299440145492554,
0.03209344297647476,
-0.16707903146743774,
-0.26789602637290955,
-0.2225736379623413,
0.10583006590604782,
0.45260751247406006,
-0.294274240732193,
0.3929225206375122,
0.7302289009094238,
-0.5170283317565918,
-0.011034444905817509,
-0.5975976586341858,
0.07672300934791565,
-0.3602803349494934,
0.44920557737350464,
-0.05791597440838814,
-0.573260486125946,
0.7102431058883667,
-0.05708463490009308,
0.11293192952871323,
0.6313358545303345,
0.09537842869758606,
-0.4365352392196655,
0.5390419363975525,
0.4998738765716553,
-0.07936317473649979,
0.06023929640650749,
0.13271880149841309,
-0.09082143008708954,
-0.7794269919395447,
0.1480361521244049,
-0.7844001054763794,
-0.1702272593975067,
-0.5746039152145386,
-0.27426040172576904,
0.5501919984817505,
0.37263351678848267,
0.05040410906076431,
0.39408934116363525,
-0.28074148297309875,
0.34992361068725586,
0.5547123551368713,
-0.19962075352668762,
0.5166934728622437,
-0.09154228866100311,
-0.10829944908618927,
-0.2313137799501419,
-0.53400719165802,
-0.7390803098678589,
1.441664457321167,
0.36253851652145386,
0.5161097645759583,
0.09502873569726944,
0.7372161149978638,
0.29873237013816833,
0.12377049028873444,
-0.26861998438835144,
0.21685728430747986,
-0.0518544502556324,
-0.6948040723800659,
-0.7464399337768555,
-0.6411016583442688,
-0.6940891146659851,
0.3682831823825836,
-0.408907413482666,
-1.0962120294570923,
-0.14516489207744598,
0.035628337413072586,
-0.698497474193573,
0.37255364656448364,
-0.7232230305671692,
0.6337534785270691,
-0.04482635110616684,
0.21149905025959015,
0.06127690523862839,
-0.8057264685630798,
0.36510998010635376,
-0.22223852574825287,
0.30187973380088806,
-0.14347657561302185,
-0.2591007351875305,
0.9713715314865112,
-0.25010472536087036,
0.5790145993232727,
0.2227732092142105,
-0.08904422074556351,
0.4250655770301819,
0.06479732692241669,
0.41596877574920654,
0.2944469451904297,
-0.31573039293289185,
0.48344090580940247,
-0.12027157098054886,
-0.1722639799118042,
-0.3984782099723816,
0.23499180376529694,
-0.7167260050773621,
-0.056416094303131104,
-0.6914356350898743,
-0.6080886125564575,
-0.5959921479225159,
0.25004974007606506,
0.9022844433784485,
0.46341532468795776,
-0.38313210010528564,
0.14098341763019562,
0.3884969651699066,
-0.06635496020317078,
0.8333264589309692,
0.11417602002620697,
0.0909680500626564,
-0.685725748538971,
0.5414586663246155,
0.15956974029541016,
0.5717383027076721,
0.41471919417381287,
0.30197975039482117,
-0.26886114478111267,
-0.9281847476959229,
-0.3969687819480896,
-0.08562314510345459,
-0.32483479380607605,
-0.46086734533309937,
-0.639875590801239,
-0.04308050498366356,
-0.2242034673690796,
-0.19649724662303925,
-0.6495739221572876,
-0.4459311068058014,
-0.10924026370048523,
-0.38931894302368164,
0.3349286615848541,
0.6622911095619202,
-0.022380882874131203,
0.6612288951873779,
-0.9076142907142639,
0.2901363968849182,
0.13052169978618622,
0.6185360550880432,
-0.35006967186927795,
-0.5365778207778931,
-0.3180599510669708,
0.18065305054187775,
-0.28395795822143555,
-0.8579577207565308,
0.0390607975423336,
0.23165245354175568,
0.6018347144126892,
0.24519897997379303,
0.23030826449394226,
0.3710429072380066,
-0.12457076460123062,
1.011100172996521,
0.19007547199726105,
-1.1352752447128296,
0.3026394546031952,
-0.5654792785644531,
0.47280192375183105,
0.9717997312545776,
0.22229567170143127,
-0.22379601001739502,
-0.8026589155197144,
-0.7344455718994141,
-0.8380790948867798,
0.4010232388973236,
0.6166818141937256,
-0.456598699092865,
0.10625133663415909,
0.21451334655284882,
-0.040385276079177856,
0.3888565003871918,
-0.3816981017589569,
-0.34710878133773804,
-0.024014104157686234,
-0.1380366086959839,
-0.04618261381983757,
-0.4787326753139496,
0.11967555433511734,
0.19945783913135529,
0.5517885088920593,
-0.07238410413265228,
-0.06430307775735855,
0.09610696136951447,
-0.08201689273118973,
-0.1468161642551422,
0.4097926616668701,
0.6989896893501282,
0.8876933455467224,
-0.6313299536705017,
-0.019268687814474106,
0.42962372303009033,
-0.7435470819473267,
-0.01925646699965,
0.0454094335436821,
-0.1758260875940323,
0.34272557497024536,
0.5691510438919067,
0.3561374247074127,
0.5242463946342468,
-0.48569637537002563,
0.4134083688259125,
-0.47465458512306213,
-0.2152886986732483,
-0.24194186925888062,
-0.32126978039741516,
-0.06565690040588379,
-0.20150704681873322,
0.41149190068244934,
0.46858224272727966,
0.42111778259277344,
0.0016624756390228868,
0.2996046841144562,
0.10983388125896454,
-0.4870915114879608,
-0.17641295492649078,
0.7495163083076477,
0.14512869715690613,
0.017216043546795845,
0.14795643091201782,
-0.26290005445480347,
-0.2749759256839752,
0.45753106474876404,
0.12441679835319519,
1.1641948223114014,
-0.31914693117141724,
0.5497785806655884,
0.5798370838165283,
0.7537574172019958,
-0.4277554452419281,
0.15480567514896393,
0.3089985251426697,
-0.5823108553886414,
-0.5417520403862,
-0.5305259227752686,
-0.6851422190666199,
-0.29093649983406067,
-0.8704088926315308,
-0.21637071669101715,
-0.14043575525283813,
-0.5567293763160706,
-0.298489511013031,
0.0004836746375076473,
-0.4292431175708771,
0.41384157538414,
-0.10475270450115204,
0.7292969226837158,
-0.7757219672203064,
0.21629910171031952,
0.5244698524475098,
-0.11091362684965134,
-0.8428323864936829,
0.3361993730068207,
0.19464550912380219,
-0.1509598344564438,
-0.11960995197296143,
-0.07016870379447937,
-0.38895857334136963,
-0.42795562744140625,
0.029275789856910706,
-0.8993719220161438,
1.2811387777328491,
0.3780358135700226,
-0.372433066368103,
-0.03465776517987251,
0.30564388632774353,
0.6241467595100403,
0.008817726746201515,
0.6651877760887146,
0.7729852199554443,
0.4798162877559662,
-0.16311746835708618,
-1.1828784942626953,
-0.02938859909772873,
0.17764388024806976,
0.23349805176258087,
0.1358000785112381,
-0.4643262028694153,
0.5627329349517822,
-0.3311680853366852,
-0.38681796193122864,
0.1438804715871811,
0.7852156162261963,
0.19639377295970917,
0.2627166509628296,
0.41814106702804565,
0.4306396543979645,
0.9073651432991028,
-0.33130502700805664,
1.0763561725616455,
-0.24795116484165192,
0.37256914377212524,
1.4683228731155396,
-0.0036932434886693954,
0.7523647546768188,
0.33416256308555603,
-0.4853860139846802,
0.08659712225198746,
0.4622047245502472,
0.3540913462638855,
0.12676234543323517,
-0.034141603857278824,
0.11679406464099884,
-0.07938335090875626,
0.005228017456829548,
-0.26953017711639404,
0.4948490858078003,
0.2832165062427521,
-0.19208768010139465,
-0.4306333363056183,
-0.5508597493171692,
0.11467866599559784,
0.4635370671749115,
0.09764055162668228,
0.7520604729652405,
0.09102039039134979,
-0.5635728240013123,
0.17972825467586517,
-0.11795090138912201,
0.6931192278862,
-0.5950137376785278,
0.3623497784137726,
-0.08839737623929977,
-0.06973302364349365,
-0.0016523462254554033,
-0.6775442361831665,
0.3486570715904236,
0.16864295303821564,
0.2487783581018448,
-0.02948555164039135,
0.44961678981781006,
-0.09016615897417068,
-0.6373770236968994,
0.04920632019639015,
0.617190957069397,
-0.0009615168091841042,
-0.2536109685897827,
-0.28373798727989197,
-0.1272759884595871,
-0.08287432044744492,
-0.28489187359809875,
0.13256345689296722,
0.6520932912826538,
0.11984724551439285,
0.5612986087799072,
0.18091580271720886,
0.1532716155052185,
0.047329146414995193,
0.04196958243846893,
0.20785610377788544,
-0.3571150302886963,
-0.3124069571495056,
-0.8465937972068787,
0.7886759638786316,
-0.3709217607975006,
-0.894264817237854,
0.9938903450965881,
0.4927440881729126,
0.6211572289466858,
0.14573021233081818,
1.0350255966186523,
0.22170715034008026,
0.5629280805587769,
-0.32007813453674316,
0.7651034593582153,
-0.17025011777877808,
0.15349455177783966,
-0.8791828751564026,
-0.9333305358886719,
-0.366802841424942,
0.3319806456565857,
-0.008779344148933887,
0.22160756587982178,
0.9159361124038696,
0.23514454066753387,
0.312113493680954,
0.2870683968067169,
0.32318976521492004,
-0.13547296822071075,
0.18083077669143677,
0.14629872143268585,
0.41823530197143555,
-0.8711310625076294,
0.5966706871986389,
-0.4610747694969177,
-0.18483847379684448,
0.03815352916717529,
-1.278445839881897,
-0.8088032007217407,
-0.4802725315093994,
-0.3588881194591522,
0.005980899091809988,
-0.08040913939476013,
0.6627333760261536,
0.47601690888404846,
-0.7448456883430481,
-0.259068101644516,
-0.015202331356704235,
0.1625748574733734,
-0.5640773773193359,
-0.13210035860538483,
0.39805278182029724,
-0.16547197103500366,
-0.5931482315063477,
0.030245861038565636,
0.32222527265548706,
0.19640956819057465,
-0.1151723638176918,
0.1084144115447998,
-0.09444157779216766,
0.20807886123657227,
0.15778706967830658,
0.11399468779563904,
-0.6142064332962036,
-0.38927724957466125,
-0.1197909265756607,
-0.1357066035270691,
-0.3296545743942261,
0.5579690337181091,
-0.2727198600769043,
0.36948415637016296,
0.2746404707431793,
0.6972836852073669,
0.16438046097755432,
0.29480040073394775,
0.9324419498443604,
-1.083869457244873,
-0.2192610502243042,
0.06944111734628677,
0.45908114314079285,
0.3478001058101654,
-0.174754798412323,
0.7053795456886292,
-0.25912120938301086,
-0.6055551767349243,
-0.9143326282501221,
0.004017622675746679,
-0.9158956408500671,
0.10558038204908371,
0.9383589029312134,
-0.30570292472839355,
0.09604732692241669,
-0.08189114928245544,
0.2884083092212677,
0.36467164754867554,
-0.5183297395706177,
0.9112655520439148,
0.8218608498573303,
0.08506453782320023,
0.08293182402849197,
-0.5302738547325134,
0.5519214868545532,
0.32166439294815063,
-0.9406408667564392,
0.2132536619901657,
0.2529343366622925,
-0.022374577820301056,
0.43361881375312805,
0.3945777714252472,
-0.08053338527679443,
0.23623761534690857,
0.13582348823547363,
0.12677712738513947,
0.13091397285461426,
-0.3209494650363922,
-0.11306163668632507,
-0.033958468586206436,
-0.027918320149183273,
-0.11249533295631409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17271v1 | DARG: Dynamic Evaluation of Large Language Models via Adaptive Reasoning Graph | 2024-06-25T04:27:53 | 2024-06-25T04:27:53 | Zhehao Zhang, Jiaao Chen, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The current paradigm of evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) through
static benchmarks comes with significant limitations, such as vulnerability to
data contamination and a lack of adaptability to the evolving capabilities of
LLMs. Therefore, evaluation methods that can adapt and generate evaluation data
with controlled complexity are urgently needed. In this work, we introduce
Dynamic Evaluation of LLMs via Adaptive Reasoning Graph Evolvement (DARG) to
dynamically extend current benchmarks with controlled complexity and diversity.
Specifically, we first extract the reasoning graphs of data points in current
benchmarks and then perturb the reasoning graphs to generate novel testing
data. Such newly generated test samples can have different levels of complexity
while maintaining linguistic diversity similar to the original benchmarks. We
further use a code-augmented LLM to ensure the label correctness of newly
generated data. We apply our DARG framework to diverse reasoning tasks in four
domains with 15 state-of-the-art LLMs. Experimental results show that almost
all LLMs experience a performance decrease with increased complexity and
certain LLMs exhibit significant drops. Additionally, we find that LLMs exhibit
more biases when being evaluated via the data generated by DARG with higher
complexity levels. These observations provide useful insights into how to
dynamically and adaptively evaluate LLMs. The code is available at
https://github.com/SALT-NLP/DARG. | [
-0.3884395956993103,
-1.0992562770843506,
0.40401795506477356,
0.24166327714920044,
-0.2018379122018814,
0.6323526501655579,
-0.5946469306945801,
-0.29903265833854675,
-0.2788560688495636,
0.27936190366744995,
-0.42248499393463135,
-0.7260398864746094,
-0.8422751426696777,
0.1886889785528183,
-0.14178983867168427,
1.0001299381256104,
-0.12298677116632462,
-0.12673483788967133,
-0.27137964963912964,
-0.40331029891967773,
-0.5407431721687317,
-0.1917068511247635,
-0.5457236170768738,
-0.4439548850059509,
0.2840301990509033,
0.2135324776172638,
0.8366086483001709,
0.6935663819313049,
0.39814984798431396,
0.4034407436847687,
-0.3727065622806549,
0.46631014347076416,
-0.6371726989746094,
0.5136948227882385,
-0.27695372700691223,
-0.29184821248054504,
-0.5716696977615356,
-0.25447213649749756,
0.8956586122512817,
0.8822028636932373,
-0.015362577512860298,
0.15717817842960358,
-0.030530771240592003,
0.5320906043052673,
-0.5010604858398438,
0.3379017412662506,
-0.9552831053733826,
-0.1697349101305008,
-0.06839723885059357,
-0.06553120911121368,
-0.3839709758758545,
-0.44000574946403503,
0.3262159526348114,
-0.36884719133377075,
-0.24297623336315155,
0.0013395572314038873,
0.6522517800331116,
0.4579394459724426,
-0.3990386426448822,
-0.4301716685295105,
-0.5586581826210022,
0.7707581520080566,
-0.6461577415466309,
0.26552730798721313,
-0.10543222725391388,
0.5091906785964966,
-0.4888122081756592,
-0.9509039521217346,
-0.4010908305644989,
-0.5884951949119568,
0.15918280184268951,
-0.053418006747961044,
-0.25533327460289,
-0.03355879336595535,
0.43922674655914307,
0.4156179130077362,
-0.44396355748176575,
0.2123166024684906,
0.2260611653327942,
0.18604159355163574,
0.6167942881584167,
0.2582557201385498,
0.43693870306015015,
-0.06477175652980804,
-0.2631373107433319,
-0.07435047626495361,
-0.39317551255226135,
-0.181497722864151,
0.4214553236961365,
0.3270888924598694,
-0.14742550253868103,
0.16817936301231384,
-0.1605709046125412,
0.8516147136688232,
0.08750265836715698,
-0.03820168599486351,
0.6183953881263733,
-0.15674357116222382,
-0.10538425296545029,
-0.2530950903892517,
0.5451703667640686,
0.15602605044841766,
0.30679842829704285,
-0.15983416140079498,
-0.2740292251110077,
-0.2748207151889801,
0.22540055215358734,
-0.5736464262008667,
-0.28274771571159363,
0.1367701143026352,
-0.3706904947757721,
-0.3199775218963623,
-0.2806864380836487,
-1.0892438888549805,
-0.767774760723114,
-0.22668975591659546,
0.25641393661499023,
-0.4390014708042145,
-0.27816081047058105,
0.2648294270038605,
-0.09213989973068237,
-0.09834349155426025,
0.5397946834564209,
-0.5674306154251099,
0.44260603189468384,
0.6032141447067261,
0.6604225635528564,
-0.5897619128227234,
-0.2856729328632355,
-0.6769860982894897,
0.04508756846189499,
-0.15896040201187134,
0.7577520608901978,
-0.8728578686714172,
-0.21386562287807465,
-0.04980485141277313,
-0.17161370813846588,
-0.10407420247793198,
-0.945091187953949,
0.6036229133605957,
-0.5689386129379272,
-0.23300041258335114,
-0.18575279414653778,
-0.5695288777351379,
-0.1279456615447998,
0.3745895028114319,
-0.572340726852417,
1.1971428394317627,
0.43035921454429626,
-0.7261596322059631,
0.30205675959587097,
-0.8333302736282349,
-0.42769309878349304,
0.3631611466407776,
-0.15492664277553558,
-0.5154746770858765,
-0.0005206019850447774,
0.2972818613052368,
0.044733528047800064,
-0.42615294456481934,
0.4039989709854126,
-0.6059737205505371,
-0.23034021258354187,
0.37100303173065186,
-0.35180535912513733,
0.7894204258918762,
0.19539886713027954,
-0.513572096824646,
0.311273455619812,
-1.1297941207885742,
0.2851334512233734,
0.07209102809429169,
-0.5631080865859985,
-0.18664725124835968,
0.21226969361305237,
-0.4000118374824524,
-0.0539250373840332,
0.18090583384037018,
-0.24059008061885834,
0.3380354046821594,
-0.21158947050571442,
0.31924188137054443,
0.9048063158988953,
-0.042252689599990845,
0.30886533856391907,
-0.3258105218410492,
0.7087576389312744,
-0.14099374413490295,
-0.049337394535541534,
-0.013288365676999092,
-0.3437201976776123,
-0.9644510746002197,
-0.36194610595703125,
0.39859241247177124,
0.5510558485984802,
-0.7990818023681641,
0.501011312007904,
-0.5421816110610962,
-0.5567573308944702,
-0.2759544849395752,
0.16157236695289612,
0.19293808937072754,
0.2036210596561432,
0.23353338241577148,
-0.13472849130630493,
-0.5253254771232605,
-0.6036657094955444,
-0.38707733154296875,
-0.16542458534240723,
0.013820674270391464,
0.7582367658615112,
0.41603031754493713,
-0.4179966151714325,
0.6572708487510681,
-0.42581892013549805,
0.3455813527107239,
-0.3799269199371338,
0.21720436215400696,
0.3232654333114624,
0.3141360580921173,
0.666705846786499,
-0.4482451379299164,
-0.4979504942893982,
0.2800210118293762,
-0.5728824138641357,
-0.7525911927223206,
-0.23025211691856384,
-0.1397472321987152,
0.029063202440738678,
0.3228369653224945,
-0.4527853727340698,
0.06081269681453705,
0.635562539100647,
-0.21451744437217712,
0.8806567788124084,
-0.16675381362438202,
0.02321852184832096,
-0.5456428527832031,
-0.09271011501550674,
-0.2531147599220276,
-0.2936713695526123,
-0.5197587609291077,
0.3350258767604828,
-0.17398515343666077,
0.02520449459552765,
-0.06732109189033508,
0.8190470337867737,
-0.5531413555145264,
-0.1913267970085144,
-0.41255706548690796,
0.27785998582839966,
-0.11897214502096176,
0.21277634799480438,
-0.3944268226623535,
0.5872507691383362,
0.8150089383125305,
-0.6407397985458374,
0.7801726460456848,
0.061887118965387344,
-0.7292940020561218,
0.24295316636562347,
-0.46947452425956726,
0.19127494096755981,
0.06547563523054123,
0.29263967275619507,
-0.8515080213546753,
0.0013471744023263454,
0.08946626633405685,
-0.17998309433460236,
0.26023998856544495,
-0.20349198579788208,
-0.6060540676116943,
-0.3715244233608246,
-0.06251700222492218,
0.5118153095245361,
0.5271002054214478,
-0.827722430229187,
0.7550534009933472,
0.2793672978878021,
-0.39959871768951416,
-0.4054245352745056,
-0.3664300739765167,
0.17883098125457764,
-0.34546297788619995,
-0.6774881482124329,
0.320318341255188,
-0.27775564789772034,
-0.4129399359226227,
-0.11680405586957932,
-0.27156612277030945,
0.15876521170139313,
0.2419360876083374,
0.020688608288764954,
-0.06594434380531311,
-0.10232817381620407,
0.26597121357917786,
0.12465569376945496,
-0.006365182343870401,
0.017470914870500565,
-0.33981746435165405,
0.7665619254112244,
-0.2729052007198334,
-0.27015364170074463,
-0.019926294684410095,
-0.0630374476313591,
0.5212504863739014,
-0.2561100423336029,
0.4075543284416199,
0.6671987771987915,
-0.23954741656780243,
-0.8960443735122681,
-0.32132285833358765,
0.22496148943901062,
-0.5451318621635437,
0.6380820274353027,
-0.5593835711479187,
-0.9113397002220154,
0.7870259881019592,
-0.6815882921218872,
-0.010341169312596321,
0.118294358253479,
1.001792073249817,
0.30764174461364746,
0.7802100777626038,
0.22296679019927979,
0.3487519919872284,
0.3427804410457611,
-0.054447758942842484,
0.2046055644750595,
-0.6443111300468445,
-0.19992667436599731,
-0.37244486808776855,
-0.357113778591156,
-0.7819689512252808,
-0.6601802706718445,
0.2918316423892975,
0.18051370978355408,
-0.2888345420360565,
0.0204418133944273,
-0.3605063855648041,
0.46214720606803894,
0.21851880848407745,
0.06073945388197899,
0.27577105164527893,
-0.11318536102771759,
-0.32730457186698914,
0.20787309110164642,
-0.6304870247840881,
-0.44779688119888306,
1.0216448307037354,
0.38983353972435,
0.9091757535934448,
0.12071551382541656,
0.3707188665866852,
0.5703477263450623,
0.31841787695884705,
-0.5907611846923828,
0.7233023047447205,
-0.43456125259399414,
-0.13291636109352112,
-0.21029625833034515,
-0.6676231622695923,
-0.8687646389007568,
0.3672834038734436,
-0.13619457185268402,
-0.672054648399353,
0.03928500786423683,
-0.027483148500323296,
-0.07568532228469849,
0.2960290014743805,
-0.535239577293396,
0.5972933769226074,
-0.5418547987937927,
-0.2957349419593811,
-0.17153380811214447,
-0.3106999099254608,
0.304031640291214,
-0.32215964794158936,
0.2644606828689575,
-0.32087472081184387,
-0.006684004794806242,
0.5906412601470947,
-0.3709559142589569,
0.6673916578292847,
-0.1737636923789978,
-0.17740154266357422,
0.24590829014778137,
0.16651390492916107,
0.6177091598510742,
0.18156678974628448,
-0.5099830627441406,
0.0764535516500473,
-0.25965097546577454,
-0.436949223279953,
-0.9012477993965149,
0.8665863275527954,
-0.7432413697242737,
-0.8153100609779358,
-0.4104100465774536,
-1.1035550832748413,
-0.38063058257102966,
0.2665291428565979,
-0.4364856481552124,
0.10475216060876846,
0.08055960386991501,
0.17780625820159912,
0.32925844192504883,
-0.7789151072502136,
0.18810735642910004,
0.41563546657562256,
-0.33330532908439636,
-0.5731483101844788,
0.6805211901664734,
-0.020784303545951843,
0.5260082483291626,
0.03384823724627495,
0.3860264718532562,
-0.1647612750530243,
-0.9968169331550598,
-0.3041872978210449,
0.0832185372710228,
-0.862995982170105,
-0.1673586070537567,
-0.5446446537971497,
-0.20393574237823486,
-0.31729182600975037,
0.01849220134317875,
-0.15850242972373962,
-0.43603384494781494,
0.05662631243467331,
-0.08693589270114899,
0.4411746561527252,
0.6349669694900513,
-0.012137209996581078,
0.32871219515800476,
-0.5303128361701965,
0.24407881498336792,
0.32107535004615784,
0.6400802731513977,
0.02673926018178463,
-0.568611204624176,
-0.14614832401275635,
-0.0695943608880043,
-0.22706902027130127,
-0.5877741575241089,
0.19375964999198914,
0.2790769636631012,
0.9117656946182251,
0.14775903522968292,
0.14571404457092285,
0.7255906462669373,
-0.5588203072547913,
0.6364233493804932,
-0.17570772767066956,
-1.1636422872543335,
0.33661016821861267,
-0.5404514074325562,
0.4701732099056244,
0.2923712134361267,
-0.005909987725317478,
-0.19169753789901733,
-0.3610740602016449,
-0.41863924264907837,
-0.8306606411933899,
0.6224924921989441,
0.08449859917163849,
0.17438288033008575,
0.06256124377250671,
0.6056689620018005,
0.3063715100288391,
0.1001744493842125,
-0.7193800806999207,
-0.26653987169265747,
-0.04222346469759941,
-0.1186193972826004,
0.2646183371543884,
-0.22003737092018127,
-0.18184970319271088,
-0.27385973930358887,
0.40183812379837036,
-0.22678320109844208,
0.11713442951440811,
-0.38727834820747375,
-0.07454312592744827,
0.09117023646831512,
0.23204047977924347,
0.311531662940979,
0.8701789975166321,
-0.1959100067615509,
0.25959697365760803,
0.5388585329055786,
-0.22556380927562714,
0.096200130879879,
0.2585480213165283,
-0.15239903330802917,
-0.07932644337415695,
0.4206234812736511,
1.2017930746078491,
0.06857282668352127,
-1.0366244316101074,
0.2481413334608078,
0.011564038693904877,
-0.07786335796117783,
-0.02013135887682438,
0.3531232178211212,
-0.00845714658498764,
0.39775821566581726,
0.14606109261512756,
-0.06737957894802094,
-0.13675031065940857,
-0.3878447413444519,
0.3786952793598175,
0.426362544298172,
0.09496010094881058,
-0.09235239028930664,
0.44659632444381714,
0.22237977385520935,
-0.2708665132522583,
0.4643976092338562,
-0.4148475229740143,
-0.6081908345222473,
0.6500711441040039,
0.7396445274353027,
0.8284966349601746,
-0.14037609100341797,
0.2164483368396759,
0.25869664549827576,
0.1770995855331421,
0.2662942111492157,
0.21502570807933807,
0.02779756672680378,
-0.7552706003189087,
-0.5241789817810059,
-0.8456102609634399,
-0.4816429913043976,
0.2918075621128082,
-0.32270893454551697,
0.44295361638069153,
-0.6153880953788757,
-0.17353995144367218,
-0.023278292268514633,
0.024644024670124054,
-0.31482625007629395,
0.29214462637901306,
0.14674527943134308,
0.887565016746521,
-0.4974188804626465,
0.7469763159751892,
0.7386681437492371,
0.09670939296483994,
-0.32592320442199707,
0.08708609640598297,
-0.16340011358261108,
-0.921527087688446,
0.7961684465408325,
-0.06887708604335785,
-0.0372389517724514,
-0.07224886119365692,
-0.40833574533462524,
-1.0370359420776367,
0.9081570506095886,
0.6280479431152344,
-0.3314482569694519,
0.20529024302959442,
0.2942722737789154,
0.6657378673553467,
-0.4684787094593048,
0.3249397277832031,
0.7546094655990601,
0.6751874685287476,
0.19938915967941284,
-0.8320061564445496,
0.1122833788394928,
-0.40328508615493774,
0.0345349945127964,
0.03100721538066864,
-0.4808539152145386,
0.8318666815757751,
-0.1642620712518692,
-0.2730056643486023,
0.08534374088048935,
0.43114233016967773,
0.5448411107063293,
0.11910300701856613,
0.7230867743492126,
0.6482430696487427,
0.9106714129447937,
-0.3292646110057831,
0.964408814907074,
-0.3585571348667145,
0.3335450291633606,
1.2498310804367065,
-0.4925094544887543,
0.48331108689308167,
-0.027210213243961334,
-0.31551024317741394,
0.7736246585845947,
0.5612956881523132,
-0.33864888548851013,
0.23831604421138763,
0.8676931262016296,
-0.3544754683971405,
-0.29692548513412476,
-0.07374563813209534,
-0.14442627131938934,
0.4991193413734436,
0.35608282685279846,
-0.23068569600582123,
-0.4071689546108246,
-0.012374155223369598,
-0.00015685833932366222,
0.16620659828186035,
-0.15644384920597076,
0.608112633228302,
-0.14599330723285675,
-0.6022380590438843,
1.0247305631637573,
0.05188097432255745,
0.4472229480743408,
-0.5709887146949768,
0.06658726930618286,
-0.16144534945487976,
0.20600715279579163,
-0.13756628334522247,
-0.7327218651771545,
0.13962477445602417,
0.10485318303108215,
-0.031031403690576553,
-0.17533446848392487,
0.7583736181259155,
-0.34107235074043274,
-0.42732366919517517,
0.6072308421134949,
0.5444191098213196,
0.07024747133255005,
0.3686641752719879,
-0.8381755948066711,
0.497925728559494,
0.034871138632297516,
-0.20206846296787262,
0.33471375703811646,
0.6255210041999817,
-0.14437945187091827,
0.9991621971130371,
0.6274757385253906,
0.3150789141654968,
0.43326687812805176,
0.46734723448753357,
1.0386228561401367,
-0.3906130790710449,
-0.35105979442596436,
-0.8671645522117615,
0.3712029755115509,
-0.1727733016014099,
-0.0847645252943039,
0.6445411443710327,
0.3686456084251404,
0.7023533582687378,
0.044782605022192,
1.0079984664916992,
-0.08544954657554626,
0.410789430141449,
-0.41845765709877014,
0.6552605628967285,
-0.45341765880584717,
0.5687971711158752,
-0.39332592487335205,
-0.9194379448890686,
-0.4364745020866394,
0.4054631292819977,
-0.4827786982059479,
0.3360413908958435,
0.6762974262237549,
0.5960961580276489,
0.13275933265686035,
-0.15965870022773743,
0.1586718112230301,
0.631941020488739,
0.7033970355987549,
0.48260265588760376,
0.8519359827041626,
-0.08159708976745605,
0.5191987156867981,
0.05258767306804657,
-0.553169310092926,
0.14339126646518707,
-1.185246467590332,
-0.8689388036727905,
-0.2173905223608017,
-0.6988313794136047,
-0.4229995608329773,
0.21151557564735413,
0.692956805229187,
0.4524952471256256,
-0.7729318737983704,
-0.24846571683883667,
-0.20965442061424255,
0.3036535680294037,
-0.19093580543994904,
-0.25304198265075684,
0.5215550661087036,
-0.60154128074646,
-0.9583013653755188,
0.4088825583457947,
0.4228019416332245,
-0.11546535789966583,
-0.14660660922527313,
-0.2025216966867447,
-0.20484121143817902,
0.12679144740104675,
0.664919376373291,
-0.021278979256749153,
-0.706605076789856,
-0.4366361200809479,
-0.2900000214576721,
0.2698571979999542,
-0.025620970875024796,
0.6166671514511108,
-0.7410938739776611,
0.6484693884849548,
0.6022626757621765,
1.046639323234558,
0.28794369101524353,
0.08691727370023727,
0.5443869829177856,
-0.5216579437255859,
-0.15540193021297455,
0.20308110117912292,
0.25893646478652954,
0.30048978328704834,
0.0352378785610199,
0.44162440299987793,
0.3478720188140869,
-0.6852346658706665,
-1.1450921297073364,
0.3954547941684723,
-1.082521677017212,
-0.3314196467399597,
1.4347436428070068,
-0.34565311670303345,
0.040433820337057114,
-0.03281534090638161,
-0.051276568323373795,
0.20975427329540253,
-0.1803116798400879,
0.9789703488349915,
0.7993248105049133,
-0.2728756070137024,
-0.3473392426967621,
-0.28062188625335693,
0.4870882034301758,
0.3901631236076355,
-1.2012706995010376,
0.3466576039791107,
0.40327367186546326,
0.394321471452713,
-0.0009292177855968475,
0.2588031589984894,
-0.15556924045085907,
0.10841553658246994,
-0.030059490352869034,
-0.21039998531341553,
-0.014288939535617828,
-0.061743322759866714,
-0.30064883828163147,
0.18561381101608276,
0.23782764375209808,
0.12688873708248138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17266v1 | AG-LSEC: Audio Grounded Lexical Speaker Error Correction | 2024-06-25T04:20:49 | 2024-06-25T04:20:49 | Rohit Paturi, Xiang Li, Sundararajan Srinivasan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Speaker Diarization (SD) systems are typically audio-based and operate
independently of the ASR system in traditional speech transcription pipelines
and can have speaker errors due to SD and/or ASR reconciliation, especially
around speaker turns and regions of speech overlap. To reduce these errors, a
Lexical Speaker Error Correction (LSEC), in which an external language model
provides lexical information to correct the speaker errors, was recently
proposed. Though the approach achieves good Word Diarization error rate (WDER)
improvements, it does not use any additional acoustic information and is prone
to miscorrections. In this paper, we propose to enhance and acoustically ground
the LSEC system with speaker scores directly derived from the existing SD
pipeline. This approach achieves significant relative WDER reductions in the
range of 25-40% over the audio-based SD, ASR system and beats the LSEC system
by 15-25% relative on RT03-CTS, Callhome American English and Fisher datasets. | [
-0.35654520988464355,
-0.516846239566803,
0.5698302984237671,
-0.06807158887386322,
-0.05334749072790146,
0.30095112323760986,
-0.19782210886478424,
-0.22107192873954773,
0.7894968390464783,
0.26457786560058594,
-0.34358298778533936,
-0.5375871658325195,
-0.46679309010505676,
0.11570768803358078,
-0.36821112036705017,
0.37292829155921936,
0.3297286033630371,
0.17756734788417816,
0.10457773506641388,
-0.10238662362098694,
-0.5152172446250916,
-0.401065468788147,
-0.6603695154190063,
-0.13639435172080994,
0.05779765546321869,
0.513649582862854,
0.7306867241859436,
0.5153802633285522,
0.5108228921890259,
0.35687461495399475,
-0.6494017243385315,
0.30388450622558594,
-0.25614604353904724,
0.004724170546978712,
-0.3246322274208069,
-0.0654691830277443,
-0.9062339067459106,
-0.16617687046527863,
0.8376219868659973,
0.9291626811027527,
-0.5554084181785583,
-0.3538395166397095,
0.061644040048122406,
0.6787207722663879,
-0.69732266664505,
-0.03702356666326523,
-0.701083779335022,
-0.12324435263872147,
-0.038273297250270844,
-0.4143090546131134,
-0.6460062265396118,
-0.20641028881072998,
-0.4264569878578186,
-0.1821291595697403,
0.4468781650066376,
-0.3127657473087311,
0.6738895177841187,
0.4057503938674927,
-0.1180514320731163,
-0.15450109541416168,
-0.944778561592102,
0.4044947624206543,
-0.9009861946105957,
0.8586552739143372,
0.6351433396339417,
0.20355848968029022,
0.008930844254791737,
-0.334503173828125,
-0.18647761642932892,
-0.1980533003807068,
0.06961416453123093,
0.36209097504615784,
0.12540265917778015,
0.33831608295440674,
0.34911730885505676,
0.40408673882484436,
-0.06765647977590561,
0.14808017015457153,
-0.7241639494895935,
-0.412506103515625,
0.5884076356887817,
-0.04910435155034065,
0.061976250261068344,
0.023688100278377533,
-0.06515523046255112,
-0.2381761521100998,
-0.8243280649185181,
0.171675905585289,
0.4105291962623596,
0.8235393762588501,
0.002073268871754408,
0.6971799731254578,
-0.063624307513237,
0.587826132774353,
0.23321376740932465,
-0.10641373693943024,
0.4703986346721649,
-0.23586726188659668,
-0.02264823578298092,
0.8976812958717346,
0.3991754949092865,
0.6601430177688599,
0.06517831236124039,
-0.005166169721633196,
-0.5062663555145264,
0.5775690078735352,
0.3473222851753235,
-0.49695679545402527,
-0.14369814097881317,
0.11297304183244705,
-0.10235104709863663,
0.1336950957775116,
0.2905111312866211,
-0.5788047909736633,
-0.5092744827270508,
-0.5660545825958252,
0.2802113890647888,
-0.4220101833343506,
-0.005642322823405266,
0.08629478514194489,
-0.18943741917610168,
0.04633691906929016,
0.4736080467700958,
-0.6085018515586853,
0.673077404499054,
0.3604842722415924,
0.9162080883979797,
0.06907345354557037,
-0.02142064832150936,
-0.9353671073913574,
0.3803853392601013,
-0.5746411085128784,
0.6922588348388672,
-0.36020469665527344,
-0.6619822382926941,
-0.17723903059959412,
-0.03071555681526661,
-0.07308477908372879,
-0.4776490330696106,
0.878903329372406,
-0.32136642932891846,
-0.036927949637174606,
-0.4378058612346649,
-0.7746538519859314,
0.3695479929447174,
-0.21087627112865448,
-0.45856404304504395,
0.8359085917472839,
-0.06315720826387405,
-0.8270324468612671,
0.04338942468166351,
-0.31920114159584045,
-0.2888554334640503,
0.0758267492055893,
-0.2021121233701706,
-0.0021922967862337828,
0.02435286156833172,
0.4987153708934784,
0.39453792572021484,
0.19872383773326874,
0.2077767252922058,
0.032198451459407806,
-0.9091780781745911,
-0.24633921682834625,
-0.1244305670261383,
0.2706351578235626,
0.20493735373020172,
-0.5277184844017029,
0.0031478460878133774,
-1.236027479171753,
0.016735879704356194,
-0.15605632960796356,
-0.2956458628177643,
-0.6797743439674377,
0.28737056255340576,
-0.3013809621334076,
-0.24040527641773224,
-0.22715497016906738,
-0.7194581031799316,
-0.38698798418045044,
-0.6399440765380859,
0.4324524700641632,
0.9276803135871887,
-0.19358988106250763,
0.47017136216163635,
0.0874001756310463,
0.07131975889205933,
-0.04209654778242111,
-0.5457747578620911,
-0.4652325510978699,
-0.24405591189861298,
-0.7787434458732605,
-0.3827047049999237,
0.3931868374347687,
0.8447529673576355,
-0.5940647125244141,
0.9418392181396484,
-0.5006198883056641,
-0.5890916585922241,
-0.7720144987106323,
-0.2661633789539337,
0.3709940016269684,
0.6823083758354187,
0.5482287406921387,
-0.487492173910141,
-0.6465339660644531,
-0.7048206329345703,
-0.07623293250799179,
-0.3386080861091614,
-0.11808931827545166,
0.3929472863674164,
-0.28879082202911377,
-0.3413795530796051,
1.0710726976394653,
-0.30581071972846985,
-0.48058435320854187,
-0.029965154826641083,
-0.2883000671863556,
0.5436359643936157,
0.3617461025714874,
0.20389962196350098,
-0.35976776480674744,
-0.2761276662349701,
0.07925531268119812,
-0.272401362657547,
-0.574008584022522,
-0.014110039919614792,
0.42023685574531555,
-0.03678590804338455,
0.9549340009689331,
-0.631166398525238,
0.605773389339447,
0.4296823740005493,
-0.49453020095825195,
0.5580525994300842,
-0.23783859610557556,
0.3682834804058075,
-0.7647009491920471,
-0.26288872957229614,
-0.08570408076047897,
-0.3473808169364929,
-0.7135429382324219,
-0.06563476473093033,
0.146763414144516,
-0.17053845524787903,
-0.44269561767578125,
0.2257080078125,
-0.19220441579818726,
-0.23521189391613007,
-0.11119712889194489,
0.4395448863506317,
0.024119053035974503,
0.11472517997026443,
-0.005589521024376154,
1.2716068029403687,
0.413499116897583,
-0.771420419216156,
0.49745669960975647,
0.5529749393463135,
-0.2506181597709656,
0.6665757298469543,
-0.8572995066642761,
0.2587406635284424,
-0.3314041793346405,
0.37703484296798706,
-1.0756816864013672,
0.04882930591702461,
-0.03275696188211441,
-0.5281612873077393,
0.3519190549850464,
0.13203682005405426,
0.013124078512191772,
-0.13581109046936035,
-0.2238745391368866,
0.18768802285194397,
0.37874600291252136,
-0.660294771194458,
0.45731988549232483,
0.26532846689224243,
-0.4736256003379822,
-0.2699664533138275,
-0.6792802810668945,
0.26945188641548157,
0.00567719666287303,
-0.5209256410598755,
0.3994884490966797,
0.03311675414443016,
-0.5523316264152527,
-0.13662192225456238,
-0.2145671397447586,
0.46917256712913513,
-0.3405939042568207,
0.09903921186923981,
-0.019367951899766922,
-0.3694290816783905,
0.17790620028972626,
-0.13564260303974152,
-0.2967032790184021,
-0.16571329534053802,
0.16647903621196747,
0.4799017906188965,
-0.2500271201133728,
-0.756818413734436,
-0.5526766777038574,
0.397110253572464,
0.4208136796951294,
0.039354108273983,
0.6977705955505371,
0.13001683354377747,
-0.2979257106781006,
0.19586841762065887,
-0.773207426071167,
-0.15270894765853882,
-0.5011188387870789,
0.3137475550174713,
-0.5598548650741577,
-0.8205658793449402,
0.5592958331108093,
0.025470368564128876,
-0.13712848722934723,
0.595891535282135,
0.307966023683548,
-0.1923511028289795,
0.8222799897193909,
0.040545687079429626,
-0.15279285609722137,
0.030248934403061867,
0.20503999292850494,
0.41567328572273254,
-0.7687250375747681,
-0.029389964416623116,
-0.7426896095275879,
-0.08844102919101715,
-0.45594704151153564,
-0.42946651577949524,
0.21844486892223358,
-0.040102437138557434,
-0.3877085745334625,
0.5979142189025879,
-0.29004642367362976,
0.4927580654621124,
0.4996449053287506,
0.1372617930173874,
0.11155090481042862,
0.014592139050364494,
-0.4795161485671997,
-0.4295179843902588,
-0.2288408875465393,
-0.3635116219520569,
0.4990265965461731,
0.8072364926338196,
0.8884109258651733,
0.05125749856233597,
0.7718757390975952,
0.6405077576637268,
-0.518998920917511,
-0.6130021810531616,
0.6262063384056091,
-0.33738577365875244,
0.009306458756327629,
-0.4538038372993469,
-0.5312763452529907,
-0.21727705001831055,
0.25654473900794983,
0.1602763533592224,
-0.7222005128860474,
0.4865875840187073,
0.018792275339365005,
-0.43410375714302063,
0.396247535943985,
-0.8697293996810913,
0.0988055020570755,
-0.0321459099650383,
-0.13426461815834045,
-0.08808181434869766,
-0.6866121888160706,
-0.13203540444374084,
0.04852328449487686,
0.6522960662841797,
0.016271838918328285,
0.17061594128608704,
0.7357374429702759,
-0.5238084197044373,
0.7535071969032288,
-0.6415877342224121,
-0.48759591579437256,
0.21356254816055298,
0.020933199673891068,
1.0035679340362549,
-0.2375779151916504,
-0.28404659032821655,
0.11022969335317612,
-0.23948369920253754,
0.10688472539186478,
-0.35413894057273865,
0.5287312269210815,
-0.8998782634735107,
-0.593926191329956,
-0.1621626317501068,
-0.0871846005320549,
-0.7407627105712891,
-0.19386467337608337,
0.12990953028202057,
0.4536726176738739,
-0.3064386546611786,
0.4634355902671814,
0.6963843703269958,
-0.05207517743110657,
0.1733100712299347,
0.26901641488075256,
0.12459354102611542,
-0.912965714931488,
0.6259298324584961,
-0.13233506679534912,
0.3254685699939728,
0.12345687299966812,
0.003564542392268777,
-0.3392709791660309,
-0.5111821889877319,
-0.20371419191360474,
0.1822785586118698,
-1.0186926126480103,
-0.26146823167800903,
-0.7024660706520081,
-0.6162331700325012,
-0.8137021064758301,
-0.32027122378349304,
-0.8325635194778442,
-0.5549859404563904,
-0.3611590564250946,
-0.5967063903808594,
0.2822529673576355,
0.15576070547103882,
-0.2315768599510193,
0.9726683497428894,
-1.0846136808395386,
0.5623192191123962,
0.0789809599518776,
0.5045982599258423,
-0.4941384494304657,
-1.0553267002105713,
-0.14053508639335632,
0.3340178430080414,
0.04237259179353714,
-0.7611452341079712,
0.2655694782733917,
0.7427485585212708,
0.41924819350242615,
0.5432161688804626,
-0.09867402911186218,
1.3799515962600708,
-1.1201715469360352,
0.9520562887191772,
0.5329285860061646,
-1.2995802164077759,
0.7792022824287415,
-0.26546066999435425,
0.08683978021144867,
0.6211418509483337,
-0.2505078911781311,
-0.7768582105636597,
-0.4485207200050354,
-0.7110319137573242,
-1.063470721244812,
0.8302645683288574,
0.47058209776878357,
0.033170875161886215,
-0.10719626396894455,
0.19503352046012878,
-0.17165519297122955,
-0.0677265077829361,
-0.32576459646224976,
-0.04977931082248688,
-0.37184128165245056,
0.06928777694702148,
-0.5533536672592163,
-0.4884796440601349,
-0.20844760537147522,
-0.3938067853450775,
1.1682515144348145,
-0.10841099172830582,
0.17805840075016022,
0.4371628761291504,
0.07528461515903473,
-0.36409124732017517,
0.5192546248435974,
0.6198601722717285,
0.382209450006485,
-0.4863905608654022,
0.3692414462566376,
0.47524216771125793,
-0.6146467924118042,
0.368951678276062,
-0.2053185999393463,
-0.047106966376304626,
0.2547265589237213,
0.31631144881248474,
1.1480035781860352,
0.2505001723766327,
-0.6640611886978149,
0.40434128046035767,
0.12680606544017792,
-0.1521611511707306,
-0.4134356677532196,
0.00932321883738041,
0.16241075098514557,
0.14566835761070251,
0.35281240940093994,
0.1680835634469986,
0.02076362445950508,
-0.14517533779144287,
0.5197321772575378,
0.2164035141468048,
-0.572750449180603,
-0.18034903705120087,
0.5075220465660095,
0.3780747056007385,
-0.36532917618751526,
0.6166795492172241,
-0.06263837963342667,
-0.41594046354293823,
0.41940340399742126,
0.6861576437950134,
0.7386507391929626,
-0.992345929145813,
-0.016219748184084892,
0.5149982571601868,
0.6048578023910522,
-0.11301254481077194,
0.17848867177963257,
0.00032082220423035324,
-0.9274784922599792,
-0.44214972853660583,
-0.6162549257278442,
-0.5183099508285522,
-0.04242590442299843,
-0.6976016163825989,
0.6264684796333313,
-0.40190720558166504,
-0.24251484870910645,
-0.3200075924396515,
-0.3678448796272278,
-0.10336074978113174,
0.46848633885383606,
0.48946481943130493,
0.9883162379264832,
-1.2520312070846558,
0.5170798897743225,
0.7071963548660278,
0.29882463812828064,
-0.8462888598442078,
-0.28928735852241516,
-0.07830555737018585,
-0.5566236972808838,
0.39005202054977417,
0.11402789503335953,
-0.40799078345298767,
-0.10460951924324036,
-0.17707042396068573,
-0.8721839785575867,
0.8688982725143433,
0.2975000739097595,
-0.9632136821746826,
0.034718360751867294,
0.41403958201408386,
0.6070089340209961,
-0.2832157611846924,
0.42318177223205566,
0.8326535820960999,
0.4132040739059448,
0.6498051881790161,
-1.2217553853988647,
-0.345734566450119,
-0.305968314409256,
0.10550536215305328,
0.1743161976337433,
-0.14849905669689178,
0.6345213055610657,
-0.0778254047036171,
-0.2088600993156433,
-0.19514572620391846,
0.845027506351471,
0.4781948924064636,
0.26509812474250793,
0.8154677748680115,
0.917579710483551,
0.7400524616241455,
-0.12956011295318604,
0.3385315537452698,
-0.03150473162531853,
0.28429436683654785,
1.1927634477615356,
-0.7500738501548767,
0.7785319089889526,
0.7819222211837769,
-0.5548232197761536,
0.1897466480731964,
0.5229155421257019,
0.17415191233158112,
0.7717719674110413,
0.0719367042183876,
-0.057840198278427124,
-0.2563531994819641,
-0.16279664635658264,
-0.7023270130157471,
0.7403085827827454,
0.7034620046615601,
-0.14133286476135254,
-0.26529452204704285,
-0.01668923906981945,
-0.3509651720523834,
0.3230897784233093,
-0.5568799376487732,
0.7198819518089294,
0.11327647417783737,
-0.14820726215839386,
0.6950868964195251,
0.10329041630029678,
0.5621957182884216,
-0.5951231718063354,
-0.0034851308446377516,
-0.24036608636379242,
0.5450719594955444,
-0.37076234817504883,
-0.37056320905685425,
0.5492973923683167,
0.03903587907552719,
-0.004115156829357147,
-0.2946855425834656,
0.9082031846046448,
-0.3875865340232849,
-0.43471473455429077,
0.47237884998321533,
0.3386963903903961,
0.10414764285087585,
0.04124712944030762,
-0.09534750878810883,
0.25622013211250305,
0.020886288955807686,
0.08755810558795929,
-0.042226552963256836,
0.1805744767189026,
0.050425224006175995,
0.3479088544845581,
0.632899284362793,
0.6415797472000122,
0.07138931006193161,
0.45732149481773376,
0.8032720685005188,
-0.8471074104309082,
-0.9967377781867981,
-0.6655328273773193,
0.4547007977962494,
-0.11080477386713028,
0.3800051510334015,
0.5130596160888672,
0.4710804224014282,
0.4783983826637268,
-0.11960399150848389,
0.46072763204574585,
-0.045741256326436996,
1.1949243545532227,
-0.6350407600402832,
0.5645519495010376,
-0.35937973856925964,
0.6840410828590393,
-0.6520764231681824,
-1.250783920288086,
-0.1386418342590332,
0.7006584405899048,
0.22783702611923218,
-0.09924853593111038,
0.7184486389160156,
0.9016055464744568,
-0.17794425785541534,
0.3300493061542511,
0.5420954823493958,
0.2512494921684265,
0.4121758043766022,
0.05830485373735428,
0.822117030620575,
-0.5968549251556396,
-0.0751689150929451,
-0.24967177212238312,
-0.35292455554008484,
-0.000629610032774508,
-0.7579231262207031,
-0.42639002203941345,
-0.47135359048843384,
-0.5146673321723938,
-0.4783545136451721,
0.38056087493896484,
0.9943887591362,
0.07063600420951843,
-1.2960063219070435,
-0.2938103675842285,
0.016067594289779663,
-0.3287818133831024,
-0.2742130756378174,
-0.22013269364833832,
0.5048967003822327,
-0.2475086748600006,
-0.44725507497787476,
1.157544493675232,
0.2683200240135193,
-0.11502686887979507,
0.24622896313667297,
-0.3177416920661926,
0.0009826767491176724,
0.17311973869800568,
0.4962071180343628,
0.02891400083899498,
-0.7230216264724731,
-0.8134431838989258,
-0.011419333517551422,
-0.044219814240932465,
0.18313759565353394,
0.708230197429657,
-0.8994495272636414,
0.2905864715576172,
0.2454746663570404,
0.6307456493377686,
-0.052731890231370926,
0.2686096727848053,
0.2813262343406677,
-1.1294529438018799,
0.3672369122505188,
0.3394007384777069,
0.6080381274223328,
0.5073238015174866,
-0.3506163954734802,
0.6319756507873535,
0.503653883934021,
-0.4100508689880371,
-0.9035463333129883,
-0.15697072446346283,
-0.9696252346038818,
0.19554802775382996,
1.485748529434204,
0.04239875078201294,
0.15369197726249695,
-0.04948612302541733,
-0.3651106655597687,
0.1780618280172348,
-0.41122421622276306,
0.4849366545677185,
0.7614017724990845,
0.30036062002182007,
-0.15890704095363617,
-0.17851604521274567,
0.23233172297477722,
0.4176079034805298,
-0.48124027252197266,
0.18520067632198334,
0.6586745381355286,
-0.06653586775064468,
0.5387783050537109,
0.7780080437660217,
-0.1098470613360405,
0.18029552698135376,
-0.11234868317842484,
0.21513023972511292,
0.14479395747184753,
-0.4848703145980835,
-0.40600642561912537,
-0.05531163141131401,
-0.12483049184083939,
-0.29677045345306396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17262v1 | D2LLM: Decomposed and Distilled Large Language Models for Semantic Search | 2024-06-25T04:03:04 | 2024-06-25T04:03:04 | Zihan Liao, Hang Yu, Jianguo Li, Jun Wang, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The key challenge in semantic search is to create models that are both
accurate and efficient in pinpointing relevant sentences for queries. While
BERT-style bi-encoders excel in efficiency with pre-computed embeddings, they
often miss subtle nuances in search tasks. Conversely, GPT-style LLMs with
cross-encoder designs capture these nuances but are computationally intensive,
hindering real-time applications. In this paper, we present D2LLMs-Decomposed
and Distilled LLMs for semantic search-that combines the best of both worlds.
We decompose a cross-encoder into an efficient bi-encoder integrated with
Pooling by Multihead Attention and an Interaction Emulation Module, achieving
nuanced understanding and pre-computability. Knowledge from the LLM is
distilled into this model using contrastive, rank, and feature imitation
techniques. Our experiments show that D2LLM surpasses five leading baselines in
terms of all metrics across three tasks, particularly improving NLI task
performance by at least 6.45%. The source code is available at
https://github.com/codefuse-ai/D2LLM. | [
-0.2273409217596054,
-0.763674795627594,
0.7633328437805176,
0.26218223571777344,
-0.2339496910572052,
0.16329431533813477,
-0.20199675858020782,
-0.349494993686676,
-0.08686711639165878,
0.39026975631713867,
-0.5730060338973999,
-0.40730342268943787,
-0.7703462839126587,
0.042873263359069824,
-0.41924190521240234,
0.47123661637306213,
-0.03864942863583565,
0.07257985323667526,
-0.40628382563591003,
0.16488340497016907,
-0.49406102299690247,
-0.259505033493042,
-0.3937278985977173,
-0.5254859328269958,
0.6863875985145569,
0.07076322287321091,
0.7348682284355164,
0.5565349459648132,
0.44925424456596375,
0.2977195084095001,
-0.3626609444618225,
0.3794732987880707,
-0.8294047117233276,
0.32571670413017273,
-0.3681655526161194,
-0.5433338284492493,
-0.3106224536895752,
0.1878163069486618,
0.42664262652397156,
0.7070765495300293,
-0.049533694982528687,
0.03830137848854065,
0.18785981833934784,
0.7227168679237366,
-0.48257729411125183,
0.5741486549377441,
-0.8845968842506409,
-0.009245251305401325,
0.015590346418321133,
-0.15023273229599,
-0.34188443422317505,
-0.036069273948669434,
0.2053723782300949,
-0.5053458213806152,
0.03601694107055664,
0.016736384481191635,
0.48877543210983276,
0.6123210787773132,
-0.2553320825099945,
-0.43770623207092285,
-0.5860441327095032,
0.9112644195556641,
-0.5352649688720703,
0.5644401907920837,
0.2458985298871994,
0.1282910406589508,
-0.44338855147361755,
-0.7384546995162964,
-0.5621306300163269,
0.12389205396175385,
-0.2450627088546753,
0.1462995558977127,
-0.23513425886631012,
0.030456556007266045,
0.030164161697030067,
0.44738978147506714,
-0.7830906510353088,
0.37880533933639526,
-0.16391430795192719,
0.191362664103508,
0.5434433221817017,
0.15343917906284332,
0.2714405059814453,
0.18710826337337494,
-0.4351710379123688,
-0.08086840063333511,
-0.6014871001243591,
-0.3254356384277344,
0.14036442339420319,
0.05412524566054344,
0.18072444200515747,
0.6684036254882812,
-0.21999335289001465,
0.7315053343772888,
-0.02458709105849266,
-0.0809422954916954,
0.0074578747153282166,
-0.5184239745140076,
0.03444967046380043,
-0.002498760586604476,
0.33153876662254333,
0.34735918045043945,
0.11657878011465073,
-0.5407010912895203,
-0.27690479159355164,
0.0671444684267044,
0.16545027494430542,
-0.9048154354095459,
-0.3363126516342163,
0.41007986664772034,
-0.4500635266304016,
-0.19341933727264404,
-0.15020817518234253,
-0.5866135358810425,
-0.17064079642295837,
-0.42721104621887207,
0.34501540660858154,
-0.2944639325141907,
-0.2026367336511612,
0.40970849990844727,
-0.306296169757843,
0.42534375190734863,
0.2368418425321579,
-0.6446022391319275,
0.2838556468486786,
0.7742829322814941,
0.6874322295188904,
-0.17701509594917297,
-0.1988915055990219,
-0.567396342754364,
0.11991012841463089,
-0.16888006031513214,
0.505993664264679,
-0.5386053323745728,
-0.27420711517333984,
-0.09685689955949783,
-0.21209652721881866,
0.03429924696683884,
-0.6553155779838562,
0.20086316764354706,
-1.0211881399154663,
0.07179168611764908,
-0.13981693983078003,
-0.7696619629859924,
-0.3615691661834717,
0.3158625662326813,
-0.838234007358551,
1.1805460453033447,
0.19940881431102753,
-0.6676039695739746,
0.21402005851268768,
-0.627349317073822,
-0.32600340247154236,
0.1701931655406952,
-0.041020069271326065,
-0.22537408769130707,
0.27559733390808105,
0.15294618904590607,
0.41274383664131165,
-0.5804462432861328,
0.2848134934902191,
-0.3968157172203064,
-0.6455875039100647,
0.24333450198173523,
-0.18206386268138885,
0.7542429566383362,
0.0671302080154419,
-0.36097875237464905,
-0.37832632660865784,
-0.514074981212616,
0.022785842418670654,
0.4495519697666168,
-0.5053467154502869,
-0.5060040950775146,
0.16155554354190826,
-0.03222161903977394,
0.31252557039260864,
0.42340922355651855,
-0.5691140294075012,
-0.03583775460720062,
-0.5349652171134949,
0.5124711990356445,
0.3285580575466156,
-0.4797731339931488,
0.49972328543663025,
-0.059473492205142975,
-0.10330333560705185,
0.09917712211608887,
-0.032042305916547775,
0.13129933178424835,
-0.3224585950374603,
-0.6953861117362976,
-0.40967515110969543,
0.25592273473739624,
0.6186665296554565,
-0.6006535291671753,
0.8551832437515259,
-0.47833412885665894,
-0.3236234784126282,
-0.7691529393196106,
0.46010148525238037,
0.23289650678634644,
0.24358364939689636,
0.5590250492095947,
0.04065379872918129,
-0.3596535325050354,
-0.7171400785446167,
-0.11275579780340195,
-0.04970212280750275,
-0.20113225281238556,
0.27936333417892456,
0.31561386585235596,
-0.6980593800544739,
1.0275747776031494,
-0.5929907560348511,
-0.4616261422634125,
-0.48633840680122375,
0.04181833937764168,
0.04760868474841118,
0.13826341927051544,
0.307003915309906,
-0.9899333119392395,
-0.3503113090991974,
-0.25713592767715454,
-0.7898476719856262,
-0.15399493277072906,
0.3053077757358551,
-0.11828833073377609,
0.0037440683227032423,
0.3347161114215851,
-0.6472294926643372,
0.4058713912963867,
0.3972002863883972,
-0.04032403230667114,
-0.07879836857318878,
-0.3571259081363678,
-0.20161375403404236,
-0.8149904608726501,
0.2086019366979599,
-0.24580344557762146,
-0.15251792967319489,
-0.4826878607273102,
0.11178398132324219,
0.0447969064116478,
-0.03546352684497833,
-0.41049379110336304,
0.5520485639572144,
-0.6579543352127075,
-0.2261791080236435,
-0.49480488896369934,
0.6743770837783813,
0.3028963804244995,
0.40759414434432983,
0.22176766395568848,
0.5033751130104065,
0.36433255672454834,
-0.6183609962463379,
0.7124670147895813,
0.3362704813480377,
-0.391399621963501,
0.06633572280406952,
-0.7500530481338501,
0.22744867205619812,
-0.2699389159679413,
0.34857290983200073,
-0.9809165596961975,
0.09243538975715637,
-0.2237294763326645,
-0.10633622854948044,
0.47568756341934204,
-0.04183337837457657,
-0.8314876556396484,
-0.3026081919670105,
-0.5680869817733765,
0.5956443548202515,
0.6185119152069092,
-0.8049486875534058,
0.4723452031612396,
0.404954731464386,
-0.12050125747919083,
-0.4596293866634369,
-0.8295989036560059,
0.13163913786411285,
-0.02514103427529335,
-0.6677684783935547,
0.6361480951309204,
0.007741900626569986,
-0.2237759530544281,
0.16706441342830658,
-0.04707736521959305,
0.0004382254555821419,
0.3851820230484009,
-0.11036097258329391,
0.2969972789287567,
0.18019670248031616,
0.037450067698955536,
-0.0574205219745636,
-0.2034006267786026,
-0.10788308084011078,
-0.36342909932136536,
0.7141504883766174,
0.23042944073677063,
-0.39643096923828125,
-0.1729261875152588,
0.5603318810462952,
0.45503929257392883,
-0.31001293659210205,
0.46874216198921204,
0.7343121767044067,
-0.4243697226047516,
-0.2584274709224701,
-0.6528440713882446,
-0.3496212363243103,
-0.43516406416893005,
0.6923649907112122,
-0.37781813740730286,
-0.9790208339691162,
0.22117024660110474,
-0.35242506861686707,
-0.07526156306266785,
0.2940673530101776,
0.6570513248443604,
-0.2007596492767334,
0.9646024703979492,
0.4888134300708771,
-0.025586172938346863,
0.19852836430072784,
-0.41658082604408264,
0.43839433789253235,
-0.8543163537979126,
-0.5278505086898804,
-0.2757699191570282,
-0.6725766062736511,
-0.6122663021087646,
-0.7611351609230042,
0.23481877148151398,
0.16725122928619385,
0.10955087095499039,
0.19737277925014496,
-0.5240994691848755,
0.49774932861328125,
0.5096577405929565,
0.23379746079444885,
0.2305983006954193,
-0.004361741244792938,
0.03394677862524986,
-0.030023546889424324,
-0.7741325497627258,
-0.23405484855175018,
0.7633833289146423,
0.3250456750392914,
1.0541549921035767,
0.13857720792293549,
0.732400119304657,
0.10221648961305618,
-0.2816155254840851,
-0.9465848207473755,
0.501758337020874,
-0.416378915309906,
-0.5746974945068359,
-0.3577463924884796,
-0.417955219745636,
-0.9173917174339294,
0.3236553966999054,
0.04132268577814102,
-0.4219355881214142,
0.07673624157905579,
-0.17011363804340363,
-0.08550115674734116,
0.17216885089874268,
-0.3157258927822113,
0.7804597020149231,
-0.48068562150001526,
-0.4528592526912689,
-0.44050946831703186,
-0.6565757989883423,
0.28731879591941833,
-0.05383572354912758,
0.058194104582071304,
-0.4071164131164551,
-0.258266419172287,
0.4103171229362488,
-0.16229382157325745,
0.6500946283340454,
-0.17644821107387543,
-0.09243448078632355,
0.18095867335796356,
0.14616194367408752,
0.6404129266738892,
0.17620447278022766,
-0.014046267606317997,
0.2807426452636719,
-0.18517591059207916,
-0.4152202308177948,
-0.6163743138313293,
1.0097553730010986,
-0.5671994090080261,
-0.5725303292274475,
-0.2366880625486374,
-0.5284433960914612,
0.0382247194647789,
0.07203688472509384,
-0.04619188979268074,
0.3135315775871277,
-0.16844098269939423,
0.2653270363807678,
0.9950851202011108,
-0.21420344710350037,
0.383549302816391,
0.46289026737213135,
-0.1091107651591301,
-0.04577215760946274,
0.7148523926734924,
-0.06865071505308151,
0.025325162336230278,
0.8452789187431335,
0.04680902883410454,
-0.7644943594932556,
-0.6004642844200134,
-0.3641723394393921,
0.18196582794189453,
-0.5846844911575317,
-0.21231673657894135,
-0.8107150793075562,
-0.21991512179374695,
-0.3155120313167572,
0.044149644672870636,
-0.4837310314178467,
-0.1640586107969284,
-0.3775426745414734,
-0.027631748467683792,
0.372035413980484,
0.5917514562606812,
0.0020337277092039585,
-0.17397849261760712,
-0.7902808785438538,
0.4157586991786957,
0.4703100919723511,
0.3997536599636078,
-0.19598254561424255,
-0.30630582571029663,
-0.3128354847431183,
0.22098895907402039,
0.07434163242578506,
-0.47999247908592224,
0.30395087599754333,
0.1567811518907547,
0.7077541947364807,
-0.21373015642166138,
0.1409638375043869,
0.6533695459365845,
-0.35608232021331787,
0.6076223254203796,
-0.011026579886674881,
-0.7340956330299377,
0.4539564251899719,
0.23001444339752197,
0.2798771560192108,
0.5405182838439941,
0.38884055614471436,
-0.2776421904563904,
-0.12863507866859436,
-0.008748345077037811,
-0.9784712791442871,
0.8054351806640625,
0.21983693540096283,
-0.09982675313949585,
-0.0211486853659153,
0.34522637724876404,
0.07544431835412979,
-0.043205343186855316,
-0.2952882945537567,
-0.17984531819820404,
-0.09225265681743622,
-0.5185619592666626,
-0.03047592006623745,
-0.6424508690834045,
0.021324921399354935,
-0.12657956779003143,
0.4690997302532196,
0.07234594970941544,
0.165113165974617,
0.23130850493907928,
-0.6387917995452881,
0.5306345820426941,
0.0013047404354438186,
0.163720041513443,
0.3696795105934143,
-0.23850499093532562,
0.5141201019287109,
0.13768158853054047,
-0.33403438329696655,
0.10139770060777664,
0.35641759634017944,
0.09628044813871384,
0.10590306669473648,
0.24320311844348907,
0.6790758967399597,
0.41925907135009766,
-0.7604590058326721,
0.4141135811805725,
-0.11251387745141983,
-0.04089275747537613,
-0.17816680669784546,
-0.12339112162590027,
0.4018211364746094,
0.3510841429233551,
0.27788370847702026,
-0.5800171494483948,
0.5818638801574707,
-0.5442540645599365,
0.18316425383090973,
0.39940133690834045,
-0.1546417474746704,
-0.23678326606750488,
0.5962682962417603,
0.35906022787094116,
0.0757669061422348,
0.8263697028160095,
-0.13494747877120972,
-0.47308415174484253,
0.2187609076499939,
0.3694756329059601,
0.9504451155662537,
0.036407504230737686,
-0.15078529715538025,
0.025977717712521553,
0.17621764540672302,
-0.09913717210292816,
0.19664376974105835,
-0.1729220151901245,
-0.6470109224319458,
-0.43787944316864014,
-0.7606311440467834,
-0.17891961336135864,
0.013975432142615318,
-0.44633373618125916,
0.22684384882450104,
0.0835537537932396,
0.03710644319653511,
-0.02356920763850212,
0.16658492386341095,
-0.891189694404602,
0.024722373113036156,
0.2700725495815277,
0.7649928331375122,
-0.2833198606967926,
0.8547847867012024,
0.6388853788375854,
-0.18641740083694458,
-0.37312787771224976,
-0.2642178237438202,
-0.15247203409671783,
-0.8464204668998718,
0.8079956769943237,
0.18862831592559814,
-0.20221424102783203,
0.12073566764593124,
-0.11245670169591904,
-0.8115019202232361,
1.3889031410217285,
0.370525598526001,
-0.6662598848342896,
-0.24024446308612823,
0.43529942631721497,
0.3072895407676697,
-0.2927272915840149,
0.35793760418891907,
0.7069283127784729,
0.46150118112564087,
0.13976062834262848,
-0.8300737738609314,
0.023543745279312134,
-0.015903355553746223,
0.4471723139286041,
0.0482037290930748,
-0.5149499177932739,
0.652766227722168,
-0.06898012012243271,
-0.1609528511762619,
-0.12927916646003723,
0.18260353803634644,
0.20707832276821136,
0.22610363364219666,
0.3336488604545593,
0.6788343191146851,
0.472640722990036,
-0.1768997758626938,
0.8295613527297974,
-0.4635745584964752,
0.38843971490859985,
1.0079853534698486,
-0.689544677734375,
0.7852041125297546,
0.4440120458602905,
-0.10742565989494324,
0.17471668124198914,
0.5689465403556824,
0.14082549512386322,
0.8171654939651489,
0.35284683108329773,
-0.26126548647880554,
-0.32037270069122314,
0.10243471711874008,
-0.09860289096832275,
0.7979113459587097,
0.30889585614204407,
-0.2873081862926483,
-0.5465978980064392,
-0.10317835956811905,
-0.15829862654209137,
0.209138423204422,
-0.03302701190114021,
1.2276742458343506,
0.14499503374099731,
-0.28845202922821045,
0.5812244415283203,
0.09630606323480606,
0.7819201946258545,
-0.39382439851760864,
-0.11333704739809036,
-0.38023704290390015,
0.4749319553375244,
-0.08676158636808395,
-0.8576883673667908,
0.34452658891677856,
-0.12986432015895844,
-0.40951985120773315,
-0.25724563002586365,
0.9066181182861328,
-0.8583303093910217,
-0.40004366636276245,
0.9240596294403076,
0.5151128768920898,
0.2567627429962158,
-0.2255936712026596,
-0.7002903819084167,
0.3623296618461609,
-0.1571429967880249,
-0.264173686504364,
0.48534032702445984,
0.5008928775787354,
0.22651872038841248,
0.4944317042827606,
0.43628278374671936,
-0.20315277576446533,
0.10527647286653519,
-0.030687961727380753,
0.9985072016716003,
-0.6897714734077454,
-0.045828916132450104,
-1.0244901180267334,
0.3103618025779724,
-0.14903141558170319,
0.3612179458141327,
0.48924973607063293,
0.8413020968437195,
0.8656753897666931,
0.0004353894619271159,
0.7095494270324707,
0.13749438524246216,
0.41668176651000977,
-0.5652772784233093,
0.7445117831230164,
-0.5932808518409729,
0.2544765770435333,
0.31238994002342224,
-1.0315321683883667,
-0.18944577872753143,
0.46978798508644104,
0.10776780545711517,
0.02093750238418579,
0.3112264573574066,
0.8823808431625366,
-0.1406179964542389,
-0.272763192653656,
0.4072761833667755,
0.08845070004463196,
0.26938551664352417,
0.7425552606582642,
0.7108466625213623,
-0.45518743991851807,
0.5120272040367126,
-0.1887955367565155,
-0.29127734899520874,
-0.5125494003295898,
-0.5965251326560974,
-0.8387196660041809,
-0.3250182867050171,
-0.37774062156677246,
0.07563188672065735,
0.04778981953859329,
0.6946752071380615,
0.5735374093055725,
-0.38382723927497864,
-0.0657062903046608,
-0.024732481688261032,
0.21490685641765594,
-0.013305403292179108,
-0.17415091395378113,
0.24704083800315857,
-0.543084979057312,
-0.9590341448783875,
0.6439670324325562,
0.5313429832458496,
-0.0873890072107315,
-0.42869749665260315,
-0.1392606496810913,
-0.27368709444999695,
0.10287134349346161,
0.9296755790710449,
-0.4152665436267853,
-0.7948541641235352,
-0.0954277366399765,
0.14196690917015076,
-0.29530513286590576,
-0.23660504817962646,
0.5604709386825562,
-0.7779437899589539,
0.5083194971084595,
0.6116398572921753,
0.8366438150405884,
0.8841038346290588,
-0.15950827300548553,
0.42160308361053467,
-0.6262245178222656,
0.17556841671466827,
0.3302050232887268,
0.33683860301971436,
0.24785122275352478,
-0.34412217140197754,
0.6336727738380432,
0.19669978320598602,
-0.33989834785461426,
-0.7036979794502258,
0.17889748513698578,
-1.0712531805038452,
-0.4923781156539917,
1.2565257549285889,
-0.19359707832336426,
-0.22162139415740967,
-0.14672717452049255,
-0.07939434796571732,
0.30197590589523315,
-0.1092221662402153,
0.6667643189430237,
0.4933456778526306,
0.022248469293117523,
0.029406871646642685,
-0.3247242569923401,
0.28305041790008545,
0.23972196877002716,
-0.37090378999710083,
0.17685723304748535,
0.4006211757659912,
0.33297786116600037,
-0.0014379438944160938,
0.11774004995822906,
-0.4447212219238281,
0.036818649619817734,
0.14559045433998108,
0.10970193147659302,
-0.3337569832801819,
-0.12185584753751755,
-0.14092855155467987,
0.01034992653876543,
0.0572163350880146,
-0.287092924118042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17261v1 | TRAWL: Tensor Reduced and Approximated Weights for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T04:01:32 | 2024-06-25T04:01:32 | Yiran Luo, Het Patel, Yu Fu, Dawon Ahn, Jia Chen, Yue Dong, Evangelos E. Papalexakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 (Primary), 65F55 (Secondary), I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have fundamentally transformed artificial
intelligence, catalyzing recent advancements while imposing substantial
environmental and computational burdens. We introduce TRAWL (Tensor Reduced and
Approximated Weights for Large Language Models), a novel methodology for
optimizing LLMs through tensor decomposition. TRAWL leverages diverse
strategies to exploit matrices within transformer-based architectures,
realizing notable performance enhancements without necessitating retraining.
The most significant improvements were observed through a layer-by-layer
intervention strategy, particularly when applied to fully connected weights of
the final layers, yielding up to 16% enhancement in accuracy without the need
for additional data or fine-tuning. These results underscore the importance of
targeted and adaptive techniques in increasing the efficiency and effectiveness
of large language model optimization, thereby promoting the development of more
sustainable and accessible AI systems. | [
-0.26262518763542175,
-0.8164451122283936,
0.2836340069770813,
0.16196107864379883,
-0.19438761472702026,
0.6352705955505371,
-0.4317687451839447,
-0.207368865609169,
0.13324373960494995,
0.3170197010040283,
-0.5958550572395325,
-0.45435279607772827,
-0.5606145262718201,
-0.20415455102920532,
-0.528782308101654,
0.5970229506492615,
0.07118503004312515,
0.03373587131500244,
-0.012048753909766674,
-0.31929025053977966,
-0.35996752977371216,
-0.35630980134010315,
-0.8768717050552368,
-0.5172616243362427,
0.527725100517273,
0.057836420834064484,
0.7902462482452393,
0.9107213020324707,
0.716244101524353,
0.4086548686027527,
-0.14432421326637268,
0.2730817496776581,
-0.7459517121315002,
0.14943908154964447,
0.038163114339113235,
-0.7435824871063232,
-0.5372676253318787,
-0.04813195765018463,
0.8734843134880066,
0.9213739633560181,
-0.18564651906490326,
0.5602923631668091,
0.08792439848184586,
0.8089699149131775,
-0.8746934533119202,
0.24581797420978546,
-0.31776854395866394,
0.2901148200035095,
-0.18800482153892517,
-0.3491097688674927,
-0.6838050484657288,
-0.309987872838974,
0.12632101774215698,
-0.4919745624065399,
0.09908030927181244,
-0.06448439508676529,
0.3039343059062958,
0.47204092144966125,
-0.30905789136886597,
0.01308014988899231,
-0.9998675584793091,
1.182860016822815,
-0.8333024382591248,
0.5726852416992188,
-0.15440383553504944,
0.1939740777015686,
-0.21286910772323608,
-1.0962671041488647,
-0.31669217348098755,
-0.2599851191043854,
0.023483477532863617,
-0.009720739908516407,
-0.5668290257453918,
0.30670177936553955,
0.18907210230827332,
0.031387001276016235,
-0.5267156362533569,
0.067874975502491,
-0.3929598331451416,
-0.004654367454349995,
0.7027800679206848,
0.1648014783859253,
0.37403085827827454,
0.30699747800827026,
-0.015666142106056213,
-0.4493381977081299,
-0.6987394690513611,
-0.06490111351013184,
0.1387035846710205,
0.17472988367080688,
-0.04995814338326454,
0.5424750447273254,
0.2558889389038086,
0.47835400700569153,
-0.24015852808952332,
-0.2181190699338913,
0.1850019097328186,
0.2716086506843567,
-0.3510671555995941,
0.048190824687480927,
0.5090453028678894,
0.3305550217628479,
0.29184776544570923,
-0.21507591009140015,
-0.305522620677948,
0.24617385864257812,
0.34104591608047485,
-0.5779422521591187,
-0.21976859867572784,
0.23895563185214996,
-0.5412489771842957,
-0.5183734893798828,
-0.36412715911865234,
-0.6478081345558167,
-0.26396554708480835,
-0.2111695557832718,
0.39768487215042114,
-0.24034178256988525,
-0.23181329667568207,
0.026960959658026695,
-0.16701780259609222,
0.3830442428588867,
0.23035097122192383,
-0.4469161629676819,
0.35033485293388367,
0.8433535099029541,
1.101337194442749,
-0.20185261964797974,
-0.18113961815834045,
-0.6259839534759521,
0.44314977526664734,
-0.6273680925369263,
0.39377766847610474,
-0.6833443641662598,
-0.29063981771469116,
-0.06880645453929901,
-0.491067498922348,
-0.1058977022767067,
-0.5043113827705383,
0.4472090005874634,
-0.6909599900245667,
0.169425368309021,
0.26568564772605896,
-0.3585982918739319,
-0.3352082371711731,
0.20777484774589539,
-0.9957574009895325,
1.0816385746002197,
0.35397544503211975,
-0.5015220642089844,
-0.16558559238910675,
-1.2017464637756348,
-0.6801162958145142,
0.008417179808020592,
0.627655565738678,
-0.5133218169212341,
0.4765916168689728,
0.26795825362205505,
0.4214532971382141,
-0.4896474778652191,
0.2294108271598816,
-0.3918800354003906,
-0.48286718130111694,
0.021233398467302322,
-0.2863602042198181,
0.6546791195869446,
0.3457811772823334,
-0.4000430405139923,
0.2975026071071625,
-0.6445338726043701,
0.27896779775619507,
0.1974380761384964,
-0.47080451250076294,
-0.4078410863876343,
0.2671779990196228,
0.029524540528655052,
-0.04070596396923065,
0.1210361197590828,
-0.23060794174671173,
0.12054010480642319,
-0.5934029817581177,
1.043251872062683,
0.8645181655883789,
-0.38433122634887695,
0.5735390782356262,
-0.2653571665287018,
0.7023792266845703,
-0.1607828289270401,
0.058135174214839935,
0.2533130347728729,
0.08959418535232544,
-0.92414391040802,
-0.3880898058414459,
0.2541198134422302,
0.30980807542800903,
-0.8365868926048279,
0.12239130586385727,
-0.7589842081069946,
-0.6011451482772827,
-0.7615975737571716,
-0.019656436517834663,
0.39230674505233765,
0.31459492444992065,
0.42299002408981323,
-0.04449994117021561,
-0.8519309759140015,
-0.8085423707962036,
-0.44487935304641724,
-0.31334683299064636,
-0.14307330548763275,
-0.00791875459253788,
0.2528461813926697,
-0.18046268820762634,
0.6726300120353699,
-0.5081509351730347,
-0.13430455327033997,
-0.5487470030784607,
0.18072083592414856,
0.05870131030678749,
0.4291927218437195,
0.5527045726776123,
-0.6810722947120667,
-0.32955172657966614,
-0.04827683046460152,
-0.6810726523399353,
0.0022025322541594505,
-0.014146602712571621,
-0.0427040196955204,
0.18078310787677765,
0.5813537836074829,
-0.8444137573242188,
0.24707898497581482,
0.593174159526825,
0.08247312903404236,
0.3029950261116028,
-0.22295893728733063,
-0.3095875680446625,
-0.8454726338386536,
0.07174117863178253,
0.02337159775197506,
-0.42415282130241394,
-0.9545516967773438,
0.5968953371047974,
-0.06018751487135887,
-0.08482357114553452,
-0.43315503001213074,
0.41794252395629883,
-0.529991090297699,
-0.1830212026834488,
-0.12998844683170319,
-0.029512599110603333,
-0.12394333630800247,
0.5559546947479248,
-0.12129723280668259,
0.9776027202606201,
0.40771523118019104,
-0.44684508442878723,
0.45226991176605225,
0.06881896406412125,
-0.20822584629058838,
0.37130436301231384,
-0.7573082447052002,
0.3607078194618225,
-0.41511040925979614,
0.24129074811935425,
-0.7909498810768127,
0.2057657539844513,
-0.03911919519305229,
-0.13533079624176025,
0.28701138496398926,
0.007480007596313953,
-0.17594550549983978,
-0.5504924058914185,
-0.8432117700576782,
0.5495108366012573,
0.5910636186599731,
-0.5254819989204407,
1.2316961288452148,
0.4909413456916809,
0.061829157173633575,
-0.6441468596458435,
-0.8514617085456848,
0.3160356879234314,
-0.5232712626457214,
-0.6033636927604675,
0.35147199034690857,
-0.1949750930070877,
-0.40795642137527466,
-0.11803924292325974,
0.03235310688614845,
0.19450350105762482,
0.27596476674079895,
-0.16820688545703888,
0.07138503342866898,
-0.6125282645225525,
0.024086058139801025,
-0.1455068588256836,
-0.05304458364844322,
0.12799538671970367,
-0.6760408282279968,
0.9983841180801392,
-0.22368137538433075,
-0.024772483855485916,
-0.25683116912841797,
0.2416340857744217,
0.8221999406814575,
-0.4432649314403534,
0.6928675770759583,
0.8368824124336243,
-0.20104970037937164,
-0.4835038483142853,
-0.4559776782989502,
0.11610813438892365,
-0.5679553747177124,
0.7805342078208923,
-0.3386511206626892,
-0.8615031838417053,
0.3989625573158264,
-0.1700165569782257,
0.17875750362873077,
0.34079569578170776,
0.6659038662910461,
-0.16513067483901978,
1.3365689516067505,
0.6537768244743347,
-0.44637733697891235,
0.5277052521705627,
-0.49082088470458984,
0.39062628149986267,
-0.9627431035041809,
-0.12263219803571701,
-0.3654252290725708,
-0.8437994122505188,
-0.6987168788909912,
-0.438539057970047,
0.4576575756072998,
-0.3430325984954834,
-0.41476449370384216,
0.2746289372444153,
-0.49620321393013,
0.4459482729434967,
0.7421786785125732,
0.2825383245944977,
0.07845837622880936,
-0.04445643350481987,
0.1065981537103653,
0.15317286550998688,
-0.7736369967460632,
-0.30470725893974304,
1.1256376504898071,
0.47323253750801086,
0.6428149938583374,
0.2220642864704132,
0.49951598048210144,
0.7055147886276245,
0.2694173753261566,
-0.9494292140007019,
0.7244612574577332,
-0.14597143232822418,
-0.1484600454568863,
-0.4047495126724243,
-0.6861253380775452,
-0.9686762094497681,
0.3251464366912842,
-0.08972208201885223,
-0.48178571462631226,
-0.34266233444213867,
-0.05898674950003624,
0.04339273273944855,
0.5630000233650208,
-0.8751583695411682,
0.36401262879371643,
-0.1405736356973648,
-0.24626484513282776,
-0.6627047657966614,
-0.4677475094795227,
0.3089938163757324,
-0.16084067523479462,
0.19435065984725952,
0.06867382675409317,
-0.2847239375114441,
0.9176203012466431,
-0.5691107511520386,
0.5088129639625549,
-0.36950185894966125,
-0.09518036991357803,
-0.030673997476696968,
0.3259061574935913,
0.8374913930892944,
-0.27516883611679077,
-0.2232225388288498,
0.022361431270837784,
-0.10988812893629074,
-0.4849584400653839,
-0.7749007344245911,
0.5535948276519775,
-1.0426212549209595,
-0.7405137419700623,
-0.031857118010520935,
-1.0140867233276367,
-0.21746665239334106,
0.20426416397094727,
-0.28807851672172546,
0.4879970848560333,
-0.14094938337802887,
0.3645688593387604,
0.5321498513221741,
-0.2244952917098999,
0.7803220152854919,
0.20777639746665955,
0.1303233653306961,
-0.45936319231987,
0.678901731967926,
0.036931946873664856,
0.06510694324970245,
0.6030446290969849,
0.15297050774097443,
-0.3781419098377228,
-0.856418788433075,
-0.031171757727861404,
0.23309731483459473,
-0.7108646035194397,
-0.29667481780052185,
-0.5014147162437439,
-0.2543639540672302,
-0.23520532250404358,
-0.2836821973323822,
-0.44475510716438293,
-0.5167731046676636,
-0.15985628962516785,
-0.16513371467590332,
0.12314612418413162,
0.7242031097412109,
0.21582730114459991,
0.6571052074432373,
-0.6567500233650208,
0.190423384308815,
-0.011238127015531063,
0.37795883417129517,
0.3334909677505493,
-0.3819097876548767,
-0.2791537344455719,
0.2081533670425415,
0.0515870563685894,
-0.18304547667503357,
0.6775349378585815,
0.5485597848892212,
0.4508281648159027,
0.1386488825082779,
0.05862078443169594,
0.9596397876739502,
-0.5247872471809387,
0.5551331639289856,
0.055262647569179535,
-1.1704167127609253,
0.24626880884170532,
-0.11553171277046204,
0.45128899812698364,
0.17900288105010986,
0.13735760748386383,
-0.4504150450229645,
-0.4700166881084442,
-0.4736998975276947,
-0.8423050045967102,
0.6018317937850952,
0.18077532947063446,
0.3378956913948059,
0.43747618794441223,
0.2365500032901764,
-0.40191295742988586,
0.1379542350769043,
-0.6750240325927734,
-0.3146035671234131,
0.11973612755537033,
-0.5656014084815979,
-0.10733772814273834,
-0.3274647295475006,
-0.006146257743239403,
-0.3213448226451874,
0.7844730615615845,
-0.22437778115272522,
0.29904472827911377,
-0.2421247363090515,
-0.6393114924430847,
-0.16065020859241486,
-0.0636739507317543,
0.8147109150886536,
0.7736650705337524,
-0.0029485851991921663,
0.40931975841522217,
0.49656909704208374,
-0.7512679100036621,
0.30490878224372864,
-0.34082457423210144,
-0.09869696199893951,
-0.23227398097515106,
0.7571861147880554,
0.6798551082611084,
0.24819545447826385,
-0.6284885406494141,
0.16086377203464508,
-0.14280956983566284,
-0.04792158305644989,
-0.28520140051841736,
0.13215689361095428,
0.07733877748250961,
0.621436357498169,
0.5358890891075134,
0.09984546154737473,
-0.13161496818065643,
-0.18467575311660767,
0.22007282078266144,
0.6254360675811768,
-0.24539914727210999,
-0.40337708592414856,
0.640562117099762,
0.004164054524153471,
-0.41620194911956787,
0.6132074594497681,
0.353861927986145,
-0.5983058214187622,
0.3229202926158905,
0.6441273093223572,
0.8897626399993896,
-0.41565194725990295,
0.16303159296512604,
0.12128560245037079,
0.4554126560688019,
-0.0500296950340271,
-0.059683363884687424,
0.11756870895624161,
-0.7135844826698303,
-0.6225054860115051,
-0.6168237328529358,
-0.1828901320695877,
0.10026559978723526,
-0.43515682220458984,
0.3194412887096405,
-0.8368382453918457,
-0.10798249393701553,
0.003658382222056389,
0.24094253778457642,
-0.501305103302002,
0.021629102528095245,
0.22178952395915985,
0.8740422129631042,
-0.5971038341522217,
0.872040331363678,
0.7152788043022156,
-0.11831223219633102,
-0.9081389307975769,
-0.26025599241256714,
-0.1356494426727295,
-1.0112966299057007,
0.5725398063659668,
-0.09001117199659348,
-0.36137744784355164,
0.4896329343318939,
-0.5713561773300171,
-1.0586292743682861,
1.141282081604004,
0.8495011329650879,
-0.22706472873687744,
-0.3198884129524231,
0.6723264455795288,
0.5293974280357361,
-0.31328868865966797,
0.5496169328689575,
0.8140383958816528,
0.5969355702400208,
0.14370951056480408,
-0.6974327564239502,
-0.04754088446497917,
-0.38268300890922546,
0.4964718520641327,
0.45993688702583313,
-0.654406726360321,
0.7500697374343872,
-0.0332520417869091,
-0.1692967414855957,
-0.1766040176153183,
0.8501485586166382,
0.019657202064990997,
-0.11780404299497604,
0.5476370453834534,
0.467835009098053,
0.9069682955741882,
0.015362709760665894,
0.8103806376457214,
-0.2969413101673126,
0.39830872416496277,
0.5594653487205505,
-0.36257484555244446,
0.8072410225868225,
0.5299234390258789,
-0.29386427998542786,
0.5035139918327332,
0.32286912202835083,
-0.03754165396094322,
0.43300026655197144,
0.13931088149547577,
-0.2091335505247116,
-0.15690045058727264,
-0.16354799270629883,
-0.017853934317827225,
0.7002393007278442,
0.29058295488357544,
-0.14078083634376526,
-0.32858821749687195,
0.15605641901493073,
0.11658793687820435,
-0.053971562534570694,
-0.5633644461631775,
0.6883348822593689,
0.054572366178035736,
-0.36554154753685,
0.9010204672813416,
0.3263922929763794,
0.6794829368591309,
-0.4927467703819275,
0.07384287565946579,
-0.2750857174396515,
0.4677082300186157,
-0.21201972663402557,
-0.5294035077095032,
0.3528057038784027,
-0.05736956372857094,
0.08535170555114746,
-0.25836798548698425,
0.8029991388320923,
-0.45262041687965393,
-0.6179060935974121,
0.40251877903938293,
0.3739665746688843,
-0.21317942440509796,
-0.004848604556173086,
-0.6066034436225891,
0.11070407927036285,
-0.021622823551297188,
-0.45135465264320374,
0.06855649501085281,
0.12815482914447784,
-0.1940443515777588,
1.2600330114364624,
0.8070754408836365,
0.26149776577949524,
0.08430655300617218,
-0.11434069275856018,
1.0633950233459473,
-0.5865853428840637,
-0.38631799817085266,
-1.0546234846115112,
0.4249257445335388,
0.11890992522239685,
0.17825917899608612,
0.5020245909690857,
0.6373652219772339,
0.8019927740097046,
-0.18018411099910736,
0.6921742558479309,
0.07920755445957184,
0.2873777747154236,
-0.6006758809089661,
0.9024855494499207,
-0.5202693343162537,
0.4191022515296936,
-0.18926644325256348,
-1.193292498588562,
-0.685581624507904,
0.4377460777759552,
-0.20017322897911072,
0.0875018760561943,
0.6812801957130432,
0.8595452308654785,
-0.18385174870491028,
-0.06214611232280731,
0.4152515232563019,
0.3504030704498291,
0.566577136516571,
0.6504743695259094,
0.8600645661354065,
-0.39255857467651367,
0.5344299077987671,
-0.18482083082199097,
0.0568573996424675,
-0.07004326581954956,
-0.8348214626312256,
-1.035483479499817,
-0.4637283682823181,
-0.3234722912311554,
-0.07796451449394226,
0.17449083924293518,
1.1998012065887451,
0.686540961265564,
-0.8211690783500671,
-0.547141969203949,
0.041262444108724594,
0.1258632391691208,
-0.22414323687553406,
-0.21132045984268188,
0.5147667527198792,
-0.2765823304653168,
-0.7056854367256165,
0.49425989389419556,
0.3094598352909088,
-0.33711203932762146,
-0.37695586681365967,
-0.19417865574359894,
-0.19170789420604706,
0.06962210685014725,
0.9134936928749084,
-0.06743723899126053,
-0.4451373517513275,
-0.5356554985046387,
0.05940205976366997,
0.025948740541934967,
0.19644296169281006,
0.8071136474609375,
-0.9268245697021484,
0.011747287586331367,
0.48210304975509644,
0.7407735586166382,
0.680508017539978,
-0.11545385420322418,
0.8827563524246216,
-0.86107337474823,
0.3377586305141449,
0.4445696771144867,
0.2987162172794342,
0.20827218890190125,
-0.1218743547797203,
0.7170801162719727,
0.08726203441619873,
-0.0870082825422287,
-1.1236120462417603,
0.01135749276727438,
-0.7463420033454895,
-0.13128811120986938,
0.8996923565864563,
-0.07715725153684616,
-0.669938862323761,
0.1734662652015686,
0.13296149671077728,
0.3985213339328766,
-0.08828893303871155,
0.7392255067825317,
0.3217433989048004,
0.3121412694454193,
-0.5970520973205566,
-0.3413800001144409,
0.26603788137435913,
0.5472735166549683,
-0.6528458595275879,
0.15027496218681335,
0.1744270771741867,
0.07901787012815475,
0.015019417740404606,
0.06498054414987564,
0.07930813729763031,
-0.009323081001639366,
-0.3815281093120575,
0.08852168917655945,
-0.24400638043880463,
-0.2460954785346985,
-0.29375332593917847,
0.3697953522205353,
0.12598401308059692,
0.12687672674655914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17260v1 | Mitigating Hallucination in Fictional Character Role-Play | 2024-06-25T03:56:33 | 2024-06-25T03:56:33 | Nafis Sadeq, Zhouhang Xie, Byungkyu Kang, Prarit Lamba, Xiang Gao, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Role-playing has wide-ranging applications in customer support, embodied
agents, computational social science, etc. The influence of parametric world
knowledge of large language models (LLMs) often causes role-playing characters
to act out of character and hallucinate about things outside the scope of their
knowledge. In this work, we focus on the evaluation and mitigation of
hallucination in fictional character role-play. We introduce a dataset with
more than 2,000 characters and 72,000 interviews, including 18,000 adversarial
questions. We propose RoleFact, a role-playing method that mitigates
hallucination by modulating the influence of parametric knowledge using a
pre-calibrated confidence threshold. Experiments show that the proposed method
improves the factual precision of generated responses by 18% for adversarial
questions with a 44% reduction in temporal hallucination for time-sensitive
interviews. The code and the dataset will be available at
https://github.com/NafisSadeq/rolefact.git. | [
-0.4666302502155304,
-0.9775478839874268,
0.4490709900856018,
0.32409927248954773,
0.09498147666454315,
-0.06280148029327393,
-0.0956922248005867,
-0.4747755527496338,
0.5067769885063171,
0.8393571972846985,
-0.6359066963195801,
-0.3412250280380249,
-0.27434706687927246,
0.011135673150420189,
-0.13939517736434937,
0.8570693135261536,
0.22699587047100067,
0.1357613056898117,
-0.4657301604747772,
0.08839471638202667,
-0.4477059841156006,
-0.7093307375907898,
-0.805790364742279,
-0.2913810908794403,
0.5856330990791321,
0.1907660961151123,
0.9377129673957825,
0.09878018498420715,
0.2975880205631256,
0.22371511161327362,
0.28303468227386475,
0.39158639311790466,
-0.8450878262519836,
0.5866326689720154,
-0.03515198826789856,
-0.6809672117233276,
-0.30933094024658203,
0.010337285697460175,
0.5340173840522766,
0.49923259019851685,
-0.054911959916353226,
-0.028605032712221146,
0.027246203273534775,
0.2511250376701355,
-0.5945565104484558,
0.390421062707901,
-0.4780954122543335,
0.2227226048707962,
0.08077652007341385,
-0.5460475087165833,
-0.4141576290130615,
-0.3249659538269043,
-0.19443343579769135,
-0.821929395198822,
0.5236506462097168,
0.016469452530145645,
0.6280675530433655,
0.4830920994281769,
-0.14910945296287537,
-0.2307576835155487,
-0.8973293900489807,
0.5066887736320496,
-0.5735226273536682,
0.09127575159072876,
0.915921151638031,
0.3751782774925232,
-0.1548755019903183,
-0.07424666732549667,
-0.5829162001609802,
-0.48838070034980774,
-0.1940123438835144,
-0.020150909200310707,
0.22338104248046875,
0.055030226707458496,
0.7393542528152466,
0.08124123513698578,
-0.6559514999389648,
-0.13309644162654877,
-0.25063955783843994,
-0.3257320523262024,
0.5552319288253784,
0.12273897230625153,
0.26372793316841125,
-0.12535777688026428,
-0.03689821809530258,
-0.22506366670131683,
-0.6546019315719604,
-0.029480574652552605,
0.46687451004981995,
0.02815086767077446,
0.4524034261703491,
0.6544132232666016,
-0.04624057561159134,
0.13217514753341675,
0.15117065608501434,
0.11759161949157715,
-0.06683827191591263,
0.08609883487224579,
-0.07693523168563843,
0.28753724694252014,
0.35197556018829346,
0.35611647367477417,
0.4448927938938141,
-0.3576517105102539,
-0.045125361531972885,
0.3837306797504425,
0.5890343189239502,
-0.7859399914741516,
-0.12395758926868439,
0.15453557670116425,
-0.17736203968524933,
-0.357437402009964,
0.0689932107925415,
-0.8811211585998535,
-1.0927127599716187,
-0.0977293998003006,
0.7258310914039612,
-0.5876857042312622,
-0.10997992753982544,
-0.010517417453229427,
-0.09496337920427322,
0.1828845888376236,
0.2561675012111664,
-0.6303241848945618,
0.3766396939754486,
0.5741931200027466,
0.6570255160331726,
-0.0057565877214074135,
-0.39351552724838257,
-0.9629444479942322,
0.18324629962444305,
-0.6077137589454651,
0.5666471719741821,
-0.40022704005241394,
-0.4519491493701935,
-0.18801571428775787,
0.08383308351039886,
-0.1469413936138153,
-0.6631524562835693,
0.411090224981308,
-0.46281275153160095,
-0.03393522650003433,
-0.468061625957489,
-0.30969637632369995,
-0.03675783425569534,
0.42528364062309265,
-0.9281977415084839,
0.769515872001648,
-0.1763230413198471,
-0.4553263783454895,
0.32654452323913574,
-0.42088592052459717,
-0.6543765664100647,
0.10221133381128311,
-0.37405163049697876,
-0.3175993263721466,
0.16188637912273407,
0.34218305349349976,
0.43759456276893616,
-0.19744575023651123,
0.26875072717666626,
-0.3970741033554077,
-0.8229339122772217,
0.5282495021820068,
-0.4598548710346222,
0.5176194310188293,
-0.04133662208914757,
-0.5691631436347961,
-0.1388619989156723,
-0.4298969805240631,
-0.23243273794651031,
0.011415581218898296,
0.34581226110458374,
-0.4404125511646271,
-0.013019194826483727,
-0.12247595191001892,
0.2455880045890808,
-0.1494177281856537,
-0.24700550734996796,
-0.06301511824131012,
-0.335983008146286,
-0.08372747898101807,
0.5138657689094543,
0.3779006600379944,
0.12396499514579773,
-0.7445036768913269,
0.771481454372406,
-0.27296438813209534,
0.1744886040687561,
0.1633860468864441,
-0.28563791513442993,
-0.7126767039299011,
-0.2747322618961334,
0.10419860482215881,
0.4321596920490265,
-1.1983453035354614,
0.5573633313179016,
0.09181159734725952,
-0.4762590229511261,
-0.2823435366153717,
-0.23478026688098907,
0.4153301417827606,
0.4969296157360077,
0.49764177203178406,
-0.07586358487606049,
-0.4933990240097046,
-0.7479484677314758,
-0.34198877215385437,
-0.42600685358047485,
-0.2493765652179718,
0.33378922939300537,
0.37188154458999634,
-0.11231186240911484,
0.6282182335853577,
-0.5787718296051025,
-0.5633114576339722,
-0.06744488328695297,
0.28801894187927246,
-0.25671443343162537,
0.5554407238960266,
0.35757285356521606,
-0.8582188487052917,
-0.1239384338259697,
-0.4847128689289093,
-0.8224718570709229,
-0.12126995623111725,
-0.6098008751869202,
-0.1158570796251297,
0.29683077335357666,
0.7354128360748291,
-0.9929565191268921,
0.6743126511573792,
0.4025545120239258,
-0.5850643515586853,
0.7056189775466919,
-0.1965835988521576,
0.842388391494751,
-0.8173180222511292,
0.3942925035953522,
-0.2423332929611206,
-0.13255377113819122,
-0.5781733989715576,
0.0695340558886528,
-0.24488060176372528,
-0.14475493133068085,
-0.09477559477090836,
0.42062416672706604,
-0.3457775413990021,
-0.04069886729121208,
-0.04548317939043045,
0.17932206392288208,
0.10614881664514542,
0.48178771138191223,
0.13865074515342712,
0.8995048999786377,
0.2233898937702179,
-0.7237680554389954,
0.15606914460659027,
0.2963580787181854,
-0.44734489917755127,
0.4895826280117035,
-0.5202224254608154,
0.05810825526714325,
-0.0992388129234314,
0.25534945726394653,
-1.0151090621948242,
-0.2248743623495102,
0.3567231595516205,
-0.40551483631134033,
0.15981531143188477,
-0.019673047587275505,
-0.6828400492668152,
-0.037647489458322525,
-0.313972532749176,
0.3971202075481415,
0.3764258623123169,
-0.36562445759773254,
0.6299379467964172,
0.29726555943489075,
-0.10432599484920502,
-0.4464189112186432,
-0.7109426856040955,
0.20507416129112244,
-0.4004940986633301,
-0.5379701852798462,
0.7109798192977905,
-0.6103612780570984,
-0.27162986993789673,
-0.3112824559211731,
-0.30866488814353943,
0.00043291234760545194,
0.08704450726509094,
0.19775106012821198,
0.11072610318660736,
0.05473256856203079,
0.1598336100578308,
0.12560279667377472,
0.051281366497278214,
0.20578879117965698,
0.3158445358276367,
0.7818442583084106,
0.003906161757186055,
-0.4773760735988617,
-0.22601939737796783,
0.34390053153038025,
0.6858077049255371,
0.1423145979642868,
0.7988196611404419,
0.5304474234580994,
-0.5518966317176819,
-0.25382301211357117,
-0.906538724899292,
-0.5755664110183716,
-0.43358829617500305,
0.3787499964237213,
-0.42062556743621826,
-0.628921627998352,
0.8583669066429138,
0.289973646402359,
-0.34161633253097534,
0.22504033148288727,
0.2946106791496277,
0.12593385577201843,
0.921558141708374,
0.08504142612218857,
0.19835758209228516,
0.23343877494335175,
0.0018844259902834892,
0.16398334503173828,
-0.5243768095970154,
-0.2831890285015106,
-0.30367526412010193,
-0.23300965130329132,
-0.4245838224887848,
-0.8012909293174744,
0.3564087450504303,
0.09308252483606339,
-0.03535054251551628,
0.3496035635471344,
0.05301934853196144,
0.5418527126312256,
0.24839189648628235,
0.46966707706451416,
0.25459855794906616,
-0.04505840688943863,
0.0865214541554451,
-0.23229646682739258,
-0.5355568528175354,
-0.33920881152153015,
0.8667198419570923,
0.2273564636707306,
0.754780113697052,
0.342393696308136,
0.676239013671875,
0.5710514187812805,
-0.15018053352832794,
-0.48900702595710754,
0.7497000098228455,
0.07676473259925842,
-0.8060708045959473,
-0.7797510027885437,
-0.5476017594337463,
-0.5873486995697021,
0.061317071318626404,
-0.3816726505756378,
-0.6465930342674255,
0.2997317612171173,
0.1388089805841446,
-0.6072278022766113,
0.08968931436538696,
-0.46440523862838745,
0.6500614285469055,
0.045532163232564926,
-0.5785812735557556,
-0.3033037483692169,
-0.45821166038513184,
0.38672715425491333,
-0.1457599699497223,
-0.08883149176836014,
0.21478162705898285,
0.18138249218463898,
0.5378963351249695,
-0.12294569611549377,
1.1278685331344604,
-0.29035988450050354,
-0.09269183874130249,
0.16797280311584473,
0.6891631484031677,
0.7424337863922119,
0.5852043628692627,
-0.20820212364196777,
0.141752690076828,
0.29679808020591736,
-0.26055338978767395,
-0.9103538393974304,
0.7151157259941101,
-0.49536460638046265,
-0.7780675888061523,
-0.5592551827430725,
-0.8091100454330444,
-0.6248224377632141,
-0.18730594217777252,
0.29268017411231995,
0.26573413610458374,
-0.7814374566078186,
0.4184260368347168,
1.0868905782699585,
-0.41283634305000305,
0.23998114466667175,
0.23623549938201904,
-0.2121419608592987,
-0.3239588737487793,
0.7911164164543152,
0.2079022079706192,
0.22605495154857635,
0.25462302565574646,
0.12739531695842743,
-0.28357958793640137,
-0.05102911591529846,
-0.10415524989366531,
0.29383912682533264,
-0.5798851251602173,
-0.12317319959402084,
-0.6859596371650696,
-0.3692183494567871,
-0.7187577486038208,
-0.04397573694586754,
-0.2370803952217102,
-0.6010460257530212,
-0.38795119524002075,
-0.00462139630690217,
0.1705133616924286,
0.40912002325057983,
-0.00953638181090355,
0.073590949177742,
-0.2711513340473175,
0.5593680143356323,
0.2607276439666748,
0.26479223370552063,
-0.11702283471822739,
-0.4147644639015198,
-0.04183386266231537,
-0.029891058802604675,
0.09459540992975235,
-0.6999340653419495,
0.4454207122325897,
0.1286332607269287,
0.7961888313293457,
0.5047981142997742,
0.4903184473514557,
0.9528025984764099,
-0.28857094049453735,
0.7658705711364746,
-0.07525871694087982,
-0.9640936851501465,
0.14932340383529663,
-0.29372313618659973,
0.09280088543891907,
0.782135546207428,
0.3189185857772827,
-0.726773738861084,
-0.43552520871162415,
-0.5731316804885864,
-0.4192357361316681,
0.6309463381767273,
0.5864124894142151,
-0.02609843946993351,
-0.01142118964344263,
0.3487955629825592,
0.28045886754989624,
0.31678277254104614,
-0.5870499610900879,
0.06070765107870102,
-0.16211849451065063,
0.05875126272439957,
-0.6197463870048523,
-0.3207346796989441,
-0.38486096262931824,
-0.13778795301914215,
0.6859225630760193,
-0.12931567430496216,
0.2607763111591339,
0.40593525767326355,
-0.42938846349716187,
-0.11858218908309937,
-0.08203227072954178,
0.9727822542190552,
0.5721645951271057,
-0.24790996313095093,
0.25571125745773315,
0.1781565546989441,
-0.4987403452396393,
-0.1492394506931305,
0.16646255552768707,
-0.1763615608215332,
-0.14337019622325897,
0.4316524565219879,
0.43121659755706787,
0.31431615352630615,
-0.5958186984062195,
0.37837910652160645,
-0.1290741264820099,
-0.27858904004096985,
-0.39657413959503174,
0.18262021243572235,
-0.16324461996555328,
0.4693625271320343,
0.25160887837409973,
0.020791664719581604,
0.21731582283973694,
-0.5439878106117249,
0.49169737100601196,
0.3267599940299988,
-0.3284657299518585,
-0.09286651760339737,
0.5769641995429993,
-0.0644536167383194,
-0.43716251850128174,
0.39381375908851624,
-0.12209776043891907,
-0.5019175410270691,
0.8916486501693726,
0.6643936038017273,
0.8408677577972412,
-0.4393216669559479,
0.6322794556617737,
0.17139193415641785,
0.5158630013465881,
-0.18050843477249146,
0.17550362646579742,
0.10783413052558899,
-0.5969725847244263,
-0.11771832406520844,
-0.3297805190086365,
-0.3085760772228241,
0.3650454878807068,
-0.44677022099494934,
0.3091130554676056,
-0.5281060934066772,
-0.0577019602060318,
-0.44428786635398865,
0.1544303447008133,
-0.5403838753700256,
0.0468115471303463,
0.02654079720377922,
0.38835203647613525,
-0.8867545127868652,
0.5595088005065918,
0.09421572089195251,
-0.5628430247306824,
-0.3073800206184387,
0.763588011264801,
-0.18462428450584412,
-0.5170804262161255,
0.5082006454467773,
0.2541987895965576,
-0.24747219681739807,
0.00010956956975860521,
-0.2257910966873169,
-0.564862072467804,
1.0724527835845947,
0.38215047121047974,
-0.28318604826927185,
-0.1898246556520462,
0.3284396529197693,
0.6248847246170044,
-0.46189209818840027,
0.25518131256103516,
0.4254016876220703,
0.42521461844444275,
0.16875427961349487,
-0.5128628611564636,
0.4255220592021942,
-0.27267733216285706,
0.01805817149579525,
-0.26521602272987366,
-0.48815903067588806,
0.5881887078285217,
-0.021262886002659798,
-0.008272906765341759,
0.13817709684371948,
0.5524728298187256,
0.5375449061393738,
0.3208148181438446,
0.8866320848464966,
-0.0645451694726944,
0.8522790670394897,
0.2889506220817566,
0.602433979511261,
-0.34031444787979126,
0.04421190544962883,
1.0480363368988037,
-0.4493056535720825,
0.3263067305088043,
0.7216116786003113,
0.3528853952884674,
0.23591092228889465,
0.5123370289802551,
-0.12043624371290207,
0.4349740147590637,
0.40842658281326294,
-0.2896265685558319,
-0.5832877159118652,
0.03821639344096184,
-0.3232211470603943,
0.3466210961341858,
0.41198477149009705,
-0.08522054553031921,
-0.005923173855990171,
0.2134450078010559,
-0.036271918565034866,
0.2292560189962387,
0.057927004992961884,
0.36660125851631165,
-0.08222363144159317,
-0.8754961490631104,
0.45445480942726135,
-0.29345476627349854,
0.3080425262451172,
-0.6327204704284668,
-0.4436987042427063,
-0.37202027440071106,
0.13246767222881317,
0.014486275613307953,
-0.21890568733215332,
0.2672989070415497,
-0.21019107103347778,
-0.1539604812860489,
-0.10902221500873566,
0.5780275464057922,
-0.5289697647094727,
-0.5115297436714172,
0.34573090076446533,
0.28077712655067444,
0.23512902855873108,
-0.5198324918746948,
-0.48824334144592285,
-0.029590386897325516,
-0.23346750438213348,
-0.25353583693504333,
0.20087411999702454,
0.4019671678543091,
-0.21166059374809265,
0.4754018783569336,
0.5178123116493225,
0.09540855884552002,
-0.2311207801103592,
0.20869918167591095,
0.7227156162261963,
-0.6310683488845825,
-0.7079600691795349,
-0.5936299562454224,
0.2918742597103119,
-0.26505765318870544,
-0.2254936844110489,
0.7417474985122681,
0.5392389297485352,
0.4847916066646576,
-0.2441248893737793,
0.5381408333778381,
-0.054514240473508835,
0.23358778655529022,
-0.6952670216560364,
1.2449270486831665,
-0.4593663215637207,
0.6042112112045288,
-0.5496478080749512,
-0.8977715969085693,
-0.470589816570282,
0.6750064492225647,
-0.2561582028865814,
0.1886778473854065,
0.848295271396637,
1.2410569190979004,
0.08097205311059952,
0.055817294865846634,
0.932502806186676,
0.15352720022201538,
0.346807599067688,
0.38541480898857117,
0.8736745715141296,
-0.4312286078929901,
0.5446757078170776,
-0.2626052796840668,
-0.3093859553337097,
-0.3424518406391144,
-0.7706955075263977,
-1.3989391326904297,
-0.6479164958000183,
-0.34032580256462097,
-0.8296668529510498,
0.30604445934295654,
0.8022289872169495,
0.5240169763565063,
-0.6898126006126404,
-0.23364655673503876,
-0.08245930075645447,
-0.03970544785261154,
-0.5528939962387085,
-0.2548273503780365,
0.26434120535850525,
-0.3789014518260956,
-0.5232638716697693,
0.6270140409469604,
-0.22268863022327423,
-0.1993282288312912,
-0.48820799589157104,
-0.21774017810821533,
-0.27833640575408936,
0.4847385287284851,
0.48518234491348267,
0.13227605819702148,
-0.6298820376396179,
-0.40425431728363037,
0.37370139360427856,
-0.009705533273518085,
-0.0970621258020401,
1.100137710571289,
-0.743277907371521,
0.34507089853286743,
0.3619246780872345,
0.41693732142448425,
0.561682403087616,
0.07149684429168701,
0.7072925567626953,
-0.7413308024406433,
0.05684344470500946,
0.4336509108543396,
-0.04333018511533737,
0.10831011831760406,
-1.0588421821594238,
0.546015739440918,
0.39141222834587097,
-0.4280613958835602,
-0.8106853365898132,
0.16563758254051208,
-0.7432107329368591,
-0.5346445441246033,
1.1633412837982178,
0.010852097533643246,
-0.12069568783044815,
-0.1469712108373642,
-0.18731583654880524,
0.38689810037612915,
-0.2446434497833252,
1.3077526092529297,
0.9352760910987854,
-0.17779545485973358,
-0.058069877326488495,
-0.49610063433647156,
0.8612906336784363,
0.5129843950271606,
-0.8173826932907104,
0.4079684913158417,
0.6044803261756897,
-0.05645793303847313,
0.14330333471298218,
0.4424667954444885,
-0.08098350465297699,
0.17995555698871613,
0.12680067121982574,
0.17426112294197083,
-0.0758509635925293,
-0.805683970451355,
-0.2520903944969177,
0.21906208992004395,
-0.3291867971420288,
0.17135728895664215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17257v1 | Leveraging Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Multi-Lingual Text-to-Speech Adaptation | 2024-06-25T03:50:54 | 2024-06-25T03:50:54 | Yingting Li, Ambuj Mehrish, Bryan Chew, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Different languages have distinct phonetic systems and vary in their prosodic
features making it challenging to develop a Text-to-Speech (TTS) model that can
effectively synthesise speech in multilingual settings. Furthermore, TTS
architecture needs to be both efficient enough to capture nuances in multiple
languages and efficient enough to be practical for deployment. The standard
approach is to build transformer based model such as SpeechT5 and train it on
large multilingual dataset. As the size of these models grow the conventional
fine-tuning for adapting these model becomes impractical due to heavy
computational cost. In this paper, we proposes to integrate parameter-efficient
transfer learning (PETL) methods such as adapters and hypernetwork with TTS
architecture for multilingual speech synthesis. Notably, in our experiments
PETL methods able to achieve comparable or even better performance compared to
full fine-tuning with only $\sim$2.5\% tunable parameters.The code and samples
are available at: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/multilingualTTS-BA4C. | [
-0.3929550051689148,
-0.36707332730293274,
0.23586271703243256,
0.4472319185733795,
-0.31934747099876404,
0.01907879114151001,
-0.39753270149230957,
-0.3607715666294098,
-0.07934001088142395,
0.25896644592285156,
-0.37705713510513306,
-0.3150193691253662,
-0.33809220790863037,
0.29847294092178345,
0.12845028936862946,
0.9762645363807678,
0.10763012617826462,
-0.015299650840461254,
0.5086984634399414,
-0.2780027389526367,
-0.3622191548347473,
-0.5248644351959229,
-0.6863729953765869,
-0.13792547583580017,
0.5072633624076843,
0.48891204595565796,
0.2670822739601135,
0.46736037731170654,
0.25948041677474976,
0.24111120402812958,
-0.11349986493587494,
0.4126569330692291,
-0.37085673213005066,
0.06247378885746002,
-0.2693038582801819,
-0.27368202805519104,
-0.4029662609100342,
-0.32893502712249756,
0.9286119341850281,
0.5432776212692261,
-0.02766535058617592,
0.044821787625551224,
0.13968347012996674,
0.43141692876815796,
-0.6181432008743286,
0.20068256556987762,
-0.7758893370628357,
0.12243111431598663,
-0.07430396229028702,
-0.20586900413036346,
-0.6714828610420227,
-0.24192304909229279,
0.3384036421775818,
-0.792000949382782,
-0.04597337171435356,
-0.07405079156160355,
0.4115349054336548,
0.005049902480095625,
-0.4220541715621948,
-0.15600889921188354,
-0.8975130319595337,
0.8045279383659363,
-0.626376211643219,
0.9921404719352722,
0.28071391582489014,
0.2504328489303589,
0.05843507871031761,
-0.7307306528091431,
-0.3509882390499115,
-0.253930926322937,
-0.009175333194434643,
0.12660875916481018,
-0.003958546556532383,
-0.060297440737485886,
-0.02987316995859146,
-0.10592808574438095,
-0.7290530800819397,
0.1287965327501297,
-0.33138012886047363,
-0.4488363265991211,
0.2699390947818756,
-0.21699748933315277,
0.04328998178243637,
-0.038209784775972366,
-0.43383222818374634,
-0.3698045313358307,
-0.40895283222198486,
-0.02628757432103157,
0.28332021832466125,
0.8079199194908142,
-0.31529510021209717,
-0.15880616009235382,
0.28303372859954834,
0.6724880337715149,
0.18202947080135345,
-0.21788005530834198,
0.3620299696922302,
-0.5325354337692261,
0.07317531108856201,
0.2608700096607208,
0.7639445662498474,
-0.10750307142734528,
0.4848034679889679,
-0.2392403483390808,
0.06718339025974274,
-0.4971655011177063,
0.10054299980401993,
-1.1034109592437744,
-0.06701049953699112,
0.03396939858794212,
-0.28007856011390686,
0.04609519615769386,
-0.13471074402332306,
-0.7415246367454529,
-0.06767724454402924,
-0.28989899158477783,
0.40962424874305725,
-0.559424102306366,
-0.39679065346717834,
0.13823841512203217,
0.02291075326502323,
0.209929957985878,
0.08635694533586502,
-0.9954460859298706,
0.1236637681722641,
0.30263274908065796,
0.9912470579147339,
-0.2608996033668518,
-0.7991985082626343,
-0.8815505504608154,
0.446015328168869,
-0.46471989154815674,
0.5183504223823547,
-0.34378692507743835,
-0.4528096914291382,
-0.1758781373500824,
0.1952696591615677,
-0.3495281934738159,
-0.46396127343177795,
0.6107676029205322,
-0.4184172451496124,
0.06304105371236801,
-0.03383046016097069,
-0.1791146695613861,
-0.17288057506084442,
-0.10757358372211456,
-0.6712948083877563,
0.9092234969139099,
-0.12103357166051865,
-0.4811095595359802,
0.058263715356588364,
-0.7169662714004517,
-0.7149841785430908,
-0.08136770874261856,
0.27066144347190857,
-0.4713190495967865,
0.024691957980394363,
0.2541990280151367,
0.5495352149009705,
-0.2307099997997284,
0.29070836305618286,
-0.1251276582479477,
-0.253267377614975,
0.2713516652584076,
-0.6361055970191956,
0.6309292912483215,
0.37617722153663635,
-0.28224319219589233,
0.16600236296653748,
-0.9132854342460632,
0.11046893149614334,
-0.23829346895217896,
-0.5531927347183228,
-0.3274962306022644,
-0.30320364236831665,
0.6389496326446533,
0.14017148315906525,
0.06872797012329102,
-0.3002105951309204,
-0.11441598832607269,
-0.4448166489601135,
0.5708650946617126,
0.6261468529701233,
-0.10419876873493195,
0.46478018164634705,
-0.24601447582244873,
0.32335180044174194,
0.07671144604682922,
0.10065861791372299,
-0.0029515805654227734,
-0.1278710812330246,
-0.4126208424568176,
-0.4220863878726959,
0.6110005974769592,
0.4190824329853058,
-0.7553053498268127,
0.2178288996219635,
-0.3148994743824005,
-0.6551357507705688,
-0.5802863240242004,
-0.1415836364030838,
0.42278531193733215,
0.5004338622093201,
0.4705784022808075,
-0.1297214925289154,
-0.5035951733589172,
-0.6366321444511414,
-0.29370546340942383,
-0.25481584668159485,
-0.09005390107631683,
0.12828552722930908,
0.22929835319519043,
0.17147959768772125,
0.49331769347190857,
-0.08217833191156387,
-0.1318473219871521,
-0.12635289132595062,
0.1443158984184265,
0.021246429532766342,
0.503480076789856,
0.7150041460990906,
-0.8456219434738159,
-0.7306379675865173,
0.42012861371040344,
-0.2861619293689728,
-0.12884964048862457,
-0.23069335520267487,
-0.10192342102527618,
0.15242688357830048,
0.553351104259491,
-0.19882069528102875,
-0.23803944885730743,
0.8052176237106323,
-0.12308523803949356,
0.7433449625968933,
-0.49583593010902405,
0.15783452987670898,
-1.4046144485473633,
0.41097772121429443,
-0.05825391039252281,
-0.34820330142974854,
-1.0728378295898438,
-0.1103530153632164,
0.17639809846878052,
-0.27449384331703186,
-0.8330371975898743,
0.6231411695480347,
-0.4300829768180847,
-0.1001129001379013,
-0.22744490206241608,
-0.04320727661252022,
-0.13310043513774872,
0.6394190788269043,
0.2292642593383789,
1.097938895225525,
0.631598174571991,
-0.6990206837654114,
0.08929209411144257,
0.19372953474521637,
0.07328526675701141,
0.6103213429450989,
-0.4404914975166321,
0.2384282499551773,
0.06886463612318039,
0.286085844039917,
-0.6658872961997986,
0.10400845110416412,
0.19235412776470184,
-0.29488605260849,
0.1459781527519226,
-0.18490499258041382,
-0.17200206220149994,
0.1845441460609436,
-0.30726537108421326,
0.5723336338996887,
0.38440296053886414,
-0.6221500039100647,
0.844463050365448,
0.15240933001041412,
-0.29288482666015625,
-0.41591590642929077,
-0.727702260017395,
0.004982662387192249,
-0.42219746112823486,
-0.23998165130615234,
0.7380965352058411,
-0.2990097999572754,
0.32566511631011963,
-0.14200271666049957,
0.07204671949148178,
-0.27553123235702515,
-0.13299062848091125,
-0.3063158690929413,
-0.08944622427225113,
-0.418195903301239,
0.08306163549423218,
0.05413708835840225,
-0.22137144207954407,
-0.24011313915252686,
-0.5058683753013611,
0.44792020320892334,
-0.21795721352100372,
-0.20088952779769897,
-0.5930315852165222,
0.41531872749328613,
1.099642038345337,
-0.44523316621780396,
0.5023618340492249,
0.9353543519973755,
-0.20000037550926208,
-0.27391552925109863,
-0.14194631576538086,
-0.2742196023464203,
-0.47211959958076477,
0.7190648913383484,
-0.8331040740013123,
-0.66899174451828,
0.6094803810119629,
-0.39620640873908997,
0.00537519808858633,
0.168901726603508,
0.7305728197097778,
0.3766198456287384,
0.8025394678115845,
0.5536545515060425,
-0.124411940574646,
0.6544919610023499,
0.09740977734327316,
0.09849883615970612,
-0.8995315432548523,
0.02118847519159317,
-0.6072754859924316,
-0.08821647614240646,
-0.9530234336853027,
-0.44831299781799316,
0.6893881559371948,
-0.21252010762691498,
-0.2209760993719101,
0.4863647520542145,
-0.3749468922615051,
0.2295985221862793,
0.6573357582092285,
0.11332336813211441,
0.23182325065135956,
0.141824409365654,
-0.21806712448596954,
-0.020111635327339172,
-0.8398094773292542,
-0.12307489663362503,
0.945184051990509,
0.13953524827957153,
0.445429265499115,
0.22169212996959686,
0.330005943775177,
0.03926894813776016,
-0.3031158745288849,
-0.7491956949234009,
0.38692501187324524,
-0.5642009973526001,
-0.23225213587284088,
-0.388654887676239,
-0.4303169548511505,
-0.9388148784637451,
0.5022698640823364,
-0.2137838751077652,
-0.5227720141410828,
0.4124733507633209,
0.03513844683766365,
-0.2680223882198334,
0.25420650839805603,
-0.7225975394248962,
0.6647326946258545,
-0.25971123576164246,
-0.4949493408203125,
-0.30238908529281616,
-0.793356716632843,
-0.23428083956241608,
-0.4827544689178467,
0.24444493651390076,
0.10493994504213333,
0.02065948210656643,
0.7391549944877625,
-0.030131425708532333,
0.7646564841270447,
-0.24347437918186188,
-0.08797509223222733,
-0.05606257542967796,
-0.009240659885108471,
0.40210023522377014,
-0.14264482259750366,
-0.3756939470767975,
0.12148585170507431,
0.12734687328338623,
-0.24929213523864746,
-0.5801968574523926,
0.5134935975074768,
-0.7947633862495422,
-0.12435007095336914,
-0.07597147673368454,
-0.7645063400268555,
-0.6027641296386719,
0.19020913541316986,
0.07436060905456543,
0.5552955269813538,
-0.18559855222702026,
0.2908133864402771,
0.6001579165458679,
-0.20022399723529816,
0.6453710794448853,
0.6563650965690613,
0.029452666640281677,
-0.5291471481323242,
1.1810901165008545,
0.17725753784179688,
0.32086923718452454,
0.5081096291542053,
0.5860888957977295,
-0.40651971101760864,
-0.6346801519393921,
-0.815223217010498,
0.31840094923973083,
-0.4522170126438141,
-0.04300738126039505,
-0.2841816544532776,
-0.3219221532344818,
-0.2527327239513397,
-0.11990378051996231,
-0.6520280241966248,
-0.200187548995018,
-0.37640294432640076,
0.1766507625579834,
0.49424251914024353,
0.24275968968868256,
-0.2655295431613922,
0.35898497700691223,
-0.8651180267333984,
0.38862255215644836,
0.312855064868927,
0.41930994391441345,
-0.008412645198404789,
-0.7880187630653381,
-0.4260231554508209,
-0.09741618484258652,
-0.1687743365764618,
-0.8125113844871521,
0.2229459136724472,
0.6611696481704712,
0.41114184260368347,
0.04436255991458893,
0.11906691640615463,
0.7471058964729309,
-0.6625863313674927,
0.5534725785255432,
0.1823241412639618,
-1.0493677854537964,
0.23313918709754944,
-0.16695952415466309,
0.4371839165687561,
0.4060061275959015,
0.5707460045814514,
-0.6761661767959595,
-0.11687128990888596,
-0.2494356632232666,
-0.7565124034881592,
0.830388069152832,
0.0977795347571373,
0.10230471193790436,
0.5610376000404358,
0.29236745834350586,
0.25854969024658203,
-0.16612361371517181,
-0.5490877032279968,
-0.1197381243109703,
-0.13681180775165558,
-0.36592257022857666,
-0.06953836232423782,
0.02019616961479187,
0.1728268712759018,
-0.2635173499584198,
0.8797762989997864,
-0.4257120192050934,
0.07124616950750351,
0.0515156090259552,
-0.15152806043624878,
0.24560315907001495,
0.39518654346466064,
0.7506946325302124,
0.5046698451042175,
-0.005328487139195204,
0.25093236565589905,
0.4046459197998047,
-0.5403273105621338,
0.39357441663742065,
0.2790934145450592,
0.10610122978687286,
0.043542057275772095,
0.23245108127593994,
1.1695159673690796,
0.281220018863678,
-0.4146624207496643,
0.2369537055492401,
-0.00048584010801278055,
-0.46166008710861206,
0.21325160562992096,
-0.22398917376995087,
0.30591529607772827,
0.21095333993434906,
0.25027722120285034,
0.027740247547626495,
0.14033135771751404,
-0.3529070019721985,
0.29458361864089966,
0.057231318205595016,
-0.25750261545181274,
-0.6433933973312378,
0.6035667061805725,
0.24916264414787292,
-0.4336162805557251,
0.3263779580593109,
0.09274541586637497,
-0.4378090500831604,
0.23892788589000702,
0.9453287124633789,
0.8971660137176514,
-0.8155819177627563,
0.21950440108776093,
0.2466403692960739,
0.034783586859703064,
0.032689712941646576,
0.10980768501758575,
-0.04105638340115547,
-0.4763435125350952,
-0.6529722809791565,
-0.664621889591217,
-0.6098616123199463,
0.21472914516925812,
-0.3459934890270233,
0.42130807042121887,
-0.09607560932636261,
0.08424143493175507,
0.11391676217317581,
-0.4072919189929962,
-0.38988831639289856,
0.1250942498445511,
0.0973561555147171,
0.6037682294845581,
-0.9470167756080627,
0.9350605010986328,
0.7780577540397644,
0.006732122972607613,
-0.9261365532875061,
0.11393792182207108,
-0.3900320827960968,
-0.6333188414573669,
0.4302024245262146,
-0.22170017659664154,
-0.5014415383338928,
0.21537058055400848,
0.2725408375263214,
-0.8259485363960266,
0.5748229026794434,
0.8971719145774841,
-0.5912739038467407,
-0.015650615096092224,
0.4721389412879944,
0.5700510740280151,
-0.09791997075080872,
0.32193347811698914,
0.4345879554748535,
0.6211737990379333,
0.10374803841114044,
-1.3514373302459717,
-0.042240727692842484,
0.008803836070001125,
0.19763734936714172,
0.04177781939506531,
-0.7736169099807739,
0.591097354888916,
0.10207847505807877,
0.1793925166130066,
-0.3094038665294647,
0.4514142572879791,
0.16817571222782135,
-0.04322643205523491,
0.6221812963485718,
0.046555452048778534,
0.6994653940200806,
0.31936848163604736,
0.4522097408771515,
-0.5653169751167297,
0.20813682675361633,
0.8433470726013184,
-0.10517358779907227,
0.9237042665481567,
0.46963733434677124,
-0.09217808395624161,
0.25301599502563477,
0.5234652161598206,
0.33124876022338867,
0.8218705654144287,
-0.01870373822748661,
-0.26904067397117615,
-0.1720244437456131,
-0.13297666609287262,
-0.33825361728668213,
0.8603512048721313,
0.2763892710208893,
-0.18511834740638733,
-0.2694453299045563,
0.4068106412887573,
-0.07999390363693237,
-0.12423627823591232,
-0.12741336226463318,
0.9316813349723816,
-0.06161890923976898,
-0.512143611907959,
0.9847140312194824,
0.029661813750863075,
0.6544573903083801,
-0.7591615915298462,
-0.02307290770113468,
-0.14176547527313232,
0.18819169700145721,
0.0039978655986487865,
-0.4634484648704529,
0.3139137625694275,
-0.0739055946469307,
-0.2408537119626999,
-0.2622963786125183,
0.6167100667953491,
-0.6122810244560242,
-0.39258959889411926,
0.3399411141872406,
0.6750601530075073,
0.18279951810836792,
-0.024050066247582436,
-0.7087085843086243,
-0.016146963462233543,
0.021810976788401604,
-0.2217041254043579,
0.3887670934200287,
0.4449717104434967,
-0.2174992710351944,
0.5005679130554199,
0.7131471633911133,
0.41089963912963867,
0.002310611540451646,
0.17867955565452576,
0.4748489558696747,
-0.36495405435562134,
-0.8117644786834717,
-0.7795648574829102,
0.3581841289997101,
0.36694973707199097,
-0.39298418164253235,
0.45997095108032227,
0.6097050309181213,
0.8449423909187317,
-0.28679564595222473,
0.8863711357116699,
0.2559780478477478,
0.37170523405075073,
-0.5759099721908569,
0.6372456550598145,
-0.612909734249115,
-0.07457870244979858,
-0.22807426750659943,
-0.7821260094642639,
-0.29842430353164673,
0.4402955174446106,
-0.008830993436276913,
0.0345400832593441,
0.6794642806053162,
0.8426805138587952,
-0.35809946060180664,
0.043886762112379074,
0.46050649881362915,
0.024136625230312347,
0.28784996271133423,
0.577029824256897,
0.4472638666629791,
-0.33677351474761963,
0.7447092533111572,
-0.1505318433046341,
-0.1359727680683136,
-0.26907479763031006,
-0.9261062741279602,
-0.4061766564846039,
-0.9054193496704102,
-0.28933703899383545,
-0.05239928513765335,
0.48135387897491455,
0.8539936542510986,
1.0519535541534424,
-0.8700709939002991,
-0.5422499775886536,
-0.08743944764137268,
-0.05972665175795555,
-0.46637022495269775,
-0.15882651507854462,
0.7210956811904907,
-0.37554267048835754,
-0.9854538440704346,
0.5444340109825134,
0.1049596443772316,
-0.0005436556530185044,
-0.02743791602551937,
-0.15607619285583496,
-0.11626870930194855,
-0.010621298104524612,
0.6769382357597351,
0.3135225176811218,
-0.4232262372970581,
-0.3660151958465576,
0.030666697770357132,
0.20324382185935974,
0.22450736165046692,
0.7483111619949341,
-0.575482964515686,
0.5425362586975098,
0.4065680205821991,
1.0017578601837158,
0.6385017037391663,
-0.21711118519306183,
0.6010372042655945,
-0.913023054599762,
0.23054373264312744,
0.13759949803352356,
0.04997140169143677,
0.40616506338119507,
-0.11602959036827087,
0.20596066117286682,
0.21834127604961395,
-0.5872372388839722,
-0.6846686601638794,
0.16352809965610504,
-0.9961903095245361,
-0.4194839298725128,
1.1347945928573608,
-0.07284406572580338,
-0.061724357306957245,
0.028519129380583763,
-0.3740839958190918,
0.5288821458816528,
-0.30794966220855713,
0.4017435312271118,
0.3774600625038147,
-0.28881460428237915,
-0.17634063959121704,
-0.4027741551399231,
0.5084420442581177,
0.525626003742218,
-0.7997751832008362,
0.2857014834880829,
0.17962923645973206,
0.345718115568161,
-0.01176408026367426,
0.39969202876091003,
0.13024967908859253,
0.37280482053756714,
-0.08190976828336716,
-0.0026638940908014774,
-0.09231646358966827,
-0.41219231486320496,
-0.4127127528190613,
0.27031293511390686,
0.1804538518190384,
-0.4519716501235962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17255v1 | MPCODER: Multi-user Personalized Code Generator with Explicit and Implicit Style Representation Learning | 2024-06-25T03:45:28 | 2024-06-25T03:45:28 | Zhenlong Dai, Chang Yao, WenKang Han, Ying Yuan, Zhipeng Gao, Jingyuan Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential for assisting
developers in their daily development. However, most research focuses on
generating correct code, how to use LLMs to generate personalized code has
seldom been investigated. To bridge this gap, we proposed MPCoder (Multi-user
Personalized Code Generator) to generate personalized code for multiple users.
To better learn coding style features, we utilize explicit coding style
residual learning to capture the syntax code style standards and implicit style
learning to capture the semantic code style conventions. We train a multi-user
style adapter to better differentiate the implicit feature representations of
different users through contrastive learning, ultimately enabling personalized
code generation for multiple users. We further propose a novel evaluation
metric for estimating similarities between codes of different coding styles.
The experimental results show the effectiveness of our approach for this novel
task. | [
-0.5543694496154785,
-0.08747077733278275,
0.33757928013801575,
0.36504480242729187,
0.04117820784449577,
0.26248490810394287,
-0.3808322846889496,
0.0637139305472374,
0.15163984894752502,
0.2996571362018585,
-0.4356288015842438,
-0.6342962980270386,
-0.467025488615036,
0.3706572353839874,
-0.1502629518508911,
0.858333170413971,
0.09564324468374252,
0.030619816854596138,
-0.2646405100822449,
-0.10990109294652939,
-0.4880525767803192,
-0.8737305998802185,
-0.3444429337978363,
-0.11218876391649246,
0.6103324294090271,
0.5385082960128784,
0.1829986572265625,
0.3586629629135132,
0.3687550723552704,
0.34028884768486023,
0.35509395599365234,
0.16540835797786713,
-0.45804211497306824,
0.04736046865582466,
0.16876213252544403,
-0.050688404589891434,
-0.10402587056159973,
-0.3823702037334442,
0.29288581013679504,
0.1576596051454544,
-0.20909367501735687,
0.4394538402557373,
0.08286461234092712,
0.4177373945713043,
-0.5809876918792725,
0.09916723519563675,
-0.6120321154594421,
0.21162433922290802,
0.13336260616779327,
-0.4586068093776703,
-0.42571523785591125,
-0.7046782970428467,
-0.28640952706336975,
-0.21279382705688477,
0.16259843111038208,
-0.17064343392848969,
0.47579893469810486,
-0.013713478110730648,
-0.5601747035980225,
-0.4376421272754669,
-0.7796964049339294,
0.6742382049560547,
-0.6786039471626282,
0.3589736521244049,
-0.01569177955389023,
0.49525758624076843,
0.2934643030166626,
-0.9045877456665039,
-0.7634589076042175,
-0.35316476225852966,
-0.2792288362979889,
-0.10504087060689926,
-0.06076551973819733,
-0.3213198482990265,
0.16639195382595062,
0.21067838370800018,
-0.36957064270973206,
-0.08991318941116333,
-0.3820571005344391,
-0.1075882539153099,
0.5340905785560608,
0.22228668630123138,
0.5091261267662048,
-0.08411315083503723,
-0.4625276029109955,
-0.007899648509919643,
-0.5362098813056946,
0.0810290277004242,
0.639091968536377,
0.009871347807347775,
-0.192205548286438,
0.257832407951355,
-0.16762258112430573,
0.3887019455432892,
-0.051915496587753296,
-0.45597541332244873,
0.6026882529258728,
-0.3072222173213959,
0.1636127531528473,
-0.079997219145298,
0.7880327105522156,
0.5097726583480835,
0.41322842240333557,
-0.20829175412654877,
-0.314776748418808,
-0.05876419320702553,
0.3149760663509369,
-0.9089753031730652,
-0.3546281158924103,
-0.11275169998407364,
-0.5419057607650757,
-0.3623761832714081,
0.3534735143184662,
-0.8793375492095947,
-0.434535413980484,
-0.4166978895664215,
0.016749506816267967,
-0.26549336314201355,
-0.2352340817451477,
-0.04960661754012108,
-0.11225231736898422,
0.16622759401798248,
0.08123933523893356,
-0.9487025141716003,
0.22993917763233185,
0.2737339437007904,
0.5402688384056091,
-0.0708804726600647,
-0.5607219338417053,
-0.40557602047920227,
0.28433719277381897,
-0.052723515778779984,
0.4326971769332886,
-0.7426032423973083,
-0.4468221366405487,
0.1039653941988945,
-0.4001549780368805,
0.2886304557323456,
-0.3688768148422241,
0.10384229570627213,
-0.3524862229824066,
-0.015910854563117027,
-0.16674529016017914,
-0.24409882724285126,
0.06710077077150345,
-0.007854309864342213,
-0.43133309483528137,
0.6233744025230408,
0.39791226387023926,
-0.6360132694244385,
0.46885553002357483,
-0.5378284454345703,
-0.1850268691778183,
0.2141837626695633,
-0.5230765342712402,
-0.7066699862480164,
0.20728261768817902,
0.15539248287677765,
0.6170549988746643,
0.10044648498296738,
0.25370410084724426,
-0.48183056712150574,
-0.6321622729301453,
0.4480561316013336,
-0.13720542192459106,
0.2428172081708908,
0.394513875246048,
-0.10684164613485336,
0.4759010374546051,
-0.845759391784668,
0.027843592688441277,
0.16858477890491486,
-0.7116871476173401,
0.05052124336361885,
-0.016021408140659332,
0.29482826590538025,
0.5136245489120483,
0.3800172507762909,
-0.468504399061203,
0.32224681973457336,
0.24483388662338257,
0.40304723381996155,
0.9112019538879395,
0.0811433270573616,
0.10301492363214493,
-0.2400311827659607,
0.5114167332649231,
-0.22842179238796234,
-0.15759755671024323,
-0.49794813990592957,
-0.016288189217448235,
-0.6322925686836243,
-0.2996651232242584,
0.09781164675951004,
0.30555152893066406,
-0.5825759768486023,
0.4990506172180176,
-0.35004791617393494,
-0.10180958360433578,
-0.20156215131282806,
0.6418938040733337,
0.7854288220405579,
0.16009379923343658,
0.2801012098789215,
-0.4299614131450653,
-0.7036884427070618,
-0.6963561177253723,
-0.14731049537658691,
0.1595139503479004,
-0.2273247241973877,
0.6848840117454529,
0.4010210335254669,
-0.7003767490386963,
1.024400234222412,
-0.7878432869911194,
-0.23442448675632477,
-0.412076473236084,
0.05826900899410248,
-0.2241404503583908,
0.5896102786064148,
0.6945832371711731,
-0.9202415943145752,
-0.5611365437507629,
0.13327910006046295,
-0.5286778807640076,
-0.12226182222366333,
-0.1323811560869217,
0.08594649285078049,
0.1524854600429535,
0.547501266002655,
0.14002883434295654,
0.0038427088875323534,
0.6814353466033936,
-0.3426535129547119,
0.5648823380470276,
-0.37553632259368896,
0.26078611612319946,
-1.2070939540863037,
0.27882853150367737,
0.23931817710399628,
-0.1423993706703186,
-0.3596235513687134,
0.29266127943992615,
0.10708725452423096,
-0.4453172981739044,
-0.3796112835407257,
0.4107934534549713,
-0.4226043224334717,
-0.21772952377796173,
-0.017922978848218918,
-0.4147455394268036,
-0.1043330505490303,
0.8972288966178894,
0.034546080976724625,
1.0231646299362183,
0.21469378471374512,
-0.41538023948669434,
0.3723624646663666,
0.017652083188295364,
-0.37999793887138367,
0.2971589267253876,
-0.6559273600578308,
0.6515434384346008,
-0.055345308035612106,
0.0671829879283905,
-1.0515695810317993,
-0.41034552454948425,
-0.04689151048660278,
-0.327989786863327,
0.22477294504642487,
-0.43000540137290955,
-0.573057234287262,
-0.3033512532711029,
-0.3476043939590454,
0.12907692790031433,
0.9534823298454285,
-0.7264345288276672,
0.38201531767845154,
0.1621345430612564,
-0.17765913903713226,
-0.3169666826725006,
-0.3926478624343872,
-0.0760222002863884,
-0.27800053358078003,
-0.5283701419830322,
0.2528262436389923,
-0.17148955166339874,
-0.04108486697077751,
-0.11808035522699356,
-0.2814141809940338,
-0.1834135502576828,
0.04865029454231262,
0.31600111722946167,
0.04156839847564697,
-0.2508706748485565,
0.03460492193698883,
0.08895186334848404,
-0.24433477222919464,
-0.04142247512936592,
-0.05405781790614128,
0.7805054783821106,
-0.2161104530096054,
-0.45512518286705017,
-0.15823526680469513,
0.47949686646461487,
0.2802973687648773,
-0.6677690148353577,
0.6233016848564148,
0.9295169711112976,
0.011168989352881908,
-0.29035377502441406,
-0.645513117313385,
0.12370874732732773,
-0.5407692193984985,
0.45244792103767395,
-0.6799765229225159,
-1.1233280897140503,
0.4041702449321747,
-0.4103945791721344,
-0.20487822592258453,
0.0797753632068634,
0.7089833617210388,
0.07067716866731644,
1.1265922784805298,
1.0686333179473877,
0.08806675672531128,
0.5273458957672119,
-0.11200699210166931,
-0.08043999969959259,
-0.7840047478675842,
-0.5439729690551758,
-0.5765277743339539,
-0.27576419711112976,
-0.29813793301582336,
-0.10959881544113159,
0.2110583633184433,
0.24539156258106232,
-0.45617255568504333,
0.29982852935791016,
-0.6693189144134521,
0.7501474022865295,
0.5640581846237183,
0.20337824523448944,
0.1614689975976944,
0.21793122589588165,
-0.22452044486999512,
-0.11580512672662735,
-0.2234048992395401,
-0.4818122684955597,
0.9092140793800354,
0.21612805128097534,
1.037500023841858,
0.40670350193977356,
1.0551338195800781,
0.32694390416145325,
0.14216198027133942,
-0.4464052617549896,
0.15824829041957855,
-0.3061579167842865,
0.1414392590522766,
0.235441192984581,
-0.594221830368042,
-0.42919039726257324,
0.04811464622616768,
-0.09997978061437607,
-0.7363649010658264,
0.2499392032623291,
0.3622397482395172,
-0.250578373670578,
0.020577462390065193,
-1.0626140832901,
0.9849135875701904,
-0.20350529253482819,
-0.15747906267642975,
0.09463220089673996,
-0.5455561280250549,
0.4578263461589813,
-0.31157371401786804,
0.014619621448218822,
-0.041386928409338,
-0.2136121541261673,
0.3681319057941437,
-0.18968938291072845,
0.9406563639640808,
-0.17808693647384644,
0.10415951162576675,
-0.07055839151144028,
0.25519582629203796,
0.26135560870170593,
0.3112933933734894,
0.017420552670955658,
-0.027292465791106224,
-0.3785565197467804,
-0.11585003137588501,
-0.5803186893463135,
0.9835888743400574,
-0.6494601964950562,
-0.3336298167705536,
-0.12782317399978638,
-0.23353944718837738,
-0.0988340899348259,
0.17677180469036102,
0.22106368839740753,
0.5740898251533508,
-0.19139403104782104,
0.12487510591745377,
0.5382944941520691,
-0.4071328938007355,
0.6759340167045593,
0.30837634205818176,
-0.22625376284122467,
-0.6121473908424377,
1.194515347480774,
-0.455854207277298,
0.004718772601336241,
0.33705660700798035,
0.24266915023326874,
-0.04389277100563049,
-0.4456120431423187,
-0.39499756693840027,
-0.05107179656624794,
-0.7107336521148682,
-0.1969539076089859,
-0.6148340106010437,
-0.03426118567585945,
-0.2956123650074005,
-0.5392194390296936,
0.040817517787218094,
0.16978180408477783,
-0.14360196888446808,
0.3018604516983032,
0.39094164967536926,
0.7737385630607605,
0.41829514503479004,
0.2889082431793213,
-0.9413536190986633,
0.49130380153656006,
0.4941279888153076,
0.4475601017475128,
-0.17183439433574677,
-0.18746741116046906,
-0.06769655644893646,
-0.38075125217437744,
-0.2772923707962036,
-0.8319475650787354,
0.4688280522823334,
0.2714957594871521,
0.6115769743919373,
0.2783032953739166,
-0.14365524053573608,
0.5153115391731262,
-0.7145016193389893,
0.6470156311988831,
0.5148406028747559,
-1.0618542432785034,
0.3859086036682129,
0.03762410953640938,
0.5074711441993713,
0.5921823978424072,
0.5126306414604187,
-0.7510274052619934,
-0.06308979541063309,
-0.21268223226070404,
-0.5569578409194946,
0.5236141085624695,
0.05561863258481026,
0.6064391136169434,
0.07642319798469543,
0.36887478828430176,
0.2892795503139496,
0.24824456870555878,
-0.7445418834686279,
-0.21116439998149872,
-0.40168896317481995,
-0.3805783987045288,
-0.13150213658809662,
-0.4044027030467987,
0.05283239856362343,
-0.1852085441350937,
0.08607923239469528,
-0.6226040124893188,
0.5145322680473328,
-0.12320242077112198,
-0.08895649760961533,
0.26089370250701904,
0.5891287922859192,
0.6907405257225037,
0.9190061092376709,
-0.1162293329834938,
0.08258038014173508,
0.08931862562894821,
-0.246231809258461,
0.12018951028585434,
0.16238556802272797,
0.09070675820112228,
-0.10715553164482117,
0.1618829220533371,
0.680976927280426,
0.17918425798416138,
-0.5853926539421082,
0.7483338713645935,
-0.3779541552066803,
0.06883934140205383,
-0.4647180140018463,
0.22842203080654144,
0.23069645464420319,
-0.04392435774207115,
0.11882900446653366,
0.5905223488807678,
0.12199538201093674,
-0.39121508598327637,
0.4062820374965668,
0.14829027652740479,
-0.4240957200527191,
-0.23847614228725433,
0.5625133514404297,
0.6203833222389221,
-0.32283392548561096,
0.4217335879802704,
-0.43993186950683594,
-0.5388101935386658,
0.5258389711380005,
0.683468759059906,
0.9705298542976379,
-0.11146825551986694,
0.07425736635923386,
0.2828449308872223,
-0.14278943836688995,
0.3350292146205902,
0.3427399694919586,
-0.3243698477745056,
-0.5793581604957581,
-0.4612840414047241,
-0.9368414878845215,
-0.10768330842256546,
-0.16284239292144775,
-0.4963158667087555,
0.589937150478363,
-0.6243348717689514,
0.26049113273620605,
-0.19902163743972778,
-0.268863707780838,
-0.5475003719329834,
-0.18391303718090057,
0.33589884638786316,
0.6674339771270752,
-0.510712742805481,
1.0493422746658325,
0.7169619202613831,
-0.6846871376037598,
-0.7140164375305176,
0.17736732959747314,
0.23116785287857056,
-0.5416808128356934,
0.8128450512886047,
0.23213525116443634,
-0.36293816566467285,
-0.0188006404787302,
-0.42121049761772156,
-0.44674673676490784,
0.9557552933692932,
0.5863946080207825,
-0.6759005188941956,
0.09354725480079651,
-0.22448194026947021,
0.4148392975330353,
-0.8057442307472229,
0.18892019987106323,
0.38623929023742676,
0.010383878834545612,
0.11608994752168655,
-0.5935330986976624,
0.019655056297779083,
-0.48795652389526367,
0.4808885157108307,
0.29966142773628235,
-0.5659213662147522,
0.7345190644264221,
-0.42716076970100403,
-0.07092910259962082,
0.009965643286705017,
0.3937624394893646,
0.3102627098560333,
0.06755927950143814,
0.07966900616884232,
0.18301664292812347,
0.42302021384239197,
0.050757039338350296,
1.3115142583847046,
-0.5128368735313416,
0.365925669670105,
1.0877070426940918,
-0.2263057827949524,
0.6553963422775269,
0.13096822798252106,
-0.05676685646176338,
0.6771716475486755,
0.06232203170657158,
-0.26601889729499817,
0.4450396001338959,
0.399873822927475,
-0.3508974611759186,
-0.08022140711545944,
0.1729183942079544,
-0.5331367254257202,
0.3218923509120941,
0.09127038717269897,
-0.6114300489425659,
0.08141810446977615,
-0.062212247401475906,
0.1630864292383194,
0.3275861442089081,
-0.12640270590782166,
1.066646933555603,
-0.021138319745659828,
-0.16945648193359375,
0.45687630772590637,
0.3232386112213135,
1.1822272539138794,
-0.8529534935951233,
-0.42869818210601807,
-0.41598501801490784,
0.3591368496417999,
-0.4496634900569916,
-0.6677489280700684,
0.12249549478292465,
0.17089001834392548,
-0.11634496599435806,
-0.3673218786716461,
0.7673351168632507,
-0.42648860812187195,
-0.45456162095069885,
0.1403026282787323,
0.19583310186862946,
-0.22622160613536835,
0.165113165974617,
-0.527048647403717,
0.24558089673519135,
0.19511578977108002,
0.11159668117761612,
0.3862208425998688,
0.17358238995075226,
0.36252662539482117,
0.6886091232299805,
0.6487718820571899,
-0.12230881303548813,
0.3591652810573578,
0.2921518385410309,
0.9628887176513672,
-0.6176519393920898,
-0.37099042534828186,
-0.8681097626686096,
0.36838698387145996,
-0.08705157041549683,
-0.622829020023346,
0.9179368615150452,
0.6852176785469055,
1.091329574584961,
-0.6549884676933289,
0.7357094287872314,
-0.09136383980512619,
0.09924288839101791,
-0.5591790080070496,
0.7291228175163269,
-0.2542724907398224,
0.4173610210418701,
-0.5196468234062195,
-1.1374826431274414,
-0.26125338673591614,
0.3646596372127533,
0.1720104068517685,
0.399501770734787,
0.47390100359916687,
0.627329409122467,
-0.30050280690193176,
-0.39141860604286194,
0.2192380279302597,
-0.347730427980423,
0.39154526591300964,
0.7103538513183594,
0.8726199269294739,
-0.06626547127962112,
0.7851827144622803,
-0.549391508102417,
-0.15489961206912994,
-0.13015629351139069,
-0.8555123209953308,
-0.8240763545036316,
-0.558263897895813,
-0.2993936836719513,
-0.2873537838459015,
-0.02728436328470707,
1.1551555395126343,
0.8951730132102966,
-0.6596428751945496,
-0.4494223892688751,
0.09506066888570786,
-0.01972954161465168,
-0.2018241435289383,
-0.193944051861763,
0.08717045933008194,
-0.4519056975841522,
-0.7339950203895569,
0.07708021253347397,
0.05814160034060478,
-0.043774303048849106,
-0.38440537452697754,
-0.6039103269577026,
0.31917640566825867,
-0.24996381998062134,
0.5890127420425415,
0.32002881169319153,
-0.5977110862731934,
-0.21767745912075043,
-0.25175875425338745,
-0.3412800133228302,
0.23932810127735138,
1.300087809562683,
-0.7661975026130676,
0.407444030046463,
0.6352699995040894,
0.6608467698097229,
0.4067695140838623,
0.07803870737552643,
0.447773814201355,
-1.2718628644943237,
-0.10993774980306625,
-0.06612234562635422,
0.4513958990573883,
0.31378576159477234,
-0.4923361539840698,
0.33460673689842224,
0.08241831511259079,
-0.36495277285575867,
-0.5514823794364929,
0.3398815095424652,
-0.9197004437446594,
-0.26648038625717163,
1.1692777872085571,
-0.370181679725647,
0.12435874342918396,
0.054408010095357895,
-0.5329802632331848,
-0.17780815064907074,
-0.7623520493507385,
0.35635265707969666,
0.21426856517791748,
-0.2518604099750519,
-0.471413254737854,
-0.1776314526796341,
0.486912339925766,
-0.1981363296508789,
-0.8702141642570496,
-0.20734374225139618,
0.5947199463844299,
0.5207871794700623,
0.24970541894435883,
0.594240128993988,
-0.04924621805548668,
0.4332713186740875,
0.1875462532043457,
0.5060718655586243,
-0.6787001490592957,
-0.4032111167907715,
-0.7203240990638733,
0.43784376978874207,
0.26372191309928894,
0.11331246048212051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17253v1 | How Well Can Knowledge Edit Methods Edit Perplexing Knowledge? | 2024-06-25T03:41:02 | 2024-06-25T03:41:02 | Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) are widely deployed, targeted editing of
their knowledge has become a critical challenge. Recently, advancements in
model editing techniques, such as Rank-One Model Editing (ROME), have paved the
way for updating LLMs with new knowledge. However, the efficacy of these
methods varies across different types of knowledge. This study investigates the
capability of knowledge editing methods to incorporate new knowledge with
varying degrees of "perplexingness", a term we use to describe the initial
difficulty LLMs have in understanding new concepts. We begin by quantifying the
"perplexingness" of target knowledge using pre-edit conditional probabilities,
and assess the efficacy of edits through post-edit conditional probabilities.
Utilizing the widely-used CounterFact dataset, we find significant negative
correlations between the "perplexingness" of the new knowledge and the edit
efficacy across all 12 scenarios. To dive deeper into this phenomenon, we
introduce a novel dataset, HierarchyData, consisting of 99 hyponym-hypernym
pairs across diverse categories. Our analysis reveal that more abstract
concepts (hypernyms) tend to be more perplexing than their specific
counterparts (hyponyms). Further exploration into the influence of knowledge
hierarchy on editing outcomes indicates that knowledge positioned at higher
hierarchical levels is more challenging to modify in some scenarios. Our
research highlights a previously overlooked aspect of LLM editing: the variable
efficacy of editing methods in handling perplexing knowledge. By revealing how
hierarchical relationships can influence editing outcomes, our findings offer
new insights into the challenges of updating LLMs and pave the way for more
nuanced approaches to model editing in the future. | [
-0.1234210953116417,
-0.8664049506187439,
0.7870481014251709,
-0.03892580047249794,
0.005994187202304602,
0.4049104154109955,
-0.06480497866868973,
-0.31051105260849,
0.04195013269782066,
0.27826565504074097,
-0.4892042279243469,
-0.6837146282196045,
-0.8301149606704712,
0.2040690928697586,
-0.40872129797935486,
0.9758648872375488,
-0.07714862376451492,
-0.27626949548721313,
-0.27376535534858704,
-0.12289251387119293,
-0.36872032284736633,
-0.9626888632774353,
-0.15675339102745056,
-0.295127272605896,
0.7020294666290283,
0.4786585569381714,
1.2478104829788208,
0.692718505859375,
0.7193355560302734,
0.3269786238670349,
-0.7554442286491394,
0.04543965309858322,
-0.7365924715995789,
-0.023331256583333015,
-0.32048964500427246,
-0.705915629863739,
-0.7978318333625793,
0.05003967508673668,
0.6803140044212341,
0.8353213667869568,
-0.02411440573632717,
0.04573173075914383,
0.014831207692623138,
0.5143256187438965,
-0.8009862303733826,
-0.21356938779354095,
-0.9574289321899414,
0.2078213393688202,
-0.33540189266204834,
-0.30251815915107727,
-0.007034280803054571,
0.008602386340498924,
0.44698697328567505,
-0.9618220925331116,
-0.0020463503897190094,
-0.05085274577140808,
0.7969944477081299,
0.389970988035202,
-0.20337079465389252,
-0.43449413776397705,
-0.6854047775268555,
0.31789395213127136,
-0.849647045135498,
0.2937840521335602,
0.2543102502822876,
-0.14772620797157288,
-0.2985667288303375,
-0.5465731024742126,
-0.7578614354133606,
0.11772355437278748,
-0.0669589713215828,
-0.11513698846101761,
-0.35599881410598755,
0.13574808835983276,
0.8317092657089233,
0.2384917140007019,
-0.06224694848060608,
0.27875274419784546,
-0.01992030069231987,
0.046147625893354416,
0.3542274534702301,
0.27253955602645874,
0.34488973021507263,
-0.5915560126304626,
-0.2529325485229492,
0.17024081945419312,
-0.8688167929649353,
0.031797975301742554,
0.5205941796302795,
-0.1289132535457611,
0.18012812733650208,
0.8915771842002869,
-0.1921015828847885,
0.47192585468292236,
0.20257164537906647,
-0.38965466618537903,
0.13154098391532898,
-0.13514389097690582,
-0.48146024346351624,
-0.09468751400709152,
0.3572351634502411,
0.3615133464336395,
0.014679357409477234,
-0.18037238717079163,
-0.25323745608329773,
-0.3364673852920532,
0.12184865027666092,
-0.267559677362442,
-0.2500404417514801,
0.13181249797344208,
-0.09723906219005585,
-0.391423761844635,
-0.2811383008956909,
-0.356927752494812,
-0.8009401559829712,
-0.1882113218307495,
0.6088296175003052,
-0.40931957960128784,
-0.07069003582000732,
0.3034420609474182,
-0.11453324556350708,
-0.09663726389408112,
0.7127560973167419,
-0.5743396282196045,
0.007158363703638315,
0.7488893270492554,
0.5402509570121765,
-0.055100277066230774,
-0.5019325017929077,
-0.0999426394701004,
0.28020209074020386,
-0.4253793954849243,
0.6517723202705383,
-0.7273356318473816,
-0.26668208837509155,
-0.16351693868637085,
-0.2967555820941925,
-0.04696103557944298,
-0.5830985307693481,
0.2003457397222519,
-0.7868224382400513,
-0.045808691531419754,
-0.42862585186958313,
-0.8455537557601929,
0.1050698533654213,
0.2262652963399887,
-0.47303783893585205,
0.635593056678772,
0.07182628661394119,
-1.1190623044967651,
0.3614868223667145,
-0.5725011229515076,
-0.2918875515460968,
-0.1318867951631546,
0.13255445659160614,
-0.15398791432380676,
0.2659870386123657,
0.0610165037214756,
0.13511571288108826,
-0.09684793651103973,
0.26835542917251587,
-0.14329861104488373,
-0.09364604949951172,
0.5131514072418213,
-0.09090352058410645,
0.5587551593780518,
-0.030568743124604225,
-0.01807643286883831,
0.13673652708530426,
-0.626999020576477,
-0.43559253215789795,
-0.10745186358690262,
-0.29745009541511536,
-0.6382003426551819,
-0.10295552760362625,
-0.557930588722229,
0.26879462599754333,
0.3629908561706543,
-0.3000074625015259,
0.4929536283016205,
-0.057886138558387756,
0.24218174815177917,
0.7520444393157959,
0.20505185425281525,
0.35647451877593994,
-0.48154813051223755,
0.7843579053878784,
0.1614343523979187,
0.2223125845193863,
-0.0429346077144146,
-0.43107226490974426,
-0.6354678869247437,
0.11496952921152115,
0.5617726445198059,
0.7517145276069641,
-0.8260467648506165,
0.05923861265182495,
-0.21351678669452667,
-0.29569119215011597,
-0.5922293663024902,
0.4646371006965637,
0.5304902195930481,
0.7530810832977295,
0.4136927127838135,
-0.1056695431470871,
-0.4659467935562134,
-0.8654913902282715,
-0.5784211754798889,
-0.20440955460071564,
0.11441800743341446,
0.1981896460056305,
0.553226888179779,
-0.258714497089386,
0.7351980209350586,
-0.5362011790275574,
-0.024426547810435295,
-0.016730323433876038,
0.277534157037735,
0.11369218677282333,
0.47782567143440247,
0.23443561792373657,
-0.6387319564819336,
-0.15284743905067444,
-0.1163376122713089,
-0.907073974609375,
-0.1860562413930893,
-0.23253042995929718,
-0.1629110425710678,
0.07916013896465302,
0.6807069778442383,
-0.5744683742523193,
0.4389249384403229,
0.3119352161884308,
-0.15460804104804993,
0.8617638349533081,
-0.22211000323295593,
0.3015594482421875,
-0.8872379660606384,
-0.27052444219589233,
-0.10639654844999313,
0.27766504883766174,
-0.6908466815948486,
0.2189333140850067,
0.049537647515535355,
0.33188727498054504,
-0.4965948164463043,
0.1813022345304489,
-0.4353361427783966,
0.14353036880493164,
0.13005346059799194,
0.1308663785457611,
-0.26707327365875244,
0.32468119263648987,
-0.21943747997283936,
0.480720192193985,
0.2631213366985321,
-0.29178595542907715,
0.2027280181646347,
0.5422211289405823,
-0.6242517232894897,
0.4620511829853058,
-0.38049694895744324,
0.2699100971221924,
-0.26398876309394836,
-0.04559076204895973,
-0.8892682790756226,
-0.26236218214035034,
0.05050553008913994,
-0.29957133531570435,
0.10074211657047272,
-0.22858203947544098,
-0.6458685994148254,
-0.03306901082396507,
-0.15626655519008636,
0.4296611547470093,
0.23847270011901855,
-0.24581892788410187,
0.424201637506485,
0.3652268052101135,
-0.4447205662727356,
-0.9251461625099182,
-0.7339344620704651,
0.5673243999481201,
-0.3039640188217163,
-0.6471136212348938,
0.4651670753955841,
-0.01944582350552082,
-0.5119869112968445,
0.27174830436706543,
-0.4260847568511963,
0.02356957271695137,
0.23780407011508942,
0.035265251994132996,
0.2270306944847107,
-0.07292885333299637,
0.16674396395683289,
0.27199429273605347,
-0.04924966022372246,
0.08702756464481354,
0.01630663312971592,
0.01600741595029831,
0.3916517496109009,
-0.30115842819213867,
-0.5679547190666199,
-0.031733736395835876,
0.6677512526512146,
-0.14435553550720215,
0.5593801736831665,
-0.14701227843761444,
-0.49681994318962097,
0.0937599167227745,
-0.7581899762153625,
0.166499525308609,
-0.4153222441673279,
0.6246644258499146,
-0.842114269733429,
-1.0069040060043335,
0.6466174721717834,
-0.18252195417881012,
-0.02758791111409664,
0.443635493516922,
0.24737390875816345,
-0.29408490657806396,
0.8482953310012817,
0.6211229562759399,
0.1139800027012825,
0.3735419511795044,
-0.22332774102687836,
0.22024714946746826,
-1.0846937894821167,
-0.23663809895515442,
-0.49034249782562256,
-0.41002804040908813,
-0.7026500105857849,
-0.5293963551521301,
0.5308159589767456,
0.3716629147529602,
-0.005599283147603273,
0.17123761773109436,
0.06844525039196014,
0.5489814877510071,
0.19565755128860474,
0.16387033462524414,
0.9210665822029114,
-0.08920978754758835,
-0.14187398552894592,
-0.22033102810382843,
-0.9763563871383667,
-0.529322624206543,
1.2424554824829102,
0.39358752965927124,
0.8613389134407043,
0.3420097827911377,
0.5758061408996582,
0.15560217201709747,
0.31978872418403625,
-0.6437312364578247,
0.3528897166252136,
-0.3439972996711731,
-0.5640007853507996,
-0.620459794998169,
-0.36658361554145813,
-0.6277252435684204,
0.05724521726369858,
-0.7039905786514282,
-0.6956155300140381,
0.5096617341041565,
0.3499993085861206,
-0.4660283029079437,
0.7184698581695557,
-0.6162881851196289,
0.6913223266601562,
-0.051351889967918396,
-0.3164859414100647,
-0.16713252663612366,
-0.6957864165306091,
0.361541748046875,
-0.26062101125717163,
0.5159221887588501,
0.2571113109588623,
-0.07583342492580414,
0.7352091670036316,
-0.340349406003952,
0.566493809223175,
0.01398990023881197,
-0.5090094804763794,
-0.1616312861442566,
0.3571333587169647,
0.5392042994499207,
0.0373026542365551,
-0.29536131024360657,
-0.047158192843198776,
-0.03946918621659279,
-0.39139819145202637,
-1.0828722715377808,
0.5466657280921936,
-0.756959855556488,
-1.2092654705047607,
-0.24044130742549896,
-0.9414998292922974,
-0.5225114822387695,
-0.060192760080099106,
0.258821964263916,
0.3380247950553894,
-0.017537560313940048,
0.11733674257993698,
0.8716625571250916,
-0.40738388895988464,
-0.11280950158834457,
0.44424059987068176,
-0.19695048034191132,
-0.10520748049020767,
0.7047857046127319,
0.6965606808662415,
0.565517246723175,
0.5588831901550293,
0.19410650432109833,
-0.037192363291978836,
-0.9962713718414307,
-0.18318632245063782,
0.04373744875192642,
-0.7144995927810669,
0.07652531564235687,
-0.8626952171325684,
-0.221841499209404,
-0.35224783420562744,
-0.29603224992752075,
-0.04276478290557861,
-0.6323809623718262,
-0.010863127186894417,
-0.16613692045211792,
0.17309753596782684,
1.0639889240264893,
-0.1072903499007225,
0.34926745295524597,
-0.43756750226020813,
0.5044218301773071,
0.5364267826080322,
0.16979223489761353,
0.004826640244573355,
-0.7499180436134338,
-0.13929733633995056,
0.008336516097187996,
-0.007332646753638983,
-1.0237154960632324,
-0.07614261656999588,
-0.25202637910842896,
0.4379691183567047,
0.1886979341506958,
-0.021845519542694092,
0.9838504195213318,
-0.22591529786586761,
0.466208815574646,
-0.06306766718626022,
-1.1175693273544312,
0.34751659631729126,
-0.37299269437789917,
0.3476316034793854,
0.3438507914543152,
0.549134373664856,
-0.6877353191375732,
-0.6673640608787537,
-0.711391806602478,
-0.6662210822105408,
0.5628467202186584,
0.08225398510694504,
0.06492938101291656,
0.3598840832710266,
0.7913401126861572,
0.02831871807575226,
0.35984596610069275,
-0.4103320837020874,
-0.2878864109516144,
-0.023673320189118385,
0.20490893721580505,
-0.12560923397541046,
-0.6500117778778076,
-0.11653782427310944,
-0.6196522116661072,
0.563389241695404,
0.3680538535118103,
-0.22281035780906677,
0.39708179235458374,
-0.44809818267822266,
-0.3118891716003418,
0.550062894821167,
0.5308917164802551,
1.0122321844100952,
-0.21659334003925323,
0.21056100726127625,
0.502213180065155,
-0.29034650325775146,
0.11904832720756531,
-0.03704452887177467,
-0.3273707628250122,
-0.3040441870689392,
0.7347526550292969,
0.8550556302070618,
0.4225330948829651,
-0.2375812977552414,
0.18504974246025085,
0.1272231936454773,
-0.46318379044532776,
0.2404424548149109,
0.1266043782234192,
0.1988714337348938,
0.19553227722644806,
0.4066033959388733,
0.11135721206665039,
-0.0072917756624519825,
-0.6548011302947998,
-0.1277320384979248,
0.17811115086078644,
0.021229462698101997,
-0.19674821197986603,
0.42353135347366333,
-0.06899488717317581,
-0.4259754419326782,
0.3862445056438446,
-0.23109634220600128,
-0.7076579332351685,
0.4884384572505951,
0.45482224225997925,
0.4932847321033478,
-0.27998337149620056,
0.1360704004764557,
0.05058877170085907,
0.4846400320529938,
0.2545214891433716,
-0.14963418245315552,
0.22962363064289093,
-0.9493222236633301,
-0.5003563165664673,
-0.41224321722984314,
-0.7618179321289062,
0.37852180004119873,
-0.44494199752807617,
0.07578401267528534,
-0.5012433528900146,
-0.14430974423885345,
0.3196708858013153,
-0.13602688908576965,
-0.5545682907104492,
0.17790862917900085,
-0.31484246253967285,
0.9452864527702332,
-0.7405747175216675,
0.7343247532844543,
1.077506184577942,
-0.12074168026447296,
-0.7660292983055115,
0.32916226983070374,
0.34039008617401123,
-0.47773048281669617,
0.4480307996273041,
-0.5433233976364136,
-0.12350604683160782,
0.11909643560647964,
-0.6253254413604736,
-0.7806549668312073,
0.7615242004394531,
0.46093690395355225,
-0.678585946559906,
-0.43835529685020447,
0.14761167764663696,
0.5944974422454834,
-0.2615349590778351,
-0.13292784988880157,
0.8465567827224731,
0.676882266998291,
0.17881636321544647,
-0.8928487300872803,
0.014859294518828392,
-0.2763051390647888,
-0.16241085529327393,
-0.063618965446949,
-0.25628361105918884,
1.0118588209152222,
-0.4646613299846649,
-0.0323106124997139,
0.08117806911468506,
0.2858865261077881,
-0.022622736170887947,
0.15766887366771698,
0.5750184655189514,
0.8161346316337585,
0.8527002930641174,
0.10315368324518204,
0.8179704546928406,
-0.11273710429668427,
0.1215309351682663,
1.2834903001785278,
-0.24962863326072693,
0.6257720589637756,
0.4700125753879547,
-0.2242880016565323,
0.723478376865387,
0.3223698139190674,
0.23139701783657074,
0.012519177049398422,
0.3930169343948364,
-0.2427503913640976,
-0.3827364444732666,
0.021406719461083412,
-0.3139495551586151,
0.3988368809223175,
0.4411836862564087,
-0.018347688019275665,
-0.09388832002878189,
-0.03853969648480415,
0.38446226716041565,
0.14368614554405212,
-0.159817174077034,
0.8345121741294861,
-0.14197741448879242,
-0.5067691206932068,
0.4967789947986603,
0.04279132932424545,
0.628524899482727,
-0.3857473134994507,
-0.01816992275416851,
-0.13137929141521454,
-0.32993370294570923,
-0.48785895109176636,
-0.969649612903595,
0.13595333695411682,
0.27150771021842957,
-0.23964881896972656,
-0.062351394444704056,
0.4800858199596405,
-0.2299036681652069,
-0.31566545367240906,
0.23905979096889496,
0.8890236020088196,
-0.07140879333019257,
-0.11317720264196396,
-0.495737761259079,
0.058928318321704865,
-0.08399386703968048,
-0.2020338475704193,
0.33469313383102417,
0.886479914188385,
-0.1008228287100792,
0.6174666285514832,
0.6231269836425781,
0.30559661984443665,
-0.04058489948511124,
-0.04002562165260315,
0.8079721331596375,
-0.7162843942642212,
-0.27510765194892883,
-0.732528805732727,
0.5140934586524963,
0.07114860415458679,
-0.5772151947021484,
0.7472638487815857,
0.2971336841583252,
0.9169744253158569,
0.1182902529835701,
0.8532254695892334,
0.016758134588599205,
0.3779695928096771,
-0.5787257552146912,
0.7419621348381042,
-0.5794072151184082,
0.6710809469223022,
-0.8355128765106201,
-0.6158038973808289,
-0.37750548124313354,
0.249578595161438,
-0.7816513776779175,
-0.2381456047296524,
0.9341395497322083,
0.8430171608924866,
0.16889041662216187,
0.04960157722234726,
0.44702988862991333,
0.97986900806427,
-0.03804947808384895,
0.5649440288543701,
1.1308565139770508,
-0.1104680746793747,
0.23346951603889465,
-0.5863015055656433,
-0.3767153322696686,
-0.004931147675961256,
-0.9041914343833923,
-0.7732508778572083,
-0.5021778345108032,
-0.3251160681247711,
-0.2203332632780075,
0.6222510933876038,
0.7760635018348694,
0.3797531723976135,
-0.5537625551223755,
-0.17520636320114136,
0.14180319011211395,
0.7817278504371643,
-0.04215945675969124,
-0.13059839606285095,
0.34124496579170227,
-0.2323666661977768,
-0.47218725085258484,
0.19410470128059387,
0.10727853327989578,
0.03139318898320198,
0.005974593572318554,
0.06887926906347275,
-0.4627622961997986,
0.07108346372842789,
0.6619223356246948,
0.07564163953065872,
-0.6098944544792175,
-0.2915075421333313,
-0.08070456236600876,
0.012848097831010818,
0.07951577007770538,
0.7645846009254456,
-0.6220316290855408,
0.4579694867134094,
0.35802924633026123,
0.6529813408851624,
0.2684749364852905,
0.19406162202358246,
0.3886590898036957,
-0.31490927934646606,
-0.2572895288467407,
-0.04002247005701065,
0.19050009548664093,
0.3338490128517151,
-0.4637013077735901,
0.16362011432647705,
0.4908480942249298,
-0.3879498839378357,
-0.8256486058235168,
0.07053903490304947,
-0.629856526851654,
-0.3593316078186035,
1.0107630491256714,
-0.2580821216106415,
-0.026274286210536957,
-0.23952443897724152,
-0.23011022806167603,
0.28727346658706665,
0.0024574005510658026,
1.0382195711135864,
1.1175860166549683,
-0.2597857117652893,
0.0056775412522256374,
-0.5021615624427795,
0.606011152267456,
0.703223466873169,
-0.694834291934967,
0.07647351920604706,
0.46822401881217957,
0.4117072522640228,
0.03623555600643158,
0.26004377007484436,
-0.13953053951263428,
0.42525219917297363,
-0.20110614597797394,
-0.14017941057682037,
-0.16301551461219788,
-0.4662257134914398,
-0.4275859594345093,
0.37083202600479126,
0.3217179775238037,
0.5004757642745972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17245v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17245v1 | Unlocking Continual Learning Abilities in Language Models | 2024-06-25T03:24:06 | 2024-06-25T03:24:06 | Wenyu Du, Shuang Cheng, Tongxu Luo, Zihan Qiu, Zeyu Huang, Ka Chun Cheung, Reynold Cheng, Jie Fu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Language models (LMs) exhibit impressive performance and generalization
capabilities. However, LMs struggle with the persistent challenge of
catastrophic forgetting, which undermines their long-term sustainability in
continual learning (CL). Existing approaches usually address the issue by
incorporating old task data or task-wise inductive bias into LMs. However, old
data and accurate task information are often unavailable or costly to collect,
hindering the availability of current CL approaches for LMs. To address this
limitation, we introduce $\textbf{MIGU}$ ($\textbf{M}$agn$\textbf{I}$tude-based
$\textbf{G}$radient $\textbf{U}$pdating for continual learning), a
rehearsal-free and task-label-free method that only updates the model
parameters with large magnitudes of output in LMs' linear layers. MIGU is based
on our observation that the L1-normalized magnitude distribution of the output
in LMs' linear layers is different when the LM models deal with different task
data. By imposing this simple constraint on the gradient update process, we can
leverage the inherent behaviors of LMs, thereby unlocking their innate CL
abilities. Our experiments demonstrate that MIGU is universally applicable to
all three LM architectures (T5, RoBERTa, and Llama2), delivering
state-of-the-art or on-par performance across continual finetuning and
continual pre-training settings on four CL benchmarks. For example, MIGU brings
a 15.2% average accuracy improvement over conventional parameter-efficient
finetuning baselines in a 15-task CL benchmark. MIGU can also seamlessly
integrate with all three existing CL types to further enhance performance. Code
is available at \href{https://github.com/wenyudu/MIGU}{this https URL}. | [
-0.08358871191740036,
-0.7363947033882141,
0.4055437743663788,
0.27477726340293884,
-0.10259601473808289,
0.22098106145858765,
-0.6341675519943237,
-0.34577661752700806,
-0.2482534646987915,
0.2665749192237854,
-0.4494223892688751,
-0.5022714734077454,
-0.3730752170085907,
-0.22757212817668915,
-0.1343722939491272,
0.8968145251274109,
0.07895826548337936,
0.1749494969844818,
-0.16645120084285736,
-0.49171239137649536,
-0.8171307444572449,
-0.3499560058116913,
-1.0641164779663086,
-0.6595258116722107,
0.8788595199584961,
0.45774200558662415,
0.41283971071243286,
0.45875057578086853,
0.07810518890619278,
0.17617224156856537,
-0.05102080851793289,
0.18187391757965088,
-0.7231091260910034,
0.05799397453665733,
-0.22868987917900085,
-0.363881915807724,
-0.3013879358768463,
-0.10103382915258408,
1.0394994020462036,
0.7355594038963318,
-0.24706412851810455,
-0.1606348752975464,
0.6048985719680786,
0.8622832894325256,
-0.5676330327987671,
0.22149039804935455,
-0.9220584630966187,
-0.1807769536972046,
-0.24429437518119812,
0.06698382645845413,
-0.4774944484233856,
-0.19831159710884094,
0.05774657800793648,
-0.37956634163856506,
-0.012867901474237442,
-0.2818022668361664,
1.2006477117538452,
0.29589876532554626,
-0.059479910880327225,
-0.19620493054389954,
-0.9880478978157043,
0.9379326701164246,
-0.6302234530448914,
0.6073116660118103,
0.19018198549747467,
0.30226579308509827,
-0.3110496401786804,
-0.5543527603149414,
-0.12379182130098343,
-0.5885931253433228,
0.05095994099974632,
0.2343239039182663,
-0.07376809418201447,
0.1681416630744934,
-0.08794618397951126,
0.534652590751648,
-0.3817157447338104,
0.3307551443576813,
-0.017772145569324493,
-0.009320405311882496,
0.27073803544044495,
-0.02163916639983654,
0.24783197045326233,
0.20994168519973755,
-0.27921926975250244,
0.13137677311897278,
-0.698302686214447,
0.045077186077833176,
0.04519028961658478,
0.10808504372835159,
-0.07939143478870392,
0.009609850123524666,
-0.03516073152422905,
0.7303286790847778,
0.03274962678551674,
-0.06231357157230377,
0.14522168040275574,
0.011972172185778618,
-0.1543481945991516,
-0.48924440145492554,
0.5958860516548157,
-0.10833518952131271,
0.26023775339126587,
-0.7392726540565491,
-0.3932543098926544,
0.01693183183670044,
0.24284058809280396,
-0.31879669427871704,
-0.30974993109703064,
0.18344449996948242,
0.03678407520055771,
-0.07126806676387787,
-0.01363635715097189,
-0.5508826375007629,
0.09508227556943893,
-0.49792352318763733,
0.5656456351280212,
-0.6156671047210693,
-0.3783031404018402,
0.12315059453248978,
0.1712159812450409,
0.1544979363679886,
0.127099871635437,
-0.8092250227928162,
0.2792609930038452,
0.5230727791786194,
0.9676883816719055,
-0.5337697863578796,
-0.5055897235870361,
-0.6424152851104736,
0.3496231734752655,
-0.3129023611545563,
0.5652475357055664,
-0.45124077796936035,
-0.2784256339073181,
-0.10459401458501816,
0.14742131531238556,
-0.39406901597976685,
-0.7398676872253418,
0.3036687970161438,
-0.39164939522743225,
-0.12833915650844574,
-0.1800691932439804,
-0.5035691857337952,
-0.04382146894931793,
0.1083991676568985,
-0.5582042336463928,
1.139265537261963,
0.3057657480239868,
-0.3128139078617096,
0.3034403622150421,
-0.6535404324531555,
-0.2702604830265045,
0.16519680619239807,
-0.058132629841566086,
-0.6792668700218201,
0.14613252878189087,
-0.05601460859179497,
0.4290756583213806,
-0.11980711668729782,
0.7214800715446472,
-0.2495052069425583,
-0.29804661870002747,
0.04565918445587158,
-0.4833090305328369,
0.5384405255317688,
0.23499850928783417,
-0.3638036549091339,
0.14326584339141846,
-0.6631669998168945,
-0.2831450402736664,
0.20508000254631042,
-0.5198810696601868,
-0.2296685427427292,
0.04340379312634468,
-0.2048867642879486,
0.04690937325358391,
0.22191007435321808,
-0.3741382658481598,
0.22208650410175323,
-0.1865585446357727,
0.38873612880706787,
0.9628084301948547,
-0.04458232969045639,
0.5159135460853577,
-0.7127603888511658,
0.452255517244339,
0.13175366818904877,
0.159882053732872,
-0.09346617758274078,
-0.24078480899333954,
-1.1591438055038452,
-0.2007680982351303,
0.2516011595726013,
0.6636349558830261,
-0.6121160984039307,
0.19868002831935883,
-0.43633320927619934,
-0.8148475289344788,
-0.20827007293701172,
0.617277204990387,
0.5858854651451111,
0.564563512802124,
0.48418837785720825,
-0.16379229724407196,
-0.3098357617855072,
-0.5956259965896606,
-0.3280385136604309,
-0.07452179491519928,
-0.11815811693668365,
0.4804931879043579,
0.25855329632759094,
-0.25975528359413147,
0.7731038331985474,
-0.1131429374217987,
-0.2643250524997711,
-0.41859200596809387,
0.13953779637813568,
0.16816513240337372,
0.92789226770401,
0.5317420959472656,
-0.36670950055122375,
-0.34226927161216736,
0.1876678466796875,
-1.0279356241226196,
-0.1230582743883133,
-0.649319589138031,
-0.28375449776649475,
0.4249555468559265,
0.515137791633606,
-0.5012721419334412,
0.12940151989459991,
0.5830839276313782,
-0.10993794351816177,
0.664217472076416,
-0.19564266502857208,
-0.24869254231452942,
-0.8137023448944092,
0.25679218769073486,
0.10630926489830017,
-0.27106115221977234,
-0.6923883557319641,
0.24285265803337097,
0.14437690377235413,
-0.07364723086357117,
-0.38329312205314636,
0.6716820597648621,
-0.625011146068573,
0.18194498121738434,
-0.11066476255655289,
0.004524607211351395,
-0.07487334311008453,
0.8116137385368347,
-0.21855056285858154,
0.6121198534965515,
0.8673484325408936,
-1.1081445217132568,
-0.04220772162079811,
-0.22128665447235107,
-0.19528067111968994,
0.34141337871551514,
-0.6651430726051331,
0.3309602737426758,
-0.24119725823402405,
0.09449956566095352,
-0.6111564636230469,
-0.029078856110572815,
0.32116955518722534,
-0.3110339045524597,
0.6578558683395386,
-0.4382728040218353,
-0.43749094009399414,
-0.1941681057214737,
0.18078382313251495,
0.16697588562965393,
0.5313768982887268,
-0.51377934217453,
1.0081205368041992,
0.3287684917449951,
-0.052505943924188614,
-0.46736693382263184,
-0.47839948534965515,
0.29007548093795776,
-0.31229153275489807,
-0.3554152548313141,
0.3447332978248596,
-0.3524799346923828,
-0.06798683851957321,
-0.01598900370299816,
-0.29299139976501465,
0.1564788967370987,
0.35331201553344727,
0.07734907418489456,
0.39394518733024597,
-0.1481538861989975,
0.42219990491867065,
0.11141949892044067,
-0.1968144029378891,
-0.06318704783916473,
-0.7889768481254578,
0.715056300163269,
-0.3013685941696167,
-0.03798062726855278,
-0.31978365778923035,
0.12273520231246948,
0.6263114809989929,
-0.2751491367816925,
0.8213978409767151,
0.6608977913856506,
-0.496472030878067,
-0.24664635956287384,
-0.8640231490135193,
-0.008805293589830399,
-0.4757760167121887,
0.23700553178787231,
-0.43624699115753174,
-0.9048586487770081,
0.6233134269714355,
-0.16685982048511505,
0.3718900680541992,
0.31305038928985596,
0.2366572916507721,
-0.21619322896003723,
0.558025598526001,
0.6817731261253357,
-0.4177672266960144,
0.6900328993797302,
-0.4492467939853668,
-0.21372194588184357,
-0.7662390470504761,
-0.4372558295726776,
-0.31732138991355896,
-0.2297353893518448,
-0.09122079610824585,
-0.08526041358709335,
0.35843607783317566,
0.6925495266914368,
-0.029586322605609894,
0.34048303961753845,
-0.27407029271125793,
0.44156453013420105,
0.48574650287628174,
0.3627023994922638,
0.08954209089279175,
-0.02812601998448372,
-0.37346887588500977,
0.18659472465515137,
-0.9597307443618774,
-0.17233455181121826,
0.9985554218292236,
0.2963458299636841,
0.6788946986198425,
0.06937514990568161,
0.6929408311843872,
0.29136383533477783,
0.44465333223342896,
-0.6157543063163757,
0.5933384895324707,
-0.10614846646785736,
-0.08875880390405655,
-0.2385660707950592,
-0.5355067253112793,
-1.0128308534622192,
-0.08011351525783539,
-0.0677729994058609,
-0.7186570763587952,
-0.02769577130675316,
0.5367478132247925,
-0.05601944401860237,
0.5741469860076904,
-0.668953537940979,
0.7781606912612915,
-0.2503567636013031,
-0.6379839181900024,
-0.3291204273700714,
-0.394970566034317,
0.10007334500551224,
-0.16557611525058746,
0.006874272134155035,
-0.09478544443845749,
0.1670232117176056,
0.5911262631416321,
-0.16161222755908966,
0.822516918182373,
-0.39851129055023193,
-0.19340717792510986,
0.34649381041526794,
0.2343212068080902,
0.6031602621078491,
0.22137653827667236,
0.06660763919353485,
0.4047318398952484,
-0.3385143280029297,
-0.7130358815193176,
-0.5158933401107788,
1.0768195390701294,
-0.5769724249839783,
-0.8060752749443054,
-0.2790796756744385,
-0.6749646067619324,
-0.32008883357048035,
0.17405234277248383,
0.07010672986507416,
0.6115778088569641,
-0.02992323972284794,
0.10154327005147934,
0.7781078815460205,
-0.15631596744060516,
0.5483214855194092,
0.3867688775062561,
-0.08070801198482513,
-0.3419157862663269,
1.2883927822113037,
0.13622470200061798,
0.5292513370513916,
0.15057937800884247,
0.3873920738697052,
-0.11987579613924026,
-0.6034405827522278,
-0.4226062595844269,
0.42874228954315186,
-0.6258069276809692,
-0.19858869910240173,
-0.7953526973724365,
-0.3764081299304962,
-0.08913245052099228,
-0.20158541202545166,
-0.23035123944282532,
-0.05832953378558159,
-0.4263230562210083,
-0.014095889404416084,
0.22354722023010254,
0.5452200174331665,
-0.33044394850730896,
0.043612074106931686,
-0.7785992622375488,
0.305703729391098,
0.39003437757492065,
0.4633201062679291,
0.28770363330841064,
-0.5491049289703369,
-0.4639829695224762,
0.0744968131184578,
-0.30099475383758545,
-0.5570257306098938,
0.125334233045578,
0.5598026514053345,
0.7286803722381592,
0.3614068925380707,
-0.2658228278160095,
0.7966407537460327,
-0.4668301045894623,
0.7317646741867065,
-0.05322038009762764,
-0.8078464865684509,
0.699988067150116,
-0.5483092665672302,
0.6938955187797546,
0.47013235092163086,
0.37621793150901794,
-0.5889348983764648,
-0.8583476543426514,
-0.49945691227912903,
-0.7227889895439148,
0.4164619445800781,
0.1536722630262375,
0.20669107139110565,
-0.13276703655719757,
0.49503597617149353,
0.1642751842737198,
-0.21056506037712097,
-0.8247830867767334,
-0.357956200838089,
-0.29173439741134644,
-0.05085097253322601,
0.014162981882691383,
-0.20197069644927979,
0.15785883367061615,
-0.39473849534988403,
0.8779535293579102,
-0.0032974823843687773,
0.2264096885919571,
0.09749617427587509,
-0.4065355360507965,
0.11162447929382324,
0.2314128875732422,
0.5208179950714111,
0.743713915348053,
-0.14554718136787415,
-0.14779217541217804,
0.3617272973060608,
-0.4851383864879608,
0.053230248391628265,
-0.04273659735918045,
-0.337185800075531,
0.23448088765144348,
0.0376448892056942,
0.6753625273704529,
0.38445886969566345,
-0.5852171778678894,
-0.021068233996629715,
0.24862416088581085,
-0.030290858820080757,
-0.6765118837356567,
0.32683295011520386,
0.12516245245933533,
-0.011264379136264324,
0.5100794434547424,
0.2515653073787689,
-0.2677995562553406,
-0.3791387379169464,
0.3745439946651459,
0.3620688319206238,
-0.6434276700019836,
-0.34485942125320435,
0.8156933188438416,
0.08494850248098373,
-0.07392716407775879,
0.530681848526001,
-0.3477151095867157,
-0.23792000114917755,
0.364879846572876,
0.7098807692527771,
0.9414829015731812,
-0.3079325258731842,
0.01316856499761343,
0.5641952157020569,
0.11651419848203659,
-0.2000369131565094,
0.08110526204109192,
-0.01130696851760149,
-0.7126147150993347,
-0.39723119139671326,
-0.635842502117157,
-0.1297180950641632,
0.4711854159832001,
-0.6356832981109619,
0.11099676787853241,
-0.652795135974884,
-0.04497349634766579,
-0.48099076747894287,
-0.30569055676460266,
-0.5844869613647461,
0.14672119915485382,
0.02999540977180004,
0.6742510199546814,
-0.5023192167282104,
1.1783853769302368,
0.34324270486831665,
-0.3157697319984436,
-0.6392935514450073,
-0.1222756877541542,
0.10821232199668884,
-0.6249744296073914,
0.3874802589416504,
0.1861240416765213,
-0.3887101411819458,
0.38799360394477844,
-0.47643887996673584,
-0.648422360420227,
1.203494906425476,
0.4155445098876953,
-0.785141110420227,
-0.24835407733917236,
-0.0859275832772255,
0.24180416762828827,
-0.1526375263929367,
-0.24825221300125122,
0.6719823479652405,
0.3082277774810791,
-0.05510175973176956,
-0.6027379035949707,
-0.2061540186405182,
-0.3050667643547058,
-0.06919171661138535,
0.2569042146205902,
-0.6314805150032043,
0.5441988110542297,
-0.22137953341007233,
-0.5268890261650085,
0.2530541718006134,
0.8443703055381775,
0.3580206334590912,
0.12632451951503754,
0.5491572618484497,
0.864227831363678,
0.7265586853027344,
-0.3674708604812622,
0.8883715271949768,
-0.49832475185394287,
0.37016838788986206,
1.1738289594650269,
0.13481824100017548,
0.5222083330154419,
0.2526773512363434,
0.16975054144859314,
0.6030868291854858,
0.28612858057022095,
-0.10493946075439453,
0.37103885412216187,
0.20272068679332733,
-0.5927030444145203,
-0.33012649416923523,
-0.2777198255062103,
-0.14011555910110474,
0.15373824536800385,
0.5055099725723267,
0.007157627958804369,
-0.12958994507789612,
0.23684799671173096,
0.4538767635822296,
0.1600235104560852,
-0.5926036834716797,
0.7106857299804688,
0.1829836070537567,
-0.70139080286026,
0.9689132571220398,
-0.11855792254209518,
0.7737691402435303,
-0.8616106510162354,
-0.05612943693995476,
-0.5311476588249207,
0.08349759131669998,
0.03171040117740631,
-0.3220292925834656,
0.20144516229629517,
0.003304326208308339,
0.07878420501947403,
-0.09020712971687317,
0.6049829125404358,
-0.6211548447608948,
-0.47324031591415405,
0.4015555679798126,
0.30935725569725037,
-0.10902449488639832,
0.07217995822429657,
-0.611060619354248,
0.04916141554713249,
-0.17523863911628723,
0.07314551621675491,
0.29556214809417725,
0.19536800682544708,
0.10735032707452774,
1.1825463771820068,
0.6352492570877075,
0.21772684156894684,
0.0898049920797348,
0.2677176892757416,
0.8653143644332886,
-0.5472116470336914,
-0.24807389080524445,
-0.7822726964950562,
0.6176241040229797,
0.13733088970184326,
-0.3003508448600769,
0.502501368522644,
0.3713255524635315,
1.1047964096069336,
-0.23699262738227844,
0.6692606806755066,
0.07159854471683502,
0.20346437394618988,
-0.963363766670227,
0.8972710967063904,
-0.6242413520812988,
0.24245984852313995,
-0.18277400732040405,
-0.8963594436645508,
-0.3590250313282013,
0.24269643425941467,
-0.023018252104520798,
0.05110152065753937,
0.7786210179328918,
0.7208213806152344,
-0.08485066890716553,
-0.4728185832500458,
0.47151869535446167,
0.2479267120361328,
0.3287048637866974,
0.929894745349884,
0.5849897861480713,
-0.2918040454387665,
0.5915141105651855,
-0.1835637241601944,
-0.12756340205669403,
0.1853400021791458,
-0.547903835773468,
-1.0064544677734375,
-0.6263666749000549,
-0.43509599566459656,
-0.3623116910457611,
0.3776695728302002,
0.6268168687820435,
0.4761119484901428,
-0.8080214858055115,
-0.320454478263855,
-0.40855711698532104,
-0.053619932383298874,
-0.4603908956050873,
-0.24813705682754517,
0.27263185381889343,
-0.7652413249015808,
-0.7817142605781555,
0.5370266437530518,
0.38734206557273865,
0.15221063792705536,
-0.22757598757743835,
-0.4308698773384094,
-0.26182135939598083,
0.020010381937026978,
0.39504116773605347,
0.6601507663726807,
-0.8291277885437012,
-0.564583957195282,
-0.006098367739468813,
0.01548156701028347,
0.24374036490917206,
0.5336365103721619,
-0.984307050704956,
0.29839858412742615,
-0.08938877284526825,
1.0353792905807495,
0.26165810227394104,
-0.3604511618614197,
0.5826994180679321,
-0.7292126417160034,
-0.012831714004278183,
0.19556722044944763,
0.486374169588089,
0.27425050735473633,
-0.18949361145496368,
0.513052761554718,
0.3758566379547119,
-0.6204593181610107,
-0.5270761251449585,
0.43397414684295654,
-1.0918129682540894,
-0.1226610541343689,
1.100460171699524,
-0.40337687730789185,
-0.017378831282258034,
-0.23335330188274384,
0.10121605545282364,
0.36889973282814026,
-0.36163297295570374,
0.8159393668174744,
0.6015056371688843,
0.42914018034935,
-0.40436697006225586,
-0.4477158188819885,
0.40443453192710876,
0.6393570303916931,
-0.6724779009819031,
0.004924717824906111,
0.37721455097198486,
0.5060548782348633,
-0.2521030902862549,
0.4071859121322632,
-0.25210800766944885,
0.35067152976989746,
-0.3843318521976471,
-0.013883878476917744,
-0.22401432693004608,
-0.7742798924446106,
-0.4382091164588928,
-0.17309880256652832,
0.2685932517051697,
-0.05996708199381828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17241v1 | What Do the Circuits Mean? A Knowledge Edit View | 2024-06-25T03:09:53 | 2024-06-25T03:09:53 | Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of language model interpretability, circuit discovery is gaining
popularity. Despite this, the true meaning of these circuits remain largely
unanswered. We introduce a novel method to learn their meanings as a holistic
object through the lens of knowledge editing. We extract circuits in the
GPT2-XL model using diverse text classification datasets, and use hierarchical
relations datasets to explore knowledge editing in the circuits. Our findings
indicate that these circuits contain entity knowledge but resist new knowledge
more than complementary circuits during knowledge editing. Additionally, we
examine the impact of circuit size, discovering that an ideal "theoretical
circuit" where essential knowledge is concentrated likely incorporates more
than 5% but less than 50% of the model's parameters. We also assess the overlap
between circuits from different datasets, finding moderate similarities. What
constitutes these circuits, then? We find that up to 60% of the circuits
consist of layer normalization modules rather than attention or MLP modules,
adding evidence to the ongoing debates regarding knowledge localization. In
summary, our findings offer new insights into the functions of the circuits,
and introduce research directions for further interpretability and safety
research of language models. | [
-0.24201369285583496,
-0.7690326571464539,
0.9707234501838684,
-0.41710183024406433,
-0.08407888561487198,
0.22033801674842834,
-0.06970660388469696,
-0.4546315371990204,
-0.08751305937767029,
0.48217156529426575,
-0.31000733375549316,
-0.25193148851394653,
-0.6537154912948608,
-0.27817338705062866,
-0.42203691601753235,
0.9953050017356873,
-0.2928890585899353,
-0.3490857481956482,
-0.03674175962805748,
0.07480613887310028,
-0.4069254994392395,
-0.3753873109817505,
-0.15169045329093933,
-0.35169297456741333,
0.7650134563446045,
0.18377329409122467,
0.9380115270614624,
0.8062740564346313,
0.4060765504837036,
0.26856619119644165,
-0.4477350115776062,
0.05902552232146263,
0.03325205296278,
-0.1788349449634552,
-0.4400560259819031,
-0.5710270404815674,
-0.4994525611400604,
0.036007918417453766,
0.37960705161094666,
1.0161914825439453,
0.1434435248374939,
0.0634126290678978,
-0.12343189120292664,
0.7168530821800232,
-0.6155388355255127,
0.2987176477909088,
-0.9423266649246216,
0.07885762304067612,
-0.27521777153015137,
-0.0007239718688651919,
-0.5481386780738831,
-0.064582459628582,
0.2152068316936493,
-0.7381102442741394,
0.12660542130470276,
0.20554713904857635,
0.8319798707962036,
-0.12290115654468536,
-0.7049566507339478,
-0.3115357756614685,
-0.785182535648346,
0.49942225217819214,
-0.32773318886756897,
0.4426787793636322,
0.20157018303871155,
0.2833866775035858,
0.12809336185455322,
-1.0006344318389893,
-0.7234342694282532,
0.21113692224025726,
-0.2808440625667572,
-0.018951203674077988,
-0.3998875916004181,
0.40856435894966125,
0.48280593752861023,
0.3505187928676605,
-0.1993863433599472,
-0.314693421125412,
-0.6049590110778809,
-0.18561215698719025,
0.2749790549278259,
-0.013926033861935139,
0.8151708841323853,
-0.4461897313594818,
0.0726790651679039,
0.4014418125152588,
-0.8568591475486755,
-0.08364469558000565,
0.444738507270813,
0.04683917388319969,
0.10713174939155579,
0.5681742429733276,
-0.08166447281837463,
0.8220199942588806,
-0.058902714401483536,
0.11529680341482162,
-0.04252665489912033,
-0.16935628652572632,
-0.5215780735015869,
0.16409239172935486,
0.5749756097793579,
0.18165497481822968,
0.5932685732841492,
-0.46195992827415466,
0.02755068987607956,
-0.2895578145980835,
0.40265771746635437,
-0.4665549695491791,
-0.8098800778388977,
-0.10419783741235733,
-0.4704979658126831,
-0.37238091230392456,
0.08537548780441284,
-0.31493839621543884,
-0.24061468243598938,
-0.6318127512931824,
0.4797350764274597,
-0.27787357568740845,
-0.3540878891944885,
0.23367655277252197,
-0.2827731668949127,
-0.047199349850416183,
0.21613278985023499,
-1.2578164339065552,
0.534606397151947,
0.43311071395874023,
0.711363673210144,
0.11852211505174637,
-0.22026784718036652,
-0.013244927860796452,
0.2761602997779846,
-0.2968641221523285,
0.8180692791938782,
-0.4770973026752472,
-0.37375012040138245,
-0.4545951187610626,
0.2721382677555084,
-0.31226617097854614,
-0.36104583740234375,
0.3689296841621399,
-1.0303350687026978,
0.1412215679883957,
-0.51850426197052,
-0.5165519118309021,
-0.21421417593955994,
-0.14855825901031494,
-0.744551420211792,
0.8278027772903442,
0.14321045577526093,
-1.1958996057510376,
0.16376589238643646,
-0.5704953074455261,
-0.7308762073516846,
-0.21938443183898926,
0.03284324333071709,
0.050639547407627106,
0.2587701976299286,
0.02876129560172558,
0.07204846292734146,
-0.036622755229473114,
0.21930059790611267,
-0.20458993315696716,
-0.00625503808259964,
0.2858501672744751,
-0.26306313276290894,
0.7614638805389404,
0.11520013213157654,
-0.35136550664901733,
0.17788751423358917,
-0.7378835082054138,
-0.0018570980755612254,
-0.1621672660112381,
0.15579883754253387,
-0.5618129372596741,
0.31357625126838684,
0.006133312359452248,
0.4711892604827881,
-0.0997120663523674,
-0.6135867834091187,
0.13942821323871613,
-0.7705487012863159,
0.980381965637207,
0.8291805386543274,
0.30879244208335876,
0.6899687647819519,
0.030911166220903397,
0.28368881344795227,
0.051851239055395126,
0.28719615936279297,
-0.14443357288837433,
-0.7371600270271301,
-0.7624086141586304,
0.4499230682849884,
0.3106350302696228,
0.49558204412460327,
-0.6444037556648254,
0.5560139417648315,
-0.09502039104700089,
-0.4174782633781433,
-0.34243670105934143,
0.1660386025905609,
0.11072266846895218,
0.709006130695343,
0.4884156286716461,
-0.05794069543480873,
-0.3626399338245392,
-1.1066569089889526,
-0.530005931854248,
-0.2908019423484802,
-0.122096948325634,
0.09123915433883667,
0.6105678081512451,
-0.03911086916923523,
0.9632284641265869,
-0.7125428915023804,
0.019907431676983833,
-0.25842341780662537,
-0.08670930564403534,
-0.05687903240323067,
0.19321660697460175,
0.2111680954694748,
-0.5462653040885925,
-0.2914488613605499,
0.48892199993133545,
-0.8675128221511841,
0.2538393437862396,
-0.18660138547420502,
-0.26662057638168335,
-0.2941703796386719,
0.42355847358703613,
-0.568814754486084,
0.4987398684024811,
0.040646400302648544,
-0.14913949370384216,
0.30627554655075073,
-0.2452123463153839,
0.016704684123396873,
-0.90566086769104,
-0.18773424625396729,
-0.2262801229953766,
0.03935202956199646,
-0.7123895287513733,
0.054628606885671616,
0.3592173457145691,
0.184254452586174,
-0.37846893072128296,
0.5656562447547913,
-0.5767431259155273,
-0.13858042657375336,
-0.344743013381958,
0.5295053720474243,
0.35656818747520447,
0.3507053852081299,
-0.04730600118637085,
0.49562564492225647,
0.44325634837150574,
-0.36655983328819275,
0.4318174123764038,
0.29079878330230713,
-0.6492180824279785,
0.22828400135040283,
-0.6755104660987854,
0.3369496166706085,
0.04478489235043526,
-0.2177198827266693,
-0.6823808550834656,
-0.43127045035362244,
0.01263800635933876,
-0.19616200029850006,
0.06558337807655334,
-0.024343108758330345,
-0.7791194319725037,
-0.2418605089187622,
0.04518904164433479,
0.5474970936775208,
0.3890252411365509,
-0.5318772196769714,
0.592593252658844,
0.8107835054397583,
-0.17324984073638916,
-0.12262172251939774,
-0.8009855151176453,
0.09654159843921661,
0.054389312863349915,
-0.7009081840515137,
0.2981727123260498,
0.25539761781692505,
-0.5544133186340332,
0.1912946254014969,
-0.09152065962553024,
-0.29609614610671997,
0.26553797721862793,
0.28355735540390015,
0.36297908425331116,
-0.05803292244672775,
0.7058181762695312,
0.6776496171951294,
0.011284217238426208,
0.44136834144592285,
-0.4896499812602997,
0.007043259218335152,
-0.007076360285282135,
-0.328897088766098,
-0.5287303328514099,
0.09937231242656708,
0.4050373136997223,
-0.370195209980011,
0.4911363124847412,
-0.012214279733598232,
-0.6843632459640503,
-0.02003568969666958,
-0.14785325527191162,
0.13091185688972473,
-0.4860793948173523,
0.33740749955177307,
-0.4800281226634979,
-0.9244623780250549,
0.42082804441452026,
-0.047829777002334595,
-0.2251620590686798,
0.7669935822486877,
0.4011918008327484,
0.026898596435785294,
1.0059559345245361,
0.5340948700904846,
-0.020118210464715958,
0.20115195214748383,
0.0669931173324585,
0.7461752891540527,
-1.0295859575271606,
-0.3928142488002777,
-0.3286648392677307,
-0.28520384430885315,
-0.5169573426246643,
-0.2859291136264801,
0.2858434319496155,
0.24940529465675354,
-0.38749393820762634,
0.30026161670684814,
-0.5553427338600159,
0.7941844463348389,
0.28900402784347534,
0.324978768825531,
0.5315489172935486,
0.024913517758250237,
-0.18594305217266083,
-0.1912282109260559,
-0.7011772394180298,
-0.5210975408554077,
1.1462560892105103,
0.3253355622291565,
0.6062759160995483,
-0.0043893479742109776,
0.1873723715543747,
0.13763843476772308,
0.3801115155220032,
-0.8157680630683899,
0.18360663950443268,
0.18113674223423004,
-0.7901442050933838,
-0.08396107703447342,
-0.2455013394355774,
-0.5966737866401672,
-0.10967503488063812,
0.058884162455797195,
-0.9815239310264587,
0.20761258900165558,
0.1516031175851822,
-0.34850454330444336,
0.8707225918769836,
-0.8518089652061462,
0.9607242941856384,
-0.3474704325199127,
-0.20144402980804443,
-0.13189725577831268,
-0.7427235245704651,
0.5151093602180481,
0.10069651901721954,
0.6046570539474487,
0.338485985994339,
0.3218717575073242,
0.7415630221366882,
-0.29400014877319336,
0.6522396802902222,
0.0367804579436779,
-0.15330401062965393,
0.5550048351287842,
0.21733500063419342,
0.32035842537879944,
0.04115522280335426,
0.1387299746274948,
-0.07026253640651703,
0.0455818697810173,
-0.2879069149494171,
-0.839827299118042,
0.7097172141075134,
-0.7857987284660339,
-0.5402289628982544,
-0.1382942646741867,
-0.6296689510345459,
-0.3014048635959625,
0.42125749588012695,
0.28397852182388306,
0.5489332675933838,
-0.09785658121109009,
-0.14272929728031158,
0.9852043390274048,
-0.29488635063171387,
0.08585295081138611,
-0.05226429924368858,
-0.4481506049633026,
-0.15575507283210754,
0.9267351031303406,
0.20434151589870453,
0.5522421002388,
0.6235899329185486,
-0.07830973714590073,
-0.2090945988893509,
-0.35205358266830444,
-0.45989760756492615,
0.02005046047270298,
-1.01998770236969,
0.21289053559303284,
-0.9689359664916992,
-0.416481077671051,
-0.1305638998746872,
-0.036669645458459854,
-0.11439360678195953,
-0.8019026517868042,
-0.1925635188817978,
-0.6646862626075745,
0.25336897373199463,
1.075548529624939,
0.16409330070018768,
0.4183189868927002,
-0.6621333956718445,
0.34038275480270386,
0.6557888388633728,
0.47470760345458984,
0.10619045048952103,
-0.48514777421951294,
-0.4527496099472046,
-0.16459862887859344,
-0.45065832138061523,
-1.1592583656311035,
-0.049763623625040054,
-0.0937386304140091,
0.3812488913536072,
0.27070093154907227,
-0.23193006217479706,
0.5028361678123474,
-0.6210466027259827,
0.7256085872650146,
0.06783030927181244,
-1.4730596542358398,
0.8566851019859314,
-0.17280669510364532,
0.20430895686149597,
0.2569792866706848,
-0.006065319757908583,
-0.6264819502830505,
-0.3911904990673065,
-0.8060245513916016,
-0.631841242313385,
0.5044434666633606,
0.27535611391067505,
0.3244129717350006,
-0.17414461076259613,
0.620188295841217,
-0.19070805609226227,
0.19846393167972565,
-0.7539106011390686,
-0.369672030210495,
-0.28155818581581116,
-0.20193594694137573,
0.39889034628868103,
-0.2789355516433716,
-0.16089504957199097,
-0.46429577469825745,
0.44993096590042114,
0.07411856204271317,
0.2700559198856354,
0.0577063225209713,
-0.31532326340675354,
-0.22489438951015472,
0.5405293703079224,
0.2658705413341522,
0.8352681994438171,
-0.045689310878515244,
0.6275792121887207,
0.12273146212100983,
-0.4599718451499939,
0.025201860815286636,
-0.2182031273841858,
-0.3336065113544464,
-0.032071713358163834,
0.5873935222625732,
0.9401054978370667,
0.34854406118392944,
-0.4481680691242218,
0.20147879421710968,
0.05300392955541611,
-0.19056333601474762,
0.18274228274822235,
0.19026944041252136,
0.22474908828735352,
-0.03863345459103584,
-0.06481803208589554,
0.47118523716926575,
0.5400532484054565,
-0.6381646394729614,
0.29111674427986145,
0.13075895607471466,
-0.782071590423584,
-0.7092117071151733,
0.7278308272361755,
0.15347737073898315,
-0.1159808337688446,
0.5735334157943726,
-0.19022072851657867,
-0.6254990100860596,
0.6884662508964539,
0.04576822370290756,
0.9205228090286255,
0.06456353515386581,
0.3154420852661133,
0.39209914207458496,
0.7895987629890442,
0.05097600817680359,
-0.15320785343647003,
-0.12250678986310959,
-0.8488482236862183,
-0.41015246510505676,
-0.4074666500091553,
-0.2822630703449249,
0.01376329455524683,
-0.9551705121994019,
0.11004593968391418,
-0.5648960471153259,
0.11407952010631561,
0.34761494398117065,
-0.37742188572883606,
-0.4230959415435791,
0.36711934208869934,
-0.2600758969783783,
1.0769612789154053,
-0.788574755191803,
1.2415111064910889,
0.6026419401168823,
-0.16203060746192932,
-1.0428580045700073,
0.09722646325826645,
-0.05835719034075737,
-0.43021708726882935,
0.7678539156913757,
-0.03508738800883293,
0.048562757670879364,
0.03315644711256027,
-0.2566174566745758,
-0.6175709962844849,
0.8897777199745178,
0.2177775502204895,
-0.6086530685424805,
-0.3338494896888733,
0.002747109392657876,
0.5169133543968201,
-0.19557642936706543,
0.31070074439048767,
0.9076178669929504,
0.4451485574245453,
-0.266645610332489,
-0.7139060497283936,
-0.06505036354064941,
-0.3937959671020508,
-0.01371325459331274,
0.40327003598213196,
-0.19052676856517792,
0.839996337890625,
-0.3589041233062744,
-0.1871720850467682,
-0.16966277360916138,
0.29873794317245483,
-0.13239963352680206,
0.2700301706790924,
0.22480829060077667,
0.2912167012691498,
0.8094684481620789,
-0.15150655806064606,
1.1387684345245361,
-0.45824870467185974,
0.5645937919616699,
1.3335715532302856,
-0.19851131737232208,
0.5286741256713867,
0.5529741644859314,
-0.38884443044662476,
0.7181077599525452,
0.6520721912384033,
0.25104427337646484,
0.6015214323997498,
0.25475096702575684,
-0.29479146003723145,
-0.4215810298919678,
0.213640496134758,
-0.19943517446517944,
-0.05288020148873329,
0.2543139159679413,
-0.6432633996009827,
-0.1693202257156372,
0.07846864312887192,
0.008003552444279194,
0.15535695850849152,
-0.36785873770713806,
0.5786210298538208,
0.17074671387672424,
-0.3663145899772644,
-0.13970790803432465,
0.12682099640369415,
-0.1710650622844696,
-0.19485807418823242,
0.012882443144917488,
0.04662128910422325,
0.07240403443574905,
-0.2854744493961334,
-1.1111077070236206,
0.5999975800514221,
0.009037851355969906,
-0.5873515009880066,
-0.19694124162197113,
0.8927702307701111,
-0.024877028539776802,
-0.7180352210998535,
0.41213205456733704,
0.4641048312187195,
-0.21887052059173584,
-0.2525429129600525,
-0.4150649607181549,
-0.2332616150379181,
0.03811870515346527,
-0.20235876739025116,
0.32009175419807434,
0.7762253284454346,
-0.1268957555294037,
0.3720645308494568,
0.190974622964859,
0.14922921359539032,
0.14322495460510254,
-0.09430023282766342,
1.0142046213150024,
-0.724284827709198,
-0.27172794938087463,
-0.7662730813026428,
0.6344272494316101,
-0.029841231182217598,
-0.34562307596206665,
0.5375736355781555,
0.5089918375015259,
0.9539646506309509,
0.03309588134288788,
1.214737892150879,
-0.11259093135595322,
0.31086692214012146,
-0.6770018339157104,
0.6890331506729126,
-0.26225876808166504,
0.6157410740852356,
-0.21186980605125427,
-0.5870547294616699,
-0.2893003523349762,
0.549484133720398,
-0.7353119254112244,
-0.054141171276569366,
0.9204455614089966,
0.5785491466522217,
-0.2542140781879425,
0.41841796040534973,
0.24101772904396057,
0.5157957077026367,
0.2679049074649811,
0.5803577899932861,
0.8364335298538208,
-0.7694799304008484,
0.2456285059452057,
-0.47191378474235535,
-0.16248464584350586,
0.4424169659614563,
-0.374612420797348,
-0.9828538298606873,
-0.5730936527252197,
-0.23083318769931793,
-0.23073314130306244,
0.08486513793468475,
0.4639360010623932,
0.4285394251346588,
-0.8194260001182556,
-0.1439405232667923,
-0.5894132256507874,
0.7379976511001587,
-0.04159022122621536,
-0.1917576640844345,
0.6117992401123047,
-0.3239884376525879,
-0.3836325705051422,
0.0862746462225914,
0.7111716866493225,
-0.35000357031822205,
-0.053569495677948,
0.11013052612543106,
-0.07947801798582077,
0.06129181757569313,
0.8336529731750488,
0.04473792389035225,
-0.8725884556770325,
-0.62664395570755,
0.26958632469177246,
0.13018950819969177,
-0.045546695590019226,
0.9327806830406189,
-0.6349764466285706,
0.8256090879440308,
0.26300910115242004,
0.4252401292324066,
0.31474611163139343,
-0.4281325042247772,
0.437252402305603,
-0.5391159653663635,
0.06345022469758987,
-0.23440760374069214,
0.43329524993896484,
0.13988251984119415,
-0.3254029154777527,
0.21792596578598022,
0.6279702186584473,
-0.5184988975524902,
-0.6899258494377136,
0.5101282596588135,
-0.9988614320755005,
-0.24307888746261597,
0.952392578125,
-0.12858445942401886,
-0.2154833972454071,
-0.3478379547595978,
-0.3010671138763428,
0.19282570481300354,
0.19272489845752716,
0.835351824760437,
0.8291404247283936,
-0.2634470760822296,
-0.3685467541217804,
-0.8569015860557556,
0.5110682249069214,
-0.030976610258221626,
-1.0591011047363281,
0.09080109000205994,
0.28453099727630615,
0.46233317255973816,
0.20346644520759583,
0.2843402624130249,
-0.18108727037906647,
0.37421587109565735,
-0.16487731039524078,
0.0646791011095047,
0.1334640234708786,
-0.42945995926856995,
0.03940056264400482,
0.19905738532543182,
0.15161333978176117,
0.28769955039024353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17233v1 | Self-Constructed Context Decompilation with Fined-grained Alignment Enhancement | 2024-06-25T02:37:53 | 2024-06-25T02:37:53 | Yunlong Feng, Yang Xu, Dechuan Teng, Honglin Mu, Xiao Xu, Libo Qin, Wanxiang Che, Qingfu Zhu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Decompilation transforms compiled code back into a high-level programming
language for analysis when source code is unavailable. Previous work has
primarily focused on enhancing decompilation performance by increasing the
scale of model parameters or training data for pre-training. Based on the
characteristics of the decompilation task, we propose two methods: (1) Without
fine-tuning, the Self-Constructed Context Decompilation (sc$^2$dec) method
recompiles the LLM's decompilation results to construct pairs for in-context
learning, helping the model improve decompilation performance. (2) Fine-grained
Alignment Enhancement (FAE), which meticulously aligns assembly code with
source code at the statement level by leveraging debugging information, is
employed during the fine-tuning phase to achieve further improvements in
decompilation. By integrating these two methods, we achieved a Re-Executability
performance improvement of approximately 7.35\% on the Decompile-Eval
benchmark, establishing a new state-of-the-art performance of 55.03\%. | [
-0.36782822012901306,
-0.7489511370658875,
0.30695194005966187,
0.09674529731273651,
-0.26214635372161865,
0.13148896396160126,
-0.17093457281589508,
-0.5284222364425659,
0.035945288836956024,
0.6546638607978821,
-0.40602269768714905,
-0.4053671956062317,
-0.21396572887897491,
0.02964499220252037,
-0.43044349551200867,
0.7363247275352478,
-0.11486776918172836,
-0.24968266487121582,
-0.35428041219711304,
0.05758900195360184,
-0.37762370705604553,
-0.5595210194587708,
-0.299689382314682,
0.05192633345723152,
-0.07990821450948715,
0.5369929671287537,
0.4401701092720032,
1.2419300079345703,
0.7370902299880981,
0.3889499306678772,
0.027716049924492836,
0.10180194675922394,
-0.6963208913803101,
0.09265832602977753,
-0.22055482864379883,
-0.036559224128723145,
-0.8207870125770569,
-0.17231981456279755,
0.6322493553161621,
0.3749847114086151,
-0.05677790939807892,
0.3714926242828369,
0.41880521178245544,
1.0229191780090332,
-0.9893910884857178,
0.07303300499916077,
-0.4390498101711273,
0.0004890011623501778,
-0.1472572386264801,
-0.5255036354064941,
-0.4715896546840668,
-0.1574586033821106,
-0.3967002034187317,
-0.4099510610103607,
0.3396620452404022,
-0.18311825394630432,
0.7016621828079224,
0.7934113144874573,
-0.34243783354759216,
-0.02240128070116043,
-0.6276673078536987,
0.784338653087616,
-0.7722400426864624,
0.5958569049835205,
0.19527213275432587,
0.0645756646990776,
-0.263024240732193,
-0.8287091255187988,
-0.09940691292285919,
0.15367190539836884,
-0.17645545303821564,
-0.04429943487048149,
-0.08607814460992813,
0.3650813102722168,
0.14836424589157104,
0.7226329445838928,
-0.4578167498111725,
0.1536610722541809,
-0.4530600905418396,
-0.44106853008270264,
0.7818354964256287,
0.18331769108772278,
0.2319156676530838,
-0.19934186339378357,
-0.7061880230903625,
-0.019605064764618874,
-0.7213699221611023,
-0.1636512279510498,
0.21012011170387268,
0.1760663390159607,
-0.0033266940154135227,
0.41128966212272644,
-0.3767528831958771,
0.5364333391189575,
0.19920675456523895,
-0.09099239856004715,
0.4050697088241577,
-0.5366724133491516,
-0.5648101568222046,
0.21394602954387665,
0.4190940260887146,
0.3774392008781433,
-0.2558775246143341,
-0.15861879289150238,
-0.3992299735546112,
-0.06043718010187149,
0.5257115364074707,
-1.0785187482833862,
-0.3748020529747009,
0.3715192377567291,
-0.6912396550178528,
-0.18848319351673126,
-0.1471138298511505,
-0.6303985714912415,
0.15752241015434265,
-0.5896821022033691,
0.33942344784736633,
-0.36876875162124634,
-0.0955195277929306,
-0.018151551485061646,
-0.03423071652650833,
0.45133528113365173,
0.2406872659921646,
-0.8126246333122253,
0.09601898491382599,
0.8193140625953674,
0.5257243514060974,
-0.2749811112880707,
-0.18775734305381775,
-0.7488980293273926,
0.24417418241500854,
-0.48610660433769226,
0.7580613493919373,
-0.38199788331985474,
-0.3680359423160553,
-0.32323893904685974,
0.10534588247537613,
0.17647570371627808,
-0.7307315468788147,
0.46594369411468506,
-0.5164868235588074,
-0.09509008377790451,
-0.23462361097335815,
-0.8046649098396301,
-0.09805089235305786,
0.2517101764678955,
-0.38296014070510864,
1.0940638780593872,
0.33522000908851624,
-0.5407909750938416,
0.0548316091299057,
-0.5450479984283447,
-0.36231154203414917,
-0.1600232869386673,
-0.17195920646190643,
-0.16689583659172058,
0.30949339270591736,
0.15313884615898132,
0.4261227548122406,
0.009445244446396828,
0.3191300630569458,
-0.3177788257598877,
-0.546622633934021,
-0.26708224415779114,
-0.42143678665161133,
0.6709694862365723,
0.569028377532959,
-0.3536258041858673,
0.11586035788059235,
-0.9887741804122925,
0.23426826298236847,
-0.11880475282669067,
-0.6176357865333557,
-0.2625891864299774,
-0.05840050056576729,
-0.28034070134162903,
0.18625719845294952,
0.6989154815673828,
-0.4282679855823517,
0.17215703427791595,
-0.7777021527290344,
0.10411339998245239,
0.7879154086112976,
0.06646576523780823,
0.638594388961792,
-0.07335081696510315,
0.40517109632492065,
-0.24390816688537598,
-0.10762511938810349,
-0.19275197386741638,
0.17974840104579926,
-0.7526150941848755,
-0.32705405354499817,
0.10989689826965332,
0.46623751521110535,
-0.3896631598472595,
0.5707058906555176,
-0.07886696606874466,
-0.19999128580093384,
-0.3228110373020172,
0.3559572696685791,
0.9656537175178528,
0.7791987061500549,
0.6244431138038635,
-0.2026301473379135,
-0.7151404619216919,
-1.0900497436523438,
-0.11410173028707504,
0.15894073247909546,
-0.0708872601389885,
0.009402143768966198,
0.21813185513019562,
-0.4613005518913269,
0.8448666930198669,
-0.6565275192260742,
-0.02915077470242977,
-0.015408539213240147,
0.0400116965174675,
-0.3892597258090973,
0.9364686012268066,
0.45394009351730347,
-0.4799538552761078,
-0.3046227991580963,
-0.03383396193385124,
-0.6022292375564575,
-0.36534154415130615,
0.14872382581233978,
-0.3666290044784546,
0.4785923659801483,
0.9355246424674988,
0.24385352432727814,
0.5296000242233276,
0.6860980987548828,
-0.2763768136501312,
0.7367594242095947,
-0.3392001986503601,
0.22897662222385406,
-1.2363849878311157,
0.09878844767808914,
-0.4457797706127167,
-0.21050108969211578,
-0.47122663259506226,
0.47811010479927063,
0.3304382264614105,
-0.12191611528396606,
-0.58669114112854,
0.4685783088207245,
-0.6343382596969604,
-0.49183544516563416,
-0.5557378530502319,
0.08096536248922348,
0.25891393423080444,
0.5595706701278687,
0.04670439660549164,
0.9767085909843445,
0.35867512226104736,
-0.641638994216919,
-0.10681881755590439,
0.18230976164340973,
-0.3072720468044281,
0.2887696325778961,
-0.5143078565597534,
0.1873810589313507,
-0.1028822809457779,
0.005854063201695681,
-1.1297671794891357,
-0.3319091498851776,
0.013366681523621082,
-0.10856815427541733,
0.6033301949501038,
-0.12087549269199371,
-0.02877180650830269,
0.06952790170907974,
-0.3434574007987976,
0.5978060364723206,
0.26363253593444824,
-0.8014019131660461,
0.3871985673904419,
0.21623826026916504,
-0.03849715739488602,
-0.6385419368743896,
-0.8006291389465332,
-0.1896185725927353,
-0.17761555314064026,
-0.5637547373771667,
0.7106140851974487,
-0.35710766911506653,
-0.1992860734462738,
-0.12342717498540878,
-0.5045726299285889,
-0.1599443554878235,
0.2779598534107208,
0.11244233697652817,
0.20929813385009766,
-0.37390652298927307,
0.06777553260326385,
0.46577006578445435,
-0.37008902430534363,
0.09945190697908401,
0.16542492806911469,
0.4472072124481201,
-0.24164797365665436,
-0.2671861946582794,
-0.5079230666160583,
0.42113104462623596,
0.40026891231536865,
-0.3332425653934479,
0.3565332293510437,
0.5851919054985046,
-0.28672289848327637,
-0.03803255036473274,
-0.49355563521385193,
-0.07911672443151474,
-0.5735576748847961,
0.31856009364128113,
-0.5386638045310974,
-0.8395950794219971,
0.5990062952041626,
-0.21906359493732452,
0.07434196025133133,
0.2800341248512268,
0.23123103380203247,
-0.01887739822268486,
0.8214625716209412,
0.5752202272415161,
0.06361363083124161,
0.5597354173660278,
-0.4063558578491211,
0.12506595253944397,
-1.2196813821792603,
0.009897212497889996,
-0.6169506311416626,
-0.41903871297836304,
-0.4836953580379486,
-0.35692769289016724,
0.05483260378241539,
0.44971051812171936,
-0.4158230125904083,
0.5778430700302124,
-0.7737805247306824,
0.6424193978309631,
0.34806060791015625,
0.16623567044734955,
0.25208133459091187,
-0.15944047272205353,
0.16133922338485718,
0.06664379686117172,
-0.4544786512851715,
-0.39324355125427246,
0.7029039859771729,
0.21653775870800018,
0.6775106191635132,
0.053005509078502655,
1.302579641342163,
0.22422008216381073,
0.05619340017437935,
-0.7738344073295593,
0.47492772340774536,
-0.11682810634374619,
-0.4246639609336853,
-0.3444005846977234,
-0.4330120086669922,
-0.7844226360321045,
0.27066901326179504,
0.19558578729629517,
-0.8207272887229919,
0.43774592876434326,
0.24544857442378998,
-0.5019001960754395,
-0.1169576495885849,
-0.8831486105918884,
1.0958311557769775,
-0.08753328025341034,
-0.25825342535972595,
-0.27038389444351196,
-0.6389474272727966,
0.45483219623565674,
-0.047758549451828,
0.1762377768754959,
-0.08758925646543503,
-0.12336213141679764,
0.707728922367096,
-0.5213449001312256,
0.6155420541763306,
-0.035051725804805756,
-0.5529065132141113,
0.30838459730148315,
0.45826584100723267,
0.5963299870491028,
-0.07664428651332855,
-0.17095941305160522,
0.1621398627758026,
0.2556348145008087,
-0.42486605048179626,
-0.712860643863678,
0.8139286637306213,
-0.4370895326137543,
-0.7067497372627258,
0.09726939350366592,
-0.45392411947250366,
0.012676315382122993,
0.32347962260246277,
0.2811849117279053,
0.8679404258728027,
-0.12362067401409149,
0.42879223823547363,
0.3189334273338318,
-0.11035803705453873,
0.7907481789588928,
0.36484116315841675,
-0.032568905502557755,
-0.4016513526439667,
0.789249837398529,
-0.09761805087327957,
0.4456562101840973,
0.5880096554756165,
0.20592255890369415,
-0.2746453881263733,
-0.4449644982814789,
-0.16896982491016388,
-0.17893828451633453,
-0.7353236079216003,
-0.6298002004623413,
-0.502103865146637,
-0.24355246126651764,
-0.490297794342041,
-0.7049278616905212,
-0.8133525848388672,
-0.3101901113986969,
-0.3989598751068115,
-0.09071763604879379,
-0.19290770590305328,
0.31804731488227844,
-0.17216867208480835,
0.1979932337999344,
-1.0788919925689697,
0.4310413599014282,
0.0481797493994236,
0.2796476185321808,
-0.11818082630634308,
-0.611885666847229,
-0.3188380002975464,
0.1308119297027588,
-0.3370125889778137,
-0.6548669338226318,
0.3338298499584198,
0.1045612096786499,
0.39937421679496765,
0.49839553236961365,
0.38817280530929565,
1.1147139072418213,
-0.2558692693710327,
0.6404225826263428,
-0.1849171370267868,
-1.1050258874893188,
0.6380682587623596,
-0.1630348563194275,
0.3688981831073761,
0.6908246874809265,
-0.07657905668020248,
0.21798424422740936,
-0.2903840243816376,
-0.4416519105434418,
-0.896007776260376,
0.7323703765869141,
-0.003845078870654106,
-0.01095462217926979,
-0.22138279676437378,
0.36362725496292114,
0.02537941187620163,
-0.0294110756367445,
-0.3840191066265106,
-0.09400269389152527,
0.08517857640981674,
-0.021862894296646118,
0.00028630587621591985,
-0.6316198110580444,
-0.018044739961624146,
-0.4508390426635742,
0.6228770613670349,
-0.3253077268600464,
0.40861237049102783,
0.3786531984806061,
-0.2351948767900467,
-0.04254150390625,
0.28058990836143494,
0.6084064841270447,
0.7185492515563965,
-0.36406588554382324,
0.1719776690006256,
0.11487235873937607,
-0.24838055670261383,
0.16658811271190643,
-0.16549615561962128,
0.12245125323534012,
-0.5787034034729004,
0.3389871418476105,
0.4148790240287781,
0.5650782585144043,
-0.4966079592704773,
0.2384728193283081,
0.17858383059501648,
-0.013536603190004826,
-0.09346885979175568,
0.3129417896270752,
-0.113151416182518,
0.3123798966407776,
0.21537886559963226,
0.07819165289402008,
0.5030972361564636,
-0.4955645203590393,
0.5488668084144592,
0.4005983769893646,
-0.03776131942868233,
-0.04409993067383766,
0.543852686882019,
0.28703707456588745,
-0.17829084396362305,
0.6419447660446167,
-0.3328215479850769,
-0.2952977418899536,
0.7245217561721802,
0.8665310740470886,
1.020492672920227,
-0.3013130724430084,
-0.04529237374663353,
0.5623266100883484,
0.04212266951799393,
0.07948537915945053,
0.17094384133815765,
-0.5573464632034302,
-0.7601228356361389,
-0.6386922001838684,
-0.820392370223999,
0.008427804335951805,
-0.06182580068707466,
-0.893062174320221,
0.09580709785223007,
-0.2266993671655655,
0.37006452679634094,
-0.4289584755897522,
0.030565284192562103,
-0.32336217164993286,
0.31421804428100586,
-0.20144228637218475,
0.8244762420654297,
-0.510883092880249,
0.8310239315032959,
0.40360787510871887,
-0.17917245626449585,
-0.8123857975006104,
0.24350933730602264,
0.005136244930326939,
-0.5120846629142761,
0.4831787943840027,
0.33811506628990173,
-0.31082895398139954,
0.27862003445625305,
-0.3634466826915741,
-1.287177562713623,
1.1464414596557617,
0.6570419669151306,
-0.6004448533058167,
0.05648964270949364,
-0.2743742763996124,
0.4340408146381378,
-0.27951356768608093,
-0.028246432542800903,
0.8643535375595093,
0.35552579164505005,
0.15138903260231018,
-0.7919579744338989,
0.264042466878891,
-0.09112522751092911,
0.08895014971494675,
0.4571954309940338,
-0.6437075734138489,
0.4338997006416321,
-0.1703791618347168,
-0.5741092562675476,
0.045344121754169464,
0.8560134172439575,
-0.01669425144791603,
0.29787370562553406,
0.17787839472293854,
0.6123989820480347,
0.5964246988296509,
0.11185396462678909,
0.908408522605896,
-0.7823655605316162,
0.47296541929244995,
1.4186062812805176,
-0.0093295993283391,
0.9479919672012329,
0.5053277611732483,
-0.04471532255411148,
0.5359206199645996,
0.5138596296310425,
0.49401503801345825,
0.5419551730155945,
-0.2654179036617279,
-0.01110299676656723,
-0.26558005809783936,
0.29632315039634705,
-0.44320350885391235,
0.830854594707489,
0.29226502776145935,
-0.35478323698043823,
-0.4761974811553955,
-0.1433224081993103,
-0.09286471456289291,
0.1543997973203659,
-0.16997399926185608,
0.8453624248504639,
-0.1730162501335144,
-0.5528133511543274,
0.972721517086029,
-0.05796699970960617,
0.5012565851211548,
-0.2105615884065628,
-0.1155955046415329,
-0.5017700791358948,
0.23913230001926422,
-0.44891291856765747,
-0.583134114742279,
0.9829591512680054,
-0.2768198251724243,
-0.14079676568508148,
-0.261227011680603,
0.8632633686065674,
-0.37428906559944153,
-0.16507188975811005,
0.3263333737850189,
0.120086170732975,
0.2897008955478668,
-0.08939828723669052,
-0.4836260676383972,
0.34543272852897644,
0.19707052409648895,
-0.4212094247341156,
0.5306521058082581,
0.10885985195636749,
0.22391144931316376,
0.5901632905006409,
0.4653832018375397,
-0.4360632002353668,
-0.05723464488983154,
-0.2961248755455017,
0.9452175498008728,
-0.6818391680717468,
-0.3714374899864197,
-0.8035412430763245,
0.6670287251472473,
0.1868389993906021,
-0.055437296628952026,
0.814961314201355,
0.9318046569824219,
1.0009390115737915,
-0.11270303279161453,
0.3048281967639923,
-0.2361668199300766,
0.14707547426223755,
-0.7358564138412476,
0.26935768127441406,
-0.7720503211021423,
0.3994413912296295,
-0.3898416757583618,
-1.0596293210983276,
-0.17647840082645416,
0.503804624080658,
-0.1832927167415619,
0.006341112777590752,
0.6409781575202942,
1.0172317028045654,
-0.1515120267868042,
-0.33400997519493103,
0.4101405739784241,
-0.06574439257383347,
0.20956049859523773,
0.3633282482624054,
0.32650524377822876,
-0.45958319306373596,
0.30276960134506226,
-0.5537047982215881,
-0.20164605975151062,
-0.39126721024513245,
-1.0040106773376465,
-0.4516173303127289,
-0.6639230847358704,
-0.43981391191482544,
-0.3463793694972992,
-0.1717691272497177,
0.7462707757949829,
0.6875734925270081,
-0.6558335423469543,
-0.03546971082687378,
-0.2409919798374176,
-0.003730522468686104,
-0.23944656550884247,
-0.3740326762199402,
0.509236752986908,
-0.7339866757392883,
-0.7136254906654358,
0.9891292452812195,
0.4677788317203522,
-0.030708080157637596,
-0.2099023163318634,
-0.19639082252979279,
0.09370646625757217,
-0.05979951098561287,
0.7482906579971313,
0.3635146915912628,
-0.5451903343200684,
-0.4745349586009979,
-0.10847067087888718,
-0.12225321680307388,
0.3558005392551422,
0.6547483205795288,
-0.6840469837188721,
0.5189870595932007,
0.9017143249511719,
0.7950770258903503,
0.3700941205024719,
0.7406168580055237,
0.48820286989212036,
-1.0191600322723389,
0.1955738216638565,
0.013370255939662457,
0.3935548961162567,
-0.05235247313976288,
-0.8131592869758606,
0.6430562734603882,
-0.12099609524011612,
-0.7811293005943298,
-0.7109645009040833,
0.23265989124774933,
-0.9127765893936157,
-0.3615114688873291,
1.067816972732544,
-0.08739479631185532,
-0.5105593800544739,
0.12404073774814606,
-0.3451119661331177,
0.3279232084751129,
-0.27825841307640076,
0.797420859336853,
0.3543517291545868,
-0.47714748978614807,
0.01816311851143837,
-0.002339499071240425,
0.49730390310287476,
0.24563808739185333,
-0.8282565474510193,
0.37087345123291016,
0.8669958114624023,
0.41907161474227905,
0.2182735949754715,
0.5779340267181396,
-0.3439336121082306,
0.22283487021923065,
0.09117509424686432,
0.3280952274799347,
-0.2720417082309723,
-0.46333497762680054,
-0.4784539043903351,
0.15794168412685394,
-0.15563717484474182,
-0.518144428730011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17232v1 | Beyond Demographics: Aligning Role-playing LLM-based Agents Using Human Belief Networks | 2024-06-25T02:37:29 | 2024-06-25T02:37:29 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Zach Studdiford, Krirk Nirunwiroj, Agam Goyal, Vincent V. Frigo, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating human-like large language model (LLM) agents is crucial for faithful
social simulation. Having LLMs role-play based on demographic information
sometimes improves human likeness but often does not. This study assessed
whether LLM alignment with human behavior can be improved by integrating
information from empirically-derived human belief networks. Using data from a
human survey, we estimated a belief network encompassing 18 topics loading on
two non-overlapping latent factors. We then seeded LLM-based agents with an
opinion on one topic, and assessed the alignment of its expressed opinions on
remaining test topics with corresponding human data. Role-playing based on
demographic information alone did not align LLM and human opinions, but seeding
the agent with a single belief greatly improved alignment for topics related in
the belief network, and not for topics outside the network. These results
suggest a novel path for human-LLM belief alignment in work seeking to simulate
and understand patterns of belief distributions in society. | [
-0.3938157558441162,
-0.3638072609901428,
0.5656946897506714,
0.21500171720981598,
0.1138036921620369,
0.41495823860168457,
-0.17773903906345367,
-0.35352012515068054,
0.48603126406669617,
0.5684916377067566,
-0.5135481953620911,
-0.3076201379299164,
-0.20448152720928192,
-0.01945481263101101,
0.24270223081111908,
0.48416009545326233,
0.23860253393650055,
0.14575697481632233,
-0.5484699606895447,
0.23057521879673004,
-0.3987927734851837,
-0.5188642144203186,
-0.7641432881355286,
-0.8610043525695801,
0.6629579067230225,
0.23447005450725555,
0.9745105504989624,
0.7158580422401428,
0.2395598441362381,
0.3364783823490143,
0.18241457641124725,
0.5922533869743347,
-0.6044303178787231,
0.12369846552610397,
-0.42649874091148376,
-0.6645342707633972,
-0.6574317812919617,
0.2817956507205963,
0.695633053779602,
0.7092452049255371,
-0.30172091722488403,
-0.03148903325200081,
0.2303471863269806,
0.3025633692741394,
-0.17523756623268127,
0.12967449426651,
-0.4897204041481018,
0.059150733053684235,
-0.04123556986451149,
-0.4981386065483093,
-0.375036358833313,
-0.42957931756973267,
0.11357031017541885,
-0.6326730251312256,
0.32361531257629395,
0.16596619784832,
0.6428133845329285,
0.06275605410337448,
-0.720418393611908,
0.11920049041509628,
-0.7737535238265991,
0.7497695088386536,
-0.721825122833252,
0.1284782588481903,
0.4561370015144348,
0.14179106056690216,
-0.7150153517723083,
0.13504569232463837,
-0.6215924024581909,
0.043077535927295685,
0.0646790862083435,
0.009037650190293789,
0.20848263800144196,
0.14174781739711761,
0.1956302523612976,
-0.40177103877067566,
-0.5267494320869446,
0.3162316679954529,
-0.21360689401626587,
-0.1655244678258896,
0.9977993965148926,
0.35145625472068787,
0.3702177405357361,
-0.08296273648738861,
-0.1793622225522995,
-0.26872551441192627,
-0.8637462258338928,
0.19353772699832916,
0.6429245471954346,
0.5664193034172058,
-0.13906075060367584,
0.6656230688095093,
0.005312157329171896,
0.3623502850532532,
0.3249077796936035,
-0.3422040343284607,
0.268382728099823,
0.11741313338279724,
-0.021206142380833626,
0.35989606380462646,
0.5779742002487183,
0.7114340662956238,
0.6040171980857849,
-0.1258181780576706,
0.03325318545103073,
0.3556292653083801,
0.5134117007255554,
-0.6014819145202637,
0.1793489158153534,
-0.12226229906082153,
-0.6513577103614807,
-0.5781964063644409,
0.32454052567481995,
-0.7088554501533508,
-1.0656143426895142,
-0.44919654726982117,
0.12418068945407867,
-0.28656578063964844,
-0.5057860016822815,
-0.14254918694496155,
-0.16278234124183655,
0.3651617765426636,
0.6806858777999878,
-0.9066371321678162,
0.34109559655189514,
0.9373536705970764,
0.6170878410339355,
-0.2719789147377014,
-0.2389346957206726,
-0.1708415448665619,
0.28992995619773865,
-0.676611065864563,
0.5223101377487183,
-0.7196928262710571,
-0.26537224650382996,
-0.0027170113753527403,
0.03957490250468254,
-0.12524232268333435,
-0.5747616291046143,
0.06088685244321823,
-0.7381008267402649,
-0.04573486000299454,
-0.4681413173675537,
-0.7535520792007446,
0.2067192792892456,
0.4205896556377411,
-0.4443758428096771,
0.8641623258590698,
-0.43950754404067993,
-0.5213889479637146,
0.5213961601257324,
-0.569598376750946,
-0.08202608674764633,
-0.034655600786209106,
-0.5556793212890625,
-0.004978442098945379,
0.11894161254167557,
-0.10563529282808304,
0.40780070424079895,
-0.3282169699668884,
0.33227741718292236,
-0.705228865146637,
-0.4820381700992584,
0.6374986171722412,
-0.5407006144523621,
0.6824802160263062,
0.11281317472457886,
-0.3654367923736572,
0.0356171689927578,
-0.18392713367938995,
-0.1980983018875122,
0.0447344072163105,
-0.07353169471025467,
-0.2900739312171936,
0.4189387559890747,
-0.49878448247909546,
0.30486568808555603,
0.08603580296039581,
-0.6228659749031067,
0.5299169421195984,
-0.42232808470726013,
0.08715914934873581,
0.9759141206741333,
0.013006629422307014,
0.7974621653556824,
-0.8059218525886536,
0.6036232709884644,
-0.09624408185482025,
0.04607018828392029,
0.32369375228881836,
-0.7027316689491272,
-0.3066997230052948,
0.07230785489082336,
0.031222455203533173,
0.5096407532691956,
-0.5153892636299133,
0.564091145992279,
-0.3791916072368622,
-0.3850499391555786,
-0.2551794946193695,
0.11762142926454544,
0.10999087244272232,
0.39755022525787354,
0.04621652513742447,
-0.2618851661682129,
-0.5880329012870789,
-0.8154110312461853,
-0.14375047385692596,
-0.7548379898071289,
0.00031439255690202117,
0.39797377586364746,
0.29765647649765015,
-0.2449265569448471,
1.204788327217102,
-0.4243963956832886,
-0.11524755507707596,
0.023251915350556374,
0.025012854486703873,
0.10909080505371094,
0.43327975273132324,
0.32883620262145996,
-0.8171210885047913,
-0.43161967396736145,
0.1979903280735016,
-0.80229651927948,
-0.05348770692944527,
-0.10237205028533936,
-0.3026415705680847,
0.09241605550050735,
0.3077647387981415,
-0.6401132345199585,
0.5303795337677002,
0.4326716363430023,
-0.4384506046772003,
0.3831137418746948,
-0.20135264098644257,
0.29492008686065674,
-1.3636232614517212,
-0.27875611186027527,
0.3810359537601471,
-0.31574106216430664,
-0.4956538677215576,
-0.3387364149093628,
-0.14269676804542542,
0.08459525555372238,
-0.20269089937210083,
0.5800811052322388,
-0.42788928747177124,
-0.25714313983917236,
-0.3309617340564728,
0.19010689854621887,
-0.07838499546051025,
0.13247357308864594,
0.09658536314964294,
0.9754547476768494,
0.3096745014190674,
-0.3246747553348541,
0.28962403535842896,
0.27439457178115845,
-0.12162023037672043,
0.6104251146316528,
-0.39453351497650146,
0.1238822489976883,
-0.548965334892273,
0.4933927357196808,
-0.9521819949150085,
-0.43249765038490295,
0.20373965799808502,
-0.3463323414325714,
0.23053166270256042,
-0.35918086767196655,
-0.4051600694656372,
-0.11304967850446701,
-0.15635797381401062,
0.24819214642047882,
0.7127293348312378,
-0.18428517878055573,
0.79958575963974,
0.4056617319583893,
-0.1558474451303482,
-0.6629773378372192,
-0.4437739849090576,
0.3187548816204071,
-0.6064366698265076,
-0.7994127869606018,
0.6243865489959717,
0.15694575011730194,
-0.5283973217010498,
-0.029986750334501266,
-0.009414700791239738,
0.158143550157547,
-0.05597282946109772,
0.40119996666908264,
0.3663652837276459,
-0.2703852951526642,
0.4244323670864105,
-0.132115438580513,
0.15818795561790466,
0.011252169497311115,
-0.3915802240371704,
0.5604382753372192,
0.17094279825687408,
-0.4868637025356293,
-0.3106530010700226,
0.20569029450416565,
0.3608357310295105,
0.10713611543178558,
0.8834765553474426,
0.1096925213932991,
-0.37574175000190735,
-0.13888700306415558,
-0.7381131052970886,
-0.19929125905036926,
-0.5199658870697021,
0.155548557639122,
0.09233753383159637,
-0.9145383238792419,
0.5129820108413696,
-0.245330810546875,
0.02222246117889881,
0.13944850862026215,
0.3924493193626404,
-0.7322911024093628,
1.0312811136245728,
0.38724207878112793,
0.20711427927017212,
0.4761943221092224,
0.12659405171871185,
-0.17072637379169464,
-0.7237681150436401,
-0.23743031919002533,
-0.18426981568336487,
-0.5035744905471802,
-0.6022627353668213,
-0.9179893136024475,
0.14562766253948212,
-0.09721994400024414,
-0.5639210343360901,
0.14690425992012024,
-0.1324157863855362,
0.27673962712287903,
-0.04238620772957802,
0.29729709029197693,
-0.1097964197397232,
0.19233623147010803,
-0.17848333716392517,
-0.1711801141500473,
-0.405331015586853,
-1.0347992181777954,
1.0183321237564087,
0.3512529730796814,
0.847147524356842,
0.39861932396888733,
0.9696652293205261,
0.6359558701515198,
0.6516846418380737,
-0.43134286999702454,
0.5477217435836792,
-0.1068134754896164,
-0.7660008072853088,
-0.5926669836044312,
-0.5439067482948303,
-0.9738492369651794,
0.39238494634628296,
-0.4910356104373932,
-1.0594213008880615,
0.5446498394012451,
0.29631510376930237,
-0.257416307926178,
0.2341831922531128,
-0.4529365003108978,
0.6789249777793884,
-0.2662546634674072,
-0.2943675220012665,
-0.25373587012290955,
-0.6408671140670776,
0.09543514996767044,
-0.10783198475837708,
0.17649658024311066,
-0.3491361141204834,
-0.052619803696870804,
0.6391323208808899,
-0.5169825553894043,
1.5584759712219238,
-0.36742112040519714,
-0.39086025953292847,
0.2755115330219269,
-0.11328373104333878,
0.6049816012382507,
-0.10882844030857086,
-0.49923309683799744,
-0.12402303516864777,
-0.1340344250202179,
-0.33839717507362366,
-1.0471495389938354,
0.5528436899185181,
-1.1895809173583984,
-1.0152541399002075,
-0.23847158253192902,
-0.5035730004310608,
-0.3781251311302185,
-0.0553743876516819,
-0.2782348394393921,
0.2568989098072052,
-0.5825100541114807,
0.19646446406841278,
0.8511174917221069,
-0.08870749175548553,
0.025699060410261154,
0.12805500626564026,
-0.282645046710968,
-0.2809467315673828,
0.6487890481948853,
0.11950667947530746,
0.4132314622402191,
0.4098796546459198,
0.28519970178604126,
-0.4736310541629791,
-0.019368352368474007,
-0.12218417972326279,
0.2928680181503296,
-0.4625040590763092,
-0.07079686969518661,
-0.584861159324646,
-0.009434913285076618,
-0.5188027024269104,
-0.10261400043964386,
-0.20126627385616302,
-0.0807114690542221,
-0.2676931321620941,
-0.11994987726211548,
0.23425890505313873,
0.6138122081756592,
0.018611636012792587,
0.5619010329246521,
-0.5853212475776672,
0.19438263773918152,
0.3911883234977722,
0.1659400463104248,
0.16301557421684265,
-0.3875182867050171,
0.017948921769857407,
0.6549164652824402,
-0.1429445594549179,
-1.1096343994140625,
0.14624559879302979,
0.07149270921945572,
0.6199450492858887,
0.6867477893829346,
0.05229780077934265,
0.9907960891723633,
-0.47645503282546997,
0.6347752809524536,
0.3134942352771759,
-0.6321821212768555,
0.1835634708404541,
-0.43471163511276245,
-0.32938945293426514,
0.3688635528087616,
0.17372965812683105,
-0.704231858253479,
-0.07222326844930649,
-0.40227121114730835,
-0.27730125188827515,
0.8094354271888733,
0.33314603567123413,
0.34691739082336426,
-0.044280484318733215,
0.5205073952674866,
-0.09231696277856827,
0.07014710456132889,
-0.3074358403682709,
-0.18682445585727692,
-0.21466031670570374,
-0.3881986737251282,
-0.31595784425735474,
0.049421120434999466,
-0.33893460035324097,
-0.10724357515573502,
0.48638322949409485,
-0.33100321888923645,
0.190625861287117,
0.114004947245121,
0.16802270710468292,
-0.4482840299606323,
0.09297718107700348,
0.5947377681732178,
0.6327594518661499,
-0.1621926873922348,
0.27906957268714905,
0.19259096682071686,
-0.2995762526988983,
0.7100575566291809,
0.020605776458978653,
-0.06370937079191208,
-0.6176465153694153,
0.35912254452705383,
0.5352326035499573,
-0.012739060446619987,
-0.33584174513816833,
0.5203053951263428,
-0.13336557149887085,
-0.1406375616788864,
-0.4027155339717865,
0.40046730637550354,
0.6206901669502258,
0.5685518980026245,
0.3900485038757324,
0.19358548521995544,
-0.4184044897556305,
-0.7943660020828247,
0.22125345468521118,
0.5581185221672058,
-0.3478580415248871,
-0.31196680665016174,
0.5269227027893066,
0.20427851378917694,
-0.7083150744438171,
0.5650110840797424,
-0.08609577268362045,
-0.2654297947883606,
0.9635869264602661,
0.7312348484992981,
0.6512337923049927,
-0.31392890214920044,
0.6231796145439148,
0.024209657683968544,
0.2971232235431671,
-0.30959179997444153,
0.12791049480438232,
0.18492956459522247,
-1.452878713607788,
-0.6926814317703247,
-0.37407946586608887,
-0.2278549075126648,
-0.48621565103530884,
-0.34811148047447205,
0.17471954226493835,
-0.1669815331697464,
-0.5757241249084473,
-0.13821305334568024,
0.12969836592674255,
-0.805519163608551,
0.14065536856651306,
0.22878560423851013,
0.6162189245223999,
-0.9736700057983398,
0.8543736338615417,
0.9745115041732788,
-0.20327891409397125,
-1.0146352052688599,
0.3705419600009918,
0.16132961213588715,
-0.7892717123031616,
0.6795473694801331,
0.033779531717300415,
-0.19507978856563568,
-0.1777493953704834,
-0.6030440330505371,
-1.0734063386917114,
1.3409826755523682,
0.48387590050697327,
-0.4080894887447357,
-0.2792695462703705,
0.3148168623447418,
0.6786338686943054,
-0.9210309386253357,
0.1668216437101364,
0.0698602944612503,
0.4685090482234955,
0.3086109757423401,
-0.6263384819030762,
0.2188330441713333,
-0.25399401783943176,
0.16308178007602692,
0.10993596911430359,
-0.6546967029571533,
0.5587152242660522,
-0.06323733180761337,
-0.07623304426670074,
-0.10068941116333008,
0.9396775364875793,
0.7733525037765503,
0.36975985765457153,
0.9246190786361694,
0.03155388683080673,
1.0011510848999023,
0.36854201555252075,
0.7284286022186279,
-0.06915032118558884,
0.11770333349704742,
0.9242722392082214,
-0.9369093775749207,
0.3830704092979431,
0.40056312084198,
-0.17107506096363068,
0.5131877064704895,
0.7685441970825195,
0.10787218064069748,
0.09432975947856903,
0.32172656059265137,
-0.014683006331324577,
-0.7586060166358948,
-0.3015531301498413,
-0.20073926448822021,
0.5470898747444153,
0.36504119634628296,
-0.18250857293605804,
0.004983057733625174,
-0.48367971181869507,
-0.22395573556423187,
0.18065033853054047,
0.01693526841700077,
0.6956672072410583,
0.12520310282707214,
-0.6707543134689331,
-0.002472481457516551,
-0.10073274374008179,
0.6752408146858215,
-0.48642274737358093,
-0.46212923526763916,
-0.03409925103187561,
-0.24095889925956726,
-0.3286588788032532,
-0.7500834465026855,
-0.016515588387846947,
-0.03642650693655014,
-0.21519504487514496,
-0.2644486427307129,
0.8135101795196533,
-0.4438738524913788,
-0.3043803572654724,
0.2762085795402527,
0.6480372548103333,
0.2639041543006897,
0.22487638890743256,
-0.42952412366867065,
-0.27055060863494873,
-0.07856252789497375,
-0.14372432231903076,
0.5316774249076843,
0.6412228345870972,
-0.5229416489601135,
0.501003086566925,
0.8663780689239502,
0.34863555431365967,
-0.18824513256549835,
0.14230281114578247,
0.7682048082351685,
-0.6331626176834106,
-0.5484444499015808,
-0.9350242614746094,
0.4061998724937439,
-0.5482385754585266,
0.09733482450246811,
0.5548967123031616,
0.28561854362487793,
0.374457448720932,
0.2611706256866455,
0.6757046580314636,
0.14133064448833466,
0.16166236996650696,
-0.186273455619812,
0.7771994471549988,
-0.4432511627674103,
0.2647831439971924,
-0.4060952961444855,
-1.18578040599823,
-0.02021130919456482,
0.5999783277511597,
-0.24155940115451813,
0.20680218935012817,
0.12053349614143372,
1.0231958627700806,
-0.00594613142311573,
-0.10797080397605896,
0.47144609689712524,
-0.060999300330877304,
0.566032350063324,
-0.0401453897356987,
1.1151758432388306,
0.14216099679470062,
0.18668539822101593,
0.1008036658167839,
-0.3608989417552948,
-0.1349383294582367,
-0.9656778573989868,
-0.9369579553604126,
-0.20350033044815063,
-0.23162181675434113,
-0.40920472145080566,
-0.0195938590914011,
1.5919605493545532,
0.755455732345581,
-0.38068604469299316,
-0.5344533920288086,
0.16685982048511505,
0.13788746297359467,
-0.38672080636024475,
-0.2956255376338959,
0.17823851108551025,
0.03524453565478325,
-0.4696201682090759,
0.355461984872818,
0.12381134927272797,
-0.07269451767206192,
-0.3819073736667633,
-0.4756808280944824,
-0.13825593888759613,
0.4689006507396698,
0.40596500039100647,
0.13544495403766632,
-0.8043303489685059,
-0.5322359800338745,
0.16037219762802124,
-0.2958807349205017,
0.07457536458969116,
0.8347828984260559,
-0.504768431186676,
0.3921990990638733,
0.321833997964859,
0.5268773436546326,
0.11482836306095123,
0.6211949586868286,
1.0370839834213257,
-0.77774578332901,
-0.03617432713508606,
0.18736039102077484,
0.2515462338924408,
0.2892010509967804,
-0.7263409495353699,
0.38905632495880127,
0.15406887233257294,
-0.5262627005577087,
-0.5643699169158936,
0.29983648657798767,
-0.7689031362533569,
-0.008283376693725586,
1.2565077543258667,
-0.05690224841237068,
-0.3044583797454834,
-0.2537028193473816,
-0.1548980474472046,
0.3698274493217468,
-0.739739716053009,
0.7093842029571533,
0.5726523995399475,
-0.3175120949745178,
-0.0864604040980339,
-0.20405831933021545,
0.23738792538642883,
0.24449732899665833,
-0.7697986960411072,
0.08314942568540573,
0.44188931584358215,
0.1749412566423416,
0.28748029470443726,
0.8154136538505554,
0.08991509675979614,
-0.06603816896677017,
-0.2296060174703598,
0.2530754804611206,
0.1466650366783142,
-0.08919036388397217,
0.019854174926877022,
0.10108783841133118,
0.10420650988817215,
0.20104730129241943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17231v1 | CogMG: Collaborative Augmentation Between Large Language Model and Knowledge Graph | 2024-06-25T02:37:12 | 2024-06-25T02:37:12 | Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have become integral to question-answering applications
despite their propensity for generating hallucinations and factually inaccurate
content. Querying knowledge graphs to reduce hallucinations in LLM meets the
challenge of incomplete knowledge coverage in knowledge graphs. On the other
hand, updating knowledge graphs by information extraction and knowledge graph
completion faces the knowledge update misalignment issue. In this work, we
introduce a collaborative augmentation framework, CogMG, leveraging knowledge
graphs to address the limitations of LLMs in QA scenarios, explicitly targeting
the problems of incomplete knowledge coverage and knowledge update
misalignment. The LLMs identify and decompose required knowledge triples that
are not present in the KG, enriching them and aligning updates with real-world
demands. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach through a supervised
fine-tuned LLM within an agent framework, showing significant improvements in
reducing hallucinations and enhancing factual accuracy in QA responses. Our
code and video are publicly available. | [
-0.5884658098220825,
-1.015371561050415,
0.623916506767273,
-0.0404471680521965,
0.03452124074101448,
0.4443216621875763,
0.019905932247638702,
-0.6578733921051025,
0.3598178029060364,
0.6370944380760193,
-0.7634145617485046,
-0.6417132616043091,
-0.32240030169487,
0.16889259219169617,
-0.009494983591139317,
0.7011370062828064,
0.074821338057518,
-0.05816885828971863,
-0.7420114874839783,
-0.22436729073524475,
-0.5439605116844177,
-0.43111351132392883,
-0.7183530926704407,
-0.5958443284034729,
0.31907323002815247,
0.3780002295970917,
1.1743189096450806,
0.26370325684547424,
0.42600202560424805,
0.3015305697917938,
0.06945163756608963,
0.882236659526825,
-0.6214807629585266,
0.11958784610033035,
-0.05272040516138077,
-0.3880354166030884,
-0.9029830098152161,
-0.18432646989822388,
0.21257781982421875,
1.0427958965301514,
-0.1247096136212349,
-0.041894733905792236,
0.10904600471258163,
0.4519250988960266,
-0.3615967631340027,
0.4286694824695587,
-0.34614452719688416,
-0.015732083469629288,
0.4513404667377472,
-0.17989888787269592,
-0.3219298720359802,
-0.490739643573761,
0.3209136128425598,
-1.0905330181121826,
0.19558662176132202,
0.3706037104129791,
0.746132493019104,
0.6768411993980408,
-0.24604691565036774,
-0.1917102038860321,
-0.4483153820037842,
0.37147945165634155,
-0.6160241365432739,
0.34112754464149475,
0.38453593850135803,
0.27491915225982666,
-0.563228189945221,
-0.7763330936431885,
-0.6152291297912598,
-0.13319188356399536,
-0.2782430350780487,
0.12134984880685806,
-0.25122153759002686,
0.5685873031616211,
0.2682616710662842,
0.4308626055717468,
-0.5246589183807373,
0.05391532555222511,
-0.25105929374694824,
-0.5021187663078308,
0.7376312613487244,
0.07674215734004974,
0.5803961753845215,
0.048541050404310226,
-0.3329903483390808,
-0.08105602115392685,
-0.6144310235977173,
-0.23098023235797882,
0.1601782590150833,
0.0143238240852952,
-0.027211537584662437,
0.5958722233772278,
-0.19965291023254395,
0.9277950525283813,
0.3282616138458252,
0.03310809284448624,
0.3601808249950409,
-0.29481279850006104,
-0.29188665747642517,
0.16018886864185333,
0.5698053240776062,
0.5483896136283875,
0.08490680158138275,
-0.6209614276885986,
0.24552299082279205,
-0.2576214075088501,
0.2648482620716095,
-0.5387463569641113,
-0.29277196526527405,
0.3291831612586975,
0.1294979304075241,
-0.125643789768219,
-0.0859464630484581,
-0.5397953391075134,
-0.7041155099868774,
-0.25133296847343445,
0.521760880947113,
-0.2841089963912964,
-0.164613738656044,
0.3118184208869934,
-0.20661289989948273,
-0.005507578607648611,
0.471640020608902,
-0.479260116815567,
0.2416384518146515,
0.6019930243492126,
0.4887165427207947,
-0.20435407757759094,
-0.29360246658325195,
-0.5870629549026489,
0.4898287057876587,
-0.3990151584148407,
0.6233341097831726,
-0.3600104749202728,
-0.14476843178272247,
-0.08214497566223145,
0.13225452601909637,
-0.02811281941831112,
-0.6867690086364746,
0.11527343094348907,
-0.907417893409729,
0.5901283025741577,
-0.3692728877067566,
-0.8390526175498962,
-0.5739089250564575,
0.6763901710510254,
-0.7166321277618408,
0.9145936965942383,
0.6200932860374451,
-0.5962756276130676,
0.11810623854398727,
-0.5753490328788757,
-0.10459903627634048,
0.2727360129356384,
-0.22580471634864807,
-0.32178550958633423,
-0.3417079448699951,
0.5493857860565186,
0.3226487338542938,
-0.10609518736600876,
0.3378433585166931,
-0.5003238916397095,
-0.5240296125411987,
-0.01641676388680935,
0.2321024388074875,
0.6441187858581543,
-0.010199664160609245,
0.052465543150901794,
0.35392218828201294,
-0.7062578201293945,
0.1188586950302124,
-0.11407379806041718,
-0.16345280408859253,
-0.28374335169792175,
-0.14493165910243988,
-0.6370084881782532,
0.06941062211990356,
0.5048622488975525,
-0.1742917150259018,
0.2444077432155609,
-0.6209502220153809,
-0.0046999151818454266,
0.41527825593948364,
0.3728151321411133,
0.6137633919715881,
-0.4977634847164154,
0.744148850440979,
-0.06134756654500961,
0.18229621648788452,
0.2734096646308899,
-0.4636061489582062,
-0.7568274736404419,
-0.2888420820236206,
0.019432850182056427,
0.5525553226470947,
-1.3223752975463867,
0.6170441508293152,
-0.25012892484664917,
-0.14129193127155304,
-0.6407175064086914,
0.2821798324584961,
0.11648880690336227,
0.5813198685646057,
0.5893158912658691,
-0.21763087809085846,
-0.7005760669708252,
-0.7432945966720581,
-0.11347789317369461,
-0.37924084067344666,
-0.1615920513868332,
0.3348628878593445,
-0.06561611592769623,
-0.5134187340736389,
1.027097225189209,
-0.7194119095802307,
-0.45230165123939514,
-0.15645287930965424,
-0.014488992281258106,
-0.07096199691295624,
0.13111039996147156,
0.3061954379081726,
-0.5726581811904907,
-0.20738735795021057,
-0.0032266925554722548,
-1.0014411211013794,
-0.2739624083042145,
0.16160205006599426,
-0.05725317448377609,
0.10241001844406128,
0.6773525476455688,
-0.4300430119037628,
-0.011555513367056847,
0.8204014301300049,
-0.31130450963974,
0.40646225214004517,
-0.3213631808757782,
0.2163163423538208,
-1.2768522500991821,
-0.4608486294746399,
-0.3550468981266022,
-0.5967651009559631,
-0.5399338603019714,
0.39936181902885437,
-0.2665521204471588,
-0.11892849951982498,
-0.14944937825202942,
0.370077520608902,
-0.47564733028411865,
-0.04151298850774765,
-0.29406672716140747,
0.6220818161964417,
0.3307459056377411,
0.6226526498794556,
-0.15628287196159363,
0.8314715623855591,
0.4975953698158264,
-0.5046936869621277,
0.6722269654273987,
0.355495423078537,
-0.07569272071123123,
0.3659111559391022,
-0.34488123655319214,
0.4793677031993866,
0.038481201976537704,
0.13918599486351013,
-0.7298141121864319,
-0.48329415917396545,
0.6157194972038269,
-0.4417041540145874,
0.05168135091662407,
-0.04210732504725456,
-0.628014862537384,
-0.31732162833213806,
-0.12125761061906815,
0.21990296244621277,
0.42476069927215576,
-0.6727687120437622,
0.7625800967216492,
0.49494972825050354,
-0.09998136013746262,
-0.39023879170417786,
-0.5186499357223511,
0.11654236167669296,
0.08815546333789825,
-1.005048394203186,
0.27588292956352234,
-0.025341834872961044,
-0.36589515209198,
0.1807468831539154,
-0.05378533527255058,
-0.1336178034543991,
0.015652958303689957,
0.12562893331050873,
0.16737323999404907,
-0.143362358212471,
0.44372043013572693,
0.11196423321962357,
0.04242495447397232,
0.1314939707517624,
-0.35175037384033203,
0.6308911442756653,
-0.005974392406642437,
-0.4974096715450287,
-0.10049663484096527,
0.10503837466239929,
0.28605028986930847,
-0.04517291486263275,
0.7184817790985107,
0.7972582578659058,
-0.5028881430625916,
-0.07399436831474304,
-0.7129576802253723,
-0.2987560033798218,
-0.5294737815856934,
0.4518069326877594,
-0.21485351026058197,
-1.4072624444961548,
0.6738294363021851,
-0.06679238379001617,
-0.5182422995567322,
0.2792852222919464,
0.30198290944099426,
-0.01677934266626835,
1.0191560983657837,
0.6475547552108765,
0.027635036036372185,
0.16652238368988037,
-0.14267806708812714,
0.268200159072876,
-0.7867884039878845,
-0.4063841998577118,
-0.08972889930009842,
0.03190336003899574,
-0.4838555157184601,
-0.6848337054252625,
0.6770675182342529,
0.33987152576446533,
0.13488437235355377,
0.06929522752761841,
-0.6045498251914978,
0.42846012115478516,
0.309684157371521,
0.4017893373966217,
0.5203437209129333,
0.04162149131298065,
0.02453436702489853,
0.18986330926418304,
-0.9313264489173889,
-0.32877102494239807,
0.722898006439209,
0.17823484539985657,
0.6497983932495117,
0.108014315366745,
0.5811578631401062,
0.34172695875167847,
0.0702829360961914,
-0.6011515259742737,
0.6231175065040588,
0.30522575974464417,
-0.5053235292434692,
-0.5550268292427063,
-0.4367906153202057,
-0.8069946765899658,
0.27559560537338257,
-0.276416152715683,
-0.5936119556427002,
0.11868534982204437,
0.19899305701255798,
-0.545120358467102,
0.15403492748737335,
-0.8184038996696472,
0.7418531179428101,
0.1134142354130745,
-0.3393738269805908,
-0.3951023817062378,
-0.4514009356498718,
0.3292595148086548,
-0.0566704161465168,
0.1349838823080063,
0.11455955356359482,
0.0010224601719528437,
0.5012848377227783,
-0.6345899701118469,
0.7758721113204956,
-0.15588393807411194,
-0.35158008337020874,
0.5252736210823059,
0.10153287649154663,
0.8783326148986816,
0.024180090054869652,
-0.020481234416365623,
-0.12877625226974487,
-0.009725065901875496,
-0.5279526710510254,
-0.8609927892684937,
0.5247862935066223,
-0.8201541304588318,
-0.9168538451194763,
-0.10889114439487457,
-1.0653798580169678,
-0.63880455493927,
0.08017415553331375,
-0.09494494646787643,
0.21517951786518097,
-0.09724844992160797,
-0.040742918848991394,
0.6525525450706482,
-0.32336291670799255,
0.11074556410312653,
0.3831723928451538,
-0.45947763323783875,
-0.5397052764892578,
0.8272565007209778,
0.04105503484606743,
0.36406686902046204,
0.061910539865493774,
0.07208189368247986,
-0.359605997800827,
-0.7188642621040344,
-0.19957056641578674,
0.15606142580509186,
-0.6861819624900818,
0.03392471745610237,
-0.7547985911369324,
-0.26005837321281433,
-0.7700309157371521,
-0.10362404584884644,
0.20713894069194794,
-0.24171794950962067,
-0.3540422022342682,
-0.21374653279781342,
0.5360389351844788,
0.6893061995506287,
-0.10859383642673492,
0.44731831550598145,
-0.9085628986358643,
0.43219098448753357,
0.6405113935470581,
0.18245206773281097,
-0.16742728650569916,
-0.15074346959590912,
-0.4082632064819336,
0.20495153963565826,
-0.11209665983915329,
-0.9116784930229187,
0.2813950479030609,
-0.14040903747081757,
0.4608083963394165,
0.15690040588378906,
0.24522370100021362,
1.0401630401611328,
-0.0015780668472871184,
0.8237295150756836,
0.0851106271147728,
-0.7918760776519775,
0.2047467678785324,
-0.497222363948822,
0.252584308385849,
0.5463414788246155,
0.047857560217380524,
-0.539148211479187,
-0.7223727107048035,
-0.6238211989402771,
-0.6416276693344116,
0.6065860986709595,
0.10940218716859818,
-0.18762846291065216,
0.07243303954601288,
0.46061307191848755,
0.010930022224783897,
0.3448931574821472,
-0.5106549263000488,
0.00429152138531208,
0.04962172359228134,
-0.2830943167209625,
0.022675910964608192,
-0.07200402766466141,
-0.4198819696903229,
-0.2608496844768524,
0.7323831915855408,
-0.5205477476119995,
0.045264579355716705,
0.4148193299770355,
-0.40280860662460327,
-0.2907891869544983,
0.11746056377887726,
0.40725117921829224,
0.7715839147567749,
-0.3343484103679657,
0.11169327795505524,
0.5917220115661621,
-0.28843367099761963,
-0.042405664920806885,
0.32402804493904114,
-0.11393681168556213,
-0.25359830260276794,
0.38932013511657715,
0.7526671886444092,
-0.10646935552358627,
-0.5221154093742371,
0.52692049741745,
0.04399397224187851,
-0.19059690833091736,
-0.2940695583820343,
0.2680415213108063,
0.10557915270328522,
0.6274339556694031,
0.33188381791114807,
0.08950165659189224,
0.1099247857928276,
-0.3975372314453125,
0.22365814447402954,
0.4123055636882782,
-0.7731407880783081,
-0.08983118087053299,
0.42879730463027954,
0.18733711540699005,
-0.3336604833602905,
0.38608571887016296,
-0.6591053009033203,
-0.5842571258544922,
0.6173604726791382,
0.3732648193836212,
0.6067651510238647,
0.19607214629650116,
0.39302003383636475,
0.10942953079938889,
0.40257886052131653,
-0.06918458640575409,
0.18870794773101807,
0.02888147160410881,
-0.9045590758323669,
-0.7254378199577332,
-0.041874174028635025,
-0.6406635046005249,
0.09749489277601242,
-0.44497525691986084,
0.14136740565299988,
-0.2048986852169037,
0.04178198054432869,
-0.5922636389732361,
0.24238286912441254,
-0.45998984575271606,
0.2715478241443634,
0.033644724637269974,
0.5050809979438782,
-0.5433220267295837,
0.7578505873680115,
0.7242928147315979,
-0.5396548509597778,
-1.055199384689331,
0.07489300519227982,
-0.31585830450057983,
-0.8479872941970825,
0.11431849002838135,
-0.10565444827079773,
-0.2302318662405014,
0.2783617377281189,
-0.6878878474235535,
-0.7242745161056519,
1.30426025390625,
0.6040318608283997,
-0.4143622815608978,
-0.2972702383995056,
0.35708558559417725,
0.8356926441192627,
-0.3483678102493286,
-0.00015794156934134662,
0.3529382646083832,
0.44589000940322876,
0.27778154611587524,
-0.7405698895454407,
0.3476710319519043,
0.15815891325473785,
-0.43665748834609985,
-0.0403834693133831,
-0.7239764928817749,
0.37338653206825256,
-0.32759931683540344,
-0.06474760919809341,
-0.13096041977405548,
0.6018478870391846,
0.4190705418586731,
0.45240798592567444,
0.5260713696479797,
0.756066083908081,
1.1842148303985596,
-0.14562924206256866,
0.9857841730117798,
-0.34934207797050476,
0.25883951783180237,
1.2466658353805542,
-0.27191948890686035,
0.2120581567287445,
0.39685484766960144,
-0.033830273896455765,
0.47595179080963135,
0.7509053945541382,
0.013260379433631897,
0.2570616602897644,
-0.010416976176202297,
-0.310404896736145,
-0.5606382489204407,
-0.2731033265590668,
-0.5271023511886597,
0.10698515921831131,
0.25501981377601624,
-0.07982048392295837,
-0.22398468852043152,
-0.03759099170565605,
-0.027655232697725296,
-0.021638423204421997,
-0.36438804864883423,
0.940464437007904,
-0.031533382833004,
-0.8393797278404236,
0.6219832897186279,
-0.2485283464193344,
0.297400563955307,
-0.23614007234573364,
-0.13332726061344147,
-0.19863025844097137,
-0.00591370789334178,
-0.4482862651348114,
-0.559689998626709,
0.33761680126190186,
-0.5092359781265259,
-0.00203320337459445,
-0.0888143926858902,
0.9768331050872803,
-0.7458707690238953,
-0.23629899322986603,
0.5542876124382019,
0.7965225577354431,
-0.07627174258232117,
-0.24503740668296814,
-0.4161286950111389,
-0.2618010342121124,
-0.09205570071935654,
0.22622336447238922,
-0.04770657792687416,
0.4135645031929016,
-0.04143625497817993,
0.7277193665504456,
0.526496410369873,
0.10250923037528992,
0.20494665205478668,
0.3701944649219513,
0.9206703305244446,
-0.341016948223114,
-0.4028984010219574,
-0.6243022680282593,
0.2333742082118988,
-0.29454222321510315,
0.4068238139152527,
0.8427950143814087,
0.5978255271911621,
0.8306393027305603,
0.0200494434684515,
0.7607170939445496,
0.09788374602794647,
0.3647204339504242,
-0.4397215247154236,
0.7594568133354187,
-0.5491048693656921,
0.3188607394695282,
-0.20049604773521423,
-0.8061495423316956,
-0.4535355567932129,
0.3251911997795105,
-0.4165830910205841,
-0.19455783069133759,
0.719525933265686,
1.1242033243179321,
0.21339252591133118,
-0.0475677065551281,
0.5532721877098083,
0.3744407594203949,
0.22082829475402832,
0.5189883708953857,
0.9546549320220947,
-0.45833832025527954,
0.6505823731422424,
-0.07742771506309509,
0.03566823527216911,
-0.1654365062713623,
-0.5888749361038208,
-1.053542137145996,
-0.42282742261886597,
-0.6104714274406433,
-0.6643846035003662,
0.2144918590784073,
1.111006736755371,
0.6476628184318542,
-0.687200129032135,
0.08512846380472183,
-0.14226745069026947,
0.560593843460083,
-0.22446048259735107,
-0.24508802592754364,
0.30225297808647156,
-0.3718375265598297,
-0.545401930809021,
0.4497782289981842,
0.3068996071815491,
0.14290276169776917,
-0.40728482604026794,
-0.29979535937309265,
-0.14336815476417542,
0.003796954406425357,
0.5038423538208008,
0.04360073432326317,
-0.5629772543907166,
-0.6559658050537109,
0.26317471265792847,
-0.062243346124887466,
0.27304768562316895,
0.41053691506385803,
-0.919463574886322,
0.65628981590271,
0.6177977919578552,
0.7202733755111694,
0.47738584876060486,
0.20788320899009705,
0.6813315749168396,
-0.9642764925956726,
0.04234927520155907,
0.13237792253494263,
0.14261968433856964,
0.4100077450275421,
-0.5351295471191406,
0.5867018103599548,
0.3786374032497406,
-0.42368316650390625,
-0.7316049933433533,
0.2227204591035843,
-1.0576343536376953,
-0.14413465559482574,
1.194710373878479,
-0.003486116649582982,
-0.287428617477417,
-0.4857604205608368,
-0.41039595007896423,
0.5987517833709717,
-0.18265622854232788,
1.0251555442810059,
0.8852441906929016,
-0.18139398097991943,
-0.30914121866226196,
-0.13159459829330444,
0.5598890781402588,
0.23492029309272766,
-1.0933902263641357,
-0.30777835845947266,
0.820237398147583,
0.1229558065533638,
0.3053312301635742,
0.7406124472618103,
0.03942372649908066,
0.27977320551872253,
-0.20991994440555573,
0.33477067947387695,
-0.44557487964630127,
-0.0010434321593493223,
-0.25055378675460815,
0.541739821434021,
0.2918403446674347,
-0.2142895609140396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17224v1 | Large Language Models are Interpretable Learners | 2024-06-25T02:18:15 | 2024-06-25T02:18:15 | Ruochen Wang, Si Si, Felix Yu, Dorothea Wiesmann, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Inderjit Dhillon | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SC, 68T05 | The trade-off between expressiveness and interpretability remains a core
challenge when building human-centric predictive models for classification and
decision-making. While symbolic rules offer interpretability, they often lack
expressiveness, whereas neural networks excel in performance but are known for
being black boxes. In this paper, we show a combination of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and symbolic programs can bridge this gap. In the proposed
LLM-based Symbolic Programs (LSPs), the pretrained LLM with natural language
prompts provides a massive set of interpretable modules that can transform raw
input into natural language concepts. Symbolic programs then integrate these
modules into an interpretable decision rule. To train LSPs, we develop a
divide-and-conquer approach to incrementally build the program from scratch,
where the learning process of each step is guided by LLMs. To evaluate the
effectiveness of LSPs in extracting interpretable and accurate knowledge from
data, we introduce IL-Bench, a collection of diverse tasks, including both
synthetic and real-world scenarios across different modalities. Empirical
results demonstrate LSP's superior performance compared to traditional
neurosymbolic programs and vanilla automatic prompt tuning methods. Moreover,
as the knowledge learned by LSP is a combination of natural language
descriptions and symbolic rules, it is easily transferable to humans
(interpretable), and other LLMs, and generalizes well to out-of-distribution
samples. | [
0.039360638707876205,
-0.5057172775268555,
0.76137775182724,
0.32978856563568115,
-0.18892733752727509,
0.2062178999185562,
-0.5616050362586975,
-0.5985450744628906,
0.03127342835068703,
0.40239372849464417,
-0.49898597598075867,
-0.3983936011791229,
-0.7989889979362488,
0.1587754487991333,
-0.451596736907959,
0.7127150893211365,
-0.03131283074617386,
0.1574065089225769,
-0.029472485184669495,
-0.0923452377319336,
-0.4364367127418518,
-0.47782763838768005,
-0.7931493520736694,
-0.6611114144325256,
0.41668403148651123,
-0.027285005897283554,
0.6480616927146912,
0.6008254885673523,
0.24725137650966644,
0.33683931827545166,
0.017323903739452362,
0.1506965309381485,
-0.2790105640888214,
0.10428734123706818,
-0.3650241494178772,
-0.6661557555198669,
-0.11365755647420883,
-0.1218298152089119,
0.5435552597045898,
0.6765475869178772,
-0.2165050059556961,
0.0744977816939354,
0.15346315503120422,
0.39516517519950867,
-0.4274523854255676,
0.6983682513237,
-0.5693404078483582,
0.03891150653362274,
0.04778561741113663,
-0.038699354976415634,
-0.6797935366630554,
-0.39291101694107056,
-0.10129816085100174,
-0.42446115612983704,
-0.3174317479133606,
-0.013819035142660141,
0.542595624923706,
0.43738821148872375,
-0.2809029817581177,
-0.11289028078317642,
-0.6175280809402466,
0.9474374651908875,
-0.7987395524978638,
0.43959933519363403,
0.3008940517902374,
0.6311390399932861,
-0.3330838680267334,
-0.67885422706604,
-0.5074305534362793,
-0.4280647337436676,
-0.2612948715686798,
-0.1808466911315918,
-0.1733783334493637,
0.05100073665380478,
0.43599849939346313,
-0.09055209159851074,
-0.4124583601951599,
0.4037992060184479,
-0.22928208112716675,
-0.010989482514560223,
0.7514795064926147,
0.25124144554138184,
0.41354799270629883,
-0.08440997451543808,
-0.07194867730140686,
-0.15001147985458374,
-0.7801780700683594,
-0.0029535465873777866,
-0.06383095681667328,
0.6251160502433777,
-0.16702038049697876,
0.6099093556404114,
-0.10371676832437515,
0.9175278544425964,
-0.2332593947649002,
-0.1853877604007721,
-0.061056338250637054,
0.09897696226835251,
-0.2518279552459717,
0.1338510513305664,
0.6480088829994202,
-0.02470131777226925,
0.6612148284912109,
-0.35121607780456543,
-0.4044584035873413,
0.12040143460035324,
0.25799599289894104,
-0.6169157028198242,
-0.002410134067758918,
0.07626792043447495,
-0.4342297315597534,
-0.17497287690639496,
-0.10925374180078506,
-0.382671594619751,
-0.6006348133087158,
-1.124741554260254,
0.5033137798309326,
-0.5851417779922485,
-0.23062677681446075,
0.15551899373531342,
0.028667693957686424,
0.13033272325992584,
0.5757245421409607,
-0.7017939686775208,
0.4534035921096802,
0.91156405210495,
0.8096647262573242,
-0.13779433071613312,
-0.2427734136581421,
-0.5058860778808594,
0.20111499726772308,
-0.24189221858978271,
0.397663950920105,
-0.5928919911384583,
-0.007778703700751066,
0.024715343490242958,
-0.1350078284740448,
-0.1841006577014923,
-0.5089148283004761,
0.34632769227027893,
-0.412811815738678,
-0.09635180234909058,
-0.1225612610578537,
-0.44323617219924927,
-0.1570124477148056,
0.24057136476039886,
-0.6261550784111023,
0.8315101265907288,
0.1576737016439438,
-0.45081475377082825,
0.310355544090271,
-0.6200900673866272,
-0.5544875860214233,
-0.011184178292751312,
-0.35661783814430237,
0.026107825338840485,
0.2591802179813385,
0.08510272204875946,
0.6938433051109314,
-0.42198997735977173,
0.5140941739082336,
-0.3108888864517212,
-0.4663461446762085,
0.3203634023666382,
-0.17861148715019226,
0.6654748916625977,
0.19803941249847412,
-0.5437965393066406,
0.30281388759613037,
-0.7876755595207214,
0.18133530020713806,
0.21485471725463867,
-0.29653409123420715,
-0.3938918709754944,
0.23199614882469177,
-0.1194567084312439,
0.4941440522670746,
-0.04519040882587433,
-0.25160306692123413,
0.0605044886469841,
-0.5479974746704102,
0.4921517074108124,
1.0627816915512085,
-0.5718562602996826,
0.37219780683517456,
-0.14832156896591187,
0.46980834007263184,
-0.13501234352588654,
-0.10302169620990753,
0.06595595926046371,
-0.07619374990463257,
-0.8154163360595703,
-0.3198219835758209,
0.07695544511079788,
0.5072831511497498,
-0.8693954348564148,
0.6501067876815796,
-0.4199424684047699,
-0.43744510412216187,
-0.2735661566257477,
0.15731534361839294,
0.22954030334949493,
0.2760027348995209,
0.26935261487960815,
0.010295439511537552,
-0.47725364565849304,
-0.8841390013694763,
-0.4357072412967682,
-0.1794469952583313,
0.03757771477103233,
0.047724250704050064,
0.4437083899974823,
0.1521841436624527,
0.723674476146698,
-0.39941170811653137,
-0.18540798127651215,
-0.6921595335006714,
0.05309018865227699,
0.5298061370849609,
0.2646354138851166,
0.2964935004711151,
-0.34077656269073486,
-0.46880316734313965,
-0.03053443878889084,
-0.8811125159263611,
-0.08870700001716614,
-0.2355373352766037,
-0.046997085213661194,
-0.05351121351122856,
0.5599759817123413,
-0.9379589557647705,
0.1934385746717453,
0.16555021703243256,
-0.2761754095554352,
0.5928322672843933,
-0.04087065905332565,
-0.2885332405567169,
-0.8609302043914795,
0.04445302113890648,
0.23381824791431427,
-0.27615517377853394,
-0.47239750623703003,
0.12285711616277695,
-0.013685664162039757,
-0.09911732375621796,
-0.4459569454193115,
0.8343839049339294,
-0.38994795083999634,
-0.2349514216184616,
-0.2440875917673111,
-0.10720571130514145,
-0.18473400175571442,
0.4606132209300995,
0.1395110785961151,
0.5647764205932617,
0.5667255520820618,
-0.49396368861198425,
0.14745837450027466,
0.040073979645967484,
-0.5327492356300354,
0.5748618841171265,
-0.6317167282104492,
-0.13698236644268036,
-0.36238980293273926,
0.376459002494812,
-0.4831525981426239,
-0.16514310240745544,
0.31815990805625916,
0.016901545226573944,
0.4745335876941681,
0.18378262221813202,
-0.6393982768058777,
-0.20472459495067596,
0.010612895712256432,
0.12692891061306,
0.543232262134552,
-0.6966502666473389,
0.8674904704093933,
0.07219575345516205,
-0.1735900342464447,
-0.6499431133270264,
-0.5402684211730957,
0.15318669378757477,
-0.11941572278738022,
-0.3136214315891266,
-0.00976040493696928,
0.23209862411022186,
-0.5034828186035156,
-0.08837445825338364,
-0.008673164062201977,
0.10225234925746918,
0.18321314454078674,
0.4740678369998932,
0.2446976751089096,
-0.11358685046434402,
0.40869513154029846,
-0.07197603583335876,
-0.07415517419576645,
0.3300272226333618,
-0.2813900113105774,
0.5335872173309326,
-0.1325620859861374,
-0.48245468735694885,
-0.5817908048629761,
0.15139301121234894,
0.6614237427711487,
-0.227584570646286,
0.9266322255134583,
0.3829117715358734,
-0.3191121816635132,
-0.6140796542167664,
-0.2928893566131592,
-0.34392279386520386,
-0.4124234914779663,
0.35196760296821594,
-0.44745421409606934,
-0.6674830317497253,
0.08861803263425827,
-0.3071812093257904,
0.23999539017677307,
0.29425129294395447,
0.4363834261894226,
-0.04302463307976723,
1.2206987142562866,
0.5506987571716309,
-0.18726897239685059,
0.4281052350997925,
-0.04336434230208397,
0.20990623533725739,
-0.4244789779186249,
-0.26807984709739685,
-0.5101150274276733,
-0.6646391749382019,
-0.15355557203292847,
-0.30950263142585754,
0.14774392545223236,
-0.08774972707033157,
-0.5781301259994507,
0.2888898551464081,
-0.4782008230686188,
0.5856118202209473,
0.4298740327358246,
0.19250652194023132,
0.16723038256168365,
0.10734733939170837,
-0.02383713610470295,
-0.034295596182346344,
-0.5136216878890991,
-0.46840333938598633,
1.0245376825332642,
0.3387061357498169,
0.8806602954864502,
-0.024594388902187347,
0.6675513982772827,
0.255381315946579,
0.6031752228736877,
-0.7884936332702637,
0.748097836971283,
-0.34649163484573364,
-0.23613345623016357,
-0.16725178062915802,
-0.533332347869873,
-0.7533283829689026,
0.37683242559432983,
-0.3285813629627228,
-1.0585492849349976,
-0.06897672265768051,
0.06280825287103653,
-0.13188770413398743,
0.363741934299469,
-0.7259498834609985,
0.7252091765403748,
-0.7376534342765808,
-0.23720066249370575,
-0.48127591609954834,
-0.6577866673469543,
0.4416693449020386,
-0.23807306587696075,
0.2574061453342438,
-0.1441517472267151,
0.14452442526817322,
0.5239267945289612,
-0.3069761097431183,
1.1398520469665527,
-0.1893732100725174,
0.0323258638381958,
-0.1316102147102356,
0.17188286781311035,
0.7134101986885071,
-0.30522143840789795,
-0.3855397403240204,
0.1966833621263504,
0.0666118785738945,
-0.21386060118675232,
-0.8703309893608093,
0.5686450004577637,
-0.8438007831573486,
-0.6313318014144897,
-0.48374220728874207,
-0.7553196549415588,
-0.22684794664382935,
0.15360841155052185,
-0.27238357067108154,
0.31955498456954956,
-0.12651729583740234,
0.08719943463802338,
0.3697514832019806,
-0.3153453767299652,
0.24327710270881653,
0.4786834120750427,
-0.399293452501297,
-0.02913128212094307,
0.8902033567428589,
-0.027623450383543968,
0.2299088090658188,
0.45049360394477844,
0.22186094522476196,
-0.5011380910873413,
-0.49047815799713135,
-0.3306482136249542,
0.4158664643764496,
-0.8210846185684204,
-0.021326344460248947,
-0.4642314016819,
-0.3241010308265686,
-0.1585436314344406,
-0.09231892228126526,
-0.0798816904425621,
-0.47933661937713623,
-0.1975831687450409,
-0.0336618572473526,
0.17889706790447235,
0.7334380149841309,
0.017866646870970726,
0.40843749046325684,
-0.6418642401695251,
0.14663013815879822,
0.018048062920570374,
0.2783740758895874,
0.11596363037824631,
-0.40223148465156555,
-0.15126049518585205,
0.059736352413892746,
0.03552829474210739,
-0.6883618831634521,
0.4690599739551544,
0.17993809282779694,
0.6839878559112549,
0.29857978224754333,
-0.005814321804791689,
0.528693675994873,
-0.34202930331230164,
0.3306996822357178,
0.49124130606651306,
-0.836383044719696,
0.5079604983329773,
-0.043866679072380066,
0.35452714562416077,
0.38761672377586365,
0.42122605443000793,
-0.4300366938114166,
-0.3744095265865326,
-0.3390420079231262,
-0.5608247518539429,
1.0046638250350952,
0.040282242000103,
0.07809364795684814,
0.21035659313201904,
0.2720804512500763,
0.10766412317752838,
0.27308449149131775,
-0.854301929473877,
0.08329497277736664,
-0.09360561519861221,
-0.6560832858085632,
-0.40371420979499817,
0.08687347173690796,
-0.2304074466228485,
-0.39254605770111084,
0.5010737776756287,
-0.2551206052303314,
-0.09427835047245026,
-0.3419720530509949,
-0.3308936655521393,
0.0875304788351059,
0.36800846457481384,
0.22382961213588715,
0.8374909162521362,
-0.14557652175426483,
0.40197667479515076,
0.02238243818283081,
-0.039638590067625046,
0.1939893364906311,
0.1659051924943924,
-0.15718185901641846,
-0.2608586847782135,
0.4521481990814209,
0.9518333077430725,
0.21676106750965118,
-1.073132872581482,
0.23772260546684265,
-0.009508631192147732,
0.02039606124162674,
-0.3824774920940399,
0.29207950830459595,
0.18181221187114716,
0.48891913890838623,
-0.0034244575072079897,
0.0062539950013160706,
-0.20927570760250092,
-0.5946062803268433,
0.034233465790748596,
0.43772533535957336,
-0.34209999442100525,
-0.303898423910141,
0.5285288095474243,
0.04233963042497635,
-0.1880456954240799,
0.8124895095825195,
0.03318683058023453,
-0.4446505308151245,
0.6212265491485596,
0.6277409791946411,
0.7527989149093628,
-0.09147214889526367,
0.30412283539772034,
0.3031938672065735,
0.3760509490966797,
-0.2516425848007202,
0.2974075973033905,
-0.06327507644891739,
-0.6425012350082397,
-0.6621862053871155,
-0.9379127025604248,
-0.12247566878795624,
0.2190970927476883,
-0.4027782678604126,
0.23637990653514862,
-0.674701452255249,
0.029414812102913857,
0.16828852891921997,
-0.35183078050613403,
-0.6688485741615295,
0.1757880598306656,
0.08205924928188324,
1.0225526094436646,
-0.9439057111740112,
0.9130212068557739,
0.8098710179328918,
-0.34553396701812744,
-1.1163617372512817,
-0.34376028180122375,
0.10923335701227188,
-0.9129718542098999,
1.143194317817688,
0.32534316182136536,
0.22387568652629852,
-0.13342012465000153,
-0.5499701499938965,
-0.6412729024887085,
0.7970490455627441,
0.6414821147918701,
-0.530225396156311,
-0.12073341012001038,
0.38156944513320923,
0.5921066999435425,
-0.18385034799575806,
0.314355731010437,
0.8505979180335999,
0.6413462162017822,
0.27056461572647095,
-0.795575737953186,
0.27385213971138,
-0.16680853068828583,
-0.3064934313297272,
0.4198469817638397,
-0.1952756941318512,
0.6531925797462463,
-0.07875955104827881,
-0.1475507766008377,
-0.0664779543876648,
0.4789980351924896,
0.44850239157676697,
0.12532706558704376,
0.5981459021568298,
0.6439061164855957,
0.5856010913848877,
-0.26250264048576355,
1.1594809293746948,
-0.27660948038101196,
-0.22448179125785828,
1.1626640558242798,
-0.4234732389450073,
0.9357852339744568,
0.45667606592178345,
-0.2506985366344452,
0.45861536264419556,
0.5188133120536804,
0.059416864067316055,
0.24101591110229492,
0.5097931623458862,
-0.31550344824790955,
-0.6748936772346497,
-0.34018266201019287,
-0.09375368058681488,
0.4745587110519409,
0.5210021734237671,
-0.4842560589313507,
-0.5038214921951294,
-0.18612311780452728,
-0.05006396770477295,
0.11854297667741776,
-0.2853321135044098,
0.47290048003196716,
0.45050013065338135,
-0.7698950171470642,
0.46008360385894775,
0.020351415500044823,
0.46680304408073425,
-0.8831002116203308,
-0.2401929348707199,
0.11098115891218185,
0.4421843886375427,
-0.2339724898338318,
-0.8235495090484619,
0.2566899061203003,
-0.21872280538082123,
0.05835147202014923,
-0.40287184715270996,
0.9158022999763489,
-0.33591893315315247,
-0.5299379229545593,
0.32697898149490356,
0.6827839016914368,
0.17752094566822052,
-0.1227506771683693,
-0.8126916885375977,
0.05598687008023262,
-0.12969054281711578,
-0.11477550119161606,
0.594493567943573,
0.22704604268074036,
-0.3664066791534424,
0.9324696660041809,
0.7675691246986389,
0.30390867590904236,
-0.17094284296035767,
0.2182733565568924,
0.8356102705001831,
-0.5902061462402344,
-0.48156049847602844,
-0.8573262095451355,
0.3214443624019623,
-0.11421468108892441,
0.18151649832725525,
0.4064370095729828,
0.2949598729610443,
0.40507209300994873,
-0.026473257690668106,
0.7614908218383789,
-0.050086554139852524,
0.3831247091293335,
-0.6020033955574036,
0.6480196118354797,
-0.5911424160003662,
0.32393500208854675,
0.035623982548713684,
-0.9685239195823669,
-0.37397295236587524,
0.6003985404968262,
-0.4820597469806671,
0.04339555278420448,
0.4684348404407501,
0.6842979192733765,
-0.12316358834505081,
0.03312606364488602,
0.24788957834243774,
0.29006803035736084,
0.2827158272266388,
0.7249402403831482,
1.1201658248901367,
0.2343614548444748,
0.2476375550031662,
-0.12395636737346649,
-0.23704813420772552,
-0.03978481888771057,
-0.7982276678085327,
-0.9062569737434387,
-0.24002772569656372,
-0.022728780284523964,
-0.19108715653419495,
0.13616928458213806,
1.1201577186584473,
0.7394911646842957,
-0.6908335089683533,
-0.4382489323616028,
-0.03312176465988159,
0.20765937864780426,
-0.34461456537246704,
-0.208461195230484,
0.49899160861968994,
-0.4235726594924927,
-0.6566506028175354,
0.46655258536338806,
0.1726624220609665,
-0.027745574712753296,
-0.23039846122264862,
-0.3568679094314575,
-0.11383436620235443,
0.013879604637622833,
0.8860307931900024,
0.41633450984954834,
-0.7831169962882996,
-0.27873966097831726,
-0.061509374529123306,
0.007836746983230114,
-0.26729124784469604,
0.7791017293930054,
-0.9190403819084167,
0.309239000082016,
0.41973182559013367,
0.7365820407867432,
0.3262394368648529,
-0.14632649719715118,
0.738365650177002,
-0.6312853097915649,
0.20900996029376984,
0.22589218616485596,
0.5123496651649475,
0.11642089486122131,
-0.11119981110095978,
0.6554784774780273,
-0.03417627513408661,
-0.22777420282363892,
-0.7922398447990417,
0.17310436069965363,
-0.9444257020950317,
-0.5872544646263123,
1.1580239534378052,
-0.08827878534793854,
-0.11868488043546677,
-0.09349604696035385,
-0.12919196486473083,
0.15783794224262238,
-0.2927553355693817,
0.8181243538856506,
0.58425372838974,
-0.24444054067134857,
-0.3115970492362976,
-0.5042722225189209,
0.352441668510437,
0.4817592203617096,
-1.0250309705734253,
0.04751931130886078,
0.6611985564231873,
0.0517149344086647,
0.07585706561803818,
0.300782710313797,
0.03760668635368347,
0.11039569228887558,
-0.3498891592025757,
0.1737312227487564,
-0.24965912103652954,
-0.33866211771965027,
-0.3030858039855957,
0.13700295984745026,
0.3180912137031555,
0.1999710500240326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17213v1 | Detecting Frames in News Headlines and Lead Images in U.S. Gun Violence Coverage | 2024-06-25T01:56:47 | 2024-06-25T01:56:47 | Isidora Chara Tourni, Lei Guo, Hengchang Hu, Edward Halim, Prakash Ishwar, Taufiq Daryanto, Mona Jalal, Boqi Chen, Margrit Betke, Fabian Zhafransyah, Sha Lai, Derry Tanti Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | News media structure their reporting of events or issues using certain
perspectives.
When describing an incident involving gun violence, for example, some
journalists may focus on mental health or gun regulation, while others may
emphasize the discussion of gun rights. Such perspectives are called
\say{frames} in communication research. We study, for the first time, the value
of combining lead images and their contextual information with text to identify
the frame of a given news article. We observe that using multiple modes of
information(article- and image-derived features) improves prediction of news
frames over any single mode of information when the images are relevant to the
frames of the headlines. We also observe that frame image relevance is related
to the ease of conveying frames via images, which we call frame concreteness.
Additionally, we release the first multimodal news framing dataset related to
gun violence in the U.S., curated and annotated by communication researchers.
The dataset will allow researchers to further examine the use of multiple
information modalities for studying media framing. | [
-0.41105926036834717,
-0.958170473575592,
0.5346367955207825,
0.23466525971889496,
-0.5422758460044861,
0.049988359212875366,
-0.03887217491865158,
-0.40251150727272034,
0.20487309992313385,
0.2816697359085083,
-0.21789126098155975,
-0.4647929072380066,
-0.9336809515953064,
-0.08202703297138214,
-0.574349045753479,
0.9166180491447449,
-0.08851727843284607,
0.1848813146352768,
0.2651507258415222,
-0.15390729904174805,
-0.4090467691421509,
-0.3956287205219269,
-0.4584878385066986,
-0.03470173850655556,
0.43425703048706055,
0.019130781292915344,
1.049773931503296,
0.6546734571456909,
0.9957700371742249,
0.18360264599323273,
-0.24895739555358887,
-0.23342479765415192,
-0.26147353649139404,
-0.035436760634183884,
-0.0559595562517643,
-0.18751153349876404,
-0.31394585967063904,
0.43943852186203003,
0.5844013690948486,
0.2965009808540344,
0.6566892266273499,
0.045721013098955154,
-0.16771933436393738,
0.6172442436218262,
-0.7290931344032288,
0.011128142476081848,
-0.3408997058868408,
0.22780627012252808,
-0.5494683980941772,
-0.5544291734695435,
-0.40280041098594666,
-0.33367037773132324,
-0.08112983405590057,
-0.40132829546928406,
0.31673046946525574,
-0.06727883219718933,
0.9977041482925415,
0.027378130704164505,
-0.6831917762756348,
-0.35952332615852356,
-0.5242828726768494,
0.16619816422462463,
-0.3316808044910431,
0.4175328314304352,
0.5002378821372986,
0.08862962573766708,
-0.24671050906181335,
-0.162489652633667,
-0.4176162779331207,
-0.03808140754699707,
-0.25432470440864563,
0.02556714601814747,
-0.33117401599884033,
-0.08286499232053757,
0.4435133635997772,
0.4676666557788849,
-0.6582457423210144,
-0.3221634328365326,
-0.8259248733520508,
-0.2984475791454315,
0.7045586109161377,
0.06369194388389587,
0.460678368806839,
-0.17035183310508728,
-0.4625861346721649,
-0.15210358798503876,
-0.4230828881263733,
0.3957376182079315,
0.316832035779953,
0.07790052145719528,
-0.2116568684577942,
0.8073103427886963,
-0.14965608716011047,
0.791594386100769,
0.22609978914260864,
-0.38215407729148865,
0.364322692155838,
-0.685063362121582,
0.07901202887296677,
0.23787906765937805,
0.619024395942688,
1.024023413658142,
0.04755912348628044,
0.212008997797966,
-0.020109757781028748,
0.17040692269802094,
0.16057616472244263,
-0.8566110134124756,
0.146744042634964,
-0.15566711127758026,
-0.799555778503418,
-0.21860601007938385,
0.2636086046695709,
-0.5665612816810608,
-0.5423180460929871,
-0.06798355281352997,
0.3151567280292511,
-0.0875944271683693,
-0.3740859031677246,
0.0011889562010765076,
-0.6449919939041138,
0.3340209126472473,
0.004719362128525972,
-0.5896317362785339,
-0.2442253977060318,
0.47554704546928406,
1.068763017654419,
-0.1222013533115387,
-0.03645991533994675,
-0.3201490640640259,
0.044234730303287506,
-0.7067226767539978,
0.8396173119544983,
-0.6945085525512695,
-0.3120034635066986,
-0.15651042759418488,
0.23800194263458252,
0.4003497064113617,
-0.2741990089416504,
0.4995088577270508,
-0.778174877166748,
0.11875820904970169,
-0.1592099368572235,
-0.36488911509513855,
-0.17746217548847198,
0.29404333233833313,
-0.8210763335227966,
0.567176878452301,
-0.05125860869884491,
-0.8838184475898743,
0.7964560985565186,
-0.17629317939281464,
-0.594774603843689,
-0.4371072053909302,
-0.24341586232185364,
-0.698868453502655,
0.29773375391960144,
0.19337968528270721,
0.37952062487602234,
0.23326638340950012,
0.3178040683269501,
-0.3039045035839081,
-0.36259913444519043,
0.10236617177724838,
-0.4536714255809784,
0.4235266149044037,
0.2875254154205322,
-0.05131838843226433,
0.09485740959644318,
-0.5743505954742432,
-0.5265806913375854,
0.09944766014814377,
-0.30981308221817017,
-0.32513055205345154,
0.07525670528411865,
0.05604928731918335,
0.014610057696700096,
-0.16600356996059418,
-0.6719560027122498,
-0.22888192534446716,
0.1523922085762024,
0.055983882397413254,
0.33382245898246765,
0.17000927031040192,
0.631670355796814,
-0.5284569263458252,
0.20290370285511017,
0.266591340303421,
0.15238149464130402,
-0.7235153317451477,
-0.6359301805496216,
-0.08081186562776566,
-0.06851523369550705,
0.035383112728595734,
0.6046317219734192,
-0.28959646821022034,
0.14600680768489838,
0.2168091982603073,
-0.18593518435955048,
0.16949190199375153,
-0.3826034665107727,
0.09234687685966492,
0.5206916332244873,
0.2671133279800415,
-0.6704160571098328,
-0.6464226245880127,
-0.7745105624198914,
-0.40702444314956665,
0.1388755589723587,
0.23425231873989105,
-0.26827871799468994,
0.19404864311218262,
0.34996530413627625,
1.1407866477966309,
-0.4841693341732025,
-0.3656523525714874,
0.01886769011616707,
0.577867329120636,
0.24726064503192902,
0.3180807828903198,
0.6737405061721802,
-1.2479548454284668,
-0.2924569845199585,
-0.49010154604911804,
-0.8579181432723999,
-0.009699399583041668,
-0.2127310335636139,
-0.0179631095379591,
-0.0736590251326561,
0.7235216498374939,
-0.20812326669692993,
0.896088182926178,
0.3730151653289795,
-0.47375261783599854,
0.3732176721096039,
0.35500046610832214,
0.6562924981117249,
-0.8543520569801331,
-0.30815771222114563,
0.33865293860435486,
-0.21717622876167297,
-0.44940871000289917,
-0.4058624804019928,
-0.005207652226090431,
-0.7137093544006348,
-0.2893878221511841,
0.2253103107213974,
-0.4520537853240967,
-0.3847378194332123,
-0.7197350263595581,
0.06444656103849411,
0.259587824344635,
0.10461538285017014,
0.31479042768478394,
0.9330849647521973,
0.608761191368103,
-0.14751087129116058,
0.376669317483902,
0.18324685096740723,
-0.550584077835083,
0.7160941958427429,
-0.34882569313049316,
-0.19857317209243774,
-0.8461783528327942,
0.6265309453010559,
-0.9082978367805481,
-0.43919652700424194,
0.29511758685112,
-0.5659290552139282,
0.15147875249385834,
-0.14620140194892883,
-0.07827217876911163,
-0.20391564071178436,
-0.2523361146450043,
0.09859499335289001,
-0.1319856345653534,
0.12077898532152176,
0.14863044023513794,
0.6959516406059265,
-0.052969783544540405,
-0.554436981678009,
-0.8124215006828308,
0.22024691104888916,
-0.16047196090221405,
-0.6355983018875122,
0.3921527862548828,
-0.03074137680232525,
-0.287284791469574,
0.42085716128349304,
-0.3951825797557831,
-0.5422388315200806,
0.09228312224149704,
0.3152235150337219,
0.21644377708435059,
-0.4451737701892853,
0.5060123205184937,
-0.09938127547502518,
-0.35856249928474426,
-0.0039511509239673615,
0.4246305227279663,
0.21395081281661987,
-0.09153592586517334,
-0.14793707430362701,
-0.6244449615478516,
0.8984175324440002,
0.632988452911377,
-0.42435455322265625,
0.5899128913879395,
0.7229896783828735,
-0.29914069175720215,
0.46962490677833557,
-0.3403124511241913,
-0.4845118522644043,
-0.33118870854377747,
0.33042681217193604,
-0.2724234461784363,
-0.6821599006652832,
0.15682175755500793,
0.174607053399086,
0.017622580751776695,
0.14545197784900665,
0.3968748152256012,
-0.02535914070904255,
0.9184189438819885,
0.6036632657051086,
-0.11502192169427872,
0.9631988406181335,
0.11991546303033829,
0.21709118783473969,
-0.46875157952308655,
-0.015202084556221962,
-0.1680975705385208,
-0.5593866109848022,
-0.07146212458610535,
-0.30360034108161926,
0.3484785556793213,
0.35050317645072937,
-0.1742834597826004,
0.5087195634841919,
-0.5700634121894836,
0.7758314609527588,
0.3700495958328247,
0.32468295097351074,
0.7174707651138306,
-0.05326884984970093,
0.4596869647502899,
0.14769279956817627,
-0.1524200290441513,
-0.45041486620903015,
1.2696952819824219,
0.1284172236919403,
0.8217735886573792,
-0.031507909297943115,
0.432480126619339,
0.43730926513671875,
0.42896410822868347,
-0.9152079224586487,
0.26642513275146484,
0.048157207667827606,
-1.0143587589263916,
0.003123783739283681,
-0.0790293887257576,
-0.9061041474342346,
0.23526126146316528,
-0.6350628137588501,
-0.39792564511299133,
0.25420135259628296,
-0.05856231227517128,
-0.5891823172569275,
0.11258361488580704,
-0.5487369298934937,
0.5718340873718262,
-0.17700353264808655,
0.00862407498061657,
-0.2917485535144806,
-0.5635097622871399,
0.2583518624305725,
-0.04372325539588928,
0.4325975179672241,
-0.7787452340126038,
0.03763974457979202,
0.5512636303901672,
0.14170753955841064,
0.4742020070552826,
0.26702794432640076,
0.1946011632680893,
0.257361501455307,
-0.4583609998226166,
0.19377855956554413,
0.2772786617279053,
0.2035106122493744,
-0.059649452567100525,
-0.10841763019561768,
-0.22479258477687836,
-0.37587451934814453,
0.226124107837677,
-0.2876657545566559,
-0.6222955584526062,
-0.5673311948776245,
-0.7617401480674744,
0.012223277240991592,
0.294779509305954,
0.6996393203735352,
0.7760666012763977,
-0.019610276445746422,
0.4843326807022095,
0.7104973196983337,
0.33061519265174866,
0.9039943814277649,
0.4557654559612274,
-0.24818868935108185,
-0.32583004236221313,
0.17769087851047516,
0.4115557372570038,
-0.11838497221469879,
0.2785460948944092,
0.05776291340589523,
-0.0015383120626211166,
-0.4703647792339325,
-0.40174537897109985,
-0.35686013102531433,
-0.4488380253314972,
-0.33150312304496765,
-0.29938793182373047,
-0.21537894010543823,
-0.22386489808559418,
-0.3403051197528839,
-0.40279915928840637,
-0.16725242137908936,
-0.3489571809768677,
-0.1849338412284851,
0.3212929666042328,
0.40469926595687866,
-0.1718556135892868,
0.45287179946899414,
-1.0079245567321777,
0.6731448173522949,
0.3909331262111664,
0.4379619061946869,
-0.5807846784591675,
-0.2074618935585022,
-0.2540808916091919,
-0.13274097442626953,
-0.6791319251060486,
-1.5105315446853638,
0.04893072694540024,
-0.0491521991789341,
0.5935654044151306,
0.45556262135505676,
0.350790411233902,
0.1984635442495346,
-0.5998812913894653,
0.605652391910553,
0.4200047552585602,
-0.6657561659812927,
0.7904478907585144,
-0.41439375281333923,
0.13237136602401733,
0.414914071559906,
0.635230302810669,
-0.10969506204128265,
-0.39062580466270447,
-0.2609941363334656,
-0.4260489344596863,
0.3233705163002014,
0.023657459765672684,
0.5029081106185913,
-0.18268312513828278,
0.0504692904651165,
-0.26488491892814636,
0.14447882771492004,
-0.8113073110580444,
-0.22889241576194763,
-0.13618846237659454,
-0.04877929016947746,
0.15094178915023804,
-0.3958812952041626,
-0.5865733027458191,
0.002886091358959675,
0.28044164180755615,
-0.07689210027456284,
0.09512104839086533,
0.4008514881134033,
-0.2940097451210022,
-0.3268909156322479,
0.34323790669441223,
0.6999643445014954,
0.9301004409790039,
-0.2657166123390198,
0.316740483045578,
-0.4111020267009735,
-0.6163352131843567,
0.38717544078826904,
0.103458471596241,
-0.1695149838924408,
0.31222984194755554,
0.21279317140579224,
0.9177631735801697,
0.3653234839439392,
-0.45082831382751465,
0.8870905041694641,
0.07197540998458862,
0.031159576028585434,
-0.11898137629032135,
-0.010770482942461967,
-0.2534412443637848,
0.860458493232727,
0.8815134167671204,
0.4663282632827759,
0.4568537175655365,
-0.8811784386634827,
0.7457374930381775,
0.5177947282791138,
-0.35518595576286316,
-0.2045430988073349,
0.6970824003219604,
0.36073604226112366,
-0.16877859830856323,
0.1720779985189438,
0.028475642204284668,
-0.25109219551086426,
0.6277036070823669,
0.638801634311676,
0.5581596493721008,
0.12554286420345306,
0.3114558458328247,
0.3739538788795471,
0.38037794828414917,
-0.2011328488588333,
0.016155697405338287,
0.07087717205286026,
-0.9969332218170166,
-0.36181914806365967,
-0.281532347202301,
-0.38005584478378296,
-0.08925136178731918,
-0.8280225396156311,
0.2421017289161682,
-0.42642003297805786,
-0.8479003310203552,
0.29746583104133606,
-0.10471483319997787,
0.016980886459350586,
0.12368199974298477,
0.842425525188446,
1.026340365409851,
-1.1698805093765259,
0.7236179113388062,
0.5384162068367004,
-0.37281373143196106,
-0.3247055411338806,
0.20863567292690277,
0.5209785103797913,
-0.35831788182258606,
0.4774462878704071,
0.5679531693458557,
0.04917509853839874,
-0.130091592669487,
-0.46187278628349304,
-0.8035189509391785,
0.888744056224823,
0.47775477170944214,
0.00974672008305788,
0.054281555116176605,
-0.3704998195171356,
-0.2074434608221054,
-0.6771042346954346,
-0.012755303643643856,
0.38659733533859253,
0.5597652196884155,
0.26741930842399597,
-0.8239148259162903,
-0.32427582144737244,
-0.2748352289199829,
-0.05506090819835663,
0.49016785621643066,
-0.7271661162376404,
0.9217216372489929,
-0.2644093632698059,
-0.39694565534591675,
-0.3605368733406067,
0.7316458821296692,
0.22172817587852478,
0.8979875445365906,
0.18045862019062042,
0.6412864327430725,
0.45541274547576904,
-0.28005897998809814,
0.7399993538856506,
-0.34812381863594055,
0.3224371075630188,
1.0300836563110352,
0.18616192042827606,
0.749514102935791,
0.2920745015144348,
-0.03358776494860649,
0.432409405708313,
0.5811296701431274,
-0.16767455637454987,
0.6452394723892212,
-0.24532821774482727,
-0.21875065565109253,
-0.16054877638816833,
-0.11760200560092926,
-0.5823675394058228,
0.7058022022247314,
0.28842103481292725,
-0.5827263593673706,
-0.8017376065254211,
0.6100310683250427,
0.3454497754573822,
0.1738886535167694,
-0.4378030002117157,
0.5944215059280396,
-0.06580936908721924,
-0.24641473591327667,
0.02234332449734211,
-0.009376682341098785,
0.6685255765914917,
-0.4813840687274933,
0.08845648914575577,
-0.20211052894592285,
-0.2238369584083557,
-0.15526174008846283,
-1.21370530128479,
1.0486856698989868,
-0.1257791966199875,
-0.7092428803443909,
-0.40520572662353516,
0.8154993653297424,
-0.3891236484050751,
-0.2089032679796219,
0.04606977477669716,
0.09304242581129074,
0.008670728653669357,
-0.42468366026878357,
-0.5137324333190918,
0.557081401348114,
-0.37179800868034363,
-0.5670785903930664,
0.3217390179634094,
-0.061822421848773956,
-0.09211926907300949,
0.15706691145896912,
0.6271915435791016,
-0.1447073221206665,
0.15578795969486237,
-0.631737470626831,
0.8364388942718506,
-0.6121507287025452,
-0.30498114228248596,
-0.6125363707542419,
0.5098715424537659,
-0.47522738575935364,
-0.5636171102523804,
0.5158575177192688,
0.6678188443183899,
0.5023068189620972,
0.10502641648054123,
0.46000435948371887,
-0.21104061603546143,
0.13058939576148987,
-0.6068561673164368,
0.574559211730957,
-0.21741589903831482,
-0.2948983907699585,
0.1152302697300911,
-0.6907861232757568,
-0.5328317880630493,
0.7410613894462585,
-0.38322076201438904,
-0.5040097236633301,
0.5931259989738464,
0.7800253033638,
0.040163829922676086,
0.29037487506866455,
0.2994343638420105,
-0.3760055601596832,
-0.2444147765636444,
0.2981966435909271,
0.5400815010070801,
-0.37259218096733093,
0.6678980588912964,
-0.3220333158969879,
-0.49236372113227844,
-0.06550593674182892,
-0.8424829244613647,
-0.8546584844589233,
-0.5988452434539795,
-0.3532024919986725,
-0.16557979583740234,
0.14319536089897156,
0.6378729939460754,
1.0193297863006592,
-0.6462735533714294,
0.18541927635669708,
0.15650688111782074,
0.363818883895874,
-0.10019388794898987,
-0.2292463332414627,
0.3369716703891754,
-0.45719173550605774,
-0.7414224147796631,
0.5122952461242676,
0.5451494455337524,
0.07674935460090637,
0.1821116954088211,
0.4563435912132263,
-0.2014426290988922,
0.06140720099210739,
0.5770196914672852,
0.21638327836990356,
-0.29834380745887756,
-0.4537777900695801,
-0.04027904197573662,
-0.4455815851688385,
0.335825115442276,
1.046351671218872,
-0.7189161777496338,
0.6135756969451904,
0.6592012643814087,
0.5685927867889404,
0.3536149263381958,
0.1732686460018158,
0.5556322932243347,
-0.6714181900024414,
0.6541751623153687,
0.004304787609726191,
0.23239365220069885,
0.11089955270290375,
-0.49000051617622375,
0.3607514798641205,
0.4354868531227112,
-0.474081814289093,
-0.5801933407783508,
0.4024396538734436,
-1.059314489364624,
-0.3460102379322052,
0.8933669924736023,
-0.15317785739898682,
-0.14000573754310608,
-0.2562353014945984,
-0.2339036613702774,
0.2021656334400177,
-0.4120854437351227,
0.314226895570755,
0.8490955829620361,
-0.1477605551481247,
-0.8164414763450623,
-0.7530749440193176,
0.3255041241645813,
-0.2652503550052643,
-0.6148001551628113,
-0.35501614212989807,
0.7492762804031372,
0.06630873680114746,
0.26252007484436035,
0.667822003364563,
-0.18068251013755798,
0.3713605999946594,
0.10626509040594101,
-0.44617128372192383,
-0.26573795080184937,
-0.39838695526123047,
-0.04618930071592331,
0.4640769064426422,
-0.6177833676338196,
-0.4717091917991638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17186v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17186v2 | CLERC: A Dataset for Legal Case Retrieval and Retrieval-Augmented Analysis Generation | 2024-06-24T23:57:57 | 2024-06-27T15:55:57 | Abe Bohan Hou, Orion Weller, Guanghui Qin, Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, Nils Holzenberger, Andrew Blair-Stanek, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Legal professionals need to write analyses that rely on citations to relevant
precedents, i.e., previous case decisions. Intelligent systems assisting legal
professionals in writing such documents provide great benefits but are
challenging to design. Such systems need to help locate, summarize, and reason
over salient precedents in order to be useful. To enable systems for such
tasks, we work with legal professionals to transform a large open-source legal
corpus into a dataset supporting two important backbone tasks: information
retrieval (IR) and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). This dataset CLERC
(Case Law Evaluation Retrieval Corpus), is constructed for training and
evaluating models on their ability to (1) find corresponding citations for a
given piece of legal analysis and to (2) compile the text of these citations
(as well as previous context) into a cogent analysis that supports a reasoning
goal. We benchmark state-of-the-art models on CLERC, showing that current
approaches still struggle: GPT-4o generates analyses with the highest ROUGE
F-scores but hallucinates the most, while zero-shot IR models only achieve
48.3% recall@1000. | [
-0.4112638533115387,
-0.3726232647895813,
0.766163170337677,
-0.1644277274608612,
-0.2879691421985626,
-0.2243240624666214,
-0.0946282222867012,
-0.37805891036987305,
0.027544766664505005,
0.7375338673591614,
-0.23158127069473267,
-0.5467833280563354,
-0.4359368681907654,
-0.05070672184228897,
-0.7194599509239197,
1.1398720741271973,
0.15934626758098602,
0.18285925686359406,
-0.30745837092399597,
-0.5575003623962402,
-0.7332771420478821,
-0.902361273765564,
-0.30663877725601196,
-0.13651706278324127,
0.46564874053001404,
0.5284343361854553,
0.4342050850391388,
0.23377445340156555,
0.5754262208938599,
0.13483746349811554,
0.1549454927444458,
-0.16406609117984772,
-0.7419158220291138,
0.2833525836467743,
-0.44146791100502014,
-0.13701117038726807,
-0.4046548306941986,
0.01647496037185192,
0.15981478989124298,
0.4924609661102295,
-0.30258697271347046,
0.3494304120540619,
-0.44665947556495667,
0.8431153893470764,
-0.9198336601257324,
0.05280173197388649,
-0.8841190934181213,
0.026352636516094208,
-0.332244873046875,
-0.27955538034439087,
-0.6856651306152344,
-0.3942583203315735,
0.33608919382095337,
-0.6262783408164978,
0.5959024429321289,
0.15545594692230225,
0.6765279769897461,
0.2700352370738983,
-0.37266796827316284,
-0.6578253507614136,
-0.5890479683876038,
0.48076337575912476,
-0.4816773533821106,
0.40707913041114807,
-0.005557497497648001,
0.4054429531097412,
-0.29457196593284607,
-1.0992475748062134,
-0.41372716426849365,
-0.38778388500213623,
-0.1597200185060501,
0.3415471613407135,
-0.07939338684082031,
0.02861698530614376,
0.43340763449668884,
0.15350846946239471,
-0.5551232099533081,
-0.2457796186208725,
-0.5558744668960571,
-0.2125028371810913,
0.6208788752555847,
0.04174730181694031,
0.028527697548270226,
-0.05011463165283203,
-0.18831601738929749,
-0.17975911498069763,
-0.6288062930107117,
-0.1954803466796875,
0.42611163854599,
0.24610447883605957,
0.34404703974723816,
0.5104353427886963,
-0.007438047789037228,
0.746606171131134,
0.06651593744754791,
0.24832545220851898,
0.058687977492809296,
-0.23623138666152954,
-0.09274781495332718,
0.40921342372894287,
0.5352156162261963,
0.2893820106983185,
0.2259356826543808,
-0.02650744467973709,
-0.31198593974113464,
-0.2672499120235443,
0.4756031036376953,
-0.7673824429512024,
-0.2747383117675781,
0.40064185857772827,
-0.4761381149291992,
-0.09225471317768097,
0.5282557010650635,
-0.7787644267082214,
-0.4806007146835327,
-0.6267598867416382,
0.006943719461560249,
-0.2144894152879715,
0.03713696077466011,
0.18855144083499908,
-0.5051500797271729,
0.24147675931453705,
0.25405871868133545,
-0.39304137229919434,
0.4273107647895813,
0.5633297562599182,
0.582714855670929,
-0.015406567603349686,
0.11006271839141846,
-0.8712813854217529,
0.16918572783470154,
-0.26100102066993713,
0.8220711350440979,
-0.7323875427246094,
-0.5488753318786621,
0.12572652101516724,
-0.10410249978303909,
0.018763883039355278,
-0.6336951851844788,
0.8382692933082581,
-0.7444928288459778,
-0.058092135936021805,
-0.37371355295181274,
-0.5601515173912048,
-0.005259088706225157,
0.13170161843299866,
-0.9280332326889038,
0.684857189655304,
0.17534102499485016,
-0.9363200068473816,
0.6791791915893555,
-0.7352678775787354,
-0.5358045101165771,
0.27354928851127625,
-0.33055180311203003,
-0.48576146364212036,
0.1598730981349945,
0.0388307087123394,
0.29608967900276184,
-0.3341454863548279,
0.5807844400405884,
-0.27436766028404236,
-0.3554983139038086,
-0.05772172287106514,
0.1646391600370407,
0.593288242816925,
0.4817313849925995,
-0.20894476771354675,
0.11354906857013702,
-0.5841605067253113,
-0.0658004879951477,
0.09329032152891159,
-0.19487209618091583,
-0.34392327070236206,
0.004585200920701027,
-0.31184571981430054,
0.2200612872838974,
0.15991796553134918,
-0.3359639644622803,
-0.0132420863956213,
-0.017192741855978966,
0.3268527090549469,
0.5092573761940002,
0.21247628331184387,
0.3131861090660095,
-0.26075583696365356,
0.43326690793037415,
-0.14761270582675934,
0.016527840867638588,
-0.016773881390690804,
-0.20805487036705017,
-0.6921460628509521,
-0.07620299607515335,
0.6345357298851013,
0.5292077660560608,
-0.5594574809074402,
0.23473890125751495,
-0.5079953074455261,
-0.3194322884082794,
-0.4067462384700775,
-0.1820862740278244,
0.2188335359096527,
0.4701736867427826,
0.5041027665138245,
-0.25217247009277344,
-0.882611095905304,
-0.8928548097610474,
-0.5824013948440552,
-0.01544563565403223,
0.21335040032863617,
0.42539167404174805,
0.8749563694000244,
-0.04468749836087227,
0.9859280586242676,
-0.152169331908226,
-0.22008028626441956,
-0.352201908826828,
0.2628505825996399,
0.3871736526489258,
0.21866843104362488,
0.440749853849411,
-0.9361268281936646,
-0.46999043226242065,
0.040736231952905655,
-0.7457043528556824,
-0.16048885881900787,
-0.4000682234764099,
-0.19066914916038513,
0.020733026787638664,
0.6777321100234985,
-0.3246595859527588,
0.7649862766265869,
-0.2567789554595947,
-0.313752144575119,
0.7824363708496094,
-0.23796094954013824,
0.2825653553009033,
-0.5305117964744568,
0.6174729466438293,
-0.0632292777299881,
-0.3281591236591339,
-0.6570754647254944,
0.12198331207036972,
-0.06970379501581192,
0.01283592451363802,
-0.30678310990333557,
0.5859423875808716,
-0.49475598335266113,
-0.3000591993331909,
-0.20905928313732147,
0.25881072878837585,
0.05089688301086426,
0.2507743537425995,
0.027549955993890762,
0.6624248027801514,
-0.06087949126958847,
-0.5337291359901428,
0.13331668078899384,
0.3236806094646454,
-0.3138955235481262,
0.7046962976455688,
-0.5592754483222961,
0.31982162594795227,
-0.0451793447136879,
0.22740204632282257,
0.009582122787833214,
-0.45488661527633667,
0.0755390077829361,
-0.12644392251968384,
0.2381000965833664,
-0.4633057117462158,
-0.6321188807487488,
-0.5549609661102295,
-0.13060466945171356,
0.3033211827278137,
0.19626396894454956,
-0.6055150628089905,
0.5859706997871399,
0.561573326587677,
-0.05117373913526535,
-0.7729179859161377,
-0.31930673122406006,
0.0023822407238185406,
-0.1396695077419281,
-0.2887805998325348,
0.37348926067352295,
0.06219060346484184,
-0.5068125128746033,
0.10628455877304077,
-0.0908450186252594,
-0.020015941932797432,
-0.12949538230895996,
0.31178244948387146,
0.15459729731082916,
-0.009412399493157864,
0.2064959555864334,
0.00407760962843895,
0.12104259431362152,
0.029618768021464348,
-0.26905548572540283,
0.5225174427032471,
-0.2124364823102951,
-0.3756959140300751,
-0.08844000101089478,
0.3516726493835449,
0.5367245674133301,
-0.28742799162864685,
0.27493152022361755,
-0.023988882079720497,
-0.10073217004537582,
-0.1617668718099594,
-0.728887140750885,
0.04183083027601242,
-0.3629138171672821,
0.01975277252495289,
-0.5737447142601013,
-0.8543606400489807,
0.47949451208114624,
-0.004887176677584648,
0.2438420057296753,
0.5980428457260132,
0.6196036338806152,
0.15379267930984497,
0.5092994570732117,
0.2632283866405487,
-0.12352491170167923,
0.4224669337272644,
-0.16681750118732452,
0.22729019820690155,
-0.5768141150474548,
-0.18028727173805237,
-0.49116554856300354,
-0.019803395494818687,
-0.19978396594524384,
-0.2169637680053711,
0.48119544982910156,
0.026724424213171005,
-0.4494582712650299,
0.2967938780784607,
-0.6411646604537964,
0.5451489090919495,
0.7926084995269775,
0.03504033014178276,
0.3719886243343353,
-0.08569910377264023,
-0.3038162291049957,
0.41734206676483154,
-0.6233755350112915,
-0.43368586897850037,
1.2662792205810547,
-0.0017732555279508233,
0.26672428846359253,
-0.031413719058036804,
0.7441511154174805,
0.6122191548347473,
0.26697593927383423,
-0.5857858061790466,
0.6346150636672974,
-0.3084253966808319,
-0.8894334435462952,
0.048794735223054886,
-0.25638318061828613,
-0.8807975649833679,
0.10485425591468811,
-0.26147839426994324,
-0.5400879383087158,
0.47850823402404785,
0.07662003487348557,
-0.4930281341075897,
0.06974110007286072,
-0.5104063153266907,
0.7052265405654907,
-0.14369115233421326,
-0.7131111025810242,
-0.24255558848381042,
-0.8120331168174744,
0.4261397421360016,
-0.00010703175939852372,
0.17384804785251617,
0.10830028355121613,
0.43303415179252625,
0.5737107396125793,
-0.7144483327865601,
0.3972311317920685,
-0.3953680694103241,
0.31995800137519836,
0.9563519358634949,
0.20874488353729248,
0.5781925916671753,
0.12436829507350922,
-0.29226693511009216,
-0.25295355916023254,
0.3272532522678375,
-0.20468421280384064,
-0.5242550373077393,
0.5533803701400757,
-0.2068767547607422,
-0.6820980310440063,
-0.625958263874054,
-0.547333300113678,
0.153975710272789,
0.23913271725177765,
0.0734647661447525,
0.41540655493736267,
-0.36295169591903687,
0.20825091004371643,
0.43499523401260376,
0.14822597801685333,
0.12541525065898895,
0.5991408824920654,
0.09950669854879379,
-0.34567853808403015,
0.7894560098648071,
0.22596874833106995,
-0.3319830298423767,
0.05371420830488205,
0.04686560481786728,
-0.2539043724536896,
-0.6400337219238281,
-0.23035027086734772,
0.1356469690799713,
-0.8733136653900146,
-0.25153985619544983,
-0.46011656522750854,
-0.23079520463943481,
-0.40655654668807983,
-0.08722923696041107,
-0.2015480399131775,
-0.34275147318840027,
-0.17504441738128662,
-0.07944686710834503,
0.336349755525589,
0.7159219980239868,
-0.07059364020824432,
-0.010218683630228043,
-0.6693478226661682,
0.17482280731201172,
0.0587056428194046,
0.2857385575771332,
-0.26871776580810547,
-0.5097626447677612,
-0.1400909423828125,
-0.2859947681427002,
-0.2131885290145874,
-0.5883693099021912,
0.3342830538749695,
0.007087827660143375,
0.5348003506660461,
0.08240167051553726,
0.23739054799079895,
0.6707668900489807,
-0.6282539963722229,
0.5152674317359924,
0.014817215502262115,
-0.74619460105896,
0.697977602481842,
-0.2465495616197586,
-0.09060947597026825,
1.0673795938491821,
0.22392502427101135,
-0.24691878259181976,
-0.02299921214580536,
-0.8251445293426514,
-0.7344977259635925,
0.570087730884552,
0.2690202593803406,
-0.32317498326301575,
0.011675137095153332,
0.8879826664924622,
0.26259952783584595,
0.22205409407615662,
-0.3806968033313751,
0.2921413481235504,
-0.3171864151954651,
-0.40536126494407654,
0.48042914271354675,
-0.1590227484703064,
-0.30585938692092896,
-0.2763112783432007,
0.6499828100204468,
-0.18444442749023438,
0.0857916995882988,
0.4926326870918274,
-0.2786911427974701,
0.362643837928772,
0.23152455687522888,
0.5636271238327026,
0.6215471625328064,
-0.3128146231174469,
0.09464019536972046,
0.1131482869386673,
-0.4096544086933136,
-0.13198761641979218,
0.1963225156068802,
-0.08054149150848389,
-0.008201400749385357,
0.29003822803497314,
0.6304580569267273,
0.01447542104870081,
-0.9409176707267761,
0.5723577737808228,
-0.2197616696357727,
-0.37954455614089966,
-0.7388968467712402,
0.14170999825000763,
-0.29109472036361694,
0.26811569929122925,
0.3058657944202423,
0.04826778173446655,
0.4862971305847168,
-0.5638229250907898,
0.5802873373031616,
0.33071643114089966,
-0.3836926817893982,
-0.05205606296658516,
0.6473578810691833,
0.20496398210525513,
0.1106797605752945,
0.6077691912651062,
-0.2123006135225296,
-0.35317525267601013,
0.5879470705986023,
0.18457108736038208,
0.5821461081504822,
0.3246845304965973,
-0.00611046003177762,
0.6424480676651001,
-0.10722361505031586,
-0.511001706123352,
0.21706388890743256,
-0.060674767941236496,
-0.36125239729881287,
-0.07302660495042801,
-0.4198378026485443,
-0.39355766773223877,
0.06479714065790176,
-0.7528300285339355,
0.49955159425735474,
-0.2935842275619507,
-0.2502463757991791,
-0.17014922201633453,
-0.06295816600322723,
-0.7185877561569214,
0.020773354917764664,
-0.19588756561279297,
0.8684243559837341,
-0.419857382774353,
0.7639027833938599,
0.22722728550434113,
-0.6380448341369629,
-0.41157758235931396,
-0.18020574748516083,
-0.09624339640140533,
-0.3308402895927429,
0.7564031481742859,
0.08354167640209198,
-0.14119641482830048,
0.011484313756227493,
-0.8039689660072327,
-0.4878763258457184,
1.2795095443725586,
0.3000296354293823,
-0.7882056832313538,
-0.06946294009685516,
0.11874072998762131,
0.6838359236717224,
-0.684527575969696,
0.2624521851539612,
1.0967085361480713,
0.49066683650016785,
0.2534855008125305,
-0.6160523891448975,
0.040689289569854736,
-0.33016684651374817,
-0.23374009132385254,
0.05291556939482689,
-0.399842768907547,
0.5779304504394531,
-0.35406652092933655,
-0.4460633099079132,
0.1575220674276352,
0.4372732937335968,
0.5504205226898193,
0.5169163942337036,
0.34895768761634827,
0.5991542935371399,
0.8762819170951843,
-0.13848520815372467,
1.2748775482177734,
-0.5266574621200562,
0.25782695412635803,
1.664005994796753,
-0.4764750003814697,
0.8063479661941528,
0.4988589584827423,
0.2572343349456787,
0.6365576386451721,
0.2677534520626068,
-0.3126187324523926,
0.4599558115005493,
0.3532026410102844,
-0.2002851516008377,
-0.3198598623275757,
-0.21780581772327423,
-0.043107978999614716,
0.11031468957662582,
0.4817699193954468,
-0.4819529950618744,
-0.07199849933385849,
-0.30379825830459595,
-0.13852474093437195,
0.2437109798192978,
-0.23188157379627228,
0.8091347813606262,
0.035812776535749435,
-0.8252447843551636,
0.19535712897777557,
-0.39719563722610474,
-0.009829999879002571,
-0.23923754692077637,
-0.29760125279426575,
-0.20110878348350525,
0.1567879617214203,
-0.27210715413093567,
-0.8635733723640442,
0.26598915457725525,
0.15546995401382446,
-0.2660583257675171,
0.10637038946151733,
0.8676851987838745,
-0.08730993419885635,
-0.296385794878006,
0.40177831053733826,
0.4055551588535309,
0.27374592423439026,
0.041269537061452866,
-0.7198938727378845,
-0.05252371355891228,
-0.11416987329721451,
-0.13488811254501343,
0.08524948358535767,
0.3516680598258972,
-0.3357716500759125,
0.5613862872123718,
0.5995840430259705,
0.04020162299275398,
0.12050297111272812,
0.4963839054107666,
0.9824544787406921,
-0.6333121061325073,
-0.10251577943563461,
-0.5514660477638245,
0.6502639055252075,
-0.5217750072479248,
-0.13069336116313934,
0.13080085813999176,
0.732722282409668,
0.6659582853317261,
-0.056138429790735245,
0.9476282596588135,
-0.32366499304771423,
0.7039696574211121,
-0.6281337141990662,
0.45964720845222473,
-0.2535913586616516,
0.34933024644851685,
0.12579475343227386,
-0.6775016188621521,
-0.37773945927619934,
0.3771592080593109,
-0.42618528008461,
-0.10396036505699158,
0.618635356426239,
0.6730852723121643,
-0.0714435949921608,
0.0299529992043972,
0.17968082427978516,
0.013319423422217369,
0.4935236871242523,
0.4123508334159851,
0.7233097553253174,
-0.4687740206718445,
0.6480789184570312,
0.02728714793920517,
0.04187725856900215,
-0.4798498749732971,
-0.7405136227607727,
-0.9804132580757141,
-0.44510969519615173,
-0.09375222772359848,
-0.3553812801837921,
0.2908708155155182,
0.7867760062217712,
0.4747152030467987,
-1.0717991590499878,
-0.22133100032806396,
-0.5086946487426758,
-0.05826032534241676,
0.15379729866981506,
-0.20590505003929138,
0.43589040637016296,
-0.5891031622886658,
-0.4418925344944,
0.3938259780406952,
0.10359077900648117,
-0.23288409411907196,
0.11277773231267929,
-0.05118226632475853,
-0.391366571187973,
0.06258026510477066,
0.4034698009490967,
0.4941571354866028,
-0.599014401435852,
-0.5777353048324585,
-0.13346955180168152,
-0.061291471123695374,
0.22976154088974,
1.3853113651275635,
-0.8041432499885559,
0.7198165655136108,
0.519841730594635,
0.4335505962371826,
0.6387593150138855,
0.2439006268978119,
0.7901166081428528,
-0.6490299105644226,
0.1508786976337433,
0.4674070477485657,
0.6254522204399109,
0.08954917639493942,
-0.1027422845363617,
0.8915241956710815,
0.19346390664577484,
-0.7925055027008057,
-0.7394382357597351,
-0.02201131545007229,
-0.8086695075035095,
-0.4819510579109192,
0.8657763004302979,
-0.0773313120007515,
-0.2202288657426834,
-0.3493026793003082,
-0.23988765478134155,
0.3058031499385834,
-0.5267385840415955,
0.5898846387863159,
0.6471508741378784,
-0.22523120045661926,
0.03219601511955261,
-0.9037377834320068,
0.49561288952827454,
0.06538448482751846,
-0.6560643315315247,
0.11038675904273987,
0.7287660837173462,
0.2963917553424835,
0.349153071641922,
0.5478242635726929,
-0.3147629201412201,
0.403205007314682,
0.0006048976792953908,
0.358928382396698,
0.04441886395215988,
-0.44375115633010864,
-0.15235942602157593,
0.4365502893924713,
-0.18981817364692688,
0.34166419506073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17185v1 | Vaporetto: Efficient Japanese Tokenization Based on Improved Pointwise Linear Classification | 2024-06-24T23:47:20 | 2024-06-24T23:47:20 | Koichi Akabe, Shunsuke Kanda, Yusuke Oda, Shinsuke Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes an approach to improve the runtime efficiency of Japanese
tokenization based on the pointwise linear classification (PLC) framework,
which formulates the whole tokenization process as a sequence of linear
classification problems. Our approach optimizes tokenization by leveraging the
characteristics of the PLC framework and the task definition. Our approach
involves (1) composing multiple classifications into array-based operations,
(2) efficient feature lookup with memory-optimized automata, and (3) three
orthogonal pre-processing methods for reducing actual score calculation. Thus,
our approach makes the tokenization speed 5.7 times faster than the current
approach based on the same model without decreasing tokenization accuracy. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/daac-tools/vaporetto under
the MIT or Apache-2.0 license. | [
-0.23160670697689056,
-0.37319231033325195,
0.4224419891834259,
0.12881696224212646,
-0.5315132737159729,
0.11160673946142197,
-0.057678740471601486,
-0.4048176407814026,
0.24963442981243134,
0.26946279406547546,
-0.12157627940177917,
-0.5763509273529053,
-0.5781235694885254,
-0.35591140389442444,
-0.3450413644313812,
0.6105194091796875,
-0.2790132164955139,
0.2566761076450348,
0.2476942390203476,
-0.082123301923275,
-0.43393605947494507,
-0.7914244532585144,
-0.8912767767906189,
-0.011230054311454296,
0.394593745470047,
0.3726017475128174,
0.39763709902763367,
0.8210789561271667,
0.5711376667022705,
0.3779303729534149,
0.019124599173665047,
-0.16441553831100464,
-0.5450389385223389,
0.05458946153521538,
0.08728206902742386,
-0.6199623346328735,
-0.49219197034835815,
-0.4450128972530365,
0.4318864941596985,
0.3706044554710388,
-0.10704454779624939,
0.2269032597541809,
0.0021946884226053953,
0.24929681420326233,
-1.0772886276245117,
0.1321980059146881,
-0.5174503922462463,
0.19244380295276642,
-0.328280508518219,
-0.416927307844162,
-0.32029467821121216,
-0.5944815874099731,
-0.252772718667984,
-0.7834214568138123,
0.12750522792339325,
-0.011557676829397678,
0.6834540367126465,
-0.024389570578932762,
-0.26715797185897827,
-0.07259202003479004,
-0.6444461345672607,
0.645307183265686,
-0.7375971674919128,
0.18897280097007751,
-0.13755002617835999,
0.5761639475822449,
0.047297392040491104,
-1.028090238571167,
-0.4385688900947571,
0.1170620396733284,
0.17436081171035767,
-0.08882274478673935,
-0.14574234187602997,
0.49020615220069885,
0.36180579662323,
0.14167657494544983,
-0.4262017607688904,
0.46232300996780396,
-0.3196645975112915,
-0.3552117645740509,
0.31548914313316345,
0.3098892867565155,
0.3284592628479004,
-0.5160658359527588,
-0.5636516213417053,
-0.11401843279600143,
-0.586422860622406,
0.40767231583595276,
0.31031307578086853,
0.31433120369911194,
0.3095625638961792,
0.2882348895072937,
-0.25907373428344727,
0.677791953086853,
-0.02014320343732834,
-0.3613348603248596,
0.28303247690200806,
-0.39596641063690186,
-0.08360695838928223,
0.3132137358188629,
0.7965248227119446,
0.5010745525360107,
-0.056841421872377396,
0.19340677559375763,
-0.25881707668304443,
-0.29463014006614685,
0.184653177857399,
-1.290865421295166,
-0.26060327887535095,
0.10883063077926636,
-0.8984121084213257,
-0.40380313992500305,
0.507586658000946,
-0.6914432048797607,
-0.07801919430494308,
-0.1375342309474945,
0.5144767761230469,
-0.64525306224823,
-0.14156951010227203,
-0.11879568547010422,
-0.5260410308837891,
0.2392600178718567,
0.4264660179615021,
-0.7726629376411438,
0.22919708490371704,
1.2089098691940308,
1.3081856966018677,
-0.23222002387046814,
-0.13877154886722565,
-0.38364148139953613,
0.30514004826545715,
-0.2783113121986389,
0.6207428574562073,
-0.40118780732154846,
-0.7984662652015686,
-0.3338387906551361,
-0.4548901319503784,
0.07786664366722107,
-0.3900979161262512,
0.19416958093643188,
-0.022464672103524208,
0.15984952449798584,
-0.315738707780838,
-0.4746238589286804,
-0.2931305170059204,
0.07031378895044327,
-0.3687048554420471,
1.088007926940918,
0.1371847242116928,
-0.6409043669700623,
0.5445907115936279,
-0.7193846702575684,
-0.3273378908634186,
0.3661513924598694,
-0.015928028151392937,
-0.12436407804489136,
0.34696778655052185,
0.2614075839519501,
0.42727363109588623,
-0.11253379285335541,
0.515627384185791,
-0.24300964176654816,
-0.8289119005203247,
0.012625028379261494,
-0.582493245601654,
0.8865769505500793,
0.23403489589691162,
-0.7104170918464661,
0.26128095388412476,
-0.9342635273933411,
0.40159252285957336,
-0.38054877519607544,
0.028403598815202713,
-0.5252236723899841,
0.018123382702469826,
0.13537786900997162,
0.09938789159059525,
0.557646632194519,
-0.319610595703125,
0.40025442838668823,
-0.6193174719810486,
0.30348509550094604,
1.011501669883728,
0.17789654433727264,
0.15199130773544312,
0.11878415197134018,
0.7367377281188965,
-0.03753954917192459,
0.7682372331619263,
-0.19125524163246155,
-0.5343055129051208,
-1.1734437942504883,
-0.48194169998168945,
0.30852773785591125,
0.4811410903930664,
-0.9226703643798828,
0.8612284064292908,
-0.1691461205482483,
-0.8252660632133484,
-0.20540151000022888,
-0.28593048453330994,
0.541886568069458,
0.6478428244590759,
0.2509469985961914,
-0.6760892271995544,
-0.7092093825340271,
-0.8941123485565186,
-0.0986531674861908,
-0.3535315990447998,
0.016290193423628807,
0.048826660960912704,
0.2682079076766968,
-0.04902796447277069,
0.719498872756958,
-0.634341299533844,
0.11824137717485428,
0.03141842037439346,
0.3843681812286377,
0.38763776421546936,
0.7187919020652771,
0.7486075758934021,
-0.4402889907360077,
-0.6250975131988525,
0.21227148175239563,
-0.4480424225330353,
-0.12071840465068817,
0.07869941741228104,
-0.23544864356517792,
-0.0629325807094574,
0.3823740482330322,
-0.15202176570892334,
0.780280590057373,
-0.004444028250873089,
-0.24415522813796997,
0.18927431106567383,
-0.19269467890262604,
0.4933808445930481,
-1.1279970407485962,
0.4150301516056061,
-0.3483484089374542,
-0.3475315272808075,
-0.7225564122200012,
-0.0022443693596869707,
-0.016977494582533836,
-0.2842673659324646,
-0.5248808264732361,
0.11831004172563553,
-0.20766760408878326,
-0.07609614729881287,
-0.4184083342552185,
0.021146759390830994,
-0.08073132485151291,
0.5117200613021851,
-0.11254360526800156,
0.807752251625061,
0.810429036617279,
-0.7263749837875366,
0.4202112555503845,
-0.3338630199432373,
-0.23232120275497437,
0.83925461769104,
-0.5784522891044617,
0.08079145848751068,
-0.1877133548259735,
0.13016943633556366,
-0.7665644884109497,
0.2810562252998352,
0.43057864904403687,
-0.32892730832099915,
0.09717674553394318,
0.026648249477148056,
-0.12666745483875275,
-0.472621351480484,
-0.7495408058166504,
0.36490166187286377,
0.45137715339660645,
-0.6785153150558472,
0.571632444858551,
0.3015458881855011,
0.05576328560709953,
-0.6612860560417175,
-0.4507531523704529,
-0.020045777782797813,
-0.31162023544311523,
0.03897508233785629,
0.46442994475364685,
0.1986045092344284,
0.11869513988494873,
-0.15654553472995758,
-0.16584694385528564,
-0.19660931825637817,
0.20770446956157684,
0.25739702582359314,
0.25806915760040283,
-0.12115848809480667,
0.09766048938035965,
0.19869063794612885,
-0.5569189190864563,
-0.24939991533756256,
-0.6099742650985718,
0.755374550819397,
0.09945613145828247,
-0.18600979447364807,
-0.9416717290878296,
0.21634449064731598,
0.4240694046020508,
0.0382167249917984,
0.6342930793762207,
0.6305015087127686,
-0.3444956839084625,
-0.24757854640483856,
-0.23513543605804443,
0.1877504289150238,
-0.5528953075408936,
0.5487666130065918,
-0.6731104254722595,
-0.5642611980438232,
0.4811462461948395,
-0.0021721827797591686,
-0.11366386711597443,
0.5069929361343384,
0.445720911026001,
0.21051234006881714,
1.082948088645935,
0.5054384469985962,
-0.2997453808784485,
0.7891286611557007,
-0.49810653924942017,
0.4874994456768036,
-0.678544282913208,
-0.555330216884613,
-0.9519206881523132,
-0.3730922043323517,
-0.5528948903083801,
-0.5678532719612122,
0.5323283672332764,
0.34821146726608276,
-0.3817141056060791,
0.6031843423843384,
-0.8600535988807678,
0.5053492784500122,
0.5736812949180603,
-0.012066371738910675,
0.11033472418785095,
-0.44810158014297485,
-0.08157208561897278,
0.001220227568410337,
-0.9073988795280457,
-0.26481592655181885,
1.1560336351394653,
0.19273589551448822,
0.466469407081604,
0.09603450447320938,
0.912559986114502,
0.126014843583107,
0.2531565725803375,
-0.9236882328987122,
0.6596084833145142,
-0.15595471858978271,
-0.2223956286907196,
-0.08588626235723495,
-0.5364523530006409,
-0.7582793235778809,
0.3212544620037079,
0.018647657707333565,
-0.8654619455337524,
0.34715110063552856,
0.17013907432556152,
-0.17100045084953308,
0.345948189496994,
-0.5877224802970886,
0.8931165933609009,
-0.7877141833305359,
0.06230715289711952,
-0.28561124205589294,
-0.13936688005924225,
0.31740090250968933,
-0.09678895026445389,
0.022083749994635582,
0.008294018916785717,
-0.4824308753013611,
1.0623657703399658,
-1.2190574407577515,
0.6307178139686584,
-0.9640846848487854,
0.1556275635957718,
0.1659894734621048,
-0.10703006386756897,
0.28363052010536194,
-0.0016492466675117612,
-0.13317707180976868,
0.23797260224819183,
0.26447904109954834,
-0.3509054481983185,
-0.9447102546691895,
0.7364723086357117,
-0.8376554250717163,
-0.34077513217926025,
-0.446499764919281,
0.12758255004882812,
-0.026767263188958168,
0.49190443754196167,
0.5926440358161926,
0.5488979816436768,
-0.182091623544693,
0.05031273886561394,
0.11869262903928757,
0.08673230558633804,
0.5442372560501099,
0.2422662079334259,
-0.5380180478096008,
-0.6997706294059753,
0.9958264827728271,
0.329509437084198,
-0.14845409989356995,
0.556983470916748,
0.2482302486896515,
-0.28605684638023376,
-0.9029175043106079,
-0.24602775275707245,
-0.2644025385379791,
-0.8130976557731628,
-0.5066778063774109,
-0.22231750190258026,
0.012151963077485561,
-0.49409323930740356,
-0.293565958738327,
-0.5192641019821167,
-0.79555344581604,
-0.4737699329853058,
0.037315160036087036,
0.2658482491970062,
0.6292708516120911,
0.20547537505626678,
0.7161238789558411,
-0.529838502407074,
0.3579358160495758,
0.12187553942203522,
0.5395403504371643,
0.30124717950820923,
-0.35606881976127625,
-0.24700960516929626,
-0.18495206534862518,
-0.19083064794540405,
-0.788054347038269,
0.1627533733844757,
0.17327511310577393,
0.696660578250885,
0.7236694097518921,
-0.15994125604629517,
1.332651972770691,
-0.2637883126735687,
0.8421926498413086,
0.718058705329895,
-1.6257121562957764,
0.7034467458724976,
0.11147402971982956,
0.07502628117799759,
1.0590710639953613,
0.5935653448104858,
-0.5548685193061829,
-0.09336050599813461,
-0.5223746299743652,
-1.151939868927002,
0.4965346157550812,
-0.12480247020721436,
-0.04679091274738312,
0.1643066555261612,
0.563517153263092,
0.14578011631965637,
0.3815212845802307,
-0.4525851607322693,
-0.20646435022354126,
-0.5572270154953003,
-0.37151476740837097,
-0.05791466683149338,
-0.1381974220275879,
0.4448379874229431,
-0.6190822720527649,
0.784777820110321,
-0.22859744727611542,
0.1542353332042694,
-0.039666227996349335,
0.09345641732215881,
0.2019573450088501,
-0.23891344666481018,
0.35833683609962463,
0.7551863193511963,
-0.008934732526540756,
-0.10542591661214828,
0.11910129338502884,
-0.45586487650871277,
0.3452470004558563,
-0.19206981360912323,
-0.4939251244068146,
0.010047409683465958,
0.2869502604007721,
1.2120945453643799,
0.37777015566825867,
-0.5104297995567322,
0.7398646473884583,
-0.1727655529975891,
-0.06934459507465363,
-0.29168277978897095,
0.5574498772621155,
-0.43738800287246704,
-0.017094150185585022,
0.1739627867937088,
0.10156640410423279,
0.5709994435310364,
-0.48041167855262756,
0.12655958533287048,
0.4056348204612732,
-0.2737206816673279,
-0.016244957223534584,
0.584679365158081,
0.43359532952308655,
-0.6338059902191162,
0.38884273171424866,
0.005017766263335943,
-0.7094693779945374,
0.4893358647823334,
0.44494956731796265,
1.1338289976119995,
-0.353203147649765,
0.11074105650186539,
0.579731285572052,
-0.045095738023519516,
-0.10367467999458313,
0.16905491054058075,
-0.4915451407432556,
-0.44285261631011963,
-0.16755469143390656,
-0.5245090126991272,
-0.6340247988700867,
-0.3644034266471863,
-0.7156152129173279,
0.5875232219696045,
-1.0666630268096924,
-0.2973873019218445,
-0.21683751046657562,
-0.1061445027589798,
-0.24246104061603546,
0.0012861164286732674,
-0.09001898765563965,
0.8685349822044373,
-0.5313807725906372,
1.0882630348205566,
0.06295935809612274,
-0.12284399569034576,
-0.9182986617088318,
-0.05961902067065239,
-0.22256265580654144,
-0.590183436870575,
0.534928560256958,
0.4336763918399811,
-0.36748605966567993,
-0.08979247510433197,
-0.06511428952217102,
-0.9578806161880493,
1.2666631937026978,
0.15722094476222992,
-0.8979073762893677,
0.04148462042212486,
-0.00859566405415535,
0.5885616540908813,
-0.27931076288223267,
0.4887942671775818,
0.6625070571899414,
0.5567710995674133,
0.06804472208023071,
-0.8763087391853333,
-0.18060266971588135,
-0.4915381669998169,
0.6697117686271667,
0.38165178894996643,
-0.7041031122207642,
0.6969976425170898,
0.45507776737213135,
-0.041951991617679596,
0.23203888535499573,
0.6042458415031433,
0.07962338626384735,
0.1892009973526001,
0.4487771987915039,
0.48318609595298767,
1.219585657119751,
-0.21257284283638,
0.7859939336776733,
-0.5625407099723816,
0.5049763917922974,
0.6898003816604614,
-0.19249297678470612,
0.9557889699935913,
0.46682658791542053,
-0.2905869781970978,
0.7245016694068909,
0.3167668282985687,
-0.04899250343441963,
0.29052263498306274,
0.3601083755493164,
-0.2024146467447281,
0.15948085486888885,
0.14699555933475494,
-0.28953707218170166,
0.9481266736984253,
0.012748598121106625,
-0.15000341832637787,
0.0867864340543747,
0.37281709909439087,
0.1988535076379776,
-0.0345163457095623,
-0.7476232647895813,
0.7110773324966431,
-0.3097291886806488,
-0.6611053347587585,
0.8035873174667358,
0.45356935262680054,
1.0733236074447632,
-0.7986621260643005,
0.2083931416273117,
0.08388001471757889,
0.18031758069992065,
-0.19071663916110992,
-0.30431702733039856,
0.23153507709503174,
0.2916971445083618,
0.15450435876846313,
-0.30571770668029785,
0.6390483379364014,
-0.022100700065493584,
-0.6503512859344482,
0.12763158977031708,
-0.06520745903253555,
0.10425049811601639,
0.21654012799263,
-0.7662977576255798,
0.1938301920890808,
0.07260532677173615,
-0.22773365676403046,
0.017218617722392082,
0.17717106640338898,
-0.030860599130392075,
0.5057163834571838,
0.572480320930481,
0.3474903702735901,
0.089187391102314,
0.11366075277328491,
0.7271518111228943,
-0.8933847546577454,
-0.9026352167129517,
-0.914645254611969,
0.3463504910469055,
-0.43769389390945435,
-0.4223223924636841,
0.8305178284645081,
0.9463881850242615,
0.6446977257728577,
0.10109066218137741,
0.7907347679138184,
-0.2084767371416092,
0.2536289691925049,
-0.7325538396835327,
0.5112144351005554,
-0.33462581038475037,
0.24665553867816925,
-0.28609198331832886,
-0.9422877430915833,
-0.4891977310180664,
0.6706392168998718,
-0.1924504190683365,
0.286795049905777,
0.7173933386802673,
0.7309191226959229,
0.11682727187871933,
-0.2499944120645523,
0.13163511455059052,
-0.06441586464643478,
0.7244702577590942,
0.928307294845581,
0.519493043422699,
-0.49103716015815735,
0.20803283154964447,
-0.6356086134910583,
-0.34517690539360046,
-0.30253124237060547,
-0.9330796003341675,
-0.5952962040901184,
-0.3919471204280853,
-0.22793583571910858,
-0.12768137454986572,
-0.13092337548732758,
0.7570796012878418,
0.7600252032279968,
-0.9642065167427063,
-0.38273391127586365,
-0.3352685570716858,
0.08193143457174301,
-0.07521232962608337,
-0.28437721729278564,
0.41823506355285645,
-0.331768274307251,
-0.8659390211105347,
0.2008562535047531,
0.6549689769744873,
-0.1555589735507965,
-0.40245017409324646,
-0.18465092778205872,
0.2597759962081909,
-0.08719857782125473,
0.3682081997394562,
0.18598398566246033,
-0.3931107223033905,
-0.5244898200035095,
-0.3959389925003052,
0.1307208240032196,
0.26978328824043274,
1.295150637626648,
-0.7996656894683838,
0.607938289642334,
0.7793342471122742,
0.20356090366840363,
0.7662540078163147,
0.17966441810131073,
0.4846949875354767,
-0.4067589342594147,
0.6536589860916138,
0.2666707932949066,
0.39616915583610535,
0.08322762697935104,
-0.36628708243370056,
0.11971695721149445,
0.5486670136451721,
-0.10345885902643204,
-0.6921592950820923,
0.04052161052823067,
-1.0249186754226685,
-0.4594555199146271,
0.5933934450149536,
-0.2638454735279083,
-0.6005914211273193,
-0.038797035813331604,
-0.3972357213497162,
0.23111757636070251,
-0.10184827446937561,
0.45835527777671814,
0.2406712919473648,
-0.28811532258987427,
-0.03988390788435936,
0.0611451230943203,
0.335638165473938,
0.04651471599936485,
-0.8635126948356628,
-0.19033409655094147,
0.33992505073547363,
0.28012412786483765,
0.10748016089200974,
0.9790841937065125,
-0.11704494804143906,
0.3938089609146118,
0.06279902905225754,
0.26927703619003296,
-0.2642713189125061,
-0.43369489908218384,
-0.5155499577522278,
0.44110536575317383,
0.37252554297447205,
-0.2571466863155365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17169v1 | Multi-LogiEval: Towards Evaluating Multi-Step Logical Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T23:02:56 | 2024-06-24T23:02:56 | Nisarg Patel, Mohith Kulkarni, Mihir Parmar, Aashna Budhiraja, Mutsumi Nakamura, Neeraj Varshney, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) continue to exhibit remarkable performance in
natural language understanding tasks, there is a crucial need to measure their
ability for human-like multi-step logical reasoning. Existing logical reasoning
evaluation benchmarks often focus primarily on simplistic single-step or
multi-step reasoning with a limited set of inference rules. Furthermore, the
lack of datasets for evaluating non-monotonic reasoning represents a crucial
gap since it aligns more closely with human-like reasoning. To address these
limitations, we propose Multi-LogiEval, a comprehensive evaluation dataset
encompassing multi-step logical reasoning with various inference rules and
depths. Multi-LogiEval covers three logic types--propositional, first-order,
and non-monotonic--consisting of more than 30 inference rules and more than 60
of their combinations with various depths. Leveraging this dataset, we conduct
evaluations on a range of LLMs including GPT-4, ChatGPT, Gemini-Pro, Yi, Orca,
and Mistral, employing a zero-shot chain-of-thought. Experimental results show
that there is a significant drop in the performance of LLMs as the reasoning
steps/depth increases (average accuracy of ~68% at depth-1 to ~43% at depth-5).
We further conduct a thorough investigation of reasoning chains generated by
LLMs which reveals several important findings. We believe that Multi-LogiEval
facilitates future research for evaluating and enhancing the logical reasoning
ability of LLMs. Data is available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/Multi-LogiEval. | [
-0.34298601746559143,
-0.8251214027404785,
0.6384546160697937,
0.27840620279312134,
-0.268967866897583,
0.09429048001766205,
-0.19013972580432892,
-0.39950665831565857,
-0.12719246745109558,
0.5381228923797607,
-0.5782899856567383,
-0.7055988907814026,
-0.5995633602142334,
0.12850898504257202,
-0.2819342315196991,
0.9094435572624207,
0.1429029405117035,
0.10375463962554932,
-0.27726423740386963,
-0.3895511031150818,
-0.5910329222679138,
-0.4281530976295471,
-0.6342505216598511,
-0.405936062335968,
0.49510952830314636,
0.3811357617378235,
0.5859254598617554,
0.05792741850018501,
0.32954901456832886,
0.26930418610572815,
-0.20143529772758484,
0.2739415764808655,
-0.3310074508190155,
0.06567300111055374,
-0.147896870970726,
-0.48973196744918823,
-0.5670960545539856,
-0.10511891543865204,
0.8975005745887756,
0.4489758014678955,
-0.18141694366931915,
0.28134870529174805,
-0.19919264316558838,
0.8270066976547241,
-0.6522474884986877,
0.23806259036064148,
-0.671457052230835,
0.016083993017673492,
-0.03245100378990173,
-0.04848829284310341,
-0.6424732804298401,
-0.4043041169643402,
-0.011212566867470741,
-0.3000940680503845,
-0.08370624482631683,
0.07435684651136398,
0.3342146873474121,
0.14157646894454956,
-0.7812812924385071,
-0.23236441612243652,
-0.43650326132774353,
0.884190022945404,
-0.7919796705245972,
0.6771788001060486,
0.013668570667505264,
0.22086183726787567,
-0.24401777982711792,
-0.4661366641521454,
-0.47471070289611816,
-0.4205489158630371,
-0.21691522002220154,
0.013029249384999275,
-0.030558478087186813,
0.14877858757972717,
0.40692824125289917,
0.25182631611824036,
-0.7009706497192383,
-0.07143669575452805,
-0.10974444448947906,
-0.2275671809911728,
0.7018942832946777,
0.36581510305404663,
0.06976568698883057,
-0.11761321872472763,
-0.4505177438259125,
-0.2152133733034134,
-0.5020653009414673,
0.3354637324810028,
0.25871482491493225,
0.26100635528564453,
0.17782071232795715,
0.4846237003803253,
-0.22574734687805176,
1.0833181142807007,
-0.3422836363315582,
-0.7257377505302429,
0.41134458780288696,
-0.7536213994026184,
-0.33898451924324036,
0.09650307893753052,
0.7172049283981323,
0.21131229400634766,
0.288326233625412,
0.1683749407529831,
-0.27340465784072876,
0.18657755851745605,
-0.08721020817756653,
-0.7806370854377747,
-0.11239109188318253,
0.21848081052303314,
-0.33887606859207153,
-0.07124555110931396,
-0.17960479855537415,
-0.9118176698684692,
-0.4868944585323334,
-0.23097021877765656,
0.564953625202179,
-0.532401978969574,
-0.25875577330589294,
0.6812110543251038,
-0.15456122159957886,
0.29533153772354126,
0.6223754286766052,
-0.554266631603241,
0.4473818838596344,
0.6303632855415344,
0.5720583200454712,
0.18278585374355316,
-0.5902128219604492,
-0.7973116636276245,
-0.13020721077919006,
-0.36337706446647644,
0.9409762620925903,
-0.8052151203155518,
-0.12429292500019073,
-0.34667572379112244,
-0.18835535645484924,
-0.35241174697875977,
-0.4168243110179901,
0.931429386138916,
-0.49245914816856384,
-0.048979274928569794,
0.02910846844315529,
-0.6159417629241943,
-0.4069296717643738,
0.4117344617843628,
-0.7553000450134277,
0.8341593742370605,
-0.332660973072052,
-0.7079091668128967,
0.5138880610466003,
-0.777751624584198,
-0.7522185444831848,
-0.06097592040896416,
-0.289180725812912,
-0.22051715850830078,
0.11710026115179062,
0.38586166501045227,
0.2888963222503662,
-0.6154450178146362,
0.18705663084983826,
-0.40930941700935364,
-0.24753576517105103,
0.08802187442779541,
-0.7206697463989258,
0.916713535785675,
-0.09247571974992752,
-0.24815933406352997,
0.08432518690824509,
-0.8700663447380066,
0.20396853983402252,
-0.09452059864997864,
-0.42147061228752136,
-0.3747847378253937,
-0.03669087216258049,
-0.4155115783214569,
0.4876407980918884,
0.10597828030586243,
-0.4712662696838379,
0.27330997586250305,
-0.15488451719284058,
0.21927481889724731,
0.6618612408638,
0.1935945451259613,
-0.018997300416231155,
-0.09487203508615494,
0.4541921615600586,
0.16228456795215607,
0.37281763553619385,
-0.45653650164604187,
-0.7463728189468384,
-0.69645094871521,
-0.6064687967300415,
0.2011755406856537,
0.6896200180053711,
-0.40131592750549316,
0.2641083598136902,
-0.0837896540760994,
-0.5041451454162598,
-0.529632568359375,
0.30358073115348816,
0.4860982894897461,
0.41138970851898193,
0.48917633295059204,
-0.21682286262512207,
-0.1308819055557251,
-0.9132441282272339,
-0.5241483449935913,
-0.4024927318096161,
0.062177401036024094,
0.19563233852386475,
0.6005134582519531,
-0.19099658727645874,
0.4675156772136688,
-0.3252740204334259,
0.059065625071525574,
0.01425501424819231,
0.4238434135913849,
0.6097458600997925,
0.13661175966262817,
-0.04712230712175369,
-0.5253483653068542,
0.004190994426608086,
-0.02324775606393814,
-0.7193829417228699,
0.19493751227855682,
-0.3057197630405426,
-0.18295229971408844,
0.20342569053173065,
0.1334720402956009,
-1.0631732940673828,
0.5175918340682983,
0.45160049200057983,
-0.6142122149467468,
0.7602021098136902,
-0.11948905885219574,
0.46830740571022034,
-0.5197773575782776,
-0.06559400260448456,
0.21086706221103668,
-0.21836839616298676,
-0.6599685549736023,
0.10772357881069183,
0.11305833607912064,
0.24540545046329498,
-0.27662062644958496,
0.5589148998260498,
-0.40492749214172363,
-0.1222391277551651,
0.1797684133052826,
0.3025495111942291,
0.31685638427734375,
0.3454225957393646,
0.12346774339675903,
0.39302515983581543,
0.637913703918457,
-0.5919008255004883,
0.5803974866867065,
0.177687868475914,
-0.8134773969650269,
0.6140538454055786,
-0.43926674127578735,
0.2665599584579468,
-0.14833514392375946,
0.44955918192863464,
-1.0782612562179565,
0.16338178515434265,
0.06603711098432541,
-0.2171037793159485,
0.03311096876859665,
-0.16339319944381714,
-0.8826652765274048,
-0.31520527601242065,
-0.29922395944595337,
0.47172948718070984,
0.19523319602012634,
-0.4586338996887207,
0.732144832611084,
0.06975073367357254,
-0.08986537158489227,
-0.7182592749595642,
-0.4608396589756012,
0.20526054501533508,
-0.3055111765861511,
-0.9308667182922363,
-0.17839716374874115,
-0.25610437989234924,
-0.4404129087924957,
-0.07218005508184433,
-0.3272700905799866,
-0.005432776641100645,
-0.04757346585392952,
-0.1417321264743805,
0.3597453832626343,
-0.3232302963733673,
0.31458067893981934,
0.0012561992043629289,
-0.07277863472700119,
0.135066956281662,
-0.5309220552444458,
0.21790985763072968,
-0.6386500597000122,
-0.6281813383102417,
-0.19754326343536377,
0.0636223703622818,
0.8230423331260681,
-0.5601687431335449,
0.7187701463699341,
0.5024538040161133,
-0.4480943977832794,
-0.05626292526721954,
-0.7121139168739319,
-0.11340546607971191,
-0.2787776589393616,
0.16959553956985474,
-0.716489315032959,
-0.9166012406349182,
0.1843203455209732,
-0.08732189238071442,
0.22002878785133362,
0.4246658980846405,
0.6516659259796143,
0.1940614879131317,
0.9059607982635498,
0.09607771784067154,
-0.02243344858288765,
-0.2266617715358734,
0.0663832426071167,
0.5093764066696167,
-0.5323976278305054,
-0.4494744837284088,
-0.4744536876678467,
0.005023686680942774,
-0.5462718605995178,
-0.6710533499717712,
0.291795015335083,
0.3913332521915436,
-0.21206384897232056,
0.1526867300271988,
-0.03486886993050575,
0.4847022593021393,
0.22154758870601654,
0.048775576055049896,
0.8710480332374573,
-0.20407095551490784,
-0.41272878646850586,
0.3193095922470093,
-0.637590229511261,
-0.536186933517456,
0.9539551734924316,
0.45160913467407227,
0.9218888878822327,
0.24886660277843475,
0.5672984719276428,
0.24752506613731384,
0.16111882030963898,
-0.9133530259132385,
0.6808704137802124,
0.06267507374286652,
-0.9345560073852539,
-0.7315148711204529,
-0.5852200984954834,
-0.7044337391853333,
0.6786355972290039,
-0.09170187264680862,
-0.9325494170188904,
0.08491600304841995,
0.08984202891588211,
-0.3091244399547577,
0.31705230474472046,
-0.7517040967941284,
1.0724583864212036,
-0.506304919719696,
-0.27003762125968933,
-0.4945701062679291,
-0.6617074012756348,
0.8426746726036072,
-0.354631632566452,
0.5266646146774292,
-0.2733525335788727,
0.03237671032547951,
0.39541327953338623,
-0.2900133728981018,
0.6325714588165283,
-0.23278500139713287,
-0.3234141767024994,
0.5328857898712158,
0.20797966420650482,
0.48704400658607483,
0.34087321162223816,
-0.18633611500263214,
0.16681155562400818,
0.29341018199920654,
-0.37047168612480164,
-0.7654008865356445,
0.541630744934082,
-0.2673644721508026,
-0.5615240335464478,
-0.34609681367874146,
-0.3494795858860016,
-0.3924103081226349,
0.10138269513845444,
-0.29127436876296997,
0.5196388363838196,
-0.045603036880493164,
0.13659442961215973,
0.6245601773262024,
-0.18834353983402252,
0.2277027666568756,
0.3186036944389343,
-0.39032378792762756,
-0.40181586146354675,
0.7639195322990417,
-0.20252999663352966,
0.37175771594047546,
0.5192281603813171,
0.21688614785671234,
-0.6670534610748291,
-0.33052924275398254,
-0.6448727250099182,
0.19645844399929047,
-1.0613727569580078,
-0.10865669697523117,
-0.46384450793266296,
-0.03858243674039841,
-0.11438637226819992,
0.3837408423423767,
-0.2733641266822815,
-0.4501500427722931,
0.2664705216884613,
-0.16614417731761932,
0.3469678461551666,
0.7232389450073242,
0.09975293278694153,
-0.3644331097602844,
-1.0143238306045532,
0.38423293828964233,
0.49005550146102905,
0.3766075074672699,
0.04199964925646782,
-0.48463043570518494,
-0.03734875097870827,
-0.23284590244293213,
0.01837524026632309,
-0.701624870300293,
-0.07083380222320557,
0.13401275873184204,
0.6892621517181396,
0.31961119174957275,
-0.22050897777080536,
0.9016100168228149,
-0.5881940722465515,
0.4977680742740631,
0.4100989103317261,
-1.0860061645507812,
0.45555397868156433,
-0.02712157368659973,
0.39889776706695557,
0.6940392255783081,
0.3091878592967987,
-0.5851505994796753,
-0.16291764378547668,
-0.40727511048316956,
-0.6270147562026978,
0.46256375312805176,
0.25537705421447754,
-0.20524050295352936,
0.06578274816274643,
0.07901480048894882,
0.19869957864284515,
0.4341789782047272,
-0.6983128786087036,
-0.15688419342041016,
-0.03104826807975769,
0.11505534499883652,
-0.26915308833122253,
-0.019166355952620506,
-0.031101970002055168,
-0.4645530879497528,
0.5509160757064819,
-0.14226627349853516,
0.12594984471797943,
0.049181658774614334,
-0.22743093967437744,
0.12299910187721252,
0.5663403868675232,
0.5780196785926819,
0.943756103515625,
-0.2142481803894043,
0.31714126467704773,
0.4128265380859375,
-0.08503720909357071,
0.3180191218852997,
0.0629221498966217,
0.24798226356506348,
-0.05376783013343811,
0.8321069478988647,
0.826948881149292,
0.1930222362279892,
-0.9043153524398804,
0.46351805329322815,
-0.24812299013137817,
-0.184971421957016,
-0.09889455884695053,
-0.006373268086463213,
0.23860104382038116,
0.3871687650680542,
0.11218693107366562,
0.08651101589202881,
0.17128098011016846,
-0.6995071768760681,
0.31437161564826965,
0.341187447309494,
-0.1195894256234169,
-0.1345548927783966,
0.17997749149799347,
-0.016800440847873688,
-0.15235872566699982,
0.7626358866691589,
-0.41572076082229614,
-0.2268960326910019,
0.37965333461761475,
0.34826526045799255,
0.679918646812439,
-0.22670580446720123,
0.19972243905067444,
0.46961653232574463,
0.6953417062759399,
0.04697394371032715,
0.3089730143547058,
0.03411329537630081,
-0.8369863033294678,
-0.8788650631904602,
-0.8072890043258667,
-0.24667218327522278,
0.3660222291946411,
-0.5338597893714905,
0.31935709714889526,
-0.42511847615242004,
-0.03780839964747429,
0.03647811710834503,
-0.18271435797214508,
-0.7738857865333557,
0.24531279504299164,
0.10673141479492188,
1.2341810464859009,
-0.8207594752311707,
0.7386369705200195,
0.6821311712265015,
-0.22879213094711304,
-0.4884054660797119,
0.13253086805343628,
0.13783156871795654,
-0.7210294008255005,
0.606815755367279,
0.3438539505004883,
-0.6438166499137878,
-0.19381077587604523,
-0.24844476580619812,
-0.510188639163971,
0.9878012537956238,
0.2786223292350769,
-0.6888799071311951,
0.191725954413414,
-0.014375207014381886,
0.5793291926383972,
-0.47949331998825073,
0.5820705890655518,
0.9450125098228455,
0.8340466022491455,
0.15764889121055603,
-0.9064918756484985,
-0.005219243932515383,
-0.15496036410331726,
-0.1387072056531906,
0.3874529004096985,
-0.6850997805595398,
0.6844449043273926,
-0.2595559358596802,
-0.04201444238424301,
-0.21790829300880432,
0.2327304631471634,
0.6628779768943787,
0.2752310037612915,
0.8690925240516663,
0.8809412717819214,
1.0078957080841064,
0.17826122045516968,
0.9765085577964783,
-0.26628509163856506,
0.29972195625305176,
1.095571517944336,
-0.5088561773300171,
0.8512462973594666,
0.3051471710205078,
-0.21272799372673035,
0.73236083984375,
0.6018615365028381,
0.25976207852363586,
0.21702001988887787,
0.4185371994972229,
-0.6313024759292603,
-0.6878666281700134,
0.01359228603541851,
-0.0047829351387917995,
0.5560034513473511,
0.47401031851768494,
-0.011117707937955856,
-0.179030179977417,
-0.3368285000324249,
-0.08048141002655029,
-0.29314881563186646,
-0.2964898645877838,
0.5840150117874146,
0.10480991005897522,
-0.647365391254425,
0.7084582448005676,
0.06039879843592644,
0.25071361660957336,
-0.5346255302429199,
-0.32197773456573486,
-0.1531463861465454,
0.02488281950354576,
-0.23822519183158875,
-0.9314942359924316,
-0.11369122564792633,
0.13097956776618958,
0.13933207094669342,
0.11170386523008347,
0.8531689047813416,
-0.13307568430900574,
-0.7280503511428833,
0.7617232203483582,
0.6218190789222717,
0.4052808880805969,
0.021161001175642014,
-0.7816440463066101,
0.03615289181470871,
-0.05763307586312294,
-0.36115631461143494,
0.1408882588148117,
0.6196532249450684,
-0.10638447105884552,
0.7339025735855103,
0.48953062295913696,
-0.10814161598682404,
0.12114712595939636,
0.45216697454452515,
0.718663215637207,
-0.8469838500022888,
0.05133083462715149,
-1.1918110847473145,
0.7178640365600586,
0.08115022629499435,
-0.26835349202156067,
0.6004918217658997,
0.6524879932403564,
0.8534935712814331,
0.03788086399435997,
0.8048147559165955,
0.11191710829734802,
0.1742364764213562,
-0.8206937313079834,
0.03643244504928589,
-0.5556318163871765,
0.2362929880619049,
-0.430637001991272,
-0.881194531917572,
-0.3110634684562683,
0.6270393133163452,
-0.18643787503242493,
0.14060889184474945,
1.0455089807510376,
0.6745561361312866,
-0.005418798420578241,
0.2923043966293335,
0.5360537767410278,
0.24516132473945618,
0.09067688137292862,
0.8066962361335754,
1.0906355381011963,
-0.17578144371509552,
0.5545040369033813,
0.11676590144634247,
-0.4518764019012451,
0.07401685416698456,
-1.084681510925293,
-1.0487645864486694,
-0.2925688922405243,
-0.18055905401706696,
-0.18739180266857147,
0.0265742726624012,
0.863281786441803,
0.5455297231674194,
-0.728674590587616,
-0.4691983759403229,
-0.012775140814483166,
0.3057822585105896,
-0.27594736218452454,
-0.16298353672027588,
0.07212194055318832,
-0.4223250150680542,
-0.3345367908477783,
0.682075023651123,
0.7121610641479492,
-0.44050779938697815,
-0.3888029158115387,
-0.17142118513584137,
-0.6187711358070374,
0.14810337126255035,
1.0653297901153564,
-0.07219099998474121,
-0.8515899777412415,
-0.2780435383319855,
-0.24026687443256378,
0.3008221387863159,
0.2145589143037796,
0.8199640512466431,
-0.6474354863166809,
0.5395798087120056,
0.5022523999214172,
0.7462201118469238,
0.759925127029419,
-0.00828506052494049,
0.1554584801197052,
-0.39388254284858704,
-0.04587715491652489,
0.13867105543613434,
0.43116241693496704,
0.0984242632985115,
-0.09950444847345352,
0.45211994647979736,
0.24940335750579834,
-0.4615905284881592,
-0.5634557604789734,
0.3851105868816376,
-0.4713960587978363,
-0.23628364503383636,
0.9703781008720398,
-0.31460490822792053,
0.05742591992020607,
-0.006688952911645174,
0.004534844774752855,
-0.05317522957921028,
-0.3935679495334625,
0.3205784857273102,
1.070283055305481,
-0.6306137442588806,
-0.3462177813053131,
-0.9434102177619934,
0.07100468128919601,
0.4657890200614929,
-1.1154390573501587,
0.15153726935386658,
0.7261554002761841,
0.23015911877155304,
0.23638668656349182,
0.6655667424201965,
-0.2115030437707901,
0.026840263977646828,
0.057339392602443695,
-0.07118181884288788,
0.4353852868080139,
-0.9051625728607178,
-0.5439924001693726,
0.029052989557385445,
0.36226680874824524,
0.01790696382522583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17163v1 | Paraphrase and Aggregate with Large Language Models for Minimizing Intent Classification Errors | 2024-06-24T22:30:26 | 2024-06-24T22:30:26 | Vikas Yadav, Zheng Tang, Vijay Srinivasan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLM) have achieved remarkable success in natural
language generation but lesser focus has been given to their applicability in
decision making tasks such as classification. We show that LLMs like LLaMa can
achieve high performance on large multi-class classification tasks but still
make classification errors and worse, generate out-of-vocabulary class labels.
To address these critical issues, we introduce Paraphrase and AGgregate
(PAG)-LLM approach wherein an LLM generates multiple paraphrases of the input
query (parallel queries), performs multi-class classification for the original
query and each paraphrase, and at the end aggregate all the classification
labels based on their confidence scores. We evaluate PAG-LLM on two large
multi-class classication datasets: CLINC, and Banking and show 22.7% and 15.1%
error reduction. We show that PAG-LLM is especially effective for hard examples
where LLM is uncertain, and reduces the critical misclassification and
hallucinated label generation errors | [
-0.10176325589418411,
-0.9892480373382568,
0.7700839042663574,
0.37481990456581116,
-0.26975885033607483,
-0.02542388252913952,
-0.29194653034210205,
-0.11253981292247772,
-0.01458222046494484,
0.8127090334892273,
0.1127856969833374,
-0.666985273361206,
-0.758064329624176,
0.10885407775640488,
-0.46950563788414,
0.9957820773124695,
0.04087428003549576,
-0.09816072881221771,
-0.4522530436515808,
-0.27607694268226624,
-0.13482153415679932,
-0.9374629855155945,
-0.9372667670249939,
-0.10291837155818939,
0.3644852638244629,
0.5348803997039795,
0.7368621826171875,
0.44881337881088257,
0.5905332565307617,
0.2731070816516876,
-0.24842305481433868,
0.3964605927467346,
-0.4097747504711151,
0.21129679679870605,
-0.04576211795210838,
-0.44225600361824036,
-0.621088445186615,
-0.19150422513484955,
0.804903507232666,
0.775498628616333,
-0.3727976977825165,
0.0916934460401535,
0.33475232124328613,
0.6263136267662048,
-0.7811166048049927,
0.45252129435539246,
-0.6305367350578308,
-0.3467645049095154,
-0.10358358919620514,
-0.18814103305339813,
-0.59627765417099,
-0.45586249232292175,
0.027272384613752365,
-0.36155378818511963,
0.06814762949943542,
0.19914168119430542,
0.41988304257392883,
0.22999690473079681,
-0.37737998366355896,
-0.5437449812889099,
-0.49461987614631653,
0.9607951641082764,
-0.794248104095459,
0.07933491468429565,
0.4003458619117737,
0.13760635256767273,
-0.2003117799758911,
-0.8898489475250244,
-0.540132999420166,
-0.21080908179283142,
-0.13359464704990387,
-0.1420084685087204,
-0.04155311360955238,
0.22118794918060303,
-0.027726368978619576,
0.39018791913986206,
-0.4333430528640747,
0.11983475089073181,
-0.19709017872810364,
-0.1009300947189331,
0.5347172021865845,
0.21525536477565765,
0.0011254748096689582,
-0.1071435809135437,
-0.3563632667064667,
-0.11357758194208145,
-0.7156190872192383,
-0.08770779520273209,
0.10213397443294525,
0.40061014890670776,
0.24616789817810059,
0.6525582671165466,
-0.24489140510559082,
0.7161250710487366,
-0.20517215132713318,
-0.5555594563484192,
0.059055835008621216,
-0.3166501224040985,
-0.33869174122810364,
0.12987174093723297,
0.8999572396278381,
0.5453450679779053,
0.189452663064003,
-0.2864556908607483,
-0.1834169328212738,
0.07212717086076736,
-0.08759522438049316,
-0.587425708770752,
0.0041620791889727116,
0.13310733437538147,
-0.5010919570922852,
-0.389927476644516,
-0.15794825553894043,
-0.9739140272140503,
-0.34936222434043884,
-0.32265999913215637,
0.3617914021015167,
-0.23467034101486206,
0.211904838681221,
0.2588809132575989,
-0.07879451662302017,
0.4133624732494354,
0.3179858922958374,
-0.5659371614456177,
0.5431703925132751,
0.7016059756278992,
0.8948079347610474,
-0.2971873879432678,
-0.4965497851371765,
-0.6781381368637085,
0.5417144298553467,
-0.21684326231479645,
0.782586932182312,
-0.5243247747421265,
-0.38349783420562744,
-0.05596844106912613,
-0.4199395775794983,
-0.3292381763458252,
-0.6173608899116516,
0.948702335357666,
-0.45041975378990173,
0.11036231368780136,
0.000451945437816903,
-0.7900264859199524,
-0.308379203081131,
0.2953968644142151,
-0.4378981590270996,
0.7947549223899841,
-0.18228106200695038,
-0.6660864949226379,
0.19096079468727112,
-0.4042329490184784,
-0.560783326625824,
-0.04680726304650307,
-0.033759839832782745,
-0.3800051212310791,
0.19357268512248993,
0.39544299244880676,
0.6656751036643982,
-0.6520931124687195,
0.4444718360900879,
-0.37058180570602417,
-0.16612353920936584,
0.30272698402404785,
-0.6130441427230835,
0.4132547676563263,
0.3112866282463074,
-0.13754484057426453,
-0.05569023638963699,
-0.5738404393196106,
-0.1664227545261383,
0.06585978716611862,
-0.5159704685211182,
-0.5559059977531433,
0.18860988318920135,
0.06020098924636841,
0.2749518156051636,
0.4639126658439636,
-0.18772292137145996,
0.14585714042186737,
-0.05793095752596855,
0.3117585778236389,
0.7128748297691345,
0.18354204297065735,
0.4268576502799988,
-0.5686225295066833,
0.35006481409072876,
-0.1439187377691269,
0.11709219217300415,
0.12069827318191528,
-0.5551444292068481,
-0.7749747037887573,
-0.1817995011806488,
0.17606031894683838,
0.5904369354248047,
-0.7246308326721191,
0.3861245810985565,
-0.4215482175350189,
-0.5166822075843811,
-0.11854129284620285,
0.38294893503189087,
0.3650921881198883,
0.5106444954872131,
0.5301761627197266,
-0.05736648291349411,
-0.22304247319698334,
-0.8081594109535217,
-0.49423640966415405,
-0.24320799112319946,
0.13482855260372162,
0.33641722798347473,
0.11558055132627487,
-0.0618450827896595,
0.6564285755157471,
-0.6948959827423096,
-0.3438269793987274,
-0.5951635837554932,
0.1813291609287262,
0.21276447176933289,
0.3167738616466522,
0.5904864072799683,
-0.8478075265884399,
-0.5388875007629395,
-0.17745836079120636,
-0.7427388429641724,
-0.10211523622274399,
-0.2081875056028366,
-0.052347470074892044,
0.18283838033676147,
0.4888313412666321,
-0.7040777206420898,
0.1261271983385086,
0.4480879306793213,
0.003576476126909256,
0.3119145333766937,
-0.33032160997390747,
0.17641477286815643,
-1.1220608949661255,
-0.2526114284992218,
0.03245319798588753,
-0.08430436998605728,
-0.6365160346031189,
0.12437515705823898,
-0.007869573310017586,
0.09996391832828522,
-0.4537724256515503,
0.37809649109840393,
-0.2576969563961029,
0.11066834628582001,
-0.3114912807941437,
-0.0447663739323616,
-0.17169108986854553,
0.46283817291259766,
0.08182909339666367,
0.6322141885757446,
0.8643707036972046,
-1.0518196821212769,
0.2180584818124771,
0.24876277148723602,
-0.4027586877346039,
0.4863862693309784,
-0.4770842492580414,
0.0743175521492958,
-0.23948492109775543,
0.3245265781879425,
-1.0903918743133545,
-0.5332300066947937,
0.16501004993915558,
-0.1750621199607849,
0.24814629554748535,
-0.026390690356492996,
-0.577792763710022,
-0.16779370605945587,
-0.3368244767189026,
0.28439733386039734,
0.5696687698364258,
-0.6855176687240601,
0.6886326670646667,
0.38905325531959534,
-0.49575915932655334,
-0.5743708610534668,
-0.5590469837188721,
0.34030771255493164,
-0.6622293591499329,
-0.4892493784427643,
0.05491657927632332,
0.04618418961763382,
-0.41006991267204285,
-0.3267459571361542,
0.02816842868924141,
-0.26044610142707825,
0.09504672139883041,
-0.12676937878131866,
0.14555399119853973,
-0.05458957329392433,
0.1492134928703308,
0.1756526380777359,
0.23623932898044586,
0.04101507365703583,
-0.22285909950733185,
0.662822961807251,
-0.1390647292137146,
-0.3086344003677368,
-0.22942370176315308,
0.376772403717041,
0.9054439067840576,
-0.18139909207820892,
0.969545841217041,
0.19330494105815887,
-0.07008970528841019,
0.03948590159416199,
-0.734856367111206,
0.1149161234498024,
-0.4443868100643158,
0.2758113741874695,
-0.22789651155471802,
-0.5978142619132996,
0.3147134482860565,
-0.0858134925365448,
0.24989667534828186,
0.48954859375953674,
0.5234599113464355,
0.07285995036363602,
0.8622085452079773,
0.2546512484550476,
-0.22969089448451996,
0.22563469409942627,
0.06338023394346237,
0.12749417126178741,
-0.5619163513183594,
-0.16701966524124146,
-0.5801595449447632,
-0.1922190934419632,
-0.4932094216346741,
-0.5617567300796509,
0.4949909448623657,
0.20326747000217438,
0.1635279357433319,
0.06139209493994713,
-0.20104224979877472,
0.46749746799468994,
0.6067015528678894,
0.23119550943374634,
0.4102945923805237,
0.15631930530071259,
0.2320147454738617,
0.1456037163734436,
-0.7700172662734985,
-0.6963006258010864,
1.4034892320632935,
-0.02595958672463894,
0.9009328484535217,
0.21694710850715637,
0.9914103746414185,
0.055060308426618576,
0.39795324206352234,
-0.7902424931526184,
0.6922293901443481,
-0.40511560440063477,
-0.4339316487312317,
-0.30060139298439026,
-0.6215376257896423,
-0.8082568049430847,
0.42287248373031616,
-0.015938276425004005,
-0.4175129532814026,
0.11612820625305176,
0.270921528339386,
-0.17131586372852325,
0.42280104756355286,
-0.7121738791465759,
0.7862968444824219,
-0.17668218910694122,
-0.20771841704845428,
-0.14560633897781372,
-0.597290575504303,
0.6170978546142578,
-0.40498456358909607,
0.5458729863166809,
-0.015386827290058136,
-0.26578742265701294,
0.8380752801895142,
-0.3815518617630005,
0.7754467725753784,
-0.052479568868875504,
-0.0006240089423954487,
0.7143948674201965,
-0.055016253143548965,
0.8485899567604065,
-0.09898024797439575,
-0.2843683362007141,
0.05071375519037247,
-0.327320396900177,
-0.415999174118042,
-0.4498922526836395,
0.634791910648346,
-0.47054919600486755,
-0.5968979597091675,
-0.2636357843875885,
-0.6164149045944214,
-0.2654159665107727,
-0.130117729306221,
0.38687965273857117,
0.27485430240631104,
-0.03520611301064491,
0.6163781881332397,
0.5473052859306335,
-0.07616380602121353,
0.5401994585990906,
0.11024110019207001,
0.04047064483165741,
-0.4176422655582428,
0.9242653250694275,
0.10403655469417572,
0.489256352186203,
0.36906036734580994,
0.5048994421958923,
-0.4499654471874237,
-0.8809369802474976,
-0.07265238463878632,
0.196285218000412,
-0.9409189224243164,
-0.20378658175468445,
-0.8711668848991394,
0.052809957414865494,
-0.7015658617019653,
0.042850062251091,
-0.03965817764401436,
-0.4522586166858673,
-0.1710350513458252,
0.09526123106479645,
0.27122676372528076,
0.6084244847297668,
0.0778350979089737,
0.7154416441917419,
-0.9747187495231628,
0.3114851713180542,
0.4786266088485718,
-0.008264978416264057,
-0.035231366753578186,
-0.701319694519043,
-0.03297301009297371,
-0.2259947508573532,
-0.2969248592853546,
-0.8654471039772034,
0.5135515332221985,
0.5393084287643433,
0.7662737965583801,
0.20072370767593384,
0.24180878698825836,
0.5840232968330383,
-0.3764936923980713,
0.7327220439910889,
0.16930393874645233,
-0.8891598582267761,
0.35874664783477783,
-0.16669078171253204,
-0.030202405527234077,
0.6857656836509705,
0.4694591462612152,
-0.497251033782959,
-0.7134671807289124,
-0.6085536479949951,
-1.2489267587661743,
0.5684837102890015,
0.20399342477321625,
0.08275005966424942,
-0.24944137036800385,
0.3174920380115509,
0.09883960336446762,
0.32266905903816223,
-0.8554577231407166,
-0.3704111874103546,
0.18886923789978027,
-0.4373849630355835,
-0.40150174498558044,
-0.4371804893016815,
-0.0023704515770077705,
-0.05825351923704147,
0.6198950409889221,
-0.14590534567832947,
-0.13318879902362823,
-0.04937744140625,
-0.3071618676185608,
0.3237418830394745,
0.4991135895252228,
0.45121780037879944,
0.6994655132293701,
-0.02544388175010681,
0.29052597284317017,
0.41983509063720703,
-0.3428693413734436,
0.21378789842128754,
-0.06662476807832718,
-0.07350438088178635,
-0.03437929227948189,
0.35914185643196106,
0.4978072941303253,
0.2521243393421173,
-0.7075161933898926,
0.49209004640579224,
-0.04691488295793533,
-0.2892623841762543,
-0.13053520023822784,
-0.0434422567486763,
0.09315091371536255,
0.1078040823340416,
0.35272839665412903,
0.013465641997754574,
0.39755308628082275,
-0.36563166975975037,
0.05902408808469772,
0.20891554653644562,
0.1797173023223877,
0.14609897136688232,
0.4925360679626465,
-0.052875764667987823,
0.03818392753601074,
0.4893788993358612,
-0.1752629578113556,
-0.3647393584251404,
0.44859516620635986,
0.5431532263755798,
0.897803783416748,
-0.29544419050216675,
-0.017092296853661537,
0.2589406967163086,
0.17820483446121216,
-0.6492358446121216,
-0.05414114519953728,
-0.12433038651943207,
-0.6346979141235352,
-0.5648479461669922,
-0.9227465987205505,
-0.7219343185424805,
0.16715572774410248,
-0.6632236838340759,
0.18198484182357788,
-0.36238375306129456,
0.13114358484745026,
-0.06354954093694687,
-0.65880286693573,
-0.3678065538406372,
0.1320352554321289,
0.06679704785346985,
0.39250385761260986,
-0.8710057139396667,
0.759894609451294,
0.8717964887619019,
-0.22912168502807617,
-0.8298182487487793,
0.13224533200263977,
-0.36336350440979004,
-0.6792364716529846,
0.6912899613380432,
0.10986039787530899,
-0.026662372052669525,
-0.042756494134664536,
-0.4278353154659271,
-0.835345447063446,
0.8505527973175049,
0.24105298519134521,
-0.5137885212898254,
-0.10828626155853271,
0.10983539372682571,
0.31301194429397583,
-0.23068316280841827,
-0.08077585697174072,
0.7676807045936584,
0.5143454074859619,
0.3983612358570099,
-0.840514600276947,
-0.14794737100601196,
0.3335275948047638,
-0.1939375102519989,
0.23125560581684113,
-0.5741717219352722,
1.1505625247955322,
-0.010255816392600536,
0.17732550203800201,
0.008781912736594677,
0.5400935411453247,
0.3735311031341553,
0.5010443925857544,
0.5637461543083191,
0.5569409132003784,
0.80867600440979,
0.009437557309865952,
1.238275408744812,
-0.23720407485961914,
0.37563931941986084,
1.2370920181274414,
-0.24476122856140137,
0.93976229429245,
0.4699245095252991,
-0.2896040678024292,
0.05346060171723366,
0.5345951318740845,
0.37727823853492737,
0.4170609712600708,
0.016790714114904404,
-0.5897201299667358,
-0.4523454010486603,
0.16162721812725067,
-0.1726498156785965,
0.5959552526473999,
0.5442417860031128,
-0.5063157677650452,
-0.3526574373245239,
-0.05850326642394066,
0.020324664190411568,
0.05804795026779175,
-0.5904751420021057,
0.9763882756233215,
0.18000859022140503,
-0.7758192420005798,
0.546582818031311,
0.050873272120952606,
0.7602500319480896,
-0.3918268382549286,
0.14790160953998566,
-0.38338232040405273,
0.3588339388370514,
-0.08404478430747986,
-0.6549220085144043,
0.30495694279670715,
0.060741253197193146,
0.03240005299448967,
-0.2531677484512329,
0.629213273525238,
-0.48851412534713745,
-0.6775431632995605,
0.1491282880306244,
0.429313600063324,
0.5287730097770691,
-0.38575854897499084,
-0.486733078956604,
-0.28069329261779785,
-0.09744926542043686,
-0.2756343483924866,
0.3618955612182617,
0.5063284635543823,
-0.07238775491714478,
0.651347279548645,
0.5716758966445923,
0.06493175774812698,
0.29959672689437866,
-0.06394550204277039,
0.6852807998657227,
-0.5763525366783142,
-0.45041632652282715,
-1.196440577507019,
-0.05700692534446716,
-0.2061721831560135,
-0.1333402395248413,
0.9014992117881775,
0.7336766719818115,
0.5454838871955872,
-0.13971830904483795,
0.7425788044929504,
0.08397075533866882,
0.41465556621551514,
-0.6124873757362366,
0.42007678747177124,
-0.5033613443374634,
0.20287950336933136,
-0.36793795228004456,
-1.1779568195343018,
-0.42655110359191895,
0.5205385684967041,
-0.3398459255695343,
-0.11574213951826096,
0.6891016364097595,
0.6407219767570496,
0.09251746535301208,
-0.23678332567214966,
0.3877314329147339,
-0.03708026185631752,
0.4261590838432312,
0.6188920736312866,
0.8834259510040283,
-0.292712539434433,
1.0460057258605957,
-0.29495564103126526,
-0.19193381071090698,
-0.3467327356338501,
-0.712924599647522,
-0.824379563331604,
-0.09211388975381851,
-0.39901337027549744,
-0.2659943997859955,
-0.19671787321567535,
0.8296209573745728,
0.25606638193130493,
-0.7891203165054321,
-0.4173703193664551,
-0.34171250462532043,
0.3061661720275879,
-0.1719050258398056,
-0.20818772912025452,
0.4551255404949188,
-0.8562018871307373,
-0.9447610974311829,
0.3747871220111847,
0.18228615820407867,
0.16089864075183868,
0.2021879404783249,
-0.11294083297252655,
-0.25927162170410156,
0.07303960621356964,
0.7393214702606201,
0.04451379179954529,
-0.6411027908325195,
-0.11196102201938629,
-0.162017360329628,
-0.16995134949684143,
0.025697195902466774,
0.7091473340988159,
-0.39120352268218994,
0.04237983748316765,
0.511909008026123,
0.7781810164451599,
0.4394254982471466,
0.17915122210979462,
0.3132055103778839,
-0.7117806077003479,
0.1143001839518547,
0.3097919821739197,
0.4814075529575348,
0.2287730723619461,
-0.17675666511058807,
0.36075425148010254,
0.1921655684709549,
-0.7026102542877197,
-0.7634044289588928,
0.033927906304597855,
-0.9399691224098206,
-0.46302250027656555,
1.4102329015731812,
-0.21015167236328125,
-0.3296082317829132,
-0.23804029822349548,
-0.2351333498954773,
0.18501324951648712,
-0.27316829562187195,
0.6188750863075256,
0.7192361950874329,
-0.15579071640968323,
0.12211000919342041,
-0.43836653232574463,
0.36041101813316345,
0.565155029296875,
-0.9330570697784424,
0.2933259904384613,
0.6843951344490051,
0.28693726658821106,
0.1482769101858139,
0.4019879400730133,
-0.04092837870121002,
0.1954796314239502,
-0.02393699623644352,
-0.01609032414853573,
0.15649071335792542,
-0.22064754366874695,
-0.15710966289043427,
0.5553454160690308,
0.46590498089790344,
-0.35785651206970215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17158v1 | DEXTER: A Benchmark for open-domain Complex Question Answering using LLMs | 2024-06-24T22:09:50 | 2024-06-24T22:09:50 | Venktesh V. Deepali Prabhu, Avishek Anand | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Open-domain complex Question Answering (QA) is a difficult task with
challenges in evidence retrieval and reasoning. The complexity of such
questions could stem from questions being compositional, hybrid evidence, or
ambiguity in questions. While retrieval performance for classical QA tasks is
well explored, their capabilities for heterogeneous complex retrieval tasks,
especially in an open-domain setting, and the impact on downstream QA
performance, are relatively unexplored. To address this, in this work, we
propose a benchmark composing diverse complex QA tasks and provide a toolkit to
evaluate state-of-the-art pre-trained dense and sparse retrieval models in an
open-domain setting. We observe that late interaction models and surprisingly
lexical models like BM25 perform well compared to other pre-trained dense
retrieval models. In addition, since context-based reasoning is critical for
solving complex QA tasks, we also evaluate the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
and the impact of retrieval performance on their reasoning capabilities.
Through experiments, we observe that much progress is to be made in retrieval
for complex QA to improve downstream QA performance. Our software and related
data can be accessed at https://github.com/VenkteshV/DEXTER | [
-0.4097900390625,
-1.0215740203857422,
0.7998147010803223,
0.21130937337875366,
-0.07777877151966095,
0.2925962209701538,
-0.08082686364650726,
-0.5318995118141174,
0.1559056043624878,
0.383747398853302,
-0.5493820309638977,
-0.5289098024368286,
-0.24490001797676086,
0.22433072328567505,
-0.07170859724283218,
0.4434296488761902,
-0.36245325207710266,
0.34948474168777466,
-0.4166676700115204,
-0.23911398649215698,
-0.5024228096008301,
-0.39606258273124695,
-0.2718556225299835,
0.17419439554214478,
0.4365406036376953,
0.2837066054344177,
0.5857406258583069,
0.45856958627700806,
0.6387951970100403,
0.20822587609291077,
-0.025083985179662704,
0.4255836308002472,
-0.7452569603919983,
0.5297732353210449,
-0.41781002283096313,
-0.5034927129745483,
-0.6008661985397339,
-0.015424494631588459,
0.7632642388343811,
1.0158674716949463,
0.08004263043403625,
0.3982597291469574,
-0.2642647325992584,
0.2354370355606079,
-1.0797449350357056,
-0.20241598784923553,
-0.787416934967041,
-0.05834316089749336,
-0.3470492660999298,
-0.3678126037120819,
-0.2654915452003479,
-0.3867838978767395,
0.3921983540058136,
-0.6814029216766357,
0.09337718039751053,
0.3179427683353424,
0.6943947076797485,
0.18873879313468933,
-0.40028050541877747,
0.033002447336912155,
-0.623757004737854,
0.7201145887374878,
-0.7020366191864014,
0.4469263255596161,
0.09191722422838211,
0.5039911270141602,
-0.2669776678085327,
-0.9565274119377136,
-0.5180131196975708,
-0.011853067204356194,
0.27617767453193665,
0.41297733783721924,
0.004465797450393438,
0.19419652223587036,
0.48421046137809753,
0.43928807973861694,
-0.5878109335899353,
-0.04830603301525116,
-0.20570401847362518,
-0.16256748139858246,
0.4104827046394348,
0.5311661958694458,
0.26527291536331177,
0.30137497186660767,
-0.4573557376861572,
0.0591123104095459,
-0.7172656059265137,
0.4543076157569885,
0.24319998919963837,
0.06001049652695656,
0.14760816097259521,
0.9523012638092041,
-0.4831511378288269,
0.7121933698654175,
-0.20262564718723297,
0.08674044162034988,
0.23048390448093414,
-0.2939741909503937,
-0.2243933230638504,
-0.3079453110694885,
0.42961442470550537,
0.28544989228248596,
0.1255774199962616,
-0.3717532157897949,
-0.39022597670555115,
-0.228104367852211,
0.44552475214004517,
-0.761384904384613,
-0.06625591963529587,
0.36615636944770813,
-0.31455475091934204,
0.3463640809059143,
0.2439430207014084,
-0.46843162178993225,
-0.1474517583847046,
-0.2821524441242218,
0.696743905544281,
-0.18647398054599762,
-0.036220259964466095,
0.36430180072784424,
-0.1753993183374405,
0.2998757064342499,
0.595211923122406,
-0.4894726872444153,
0.7362356185913086,
0.7289454340934753,
0.6835312247276306,
-0.536279022693634,
-0.23387768864631653,
-1.1957552433013916,
0.005336384288966656,
-0.17033712565898895,
0.7027393579483032,
-0.39330700039863586,
0.012019899673759937,
0.055664535611867905,
0.14248640835285187,
-0.3615932762622833,
-0.8686435222625732,
0.5252266526222229,
-0.8879284262657166,
-0.09885485470294952,
-0.30024755001068115,
-0.5385836958885193,
-0.16084085404872894,
0.6132463812828064,
-0.7823418974876404,
0.9065271019935608,
0.33534932136535645,
-0.6235414743423462,
0.02995007112622261,
-0.27499687671661377,
-0.35749727487564087,
0.3204070031642914,
-0.033157382160425186,
-0.12367133051156998,
-0.02786003239452839,
0.013798103667795658,
0.609761655330658,
-0.5947220921516418,
0.2634778618812561,
-0.6748501658439636,
-0.6487164497375488,
0.28463470935821533,
-0.1831052005290985,
0.4039815664291382,
0.018566736951470375,
-0.17060892283916473,
0.27385884523391724,
-0.6172135472297668,
0.22474676370620728,
0.029364779591560364,
-0.4519416391849518,
-0.4415755569934845,
-0.037638451904058456,
-0.20318225026130676,
0.10336380451917648,
0.3520064651966095,
-0.8793579339981079,
0.20574498176574707,
-0.3312170207500458,
0.1958547979593277,
0.546594500541687,
-0.047557368874549866,
0.14429374039173126,
-0.5941173434257507,
0.5311740636825562,
0.2527788281440735,
0.19963029026985168,
0.13371944427490234,
-0.4126991629600525,
-0.3442527949810028,
-0.5689519643783569,
0.2653621435165405,
0.5467599034309387,
-0.78013676404953,
-0.0005739227635785937,
-0.3405340313911438,
-0.34399911761283875,
-0.8519638180732727,
0.18503393232822418,
0.46887722611427307,
0.5507976412773132,
0.672227680683136,
-0.4768313467502594,
-0.23990333080291748,
-0.8754237294197083,
-0.41165074706077576,
0.17508146166801453,
-0.15398621559143066,
0.6328430771827698,
0.33644506335258484,
-0.2041846662759781,
0.9404982328414917,
-0.6031181812286377,
0.002624094719067216,
-0.0646844431757927,
-0.13948006927967072,
0.19022049009799957,
0.3124738037586212,
0.30597198009490967,
-0.7589151263237,
-0.2815462648868561,
-0.23412831127643585,
-0.6255258321762085,
-0.15261037647724152,
0.14055971801280975,
-0.4107604920864105,
-0.21086090803146362,
0.3680998980998993,
-0.7647901773452759,
0.19813886284828186,
0.38405463099479675,
-0.3474515974521637,
0.8907456994056702,
-0.020367207005620003,
0.19899693131446838,
-0.8337215185165405,
0.39448708295822144,
-0.07895322889089584,
-0.3944076597690582,
-0.4516928493976593,
0.1731005162000656,
0.3282040059566498,
0.21573522686958313,
-0.6859394907951355,
0.7210413217544556,
-0.4295527935028076,
-0.4044249355792999,
0.4228036403656006,
0.3904077410697937,
0.1738506555557251,
0.5881243348121643,
-0.09816530346870422,
0.9965359568595886,
0.28744107484817505,
-0.54981929063797,
0.3674151599407196,
0.1875026524066925,
-0.47756579518318176,
0.4322705864906311,
-0.8848486542701721,
-0.15777409076690674,
0.029276227578520775,
-0.022435272112488747,
-1.0662612915039062,
-0.20363585650920868,
0.0394645631313324,
-0.12895368039608002,
0.22227251529693604,
-0.0591871403157711,
-0.6748033165931702,
-0.3411363363265991,
-0.5408646464347839,
0.6299575567245483,
0.25061771273612976,
-0.4466423988342285,
0.6903477311134338,
0.20002523064613342,
-0.18485665321350098,
-0.6249182224273682,
-0.11248897761106491,
-0.30710598826408386,
0.17174650728702545,
-0.707584023475647,
0.4642946422100067,
-0.3668540120124817,
-0.4338774085044861,
-0.09254911541938782,
-0.4650650918483734,
-0.1186300590634346,
0.5184925198554993,
0.07707785815000534,
0.34545645117759705,
-0.4640233814716339,
-0.0811999961733818,
0.4477604329586029,
0.25472313165664673,
0.2646788954734802,
0.12541763484477997,
0.5082636475563049,
-0.19707460701465607,
-0.4978535771369934,
-0.1168479397892952,
0.3319333493709564,
0.7353200912475586,
-0.4566100239753723,
0.5270774960517883,
0.31036046147346497,
-0.2413594126701355,
-0.3448401689529419,
-0.6676071882247925,
-0.2659267485141754,
-0.396630197763443,
0.12301165610551834,
-0.6427134275436401,
-1.0931508541107178,
0.7672273516654968,
-0.5182781219482422,
0.08490993082523346,
0.28469276428222656,
0.5714863538742065,
-0.2876446545124054,
1.0571869611740112,
-0.018910467624664307,
0.2721364200115204,
0.15492860972881317,
-0.31689542531967163,
-0.12197819352149963,
-1.133812665939331,
-0.3008565604686737,
-0.36955082416534424,
-0.25027579069137573,
0.0011957114329561591,
-0.40198493003845215,
0.5594633221626282,
0.4099489748477936,
-0.37502893805503845,
0.06260058283805847,
-0.05449643358588219,
0.20498381555080414,
0.7592188715934753,
0.27479639649391174,
0.3692944347858429,
-0.5135294198989868,
-0.356196790933609,
0.27682384848594666,
-0.6370465755462646,
-0.43217670917510986,
1.0994607210159302,
0.24644428491592407,
0.6988247036933899,
0.4114667773246765,
0.29136887192726135,
0.2306346297264099,
0.25161200761795044,
-0.6503514647483826,
0.5167720317840576,
0.11581676453351974,
-0.511098325252533,
-0.28523722290992737,
-0.5242869853973389,
-0.9328557252883911,
0.5090458989143372,
-0.24984265863895416,
-0.600343644618988,
-0.031665049493312836,
-0.22178970277309418,
-0.503332257270813,
0.31235530972480774,
-0.4462416470050812,
0.9759864807128906,
-0.04494134336709976,
-0.5695422291755676,
-0.022128794342279434,
-0.9821940660476685,
0.4665829837322235,
-0.009418617933988571,
-0.22278377413749695,
-0.3173980712890625,
-0.010223397053778172,
0.5838168859481812,
-0.35020655393600464,
0.571283757686615,
-0.001959010725840926,
0.0034764930605888367,
0.0512961819767952,
0.3778125047683716,
0.4726477563381195,
0.24031539261341095,
-0.15131935477256775,
-0.01474806759506464,
0.48117494583129883,
-0.48781245946884155,
-0.5757551193237305,
0.6356443762779236,
-0.8748254776000977,
-0.7213271856307983,
-0.10155531018972397,
-0.8242594003677368,
-0.6963057518005371,
0.31863006949424744,
-0.07677953690290451,
0.686970591545105,
-0.15794245898723602,
0.2550341486930847,
1.0740104913711548,
0.007568130735307932,
0.11256644874811172,
0.5958358645439148,
0.09501872211694717,
-0.412433385848999,
0.6097483038902283,
0.03832288458943367,
0.4622442424297333,
0.4986884295940399,
-0.09512227773666382,
-0.2589991092681885,
-0.7370558381080627,
-0.6907187700271606,
0.37062573432922363,
-0.6475021839141846,
-0.3911510407924652,
-0.9641309380531311,
-0.12421809881925583,
-0.3332521915435791,
-0.09586240351200104,
-0.13658377528190613,
-0.4197967052459717,
-0.4314882457256317,
0.23712526261806488,
-0.06207147240638733,
0.2153489738702774,
0.5132278800010681,
-0.05244362726807594,
-0.9839721918106079,
0.6538558006286621,
0.4531365931034088,
0.5820339322090149,
-0.03673315793275833,
-0.3273521363735199,
-0.1607884168624878,
0.12386894971132278,
-0.2738255560398102,
-0.4619384706020355,
0.1161745935678482,
-0.04879190772771835,
0.8970931172370911,
0.11238411068916321,
0.5663661360740662,
0.5766913890838623,
-0.13315576314926147,
0.6767964959144592,
-0.1935485154390335,
-0.8536525964736938,
0.2947444021701813,
-0.33870798349380493,
0.25599899888038635,
0.7840887904167175,
0.6566247344017029,
-0.12417475879192352,
-0.3821195363998413,
-0.41919466853141785,
-0.7556755542755127,
0.6751365661621094,
0.007671985309571028,
-0.24573387205600739,
-0.05454551801085472,
0.38485145568847656,
0.19072124361991882,
0.42918649315834045,
-0.19225504994392395,
-0.03314395993947983,
0.026126790791749954,
-0.30062833428382874,
0.15243946015834808,
-0.2970496118068695,
-0.30061179399490356,
-0.17566616833209991,
0.5118439197540283,
-0.3362528383731842,
0.06359081715345383,
0.4696928858757019,
-0.42947474122047424,
-0.2266264408826828,
0.18692860007286072,
0.6293601393699646,
0.5598936080932617,
-0.5364904999732971,
0.1449449509382248,
0.14769117534160614,
-0.5960661768913269,
-0.1803259551525116,
0.23308616876602173,
-0.1036490723490715,
-0.3255508840084076,
0.4728095829486847,
0.5307510495185852,
0.17262545228004456,
-1.3160699605941772,
0.830294668674469,
-0.15834547579288483,
-0.21554093062877655,
-0.021448971703648567,
0.1646171659231186,
-0.15193885564804077,
0.5472844243049622,
0.4137497842311859,
-0.08802933990955353,
0.43068331480026245,
-0.595434308052063,
-0.053638260811567307,
0.5638267993927002,
-0.35675719380378723,
-0.29955512285232544,
0.7521771788597107,
0.0723266676068306,
-0.028358157724142075,
0.7004801034927368,
0.035891707986593246,
-0.49468716979026794,
0.596531093120575,
0.46462613344192505,
0.7425410151481628,
0.11233656108379364,
-0.11474263668060303,
0.07871557772159576,
0.05654080957174301,
-0.08943162113428116,
0.8874313235282898,
-0.24104802310466766,
-0.6856438517570496,
-0.3826906681060791,
-0.498575359582901,
-0.7388039231300354,
-0.21350838243961334,
-0.7201517820358276,
-0.18628232181072235,
-0.4729764461517334,
-0.09456020593643188,
-0.13954231142997742,
0.26288270950317383,
-0.6889000535011292,
0.18470610678195953,
-0.27620357275009155,
1.2318769693374634,
-0.272201806306839,
0.5518821477890015,
0.8110305070877075,
-0.3369664251804352,
-0.7906750440597534,
-0.09603631496429443,
-0.20441506803035736,
-0.6120546460151672,
0.6280654668807983,
0.20638269186019897,
-0.3911716938018799,
0.2449968010187149,
-0.6154754757881165,
-0.6433638334274292,
1.353763222694397,
0.24388305842876434,
-0.3537059724330902,
0.1364707052707672,
-0.04850811883807182,
0.4974839389324188,
-0.38192227482795715,
0.35727423429489136,
0.3430800139904022,
0.358784943819046,
0.09131011366844177,
-0.9230586886405945,
0.3223799169063568,
-0.47393983602523804,
-0.14376166462898254,
0.1213558092713356,
-0.4886888563632965,
1.0847105979919434,
-0.2458057999610901,
-0.2637011408805847,
0.4168686866760254,
0.4159543812274933,
0.4521014988422394,
0.6630598306655884,
0.31106337904930115,
0.4684048593044281,
0.6829550266265869,
-0.1338435411453247,
0.8717087507247925,
-0.30995050072669983,
0.05386018380522728,
1.0988351106643677,
-0.7058194279670715,
0.9485313892364502,
0.3937138617038727,
0.06401929259300232,
0.3444657623767853,
0.5778945088386536,
0.1937464475631714,
0.4536578357219696,
0.5739705562591553,
-0.3582657277584076,
-0.45107874274253845,
-0.1799321174621582,
-0.22136683762073517,
0.030114244669675827,
0.4103831350803375,
0.013662255369126797,
-0.161871075630188,
-0.015310825780034065,
-0.30810675024986267,
0.03862691670656204,
-0.45130446553230286,
0.8158652782440186,
-0.09408003836870193,
-0.8171846270561218,
0.5584149956703186,
-0.05568826571106911,
0.5258367657661438,
-0.5958577394485474,
-0.01576336659491062,
-0.22812825441360474,
0.145560160279274,
-0.09347830712795258,
-0.917701005935669,
-0.010452239774167538,
-0.4466964304447174,
-0.1295982003211975,
0.1618163287639618,
0.5614992380142212,
-0.4019625186920166,
0.2680693566799164,
0.31616371870040894,
0.909463107585907,
0.03622467443346977,
-0.28054553270339966,
-0.38268306851387024,
0.05790539085865021,
-0.5469934940338135,
-0.3482196629047394,
0.2903144061565399,
0.6301621198654175,
-0.21919161081314087,
0.9413732290267944,
0.7873273491859436,
-0.07410845905542374,
0.20925864577293396,
0.19708795845508575,
1.1686824560165405,
-0.6864118576049805,
-0.047982655465602875,
-0.438680499792099,
0.28989604115486145,
-0.022522497922182083,
-0.41704604029655457,
0.8196507692337036,
0.7974205017089844,
0.9238393902778625,
-0.1560879349708557,
0.44478195905685425,
0.2651008367538452,
0.6815617084503174,
-0.5797121524810791,
0.43917492032051086,
-0.6065084338188171,
0.22602137923240662,
-0.2664943039417267,
-0.9164642095565796,
-0.4424280524253845,
0.027890758588910103,
-0.17735646665096283,
-0.19475802779197693,
0.5409951210021973,
0.7065002918243408,
-0.2632182836532593,
0.0484762042760849,
0.44384464621543884,
0.23788224160671234,
0.2888108789920807,
0.4921414852142334,
1.0435374975204468,
-0.3123454749584198,
0.21110588312149048,
-0.0615164190530777,
-0.1067899689078331,
-0.4660204350948334,
-0.4193976819515228,
-0.910364031791687,
-0.43820831179618835,
-0.05952834337949753,
-0.44382622838020325,
0.020907830446958542,
1.0250040292739868,
0.47242921590805054,
-0.6289191246032715,
-0.10253077745437622,
0.22457116842269897,
0.25886592268943787,
-0.502365231513977,
-0.21124714612960815,
0.24741695821285248,
-0.3616391122341156,
-0.5347503423690796,
0.49937665462493896,
0.3701809346675873,
0.05921958386898041,
-0.234288290143013,
-0.027076231315732002,
-0.4584413468837738,
0.17869114875793457,
0.8610450029373169,
0.2993621230125427,
-0.5899339914321899,
-0.29891929030418396,
0.47492411732673645,
-0.318845272064209,
-0.016885289922356606,
0.9126108288764954,
-0.8567348718643188,
0.4497925043106079,
0.6694883704185486,
1.0209931135177612,
0.5018470287322998,
0.21280308067798615,
0.5194841623306274,
-0.3763965964317322,
-0.6486203074455261,
0.5915877819061279,
0.44151920080184937,
-0.08830278366804123,
-0.16363243758678436,
0.6756352782249451,
0.34792160987854004,
-0.44173774123191833,
-1.0102721452713013,
0.06594859808683395,
-1.554975986480713,
-0.32644444704055786,
0.9822214245796204,
-0.4177493453025818,
-0.21187877655029297,
-0.6092297434806824,
-0.16692017018795013,
0.050336312502622604,
-0.1879105567932129,
0.46447065472602844,
0.30954602360725403,
0.06452900916337967,
0.08816640079021454,
-0.3803328573703766,
0.08482329547405243,
0.31618523597717285,
-0.932422935962677,
-0.032674942165613174,
0.5472130179405212,
0.3436967730522156,
-0.1517476588487625,
0.6988058090209961,
-0.12376274168491364,
0.5341310501098633,
-0.32282179594039917,
-0.007913082838058472,
-0.28277164697647095,
-0.500839352607727,
-0.03184273838996887,
0.5373656749725342,
-0.031022697687149048,
-0.051595766097307205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17135v1 | Testing network clustering algorithms with Natural Language Processing | 2024-06-24T20:54:32 | 2024-06-24T20:54:32 | Ixandra Achitouv, David Chavalarias, Bruno Gaume | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph | The advent of online social networks has led to the development of an
abundant literature on the study of online social groups and their relationship
to individuals' personalities as revealed by their textual productions. Social
structures are inferred from a wide range of social interactions. Those
interactions form complex -- sometimes multi-layered -- networks, on which
community detection algorithms are applied to extract higher order structures.
The choice of the community detection algorithm is however hardily questioned
in relation with the cultural production of the individual they classify. In
this work, we assume the entangled nature of social networks and their cultural
production to propose a definition of cultural based online social groups as
sets of individuals whose online production can be categorized as social
group-related. We take advantage of this apparently self-referential
description of online social groups with a hybrid methodology that combines a
community detection algorithm and a natural language processing classification
algorithm. A key result of this analysis is the possibility to score community
detection algorithms using their agreement with the natural language processing
classification. A second result is that we can assign the opinion of a random
user at >85% accuracy. | [
-0.7342403531074524,
-1.0150694847106934,
0.1158066913485527,
0.4264891743659973,
-0.1495717614889145,
0.5566374063491821,
-0.41468822956085205,
-0.7677149772644043,
1.0343393087387085,
0.4329497516155243,
-0.4850304424762726,
-0.4058614671230316,
-0.49243298172950745,
0.4448385238647461,
-0.4114645719528198,
0.7405224442481995,
0.04347485676407814,
-0.010197649709880352,
-0.15627969801425934,
-0.319840669631958,
-0.08988320082426071,
-0.5481075048446655,
-0.8748471736907959,
-0.30235883593559265,
0.36099377274513245,
0.14496813714504242,
0.42949703335762024,
0.6484583616256714,
0.4502882957458496,
0.4396527409553528,
-0.16790935397148132,
0.15980428457260132,
-0.3991599380970001,
0.005120051093399525,
-0.14329251646995544,
-0.46613141894340515,
-0.16772978007793427,
0.04750964790582657,
0.4308106005191803,
0.7082955837249756,
-0.1160084530711174,
0.4340786039829254,
-0.06643816828727722,
0.5402660369873047,
-0.49083638191223145,
-0.20907196402549744,
-0.6078502535820007,
0.3584458529949188,
-0.139984130859375,
-0.27585840225219727,
-0.23067663609981537,
-0.7864909172058105,
-0.11013907939195633,
-0.28130561113357544,
0.501390814781189,
0.23459340631961823,
0.4307215213775635,
-0.158868670463562,
-0.5898338556289673,
-0.30973032116889954,
-0.9283803701400757,
0.6397256255149841,
-0.48937997221946716,
0.04274475574493408,
0.5807713866233826,
0.5489557981491089,
-0.16602887213230133,
-0.507072925567627,
-0.800123393535614,
0.05068468675017357,
-0.09094288945198059,
0.19594812393188477,
0.05944867432117462,
0.06946582347154617,
0.048971593379974365,
0.8847354054450989,
-0.6313332319259644,
0.12706713378429413,
-0.655283510684967,
-0.18215523660182953,
0.6675194501876831,
-0.11915002018213272,
0.38341712951660156,
-0.11211477220058441,
-0.12025876343250275,
0.18780097365379333,
-0.35249030590057373,
0.019754622131586075,
0.5885341763496399,
0.28496670722961426,
-0.016022974625229836,
0.5860082507133484,
-0.554763913154602,
0.35655802488327026,
0.2273242175579071,
0.08521666377782822,
0.41977423429489136,
-0.24378257989883423,
-0.28972434997558594,
0.1735243797302246,
0.8241145610809326,
0.4036511480808258,
0.6176744103431702,
-0.02344413846731186,
0.18387384712696075,
0.5838050246238708,
0.1525774747133255,
-0.3837883174419403,
-0.15878723561763763,
-0.05330141261219978,
-0.8751451373100281,
-0.5284346342086792,
0.3457070589065552,
-0.5499178767204285,
-0.4777563512325287,
-0.06526952236890793,
0.11134162545204163,
0.12163513898849487,
-0.6994828581809998,
-0.10253095626831055,
-0.2821004092693329,
0.042209457606077194,
-0.06524673104286194,
-0.5333444476127625,
0.7130399942398071,
0.5574806928634644,
1.0647938251495361,
-0.3810163736343384,
-0.07510287314653397,
-0.3193961977958679,
-0.03878341615200043,
-0.17368514835834503,
0.8845319747924805,
-0.55559241771698,
-0.2599758505821228,
0.013479143381118774,
0.11128541827201843,
-0.02178741805255413,
-0.5134923458099365,
0.23981332778930664,
-0.6000514626502991,
0.2514289617538452,
-0.317705363035202,
-0.7274396419525146,
-0.15766410529613495,
0.5587783455848694,
-0.6386366486549377,
0.9181506037712097,
-0.045134976506233215,
-0.63795405626297,
0.38509443402290344,
-0.7977863550186157,
-0.7065666913986206,
0.22641286253929138,
-0.08854478597640991,
0.1400318741798401,
-0.0027605248615145683,
-0.08403099328279495,
0.48473498225212097,
-0.11276548355817795,
0.007881714962422848,
-0.7491521239280701,
-0.32478538155555725,
0.4912901222705841,
-0.020320823416113853,
0.7486153244972229,
0.30795103311538696,
-0.4633112847805023,
0.08933014422655106,
-0.6453980803489685,
0.16207319498062134,
0.14122788608074188,
-0.4264044463634491,
-0.5705989003181458,
0.26175379753112793,
-0.05797524005174637,
0.1950121521949768,
0.031197499483823776,
-0.6835543513298035,
-0.11836449056863785,
-0.45205503702163696,
0.5339479446411133,
0.7321911454200745,
0.21543170511722565,
0.4577902555465698,
0.03147155046463013,
0.37192076444625854,
0.021989481523633003,
0.27885740995407104,
0.3089011013507843,
-0.7129774689674377,
-0.9515866637229919,
0.2241431176662445,
-0.07315081357955933,
0.49263057112693787,
-0.9481035470962524,
0.8116832971572876,
-0.04477973282337189,
-0.6311130523681641,
-0.1800563931465149,
0.08384904265403748,
0.034897107630968094,
0.13125285506248474,
0.22062712907791138,
-0.8357572555541992,
-0.43518516421318054,
-0.9085729122161865,
-0.315924733877182,
-0.22688229382038116,
0.03174373880028725,
0.002123076468706131,
0.19207492470741272,
-0.36334049701690674,
1.0267764329910278,
-0.5776543617248535,
-0.2826986014842987,
-0.3263949155807495,
0.29818159341812134,
0.24616914987564087,
0.33603402972221375,
0.20416763424873352,
-0.8791523575782776,
-0.7790551781654358,
0.2564654052257538,
-0.6914054751396179,
0.0587649792432785,
0.542959988117218,
0.10034635663032532,
0.13755013048648834,
0.3425211012363434,
-0.15575191378593445,
0.46623075008392334,
0.49865177273750305,
-0.257426917552948,
0.3379751145839691,
-0.043584104627370834,
0.26720404624938965,
-1.2001581192016602,
-0.2629022002220154,
0.29087206721305847,
-0.19498543441295624,
-0.7830789089202881,
0.21467728912830353,
-0.437548965215683,
0.18568255007266998,
-0.054252512753009796,
0.14914387464523315,
-0.4898524582386017,
-0.3149110972881317,
-0.5355697274208069,
-0.0281086303293705,
-0.14819587767124176,
0.40777766704559326,
0.006943450774997473,
0.11009624600410461,
0.4950522482395172,
-0.7354565858840942,
0.5747389197349548,
-0.14506758749485016,
-0.4735826849937439,
0.8443040251731873,
-0.5091652870178223,
0.3610858917236328,
-0.22138740122318268,
0.4585764408111572,
-1.071976900100708,
-0.3569861948490143,
0.27306538820266724,
-0.3983131945133209,
-0.44591960310935974,
-0.22972524166107178,
-0.6671491265296936,
-0.4942619502544403,
-0.16871029138565063,
0.575637936592102,
0.27796536684036255,
-0.3086665868759155,
0.5263886451721191,
0.7246593832969666,
0.19310443103313446,
-0.06367821991443634,
-0.799130916595459,
-0.06721213459968567,
-0.5743264555931091,
-0.7718974947929382,
0.14219121634960175,
-0.17110177874565125,
-0.38509029150009155,
0.10957520455121994,
0.18712174892425537,
-0.5660421252250671,
0.24257943034172058,
0.2721748948097229,
-0.20132526755332947,
-0.32964643836021423,
0.13791094720363617,
-0.03085884265601635,
0.1108599603176117,
-0.011974492110311985,
-0.07042016834020615,
0.6366028189659119,
-0.3615264892578125,
-0.403341144323349,
-0.03969346359372139,
0.4886888265609741,
0.36696457862854004,
-0.37641745805740356,
0.8390876054763794,
0.8405560851097107,
-0.6706417798995972,
-0.30168721079826355,
-0.760282576084137,
-0.18979895114898682,
-0.54709792137146,
0.11912281066179276,
0.01924591325223446,
-1.2143563032150269,
0.8078675866127014,
0.06227065622806549,
-0.22380955517292023,
0.4130594730377197,
0.4143954813480377,
-0.08059242367744446,
0.8515812754631042,
0.5394447445869446,
-0.20317411422729492,
0.05636494234204292,
-0.03663340210914612,
0.6184909343719482,
-0.3864644467830658,
0.21982242166996002,
-0.5818364024162292,
-0.7164202928543091,
-0.9313521981239319,
-0.2859640419483185,
0.456357479095459,
-0.10088075697422028,
-0.016614293679594994,
0.37876781821250916,
-0.49787580966949463,
0.8363487720489502,
0.5482287406921387,
0.03991951420903206,
0.558120608329773,
0.2723352015018463,
0.04131881892681122,
0.17780081927776337,
-0.423825740814209,
-0.339826375246048,
0.5083025097846985,
0.22830505669116974,
0.38345134258270264,
0.2550404369831085,
0.5989105701446533,
0.624903678894043,
0.5393303632736206,
-0.8057013154029846,
0.5503412485122681,
-0.18576130270957947,
-0.7263604402542114,
-0.2692745327949524,
-0.46499234437942505,
-0.8881851434707642,
0.1967720240354538,
-0.40435370802879333,
-0.8426351547241211,
0.15086933970451355,
0.0786580964922905,
-0.17365990579128265,
0.41631463170051575,
-0.6552676558494568,
0.7616780400276184,
0.049678269773721695,
0.03540124371647835,
-0.4865596294403076,
-0.5825281739234924,
0.40306398272514343,
0.0011853353353217244,
0.5350708365440369,
-0.17128625512123108,
0.5474942326545715,
0.6628337502479553,
-0.21150285005569458,
1.078616738319397,
0.04006945714354515,
0.376352459192276,
0.5295778512954712,
0.31095895171165466,
0.14600585401058197,
-0.2509439289569855,
-0.012767438776791096,
0.1958027184009552,
0.15847134590148926,
-0.09468628466129303,
-0.5349652767181396,
0.7849234938621521,
-0.6853476166725159,
-0.23839084804058075,
-0.1669931262731552,
0.08023370802402496,
-0.031960561871528625,
0.1330593377351761,
0.27442020177841187,
0.41881176829338074,
-0.2409427911043167,
0.09536450356245041,
0.35402175784111023,
-0.031062452122569084,
0.33661192655563354,
0.30654820799827576,
-0.41378253698349,
-0.40865862369537354,
1.1263395547866821,
0.2562980055809021,
0.260008841753006,
0.23258915543556213,
0.4875160753726959,
-0.1209762766957283,
-0.49670910835266113,
-0.11933594197034836,
0.14535211026668549,
-0.8560136556625366,
0.18408234417438507,
-0.44390684366226196,
-0.2303946614265442,
-0.4252077043056488,
-0.12240960448980331,
-0.029956167563796043,
-0.1713317483663559,
-0.0325561985373497,
-0.2430235892534256,
-0.004517657682299614,
0.967989444732666,
0.14872297644615173,
0.37958815693855286,
-0.7259370684623718,
0.062148161232471466,
0.30994850397109985,
0.6259964108467102,
0.18418630957603455,
0.085787333548069,
-0.23687362670898438,
-0.13110719621181488,
-0.1620444804430008,
-1.1682296991348267,
0.12527093291282654,
0.24023449420928955,
0.4615046977996826,
0.5671718120574951,
-0.0003002232115250081,
0.6058586835861206,
-0.07496096938848495,
0.6878178119659424,
0.06826334446668625,
-0.7154760360717773,
0.3766040503978729,
-0.3890092372894287,
-0.09107993543148041,
0.7607263326644897,
0.4140964448451996,
-1.007802963256836,
-0.4250575602054596,
-0.5679865479469299,
-0.6514832973480225,
0.35261663794517517,
0.3122723400592804,
-0.060193050652742386,
-0.4437178075313568,
0.2867266833782196,
-0.03783859685063362,
0.3305220901966095,
-1.0661934614181519,
-0.3744308650493622,
-0.036706965416669846,
-0.16016785800457,
-0.014733189716935158,
0.05986833944916725,
-0.0670173391699791,
-0.1807216852903366,
0.41151174902915955,
-0.3763388395309448,
0.12029043585062027,
0.21737278997898102,
-0.0460776761174202,
-0.44581910967826843,
0.015211866237223148,
0.29706433415412903,
0.8739928603172302,
0.055139753967523575,
0.3447606563568115,
0.004997082520276308,
-0.26808324456214905,
0.10706012696027756,
-0.4470882713794708,
-0.11439872533082962,
-0.1499311327934265,
0.3069044053554535,
0.45745497941970825,
-0.17208309471607208,
-0.30901268124580383,
0.5149344801902771,
-0.24839167296886444,
-0.026098724454641342,
-0.7097597718238831,
0.07492633908987045,
0.12256627529859543,
0.01694333367049694,
0.5034814476966858,
0.2497667372226715,
0.3678113520145416,
-0.6888248920440674,
-0.020760299637913704,
0.344467431306839,
-0.6155786514282227,
-0.40658992528915405,
-0.04889311268925667,
0.3443466126918793,
-0.5504501461982727,
0.36903640627861023,
-0.5664371848106384,
-0.659914493560791,
0.7949051856994629,
0.392659455537796,
1.058980107307434,
-0.19453825056552887,
0.5301332473754883,
0.37405040860176086,
0.4816911220550537,
-0.04588763415813446,
-0.02104630321264267,
0.13077852129936218,
-1.3393815755844116,
-0.6643174886703491,
-0.8967545628547668,
-0.10474592447280884,
-0.166067972779274,
-0.6827878355979919,
-0.04119190201163292,
-0.6294649243354797,
-0.28675010800361633,
-0.1398455947637558,
-0.27623966336250305,
-0.41019344329833984,
0.2478218823671341,
0.10767372697591782,
0.7598944306373596,
-1.1691540479660034,
0.4944777190685272,
0.8220733404159546,
0.052144791930913925,
-0.5781659483909607,
0.10193618386983871,
0.17561011016368866,
-0.4230623245239258,
0.41797274351119995,
0.48477670550346375,
-0.010569126345217228,
0.019690915942192078,
-0.3801491856575012,
-0.8340979814529419,
0.7709354758262634,
-0.20436589419841766,
0.015709301456809044,
0.41498109698295593,
0.13948123157024384,
0.843974769115448,
-0.4436667263507843,
0.2612304091453552,
0.3864884674549103,
0.4010375738143921,
0.09142835438251495,
-0.9315550327301025,
0.007139386609196663,
-0.5697346329689026,
-0.11824943125247955,
0.2581266462802887,
-0.5797439217567444,
0.6340281963348389,
0.4617299437522888,
-0.3583340644836426,
-0.3606153428554535,
0.7832183241844177,
0.22228258848190308,
0.4632256031036377,
1.1345797777175903,
0.29070374369621277,
0.7835174798965454,
0.05688856914639473,
0.9076114296913147,
0.03257273882627487,
0.25821325182914734,
0.6223331689834595,
-0.3023330569267273,
0.6836519241333008,
0.3345967233181,
-0.35178858041763306,
0.8666735887527466,
0.961043119430542,
0.010776893235743046,
0.16772420704364777,
0.42429912090301514,
-0.2782686948776245,
-0.24106420576572418,
-0.35678428411483765,
-0.18029139935970306,
0.3885793387889862,
0.14648441970348358,
-0.29871246218681335,
0.001556736184284091,
-0.22505733370780945,
-0.3499602973461151,
0.35003188252449036,
-0.5945844054222107,
0.7176015377044678,
0.11824754625558853,
-0.7290019392967224,
-0.0737745389342308,
0.4239821434020996,
0.8637905120849609,
-0.4573209583759308,
0.22330507636070251,
-0.1095103994011879,
0.02502790279686451,
-0.44518518447875977,
-0.48499536514282227,
0.5836916565895081,
-0.24753476679325104,
-0.19214560091495514,
0.1612466275691986,
1.067110538482666,
-0.2293594777584076,
-0.7495766282081604,
0.5606222748756409,
0.5437636971473694,
0.20714214444160461,
-0.17664188146591187,
-0.38005805015563965,
-0.27285343408584595,
-0.14967094361782074,
0.08163980394601822,
0.31188592314720154,
0.07278480380773544,
-0.33593764901161194,
0.4045386016368866,
0.810735821723938,
0.13819476962089539,
0.4585711658000946,
0.1284661591053009,
0.5133897662162781,
-0.5004176497459412,
-0.991027295589447,
-0.975861132144928,
0.12524063885211945,
-0.4639982283115387,
-0.25561901926994324,
0.8885394334793091,
0.3442002832889557,
1.0290701389312744,
0.10593391954898834,
0.8120213747024536,
-0.4069920480251312,
0.34556180238723755,
-0.19705475866794586,
0.598824143409729,
-0.26505419611930847,
-0.18177561461925507,
-0.3079548478126526,
-1.0407766103744507,
-0.12435031682252884,
0.5722990036010742,
-0.2294619083404541,
0.08834566175937653,
0.7743545770645142,
0.7193889021873474,
-0.1975610852241516,
0.6487835645675659,
-0.0389249324798584,
0.1954982727766037,
0.22298020124435425,
0.08292747288942337,
0.891081690788269,
-0.03359748050570488,
0.20588792860507965,
-0.5289211273193359,
-0.4587005376815796,
0.0698167011141777,
-0.8219724297523499,
-1.151548147201538,
-0.5941423177719116,
-0.27276796102523804,
-0.3485506474971771,
-0.6050122976303101,
1.1700388193130493,
0.4975820481777191,
-0.8846935629844666,
-0.6109129786491394,
-0.016244128346443176,
0.2068501114845276,
-0.485772967338562,
-0.35917404294013977,
0.0044038076885044575,
0.23621264100074768,
-0.4463026821613312,
0.5436298251152039,
0.3703293800354004,
-0.22582729160785675,
-0.6932227611541748,
-0.023376010358333588,
-0.22999617457389832,
-0.17173020541667938,
0.6484318971633911,
0.17532965540885925,
-0.5743805766105652,
-0.364104688167572,
0.0612884983420372,
0.21849273145198822,
-0.01376632321625948,
0.8343797922134399,
-0.30929121375083923,
0.45808130502700806,
0.6535029411315918,
0.586327075958252,
0.41574567556381226,
0.09991386532783508,
0.5383363366127014,
-0.7983747124671936,
-0.3058587610721588,
0.024242747575044632,
0.2684016227722168,
0.4205380082130432,
-0.4555498957633972,
0.44391030073165894,
0.7716304063796997,
-0.4333361089229584,
-0.6000869870185852,
0.3454034626483917,
-0.8551302552223206,
-0.12160217761993408,
0.9696014523506165,
0.09489830583333969,
-0.32423877716064453,
-0.4257035255432129,
0.08862095326185226,
0.33792659640312195,
0.006638001184910536,
0.894549548625946,
0.6325505375862122,
-0.029857296496629715,
0.2031584084033966,
-0.28070342540740967,
0.04484604299068451,
0.008221006952226162,
-0.8384767174720764,
-0.5493203401565552,
0.2007446587085724,
0.36269745230674744,
0.614167332649231,
0.8549198508262634,
0.1999286413192749,
-0.04926922172307968,
-0.7909689545631409,
0.03454822301864624,
0.1769208312034607,
0.0486077181994915,
-0.18848314881324768,
0.7014269232749939,
-0.22201067209243774,
0.11389387398958206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17104v1 | Automated Adversarial Discovery for Safety Classifiers | 2024-06-24T19:45:12 | 2024-06-24T19:45:12 | Yash Kumar Lal, Preethi Lahoti, Aradhana Sinha, Yao Qin, Ananth Balashankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Safety classifiers are critical in mitigating toxicity on online forums such
as social media and in chatbots. Still, they continue to be vulnerable to
emergent, and often innumerable, adversarial attacks. Traditional automated
adversarial data generation methods, however, tend to produce attacks that are
not diverse, but variations of previously observed harm types. We formalize the
task of automated adversarial discovery for safety classifiers - to find new
attacks along previously unseen harm dimensions that expose new weaknesses in
the classifier. We measure progress on this task along two key axes (1)
adversarial success: does the attack fool the classifier? and (2) dimensional
diversity: does the attack represent a previously unseen harm type? Our
evaluation of existing attack generation methods on the CivilComments toxicity
task reveals their limitations: Word perturbation attacks fail to fool
classifiers, while prompt-based LLM attacks have more adversarial success, but
lack dimensional diversity. Even our best-performing prompt-based method finds
new successful attacks on unseen harm dimensions of attacks only 5\% of the
time. Automatically finding new harmful dimensions of attack is crucial and
there is substantial headroom for future research on our new task. | [
-0.40105122327804565,
-0.7975342869758606,
0.5069859623908997,
0.04173266515135765,
0.19419044256210327,
0.21651345491409302,
0.16714589297771454,
-0.29495128989219666,
0.013892879709601402,
0.242920383810997,
-0.4342617988586426,
-0.8107262849807739,
-1.0221606492996216,
-0.09124147891998291,
-0.3096238374710083,
1.1126035451889038,
0.21313057839870453,
-0.1164076179265976,
-0.04889843240380287,
-0.029726073145866394,
-0.3868463337421417,
-0.7450442314147949,
-0.8762316107749939,
0.09191469103097916,
0.9741900563240051,
0.4287305474281311,
0.8602350950241089,
0.6286792159080505,
0.8453852534294128,
0.38338133692741394,
-0.3853532373905182,
-0.008994384668767452,
-0.3910735547542572,
0.2180948704481125,
-0.06705120205879211,
-0.40753939747810364,
-0.25011688470840454,
0.11065944284200668,
0.1645960956811905,
0.5982979536056519,
0.1695573776960373,
-0.10159450769424438,
0.0646534115076065,
0.7291572093963623,
-0.8972523808479309,
0.03852545842528343,
-0.7579880952835083,
0.3819882571697235,
-0.2006262242794037,
-0.22806842625141144,
-0.47710689902305603,
-0.5660531520843506,
0.10552669316530228,
-0.36454474925994873,
0.3790220320224762,
-0.0870092436671257,
0.42425537109375,
0.5073793530464172,
-0.8602202534675598,
-0.4547339081764221,
-0.7347977161407471,
0.5924890637397766,
-0.24049879610538483,
-0.030312880873680115,
0.06484034657478333,
0.5584020018577576,
-0.6248776912689209,
-0.5301734805107117,
-0.1423867642879486,
-0.5052490234375,
0.03735344856977463,
-0.11764083802700043,
-0.2801106572151184,
0.12784934043884277,
0.39319202303886414,
0.17164574563503265,
-0.5364950299263,
0.1417282670736313,
-0.2572096288204193,
-0.36518919467926025,
1.0845218896865845,
0.3495192527770996,
0.4331754148006439,
-0.03006703220307827,
-0.4350565969944,
-0.35854074358940125,
-0.5755816102027893,
0.08723823726177216,
0.7494410276412964,
0.2746182978153229,
0.06499158591032028,
0.2676376402378082,
0.02905144914984703,
0.15739552676677704,
-0.07371823489665985,
0.00957537442445755,
0.15138360857963562,
-0.2852986454963684,
0.08781908452510834,
0.21159155666828156,
1.019270658493042,
0.2192470282316208,
-0.197260320186615,
-0.07824036478996277,
-0.07841817289590836,
0.2989520728588104,
0.5816650986671448,
-0.5844416618347168,
-0.8493895530700684,
0.01718190312385559,
-0.2616955637931824,
-1.0127335786819458,
0.000719253090210259,
-0.7714191675186157,
-1.166345238685608,
0.3370959162712097,
0.6102396845817566,
-0.3635372519493103,
-0.04677080735564232,
-0.12203327566385269,
-0.5494100451469421,
-0.11612298339605331,
0.2912156879901886,
-0.46854498982429504,
0.02437015436589718,
0.32246679067611694,
0.7413008213043213,
-0.17324839532375336,
-0.11580485850572586,
-0.6255960464477539,
-0.23578278720378876,
-0.4391307234764099,
0.8405081629753113,
-0.29368168115615845,
-0.634424090385437,
-0.14932671189308167,
-0.07403187453746796,
-0.006179174408316612,
-0.534317672252655,
0.8381398320198059,
-0.4223179221153259,
0.14506104588508606,
-0.5163208246231079,
-0.271699994802475,
-0.38150256872177124,
0.3244656026363373,
-0.7975730895996094,
0.5291733145713806,
-0.06836850941181183,
-1.0133976936340332,
0.36334577202796936,
-0.8960424065589905,
-0.604701042175293,
-0.14320896565914154,
0.03775017708539963,
-0.7857974171638489,
-0.02301446534693241,
0.06213292479515076,
0.32017412781715393,
-0.14221933484077454,
-0.10872281342744827,
-0.7113265991210938,
-0.232364222407341,
0.2776623070240021,
-0.5944381356239319,
1.1187187433242798,
0.24462872743606567,
-0.577297568321228,
0.3403347432613373,
-0.7521615028381348,
-0.03983309864997864,
0.3771562874317169,
-0.3768157958984375,
-0.20579729974269867,
0.3102266192436218,
-0.07426687330007553,
0.1990681290626526,
0.20175181329250336,
-0.6363745927810669,
-0.10427270829677582,
-0.13788439333438873,
0.13278689980506897,
0.9383705854415894,
0.24801713228225708,
0.13663923740386963,
-0.45873817801475525,
0.50428706407547,
0.1645122617483139,
0.5539059042930603,
0.10682293772697449,
-0.44779065251350403,
-0.7203314304351807,
-0.07449240982532501,
0.1549665778875351,
0.7152010798454285,
-0.6026766300201416,
0.6372650265693665,
0.1112651452422142,
-0.9248101115226746,
-0.01903783716261387,
-0.060110658407211304,
0.4753378629684448,
0.29454877972602844,
0.4254472255706787,
-0.27775949239730835,
-0.409549355506897,
-0.8110281825065613,
-0.29811835289001465,
-0.3689230680465698,
-0.06076089292764664,
0.3176426589488983,
0.39879465103149414,
-0.6114604473114014,
0.46578162908554077,
-0.5522748231887817,
-0.26616400480270386,
0.16636453568935394,
0.261167049407959,
-0.48343896865844727,
0.4004785418510437,
0.6889181733131409,
-0.7556804418563843,
-0.3670644164085388,
-0.16474227607250214,
-0.9451646208763123,
0.09054211527109146,
-0.004748118110001087,
0.06407494097948074,
0.1056947186589241,
0.3437292277812958,
-0.187890887260437,
0.20937596261501312,
0.31689366698265076,
-0.26520487666130066,
0.34180089831352234,
0.04008212313055992,
0.13595321774482727,
-0.7162061929702759,
-0.1565026342868805,
-0.09102419018745422,
0.1182439997792244,
-0.9915636777877808,
0.0815322995185852,
0.038925714790821075,
-0.11920894682407379,
-0.6097825169563293,
0.09311358630657196,
-0.1264062374830246,
0.237611785531044,
-0.23486262559890747,
-0.03703617677092552,
-0.22194965183734894,
0.3203599154949188,
-0.5313488841056824,
0.31930598616600037,
0.7585315704345703,
-0.6566543579101562,
0.5188112854957581,
-0.06478244066238403,
0.2338845431804657,
0.43618130683898926,
-0.5083548426628113,
0.16023513674736023,
-0.22688515484333038,
0.3586227297782898,
-0.8971554040908813,
-0.4169308543205261,
0.44101691246032715,
-0.522612988948822,
0.3728984594345093,
-0.038162268698215485,
-0.24761876463890076,
-0.45913752913475037,
-0.6844716668128967,
0.23788490891456604,
0.23799069225788116,
-0.7338502407073975,
0.4107201397418976,
0.6383651494979858,
-0.10294236242771149,
-0.7403238415718079,
-0.3618149757385254,
0.2737411558628082,
-0.46756258606910706,
-0.6765300631523132,
0.012059571221470833,
-0.20304247736930847,
-0.3195972740650177,
-0.22594696283340454,
-0.1918887346982956,
0.09089019149541855,
0.6774638891220093,
0.5587604641914368,
0.008715183474123478,
0.10568847507238388,
-0.03346267342567444,
-0.19681492447853088,
-0.13612942397594452,
0.6887974143028259,
-0.04852171614766121,
0.29145070910453796,
-0.28225794434547424,
-0.4298163056373596,
-0.3752043843269348,
0.4024289846420288,
0.5783955454826355,
0.028394076973199844,
0.5169979929924011,
0.5339741110801697,
-0.3799266815185547,
-0.10144462436437607,
-0.23102155327796936,
0.034463755786418915,
-0.5541504621505737,
0.4558008313179016,
0.1256362795829773,
-0.7278376221656799,
0.393145352602005,
0.042377445846796036,
0.3046431839466095,
0.856614887714386,
0.15234029293060303,
0.022788161411881447,
1.5092945098876953,
0.5385168790817261,
-0.21544045209884644,
0.29907312989234924,
-0.11046656221151352,
0.21724632382392883,
-0.26257985830307007,
-0.3648033142089844,
-0.506160318851471,
-0.35879483819007874,
-0.9574962258338928,
0.06667362153530121,
0.7653635144233704,
-0.15204408764839172,
-0.4684583842754364,
0.22199271619319916,
-0.5327776074409485,
0.2825755476951599,
0.7632683515548706,
0.3355496823787689,
0.050454288721084595,
-0.1488126814365387,
0.154123917222023,
0.21127887070178986,
-0.6119003891944885,
-0.3718976080417633,
1.2459114789962769,
0.5110347270965576,
0.7406864762306213,
0.2530435621738434,
1.0258764028549194,
0.35373613238334656,
0.5387822985649109,
-0.7255502939224243,
0.6359388828277588,
-0.28686919808387756,
-0.6572334170341492,
-0.3221678137779236,
-0.5563201904296875,
-0.9815019965171814,
-0.014850115403532982,
-0.2628836929798126,
-0.13073498010635376,
-0.06601965427398682,
0.4172738492488861,
-0.3598608374595642,
0.45851239562034607,
-0.6668726801872253,
0.707781970500946,
-0.5049909353256226,
0.011509422212839127,
-0.07523834705352783,
-0.8201524019241333,
0.46426427364349365,
-0.26478976011276245,
0.10213778167963028,
0.16211214661598206,
0.3423045575618744,
0.6926220655441284,
-0.31344643235206604,
0.9343699216842651,
-0.4997062385082245,
-0.2281111627817154,
0.27538952231407166,
0.09281230717897415,
0.6342888474464417,
-0.13585913181304932,
0.21094851195812225,
0.001166338799521327,
-0.36649900674819946,
-0.3328583836555481,
-0.39585787057876587,
0.6485329866409302,
-0.6003367304801941,
-0.7213499546051025,
-0.7409942746162415,
-0.5622129440307617,
-0.06863388419151306,
0.1039963886141777,
0.3979799151420593,
0.021269863471388817,
-0.35303041338920593,
0.2366325855255127,
0.9619494676589966,
-0.58427494764328,
0.4265434741973877,
0.37610167264938354,
0.41413435339927673,
-0.3917328119277954,
1.1932942867279053,
0.14501649141311646,
0.10864434391260147,
0.24864934384822845,
0.25022077560424805,
-0.15528884530067444,
-0.7017356157302856,
-0.14141714572906494,
-0.3587219715118408,
-0.7360743284225464,
-0.308175653219223,
-0.6795944571495056,
-0.4821161925792694,
-0.4296148419380188,
-0.18496933579444885,
-0.232476145029068,
-0.26422038674354553,
-0.1234760507941246,
-0.1411777287721634,
0.3589761555194855,
0.8625467419624329,
-0.22702135145664215,
0.12950117886066437,
-0.7986243367195129,
0.11591684818267822,
0.6501954197883606,
0.06315387040376663,
-0.34621238708496094,
-0.09743884205818176,
0.03382512554526329,
0.20005741715431213,
-0.8132779002189636,
-0.8794093132019043,
0.2791675925254822,
-0.1304442137479782,
0.42645132541656494,
0.5830711722373962,
0.4588847756385803,
0.15721666812896729,
-0.289506733417511,
0.7886469960212708,
0.21488940715789795,
-0.506409764289856,
0.66286301612854,
-0.3752385377883911,
-0.09081187099218369,
0.36649057269096375,
0.655998706817627,
-0.22194086015224457,
-0.55836021900177,
-0.936839759349823,
-0.7077739834785461,
0.21246139705181122,
0.3164236843585968,
-0.08855520933866501,
-0.20084209740161896,
-0.08742932230234146,
-0.04644232615828514,
-0.03958890959620476,
-0.5568006634712219,
-0.5700697898864746,
-0.23672528564929962,
-0.05782844126224518,
-0.09327072650194168,
-0.16742147505283356,
-0.43789032101631165,
0.24569983780384064,
0.6367908120155334,
0.1250540018081665,
0.16490469872951508,
-0.05196721479296684,
0.1521608531475067,
-0.2338782548904419,
0.3875359296798706,
0.3619500398635864,
-0.0886709988117218,
-0.07005413621664047,
0.45588231086730957,
0.40577182173728943,
-0.607322096824646,
0.3229306638240814,
0.5837153792381287,
-0.15170235931873322,
-0.24495434761047363,
0.3677814304828644,
0.439187616109848,
-0.15254618227481842,
-0.49813157320022583,
0.5939350128173828,
-0.30146023631095886,
-0.39616209268569946,
-0.58110511302948,
0.675690770149231,
-0.36965256929397583,
0.33231019973754883,
0.19130977988243103,
0.5145693421363831,
0.5026823282241821,
-0.48892760276794434,
0.3836091458797455,
0.8040199875831604,
-0.4283682703971863,
-0.09404167532920837,
0.8137838840484619,
0.24367325007915497,
-0.3317949175834656,
0.11745353788137436,
-0.37894514203071594,
-0.7000753283500671,
0.8455795049667358,
0.16070163249969482,
1.0116288661956787,
-0.5035018920898438,
0.22142474353313446,
0.25486719608306885,
0.4578712284564972,
0.044746093451976776,
0.13031616806983948,
0.18666337430477142,
-0.3596534729003906,
0.41083434224128723,
-0.3099863827228546,
-0.47558921575546265,
0.344007283449173,
-0.5584214329719543,
0.028806274756789207,
-0.7733533382415771,
-0.12433858960866928,
0.18758568167686462,
0.08364538103342056,
-0.36504077911376953,
0.5022796988487244,
0.01644868403673172,
0.4588035047054291,
-0.9638713002204895,
0.1785791665315628,
0.5588810443878174,
-0.18171964585781097,
-0.44034042954444885,
0.09902460873126984,
0.6007431149482727,
-0.34597012400627136,
0.46362683176994324,
0.33774101734161377,
-0.12172740697860718,
-0.2839409112930298,
-0.5293856859207153,
-0.8280049562454224,
0.9779177308082581,
0.2361718863248825,
-0.3713643550872803,
0.11156497150659561,
0.17644865810871124,
0.6502701640129089,
0.11070943623781204,
-0.09989149123430252,
0.2262289971113205,
0.43919801712036133,
-0.019260697066783905,
-0.4756168723106384,
0.25030311942100525,
-0.4402112066745758,
-0.07937481999397278,
0.3445340692996979,
-0.5802469253540039,
0.7669327259063721,
-0.4022846519947052,
-0.3571026623249054,
-0.23659583926200867,
0.49592670798301697,
0.10144679248332977,
0.6111339926719666,
0.8467587828636169,
0.6245813965797424,
0.748119592666626,
-0.08535759896039963,
0.9106345176696777,
-0.07732158154249191,
0.0364728607237339,
0.8564748167991638,
-0.034150369465351105,
0.4438321888446808,
-0.08888869732618332,
-0.04101979732513428,
0.27486634254455566,
0.7143241763114929,
-0.27313724160194397,
0.40061330795288086,
0.3309767246246338,
-0.5548456311225891,
-0.07012751698493958,
-0.04738635569810867,
-0.3040563762187958,
0.1687776893377304,
0.26158496737480164,
-0.5022984147071838,
-0.24197569489479065,
0.21411772072315216,
0.1431097835302353,
-0.09830745309591293,
-0.08709442615509033,
0.7861456274986267,
-0.2799551486968994,
-0.49460673332214355,
0.5737390518188477,
0.031757596880197525,
0.6344528794288635,
-0.30381542444229126,
0.0667392909526825,
-0.04655984789133072,
0.23533742129802704,
-0.19925357401371002,
-0.697291910648346,
0.3146447241306305,
-0.05374343320727348,
-0.016107646748423576,
0.0928124338388443,
0.6477816104888916,
-0.11772564798593521,
-0.3134772479534149,
0.36212390661239624,
0.011213219724595547,
0.010464495047926903,
-0.19558176398277283,
-0.4174180328845978,
-0.29300016164779663,
-0.03594115749001503,
-0.15169157087802887,
0.4473361372947693,
0.33146578073501587,
-0.021452410146594048,
0.8017943501472473,
0.5956643223762512,
-0.09590234607458115,
0.14497408270835876,
-0.0343928337097168,
0.9928606152534485,
-0.6080912351608276,
-0.34712666273117065,
-0.7119001150131226,
0.34704652428627014,
-0.1974378526210785,
-0.18340067565441132,
0.8201804161071777,
0.4430883824825287,
0.7582600116729736,
0.1186075210571289,
1.08668851852417,
-0.14856906235218048,
0.3916472792625427,
-0.23643766343593597,
0.8153287768363953,
-0.40635788440704346,
0.46555545926094055,
-0.3006073534488678,
-0.4770042598247528,
-0.5595355033874512,
0.2646465599536896,
-0.14486607909202576,
-0.10050076246261597,
0.706427812576294,
0.9702123999595642,
0.21207717061042786,
0.05814671888947487,
-0.0022935683373361826,
0.23669320344924927,
0.7453044652938843,
0.5641470551490784,
0.8969460129737854,
-0.5096274614334106,
1.0209406614303589,
-0.4185969829559326,
-0.5111154317855835,
-0.07971975952386856,
-0.7482649087905884,
-1.1137008666992188,
-0.36402732133865356,
-0.46586036682128906,
-0.46551457047462463,
0.3087041974067688,
0.5859346985816956,
0.2601420283317566,
-0.9046792984008789,
0.41791725158691406,
-0.3536412715911865,
0.17345716059207916,
-0.051813241094350815,
-0.28781256079673767,
0.288265585899353,
-0.4192868769168854,
-0.42482948303222656,
0.4847656786441803,
0.0745898187160492,
0.2009287178516388,
-0.33771467208862305,
0.02025606855750084,
0.1726352870464325,
0.04086814075708389,
0.5791573524475098,
0.39556142687797546,
-0.39920586347579956,
-0.5601209402084351,
-0.2145794928073883,
-0.29640811681747437,
-0.3330616354942322,
0.44303858280181885,
-0.2929973602294922,
0.3354330360889435,
0.5543394684791565,
0.7330967783927917,
-0.2880653142929077,
-0.2532414495944977,
0.4010103642940521,
-0.7075467705726624,
-0.16339156031608582,
0.332817941904068,
0.24472716450691223,
0.2445179522037506,
-0.7864733338356018,
0.517342746257782,
0.30213692784309387,
-0.6346104741096497,
-0.8308302760124207,
0.4227331578731537,
-0.528560996055603,
-0.3413715660572052,
0.9476006031036377,
-0.12545503675937653,
0.07141177356243134,
-0.15348853170871735,
-0.21974138915538788,
0.29315972328186035,
-0.16661059856414795,
1.3186168670654297,
0.2962820827960968,
-0.06180427968502045,
0.3172506093978882,
-0.24535101652145386,
0.8157111406326294,
0.20138412714004517,
-1.0278023481369019,
0.02006240002810955,
0.5314335823059082,
0.10696527361869812,
0.5808249115943909,
0.1322186291217804,
-0.18887822329998016,
0.45635539293289185,
0.2395796775817871,
-0.2108127474784851,
0.053001146763563156,
-0.7025131583213806,
-0.24288931488990784,
0.4142095744609833,
-0.20231278240680695,
-0.31141871213912964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17095v1 | Attention Instruction: Amplifying Attention in the Middle via Prompting | 2024-06-24T19:35:11 | 2024-06-24T19:35:11 | Meiru Zhang, Zaiqiao Meng, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL | The context window of large language models has been extended to 128k tokens
or more. However, language models still suffer from position bias and have
difficulty in accessing and using the middle part of the context due to the
lack of attention. We examine the relative position awareness of LLMs and the
feasibility of mitigating disproportional attention through prompting. We
augment the original task instruction with $\texttt{attention instructions}$
that direct language models to allocate more attention towards a selected
segment of the context. We conduct a comprehensive investigation on
multi-document question answering task with both position-based and index-based
instructions. We find that language models do not have relative position
awareness of the context. Nevertheless, they demonstrate the capacity to adapt
attention to a specific segment using matching indexes. Our analysis
contributes to a deeper understanding of position bias in LLMs and provides a
pathway to mitigate this bias by instruction, thus benefiting LLMs in locating
and utilizing relevant information from retrieved documents in RAG
applications. | [
-0.24081799387931824,
-0.9147641062736511,
0.9186297059059143,
0.12907259166240692,
0.050945162773132324,
-0.11428294330835342,
-0.08802615106105804,
-0.18450935184955597,
-0.1344917118549347,
0.3130466639995575,
-0.7421016693115234,
-0.3806595802307129,
-0.7183950543403625,
-0.02255258522927761,
-0.38445529341697693,
0.8126444816589355,
0.05922999978065491,
0.056209057569503784,
-0.4703470766544342,
-0.02279476635158062,
-0.8392193913459778,
-0.6132413744926453,
-0.5902462601661682,
-0.09199473261833191,
0.5988207459449768,
0.714733362197876,
0.32060351967811584,
0.5914590954780579,
0.32122495770454407,
0.40428295731544495,
-0.18729481101036072,
0.04239906743168831,
-0.5914541482925415,
0.21477249264717102,
-0.2993488907814026,
-0.8431342244148254,
-0.28781765699386597,
0.1494896560907364,
0.9563148021697998,
0.7380458116531372,
-0.08232002705335617,
0.1501895636320114,
0.053346216678619385,
0.936156690120697,
-0.6877542734146118,
-0.18406154215335846,
-0.6662381291389465,
-0.13615907728672028,
-0.2878800630569458,
-0.408308207988739,
-0.5637737512588501,
-0.00101550854742527,
0.33346888422966003,
-0.3539048731327057,
0.37603452801704407,
0.2869897484779358,
0.6191425919532776,
0.5276681184768677,
-0.31483444571495056,
-0.3019593060016632,
-0.5158768892288208,
0.9681220650672913,
-0.2181728184223175,
0.3291613459587097,
0.4348544478416443,
0.1634148806333542,
-0.09784006327390671,
-0.2794284224510193,
-0.42413169145584106,
0.08894741535186768,
0.0028546457178890705,
0.11425460129976273,
-0.026624875143170357,
0.12574245035648346,
0.47743669152259827,
0.052584946155548096,
-0.388056218624115,
0.01814858987927437,
-0.2740403115749359,
0.04449642449617386,
0.09214115887880325,
0.16566377878189087,
0.3219043016433716,
0.0535469725728035,
-0.45267927646636963,
-0.10912644118070602,
-0.6394538283348083,
0.07106585800647736,
0.18634405732154846,
0.04719451069831848,
-0.11100765317678452,
0.5223680734634399,
0.06811302900314331,
1.0364887714385986,
0.5023080706596375,
-0.21335525810718536,
-0.18077200651168823,
-0.16743409633636475,
-0.3436526954174042,
0.15694445371627808,
0.06520113348960876,
0.41719529032707214,
0.08017835766077042,
-0.04236234724521637,
0.007366551551967859,
-0.3481128513813019,
0.5368852615356445,
-0.3842799961566925,
0.45110636949539185,
0.22159358859062195,
-0.33905118703842163,
0.128634512424469,
-0.09999172389507294,
-0.6503688097000122,
-0.3412756621837616,
-0.4272470474243164,
0.1910705417394638,
-0.11551547795534134,
0.32208967208862305,
0.01250944472849369,
-0.14313380420207977,
0.5497068166732788,
0.44514572620391846,
-1.246877670288086,
0.1133362278342247,
0.8317055106163025,
0.7146932482719421,
-0.17275109887123108,
-0.3019670248031616,
-0.4445374011993408,
0.5826250910758972,
-0.21762414276599884,
0.8773288726806641,
-0.7255150079727173,
-0.40815600752830505,
-0.1319742351770401,
0.21663250029087067,
-0.4546282887458801,
-0.3409728705883026,
0.34882622957229614,
-0.6544167399406433,
0.5483701229095459,
-0.463784396648407,
-0.5508073568344116,
-0.1893792748451233,
0.48701319098472595,
-0.5022752285003662,
1.0750064849853516,
0.19040144979953766,
-0.8937612771987915,
-0.1604291945695877,
-0.7755653262138367,
-0.39840877056121826,
-0.2848183512687683,
-0.13255754113197327,
-0.0350329652428627,
0.1656913459300995,
0.44442272186279297,
0.40113013982772827,
-0.2215401828289032,
-0.15270771086215973,
-0.02632552944123745,
-0.6155266165733337,
0.39524760842323303,
-0.499288946390152,
0.5332250595092773,
-0.06863845139741898,
-0.28963467478752136,
0.13277140259742737,
-0.3478187918663025,
-0.3603675365447998,
0.06574346870183945,
-0.38934728503227234,
-0.6680446267127991,
-0.25829535722732544,
-0.4762832224369049,
0.09656944125890732,
0.3770234286785126,
-0.19041575491428375,
0.2537821829319,
-0.4957600235939026,
0.17149889469146729,
0.9695258736610413,
0.1335018128156662,
0.9237701296806335,
-0.29223811626434326,
0.7717384099960327,
-0.0876639112830162,
0.2566682696342468,
-0.3163236975669861,
-0.2369716763496399,
-0.8751516938209534,
0.060510486364364624,
0.05952753871679306,
0.6507197022438049,
-0.5641353130340576,
0.01964106410741806,
-0.06400839984416962,
0.04511931911110878,
-0.5986274480819702,
0.07437870651483536,
0.6303958296775818,
0.8530198931694031,
0.09864497929811478,
0.031077079474925995,
-0.39305809140205383,
-0.9726188778877258,
-0.02813946269452572,
0.06813060492277145,
0.12795184552669525,
0.3665684163570404,
-0.0013769951183348894,
0.0022636018693447113,
0.6067542433738708,
-0.6131023168563843,
-0.13035663962364197,
-0.27698418498039246,
-0.24366535246372223,
0.23405992984771729,
0.10300377756357193,
0.40427955985069275,
-0.7621601819992065,
-0.6399236917495728,
-0.42176300287246704,
-0.4127242863178253,
-0.24113090336322784,
-0.12542228400707245,
-0.5339109897613525,
0.2227541208267212,
0.858768105506897,
-0.5515047311782837,
0.1117357462644577,
0.42096513509750366,
-0.06458839774131775,
0.41525542736053467,
-0.2773517966270447,
0.09783687442541122,
-1.206466794013977,
0.08578884601593018,
0.03333151713013649,
-0.18328453600406647,
-0.7077897787094116,
-0.11871392279863358,
0.1210983619093895,
0.028799323365092278,
-0.5687516927719116,
0.8352922201156616,
-0.8762019872665405,
-0.2813960909843445,
-0.6161218881607056,
0.48745930194854736,
0.2707139551639557,
0.521337628364563,
-0.05231834948062897,
0.9706624746322632,
0.46252337098121643,
-0.6173296570777893,
-0.052580058574676514,
0.2785218358039856,
-0.2117382436990738,
0.8889525532722473,
-0.5028021931648254,
0.3766455054283142,
-0.44797372817993164,
0.14665694534778595,
-1.1381803750991821,
-0.18495339155197144,
0.2587762176990509,
-0.32310885190963745,
0.7740116715431213,
-0.1897265762090683,
-0.08332152664661407,
-0.355832040309906,
-0.4627528786659241,
0.15436378121376038,
0.17072971165180206,
-0.3391139507293701,
0.2963515818119049,
0.5853754281997681,
-0.41844722628593445,
-1.1276507377624512,
-0.5540151000022888,
-0.17344529926776886,
-0.3095526695251465,
-0.4437686502933502,
0.33709296584129333,
-0.10460105538368225,
-0.3789272606372833,
-0.11472187936306,
-0.2769003212451935,
0.11691753566265106,
0.17803935706615448,
0.19956880807876587,
0.42761459946632385,
0.04333752393722534,
0.3282616436481476,
-0.0640917643904686,
-0.26759424805641174,
0.02418910339474678,
-0.25533097982406616,
0.3700159788131714,
0.1744774878025055,
-0.5088820457458496,
-0.3833097815513611,
0.5584955811500549,
0.5391760468482971,
0.021001914516091347,
0.6502498388290405,
0.3438067138195038,
-0.26249438524246216,
-0.17309360206127167,
-0.7498891353607178,
-0.3857952058315277,
-0.5005794763565063,
0.4068712592124939,
-0.1644684076309204,
-0.9984437823295593,
0.2562870383262634,
0.09225180000066757,
-0.012241646647453308,
0.08821593225002289,
0.6751654148101807,
-0.29788675904273987,
1.0771191120147705,
0.7934116721153259,
-0.3891020119190216,
0.8554017543792725,
0.05027009919285774,
0.21975933015346527,
-1.299949049949646,
-0.006683412007987499,
-0.7452630400657654,
-0.520379364490509,
-0.15669673681259155,
-0.6213529706001282,
0.5148673057556152,
-0.05160627141594887,
0.15627671778202057,
-0.18672706186771393,
-0.7689929604530334,
0.8011738061904907,
0.672566294670105,
0.07970308512449265,
-0.14966613054275513,
0.06529497355222702,
-0.17541299760341644,
-0.057697657495737076,
-0.801012396812439,
-0.533045768737793,
0.7233180403709412,
0.3330720365047455,
0.6723618507385254,
0.009490802884101868,
0.4506886601448059,
0.029364557936787605,
0.28890499472618103,
-0.754913330078125,
0.5488875508308411,
-0.09783990681171417,
-0.7430872917175293,
-0.5143678784370422,
-0.008719388395547867,
-0.9762313961982727,
0.19873200356960297,
0.310135155916214,
-0.9413855075836182,
0.14329177141189575,
-0.0022283385042101145,
-0.5344287157058716,
-0.10465922951698303,
-0.9863396883010864,
0.7570310831069946,
-0.16665787994861603,
-0.6093327403068542,
-0.08720286190509796,
-0.7337597012519836,
0.2030864953994751,
0.2605801224708557,
0.3336280882358551,
-0.1514427810907364,
-0.14384546875953674,
0.6818517446517944,
-0.23966051638126373,
1.1064434051513672,
-0.42979368567466736,
-0.17000359296798706,
0.38475415110588074,
-0.2660488784313202,
0.6478952169418335,
-0.2003786265850067,
-0.12910519540309906,
-0.4718540906906128,
-0.2595171332359314,
-0.4104596972465515,
-0.6582785248756409,
0.7806069850921631,
-0.4971555471420288,
-1.2806698083877563,
-0.3026701509952545,
-0.9883348345756531,
-0.40481722354888916,
0.12615959346294403,
-0.0162002295255661,
0.21149995923042297,
0.09251973778009415,
0.07675531506538391,
1.093703269958496,
-0.14986181259155273,
0.5161207318305969,
0.6477090120315552,
0.2882882356643677,
0.0896131843328476,
0.602568507194519,
-0.015893030911684036,
0.14125631749629974,
0.7348595857620239,
0.2869654893875122,
-0.7240811586380005,
-0.5234387516975403,
-0.3726181387901306,
0.2711712718009949,
-1.0485371351242065,
0.07571548968553543,
-0.7165569067001343,
0.009575985372066498,
-0.3787051737308502,
-0.4505617320537567,
0.043884556740522385,
-0.36237287521362305,
-0.25438323616981506,
-0.132564976811409,
0.20421303808689117,
0.5448768734931946,
0.3065299987792969,
0.5290870666503906,
-0.9013503193855286,
0.1392524242401123,
0.449715256690979,
0.006619303487241268,
0.3133510947227478,
-0.6886376738548279,
-0.36272990703582764,
-0.14742836356163025,
-0.2779650092124939,
-0.9095704555511475,
0.18829211592674255,
-0.09790290147066116,
0.956680417060852,
0.2781006097793579,
-0.07116226106882095,
0.6499857306480408,
-0.6314581632614136,
0.6919735670089722,
-0.05587821826338768,
-0.8321319222450256,
0.5656797289848328,
-0.1667463332414627,
0.8149293065071106,
0.4941427409648895,
0.4164237678050995,
-0.6578576564788818,
-0.4159165918827057,
-0.4184549152851105,
-0.654320478439331,
1.173592209815979,
-0.32528528571128845,
0.29200658202171326,
-0.07201135903596878,
0.5882036089897156,
-0.15747107565402985,
0.05467848852276802,
-0.5197098851203918,
-0.07104689627885818,
0.306262731552124,
-0.43494123220443726,
0.12198814749717712,
-0.584255039691925,
-0.35166826844215393,
-0.014811327680945396,
0.6213622093200684,
-0.1275085210800171,
0.3529919683933258,
0.3241460919380188,
-0.12754610180854797,
-0.06300470978021622,
0.3765321373939514,
0.9393270015716553,
0.7023029923439026,
0.03387708589434624,
0.25744426250457764,
0.2535032033920288,
-0.5005695819854736,
0.19821928441524506,
-0.03642139956355095,
-0.400669127702713,
-0.12582147121429443,
0.15863832831382751,
0.8412591218948364,
0.484679639339447,
-0.3424510359764099,
0.48399338126182556,
-0.03379690274596214,
0.19350384175777435,
0.06967242807149887,
0.12958019971847534,
0.4008672833442688,
0.32270073890686035,
0.410569429397583,
-0.4725895822048187,
0.06389697641134262,
-0.37235027551651,
0.04738111421465874,
0.5660892128944397,
-0.5300345420837402,
0.009473892860114574,
0.6107847094535828,
0.20885083079338074,
-0.20841673016548157,
0.338697612285614,
0.23452633619308472,
-0.5392081141471863,
0.7301855683326721,
0.6163387298583984,
0.7092796564102173,
-0.44337254762649536,
0.0292032640427351,
0.18766970932483673,
0.2823091745376587,
-0.03937471657991409,
0.28675028681755066,
-0.17429038882255554,
-0.6195961833000183,
-0.41362133622169495,
-0.340972363948822,
-0.5574489831924438,
-0.14227303862571716,
-0.4304923713207245,
0.09480596333742142,
-0.34592995047569275,
-0.0807485580444336,
0.08183789998292923,
-0.12998320162296295,
-0.38254690170288086,
0.04416463524103165,
0.10371821373701096,
0.7464456558227539,
-0.4821407198905945,
0.8653453588485718,
0.8510144352912903,
-0.07191887497901917,
-0.6510612368583679,
0.17746570706367493,
0.20707185566425323,
-0.9901494383811951,
0.38461288809776306,
0.38958340883255005,
-0.22652539610862732,
0.09957926720380783,
-0.6516867280006409,
-0.840327799320221,
1.038003921508789,
0.2555078864097595,
-0.6386660933494568,
-0.19824367761611938,
-0.06612630933523178,
0.3078766465187073,
-0.29939940571784973,
0.20428985357284546,
0.3492421805858612,
0.4829801321029663,
0.10573042929172516,
-0.4954797327518463,
0.09725814312696457,
0.056512076407670975,
0.05591397359967232,
0.137063667178154,
-0.8091211915016174,
0.6509247422218323,
-0.3088013231754303,
-0.26291024684906006,
-0.361734002828598,
0.29892829060554504,
0.41316860914230347,
0.42809027433395386,
0.5215046405792236,
0.27770376205444336,
0.839698314666748,
0.011833557859063148,
1.3110672235488892,
-0.3307040333747864,
-0.1051817387342453,
1.2238168716430664,
-0.4394964277744293,
0.6343216300010681,
0.8813955187797546,
-0.1250017136335373,
0.3197520077228546,
0.6082879304885864,
0.34243905544281006,
0.586618185043335,
0.06087835133075714,
-0.29904159903526306,
0.09949988126754761,
-0.2711977958679199,
-0.14741301536560059,
0.17097468674182892,
0.6225992441177368,
-0.36000192165374756,
-0.18781864643096924,
0.04684479534626007,
-0.08075587451457977,
0.1504410356283188,
-0.40626218914985657,
0.8135949373245239,
0.2076662927865982,
-0.9422027468681335,
0.5180141925811768,
0.03721600025892258,
0.4337099492549896,
-0.5884557366371155,
-0.03304588049650192,
-0.324677050113678,
0.13105882704257965,
0.046932365745306015,
-0.7277190685272217,
0.30199021100997925,
-0.05889697000384331,
-0.7382856011390686,
-0.40679338574409485,
0.8899943828582764,
-0.5085930824279785,
-0.2216089963912964,
0.08579409867525101,
0.45851629972457886,
0.1563117951154709,
0.0024484111927449703,
-0.7874027490615845,
0.03864521533250809,
0.12422613054513931,
-0.3522821068763733,
0.4961622357368469,
0.6286007165908813,
-0.34391114115715027,
0.6091024875640869,
0.6394690275192261,
-0.32807010412216187,
0.1993219405412674,
0.28396105766296387,
0.6587044596672058,
-0.5365473628044128,
-0.5491718649864197,
-0.8337606191635132,
0.4202515184879303,
-0.19021843373775482,
0.07351882755756378,
0.9123408794403076,
0.14337319135665894,
0.6690788865089417,
-0.19768863916397095,
0.684319794178009,
0.2310495525598526,
0.7170221209526062,
-0.6173758506774902,
0.41839954257011414,
-0.4703303873538971,
0.37648555636405945,
-0.09719844907522202,
-0.9560062885284424,
-0.17374958097934723,
0.4644853472709656,
-0.6868133544921875,
0.03659162297844887,
0.7703891396522522,
0.9108693599700928,
0.05109257251024246,
-0.2948985695838928,
0.3584846258163452,
0.11125806719064713,
-0.0616169273853302,
0.6854314208030701,
0.8704043030738831,
0.007008069194853306,
0.4511200487613678,
-0.07541526854038239,
-0.31410524249076843,
-0.5093533396720886,
-0.728686511516571,
-0.7910817265510559,
-0.34466853737831116,
-0.036886345595121384,
-0.045058876276016235,
0.14629079401493073,
0.6272420287132263,
0.6591342091560364,
-0.5569851994514465,
-0.07512828707695007,
0.09748254716396332,
0.6167839169502258,
-0.15225206315517426,
-0.2001306563615799,
0.540002167224884,
-0.43978235125541687,
-1.1316730976104736,
0.6111831665039062,
0.6047844290733337,
0.24519845843315125,
-0.3579508066177368,
0.05812979117035866,
-0.6753899455070496,
0.18540549278259277,
0.5767341256141663,
0.24832597374916077,
-0.6370505094528198,
-0.20452068746089935,
0.40946608781814575,
-0.5352966785430908,
0.12402725964784622,
0.788928747177124,
-0.21264897286891937,
0.40100160241127014,
0.6387945413589478,
0.7048735618591309,
0.32505178451538086,
0.37862375378608704,
0.6076636910438538,
-1.2338532209396362,
0.4647815227508545,
0.016777582466602325,
0.2393583506345749,
0.481638103723526,
-0.7039785385131836,
0.43247729539871216,
-0.05440674349665642,
-0.6025978922843933,
-0.6068967580795288,
0.0056306952610611916,
-0.8373473286628723,
-0.424405038356781,
1.1492112874984741,
-0.018479926511645317,
-0.7118375897407532,
-0.2688427269458771,
-0.625761866569519,
0.2545681297779083,
-0.30130326747894287,
0.8875596523284912,
1.0389978885650635,
-0.14691497385501862,
-0.4881843626499176,
-0.8206624388694763,
0.3073095977306366,
0.8504783511161804,
-0.733435332775116,
0.15006548166275024,
0.49754324555397034,
0.09516534209251404,
0.07060215622186661,
0.8125023245811462,
-0.16411401331424713,
0.21313872933387756,
-0.28614363074302673,
-0.016712460666894913,
0.14270459115505219,
-0.39399489760398865,
-0.45735305547714233,
0.20618057250976562,
0.12406465411186218,
-0.3508589565753937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17055v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17055v2 | Large Language Models Assume People are More Rational than We Really are | 2024-06-24T18:15:27 | 2024-07-01T17:29:54 | Ryan Liu, Jiayi Geng, Joshua C. Peterson, Ilia Sucholutsky, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | In order for AI systems to communicate effectively with people, they must
understand how we make decisions. However, people's decisions are not always
rational, so the implicit internal models of human decision-making in Large
Language Models (LLMs) must account for this. Previous empirical evidence seems
to suggest that these implicit models are accurate -- LLMs offer believable
proxies of human behavior, acting how we expect humans would in everyday
interactions. However, by comparing LLM behavior and predictions to a large
dataset of human decisions, we find that this is actually not the case: when
both simulating and predicting people's choices, a suite of cutting-edge LLMs
(GPT-4o & 4-Turbo, Llama-3-8B & 70B, Claude 3 Opus) assume that people are more
rational than we really are. Specifically, these models deviate from human
behavior and align more closely with a classic model of rational choice --
expected value theory. Interestingly, people also tend to assume that other
people are rational when interpreting their behavior. As a consequence, when we
compare the inferences that LLMs and people draw from the decisions of others
using another psychological dataset, we find that these inferences are highly
correlated. Thus, the implicit decision-making models of LLMs appear to be
aligned with the human expectation that other people will act rationally,
rather than with how people actually act. | [
-0.35009291768074036,
-0.7134811878204346,
1.100925087928772,
0.27993887662887573,
0.13620132207870483,
0.01747060939669609,
-0.3610477149486542,
-0.7395752668380737,
-0.030282415449619293,
0.15517649054527283,
-0.46569302678108215,
-0.1380714476108551,
-0.4899776875972748,
-0.022842640057206154,
-0.18395255506038666,
0.6692602634429932,
0.11117800325155258,
0.3407619893550873,
-0.3282110393047333,
-0.09634904563426971,
-0.2587253451347351,
-0.7422493100166321,
-0.8964012265205383,
-0.7422567009925842,
0.48927587270736694,
-0.0011475656647235155,
1.079802393913269,
0.4406030476093292,
0.14107361435890198,
0.25730395317077637,
-0.0011226466158404946,
-0.11324167996644974,
-0.5942255258560181,
-0.06938645988702774,
-0.29262134432792664,
-0.6786914467811584,
-0.33329150080680847,
0.36228591203689575,
0.5160453915596008,
0.6500590443611145,
0.00045798099017702043,
-0.03827337175607681,
-0.15750965476036072,
0.6815879940986633,
-0.4296528697013855,
0.23755688965320587,
-0.4932160973548889,
-0.10834329575300217,
0.13624125719070435,
0.017588749527931213,
-0.5673197507858276,
-0.2719458341598511,
0.34494027495384216,
-0.5187192559242249,
-0.07613445073366165,
0.3909446895122528,
0.7021498680114746,
0.38804298639297485,
-0.6337419748306274,
-0.216070756316185,
-0.9801206588745117,
0.848680317401886,
-0.6616209149360657,
0.3018712103366852,
0.6290143132209778,
0.1698448210954666,
-0.5155190825462341,
-0.3981586694717407,
-0.7610371708869934,
-0.5505415797233582,
-0.16347026824951172,
0.026230202987790108,
-0.0174495130777359,
0.308867871761322,
0.612064778804779,
-0.10594993829727173,
-0.30181869864463806,
0.2323688417673111,
-0.2907419502735138,
0.10782159119844437,
0.7816397547721863,
0.25073766708374023,
0.21353207528591156,
0.06237420812249184,
-0.4017363488674164,
-0.03618739917874336,
-0.8016507029533386,
0.1470651924610138,
0.2551717758178711,
0.04199523106217384,
-0.03624430671334267,
0.626264214515686,
-0.009942526929080486,
0.4869939684867859,
0.17876924574375153,
-0.19446460902690887,
0.08314516395330429,
0.02399790659546852,
-0.3458611071109772,
0.32365965843200684,
0.7433688044548035,
0.5759963989257812,
1.0214229822158813,
0.03766715154051781,
-0.16799983382225037,
0.3288081884384155,
0.1611998975276947,
-0.5473875999450684,
0.0035838314797729254,
0.44763582944869995,
-0.3722318410873413,
-0.025353077799081802,
0.010476144962012768,
-0.5742871165275574,
-0.5155366659164429,
-0.6787554621696472,
0.37819886207580566,
-0.15427862107753754,
-0.23499710857868195,
0.11232168227434158,
0.09063879400491714,
0.2909165322780609,
0.6196277737617493,
-0.867117166519165,
0.4336947202682495,
1.0334144830703735,
0.6243225336074829,
-0.2793934643268585,
-0.7201296091079712,
-0.30194342136383057,
0.32296091318130493,
-0.7164047360420227,
0.8397716283798218,
-0.7216737270355225,
-0.3665243983268738,
-0.13000726699829102,
-0.2244519144296646,
-0.09004040062427521,
-0.3558761477470398,
0.4942982792854309,
-0.4736478328704834,
0.07702124863862991,
-0.6377881169319153,
-0.6336520910263062,
-0.28205594420433044,
0.1619826853275299,
-0.5325649380683899,
0.6995028853416443,
-0.0069026281125843525,
-0.4899800419807434,
0.689802885055542,
-0.497134804725647,
-0.23670414090156555,
-0.0839286595582962,
-0.47440680861473083,
-0.09304071217775345,
0.2945125699043274,
-0.04615577310323715,
0.3936064541339874,
-0.651755690574646,
0.515783965587616,
-0.6943831443786621,
-0.4586637020111084,
0.7786580920219421,
-0.5414548516273499,
0.7539321184158325,
0.16588681936264038,
-0.35595905780792236,
0.2392185628414154,
-0.22232556343078613,
-0.021569229662418365,
0.04332314059138298,
-0.3062107264995575,
-0.5314953923225403,
0.39934271574020386,
-0.2180458903312683,
0.5108853578567505,
0.10750839859247208,
-0.33886539936065674,
0.40185976028442383,
-0.16458185017108917,
0.5319716334342957,
1.1642630100250244,
-0.4177420437335968,
0.6894819736480713,
-0.6130260825157166,
0.2630043029785156,
-0.23958683013916016,
0.19176645576953888,
0.267608106136322,
-0.5302118062973022,
-0.7424196004867554,
-0.4197908639907837,
0.07210370153188705,
0.4421381652355194,
0.021810127422213554,
0.08023322373628616,
-0.4440089464187622,
-0.23290392756462097,
-0.37505364418029785,
-0.14368219673633575,
0.17198792099952698,
0.2621896266937256,
0.08460278064012527,
0.1903737485408783,
-0.5003800988197327,
-0.9419017434120178,
-0.4263589680194855,
-0.5586870908737183,
0.03689766675233841,
0.35063570737838745,
0.4894154965877533,
-0.28519830107688904,
1.0991078615188599,
-0.2475845068693161,
0.060797467827796936,
-0.215862438082695,
0.2523319125175476,
0.14909407496452332,
0.4708719849586487,
0.3807823061943054,
-0.7675489187240601,
-0.3263342082500458,
-0.04411449655890465,
-0.7063328623771667,
0.025443051010370255,
-0.27298256754875183,
-0.21471305191516876,
0.43830570578575134,
0.3547387719154358,
-0.8533705472946167,
0.25246602296829224,
0.4186599850654602,
-0.48488304018974304,
0.387437641620636,
-0.34266623854637146,
0.09380730986595154,
-0.7616558074951172,
-0.23816128075122833,
0.17363731563091278,
-0.1539027988910675,
-0.4488072991371155,
-0.30758944153785706,
-0.025002261623740196,
0.4915717542171478,
-0.3166531026363373,
0.7655104398727417,
-0.39896634221076965,
-0.5503916144371033,
-0.0851505845785141,
-0.14560021460056305,
-0.1952190399169922,
0.452532559633255,
0.09994928538799286,
0.8827082514762878,
0.4082699716091156,
-0.540727436542511,
0.15299296379089355,
-0.07767760753631592,
-0.48982399702072144,
0.6723220348358154,
-0.6714198589324951,
-0.010611085221171379,
-0.38485899567604065,
0.5121697187423706,
-0.839652419090271,
-0.5314136743545532,
-0.008590130135416985,
-0.349857360124588,
0.1869141310453415,
-0.1323670595884323,
-0.5530677437782288,
-0.21542853116989136,
-0.13733644783496857,
0.3443993926048279,
0.8216878175735474,
-0.5734018087387085,
0.9642783999443054,
0.5214400887489319,
-0.22620724141597748,
-0.49892348051071167,
-0.7786374688148499,
0.0485224686563015,
-0.29967552423477173,
-0.6644174456596375,
0.018000919371843338,
-0.21856987476348877,
-0.950665295124054,
-0.1071760430932045,
0.09159454703330994,
-0.1982264220714569,
0.010439980775117874,
0.3480997681617737,
0.6531352400779724,
-0.1632697433233261,
0.08670896291732788,
-0.27054306864738464,
-0.06779032200574875,
0.3452811539173126,
-0.21056292951107025,
0.44642144441604614,
-0.2372405230998993,
-0.5904825329780579,
-0.3730188012123108,
0.15461745858192444,
0.8774895071983337,
0.14376035332679749,
0.7984763979911804,
0.19556330144405365,
-0.4087461531162262,
-0.015232505276799202,
-0.8060532808303833,
-0.15175755321979523,
-0.4097186326980591,
0.23383396863937378,
-0.3462112545967102,
-0.8614652156829834,
0.4941122233867645,
-0.013461558148264885,
0.016401948407292366,
0.4099406599998474,
0.5716313123703003,
-0.3244507908821106,
1.6528712511062622,
0.36713293194770813,
0.013067895546555519,
0.21805934607982635,
0.1195753663778305,
0.09115162491798401,
-0.8395225405693054,
-0.22323305904865265,
-0.4723966419696808,
-0.3643568158149719,
-0.792239248752594,
-0.2589307725429535,
0.11311360448598862,
0.01092562172561884,
-0.7077139616012573,
-0.17054203152656555,
-0.13168492913246155,
0.6989542841911316,
0.44448792934417725,
-0.25485920906066895,
0.24971453845500946,
0.02330896258354187,
0.04307670146226883,
-0.10543055087327957,
-0.5829973816871643,
-0.7519630193710327,
0.9708859324455261,
0.3893999457359314,
1.0180991888046265,
0.16326919198036194,
0.20777492225170135,
0.24016784131526947,
0.7764813303947449,
-0.8493552207946777,
0.450450599193573,
0.1464194804430008,
-0.6963713765144348,
-0.2660091519355774,
-0.4970964193344116,
-0.9153691530227661,
0.40205979347229004,
-0.30924615263938904,
-0.8917620778083801,
0.24161241948604584,
0.11192819476127625,
-0.3940334618091583,
0.1526065319776535,
-0.8918919563293457,
0.5370643734931946,
-0.508131742477417,
-0.4815400540828705,
-0.36466699838638306,
-0.4680297374725342,
0.6272336840629578,
-0.16338185966014862,
0.3376118838787079,
-0.4235457181930542,
-0.17252418398857117,
0.5743221044540405,
-0.18264608085155487,
0.866080641746521,
0.033196598291397095,
-0.10251723974943161,
0.20479993522167206,
0.20668873190879822,
0.738489031791687,
0.045364368706941605,
-0.32358497381210327,
0.30185097455978394,
-0.05882348120212555,
-0.38726794719696045,
-0.5973193049430847,
0.8292471766471863,
-1.0729963779449463,
-0.7619696259498596,
-0.7025964856147766,
-0.5162675976753235,
-0.15223060548305511,
-0.06200515106320381,
0.12733013927936554,
0.3290591239929199,
-0.2960457503795624,
-0.08671152591705322,
0.5323726534843445,
-0.07417487353086472,
0.17763490974903107,
0.5104656219482422,
-0.32748278975486755,
-0.24384716153144836,
0.6501103639602661,
0.22992540895938873,
0.3933665156364441,
0.2270149290561676,
0.30235812067985535,
-0.47345325350761414,
-0.318802148103714,
-0.14302928745746613,
0.4818877577781677,
-0.7478030323982239,
0.36120349168777466,
-0.6039782166481018,
0.14784890413284302,
-0.31065231561660767,
-0.38211455941200256,
-0.22867824137210846,
-0.15513058006763458,
-0.11989939957857132,
-0.24982231855392456,
0.2582748830318451,
1.1674124002456665,
-0.026060855016112328,
0.07393153756856918,
-0.6050074100494385,
0.07077717781066895,
0.5713760852813721,
0.21129457652568817,
0.1547183245420456,
-0.3845418095588684,
0.09776151180267334,
0.24366049468517303,
0.14075030386447906,
-0.5640677213668823,
0.38249796628952026,
-0.13417202234268188,
0.8186793327331543,
0.32045069336891174,
0.014057834632694721,
0.7205823659896851,
-0.4661209285259247,
0.6978151202201843,
-0.01801452599465847,
-0.8311815857887268,
-0.011951436288654804,
-0.39154142141342163,
0.01710221916437149,
0.41595712304115295,
0.43213149905204773,
-0.5935792922973633,
-0.05072682350873947,
-0.6105383038520813,
-0.5641462206840515,
0.9124110341072083,
0.02997545339167118,
0.10914956778287888,
-0.14504262804985046,
0.2326352745294571,
0.011682383716106415,
0.1612696796655655,
-0.8450254201889038,
-0.2100508213043213,
0.05483910068869591,
-0.25438228249549866,
-0.24919596314430237,
-0.32304999232292175,
-0.04031962901353836,
-0.1852763593196869,
0.4765697419643402,
-0.0778074562549591,
0.40583786368370056,
0.1448807567358017,
0.07034942507743835,
-0.4555300772190094,
0.24876566231250763,
0.8672836422920227,
0.876916229724884,
-0.26125603914260864,
0.1860148012638092,
0.3213317394256592,
-0.12815816700458527,
0.25612667202949524,
-0.18354077637195587,
0.016719549894332886,
-0.4895128607749939,
0.33827289938926697,
0.8534384965896606,
0.21186816692352295,
-0.9468567967414856,
0.5240843892097473,
-0.27266648411750793,
-0.1166340783238411,
-0.7984606027603149,
0.17970256507396698,
0.21933968365192413,
0.41680169105529785,
0.41897112131118774,
0.30002400279045105,
-0.12756389379501343,
-0.6998001337051392,
-0.14992934465408325,
0.6090187430381775,
-0.3153384327888489,
-0.39212939143180847,
0.5356854796409607,
0.2242671251296997,
-0.5553215742111206,
0.7211161851882935,
-0.1540111005306244,
-0.5721636414527893,
0.7168456315994263,
0.4052199125289917,
1.0002421140670776,
-0.019507508724927902,
0.036513183265924454,
0.3592804968357086,
0.42229920625686646,
-0.6013335585594177,
0.030497213825583458,
0.1515807956457138,
-0.9155967831611633,
-0.8304662704467773,
-0.3832928240299225,
-0.3745066523551941,
0.3153906762599945,
-0.41014665365219116,
0.1670285165309906,
-0.4014471173286438,
-0.09141309559345245,
-0.26618701219558716,
-0.15695412456989288,
-0.557878315448761,
0.07798445969820023,
0.2731197774410248,
0.8637105226516724,
-0.7163093090057373,
0.8462188243865967,
0.5053191781044006,
-0.28092244267463684,
-0.82601398229599,
0.2456798106431961,
-0.07952898740768433,
-0.8671174645423889,
1.069960355758667,
0.26666978001594543,
-0.0591256320476532,
-0.10008108615875244,
-0.7058500647544861,
-1.1007171869277954,
0.8993268013000488,
0.5865472555160522,
-0.49644705653190613,
-0.1618701070547104,
0.07123807817697525,
0.5292331576347351,
-0.595323920249939,
0.48552101850509644,
0.5890037417411804,
0.756749153137207,
0.2033957988023758,
-0.8914933204650879,
-0.04538523405790329,
0.039957135915756226,
-0.02543395385146141,
0.24716027081012726,
-0.7388026714324951,
1.168352723121643,
-0.4974275827407837,
-0.2295851707458496,
-0.11257611960172653,
0.44758671522140503,
0.3561265766620636,
0.17828217148780823,
0.5929940938949585,
0.3739713728427887,
0.7635154128074646,
-0.10399371385574341,
1.4662518501281738,
-0.09668384492397308,
0.17982454597949982,
1.206526756286621,
-0.6770224571228027,
0.8504283428192139,
0.3641373813152313,
-0.318850040435791,
0.33512797951698303,
0.7830767035484314,
0.21810533106327057,
0.2528035640716553,
-0.054955191910266876,
-0.20612254738807678,
-0.7044582962989807,
0.04885777831077576,
-0.07531992346048355,
0.4068354368209839,
0.7227781414985657,
-0.3493865430355072,
0.12865440547466278,
-0.5498848557472229,
0.023885859176516533,
-0.15276247262954712,
-0.2787909507751465,
0.8833037614822388,
0.015854623168706894,
-1.1187739372253418,
0.5216141939163208,
-0.16098016500473022,
0.5983246564865112,
-0.44834068417549133,
-0.0021647245157510042,
0.07375545799732208,
0.037459950894117355,
-0.17301063239574432,
-0.9593203663825989,
-0.005630443338304758,
-0.0388176292181015,
-0.25500816106796265,
-0.12083223462104797,
0.5142672061920166,
-0.22787147760391235,
-0.3166431486606598,
0.46443527936935425,
0.5586748123168945,
0.21055665612220764,
0.013396929018199444,
-0.8163531422615051,
0.038522183895111084,
0.056317877024412155,
-0.5012383460998535,
0.46906813979148865,
0.24181868135929108,
-0.31143420934677124,
0.8301538825035095,
0.9298382997512817,
0.16229714453220367,
0.036937110126018524,
-0.003771525574848056,
0.45332595705986023,
-0.6264263391494751,
-0.34863972663879395,
-1.1475417613983154,
0.26281067728996277,
-0.14186879992485046,
-0.17187075316905975,
0.40536177158355713,
0.25511834025382996,
0.8362053036689758,
0.19947251677513123,
1.0561190843582153,
0.4012558162212372,
0.21316075325012207,
-0.5689195990562439,
0.3381637930870056,
-0.3013993203639984,
0.2913070321083069,
-0.1274605095386505,
-1.0565221309661865,
0.03763363137841225,
0.9250537157058716,
-0.7277061343193054,
0.4179476499557495,
0.6752576231956482,
0.7032923102378845,
0.1634162962436676,
0.14556971192359924,
0.46616771817207336,
0.553796648979187,
0.2848193049430847,
0.5222496390342712,
1.2192796468734741,
0.16615882515907288,
0.21793930232524872,
0.09912332892417908,
-0.29242071509361267,
-0.3798908591270447,
-0.9710078835487366,
-0.8903910517692566,
-0.4246640205383301,
0.02629324235022068,
-0.1545208990573883,
-0.10898607969284058,
1.526132583618164,
0.7024136185646057,
-0.6159392595291138,
-0.4009692072868347,
-0.25470706820487976,
0.15701796114444733,
-0.03473634272813797,
-0.21512146294116974,
0.0403745211660862,
-0.15633100271224976,
-0.9591237306594849,
0.17625728249549866,
0.3227215111255646,
0.36322927474975586,
-0.4409346878528595,
-0.4101298451423645,
-0.13991418480873108,
0.4792557656764984,
0.6105267405509949,
0.22639523446559906,
-0.9814969301223755,
-0.32673314213752747,
-0.15556766092777252,
-0.513837456703186,
0.13524408638477325,
0.6251177787780762,
-0.8093211054801941,
0.08734506368637085,
0.4821392595767975,
0.4531107544898987,
0.1898234635591507,
-0.07176079601049423,
0.801903486251831,
-0.04913675785064697,
-0.03825097158551216,
0.08946150541305542,
0.552972137928009,
0.34180161356925964,
-0.42276015877723694,
0.47636738419532776,
0.041054967790842056,
-0.7957002520561218,
-0.6330434083938599,
0.3567262291908264,
-0.7921423316001892,
-0.4559696316719055,
1.373898983001709,
0.0480520986020565,
-0.48451682925224304,
-0.17662666738033295,
-0.35189104080200195,
-0.0021700155921280384,
-0.7926092147827148,
0.8381343483924866,
0.8183592557907104,
-0.27158787846565247,
0.14987757802009583,
-0.7697529792785645,
0.5513709187507629,
0.36526811122894287,
-0.7810252904891968,
0.291232705116272,
0.7025853395462036,
0.14193779230117798,
0.09150880575180054,
0.6300328373908997,
0.31514397263526917,
0.2106277197599411,
-0.21157482266426086,
-0.19649507105350494,
0.16742980480194092,
-0.02136966958642006,
-0.2364867925643921,
-0.04109279811382294,
0.38473498821258545,
0.39771658182144165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17038v1 | modeLing: A Novel Dataset for Testing Linguistic Reasoning in Language Models | 2024-06-24T18:00:59 | 2024-06-24T18:00:59 | Nathan A. Chi, Teodor Malchev, Riley Kong, Ryan A. Chi, Lucas Huang, Ethan A. Chi, R. Thomas McCoy, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce modeLing, a novel benchmark of Linguistics Olympiad-style
puzzles which tests few-shot reasoning in AI systems. Solving these puzzles
necessitates inferring aspects of a language's grammatical structure from a
small number of examples. Such puzzles provide a natural testbed for language
models, as they require compositional generalization and few-shot inductive
reasoning. Consisting solely of new puzzles written specifically for this work,
modeLing has no risk of appearing in the training data of existing AI systems:
this ameliorates the risk of data leakage, a potential confounder for many
prior evaluations of reasoning. Evaluating several large open source language
models and GPT on our benchmark, we observe non-negligible accuracy,
demonstrating few-shot emergent reasoning ability which cannot merely be
attributed to shallow memorization. However, imperfect model performance
suggests that modeLing can be used to measure further progress in linguistic
reasoning. | [
-0.06556471437215805,
-1.136789321899414,
0.6885881423950195,
-0.003741301828995347,
-0.039225589483976364,
-0.21038618683815002,
-0.1454172283411026,
-0.20634722709655762,
-0.41968390345573425,
0.35409489274024963,
-0.5960211157798767,
-0.43764451146125793,
-0.40692636370658875,
0.03981240466237068,
-0.6224343776702881,
0.6802482604980469,
0.06492675840854645,
0.029787516221404076,
-0.6263081431388855,
0.08749665319919586,
-0.43201735615730286,
-0.330865740776062,
-0.5363907814025879,
-0.6036767959594727,
0.22461414337158203,
0.3374394178390503,
0.779782772064209,
0.7371784448623657,
0.45523717999458313,
0.22693371772766113,
-0.04580633342266083,
-0.15504655241966248,
-0.30408257246017456,
0.06716796010732651,
-0.22261136770248413,
-0.9316529035568237,
-0.14813978970050812,
0.20863527059555054,
0.6337952017784119,
0.8939249515533447,
-0.09786827117204666,
0.20633454620838165,
-0.34441033005714417,
0.44081732630729675,
-0.45983120799064636,
0.36842042207717896,
-0.8963689804077148,
-0.030382080003619194,
-0.4190026819705963,
0.30697622895240784,
-0.5106061100959778,
-0.26879557967185974,
-0.019861768931150436,
-0.505826473236084,
0.2126474231481552,
0.08511289209127426,
0.8285159468650818,
0.38257119059562683,
-0.28717631101608276,
-0.08800243586301804,
-0.6862258315086365,
0.5715212225914001,
-0.957568347454071,
0.23056310415267944,
0.47341880202293396,
0.7216890454292297,
-0.153766930103302,
-0.561270534992218,
-0.6608904600143433,
-0.6766636371612549,
-0.013723915442824364,
-0.051560454070568085,
-0.1155642420053482,
-0.18715885281562805,
0.4560787081718445,
0.24974535405635834,
-0.9009361267089844,
0.02737140655517578,
-0.23309409618377686,
0.150778129696846,
0.7688378095626831,
0.34471437335014343,
0.4542856514453888,
-0.008504576981067657,
0.023146485909819603,
-0.003731355769559741,
-0.9746025204658508,
-0.09442923218011856,
0.540830135345459,
0.47401872277259827,
-0.10195599496364594,
0.8576974868774414,
-0.30126383900642395,
0.8012120723724365,
-0.3432958722114563,
0.2492399662733078,
0.09104674309492111,
-0.2661047577857971,
-0.22866828739643097,
-0.31725218892097473,
0.7209683656692505,
-0.11940175294876099,
0.4152953624725342,
-0.18659737706184387,
-0.24235162138938904,
0.38799798488616943,
-0.024989033117890358,
-0.449174702167511,
-0.7039401531219482,
-0.06996922194957733,
-0.30633115768432617,
-0.2871474325656891,
-0.12872245907783508,
-0.5815471410751343,
-0.2287885695695877,
-0.20308062434196472,
0.39909690618515015,
-0.5559945106506348,
-0.4061172604560852,
0.14330774545669556,
-0.1147138848900795,
0.07942686229944229,
0.14074967801570892,
-0.8838142156600952,
0.41066429018974304,
1.0779205560684204,
0.6564208269119263,
-0.11804883927106857,
-0.45555222034454346,
-0.22745220363140106,
-0.3300936222076416,
-0.6073883771896362,
0.9325990676879883,
-0.7834320664405823,
-0.1967429220676422,
-0.09986124187707901,
-0.267964631319046,
-0.1883368045091629,
-0.6472405195236206,
0.4449790418148041,
-0.31327566504478455,
0.11652347445487976,
0.01855640858411789,
-0.9809232950210571,
-0.04941499978303909,
0.4325218200683594,
-0.637319028377533,
1.1279219388961792,
0.10106765478849411,
-0.3929537236690521,
0.21053701639175415,
-0.7430930733680725,
-0.21320419013500214,
0.20677395164966583,
-0.37794408202171326,
-0.4146967828273773,
0.2964746057987213,
0.004578621592372656,
0.043156567960977554,
-0.41646623611450195,
0.29879024624824524,
-0.5451324582099915,
-0.36972013115882874,
0.2989861071109772,
-0.3023459315299988,
0.9004643559455872,
0.10489978641271591,
-0.2279413938522339,
-0.25315430760383606,
-0.8297111392021179,
0.2846449315547943,
0.35436469316482544,
-0.1332777738571167,
-0.21745210886001587,
0.14819654822349548,
-0.1375715583562851,
0.24363790452480316,
0.035128600895404816,
-0.4688401222229004,
0.5143916606903076,
-0.5655619502067566,
0.3150394558906555,
0.5181730389595032,
-0.18869613111019135,
0.37869104743003845,
-0.5468087196350098,
0.5911609530448914,
-0.05840998515486717,
-0.0016282136784866452,
-0.3185902535915375,
-0.8848931789398193,
-0.8316280841827393,
-0.13428081572055817,
0.4696104824542999,
0.5787358283996582,
-0.500018835067749,
0.06124553456902504,
-0.19580663740634918,
-0.6476781368255615,
-0.49798059463500977,
-0.013911775313317776,
0.365263432264328,
0.35907718539237976,
0.08337559551000595,
0.08072245121002197,
-0.38993334770202637,
-1.0257974863052368,
-0.6374639868736267,
-0.39846596121788025,
-0.05535483360290527,
0.2859863042831421,
0.9333717226982117,
0.05322927609086037,
1.028077244758606,
-0.31254294514656067,
0.10707738995552063,
-0.2985413074493408,
0.5815033316612244,
0.34648823738098145,
0.5409588813781738,
0.5162540078163147,
-0.538457989692688,
-0.34495803713798523,
-0.08697717636823654,
-0.8190528750419617,
-0.22254349291324615,
0.046777546405792236,
0.052054356783628464,
-0.02565338835120201,
0.4173353910446167,
-0.769808292388916,
0.47702115774154663,
0.30400875210762024,
-0.33710771799087524,
0.7710868716239929,
0.022898389026522636,
-0.09647805988788605,
-0.546838104724884,
0.1264125108718872,
-0.24448929727077484,
-0.04160010442137718,
-0.5594335198402405,
0.38026946783065796,
-0.015494713559746742,
-0.2580641806125641,
-0.47381141781806946,
0.754925549030304,
-0.37152931094169617,
-0.0647551640868187,
-0.26597243547439575,
-0.09601258486509323,
-0.14700092375278473,
0.22775842249393463,
0.012481454759836197,
0.5967469811439514,
0.6528282165527344,
-0.4351139962673187,
0.424432635307312,
0.10756823420524597,
-0.6538757085800171,
0.4689599573612213,
-0.7600152492523193,
0.45429185032844543,
-0.21961255371570587,
-0.2504429221153259,
-0.729911744594574,
-0.27416756749153137,
-0.1096067726612091,
-0.49539875984191895,
0.049635790288448334,
-0.4516182243824005,
-0.6650848388671875,
-0.3506154716014862,
0.19812986254692078,
0.40571141242980957,
0.5337041020393372,
-0.2933695912361145,
0.41682595014572144,
0.1395331770181656,
-0.18758663535118103,
-0.1669641137123108,
-0.7887188792228699,
-0.07090073823928833,
-0.11967949569225311,
-0.733447790145874,
0.008611226454377174,
-0.22481675446033478,
-0.5662290453910828,
0.252729594707489,
0.11423097550868988,
-0.38264092803001404,
0.43583446741104126,
0.08868707716464996,
0.25716733932495117,
-0.6616278290748596,
0.3069629371166229,
-0.21466098725795746,
-0.022106420248746872,
0.16719841957092285,
-0.1980944573879242,
0.3358284533023834,
-0.2989470660686493,
-0.6167435050010681,
-0.27877315878868103,
0.5038962960243225,
0.2991756200790405,
-0.27040743827819824,
0.5574817061424255,
0.06663087010383606,
-0.7261125445365906,
-0.531237781047821,
-0.4114784896373749,
-0.2552906572818756,
-0.36392611265182495,
0.42917633056640625,
-0.673315703868866,
-0.6492605805397034,
0.5116563439369202,
0.004974117502570152,
-0.10300794988870621,
0.43561822175979614,
0.5902557373046875,
0.01872692070901394,
1.1648508310317993,
0.512789249420166,
-0.06171530485153198,
0.1638336032629013,
-0.19592788815498352,
0.24010039865970612,
-0.3403569459915161,
-0.05593663454055786,
-0.7941426038742065,
-0.21206486225128174,
-0.3271259665489197,
-0.3387068510055542,
0.11448147147893906,
0.15822981297969818,
-0.41894060373306274,
0.2785436809062958,
-0.15659216046333313,
0.9671284556388855,
0.6937966346740723,
-0.2518438994884491,
0.46063053607940674,
-0.43198785185813904,
-0.32309240102767944,
-0.09762212634086609,
-0.6518097519874573,
-0.6605051755905151,
1.176674246788025,
0.026816850528120995,
0.9899935126304626,
0.0332917645573616,
0.5426360368728638,
0.04641100764274597,
0.2901707887649536,
-0.6142174601554871,
0.41894394159317017,
-0.048117496073246,
-1.047767162322998,
-0.21946296095848083,
-0.5430711507797241,
-0.7687607407569885,
0.2997913658618927,
-0.21354103088378906,
-0.9309409856796265,
-0.03274581953883171,
0.29771432280540466,
-0.2984529137611389,
0.21433097124099731,
-0.621239185333252,
1.1931676864624023,
-0.24951818585395813,
-0.145331472158432,
0.004957686644047499,
-0.4026995003223419,
0.748333215713501,
0.18989136815071106,
0.1321353167295456,
-0.4663815498352051,
0.2658596336841583,
0.42685815691947937,
-0.3886982798576355,
0.693583071231842,
0.1265527904033661,
0.3242241442203522,
0.2949155569076538,
0.5584277510643005,
0.4911746680736542,
0.06427114456892014,
-0.1969178020954132,
-0.0651010200381279,
0.031856097280979156,
-0.43577006459236145,
-0.8573580980300903,
0.5169398188591003,
-0.5419290065765381,
-0.4876323640346527,
-0.5001461505889893,
-0.7575313448905945,
-0.2675980031490326,
0.18173432350158691,
0.2507242262363434,
0.27368322014808655,
-0.4044232964515686,
0.059262603521347046,
0.5081876516342163,
0.1593564748764038,
0.23540432751178741,
0.5583452582359314,
-0.17533454298973083,
0.02017854154109955,
0.6942048072814941,
-0.08094989508390427,
0.38435038924217224,
0.33295178413391113,
0.3559105694293976,
-0.19901619851589203,
-0.7888361811637878,
-0.3009185194969177,
0.21453510224819183,
-0.7030513882637024,
-0.02705935575067997,
-0.3267081677913666,
-0.2556462585926056,
-0.41959381103515625,
0.2117639034986496,
-0.7112888097763062,
-0.6584912538528442,
-0.028911184519529343,
0.025831418111920357,
0.052907925099134445,
1.004523515701294,
0.05965286120772362,
0.19957423210144043,
-0.4452897310256958,
0.1742488443851471,
0.39469245076179504,
0.27515897154808044,
-0.24568720161914825,
-0.36891207098960876,
-0.10893549770116806,
0.18531395494937897,
-0.23016002774238586,
-0.8441551327705383,
0.31581705808639526,
0.33858954906463623,
0.7335078120231628,
0.2244359403848648,
-0.28794586658477783,
0.4580765664577484,
-0.6837024092674255,
0.8798670768737793,
-0.24547937512397766,
-1.0117661952972412,
0.8027041554450989,
-0.5134979486465454,
0.4246601164340973,
0.5779388546943665,
0.20431996881961823,
-0.5566140413284302,
-0.46277663111686707,
-0.7776788473129272,
-0.29114431142807007,
0.5553465485572815,
0.22443853318691254,
-0.12100563198328018,
-0.10944290459156036,
0.3462458550930023,
0.06630097329616547,
0.18533898890018463,
-0.7078438401222229,
-0.22541503608226776,
-0.028282063081860542,
-0.3213042914867401,
-0.16887420415878296,
-0.09983853995800018,
-0.11117544025182724,
-0.30592259764671326,
0.7338870167732239,
-0.2726770043373108,
0.15691542625427246,
-0.2081756591796875,
-0.3978677988052368,
0.08003894984722137,
0.14267787337303162,
0.6181761622428894,
0.6306394934654236,
-0.010634306818246841,
0.24112993478775024,
-0.14879067242145538,
-0.12177882343530655,
0.17999906837940216,
0.20050634443759918,
-0.4480990171432495,
0.04880690947175026,
0.4987792670726776,
0.6944916844367981,
0.2924826443195343,
-0.6687663793563843,
0.6126512885093689,
0.06868796050548553,
-0.20619522035121918,
-0.17710086703300476,
0.057093266397714615,
0.27692657709121704,
0.2737022042274475,
0.06117207556962967,
0.06940193474292755,
0.1881837099790573,
-0.6992591619491577,
0.2613948881626129,
0.48879268765449524,
-0.14772695302963257,
-0.5303426384925842,
0.8184310793876648,
-0.11593018472194672,
-0.41118323802948,
0.8194148540496826,
-0.4276893436908722,
-0.39388787746429443,
0.7574829459190369,
0.6267864108085632,
0.776192307472229,
-0.18462532758712769,
0.24679389595985413,
0.35661256313323975,
0.5241213440895081,
-0.38308146595954895,
0.284485787153244,
0.17840299010276794,
-0.726141095161438,
-0.281027615070343,
-0.2723064422607422,
-0.41703370213508606,
0.2946151793003082,
-0.35712480545043945,
0.3311551511287689,
-0.2653704285621643,
0.0664442852139473,
0.2270650714635849,
-0.12742070853710175,
-0.6951555609703064,
-0.05536678805947304,
0.3660878837108612,
1.1392914056777954,
-1.1450854539871216,
0.824313223361969,
0.6226682662963867,
-0.5304849743843079,
-0.5118205547332764,
-0.4513668417930603,
0.46554696559906006,
-0.7050766944885254,
0.7469376921653748,
0.046085506677627563,
0.2571268379688263,
-0.220598965883255,
-0.703097403049469,
-0.8966155052185059,
0.718557596206665,
0.716046154499054,
-0.39130252599716187,
-0.15014906227588654,
0.3335433602333069,
0.47506335377693176,
-0.5711554288864136,
0.43321070075035095,
0.8753632307052612,
0.3629639148712158,
-0.0451136976480484,
-0.9384416937828064,
-0.24296359717845917,
-0.6346194744110107,
0.08925668150186539,
0.10096101462841034,
-0.15406621992588043,
1.2975656986236572,
-0.14111173152923584,
-0.2416323721408844,
0.5407865047454834,
0.4822951555252075,
0.3127113878726959,
0.2209910750389099,
0.2734210193157196,
0.9652486443519592,
0.7737559676170349,
-0.38529202342033386,
1.2238303422927856,
0.18270348012447357,
0.4077244997024536,
1.583616018295288,
-0.43148157000541687,
0.8988057374954224,
0.16827985644340515,
-0.2204514741897583,
0.513296902179718,
0.4903237521648407,
-0.04147949069738388,
0.5199129581451416,
0.6307655572891235,
-0.16579584777355194,
-0.5217217803001404,
0.13797150552272797,
-0.3831652104854584,
0.6055046319961548,
0.30211615562438965,
-0.14574746787548065,
-0.47447502613067627,
-0.09009578078985214,
-0.02910965494811535,
0.3547256588935852,
-0.02765454538166523,
0.732053816318512,
0.07506211847066879,
-0.7455608248710632,
0.4733985364437103,
-0.15272614359855652,
0.34028252959251404,
-0.3812499940395355,
-0.1696430891752243,
-0.32102784514427185,
0.27877548336982727,
0.1271628588438034,
-0.5568157434463501,
0.3853042423725128,
-0.0030803638510406017,
-0.07547267526388168,
0.048453282564878464,
0.5497485399246216,
-0.579232394695282,
-0.7874975800514221,
-0.09596511721611023,
0.7317950129508972,
0.41664671897888184,
-0.21421097218990326,
-0.8134753108024597,
0.00790404248982668,
-0.4766826629638672,
-0.13061539828777313,
0.05765320733189583,
0.44643455743789673,
-0.07696174830198288,
0.8020200729370117,
0.43521881103515625,
0.22204379737377167,
0.5332410335540771,
0.23297706246376038,
0.5591479539871216,
-0.6902526617050171,
-0.4894239008426666,
-1.02202570438385,
0.3712696433067322,
-0.07282222807407379,
-0.46139463782310486,
0.6026716828346252,
0.8156811594963074,
0.872160792350769,
-0.18081215023994446,
0.8130455017089844,
0.11027919501066208,
0.4968145787715912,
-0.4882555305957794,
0.8143707513809204,
-0.31529268622398376,
-0.03430982306599617,
-0.04719413444399834,
-0.6883978843688965,
-0.40300750732421875,
0.6221327781677246,
-0.3300485908985138,
-0.009794813580811024,
0.8337405920028687,
0.9366323947906494,
-0.1393287479877472,
0.2508021593093872,
0.455677330493927,
0.32999226450920105,
0.2730085849761963,
0.8480921983718872,
1.1707321405410767,
-0.4322550594806671,
0.3085826337337494,
-0.43450257182121277,
-0.08118489384651184,
-0.10397860407829285,
-0.936703622341156,
-1.1044652462005615,
-0.572744607925415,
-0.4766584634780884,
0.06503250449895859,
0.18777985870838165,
0.6852381825447083,
0.9163234829902649,
-0.7981308102607727,
-0.27263012528419495,
-0.4081035256385803,
0.2729414701461792,
-0.3544641137123108,
-0.2348284274339676,
-0.017803402617573738,
-0.5485311150550842,
-0.7845192551612854,
0.687052309513092,
0.1401166319847107,
0.13782206177711487,
-0.28897106647491455,
0.12075283378362656,
-0.4547138214111328,
0.09140890836715698,
0.2715587913990021,
0.3518711030483246,
-0.8319134712219238,
-0.28750506043434143,
0.07082652300596237,
0.09572604298591614,
-0.04172385856509209,
0.8955357074737549,
-0.8079338073730469,
0.539272129535675,
0.642767608165741,
0.6356499791145325,
0.5823079347610474,
-0.25631093978881836,
0.6639475226402283,
-0.6369389295578003,
0.22824348509311676,
0.5440376400947571,
0.5073085427284241,
0.2743493318557739,
-0.061913859099149704,
0.5506665110588074,
0.4257659912109375,
-0.44135522842407227,
-1.065499186515808,
0.3069140613079071,
-0.4936864972114563,
-0.1370983123779297,
0.7669187188148499,
-0.2596416771411896,
-0.3669916093349457,
-0.0006833193474449217,
0.289172887802124,
-0.09472827613353729,
-0.034501779824495316,
0.7329971194267273,
1.0331392288208008,
-0.03853035345673561,
-0.3371350169181824,
-0.781740128993988,
0.5665152072906494,
0.4281218945980072,
-1.0489537715911865,
-0.0020025961566716433,
0.3785531222820282,
0.32265177369117737,
0.07893753051757812,
0.5343273282051086,
-0.17222626507282257,
0.508148729801178,
0.3674900233745575,
-0.18477821350097656,
-0.10753510147333145,
-0.41722145676612854,
-0.34243133664131165,
0.11576076596975327,
0.14755500853061676,
-0.05792061612010002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16858v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16858v2 | EAGLE-2: Faster Inference of Language Models with Dynamic Draft Trees | 2024-06-24T17:59:11 | 2024-06-30T15:03:25 | Yuhui Li, Fangyun Wei, Chao Zhang, Hongyang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Inference with modern Large Language Models (LLMs) is expensive and
time-consuming, and speculative sampling has proven to be an effective
solution. Most speculative sampling methods such as EAGLE use a static draft
tree, implicitly assuming that the acceptance rate of draft tokens depends only
on their position. Interestingly, we found that the acceptance rate of draft
tokens is also context-dependent. In this paper, building upon EAGLE, we
propose EAGLE-2, which introduces a new technique of context-aware dynamic
draft tree into drafting modeling. This improvement leverages the fact that the
draft model of EAGLE is well-calibrated: the confidence scores from the draft
model approximate acceptance rates with small errors. We conducted extensive
evaluations on three series of LLMs and six tasks, with EAGLE-2 achieving
speedup ratios 3.05x-4.26x, which is 20%-40% faster than EAGLE-1. EAGLE-2 also
ensures that the distribution of the generated text remains unchanged, making
it a lossless acceleration algorithm. | [
-0.20416010916233063,
-1.0317809581756592,
0.5349503755569458,
0.6399604678153992,
-0.21469004452228546,
0.3140428066253662,
-0.000672093708999455,
-1.1171047687530518,
0.36444661021232605,
0.3403874933719635,
-0.695513129234314,
-0.18370352685451508,
-0.6378024220466614,
0.0022082270588725805,
-0.6486133933067322,
0.21983778476715088,
-0.1515146940946579,
-0.47618532180786133,
0.3547447919845581,
0.14074094593524933,
-0.04494251310825348,
-0.06170782819390297,
-0.8785963654518127,
-0.31148165464401245,
0.26325342059135437,
0.4166088104248047,
0.6671796441078186,
1.0245627164840698,
0.27299603819847107,
0.21376731991767883,
-0.3960295617580414,
0.0827409103512764,
-0.23185817897319794,
0.32545197010040283,
0.1592174619436264,
-0.47578930854797363,
-0.6349571347236633,
0.08593808859586716,
0.7950025200843811,
0.48220404982566833,
0.012428191490471363,
0.2575535476207733,
-0.23571482300758362,
0.6942880153656006,
-0.6807145476341248,
0.1219114437699318,
-1.006854772567749,
0.13404050469398499,
-0.37306109070777893,
-0.38658851385116577,
-0.5434568524360657,
-0.021842235699295998,
0.3506341874599457,
-0.9136174321174622,
0.16946500539779663,
0.15409480035305023,
0.5667725205421448,
0.13205598294734955,
-0.5486854314804077,
-0.40989431738853455,
-0.520344078540802,
0.7803528904914856,
-0.6338987350463867,
0.4352841377258301,
0.41102898120880127,
0.5520313382148743,
-0.17557668685913086,
-1.032969355583191,
-0.7511268258094788,
-0.0940842553973198,
0.2539059817790985,
0.01555434986948967,
0.10076679289340973,
0.030094509944319725,
-0.058913249522447586,
0.21822792291641235,
-0.40250152349472046,
0.35152435302734375,
-0.08574558049440384,
-0.14284875988960266,
0.6484769582748413,
-0.08748364448547363,
0.11214497685432434,
0.022821320220828056,
-0.20913930237293243,
-0.313896119594574,
-0.8281735777854919,
0.3240346312522888,
0.4475824236869812,
0.5612875819206238,
-0.05202183499932289,
0.45451730489730835,
-0.3576088547706604,
0.6780678033828735,
0.4132574796676636,
-0.22719359397888184,
0.33300262689590454,
-0.2947835326194763,
-0.3208954930305481,
0.14533266425132751,
0.3787094056606293,
0.2174272984266281,
0.07509811222553253,
-0.05866840481758118,
-0.17627890408039093,
-0.14688412845134735,
-0.15967051684856415,
-0.9655612111091614,
0.2018214762210846,
0.5620526671409607,
-0.6157508492469788,
-0.38976457715034485,
-0.09083989262580872,
-0.4818583130836487,
-0.3959515690803528,
-0.09508273750543594,
-0.3653873801231384,
-0.29302531480789185,
-0.6442968845367432,
0.11811280250549316,
-0.14598415791988373,
0.27843737602233887,
0.5111986398696899,
-0.9848493933677673,
0.2057284563779831,
0.9209688305854797,
0.791082501411438,
-0.07119226455688477,
-0.3071868419647217,
-0.9815844297409058,
0.08284926414489746,
-0.7631771564483643,
1.2624670267105103,
-0.8503841757774353,
-0.23538243770599365,
0.12877222895622253,
-0.23188909888267517,
0.1473766714334488,
-0.501171350479126,
0.6387747526168823,
-0.8448559641838074,
-0.20534640550613403,
-0.5887243747711182,
-0.45610517263412476,
-0.1974114328622818,
0.19748812913894653,
-0.7703724503517151,
1.2625256776809692,
0.22914224863052368,
-0.767192542552948,
0.6934409141540527,
-0.5846344232559204,
-0.4294146001338959,
0.13441623747348785,
-0.18728911876678467,
-0.05731218308210373,
-0.05191866308450699,
0.1283690184354782,
0.2324112057685852,
-0.2578757107257843,
0.07533898204565048,
-0.6663231253623962,
-0.7731217741966248,
-0.23749537765979767,
-0.2492828071117401,
0.8907485008239746,
0.6574695706367493,
-0.4034877419471741,
-0.15962232649326324,
-0.37166693806648254,
0.23673909902572632,
-0.2094689905643463,
-0.7016118764877319,
-0.20309077203273773,
0.28301122784614563,
0.29465922713279724,
0.08815906196832657,
-0.09174273163080215,
-0.41259393095970154,
0.2766028940677643,
-0.7952566742897034,
0.1905767321586609,
0.4616100490093231,
-0.0799514576792717,
0.4794104993343353,
-0.1771783083677292,
0.4321633279323578,
-0.17143124341964722,
-0.26547929644584656,
-0.11340634524822235,
-0.2962064743041992,
-0.6384851932525635,
-0.4739903509616852,
0.1856745183467865,
0.6522441506385803,
-0.7499251961708069,
0.39129209518432617,
-0.13459670543670654,
-0.45026397705078125,
-0.1475173383951187,
0.1518782377243042,
0.3293743133544922,
0.13914339244365692,
0.030057502910494804,
0.08832486718893051,
-0.6908416152000427,
-0.6188475489616394,
-0.5947355031967163,
-0.728805661201477,
0.12192997336387634,
0.20604068040847778,
0.21913973987102509,
0.010129133239388466,
0.7575234770774841,
-0.04430832713842392,
0.0018374334322288632,
-0.25754615664482117,
0.5627861022949219,
-0.11539355665445328,
0.38000163435935974,
0.9144283533096313,
-0.6241961717605591,
-0.7359651923179626,
-0.17548473179340363,
-0.612889289855957,
-0.2703081965446472,
-0.15249358117580414,
-0.18732009828090668,
0.34670642018318176,
0.6342499852180481,
-0.6321620941162109,
0.08935243636369705,
0.6694871783256531,
-0.5893356204032898,
0.26339051127433777,
0.005664362572133541,
-0.006088920868933201,
-1.0728994607925415,
0.093685582280159,
-0.045058008283376694,
-0.10321833193302155,
-0.5154619216918945,
0.3958304226398468,
0.1434122622013092,
0.27760082483291626,
-0.7504994869232178,
0.9474086761474609,
-0.7920743227005005,
-0.17337068915367126,
-0.44799306988716125,
0.012179577723145485,
-0.19639331102371216,
-0.015376032330095768,
0.11598018556833267,
1.0981011390686035,
0.574884295463562,
-0.3955411911010742,
0.030779628083109856,
0.04709498956799507,
-0.541757345199585,
0.19547010958194733,
-0.40792083740234375,
0.13749799132347107,
-0.15149249136447906,
0.8344230055809021,
-0.8864444494247437,
-0.18657179176807404,
0.20026786625385284,
-0.24686259031295776,
0.2716003954410553,
0.09825577586889267,
-0.6358402967453003,
-0.27851951122283936,
-0.46031996607780457,
0.3923341929912567,
0.3448508083820343,
-0.5073947310447693,
0.6860729455947876,
0.3749914765357971,
-0.10356700420379639,
-0.9419311285018921,
-0.9795371294021606,
0.1322658210992813,
0.06761150062084198,
-0.5227928757667542,
0.3920850157737732,
-0.004652561619877815,
-0.4112775921821594,
0.0544099435210228,
-0.1272992491722107,
-0.2903091013431549,
0.1364089995622635,
0.12227477878332138,
-0.30118486285209656,
-0.3448406755924225,
0.0364854671061039,
0.41798415780067444,
-0.09274094551801682,
-0.11963723599910736,
-0.44028085470199585,
0.22162729501724243,
-0.13874082267284393,
-0.37906134128570557,
-0.6655025482177734,
0.2678360641002655,
0.8074115514755249,
-0.277739942073822,
0.46724435687065125,
0.24607951939105988,
-0.471394419670105,
-0.32337895035743713,
-0.7593486309051514,
-0.19367742538452148,
-0.453194260597229,
0.4627692699432373,
-0.47191452980041504,
-0.9111963510513306,
0.3945755958557129,
-0.16100700199604034,
0.4920344352722168,
0.37213876843452454,
0.521908700466156,
0.07989722490310669,
0.9783094525337219,
0.6866026520729065,
0.01274549774825573,
0.6841965913772583,
-0.2648925185203552,
0.11989667266607285,
-0.7273939847946167,
-0.01643158309161663,
-0.5691818594932556,
-0.2964528799057007,
-0.31016942858695984,
-0.6234548091888428,
-0.12557920813560486,
0.2999122440814972,
-0.05813983082771301,
-0.0020906683057546616,
-0.19634974002838135,
0.5017361640930176,
0.4347546696662903,
-0.18352161347866058,
0.33317995071411133,
0.28772982954978943,
-0.09711513668298721,
0.2526257634162903,
-0.5689361691474915,
-0.6756996512413025,
1.138922095298767,
0.44323477149009705,
0.22777868807315826,
0.21157771348953247,
0.3432905972003937,
0.16454046964645386,
0.6715703010559082,
-0.6419360637664795,
0.5414867997169495,
-0.31436628103256226,
-0.9851348996162415,
-0.3039688766002655,
-0.00021423932048492134,
-0.6301592588424683,
0.26361915469169617,
-0.30208641290664673,
-0.8414689898490906,
0.14914041757583618,
0.6255425214767456,
-0.5644046068191528,
0.3158433139324188,
-0.6373738646507263,
0.4143703281879425,
-0.026028642430901527,
-0.3361692428588867,
-0.3237440288066864,
-0.3337949514389038,
0.8150511980056763,
-0.49056684970855713,
0.02899887040257454,
-0.3577825129032135,
-0.1772613674402237,
0.6241942048072815,
-0.5709385275840759,
0.6762114763259888,
-0.36038315296173096,
0.02202402800321579,
0.8496922254562378,
0.3670926094055176,
0.9759838581085205,
0.09066656976938248,
-0.7075885534286499,
-0.3131198585033417,
0.22921456396579742,
-0.3174915313720703,
-0.6943413019180298,
0.7487244606018066,
-0.6349841952323914,
-0.37132132053375244,
-0.48804619908332825,
-0.761836588382721,
-0.128398135304451,
0.11897831410169601,
-0.04256648197770119,
0.2564567029476166,
0.01818152330815792,
0.2649480998516083,
0.18059885501861572,
-0.11399880796670914,
0.5376811027526855,
0.7693013548851013,
-0.26714950799942017,
0.09088880568742752,
0.38369691371917725,
0.3918021619319916,
0.050121910870075226,
0.43991217017173767,
-0.03453686833381653,
-0.6474935412406921,
-0.6328203678131104,
-0.4877067506313324,
0.20162057876586914,
-0.5192944407463074,
0.13373880088329315,
-0.8525132536888123,
0.04143458977341652,
-0.3190050721168518,
-0.21696418523788452,
-0.5312747359275818,
-0.6396834254264832,
-0.05755138397216797,
-0.31905433535575867,
0.40947824716567993,
0.30454909801483154,
0.11131065338850021,
0.5645425319671631,
-0.4372429847717285,
0.12821343541145325,
0.11091269552707672,
0.43956032395362854,
0.2640822231769562,
-0.5327799320220947,
0.18376927077770233,
-0.005261474289000034,
-0.20201173424720764,
-0.6360194087028503,
0.0026183302979916334,
0.3084290027618408,
0.5101022124290466,
0.5469818711280823,
0.12813201546669006,
0.795652449131012,
-0.35854122042655945,
0.7776567935943604,
-0.10462608933448792,
-0.7946153879165649,
0.15561217069625854,
-0.25842148065567017,
0.3190498650074005,
0.8192750215530396,
-0.19306211173534393,
-0.3973402976989746,
-0.6120913624763489,
-0.3998609781265259,
-0.697108268737793,
0.826221764087677,
0.15295690298080444,
0.11360438168048859,
-0.05358847975730896,
0.6699764728546143,
-0.07322349399328232,
0.003055855631828308,
-0.24556580185890198,
-0.13526593148708344,
-0.09832827746868134,
-0.16076290607452393,
-0.0702066421508789,
-0.6332051753997803,
0.39669719338417053,
-0.11768168210983276,
0.7367186546325684,
-0.1891261339187622,
0.1742398589849472,
0.10724420100450516,
0.0915580466389656,
-0.5081751942634583,
0.0030816644430160522,
0.7077745199203491,
0.6228682994842529,
-0.4645426571369171,
0.45586708188056946,
0.27456456422805786,
-0.4589223563671112,
0.2322472184896469,
0.1645817905664444,
-0.45184722542762756,
0.03523765131831169,
0.6661298274993896,
0.6508569717407227,
0.02974758855998516,
-0.7890877723693848,
0.28739628195762634,
-0.05869724601507187,
-0.4863177239894867,
-0.3414967656135559,
0.03682272508740425,
0.2851710319519043,
0.38754788041114807,
0.48923763632774353,
0.029020298272371292,
0.20740805566310883,
-0.5116068720817566,
0.2969675064086914,
0.6537847518920898,
-0.15183311700820923,
-0.3258320391178131,
0.7492865920066833,
0.3504857122898102,
-0.4871741831302643,
0.501150906085968,
-0.38115546107292175,
-0.23042529821395874,
0.6587880849838257,
0.6592145562171936,
0.9585103988647461,
-0.13295865058898926,
0.1403196156024933,
0.37417036294937134,
0.25494250655174255,
-0.3862636983394623,
0.571282684803009,
0.02072988450527191,
-0.5907999277114868,
-0.6738878488540649,
-0.6289443373680115,
-0.2644486725330353,
0.39808687567710876,
-0.1594105213880539,
0.08145109564065933,
-0.4696758985519409,
-0.18028931319713593,
-0.08830268681049347,
0.33052539825439453,
-0.47917136549949646,
0.061927106231451035,
-0.026369202882051468,
1.8229402303695679,
-0.9516027569770813,
1.0375335216522217,
0.7585133910179138,
-0.03483857586979866,
-1.1492115259170532,
0.27831944823265076,
0.3807181119918823,
-0.6472213864326477,
0.8719719648361206,
0.26423412561416626,
-0.38809385895729065,
0.21108275651931763,
-0.15964139997959137,
-1.0579224824905396,
1.1912951469421387,
0.31339848041534424,
-0.47294238209724426,
-0.03692847862839699,
-0.04767422005534172,
0.4740556478500366,
-0.4178682863712311,
0.5767318606376648,
0.536537766456604,
0.7533010244369507,
0.3237732946872711,
-0.7444374561309814,
0.04422440007328987,
-0.38517308235168457,
0.21027147769927979,
-0.12368392944335938,
-0.6495468616485596,
0.9364307522773743,
0.08871422708034515,
-0.3056076467037201,
0.2134089320898056,
0.9790250062942505,
0.8237351775169373,
0.28828999400138855,
0.895645022392273,
0.25837820768356323,
0.9182257056236267,
0.20364844799041748,
0.9825489521026611,
-0.7578724026679993,
0.082976333796978,
0.9316184520721436,
-0.6092088222503662,
1.205324649810791,
0.765662431716919,
0.06705418974161148,
0.4109640419483185,
0.9071739912033081,
0.586997926235199,
0.4268794655799866,
-0.031820036470890045,
-0.45727068185806274,
-0.27411043643951416,
-0.062207095324993134,
-0.4059569239616394,
0.4069967269897461,
0.010661426931619644,
-0.29177218675613403,
-0.3013901710510254,
-0.5151907205581665,
0.15574771165847778,
-0.026824595406651497,
0.1661924421787262,
0.26091083884239197,
0.04482128098607063,
-1.0577263832092285,
0.600800096988678,
0.408724308013916,
0.5272340178489685,
-0.623490571975708,
-0.04959055036306381,
-0.28958189487457275,
0.2608756721019745,
0.03335818648338318,
-0.6255890727043152,
0.3921549618244171,
0.14107652008533478,
-0.19827228784561157,
-0.268180787563324,
0.36860236525535583,
-0.3016282618045807,
-0.8892849683761597,
0.2970936894416809,
0.5266819000244141,
0.3066657781600952,
-0.13739728927612305,
-0.6250101923942566,
0.564538836479187,
-0.40746206045150757,
-0.740962028503418,
0.12379974871873856,
0.37698185443878174,
-0.3204357922077179,
0.6444008350372314,
0.8094195127487183,
0.23365673422813416,
0.03457813709974289,
-0.22101318836212158,
0.5229211449623108,
-0.17961485683918,
-0.6934941411018372,
-0.6975580453872681,
0.26104727387428284,
0.04562372714281082,
-0.24315574765205383,
0.4420620799064636,
0.7442013025283813,
0.5921211242675781,
0.2339862734079361,
0.8488568663597107,
-0.04849356412887573,
0.7829177975654602,
-0.6112785935401917,
0.7371135354042053,
-0.7072497010231018,
0.4881027340888977,
-0.13584858179092407,
-0.8884186744689941,
-0.35327276587486267,
0.6101833581924438,
-0.13411977887153625,
0.0004510429280344397,
0.8162286877632141,
0.9932993054389954,
-0.2751185894012451,
-0.02951155975461006,
-0.25403928756713867,
0.0970751941204071,
0.6137328147888184,
0.5896608233451843,
0.6416440606117249,
-0.39916110038757324,
0.435817688703537,
-0.18906600773334503,
-0.3171732723712921,
-0.5061112642288208,
-1.3341604471206665,
-0.7403137683868408,
-0.41937392950057983,
-0.025786936283111572,
-0.258596807718277,
0.23317603766918182,
1.130515456199646,
1.1564754247665405,
-0.6168081164360046,
-0.39557573199272156,
-0.31957393884658813,
-0.17670994997024536,
-0.5546116828918457,
-0.16876964271068573,
0.4528064429759979,
-0.2961977422237396,
-0.7388361692428589,
0.6353715658187866,
0.13028959929943085,
0.051421474665403366,
-0.07710663974285126,
-0.45867452025413513,
-0.2681000828742981,
0.3643706738948822,
0.5670565366744995,
0.45924967527389526,
-1.2030173540115356,
-0.4294108748435974,
0.031674448400735855,
-0.16702808439731598,
-0.32831668853759766,
0.8435070514678955,
-0.8731249570846558,
0.5254709124565125,
0.6350419521331787,
0.8423436880111694,
0.5518413186073303,
0.25987493991851807,
0.39347267150878906,
-0.4222860336303711,
0.6954447627067566,
-0.1932595670223236,
0.012669992633163929,
0.06599167734384537,
-0.2818255126476288,
0.2656356990337372,
0.22893691062927246,
-0.02089555934071541,
-1.0950413942337036,
0.24933481216430664,
-0.7972670197486877,
-0.42176055908203125,
1.1229150295257568,
0.08657199144363403,
-0.1463930755853653,
0.023350995033979416,
-0.27005696296691895,
0.3181951344013214,
-0.3269798457622528,
0.6687371730804443,
0.5519862174987793,
-0.12039567530155182,
-0.2352207452058792,
-0.6264054179191589,
0.5747034549713135,
0.4497939348220825,
-0.7441006302833557,
0.24707700312137604,
0.2546966075897217,
0.24540916085243225,
-0.17088055610656738,
1.2068760395050049,
0.25963693857192993,
0.31065985560417175,
0.23159675300121307,
-0.16310885548591614,
-0.47401702404022217,
-0.39435407519340515,
0.06469357013702393,
0.24723419547080994,
0.6170318126678467,
0.2020915001630783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16851v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16851v2 | Losing Visual Needles in Image Haystacks: Vision Language Models are Easily Distracted in Short and Long Contexts | 2024-06-24T17:58:03 | 2024-07-03T03:55:59 | Aditya Sharma, Michael Saxon, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | We present LoCoVQA, a dynamic benchmark generator for evaluating long-context
extractive reasoning in vision language models (VLMs). LoCoVQA augments test
examples for mathematical reasoning, VQA, and character recognition tasks with
increasingly long visual contexts composed of both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution distractor images.
Across these tasks, a diverse set of VLMs rapidly lose performance as the
visual context length grows, often exhibiting a striking logarithmic decay
trend. This test assesses how well VLMs can ignore irrelevant information when
answering queries -- a task that is quite easy for language models (LMs) in the
text domain -- demonstrating that current state-of-the-art VLMs lack this
essential capability for many long-context applications. | [
-0.21648229658603668,
-0.7377219796180725,
0.7320031523704529,
0.29766038060188293,
-0.5772981643676758,
-0.28551995754241943,
-0.04251833260059357,
-0.6240410208702087,
-0.23741452395915985,
0.6560373902320862,
-0.4880548119544983,
-0.410160094499588,
-0.406008243560791,
-0.004102453123778105,
-0.6308423280715942,
0.42520925402641296,
-0.053842946887016296,
-0.21237371861934662,
-0.7743573188781738,
-0.2925795614719391,
-0.718268096446991,
-0.38369008898735046,
-0.44352033734321594,
0.21552148461341858,
0.6379647850990295,
-0.012913886457681656,
0.5267931818962097,
0.7876458168029785,
0.7358312010765076,
0.254802942276001,
-0.1981571465730667,
0.2121804654598236,
-0.4500313103199005,
0.421019971370697,
-0.3440850079059601,
-0.22500501573085785,
0.012984340079128742,
-0.2629720866680145,
0.723493754863739,
0.5622215270996094,
-0.022813992574810982,
0.12679460644721985,
-0.10788541287183762,
0.5675123333930969,
-1.1451740264892578,
0.13949990272521973,
-0.7443439364433289,
-0.19914880394935608,
-0.3691323399543762,
0.02675621397793293,
-0.35638222098350525,
-0.17978717386722565,
0.1928306370973587,
-0.43047067523002625,
-0.0252149049192667,
0.05606597661972046,
1.086255431175232,
0.6662689447402954,
-0.6084146499633789,
-0.1288914680480957,
-0.5750862956047058,
0.8566219806671143,
-0.25655466318130493,
0.5867065191268921,
0.3933912515640259,
0.6095041632652283,
0.03780199587345123,
-0.989253580570221,
-0.5089017152786255,
-0.15473847091197968,
0.08038561791181564,
0.17001059651374817,
-0.09115070849657059,
-0.15735095739364624,
0.4444881081581116,
-0.04073265567421913,
-0.33552539348602295,
-0.11893665045499802,
-0.42019277811050415,
-0.035311028361320496,
0.4534657597541809,
0.5968381762504578,
-0.09311112761497498,
-0.15268070995807648,
-0.5256779789924622,
-0.1719401627779007,
-0.8129509091377258,
0.22398574650287628,
-0.20016679167747498,
-0.13936738669872284,
0.25608769059181213,
0.4342304468154907,
-0.35424405336380005,
1.074543833732605,
-0.27574917674064636,
0.1206984743475914,
0.14220771193504333,
-0.43789389729499817,
-0.4460504949092865,
-0.5474892258644104,
0.6828330755233765,
0.5536146759986877,
-0.04036322608590126,
0.039700787514448166,
-0.3350365161895752,
-0.11739081144332886,
0.20185486972332,
-0.7215796113014221,
-0.2575033903121948,
-0.01160077191889286,
-0.3068312704563141,
-0.17611436545848846,
-0.2612104117870331,
-0.9725354909896851,
-0.48415741324424744,
0.053458455950021744,
0.533191978931427,
-0.29650792479515076,
0.24669688940048218,
0.021794842556118965,
-0.3328245282173157,
0.5252317786216736,
0.5372724533081055,
-0.5574142336845398,
0.09711893647909164,
0.5341896414756775,
0.663200318813324,
-0.3721035420894623,
-0.2845768630504608,
-1.0651495456695557,
-0.23783467710018158,
-0.4743400514125824,
0.6781806945800781,
-0.473945289850235,
-0.3819919526576996,
0.12874041497707367,
0.2958419620990753,
0.01334446482360363,
-0.8203984498977661,
0.6086304783821106,
-0.4851405918598175,
0.137923464179039,
-0.45194166898727417,
-0.28860917687416077,
-0.020470254123210907,
0.28372958302497864,
-0.6818884015083313,
1.2398326396942139,
0.20971165597438812,
-0.4499066472053528,
0.5362488031387329,
-0.2611813545227051,
-0.21179409325122833,
0.41676440834999084,
-0.3472329080104828,
-0.42297446727752686,
0.056842442601919174,
0.023410286754369736,
0.3977656960487366,
-0.5072321891784668,
0.10899614542722702,
-0.42142659425735474,
-0.6341596245765686,
0.2578312158584595,
-0.4769737124443054,
0.7107935547828674,
0.019492678344249725,
-0.5694665312767029,
0.07677339017391205,
-0.8637205362319946,
0.1357719451189041,
0.11322537064552307,
-0.3226032853126526,
-0.8962677121162415,
0.4750775396823883,
0.06461112201213837,
0.4751306474208832,
0.15267331898212433,
-0.2622549831867218,
-0.030306078493595123,
-0.126974418759346,
0.3277525305747986,
0.7081080079078674,
-0.10952936857938766,
0.003373482497408986,
0.08581528812646866,
0.2961947023868561,
0.2018161118030548,
0.26477789878845215,
-0.322917640209198,
-0.3852720558643341,
-1.144845962524414,
-0.5203366875648499,
0.042217228561639786,
0.48416468501091003,
-1.253006935119629,
0.11529131978750229,
-0.3438124656677246,
-0.37809333205223083,
-0.27029645442962646,
0.07249061018228531,
0.5244249105453491,
0.6186484694480896,
0.2678168714046478,
-0.34976670145988464,
-0.33802616596221924,
-1.121524691581726,
-0.5029413104057312,
-0.12602396309375763,
-0.0626949593424797,
0.3852575421333313,
0.6798838376998901,
-0.2863534390926361,
0.7905336022377014,
-0.31616467237472534,
-0.04063433036208153,
0.25172680616378784,
-0.15803706645965576,
-0.04693744331598282,
0.1948632299900055,
0.4592847228050232,
-1.082355260848999,
-0.2774520814418793,
-0.14078263938426971,
-0.8691483736038208,
-0.07175587117671967,
-0.16443310678005219,
-0.16278329491615295,
0.30696558952331543,
0.7286396026611328,
-0.6913034915924072,
1.0086995363235474,
0.35444697737693787,
-0.7076422572135925,
0.7077206373214722,
0.059671755880117416,
0.023883236572146416,
-0.5261083841323853,
0.2876403033733368,
0.06291323155164719,
-0.4546172320842743,
-0.40168246626853943,
0.28518375754356384,
0.43502873182296753,
0.1163458526134491,
-0.6591564416885376,
0.8654916286468506,
-0.608851969242096,
-0.057884763926267624,
-0.05103537067770958,
0.1736120879650116,
0.2816983461380005,
0.3036731481552124,
0.3318285346031189,
0.8194474577903748,
0.6473314166069031,
-0.817118227481842,
0.4581749141216278,
0.06402706354856491,
-0.6567937135696411,
0.38823357224464417,
-0.7771669030189514,
-0.03684480860829353,
-0.14575912058353424,
-0.19965723156929016,
-0.8596076965332031,
-0.1887602061033249,
0.16500718891620636,
-0.02069741301238537,
-0.11137967556715012,
-0.005234885960817337,
-0.27469444274902344,
-0.515024721622467,
-0.1312817931175232,
0.6174946427345276,
0.8719392418861389,
-0.6442350149154663,
0.5567656755447388,
0.19946666061878204,
0.09547518938779831,
-0.7888991832733154,
-0.6365002393722534,
0.1346575915813446,
-0.3427128791809082,
-0.3252257704734802,
0.08629119396209717,
-0.058541323989629745,
-0.5378912687301636,
-0.030240347608923912,
0.04058530554175377,
-0.4214760959148407,
0.09289013594388962,
0.33428993821144104,
0.23689064383506775,
-0.11178209632635117,
0.39377403259277344,
-0.3006628155708313,
0.30849534273147583,
0.38138583302497864,
-0.14722704887390137,
0.2152618020772934,
-0.3229910433292389,
-0.44862979650497437,
-0.09641649574041367,
0.394788920879364,
0.8077719807624817,
-0.3504998981952667,
0.6429558992385864,
0.3521369397640228,
-0.3095536231994629,
-0.18195918202400208,
-0.4836362600326538,
0.14757318794727325,
-0.48749780654907227,
0.7553349137306213,
-0.4733191430568695,
-0.5876336693763733,
0.555814802646637,
0.08834433555603027,
0.0307475458830595,
0.48885130882263184,
0.6009908318519592,
-0.054305896162986755,
0.7155070304870605,
0.5863556861877441,
0.4727068841457367,
0.5721839070320129,
-0.038077399134635925,
-0.061168819665908813,
-0.7607019543647766,
-0.4713291525840759,
-0.26658767461776733,
0.20153073966503143,
-0.28568050265312195,
-0.8072766065597534,
0.28720757365226746,
0.0552273727953434,
0.07381467521190643,
0.23804251849651337,
-0.47375479340553284,
0.7001208066940308,
0.5963329672813416,
0.030813638120889664,
-0.06821410357952118,
-0.3498113751411438,
-0.07895107567310333,
-0.13435997068881989,
-0.605046808719635,
-0.27376219630241394,
0.7153841853141785,
0.13846144080162048,
0.6993889808654785,
-0.0051984176971018314,
0.4328458905220032,
0.002215767977759242,
0.21128492057323456,
-0.9611400961875916,
0.6967419385910034,
-0.002358677564188838,
-0.45450541377067566,
-0.4185582399368286,
-0.3802665174007416,
-0.9050752520561218,
0.5257683992385864,
-0.045608509331941605,
-0.6757211089134216,
0.5133510828018188,
0.19523608684539795,
-0.2655007541179657,
0.05244975909590721,
-0.3632935881614685,
1.0982177257537842,
-0.2256791740655899,
-0.9771066904067993,
0.2694892883300781,
-0.6032069325447083,
0.5477789044380188,
-0.26753678917884827,
0.07925280183553696,
-0.05921144410967827,
-0.25554654002189636,
0.5602966547012329,
-0.32760143280029297,
0.5761680603027344,
0.024365276098251343,
0.02924465946853161,
0.4978492259979248,
0.10758940875530243,
0.5738955736160278,
-0.12512817978858948,
0.06434231996536255,
0.11785824596881866,
0.18459013104438782,
-0.46040046215057373,
-0.6328232288360596,
0.402682900428772,
-0.10345550626516342,
-0.6589125990867615,
-0.4206365942955017,
-0.311917245388031,
-0.10246048867702484,
0.24301141500473022,
0.31481796503067017,
0.45806261897087097,
-0.18563848733901978,
0.5398067831993103,
0.8410922288894653,
-0.2796347439289093,
0.596565842628479,
0.08457554131746292,
-0.2807099521160126,
-0.14004245400428772,
0.7360203266143799,
-0.10559512674808502,
0.3448682427406311,
0.1408676952123642,
-0.04392389953136444,
-0.47360679507255554,
-0.4031662046909332,
-0.46453720331192017,
0.025333063676953316,
-1.1609851121902466,
-0.03953937441110611,
-0.39469143748283386,
-0.18239641189575195,
-0.14912261068820953,
0.13708041608333588,
-0.3848471939563751,
-0.1530938297510147,
-0.22812114655971527,
0.42351189255714417,
-0.02873399667441845,
0.5711306929588318,
0.41544127464294434,
-0.15188796818256378,
-0.7607271075248718,
0.17082910239696503,
0.7171209454536438,
0.2653602659702301,
-0.19612003862857819,
-0.5114339590072632,
-0.4329792857170105,
-0.19960306584835052,
-0.16374395787715912,
-0.7507835030555725,
0.5050148963928223,
0.15650135278701782,
0.5956396460533142,
0.2959006130695343,
0.02786954492330551,
1.0239510536193848,
-0.5803137421607971,
0.9697270393371582,
0.23886415362358093,
-0.9483646750450134,
0.3289423882961273,
-0.2624070644378662,
0.6787095069885254,
0.4208652675151825,
0.17581382393836975,
-0.5398803949356079,
-0.2894691228866577,
-0.32500529289245605,
-0.937445878982544,
0.1812347024679184,
0.26596447825431824,
-0.11336109042167664,
-0.15235547721385956,
0.3034284710884094,
-0.06405910849571228,
0.14441542327404022,
-0.7458798885345459,
0.021204873919487,
-0.19060641527175903,
-0.17786605656147003,
-0.04665030911564827,
-0.36702844500541687,
-0.09897172451019287,
-0.3697545528411865,
0.20462621748447418,
-0.15724597871303558,
0.19453005492687225,
0.38022539019584656,
-0.048164766281843185,
0.19416071474552155,
-0.11085923761129379,
0.778066098690033,
0.7982300519943237,
-0.045600518584251404,
0.3961794078350067,
0.14809875190258026,
-0.44753068685531616,
-0.23617278039455414,
-0.16097164154052734,
-0.18904301524162292,
0.2502598464488983,
0.4035061001777649,
0.8414016366004944,
0.08004212379455566,
-1.233626365661621,
0.7361105680465698,
-0.31274673342704773,
-0.3152817487716675,
-0.5093169212341309,
0.010154938325285912,
0.07989013940095901,
0.1828499436378479,
0.41797763109207153,
0.14599604904651642,
0.24299466609954834,
-0.5183252096176147,
0.27425017952919006,
0.5825724601745605,
-0.652380645275116,
-0.097157321870327,
0.8076551556587219,
0.20377403497695923,
-0.32215940952301025,
0.5733517408370972,
-0.009663205593824387,
-0.45657211542129517,
0.8071538209915161,
0.04149151220917702,
0.8167195916175842,
0.0629534125328064,
-0.26282814145088196,
0.20535950362682343,
0.3867734670639038,
-0.13897664844989777,
0.1326146274805069,
-0.11110816895961761,
-0.25025758147239685,
-0.36215469241142273,
-0.41953667998313904,
-0.21362707018852234,
0.2628168761730194,
-0.6765322089195251,
0.38102009892463684,
-0.13817769289016724,
-0.01663299836218357,
0.0796809047460556,
-0.42431509494781494,
-0.7843853831291199,
0.363598108291626,
0.0934242382645607,
0.969409704208374,
-0.4692970812320709,
0.9336112141609192,
0.4526478946208954,
-0.15123625099658966,
-0.2728080451488495,
-0.01760793849825859,
-0.13476286828517914,
-0.5692005753517151,
1.0306373834609985,
0.2967388331890106,
-0.32864248752593994,
-0.4499819874763489,
-0.7209713459014893,
-0.8343417644500732,
0.9851626753807068,
0.21158389747142792,
-0.617202877998352,
0.013724293559789658,
-0.21187151968479156,
0.5492386817932129,
-0.25515738129615784,
0.09919825196266174,
0.3315437436103821,
0.20330604910850525,
0.2696492671966553,
-0.8429110050201416,
0.07950939238071442,
-0.29043957591056824,
0.09549631923437119,
0.3245309293270111,
-0.6591036319732666,
1.1269683837890625,
-0.1723797619342804,
-0.36440569162368774,
0.40041863918304443,
0.5016471743583679,
0.2507060468196869,
0.5918543934822083,
0.5282870531082153,
0.1746574342250824,
0.5159514546394348,
-0.15927410125732422,
1.019055724143982,
0.0471840538084507,
0.3165730834007263,
1.1013392210006714,
-0.38243308663368225,
1.0925052165985107,
0.8056795597076416,
0.3321661949157715,
0.41108065843582153,
0.654346764087677,
0.1451694667339325,
0.7618494629859924,
0.2188437581062317,
-0.27288946509361267,
-0.7368028163909912,
0.15256555378437042,
-0.1771312952041626,
0.5509375929832458,
0.4052796959877014,
-0.4207572042942047,
0.008541652001440525,
-0.043591804802417755,
-0.35822898149490356,
0.0006271504098549485,
-0.15599747002124786,
0.4349115192890167,
0.11149857938289642,
-0.9481030702590942,
1.0085139274597168,
-0.2942291796207428,
0.30713629722595215,
-0.4052906334400177,
-0.20794689655303955,
-0.1915867179632187,
0.347034215927124,
0.327038437128067,
-0.6698683500289917,
0.3860701322555542,
-0.15417444705963135,
-0.03829934820532799,
0.030470306053757668,
0.7394722700119019,
-0.4574957489967346,
-0.3926711678504944,
0.2936207950115204,
0.45364755392074585,
0.2687368094921112,
-0.030076326802372932,
-0.6333454251289368,
0.23180922865867615,
-0.1634250283241272,
-0.4333544671535492,
0.25387629866600037,
0.656878650188446,
-0.4478013217449188,
1.077108383178711,
0.3551308810710907,
-0.11333255469799042,
0.19689162075519562,
-0.3000109791755676,
0.9791223406791687,
-0.9512165784835815,
-0.24994561076164246,
-0.9895537495613098,
0.445475310087204,
-0.40938299894332886,
-0.5017526745796204,
0.9235642552375793,
0.4393583834171295,
0.59404057264328,
-0.2531663775444031,
0.4643031060695648,
0.043699126690626144,
0.2192564308643341,
-0.7062281966209412,
0.5277542471885681,
-0.9604967832565308,
0.14403431117534637,
-0.09684454649686813,
-0.731058657169342,
-0.3720960319042206,
0.4403497278690338,
-0.23022665083408356,
-0.060816481709480286,
0.9155486822128296,
0.5370593667030334,
0.032811328768730164,
-0.5774272084236145,
0.8538294434547424,
-0.041074395179748535,
0.16012297570705414,
0.853308379650116,
1.2212624549865723,
-0.5629718899726868,
0.6784858703613281,
-0.12006846070289612,
-0.024657633155584335,
-0.37601521611213684,
-1.0394331216812134,
-1.1176475286483765,
-0.7551794052124023,
-0.32975077629089355,
-0.2809877097606659,
0.2969011962413788,
0.3111768662929535,
0.7547622919082642,
-0.3044110834598541,
-0.03153378516435623,
0.02273382805287838,
0.18837814033031464,
-0.36046266555786133,
-0.25072845816612244,
0.25274166464805603,
-0.14720265567302704,
-0.6955347061157227,
0.21858260035514832,
0.48410463333129883,
0.050693314522504807,
-0.2966561019420624,
-0.024940382689237595,
-0.042011383920907974,
0.15048253536224365,
0.8005205392837524,
0.36714011430740356,
-0.9276174902915955,
-0.437150239944458,
0.22224172949790955,
-0.3210746645927429,
-0.08562107384204865,
0.4944709539413452,
-1.0857619047164917,
0.6519412398338318,
0.5036366581916809,
0.4940900504589081,
0.32954996824264526,
0.008249669335782528,
0.28931164741516113,
-0.594811201095581,
0.38714855909347534,
0.4222952723503113,
0.32578033208847046,
0.18101753294467926,
-0.25014057755470276,
0.4591897428035736,
0.42942219972610474,
-0.5799804925918579,
-1.1182490587234497,
0.16152475774288177,
-0.9777294993400574,
-0.3628799021244049,
1.1942929029464722,
-0.1955985426902771,
-0.7711635828018188,
-0.13436198234558105,
-0.04443245008587837,
-0.2664881646633148,
0.014131509698927402,
0.7481099963188171,
0.685636043548584,
0.17036761343479156,
-0.4847874939441681,
-0.5301188826560974,
0.773625373840332,
0.4648975133895874,
-0.8385929465293884,
0.31153205037117004,
0.7468702793121338,
0.26096951961517334,
0.19400788843631744,
0.5975086688995361,
0.036786943674087524,
0.6343626976013184,
0.27920645475387573,
0.07587360590696335,
0.029179902747273445,
-0.45508918166160583,
-0.3252754807472229,
0.1957138478755951,
-0.09637158364057541,
-0.3716247081756592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16845v1 | RaTEScore: A Metric for Radiology Report Generation | 2024-06-24T17:49:28 | 2024-06-24T17:49:28 | Weike Zhao, Chaoyi Wu, Xiaoman Zhang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel, entity-aware metric, termed as Radiological
Report (Text) Evaluation (RaTEScore), to assess the quality of medical reports
generated by AI models. RaTEScore emphasizes crucial medical entities such as
diagnostic outcomes and anatomical details, and is robust against complex
medical synonyms and sensitive to negation expressions. Technically, we
developed a comprehensive medical NER dataset, RaTE-NER, and trained an NER
model specifically for this purpose. This model enables the decomposition of
complex radiological reports into constituent medical entities. The metric
itself is derived by comparing the similarity of entity embeddings, obtained
from a language model, based on their types and relevance to clinical
significance. Our evaluations demonstrate that RaTEScore aligns more closely
with human preference than existing metrics, validated both on established
public benchmarks and our newly proposed RaTE-Eval benchmark. | [
-0.23181505501270294,
-0.4188631772994995,
0.5740058422088623,
0.03505510836839676,
-0.02923201583325863,
-0.002775808097794652,
-0.09837938100099564,
-0.627543032169342,
0.09779185056686401,
0.24207381904125214,
0.05797990784049034,
-0.8213298916816711,
-0.6411215662956238,
0.05911867320537567,
-0.29421913623809814,
1.270470142364502,
0.0574146993458271,
0.5238882303237915,
-0.6352233290672302,
-0.20830078423023224,
-0.41531968116760254,
-0.25774744153022766,
-0.897965133190155,
-0.5032486915588379,
0.4221773147583008,
0.31570908427238464,
0.8259379267692566,
0.7341176867485046,
1.2157163619995117,
0.09888748079538345,
0.025668809190392494,
0.09561914950609207,
-0.09505453705787659,
0.1916445940732956,
0.01274319738149643,
-0.14699895679950714,
-1.109299898147583,
0.016339708119630814,
0.6509248614311218,
0.565041720867157,
-0.23223304748535156,
0.39464306831359863,
-0.36779534816741943,
0.8478639721870422,
-0.5670846104621887,
0.31347790360450745,
-0.18715350329875946,
0.16445450484752655,
-0.12199429422616959,
-0.47556814551353455,
-0.4574979245662689,
-0.6061727404594421,
0.08813866972923279,
-0.3443033993244171,
0.35836026072502136,
0.0024764889385551214,
0.8944718837738037,
0.02060069888830185,
-0.37155601382255554,
-0.5512518286705017,
-0.5614438652992249,
0.43319186568260193,
-0.46973249316215515,
0.2803491950035095,
0.1807657927274704,
0.48208045959472656,
0.21535027027130127,
-0.9256399273872375,
-0.17474400997161865,
-0.5754809379577637,
-0.20095133781433105,
0.25717875361442566,
-0.5827563405036926,
0.02845541387796402,
0.2302865982055664,
0.5379382371902466,
-0.7463952898979187,
0.07984758913516998,
-0.3268837034702301,
-0.38145992159843445,
0.7309152483940125,
0.5936782956123352,
0.7817572951316833,
-0.4755427837371826,
-0.34798410534858704,
-0.017782635986804962,
-0.6137858033180237,
-0.10950111597776413,
0.11845797300338745,
0.15520495176315308,
-0.1241423711180687,
0.670879065990448,
-0.4366990625858307,
0.40094783902168274,
-0.08954014629125595,
-0.4004867374897003,
0.6034181714057922,
-0.16591858863830566,
0.08063021302223206,
0.492130845785141,
0.7846266627311707,
0.8265647292137146,
-0.05276436731219292,
-0.07787027955055237,
-0.38696396350860596,
0.6176204681396484,
0.4672401249408722,
-0.9326685070991516,
-0.04210950806736946,
0.2366567999124527,
-0.8178347945213318,
-0.6266176104545593,
-0.29442688822746277,
-0.2459425926208496,
-0.11705905199050903,
0.01370223518460989,
0.39143407344818115,
-0.7498849034309387,
-0.42000675201416016,
0.13368456065654755,
-0.005023025441914797,
-0.133926123380661,
0.2004837542772293,
-0.2591586112976074,
0.41594037413597107,
0.6071889996528625,
0.7809553146362305,
-0.002811399521306157,
0.08246026188135147,
-0.5233118534088135,
-0.0819745883345604,
-0.46300050616264343,
1.22329843044281,
-0.42223677039146423,
-0.7006403803825378,
-0.24315126240253448,
-0.3898603618144989,
0.2467065304517746,
-0.5517109036445618,
0.7638397812843323,
-0.39508846402168274,
0.19881278276443481,
0.19529451429843903,
-0.645254909992218,
-0.14657847583293915,
0.39995846152305603,
-0.7009842395782471,
0.8602695465087891,
0.3344459533691406,
-0.8632347583770752,
0.6778331398963928,
-0.8357403874397278,
-0.5101718306541443,
0.43256375193595886,
-0.2481015920639038,
-0.49760231375694275,
0.26004430651664734,
0.11790742725133896,
0.26613566279411316,
-0.8017904758453369,
0.5820429921150208,
0.11811462044715881,
0.11002262681722641,
0.27240437269210815,
-0.24508006870746613,
0.20562843978405,
0.5304490923881531,
0.11567328125238419,
0.056837502866983414,
-0.672497034072876,
0.34411168098449707,
0.055695146322250366,
-0.05315566062927246,
-0.4174673855304718,
0.08245814591646194,
0.08305391669273376,
0.06941942125558853,
0.2194804698228836,
-0.7474284768104553,
-0.16652552783489227,
-0.3044285774230957,
0.25309106707572937,
0.19764256477355957,
0.2776710093021393,
0.38591039180755615,
-0.7396140694618225,
0.7862914204597473,
0.19805270433425903,
0.37521088123321533,
-0.0994420275092125,
-0.35401272773742676,
-0.39089617133140564,
-0.285201758146286,
0.2502751648426056,
0.15622426569461823,
-0.1176195740699768,
0.15916810929775238,
-0.6157640218734741,
-1.140270709991455,
-0.7112699151039124,
-0.5272377729415894,
0.7239890098571777,
1.0436702966690063,
0.2571924924850464,
-0.9471634030342102,
-0.3093876242637634,
-1.2762404680252075,
-0.3555406332015991,
-0.3373931646347046,
0.18352843821048737,
0.40623152256011963,
0.25956061482429504,
0.07631657272577286,
0.7656006813049316,
-0.6737454533576965,
-0.5344998240470886,
-0.2744804918766022,
0.17670859396457672,
0.20850689709186554,
0.4514327347278595,
0.40565648674964905,
-0.6469653248786926,
-0.45154330134391785,
-0.21611922979354858,
-0.9017886519432068,
-0.03827758505940437,
0.15193791687488556,
0.02748652547597885,
0.06569946557283401,
0.301455020904541,
-0.21795181930065155,
0.42646524310112,
0.480940580368042,
-0.35221508145332336,
0.3212728798389435,
-0.4719490706920624,
0.5257405638694763,
-1.0918828248977661,
0.27968913316726685,
0.2592490315437317,
-0.35106006264686584,
-0.442200630903244,
-0.07344366610050201,
0.18935607373714447,
-0.4304148852825165,
-0.5018367767333984,
0.5538540482521057,
-0.6202399134635925,
-0.3392789363861084,
-0.03870134800672531,
0.03943606838583946,
0.1234850063920021,
-0.2748928368091583,
0.1221814826130867,
0.6776523590087891,
0.666701078414917,
-0.5942716002464294,
0.009842070750892162,
0.3650524914264679,
-0.5871337056159973,
0.8426836133003235,
-0.7721287608146667,
0.28483209013938904,
-0.32102105021476746,
0.20263053476810455,
-0.4645521342754364,
0.02462163008749485,
-0.28450509905815125,
-0.8436315059661865,
0.2553063929080963,
-0.3414160907268524,
-0.27559205889701843,
-0.31370997428894043,
-0.03952169418334961,
0.4323350489139557,
0.6322949528694153,
0.08071320503950119,
0.38002023100852966,
0.7798328399658203,
-0.10336517542600632,
-0.4791923463344574,
-0.612488329410553,
0.06677159667015076,
0.06178566440939903,
-0.677767813205719,
0.38294517993927,
-0.10006818920373917,
-0.3474137783050537,
0.5163818001747131,
0.05793331190943718,
-0.219386026263237,
0.1151864230632782,
0.6880936026573181,
0.46427372097969055,
-0.6752937436103821,
0.13363097608089447,
-0.057900991290807724,
-0.5018619298934937,
0.22377745807170868,
0.06099336966872215,
0.5612112879753113,
-0.27429109811782837,
-0.29029521346092224,
-0.5359330773353577,
0.33642709255218506,
0.44845089316368103,
-0.3893195688724518,
0.4365598261356354,
0.38461288809776306,
-0.6179174780845642,
0.2306586056947708,
-0.5057379007339478,
0.017347846180200577,
-0.30185359716415405,
0.5322756171226501,
-0.3881189823150635,
-0.7345700263977051,
0.31279852986335754,
0.1557365506887436,
-0.025449151173233986,
0.8655577301979065,
0.7475369572639465,
0.05421742796897888,
1.2562845945358276,
0.30541887879371643,
0.14839209616184235,
0.01371972169727087,
-0.14742110669612885,
0.20962746441364288,
-1.038308024406433,
-0.43619510531425476,
-0.6775135397911072,
-0.09790553897619247,
-0.5428361892700195,
-0.26221421360969543,
0.7650461196899414,
-0.21503011882305145,
-0.027066588401794434,
0.05967859551310539,
-0.894308865070343,
0.4491332769393921,
0.05810410901904106,
0.15120717883110046,
0.49543169140815735,
0.01450811792165041,
0.42332640290260315,
-0.23860317468643188,
-0.6399842500686646,
-0.6761932373046875,
1.2432894706726074,
0.26238876581192017,
0.6102508306503296,
-0.009336783550679684,
0.6146554946899414,
0.7163825631141663,
0.8748152852058411,
-0.9355968832969666,
0.3935389518737793,
-0.5596670508384705,
-1.013292670249939,
0.034719888120889664,
-0.43926355242729187,
-0.8521807193756104,
-0.17458689212799072,
-0.3555348217487335,
-0.1618567556142807,
-0.24314270913600922,
0.048639923334121704,
-0.4047475755214691,
0.11071794480085373,
-0.3599707782268524,
0.6504389643669128,
-0.2385273575782776,
0.26001954078674316,
-0.6442671418190002,
-0.21328647434711456,
0.217971071600914,
0.06134560704231262,
0.3160921335220337,
-0.7409372329711914,
-0.14034992456436157,
0.8673117756843567,
-0.17688287794589996,
0.30446532368659973,
-0.03500548377633095,
0.5159153938293457,
0.2119019627571106,
0.4666883945465088,
-0.049320295453071594,
0.4787449538707733,
-0.11777186393737793,
0.35203495621681213,
-0.13442333042621613,
-0.23923484981060028,
-0.1908431202173233,
0.7228474020957947,
-0.7782377600669861,
-0.06394097954034805,
-0.6837515830993652,
-0.5926924347877502,
-0.08618107438087463,
0.30407556891441345,
0.4910074770450592,
1.2145940065383911,
-0.6383659243583679,
-0.2661147117614746,
0.2946028411388397,
-0.39641833305358887,
-0.029884472489356995,
0.7880852222442627,
-0.08712369203567505,
-0.4815365970134735,
0.8160294890403748,
0.04313559830188751,
0.1433272510766983,
0.4809577465057373,
0.10496918112039566,
-0.09475123882293701,
-0.7518981099128723,
-0.2754407525062561,
0.20440785586833954,
-0.7007152438163757,
-0.5974178910255432,
-0.9215691685676575,
-0.5315802693367004,
-0.2477373331785202,
-0.15776647627353668,
-0.7162644863128662,
-0.26888352632522583,
-0.023647546768188477,
0.0908682718873024,
0.4895716905593872,
0.753432035446167,
-0.121656633913517,
-0.005925670266151428,
-0.9233208298683167,
0.07468068599700928,
-0.31915977597236633,
0.3727145195007324,
-0.1846970170736313,
-0.5280357003211975,
-0.2571480870246887,
-0.33883926272392273,
0.00637774495407939,
-0.6339246034622192,
0.6521835923194885,
0.23883046209812164,
0.4946974515914917,
0.08144961297512054,
0.04709450900554657,
0.4573856294155121,
-0.46511998772621155,
0.6845017075538635,
0.6006672978401184,
-0.904391348361969,
0.8505551815032959,
-0.06975909322500229,
0.07627872377634048,
0.6465805768966675,
0.5475757122039795,
-0.7422249913215637,
-0.5107281804084778,
-0.9461092352867126,
-0.8687530159950256,
0.3934657871723175,
-0.16254831850528717,
0.17205624282360077,
-0.4220258295536041,
0.2944103181362152,
0.08888090401887894,
-0.12561292946338654,
-0.24971969425678253,
-0.26953789591789246,
0.20929968357086182,
-0.1820618063211441,
-0.0708286240696907,
-0.4179506301879883,
-0.24023683369159698,
0.0518915057182312,
0.3805592358112335,
-0.08691345900297165,
0.35117992758750916,
0.6239104866981506,
-0.4935798943042755,
-0.19856218993663788,
0.35172322392463684,
0.4612886607646942,
0.9068012237548828,
-0.29120194911956787,
0.23764002323150635,
0.0024319046642631292,
-0.7043130397796631,
0.23937837779521942,
-0.20884154736995697,
-0.14156588912010193,
0.32132408022880554,
0.47222864627838135,
0.5721288323402405,
0.03615047410130501,
-0.5086560249328613,
0.709169864654541,
-0.433650404214859,
-0.062146928161382675,
-0.5370743870735168,
0.031183086335659027,
-0.08774862438440323,
-0.23224960267543793,
0.17655645310878754,
0.4074512720108032,
0.38238123059272766,
-0.2536493241786957,
0.4372884929180145,
0.08420620113611221,
-0.9568215012550354,
-0.3830796182155609,
0.6114184856414795,
0.2278221845626831,
-0.3023073673248291,
0.9787034392356873,
-0.18148815631866455,
-0.1822076290845871,
0.8104867339134216,
0.48644521832466125,
0.7478878498077393,
-0.10047838091850281,
0.49855101108551025,
0.9340407848358154,
0.26035410165786743,
-0.0064771645702421665,
0.36194851994514465,
0.6171675324440002,
-0.7187395095825195,
-0.3922789990901947,
-0.5518091320991516,
-0.1823778599500656,
-0.1867396980524063,
-1.2339130640029907,
0.358439177274704,
-0.6268139481544495,
-0.6935206055641174,
0.36289724707603455,
-0.08826727420091629,
-0.775664746761322,
0.5937281847000122,
0.1535855084657669,
1.0616127252578735,
-0.649256706237793,
0.6169371008872986,
0.8327956199645996,
-0.7600328922271729,
-0.9710277915000916,
-0.36543917655944824,
-0.0628276839852333,
-0.8486990928649902,
0.8644170761108398,
0.1304970532655716,
0.0734851285815239,
-0.09766342490911484,
-0.0328226312994957,
-0.7457480430603027,
1.0928095579147339,
0.1470119059085846,
-0.3337987959384918,
-0.028422554954886436,
-0.3164324164390564,
0.6807818412780762,
-0.8257150650024414,
0.8161664605140686,
0.4038604497909546,
0.1261991411447525,
-0.5687436461448669,
-1.0822464227676392,
0.20965731143951416,
-0.24840639531612396,
0.05147577449679375,
0.404750257730484,
-0.49531295895576477,
0.7650120258331299,
-0.4301668703556061,
-0.41673681139945984,
-0.2052983194589615,
0.490289568901062,
-0.03013353794813156,
0.6449657082557678,
0.5623473525047302,
0.6292555928230286,
0.5343100428581238,
-0.04646226391196251,
1.5379208326339722,
-0.5309072732925415,
0.3221554756164551,
0.8130907416343689,
-0.34599778056144714,
0.5913988947868347,
0.016638442873954773,
-0.0974491536617279,
0.5459821820259094,
0.40435662865638733,
0.014338858425617218,
0.3808857202529907,
-0.00001492599676566897,
-0.18156738579273224,
-0.3375736176967621,
-0.7138851284980774,
-0.726887047290802,
0.519221842288971,
0.2584809958934784,
-0.4985171854496002,
-0.28957322239875793,
-0.2542189657688141,
0.17308758199214935,
0.08760467171669006,
-0.23345448076725006,
0.8938729166984558,
0.12636934220790863,
-0.5390778183937073,
0.27188557386398315,
-0.022985881194472313,
0.3649352788925171,
-0.662131130695343,
0.17486190795898438,
-0.3780849874019623,
0.06836088746786118,
-0.5645802617073059,
-0.8948696255683899,
0.4836077392101288,
0.28585001826286316,
-0.5373022556304932,
-0.022737592458724976,
0.5796242356300354,
-0.017891190946102142,
-0.3894459307193756,
0.14060425758361816,
0.4602362811565399,
0.301042377948761,
0.2173289805650711,
-0.6211081743240356,
-0.09137498587369919,
-0.16350853443145752,
-0.14039625227451324,
0.4882284700870514,
0.12691865861415863,
-0.10947957634925842,
0.6433339715003967,
0.6057094931602478,
0.6061102747917175,
-0.6126638054847717,
0.3032850921154022,
0.7145870327949524,
-0.5864314436912537,
-0.452038437128067,
-0.5550879836082458,
0.4279204308986664,
-0.06449819356203079,
-0.6838219165802002,
0.30986487865448,
1.0199452638626099,
0.5421822667121887,
0.15074624121189117,
0.5741421580314636,
-0.22322137653827667,
0.5685552954673767,
-0.31677165627479553,
1.1042495965957642,
-0.5919126272201538,
0.11485008150339127,
-0.1218029260635376,
-0.7064235806465149,
-0.2361636608839035,
0.26369133591651917,
-0.25566330552101135,
-0.24328072369098663,
0.9931252598762512,
0.7939876914024353,
0.11813802272081375,
-0.2002527266740799,
0.33479490876197815,
0.007307971362024546,
0.3048988878726959,
0.5852768421173096,
0.8656161427497864,
-0.35922732949256897,
0.532616138458252,
-0.27901145815849304,
-0.2418728619813919,
-0.04401956498622894,
-0.7273499965667725,
-0.27768567204475403,
-0.5511103868484497,
-0.6521731615066528,
-0.6949103474617004,
0.15344877541065216,
0.6281624436378479,
0.7296121716499329,
-0.4893236458301544,
-0.12438318133354187,
0.43340590596199036,
-0.3072986602783203,
-0.07854241132736206,
-0.25880101323127747,
0.49368420243263245,
-0.3696540594100952,
-0.39357635378837585,
0.18628722429275513,
0.6067789196968079,
-0.24449153244495392,
-0.08961018174886703,
-0.022729692980647087,
0.4616752862930298,
-0.14872340857982635,
0.2750259041786194,
-0.10043060779571533,
-0.2782493531703949,
-0.1565009206533432,
-0.01360465120524168,
-0.825238049030304,
0.3740842342376709,
1.0097787380218506,
-0.6389837265014648,
0.5607114434242249,
0.48842546343803406,
0.3309039771556854,
0.4250452220439911,
-0.3833894729614258,
0.5205339193344116,
-0.2863977551460266,
0.1311749368906021,
0.7353056073188782,
0.2208261638879776,
0.47025176882743835,
-0.43695250153541565,
0.5343996286392212,
-0.032538317143917084,
-0.4822421073913574,
-1.0607231855392456,
0.2832677364349365,
-1.0365725755691528,
0.03849882259964943,
0.7797613143920898,
-0.07663934677839279,
-0.2909244894981384,
0.1362927407026291,
0.18919211626052856,
0.34007322788238525,
-0.5943387746810913,
0.5982410907745361,
0.19062276184558868,
-0.38311532139778137,
0.18043376505374908,
-0.5295590758323669,
0.548316478729248,
0.4228390157222748,
-0.9261999130249023,
-0.40803420543670654,
0.5824291706085205,
0.6067933440208435,
0.2051721066236496,
1.10124671459198,
-0.8127992153167725,
0.7229931354522705,
0.05752556398510933,
0.5760388970375061,
-0.20681995153427124,
-0.03774483874440193,
-0.19031791388988495,
0.19824756681919098,
0.4093017280101776,
0.12307929992675781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16842v1 | Exploring Factual Entailment with NLI: A News Media Study | 2024-06-24T17:47:55 | 2024-06-24T17:47:55 | Guy Mor-Lan, Effi Levi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the relationship between factuality and Natural Language Inference
(NLI) by introducing FactRel -- a novel annotation scheme that models
\textit{factual} rather than \textit{textual} entailment, and use it to
annotate a dataset of naturally occurring sentences from news articles. Our
analysis shows that 84\% of factually supporting pairs and 63\% of factually
undermining pairs do not amount to NLI entailment or contradiction,
respectively, suggesting that factual relationships are more apt for analyzing
media discourse. We experiment with models for pairwise classification on the
new dataset, and find that in some cases, generating synthetic data with GPT-4
on the basis of the annotated dataset can improve performance. Surprisingly,
few-shot learning with GPT-4 yields strong results on par with medium LMs
(DeBERTa) trained on the labelled dataset. We hypothesize that these results
indicate the fundamental dependence of this task on both world knowledge and
advanced reasoning abilities. | [
-0.4707498848438263,
-1.1193915605545044,
0.7609237432479858,
0.06807375699281693,
-0.18326298892498016,
-0.07862745970487595,
-0.1416018307209015,
-0.628422737121582,
0.20179012417793274,
0.34078657627105713,
-0.45377883315086365,
-0.4175565540790558,
-0.5067545771598816,
0.22155962884426117,
-0.2609747648239136,
1.1904017925262451,
0.1275363713502884,
-0.11374859511852264,
-0.42434096336364746,
-0.3911086618900299,
-0.33182987570762634,
-0.3538563847541809,
-0.5329420566558838,
-0.19020597636699677,
0.5679892897605896,
0.31851059198379517,
0.7222549319267273,
0.48350203037261963,
0.6294091939926147,
0.2772068381309509,
0.05864797532558441,
0.32654082775115967,
-0.4778568148612976,
-0.014911279082298279,
-0.1586252599954605,
-0.719652533531189,
-0.06075511500239372,
0.5026810169219971,
0.5928453803062439,
0.5808311104774475,
0.1734055131673813,
0.36471259593963623,
-0.21628394722938538,
0.6887910962104797,
-0.6744452714920044,
0.014928076416254044,
-0.6593013405799866,
0.13647828996181488,
-0.08411114662885666,
-0.49331164360046387,
-0.32999852299690247,
-0.6218701004981995,
0.2775603234767914,
-0.8070764541625977,
0.4831527769565582,
0.4701625108718872,
1.1531968116760254,
0.4249783456325531,
-0.7002453207969666,
-0.3593909442424774,
-0.9041785597801208,
0.7162218689918518,
-0.723182201385498,
0.4675123989582062,
0.5126287937164307,
0.2997666001319885,
0.039525922387838364,
-0.5548795461654663,
-0.8328882455825806,
-0.1948527842760086,
-0.45460233092308044,
0.45152920484542847,
-0.16146883368492126,
-0.020545300096273422,
0.5271880030632019,
0.3408289849758148,
-0.5846899747848511,
-0.146888867020607,
-0.4955076575279236,
-0.11130258440971375,
0.620491087436676,
-0.17619994282722473,
0.29761525988578796,
-0.35385066270828247,
-0.3384030759334564,
0.3494105339050293,
-0.8115978240966797,
-0.21959912776947021,
0.45411187410354614,
0.11352533847093582,
-0.16568422317504883,
0.7185913920402527,
-0.19178153574466705,
0.6064569354057312,
-0.0899285078048706,
-0.26170310378074646,
0.1846168488264084,
-0.6365335583686829,
-0.18100835382938385,
0.4381343424320221,
0.6486833095550537,
0.3098333179950714,
0.10992021858692169,
-0.2978056073188782,
0.06614100933074951,
0.3784421980381012,
0.02543599158525467,
-0.608425498008728,
-0.09940478205680847,
0.1701512187719345,
-0.22194215655326843,
-0.3272007405757904,
0.259230375289917,
-0.542378842830658,
-0.28665608167648315,
-0.6904740929603577,
0.5071889162063599,
-0.43824541568756104,
-0.19969969987869263,
0.15972740948200226,
-0.2815086841583252,
0.46964025497436523,
0.1464151293039322,
-0.5801668763160706,
0.3475848138332367,
0.8290380835533142,
0.91755610704422,
0.062160674482584,
-0.020496856421232224,
-0.5834091901779175,
0.2524564266204834,
-0.45869630575180054,
0.8553932905197144,
-0.5563024282455444,
0.041635673493146896,
-0.0403054803609848,
-0.2617446780204773,
-0.11283602565526962,
-0.3125385642051697,
1.0997954607009888,
-0.5199034810066223,
0.5485582947731018,
-0.3932291865348816,
-0.7878088355064392,
-0.4935317933559418,
0.605682909488678,
-0.8519336581230164,
0.902826726436615,
-0.32498374581336975,
-1.2404119968414307,
0.5043160319328308,
-0.6824792623519897,
-0.4932829439640045,
-0.22799360752105713,
-0.19608758389949799,
-0.38823720812797546,
0.08826418220996857,
0.22581742703914642,
0.12348469346761703,
-0.2577064633369446,
0.5787404179573059,
-0.29405808448791504,
-0.4000004827976227,
0.45153310894966125,
-0.6649638414382935,
0.5844738483428955,
0.05632747337222099,
-0.3346351087093353,
-0.23225238919258118,
-0.8802212476730347,
-0.3243822753429413,
-0.08964449167251587,
-0.3892250061035156,
-0.4356482923030853,
0.011178247630596161,
-0.15173648297786713,
0.13868863880634308,
-0.1463376134634018,
-0.8116800785064697,
-0.022924203425645828,
-0.4029069244861603,
0.2013186812400818,
0.18611788749694824,
0.3337017893791199,
0.4541218876838684,
-0.3738022744655609,
-0.026199813932180405,
-0.0939493402838707,
0.005875298287719488,
0.06280102580785751,
-0.503993034362793,
-0.8841276168823242,
-0.13357464969158173,
0.6003780961036682,
0.670558512210846,
-0.8067691326141357,
0.23157012462615967,
-0.2672138512134552,
-0.1663312464952469,
-0.5174514651298523,
-0.035337530076503754,
0.23404622077941895,
0.6572751402854919,
0.2754034698009491,
0.06848863512277603,
-0.8617695569992065,
-1.0803989171981812,
-0.3726852834224701,
-0.11806835234165192,
0.12695032358169556,
0.0870104730129242,
0.57048100233078,
-0.02411329373717308,
1.2362027168273926,
-0.5526412129402161,
-0.25373175740242004,
-0.22662299871444702,
0.5958157181739807,
0.30437347292900085,
0.28380224108695984,
0.6175915002822876,
-1.130596399307251,
-0.171725794672966,
-0.13391850888729095,
-1.1450750827789307,
-0.003548800479620695,
-0.3446727693080902,
-0.1661648005247116,
0.4174812436103821,
0.3518509268760681,
-0.7301195859909058,
0.6421954035758972,
0.2551593482494354,
-0.2229146808385849,
0.4683068096637726,
-0.0543530099093914,
0.3012847602367401,
-0.7378750443458557,
0.036596737802028656,
0.479503333568573,
-0.1798136830329895,
-0.6879646182060242,
-0.08585688471794128,
-0.2734462022781372,
0.042948491871356964,
-0.41634035110473633,
0.2104969322681427,
-0.2520572543144226,
-0.18097497522830963,
-0.2639797627925873,
0.22189070284366608,
0.25477632880210876,
0.3215599060058594,
0.20404542982578278,
0.5062869191169739,
0.46230924129486084,
-0.5479889512062073,
0.2967599034309387,
0.26600658893585205,
-0.2354758381843567,
0.4807763993740082,
-0.6186230778694153,
-0.042275551706552505,
-0.35370922088623047,
0.48213648796081543,
-0.7956445813179016,
-0.2560819983482361,
0.283897340297699,
-0.4260140359401703,
0.04511551186442375,
-0.21187394857406616,
-0.6483830809593201,
-0.08172966539859772,
-0.22462452948093414,
0.09141533821821213,
0.27141231298446655,
-0.4680652916431427,
0.595889151096344,
0.17461848258972168,
0.07842306047677994,
-0.405635267496109,
-0.8037530183792114,
0.163722425699234,
-0.44959312677383423,
-0.48350876569747925,
0.2271530032157898,
0.13117876648902893,
-0.5693771839141846,
0.18550434708595276,
-0.21057476103305817,
-0.22740952670574188,
-0.12909244000911713,
0.126068115234375,
0.30110257863998413,
-0.5133646130561829,
0.26244527101516724,
-0.07899577915668488,
0.001115681603550911,
0.240278422832489,
0.026743067428469658,
-0.0058382791467010975,
-0.2914767861366272,
-0.32595548033714294,
-0.504772961139679,
0.25436416268348694,
0.17558279633522034,
-0.30963417887687683,
0.7775983214378357,
0.8076636791229248,
-0.36121541261672974,
0.12895315885543823,
-0.711901068687439,
-0.3132091760635376,
-0.37870869040489197,
0.010468586347997189,
-0.18625713884830475,
-0.6270937323570251,
0.2686178386211395,
0.01632831059396267,
0.11682245135307312,
0.30565595626831055,
0.006118050776422024,
-0.13811039924621582,
0.728257954120636,
0.4160992205142975,
0.024931032210588455,
0.07006976008415222,
-0.46518802642822266,
0.28564542531967163,
-0.4265935719013214,
-0.06418270617723465,
-0.14715780317783356,
-0.3836672902107239,
-0.7993896007537842,
-0.2321624755859375,
0.3436067998409271,
-0.11954160779714584,
-0.1713753640651703,
0.03908028081059456,
-0.04784326255321503,
0.803288459777832,
0.6569303274154663,
0.17007297277450562,
0.5775116086006165,
-0.2085304707288742,
0.386656254529953,
-0.12126871943473816,
-0.7403443455696106,
-0.40033861994743347,
0.9653757214546204,
0.28358471393585205,
0.5496589541435242,
0.39377522468566895,
0.6532240509986877,
0.1487744003534317,
0.3437468111515045,
-0.7487936019897461,
0.43820756673812866,
-0.06084655597805977,
-0.842346727848053,
-0.11584558337926865,
-0.47973525524139404,
-0.547797441482544,
0.21276934444904327,
-0.65232253074646,
-0.3209588825702667,
0.2213655412197113,
0.04954632744193077,
-0.3517134487628937,
0.22241710126399994,
-0.7213916182518005,
0.4837086796760559,
-0.2770490050315857,
-0.581732451915741,
-0.19143739342689514,
-0.7683244347572327,
0.8065674901008606,
-0.0502275750041008,
0.3078770637512207,
-0.16563460230827332,
0.1183580830693245,
0.6638755202293396,
0.13180656731128693,
1.0263991355895996,
-0.05702567845582962,
0.008311447687447071,
0.5817318558692932,
-0.10514038056135178,
0.1941446214914322,
0.476513147354126,
-0.11263690143823624,
-0.03027411364018917,
-0.21878933906555176,
-0.30062955617904663,
-1.0878872871398926,
0.6063950657844543,
-0.5012091994285583,
-0.7281175851821899,
-0.6586706042289734,
-0.542931079864502,
-0.22041422128677368,
0.0853954628109932,
0.11359047889709473,
0.8151678442955017,
-0.2770402729511261,
0.25788211822509766,
0.8045875430107117,
0.04068811982870102,
0.3962820768356323,
0.5736633539199829,
-0.014579536393284798,
-0.18841290473937988,
0.9926561713218689,
0.191496804356575,
0.1421118974685669,
0.3949994146823883,
0.44171836972236633,
-0.510627031326294,
-0.3762522041797638,
-0.3289371728897095,
0.45334529876708984,
-0.7654854655265808,
-0.05411244556307793,
-0.5413268208503723,
-0.2638615071773529,
-0.20005683600902557,
0.08979783952236176,
-0.169581338763237,
-0.557640552520752,
0.016203472390770912,
-0.4193647503852844,
0.41363784670829773,
0.769291341304779,
-0.1294294148683548,
0.030489757657051086,
-0.6588225364685059,
0.47081127762794495,
0.3443149924278259,
0.0783933624625206,
-0.5303937792778015,
-0.44041872024536133,
-0.09556226432323456,
0.1999090015888214,
-0.42552754282951355,
-0.861764132976532,
0.06492067128419876,
0.5009598731994629,
0.5141503214836121,
0.40315547585487366,
0.35998794436454773,
0.5237113237380981,
-0.5249943733215332,
0.5625025033950806,
-0.08841197192668915,
-0.7141727209091187,
0.5936112403869629,
-0.39874139428138733,
-0.04709210619330406,
0.6338953971862793,
0.8097583055496216,
-0.2531125545501709,
-0.5572803616523743,
-0.7875150442123413,
-0.3700801134109497,
0.3243161141872406,
0.4128859043121338,
0.0011873530456796288,
-0.0298033244907856,
0.32245486974716187,
0.07243429869413376,
0.1846446543931961,
-0.6622397303581238,
-0.22960521280765533,
-0.3155604898929596,
-0.2803163528442383,
0.061214786022901535,
-0.18444794416427612,
-0.4741935133934021,
-0.4675014019012451,
0.6318680644035339,
-0.24877513945102692,
0.2925671339035034,
0.43180644512176514,
-0.1213693767786026,
0.18205615878105164,
0.34813472628593445,
0.637025773525238,
0.7528199553489685,
-0.3561181426048279,
0.48147550225257874,
0.28967657685279846,
-0.20936478674411774,
0.05244320631027222,
0.21811234951019287,
-0.2626665532588959,
0.24164651334285736,
0.5451835989952087,
0.9093664288520813,
0.3864012062549591,
-0.34234505891799927,
0.599049985408783,
0.05263351649045944,
-0.3782784044742584,
-0.3153669834136963,
-0.06859507411718369,
0.10392475873231888,
0.10302082449197769,
0.36538615822792053,
0.13650068640708923,
0.5768795609474182,
-0.8530532121658325,
0.35892772674560547,
0.2729625701904297,
-0.33146244287490845,
-0.5070820450782776,
0.4497776925563812,
0.21805542707443237,
0.18420323729515076,
0.416847825050354,
-0.35503023862838745,
-0.5070798993110657,
0.4864695072174072,
0.7005831599235535,
0.4704185426235199,
0.37632012367248535,
0.462505042552948,
0.4661617875099182,
0.30161941051483154,
-0.12251235544681549,
0.08731532096862793,
0.20674295723438263,
-0.8623948097229004,
-0.822507381439209,
-0.3896336853504181,
-0.45773056149482727,
0.11170211434364319,
-0.5729105472564697,
0.3241735100746155,
-0.27493414282798767,
0.042457181960344315,
0.3297085762023926,
-0.04394964128732681,
-0.5900840163230896,
0.3468291163444519,
0.21859438717365265,
0.7525224685668945,
-1.2198309898376465,
0.6352571845054626,
0.6949687600135803,
-0.6271440386772156,
-0.6391574144363403,
0.3374381959438324,
0.1899813562631607,
-0.3198228180408478,
0.7886596918106079,
0.2888791859149933,
-0.02609609067440033,
0.05154658481478691,
-0.6767776608467102,
-0.7935431003570557,
0.9107664227485657,
0.4049709737300873,
-0.17337654531002045,
0.07480572164058685,
0.24897845089435577,
0.44579049944877625,
-0.24040646851062775,
0.24356546998023987,
0.7845380902290344,
0.593579888343811,
0.23499970138072968,
-0.5005850791931152,
0.038086485117673874,
-0.10401346534490585,
-0.38622304797172546,
0.13347144424915314,
-0.5879846811294556,
0.4192068576812744,
-0.3333705961704254,
-0.4366123080253601,
-0.4794343411922455,
0.9537057876586914,
0.2453765571117401,
0.7490271329879761,
0.44603633880615234,
0.6971725225448608,
0.639899492263794,
-0.13806408643722534,
0.9297725558280945,
-0.0068509806878864765,
0.2241220772266388,
1.0602821111679077,
-0.28119394183158875,
0.7451919317245483,
0.37664729356765747,
-0.0865904688835144,
0.5941817760467529,
0.47680485248565674,
0.021897561848163605,
0.3088812232017517,
-0.10498245805501938,
-0.44313809275627136,
-0.26269015669822693,
-0.32393187284469604,
-0.07249751687049866,
0.7430636882781982,
0.34605738520622253,
0.03388456627726555,
-0.2914702296257019,
-0.029461698606610298,
0.15839459002017975,
0.30079105496406555,
-0.04831700772047043,
0.7814279198646545,
0.05556624010205269,
-0.6623311042785645,
0.4312002658843994,
-0.23063825070858002,
0.7475266456604004,
-0.4425464868545532,
-0.16267670691013336,
-0.1787075400352478,
-0.2453020215034485,
-0.3986355662345886,
-0.8055176734924316,
0.6893823742866516,
-0.07488042861223221,
-0.17117127776145935,
0.2955550253391266,
0.817064106464386,
-0.5756615400314331,
-0.586654782295227,
-0.21709226071834564,
0.5461013913154602,
0.036823395639657974,
0.13726384937763214,
-0.48503828048706055,
-0.034170735627412796,
-0.1638648808002472,
-0.22909022867679596,
0.06256642192602158,
0.5590360164642334,
0.05181987211108208,
0.45821505784988403,
0.7506887912750244,
-0.006443347781896591,
-0.038858991116285324,
0.04748552292585373,
0.6914425492286682,
-0.5033923387527466,
-0.2743840515613556,
-0.884721577167511,
0.2975015342235565,
-0.42065998911857605,
-0.2413424402475357,
0.924680769443512,
0.8424643278121948,
0.5391685962677002,
0.0749533399939537,
0.939631998538971,
-0.06932055205106735,
0.4986836612224579,
-0.8420509099960327,
0.4515995979309082,
-0.20412714779376984,
-0.042786311358213425,
0.06231313943862915,
-0.9439854621887207,
-0.5402958393096924,
0.3643466532230377,
-0.6343726515769958,
-0.3593103289604187,
0.893238365650177,
0.7261475920677185,
-0.27503398060798645,
0.5399999022483826,
0.12154107540845871,
-0.012073498219251633,
0.22876064479351044,
0.2473921775817871,
0.9019259810447693,
-0.359516441822052,
0.3832269310951233,
-0.3680955767631531,
-0.10002071410417557,
0.08694104105234146,
-0.9755883812904358,
-0.8723982572555542,
-0.36257871985435486,
-0.5701281428337097,
-0.12946553528308868,
0.2833542823791504,
0.7540094256401062,
0.47833746671676636,
-0.704125165939331,
0.1621692031621933,
-0.27281028032302856,
0.09645705670118332,
-0.07173046469688416,
-0.26490458846092224,
0.35030224919319153,
-0.44278401136398315,
-0.651323139667511,
0.49078086018562317,
-0.05137615278363228,
0.11267266422510147,
-0.1180991381406784,
0.09577934443950653,
-0.618074357509613,
0.2387605756521225,
0.5114398002624512,
0.24186159670352936,
-0.6690919995307922,
-0.6218656897544861,
-0.12742257118225098,
0.1922541707754135,
0.0016500292113050818,
0.8342529535293579,
-0.7827208638191223,
0.2315884530544281,
0.4444252550601959,
0.7588396072387695,
0.34481778740882874,
0.3436039388179779,
0.5102664232254028,
-1.0651218891143799,
0.3460538387298584,
0.052824411541223526,
0.19781404733657837,
0.5623175501823425,
-0.3393939137458801,
0.790378987789154,
0.5169574618339539,
-0.5406157374382019,
-0.7860679030418396,
0.34723544120788574,
-0.8778412342071533,
-0.09290587157011032,
1.2875655889511108,
0.08162162452936172,
-0.3038482666015625,
-0.31324902176856995,
-0.1966598480939865,
0.3443438410758972,
-0.17966113984584808,
0.5703622102737427,
0.5020872950553894,
-0.19707900285720825,
-0.20345523953437805,
-1.0622292757034302,
0.6082901954650879,
0.18870878219604492,
-0.8210858702659607,
-0.2869003713130951,
0.45809078216552734,
0.22396057844161987,
0.3704470694065094,
0.33565351366996765,
0.267339289188385,
0.14442066848278046,
0.076871357858181,
-0.17917278409004211,
-0.04398750141263008,
-0.28837019205093384,
0.10228804498910904,
-0.1208195760846138,
-0.15481038391590118,
-0.2651483714580536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16838v1 | From Decoding to Meta-Generation: Inference-time Algorithms for Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T17:45:59 | 2024-06-24T17:45:59 | Sean Welleck, Amanda Bertsch, Matthew Finlayson, Hailey Schoelkopf, Alex Xie, Graham Neubig, Ilia Kulikov, Zaid Harchaoui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | One of the most striking findings in modern research on large language models
(LLMs) is that scaling up compute during training leads to better results.
However, less attention has been given to the benefits of scaling compute
during inference. This survey focuses on these inference-time approaches. We
explore three areas under a unified mathematical formalism: token-level
generation algorithms, meta-generation algorithms, and efficient generation.
Token-level generation algorithms, often called decoding algorithms, operate by
sampling a single token at a time or constructing a token-level search space
and then selecting an output. These methods typically assume access to a
language model's logits, next-token distributions, or probability scores.
Meta-generation algorithms work on partial or full sequences, incorporating
domain knowledge, enabling backtracking, and integrating external information.
Efficient generation methods aim to reduce token costs and improve the speed of
generation. Our survey unifies perspectives from three research communities:
traditional natural language processing, modern LLMs, and machine learning
systems. | [
-0.29935190081596375,
-0.7588993310928345,
0.6225367188453674,
0.3947199881076813,
-0.08210962265729904,
0.01901520974934101,
-0.2743251323699951,
-0.4391304850578308,
0.13524553179740906,
0.42342689633369446,
-0.569373607635498,
-0.12316322326660156,
-0.5451884865760803,
0.17625853419303894,
-0.4494006633758545,
0.6732478737831116,
0.27050215005874634,
0.1883781999349594,
-0.062378428876399994,
0.12037590891122818,
-0.28754034638404846,
-0.5967980027198792,
-0.896876871585846,
-0.2548340857028961,
0.2892802953720093,
0.22675006091594696,
0.4978291690349579,
0.9195618629455566,
0.26779261231422424,
0.27693039178848267,
-0.12430279701948166,
0.1650974154472351,
-0.25784194469451904,
0.12806610763072968,
-0.1957039088010788,
-0.6305601000785828,
-0.38751983642578125,
-0.22327718138694763,
0.9104572534561157,
0.973873496055603,
-0.13399702310562134,
0.5615351796150208,
-0.0832439661026001,
0.5277350544929504,
-1.1199992895126343,
0.15791767835617065,
-0.7273801565170288,
0.05602499097585678,
-0.3660392463207245,
-0.292204886674881,
-0.7323058247566223,
-0.2929520010948181,
-0.13220852613449097,
-0.3151050806045532,
0.4764477014541626,
0.09414146095514297,
0.2508319914340973,
0.06331256777048111,
-0.6309400200843811,
-0.3916291296482086,
-0.8570613265037537,
1.3133785724639893,
-0.9046925902366638,
0.24822589755058289,
0.18970489501953125,
0.21819522976875305,
-0.186942920088768,
-1.007474422454834,
-0.4137812554836273,
0.12069215625524521,
-0.17136813700199127,
-0.2034761756658554,
-0.27898696064949036,
0.3133363127708435,
0.4500754177570343,
0.42260637879371643,
-0.17031829059123993,
0.21794413030147552,
-0.038897234946489334,
-0.20959743857383728,
0.5251733660697937,
0.25172993540763855,
0.21861854195594788,
-0.35482561588287354,
0.24605149030685425,
-0.06745641678571701,
-0.8685735464096069,
-0.27170413732528687,
0.21008391678333282,
0.21074384450912476,
0.34581243991851807,
0.529987633228302,
-0.035049211233854294,
0.8363261222839355,
-0.0007788189686834812,
-0.13779112696647644,
-0.07110638916492462,
-0.7026283144950867,
-0.24512942135334015,
-0.11962588876485825,
0.7805253267288208,
0.01356737595051527,
0.13370682299137115,
-0.22771598398685455,
-0.08984901756048203,
0.028319157660007477,
-0.10713962465524673,
-0.860517144203186,
0.14220823347568512,
0.13934704661369324,
-0.5792934894561768,
-0.28296053409576416,
0.039265215396881104,
-0.9560297131538391,
-0.14647234976291656,
-0.2690119743347168,
0.022136325016617775,
-0.11290203034877777,
-0.40091708302497864,
0.11272189766168594,
-0.12388499081134796,
0.3351759612560272,
0.049085624516010284,
-1.212476134300232,
0.508404552936554,
0.8692082762718201,
0.8075579404830933,
0.0812566876411438,
-0.10530729591846466,
-0.9130215048789978,
0.20513920485973358,
-0.5727974772453308,
0.4441748261451721,
-0.4972512125968933,
-0.15070824325084686,
0.21723894774913788,
-0.26354503631591797,
-0.12856316566467285,
-0.3069894015789032,
0.5738216042518616,
-0.7012059688568115,
0.20890475809574127,
-0.2673918604850769,
-0.6251227855682373,
0.10207144170999527,
-0.06672756373882294,
-0.746389627456665,
1.029866099357605,
-0.1626761555671692,
-0.9704421162605286,
0.3951500952243805,
-0.8609153032302856,
-0.6770492196083069,
-0.10822396725416183,
0.011639096774160862,
-0.19941584765911102,
0.6077126264572144,
0.5125857591629028,
0.5492128133773804,
-0.5762857794761658,
0.18540869653224945,
-0.1278008222579956,
-0.12371068447828293,
0.18415462970733643,
-0.567431628704071,
0.8508555293083191,
0.6154741048812866,
-0.5154368281364441,
-0.17907951772212982,
-0.813361406326294,
0.22027195990085602,
0.22824513912200928,
-0.3782079517841339,
-0.19409680366516113,
0.48926472663879395,
-0.2095843255519867,
-0.08466474711894989,
0.13862036168575287,
-0.5602450966835022,
0.15892137587070465,
-0.4578154683113098,
0.9759529232978821,
0.5920242667198181,
0.04239939898252487,
0.6268989443778992,
0.10432479530572891,
0.40576404333114624,
-0.1580079197883606,
-0.002600795589387417,
-0.6008638143539429,
-0.1618151068687439,
-0.7069666385650635,
-0.2684415578842163,
0.579814612865448,
0.30052655935287476,
-0.6656166911125183,
0.32339295744895935,
-0.4474150538444519,
-0.13376502692699432,
-0.4747447371482849,
0.03057350032031536,
0.31459400057792664,
0.18322709202766418,
0.2638411521911621,
0.18600112199783325,
-0.5538126230239868,
-0.6610673666000366,
-0.5270829200744629,
-0.11312884092330933,
-0.19909624755382538,
0.32527023553848267,
0.23137818276882172,
-0.22777162492275238,
0.8781420588493347,
-0.5486729145050049,
0.44512486457824707,
-0.37572336196899414,
0.24817198514938354,
0.15745456516742706,
0.3119608759880066,
0.5172387361526489,
-0.6390285491943359,
-0.2687278687953949,
-0.16540248692035675,
-0.49189233779907227,
-0.19191493093967438,
0.02258884534239769,
0.12775126099586487,
0.4147978723049164,
0.7608525156974792,
-0.5403547286987305,
0.24617959558963776,
0.6238396167755127,
-0.17306514084339142,
0.43347498774528503,
-0.20278553664684296,
0.10468722134828568,
-1.152400016784668,
-0.00925137847661972,
-0.45826032757759094,
-0.37819361686706543,
-0.818428099155426,
0.3276323080062866,
-0.023459898307919502,
0.07916491478681564,
-0.16390636563301086,
0.6205231547355652,
-0.9016495943069458,
-0.4848147928714752,
-0.2581603527069092,
0.09761067479848862,
-0.12920881807804108,
0.23712337017059326,
0.01602799817919731,
0.5493901968002319,
0.5130226016044617,
-0.7110795974731445,
0.13088978826999664,
-0.3494642674922943,
-0.2900691330432892,
0.10862085968255997,
-0.46606409549713135,
0.2468843162059784,
-0.0411335751414299,
0.37184515595436096,
-0.9879043102264404,
-0.2868512272834778,
-0.11752413958311081,
-0.3160863518714905,
0.22438597679138184,
-0.13338670134544373,
-0.9041684865951538,
-0.4637008607387543,
-0.23073306679725647,
0.853248655796051,
0.536620020866394,
-0.7037321925163269,
0.714379608631134,
0.19044016301631927,
0.04276140779256821,
-0.7812698483467102,
-0.8187142610549927,
0.16926416754722595,
-0.11919580399990082,
-0.5223309397697449,
0.0973559319972992,
0.12063638120889664,
-0.5262355804443359,
0.06463281810283661,
0.10699767619371414,
0.059682779014110565,
0.19069387018680573,
-0.11337963491678238,
-0.13971585035324097,
-0.32333824038505554,
0.1237083226442337,
0.11116474866867065,
-0.07706721872091293,
0.07792776077985764,
-0.6645416617393494,
0.7340766191482544,
-0.012671899050474167,
-0.4383057653903961,
-0.16200949251651764,
0.36390575766563416,
0.5584570169448853,
-0.3259194493293762,
0.8607614040374756,
0.5501187443733215,
-0.26286211609840393,
-0.3488251864910126,
-0.6394985914230347,
-0.15694327652454376,
-0.42282840609550476,
0.1556357592344284,
-0.3770073652267456,
-0.761436939239502,
0.4975253939628601,
-0.2302566021680832,
0.5405541658401489,
0.8205432295799255,
0.7952415943145752,
0.10740736871957779,
1.143593668937683,
0.5517929792404175,
-0.11686280369758606,
0.7596656084060669,
-0.22337152063846588,
0.15042071044445038,
-0.6125199198722839,
0.1646910309791565,
-0.7154780030250549,
-0.23174497485160828,
-0.4554523229598999,
-0.6697056889533997,
0.1001136377453804,
0.09981139004230499,
-0.1732414811849594,
0.12147464603185654,
-0.20835502445697784,
0.5152347087860107,
0.6685727834701538,
-0.3309720754623413,
0.4587409198284149,
0.22735272347927094,
-0.1148972362279892,
0.19519062340259552,
-0.9427709579467773,
-0.17186735570430756,
1.3378257751464844,
0.2736845910549164,
0.6556434035301208,
0.11034020781517029,
0.6979419589042664,
0.30359533429145813,
0.29733988642692566,
-0.6147028207778931,
0.45907947421073914,
-0.14747712016105652,
-0.7373065948486328,
-0.5502297282218933,
-0.7995545268058777,
-1.0228400230407715,
0.27151602506637573,
-0.1559433788061142,
-0.4918425977230072,
-0.013323972932994366,
0.28334733843803406,
-0.024479810148477554,
0.6593997478485107,
-0.6408175826072693,
0.4251517653465271,
-0.06901305168867111,
-0.2285970151424408,
-0.4985118806362152,
-0.6514819860458374,
0.5861571431159973,
-0.14139267802238464,
0.4309288263320923,
0.28406915068626404,
-0.10060816258192062,
0.5745143890380859,
-0.5066621899604797,
0.701412558555603,
-0.16069531440734863,
-0.13968881964683533,
0.4993956685066223,
0.16370366513729095,
0.6368653178215027,
-0.018218733370304108,
-0.18480904400348663,
0.10941822826862335,
0.1688774973154068,
-0.5702164173126221,
-0.5633059740066528,
0.32620638608932495,
-0.4534370005130768,
-0.30475297570228577,
-0.0941130593419075,
-0.5091166496276855,
-0.2189405858516693,
0.2905098497867584,
0.5541599988937378,
0.6032307147979736,
-0.2797452509403229,
0.15900833904743195,
0.6770135760307312,
-0.22157207131385803,
0.6852824091911316,
0.2899995446205139,
-0.27145811915397644,
-0.40969517827033997,
0.8799190521240234,
0.14155487716197968,
0.5241841077804565,
0.7658712863922119,
0.25930678844451904,
-0.32546788454055786,
-0.5340531468391418,
-0.41509222984313965,
0.37488749623298645,
-0.4965152144432068,
-0.1079297885298729,
-0.5379610061645508,
-0.15112996101379395,
-0.6844710111618042,
-0.03787193074822426,
-0.39839819073677063,
-0.6254953742027283,
-0.31180834770202637,
-0.24707937240600586,
0.01705426163971424,
0.733943521976471,
-0.29262861609458923,
0.46366971731185913,
-0.792969286441803,
0.3517507016658783,
0.25395017862319946,
-0.0018267545383423567,
0.29476141929626465,
-0.17803046107292175,
-0.31234702467918396,
0.013298427686095238,
-0.03448868170380592,
-0.6230380535125732,
-0.0701051652431488,
0.23823820054531097,
0.506179690361023,
0.5564102530479431,
-0.1929742395877838,
0.5185778737068176,
-0.6685400009155273,
0.889549195766449,
0.2566671371459961,
-1.1310064792633057,
0.27039170265197754,
-0.2291477769613266,
0.19099190831184387,
0.21398138999938965,
0.002878733677789569,
-0.6436797976493835,
-0.16512399911880493,
-0.6810725331306458,
-0.6263794898986816,
0.4839031398296356,
0.15421779453754425,
0.25489264726638794,
-0.18810881674289703,
0.5190806984901428,
-0.0342852883040905,
0.21310101449489594,
-0.6443943977355957,
-0.22667597234249115,
-0.056979961693286896,
-0.30462533235549927,
-0.35382094979286194,
-0.41410180926322937,
-0.10514650493860245,
0.015898313373327255,
0.2027769237756729,
-0.38804998993873596,
0.31289586424827576,
-0.10835081338882446,
-0.3124335706233978,
-0.09080503135919571,
0.49404630064964294,
0.597326397895813,
0.8304718136787415,
0.1108253002166748,
0.29385441541671753,
0.24598556756973267,
-0.2602803111076355,
0.19460844993591309,
-0.15471628308296204,
-0.17179030179977417,
-0.013464095070958138,
0.9417757391929626,
0.8700770735740662,
0.1999702751636505,
-0.5145819783210754,
0.5137248039245605,
-0.10843388736248016,
-0.41437387466430664,
-0.05828119441866875,
0.012056639418005943,
0.10970116406679153,
0.14925608038902283,
0.43100640177726746,
-0.30628710985183716,
0.19928766787052155,
-0.6566053628921509,
0.03149593994021416,
0.6410079598426819,
0.11920703202486038,
-0.5112356543540955,
0.6058282852172852,
0.08376766741275787,
-0.20957033336162567,
0.654220461845398,
0.07035277783870697,
-0.21219518780708313,
0.4640231132507324,
0.7408215403556824,
1.061618447303772,
-0.10124513506889343,
0.11858798563480377,
0.39432835578918457,
0.21788190305233002,
-0.2695496380329132,
0.11097319424152374,
-0.38293173909187317,
-0.561188280582428,
-0.888746440410614,
-0.8529604077339172,
-0.17387370765209198,
-0.046536028385162354,
-0.6968694925308228,
-0.08161888271570206,
-0.41751325130462646,
-0.24017809331417084,
-0.13140256702899933,
0.014428933151066303,
-0.6826556921005249,
-0.06067611649632454,
0.13928355276584625,
1.1477948427200317,
-0.7875457406044006,
0.36596307158470154,
0.41163671016693115,
0.11630334705114365,
-0.7604095339775085,
0.023307915776968002,
-0.21458405256271362,
-0.6950880289077759,
0.5794759392738342,
-0.28061792254447937,
-0.27765053510665894,
0.1925741732120514,
-0.6225326657295227,
-0.8350825309753418,
0.9948047399520874,
0.5471965074539185,
-0.45061028003692627,
-0.469629168510437,
0.18885605037212372,
0.5426859259605408,
-0.36408641934394836,
0.23818758130073547,
0.9926242828369141,
0.3667560815811157,
0.09561936557292938,
-0.6073872447013855,
-0.017453623935580254,
0.21783941984176636,
0.057045310735702515,
0.5484174489974976,
-0.5791104435920715,
0.8732641339302063,
-0.19740554690361023,
-0.43338197469711304,
0.1399029642343521,
0.8183123469352722,
0.22581839561462402,
0.13305115699768066,
0.605512797832489,
0.6275070905685425,
0.8106567859649658,
0.017409157007932663,
1.1237510442733765,
-0.33976051211357117,
0.3815051317214966,
0.8352339863777161,
0.09110242128372192,
0.6418408751487732,
0.44792440533638,
-0.3339281976222992,
0.5331557393074036,
0.7000524997711182,
0.19339922070503235,
0.2377832531929016,
0.3442741632461548,
-0.31244316697120667,
-0.178048774600029,
0.18739883601665497,
-0.22251199185848236,
0.14395098388195038,
0.38904523849487305,
-0.45357418060302734,
-0.40273311734199524,
-0.11110755056142807,
0.04244418442249298,
-0.3827529847621918,
-0.4849855303764343,
0.9293203949928284,
0.08930356055498123,
-0.800502359867096,
0.2661742568016052,
0.25321200489997864,
0.4040464460849762,
-0.6287769079208374,
0.03637973591685295,
-0.32111290097236633,
0.14634594321250916,
-0.18366268277168274,
-0.46972745656967163,
0.00947554036974907,
0.10891246795654297,
-0.3583963215351105,
-0.2166239321231842,
0.5848636627197266,
-0.20829492807388306,
-0.7079697847366333,
0.21298864483833313,
0.531331479549408,
0.24589908123016357,
0.08763182908296585,
-0.35967883467674255,
-0.07700424641370773,
-0.1671231985092163,
-0.42185497283935547,
0.1128176748752594,
0.6325516700744629,
-0.12613165378570557,
0.602109432220459,
0.6583346128463745,
0.30118995904922485,
0.6660908460617065,
0.16642560064792633,
0.6060410141944885,
-0.7095540165901184,
-0.3450849652290344,
-1.1171629428863525,
0.19183258712291718,
0.21999678015708923,
0.03515623137354851,
0.7679285407066345,
0.41333186626434326,
0.6195526123046875,
0.0611383318901062,
0.7404435276985168,
-0.11993998289108276,
0.40883776545524597,
-0.8026941418647766,
0.16131465137004852,
-0.5235926508903503,
0.020886577665805817,
-0.35778382420539856,
-0.9779008626937866,
-0.35222309827804565,
0.06411612778902054,
-0.2010975331068039,
0.09879163652658463,
0.6213381886482239,
0.4623098075389862,
-0.04907437041401863,
-0.23784908652305603,
0.1340826153755188,
0.0735912173986435,
0.6223577260971069,
0.41280677914619446,
0.7439870834350586,
-0.25367236137390137,
0.5503267049789429,
0.15031661093235016,
-0.2732371985912323,
-0.3196827173233032,
-1.0321625471115112,
-0.7657808065414429,
-0.381268709897995,
0.14314086735248566,
-0.20251892507076263,
-0.3638443946838379,
0.6749497056007385,
0.7838032841682434,
-0.6904950737953186,
-0.3292606770992279,
-0.4041160047054291,
0.30817583203315735,
-0.4283680319786072,
-0.20950056612491608,
0.5022110939025879,
-0.7963359951972961,
-1.0107221603393555,
0.3273271918296814,
0.019229033961892128,
-0.2637854218482971,
-0.5254440903663635,
-0.021612586453557014,
0.027802230790257454,
0.45892396569252014,
0.8325971961021423,
0.43291667103767395,
-0.5959964990615845,
0.004838098306208849,
0.12287884205579758,
-0.0831739529967308,
-0.14873439073562622,
1.4266115427017212,
-0.482305645942688,
0.27152323722839355,
0.8086571097373962,
0.9190186262130737,
0.7879244089126587,
0.17378349602222443,
0.8027753233909607,
-0.6633518934249878,
-0.026623791083693504,
0.029562827199697495,
0.4217749536037445,
0.11013267189264297,
-0.19171655178070068,
0.5537042617797852,
0.3360016644001007,
-0.5197650790214539,
-1.1050583124160767,
0.5109682679176331,
-0.4140842854976654,
-0.4625961482524872,
1.0366098880767822,
0.1744779795408249,
-0.3927203118801117,
0.22277717292308807,
0.17625075578689575,
0.1891045719385147,
0.08370257914066315,
0.2860187590122223,
0.8753790855407715,
-0.2118452787399292,
-0.04925546422600746,
-0.5872218012809753,
0.5031052827835083,
0.434095174074173,
-0.7215112447738647,
0.44197627902030945,
0.548427402973175,
0.3911570608615875,
0.284184992313385,
0.7558884620666504,
-0.16427066922187805,
0.057780198752880096,
0.15736335515975952,
-0.0180838480591774,
0.05861432105302811,
-0.47527846693992615,
-0.4566493034362793,
0.27542006969451904,
0.07087080180644989,
-0.02637222222983837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16833v1 | USDC: A Dataset of $\underline{U}$ser $\underline{S}$tance and $\underline{D}$ogmatism in Long $\underline{C}$onversations | 2024-06-24T17:41:53 | 2024-06-24T17:41:53 | Mounika Marreddy, Subba Reddy Oota, Venkata Charan Chinni, Manish Gupta, Lucie Flek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Identifying user's opinions and stances in long conversation threads on
various topics can be extremely critical for enhanced personalization, market
research, political campaigns, customer service, conflict resolution, targeted
advertising, and content moderation. Hence, training language models to
automate this task is critical. However, to train such models, gathering manual
annotations has multiple challenges: 1) It is time-consuming and costly; 2)
Conversation threads could be very long, increasing chances of noisy
annotations; and 3) Interpreting instances where a user changes their opinion
within a conversation is difficult because often such transitions are subtle
and not expressed explicitly. Inspired by the recent success of large language
models (LLMs) for complex natural language processing (NLP) tasks, we leverage
Mistral Large and GPT-4 to automate the human annotation process on the
following two tasks while also providing reasoning: i) User Stance
classification, which involves labeling a user's stance of a post in a
conversation on a five-point scale; ii) User Dogmatism classification, which
deals with labeling a user's overall opinion in the conversation on a
four-point scale. The majority voting on zero-shot, one-shot, and few-shot
annotations from these two LLMs on 764 multi-user Reddit conversations helps us
curate the USDC dataset. USDC is then used to finetune and instruction-tune
multiple deployable small language models for the 5-class stance and 4-class
dogmatism classification tasks. We make the code and dataset publicly available
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/USDC-0F7F]. | [
-0.6646655201911926,
-0.6826112866401672,
0.6687439680099487,
0.10159315168857574,
-0.1797625869512558,
-0.09822347015142441,
-0.45550185441970825,
-0.5564360022544861,
-0.1982131004333496,
0.5407214760780334,
-0.4206046164035797,
-0.7104931473731995,
-0.5768114328384399,
0.3794559836387634,
-0.11581287533044815,
1.317511796951294,
-0.10302399843931198,
-0.1447524130344391,
-0.056106287986040115,
-0.3895585834980011,
-0.06881454586982727,
-0.694297730922699,
-0.7360987067222595,
-0.3983360528945923,
0.6919357180595398,
0.4304107129573822,
0.7665514349937439,
0.4642404615879059,
0.20698800683021545,
0.349426805973053,
0.05479401350021362,
0.053537290543317795,
-0.25585219264030457,
0.08386197686195374,
-0.2932664752006531,
-0.43432626128196716,
-0.43971237540245056,
0.5520958304405212,
0.35891419649124146,
0.5732670426368713,
-0.1294647604227066,
0.30404627323150635,
-0.11231448501348495,
0.3111326992511749,
-0.28409063816070557,
0.43719482421875,
-0.5786430239677429,
-0.171201691031456,
-0.18769410252571106,
0.20902876555919647,
-0.27032941579818726,
-0.22879576683044434,
0.10031906515359879,
-0.42071154713630676,
0.2013479620218277,
-0.04725101217627525,
0.978056788444519,
0.2139090746641159,
-0.4022614061832428,
-0.21175698935985565,
-0.5268197655677795,
0.9629525542259216,
-0.7620258927345276,
0.24600648880004883,
0.8170142769813538,
0.1942453384399414,
-0.04188898950815201,
-0.6254875659942627,
-0.757962167263031,
-0.399537593126297,
-0.14401330053806305,
-0.04120423272252083,
0.02585800737142563,
0.14429284632205963,
0.5422433614730835,
0.30741843581199646,
-0.12896426022052765,
0.31890472769737244,
-0.026008566841483116,
-0.13393963873386383,
0.7910171747207642,
0.15243957936763763,
0.04772011190652847,
-0.4132327735424042,
-0.3488115966320038,
0.018395107239484787,
-0.4180251955986023,
0.23858977854251862,
0.47579020261764526,
0.26181554794311523,
-0.1753360629081726,
0.4927537739276886,
-0.40790706872940063,
0.6439763903617859,
0.20688952505588531,
-0.12027539312839508,
0.2148265391588211,
-0.3620772659778595,
-0.17680220305919647,
-0.35218581557273865,
1.0441802740097046,
0.15340401232242584,
0.19363951683044434,
0.0034312340430915356,
-0.1632407307624817,
0.14806926250457764,
0.25873956084251404,
-0.7680967450141907,
-0.11178809404373169,
0.11740735173225403,
-0.16034725308418274,
-0.4634064733982086,
0.2452048659324646,
-0.7757816314697266,
-0.48652318120002747,
-0.8603858351707458,
0.07827932387590408,
0.0231087114661932,
-0.05460568889975548,
0.0347803570330143,
0.13576041162014008,
0.22829405963420868,
0.5106912851333618,
-1.032523512840271,
0.3673359155654907,
0.7247715592384338,
0.6602751016616821,
0.018690630793571472,
-0.087197445333004,
-0.23260557651519775,
-0.1440107822418213,
-0.12974566221237183,
0.8574734926223755,
-0.6860044598579407,
-0.19255447387695312,
-0.0775258019566536,
0.26512229442596436,
-0.026063809171319008,
-0.16175706684589386,
0.5622379779815674,
-0.4072157144546509,
0.32023146748542786,
-0.41070640087127686,
-0.4731421172618866,
-0.16287967562675476,
0.45679739117622375,
-0.4921451807022095,
1.0612883567810059,
0.22364209592342377,
-0.9372395873069763,
0.274004727602005,
-0.7666283845901489,
-0.3246651589870453,
-0.10309208184480667,
-0.4276205897331238,
-0.3852842450141907,
-0.04032532125711441,
0.4282325804233551,
0.7523661851882935,
-0.5135558843612671,
0.28095743060112,
-0.4670259952545166,
-0.08684930950403214,
0.4753221273422241,
-0.19127148389816284,
0.687261700630188,
0.23052985966205597,
-0.7041353583335876,
0.07888340204954147,
-0.756191074848175,
-0.044212523847818375,
0.10017719864845276,
-0.48502427339553833,
-0.3813193738460541,
-0.1219281330704689,
0.02162444032728672,
0.3689585030078888,
0.13270941376686096,
-0.5179842710494995,
0.4152149260044098,
-0.4044281542301178,
0.5464068651199341,
0.9607452154159546,
0.015521305613219738,
0.2916319668292999,
0.022776305675506592,
0.3588448464870453,
-0.010778180323541164,
0.10218644142150879,
-0.14209286868572235,
-0.49017518758773804,
-0.8901025056838989,
-0.18754151463508606,
0.3680332601070404,
0.5162071585655212,
-0.5394896268844604,
0.5724207162857056,
-0.21718665957450867,
-0.4456981122493744,
-0.5800529718399048,
0.24663960933685303,
0.3439100384712219,
0.36340615153312683,
0.3167964816093445,
-0.23204542696475983,
-0.41632184386253357,
-0.8586810827255249,
-0.08875870704650879,
-0.24002639949321747,
-0.16381803154945374,
0.3209570050239563,
0.4993552267551422,
-0.5227746367454529,
0.9550816416740417,
-0.34601616859436035,
-0.35930973291397095,
-0.15878093242645264,
0.7506069540977478,
-0.10433304309844971,
0.20642612874507904,
0.3448445796966553,
-0.5453485250473022,
-0.42319953441619873,
0.20042307674884796,
-0.6786274313926697,
-0.2748042643070221,
-0.34908467531204224,
-0.15017126500606537,
0.48263418674468994,
0.5644069314002991,
-0.6101250052452087,
0.4897388815879822,
0.48177191615104675,
-0.21010521054267883,
0.34426212310791016,
-0.023790935054421425,
0.29886630177497864,
-1.1570055484771729,
0.15085193514823914,
0.34440216422080994,
-0.25682333111763,
-0.35413074493408203,
-0.160689115524292,
-0.24571435153484344,
-0.019035914912819862,
-0.12110117077827454,
0.515275776386261,
-0.45378342270851135,
0.17364360392093658,
-0.24915240705013275,
0.18127314746379852,
-0.22221435606479645,
0.706878125667572,
0.04480808600783348,
0.6614200472831726,
0.23729318380355835,
-0.3043958842754364,
0.4749579429626465,
0.2409297674894333,
-0.0994366854429245,
0.6514801383018494,
-0.4810521602630615,
0.40359893441200256,
-0.07292941957712173,
0.36031925678253174,
-0.8000913858413696,
-0.3754698932170868,
0.4261739253997803,
-0.2980059087276459,
0.2130340188741684,
-0.24948449432849884,
-0.6747872829437256,
-0.29764798283576965,
-0.25004175305366516,
0.06653465330600739,
0.3169128894805908,
-0.4523092210292816,
0.5155277848243713,
0.6683078408241272,
-0.14598320424556732,
-0.45767655968666077,
-0.4104406535625458,
0.2835591435432434,
-0.025921521708369255,
-0.26546525955200195,
-0.09431330859661102,
0.11705471575260162,
-0.2779465913772583,
-0.16862553358078003,
0.09048285335302353,
0.1867758333683014,
0.010156986303627491,
0.5616109371185303,
0.035440120846033096,
-0.00005541913924389519,
0.24976341426372528,
-0.12845465540885925,
-0.3916539251804352,
0.11039542406797409,
-0.252378910779953,
0.42690348625183105,
-0.49566850066185,
-0.40687859058380127,
-0.67671799659729,
0.314117431640625,
0.5363807678222656,
-0.10238519310951233,
0.47644472122192383,
0.7267871499061584,
-0.2865292727947235,
-0.19112001359462738,
-0.8137950301170349,
-0.1323997974395752,
-0.4267462193965912,
0.28425052762031555,
-0.26309481263160706,
-0.8498148918151855,
0.36649206280708313,
-0.1101280003786087,
0.3690979778766632,
0.5345466136932373,
0.7078129649162292,
-0.2117748111486435,
1.2506498098373413,
0.5455768704414368,
-0.6018573045730591,
0.43112504482269287,
-0.25511446595191956,
0.03503479063510895,
-0.4536290466785431,
0.05716634541749954,
-0.6682758927345276,
-0.3689391314983368,
-0.4787698984146118,
-0.49467459321022034,
-0.05142999440431595,
-0.25526589155197144,
-0.28569918870925903,
0.2526104748249054,
-0.3875297009944916,
0.37605178356170654,
0.506447970867157,
-0.08765226602554321,
0.22251585125923157,
0.17950370907783508,
-0.01759955659508705,
-0.23165826499462128,
-0.2890656590461731,
-0.6814042329788208,
1.059080958366394,
0.4397270679473877,
0.8579820990562439,
-0.28541529178619385,
0.5480183362960815,
0.33400407433509827,
0.5853300094604492,
-0.8147667646408081,
0.7070829272270203,
0.031473904848098755,
-0.49968862533569336,
-0.2661893665790558,
-0.4905167818069458,
-0.7963146567344666,
-0.025796005502343178,
-0.26403865218162537,
-0.622273862361908,
-0.0816919356584549,
0.15675559639930725,
-0.29679903388023376,
0.35309162735939026,
-0.4666604995727539,
0.9872434735298157,
-0.2430894523859024,
-0.0817534476518631,
-0.16848447918891907,
-0.9129482507705688,
0.14102067053318024,
-0.0644882321357727,
0.23938585817813873,
-0.21170105040073395,
-0.03342710807919502,
0.6306374073028564,
-0.38639581203460693,
1.2781370878219604,
-0.23833326995372772,
-0.04449491202831268,
0.3434077203273773,
-0.2835776209831238,
0.5850362181663513,
0.15881867706775665,
0.12168225646018982,
0.42543643712997437,
-0.26858654618263245,
-0.18601815402507782,
-0.5047210454940796,
0.5650345087051392,
-0.9764980673789978,
-0.5434611439704895,
-0.6448830366134644,
-0.21552890539169312,
-0.24597540497779846,
0.0031499192118644714,
0.06841988116502762,
0.28339073061943054,
-0.1743079572916031,
0.11111732572317123,
0.4554835855960846,
0.13134931027889252,
0.23061144351959229,
0.24557536840438843,
-0.062300968915224075,
-0.4892186224460602,
0.6317573189735413,
0.012302925810217857,
0.1812605857849121,
0.059218477457761765,
0.2170436680316925,
-0.28997474908828735,
-0.369244247674942,
-0.5192989110946655,
0.44707852602005005,
-0.7822038531303406,
-0.19237740337848663,
-0.8290683031082153,
-0.15914225578308105,
-0.2908114194869995,
-0.1222066804766655,
-0.30950844287872314,
-0.4056585431098938,
-0.4605196416378021,
-0.2310885190963745,
0.43609151244163513,
0.7119784951210022,
0.08842013031244278,
0.40100395679473877,
-0.641607940196991,
0.38116884231567383,
0.5479921102523804,
0.2636290192604065,
-0.3290677070617676,
-0.4995366334915161,
-0.2454364150762558,
0.2255592793226242,
-0.3305986821651459,
-0.7183573842048645,
0.016936110332608223,
0.220767080783844,
0.503715455532074,
0.5847645401954651,
0.1278466135263443,
0.7592211961746216,
-0.3228676915168762,
0.7634117007255554,
0.13264839351177216,
-0.9137037396430969,
0.5345491170883179,
-0.35651877522468567,
0.2160317748785019,
0.856099009513855,
0.5838935375213623,
-0.806175947189331,
-0.6696823835372925,
-0.6830276250839233,
-0.740353524684906,
0.8984755873680115,
0.14222638309001923,
0.1212170273065567,
-0.09434660524129868,
0.45916908979415894,
0.13692151010036469,
0.2318587601184845,
-0.8207067251205444,
-0.10855543613433838,
-0.19843615591526031,
-0.486057311296463,
-0.12320030480623245,
-0.24929748475551605,
-0.35914576053619385,
-0.43800845742225647,
0.70918869972229,
-0.41810688376426697,
-0.036358542740345,
0.03012966550886631,
-0.055988945066928864,
-0.09622656553983688,
0.3488466143608093,
0.35927700996398926,
0.5233592391014099,
0.03700326755642891,
0.24426184594631195,
0.24560298025608063,
-0.3997449278831482,
0.12615114450454712,
0.3147119879722595,
-0.21523599326610565,
-0.14566929638385773,
0.06540633738040924,
0.825948178768158,
0.41941994428634644,
-0.47433242201805115,
0.5587882995605469,
-0.16792063415050507,
-0.19416750967502594,
-0.45596304535865784,
-0.17238229513168335,
0.1520334780216217,
0.11389671266078949,
-0.02743677794933319,
0.16930370032787323,
-0.12202595174312592,
-0.547295093536377,
0.15911529958248138,
0.36565011739730835,
-0.43362319469451904,
-0.695645272731781,
0.5468923449516296,
0.3019315004348755,
0.02287561073899269,
0.5805971026420593,
-0.32997894287109375,
-0.595196545124054,
0.185029998421669,
0.0684371367096901,
0.9391224980354309,
-0.09284999966621399,
0.28718850016593933,
0.5637540817260742,
0.19371800124645233,
-0.2699037194252014,
0.024568814784288406,
-0.27767413854599,
-0.5262054204940796,
-0.30692288279533386,
-0.8052229881286621,
-0.3480779230594635,
0.07061044871807098,
-0.48507383465766907,
0.4227488040924072,
-0.7053278088569641,
-0.5211876630783081,
0.2504512071609497,
0.08327841013669968,
-0.774559497833252,
0.035351093858480453,
0.3153650462627411,
0.35245925188064575,
-1.004960536956787,
0.7737879157066345,
0.8017533421516418,
-0.6529781818389893,
-0.8124881982803345,
-0.1407097429037094,
0.2253723293542862,
-0.6348041296005249,
0.6374728679656982,
0.2830449044704437,
-0.11623450368642807,
-0.06946166604757309,
-0.8276405334472656,
-0.5364582538604736,
0.7921193242073059,
0.033487219363451004,
-0.4310990273952484,
0.04288477823138237,
0.3530151844024658,
0.7003580331802368,
-0.37833768129348755,
0.06890595704317093,
0.7384592890739441,
0.5881384611129761,
-0.02628365159034729,
-0.9251762628555298,
0.12658220529556274,
-0.09584375470876694,
-0.11895978450775146,
0.18422718346118927,
-0.48725369572639465,
0.8526474833488464,
-0.17889156937599182,
-0.3440302312374115,
-0.10756164789199829,
0.5544981360435486,
-0.022110460326075554,
0.1674148589372635,
0.8660991191864014,
0.771050214767456,
0.504281222820282,
-0.20335575938224792,
0.8510395884513855,
-0.061121340841054916,
0.5172738432884216,
1.0412472486495972,
-0.10405492782592773,
0.8266719579696655,
0.36829474568367004,
-0.36501458287239075,
0.4789066016674042,
0.7288520336151123,
-0.14644856750965118,
0.06907227635383606,
0.246900737285614,
-0.2853202521800995,
-0.4487217366695404,
0.1232660561800003,
-0.16559191048145294,
0.4782847464084625,
0.3651661276817322,
-0.19336988031864166,
-0.2987520098686218,
-0.0204632431268692,
0.45859625935554504,
0.07187172025442123,
-0.11656541377305984,
1.1435078382492065,
0.2197030931711197,
-0.6920522451400757,
0.4615555703639984,
0.16152985394001007,
0.6493407487869263,
-0.5798470377922058,
-0.013010841794312,
-0.09107796847820282,
0.19408278167247772,
-0.1780289262533188,
-0.6022893190383911,
0.10736870765686035,
0.20011554658412933,
-0.039836492389440536,
-0.19616365432739258,
0.5694662928581238,
-0.5273842811584473,
-0.6057683229446411,
0.11931054294109344,
0.21269775927066803,
0.19091951847076416,
-0.2158864140510559,
-0.9254498481750488,
-0.13319312036037445,
-0.005515897646546364,
-0.5551446676254272,
0.2957824170589447,
0.4919258654117584,
-0.3354785144329071,
0.430515319108963,
0.9360543489456177,
0.08151516318321228,
-0.058949682861566544,
0.3231751322746277,
0.9719358086585999,
-0.805382251739502,
-0.41336512565612793,
-0.7392709851264954,
0.4383485019207001,
-0.4160287082195282,
-0.2910325229167938,
0.5701307058334351,
0.2439829707145691,
0.914034903049469,
0.0078045520931482315,
0.8700965642929077,
-0.12202093005180359,
0.5964819192886353,
-0.27071645855903625,
0.7769832015037537,
-0.47222670912742615,
0.1735265851020813,
-0.15342195332050323,
-0.6419695019721985,
-0.41519758105278015,
0.7804600596427917,
-0.3189474046230316,
0.026649825274944305,
0.554427444934845,
0.5965062379837036,
0.045645516365766525,
0.1962517946958542,
0.015715476125478745,
0.14659617841243744,
0.5318779945373535,
0.23179668188095093,
0.8217158317565918,
-0.2932754456996918,
0.5439658761024475,
-0.3825833797454834,
-0.24564634263515472,
-0.2583857774734497,
-0.8099241852760315,
-1.1232911348342896,
-0.5600439310073853,
-0.48367226123809814,
-0.24668504297733307,
-0.2530137300491333,
1.3153661489486694,
0.6934774518013,
-0.9504250288009644,
-0.17436712980270386,
0.015459501184523106,
-0.15966925024986267,
-0.049100276082754135,
-0.1982596516609192,
0.30957603454589844,
-0.6317688822746277,
-0.7717078328132629,
-0.037914127111434937,
0.2042122781276703,
0.1745195984840393,
-0.42419496178627014,
0.06026696413755417,
-0.2224402129650116,
0.004253868013620377,
0.5074203610420227,
0.5903671383857727,
-1.093525767326355,
-0.5870074033737183,
-0.19369564950466156,
-0.39299267530441284,
0.06654589623212814,
0.9155624508857727,
-0.5688580274581909,
0.5972405672073364,
0.18383672833442688,
0.7867012023925781,
0.42851394414901733,
0.3339935839176178,
0.4602285921573639,
-0.846380352973938,
0.29951003193855286,
0.27561330795288086,
0.29349496960639954,
0.34328699111938477,
-0.16845856606960297,
0.4844335913658142,
0.371949702501297,
-0.7792804837226868,
-0.6408034563064575,
0.16402728855609894,
-1.1775352954864502,
-0.08104310184717178,
1.2453405857086182,
-0.30610620975494385,
-0.17447279393672943,
-0.35940244793891907,
-0.5806475877761841,
0.14228813350200653,
-0.45001980662345886,
0.9115908741950989,
0.8143349885940552,
0.08744048327207565,
0.009812469594180584,
-0.6874154806137085,
0.7456985712051392,
0.09264437854290009,
-1.0452200174331665,
0.35877102613449097,
0.6851351261138916,
0.3167497217655182,
0.13629932701587677,
0.7453315854072571,
-0.06158963218331337,
-0.10094615072011948,
-0.16304442286491394,
0.2394922971725464,
-0.14627324044704437,
-0.15734261274337769,
-0.29385021328926086,
0.07621779292821884,
0.02177874930202961,
-0.15702123939990997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16829v1 | Understanding and Mitigating Tokenization Bias in Language Models | 2024-06-24T17:38:02 | 2024-06-24T17:38:02 | Buu Phan, Marton Havasi, Matthew Muckley, Karen Ullrich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | State-of-the-art language models are autoregressive and operate on subword
units known as tokens. Specifically, one must encode the conditioning string
into a list of tokens before passing to the language models for next-token
prediction. We show that, for encoding schemes such as maximum prefix matching,
tokenization induces a sampling bias that cannot be mitigated with more
training or data. To counter this universal problem, we propose a novel
algorithm to obtain unbiased estimates from a model that was trained on
tokenized data. Our method does not require finetuning the model, and its
complexity, defined as the number of model runs, scales linearly with the
sequence length. As a consequence, we show that one can simulate token-free
behavior from a tokenized language model. We empirically verify the correctness
of our method through a Markov-chain setup, where it accurately recovers the
transition probabilities, as opposed to the conventional method of directly
prompting tokens into the language model. | [
-0.13736166059970856,
-0.5870600938796997,
0.265785813331604,
0.026539286598563194,
-0.4597689211368561,
0.0406140461564064,
-0.28156429529190063,
-0.1552063673734665,
0.1698439121246338,
0.4918939769268036,
-0.3857710361480713,
-0.3440156579017639,
-0.647152841091156,
-0.22757528722286224,
-0.4844675660133362,
1.1111112833023071,
0.14380432665348053,
0.5206676721572876,
-0.10896121710538864,
-0.13885129988193512,
-0.5535622239112854,
-0.8740131258964539,
-0.5773390531539917,
-0.4148997664451599,
0.09071407467126846,
0.03355753794312477,
0.6467583775520325,
0.7339087128639221,
0.2988522946834564,
0.13387541472911835,
-0.2174069583415985,
-0.0779494121670723,
-0.31548306345939636,
0.04402755945920944,
-0.14986884593963623,
-0.6351361274719238,
-0.14576637744903564,
0.19363859295845032,
0.5245431661605835,
0.9208621978759766,
-0.23113766312599182,
0.3050529658794403,
-0.19824935495853424,
0.36522912979125977,
-0.6251664161682129,
0.10408555716276169,
-1.007668375968933,
0.12986354529857635,
-0.31280437111854553,
-0.12772509455680847,
-0.7824534177780151,
0.030778158456087112,
-0.13241779804229736,
-0.41573527455329895,
0.27225691080093384,
0.28891846537590027,
0.5271438956260681,
0.10859297960996628,
-0.46717923879623413,
-0.06467143446207047,
-0.6231381297111511,
0.8781489729881287,
-0.7916893362998962,
0.5133869647979736,
0.5544204115867615,
-0.033542267978191376,
-0.24222515523433685,
-0.42519187927246094,
-0.4960905909538269,
-0.20465661585330963,
0.03660326823592186,
-0.2541565001010895,
-0.24556872248649597,
0.2489486187696457,
0.35865452885627747,
0.2816295325756073,
-0.2393503189086914,
0.18856416642665863,
-0.28660693764686584,
-0.35779309272766113,
0.25750991702079773,
-0.03794218227267265,
0.33947309851646423,
-0.10602276027202606,
-0.40636318922042847,
-0.015542203560471535,
-0.5426834225654602,
-0.028211912140250206,
0.57892906665802,
0.45663076639175415,
0.22546522319316864,
0.5889865756034851,
0.012816524133086205,
0.5591041445732117,
0.24625124037265778,
0.3262803554534912,
0.22119644284248352,
-0.45238494873046875,
-0.29997843503952026,
0.012594799511134624,
0.5410215854644775,
0.3904118537902832,
0.5020732283592224,
-0.392284631729126,
-0.342885285615921,
0.15595300495624542,
0.10568088293075562,
-0.6518355011940002,
-0.11699291318655014,
0.13113465905189514,
-0.4856301248073578,
-0.2723778188228607,
-0.03085477277636528,
-0.6185434460639954,
-0.2833954989910126,
-0.13796289265155792,
0.2722712457180023,
-0.16318079829216003,
-0.3499229848384857,
0.0727337971329689,
-0.2762841582298279,
-0.017502130940556526,
-0.22103358805179596,
-1.0648876428604126,
0.5846648216247559,
0.5237201452255249,
0.7599167227745056,
-0.10473935306072235,
-0.1268286556005478,
-0.6875942349433899,
0.006437399424612522,
-0.5987529754638672,
0.4130636155605316,
-0.7256764769554138,
-0.4116765558719635,
-0.005543035920709372,
-0.20399998128414154,
-0.04014316201210022,
-0.367276132106781,
0.3602161705493927,
-0.6569363474845886,
0.007365650497376919,
-0.22989985346794128,
-0.7530280947685242,
0.24888397753238678,
-0.01959230564534664,
-0.636107861995697,
1.01007878780365,
-0.01746983453631401,
-1.0524471998214722,
0.5803718566894531,
-0.48661819100379944,
-0.23523743450641632,
-0.33698540925979614,
0.062420304864645004,
-0.15896070003509521,
0.6061643362045288,
0.512631893157959,
0.11420489847660065,
-0.13447454571723938,
0.4485124945640564,
-0.31385499238967896,
-0.30821946263313293,
0.3189988136291504,
-0.6163873672485352,
0.714937150478363,
0.23535163700580597,
-0.32625675201416016,
0.14421026408672333,
-0.4707159399986267,
-0.1253272145986557,
-0.06165415421128273,
-0.21302740275859833,
-0.6062144637107849,
0.024580929428339005,
0.07899083197116852,
0.07198945432901382,
-0.017679309472441673,
-0.6812688112258911,
0.2789944112300873,
-0.6006023287773132,
0.4147789478302002,
1.096800446510315,
-0.07419361174106598,
0.7428738474845886,
0.05716881901025772,
0.5243170261383057,
0.3488900661468506,
0.2602103054523468,
-0.39786139130592346,
-0.32317569851875305,
-0.9109019637107849,
-0.04092073068022728,
0.7817568182945251,
0.2951483130455017,
-0.5878155827522278,
0.27709993720054626,
-0.15357355773448944,
-0.09273719042539597,
-0.5307576060295105,
-0.046015866100788116,
0.5055586099624634,
0.38086679577827454,
0.32321619987487793,
-0.6624731421470642,
-0.8328260779380798,
-0.812652587890625,
-0.6624961495399475,
-0.26470261812210083,
0.04099704697728157,
0.06881575286388397,
0.43176212906837463,
-0.06630377471446991,
1.1029471158981323,
-0.1870027482509613,
0.058579444885253906,
-0.1676614135503769,
0.20322944223880768,
0.22253377735614777,
0.8337001800537109,
0.3713100552558899,
-0.38468509912490845,
-0.1419025957584381,
-0.20062756538391113,
-0.15033189952373505,
-0.20607221126556396,
-0.034094568341970444,
-0.18640470504760742,
0.40934625267982483,
0.6776605248451233,
-0.4608669877052307,
0.6833108067512512,
0.43920955061912537,
-0.569642186164856,
0.3629607558250427,
-0.2718888223171234,
-0.26122817397117615,
-0.9164451360702515,
0.21943314373493195,
-0.08356104791164398,
-0.303208589553833,
-0.7317458987236023,
-0.04099326580762863,
-0.13042621314525604,
0.13440698385238647,
-0.20263221859931946,
0.8819939494132996,
-0.5670725107192993,
-0.13902238011360168,
-0.39164093136787415,
-0.14738430082798004,
-0.13439974188804626,
0.4808962643146515,
-0.012820414267480373,
0.6847522854804993,
0.5233568549156189,
-0.5936935544013977,
0.01666710339486599,
0.025421874597668648,
-0.2991234362125397,
0.2021225243806839,
-0.5944049954414368,
0.254351943731308,
-0.3822438418865204,
0.4511761963367462,
-0.8785873055458069,
0.20539365708827972,
0.02668869122862816,
-0.6253275871276855,
0.20349346101284027,
-0.4338681101799011,
-0.4768907427787781,
-0.2793056070804596,
-0.04704489931464195,
0.773556649684906,
0.654363214969635,
-0.4764747619628906,
0.4873657822608948,
0.6280396580696106,
0.3221830427646637,
-0.900341808795929,
-0.7134026288986206,
0.0382065512239933,
-0.06716092675924301,
0.09652417153120041,
0.12198691815137863,
-0.09448417276144028,
-0.20290923118591309,
-0.1008327528834343,
-0.28265342116355896,
0.0622909851372242,
0.2632005512714386,
0.007098583970218897,
0.19506089389324188,
0.16892670094966888,
0.17125192284584045,
-0.028461406007409096,
-0.14899864792823792,
0.12467973679304123,
-1.008190393447876,
0.8307223916053772,
0.3431021571159363,
-0.5708933472633362,
-0.2555494010448456,
0.21685299277305603,
0.5553176999092102,
-0.2338394969701767,
0.7375760674476624,
0.5136821269989014,
-0.6062784790992737,
-0.2842947840690613,
-0.6585227251052856,
-0.30718496441841125,
-0.37972161173820496,
0.44751569628715515,
-0.3281525671482086,
-0.6016075015068054,
0.698334276676178,
0.2982126772403717,
0.16077862679958344,
0.26746901869773865,
0.6527686715126038,
0.4449431002140045,
1.346169114112854,
0.6662693023681641,
-0.4496942460536957,
0.588283121585846,
-0.07723255455493927,
0.23412573337554932,
-0.8499338030815125,
-0.2240612506866455,
-0.4926951229572296,
-0.10792367905378342,
-0.5339665412902832,
-0.6248770952224731,
0.019535982981324196,
0.09768140316009521,
-0.12077919393777847,
0.20417363941669464,
-0.2996716797351837,
0.6758857369422913,
0.8606909513473511,
-0.22331050038337708,
0.11825040727853775,
0.08098965883255005,
-0.7650116682052612,
0.11522816121578217,
-0.7517322301864624,
-0.1826947182416916,
1.2441741228103638,
0.3157588839530945,
0.7346003651618958,
-0.11414343863725662,
0.40703222155570984,
0.42797642946243286,
0.2801700830459595,
-0.6243957877159119,
0.23787249624729156,
-0.13567624986171722,
-0.8597116470336914,
-0.27521854639053345,
-0.38835784792900085,
-0.8229685425758362,
0.35698992013931274,
-0.10183649510145187,
-0.9752916693687439,
0.29799342155456543,
0.3610185980796814,
-0.07479306310415268,
0.5694668292999268,
-0.47275617718696594,
0.6434711217880249,
0.05871552973985672,
-0.09482943266630173,
-0.10143198817968369,
-0.4454037547111511,
0.29452183842658997,
-0.056279998272657394,
0.4624156057834625,
-0.16633149981498718,
0.05211428925395012,
0.8785598874092102,
-0.5458947420120239,
0.8644288778305054,
-0.39795389771461487,
0.11020096391439438,
0.13825620710849762,
0.1804291158914566,
0.5676113367080688,
-0.08558762073516846,
-0.0939374789595604,
0.004279495216906071,
0.06280642002820969,
-0.7197068333625793,
-0.4990535080432892,
0.419852077960968,
-0.6201655268669128,
-0.4211989939212799,
-0.38506200909614563,
-0.5133734941482544,
-0.3864924907684326,
0.17931948602199554,
0.3216889500617981,
0.42751172184944153,
-0.42113223671913147,
-0.20142070949077606,
0.399659126996994,
-0.049571774899959564,
0.5414242148399353,
0.2677362263202667,
-0.46007415652275085,
-0.49052688479423523,
0.5684633255004883,
0.15342041850090027,
0.2820119261741638,
0.12218337506055832,
0.2889308035373688,
-0.47074803709983826,
-0.5725287795066833,
-0.48181167244911194,
0.058753035962581635,
-0.7066039443016052,
-0.06975466012954712,
-0.5959828495979309,
0.06000422313809395,
-0.5243439078330994,
0.29142457246780396,
-0.29730889201164246,
-0.5570507645606995,
-0.10835276544094086,
-0.34025511145591736,
0.14051391184329987,
0.702498733997345,
-0.10488547384738922,
0.30208340287208557,
-0.5712089538574219,
-0.18166543543338776,
0.12644214928150177,
0.5006863474845886,
0.28357431292533875,
-0.7451555132865906,
-0.3394943177700043,
0.047650065273046494,
0.27567869424819946,
-0.7553028464317322,
0.3498777747154236,
0.10982757061719894,
0.625399649143219,
0.418817937374115,
0.04781556874513626,
0.6743503212928772,
-0.716366171836853,
0.7775371670722961,
0.1815974861383438,
-1.4165141582489014,
0.343425452709198,
-0.18856893479824066,
0.215125173330307,
0.5236076712608337,
0.08552992343902588,
-0.8953570127487183,
-0.3042193353176117,
-0.7442196607589722,
-0.8906429409980774,
0.6560425162315369,
0.20581503212451935,
0.48806414008140564,
-0.4249529242515564,
0.47526243329048157,
-0.01751408353447914,
0.40813347697257996,
-0.669387698173523,
-0.17640282213687897,
-0.18377970159053802,
-0.25678902864456177,
-0.15662750601768494,
-0.4247933030128479,
0.07338272780179977,
-0.1950022429227829,
0.8050414323806763,
-0.23890022933483124,
0.1425788551568985,
-0.016168411821126938,
-0.32649755477905273,
-0.07371647655963898,
0.10730981826782227,
0.44025278091430664,
0.5172094702720642,
0.006449529435485601,
0.2974470257759094,
0.28398755192756653,
-0.4202865958213806,
0.12185973674058914,
-0.1852031648159027,
-0.39628952741622925,
0.2827843725681305,
0.1426408439874649,
1.0485246181488037,
0.035501185804605484,
-0.6356070637702942,
0.7047436833381653,
-0.11545460671186447,
0.1552504003047943,
-0.1326100379228592,
-0.33698004484176636,
-0.15058103203773499,
-0.08800782263278961,
0.3479453921318054,
0.07327160984277725,
0.033435091376304626,
-0.4869457185268402,
0.2673902213573456,
0.7747400999069214,
-0.6617428660392761,
-0.5426751971244812,
0.8359904885292053,
0.2086574286222458,
-0.2034335881471634,
0.6041178703308105,
-0.02767857350409031,
-0.565588116645813,
0.5981402397155762,
0.7003370523452759,
0.897667407989502,
-0.21211788058280945,
-0.010520408861339092,
0.4000645577907562,
0.333374559879303,
-0.3557572662830353,
0.10490654408931732,
-0.08082183450460434,
-0.8549396395683289,
-0.3887459933757782,
-0.8039054870605469,
-0.2320813685655594,
0.04216690734028816,
-0.7587814927101135,
-0.03676149994134903,
-0.42008915543556213,
-0.5684582591056824,
-0.21997834742069244,
-0.2796182930469513,
-0.6624234318733215,
0.16307146847248077,
0.2197730988264084,
1.0848356485366821,
-0.9959048628807068,
0.9146872162818909,
0.39389926195144653,
-0.43463101983070374,
-0.6897768974304199,
0.0532187782227993,
-0.18080365657806396,
-0.9318519234657288,
0.6736589670181274,
0.09974432736635208,
0.07089705020189285,
0.0040026092901825905,
-0.45740535855293274,
-0.9883254170417786,
0.4819417893886566,
0.3610227704048157,
-0.3159525990486145,
-0.2046261727809906,
0.11444980651140213,
0.3939872086048126,
-0.420460969209671,
0.4398081302642822,
0.7326974272727966,
0.29909664392471313,
-0.1306399255990982,
-0.9803856015205383,
0.024598093703389168,
-0.30337831377983093,
0.39666590094566345,
0.17735709249973297,
-0.3565145432949066,
0.8563459515571594,
-0.0774957686662674,
-0.21587441861629486,
0.10665541142225266,
0.706178605556488,
-0.032713860273361206,
-0.10198044776916504,
0.7009145617485046,
0.5191385746002197,
0.8825336694717407,
0.04513278231024742,
0.7880687713623047,
-0.6737282872200012,
0.47351935505867004,
1.046708583831787,
-0.04969611391425133,
0.6112050414085388,
0.8441192507743835,
-0.05619705840945244,
0.3682596981525421,
0.6118616461753845,
0.09042899310588837,
0.3759024143218994,
0.7761477828025818,
-0.11903158575296402,
-0.22189657390117645,
-0.45825618505477905,
-0.04104581102728844,
0.3654308319091797,
0.03339088708162308,
-0.6012409925460815,
-0.0468057356774807,
0.1159512847661972,
0.19759567081928253,
-0.006304403301328421,
-0.3589561879634857,
0.7406906485557556,
-0.05833382532000542,
-0.8409798741340637,
0.4801519811153412,
0.243918314576149,
0.8040604591369629,
-0.36925363540649414,
0.25134769082069397,
-0.4280828833580017,
0.08291850239038467,
0.016440577805042267,
-0.14515092968940735,
0.19797387719154358,
0.14923979341983795,
-0.21316885948181152,
-0.061638448387384415,
0.32885441184043884,
-0.5437137484550476,
-0.6370090842247009,
0.14147023856639862,
0.6150268316268921,
0.12262033671140671,
0.1711563766002655,
-0.3947325050830841,
-0.028848394751548767,
-0.11685363203287125,
-0.19996324181556702,
0.3643152415752411,
0.23943589627742767,
-0.41120514273643494,
0.5774345397949219,
0.7892836332321167,
0.2747170031070709,
0.30074232816696167,
0.38057228922843933,
0.703008770942688,
-0.47852009534835815,
-0.64447420835495,
-1.1094306707382202,
0.2146947681903839,
-0.08121485263109207,
-0.1384744495153427,
0.5712080597877502,
0.586231529712677,
1.002360463142395,
0.01370704360306263,
0.7702997326850891,
0.3323618471622467,
0.22965700924396515,
-0.601963996887207,
0.5430536270141602,
-0.22317014634609222,
0.34999915957450867,
-0.032483022660017014,
-0.6251034736633301,
-0.30026674270629883,
0.38548019528388977,
-0.10999316722154617,
0.13864769041538239,
0.5515298247337341,
0.757095456123352,
-0.045649535953998566,
-0.26541563868522644,
0.21110068261623383,
-0.03502819687128067,
0.20007164776325226,
0.2589159309864044,
0.5316117405891418,
-0.41119256615638733,
0.28259116411209106,
-0.062294382601976395,
-0.10572037845849991,
0.03188434988260269,
-0.8971747159957886,
-1.0796986818313599,
-0.5424059629440308,
-0.04668041318655014,
-0.49929454922676086,
0.25827109813690186,
1.2507485151290894,
0.9333396553993225,
-0.9322976469993591,
-0.3617536723613739,
-0.31630438566207886,
0.19110573828220367,
-0.16320815682411194,
-0.1355687975883484,
0.2846495509147644,
-0.6504241824150085,
-0.9406099319458008,
0.1498062163591385,
-0.06855987012386322,
0.1343572735786438,
-0.5115260481834412,
0.0940016508102417,
-0.06715811043977737,
0.615175187587738,
0.24023644626140594,
0.03936184570193291,
-0.7980765700340271,
-0.28824305534362793,
-0.03684740886092186,
0.14328575134277344,
0.12724906206130981,
1.1413750648498535,
-0.8597918748855591,
0.572658360004425,
0.4613787531852722,
0.6146780848503113,
0.35952964425086975,
0.035847246646881104,
0.8863586783409119,
-0.9914451837539673,
0.22887356579303741,
0.009306168183684349,
0.5022183060646057,
0.31873515248298645,
-0.237785205245018,
0.38373544812202454,
0.318795382976532,
-0.23616719245910645,
-1.1496511697769165,
0.5021318793296814,
-0.4224071502685547,
-0.2945981025695801,
1.1088780164718628,
-0.03542109206318855,
-0.33956772089004517,
-0.13267813622951508,
0.022476674988865852,
0.38655537366867065,
-0.41456788778305054,
0.6443057060241699,
0.7755160927772522,
0.18247736990451813,
0.09626022726297379,
-0.23085586726665497,
0.7118626832962036,
0.5459644794464111,
-0.2571790814399719,
0.37848782539367676,
0.19449810683727264,
0.3862350285053253,
-0.11582454293966293,
0.7908335328102112,
-0.08113660663366318,
-0.0666004866361618,
0.09148664027452469,
0.21004581451416016,
-0.03249495476484299,
-0.03932921960949898,
-0.6081491708755493,
-0.08722980320453644,
0.29142406582832336,
-0.3105941414833069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16828v1 | Ragnarök: A Reusable RAG Framework and Baselines for TREC 2024 Retrieval-Augmented Generation Track | 2024-06-24T17:37:52 | 2024-06-24T17:37:52 | Ronak Pradeep, Nandan Thakur, Sahel Sharifymoghaddam, Eric Zhang, Ryan Nguyen, Daniel Campos, Nick Craswell, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Did you try out the new Bing Search? Or maybe you fiddled around with Google
AI~Overviews? These might sound familiar because the modern-day search stack
has recently evolved to include retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems.
They allow searching and incorporating real-time data into large language
models (LLMs) to provide a well-informed, attributed, concise summary in
contrast to the traditional search paradigm that relies on displaying a ranked
list of documents. Therefore, given these recent advancements, it is crucial to
have an arena to build, test, visualize, and systematically evaluate RAG-based
search systems. With this in mind, we propose the TREC 2024 RAG Track to foster
innovation in evaluating RAG systems. In our work, we lay out the steps we've
made towards making this track a reality -- we describe the details of our
reusable framework, Ragnar\"ok, explain the curation of the new MS MARCO V2.1
collection choice, release the development topics for the track, and
standardize the I/O definitions which assist the end user. Next, using
Ragnar\"ok, we identify and provide key industrial baselines such as OpenAI's
GPT-4o or Cohere's Command R+. Further, we introduce a web-based user interface
for an interactive arena allowing benchmarking pairwise RAG systems by
crowdsourcing. We open-source our Ragnar\"ok framework and baselines to achieve
a unified standard for future RAG systems. | [
-0.764236330986023,
-0.3428736627101898,
0.48610204458236694,
0.0367216058075428,
-0.16819113492965698,
0.5373897552490234,
0.10407897084951401,
-0.5668847560882568,
0.45883801579475403,
0.741841733455658,
-0.4242909848690033,
-0.34660831093788147,
-0.1681106686592102,
0.10154677927494049,
-0.4285639822483063,
1.2519577741622925,
-0.2516922950744629,
-0.3786201775074005,
-0.26430654525756836,
-0.3802400529384613,
-0.6439626216888428,
-0.1939498633146286,
-0.6978541016578674,
-0.4312126040458679,
0.7726893424987793,
0.5495338439941406,
0.4433101713657379,
0.7134923338890076,
0.6732101440429688,
0.2431049942970276,
-0.1897854059934616,
0.1664963960647583,
-0.502730667591095,
0.5259292125701904,
-0.4474961757659912,
-0.28170064091682434,
-0.8659682273864746,
0.35855889320373535,
0.604739785194397,
0.33185210824012756,
-0.13179774582386017,
0.6058738231658936,
-0.06767915189266205,
0.5458769202232361,
-0.7062165141105652,
-0.23740185797214508,
-0.7844666242599487,
0.12082439661026001,
-0.49806520342826843,
-0.5106432437896729,
-0.3716154098510742,
-0.04031696543097496,
-0.14537763595581055,
-0.9282786250114441,
0.43970662355422974,
0.39234548807144165,
1.0171396732330322,
0.18568144738674164,
-0.3506128787994385,
-0.33371496200561523,
-0.669533371925354,
0.9097461700439453,
-0.2391280233860016,
0.4916425943374634,
0.24256090819835663,
0.6897807717323303,
-0.20193876326084137,
-1.3272645473480225,
-0.1958189755678177,
-0.3421209156513214,
0.18920741975307465,
0.4110875725746155,
0.17901046574115753,
-0.1845685839653015,
0.13353948295116425,
0.483318030834198,
-0.6739476919174194,
-0.05261005833745003,
-0.2022649049758911,
0.10851415246725082,
0.41252651810646057,
0.33737948536872864,
0.08000336587429047,
-0.08837798982858658,
-0.6338809728622437,
-0.036973997950553894,
-0.8398070931434631,
-0.3615059554576874,
0.0944124162197113,
0.1603584736585617,
0.01152144093066454,
0.4833318889141083,
-0.1048416942358017,
0.5120277404785156,
0.25884538888931274,
0.08001268655061722,
0.2703755795955658,
-0.2781296372413635,
-0.07180861383676529,
-0.3439942002296448,
0.341982364654541,
0.23704111576080322,
-0.280543714761734,
-0.39285925030708313,
-0.4843705892562866,
-0.1546115279197693,
0.8139140009880066,
-0.46679046750068665,
-0.025898462161421776,
0.22286544740200043,
-0.38557231426239014,
-0.41343796253204346,
-0.12111669778823853,
-0.9940231442451477,
-0.48476144671440125,
-0.4747871458530426,
0.2967764139175415,
-0.017451230436563492,
-0.2878798842430115,
-0.3498886525630951,
-0.4388788044452667,
0.4574316740036011,
0.1876215636730194,
-0.47162550687789917,
0.3034439980983734,
0.9406229257583618,
0.8238284587860107,
-0.33696693181991577,
-0.22285710275173187,
-0.7892974019050598,
0.26922371983528137,
-0.47509685158729553,
1.044248104095459,
-0.36991798877716064,
-0.5498681664466858,
-0.19522620737552643,
-0.11248786002397537,
0.274879515171051,
-0.7156593799591064,
0.7282771468162537,
-0.9273825883865356,
0.2254481315612793,
-0.19843322038650513,
-0.3595038056373596,
0.1731860488653183,
0.4955136775970459,
-0.8128190040588379,
1.0161247253417969,
-0.004112109541893005,
-0.8070387244224548,
0.4557317793369293,
-0.9203836917877197,
-0.1725100725889206,
0.45062047243118286,
-0.07010576874017715,
-0.5786758065223694,
0.2478436827659607,
-0.012726698070764542,
-0.08104308694601059,
-0.5568299293518066,
0.46875983476638794,
-0.2652031183242798,
-0.5358462333679199,
-0.08425760269165039,
-0.20622341334819794,
0.7191588878631592,
0.6557602882385254,
-0.5531136989593506,
-0.034120112657547,
-0.531335711479187,
0.3235819339752197,
-0.027314921841025352,
-0.4097091853618622,
-0.12507064640522003,
-0.1513788104057312,
0.2287299484014511,
-0.14118075370788574,
0.4441942870616913,
-0.23471972346305847,
0.04241705313324928,
-0.2482117861509323,
0.006780580617487431,
0.6628879308700562,
0.000015710937077528797,
0.44541728496551514,
-0.4538566470146179,
0.8826506733894348,
-0.49602657556533813,
0.27670150995254517,
-0.15853703022003174,
-0.15474985539913177,
-0.6178481578826904,
-0.14676257967948914,
0.641559362411499,
0.4851522147655487,
-0.8319767117500305,
0.02473602071404457,
-0.18997250497341156,
-0.5795963406562805,
-0.34400248527526855,
-0.1802983582019806,
0.4183730483055115,
0.540007472038269,
0.290616512298584,
-0.29479628801345825,
-1.0141507387161255,
-0.8099191188812256,
-0.4818423092365265,
-0.03541458770632744,
-0.2136441320180893,
0.35869553685188293,
0.2570543587207794,
-0.20908628404140472,
0.9912911057472229,
-0.1309034526348114,
-0.16924194991588593,
-0.3875136971473694,
0.31396162509918213,
0.10663624852895737,
0.44718942046165466,
0.3917493522167206,
-1.120902180671692,
-0.4170546233654022,
0.15765085816383362,
-0.9324418306350708,
-0.24069425463676453,
0.31605100631713867,
-0.2889663875102997,
0.13489943742752075,
0.6839146614074707,
-0.2848779261112213,
0.3921372890472412,
0.5257765054702759,
-0.2345789670944214,
0.5424390435218811,
-0.028538834303617477,
0.3169226050376892,
-1.2828482389450073,
0.6680703163146973,
-0.36658212542533875,
-0.2531983256340027,
-0.4017918109893799,
0.5626642107963562,
-0.1274559497833252,
-0.39004138112068176,
-0.16565793752670288,
0.896440327167511,
-0.4737350046634674,
-0.4849962294101715,
-0.3117283880710602,
0.5187353491783142,
0.2915344834327698,
0.0548010990023613,
-0.5267067551612854,
1.0129352807998657,
-0.0590728223323822,
-0.44157445430755615,
0.2111164778470993,
0.0575159452855587,
-0.03729475662112236,
0.8523005247116089,
-0.6495349407196045,
0.2695331573486328,
0.12108950316905975,
0.4492100477218628,
-0.6308812499046326,
-0.2304728776216507,
0.0054067689925432205,
-0.7542707324028015,
0.4453476369380951,
-0.1663530319929123,
-0.29867634177207947,
-0.3295867145061493,
-0.25208669900894165,
0.3644658923149109,
0.38508665561676025,
-0.6898680925369263,
0.8634196519851685,
0.8451999425888062,
0.059362784028053284,
-0.7946122884750366,
-0.42793378233909607,
0.6407180428504944,
-0.44440189003944397,
-0.38234472274780273,
0.5520329475402832,
-0.14523518085479736,
-0.29471462965011597,
0.13542428612709045,
-0.27763140201568604,
-0.1753273904323578,
0.17430177330970764,
0.189886212348938,
0.3584367334842682,
-0.2038879096508026,
0.035920120775699615,
-0.1676522046327591,
-0.46984466910362244,
-0.22903840243816376,
-0.45991891622543335,
0.38009852170944214,
-0.2460157871246338,
-0.1505037248134613,
-0.06933959573507309,
0.3660232424736023,
0.5369408130645752,
-0.49448516964912415,
0.020578620955348015,
0.6640599966049194,
-0.32025715708732605,
-0.02197577990591526,
-0.6545374989509583,
0.10010964423418045,
-0.4975655972957611,
0.14669077098369598,
-0.4743480682373047,
-0.9728440642356873,
0.48580387234687805,
-0.49913060665130615,
0.47326862812042236,
0.5567773580551147,
0.3942594826221466,
-0.4583180546760559,
0.8529559373855591,
0.8312686085700989,
0.17887310683727264,
0.42877110838890076,
-0.4004794657230377,
0.0790143683552742,
-1.2309657335281372,
-0.1357153058052063,
-0.730175256729126,
-0.506616473197937,
-0.8476665616035461,
-0.4661608040332794,
0.651498019695282,
0.012788254767656326,
-0.293023020029068,
0.3308880925178528,
-0.4512004554271698,
0.6231606602668762,
0.529543399810791,
-0.2800299823284149,
0.28581702709198,
-0.03182784467935562,
-0.2728508412837982,
-0.09625167399644852,
-0.6478626728057861,
-0.43773990869522095,
1.157926082611084,
0.13965491950511932,
0.5469251275062561,
-0.2951515018939972,
1.1371188163757324,
0.45124197006225586,
0.7901226878166199,
-0.44829076528549194,
0.5472944974899292,
-0.37789496779441833,
-1.1203497648239136,
-0.16531281173229218,
-0.31252866983413696,
-1.021266222000122,
0.06681324541568756,
0.08792079240083694,
-0.3910926580429077,
0.1432369500398636,
0.28171417117118835,
0.07940948754549026,
0.37964165210723877,
-0.4814993143081665,
0.8693045973777771,
-0.22036941349506378,
-0.5511950254440308,
-0.17416058480739594,
-0.5868412852287292,
0.28403207659721375,
0.025014473125338554,
0.27560633420944214,
0.021098598837852478,
-0.3971376121044159,
0.7185289263725281,
-0.1225348562002182,
0.38514330983161926,
-0.24172110855579376,
0.16103383898735046,
0.5043371915817261,
0.11572998017072678,
0.5170610547065735,
0.01470144372433424,
-0.16572940349578857,
-0.08719803392887115,
-0.30863651633262634,
-0.2800443470478058,
-0.487196147441864,
0.8049225211143494,
-0.3614147901535034,
-0.42990508675575256,
-0.44474223256111145,
-0.473793625831604,
-0.27882128953933716,
0.34271159768104553,
0.3329814076423645,
0.48442864418029785,
-0.4094904661178589,
0.3796525299549103,
0.5020115375518799,
0.007074420806020498,
0.05223950743675232,
0.35105016827583313,
-0.44228845834732056,
-0.7107396721839905,
1.0682709217071533,
0.004125137813389301,
0.019144544377923012,
0.3697759807109833,
0.10327407717704773,
-0.3253635764122009,
-0.4434189200401306,
-0.37709152698516846,
0.09863625466823578,
-0.4447838068008423,
-0.43106746673583984,
-0.4467979669570923,
-0.11454840749502182,
-0.2018900364637375,
-0.4080723524093628,
-0.47557532787323,
-0.3435104489326477,
0.02203880064189434,
0.13366420567035675,
0.17007379233837128,
1.0102310180664062,
-0.3713793456554413,
0.03740672394633293,
-0.5300642848014832,
0.5428354740142822,
0.12416905164718628,
0.7629141807556152,
-0.1946536898612976,
-0.5764762163162231,
-0.5775937438011169,
-0.10741250962018967,
-0.5360009074211121,
-0.41819149255752563,
0.20873944461345673,
-0.057346466928720474,
0.6277133822441101,
-0.24496372044086456,
-0.01910138502717018,
0.7790812849998474,
-0.5492470860481262,
0.6165690422058105,
-0.008555063046514988,
-0.7312051653862,
0.41934430599212646,
-0.5247646570205688,
0.17721682786941528,
0.8382359147071838,
0.15186335146427155,
-0.6502078175544739,
-0.519538402557373,
-0.8181338310241699,
-1.0128525495529175,
0.5694211721420288,
0.07210811227560043,
-0.3262251317501068,
0.22420698404312134,
0.3263009786605835,
-0.019682463258504868,
0.23153069615364075,
-0.2884807884693146,
-0.015952330082654953,
-0.2001417875289917,
-0.06776315718889236,
-0.00008537360554328188,
-0.14164778590202332,
-0.1647641956806183,
0.13836579024791718,
0.6309391856193542,
-0.0466810017824173,
0.16046293079853058,
0.016787519678473473,
0.12039528787136078,
-0.022349869832396507,
0.15125718712806702,
0.2686457335948944,
0.6881980299949646,
-0.3177662789821625,
0.10593109577894211,
0.2379264533519745,
-0.6899986863136292,
0.08881625533103943,
0.03060002811253071,
-0.24714547395706177,
0.12776759266853333,
0.04864775761961937,
0.4844072759151459,
0.3146796226501465,
-0.6027761101722717,
-0.04343971982598305,
-0.03088892064988613,
-0.06416799128055573,
-0.564275324344635,
-0.18751899898052216,
0.12960994243621826,
0.36984461545944214,
0.3683589994907379,
0.026994070038199425,
0.43742144107818604,
-0.3744763731956482,
0.5310217142105103,
0.2524101138114929,
-0.28712308406829834,
-0.03542593494057655,
0.8363063335418701,
0.2566046416759491,
-0.45625895261764526,
0.23602497577667236,
-0.4753871560096741,
-0.473467618227005,
0.5119118094444275,
0.40321385860443115,
1.3095316886901855,
-0.18047767877578735,
0.15629148483276367,
0.3253043591976166,
0.3490922451019287,
0.05734594166278839,
0.031521763652563095,
-0.0659240260720253,
-0.19873876869678497,
-0.4694927930831909,
-0.7068824172019958,
-0.7073529958724976,
0.13777762651443481,
-0.6134864091873169,
0.3914914131164551,
-0.4145614206790924,
-0.3123774528503418,
-0.2137027233839035,
0.30277377367019653,
-0.625985860824585,
0.17599962651729584,
-0.2131299525499344,
1.0165340900421143,
-0.320227712392807,
0.30572590231895447,
0.7677422761917114,
-0.2655796408653259,
-0.6417148113250732,
0.11254560202360153,
0.06461028009653091,
-0.6774530410766602,
0.5567901730537415,
-0.13228753209114075,
-0.1835428923368454,
-0.0884031429886818,
-0.6665107011795044,
-0.9532309174537659,
1.3167091608047485,
0.04788053780794144,
-0.2474914938211441,
-0.18712098896503448,
-0.22109651565551758,
0.5997980833053589,
-0.4416276812553406,
0.07373347133398056,
0.4493306279182434,
0.5936784744262695,
0.30643758177757263,
-0.7931409478187561,
-0.32074034214019775,
-0.2533923387527466,
0.09379678219556808,
0.3090076744556427,
-0.4132222831249237,
0.7484164834022522,
-0.02322522923350334,
-0.3596450090408325,
0.3459842801094055,
0.4552176296710968,
0.6329827308654785,
0.8745328187942505,
0.4281206727027893,
0.8601076006889343,
0.5088894367218018,
-0.08084142208099365,
1.083302617073059,
-0.19811275601387024,
0.32514768838882446,
1.4409066438674927,
-0.3470271825790405,
1.022779941558838,
0.3299071490764618,
-0.04435642808675766,
0.3668464720249176,
0.3645476996898651,
0.15193504095077515,
0.22797292470932007,
0.0777413621544838,
-0.20448221266269684,
-0.0832127034664154,
-0.2720302939414978,
-0.20328684151172638,
0.4940188229084015,
0.32483500242233276,
-0.05786142870783806,
-0.4840127229690552,
-0.07648848742246628,
0.06985766440629959,
0.1358555257320404,
-0.12282031029462814,
0.7630102634429932,
-0.05551476404070854,
-0.7827383279800415,
0.6793911457061768,
-0.08725974708795547,
0.5609308481216431,
-0.40788114070892334,
-0.16048645973205566,
-0.5195158123970032,
0.10707193613052368,
-0.13814449310302734,
-0.791382908821106,
0.41812074184417725,
0.37615877389907837,
-0.12852205336093903,
-0.37177082896232605,
0.7478662133216858,
-0.13889506459236145,
-0.3450261652469635,
0.20595629513263702,
0.4966098368167877,
0.26382604241371155,
0.21762855350971222,
-0.6978631615638733,
0.37248116731643677,
-0.017133820801973343,
-0.19517649710178375,
0.384164035320282,
0.5765503644943237,
-0.16449546813964844,
0.5786659717559814,
0.5152505040168762,
0.05800813063979149,
0.03017861768603325,
-0.00423266738653183,
0.8190364241600037,
-0.7204523682594299,
-0.28089407086372375,
-0.0019818423315882683,
0.5256929397583008,
-0.29097187519073486,
-0.30011802911758423,
0.5775858163833618,
0.7860403656959534,
0.7456801533699036,
0.22011105716228485,
0.7282626628875732,
-0.38653895258903503,
1.1220805644989014,
-0.15901771187782288,
0.8059278130531311,
-1.0350916385650635,
0.24633200466632843,
-0.08324892818927765,
-0.9179294109344482,
-0.1867452710866928,
0.1701803058385849,
0.09638532251119614,
0.2743620276451111,
0.5342265367507935,
0.7061991095542908,
-0.12153441458940506,
-0.0754014104604721,
0.21674373745918274,
0.11264362186193466,
0.5669869184494019,
0.20406021177768707,
0.6863796710968018,
-0.47799569368362427,
0.8449040055274963,
0.03515475615859032,
-0.3662301003932953,
-0.40826416015625,
-0.8373176455497742,
-0.38750651478767395,
-0.7514025568962097,
0.01820368506014347,
-0.25678640604019165,
0.35081061720848083,
0.4423193335533142,
0.43162670731544495,
-0.6075178384780884,
-0.48005038499832153,
-0.12828651070594788,
0.1859467774629593,
-0.04383048787713051,
-0.25240981578826904,
0.030613992363214493,
-0.7276193499565125,
-0.674909234046936,
0.45602118968963623,
0.45281684398651123,
-0.1456821709871292,
-0.19309261441230774,
-0.04054226726293564,
-0.25286832451820374,
-0.23282088339328766,
0.4796568751335144,
0.6528120040893555,
-0.5881264805793762,
-0.3174074590206146,
0.3410463035106659,
0.019411951303482056,
0.011477815918624401,
0.9962981343269348,
-1.0169036388397217,
0.5402991771697998,
0.48965689539909363,
0.7678853869438171,
0.557013988494873,
-0.05162462964653969,
0.670516312122345,
-0.6283232569694519,
-0.08945130556821823,
0.6334577202796936,
0.08677896857261658,
0.2659134864807129,
0.1387891322374344,
0.8620265126228333,
0.1723077893257141,
-0.911666750907898,
-1.1221739053726196,
0.1906052529811859,
-0.8612044453620911,
0.04174181818962097,
0.6311272978782654,
0.06432298570871353,
-0.24703308939933777,
-0.31336504220962524,
-0.11198442429304123,
0.23839923739433289,
-0.1411294788122177,
0.7819762825965881,
0.2885874807834625,
-0.07269865274429321,
0.16310720145702362,
-0.7670227885246277,
0.45032185316085815,
0.2624698281288147,
-0.8579168319702148,
0.152116596698761,
0.45469966530799866,
0.22788003087043762,
0.41717231273651123,
0.5463823080062866,
-0.5357045531272888,
0.43696460127830505,
0.23811882734298706,
0.16335748136043549,
0.006829290185123682,
-0.617264449596405,
-0.09828367829322815,
0.19290795922279358,
0.02466163970530033,
-0.14983266592025757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16810v1 | PISTOL: Dataset Compilation Pipeline for Structural Unlearning of LLMs | 2024-06-24T17:22:36 | 2024-06-24T17:22:36 | Xinchi Qiu, William F. Shen, Yihong Chen, Nicola Cancedda, Pontus Stenetorp, Nicholas D. Lane | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, machine unlearning, which seeks to erase specific data stored in
the pre-trained or fine-tuned models, has emerged as a crucial protective
measure for LLMs. However, unlearning approaches for LLMs that have been
considered thus far have focused on the removal of independent data points and
have not taken into account that the stored facts are logically connected to
one another and form an implicit knowledge graph. To facilitate the development
of structural unlearning methods, which are essential for the practical
application of unlearning, we propose PISTOL, a pipeline for compiling
multi-scenario datasets for benchmarking structural LLM unlearning.
Additionally, leveraging sample datasets synthesized using PISTOL, we conducted
benchmarks with four distinct unlearning methods on both Llama2-7B and
Mistral-7B models. This analysis helps to illustrate the prevailing challenges
in effectively and robustly removing highly inter-connected data, batched data,
or data skewed towards a specific domain. It also highlights the choice of
pre-trained model can impact unlearning performance. This work not only
advances our understandings on the limitation of current LLMs unlearning
methods and proposes future research directions, but also provides a replicable
framework for ongoing exploration and validation in the field. | [
-0.10988949239253998,
-0.6269180178642273,
0.17490237951278687,
-0.2531363368034363,
-0.4070916473865509,
0.48536163568496704,
-0.15137416124343872,
-0.025554519146680832,
-0.43859347701072693,
0.4691934585571289,
-0.6935704350471497,
-0.9272347092628479,
-0.6521691083908081,
-0.15643101930618286,
-0.5695180892944336,
1.0148712396621704,
-0.09482162445783615,
0.3469598889350891,
-0.016420677304267883,
-0.009048299863934517,
-0.4642564058303833,
-0.4759964942932129,
-0.2293996512889862,
-0.5348590016365051,
0.18298174440860748,
0.3500744104385376,
0.31633180379867554,
0.8564138412475586,
0.3157745897769928,
0.3026658296585083,
-0.31078627705574036,
0.21551065146923065,
-0.7342646718025208,
0.24790947139263153,
-0.13641108572483063,
-0.4423336684703827,
-0.23997700214385986,
-0.02672419510781765,
0.7753723859786987,
0.8509560823440552,
-0.22520245611667633,
0.34157314896583557,
0.5071421265602112,
0.7479802966117859,
-0.713944673538208,
0.49384641647338867,
-0.8132262229919434,
0.37867483496665955,
-0.4186401963233948,
-0.12982900440692902,
-0.3614911437034607,
0.04428833723068237,
-0.03553198277950287,
-0.4640112817287445,
0.40575793385505676,
-0.009500477463006973,
0.29647693037986755,
0.42551517486572266,
-0.6368528604507446,
-0.20685631036758423,
-0.5215576887130737,
0.5035127997398376,
-0.4638294279575348,
0.39264988899230957,
0.025890551507472992,
0.27996569871902466,
-0.6508140563964844,
-0.9352983236312866,
-0.014947354793548584,
0.41845181584358215,
0.08334700763225555,
0.15145863592624664,
0.031681180000305176,
0.08461674302816391,
0.15748630464076996,
0.23496238887310028,
-0.5538448095321655,
0.2281041145324707,
-1.021278977394104,
-0.3033127188682556,
0.4336571991443634,
0.18050232529640198,
-0.13217267394065857,
-0.2116047888994217,
-0.5935713648796082,
-0.026776257902383804,
-1.3263607025146484,
0.0657120943069458,
0.510298490524292,
0.49729007482528687,
-0.10325919836759567,
0.7571741342544556,
-0.16466134786605835,
0.40359818935394287,
-0.3192090094089508,
-0.15647734701633453,
0.4087658226490021,
0.10510782152414322,
-0.20717474818229675,
0.12432835251092911,
0.6645342111587524,
0.29236409068107605,
0.24160856008529663,
-0.43579137325286865,
-0.17561422288417816,
0.045719247311353683,
0.3382951021194458,
-0.6229733824729919,
-0.36795464158058167,
0.2207939475774765,
-0.575655996799469,
-0.2873075008392334,
-0.010963530279695988,
-0.7293910980224609,
-0.5417725443840027,
-0.36910367012023926,
0.25679636001586914,
-0.2399229109287262,
0.0013150813756510615,
-0.05485691875219345,
-0.3582790493965149,
-0.02983829751610756,
0.020005440339446068,
-0.47173044085502625,
-0.04158666729927063,
0.5548989176750183,
0.739695131778717,
-0.2558393180370331,
-0.3712712824344635,
-0.6067824959754944,
0.3968648314476013,
-0.2910478413105011,
0.6122079491615295,
-0.5671706795692444,
-0.64463210105896,
-0.09741430729627609,
0.03541075065732002,
0.1991005390882492,
-0.7730243802070618,
0.43361490964889526,
-0.2602297067642212,
0.12283189594745636,
-0.17168381810188293,
-0.8506489992141724,
-0.2423122674226761,
-0.016445381566882133,
-0.33297601342201233,
1.0814030170440674,
0.05901850759983063,
-0.38746321201324463,
0.6846602559089661,
-0.3050119876861572,
-0.19268593192100525,
-0.14377695322036743,
-0.26838335394859314,
-0.7158986926078796,
0.11501134186983109,
0.06294949352741241,
0.7174975275993347,
-0.34308791160583496,
0.7474806904792786,
-0.8085551261901855,
-0.4990861117839813,
-0.18936863541603088,
-0.40217918157577515,
0.6446661353111267,
0.39350631833076477,
-0.44421687722206116,
0.060143254697322845,
-0.844611644744873,
0.01103304699063301,
-0.08619886636734009,
-0.46730655431747437,
0.1456882208585739,
0.1673794388771057,
-0.37263187766075134,
0.23152704536914825,
-0.008633921854197979,
-0.3871038556098938,
0.3363301455974579,
-0.34972894191741943,
0.5139278769493103,
0.9633535742759705,
0.06633322685956955,
0.42240646481513977,
-0.2525371015071869,
0.20291811227798462,
0.3942675292491913,
0.10117129236459732,
-0.21723555028438568,
-0.16708432137966156,
-0.6903749108314514,
-0.4173624515533447,
0.1528562754392624,
0.4295533299446106,
-0.5420422554016113,
0.19990365207195282,
0.14436371624469757,
-0.656315267086029,
-0.1884477138519287,
0.6722776293754578,
0.8842341303825378,
0.7197065353393555,
0.5319623351097107,
-0.39054644107818604,
-0.8193354606628418,
-0.6481916904449463,
-0.3649420440196991,
-0.04665464907884598,
-0.10548728704452515,
-0.30979129672050476,
0.492485910654068,
-0.010706773027777672,
0.8182995915412903,
-0.5392059683799744,
-0.4366259276866913,
-0.1866883635520935,
0.21022488176822662,
0.09762251377105713,
0.2709426283836365,
0.20255820453166962,
-0.5697819590568542,
-0.029168251901865005,
-0.39879852533340454,
-1.3337968587875366,
0.07285139709711075,
0.10421472042798996,
0.016234993934631348,
0.02512275241315365,
0.6757805347442627,
-0.43970784544944763,
0.7940719127655029,
0.21349076926708221,
0.1464957594871521,
0.5360309481620789,
-0.0037330922205001116,
-0.05684904754161835,
-1.0755717754364014,
-0.050424348562955856,
-0.08132732659578323,
0.17176073789596558,
-0.5181358456611633,
-0.06216733530163765,
-0.022070907056331635,
-0.3246350586414337,
-0.7961879372596741,
0.547488272190094,
-0.8359667062759399,
-0.4482656717300415,
-0.06683502346277237,
-0.010181660763919353,
-0.0753026157617569,
0.7636646628379822,
0.10624537616968155,
0.6576535105705261,
0.6951093673706055,
-0.5850167274475098,
0.28993120789527893,
0.30129531025886536,
-0.4322413504123688,
0.16572466492652893,
-0.6332017779350281,
-0.09852631390094757,
-0.1565037965774536,
0.3195004463195801,
-0.8088058829307556,
0.10186177492141724,
0.2386644333600998,
-0.09734597057104111,
0.3329192101955414,
-0.5817261934280396,
-0.42788639664649963,
-0.123760886490345,
-0.43504905700683594,
0.11732780188322067,
0.343698114156723,
-0.5754773020744324,
0.4384925663471222,
0.447623610496521,
-0.03380543738603592,
-0.9206250309944153,
-0.4747428596019745,
-0.25335583090782166,
-0.5666071176528931,
-0.3137379288673401,
0.3091605305671692,
-0.030690373852849007,
-0.15500646829605103,
-0.1443316638469696,
-0.5054824948310852,
-0.1720162034034729,
0.06421004980802536,
0.7882001996040344,
0.31971392035484314,
0.028953792527318,
0.33471372723579407,
0.15332624316215515,
-0.32954269647598267,
0.06141074374318123,
-0.031324565410614014,
0.4582703411579132,
-0.0026641585864126682,
-0.6071252822875977,
0.011556734330952168,
0.07206062972545624,
0.2283618301153183,
-0.14416970312595367,
0.6644842028617859,
0.5193160772323608,
-0.3394767642021179,
-0.4335005283355713,
-0.2196919322013855,
-0.12140386551618576,
-0.5552597641944885,
0.18190306425094604,
-0.23272192478179932,
-0.80898517370224,
0.6085197925567627,
-0.7097259759902954,
0.5347257852554321,
0.1530708223581314,
0.5918788909912109,
-0.25224769115448,
0.5378749370574951,
0.44234827160835266,
-0.1762651652097702,
0.1884840726852417,
-0.4825398921966553,
0.14414767920970917,
-0.8786954879760742,
-0.5788715481758118,
-0.3935120105743408,
-0.39106470346450806,
-0.2593681514263153,
-0.27549004554748535,
0.6473428606987,
0.5225120782852173,
-0.5746944546699524,
0.32004693150520325,
-0.4300196170806885,
0.6006149053573608,
0.3603549599647522,
0.3955911099910736,
0.46409016847610474,
0.006873869337141514,
-0.35911253094673157,
0.17569118738174438,
-0.5765905380249023,
-0.5982587337493896,
1.8098347187042236,
0.028091054409742355,
0.7041600346565247,
-0.000010968079550366383,
0.8292865753173828,
0.34050995111465454,
0.24071519076824188,
-0.42481961846351624,
0.4485659599304199,
-0.13604974746704102,
-0.7322843670845032,
-0.19244857132434845,
-0.5130817294120789,
-0.9116945862770081,
0.18425190448760986,
-0.25414907932281494,
-0.6216700077056885,
-0.024651160463690758,
0.2590372860431671,
-0.1170295923948288,
0.6367518901824951,
-0.6707443594932556,
0.7845609188079834,
-0.04715990275144577,
-0.31909433007240295,
-0.09619978815317154,
-0.8157753348350525,
0.5761337876319885,
-0.22010479867458344,
0.10435371100902557,
-0.3006034195423126,
0.1778070032596588,
0.4750026762485504,
-0.4985845685005188,
1.109086513519287,
-0.24679800868034363,
-0.03396403789520264,
0.3490631878376007,
0.018970690667629242,
0.40546631813049316,
0.13651204109191895,
-0.2080627977848053,
0.47675633430480957,
-0.13668714463710785,
-0.16666704416275024,
-0.4397178590297699,
0.28548628091812134,
-0.6228758096694946,
-0.34126538038253784,
-0.20046685636043549,
-0.4747462868690491,
-0.37252843379974365,
0.13889797031879425,
0.5993391275405884,
0.7304962873458862,
-0.3100854456424713,
0.2968257963657379,
0.5653136968612671,
-0.007986362092196941,
0.6345831751823425,
0.5069543719291687,
0.07450828701257706,
-0.09068331122398376,
0.7086265087127686,
0.2819013297557831,
-0.04624541103839874,
0.27941471338272095,
-0.2522478401660919,
-0.3513145446777344,
-0.9115113019943237,
-0.3527510464191437,
-0.11231813579797745,
-0.7375649809837341,
-0.5717899203300476,
-0.22445650398731232,
-0.26657921075820923,
-0.253012478351593,
-0.32349294424057007,
-0.47444048523902893,
-0.37625595927238464,
-0.31186845898628235,
-0.26928773522377014,
0.21190950274467468,
0.6910558938980103,
-0.08534729480743408,
0.4496234655380249,
-0.8789040446281433,
0.4117870032787323,
-0.014233645051717758,
0.32950711250305176,
-0.06789758056402206,
-0.5684244632720947,
-0.15284445881843567,
0.12500226497650146,
-0.6063550710678101,
-0.6158046722412109,
0.37436214089393616,
0.262716144323349,
0.7610411047935486,
0.3804423213005066,
0.3189663290977478,
0.7155226469039917,
-0.41377875208854675,
0.4070392847061157,
0.11531102657318115,
-0.8697010278701782,
0.5804651975631714,
-0.44838041067123413,
0.022224755957722664,
0.4817367196083069,
0.567740797996521,
-0.06341766566038132,
-0.3352314531803131,
-0.48434722423553467,
-0.8467497229576111,
0.4225625693798065,
-0.09569228440523148,
-0.3851780295372009,
0.24537909030914307,
0.5798943042755127,
0.1236821711063385,
0.5336786508560181,
-0.3492421507835388,
-0.34475138783454895,
0.03742559254169464,
-0.16889218986034393,
-0.14369013905525208,
-0.045671530067920685,
-0.32311075925827026,
-0.14130795001983643,
0.6769230961799622,
-0.18016187846660614,
0.007413778454065323,
-0.36151736974716187,
-0.4434819221496582,
0.12968100607395172,
0.2774982154369354,
0.027058608829975128,
0.6394082307815552,
-0.20590825378894806,
-0.06472072750329971,
0.4082794487476349,
-0.39568501710891724,
0.3724503815174103,
-0.25086042284965515,
-0.14032195508480072,
-0.437461256980896,
0.4344260096549988,
0.3928253948688507,
0.5844214558601379,
-0.7667464017868042,
0.2478630542755127,
0.23126152157783508,
-0.21150974929332733,
-0.3292500972747803,
0.27692151069641113,
0.011778858490288258,
0.4767740070819855,
0.26813867688179016,
0.01940891519188881,
0.1917427033185959,
-0.6928042769432068,
0.5158055424690247,
0.4051295518875122,
-0.2901530861854553,
-0.14830079674720764,
0.49019476771354675,
0.09872763603925705,
0.11421839892864227,
0.8131746053695679,
0.01531864982098341,
-0.2937319874763489,
0.4801708459854126,
0.18743236362934113,
0.507165253162384,
-0.06379588693380356,
0.13873551785945892,
0.16882067918777466,
0.28052252531051636,
-0.17169366776943207,
-0.006173304747790098,
-0.024073604494333267,
-0.6385383009910583,
-0.1550387740135193,
-0.5798608660697937,
-0.38924720883369446,
0.16483789682388306,
-0.8393027782440186,
0.3912782073020935,
-0.6727285385131836,
0.1523353010416031,
-0.2160245180130005,
0.18577279150485992,
-0.5599362850189209,
0.17464688420295715,
-0.22798499464988708,
0.642155110836029,
-0.8006080985069275,
0.7808166146278381,
0.24682928621768951,
-0.23878006637096405,
-0.8274535536766052,
-0.4428838789463043,
1.0728682279586792,
-0.9171816110610962,
0.4913767874240875,
0.05782207101583481,
-0.15346062183380127,
-0.2691039443016052,
-0.31744253635406494,
-0.5229842662811279,
1.1933706998825073,
0.7874442934989929,
-0.5206530690193176,
-0.08785534650087357,
0.22576011717319489,
0.22705721855163574,
-0.2671240270137787,
0.15957774221897125,
0.5774919390678406,
0.23872704803943634,
0.16167528927326202,
-0.5536461472511292,
-0.2316407412290573,
-0.3743607997894287,
-0.4714546501636505,
0.365153968334198,
-0.6154500842094421,
0.8636458516120911,
-0.2642587125301361,
-0.19584788382053375,
0.02468649297952652,
0.5058867931365967,
0.46973422169685364,
0.42947736382484436,
0.19406896829605103,
0.6882597208023071,
0.7330450415611267,
-0.20078785717487335,
0.3015017509460449,
-0.3107166588306427,
0.237707257270813,
1.4965351819992065,
-0.45853111147880554,
0.8193773031234741,
0.15616610646247864,
-0.021817805245518684,
0.25836387276649475,
0.7314826250076294,
-0.08881478756666183,
0.48606646060943604,
0.21404992043972015,
-0.34426450729370117,
-0.2001461237668991,
0.30393850803375244,
-0.4988671541213989,
0.8986420631408691,
0.27018457651138306,
-0.3106244206428528,
-0.5859784483909607,
-0.14706560969352722,
0.10045437514781952,
-0.17538446187973022,
-0.19910655915737152,
0.7518505454063416,
0.06591377407312393,
-0.22372420132160187,
0.41117116808891296,
-0.03543635085225105,
0.5266594886779785,
-0.8169358968734741,
-0.04973294213414192,
-0.4722832143306732,
0.3556033968925476,
-0.3182217478752136,
-0.685142993927002,
0.45585179328918457,
0.21344873309135437,
-0.22338669002056122,
-0.36664336919784546,
0.6397334933280945,
-0.5150917172431946,
-0.12262645363807678,
0.393327534198761,
0.6144374012947083,
0.2989858388900757,
0.03678954020142555,
-0.7558644413948059,
0.0785789042711258,
-0.09847727417945862,
-0.3435089588165283,
0.8272219300270081,
0.4850500226020813,
0.03477601334452629,
1.1098452806472778,
0.8158941268920898,
-0.09549909830093384,
0.09640268236398697,
-0.05267221853137016,
1.1519523859024048,
-0.44377806782722473,
0.066736601293087,
-0.6685231328010559,
0.651794970035553,
0.137257382273674,
-0.4702478349208832,
0.8056311011314392,
0.9696120023727417,
0.9286413192749023,
0.19482797384262085,
0.5487344264984131,
0.44077056646347046,
0.5186507105827332,
-0.8833422660827637,
0.7373724579811096,
-0.44304728507995605,
0.7896693348884583,
-0.2887129783630371,
-1.009042501449585,
-0.06960292905569077,
0.2187947928905487,
0.20706035196781158,
0.0972575843334198,
0.5185549259185791,
1.0056133270263672,
-0.09886862337589264,
0.08751296252012253,
0.24915939569473267,
0.0350363627076149,
0.18572567403316498,
0.5530440807342529,
0.6787421107292175,
-0.4281325936317444,
0.6745564937591553,
-0.20924928784370422,
0.016625728458166122,
0.2605721354484558,
-0.967689573764801,
-0.8993120789527893,
-0.5844005346298218,
-0.07267189770936966,
0.02199147455394268,
0.2873174548149109,
0.5952415466308594,
0.6522771716117859,
-0.5315520167350769,
-0.42944541573524475,
-0.015709877014160156,
0.1984347701072693,
-0.014604720287024975,
-0.0904042050242424,
0.37958914041519165,
-0.31225594878196716,
-0.31009745597839355,
0.9480236172676086,
0.40358060598373413,
0.007561706937849522,
-0.20710459351539612,
-0.09731073677539825,
0.06729894876480103,
-0.3591234087944031,
0.44681304693222046,
0.44291117787361145,
-0.38744521141052246,
-0.1554488092660904,
-0.29333168268203735,
0.36054474115371704,
0.025935180485248566,
1.056262731552124,
-1.0344234704971313,
0.24229909479618073,
0.18444348871707916,
0.4178250730037689,
0.6006761193275452,
-0.21483732759952545,
0.7040293216705322,
-1.2748205661773682,
0.417236864566803,
-0.25591734051704407,
0.6376340389251709,
0.03025881201028824,
-0.2520836293697357,
0.8653252720832825,
0.23987969756126404,
-0.3640061914920807,
-1.0831677913665771,
0.12693126499652863,
-0.5164780616760254,
-0.5478877425193787,
0.6997793316841125,
-0.41106560826301575,
-0.03763410076498985,
-0.47722384333610535,
0.17238368093967438,
0.6471952199935913,
-0.21720124781131744,
0.7592757940292358,
0.5317723155021667,
0.020255060866475105,
-0.08595550805330276,
-0.34402501583099365,
0.4225987195968628,
0.25483113527297974,
-1.003191351890564,
0.4416458010673523,
0.676923930644989,
0.4245288074016571,
-0.3925020396709442,
0.3734591007232666,
-0.38519731163978577,
0.09709586203098297,
0.07343804091215134,
0.08764644712209702,
-0.4786530137062073,
-0.9275317192077637,
-0.2526648938655853,
0.4290727376937866,
-0.4531112611293793,
0.04510386660695076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16807v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16807v1 | Beyond Thumbs Up/Down: Untangling Challenges of Fine-Grained Feedback for Text-to-Image Generation | 2024-06-24T17:19:34 | 2024-06-24T17:19:34 | Katherine M. Collins, Najoung Kim, Yonatan Bitton, Verena Rieser, Shayegan Omidshafiei, Yushi Hu, Sherol Chen, Senjuti Dutta, Minsuk Chang, Kimin Lee, Youwei Liang, Georgina Evans, Sahil Singla, Gang Li, Adrian Weller, Junfeng He, Deepak Ramachandran, Krishnamurthy Dj Dvijotham | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Human feedback plays a critical role in learning and refining reward models
for text-to-image generation, but the optimal form the feedback should take for
learning an accurate reward function has not been conclusively established.
This paper investigates the effectiveness of fine-grained feedback which
captures nuanced distinctions in image quality and prompt-alignment, compared
to traditional coarse-grained feedback (for example, thumbs up/down or ranking
between a set of options). While fine-grained feedback holds promise,
particularly for systems catering to diverse societal preferences, we show that
demonstrating its superiority to coarse-grained feedback is not automatic.
Through experiments on real and synthetic preference data, we surface the
complexities of building effective models due to the interplay of model choice,
feedback type, and the alignment between human judgment and computational
interpretation. We identify key challenges in eliciting and utilizing
fine-grained feedback, prompting a reassessment of its assumed benefits and
practicality. Our findings -- e.g., that fine-grained feedback can lead to
worse models for a fixed budget, in some settings; however, in controlled
settings with known attributes, fine grained rewards can indeed be more helpful
-- call for careful consideration of feedback attributes and potentially beckon
novel modeling approaches to appropriately unlock the potential value of
fine-grained feedback in-the-wild. | [
-0.5468577742576599,
-0.5102262496948242,
0.7475862503051758,
-0.20905351638793945,
-0.16139258444309235,
0.0413387231528759,
-0.4219897985458374,
-0.5404345989227295,
-0.16995318233966827,
0.26602086424827576,
-0.5121253728866577,
-0.22354349493980408,
-0.7560861706733704,
-0.03641851246356964,
-0.22394458949565887,
1.2503092288970947,
0.03896643966436386,
0.07639086246490479,
-0.4288608133792877,
0.18646351993083954,
-0.366965115070343,
-0.4863230288028717,
-0.8568161725997925,
-0.6040008068084717,
0.816688597202301,
0.7296991348266602,
0.9984760284423828,
0.5217570662498474,
0.6846596598625183,
0.2338159680366516,
0.061469029635190964,
0.34223297238349915,
-0.540762186050415,
-0.2820582091808319,
-0.3094813823699951,
-0.45200908184051514,
-0.2400798797607422,
0.17950068414211273,
0.2264152467250824,
0.5539175868034363,
0.15038734674453735,
0.2127925008535385,
0.5040972828865051,
0.9758192896842957,
-0.8221818208694458,
-0.050923023372888565,
-0.39784497022628784,
0.1409561038017273,
-0.16724443435668945,
-0.4951997399330139,
-0.3404276669025421,
-0.46365734934806824,
0.06327401846647263,
-0.4982336461544037,
0.23511925339698792,
-0.2908500134944916,
1.0304763317108154,
0.29969537258148193,
-0.1630638837814331,
-0.5667002201080322,
-0.9223806262016296,
0.8882049322128296,
-0.4490678608417511,
-0.01905158907175064,
0.31590500473976135,
0.30304911732673645,
0.019263092428445816,
-0.6241745352745056,
-0.2311864197254181,
-0.3830483853816986,
0.0602932907640934,
0.1161506175994873,
-0.024807559326291084,
0.003991803154349327,
-0.07861321419477463,
0.5110977292060852,
0.28829243779182434,
0.3129264712333679,
-0.10916805267333984,
-0.08579419553279877,
0.6161696910858154,
0.11797750741243362,
0.17914436757564545,
-0.3948783576488495,
-0.29087018966674805,
-0.396253377199173,
-0.4850137531757355,
0.8557206392288208,
0.3658759891986847,
0.5323637127876282,
-0.028279969468712807,
0.6266931295394897,
-0.28129661083221436,
0.6013172268867493,
0.5533205270767212,
0.03263881057500839,
-0.26460498571395874,
-0.18583790957927704,
0.09228432178497314,
-0.18124543130397797,
0.7051516771316528,
0.9873379468917847,
0.16465623676776886,
-0.1426595002412796,
-0.543205738067627,
0.31570136547088623,
0.41877007484436035,
-0.8413329124450684,
-0.16037289798259735,
0.062193647027015686,
-0.7043167948722839,
-0.8947200179100037,
0.17056968808174133,
-0.9038573503494263,
-0.6110163927078247,
-0.5844588875770569,
0.6563869118690491,
-0.14191031455993652,
0.10797777771949768,
-0.008128474466502666,
-0.36273542046546936,
0.1698567122220993,
0.656851589679718,
-1.2197151184082031,
0.15672864019870758,
0.6308180689811707,
0.7781825065612793,
-0.10056197643280029,
-0.12362366169691086,
-0.557045042514801,
-0.3511807322502136,
-0.34495052695274353,
1.2586746215820312,
-0.7810226678848267,
-0.4172573387622833,
-0.1946762353181839,
-0.16262951493263245,
0.3759020268917084,
-0.560867965221405,
0.4285595715045929,
-0.18167735636234283,
-0.01686524786055088,
-0.6414399147033691,
-0.32534492015838623,
0.19705508649349213,
0.3362816572189331,
-0.48517289757728577,
0.8491529226303101,
0.04945981502532959,
-0.7037323117256165,
0.5788185000419617,
-0.4884933531284332,
-0.07864895462989807,
-0.02791587822139263,
-0.4164682626724243,
-0.14826056361198425,
0.5348927974700928,
0.2259417176246643,
0.5548012256622314,
-0.47025924921035767,
0.3662862479686737,
-0.5469067096710205,
-0.1851060539484024,
0.32001757621765137,
-0.584235429763794,
0.18447327613830566,
0.28683048486709595,
-0.5278986692428589,
0.09301935136318207,
-0.7067457437515259,
0.05802489444613457,
0.25672510266304016,
-0.37608206272125244,
-0.15733171999454498,
0.18101108074188232,
0.22564898431301117,
0.1152060478925705,
0.20620772242546082,
-0.5668145418167114,
0.2831658720970154,
0.010726391337811947,
0.6447551846504211,
0.9471368193626404,
-0.31619665026664734,
0.6805002093315125,
-0.6154106259346008,
0.2728373110294342,
-0.141158327460289,
0.155728280544281,
-0.2929295599460602,
-0.19899410009384155,
-0.5499463081359863,
0.18976370990276337,
0.6521890759468079,
0.22686763107776642,
-0.631788969039917,
-0.06717683374881744,
-0.046910692006349564,
-0.47547152638435364,
-0.5579692721366882,
-0.016400665044784546,
0.5238730907440186,
0.4313209056854248,
0.16533313691616058,
-0.7483710646629333,
0.08154875040054321,
-0.6563523411750793,
-0.11961916089057922,
-0.030944349244236946,
-0.3116550147533417,
0.5283285975456238,
0.24803169071674347,
-0.011597711592912674,
0.9803398251533508,
-0.6375675201416016,
-0.28580185770988464,
0.06534650176763535,
0.5193909406661987,
-0.3389468193054199,
0.5495496392250061,
0.4888667166233063,
-0.6961436867713928,
-0.03685424104332924,
0.25478309392929077,
-0.23109546303749084,
-0.0327288992702961,
-0.39138057827949524,
0.057737015187740326,
0.15778687596321106,
0.22092266380786896,
-0.37410029768943787,
0.4208918511867523,
0.4431053102016449,
-0.37918946146965027,
0.732293426990509,
-0.33795493841171265,
0.6331077814102173,
-0.8248010873794556,
0.11383649706840515,
0.1998014599084854,
-0.300201416015625,
-0.23894314467906952,
0.23828786611557007,
-0.008383817039430141,
-0.03998618572950363,
-0.34669411182403564,
0.3859827518463135,
-0.06200076639652252,
-0.09841405600309372,
-0.4861069917678833,
-0.1809050738811493,
0.19840751588344574,
0.5543593764305115,
0.21688547730445862,
0.6570051908493042,
0.3767382502555847,
-0.6364871859550476,
0.3135768175125122,
-0.0008748089312575758,
-0.20106056332588196,
1.0150885581970215,
-0.7101348638534546,
0.17901723086833954,
-0.12722229957580566,
0.17821455001831055,
-0.9997526407241821,
-0.6117910146713257,
-0.018417568877339363,
-0.6704619526863098,
0.4085838496685028,
0.07320192456245422,
-0.35193777084350586,
-0.3562356233596802,
-0.5681974291801453,
0.3491467833518982,
0.4399946928024292,
-0.7340151071548462,
0.20426474511623383,
0.45336663722991943,
-0.07542580366134644,
-0.245848149061203,
-0.6012811660766602,
0.11752213537693024,
0.01943441852927208,
-0.5617710947990417,
0.4662666916847229,
-0.013576395809650421,
-0.09394730627536774,
-0.12313341349363327,
-0.066416434943676,
0.08207089453935623,
0.026337062940001488,
0.1549859642982483,
0.18938830494880676,
0.159963458776474,
0.13111458718776703,
-0.03550421819090843,
-0.2714122533798218,
-0.042681362479925156,
-0.2885037064552307,
0.40847527980804443,
-0.33684879541397095,
-0.31122875213623047,
-0.3794132173061371,
0.38231220841407776,
0.4256656765937805,
-0.030309991911053658,
-0.047763653099536896,
0.5267181992530823,
-0.21037612855434418,
0.08376996964216232,
-0.2652469873428345,
-0.4665217101573944,
-0.48127731680870056,
0.1522572785615921,
-0.07313138246536255,
-1.017991065979004,
0.4480883777141571,
-0.3786953091621399,
0.19976194202899933,
0.3636554181575775,
0.5320490598678589,
-0.39919692277908325,
1.3981026411056519,
0.5671798586845398,
0.24172721803188324,
0.40488430857658386,
-0.29761961102485657,
-0.16105417907238007,
-0.6272184252738953,
-0.37796565890312195,
-0.6206757426261902,
-0.6174871921539307,
-0.6038726568222046,
-0.24497142434120178,
0.09581717848777771,
0.07778333127498627,
-0.11620688438415527,
-0.0527108870446682,
-0.8327579498291016,
0.5872002840042114,
0.6476059556007385,
0.4482463300228119,
0.28148341178894043,
-0.04455536976456642,
0.07051704823970795,
-0.03372586891055107,
-0.5068176984786987,
-0.7300136685371399,
0.7134024500846863,
0.32362017035484314,
1.1663814783096313,
-0.40427568554878235,
0.6823874711990356,
0.4189641773700714,
0.07228279113769531,
-1.0131251811981201,
0.3414437174797058,
-0.6130786538124084,
-0.2971208989620209,
-0.15484535694122314,
-0.30988961458206177,
-0.9005836248397827,
-0.21171776950359344,
-0.4014926850795746,
-0.7245439887046814,
0.3857143521308899,
0.7234310507774353,
-0.8966221809387207,
0.40401899814605713,
-0.8858851790428162,
0.8352083563804626,
-0.32650843262672424,
-0.6539923548698425,
-0.03340384364128113,
-0.8069300651550293,
0.06320472061634064,
0.15999579429626465,
0.23076334595680237,
0.09547263383865356,
0.3599315285682678,
0.4154762327671051,
-0.44915589690208435,
1.0395559072494507,
-0.09787647426128387,
-0.2426655888557434,
0.14493907988071442,
0.047388069331645966,
0.29716476798057556,
0.08591531962156296,
0.2972894012928009,
0.02221817895770073,
0.195252925157547,
-0.3743073642253876,
-0.6436775922775269,
0.7483793497085571,
-0.8630778193473816,
-0.41820263862609863,
0.03554214909672737,
-0.4338749051094055,
-0.14575058221817017,
0.08713403344154358,
0.698265552520752,
0.9529429078102112,
0.006532931700348854,
0.2045764923095703,
0.48135703802108765,
-0.13492056727409363,
0.510754406452179,
-0.11375502496957779,
-0.2746180295944214,
-0.4216369092464447,
1.217507243156433,
0.018728656694293022,
0.45689940452575684,
0.34849411249160767,
0.3489971458911896,
-0.1788993775844574,
-0.31063178181648254,
-0.6908661723136902,
-0.26848140358924866,
-0.6175142526626587,
-0.36713308095932007,
-0.17469462752342224,
0.03673785924911499,
-0.06517274677753448,
-0.6741306781768799,
-0.8051493763923645,
-0.5002046823501587,
-0.6101892590522766,
0.18667875230312347,
0.054115358740091324,
0.9913527369499207,
-0.06786669045686722,
0.2346210479736328,
-0.9684209823608398,
0.24709932506084442,
0.5326383709907532,
0.6896837949752808,
0.3279670178890228,
-0.3032481074333191,
-0.2297724336385727,
0.30439385771751404,
-0.8431298136711121,
-0.5627903938293457,
0.152138814330101,
-0.08216708153486252,
-0.10177266597747803,
0.5261011123657227,
0.10367347300052643,
0.699048638343811,
-0.35417771339416504,
0.9948351979255676,
0.36230725049972534,
-0.8964823484420776,
0.4965642988681793,
-0.3391478657722473,
0.5614706873893738,
0.7024560570716858,
0.12552516162395477,
-0.3522968292236328,
-0.4238722324371338,
-0.5478036403656006,
-0.8296656608581543,
0.7773364186286926,
0.08617924153804779,
0.23209425806999207,
0.10300862789154053,
0.48319095373153687,
0.4549322724342346,
0.18055902421474457,
-0.7100704312324524,
0.1442771703004837,
-0.41940930485725403,
0.08362191915512085,
-0.021668195724487305,
-0.14843712747097015,
-0.11255542188882828,
-0.3188576400279999,
0.23908555507659912,
-0.2345001995563507,
0.2025335133075714,
0.39498665928840637,
0.19134894013404846,
-0.4709303081035614,
0.5395104885101318,
0.4848780333995819,
0.26655682921409607,
-0.21702341735363007,
0.3070840835571289,
-0.35213884711265564,
-0.19960246980190277,
0.26087090373039246,
-0.12818065285682678,
-0.3054090738296509,
-0.2936103343963623,
0.004023781977593899,
1.0595109462738037,
0.45287200808525085,
-0.2735067307949066,
0.32559582591056824,
-0.05768261104822159,
-0.36896687746047974,
0.24594534933567047,
0.09199978411197662,
-0.2518770694732666,
0.1052568107843399,
0.23275147378444672,
0.6937536597251892,
0.29870668053627014,
-0.5951882600784302,
0.018903156742453575,
0.6744763851165771,
-0.666673481464386,
-0.45920464396476746,
0.6237816214561462,
0.5132919549942017,
-0.3943571150302887,
0.21286363899707794,
-0.14447900652885437,
-0.24520041048526764,
0.625654399394989,
0.4184810221195221,
0.7169221639633179,
0.23623284697532654,
0.7071582674980164,
0.20006313920021057,
-0.03852211683988571,
-0.32307156920433044,
-0.044586315751075745,
-0.33908316493034363,
-0.6462230086326599,
-0.3214345872402191,
-0.4835955798625946,
-0.6420918107032776,
-0.03973622992634773,
-0.923492431640625,
0.2975362539291382,
-0.3743305206298828,
-0.6883244514465332,
0.45787355303764343,
-0.07361093908548355,
-0.6048876047134399,
0.28008702397346497,
0.45883259177207947,
0.6620941758155823,
-0.6496506929397583,
0.4181135892868042,
0.9376920461654663,
-0.4133085608482361,
-1.0920681953430176,
-0.005610242486000061,
0.05401483550667763,
-0.5554960370063782,
0.4006023406982422,
0.5180489420890808,
-0.3380974233150482,
0.19820398092269897,
-0.9185874462127686,
-0.5850160717964172,
0.8205780982971191,
0.3643398880958557,
-0.39329758286476135,
-0.16359202563762665,
0.16745112836360931,
0.4214572012424469,
-0.27363014221191406,
0.45570075511932373,
0.6441054344177246,
0.4935663342475891,
0.48598045110702515,
-0.771458089351654,
-0.11415503174066544,
-0.25093597173690796,
0.3656822741031647,
0.40555739402770996,
-0.8049541711807251,
0.5498156547546387,
-0.4828318953514099,
-0.23360037803649902,
0.19234982132911682,
0.3029191792011261,
0.07976699620485306,
0.6229586601257324,
0.4798075258731842,
0.664244532585144,
0.4708165228366852,
-0.22075602412223816,
1.3833355903625488,
0.07542998343706131,
0.4809022545814514,
0.7437612414360046,
0.07383716851472855,
0.7191305160522461,
0.75068199634552,
-0.2049974799156189,
0.3795093297958374,
0.9753935933113098,
0.020110992714762688,
0.6917921304702759,
-0.06770773231983185,
0.19023779034614563,
-0.4545235335826874,
-0.3783074915409088,
-0.215103879570961,
0.37528878450393677,
-0.018327202647924423,
-0.16019901633262634,
-0.5352078676223755,
0.06888660788536072,
-0.3471304774284363,
0.17965936660766602,
-0.6810868382453918,
0.825152575969696,
-0.010330332443118095,
-1.0120625495910645,
0.3666689991950989,
-0.14738014340400696,
0.9971861243247986,
-0.34222209453582764,
-0.08316817879676819,
-0.1661500185728073,
0.1697472184896469,
-0.4560985863208771,
-1.0259543657302856,
0.16056998074054718,
0.18412582576274872,
-0.5842102766036987,
-0.17310354113578796,
0.7533736228942871,
-0.2262597233057022,
-0.3522602617740631,
-0.048004262149333954,
-0.12929783761501312,
-0.2580133080482483,
-0.11481231451034546,
-0.49256670475006104,
0.06188000366091728,
0.05968322232365608,
-0.2114529311656952,
0.5706990361213684,
0.34078922867774963,
-0.03365738317370415,
0.3756074607372284,
0.6632136702537537,
-0.058328188955783844,
-0.33128949999809265,
0.018421916291117668,
0.8708471655845642,
-0.6486999988555908,
-0.5191770195960999,
-0.9380505084991455,
0.6739862561225891,
0.010825389996170998,
-0.3349558115005493,
0.35342931747436523,
0.07218115776777267,
1.0445172786712646,
-0.2835661768913269,
0.6499511003494263,
-0.06276968866586685,
0.029892204329371452,
-0.5654556155204773,
0.5655173063278198,
-0.7565504312515259,
0.13274550437927246,
-0.4357914626598358,
-0.6462656259536743,
-0.20814882218837738,
0.38920244574546814,
-0.26746734976768494,
0.05121345818042755,
0.5231254696846008,
0.5550751090049744,
0.06085270643234253,
0.1941804736852646,
0.1357661783695221,
-0.24980123341083527,
0.27795377373695374,
0.5220051407814026,
1.1412038803100586,
-0.06675015389919281,
0.46061259508132935,
-0.5085776448249817,
-0.4755263030529022,
-0.21011486649513245,
-1.049997329711914,
-0.4894382059574127,
-0.6129171848297119,
-0.20478898286819458,
-0.2078055441379547,
-0.27327120304107666,
1.0609369277954102,
0.7623766660690308,
-0.7880317568778992,
-0.1541631668806076,
-0.416364461183548,
-0.10844076424837112,
-0.09739410877227783,
-0.2846875488758087,
0.1749381721019745,
-0.6327187418937683,
-0.7561388611793518,
-0.3590535521507263,
0.4300484359264374,
0.22480496764183044,
-0.10251394659280777,
-0.13855314254760742,
0.3860880136489868,
0.27867263555526733,
0.6189346313476562,
0.41611865162849426,
-0.7059564590454102,
-0.3757821023464203,
-0.010294829495251179,
-0.3186877369880676,
0.26834824681282043,
1.0345542430877686,
-0.6934157609939575,
0.5108205676078796,
0.3717624545097351,
0.7187680006027222,
0.19958914816379547,
0.17031893134117126,
0.6275807619094849,
-0.6520785689353943,
-0.04216235876083374,
-0.0074185822159051895,
0.1013498306274414,
0.5616841316223145,
-0.5566810369491577,
0.1131960079073906,
0.03632846102118492,
-0.9851592183113098,
-0.7140186429023743,
0.2929914593696594,
-0.9986684322357178,
-0.29199615120887756,
1.0380154848098755,
0.10052463412284851,
-0.1745244264602661,
0.45508602261543274,
-0.7588860988616943,
0.08784941583871841,
-0.5989524126052856,
1.2744126319885254,
0.7935287952423096,
-0.1681300848722458,
-0.08307112753391266,
-0.0724823921918869,
0.7163172960281372,
0.5987386703491211,
-0.8923081159591675,
0.08633147180080414,
0.7674289345741272,
-0.16353724896907806,
0.30359748005867004,
0.5068215131759644,
-0.2937318980693817,
0.5371745228767395,
-0.31659772992134094,
-0.0004540024674497545,
-0.07433081418275833,
-0.4203917682170868,
-0.5502994060516357,
0.2343771904706955,
0.4245298206806183,
-0.1714611053466797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16801v2 | RES-Q: Evaluating Code-Editing Large Language Model Systems at the Repository Scale | 2024-06-24T17:08:17 | 2024-06-25T18:04:23 | Beck LaBash, August Rosedale, Alex Reents, Lucas Negritto, Colin Wiel | cs.CL | cs.CL | The instruction-following ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
cultivated a class of LLM-based systems capable of approaching complex tasks
such as making edits to large code repositories. Due to the high sensitivity
and unpredictability of LLM behavior in response to changes in prompting,
robust evaluation tools are needed to drive future iteration of these systems.
We propose RES-Q, a natural language instruction-based benchmark for evaluating
$\textbf{R}$epository $\textbf{E}$diting $\textbf{S}$ystems, which consists of
100 handcrafted repository editing tasks derived from real GitHub commits.
Given an edit instruction and a code repository, RES-Q evaluates an LLM
system's ability to interpret the instruction, navigate the repository to
gather relevant information, and construct an appropriate edit that satisfies
the specified criteria. We argue that evaluating LLMs in this way addresses
issues with traditional benchmarks and provides a more holistic assessment of a
model's abilities. We evaluate various state-of-the-art LLMs as language agents
in a repository-editing system built on Qurrent OS, our language agent
development software. Despite their 1% pass@1 performance difference on
HumanEval, we find Claude Sonnet 3.5 outperforms GPT-4o by 12% pass@1 on RES-Q,
indicating RES-Q's capacity to differentiate model capability as traditional
benchmarks approach saturation. We further investigate token efficiency,
performance relationships with existing benchmarks, and interesting disparities
between closed and open-source LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/Qurrent-AI/RES-Q. | [
-0.19487492740154266,
-0.5765339732170105,
0.38948214054107666,
-0.0675148069858551,
0.1152300089597702,
0.2557182013988495,
-0.5971317887306213,
-0.2464979737997055,
-0.05965188890695572,
0.42140278220176697,
-0.2625732719898224,
-0.5001474022865295,
-0.39670851826667786,
0.4832213521003723,
-0.3140442669391632,
0.6648204922676086,
-0.12767662107944489,
0.1267126500606537,
-0.26966729760169983,
-0.27137210965156555,
-0.4492914378643036,
-0.4072968065738678,
-0.3232571482658386,
-0.1443505585193634,
0.40037935972213745,
0.3026025593280792,
0.7036582827568054,
0.6055416464805603,
0.6260142922401428,
0.3707966208457947,
-0.15196098387241364,
0.08933985978364944,
-0.6751042008399963,
0.36984822154045105,
-0.3810935914516449,
-0.42493489384651184,
-0.6090236902236938,
-0.15188072621822357,
0.8340725898742676,
0.14126667380332947,
-0.012578493915498257,
0.4323822557926178,
-0.03226159140467644,
1.0127613544464111,
-0.8437100052833557,
0.1007886752486229,
-0.5361777544021606,
-0.1871446669101715,
-0.005827831104397774,
-0.07167534530162811,
-0.5727968215942383,
-0.6391719579696655,
-0.0018704556860029697,
-0.45354631543159485,
-0.209713414311409,
-0.016965273767709732,
0.6819514036178589,
0.4167344570159912,
-0.018465548753738403,
-0.2714035212993622,
-0.5754757523536682,
0.7156015038490295,
-0.5586591958999634,
0.7318282127380371,
0.20144104957580566,
0.395177960395813,
-0.2371959090232849,
-0.8882645964622498,
-0.3654070794582367,
-0.38825833797454834,
0.18089298903942108,
-0.02964598499238491,
-0.4974226653575897,
0.12461503595113754,
0.43004730343818665,
0.41786885261535645,
-0.4064450263977051,
-0.04225488007068634,
-0.22541239857673645,
-0.21766526997089386,
0.2833434045314789,
0.21036460995674133,
0.35028180480003357,
-0.14020486176013947,
-0.2164091020822525,
-0.1774357259273529,
-0.7421013712882996,
-0.028928350657224655,
0.2537669539451599,
0.25288671255111694,
0.08082669973373413,
0.614159345626831,
-0.3555205762386322,
0.7569593787193298,
-0.16071286797523499,
0.08910439908504486,
0.11308532953262329,
-0.25919756293296814,
-0.33994144201278687,
-0.23956042528152466,
0.6623944640159607,
0.41118428111076355,
0.3858475983142853,
-0.3084692358970642,
-0.7649800181388855,
-0.09053628146648407,
0.4505092203617096,
-0.8800750374794006,
-0.18714943528175354,
0.1025296077132225,
-0.35826417803764343,
-0.09422345459461212,
0.0017429286381229758,
-0.612564742565155,
-0.561226487159729,
-0.34801316261291504,
0.5399337410926819,
-0.4652116894721985,
0.006134338676929474,
0.09062150120735168,
-0.08321185410022736,
0.2548600137233734,
0.3729963004589081,
-0.4448709189891815,
0.37323781847953796,
0.8900817036628723,
0.822101891040802,
0.10255486518144608,
-0.4362718164920807,
-0.7242543697357178,
-0.2084556370973587,
-0.275906503200531,
0.8312674164772034,
-0.808857262134552,
-0.22403490543365479,
-0.1278381198644638,
0.018204577267169952,
-0.058096759021282196,
-0.6272959113121033,
0.46388834714889526,
-0.857288658618927,
-0.13205409049987793,
-0.22251950204372406,
-0.7510169148445129,
0.003934467677026987,
0.3897245228290558,
-0.7619247436523438,
0.8702301979064941,
0.6271456480026245,
-0.6955611109733582,
0.0957648977637291,
-0.593148410320282,
-0.010471213608980179,
0.06311608105897903,
0.04550546407699585,
-0.13632966578006744,
0.028861112892627716,
0.04310321435332298,
0.046387121081352234,
-0.5674751400947571,
0.13024912774562836,
-0.09021325409412384,
-0.8015026450157166,
0.47689658403396606,
-0.33533602952957153,
0.5252713561058044,
0.14984478056430817,
-0.16939210891723633,
0.2951570451259613,
-0.5308294296264648,
0.20425620675086975,
-0.035643551498651505,
-0.4735017716884613,
-0.29890549182891846,
-0.2422233670949936,
-0.2607308626174927,
-0.1973053365945816,
0.3667033910751343,
-0.38755229115486145,
0.4272744059562683,
-0.1946755200624466,
0.581149697303772,
0.7767127156257629,
0.10112465918064117,
0.3845738172531128,
-0.534640908241272,
0.9034776091575623,
-0.6213107109069824,
0.2831399142742157,
-0.27101659774780273,
-0.16284197568893433,
-0.6103997230529785,
-0.49611911177635193,
0.7674927115440369,
0.4884291887283325,
-0.7723304033279419,
0.11955785006284714,
-0.47910642623901367,
-0.5532407760620117,
-0.7566531300544739,
0.0499148927628994,
0.7829235792160034,
0.14605848491191864,
0.3577507734298706,
-0.22246940433979034,
-0.48100143671035767,
-0.9725142121315002,
-0.6596890687942505,
-0.34443768858909607,
-0.021224064752459526,
0.2574561834335327,
0.508017897605896,
-0.2735738754272461,
0.7921481132507324,
-0.19172896444797516,
0.24811115860939026,
-0.02737431600689888,
-0.03141859918832779,
-0.010832268744707108,
0.2373066544532776,
0.2784474194049835,
-0.3426661193370819,
-0.29455727338790894,
-0.08457250148057938,
-0.5210173726081848,
-0.3865814208984375,
0.044178348034620285,
-0.17167243361473083,
0.2424067258834839,
0.39667776226997375,
-0.4235949218273163,
0.239440456032753,
0.4559756815433502,
-0.21888123452663422,
0.6872847080230713,
-0.322769433259964,
0.5859995484352112,
-0.6754809021949768,
0.09468214958906174,
-0.04337481036782265,
-0.16992732882499695,
-0.5456286668777466,
0.5246038436889648,
0.5254127979278564,
-0.01843166910111904,
-0.4495924413204193,
0.41277214884757996,
-0.5752208828926086,
-0.5888933539390564,
-0.1114429235458374,
0.30408230423927307,
0.21093349158763885,
0.40761038661003113,
-0.2692948579788208,
1.0305132865905762,
0.1427128165960312,
-0.33498021960258484,
0.4599986970424652,
0.029242070391774178,
-0.6131612658500671,
0.36726289987564087,
-0.7204049825668335,
0.47288745641708374,
0.3624633550643921,
0.18504151701927185,
-0.709777295589447,
0.046888742595911026,
0.2076064646244049,
-0.3815361261367798,
0.14887896180152893,
-0.3747416138648987,
-0.6932331919670105,
-0.13272665441036224,
-0.44187912344932556,
0.40512654185295105,
0.44365397095680237,
-0.3232475817203522,
0.37476786971092224,
0.1779998242855072,
-0.15953001379966736,
-0.6100884675979614,
-0.48191753029823303,
0.3271237313747406,
0.08046439290046692,
-0.4946485161781311,
0.16366885602474213,
0.04304943606257439,
-0.5297818183898926,
0.1733018308877945,
-0.03254326432943344,
-0.06756565719842911,
0.13944748044013977,
0.15022771060466766,
0.31114351749420166,
-0.3250134289264679,
0.19043375551700592,
-0.05533479526638985,
-0.05818304792046547,
0.10754568874835968,
0.0199614055454731,
0.33709287643432617,
-0.5563833117485046,
-0.537559986114502,
-0.553808867931366,
-0.32970044016838074,
1.0193970203399658,
-0.4793369472026825,
0.4401648938655853,
0.017814891412854195,
-0.3487948775291443,
-0.051018521189689636,
-0.4879142642021179,
-0.09759719669818878,
-0.3845996558666229,
0.4132295846939087,
-0.4403884708881378,
-0.8313092589378357,
0.5344746112823486,
-0.1389402151107788,
0.2297770231962204,
0.19831544160842896,
0.41333696246147156,
0.3819911777973175,
0.5311327576637268,
0.2808424234390259,
0.11631899327039719,
0.5209129452705383,
-0.20799049735069275,
0.0015314926858991385,
-1.1075223684310913,
0.04111379012465477,
-0.8097823858261108,
-0.35582950711250305,
-0.6733403205871582,
-0.8372376561164856,
0.1882859468460083,
0.2482512891292572,
-0.5159720778465271,
0.5546547174453735,
-0.5320142507553101,
0.5770936608314514,
0.36961352825164795,
0.003213767195120454,
0.515319287776947,
-0.3900429904460907,
0.023602258414030075,
0.02690829336643219,
-0.6354637742042542,
-0.8476225137710571,
1.1080230474472046,
0.6245355606079102,
0.8544790744781494,
0.15451225638389587,
0.6786808371543884,
0.5703180432319641,
0.7207930088043213,
-0.7274980545043945,
0.6082941293716431,
0.06531798839569092,
-0.2846565246582031,
-0.5575941801071167,
-0.42360514402389526,
-0.6223759651184082,
0.3539726734161377,
-0.1543736755847931,
-0.4403012990951538,
0.13828834891319275,
-0.09218338876962662,
-0.24562546610832214,
0.38474637269973755,
-0.8901405930519104,
0.9310756325721741,
-0.04977314546704292,
-0.3993323743343353,
-0.2744394540786743,
-0.1445833295583725,
0.23368827998638153,
-0.0872659757733345,
0.24446693062782288,
0.09436063468456268,
-0.41165339946746826,
0.40022358298301697,
-0.3417799472808838,
0.4596504867076874,
-0.20384903252124786,
-0.08153674751520157,
0.41520944237709045,
0.4957413077354431,
0.5798677206039429,
0.021021412685513496,
-0.4754932224750519,
-0.0529710128903389,
0.2182169407606125,
-0.3538212776184082,
-0.8230742812156677,
0.6530941724777222,
-0.7176572680473328,
-0.5885406732559204,
-0.13725587725639343,
-0.36626797914505005,
-0.14228254556655884,
-0.0006428916240110993,
-0.18336021900177002,
0.7697873115539551,
-0.36311134696006775,
0.3993242383003235,
0.44407376646995544,
-0.5486946702003479,
0.08633222430944443,
0.7339313626289368,
-0.43771862983703613,
-0.45859578251838684,
0.8488004803657532,
0.1393161118030548,
0.4669075608253479,
0.349098265171051,
0.2271222025156021,
-0.3161832094192505,
-0.5708904266357422,
-0.7364404201507568,
0.11274022608995438,
-0.7330147624015808,
-0.4271518290042877,
-0.4603685736656189,
-0.13521568477153778,
-0.18612433969974518,
-0.13969483971595764,
-0.42429494857788086,
-0.24538731575012207,
0.07791999727487564,
0.22449180483818054,
0.43386223912239075,
0.9849507212638855,
0.2788218557834625,
-0.2117932140827179,
-1.1034713983535767,
0.15085524320602417,
0.2889765799045563,
0.5941256880760193,
0.05192306637763977,
-0.9999101161956787,
-0.33225423097610474,
0.011161375790834427,
-0.11873171478509903,
-0.7898626923561096,
0.13869725167751312,
-0.016872882843017578,
0.5079730749130249,
-0.10398508608341217,
0.38950106501579285,
0.49694639444351196,
-0.3958078622817993,
0.5930910110473633,
-0.25659748911857605,
-1.1406878232955933,
0.41418027877807617,
-0.20622794330120087,
0.4977071285247803,
0.6009220480918884,
0.015790289267897606,
-0.643913209438324,
-0.7295331358909607,
-0.3171604871749878,
-0.3633687198162079,
0.7028720378875732,
0.0935642346739769,
-0.012292178347706795,
-0.10089212656021118,
0.4474228620529175,
-0.027193617075681686,
0.12015955150127411,
-0.4279222786426544,
0.07100743800401688,
0.03497467562556267,
0.19623512029647827,
0.3229631781578064,
-0.33580121397972107,
0.19079448282718658,
-0.002698069903999567,
0.4839322865009308,
0.00049970782129094,
0.04725836217403412,
0.2560447156429291,
-0.3579005002975464,
-0.2872660756111145,
0.6913231015205383,
0.6751874089241028,
0.9771355390548706,
-0.31603366136550903,
-0.07668251544237137,
0.2915658950805664,
-0.37869158387184143,
0.026064690202474594,
-0.1381131410598755,
-0.06405645608901978,
-0.2655731737613678,
0.609428346157074,
0.673088788986206,
0.4908458888530731,
-1.1283284425735474,
0.4223898649215698,
-0.37335342168807983,
-0.1076546236872673,
0.05059026926755905,
0.17959752678871155,
0.089754119515419,
0.5188795924186707,
0.19553285837173462,
-0.06522362679243088,
0.07608453929424286,
-0.530487060546875,
0.11921622604131699,
0.039103180170059204,
-0.4833117723464966,
-0.2764200270175934,
0.13383105397224426,
0.289737343788147,
-0.7741223573684692,
0.736264705657959,
-0.29979193210601807,
-0.5985507369041443,
0.6992385983467102,
0.25367024540901184,
1.092543601989746,
-0.11193876713514328,
0.004033879842609167,
0.3541993498802185,
0.46068185567855835,
0.0068855746649205685,
0.17126469314098358,
0.10216306149959564,
-0.5663546919822693,
-0.5606538653373718,
-0.4326932728290558,
-0.7262305617332458,
0.023241903632879257,
-0.8312806487083435,
0.2209414839744568,
-0.4615686237812042,
-0.19052542746067047,
-0.22619087994098663,
0.08945433050394058,
-0.4832170009613037,
-0.18488498032093048,
-0.2734670639038086,
1.1632652282714844,
-0.49049028754234314,
0.7868978381156921,
0.9980994462966919,
-0.17000721395015717,
-0.5784542560577393,
0.09886883199214935,
-0.10883855819702148,
-0.6324115991592407,
0.6375503540039062,
0.045004818588495255,
-0.22054368257522583,
-0.08217617124319077,
-0.3304612338542938,
-0.5403223633766174,
1.1645054817199707,
0.5583080649375916,
-0.9464828968048096,
0.2455201894044876,
-0.30001190304756165,
0.8142071962356567,
-0.3201269209384918,
0.5338230729103088,
0.7523406147956848,
0.421737402677536,
-0.2877475917339325,
-0.9628622531890869,
0.09143508225679398,
-0.23043318092823029,
0.0644664540886879,
0.3992885947227478,
-0.6719584465026855,
0.7422009706497192,
-0.29609817266464233,
-0.2676653265953064,
0.1966933161020279,
0.3997173011302948,
0.43222957849502563,
0.08809392899274826,
0.5636399388313293,
0.5754449963569641,
0.6242364048957825,
0.00991599541157484,
1.1423676013946533,
-0.7131655812263489,
0.3550834059715271,
1.12563955783844,
-0.4359820783138275,
1.0845630168914795,
0.31223514676094055,
-0.4388863146305084,
0.4171557128429413,
0.4020993709564209,
0.2218138575553894,
0.15951380133628845,
0.6331465840339661,
-0.21363502740859985,
-0.0988452360033989,
-0.11390381306409836,
-0.31477150321006775,
0.28454363346099854,
0.18515409529209137,
-0.18959090113639832,
-0.06562941521406174,
-0.18372038006782532,
-0.25745832920074463,
0.4308561384677887,
-0.17797178030014038,
0.6239396333694458,
-0.11879248917102814,
-0.5652868151664734,
0.7039777040481567,
0.07500163465738297,
0.28248143196105957,
-0.22833862900733948,
-0.26800337433815,
-0.34439322352409363,
-0.04886603727936745,
0.05556018278002739,
-0.9095864295959473,
0.11821435391902924,
0.5643540024757385,
-0.14254671335220337,
-0.28550419211387634,
0.5916947722434998,
-0.04806587100028992,
-0.033937543630599976,
0.41409361362457275,
0.5494886040687561,
0.19194728136062622,
-0.02755575068295002,
-0.8926407694816589,
0.5902836322784424,
-0.016112180426716805,
-0.5154827833175659,
0.4875348210334778,
0.7335172295570374,
-0.0532056950032711,
0.8798273205757141,
0.36403822898864746,
0.11459586769342422,
-0.35680967569351196,
0.32033365964889526,
0.914078414440155,
-0.6891592144966125,
-0.10602502524852753,
-0.7228864431381226,
0.1679285764694214,
0.1701982021331787,
-0.3208160698413849,
0.4275035262107849,
0.5281753540039062,
0.8683282732963562,
0.08397287875413895,
0.5711916089057922,
0.017467984929680824,
0.6044854521751404,
-0.5162094831466675,
0.5363942384719849,
-0.3309660851955414,
0.5751450657844543,
-0.17112231254577637,
-1.1189846992492676,
0.09202537685632706,
0.40332210063934326,
-0.5273985862731934,
0.06510244309902191,
0.6066868901252747,
1.0921956300735474,
0.36956289410591125,
0.06515152752399445,
0.4274667799472809,
0.18514509499073029,
0.1367809921503067,
0.4416423738002777,
1.3089134693145752,
-0.505426824092865,
0.4368838667869568,
-0.14153964817523956,
-0.20194366574287415,
-0.28615304827690125,
-0.7323552370071411,
-0.6880526542663574,
-0.38548722863197327,
-0.26193562150001526,
-0.3311263620853424,
0.3681034743785858,
1.1678311824798584,
0.239137202501297,
-0.7128626704216003,
-0.20783396065235138,
0.10184068977832794,
0.2949373424053192,
-0.14223062992095947,
-0.20438002049922943,
0.28877899050712585,
-0.38399267196655273,
-0.7869693636894226,
0.4341451823711395,
0.5046127438545227,
-0.24998822808265686,
-0.4852979779243469,
-0.2673492729663849,
0.00852250400930643,
-0.015968572348356247,
0.43492206931114197,
0.2915319800376892,
-0.7948874235153198,
-0.48714137077331543,
0.27343758940696716,
-0.6205655932426453,
-0.12437541782855988,
0.8197740912437439,
-0.744733989238739,
0.641356885433197,
0.642756998538971,
0.9668920040130615,
-0.1608523577451706,
0.1714928299188614,
0.6195906400680542,
-0.176976278424263,
-0.3190051317214966,
0.35838782787323,
0.24198664724826813,
0.29599228501319885,
-0.0618244931101799,
0.5649973154067993,
-0.01965993084013462,
-0.9336884021759033,
-1.0260642766952515,
-0.172697976231575,
-0.49480733275413513,
-0.1894492655992508,
1.031733512878418,
-0.43552571535110474,
-0.30608469247817993,
0.01759237051010132,
-0.1936987340450287,
0.2566297948360443,
-0.4608978033065796,
0.6228827834129333,
0.7199100852012634,
0.08056788891553879,
-0.30798545479774475,
-0.7641676664352417,
0.21175086498260498,
0.22720813751220703,
-0.6611891388893127,
0.41709092259407043,
0.6805852651596069,
0.13054543733596802,
-0.13556894659996033,
0.48515740036964417,
-0.19849808514118195,
0.5648460388183594,
-0.015156225301325321,
0.45854198932647705,
-0.18405985832214355,
-0.288131982088089,
-0.6368244290351868,
-0.11123020201921463,
0.5640319585800171,
0.03203420713543892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16797v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16797v2 | Lottery Ticket Adaptation: Mitigating Destructive Interference in LLMs | 2024-06-24T16:58:23 | 2024-06-25T13:46:41 | Ashwinee Panda, Berivan Isik, Xiangyu Qi, Sanmi Koyejo, Tsachy Weissman, Prateek Mittal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing methods for adapting large language models (LLMs) to new tasks are
not suited to multi-task adaptation because they modify all the model weights
-- causing destructive interference between tasks. The resulting effects, such
as catastrophic forgetting of earlier tasks, make it challenging to obtain good
performance on multiple tasks at the same time. To mitigate this, we propose
Lottery Ticket Adaptation (LoTA), a sparse adaptation method that identifies
and optimizes only a sparse subnetwork of the model. We evaluate LoTA on a wide
range of challenging tasks such as instruction following, reasoning, math, and
summarization. LoTA obtains better performance than full fine-tuning and
low-rank adaptation (LoRA), and maintains good performance even after training
on other tasks -- thus, avoiding catastrophic forgetting. By extracting and
fine-tuning over lottery tickets (or sparse task vectors), LoTA also enables
model merging over highly dissimilar tasks. Our code is made publicly available
at https://github.com/kiddyboots216/lottery-ticket-adaptation. | [
-0.11925896257162094,
-0.612342894077301,
0.0818958580493927,
0.6122122406959534,
-0.4184989333152771,
0.044931571930646896,
-0.11355695873498917,
-0.44811582565307617,
0.3026961386203766,
0.7938584089279175,
-0.5166289210319519,
-0.06401383876800537,
-0.7088145613670349,
-0.08312994986772537,
-0.3169139623641968,
1.0765920877456665,
-0.009766291826963425,
0.17002806067466736,
-0.3736458122730255,
0.037410225719213486,
-0.6937344074249268,
-0.3909571170806885,
-0.9483086466789246,
-0.24381355941295624,
0.6135799288749695,
0.31337374448776245,
0.32024073600769043,
0.2518867254257202,
0.6944238543510437,
0.4130397140979767,
0.07471779733896255,
0.35411086678504944,
-0.9637643098831177,
0.09430582821369171,
-0.4024995267391205,
-0.7050395011901855,
-0.35388854146003723,
-0.23071333765983582,
0.5832076668739319,
0.6606301069259644,
-0.08358263224363327,
0.16043005883693695,
0.4740835130214691,
0.6740802526473999,
-0.7474282383918762,
0.22453367710113525,
-0.9662807583808899,
0.09671282768249512,
-0.035588931292295456,
-0.7719752788543701,
-0.3494199514389038,
-0.27502647042274475,
-0.2844674289226532,
-0.8833049535751343,
-0.0226031094789505,
-0.0019303953740745783,
0.6728760004043579,
0.5696268677711487,
-0.1439979374408722,
-0.3558518588542938,
-0.9516469836235046,
0.670469343662262,
-0.3521387279033661,
-0.00848532747477293,
0.41090089082717896,
0.09265653789043427,
-0.6278999447822571,
-0.013152094557881355,
-0.46255677938461304,
-0.06701203435659409,
0.4549521505832672,
0.26255959272384644,
-0.2912157475948334,
0.11022897064685822,
0.22213789820671082,
-0.13058769702911377,
-0.40931519865989685,
0.1185474693775177,
-0.39540767669677734,
-0.09225992858409882,
0.578386127948761,
0.18211457133293152,
0.17721162736415863,
-0.11392614990472794,
-0.29269519448280334,
0.019890177994966507,
-0.7091682553291321,
0.005650196224451065,
0.39294010400772095,
0.35527005791664124,
-0.08165130019187927,
0.4335331916809082,
-0.1285358965396881,
0.7101831436157227,
0.3196756839752197,
-0.3898279070854187,
0.06227736547589302,
-0.3609660565853119,
-0.18475282192230225,
-0.1077263355255127,
0.4186260402202606,
0.21702364087104797,
0.35608142614364624,
-0.47799909114837646,
-0.24685180187225342,
-0.2686551809310913,
0.13425695896148682,
-0.5381684899330139,
-0.059275079518556595,
0.06774526089429855,
-0.48720067739486694,
-0.2129472941160202,
-0.2285481095314026,
-0.6286285519599915,
-0.8747439384460449,
-0.3404611647129059,
0.9426854252815247,
-0.24018149077892303,
-0.01574007421731949,
0.20772603154182434,
-0.10958829522132874,
0.23237144947052002,
0.49692174792289734,
-0.9491754174232483,
0.36503902077674866,
0.769408643245697,
0.7045214176177979,
-0.23250579833984375,
-0.6940023899078369,
-0.8961700201034546,
0.2275114804506302,
-0.45650696754455566,
0.913811445236206,
-0.01624305173754692,
-0.16472157835960388,
-0.23506052792072296,
0.04608264937996864,
-0.3869357109069824,
-0.8642800450325012,
0.34405869245529175,
-0.7558647990226746,
-0.10126744955778122,
-0.04281129315495491,
-0.26654380559921265,
-0.07020649313926697,
0.0436103530228138,
-0.7634738087654114,
0.6926053762435913,
0.21132393181324005,
-0.2711374759674072,
0.45539137721061707,
-0.5411301255226135,
-0.6068214178085327,
-0.026546848937869072,
0.30030202865600586,
-0.4284707009792328,
0.5014663934707642,
-0.0025916139129549265,
0.3386431336402893,
-0.21780306100845337,
0.14363889396190643,
-0.5327593088150024,
-0.7309585809707642,
0.30336257815361023,
-0.4480980336666107,
0.7837555408477783,
0.06777853518724442,
-0.0893079861998558,
0.16487689316272736,
-0.8716254234313965,
-0.46986159682273865,
0.03590867668390274,
-0.5212692022323608,
-0.5210801362991333,
0.29809170961380005,
0.16862493753433228,
0.25023123621940613,
0.28209665417671204,
-0.13610327243804932,
0.3141270577907562,
-0.4316944479942322,
0.02490980364382267,
1.1508047580718994,
-0.11449220776557922,
0.5964031219482422,
-0.6247201561927795,
0.4311003088951111,
0.39949291944503784,
0.22666394710540771,
0.2937200963497162,
-0.3117815852165222,
-0.8249574899673462,
0.056579310446977615,
0.5011300444602966,
0.8272852301597595,
-1.0896897315979004,
0.41187727451324463,
-0.38849329948425293,
-0.1634799838066101,
-0.4460722506046295,
0.5836526155471802,
-0.04063257575035095,
0.042612962424755096,
-0.0852096751332283,
-0.6784127950668335,
-0.8360303640365601,
-0.5026953816413879,
-0.1843898743391037,
0.038498975336551666,
0.09906627982854843,
0.3333646059036255,
0.5683456659317017,
0.1918443888425827,
0.7102867364883423,
-0.20778588950634003,
-0.6765100359916687,
-0.1201736330986023,
-0.09392933547496796,
0.29840847849845886,
0.6522451639175415,
0.6652663350105286,
-0.6442831158638,
-0.34062957763671875,
0.09873764961957932,
-0.4416925013065338,
-0.16396409273147583,
-0.6829239130020142,
-0.1117616593837738,
0.27550965547561646,
0.1739823818206787,
-0.39359429478645325,
0.31386446952819824,
0.8353650569915771,
-0.5773123502731323,
0.2537487745285034,
-0.3222212493419647,
0.13957206904888153,
-1.2655580043792725,
-0.2783239185810089,
-0.2711983323097229,
-0.2119164615869522,
-0.41416844725608826,
-0.22760027647018433,
-0.22831621766090393,
-0.02730593830347061,
-0.1993778795003891,
0.37017902731895447,
-0.4634445905685425,
-0.28569716215133667,
-0.7758992314338684,
0.22042976319789886,
-0.22847424447536469,
0.427609920501709,
-0.23573070764541626,
0.8802895545959473,
0.680072546005249,
-0.4647074043750763,
0.36286574602127075,
0.04659547656774521,
-0.42421191930770874,
0.6846646666526794,
-0.06012116000056267,
0.007145597133785486,
-0.24912896752357483,
0.037018414586782455,
-0.9047204256057739,
-0.068234384059906,
0.5296882390975952,
-0.2206043154001236,
0.3524896502494812,
-0.146088108420372,
-0.2959100604057312,
-0.017018482089042664,
-0.2850705087184906,
0.35115426778793335,
0.3324766159057617,
-0.5250305533409119,
0.9310230016708374,
0.42806699872016907,
-0.29223769903182983,
-0.5520399212837219,
-0.3405330181121826,
0.5316938757896423,
-0.16244512796401978,
-0.3114583194255829,
0.20678648352622986,
-0.1821105033159256,
-0.03132316470146179,
0.1589212268590927,
-0.0032815695740282536,
-0.25205281376838684,
0.43114933371543884,
0.32534030079841614,
0.3272441327571869,
-0.18691572546958923,
0.027246417477726936,
0.150424987077713,
-0.24079100787639618,
-0.11532969027757645,
-0.34897738695144653,
0.3161308467388153,
0.6077409982681274,
-0.26117241382598877,
-0.24560298025608063,
0.3081137537956238,
0.6092463135719299,
0.23152348399162292,
0.8052580952644348,
0.5485507845878601,
-0.46804994344711304,
-0.39972713589668274,
-0.6246863603591919,
-0.11803653836250305,
-0.4422222375869751,
0.8317000269889832,
-0.5531465411186218,
-0.9124714136123657,
0.6418303847312927,
-0.2548033893108368,
-0.2367754429578781,
0.07718224078416824,
0.6354333162307739,
0.10013671964406967,
0.4972720146179199,
0.8328580260276794,
-0.41424307227134705,
0.7749900817871094,
0.14125671982765198,
0.1990605741739273,
-0.6631777286529541,
-0.025064704939723015,
-0.5742642879486084,
-0.3729536831378937,
-0.3767710328102112,
-0.8501423001289368,
0.16553455591201782,
0.24809740483760834,
0.20130093395709991,
0.20400087535381317,
-0.24703660607337952,
0.8111823797225952,
0.5069340467453003,
0.1167180985212326,
0.3127194941043854,
0.02883666567504406,
0.6437209248542786,
0.22885853052139282,
-0.9757267236709595,
-0.06004171073436737,
1.3131948709487915,
0.05425094813108444,
0.759684145450592,
0.1203366219997406,
0.8432895541191101,
0.14724323153495789,
0.6177033185958862,
-0.537269115447998,
0.5373906493186951,
-0.39972877502441406,
-0.5498507022857666,
-0.45596984028816223,
-0.7206318378448486,
-1.0608038902282715,
0.33470672369003296,
-0.40618062019348145,
-0.9607245326042175,
0.3908306658267975,
-0.06872469186782837,
-0.5547183752059937,
0.3019363284111023,
-0.6909490823745728,
0.6428813934326172,
-0.12139218300580978,
-0.5805914402008057,
-0.4320957064628601,
0.07478681951761246,
0.5212509036064148,
-0.6926767230033875,
0.39158785343170166,
-0.13261541724205017,
-0.16940076649188995,
0.8934679627418518,
-0.0569012276828289,
1.160990834236145,
-0.06705029308795929,
-0.134579598903656,
0.20764882862567902,
0.03864111378788948,
0.8803900480270386,
-0.2618871033191681,
-0.12726494669914246,
0.13970503211021423,
0.08188102394342422,
-0.554337739944458,
-0.5266127586364746,
0.9299306273460388,
-0.9327928423881531,
-0.6210092306137085,
-0.30928316712379456,
-1.0555694103240967,
-0.17651152610778809,
-0.035667743533849716,
-0.2070363312959671,
0.1490381956100464,
0.06237014755606651,
0.027712533250451088,
0.5080744624137878,
-0.1601133942604065,
0.47878843545913696,
0.4095389246940613,
-0.03611476719379425,
-0.49349120259284973,
1.2766001224517822,
0.20353996753692627,
0.07884100079536438,
0.47821909189224243,
0.021218296140432358,
-0.04809148237109184,
-1.0706466436386108,
-0.2584351599216461,
0.08315085619688034,
-0.6404094099998474,
-0.25712355971336365,
-0.18854641914367676,
-0.04458880424499512,
-0.4907389283180237,
-0.050190240144729614,
-0.11973772197961807,
-0.5310830473899841,
-0.5769904851913452,
0.33364337682724,
0.2087079882621765,
0.8982176184654236,
-0.3207464814186096,
0.25359976291656494,
-0.6150435209274292,
0.38565346598625183,
0.32292306423187256,
0.5821741223335266,
0.21307334303855896,
-0.8478235006332397,
-0.42212191224098206,
-0.4931679368019104,
-0.3197193741798401,
-0.8595936894416809,
0.058061812072992325,
0.22403113543987274,
0.4526558220386505,
0.18610532581806183,
-0.09870301187038422,
0.9101366996765137,
-0.4765724837779999,
0.4089854657649994,
0.3979398012161255,
-0.9777249693870544,
0.002748339669778943,
-0.21598079800605774,
0.020478082820773125,
0.31453678011894226,
-0.019560683518648148,
-0.2512008845806122,
-0.2602764666080475,
-0.13300934433937073,
-0.6451302766799927,
0.9972590804100037,
0.052533622831106186,
0.25100669264793396,
0.424391508102417,
0.41557228565216064,
0.08729355782270432,
0.14291179180145264,
-0.9779465198516846,
-0.043837327510118484,
-0.02466452494263649,
-0.2693246006965637,
-0.3411742150783539,
-0.4721779227256775,
-0.2026093751192093,
-0.26054006814956665,
0.6737056374549866,
-0.3201051354408264,
-0.07425687462091446,
-0.14181914925575256,
-0.04113588482141495,
-0.45181798934936523,
0.12227007001638412,
0.8434775471687317,
0.7322161197662354,
0.07452652603387833,
-0.07257788628339767,
0.5873152613639832,
-0.5686478018760681,
0.15936234593391418,
0.3664015233516693,
-0.1523590087890625,
-0.34852734208106995,
0.48274096846580505,
0.6995380520820618,
0.6384817361831665,
-0.5768102407455444,
0.356622576713562,
0.17758327722549438,
-0.399223268032074,
-0.04845162853598595,
0.2466684877872467,
0.2115478366613388,
0.5369289517402649,
0.5004612803459167,
0.11482103168964386,
-0.05418764799833298,
-0.4801601767539978,
0.16902785003185272,
0.5975877642631531,
-0.306833952665329,
-0.08751930296421051,
0.5554527640342712,
0.3356865346431732,
-0.5231266021728516,
0.036507170647382736,
-0.32296162843704224,
-0.37442663311958313,
0.6303080320358276,
0.7157692313194275,
1.019681453704834,
-0.16393786668777466,
0.0744660347700119,
0.1272713840007782,
0.5133579969406128,
0.02929128147661686,
0.4020138382911682,
0.01818765327334404,
-0.7914534211158752,
-0.9906914830207825,
-0.6408326625823975,
-0.22413058578968048,
0.10301454365253448,
-0.19767872989177704,
-0.011516057886183262,
-0.2900099754333496,
0.11581848561763763,
-0.12160059064626694,
0.05218307301402092,
-0.3139566481113434,
-0.1880764663219452,
0.24342283606529236,
0.8063779473304749,
-0.7407222390174866,
0.8392876386642456,
0.530674397945404,
-0.23404254019260406,
-0.7089110612869263,
-0.18993695080280304,
-0.16917195916175842,
-0.6167982220649719,
0.640446662902832,
-0.5146815180778503,
0.12891444563865662,
0.013037821277976036,
-0.24858596920967102,
-1.1210219860076904,
0.9528970122337341,
0.3248264789581299,
-0.7716588973999023,
0.22601692378520966,
0.2656843960285187,
0.18739546835422516,
-0.30800163745880127,
-0.047593001276254654,
0.3710007965564728,
0.3284194767475128,
0.19309042394161224,
-1.2014654874801636,
0.06504596024751663,
0.15581876039505005,
-0.12476292997598648,
0.2713848650455475,
-0.5898433327674866,
0.6307227611541748,
-0.20326638221740723,
0.15417416393756866,
0.4058372378349304,
0.39673012495040894,
0.2233109027147293,
0.4179841876029968,
0.7157628536224365,
0.23859256505966187,
0.7171822190284729,
-0.23590941727161407,
0.6082074046134949,
-0.38232508301734924,
0.4809475541114807,
0.9187905192375183,
-0.5136885643005371,
0.69521564245224,
0.8691185712814331,
-0.34884732961654663,
0.13961154222488403,
0.3935827612876892,
0.08228451013565063,
0.4506469964981079,
0.5926223993301392,
-0.16726522147655487,
-0.5609687566757202,
0.041205909103155136,
-0.13849614560604095,
0.5598672032356262,
0.0643278956413269,
0.1673751324415207,
-0.39552655816078186,
0.2918578088283539,
-0.4979313313961029,
-0.1451679766178131,
-0.5001822710037231,
0.8954073786735535,
0.045960649847984314,
-0.7166959643363953,
0.5670211911201477,
-0.19552047550678253,
0.6808436512947083,
-0.6305405497550964,
-0.0725560337305069,
-0.13934765756130219,
0.480790913105011,
-0.025963561609387398,
-0.2592187225818634,
0.22202140092849731,
-0.256028950214386,
-0.34606465697288513,
0.04953069984912872,
0.9841579794883728,
-0.3861996531486511,
-0.4757924973964691,
0.36669352650642395,
0.5482586622238159,
0.0525098480284214,
-0.0050468165427446365,
-1.0172163248062134,
0.4703010320663452,
0.08078595250844955,
-0.2535119354724884,
0.8288258910179138,
0.5810251832008362,
-0.0031660948880016804,
0.7456401586532593,
0.8775749802589417,
0.44007429480552673,
0.044277895241975784,
0.18271145224571228,
0.812827467918396,
-0.7444298267364502,
-0.4224894642829895,
-0.5872406959533691,
0.2267332375049591,
0.0342622771859169,
-0.30111947655677795,
0.6867243051528931,
0.6418008208274841,
0.7010518312454224,
-0.25892263650894165,
0.5744327902793884,
0.26375216245651245,
0.007800018880516291,
-0.6116138100624084,
0.5699888467788696,
-0.67116779088974,
0.40174272656440735,
-0.3810614049434662,
-0.8546063303947449,
-0.3703208863735199,
0.4041282534599304,
-0.2980405390262604,
-0.06364908814430237,
0.5891002416610718,
0.909061849117279,
-0.016178585588932037,
-0.20119497179985046,
0.5857046842575073,
0.15531207621097565,
0.03680091351270676,
1.1608315706253052,
0.9629229307174683,
-0.6067122220993042,
0.9040182828903198,
-0.23602914810180664,
-0.5011657476425171,
-0.3711492717266083,
-0.9198086857795715,
-0.8281630277633667,
-0.5380697250366211,
-0.45077449083328247,
-0.5606757402420044,
0.36185309290885925,
0.8016188144683838,
0.7506802082061768,
-0.9044331908226013,
-0.6022499799728394,
0.11782238632440567,
0.6574187278747559,
-0.5983871221542358,
-0.2052939087152481,
0.3375154435634613,
-0.42482414841651917,
-0.9212557077407837,
0.2672436237335205,
0.590245246887207,
0.01860806532204151,
-0.21583393216133118,
-0.15272392332553864,
-0.04398106783628464,
0.259486585855484,
0.6452744007110596,
0.11862551420927048,
-0.4244244694709778,
-0.320060670375824,
-0.27373021841049194,
0.01745377667248249,
-0.2133193165063858,
0.8952626585960388,
-0.603064775466919,
0.1551682949066162,
0.33502933382987976,
0.8108542561531067,
0.13663332164287567,
-0.18170048296451569,
0.2868041396141052,
-0.22088757157325745,
0.2654793858528137,
0.09096401929855347,
0.2622438073158264,
0.026783430948853493,
-0.3805737793445587,
0.3224743902683258,
0.4731030762195587,
-0.5417937636375427,
-0.9762383103370667,
-0.05591272935271263,
-1.2670966386795044,
-0.5684942603111267,
1.177001714706421,
0.22927071154117584,
-0.49500125646591187,
-0.5643008947372437,
-0.17455053329467773,
-0.04025962948799133,
-0.056845810264348984,
1.220970630645752,
0.8399412631988525,
0.03244282677769661,
-0.047875650227069855,
-0.40862327814102173,
0.43900224566459656,
0.48202571272850037,
-0.852508008480072,
0.06398585438728333,
0.19645000994205475,
0.4285224378108978,
0.1345156878232956,
0.7383076548576355,
0.21837788820266724,
0.5747169852256775,
0.13882723450660706,
0.06893160939216614,
-0.05934898182749748,
-0.210971400141716,
-0.5757352709770203,
0.5034626722335815,
0.25638750195503235,
-0.37645354866981506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16783v2 | M2Lingual: Enhancing Multilingual, Multi-Turn Instruction Alignment in Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T16:45:13 | 2024-06-28T10:14:53 | Rishabh Maheshwary, Vikas Yadav, Hoang Nguyen, Khyati Mahajan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction finetuning (IFT) is critical for aligning Large Language Models
(LLMs) to follow instructions. While many effective IFT datasets have been
introduced recently, they predominantly focus on high-resource languages like
English. To better align LLMs across a broad spectrum of languages and tasks,
we propose a fully synthetic, novel taxonomy (Evol) guided Multilingual,
Multi-turn instruction finetuning dataset, called M2Lingual. It is constructed
by first selecting a diverse set of seed examples and then utilizing the
proposed Evol taxonomy to convert these seeds into complex and challenging
multi-turn instructions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of M2Lingual by
training LLMs of varying sizes and showcasing the enhanced performance across a
diverse set of languages. We contribute the 2 step Evol taxonomy with the
guided generation code: https://github.com/ServiceNow/M2Lingual, as well as the
first fully synthetic, general and task-oriented, multi-turn, multilingual
dataset built with Evol - M2Lingual:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow-AI/ M2Lingual - containing 182K
total IFT pairs, covering 70 languages and 17+ NLP tasks. | [
-0.18448008596897125,
-0.6191515922546387,
0.1137690320611,
0.28992679715156555,
0.11773626506328583,
0.21278813481330872,
-0.5221672058105469,
-0.1847667694091797,
0.053923461586236954,
0.3118576407432556,
-0.7366571426391602,
-0.5509126782417297,
-0.4720940887928009,
0.1435399055480957,
-0.17756929993629456,
1.0321815013885498,
-0.1160108745098114,
0.3502160906791687,
-0.22877702116966248,
-0.28790947794914246,
-0.5484797954559326,
-0.41167378425598145,
-0.6944392323493958,
-0.27590107917785645,
0.5369485020637512,
0.7422297596931458,
0.4537372887134552,
0.7017176747322083,
0.2931159436702728,
0.3438635766506195,
0.33815431594848633,
0.7518343329429626,
-0.3591051995754242,
-0.04067615792155266,
-0.17866697907447815,
-0.3734073042869568,
-0.516656219959259,
-0.2032102644443512,
0.6115609407424927,
0.609462320804596,
-0.37454351782798767,
0.21647535264492035,
0.3022395670413971,
0.5928163528442383,
-0.24133709073066711,
0.3183031678199768,
-0.3585575520992279,
-0.03478769212961197,
-0.3189055621623993,
-0.19457867741584778,
-0.6014041304588318,
-0.06156594678759575,
-0.08443423360586166,
-0.8316075205802917,
-0.02449515275657177,
0.13204137980937958,
0.47264665365219116,
0.11377369612455368,
-0.5263237357139587,
-0.39714181423187256,
-0.651639997959137,
0.7854812741279602,
-0.7233324646949768,
0.7104609608650208,
0.2053125947713852,
0.3190154731273651,
0.11512813717126846,
-0.42409154772758484,
-0.5389530062675476,
-0.11205562204122543,
0.05355268716812134,
0.12359322607517242,
-0.03959045186638832,
-0.0035529006272554398,
-0.031782183796167374,
0.25064313411712646,
-0.7438294291496277,
0.6018407344818115,
-0.3237854242324829,
-0.2553705871105194,
0.6322823762893677,
0.12736696004867554,
0.27089786529541016,
0.12239730358123779,
-0.35227763652801514,
-0.13019344210624695,
-0.8118770122528076,
-0.08272293955087662,
0.5266990661621094,
0.6200069785118103,
-0.24081258475780487,
0.8328776955604553,
0.03978256508708,
0.825657069683075,
0.1970807909965515,
-0.3547798693180084,
0.22303889691829681,
-0.34851643443107605,
-0.016640370711684227,
0.1881335824728012,
0.7771576642990112,
0.5044187903404236,
0.15845000743865967,
-0.06855009496212006,
-0.3175262212753296,
-0.17332851886749268,
0.10738630592823029,
-0.7813678979873657,
-0.0661066472530365,
0.15408773720264435,
-0.0098646841943264,
-0.1021006777882576,
-0.15088064968585968,
-0.6802865266799927,
-0.23497116565704346,
-0.8704954385757446,
0.37189048528671265,
-0.7031863927841187,
-0.19596894085407257,
0.07159774750471115,
0.43907085061073303,
0.4021992087364197,
0.19038225710391998,
-1.1888151168823242,
0.13127629458904266,
1.0626786947250366,
0.767047107219696,
-0.14230497181415558,
-0.601766049861908,
-0.6157034039497375,
0.19588829576969147,
-0.3423583507537842,
0.5922609567642212,
-0.5703337788581848,
-0.053199026733636856,
0.23709474503993988,
0.3035764694213867,
-0.1513655185699463,
-0.355660080909729,
0.30858319997787476,
-0.3362980782985687,
0.6149565577507019,
0.10184101015329361,
-0.7232672572135925,
-0.19817379117012024,
0.48997002840042114,
-0.3934938311576843,
0.993439257144928,
-0.020915064960718155,
-0.39981719851493835,
0.14215798676013947,
-0.6145482659339905,
-0.6928772926330566,
-0.03725912794470787,
-0.4251241087913513,
-0.3289008140563965,
-0.20552398264408112,
0.12585382163524628,
0.3781997859477997,
-0.2459268420934677,
0.18327125906944275,
0.1068020835518837,
-0.04293771833181381,
-0.09685530513525009,
-0.5914876461029053,
0.7788782715797424,
0.07033446431159973,
-0.4625231921672821,
0.3056456744670868,
-0.7158787250518799,
0.12050911039113998,
-0.030736282467842102,
-0.3993854522705078,
-0.27697789669036865,
-0.21921905875205994,
0.11205270141363144,
0.22702881693840027,
0.362377792596817,
-0.5111618041992188,
0.6377835273742676,
-0.29429784417152405,
0.4001658260822296,
0.8479971289634705,
-0.42823854088783264,
0.5230814218521118,
-0.0919373631477356,
0.6935297846794128,
-0.005926568526774645,
0.13359712064266205,
-0.17110206186771393,
-0.6054472923278809,
-0.7067928314208984,
-0.2309865951538086,
0.4055255353450775,
0.8203389644622803,
-0.9487946629524231,
0.14749585092067719,
-0.4926028847694397,
-0.3074708580970764,
-0.9189968109130859,
0.2659412920475006,
0.771380603313446,
0.25066161155700684,
0.4020814597606659,
0.1388089507818222,
-0.5906824469566345,
-0.8923075199127197,
0.0738091841340065,
0.38035115599632263,
0.10343282669782639,
0.06282779574394226,
0.1444419026374817,
-0.5758508443832397,
0.38298705220222473,
-0.35482102632522583,
-0.3918989300727844,
-0.14236335456371307,
0.09211810678243637,
0.20078690350055695,
0.6825984716415405,
0.2839883863925934,
-0.6304240822792053,
-0.7053582072257996,
0.5215610265731812,
-0.4620826840400696,
0.06422121077775955,
-0.11284845322370529,
-0.35819679498672485,
0.441987007856369,
0.4521438777446747,
-0.6091318726539612,
-0.2903155982494354,
0.8332886695861816,
-0.23463867604732513,
0.5411797761917114,
-0.4329773783683777,
0.04848629608750343,
-1.4041227102279663,
-0.23230570554733276,
-0.004751725122332573,
-0.15331481397151947,
-0.606956958770752,
0.2597165107727051,
0.24366828799247742,
-0.10529829561710358,
-0.36915162205696106,
0.6341572403907776,
-0.6789858937263489,
-0.045534513890743256,
-0.1571027636528015,
0.05252200737595558,
-0.01691928692162037,
0.43666741251945496,
-0.11949474364519119,
0.9920625686645508,
0.4661288857460022,
-0.4553670585155487,
0.3689364194869995,
0.3692389726638794,
-0.20250703394412994,
0.6663238406181335,
-0.17468945682048798,
0.14425796270370483,
0.04830146208405495,
-0.0607057549059391,
-0.6974140405654907,
-0.34291642904281616,
0.08147064596414566,
-0.28709644079208374,
1.0243971347808838,
-0.2965588867664337,
-0.45196202397346497,
-0.17079250514507294,
-0.13833065330982208,
0.26986950635910034,
0.364383727312088,
-0.6711100935935974,
0.6792495250701904,
0.1686549186706543,
-0.058710988610982895,
-0.7643861174583435,
-0.6126405596733093,
0.09005424380302429,
-0.15050232410430908,
-0.5106548070907593,
0.418285071849823,
-0.1737508922815323,
-0.08764131367206573,
-0.22996598482131958,
-0.16542036831378937,
0.10459496825933456,
-0.16596101224422455,
-0.09866376966238022,
0.32174503803253174,
-0.4872283935546875,
0.10151778906583786,
0.2916344702243805,
-0.2912876605987549,
-0.2158960998058319,
-0.7330216765403748,
0.6569814085960388,
-0.1610134243965149,
-0.4101518392562866,
-0.3763793706893921,
0.5131018161773682,
0.6175063848495483,
-0.3701559007167816,
0.801916778087616,
0.8098500370979309,
-0.21784603595733643,
-0.2633100748062134,
-0.3576676845550537,
-0.1354992538690567,
-0.48401015996932983,
0.41703492403030396,
-0.412439227104187,
-0.8068832159042358,
0.04692043364048004,
0.10418257117271423,
0.5295584201812744,
0.413562148809433,
0.6312946081161499,
-0.27359434962272644,
1.1947439908981323,
0.7039386630058289,
-0.0609796904027462,
0.30323702096939087,
-0.3099654018878937,
0.2416936755180359,
-0.7843197584152222,
-0.297402024269104,
-0.22779537737369537,
-0.3870205581188202,
-0.8664650917053223,
-0.5664046406745911,
0.1300143599510193,
-0.07954000681638718,
-0.2437622845172882,
0.294795423746109,
-0.5644632577896118,
0.45613551139831543,
0.6574757695198059,
-0.04424968361854553,
0.015953304246068,
0.1787339597940445,
-0.21343868970870972,
-0.13922205567359924,
-0.838517427444458,
-0.6592195630073547,
1.0780036449432373,
-0.0017428586725145578,
0.6102962493896484,
0.3894815742969513,
0.7422040700912476,
0.08596116304397583,
0.3596246838569641,
-0.854543924331665,
0.3662651777267456,
-0.6900616884231567,
-0.46753183007240295,
-0.2881469130516052,
-0.3416106402873993,
-0.9270943999290466,
0.19275932013988495,
-0.12544257938861847,
-0.37644141912460327,
-0.224589541554451,
0.2966655194759369,
-0.3115518391132355,
0.15447495877742767,
-1.0015146732330322,
0.9734160304069519,
-0.7514115571975708,
-0.5003538727760315,
-0.05443352088332176,
-0.5135409832000732,
0.23230202496051788,
-0.00718475179746747,
0.4186408519744873,
0.01189110241830349,
-0.0959419310092926,
0.5634100437164307,
-0.4253126382827759,
0.873076319694519,
-0.14002320170402527,
-0.4293096661567688,
0.053719766438007355,
0.0573328398168087,
0.5027753710746765,
-0.2524043023586273,
0.0033936037216335535,
0.008756594732403755,
0.009413315914571285,
-0.40594056248664856,
-0.4847414195537567,
0.935706377029419,
-0.7680320739746094,
-0.5702545046806335,
-0.20901648700237274,
-0.6616382002830505,
-0.3326236307621002,
0.33898788690567017,
0.17924490571022034,
0.6436379551887512,
-0.00645191827788949,
0.15512916445732117,
0.6764647364616394,
-0.1121242418885231,
0.08454687893390656,
0.6115870475769043,
-0.37596020102500916,
-0.45056504011154175,
1.3607807159423828,
0.3060179650783539,
0.3714980483055115,
0.6900942921638489,
0.22910767793655396,
-0.26173481345176697,
-0.4824279546737671,
-0.8475905060768127,
0.13174742460250854,
-0.5329490303993225,
-0.3532507121562958,
-0.5851774215698242,
-0.09311528503894806,
-0.4478795528411865,
-0.11632684618234634,
-0.37173300981521606,
-0.46402445435523987,
-0.266917884349823,
-0.17754220962524414,
0.4245891869068146,
0.5673238635063171,
-0.08799802511930466,
0.3931783437728882,
-0.7955904006958008,
0.11778423935174942,
0.29982101917266846,
0.2869330644607544,
-0.20426522195339203,
-0.5389375686645508,
-0.4024222791194916,
0.2893178462982178,
-0.31739065051078796,
-0.5647757053375244,
0.35967886447906494,
0.646711528301239,
0.5029827952384949,
0.42571336030960083,
-0.3505249321460724,
0.7423681020736694,
-1.0250910520553589,
0.47936704754829407,
0.26437345147132874,
-0.6593638062477112,
0.1129610538482666,
-0.37423625588417053,
0.24211551249027252,
0.3032641112804413,
0.568257749080658,
-0.7076473832130432,
-0.13659194111824036,
-0.3034926950931549,
-0.9313413500785828,
0.6606888771057129,
-0.07693894952535629,
0.25615137815475464,
0.08867628872394562,
0.21337071061134338,
0.46978694200515747,
0.16844125092029572,
-0.5714582204818726,
-0.3154876232147217,
-0.1325649470090866,
-0.8414010405540466,
-0.3097202479839325,
-0.32441410422325134,
-0.3317653238773346,
-0.1586150825023651,
0.9304072856903076,
-0.4329395294189453,
0.2564297914505005,
-0.3948608934879303,
-0.14781856536865234,
0.17098353803157806,
0.25401660799980164,
0.8928893804550171,
0.4862918555736542,
0.17227965593338013,
0.1496124267578125,
-0.10029692947864532,
-0.372341513633728,
0.22925449907779694,
0.3304470479488373,
-0.0665910616517067,
-0.2505403459072113,
0.503290593624115,
0.7012240290641785,
0.4842545688152313,
-0.5952707529067993,
0.2900982201099396,
0.1762833297252655,
-0.10712907463312149,
-0.2533704936504364,
-0.08947032690048218,
0.30161380767822266,
0.3815481662750244,
0.08116074651479721,
-0.08196776360273361,
-0.06867625564336777,
-0.4650399684906006,
0.2203589230775833,
0.3923431634902954,
-0.1860479712486267,
-0.441007524728775,
0.5042629241943359,
0.26459965109825134,
-0.4574384093284607,
0.7580879330635071,
-0.3233564496040344,
-0.4657198190689087,
0.3517647087574005,
0.8104647994041443,
0.6977701187133789,
-0.4385300278663635,
0.14750483632087708,
0.4868850111961365,
0.5220898985862732,
0.18279869854450226,
0.359086275100708,
0.1457139551639557,
-0.7250807285308838,
-0.5898044109344482,
-0.5580676794052124,
-0.33903902769088745,
-0.0668637827038765,
-0.5011110305786133,
0.2639233469963074,
-0.17417562007904053,
0.12420734018087387,
0.019380902871489525,
-0.1316898912191391,
-0.6149230003356934,
0.0013990419683977962,
0.4323624074459076,
0.7689374685287476,
-0.8469879627227783,
0.9383606314659119,
0.8528171181678772,
-0.29367876052856445,
-0.7972290515899658,
-0.2530484199523926,
0.3250097334384918,
-0.9319120049476624,
0.4658624529838562,
0.353213906288147,
-0.05595248565077782,
0.11228151619434357,
-0.2773371636867523,
-0.7719273567199707,
1.0424787998199463,
0.3585187792778015,
-0.903454601764679,
-0.12700213491916656,
0.39389604330062866,
0.4666082262992859,
-0.5224140286445618,
0.010353137739002705,
0.4671073257923126,
0.5423039793968201,
-0.04201836884021759,
-0.6706945300102234,
-0.33947041630744934,
-0.17526434361934662,
-0.1675087958574295,
0.44275927543640137,
-0.6581435799598694,
0.5989282131195068,
-0.19164258241653442,
-0.03262686729431152,
0.02463199384510517,
0.6968345642089844,
0.23915113508701324,
0.3029652535915375,
0.2631884217262268,
0.5960336327552795,
0.8564184308052063,
-0.2608478367328644,
0.9018669128417969,
-0.3666408658027649,
0.12531280517578125,
1.3788949251174927,
-0.19210204482078552,
0.7808724641799927,
0.5145757794380188,
-0.0922173485159874,
0.2226959615945816,
0.7328822612762451,
0.12867380678653717,
0.40872716903686523,
-0.06292764842510223,
-0.14003190398216248,
-0.10447096079587936,
0.08513296395540237,
-0.22472108900547028,
0.49735385179519653,
0.42188113927841187,
-0.055036760866642,
0.05313841253519058,
0.30246126651763916,
0.24585410952568054,
0.057830002158880234,
-0.34241190552711487,
0.7617107629776001,
-0.06623745709657669,
-0.618599534034729,
0.6335744261741638,
-0.0025218497030436993,
0.84520024061203,
-0.6377677321434021,
-0.10887496918439865,
-0.39836740493774414,
0.3301667273044586,
-0.3660023510456085,
-0.7976157069206238,
0.10258352756500244,
0.07620576024055481,
-0.11597763746976852,
-0.3857335150241852,
0.11722944676876068,
-1.03070867061615,
-0.6690537929534912,
0.13858066499233246,
0.33079755306243896,
-0.03115326352417469,
0.3728680908679962,
-0.7921260595321655,
-0.15137958526611328,
0.36779141426086426,
-0.055482301861047745,
0.3620012700557709,
0.6263749003410339,
-0.1323796808719635,
0.6553893089294434,
0.6304914355278015,
-0.19488215446472168,
0.44114574790000916,
0.06358036398887634,
0.5278592705726624,
-0.2836289405822754,
-0.17865049839019775,
-0.674384593963623,
0.667087197303772,
0.05843384936451912,
-0.3809240758419037,
0.9720377922058105,
0.8529603481292725,
1.1273469924926758,
-0.20556651055812836,
0.4763718247413635,
-0.07995908707380295,
0.24883514642715454,
-0.7639414072036743,
0.49845239520072937,
-0.6693599820137024,
-0.01080545037984848,
0.10009882599115372,
-1.0314339399337769,
-0.08593697845935822,
0.3296296298503876,
-0.20025920867919922,
-0.04811834171414375,
0.43433600664138794,
0.8180983662605286,
-0.3674785792827606,
-0.14090238511562347,
0.3646666705608368,
0.17657944560050964,
0.362100750207901,
0.211750790476799,
0.6483876705169678,
-0.2876943051815033,
0.4058184325695038,
-0.4646941125392914,
-0.2429831475019455,
-0.1986064463853836,
-0.75181645154953,
-0.5432000756263733,
-0.756037175655365,
-0.32776719331741333,
-0.07814091444015503,
0.0068693263456225395,
1.2454702854156494,
0.6224195957183838,
-0.9475589394569397,
-0.41203656792640686,
0.09094611555337906,
-0.0838666707277298,
-0.5276326537132263,
-0.19754289090633392,
0.330218642950058,
-0.5106195211410522,
-0.8222463726997375,
0.5961064696311951,
0.20452235639095306,
0.08548028022050858,
-0.275407075881958,
-0.2122114598751068,
-0.42030736804008484,
-0.12725935876369476,
0.9126594662666321,
0.265106201171875,
-0.6584571599960327,
-0.10961635410785675,
0.1414562314748764,
-0.10603936016559601,
0.060637667775154114,
0.6602304577827454,
-0.07840517908334732,
0.6600309014320374,
0.10122962296009064,
0.8955378532409668,
0.27356740832328796,
-0.26580917835235596,
0.689331591129303,
-0.9483230710029602,
0.2291746437549591,
0.13466088473796844,
0.3711177408695221,
0.5079501271247864,
-0.31292903423309326,
0.5101271867752075,
-0.15211006999015808,
-0.5313195586204529,
-0.6109949350357056,
0.11540429294109344,
-0.7733657360076904,
0.042220354080200195,
1.2680609226226807,
0.013493099249899387,
-0.12042141705751419,
0.31901881098747253,
-0.43690943717956543,
0.3027174770832062,
-0.17156527936458588,
0.5358535051345825,
0.6910156011581421,
-0.01527758501470089,
-0.1935478299856186,
-0.6469732522964478,
0.2870975434780121,
0.31849634647369385,
-0.7376067638397217,
0.15202002227306366,
0.6183257102966309,
0.1488402634859085,
0.13282501697540283,
0.04637424647808075,
0.04675043746829033,
0.13506783545017242,
-0.2722337543964386,
0.27735862135887146,
-0.25093114376068115,
-0.43904560804367065,
-0.28322792053222656,
-0.21708229184150696,
0.09554436057806015,
-0.23817674815654755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16779v1 | It Is Not About What You Say, It Is About How You Say It: A Surprisingly Simple Approach for Improving Reading Comprehension | 2024-06-24T16:43:11 | 2024-06-24T16:43:11 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language processing has seen rapid progress over the past decade. Due
to the speed of developments, some practices get established without proper
evaluation. Considering one such case and focusing on reading comprehension, we
ask our first research question: 1) How does the order of inputs -- i.e.,
question and context -- affect model performance? Additionally, given recent
advancements in input emphasis, we ask a second research question: 2) Does
emphasizing either the question, the context, or both enhance performance?
Experimenting with 9 large language models across 3 datasets, we find that
presenting the context before the question improves model performance, with an
accuracy increase of up to $31\%$. Furthermore, emphasizing the context yields
superior results compared to question emphasis, and in general, emphasizing
parts of the input is particularly effective for addressing questions that
models lack the parametric knowledge to answer. Experimenting with both
prompt-based and attention-based emphasis methods, we additionally find that
the best method is surprisingly simple: it only requires concatenating a few
tokens to the input and results in an accuracy improvement of up to $36\%$,
allowing smaller models to outperform their significantly larger counterparts. | [
-0.43885597586631775,
-1.1004741191864014,
0.7599398493766785,
0.2632659673690796,
-0.44334685802459717,
-0.12941478192806244,
-0.22555822134017944,
-0.6099666953086853,
-0.37170547246932983,
0.38694220781326294,
-0.25486746430397034,
-0.16381053626537323,
-0.5669057965278625,
0.35205191373825073,
-0.3521047532558441,
0.6817713379859924,
0.27261048555374146,
0.24645835161209106,
-0.3024044334888458,
-0.28616762161254883,
-0.5785320997238159,
-0.38963207602500916,
-0.808688223361969,
-0.376768559217453,
0.6255236864089966,
0.477929949760437,
0.6102893352508545,
0.9210389852523804,
0.515805184841156,
0.3337256610393524,
-0.5236726999282837,
0.12198604643344879,
-0.2813161015510559,
0.21525099873542786,
-0.15591491758823395,
-0.5340999364852905,
0.08339697122573853,
-0.19833840429782867,
0.5482314825057983,
1.0318282842636108,
0.04135556519031525,
0.10831539332866669,
0.21867744624614716,
0.6230184435844421,
-0.7030436992645264,
0.006670593749731779,
-0.19710320234298706,
-0.272390753030777,
0.004164063837379217,
-0.5382845997810364,
-0.6022889018058777,
-0.036400698125362396,
0.5819467902183533,
-0.37750333547592163,
0.16186228394508362,
0.1602112054824829,
0.7029401063919067,
0.37625980377197266,
-0.5937807559967041,
-0.2762903869152069,
-0.7021948099136353,
0.7618390917778015,
-0.7439276576042175,
0.5111779570579529,
0.6094048619270325,
0.07731367647647858,
0.2777765393257141,
-0.6876415014266968,
-0.4287835657596588,
-0.08687825500965118,
-0.23970669507980347,
0.03724648803472519,
0.12303988635540009,
0.20645394921302795,
0.43055203557014465,
0.3379017114639282,
-0.5311440825462341,
-0.29188868403434753,
-0.4729222357273102,
0.0846988707780838,
0.4461863040924072,
-0.021928349509835243,
0.38412073254585266,
-0.22484764456748962,
-0.15082450211048126,
-0.13444159924983978,
-0.24556848406791687,
0.6155503988265991,
0.03173345699906349,
0.47587278485298157,
0.22422735393047333,
0.7488168478012085,
-0.501956045627594,
0.8929356336593628,
0.26735711097717285,
-0.07427829504013062,
-0.08421265333890915,
-0.7029373645782471,
-0.31439724564552307,
-0.15258485078811646,
0.32588890194892883,
0.5077167749404907,
0.24094730615615845,
-0.21514685451984406,
-0.007864653132855892,
-0.21455898880958557,
0.3315138518810272,
-0.603219747543335,
-0.08376371115446091,
0.27167850732803345,
-0.15136733651161194,
-0.05331919342279434,
-0.021280638873577118,
-0.5704894065856934,
-0.3976237177848816,
-0.3913155496120453,
0.38892555236816406,
-0.32231637835502625,
0.20765972137451172,
0.13758517801761627,
-0.23352950811386108,
0.585207998752594,
0.3105754256248474,
-1.1687742471694946,
0.4314897358417511,
0.7089592218399048,
0.532627284526825,
-0.04377412796020508,
-0.18147747218608856,
-0.5634357333183289,
-0.04965374991297722,
-0.29393908381462097,
1.036283016204834,
-0.6404256820678711,
-0.3310602605342865,
-0.08541179448366165,
-0.042340170592069626,
-0.28692540526390076,
-0.4257633686065674,
0.6698275208473206,
-0.7946143746376038,
0.42381811141967773,
-0.5135827660560608,
-0.7533334493637085,
-0.26278266310691833,
0.18724416196346283,
-0.6268337965011597,
1.2174431085586548,
-0.2919650673866272,
-0.801998496055603,
0.4290856719017029,
-0.5688080191612244,
-0.7461274266242981,
-0.1878986358642578,
0.19896157085895538,
0.1081971526145935,
0.18677476048469543,
0.6290732026100159,
0.18933571875095367,
-0.11393275856971741,
0.04815806448459625,
-0.062248487025499344,
-0.5979273319244385,
0.4835900068283081,
-0.4263606071472168,
0.4951257109642029,
-0.07463198155164719,
-0.27522188425064087,
-0.05459481105208397,
-0.48572593927383423,
0.2606232762336731,
-0.11328428238630295,
-0.47223594784736633,
-0.4394163489341736,
-0.13196614384651184,
-0.04129313305020332,
-0.06746157258749008,
0.03471275791525841,
-0.440880686044693,
-0.0855119377374649,
-0.962547242641449,
0.4879569113254547,
0.23072178661823273,
0.2578241229057312,
0.9939541220664978,
-0.3122818171977997,
0.5548362135887146,
-0.22015538811683655,
0.08725698292255402,
-0.4754449427127838,
-0.42662864923477173,
-0.7447682619094849,
0.24740912020206451,
0.556537926197052,
0.5918810367584229,
-0.6668843626976013,
0.03707820177078247,
0.2406005859375,
-0.2399560809135437,
-0.472517192363739,
0.1086927056312561,
0.43769532442092896,
0.9510217905044556,
0.4923483729362488,
-0.17743128538131714,
-0.3179647624492645,
-0.765495777130127,
-0.5376465320587158,
-0.3934161067008972,
0.13855282962322235,
0.19246749579906464,
0.10261750966310501,
0.4044469892978668,
0.8239249587059021,
-0.6760132312774658,
0.37240248918533325,
-0.5750890970230103,
0.2471081167459488,
0.04263025522232056,
0.28084635734558105,
0.18116791546344757,
-0.7419956922531128,
-0.4784587323665619,
-0.200275719165802,
-0.299545556306839,
-0.08383092284202576,
0.14619648456573486,
-0.27837952971458435,
0.13644015789031982,
0.5018121004104614,
-0.5487481951713562,
0.28140994906425476,
0.09420160949230194,
-0.3532508611679077,
0.4000552296638489,
-0.18262389302253723,
0.1537405550479889,
-0.7887334823608398,
0.1603468507528305,
0.06629987061023712,
-0.1660723239183426,
-1.0046802759170532,
0.24306079745292664,
0.230690136551857,
-0.04607898369431496,
-0.5671809911727905,
0.8487285375595093,
-0.29073426127433777,
0.24971206486225128,
-0.2782595157623291,
0.10111076384782791,
0.3735796809196472,
0.5096887350082397,
-0.05402039363980293,
0.788711428642273,
0.5054507851600647,
-0.690413773059845,
-0.1836596131324768,
0.18542158603668213,
-0.3940093517303467,
0.6400187611579895,
-0.8657445907592773,
0.3716316521167755,
-0.38595953583717346,
0.07078580558300018,
-1.341729998588562,
-0.19244028627872467,
0.2550084590911865,
-0.5227611064910889,
0.43860217928886414,
-0.04453559219837189,
-0.3278966248035431,
-0.27459806203842163,
-0.08554744720458984,
0.380039244890213,
0.39816781878471375,
-0.37939876317977905,
0.5212985873222351,
0.07383757084608078,
-0.38556259870529175,
-0.7117205262184143,
-0.9657915830612183,
-0.16197167336940765,
-0.2660822570323944,
-0.6501628756523132,
0.2292351871728897,
-0.2687700688838959,
-0.4018075466156006,
-0.24218840897083282,
-0.29721352458000183,
-0.699426531791687,
0.3402774930000305,
-0.15945273637771606,
0.0776357501745224,
-0.3418761193752289,
0.5041428804397583,
0.12766897678375244,
-0.005170063115656376,
-0.0505121648311615,
0.0435430146753788,
0.3363867402076721,
0.0698566883802414,
0.07969405502080917,
-0.5298059582710266,
0.436147004365921,
0.3873915672302246,
-0.3943753242492676,
0.621992290019989,
0.1465136557817459,
-0.07646685093641281,
-0.388801634311676,
-0.4678155183792114,
-0.5771727561950684,
-0.4754878282546997,
0.2814430892467499,
-0.24530377984046936,
-0.753862202167511,
0.14784003794193268,
0.28972992300987244,
0.16112132370471954,
0.04387884959578514,
0.25028035044670105,
-0.616396963596344,
1.2364959716796875,
0.6956868171691895,
0.22309553623199463,
0.6190869808197021,
0.005708919372409582,
0.3606712222099304,
-0.8151566982269287,
0.09679525345563889,
-0.5674031972885132,
-0.2857891023159027,
-0.024234017357230186,
-0.5132347941398621,
0.07002414762973785,
0.2495986521244049,
0.21268564462661743,
0.14126059412956238,
-0.36946436762809753,
0.6797771453857422,
0.4950127601623535,
0.17468658089637756,
0.5661332011222839,
-0.07881933450698853,
-0.0604727640748024,
-0.07051343470811844,
-0.595659613609314,
-0.7043064832687378,
1.0064860582351685,
0.3345588445663452,
0.4656563401222229,
-0.080551877617836,
0.4596235454082489,
-0.04311946779489517,
0.18130844831466675,
-0.9797242879867554,
0.37027594447135925,
0.23557546734809875,
-0.8460811972618103,
-0.700984537601471,
-0.11915300786495209,
-1.1218947172164917,
0.6379420161247253,
0.060354702174663544,
-0.6031661629676819,
0.2886006236076355,
0.2918224632740021,
-0.883262574672699,
-0.3032147288322449,
-0.9870873093605042,
0.7643447518348694,
-0.1183047741651535,
-0.41670793294906616,
0.05721276253461838,
-0.6995000839233398,
0.1982627660036087,
0.34314021468162537,
0.15209853649139404,
-0.04085201025009155,
-0.09897998720407486,
0.6348670125007629,
-0.3507287800312042,
0.5779476761817932,
-0.09890711307525635,
0.17237664759159088,
0.5083016753196716,
-0.24865618348121643,
0.2135826051235199,
0.08943364024162292,
-0.26509734988212585,
-0.4913078844547272,
0.2546994090080261,
-0.46747079491615295,
-1.1104077100753784,
0.0950830802321434,
-0.4366569221019745,
-0.6340503096580505,
-0.23481450974941254,
-0.667810320854187,
-0.521669864654541,
0.19396890699863434,
0.17912815511226654,
0.8198935389518738,
-0.23359447717666626,
0.22900564968585968,
0.9478914141654968,
0.1418272852897644,
0.6325175166130066,
0.43968015909194946,
0.03239443898200989,
-0.1570804864168167,
0.46688151359558105,
0.2889151871204376,
0.3563495874404907,
0.55605149269104,
0.2855047285556793,
-0.6712983250617981,
-0.4050788879394531,
-0.5670087933540344,
0.5383227467536926,
-0.9617108702659607,
0.19940179586410522,
-0.9883750677108765,
0.09772161394357681,
-0.5573052167892456,
-0.1037149652838707,
-0.018362492322921753,
-0.45938706398010254,
-0.34519198536872864,
-0.21020996570587158,
0.2170325070619583,
0.5964787006378174,
0.34991928935050964,
0.5051303505897522,
-0.363496333360672,
0.22129902243614197,
0.5285665392875671,
0.08722510933876038,
0.1927533894777298,
-0.6426747441291809,
-0.1553647220134735,
-0.12116194516420364,
-0.3452913165092468,
-0.978945255279541,
0.23906804621219635,
-0.02343055233359337,
0.534609317779541,
0.1479724496603012,
0.1448799967765808,
0.65358966588974,
-0.42216113209724426,
0.6901425123214722,
-0.3079150915145874,
-0.9067602157592773,
0.4115361273288727,
-0.03845422342419624,
0.7756808996200562,
1.1720001697540283,
0.10110867023468018,
-0.5565806031227112,
-0.46705201268196106,
-0.5324133038520813,
-0.7741996049880981,
0.7770699858665466,
-0.014879235997796059,
0.2181115746498108,
0.06116824597120285,
0.3679658770561218,
-0.1189902052283287,
0.1974320411682129,
-0.5022250413894653,
-0.3058955669403076,
0.08297812938690186,
-0.21667233109474182,
-0.20808513462543488,
-0.2967536747455597,
-0.13032294809818268,
-0.46825820207595825,
0.5481262803077698,
-0.2442716807126999,
0.24396702647209167,
0.5428257584571838,
-0.3837704360485077,
0.16457633674144745,
0.39798256754875183,
0.7083683013916016,
0.8857118487358093,
0.0035210284404456615,
0.3769038915634155,
0.34288349747657776,
-0.2624285817146301,
-0.07491515576839447,
0.05520452931523323,
-0.43151968717575073,
-0.003555540693923831,
0.48932793736457825,
0.7447993159294128,
0.5736123919487,
-0.6099224090576172,
0.33862754702568054,
-0.16777276992797852,
-0.11823001503944397,
0.3945469558238983,
0.10540152341127396,
0.3397274315357208,
0.21015521883964539,
0.31502634286880493,
-0.1406070739030838,
0.42964404821395874,
-0.6786355376243591,
0.1308007836341858,
0.07673133909702301,
-0.4374842047691345,
-0.15322798490524292,
0.36763888597488403,
0.3177715539932251,
-0.3090624213218689,
0.2966941297054291,
0.08677442371845245,
-0.5111425518989563,
0.7846575975418091,
0.48030152916908264,
0.6700762510299683,
-0.22449252009391785,
0.33754026889801025,
0.48736220598220825,
0.2746690511703491,
-0.18180036544799805,
0.6300365924835205,
-0.6455069184303284,
-0.543864905834198,
-0.5773522257804871,
-0.4713360667228699,
-0.45680633187294006,
-0.21067363023757935,
-0.7446048259735107,
0.07428131252527237,
-0.4203017055988312,
-0.24086830019950867,
0.08823157846927643,
0.19148823618888855,
-0.44817307591438293,
0.4503135681152344,
-0.00970588717609644,
0.9747132658958435,
-0.7134233713150024,
0.564663827419281,
0.8469895124435425,
-0.3059367537498474,
-1.0282758474349976,
0.35523664951324463,
-0.4213689863681793,
-0.4647243320941925,
0.10885011404752731,
0.33523494005203247,
0.24905304610729218,
0.2902146577835083,
-0.5276924967765808,
-1.228103756904602,
0.6875689625740051,
-0.03896024078130722,
-0.2775293290615082,
-0.14529433846473694,
-0.0403096079826355,
0.7151861190795898,
-0.024786513298749924,
0.49753597378730774,
0.7443959712982178,
0.7139783501625061,
0.19933626055717468,
-0.6479359269142151,
-0.17478597164154053,
-0.26057833433151245,
-0.007150853984057903,
-0.03572101891040802,
-0.4879434108734131,
0.4519711136817932,
-0.3514351546764374,
-0.4862728714942932,
0.09744696319103241,
0.8028776049613953,
0.05412199720740318,
0.5800358057022095,
0.43293753266334534,
0.28707581758499146,
1.0605030059814453,
-0.10426825284957886,
1.4820356369018555,
-0.06082319840788841,
0.054459016770124435,
1.1577098369598389,
-0.12423316389322281,
0.7537364959716797,
0.6237375140190125,
-0.0671670213341713,
0.2802574932575226,
0.8636259436607361,
0.33509644865989685,
0.697756290435791,
-0.0690155029296875,
0.057977620512247086,
-0.10434988886117935,
-0.14772875607013702,
-0.14928723871707916,
0.1473723202943802,
0.015270669013261795,
-0.40478935837745667,
-0.1768263727426529,
0.2257273644208908,
-0.17257513105869293,
0.30613675713539124,
-0.09349500387907028,
0.8986991047859192,
0.11391183733940125,
-1.1361688375473022,
0.4911838173866272,
0.08201515674591064,
0.3804195821285248,
-0.29492613673210144,
0.2153310626745224,
-0.36641743779182434,
-0.08740043640136719,
0.11142880469560623,
-0.8189228773117065,
0.23721137642860413,
-0.00112304522190243,
-0.6275331974029541,
-0.19651877880096436,
0.37556278705596924,
-0.5299112200737,
-0.5648155808448792,
0.030167026445269585,
0.47465044260025024,
0.030293932184576988,
0.0134437782689929,
-0.6099459528923035,
0.06800893694162369,
-0.3148888945579529,
-0.35912585258483887,
-0.10767752677202225,
0.2907792329788208,
0.036155056208372116,
0.4345567524433136,
0.5173455476760864,
-0.1811407208442688,
0.23890598118305206,
0.21113544702529907,
0.518819272518158,
-0.6963419318199158,
-0.537090539932251,
-0.7205644845962524,
0.7000283598899841,
-0.14737148582935333,
-0.6252579689025879,
0.7520049214363098,
0.1387789398431778,
0.5461187958717346,
0.18346527218818665,
0.4751608073711395,
0.1795041859149933,
0.6412009596824646,
-0.36841922998428345,
0.3450210690498352,
-0.5068214535713196,
-0.04340134561061859,
-0.272006094455719,
-0.9537628293037415,
-0.4558194577693939,
0.4094017446041107,
-0.6701589822769165,
0.07536181062459946,
1.1084574460983276,
0.671014130115509,
0.24219487607479095,
0.30291926860809326,
0.4628280699253082,
0.04939541593194008,
-0.032488543540239334,
0.24286331236362457,
0.9635799527168274,
-0.46160855889320374,
0.3408869206905365,
-0.4808179438114166,
-0.10134612768888474,
-0.16382746398448944,
-0.4081740081310272,
-0.7916976809501648,
-0.2770995497703552,
-0.24499119818210602,
-0.10379892587661743,
0.11561413109302521,
0.5159279108047485,
0.7479482889175415,
-0.616306722164154,
-0.17487037181854248,
-0.03292027860879898,
0.404742032289505,
-0.35403871536254883,
-0.1708659529685974,
0.1927819550037384,
-0.5415353178977966,
-1.0235469341278076,
0.5475279092788696,
0.19867102801799774,
-0.11706282198429108,
-0.018087133765220642,
0.1153302937746048,
-0.41531628370285034,
0.5457838773727417,
0.5592415928840637,
0.32315537333488464,
-0.7356624007225037,
-0.15474833548069,
0.35689476132392883,
-0.5204260349273682,
0.25226953625679016,
0.7391543984413147,
-0.5309967994689941,
0.745475709438324,
0.8106414675712585,
0.9206934571266174,
0.36131376028060913,
0.6455148458480835,
0.5960620641708374,
-0.4636235535144806,
-0.1263975203037262,
0.21132688224315643,
0.12660466134548187,
0.4161253571510315,
-0.578188955783844,
0.3765571713447571,
-0.10201521962881088,
-0.5269365906715393,
-0.867642879486084,
-0.11206202954053879,
-0.9732716083526611,
-0.4585682451725006,
0.9309235215187073,
0.302253395318985,
-0.4375225901603699,
-0.38014376163482666,
-0.47200527787208557,
0.1458592563867569,
-0.3435811698436737,
0.5276907682418823,
1.0450373888015747,
-0.27874040603637695,
-0.32135194540023804,
-0.5891976356506348,
0.4537756145000458,
1.1802723407745361,
-0.5109912157058716,
0.04863997548818588,
0.2526179552078247,
0.09815289825201035,
0.0769212543964386,
0.5972806215286255,
0.04158928990364075,
0.5114460587501526,
-0.37412360310554504,
-0.3371579647064209,
0.2550909221172333,
-0.42674970626831055,
-0.6729124188423157,
0.42941761016845703,
0.1707327961921692,
0.03908409923315048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16778v1 | Finding Transformer Circuits with Edge Pruning | 2024-06-24T16:40:54 | 2024-06-24T16:40:54 | Adithya Bhaskar, Alexander Wettig, Dan Friedman, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The path to interpreting a language model often proceeds via analysis of
circuits -- sparse computational subgraphs of the model that capture specific
aspects of its behavior. Recent work has automated the task of discovering
circuits. Yet, these methods have practical limitations, as they rely either on
inefficient search algorithms or inaccurate approximations. In this paper, we
frame automated circuit discovery as an optimization problem and propose *Edge
Pruning* as an effective and scalable solution. Edge Pruning leverages
gradient-based pruning techniques, but instead of removing neurons or
components, it prunes the \emph{edges} between components. Our method finds
circuits in GPT-2 that use less than half the number of edges compared to
circuits found by previous methods while being equally faithful to the full
model predictions on standard circuit-finding tasks. Edge Pruning is efficient
even with as many as 100K examples, outperforming previous methods in speed and
producing substantially better circuits. It also perfectly recovers the
ground-truth circuits in two models compiled with Tracr. Thanks to its
efficiency, we scale Edge Pruning to CodeLlama-13B, a model over 100x the scale
that prior methods operate on. We use this setting for a case study comparing
the mechanisms behind instruction prompting and in-context learning. We find
two circuits with more than 99.96% sparsity that match the performance of the
full model and reveal that the mechanisms in the two settings overlap
substantially. Our case study shows that Edge Pruning is a practical and
scalable tool for interpretability and sheds light on behaviors that only
emerge in large models. | [
-0.6509225964546204,
-0.8984328508377075,
0.7265783548355103,
0.015298551879823208,
-0.14540201425552368,
-0.11797071993350983,
-0.21149319410324097,
0.059550583362579346,
-0.06023254618048668,
0.276195764541626,
-0.9626246690750122,
-0.2506967782974243,
-0.45192259550094604,
-0.30984166264533997,
-0.4830562472343445,
0.6967746615409851,
-0.023195717483758926,
-0.2693047523498535,
0.0060021295212209225,
0.05888601019978523,
-0.444161593914032,
-0.26747891306877136,
-0.5759016871452332,
-0.6340419054031372,
0.23783467710018158,
0.46870189905166626,
0.7953296899795532,
0.7195085287094116,
0.517915666103363,
0.2914566695690155,
-0.39644989371299744,
0.15446701645851135,
-0.3512350618839264,
-0.00852188840508461,
0.024684546515345573,
-0.3079076111316681,
-0.1518968939781189,
-0.09256330132484436,
0.40690529346466064,
0.7543801665306091,
-0.12767833471298218,
0.1313941329717636,
0.03924696892499924,
0.7371625900268555,
-0.43399083614349365,
-0.07687290757894516,
-0.5578501224517822,
0.11694701015949249,
-0.22466841340065002,
-0.30456143617630005,
-0.6220197677612305,
-0.3116018772125244,
-0.07438348233699799,
-0.5235048532485962,
0.48951786756515503,
-0.22225120663642883,
1.0650635957717896,
0.34163668751716614,
-0.42162179946899414,
-0.32576143741607666,
-1.0287610292434692,
0.5485360622406006,
-0.20899055898189545,
0.6121097803115845,
0.1935332715511322,
0.409712016582489,
-0.157158762216568,
-1.1356807947158813,
-0.3756559193134308,
-0.13946734368801117,
-0.1816214919090271,
0.03415174409747124,
-0.49938467144966125,
0.34261348843574524,
0.5900434255599976,
0.3864079415798187,
-0.517342746257782,
-0.10523217171430588,
-0.5226622819900513,
-0.38047337532043457,
0.20858268439769745,
-0.023865560069680214,
0.5539600253105164,
-0.037671662867069244,
-0.15671198070049286,
-0.33197417855262756,
-1.0181429386138916,
0.26932933926582336,
0.6426516771316528,
0.05014936625957489,
0.47780588269233704,
0.26600584387779236,
0.22716976702213287,
0.7460501194000244,
-0.03694051504135132,
-0.00851047970354557,
-0.021358052268624306,
-0.2044427990913391,
0.015849675983190536,
-0.25115954875946045,
0.47967684268951416,
0.359667032957077,
0.5483613014221191,
-0.006644861772656441,
-0.3620470464229584,
0.03734489530324936,
0.49973198771476746,
-0.7857092618942261,
-0.7945343852043152,
-0.17181159555912018,
-0.49631357192993164,
0.08215700089931488,
0.06456039845943451,
-0.6110706329345703,
0.0661381408572197,
-0.32633277773857117,
0.43841683864593506,
-0.4930030405521393,
-0.2336210310459137,
-0.2306707203388214,
-0.4108096659183502,
0.21921303868293762,
-0.02126265875995159,
-0.9327111840248108,
0.5914978384971619,
0.6966005563735962,
1.066044569015503,
0.16215915977954865,
0.03139891102910042,
-0.6313385367393494,
-0.33200690150260925,
-0.43782752752304077,
0.6859241127967834,
-0.6531146764755249,
-0.6062580347061157,
-0.17366255819797516,
0.09540409594774246,
-0.23323751986026764,
-0.6655559539794922,
0.9039915204048157,
-0.5872058868408203,
-0.2895174026489258,
-0.36001285910606384,
-0.2975876033306122,
-0.1602596789598465,
-0.16548354923725128,
-0.8637129068374634,
1.0411765575408936,
0.09998985379934311,
-0.5417383909225464,
0.06502979248762131,
-0.5629124045372009,
-0.6928268671035767,
-0.09242270886898041,
-0.11405551433563232,
-0.595051109790802,
0.3499037027359009,
0.47377026081085205,
0.015165246091783047,
-0.04006456211209297,
0.3872165381908417,
0.10380325466394424,
-0.6482444405555725,
-0.1982467770576477,
-0.5258241295814514,
0.825404703617096,
0.1130111888051033,
-0.4946965277194977,
0.1717834621667862,
-0.3723788857460022,
0.08617757260799408,
0.12847380340099335,
0.22856242954730988,
-0.234638974070549,
0.10283667594194412,
-0.02670346386730671,
0.28912991285324097,
-0.1838783323764801,
-0.4257223606109619,
0.08913347125053406,
-0.5630784034729004,
0.9038198590278625,
0.8822939395904541,
0.15291538834571838,
0.5260012149810791,
-0.22035442292690277,
0.47856462001800537,
-0.23451274633407593,
0.34551510214805603,
-0.4608384668827057,
-0.3841151297092438,
-0.9953267574310303,
0.130438894033432,
0.113156259059906,
0.31255409121513367,
-0.5885865688323975,
0.47132667899131775,
-0.1743757128715515,
-0.4733778238296509,
-0.45411476492881775,
-0.09577528387308121,
0.15426495671272278,
0.5697884559631348,
0.6018387675285339,
-0.21391336619853973,
-0.20382745563983917,
-1.1994150876998901,
-0.35781484842300415,
0.10073456913232803,
-0.3208545744419098,
0.2845691740512848,
0.4276078939437866,
-0.18365278840065002,
1.1191867589950562,
-0.5855249762535095,
-0.2643570601940155,
-0.3801754117012024,
0.13322514295578003,
0.1767105609178543,
0.5809226632118225,
0.1751735508441925,
-0.9079530239105225,
-0.39563801884651184,
0.040215589106082916,
-0.3295387327671051,
-0.01773379184305668,
-0.20628167688846588,
0.1533990502357483,
-0.42317280173301697,
0.49236905574798584,
-0.4386691749095917,
0.6415531635284424,
0.09844610095024109,
0.2597540318965912,
0.18198277056217194,
-0.17614486813545227,
-0.2321234494447708,
-0.4355737864971161,
-0.0427023209631443,
0.24089933931827545,
-0.031104065477848053,
-0.7989004850387573,
0.06844404339790344,
0.3523179292678833,
-0.1942739635705948,
-0.14177356660366058,
0.3909778892993927,
-0.5510942339897156,
-0.06950149685144424,
-0.33282241225242615,
0.050915226340293884,
0.055626459419727325,
0.7902514338493347,
0.08062829077243805,
0.8941673040390015,
0.4333912432193756,
-0.5260331034660339,
0.0029982971027493477,
0.051542989909648895,
-0.08732674270868301,
0.23678867518901825,
-0.8047823309898376,
0.31318673491477966,
-0.2132219821214676,
0.31538113951683044,
-0.6724740266799927,
0.01094758789986372,
0.0948939248919487,
-0.31832781434059143,
0.15772207081317902,
-0.3895088732242584,
-0.23449596762657166,
-0.5694686770439148,
-0.2085355818271637,
0.3320002853870392,
0.8535770773887634,
-0.955082893371582,
0.7772958278656006,
0.4320918321609497,
-0.19523343443870544,
-0.2337116003036499,
-0.36578840017318726,
-0.1628960371017456,
0.0032317026052623987,
-0.8034564256668091,
0.5657204389572144,
0.1400289237499237,
-0.14654627442359924,
-0.10109914839267731,
-0.6574905514717102,
-0.18024416267871857,
0.14542247354984283,
0.39445918798446655,
0.15217170119285583,
-0.015202635899186134,
0.17157725989818573,
0.3461531102657318,
-0.3793313503265381,
0.3118567168712616,
-0.48452451825141907,
0.617598831653595,
-0.36345115303993225,
-0.6045036315917969,
-0.45043036341667175,
0.2111370712518692,
0.39300331473350525,
-0.46785062551498413,
-0.016370173543691635,
0.5747783184051514,
-0.4972672164440155,
-0.5627323389053345,
-0.4347163438796997,
-0.5315245985984802,
-0.6123210191726685,
0.21528242528438568,
-0.47038453817367554,
-0.5412496328353882,
0.3846653997898102,
-0.4848572015762329,
0.03315649926662445,
0.5681137442588806,
0.15375329554080963,
0.21383090317249298,
1.1720077991485596,
0.8146277666091919,
0.1790492832660675,
0.537939727306366,
-0.5452259182929993,
0.7966911196708679,
-0.8313072919845581,
-0.38357165455818176,
-0.508924126625061,
-0.4444236159324646,
-0.46476003527641296,
-0.06304122507572174,
0.6751636266708374,
-0.14377973973751068,
-0.08666791766881943,
0.4422297775745392,
-1.020995855331421,
0.6894983649253845,
0.8563250303268433,
0.2152594029903412,
0.2305597960948944,
0.1580238938331604,
-0.21718934178352356,
-0.17245352268218994,
-0.9030974507331848,
-0.44613784551620483,
0.7543230056762695,
0.4666251242160797,
0.5581073760986328,
-0.3684495985507965,
0.5522957444190979,
-0.11700143665075302,
0.35986217856407166,
-0.8848491907119751,
0.3989357650279999,
0.04079370200634003,
-0.36228811740875244,
-0.22552257776260376,
-0.4968166649341583,
-0.7874964475631714,
-0.03722703456878662,
0.26023754477500916,
-0.8403631448745728,
0.24720028042793274,
0.17746400833129883,
-0.2506837546825409,
0.48606643080711365,
-0.7442427277565002,
0.9245170950889587,
-0.10380734503269196,
-0.21741273999214172,
-0.09849715232849121,
-0.7080912590026855,
0.25081175565719604,
0.2975054681301117,
0.24221976101398468,
0.2817420959472656,
0.3822314739227295,
0.7617086172103882,
-0.653738260269165,
0.4040762186050415,
-0.2570381164550781,
0.17754487693309784,
0.6041123270988464,
0.2536732256412506,
0.7093122005462646,
-0.2259865403175354,
0.3269660770893097,
-0.17268294095993042,
-0.36086398363113403,
-0.16083604097366333,
-0.7984450459480286,
0.7409594058990479,
-0.6066486835479736,
-0.6753366589546204,
-0.1498108059167862,
-0.37624046206474304,
-0.14201568067073822,
0.09175806492567062,
0.5971619486808777,
0.8208568096160889,
0.07411769032478333,
0.03716762363910675,
0.8578689098358154,
0.050089530646800995,
0.6210193634033203,
-0.10798689723014832,
0.15690353512763977,
-0.04145253077149391,
1.2242653369903564,
0.3242122530937195,
0.09402304142713547,
0.19481122493743896,
0.05973072722554207,
-0.19930244982242584,
-0.5539539456367493,
-0.4235130846500397,
0.05416901037096977,
-0.8128960132598877,
-0.06833228468894958,
-0.7618291974067688,
-0.5018653273582458,
0.17338280379772186,
-0.27086952328681946,
-0.4371488392353058,
-0.4876876175403595,
0.06294042617082596,
-0.2951722741127014,
0.17269733548164368,
0.6797189712524414,
0.016669267788529396,
0.7386242151260376,
-0.6928139925003052,
0.18590041995048523,
0.38964009284973145,
0.3125380575656891,
0.32632583379745483,
-0.38249465823173523,
-0.03729408606886864,
-0.03414931520819664,
-0.7005974650382996,
-0.8341377377510071,
0.3410169780254364,
0.02733803354203701,
0.5211707949638367,
0.2946973443031311,
0.056795015931129456,
0.675930917263031,
-0.5839884281158447,
0.5192949175834656,
0.10293377190828323,
-1.2234069108963013,
0.6008935570716858,
0.07711874693632126,
0.16649384796619415,
0.49798721075057983,
0.3934454619884491,
-0.5425873398780823,
-0.2509790062904358,
-0.9623581767082214,
-1.2003729343414307,
0.34562909603118896,
0.4438880383968353,
0.027502788230776787,
0.031879596412181854,
0.1831895262002945,
-0.07363760471343994,
-0.08488752692937851,
-0.7353870272636414,
-0.29012736678123474,
-0.23066499829292297,
-0.20254825055599213,
0.360392302274704,
0.03638613596558571,
-0.28396710753440857,
-0.14096586406230927,
0.555107057094574,
-0.07868564873933792,
0.24515672028064728,
0.222628653049469,
-0.32129958271980286,
-0.1599920690059662,
0.0788678303360939,
0.30639275908470154,
0.8569902181625366,
0.08172980695962906,
0.3342089354991913,
0.1188727468252182,
-0.5634647607803345,
0.2511906325817108,
0.11520915478467941,
-0.3456326723098755,
0.3408355712890625,
0.4312417507171631,
0.7069767117500305,
-0.08577520400285721,
-0.6129278540611267,
0.6523476243019104,
-0.11329496651887894,
-0.0827186331152916,
-0.268032044172287,
0.17452874779701233,
0.030869536101818085,
0.02171100117266178,
0.7121677994728088,
0.21882769465446472,
0.3842988610267639,
-0.2227354496717453,
0.5992171764373779,
0.5754879713058472,
-0.6685949563980103,
-0.27559593319892883,
0.46340492367744446,
0.23709306120872498,
-0.724677562713623,
1.0734803676605225,
-0.23359693586826324,
-0.8414471745491028,
0.9733744859695435,
0.2579174339771271,
0.8614036440849304,
-0.07952629774808884,
0.2008090317249298,
0.5025126934051514,
0.7109863758087158,
-0.20778484642505646,
-0.43619275093078613,
-0.21465173363685608,
-0.3492369055747986,
-0.3700951635837555,
-0.11447027325630188,
-0.3908385932445526,
-0.027910009026527405,
-0.7603206634521484,
0.2836484909057617,
-0.37563347816467285,
-0.016896072775125504,
0.04940659552812576,
-0.05800841003656387,
-0.5334868431091309,
0.18622098863124847,
-0.31094256043434143,
1.0336142778396606,
-1.1093811988830566,
0.7395910620689392,
0.23069897294044495,
-0.16413576900959015,
-1.0366313457489014,
0.08814972639083862,
-0.07877981662750244,
-0.6413795948028564,
0.4593318998813629,
0.5139124393463135,
-0.1770118623971939,
0.08169104903936386,
-0.23705370724201202,
-0.5121474862098694,
1.065064787864685,
0.09572073817253113,
-0.7860153317451477,
-0.20063981413841248,
-0.4512714445590973,
0.30957749485969543,
-0.048101723194122314,
0.7471337914466858,
0.8107543587684631,
0.5979979038238525,
0.27834415435791016,
-0.726395845413208,
0.11304404586553574,
-0.45420488715171814,
-0.04616608843207359,
0.6982412934303284,
-0.4213689863681793,
0.909850537776947,
-0.1978263109922409,
-0.5309436321258545,
-0.27338162064552307,
0.542320728302002,
0.04248123988509178,
0.49822381138801575,
0.6693831086158752,
0.40598100423812866,
0.7625287175178528,
-0.3296256959438324,
0.7403013110160828,
-0.38559210300445557,
0.5434028506278992,
0.6698805689811707,
0.039570849388837814,
0.25500819087028503,
0.5304552316665649,
-0.12656542658805847,
0.38952285051345825,
0.8016137480735779,
-0.02963615208864212,
0.5749756693840027,
0.3896144926548004,
0.049757007509469986,
-0.2781883776187897,
0.10049500316381454,
-0.26993489265441895,
-0.25544118881225586,
0.38623231649398804,
-0.15334895253181458,
-0.3999270498752594,
-0.052282195538282394,
0.0826510563492775,
0.21379712224006653,
-0.3106154799461365,
0.5644848942756653,
0.08678590506315231,
-0.845212459564209,
0.42244237661361694,
0.06148240342736244,
0.30800336599349976,
-0.3878580927848816,
-0.33292680978775024,
-0.3265065550804138,
0.08147504925727844,
-0.26644206047058105,
-0.5531923174858093,
0.4802407920360565,
-0.29786282777786255,
0.07384148985147476,
-0.4228334128856659,
0.9306051135063171,
-0.0942564457654953,
-0.4703298807144165,
0.28907865285873413,
0.516004204750061,
-0.15056420862674713,
-0.18059095740318298,
-0.18196271359920502,
0.11078017950057983,
0.16592898964881897,
-0.39662763476371765,
0.18978895246982574,
0.26972696185112,
-0.19646158814430237,
0.7943152785301208,
0.49986153841018677,
-0.09637642651796341,
-0.12755315005779266,
-0.1818859577178955,
1.234201431274414,
-0.5536944270133972,
-0.33031293749809265,
-0.9163054823875427,
0.425142765045166,
-0.20254573225975037,
-0.27555137872695923,
0.3996969759464264,
0.5538915395736694,
0.8549484610557556,
0.29317981004714966,
0.7430347204208374,
0.1253930777311325,
0.10250639170408249,
-0.492995023727417,
0.19900460541248322,
-0.25811463594436646,
0.33298489451408386,
-0.021572282537817955,
-1.0197557210922241,
-0.1164049357175827,
0.9133424758911133,
-0.5003761053085327,
0.07541166245937347,
0.859342634677887,
1.0135987997055054,
-0.4781560003757477,
0.3609209358692169,
-0.08367818593978882,
-0.08122662454843521,
0.38609686493873596,
0.5626152753829956,
0.7884393930435181,
-0.23760680854320526,
0.7625025510787964,
-0.45999664068222046,
-0.5040639638900757,
-0.045399922877550125,
-0.6045238971710205,
-0.7603321671485901,
-0.5937586426734924,
-0.05430872365832329,
-0.18233337998390198,
0.0595792792737484,
0.7325088977813721,
0.6990169286727905,
-0.38007912039756775,
-0.16747742891311646,
-0.6625888347625732,
0.596967875957489,
-0.5334812998771667,
-0.2500770092010498,
0.43542054295539856,
-0.3384510576725006,
-0.5844938158988953,
0.5014210343360901,
0.288220077753067,
-0.1897377222776413,
-0.14222599565982819,
-0.03051880933344364,
0.21400587260723114,
-0.05181128904223442,
0.16455160081386566,
0.2650340497493744,
-0.5548829436302185,
-0.20122112333774567,
0.4083555340766907,
0.1864573210477829,
0.17095744609832764,
1.2149876356124878,
-0.7285977005958557,
0.28237971663475037,
0.254211962223053,
0.5799588561058044,
0.9491111636161804,
0.04559556022286415,
0.720369815826416,
-0.6458585262298584,
-0.015214208513498306,
0.3970112204551697,
0.200866237282753,
0.10522909462451935,
-0.17528951168060303,
0.5020545721054077,
0.1701589971780777,
-0.6178677678108215,
-0.8925032019615173,
0.5455370545387268,
-0.6003626585006714,
-0.3020297586917877,
0.8128292560577393,
-0.06416614353656769,
-0.24859198927879333,
0.13159514963626862,
-0.2411050647497177,
0.04977622628211975,
-0.22993990778923035,
0.37484651803970337,
0.5255740880966187,
-0.23734787106513977,
-0.2465847134590149,
-0.6030738949775696,
0.5618028044700623,
0.25140032172203064,
-0.3800790309906006,
-0.021694723516702652,
0.19126667082309723,
0.013104332610964775,
0.3587401807308197,
0.3756652772426605,
0.2591104507446289,
0.36712896823883057,
0.043163422495126724,
-0.10454414039850235,
-0.2943592667579651,
-0.8068716526031494,
-0.24877916276454926,
0.3162994682788849,
-0.05948328226804733,
-0.010784785263240337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16777v1 | Blending LLMs into Cascaded Speech Translation: KIT's Offline Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024 | 2024-06-24T16:38:17 | 2024-06-24T16:38:17 | Sai Koneru, Thai-Binh Nguyen, Ngoc-Quan Pham, Danni Liu, Zhaolin Li, Alexander Waibel, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are currently under exploration for various
tasks, including Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Machine Translation (MT),
and even End-to-End Speech Translation (ST). In this paper, we present KIT's
offline submission in the constrained + LLM track by incorporating recently
proposed techniques that can be added to any cascaded speech translation.
Specifically, we integrate
Mistral-7B\footnote{mistralai/Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.1} into our system to
enhance it in two ways. Firstly, we refine the ASR outputs by utilizing the
N-best lists generated by our system and fine-tuning the LLM to predict the
transcript accurately. Secondly, we refine the MT outputs at the document level
by fine-tuning the LLM, leveraging both ASR and MT predictions to improve
translation quality. We find that integrating the LLM into the ASR and MT
systems results in an absolute improvement of $0.3\%$ in Word Error Rate and
$0.65\%$ in COMET for tst2019 test set. In challenging test sets with
overlapping speakers and background noise, we find that integrating LLM is not
beneficial due to poor ASR performance. Here, we use ASR with chunked long-form
decoding to improve context usage that may be unavailable when transcribing
with Voice Activity Detection segmentation alone. | [
-0.30157727003097534,
-0.4933285117149353,
0.27896392345428467,
0.38882532715797424,
-0.4451875388622284,
0.6084045171737671,
-0.3577304482460022,
-0.6347692012786865,
0.17136651277542114,
0.5411079525947571,
-0.7472606897354126,
-0.2555859386920929,
-0.5172070860862732,
0.32266658544540405,
-0.6635176539421082,
0.7873883247375488,
-0.18066895008087158,
0.41686901450157166,
-0.13297578692436218,
-0.07804766297340393,
-0.6024798154830933,
-0.36899861693382263,
-0.6094032526016235,
-0.6559514403343201,
0.3855315148830414,
0.24793387949466705,
0.34315750002861023,
0.773970901966095,
0.4058551788330078,
0.2839412987232208,
-0.2614281475543976,
0.2168852537870407,
-0.39147064089775085,
0.33112770318984985,
-0.11141946166753769,
-0.30824875831604004,
-0.7630618810653687,
-0.31296104192733765,
0.8833099603652954,
0.6085742712020874,
-0.06474777311086655,
0.20663830637931824,
0.2566368281841278,
0.37622150778770447,
-0.340122789144516,
-0.03660085052251816,
-0.6916528344154358,
0.015673436224460602,
-0.43757814168930054,
-0.4993761479854584,
-0.2742435336112976,
0.029444659128785133,
0.028465116396546364,
-0.46091973781585693,
-0.1471773236989975,
0.09352508932352066,
0.5074486136436462,
0.6223483085632324,
-0.5284979939460754,
-0.38440895080566406,
-0.8897804617881775,
0.8306928277015686,
-0.8544660210609436,
0.5101609230041504,
0.2973659932613373,
0.2695561945438385,
-0.41413983702659607,
-0.8605974316596985,
-0.3626319169998169,
-0.0628892332315445,
0.2612431049346924,
0.37782302498817444,
-0.24810609221458435,
0.3577045500278473,
0.03803979605436325,
0.5006575584411621,
-0.4258519113063812,
0.3322600722312927,
-0.20587801933288574,
-0.2169332504272461,
0.6485491394996643,
0.15182846784591675,
0.07621574401855469,
0.08928927034139633,
-0.3162652552127838,
0.025506528094410896,
-0.707230269908905,
0.00308349565602839,
0.08888295292854309,
0.5934460759162903,
-0.13910788297653198,
0.6130827069282532,
-0.16929489374160767,
0.6421605348587036,
0.2301180362701416,
-0.406005859375,
0.20805799961090088,
-0.5223575234413147,
-0.1364506036043167,
0.3887888789176941,
0.7352151870727539,
0.05073584243655205,
-0.17792117595672607,
-0.1572907418012619,
-0.44833695888519287,
-0.3789539337158203,
0.08714895695447922,
-0.660468578338623,
0.1896241456270218,
0.3594287037849426,
-0.25979331135749817,
-0.22325310111045837,
-0.14417287707328796,
-0.36974039673805237,
-0.24231722950935364,
-0.5119189620018005,
0.6703469157218933,
-0.06284507364034653,
0.03373297303915024,
-0.09907258301973343,
-0.08990287780761719,
0.0630791187286377,
0.5495710372924805,
-0.3508217930793762,
0.47993046045303345,
0.523554801940918,
0.8918119668960571,
-0.41551733016967773,
-0.18406404554843903,
-1.112187147140503,
0.17834830284118652,
-0.34028691053390503,
0.5439298152923584,
-0.14963755011558533,
-0.5032635927200317,
0.03995053842663765,
-0.07087083905935287,
0.1747465580701828,
-0.6440338492393494,
0.5039173364639282,
-0.4759417772293091,
0.06881359964609146,
-0.2809399664402008,
-0.6756188273429871,
0.09196314960718155,
0.23420237004756927,
-0.4513499438762665,
1.2956064939498901,
-0.08141963183879852,
-0.4064955711364746,
-0.0051424517296254635,
-0.6265974044799805,
-0.4729279577732086,
0.24262197315692902,
0.03240686282515526,
-0.2501923739910126,
0.10744785517454147,
-0.018064770847558975,
0.3571564257144928,
-0.36279889941215515,
0.4785042405128479,
-0.07892867922782898,
-0.29155659675598145,
0.38672852516174316,
-0.40968766808509827,
0.5529626607894897,
0.11326859891414642,
-0.6142919063568115,
0.38746994733810425,
-0.7347433567047119,
0.12279729545116425,
-0.3094600737094879,
-0.7088309526443481,
0.009696323424577713,
0.07717631012201309,
0.38154685497283936,
0.33691245317459106,
0.15643763542175293,
-0.5756925344467163,
0.08352271467447281,
-0.39403095841407776,
0.6577792763710022,
0.5816711783409119,
-0.31193992495536804,
0.5565136075019836,
-0.35419961810112,
0.4880319833755493,
-0.1887967437505722,
0.0027007923927158117,
0.047062065452337265,
-0.6695425510406494,
-0.9155101776123047,
-0.3857688307762146,
0.4369284510612488,
0.7480730414390564,
-0.8526852130889893,
0.6176514029502869,
-0.496284544467926,
-0.26140302419662476,
-0.5763333439826965,
0.12568332254886627,
0.46977177262306213,
0.43119025230407715,
0.6013948321342468,
-0.2900841236114502,
-0.6804924011230469,
-0.4795476794242859,
-0.08767857402563095,
-0.0974302738904953,
-0.05188198387622833,
0.00596590805798769,
0.2635312080383301,
-0.4349896013736725,
0.9763723611831665,
-0.0006688204011879861,
-0.3795013129711151,
-0.4011780023574829,
0.13061490654945374,
0.03036724030971527,
0.39337027072906494,
-0.17245642840862274,
-0.6271936893463135,
-0.5881322622299194,
0.21383658051490784,
-0.3381166458129883,
-0.5095821619033813,
-0.03988677263259888,
0.04757523536682129,
0.1903727799654007,
0.7733007669448853,
-0.507542610168457,
0.5411732792854309,
0.6453559994697571,
0.020847711712121964,
0.3919013738632202,
-0.2532375454902649,
0.05740918591618538,
-1.2363722324371338,
-0.09275462478399277,
-0.35754895210266113,
-0.8545281291007996,
-0.8901427984237671,
-0.022482456639409065,
0.1493716686964035,
-0.007384921424090862,
-0.6668487191200256,
0.6153230667114258,
-0.5610975623130798,
-0.37724947929382324,
-0.5477513670921326,
0.39346423745155334,
-0.08393651247024536,
0.058399129658937454,
-0.15314556658267975,
0.7732424736022949,
0.2986924946308136,
-0.4738589823246002,
0.3315134346485138,
0.23787131905555725,
-0.14327353239059448,
0.4033556580543518,
-0.32587456703186035,
0.07291462272405624,
0.11718202382326126,
0.8303704261779785,
-0.8044708371162415,
-0.35419902205467224,
0.22231493890285492,
-0.40477439761161804,
0.5827493071556091,
0.09461089223623276,
-0.5828986167907715,
-0.17240481078624725,
-0.28414270281791687,
0.399519681930542,
0.49021703004837036,
-0.6058314442634583,
0.6759607195854187,
0.29752475023269653,
-0.335763543844223,
-0.40262943506240845,
-1.0061193704605103,
0.4970833957195282,
-0.24717748165130615,
-0.46358898282051086,
0.942520022392273,
-0.36689677834510803,
-0.1967826932668686,
-0.1801965832710266,
-0.1522158533334732,
-0.03905867412686348,
-0.24301493167877197,
0.17904196679592133,
0.012700021266937256,
-0.313345342874527,
-0.045382559299468994,
0.241865336894989,
-0.03523185849189758,
-0.22261251509189606,
-0.5297833681106567,
0.5849917531013489,
0.16568614542484283,
-0.37551549077033997,
-0.5047255754470825,
0.4343763589859009,
0.5810070037841797,
0.029214397072792053,
0.2972045838832855,
0.7516975402832031,
-0.4189229905605316,
-0.1553143858909607,
-0.7778511643409729,
0.038349028676748276,
-0.4695456326007843,
0.31830456852912903,
-0.4288994073867798,
-1.136256456375122,
0.5955312252044678,
-0.11847858875989914,
0.05617199093103409,
0.34123316407203674,
0.5629920959472656,
-0.23640485107898712,
0.8540804982185364,
0.39281710982322693,
-0.10835778713226318,
0.570328414440155,
-0.025463439524173737,
0.13224811851978302,
-1.1643664836883545,
-0.33027520775794983,
-0.3569219708442688,
-0.44790688157081604,
-0.5909054279327393,
-0.8282656669616699,
0.38586997985839844,
0.2697966694831848,
0.16785828769207,
0.36375582218170166,
-0.3397755026817322,
0.3167778253555298,
0.5894302725791931,
0.07462307065725327,
0.5683726072311401,
-0.12464448809623718,
0.12643586099147797,
0.06319887936115265,
-0.7296651005744934,
-0.2267737090587616,
0.9164221286773682,
0.3393379747867584,
0.5732910633087158,
0.07088853418827057,
0.6667227149009705,
0.2475820928812027,
0.23016971349716187,
-0.9795020222663879,
0.5087710618972778,
-0.3199949264526367,
-0.5423026084899902,
-0.2875327467918396,
-0.4918791949748993,
-0.6726966500282288,
0.24112103879451752,
0.07050510495901108,
-0.510974645614624,
-0.02063140459358692,
0.13094107806682587,
-0.25849005579948425,
0.19139842689037323,
-0.15938150882720947,
0.3012280762195587,
-0.27281540632247925,
-0.054767850786447525,
-0.1336136907339096,
-0.9110189080238342,
0.20688496530056,
-0.41696879267692566,
0.46162623167037964,
0.00938322115689516,
-0.22649912536144257,
0.5846198201179504,
-0.5949223041534424,
0.8424729108810425,
0.14358103275299072,
-0.2969835102558136,
0.18445473909378052,
-0.18265539407730103,
0.6425856947898865,
-0.19834139943122864,
-0.08502940088510513,
0.17567178606987,
0.07264529168605804,
-0.1278696358203888,
-0.33860185742378235,
0.8226903080940247,
-0.6733837723731995,
-0.45816779136657715,
-0.45246565341949463,
-0.7900004386901855,
-0.27629896998405457,
0.20436757802963257,
0.5468165874481201,
0.7360857725143433,
-0.06344090402126312,
0.3412943184375763,
0.654217541217804,
-0.07396160066127777,
0.6512452960014343,
0.4249493181705475,
-0.31717634201049805,
-0.8398117423057556,
0.8677419424057007,
0.436557799577713,
0.6419367790222168,
0.563336193561554,
0.40233469009399414,
-0.4492599666118622,
-0.6921463012695312,
-0.7449739575386047,
-0.0049375807866454124,
-0.87261962890625,
-0.4137634336948395,
-0.6815441250801086,
-0.3686912953853607,
-0.43327292799949646,
-0.2444346398115158,
-0.3792206048965454,
-0.5845567584037781,
-0.5444468855857849,
0.29403215646743774,
0.2138775885105133,
0.8846965432167053,
-0.059725407510995865,
0.5905532240867615,
-0.8385857939720154,
0.23543207347393036,
0.05478091910481453,
-0.18386289477348328,
-0.2212429940700531,
-0.9918927550315857,
-0.2962683439254761,
0.19359444081783295,
-0.32221469283103943,
-0.592513918876648,
0.4451749324798584,
0.5373973846435547,
0.364477276802063,
0.07940080016851425,
0.1465214192867279,
1.2512873411178589,
-0.6919837594032288,
0.7423892021179199,
0.23764988780021667,
-1.1811268329620361,
0.416042298078537,
-0.469931036233902,
0.6680294275283813,
0.5407665967941284,
0.045080412179231644,
-0.4017626941204071,
-0.6478984951972961,
-0.2230522185564041,
-0.9518649578094482,
0.8396880626678467,
0.42511963844299316,
0.07948464155197144,
0.3613983392715454,
0.2552517354488373,
0.02713405340909958,
0.2111412137746811,
-0.6340171098709106,
-0.1848497837781906,
-0.026808280497789383,
-0.36062857508659363,
-0.13978131115436554,
-0.04137624055147171,
-0.04147741198539734,
-0.3467452824115753,
0.8880524039268494,
-0.06872141361236572,
0.02339952066540718,
0.11842448264360428,
-0.21366922557353973,
-0.3366992473602295,
0.2200518101453781,
0.813610851764679,
0.34095561504364014,
-0.12006688863039017,
0.10850729793310165,
0.5297040939331055,
-0.5991447567939758,
0.21667435765266418,
0.17229002714157104,
-0.05618054047226906,
0.2034415900707245,
0.4340774714946747,
0.7364059090614319,
0.5288161635398865,
-0.6248862743377686,
0.43594545125961304,
0.0895330086350441,
-0.26006191968917847,
-0.2927738428115845,
-0.3389397859573364,
0.0810161754488945,
0.33815276622772217,
0.4623526334762573,
0.25988245010375977,
0.21625752747058868,
-0.5427648425102234,
0.11350610107183456,
0.3809351623058319,
-0.4818262755870819,
-0.38995909690856934,
0.6282682418823242,
0.3799615800380707,
-0.4852147102355957,
0.16871756315231323,
-0.21598578989505768,
-0.6106134057044983,
0.21166366338729858,
0.8100667595863342,
0.9969574213027954,
-0.38586676120758057,
-0.2074984610080719,
0.1314544528722763,
0.2876203656196594,
-0.39457014203071594,
0.07301019132137299,
-0.16267560422420502,
-0.30114924907684326,
-0.7644181251525879,
-0.7410656213760376,
-0.5725149512290955,
0.23876716196537018,
-0.6809408664703369,
0.5131795406341553,
-0.10172365605831146,
-0.2210555523633957,
-0.39444661140441895,
-0.2106904238462448,
-0.3399108648300171,
0.29561492800712585,
0.16021355986595154,
0.8146453499794006,
-0.47608882188796997,
1.0634814500808716,
0.5623781085014343,
-0.02717256173491478,
-0.6776738166809082,
0.363566517829895,
0.22623395919799805,
-0.5808439254760742,
0.49495887756347656,
0.13474150002002716,
-0.3427034318447113,
0.32353365421295166,
-0.13428038358688354,
-1.2596538066864014,
1.3135669231414795,
0.3809317350387573,
-0.7195412516593933,
-0.06888840347528458,
0.3617385923862457,
0.30354973673820496,
-0.2600228190422058,
0.05658089369535446,
0.3724604845046997,
0.32352080941200256,
0.49713486433029175,
-1.480639934539795,
-0.06282217800617218,
-0.006320249289274216,
0.08941423892974854,
0.16268318891525269,
-0.3510421812534332,
0.5966793298721313,
0.2649971842765808,
-0.14788249135017395,
0.3390488624572754,
0.586238443851471,
0.2924734354019165,
0.4012105166912079,
0.43129345774650574,
0.3415507376194,
0.5840121507644653,
-0.06513603031635284,
0.8396307826042175,
-0.10706823319196701,
0.039180777966976166,
1.3591032028198242,
-0.21131546795368195,
1.2186371088027954,
0.6753909587860107,
-0.11966992169618607,
0.1772775501012802,
0.7200188636779785,
0.5615719556808472,
0.5990650057792664,
0.34031927585601807,
-0.528469443321228,
-0.21290209889411926,
-0.30161938071250916,
-0.45720174908638,
0.4327661395072937,
0.32631081342697144,
-0.02765613980591297,
-0.08718344569206238,
0.3329944610595703,
-0.1161685511469841,
-0.22358457744121552,
-0.4397602081298828,
0.8479596972465515,
0.45396631956100464,
-0.55287766456604,
0.5126709342002869,
0.09714820235967636,
0.8825162053108215,
-0.6884427666664124,
0.27055495977401733,
-0.07435491681098938,
0.17828160524368286,
-0.31883764266967773,
-0.5565688610076904,
0.3502254784107208,
0.11834720522165298,
-0.10656053572893143,
-0.6019007563591003,
0.7640897631645203,
-0.7449700236320496,
-0.554777979850769,
0.44054266810417175,
0.4003768861293793,
0.22034510970115662,
-0.18768653273582458,
-0.48142209649086,
0.48081326484680176,
-0.002967728301882744,
-0.11801663786172867,
0.44125115871429443,
0.43627309799194336,
-0.25251537561416626,
0.7072309255599976,
0.6637058854103088,
0.2597518861293793,
0.34142613410949707,
0.29288050532341003,
1.0309393405914307,
-0.3885647654533386,
-0.4737168252468109,
-0.8903169631958008,
0.9145981669425964,
0.08646547794342041,
-0.14524516463279724,
0.7597604393959045,
0.6230661869049072,
0.7683245539665222,
0.13719238340854645,
0.7110698819160461,
0.015193705447018147,
0.3914032280445099,
-0.5829448699951172,
0.541266143321991,
-0.688228964805603,
0.21996371448040009,
-0.30466359853744507,
-1.0373656749725342,
-0.4113973379135132,
0.3186533749103546,
0.03217695280909538,
-0.312103807926178,
0.685448944568634,
0.6878901720046997,
-0.042199693620204926,
-0.1034218892455101,
0.4958505630493164,
0.06389660388231277,
0.384240984916687,
0.01415479090064764,
0.9447287917137146,
-0.7322226762771606,
0.8251339197158813,
-0.1286795288324356,
-0.3176446855068207,
-0.3070657551288605,
-0.9569927453994751,
-0.7557049989700317,
-0.6904675364494324,
-0.49371078610420227,
-0.3009951114654541,
-0.03728547692298889,
1.0793964862823486,
0.7486429214477539,
-0.8315416574478149,
-0.5561721920967102,
-0.24079354107379913,
-0.310686856508255,
0.08957117795944214,
-0.1196267157793045,
-0.17089404165744781,
-0.24765364825725555,
-0.7372919917106628,
1.087156057357788,
0.5060790181159973,
0.07767793536186218,
-0.23510265350341797,
-0.4259450137615204,
-0.14347288012504578,
0.0943416953086853,
0.7891494631767273,
-0.11360695958137512,
-1.2112220525741577,
-0.11404449492692947,
0.05449263006448746,
0.028391677886247635,
0.07814504206180573,
0.7135055661201477,
-0.5312029719352722,
0.5875809192657471,
0.5161436796188354,
0.7399922013282776,
0.7705626487731934,
0.07417146861553192,
0.6338835954666138,
-0.9158050417900085,
-0.08187330514192581,
0.24117159843444824,
0.17852330207824707,
0.47494032979011536,
-0.23043015599250793,
0.22637420892715454,
0.04663113132119179,
-0.6638185977935791,
-1.1046085357666016,
0.09500804543495178,
-1.0933798551559448,
0.05591563880443573,
1.217795968055725,
-0.015439555048942566,
0.04727655649185181,
-0.3068924844264984,
-0.1870317906141281,
0.487018883228302,
-0.38657259941101074,
0.31396520137786865,
0.6502876281738281,
-0.26252567768096924,
-0.03041328489780426,
-0.7014521956443787,
0.4371444582939148,
0.3027694523334503,
-0.8464048504829407,
-0.12063372135162354,
0.2897263467311859,
0.1699472814798355,
0.1355462670326233,
0.8476355671882629,
-0.0015101464232429862,
0.05149391293525696,
-0.3326609432697296,
-0.08943603932857513,
0.055678896605968475,
-0.10750176012516022,
-0.5360215306282043,
-0.26548147201538086,
0.08946239948272705,
-0.21942371129989624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16772v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16772v2 | OlympicArena Medal Ranks: Who Is the Most Intelligent AI So Far? | 2024-06-24T16:31:12 | 2024-06-26T15:00:04 | Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this report, we pose the following question: Who is the most intelligent
AI model to date, as measured by the OlympicArena (an Olympic-level,
multi-discipline, multi-modal benchmark for superintelligent AI)? We
specifically focus on the most recently released models: Claude-3.5-Sonnet,
Gemini-1.5-Pro, and GPT-4o. For the first time, we propose using an Olympic
medal Table approach to rank AI models based on their comprehensive performance
across various disciplines. Empirical results reveal: (1) Claude-3.5-Sonnet
shows highly competitive overall performance over GPT-4o, even surpassing
GPT-4o on a few subjects (i.e., Physics, Chemistry, and Biology). (2)
Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4V are ranked consecutively just behind GPT-4o and
Claude-3.5-Sonnet, but with a clear performance gap between them. (3) The
performance of AI models from the open-source community significantly lags
behind these proprietary models. (4) The performance of these models on this
benchmark has been less than satisfactory, indicating that we still have a long
way to go before achieving superintelligence. We remain committed to
continuously tracking and evaluating the performance of the latest powerful
models on this benchmark (available at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/OlympicArena). | [
-0.5716109871864319,
-0.24886758625507355,
0.8998620510101318,
-0.1307579129934311,
-0.12905575335025787,
-0.03711801394820213,
0.11271736025810242,
-1.0117425918579102,
0.007296104449778795,
0.26677659153938293,
-0.21852529048919678,
-0.4455051124095917,
-1.014255166053772,
0.06621280312538147,
-0.713721513748169,
1.1394190788269043,
0.23555366694927216,
0.32786208391189575,
-0.3543566167354584,
-0.433561235666275,
-0.3871518671512604,
-0.4326465427875519,
-0.7481561899185181,
-0.679612398147583,
0.688297688961029,
0.34507665038108826,
0.45191091299057007,
0.7364271283149719,
0.7313475608825684,
0.3529791235923767,
0.020097047090530396,
0.0006539114401675761,
-0.2856769859790802,
-0.07608406990766525,
-0.22128818929195404,
-0.6576545834541321,
-0.7086882591247559,
0.34556248784065247,
0.1200999841094017,
0.46372655034065247,
0.31163981556892395,
0.46597832441329956,
-0.25690171122550964,
0.6255114078521729,
-0.18310455977916718,
0.19167301058769226,
-0.6058585047721863,
-0.10629676282405853,
-0.25717225670814514,
0.1603403240442276,
-0.11303707212209702,
-0.3226427137851715,
0.1245080903172493,
-0.6842128038406372,
0.0015661359066143632,
0.3071988523006439,
0.5038548707962036,
0.4689691364765167,
-0.2687039077281952,
-0.006941409781575203,
-0.6813170909881592,
0.7308964729309082,
-0.5668722987174988,
0.06849520653486252,
0.2694796621799469,
0.36809206008911133,
0.18739435076713562,
-0.9799750447273254,
-0.48786234855651855,
-0.6570261120796204,
0.6058638095855713,
0.5225073099136353,
-0.17468033730983734,
-0.30378472805023193,
0.011531173251569271,
-0.10640250146389008,
-0.7914649248123169,
0.3260824978351593,
-0.6253155469894409,
0.2870781123638153,
0.9925519227981567,
0.210383802652359,
0.21605071425437927,
0.41182464361190796,
-0.08330444991588593,
0.0702415257692337,
-0.47357550263404846,
-0.21675574779510498,
0.4044454097747803,
-0.05475282669067383,
0.002641164930537343,
0.6078232526779175,
-0.21182940900325775,
0.2419525682926178,
-0.20695993304252625,
0.4231491684913635,
0.12209517508745193,
-0.030543632805347443,
0.21746768057346344,
0.38631200790405273,
0.9669323563575745,
0.3849213421344757,
0.41221699118614197,
-0.46786102652549744,
-0.2738206386566162,
0.18718011677265167,
0.34395191073417664,
-0.5440159440040588,
-0.5843586921691895,
0.3512386679649353,
-0.4682523012161255,
-0.18614234030246735,
0.24868956208229065,
-0.34632056951522827,
-0.4578680694103241,
-0.14347797632217407,
0.7566925883293152,
-0.3437201678752899,
-0.09721380472183228,
-0.2898535430431366,
-0.030169527977705002,
-0.14378021657466888,
0.40857231616973877,
-0.6239330768585205,
0.140407532453537,
1.1194941997528076,
0.8208479881286621,
-0.13503554463386536,
-0.5811504125595093,
-0.23652735352516174,
-0.22997517883777618,
-0.6213158369064331,
0.8995628952980042,
-0.6147391200065613,
-0.08544911444187164,
-0.43133610486984253,
-0.4567854702472687,
-0.09769290685653687,
-0.5700564384460449,
0.48208361864089966,
-0.7352434992790222,
0.059536535292863846,
-0.20583824813365936,
-0.6678756475448608,
-0.2268717885017395,
0.30031245946884155,
-0.7433068752288818,
0.723624050617218,
-0.20990531146526337,
-0.6774224042892456,
0.3439677655696869,
-0.9838906526565552,
0.022477656602859497,
0.16909658908843994,
-0.06008268520236015,
-0.3201862871646881,
0.009143774397671223,
0.09356178343296051,
0.36821940541267395,
-0.765354335308075,
0.2232961356639862,
-0.5089170336723328,
-0.4995628595352173,
0.4459669888019562,
-0.18380068242549896,
0.47466662526130676,
0.2524541914463043,
-0.582688570022583,
0.26004528999328613,
-0.7913805246353149,
-0.017017938196659088,
-0.0663469061255455,
0.055056795477867126,
0.1251632571220398,
0.04937902092933655,
-0.14477866888046265,
0.3514308035373688,
0.36758801341056824,
-0.7604471445083618,
0.01795029453933239,
-0.11392764002084732,
0.7205307483673096,
0.8577448725700378,
-0.13063548505306244,
0.1618996411561966,
-0.6318091750144958,
0.37638989090919495,
-0.24095983803272247,
0.42206254601478577,
0.3261355757713318,
-0.9718811511993408,
-0.5466492176055908,
-0.3043097257614136,
0.5222243666648865,
0.7182235717773438,
-0.37308648228645325,
0.394093781709671,
-0.3825800120830536,
-0.9799318313598633,
-0.5998618006706238,
-0.2135467231273651,
0.31127169728279114,
0.5387965440750122,
0.24638192355632782,
-0.12180601060390472,
-0.01060427539050579,
-0.9903271198272705,
-0.5023775696754456,
-0.3799143433570862,
0.1843993365764618,
0.07802242785692215,
1.078329086303711,
0.02331726998090744,
0.5930184125900269,
0.004692567512392998,
-0.04142352566123009,
-0.30824780464172363,
0.5533344745635986,
0.34719839692115784,
0.7128080129623413,
0.4589526355266571,
-0.8229638934135437,
-0.387445867061615,
0.2579371929168701,
-1.129266619682312,
0.05379310995340347,
0.24271900951862335,
-0.0792769268155098,
-0.20632711052894592,
0.24899329245090485,
-0.44791191816329956,
0.41237422823905945,
0.32415902614593506,
-0.23654957115650177,
0.628882110118866,
-0.21390245854854584,
0.4389619827270508,
-0.8104590773582458,
0.5382445454597473,
-0.05994333699345589,
-0.1513407826423645,
-0.7038673758506775,
-0.026107309386134148,
-0.17291736602783203,
-0.05573654919862747,
-0.23968902230262756,
0.6098381876945496,
-0.029278477653861046,
-0.07340970635414124,
-0.19155432283878326,
0.18633326888084412,
-0.41712602972984314,
0.1831684708595276,
-0.3048284351825714,
0.5748081207275391,
0.8062036037445068,
-0.5113340616226196,
0.6888070106506348,
0.10379079729318619,
-0.5038642287254333,
0.43453890085220337,
-0.8013454079627991,
0.18870581686496735,
-0.2594437301158905,
0.07512184232473373,
-0.6780796051025391,
-0.10933297872543335,
0.16960717737674713,
-0.6771181225776672,
-0.07810073345899582,
0.08031939715147018,
-0.4254593551158905,
-0.48253512382507324,
-0.24022912979125977,
0.6560607552528381,
0.3288186192512512,
-0.41217637062072754,
0.30191749334335327,
0.4671325087547302,
-0.3604366183280945,
-0.5245264172554016,
-0.8665908575057983,
0.10183048248291016,
-0.23730963468551636,
-0.5321172475814819,
0.0572691410779953,
-0.332187294960022,
-0.2862892746925354,
0.15752829611301422,
-0.0010778662981465459,
-0.02632770501077175,
0.2613120377063751,
0.18242274224758148,
0.2175065279006958,
-0.18896420300006866,
-0.11225347220897675,
-0.4101593792438507,
-0.4801827073097229,
0.024708572775125504,
-0.3425779342651367,
0.28248831629753113,
-0.4979492425918579,
-0.4490966796875,
-0.8617245554924011,
0.2780650556087494,
0.9871056079864502,
-0.5811853408813477,
0.9512760043144226,
0.3404981195926666,
-0.2944663166999817,
0.23445670306682587,
-0.39550548791885376,
-0.041729263961315155,
-0.32951876521110535,
0.46321436762809753,
-0.14032723009586334,
-0.6148192882537842,
0.8720901012420654,
0.07984545826911926,
0.11312637478113174,
0.5737420916557312,
0.2594575881958008,
0.04485059902071953,
1.651444435119629,
0.5619381070137024,
-0.43024516105651855,
0.4583317041397095,
-0.6364879608154297,
0.22474296391010284,
-0.9216930270195007,
-0.4427478611469269,
-0.6860849857330322,
-0.727030873298645,
-0.7038450837135315,
0.16169843077659607,
0.8542198538780212,
-0.20002830028533936,
-0.6887221336364746,
0.003947477322071791,
-0.6228482127189636,
0.2823435664176941,
0.9638195633888245,
0.10628072917461395,
0.18437649309635162,
-0.4988603889942169,
0.03578067198395729,
0.22202648222446442,
-0.9652368426322937,
-0.5500327348709106,
1.3949058055877686,
0.13277563452720642,
0.5114463567733765,
-0.04486736282706261,
0.8856743574142456,
0.37055036425590515,
0.6015740633010864,
-0.27652639150619507,
0.5686395168304443,
-0.165594220161438,
-0.9065088629722595,
-0.18147435784339905,
-0.6034337282180786,
-1.01569664478302,
0.07038778066635132,
-0.241112619638443,
-1.0190328359603882,
0.006554180756211281,
0.15631116926670074,
-0.4970118999481201,
0.4674251079559326,
-0.24056924879550934,
0.9032633900642395,
-0.45192262530326843,
-0.4316043257713318,
-0.324301153421402,
-0.7645416855812073,
0.46179237961769104,
-0.10536012053489685,
0.2924841046333313,
-0.22946472465991974,
-0.017161071300506592,
0.9615780711174011,
-0.4446393549442291,
0.19548887014389038,
0.036774951964616776,
0.5035106539726257,
0.22161684930324554,
-0.2178432196378708,
0.3160221576690674,
0.19090090692043304,
-0.4863884150981903,
0.16133072972297668,
-0.08954667299985886,
-0.5726301670074463,
-0.23994973301887512,
0.9331974983215332,
-1.2426798343658447,
-0.3571702837944031,
-0.6363510489463806,
-0.2232704907655716,
-0.13844415545463562,
0.3898032307624817,
0.7081058621406555,
0.8145090937614441,
-0.011615240015089512,
0.12424192577600479,
0.5865818858146667,
0.10956127941608429,
0.32357773184776306,
0.10831905156373978,
0.1163620799779892,
-0.5105174779891968,
1.106681227684021,
0.48632583022117615,
-0.3010939657688141,
0.4029777944087982,
0.13017043471336365,
-0.3146316111087799,
-0.8963711857795715,
-0.5526604652404785,
0.2877846956253052,
-0.5045560598373413,
-0.035982828587293625,
-0.49085724353790283,
-0.19178736209869385,
-0.35012081265449524,
0.02348829247057438,
-0.7557018399238586,
-0.5804318189620972,
-0.026396431028842926,
0.09872539341449738,
0.037280116230249405,
1.2780005931854248,
0.0761825367808342,
0.06269753724336624,
-0.6244937181472778,
0.1449078619480133,
0.446105033159256,
0.3386286497116089,
-0.10058843344449997,
-0.38152289390563965,
-0.35480883717536926,
-0.22314196825027466,
-0.1153532862663269,
-0.6181702613830566,
-0.07627201080322266,
-0.060763608664274216,
0.8262912631034851,
0.34542152285575867,
0.02615487016737461,
0.2849064767360687,
-0.3354719579219818,
1.1758893728256226,
0.21019339561462402,
-0.5876172184944153,
0.3054816424846649,
-0.28289994597435,
0.35527488589286804,
0.5978825688362122,
0.19045190513134003,
-0.3173013925552368,
-0.6495202779769897,
-0.8390918970108032,
-0.8418673276901245,
0.9222350716590881,
0.018772948533296585,
-0.15687313675880432,
0.04161345958709717,
0.3783327043056488,
0.25480785965919495,
0.4342312514781952,
-0.6696118116378784,
-0.24934126436710358,
-0.22579848766326904,
-0.41954684257507324,
-0.008412101306021214,
0.20642124116420746,
-0.14840663969516754,
-0.0007649532635696232,
1.0802556276321411,
0.011341678909957409,
0.3782620131969452,
0.1686883568763733,
0.01780635304749012,
0.017962215468287468,
-0.18909110128879547,
0.5143721699714661,
1.0816682577133179,
0.13808079063892365,
0.05232805013656616,
0.06131552532315254,
-0.2607247233390808,
-0.15980558097362518,
0.38452085852622986,
-0.3092315196990967,
-0.47211015224456787,
0.8683956265449524,
0.657640814781189,
-0.192181795835495,
-0.6184487342834473,
0.33486953377723694,
-0.22479248046875,
-0.23048074543476105,
-0.3100566864013672,
0.3678019344806671,
-0.17321334779262543,
0.7743631601333618,
0.34559959173202515,
0.42850446701049805,
0.2430117279291153,
-0.6875978708267212,
-0.03405660390853882,
0.3336643576622009,
-0.40029385685920715,
-0.498382568359375,
1.4140042066574097,
0.2541130483150482,
-0.2417445033788681,
0.5370148420333862,
-0.10671974718570709,
-0.7192460298538208,
0.7349489331245422,
0.11945107579231262,
0.8794819712638855,
-0.008307108655571938,
0.18043290078639984,
0.20135678350925446,
0.3083271384239197,
-0.4229041635990143,
0.3108324706554413,
0.1088205873966217,
-0.35244879126548767,
0.05508565902709961,
-0.24705208837985992,
-0.4202754497528076,
0.15552109479904175,
-0.29899561405181885,
-0.2171688973903656,
-0.4000663757324219,
-0.3514416813850403,
0.03272140026092529,
0.3603295087814331,
-0.6632331013679504,
0.27038291096687317,
0.3630295395851135,
0.9678484797477722,
-0.7407985329627991,
0.44664230942726135,
1.084514856338501,
-0.3366727828979492,
-0.5409523248672485,
-0.2596453130245209,
-0.15360863506793976,
-0.47380897402763367,
0.38178545236587524,
0.17913149297237396,
-0.17032809555530548,
0.1952589601278305,
-0.7461003661155701,
-0.8544881939888,
1.2260838747024536,
0.3953663408756256,
-0.183882936835289,
0.4885759651660919,
0.052120767533779144,
0.548628032207489,
-0.36950817704200745,
0.6488884687423706,
0.4703001379966736,
0.7328281998634338,
-0.2579556405544281,
-0.7906322479248047,
-0.41974323987960815,
-0.6106497049331665,
-0.15050041675567627,
-0.03468649089336395,
-1.1711105108261108,
0.801832914352417,
0.0037188981659710407,
0.3144315779209137,
0.7466513514518738,
0.9118096232414246,
0.2598673701286316,
0.8505814671516418,
0.22899289429187775,
0.8105961680412292,
0.8505768179893494,
-0.1227559745311737,
1.048363208770752,
-0.5671153664588928,
-0.009391825646162033,
0.7153620719909668,
-0.29973286390304565,
0.62255859375,
-0.07066606730222702,
0.1065344512462616,
0.194620743393898,
0.6037954092025757,
0.018088411539793015,
0.4618460237979889,
-0.09904763102531433,
-0.026746833696961403,
-0.3253748416900635,
0.09110482782125473,
-0.33436647057533264,
0.43503889441490173,
-0.15544633567333221,
-0.23072439432144165,
0.05126826465129852,
0.10062767565250397,
0.18656913936138153,
0.04093484580516815,
-0.5215262770652771,
0.5487726330757141,
-0.11422685533761978,
-1.1175329685211182,
0.28502604365348816,
-0.002921306760981679,
0.21284407377243042,
-0.5879508256912231,
0.09797479212284088,
-0.3233617842197418,
0.3522399067878723,
0.09681818634271622,
-0.620509147644043,
-0.37024667859077454,
0.33932504057884216,
-0.03039569780230522,
0.08648911118507385,
0.2546652555465698,
-0.11156890541315079,
-0.5333505272865295,
0.19090552628040314,
0.4505027234554291,
0.4156101644039154,
-0.05791325867176056,
-0.9957235455513,
0.012861350551247597,
-0.4695582091808319,
-0.3497176468372345,
0.2220681607723236,
0.5071133971214294,
-0.23886533081531525,
0.953227162361145,
0.4353703558444977,
0.16014838218688965,
0.2929879426956177,
0.10301969945430756,
0.7221671938896179,
-0.4670543074607849,
-0.6771059632301331,
-0.6569911241531372,
0.355684369802475,
-0.18378542363643646,
-0.9059506058692932,
0.42606908082962036,
0.7673346400260925,
0.49034878611564636,
0.31224021315574646,
0.9034169316291809,
-0.024895425885915756,
0.21392206847667694,
-0.2918902635574341,
1.0219701528549194,
-0.7542416453361511,
0.1730664223432541,
-0.20548661053180695,
-1.0137660503387451,
-0.35169273614883423,
0.3982420265674591,
-0.5363528728485107,
0.3287031948566437,
0.527188241481781,
0.545298159122467,
0.03882433846592903,
0.24810394644737244,
0.3631954789161682,
0.4388112425804138,
0.5148348212242126,
0.5148862600326538,
0.9993719458580017,
-0.2598777711391449,
0.5148067474365234,
-0.17944316565990448,
-0.6500642895698547,
-0.5002091526985168,
-0.5658419728279114,
-0.6812996864318848,
-0.4629652798175812,
-0.3250398635864258,
0.2768711745738983,
0.34949228167533875,
0.7730295658111572,
0.9744564294815063,
-0.8279608488082886,
-0.011235986836254597,
-0.1760368049144745,
0.00878584012389183,
-0.47216910123825073,
-0.09161397814750671,
0.25823667645454407,
-0.08705151081085205,
-0.9631960988044739,
0.3840624690055847,
0.3595653474330902,
-0.4939054846763611,
0.03919641673564911,
-0.09609568864107132,
-0.2047942727804184,
0.21837586164474487,
0.2513381242752075,
0.35248076915740967,
-0.38802918791770935,
-0.5704935193061829,
-0.2238164246082306,
-0.11377109587192535,
-0.19026266038417816,
0.35479849576950073,
-0.6796918511390686,
0.36048784852027893,
0.5315945744514465,
0.4348161220550537,
0.5240082144737244,
0.035516999661922455,
0.29836905002593994,
0.18225091695785522,
-0.21975766122341156,
0.5302736759185791,
0.37871336936950684,
0.14233653247356415,
-0.1358339488506317,
0.782901406288147,
0.2881096303462982,
-1.244542121887207,
-0.655174195766449,
0.07186815142631531,
-0.7683901190757751,
-0.29149317741394043,
0.40888896584510803,
0.0016297040274366736,
-0.45679032802581787,
0.05814189463853836,
0.048564959317445755,
0.4012630879878998,
-0.2959437370300293,
1.1536016464233398,
0.6063215136528015,
-0.9394404292106628,
0.03069194220006466,
-1.0203921794891357,
0.028642917051911354,
0.5473268628120422,
-0.7337810397148132,
-0.30290958285331726,
0.09569299966096878,
0.10590075701475143,
0.28593626618385315,
0.3706236779689789,
-0.17095428705215454,
0.5707038044929504,
0.16666771471500397,
-0.08179277926683426,
-0.35028132796287537,
-0.8053225874900818,
0.07375463098287582,
0.1733378767967224,
0.1366860568523407,
-0.25255271792411804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16767v1 | The GPT-WritingPrompts Dataset: A Comparative Analysis of Character Portrayal in Short Stories | 2024-06-24T16:24:18 | 2024-06-24T16:24:18 | Xi Yu Huang, Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Frank Rudzicz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The improved generative capabilities of large language models have made them
a powerful tool for creative writing and storytelling. It is therefore
important to quantitatively understand the nature of generated stories, and how
they differ from human storytelling. We augment the Reddit WritingPrompts
dataset with short stories generated by GPT-3.5, given the same prompts. We
quantify and compare the emotional and descriptive features of storytelling
from both generative processes, human and machine, along a set of six
dimensions. We find that generated stories differ significantly from human
stories along all six dimensions, and that human and machine generations
display similar biases when grouped according to the narrative point-of-view
and gender of the main protagonist. We release our dataset and code at
https://github.com/KristinHuangg/gpt-writing-prompts. | [
-0.533628523349762,
-0.5992537140846252,
0.8577411770820618,
0.1964491903781891,
-0.15841136872768402,
0.12115134298801422,
-0.20557662844657898,
-0.5170541405677795,
0.3791830241680145,
0.26037171483039856,
-0.8914168477058411,
-0.4792001247406006,
-0.4113571047782898,
0.5689892768859863,
-0.19351084530353546,
1.197051763534546,
-0.10234726220369339,
-0.2607862055301666,
-0.40816375613212585,
0.03869418054819107,
-0.476152628660202,
-0.47822391986846924,
-0.5332794189453125,
-0.07161273807287216,
0.896854043006897,
0.20415940880775452,
0.6899010539054871,
0.3765547573566437,
0.560295820236206,
0.21694672107696533,
0.28721868991851807,
-0.143185555934906,
-0.39037153124809265,
0.25864407420158386,
0.04514998570084572,
-0.11550157517194748,
-0.05995573103427887,
0.33512958884239197,
0.5979999899864197,
0.45613229274749756,
0.16726070642471313,
0.18909165263175964,
0.2074395716190338,
0.6669476628303528,
-0.2202053815126419,
0.0270772073417902,
0.078073650598526,
0.14016520977020264,
-0.2702096402645111,
-0.09769861400127411,
-0.04172093793749809,
-0.7371721863746643,
0.18944789469242096,
-0.5274690985679626,
1.1807492971420288,
0.08840461820363998,
0.7138442397117615,
-0.08922094851732254,
-0.2143588364124298,
-0.48821166157722473,
-0.654606819152832,
0.5316253900527954,
-0.25607070326805115,
-0.1422753632068634,
0.057956960052251816,
0.4493567645549774,
0.29357171058654785,
-0.639415442943573,
-0.7307548522949219,
-0.4420655071735382,
-0.4461319148540497,
-0.08395542949438095,
-0.36693665385246277,
-0.22728662192821503,
0.5384880304336548,
0.6064932942390442,
-1.2314132452011108,
0.08801554888486862,
-0.4683700501918793,
-0.27824151515960693,
0.7879287600517273,
0.5170004367828369,
0.5536506175994873,
-0.4219377338886261,
-0.09829478710889816,
-0.2935519218444824,
-0.7523444890975952,
-0.09274807572364807,
0.8764630556106567,
0.13302405178546906,
-0.33015552163124084,
0.5992268323898315,
-0.05697778984904289,
0.36776304244995117,
-0.05902551859617233,
-0.1414172351360321,
0.3912535607814789,
-0.21427877247333527,
0.08998085558414459,
0.09660955518484116,
1.1436935663223267,
0.828485369682312,
0.35429075360298157,
0.04183844476938248,
-0.0948178842663765,
0.25662103295326233,
0.23485462367534637,
-0.7203813791275024,
-0.3703833818435669,
-0.0387711226940155,
-0.6391247510910034,
-0.3100009262561798,
0.15723095834255219,
-0.7111207842826843,
-0.9911029934883118,
-0.2788122594356537,
0.1751379519701004,
-0.3455932140350342,
-0.14214009046554565,
-0.10131178796291351,
-0.5998325943946838,
0.0055125122889876366,
0.09274490177631378,
-1.007957100868225,
0.028971264138817787,
0.6248044967651367,
0.8935036063194275,
-0.17243576049804688,
-0.43077072501182556,
-0.052607081830501556,
-0.3246903419494629,
-0.14077048003673553,
0.8932062387466431,
-0.31930437684059143,
-0.3961750566959381,
-0.2868686020374298,
-0.22372214496135712,
0.04347914829850197,
-0.6937018036842346,
0.6343075633049011,
0.056450795382261276,
0.5585914254188538,
-0.691962718963623,
-0.2889939248561859,
0.002000050386413932,
0.02094324678182602,
-0.85545814037323,
0.7913373708724976,
0.39607810974121094,
-0.8924123644828796,
0.6746460199356079,
-0.7019797563552856,
-0.2984985411167145,
0.04482565447688103,
-0.265423059463501,
-0.38859209418296814,
0.264329731464386,
0.42565974593162537,
0.5694726705551147,
-0.4771115183830261,
0.09375268220901489,
-0.17459160089492798,
-0.4428066611289978,
0.30297186970710754,
-0.314389169216156,
0.5235426425933838,
0.2147003561258316,
-0.15384332835674286,
0.035185206681489944,
-0.6522781848907471,
-0.1919647455215454,
0.44617417454719543,
0.0399642251431942,
-0.0006403815350495279,
-0.1874338686466217,
-0.09512129426002502,
0.045026008039712906,
-0.060686033219099045,
-0.6205163598060608,
0.3520146906375885,
-0.04288644716143608,
0.6117609739303589,
0.2868771255016327,
0.41240745782852173,
0.1048702821135521,
-0.5683496594429016,
0.8327085971832275,
-0.07033830881118774,
0.018221748992800713,
-0.10817861557006836,
-0.5970999002456665,
-0.22447387874126434,
-0.33201467990875244,
-0.018983839079737663,
0.3529475927352905,
-0.6320770978927612,
0.2934432029724121,
-0.1444769948720932,
-0.5079694390296936,
-0.5369743704795837,
-0.28964337706565857,
0.40080660581588745,
0.5452795624732971,
0.23398607969284058,
-0.12036332488059998,
-0.5183279514312744,
-1.0182620286941528,
-0.5452702641487122,
-0.311829537153244,
-0.6454952359199524,
-0.06063861772418022,
0.37842974066734314,
0.014591267332434654,
0.8841100335121155,
-0.7119711637496948,
-0.017640691250562668,
-0.6288066506385803,
0.5887919664382935,
0.21899822354316711,
0.32894599437713623,
0.8689709305763245,
-0.44088828563690186,
-0.7596323490142822,
-0.25327247381210327,
-0.8440881967544556,
-0.409649521112442,
-0.3050048351287842,
0.08770660310983658,
0.037466470152139664,
-0.010686870664358139,
-1.028361201286316,
0.4217401146888733,
0.2735237777233124,
-0.6666334271430969,
1.0500863790512085,
-0.03424214571714401,
0.46281498670578003,
-0.8717961311340332,
-0.06453443318605423,
0.2964550256729126,
-0.015744846314191818,
-0.3673252463340759,
-0.34150591492652893,
-0.17942817509174347,
-0.34612688422203064,
-0.2006337195634842,
0.36116042733192444,
-0.5251343250274658,
-0.45687440037727356,
0.051394056528806686,
0.23886778950691223,
0.4095168709754944,
0.3129280209541321,
-0.027610329911112785,
0.9591178894042969,
0.34033632278442383,
-0.16036058962345123,
0.7154181599617004,
0.20627205073833466,
-0.54852694272995,
0.7537858486175537,
-0.7514164447784424,
0.21247078478336334,
-0.2690216600894928,
0.21746061742305756,
-0.695101261138916,
-0.37965837121009827,
0.3537566363811493,
-0.6611613631248474,
0.0008425461128354073,
0.11024922877550125,
-0.7827852964401245,
-0.5458256602287292,
-0.4496767520904541,
0.12388032674789429,
0.8015540242195129,
-0.27544236183166504,
0.3070603311061859,
-0.14238746464252472,
-0.6757394671440125,
0.011832202784717083,
-0.5071150660514832,
0.15097858011722565,
-0.7994662523269653,
-0.5798923969268799,
0.32117173075675964,
-0.10399100184440613,
-0.49301058053970337,
-0.016809310764074326,
0.35792073607444763,
0.16649183630943298,
-0.41873273253440857,
0.24555280804634094,
-0.04118071496486664,
-0.28506040573120117,
0.06386591494083405,
-0.04176460579037666,
-0.2877071499824524,
0.3029787838459015,
0.09680227190256119,
0.38173383474349976,
-0.07472581416368484,
-0.22906143963336945,
-0.5787503123283386,
0.6372107267379761,
0.4240284562110901,
0.01663551665842533,
0.5817016363143921,
0.7885429859161377,
0.06572970747947693,
0.00239800987765193,
-0.284950852394104,
-0.11435168236494064,
-0.36292633414268494,
0.1835182011127472,
-0.3638957440853119,
-0.7938743233680725,
0.6737381815910339,
0.6347039341926575,
-0.12555378675460815,
0.8137549161911011,
0.541677713394165,
-0.25010448694229126,
1.0943833589553833,
0.5835720896720886,
0.10145039856433868,
0.2541268765926361,
-0.05183632671833038,
0.23000551760196686,
-0.6080376505851746,
-0.03959833085536957,
-0.45597678422927856,
-0.5335303544998169,
-0.47255876660346985,
0.02561551332473755,
0.3831324875354767,
-0.019063228741288185,
-0.4692894518375397,
0.13465625047683716,
-0.5435171723365784,
0.8854715824127197,
0.6338761448860168,
-0.07793936878442764,
0.23799863457679749,
-0.03277919441461563,
0.1515369713306427,
-0.4675452709197998,
-0.49926647543907166,
-0.754220724105835,
0.7913066744804382,
0.3412516117095947,
0.40642330050468445,
0.04368048161268234,
0.6375226378440857,
0.5876098871231079,
0.16787798702716827,
-0.3650049567222595,
0.36509594321250916,
-0.30974462628364563,
-0.3449915945529938,
-0.0766652300953865,
-0.6388400793075562,
-0.7248312830924988,
0.09453379362821579,
-0.09883403033018112,
-0.8349338173866272,
0.09900747984647751,
0.00885302759706974,
-0.722015917301178,
0.197860985994339,
-1.1355048418045044,
0.9538033604621887,
-0.14494599401950836,
-0.0035144551657140255,
0.10645387321710587,
-0.6675788164138794,
0.23687489330768585,
0.14371465146541595,
-0.32328444719314575,
-0.2874201834201813,
0.40275028347969055,
0.7753667235374451,
-0.5589537024497986,
0.9294929504394531,
-0.2883061170578003,
-0.022448472678661346,
0.7444098591804504,
0.1740090698003769,
0.23269958794116974,
0.21500040590763092,
0.03588137775659561,
-0.08430387824773788,
-0.07905902713537216,
-0.289764940738678,
-0.673949122428894,
0.6003704071044922,
-0.871451735496521,
-0.3744654059410095,
-0.4294215738773346,
-0.6355511546134949,
-0.09656733274459839,
-0.1869882047176361,
0.7363190650939941,
0.5268989205360413,
-0.4622578024864197,
-0.11002496629953384,
0.19617807865142822,
-0.40751612186431885,
0.5757660269737244,
0.05131461098790169,
-0.11108344793319702,
-0.2830229699611664,
0.8998361229896545,
-0.03395469859242439,
0.20675700902938843,
0.21132344007492065,
0.3497263193130493,
-0.505331814289093,
-0.23862919211387634,
-0.33856523036956787,
0.3957764804363251,
-0.6394011378288269,
-0.11208069324493408,
-0.4933454394340515,
-0.1366613805294037,
-0.1959967464208603,
-0.37464213371276855,
0.0513136200606823,
-0.30903160572052,
-0.4486835300922394,
-0.4720735549926758,
0.5761882066726685,
0.9789302349090576,
-0.11024753749370575,
0.22827351093292236,
-0.8006176352500916,
0.477033406496048,
0.37465760111808777,
0.0932152271270752,
-0.1862061321735382,
-0.24611550569534302,
0.025600815191864967,
-0.07121753692626953,
-0.42574456334114075,
-0.7391137480735779,
0.49473848938941956,
0.13365963101387024,
0.2031189203262329,
0.31758856773376465,
0.016983678564429283,
0.4406488239765167,
-0.20794251561164856,
1.2478641271591187,
0.3174412250518799,
-0.8079642057418823,
0.4994325041770935,
-0.6777118444442749,
0.3676542043685913,
0.42550376057624817,
0.45761626958847046,
-0.7076351642608643,
-0.22452037036418915,
-0.7526180744171143,
-0.48936158418655396,
0.38720813393592834,
0.4414176046848297,
0.00850182306021452,
-0.06140962615609169,
0.42911216616630554,
0.6417878866195679,
0.12332866340875626,
-0.6265106797218323,
0.15689407289028168,
-0.3300052285194397,
-0.42602139711380005,
-0.3328206539154053,
-0.3430592119693756,
-0.004228092264384031,
-0.24152253568172455,
0.12212760746479034,
-0.046369001269340515,
0.6105732321739197,
0.09622861444950104,
-0.00925609190016985,
-0.055379126220941544,
0.06656397134065628,
0.6001895070075989,
0.7418729066848755,
-0.09644103795289993,
0.18842250108718872,
-0.014271589927375317,
-0.6108527779579163,
-0.014232865534722805,
-0.045483771711587906,
0.00538646150380373,
0.14318230748176575,
0.9764833450317383,
1.1089732646942139,
-0.2617254853248596,
-0.5559468269348145,
0.37884384393692017,
-0.28633642196655273,
-0.5041499733924866,
-0.05010795593261719,
0.19627273082733154,
-0.06269808113574982,
0.49982354044914246,
0.22156694531440735,
-0.18942180275917053,
0.07562369853258133,
-0.6002678275108337,
-0.15399156510829926,
-0.21245840191841125,
-0.15297912061214447,
-0.6868050694465637,
0.4413113296031952,
0.2634458541870117,
-0.20135711133480072,
1.0075722932815552,
-0.452853262424469,
-0.2711482346057892,
0.7869665026664734,
0.4193669259548187,
1.1374962329864502,
0.19078727066516876,
0.6430150270462036,
0.4340745210647583,
0.07278622686862946,
0.13646499812602997,
0.29790592193603516,
0.23051010072231293,
-0.48174670338630676,
-0.22234298288822174,
-0.6233837008476257,
-0.14390569925308228,
0.25449737906455994,
-0.6237034201622009,
0.2005809098482132,
-0.15001295506954193,
-0.07584066689014435,
0.12400052696466446,
0.07043687999248505,
-0.5820372104644775,
0.1390264928340912,
-0.01803651452064514,
0.3001992702484131,
-1.045516014099121,
0.2376033067703247,
0.48335930705070496,
-0.5068685412406921,
-0.576254665851593,
0.28513190150260925,
0.1190321072936058,
-0.2983228862285614,
0.5018215179443359,
0.3357846140861511,
0.16612035036087036,
-0.07510137557983398,
-0.35016822814941406,
-0.3560703694820404,
1.1056820154190063,
0.4893501400947571,
-0.46475866436958313,
-0.10244058817625046,
0.4890698492527008,
0.920068621635437,
-0.5444318056106567,
0.02639913745224476,
0.6445813775062561,
0.39789679646492004,
-0.17201241850852966,
-0.7231281995773315,
-0.02899971231818199,
-0.25615185499191284,
0.052815038710832596,
0.11940781027078629,
-0.30779972672462463,
1.0166964530944824,
-0.44043606519699097,
-0.5265449285507202,
0.12391318380832672,
0.5224584341049194,
0.5212377309799194,
0.338344544172287,
0.27144426107406616,
0.4161706268787384,
0.5755337476730347,
-0.248320072889328,
1.349230170249939,
0.06541988998651505,
0.24925142526626587,
0.8727971315383911,
-0.3257429897785187,
0.15999555587768555,
0.14954492449760437,
-0.36642739176750183,
0.48242852091789246,
0.9038792252540588,
-0.08027814328670502,
0.42848822474479675,
0.27180731296539307,
-0.3427465260028839,
0.019223889335989952,
0.18170103430747986,
-0.500482439994812,
0.07878424972295761,
-0.01869886927306652,
-0.5081673860549927,
-0.2524336278438568,
0.2497575283050537,
-0.007632231805473566,
0.10541535168886185,
-0.14777082204818726,
0.8510615825653076,
0.12368174642324448,
-0.41096988320350647,
0.30748409032821655,
-0.24432392418384552,
0.32430222630500793,
-0.36921197175979614,
-0.010511528700590134,
-0.3503815233707428,
-0.1132090762257576,
0.004152962472289801,
-1.2036136388778687,
0.5010455846786499,
0.43582677841186523,
-0.5499336123466492,
-0.4389878511428833,
0.6525077819824219,
-0.20953789353370667,
-0.40939009189605713,
-0.28461337089538574,
0.6027116775512695,
0.22523483633995056,
-0.434567928314209,
-0.4701518416404724,
0.012786932289600372,
-0.16774289309978485,
-0.1995019167661667,
0.2158251851797104,
0.8008251786231995,
-0.2629794180393219,
0.31153467297554016,
0.3006260097026825,
-0.08201660215854645,
-0.1616813689470291,
0.44659796357154846,
0.6001201868057251,
-0.8956810832023621,
-0.837123692035675,
-0.8621258735656738,
0.6535400748252869,
-0.10275586694478989,
-0.6598467230796814,
0.6877237558364868,
0.4932531714439392,
0.4000033140182495,
-0.5223504304885864,
0.9364223480224609,
-0.32411593198776245,
0.8669235110282898,
-0.5950806736946106,
0.806846559047699,
-0.07641015201807022,
0.15207090973854065,
-0.12477489560842514,
-1.1851413249969482,
-0.12603019177913666,
0.32940149307250977,
-0.41602444648742676,
0.33027252554893494,
0.956628680229187,
0.5757962465286255,
0.09746694564819336,
0.10849304497241974,
0.03367181867361069,
-0.03851994499564171,
0.22272075712680817,
0.4165033996105194,
1.235023856163025,
0.07092223316431046,
0.11104179173707962,
-0.17277629673480988,
0.005504894070327282,
-0.011291750706732273,
-0.8698300123214722,
-0.940529465675354,
-0.778990626335144,
-0.35158565640449524,
-0.02591950260102749,
0.07756155729293823,
0.42913320660591125,
0.2745065689086914,
-0.47630375623703003,
0.0954466313123703,
-0.07988345623016357,
-0.10266967862844467,
-0.21776741743087769,
-0.2928646206855774,
0.27826058864593506,
0.010680885054171085,
-0.44837111234664917,
0.1143839955329895,
0.013570579700171947,
0.2394205629825592,
-0.37110641598701477,
-0.0521434023976326,
0.4826776385307312,
-0.09313606470823288,
0.5584284067153931,
0.19092510640621185,
-0.446505606174469,
-0.5568885207176208,
-0.22958119213581085,
-0.07501388341188431,
0.18140603601932526,
1.2195922136306763,
-0.6602068543434143,
0.03499700501561165,
0.706899881362915,
-0.003952463623136282,
0.30993494391441345,
0.2128523290157318,
0.6400142908096313,
-1.1306791305541992,
-0.10139045864343643,
0.25029680132865906,
0.2152082771062851,
0.53528892993927,
-0.677726686000824,
0.404262900352478,
0.440358430147171,
-0.5768934488296509,
-0.4879004657268524,
0.419931560754776,
-0.8117830157279968,
-0.1585617959499359,
0.942083477973938,
-0.05713830888271332,
0.04463309422135353,
0.1082715168595314,
-0.47841310501098633,
0.03431152552366257,
-0.25792428851127625,
0.8589736223220825,
0.7946294546127319,
-0.5639144778251648,
-0.40059539675712585,
-0.6629126667976379,
0.6670212745666504,
-0.10892650485038757,
-0.8909710645675659,
0.20265400409698486,
0.7235915660858154,
0.19308023154735565,
0.02526511438190937,
0.5918878316879272,
-0.03969796746969223,
0.13388682901859283,
0.35220012068748474,
0.20660634338855743,
-0.09386659413576126,
-0.40070661902427673,
-0.07498915493488312,
0.38077789545059204,
-0.24410676956176758,
0.0937768816947937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16758v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16758v1 | Towards Fast Multilingual LLM Inference: Speculative Decoding and Specialized Drafters | 2024-06-24T16:06:50 | 2024-06-24T16:06:50 | Euiin Yi, Taehyeon Kim, Hongseok Jeung, Du-Seong Chang, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
and broadened their applicability across diverse commercial applications.
However, the deployment of these models is constrained by high inference time
in multilingual settings. To mitigate this challenge, this paper explores a
training recipe of an assistant model in speculative decoding, which are
leveraged to draft and-then its future tokens are verified by the target LLM.
We show that language-specific draft models, optimized through a targeted
pretrain-and-finetune strategy, substantially brings a speedup of inference
time compared to the previous methods. We validate these models across various
languages in inference time, out-of-domain speedup, and GPT-4o evaluation. | [
-0.19456544518470764,
-0.7260661721229553,
0.6463071703910828,
0.40030544996261597,
-0.16479994356632233,
0.22645477950572968,
-0.2701803147792816,
-0.6289477944374084,
0.23128437995910645,
0.73259037733078,
-0.7222996354103088,
-0.20004768669605255,
-0.5699360966682434,
0.36697688698768616,
-0.2908104658126831,
0.7469436526298523,
-0.1823786497116089,
0.0029359920881688595,
0.15922875702381134,
0.14811697602272034,
0.053542908281087875,
-0.7900108695030212,
-0.9014365673065186,
-0.1921391785144806,
0.3973099887371063,
0.17857740819454193,
0.5547621250152588,
0.6941502094268799,
0.028361773118376732,
0.29850393533706665,
-0.03125670179724693,
0.3308403193950653,
-0.4734889268875122,
0.07969720661640167,
0.06954506784677505,
-0.7318923473358154,
-0.47922661900520325,
0.001558325719088316,
0.5942936539649963,
0.6093704700469971,
-0.06289933621883392,
0.061868079006671906,
-0.2495793253183365,
0.3408508002758026,
-0.8315519094467163,
0.05201910808682442,
-0.9734829664230347,
0.015177000313997269,
-0.3850610554218292,
-0.2469879686832428,
-0.8131816983222961,
-0.23824410140514374,
0.01673905737698078,
-0.9216122031211853,
0.5474280714988708,
0.08651942759752274,
0.6841030716896057,
0.05539074167609215,
-0.46535590291023254,
-0.16744957864284515,
-0.6486502885818481,
0.6395670771598816,
-0.8339168429374695,
0.7057502865791321,
0.4279692471027374,
0.34281718730926514,
-0.13275398313999176,
-0.8462535738945007,
-0.6648593544960022,
-0.23581606149673462,
0.07805278897285461,
0.011704746633768082,
0.25907957553863525,
0.12048632651567459,
0.14757829904556274,
0.18466445803642273,
-0.5490289330482483,
0.24638721346855164,
-0.00277545559220016,
-0.5005199313163757,
0.6044065952301025,
0.09454513341188431,
0.00012684422836173326,
0.16637438535690308,
-0.19915390014648438,
0.09701663255691528,
-0.6075258851051331,
-0.2524794340133667,
0.7436131238937378,
0.1866876631975174,
-0.20605553686618805,
0.43283727765083313,
-0.31699907779693604,
0.644177258014679,
0.14452993869781494,
-0.2515662908554077,
0.18086402118206024,
-0.5235877633094788,
-0.1748199462890625,
-0.0949382334947586,
0.6838932633399963,
0.03246635943651199,
0.3396758735179901,
-0.4145452380180359,
-0.20626749098300934,
0.2267262041568756,
-0.14631813764572144,
-0.7597541213035583,
-0.20562663674354553,
0.21084202826023102,
-0.25732704997062683,
-0.04052101820707321,
-0.27971237897872925,
-0.5613575577735901,
-0.1342644989490509,
-0.10818634182214737,
-0.052918922156095505,
-0.4623546302318573,
-0.39798691868782043,
0.48368871212005615,
-0.23263035714626312,
0.1789112091064453,
0.3271392285823822,
-1.3487017154693604,
0.08237779140472412,
0.5471442341804504,
0.6031330227851868,
-0.2458261400461197,
-0.6603288650512695,
-0.7018754482269287,
0.40196117758750916,
-0.7041620016098022,
1.1247230768203735,
-0.6328177452087402,
-0.3697085380554199,
-0.019447702914476395,
-0.09276002645492554,
-0.27355507016181946,
-0.14278897643089294,
0.7194989919662476,
-0.8212169408798218,
-0.08949340879917145,
-0.16997136175632477,
-0.6349577903747559,
0.1965656876564026,
0.5975227952003479,
-0.7363058924674988,
0.7887623906135559,
-0.024829445406794548,
-0.7699036598205566,
0.661694347858429,
-0.3210817277431488,
-0.5371708273887634,
-0.044337838888168335,
-0.05763925611972809,
0.00899076834321022,
0.030076516792178154,
0.6771656274795532,
0.696291983127594,
-0.3926413357257843,
0.15384289622306824,
-0.4184924364089966,
-0.5512735247612,
0.03860330954194069,
-0.768807053565979,
0.4664267599582672,
0.4192914664745331,
0.11042822152376175,
0.14533722400665283,
-0.7647085785865784,
0.06774324923753738,
0.16863355040550232,
-0.6520689129829407,
-0.1667962670326233,
-0.29861676692962646,
0.11035823822021484,
0.029903599992394447,
0.03084985539317131,
-0.3136497437953949,
0.2531799376010895,
-0.553306519985199,
0.4642723500728607,
0.608210027217865,
-0.03572242707014084,
0.4967670738697052,
0.0015936625422909856,
0.7723084092140198,
-0.023271072655916214,
0.0754648894071579,
-0.45364224910736084,
-0.06529060006141663,
-0.8174040913581848,
-0.38164883852005005,
0.5211361050605774,
0.451309472322464,
-1.2991911172866821,
0.018963707610964775,
-0.21024630963802338,
-0.31111180782318115,
-0.6441070437431335,
0.10344653576612473,
0.48241108655929565,
0.10659117996692657,
0.19162297248840332,
0.24398677051067352,
-0.4407854378223419,
-0.7549586892127991,
-0.5918020009994507,
0.011438514105975628,
0.21471558511257172,
-0.06944604218006134,
0.2425604909658432,
-0.32216572761535645,
0.315611332654953,
-0.3197699785232544,
0.22129736840724945,
-0.848547637462616,
0.3111967444419861,
0.21167755126953125,
0.3621320128440857,
0.6440892815589905,
-0.5875543355941772,
-0.5186863541603088,
-0.028599590063095093,
-0.6125989556312561,
0.06361386179924011,
-0.35619112849235535,
-0.2674897313117981,
0.3054944574832916,
0.8623281717300415,
-0.7315487265586853,
0.022071173414587975,
0.6380489468574524,
-0.3129770755767822,
0.7273650765419006,
-0.47371602058410645,
0.2035515159368515,
-1.0375195741653442,
-0.09738070517778397,
-0.022103043273091316,
-0.1629224568605423,
-0.6558441519737244,
0.3508627116680145,
0.2152148336172104,
-0.02306544780731201,
-0.5338541269302368,
0.8992601633071899,
-0.8527647256851196,
0.20377254486083984,
-0.12996011972427368,
-0.09938988834619522,
0.11008494347333908,
0.39224115014076233,
0.38735008239746094,
0.8255494832992554,
0.5434824228286743,
-0.5085142254829407,
-0.029342127963900566,
-0.13315652310848236,
-0.28198179602622986,
0.1478903740644455,
-0.47532254457473755,
0.3955516815185547,
-0.03554894030094147,
0.4957749545574188,
-0.7384236454963684,
-0.39008674025535583,
0.012167566455900669,
-0.0009428969933651388,
0.41026008129119873,
-0.2594819962978363,
-0.7714905142784119,
-0.4375247061252594,
-0.21705791354179382,
0.6489142775535583,
0.0206980612128973,
-0.5174739956855774,
0.863645613193512,
0.220541313290596,
0.04524403065443039,
-0.8052079081535339,
-0.7403641939163208,
-0.020640084519982338,
-0.1227664053440094,
-0.5714135766029358,
0.27708950638771057,
-0.05180429294705391,
-0.22458094358444214,
-0.3171965479850769,
0.13050708174705505,
-0.21006010472774506,
0.1550271064043045,
-0.25348836183547974,
0.14555910229682922,
-0.20458675920963287,
-0.16223667562007904,
0.4254944324493408,
-0.32653284072875977,
-0.10051607340574265,
-0.3620750606060028,
0.49757638573646545,
0.15077848732471466,
-0.4669680595397949,
-0.275701642036438,
0.4865683615207672,
0.4770028293132782,
-0.3988317549228668,
0.6006447076797485,
0.6864668130874634,
-0.06957721710205078,
-0.4493420720100403,
-0.992620587348938,
-0.23400256037712097,
-0.4419911503791809,
0.38519957661628723,
-0.8076149821281433,
-0.7830774188041687,
0.5821539759635925,
-0.22439660131931305,
0.11567351222038269,
0.3793932795524597,
0.5021592378616333,
0.5513783097267151,
0.8422501087188721,
0.760488748550415,
0.0334770530462265,
0.26287153363227844,
-0.36746299266815186,
0.09230048954486847,
-0.59824138879776,
-0.09649527072906494,
-0.5224438905715942,
0.17209036648273468,
-0.346812903881073,
-0.7549303770065308,
0.1619122177362442,
0.01638237200677395,
0.14703714847564697,
-0.021243223920464516,
0.07471083104610443,
0.8550750613212585,
0.5411857962608337,
-0.04543504863977432,
0.3785162568092346,
-0.1699310541152954,
-0.5391851663589478,
0.1196751594543457,
-0.9833154082298279,
-0.44450896978378296,
1.1750972270965576,
0.30274340510368347,
0.7804078459739685,
-0.060561403632164,
0.585608184337616,
-0.1290448158979416,
0.22698651254177094,
-0.6234825849533081,
0.48198679089546204,
-0.2718622088432312,
-0.8355506062507629,
-0.23136049509048462,
-0.2950354516506195,
-0.5798715949058533,
0.3693735599517822,
-0.2596963346004486,
-0.49133238196372986,
0.05860443040728569,
0.43945246934890747,
-0.43949270248413086,
0.2912713289260864,
-0.9996012449264526,
0.8483298420906067,
-0.21535378694534302,
-0.5041903257369995,
-0.3405364453792572,
-0.4830601215362549,
0.5678634643554688,
-0.34556108713150024,
0.1671789139509201,
-0.2141929417848587,
0.09515305608510971,
0.3825255036354065,
-0.24869370460510254,
0.7044638991355896,
-0.0147932143881917,
-0.10241905599832535,
0.19792720675468445,
0.2892330288887024,
0.7380613088607788,
0.2508249580860138,
-0.6704245209693909,
0.24824237823486328,
-0.04502492398023605,
-0.462752103805542,
-0.41051584482192993,
0.6148548722267151,
-0.7028138637542725,
-0.5777535438537598,
-0.2567865550518036,
-0.7745019793510437,
-0.5814055800437927,
0.21511410176753998,
0.5415073037147522,
0.34391602873802185,
-0.3756886422634125,
-0.36029937863349915,
0.5106748342514038,
-0.11832381039857864,
0.4151265323162079,
0.6579344868659973,
-0.03879345580935478,
-0.07454261183738708,
0.6097678542137146,
-0.019999278709292412,
0.3836780786514282,
0.5824218988418579,
0.08873976767063141,
-0.4597458839416504,
-1.0251185894012451,
-0.6569811105728149,
0.3460431694984436,
-0.8081329464912415,
0.1082482635974884,
-0.8089853525161743,
-0.002970114117488265,
-0.4844619333744049,
-0.2372642606496811,
-0.48187702894210815,
-0.3230389356613159,
-0.13595296442508698,
-0.22188995778560638,
0.2014935314655304,
0.5258546471595764,
0.18827547132968903,
0.3932119905948639,
-0.7581743001937866,
0.45017802715301514,
0.017314523458480835,
0.2070140391588211,
0.10073903203010559,
-0.5234503149986267,
-0.3880181908607483,
-0.08566296100616455,
0.03677497059106827,
-0.5161997675895691,
0.2787375748157501,
0.14944934844970703,
0.8479580283164978,
0.4394013583660126,
-0.07276711612939835,
0.742595374584198,
-0.7615563869476318,
0.7586866021156311,
-0.010200726799666882,
-0.908882200717926,
0.2427748292684555,
-0.36082419753074646,
0.44826218485832214,
0.4900549054145813,
0.4702334403991699,
-0.35839909315109253,
-0.5726638436317444,
-0.3145449757575989,
-0.8629233837127686,
0.6231385469436646,
-0.11060280352830887,
0.253546804189682,
-0.27869918942451477,
0.41283559799194336,
0.49486759305000305,
-0.014003416523337364,
-0.47750797867774963,
-0.02356662042438984,
-0.04073986038565636,
0.1226760596036911,
-0.31613627076148987,
-0.6321067214012146,
0.1875111609697342,
-0.11248067021369934,
0.6570725440979004,
-0.4706498980522156,
0.08422043919563293,
0.013271514326334,
-0.16020755469799042,
0.12964849174022675,
0.3090858459472656,
0.5026661157608032,
0.6461352109909058,
-0.032314982265233994,
0.11193834245204926,
0.40906062722206116,
-0.30462193489074707,
0.1843983232975006,
0.3586118519306183,
0.16118119657039642,
0.04097751900553703,
0.8146222233772278,
0.8942307829856873,
0.3181355595588684,
-0.48967570066452026,
0.12211154401302338,
-0.44138815999031067,
-0.38923928141593933,
-0.058971527963876724,
0.04112448915839195,
0.24891139566898346,
0.24327674508094788,
0.21994517743587494,
0.10468122363090515,
0.09122297167778015,
-0.4205070734024048,
-0.05427874997258186,
0.32660427689552307,
0.2596280872821808,
-0.4794391393661499,
0.8204391598701477,
0.2926538586616516,
0.08131769299507141,
0.48735952377319336,
-0.37761190533638,
-0.33421632647514343,
0.36787620186805725,
0.6546411514282227,
0.8717222809791565,
-0.2020093947649002,
0.03835694119334221,
0.15263590216636658,
0.1987142562866211,
-0.405140221118927,
0.39097678661346436,
0.05655759572982788,
-0.9448860287666321,
-0.7367900609970093,
-0.7041200995445251,
-0.2777169942855835,
0.1124955415725708,
-0.3263312578201294,
0.13558930158615112,
-0.2969796061515808,
-0.12102984637022018,
0.010602828115224838,
-0.1630864441394806,
-0.8782700896263123,
-0.012648948468267918,
0.08907592296600342,
1.233071208000183,
-0.7886485457420349,
1.18601655960083,
0.5229801535606384,
0.09484083950519562,
-1.0315402746200562,
0.30481550097465515,
-0.03509172797203064,
-0.7722728848457336,
0.7174265384674072,
0.07948850840330124,
-0.34628117084503174,
0.06641771644353867,
0.0438462570309639,
-0.7151141166687012,
0.7090588808059692,
0.9258540868759155,
-0.8416739106178284,
-0.32056328654289246,
-0.01121148094534874,
0.4978654682636261,
-0.23190070688724518,
0.4299107491970062,
0.7686783671379089,
0.4036622941493988,
0.14687703549861908,
-0.9301663041114807,
-0.07219813764095306,
-0.27341005206108093,
0.027657652273774147,
0.05595919117331505,
-0.5477831363677979,
0.934436559677124,
-0.3902139365673065,
0.008825775235891342,
0.1495806872844696,
0.7425308227539062,
0.31499725580215454,
0.10884544253349304,
0.43993112444877625,
0.3734283149242401,
0.8119583129882812,
0.10617227107286453,
1.4862911701202393,
-0.5610345602035522,
-0.1088603064417839,
1.1031460762023926,
-0.4588528871536255,
0.8043779730796814,
0.5147300362586975,
0.14545810222625732,
0.21756118535995483,
0.7960835695266724,
0.37803915143013,
0.5139386057853699,
-0.04033620283007622,
-0.359355628490448,
-0.45534276962280273,
-0.1332445591688156,
-0.3224605917930603,
0.42723900079727173,
0.42291542887687683,
-0.3133056163787842,
-0.08092863857746124,
-0.0709291622042656,
0.09902285784482956,
0.10363226383924484,
-0.289811372756958,
0.5748447775840759,
0.07570625841617584,
-0.9173851609230042,
0.6968675851821899,
0.23844242095947266,
0.7481640577316284,
-0.8157505393028259,
0.22760264575481415,
-0.28378424048423767,
0.4340444505214691,
0.22546909749507904,
-0.36366575956344604,
0.18560299277305603,
-0.02070525661110878,
-0.07029230892658234,
-0.30598801374435425,
0.42524638772010803,
-0.440678209066391,
-0.8216384053230286,
0.45502135157585144,
0.7895269989967346,
0.025445200502872467,
-0.13010382652282715,
-0.6688091158866882,
0.3220210373401642,
-0.18811744451522827,
-0.4763157367706299,
0.10903897136449814,
0.9050998091697693,
-0.2931824028491974,
0.6163343191146851,
0.8169211745262146,
0.3450264632701874,
0.09033223241567612,
0.48644208908081055,
0.8373327851295471,
-0.33342140913009644,
-0.7789452075958252,
-1.03014075756073,
0.2774648368358612,
0.25327229499816895,
-0.37282827496528625,
0.875950276851654,
0.49385061860084534,
0.8732704520225525,
-0.33442139625549316,
0.8469910621643066,
0.5159965753555298,
0.25181061029434204,
-1.0536248683929443,
0.5931381583213806,
-0.298152357339859,
0.3111852705478668,
-0.08728329837322235,
-0.6517548561096191,
-0.20605269074440002,
0.2903178334236145,
-0.34987279772758484,
0.04919349402189255,
0.76806640625,
0.8220534920692444,
-0.26917704939842224,
-0.10504021495580673,
0.31697285175323486,
0.027909237891435623,
0.36724188923835754,
0.6018677353858948,
0.9111166000366211,
-0.18511494994163513,
0.4405657649040222,
-0.2834569215774536,
0.013702940195798874,
-0.12767992913722992,
-1.1727848052978516,
-1.3589226007461548,
-0.32457268238067627,
-0.04673793539404869,
-0.10594876855611801,
0.22458535432815552,
0.9308345913887024,
1.0688916444778442,
-0.6007145643234253,
-0.26981812715530396,
-0.08740010112524033,
-0.006507002282887697,
-0.28731420636177063,
-0.12215632200241089,
0.27666980028152466,
-0.3713294267654419,
-0.7842708826065063,
0.6147297024726868,
0.07265227288007736,
0.17566965520381927,
-0.21335025131702423,
-0.14470280706882477,
-0.28905412554740906,
0.32876718044281006,
0.6226557493209839,
0.017574431374669075,
-0.7944846153259277,
0.20506106317043304,
0.03817383572459221,
-0.005517374724149704,
-0.30493485927581787,
1.1661670207977295,
-0.6268627047538757,
0.36113137006759644,
0.41989415884017944,
0.6462193131446838,
0.6490252614021301,
-0.20909276604652405,
0.9585303664207458,
-0.8046417832374573,
0.8862735629081726,
0.1395372748374939,
0.5062590837478638,
0.20445547997951508,
-0.567467451095581,
0.34699463844299316,
0.15186510980129242,
-0.1751602441072464,
-0.7872743010520935,
0.18292294442653656,
-0.4156017601490021,
-0.39791762828826904,
1.2010424137115479,
-0.37646639347076416,
-0.17647744715213776,
-0.18267902731895447,
-0.14119559526443481,
0.23855377733707428,
-0.41792744398117065,
0.5934223532676697,
0.6501519083976746,
0.060794565826654434,
-0.1402982920408249,
-0.5592967867851257,
0.5384942293167114,
0.25205138325691223,
-0.904687225818634,
0.2637055814266205,
0.20713169872760773,
0.10457661747932434,
-0.041787926107645035,
1.0144096612930298,
0.25261539220809937,
0.21501417458057404,
0.3812110722064972,
-0.11634108424186707,
-0.28092873096466064,
-0.5540720820426941,
-0.07393009215593338,
0.07494752109050751,
0.37030476331710815,
0.2723124027252197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16751v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16751v2 | Towards Zero-Shot Text-To-Speech for Arabic Dialects | 2024-06-24T15:58:15 | 2024-06-25T14:18:21 | Khai Duy Doan, Abdul Waheed, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Zero-shot multi-speaker text-to-speech (ZS-TTS) systems have advanced for
English, however, it still lags behind due to insufficient resources. We
address this gap for Arabic, a language of more than 450 million native
speakers, by first adapting a sizeable existing dataset to suit the needs of
speech synthesis. Additionally, we employ a set of Arabic dialect
identification models to explore the impact of pre-defined dialect labels on
improving the ZS-TTS model in a multi-dialect setting. Subsequently, we
fine-tune the
XTTS\footnote{https://docs.coqui.ai/en/latest/models/xtts.html}\footnote{https://medium.com/machine-learns/xtts-v2-new-version-of-the-open-source-text-to-speech-model-af73914db81f}\footnote{https://medium.com/@erogol/xtts-v1-techincal-notes-eb83ff05bdc}
model, an open-source architecture. We then evaluate our models on a dataset
comprising 31 unseen speakers and an in-house dialectal dataset. Our automated
and human evaluation results show convincing performance while capable of
generating dialectal speech. Our study highlights significant potential for
improvements in this emerging area of research in Arabic. | [
-0.43493014574050903,
-0.4882436692714691,
0.4683561623096466,
-0.05876971408724785,
-0.3519267737865448,
0.297576904296875,
-0.2037876695394516,
-0.48201727867126465,
0.2720322906970978,
0.40107834339141846,
-0.4625682234764099,
-0.7772815823554993,
-0.4793202877044678,
0.1922086924314499,
-0.5744937658309937,
0.9125156402587891,
0.34537601470947266,
-0.06590459495782852,
0.44067880511283875,
-0.19307713210582733,
-0.3593023717403412,
-0.5669621229171753,
-0.6380445957183838,
-0.001552073284983635,
0.4626726508140564,
0.9412093162536621,
0.975346028804779,
0.6819857954978943,
-0.3319929540157318,
0.19165869057178497,
-0.04882558807730675,
-0.07646748423576355,
-0.11273674666881561,
0.40089213848114014,
0.03158790245652199,
-0.03273159638047218,
-0.4583702087402344,
-0.4535442888736725,
0.6786940097808838,
0.6579739451408386,
-0.09914615750312805,
0.07761593908071518,
-0.23472358286380768,
0.5841549634933472,
-0.6430029273033142,
-0.059662118554115295,
-0.6245976686477661,
-0.03766210377216339,
-0.4731474220752716,
0.1437995284795761,
-0.4348220229148865,
-0.10723067075014114,
0.28354769945144653,
-0.09248936921358109,
0.32304948568344116,
-0.1078772023320198,
0.598249077796936,
-0.1591203510761261,
-0.6566267609596252,
-0.13033348321914673,
-0.8604020476341248,
0.6774349212646484,
-0.7526001930236816,
0.6071428060531616,
0.1285679191350937,
0.4459879994392395,
0.0725427195429802,
-0.583450436592102,
-0.5584181547164917,
-0.42113301157951355,
0.3661280870437622,
0.10073386877775192,
-0.19842176139354706,
0.1468556821346283,
-0.19629362225532532,
0.205139622092247,
-0.5926135182380676,
0.005682326387614012,
-0.10821395367383957,
-0.22623156011104584,
0.6000221371650696,
0.07840294390916824,
0.3094034194946289,
-0.00316910189576447,
-0.12711605429649353,
0.03281010687351227,
-0.8140318393707275,
-0.02976408414542675,
0.21054987609386444,
0.8670153021812439,
-0.3524512052536011,
0.4007240831851959,
-0.3658957779407501,
0.776095986366272,
-0.05263378471136093,
0.11081159859895706,
0.13919775187969208,
-0.46244531869888306,
-0.0972495749592781,
0.4028701186180115,
0.8015967607498169,
-0.12878276407718658,
0.3016766309738159,
-0.340626984834671,
-0.27720990777015686,
-0.20944440364837646,
0.11265149712562561,
-0.9361696839332581,
-0.02218480594456196,
0.3729649484157562,
0.03158199414610863,
-0.13146492838859558,
-0.08914516866207123,
-0.7391177415847778,
-0.25335273146629333,
-0.0691545307636261,
0.5833179354667664,
-0.5924798250198364,
-0.3075532615184784,
0.1236100047826767,
-0.18073084950447083,
-0.11277846992015839,
0.30811741948127747,
-0.9039281606674194,
0.29643404483795166,
0.23292596638202667,
1.1276575326919556,
0.24790920317173004,
-0.17073392868041992,
-0.3606972396373749,
0.3965281844139099,
-0.6279675364494324,
0.5490924715995789,
-0.38563811779022217,
-0.548653781414032,
0.21717624366283417,
-0.5955026149749756,
0.20274917781352997,
-0.5540501475334167,
0.4995030164718628,
-0.2399802803993225,
0.01692277193069458,
-0.17309045791625977,
-0.31810325384140015,
0.06115478277206421,
-0.11573505401611328,
-0.652133047580719,
0.9653337001800537,
0.26788538694381714,
-0.2867792844772339,
-0.00022533272567670792,
-0.6580954790115356,
-0.5802852511405945,
-0.03207824006676674,
-0.2775644361972809,
-0.5633761286735535,
0.28328579664230347,
0.28431737422943115,
0.210098534822464,
-0.3754623830318451,
0.17088282108306885,
0.00530348252505064,
-0.3623570203781128,
0.120822012424469,
-0.5921319127082825,
0.7321692109107971,
0.3869931399822235,
-0.6287291049957275,
0.15695367753505707,
-0.8232527375221252,
0.3027060925960541,
-0.033577173948287964,
0.20464348793029785,
0.03100508078932762,
0.09564711153507233,
0.364449143409729,
0.2144400030374527,
-0.05537629872560501,
-0.6425595283508301,
-0.1405630260705948,
-0.6862890720367432,
0.41467753052711487,
0.5192741751670837,
-0.1587051898241043,
0.1957983523607254,
-0.528870165348053,
0.40844860672950745,
0.13265195488929749,
-0.14010325074195862,
-0.541580319404602,
-0.41075897216796875,
-1.005530834197998,
-0.5542625188827515,
0.4149855971336365,
0.3064809739589691,
-0.8795834183692932,
0.4100499153137207,
-0.3645625412464142,
-0.7199093699455261,
-0.4360322952270508,
-0.32189521193504333,
0.40692031383514404,
0.3106323778629303,
0.5107815861701965,
-0.48865553736686707,
-0.5715340971946716,
-0.823271632194519,
-0.12088587135076523,
-0.3330598473548889,
-0.18046754598617554,
0.19774314761161804,
0.2676340341567993,
0.13116984069347382,
1.2263214588165283,
-0.08647904545068741,
-0.23657254874706268,
-0.28288644552230835,
0.2256496697664261,
-0.14428527653217316,
0.1385936290025711,
0.7298067808151245,
-0.3610121011734009,
-0.8151640892028809,
0.2527528703212738,
-0.2662208378314972,
-0.339234858751297,
0.06616294384002686,
0.17568059265613556,
0.528370201587677,
0.2487141638994217,
-0.475667268037796,
0.5262722373008728,
0.44260039925575256,
-0.4578454792499542,
0.6622211337089539,
0.20786476135253906,
0.10929325222969055,
-1.1960965394973755,
-0.051999181509017944,
-0.025328228250145912,
-0.3478653132915497,
-0.992438793182373,
-0.06830564141273499,
-0.26189282536506653,
-0.39833638072013855,
-0.5541014671325684,
0.7049022912979126,
-0.45165976881980896,
-0.03478435054421425,
-0.26078200340270996,
0.16437330842018127,
-0.035006385296583176,
0.33375781774520874,
0.15578655898571014,
1.193750023841858,
0.5440263152122498,
-0.37755197286605835,
0.2212103307247162,
0.15792742371559143,
-0.4568426012992859,
0.3712044954299927,
-0.6315076947212219,
0.3948069214820862,
0.042950183153152466,
0.11091054975986481,
-1.1486544609069824,
-0.06489913910627365,
0.33119016885757446,
-0.7023404836654663,
0.15771271288394928,
-0.10036332160234451,
-0.2565157115459442,
0.12442364543676376,
-0.3406418561935425,
0.5283250212669373,
0.34996941685676575,
-0.25441375374794006,
0.48552095890045166,
0.28535568714141846,
-0.7108851671218872,
-0.3777828812599182,
-0.361467570066452,
0.5720067620277405,
0.06128591299057007,
-0.6098406314849854,
0.4233510494232178,
0.26749375462532043,
-0.25982600450515747,
-0.07321249693632126,
-0.027713026851415634,
-0.4374034106731415,
-0.07361651211977005,
0.2089976966381073,
-0.010693351738154888,
-0.4891088902950287,
0.27737292647361755,
0.24488261342048645,
0.019293541088700294,
-0.17107635736465454,
-0.5000501275062561,
0.6274604797363281,
0.059653863310813904,
-0.3481464684009552,
-0.665518581867218,
0.765467643737793,
0.7591012716293335,
-0.2031470239162445,
0.6500367522239685,
0.3973456919193268,
-0.2213842123746872,
-0.2180781066417694,
-0.3289962112903595,
0.03449564799666405,
-0.46277424693107605,
0.7159214615821838,
-0.4583708941936493,
-0.784661591053009,
0.2195063978433609,
0.08468521386384964,
-0.07105714082717896,
0.3688959777355194,
0.60017991065979,
0.06134000048041344,
0.8905230164527893,
0.6775416731834412,
-0.45615115761756897,
0.5646085143089294,
0.04494132846593857,
0.2938414514064789,
-0.16036456823349,
-0.04169074073433876,
-0.9322193264961243,
0.06762896478176117,
-0.4273702800273895,
-0.2835373282432556,
0.7411243319511414,
-0.28942230343818665,
-0.5305357575416565,
0.20994272828102112,
-0.1198946163058281,
0.2217150777578354,
0.73197340965271,
-0.012840572744607925,
0.09735991060733795,
0.36139801144599915,
-0.1430020034313202,
0.004636470228433609,
-0.7642409801483154,
-0.5784627795219421,
1.0755553245544434,
0.05289332568645477,
0.24747242033481598,
0.5140581727027893,
0.764180064201355,
0.6550740003585815,
0.12137014418840408,
-0.7904103994369507,
0.48065176606178284,
-0.0847526416182518,
-0.46112900972366333,
-0.538031280040741,
-0.2351546734571457,
-0.8809762597084045,
0.09790819138288498,
-0.011171003803610802,
-0.667289137840271,
-0.11574636399745941,
0.08027652651071548,
-0.6318222284317017,
0.33037230372428894,
-0.7485067844390869,
0.5394647717475891,
-0.0765325054526329,
-0.4074252247810364,
-0.3012809455394745,
-0.7033570408821106,
-0.14078202843666077,
-0.11536018550395966,
0.19559788703918457,
-0.07748427242040634,
0.06041102483868599,
0.5517793893814087,
-0.6679237484931946,
0.8125980496406555,
-0.17718487977981567,
-0.2062004953622818,
0.5522223114967346,
-0.04963401332497597,
0.11476927250623703,
-0.24428091943264008,
-0.4768679738044739,
0.4989846646785736,
0.19511733949184418,
-0.6463087201118469,
-0.45855167508125305,
0.32880643010139465,
-0.9934938549995422,
-0.5579178333282471,
-0.5352061986923218,
-0.549627959728241,
-0.4768666625022888,
0.05399854853749275,
0.17712587118148804,
0.7318029999732971,
-0.4346391260623932,
0.025171326473355293,
0.27616214752197266,
-0.2168424278497696,
0.5356269478797913,
0.6395036578178406,
-0.339494913816452,
-0.7478597164154053,
0.8552457690238953,
0.3241996169090271,
0.3644573986530304,
0.2613789737224579,
-0.03787272050976753,
-0.3932884633541107,
-0.698232114315033,
-1.1114284992218018,
0.11469969153404236,
-0.30563387274742126,
-0.2322787046432495,
-0.09842311590909958,
-0.43755778670310974,
-0.7085252404212952,
-0.006689332891255617,
-0.41450226306915283,
-0.5976437330245972,
-0.25596383213996887,
0.04352341592311859,
0.30813533067703247,
0.8458937406539917,
0.0477852039039135,
0.6330474615097046,
-1.0998461246490479,
0.2679814398288727,
0.10688834637403488,
0.1524648815393448,
0.11636222153902054,
-0.961711049079895,
-0.6306339502334595,
0.35826268792152405,
-0.3816651701927185,
-1.1953234672546387,
0.5384423732757568,
0.45399194955825806,
0.0009964810451492667,
0.459394633769989,
0.2811822295188904,
0.6658986806869507,
-0.9053338766098022,
0.9481242895126343,
0.16862666606903076,
-1.4569454193115234,
0.40815308690071106,
-0.3864910900592804,
0.4347139596939087,
0.26694315671920776,
0.1814342439174652,
-0.9976240992546082,
-0.3913595676422119,
-0.2712896466255188,
-0.9131250381469727,
0.7462573647499084,
0.4587516188621521,
0.4114301800727844,
-0.008315961807966232,
0.35944652557373047,
0.17189337313175201,
0.34138223528862,
-0.41323593258857727,
-0.5462836623191833,
-0.17373119294643402,
-0.4654013216495514,
-0.15072770416736603,
-0.437684029340744,
0.09622111171483994,
-0.17442795634269714,
0.8447997570037842,
-0.020576059818267822,
0.31007006764411926,
0.1380719095468521,
0.034562911838293076,
-0.2537309527397156,
0.6600406765937805,
0.7289153337478638,
0.4661772549152374,
-0.16276732087135315,
0.0966259092092514,
-0.1033085435628891,
-0.289714515209198,
0.5349976420402527,
0.24298334121704102,
-0.43185877799987793,
0.5338537693023682,
0.28842470049858093,
0.9167633056640625,
-0.08186805993318558,
-0.7183238863945007,
0.3590748608112335,
0.23184527456760406,
-0.14151185750961304,
-0.3869132101535797,
-0.04751964285969734,
-0.2296631932258606,
0.1854282021522522,
0.527011513710022,
0.08435752987861633,
-0.036090970039367676,
-0.7445351481437683,
0.3252065181732178,
0.5129903554916382,
-0.42878085374832153,
-0.5912006497383118,
0.4880782961845398,
0.5244798064231873,
-0.7471333146095276,
0.3489821255207062,
-0.13030049204826355,
-0.5023499727249146,
0.5269177556037903,
0.5293532013893127,
0.9461498856544495,
-0.6018640995025635,
0.4596390128135681,
0.18100284039974213,
0.12257353961467743,
0.25881102681159973,
0.3933957815170288,
-0.28897374868392944,
-0.6720491051673889,
-0.28768253326416016,
-0.27163273096084595,
-0.7705111503601074,
0.06863485276699066,
-0.5475155711174011,
0.4414365887641907,
-0.30277422070503235,
-0.28947845101356506,
0.048898618668317795,
-0.11232327669858932,
-0.16745205223560333,
0.3578132092952728,
0.33186858892440796,
0.7518391609191895,
-0.9837138652801514,
1.1342145204544067,
0.41031864285469055,
-0.26637157797813416,
-0.5769314765930176,
0.2391791045665741,
-0.02860407903790474,
-0.6197704672813416,
0.26607686281204224,
0.17039130628108978,
-0.5498684048652649,
0.27179795503616333,
-0.3409019112586975,
-0.9399616718292236,
0.7306263446807861,
0.6348125338554382,
-0.7143402695655823,
0.16634534299373627,
0.7031880021095276,
0.46239978075027466,
-0.05020425468683243,
0.42198094725608826,
0.3831314742565155,
0.17266498506069183,
0.18457594513893127,
-1.1813753843307495,
-0.3449974060058594,
-0.06043814495205879,
-0.13953760266304016,
0.34837573766708374,
-0.7078357338905334,
0.9338454008102417,
-0.2817261219024658,
-0.3221316337585449,
0.6145895719528198,
0.7241841554641724,
-0.12154921889305115,
0.48075562715530396,
0.2738494277000427,
0.5324530005455017,
0.5244665741920471,
-0.07026834040880203,
0.6915246248245239,
-0.42877477407455444,
0.09816514700651169,
1.231638789176941,
-0.6832324862480164,
0.9750660061836243,
0.3538423478603363,
-0.27983126044273376,
0.5924056172370911,
0.31490370631217957,
0.5245668888092041,
0.64022296667099,
0.09113682806491852,
-0.9984727501869202,
-0.15975968539714813,
-0.4452354311943054,
-0.5349932312965393,
0.6262986660003662,
0.2684158682823181,
-0.27358758449554443,
-0.3548608720302582,
-0.21375052630901337,
0.0643492192029953,
0.07964612543582916,
-0.2176814079284668,
0.5867109894752502,
-0.20614483952522278,
-0.48531678318977356,
0.7131670117378235,
0.45950350165367126,
0.2739488482475281,
-0.8168572783470154,
-0.03652695193886757,
-0.2499290108680725,
-0.032989807426929474,
0.11494322866201401,
-0.46022942662239075,
0.3476818799972534,
0.24603590369224548,
-0.14462098479270935,
-0.0905442088842392,
0.4324248731136322,
-0.6191361546516418,
-0.4509393572807312,
0.08072174340486526,
0.9004794955253601,
0.0958285927772522,
-0.2691914141178131,
-0.2476636916399002,
-0.0004534736508503556,
0.18638913333415985,
0.17848257720470428,
0.28961461782455444,
0.5463939905166626,
-0.1518835425376892,
0.4669693112373352,
0.3037475049495697,
0.24710498750209808,
-0.03975336626172066,
0.18043002486228943,
0.6311749219894409,
-0.9102553129196167,
-0.4225122928619385,
-1.0486823320388794,
0.3851081430912018,
0.2579316794872284,
-0.14358067512512207,
0.8259329199790955,
0.6619167327880859,
0.8636501431465149,
0.06594540178775787,
1.1386781930923462,
0.0841200053691864,
0.5831892490386963,
-0.3573782742023468,
0.7200564742088318,
-0.46591147780418396,
0.02730332687497139,
-0.30932626128196716,
-0.40876370668411255,
-0.2498902976512909,
0.374867707490921,
0.06831091642379761,
0.16145296394824982,
0.4471594989299774,
0.9343242645263672,
0.27534759044647217,
0.1640796959400177,
0.7928122878074646,
0.2806338667869568,
0.18877962231636047,
0.3856319785118103,
0.8356574177742004,
-0.4509293735027313,
0.5777861475944519,
-0.22932551801204681,
0.04742051288485527,
-0.033922504633665085,
-0.7367956638336182,
-0.517630398273468,
-0.5479020476341248,
-0.29093921184539795,
-0.26570042967796326,
0.5220789909362793,
1.204596996307373,
0.7854306697845459,
-1.0696488618850708,
-0.7442134618759155,
0.1320422887802124,
-0.000835301005281508,
-0.2115967720746994,
-0.11815454810857773,
0.25162917375564575,
-0.11528075486421585,
-0.8850427865982056,
0.5151082873344421,
0.5253796577453613,
0.1966799944639206,
0.001391520258039236,
-0.06247486546635628,
-0.11530973017215729,
0.3702159821987152,
0.6502059698104858,
0.34348633885383606,
-0.7523654699325562,
-0.42318397760391235,
-0.14767791330814362,
0.11233356595039368,
0.33205753564834595,
0.6877005100250244,
-0.965241551399231,
0.5255391001701355,
-0.09098290652036667,
0.5556572079658508,
0.22059974074363708,
-0.14398986101150513,
0.5061293244361877,
-1.074429988861084,
0.3313744366168976,
0.31760841608047485,
0.11547697335481644,
0.4039076268672943,
0.20250211656093597,
0.20102539658546448,
0.2279636263847351,
-0.2768894135951996,
-0.7293995022773743,
0.39590945839881897,
-0.7452127933502197,
-0.15914005041122437,
1.071574330329895,
-0.10465505719184875,
0.20304593443870544,
-0.47860297560691833,
-0.39905112981796265,
0.522341787815094,
-0.6522780060768127,
0.95264732837677,
0.6244953274726868,
-0.04178239032626152,
-0.10138007998466492,
-0.2801729142665863,
0.27916646003723145,
0.7891508340835571,
-0.6414508819580078,
-0.0013223268324509263,
0.7032589316368103,
0.10997533053159714,
-0.005677474662661552,
0.7070091962814331,
0.27859094738960266,
0.3650125563144684,
-0.05251696705818176,
0.11771877855062485,
-0.07657122611999512,
-0.48268479108810425,
-0.48954537510871887,
0.24319373071193695,
0.3985239863395691,
-0.4644855558872223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16748v1 | OCALM: Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models | 2024-06-24T15:57:48 | 2024-06-24T15:57:48 | Timo Kaufmann, Jannis Blüml, Antonia Wüst, Quentin Delfosse, Kristian Kersting, Eyke Hüllermeier | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Properly defining a reward signal to efficiently train a reinforcement
learning (RL) agent is a challenging task. Designing balanced objective
functions from which a desired behavior can emerge requires expert knowledge,
especially for complex environments. Learning rewards from human feedback or
using large language models (LLMs) to directly provide rewards are promising
alternatives, allowing non-experts to specify goals for the agent. However,
black-box reward models make it difficult to debug the reward. In this work, we
propose Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models (OCALM) to derive
inherently interpretable reward functions for RL agents from natural language
task descriptions. OCALM uses the extensive world-knowledge of LLMs while
leveraging the object-centric nature common to many environments to derive
reward functions focused on relational concepts, providing RL agents with the
ability to derive policies from task descriptions. | [
-0.2770780920982361,
-0.8238788843154907,
0.4797637462615967,
0.09283079206943512,
0.1774147003889084,
0.029647309333086014,
-0.42764514684677124,
-0.6137456893920898,
-0.16117699444293976,
0.5053393840789795,
-0.5768686532974243,
-0.25500595569610596,
-0.5665152072906494,
-0.04271874576807022,
0.23381192982196808,
0.9813429117202759,
-0.23340241611003876,
-0.05648253113031387,
-0.5136793255805969,
-0.12923797965049744,
-0.5739237666130066,
-0.4138212203979492,
-0.7812398672103882,
-0.8381821513175964,
0.7263097763061523,
0.5377893447875977,
0.4803296625614166,
0.46615126729011536,
0.3350335657596588,
0.28880444169044495,
0.21953295171260834,
0.16014952957630157,
-0.4811311364173889,
0.015560973435640335,
-0.736547589302063,
-0.39003825187683105,
-0.6548478603363037,
0.06844749301671982,
0.20115779340267181,
0.4261731505393982,
-0.2809082567691803,
0.1478336602449417,
-0.11123312264680862,
0.4819943606853485,
-0.8849912881851196,
1.0204241275787354,
-0.48643797636032104,
0.3390929400920868,
0.4830324649810791,
-0.2299869954586029,
-0.6023087501525879,
-0.19862687587738037,
0.2524825632572174,
-0.5700297951698303,
-0.2908951938152313,
-0.01026998832821846,
0.7473828792572021,
0.3017076849937439,
-0.097557432949543,
-0.45906513929367065,
-0.6380249857902527,
1.1165595054626465,
-0.38240817189216614,
0.023805508390069008,
0.36387160420417786,
0.6137372255325317,
0.028535179793834686,
-0.4282847046852112,
-0.3908001482486725,
-0.7835031747817993,
-0.22333842515945435,
0.13387325406074524,
0.29295721650123596,
-0.053334351629018784,
0.10987501591444016,
0.2968631684780121,
-0.24489223957061768,
0.2208649069070816,
-0.06444524228572845,
-0.1462765485048294,
0.9469403624534607,
0.5112099647521973,
0.24749407172203064,
-0.014939145185053349,
-0.745948076248169,
-0.45334360003471375,
-0.4807121753692627,
0.5961264967918396,
0.25530630350112915,
0.5949200987815857,
-0.049649711698293686,
0.6474456787109375,
-0.32783934473991394,
0.7879198789596558,
-0.22854459285736084,
-0.3199023902416229,
-0.019096538424491882,
-0.08584384620189667,
-0.15408071875572205,
0.2318354994058609,
0.7503331303596497,
0.4374847710132599,
0.36878103017807007,
-0.41153576970100403,
-0.5295458436012268,
0.13770049810409546,
0.6890888214111328,
-0.9789674282073975,
0.16336962580680847,
0.361348032951355,
-0.25094741582870483,
-0.5386056303977966,
0.202140212059021,
-0.7624083757400513,
-0.5266038775444031,
-0.5176447629928589,
0.5650124549865723,
-0.19199416041374207,
-0.4467408061027527,
0.5060015916824341,
-0.045827388763427734,
0.373138427734375,
0.3395724594593048,
-0.765163779258728,
0.4751288890838623,
0.6704853773117065,
0.25627174973487854,
-0.42851558327674866,
-0.5528770685195923,
-0.8061425685882568,
-0.18241484463214874,
-0.0652402713894844,
0.7894673943519592,
-0.4751245081424713,
-0.40707024931907654,
0.2125450074672699,
0.11530398577451706,
-0.27162888646125793,
-0.549618661403656,
0.278778612613678,
-0.5381022691726685,
-0.07394284009933472,
-0.05652268975973129,
-0.41096031665802,
-0.39199593663215637,
0.8429720401763916,
-0.3923812806606293,
0.9801233410835266,
0.4494435489177704,
-0.29961565136909485,
0.2637014091014862,
-1.019500732421875,
-0.3963767886161804,
0.06684659421443939,
-0.22108067572116852,
-0.32730725407600403,
-0.050442494451999664,
0.12245424836874008,
0.48324888944625854,
-0.3203023672103882,
0.22512035071849823,
-0.3515048027038574,
-0.14230644702911377,
0.5961182713508606,
-0.04435824975371361,
0.21855804324150085,
0.1317257285118103,
-0.5437085032463074,
0.26789095997810364,
-0.42433297634124756,
0.21478073298931122,
0.3960510194301605,
-0.2398701161146164,
-0.1361927092075348,
0.29753178358078003,
-0.044613905251026154,
0.1139330193400383,
0.5415664911270142,
-0.6385328769683838,
0.2788796126842499,
-0.2895616590976715,
0.2987592816352844,
0.5074476003646851,
-0.09465152025222778,
0.4465000331401825,
-0.34184160828590393,
0.7978018522262573,
-0.1939495950937271,
0.3067379891872406,
-0.0703558698296547,
-0.09787816554307938,
-0.4704352617263794,
-0.24562519788742065,
-0.032649531960487366,
0.6183244585990906,
-0.5290364623069763,
0.372097373008728,
-0.13295553624629974,
-0.48935580253601074,
-0.3089058995246887,
-0.022986462339758873,
0.5273205637931824,
0.5088361501693726,
0.3823142349720001,
-0.40729570388793945,
-0.05915595218539238,
-0.7218528985977173,
-0.16680970788002014,
-0.34493163228034973,
0.2923794984817505,
0.5947232246398926,
0.521456241607666,
-0.12791620194911957,
1.0486559867858887,
-0.7212876677513123,
-0.6754277348518372,
-0.5438144207000732,
0.1477179229259491,
-0.12325132638216019,
0.22310706973075867,
0.3005291521549225,
-0.7344350814819336,
-0.3614409267902374,
0.3443354070186615,
-0.8702560663223267,
0.01997075043618679,
0.03978322446346283,
0.04774915799498558,
-0.04853788763284683,
0.554164707660675,
-0.3478196859359741,
0.3922848701477051,
-0.07410089671611786,
-0.4250519573688507,
0.5808832049369812,
-0.2929757833480835,
0.11341438442468643,
-0.3726808726787567,
0.11254772543907166,
-0.1332857608795166,
-0.4887731969356537,
-0.2214229255914688,
0.4328242242336273,
0.004145009443163872,
0.06351163983345032,
-0.8213865756988525,
1.053929328918457,
-0.24397803843021393,
-0.2018931806087494,
-0.5662338733673096,
0.3153720498085022,
-0.016985664144158363,
0.8403324484825134,
0.44450435042381287,
0.3655184209346771,
0.5442404747009277,
-0.6497138738632202,
0.37561869621276855,
0.08553947508335114,
-0.048239342868328094,
0.9483522176742554,
-0.6973578929901123,
0.0351053886115551,
-0.16696420311927795,
-0.12872937321662903,
-0.5955837965011597,
-0.0289753507822752,
0.20442640781402588,
-0.3742823004722595,
0.06629724055528641,
0.019857531413435936,
-0.23828351497650146,
-0.16705898940563202,
-0.2079036384820938,
0.42081499099731445,
0.21183058619499207,
-0.5338300466537476,
0.7436357140541077,
0.4791746437549591,
-0.06853106617927551,
-0.6898618340492249,
-0.32584986090660095,
-0.47344550490379333,
-0.12122824788093567,
-0.1383618861436844,
0.14866076409816742,
0.003303815145045519,
-0.21679948270320892,
0.19197480380535126,
-0.013949248939752579,
-0.009509013965725899,
0.4220833480358124,
0.4308760464191437,
0.47651633620262146,
-0.10586224496364594,
0.20653969049453735,
-0.4423268735408783,
-0.11820397526025772,
0.44242358207702637,
-0.18112888932228088,
0.5187877416610718,
-0.43397223949432373,
-0.4607952833175659,
0.03701993077993393,
0.06479933857917786,
0.36453351378440857,
-0.5524757504463196,
0.5063896775245667,
0.7251118421554565,
-0.18769924342632294,
-0.5415905714035034,
-0.21622158586978912,
-0.29000917077064514,
-0.380807489156723,
0.7126722931861877,
-0.45638933777809143,
-0.7168158888816833,
0.26102566719055176,
0.05167645961046219,
0.20265093445777893,
0.2697399854660034,
0.6907288432121277,
0.5025780200958252,
1.0253912210464478,
0.40583503246307373,
-0.06831645220518112,
0.45005038380622864,
-0.31719550490379333,
-0.09847346693277359,
-0.725001871585846,
-0.6620773673057556,
-0.47561216354370117,
-0.13893598318099976,
0.028163719922304153,
-0.43348196148872375,
0.06128162518143654,
-0.0529874786734581,
-0.32027482986450195,
0.2636012136936188,
-0.5713728666305542,
0.5104451179504395,
0.17660552263259888,
0.12450376152992249,
0.19430875778198242,
-0.06954247504472733,
0.026047781109809875,
0.31275832653045654,
-0.30143728852272034,
-0.5656241774559021,
1.0148794651031494,
0.5095704197883606,
1.0673613548278809,
-0.15923680365085602,
0.5378305315971375,
0.42155295610427856,
0.6045102477073669,
-1.2894001007080078,
0.5203751921653748,
0.24108931422233582,
-0.3006153404712677,
-0.46780499815940857,
-0.4417990446090698,
-1.0808298587799072,
0.42581790685653687,
0.026471078395843506,
-0.9244896173477173,
-0.1466975063085556,
-0.010002678260207176,
-0.24501682817935944,
0.02961886301636696,
-0.556134819984436,
1.299157738685608,
-0.5021920204162598,
-0.453054279088974,
-0.23129422962665558,
-0.27249717712402344,
0.23822183907032013,
0.3053787648677826,
0.2943955361843109,
-0.34525275230407715,
-0.06396270543336868,
0.6696970462799072,
-0.42391109466552734,
0.7554820775985718,
-0.45323610305786133,
-0.07096105068922043,
0.5246651768684387,
0.37156620621681213,
0.4989320933818817,
0.30763521790504456,
-0.10738510638475418,
-0.4305332899093628,
0.10887177288532257,
-0.4574965238571167,
-0.7847992777824402,
0.6037116050720215,
-0.8114474415779114,
-0.4451141357421875,
-0.4271191954612732,
-0.8431329131126404,
-0.38065335154533386,
0.056643906980752945,
-0.39357516169548035,
0.39296355843544006,
-0.3356083631515503,
-0.2053322046995163,
0.48219865560531616,
-0.22201628983020782,
0.277444064617157,
0.8929027318954468,
-0.6359288692474365,
-0.02874334156513214,
1.1747360229492188,
-0.5111402273178101,
0.45105433464050293,
0.4560093879699707,
0.38354524970054626,
-0.6292434930801392,
-0.20089492201805115,
-0.4512857496738434,
0.10156243294477463,
-0.6330369710922241,
-0.036973822861909866,
-0.33185216784477234,
-0.11740976572036743,
-0.041987888514995575,
-0.09142199158668518,
-0.6015087962150574,
-0.010594462975859642,
-0.021800769492983818,
-0.21498499810695648,
0.24104447662830353,
0.9863768815994263,
0.26426517963409424,
0.11782469600439072,
-0.5354981422424316,
0.17156386375427246,
0.5775787234306335,
0.18998289108276367,
0.20504236221313477,
-0.29648131132125854,
-0.30510005354881287,
0.0914163589477539,
-0.45481202006340027,
-0.5389112234115601,
0.500232994556427,
-0.08182220906019211,
0.7878888845443726,
0.18356682360172272,
0.24733637273311615,
0.35066404938697815,
-0.22491247951984406,
0.6897817254066467,
0.24019688367843628,
-0.7402399778366089,
0.3572775721549988,
-0.03852975741028786,
0.10846710205078125,
0.40096262097358704,
0.21917001903057098,
-0.4307345449924469,
-0.3855476677417755,
-0.46501368284225464,
-0.6911018490791321,
1.1009169816970825,
-0.2468164563179016,
-0.07588326185941696,
-0.05847354233264923,
0.1938590407371521,
0.18410219252109528,
0.27621451020240784,
-1.033647894859314,
-0.042013052850961685,
-0.30455613136291504,
-0.33584412932395935,
-0.23967766761779785,
0.11079572141170502,
-0.20411808788776398,
0.22723926603794098,
0.46888095140457153,
-0.44157278537750244,
0.3709214925765991,
0.41674402356147766,
-0.5076473951339722,
-0.1781407743692398,
0.4308777153491974,
0.6329052448272705,
0.6114892959594727,
-0.4006982147693634,
0.3190712034702301,
0.038906194269657135,
-0.03025466948747635,
0.3248801529407501,
-0.005962682887911797,
0.296722948551178,
-0.5403666496276855,
0.29309046268463135,
1.0049264430999756,
0.2843889594078064,
-1.2921534776687622,
0.7043128609657288,
-0.12528172135353088,
-0.13903437554836273,
-0.37157705426216125,
0.29835250973701477,
0.1384294182062149,
0.274947851896286,
0.1296720951795578,
-0.31803539395332336,
-0.072993703186512,
-0.8413721919059753,
0.20791159570217133,
0.5157216191291809,
-1.0998376607894897,
-0.276762455701828,
0.45435839891433716,
-0.15787546336650848,
-0.42488524317741394,
0.3968064486980438,
-0.5705980658531189,
-0.6131635308265686,
0.9299657940864563,
0.3253970146179199,
0.820090115070343,
-0.12420573830604553,
0.5497355461120605,
0.35622304677963257,
0.07586663961410522,
-0.15234994888305664,
0.17532996833324432,
-0.032925523817539215,
-0.7095781564712524,
-0.2619982063770294,
-0.6788408160209656,
-0.5398976802825928,
0.02084958367049694,
-0.9510166645050049,
0.10757220536470413,
-0.272073358297348,
0.054935190826654434,
-0.09013141691684723,
-0.1384931057691574,
-0.7360357046127319,
0.23061707615852356,
0.07949782907962799,
0.7034845352172852,
-0.7207689881324768,
0.5884320735931396,
1.0416829586029053,
-0.7161332964897156,
-1.0477511882781982,
-0.5082998871803284,
-0.4125024378299713,
-1.1156206130981445,
1.1787322759628296,
0.1285218447446823,
-0.07287724316120148,
-0.28841444849967957,
-0.14653246104717255,
-0.3113592267036438,
1.00276780128479,
0.17807450890541077,
-0.0378437377512455,
-0.07557491213083267,
0.5310513973236084,
0.5952101349830627,
-0.8344936370849609,
0.8166804909706116,
0.35332226753234863,
0.6478002667427063,
-0.026126375421881676,
-0.7607391476631165,
0.12776552140712738,
-0.0049307201988995075,
-0.13191990554332733,
0.1816132813692093,
-0.3618679344654083,
0.8639568090438843,
-0.19716320931911469,
0.13560715317726135,
-0.1266682893037796,
0.45645618438720703,
0.375823438167572,
0.32515066862106323,
0.8107466697692871,
0.3158850371837616,
0.23417600989341736,
0.10831841826438904,
1.3028271198272705,
-0.07421884685754776,
0.6638292670249939,
1.0882779359817505,
-0.3419983983039856,
1.0052069425582886,
0.5203863382339478,
-0.17268332839012146,
0.5367854237556458,
0.5298543572425842,
0.15715771913528442,
0.37858501076698303,
0.48474177718162537,
0.07856132835149765,
-0.550957441329956,
-0.4059410095214844,
-0.0687611848115921,
0.40443986654281616,
0.3119920790195465,
-0.13190793991088867,
-0.5501903295516968,
0.17123965919017792,
-0.20871134102344513,
0.3798398971557617,
-0.6078758239746094,
0.7483433485031128,
0.13447195291519165,
-1.1692992448806763,
0.4999707341194153,
0.08189540356397629,
0.36050310730934143,
-0.575704038143158,
-0.20250749588012695,
0.0018228675471618772,
0.5672627091407776,
-0.14498043060302734,
-0.8425357937812805,
0.12691742181777954,
-0.25799885392189026,
0.013766905292868614,
-0.24627453088760376,
0.5331146717071533,
-0.6603867411613464,
-0.1959395706653595,
0.6550741791725159,
0.4564439356327057,
0.04949912056326866,
-0.3106592297554016,
-0.9419702887535095,
-0.08972670882940292,
-0.23049765825271606,
-0.2616339325904846,
0.6079697608947754,
0.14772437512874603,
-0.1049681082367897,
0.8342469930648804,
0.2755095660686493,
0.08976613730192184,
-0.1389673501253128,
-0.19606724381446838,
0.4725843071937561,
-0.5991141200065613,
-0.5765707492828369,
-0.7405291199684143,
0.461700439453125,
0.14094769954681396,
0.07797490805387497,
0.39905259013175964,
0.4441990554332733,
0.8109049797058105,
-0.46682846546173096,
0.4993574321269989,
-0.16728009283542633,
0.4428103268146515,
-0.5039781928062439,
0.40605491399765015,
-0.894701361656189,
0.195586696267128,
0.03715506196022034,
-0.6847538352012634,
0.23095154762268066,
0.5831369757652283,
-0.5107385516166687,
-0.019441576674580574,
0.8168890476226807,
0.8723329901695251,
-0.003299246309325099,
-0.1919306367635727,
0.44121935963630676,
-0.17032396793365479,
0.44154831767082214,
0.8517680764198303,
1.2808390855789185,
-0.13691987097263336,
0.5818314552307129,
-0.3124951124191284,
-0.05206645280122757,
-0.4361032545566559,
-0.7733607888221741,
-1.038943886756897,
-0.2792893946170807,
-0.6342871189117432,
-0.11680782586336136,
-0.14100486040115356,
1.0196335315704346,
0.8005165457725525,
-0.7410855889320374,
-0.7129973769187927,
-0.10564478486776352,
0.4426700472831726,
-0.6570814251899719,
-0.32903507351875305,
0.3532916307449341,
-0.7532632350921631,
-0.884707510471344,
0.38842979073524475,
0.3035085201263428,
-0.4725607633590698,
-0.5237675905227661,
-0.5965169072151184,
0.11238910257816315,
0.055372804403305054,
0.6999853253364563,
0.4826888144016266,
-0.7915889620780945,
-0.4386260211467743,
0.03332575410604477,
-0.3493548333644867,
0.018734443932771683,
0.8436885476112366,
-0.8133882880210876,
0.5454964637756348,
0.3271006643772125,
0.7573002576828003,
0.35421109199523926,
-0.021315937861800194,
0.6109611392021179,
-0.44265851378440857,
0.21758081018924713,
0.2604120373725891,
0.2756677567958832,
0.1579292267560959,
-0.29432031512260437,
0.518826425075531,
-0.029400072991847992,
-0.4803396165370941,
-0.9697741866111755,
0.34910455346107483,
-1.2804778814315796,
-0.26102033257484436,
1.1250360012054443,
-0.6316890716552734,
-0.6649383306503296,
0.03553815558552742,
-0.4277728796005249,
-0.08214303106069565,
-0.4534648358821869,
0.7060988545417786,
0.3431605398654938,
0.053411565721035004,
-0.05610252171754837,
-0.43933820724487305,
0.549302339553833,
0.5323674082756042,
-1.1519945859909058,
0.08238223940134048,
0.07944557070732117,
0.2539912164211273,
0.17599231004714966,
0.3536562919616699,
-0.2772875428199768,
0.42807361483573914,
-0.2861984372138977,
0.46881693601608276,
-0.6331961154937744,
-0.17890167236328125,
-0.12172901630401611,
0.4734656512737274,
0.6077665090560913,
-0.3316862881183624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16747v1 | Sparser is Faster and Less is More: Efficient Sparse Attention for Long-Range Transformers | 2024-06-24T15:55:59 | 2024-06-24T15:55:59 | Chao Lou, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Accommodating long sequences efficiently in autoregressive Transformers,
especially within an extended context window, poses significant challenges due
to the quadratic computational complexity and substantial KV memory
requirements inherent in self-attention mechanisms. In this work, we introduce
SPARSEK Attention, a novel sparse attention mechanism designed to overcome
these computational and memory obstacles while maintaining performance. Our
approach integrates a scoring network and a differentiable top-k mask operator,
SPARSEK, to select a constant number of KV pairs for each query, thereby
enabling gradient-based optimization. As a result, SPARSEK Attention offers
linear time complexity and constant memory footprint during generation.
Experimental results reveal that SPARSEK Attention outperforms previous sparse
attention methods and provides significant speed improvements during both
training and inference, particularly in language modeling and downstream tasks.
Furthermore, our method can be seamlessly integrated into pre-trained Large
Language Models (LLMs) with minimal fine-tuning, offering a practical solution
for effectively managing long-range dependencies in diverse applications. | [
-0.6320147514343262,
-0.5622351765632629,
0.2775728106498718,
0.8088314533233643,
-0.295321524143219,
-0.117514967918396,
-0.48577219247817993,
-0.315095454454422,
0.5512614846229553,
0.33929675817489624,
-1.0093392133712769,
-0.028596194460988045,
-0.6579197645187378,
0.013587997294962406,
-0.331386536359787,
0.9753071069717407,
0.14268028736114502,
-0.5162647366523743,
-0.07462283968925476,
-0.25297653675079346,
-0.5648265480995178,
-0.20301321148872375,
-0.6551746129989624,
-0.0037317981477826834,
0.9639595150947571,
0.15479212999343872,
0.6633037328720093,
0.8653353452682495,
0.3475497364997864,
0.38718530535697937,
0.05618949607014656,
-0.0517030730843544,
-1.0295801162719727,
0.3896951675415039,
0.0894007459282875,
-0.013742068782448769,
-0.3947945535182953,
-0.09993547201156616,
0.6679866909980774,
0.7573925256729126,
0.04978356137871742,
0.36957505345344543,
0.3762089014053345,
0.8498525619506836,
-0.9102935194969177,
0.22791866958141327,
-0.626336932182312,
0.08405108749866486,
0.03605687618255615,
-0.0992395356297493,
-0.32549548149108887,
-0.00361218792386353,
0.08763193339109421,
-0.8351542353630066,
0.4288410544395447,
-0.11716018617153168,
0.7433199882507324,
0.9985373616218567,
0.008582009933888912,
0.20442989468574524,
-0.603789210319519,
1.0372248888015747,
0.1462213695049286,
0.785978376865387,
0.45531535148620605,
0.3460543751716614,
0.033475276082754135,
-0.6075801849365234,
-0.12375108152627945,
-0.24936789274215698,
-0.18041028082370758,
0.33702725172042847,
-0.08972672373056412,
0.253317266702652,
0.4955590069293976,
0.1544640213251114,
-0.46473222970962524,
-0.08820748329162598,
-0.11813613772392273,
-0.2601262331008911,
0.2726856768131256,
0.18954050540924072,
-0.3171217143535614,
-0.16072270274162292,
-0.2637224793434143,
0.20598958432674408,
-0.41709670424461365,
-0.12392978370189667,
0.24260357022285461,
0.14750801026821136,
-0.09229835867881775,
0.2658805251121521,
-0.471065878868103,
0.6804945468902588,
0.5612446665763855,
0.211953803896904,
-0.20211632549762726,
-0.3411487638950348,
-0.10053928941488266,
-0.08861184120178223,
0.6492297053337097,
0.006794581189751625,
0.16543075442314148,
-0.44678691029548645,
-0.08981957286596298,
-0.11889534443616867,
0.5291667580604553,
-0.6767520904541016,
-0.33206290006637573,
-0.0016815843991935253,
-0.420136034488678,
-0.04884537681937218,
-0.5310178995132446,
-1.0787783861160278,
0.11859311908483505,
-0.3170120418071747,
0.3980025351047516,
0.16803650557994843,
0.028923435136675835,
-0.17075864970684052,
0.3129273056983948,
0.22929586470127106,
0.380480021238327,
-1.2859638929367065,
0.39960023760795593,
0.5670347809791565,
0.8291481137275696,
-0.25143295526504517,
-0.20105117559432983,
-0.9061110019683838,
0.1421961933374405,
-0.3869743049144745,
0.7458012104034424,
-0.26354697346687317,
-0.05634273588657379,
-0.24526427686214447,
0.05969209223985672,
-0.12132997810840607,
-0.4312953054904938,
0.2554987668991089,
-0.5803982615470886,
-0.20650553703308105,
0.0030575396958738565,
0.13574020564556122,
0.3477288484573364,
0.08977855741977692,
-0.8963616490364075,
1.562783122062683,
0.5809905529022217,
-0.5488395690917969,
0.360661119222641,
-0.43721213936805725,
-0.5454370379447937,
0.36746764183044434,
0.020347852259874344,
-0.4618961811065674,
0.05498232692480087,
0.28782397508621216,
0.5341479182243347,
-0.2097265124320984,
-0.04446276277303696,
-0.3337758481502533,
-0.4750217795372009,
-0.023437829688191414,
-0.35985997319221497,
0.2977537214756012,
0.1239008828997612,
-0.4399861991405487,
0.11347971856594086,
-0.7511050701141357,
-0.182414710521698,
0.1384541392326355,
-0.4153929650783539,
-0.30506667494773865,
-0.08812126517295837,
0.1544434130191803,
0.20457780361175537,
0.3110133707523346,
-0.5379508137702942,
0.16232334077358246,
-0.5881089568138123,
0.3987162709236145,
0.8930913209915161,
-0.2160360962152481,
0.654448390007019,
-0.0012759184464812279,
0.5746061205863953,
-0.47148895263671875,
0.304977685213089,
-0.26317232847213745,
-0.14390040934085846,
-1.0294170379638672,
-0.6967607140541077,
0.33496925234794617,
0.199647918343544,
-0.3075038194656372,
0.5190646648406982,
-0.4934978783130646,
0.07609108835458755,
-0.6397784352302551,
0.41247469186782837,
0.05115430802106857,
0.4596855044364929,
0.2608204782009125,
-0.22476008534431458,
-0.49852830171585083,
-0.9136267304420471,
-0.028967322781682014,
0.1448955088853836,
-0.16059885919094086,
0.6924915909767151,
0.10166046023368835,
-0.24225081503391266,
0.7198470830917358,
-0.730564534664154,
-0.3450024127960205,
-0.25761446356773376,
-0.17152506113052368,
0.14287421107292175,
0.31079721450805664,
0.24116389453411102,
-0.5429863929748535,
-0.8603335618972778,
-0.06750616431236267,
-0.16473233699798584,
-0.14193247258663177,
-0.3671911060810089,
-0.502414345741272,
0.15996535122394562,
0.6030137538909912,
-0.8702521324157715,
0.3172406256198883,
0.15162229537963867,
0.17125184834003448,
0.06255009770393372,
0.15364229679107666,
-0.05971356853842735,
-0.8509430885314941,
0.15427371859550476,
-0.06287495046854019,
-0.42615142464637756,
-0.3561153709888458,
-0.16724815964698792,
0.12414052337408066,
-0.3185899257659912,
-0.1740061193704605,
0.48770132660865784,
-0.32343289256095886,
-0.04737480357289314,
-0.19720257818698883,
-0.02703756093978882,
-0.04610509052872658,
1.0208706855773926,
-0.03761591762304306,
0.6162057518959045,
0.37550562620162964,
-0.4101322591304779,
0.5072392821311951,
0.11641905456781387,
-0.26167452335357666,
0.3144519329071045,
-0.46309414505958557,
0.2075657695531845,
-0.23892539739608765,
0.05843980610370636,
-1.4089136123657227,
-0.258604496717453,
0.2429404854774475,
-0.39586856961250305,
0.7213296890258789,
-0.3384947180747986,
-0.4162275791168213,
-0.4135681986808777,
-0.30114755034446716,
0.5855926275253296,
0.5774872303009033,
-0.6876307725906372,
0.7265858054161072,
0.07506748288869858,
-0.4377669394016266,
-0.9159754514694214,
-0.43735605478286743,
0.03435554355382919,
-0.12286026775836945,
-0.6029278039932251,
0.09045629948377609,
0.04192797839641571,
0.23879209160804749,
-0.0847756415605545,
-0.34198349714279175,
-0.07034273445606232,
0.21793603897094727,
0.12836602330207825,
0.14305967092514038,
-0.2909371852874756,
0.15809878706932068,
0.057309068739414215,
-0.5691695213317871,
-0.02297843061387539,
-0.3356459438800812,
0.4813273549079895,
0.36972686648368835,
-0.01806715503334999,
-0.299782395362854,
0.8310649991035461,
0.6383405327796936,
-0.23718573153018951,
0.4694737195968628,
0.5607187747955322,
-0.2689714729785919,
-0.5712210536003113,
-0.781591534614563,
-0.3570561110973358,
-0.5408743023872375,
0.855650007724762,
-0.23395226895809174,
-1.1048988103866577,
0.33844301104545593,
-0.045656900852918625,
-0.142399400472641,
0.43029627203941345,
0.7620677947998047,
-0.08585206419229507,
1.100104808807373,
0.7099685072898865,
-0.5144888162612915,
0.4807868003845215,
-0.11047127842903137,
0.4555099308490753,
-0.7660245895385742,
0.006703319028019905,
-0.3575182557106018,
-0.3973000645637512,
-0.3886125385761261,
-0.3460797965526581,
0.2746698558330536,
-0.12043716758489609,
-0.08971568197011948,
0.3665657639503479,
-0.6930652260780334,
0.5847841501235962,
0.1946677714586258,
-0.10466285794973373,
-0.15072853863239288,
0.1584104746580124,
0.1475314497947693,
-0.16370314359664917,
-0.8412485718727112,
0.3174304664134979,
0.850908637046814,
0.47324812412261963,
0.9816635251045227,
-0.24871474504470825,
0.4174196422100067,
0.20679394900798798,
0.4068288207054138,
-0.9455626606941223,
0.5056332349777222,
-0.15462402999401093,
-0.34748324751853943,
-0.4466235041618347,
-0.422853946685791,
-0.9913398623466492,
0.047309476882219315,
0.30200180411338806,
-0.7182528972625732,
0.038597654551267624,
0.2784005105495453,
-0.702376663684845,
-0.31829968094825745,
-0.6588009595870972,
0.9705062508583069,
0.08269115537405014,
-0.7087352275848389,
-0.3573092520236969,
-0.7347968220710754,
0.1594047099351883,
-0.29076167941093445,
-0.21843194961547852,
-0.16508983075618744,
-0.24003328382968903,
0.41610538959503174,
-0.07382138073444366,
0.8012672662734985,
0.054608434438705444,
-0.04467111453413963,
0.1519811600446701,
0.08975894004106522,
0.6392950415611267,
0.09745325893163681,
0.42907652258872986,
0.04765497148036957,
-0.5488121509552002,
-0.4230792224407196,
-0.6597040295600891,
1.0629606246948242,
-0.5122950077056885,
-0.5210419297218323,
-0.14614182710647583,
-0.7787511944770813,
-0.18883922696113586,
-0.03835156187415123,
0.12392935901880264,
0.24144650995731354,
0.15672186017036438,
0.26447412371635437,
0.8795831799507141,
-0.1398414671421051,
0.4476546347141266,
0.29133445024490356,
0.436649352312088,
-0.37029585242271423,
0.9562107920646667,
0.2429230660200119,
0.30521655082702637,
0.6011679768562317,
-0.06510622799396515,
-0.4103156328201294,
-0.19785168766975403,
-0.43103399872779846,
0.28263482451438904,
-0.6423602104187012,
-0.4013896584510803,
-1.073348879814148,
-0.3334389925003052,
-0.3925136625766754,
-0.2544425129890442,
-0.5867281556129456,
-0.4544166922569275,
-0.1196226105093956,
0.11558469384908676,
0.363798052072525,
0.3354344666004181,
-0.03302205353975296,
0.2882401943206787,
-0.4659208059310913,
0.7872826457023621,
0.6377378702163696,
0.7863842248916626,
0.22974176704883575,
-0.4804907441139221,
-0.6663442254066467,
-0.533371090888977,
-0.19011569023132324,
-0.3113056719303131,
0.3287515640258789,
0.2913174033164978,
0.5298625230789185,
0.21686998009681702,
-0.2073976993560791,
0.7967644929885864,
-0.6543130278587341,
0.38863328099250793,
0.00019728936604224145,
-0.6677002310752869,
0.30298078060150146,
-0.43059247732162476,
0.5233280062675476,
0.3345085680484772,
0.38896995782852173,
-0.46281546354293823,
-0.40089696645736694,
-0.15545447170734406,
-1.0299208164215088,
0.9459114670753479,
0.2340508997440338,
0.23613642156124115,
-0.07725983113050461,
0.4370626211166382,
-0.04737219959497452,
-0.023350166156888008,
-0.6570033431053162,
-0.3753611147403717,
-0.37399402260780334,
-0.42402923107147217,
-0.11063608527183533,
-0.4498865306377411,
0.08993063122034073,
-0.2237439751625061,
0.47627678513526917,
-0.2617661654949188,
0.5364153385162354,
0.19083483517169952,
-0.1591397374868393,
-0.5800634622573853,
0.011945907026529312,
0.5666481256484985,
0.09495051950216293,
-0.13780315220355988,
0.014676838181912899,
0.2982386648654938,
-0.737214207649231,
0.035368748009204865,
0.43954145908355713,
0.010722782462835312,
-0.18771597743034363,
0.1768009066581726,
0.5257653594017029,
0.5627033710479736,
-0.37459027767181396,
0.3936607837677002,
-0.16988582909107208,
-0.15828967094421387,
-0.14781822264194489,
-0.1715969741344452,
0.17327159643173218,
0.10207173973321915,
0.35003960132598877,
0.02666032500565052,
0.23192761838436127,
0.2696598768234253,
0.4159129559993744,
0.39868587255477905,
-0.4402123689651489,
-0.11836265027523041,
0.8355065584182739,
0.1501084417104721,
-0.04377100244164467,
0.513692319393158,
0.20997285842895508,
-0.4292735755443573,
0.6322211027145386,
0.2285768687725067,
1.0798254013061523,
-0.466562420129776,
-0.2646768391132355,
0.553510308265686,
0.3040328323841095,
0.12704607844352722,
-0.1717211902141571,
-0.6821497082710266,
-0.11373335868120193,
-0.9791079163551331,
-0.7709051370620728,
0.24904796481132507,
0.37660902738571167,
-0.35150444507598877,
0.08167745918035507,
-0.6204331517219543,
0.013672559522092342,
0.15825752913951874,
-0.08876834064722061,
-0.5488896369934082,
-0.02734445221722126,
0.08469820767641068,
0.5180277228355408,
-0.48914822936058044,
0.7221320271492004,
0.07204942405223846,
0.04584566503763199,
-0.52339768409729,
-0.12618061900138855,
-0.4008027911186218,
-0.731039822101593,
0.9356590509414673,
0.418021023273468,
-0.30830103158950806,
0.14261825382709503,
-0.5059600472450256,
-1.237632393836975,
0.6193322539329529,
0.31043922901153564,
-0.6231107115745544,
0.18263618648052216,
0.24548085033893585,
0.37966570258140564,
-0.08737314492464066,
0.10510974377393723,
0.46893638372421265,
0.20472578704357147,
0.03498781472444534,
-0.7596145272254944,
-0.09490596503019333,
-0.1361016184091568,
-0.016442419961094856,
0.788880467414856,
-1.1050206422805786,
0.49875178933143616,
0.08604192733764648,
-0.15532276034355164,
0.3098244071006775,
0.8659899234771729,
-0.30352869629859924,
-0.12471668422222137,
0.5456550717353821,
0.7381473183631897,
0.05253017321228981,
0.017335793003439903,
0.7820562720298767,
-0.3274972438812256,
0.3535696268081665,
0.9110010266304016,
-0.15338560938835144,
0.32373207807540894,
0.545493483543396,
-0.14884327352046967,
0.07531315833330154,
0.5647513270378113,
-0.008532145991921425,
0.8540931940078735,
0.3387550413608551,
-0.47669127583503723,
-0.5089223384857178,
-0.13154315948486328,
-0.1204933449625969,
0.2361144721508026,
0.45393767952919006,
-0.22225305438041687,
-0.37153923511505127,
-0.024099061265587807,
-0.4157527685165405,
-0.06597396731376648,
-0.4857754409313202,
0.8216617703437805,
0.0425356887280941,
-0.8880831599235535,
0.8446651101112366,
-0.14868684113025665,
0.5275142788887024,
-0.7536444664001465,
-0.19239294528961182,
-0.21097245812416077,
0.34695279598236084,
0.10788948833942413,
-0.2512621283531189,
0.2626730799674988,
-0.222246453166008,
-0.4559513032436371,
-0.2668984532356262,
0.8434571623802185,
-0.5505338907241821,
-0.2931276559829712,
0.3636992573738098,
-0.10325481742620468,
-0.1472976952791214,
-0.13693444430828094,
-0.7175798416137695,
0.021508097648620605,
-0.16928166151046753,
-0.2541133165359497,
0.5971320867538452,
0.3996855318546295,
0.05494967848062515,
0.7620058059692383,
0.5577161312103271,
-0.23030012845993042,
0.4143460988998413,
0.04237058386206627,
1.010534644126892,
-0.5295661091804504,
-0.7494307160377502,
-0.5906738042831421,
0.18164575099945068,
0.11825451999902725,
-0.2047111988067627,
0.6355385780334473,
0.5317192077636719,
0.5572497248649597,
-0.1649615466594696,
0.4762432277202606,
0.3061966896057129,
0.5311024785041809,
-0.19839642941951752,
0.6472818851470947,
-0.42450395226478577,
-0.09323368966579437,
-0.13024231791496277,
-1.0536555051803589,
-0.2972857356071472,
0.6778856515884399,
-0.04800008609890938,
0.2372048944234848,
0.5628237128257751,
0.6956907510757446,
-0.344948947429657,
-0.46198374032974243,
0.5064288377761841,
0.27333810925483704,
-0.12013977020978928,
0.8894892334938049,
0.8541743755340576,
-0.3815995752811432,
0.7189044952392578,
-0.48935839533805847,
-0.0444311760365963,
-0.11509980261325836,
-0.6269048452377319,
-0.9960715174674988,
-0.3948338031768799,
-0.34416663646698,
-0.25953254103660583,
0.0024352394975721836,
0.7325540781021118,
0.8697910308837891,
-0.5685482621192932,
0.05174576863646507,
0.04688647761940956,
-0.05086539685726166,
-0.05004854127764702,
-0.2694804072380066,
0.5180975794792175,
-0.6945237517356873,
-0.6477590203285217,
0.2529680132865906,
0.6615597605705261,
-0.17225655913352966,
-0.40017399191856384,
-0.05163097381591797,
-0.03505827486515045,
-0.04766147583723068,
0.6732419729232788,
0.2877611517906189,
-0.5793787240982056,
-0.24958717823028564,
0.36745697259902954,
-0.16155660152435303,
0.22439047694206238,
0.8792245388031006,
-0.8924862742424011,
0.4509876072406769,
0.3982006907463074,
0.9486286044120789,
0.6333780288696289,
-0.03831327706575394,
0.29700323939323425,
-0.9636732935905457,
0.4639533460140228,
0.48768624663352966,
0.12519533932209015,
0.2330954521894455,
-0.8192694783210754,
0.32396337389945984,
0.30188220739364624,
-0.7075371742248535,
-0.6567761301994324,
0.13110758364200592,
-1.2647680044174194,
0.04357554391026497,
0.9902570843696594,
0.05866951867938042,
-0.43689411878585815,
-0.46616634726524353,
-0.07877790182828903,
0.05586417764425278,
-0.5469226241111755,
0.8278657793998718,
0.6866907477378845,
0.1682015210390091,
-0.40980595350265503,
-0.6017770171165466,
0.7520586848258972,
0.8381094932556152,
-0.390696257352829,
0.4877578616142273,
0.2499551922082901,
0.16629892587661743,
-0.01929558999836445,
0.5570021271705627,
0.07559540867805481,
0.5741087794303894,
-0.09672357887029648,
-0.17063270509243011,
0.2102435678243637,
-0.48074042797088623,
-0.4229831397533417,
0.21068653464317322,
-0.22638262808322906,
-0.10735679417848587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16746v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16746v2 | The Responsible Foundation Model Development Cheatsheet: A Review of Tools & Resources | 2024-06-24T15:55:49 | 2024-06-26T02:19:01 | Shayne Longpre, Stella Biderman, Alon Albalak, Hailey Schoelkopf, Daniel McDuff, Sayash Kapoor, Kevin Klyman, Kyle Lo, Gabriel Ilharco, Nay San, Maribeth Rauh, Aviya Skowron, Bertie Vidgen, Laura Weidinger, Arvind Narayanan, Victor Sanh, David Adelani, Percy Liang, Rishi Bommasani, Peter Henderson, Sasha Luccioni, Yacine Jernite, Luca Soldaini | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Foundation model development attracts a rapidly expanding body of
contributors, scientists, and applications. To help shape responsible
development practices, we introduce the Foundation Model Development
Cheatsheet: a growing collection of 250+ tools and resources spanning text,
vision, and speech modalities. We draw on a large body of prior work to survey
resources (e.g. software, documentation, frameworks, guides, and practical
tools) that support informed data selection, processing, and understanding,
precise and limitation-aware artifact documentation, efficient model training,
advance awareness of the environmental impact from training, careful model
evaluation of capabilities, risks, and claims, as well as responsible model
release, licensing and deployment practices. We hope this curated collection of
resources helps guide more responsible development. The process of curating
this list, enabled us to review the AI development ecosystem, revealing what
tools are critically missing, misused, or over-used in existing practices. We
find that (i) tools for data sourcing, model evaluation, and monitoring are
critically under-serving ethical and real-world needs, (ii) evaluations for
model safety, capabilities, and environmental impact all lack reproducibility
and transparency, (iii) text and particularly English-centric analyses continue
to dominate over multilingual and multi-modal analyses, and (iv) evaluation of
systems, rather than just models, is needed so that capabilities and impact are
assessed in context. | [
-0.2561676800251007,
-0.4291836619377136,
0.19728507101535797,
0.3604349195957184,
-0.057834457606077194,
-0.07770711928606033,
0.29364925622940063,
-0.4868105351924896,
-0.27197983860969543,
0.9553797245025635,
-0.6729839444160461,
-0.10119219869375229,
-0.4533243477344513,
-0.0718972235918045,
-0.5640223622322083,
1.1666697263717651,
-0.014488358981907368,
0.18727855384349823,
-0.5983350276947021,
0.07358723133802414,
-0.6557839512825012,
0.013027193956077099,
-0.32174304127693176,
-0.19539417326450348,
0.23545974493026733,
0.2950512766838074,
0.7324795126914978,
0.82282555103302,
0.8089733123779297,
0.26413199305534363,
-0.1514776200056076,
-0.18221813440322876,
-0.5942971706390381,
-0.1553085744380951,
-0.3340207636356354,
0.06383472681045532,
-0.748289942741394,
0.5475190877914429,
0.16088566184043884,
0.839879035949707,
-0.17831239104270935,
0.6345619559288025,
0.04211375117301941,
0.40351393818855286,
-0.8973378539085388,
0.4056813716888428,
-0.06866113096475601,
-0.10741010308265686,
-0.24257829785346985,
-0.01095683965831995,
-0.3406928479671478,
-0.11469605565071106,
0.09125210344791412,
-0.6368191838264465,
0.2696547508239746,
-0.3327900171279907,
0.3015952706336975,
0.5173598527908325,
-0.5527657866477966,
-0.41484737396240234,
-0.7738924026489258,
0.9154224991798401,
-0.48478010296821594,
0.6576792597770691,
0.602992057800293,
0.29649490118026733,
-0.20274695754051208,
-1.028350591659546,
-0.22293338179588318,
-0.3609975576400757,
0.11389469355344772,
0.012582074850797653,
-0.01851731725037098,
-0.00007559661025879905,
0.13641998171806335,
0.18100710213184357,
-0.23494817316532135,
-0.07207467406988144,
-0.8351606726646423,
-0.6280175447463989,
0.9749699234962463,
0.022576896473765373,
0.24832327663898468,
-0.33227574825286865,
-0.323670893907547,
-0.26139187812805176,
-0.869263768196106,
0.10821054130792618,
0.48207685351371765,
0.1672181934118271,
-0.24346789717674255,
0.6636333465576172,
0.16779404878616333,
0.7733966708183289,
-0.22214804589748383,
-0.09046906232833862,
-0.07519159466028214,
-0.7705402970314026,
-0.1755816638469696,
-0.038927625864744186,
0.2464715540409088,
0.33183661103248596,
0.08231942355632782,
-0.17341746389865875,
-0.36870768666267395,
0.12093693763017654,
0.6722807288169861,
-0.8570509552955627,
-0.4265994429588318,
0.32763513922691345,
-0.4564577043056488,
-0.3199065625667572,
0.026214633136987686,
-0.7719377279281616,
-0.6408220529556274,
-0.4684029519557953,
-0.020250853151082993,
0.019282767549157143,
-0.3463832437992096,
-0.057484421879053116,
-0.4156453013420105,
0.08390668034553528,
0.29401257634162903,
-0.5769982933998108,
0.28083178400993347,
0.6646155714988708,
0.42150092124938965,
0.0700262263417244,
-0.21266333758831024,
-0.5327896475791931,
0.19044648110866547,
-0.540327787399292,
0.47466957569122314,
-0.5221743583679199,
-0.8280392289161682,
-0.20083367824554443,
-0.02025231346487999,
0.42163485288619995,
-0.3551805913448334,
0.38643965125083923,
-0.19955196976661682,
-0.07938529551029205,
-0.37119603157043457,
-0.2997942268848419,
-0.2776457965373993,
0.13500523567199707,
-1.0486632585525513,
0.7676790356636047,
0.24652506411075592,
-0.4364696443080902,
0.5772166848182678,
-0.8142598867416382,
-0.4547590911388397,
0.0022301715798676014,
-0.11881276220083237,
-0.2770048975944519,
-0.1121176928281784,
0.011538410559296608,
0.47821223735809326,
-0.4939507246017456,
0.6447091698646545,
-0.2540927827358246,
-0.29776138067245483,
-0.23111343383789062,
-0.2858508825302124,
1.2809969186782837,
0.24307969212532043,
-0.5354506373405457,
0.25687292218208313,
-0.6965422630310059,
0.09223347902297974,
-0.14783412218093872,
-0.3169524371623993,
0.011661292985081673,
0.0828605443239212,
0.4990508556365967,
0.11279183626174927,
0.20552104711532593,
-0.24745433032512665,
-0.25529876351356506,
0.17495602369308472,
0.6405020356178284,
0.9238918423652649,
-0.031467486172914505,
0.478682279586792,
-0.16537559032440186,
0.8276761174201965,
-0.05041547864675522,
0.4915315806865692,
-0.32154381275177,
-0.3629792332649231,
-0.5315431952476501,
-0.16385136544704437,
0.10911022871732712,
0.3133443295955658,
0.010925480164587498,
0.28431451320648193,
-0.13034039735794067,
-0.8652700781822205,
-0.595026969909668,
0.2539934813976288,
0.5265695452690125,
0.7039324045181274,
0.33282285928726196,
-0.31780362129211426,
-0.4449193477630615,
-1.0108405351638794,
-0.09347929060459137,
-0.3385278880596161,
0.4447658360004425,
0.3785851299762726,
0.8500508069992065,
-0.4291248619556427,
1.0752050876617432,
-0.08553119748830795,
-0.24666261672973633,
-0.0363229438662529,
-0.028349289670586586,
-0.40930092334747314,
0.7881081700325012,
0.7716717720031738,
-1.3174370527267456,
0.1023387461900711,
-0.21623077988624573,
-0.5066268444061279,
0.060091350227594376,
-0.0184977687895298,
-0.11077091842889786,
-0.09862755239009857,
0.4951578676700592,
-0.6554582118988037,
0.3468605875968933,
0.5175099968910217,
-0.5677961707115173,
0.48749104142189026,
0.18734923005104065,
0.01104605570435524,
-0.853722095489502,
0.7367857098579407,
0.012999285012483597,
-0.14482487738132477,
-0.32712680101394653,
0.4932573139667511,
0.31812140345573425,
-0.320386677980423,
-0.3991047441959381,
0.822634220123291,
-0.5779173374176025,
-0.2779931426048279,
0.14628270268440247,
0.11089467257261276,
0.26519617438316345,
-0.2535417377948761,
-0.21579697728157043,
1.0630478858947754,
0.2810761332511902,
-0.6647427678108215,
0.46928954124450684,
0.45729902386665344,
-0.18408477306365967,
0.5489301681518555,
-0.7137466073036194,
0.0036911247298121452,
-0.15032656490802765,
0.4247789680957794,
-0.0433054082095623,
-0.40743234753608704,
0.22324024140834808,
-0.27812471985816956,
0.27370429039001465,
-0.0366254523396492,
-0.3999875783920288,
-0.265382319688797,
-0.10920881479978561,
0.1993129998445511,
0.26353293657302856,
-0.24261385202407837,
0.5504174828529358,
0.8594422340393066,
-0.010533129796385765,
-0.8584272861480713,
-0.9604505300521851,
-0.09332646429538727,
0.02568918466567993,
-0.5716818571090698,
0.32187843322753906,
-0.20580703020095825,
-0.5417627692222595,
0.3504824638366699,
-0.30949127674102783,
-0.45038336515426636,
0.449117511510849,
0.35995903611183167,
0.003212215146049857,
-0.02629839815199375,
0.006787119898945093,
-0.305418461561203,
-0.09982030838727951,
0.4858735501766205,
0.04757613316178322,
-0.014346889220178127,
-0.10839060693979263,
-0.4230363667011261,
-0.0031182344537228346,
0.43157869577407837,
0.7062824368476868,
-0.6749321222305298,
0.19188649952411652,
0.41179826855659485,
-0.6644479632377625,
-0.20715557038784027,
-0.34032610058784485,
-0.415942907333374,
-0.4037596881389618,
0.44458216428756714,
0.02744467183947563,
-0.6078961491584778,
0.48714712262153625,
0.15912757813930511,
0.27210938930511475,
0.4219595193862915,
0.21871833503246307,
0.22811131179332733,
0.9092363119125366,
1.2202205657958984,
-0.06417174637317657,
0.17822369933128357,
-0.5064482688903809,
0.4105304777622223,
-0.7324928045272827,
-0.5424209237098694,
-0.5223814249038696,
-0.06999561935663223,
-0.39321431517601013,
-0.33221757411956787,
-0.053187187761068344,
0.2931843101978302,
-0.27058571577072144,
0.25179508328437805,
-0.6206899285316467,
0.4508027136325836,
0.40937602519989014,
-0.02994505502283573,
0.1981145441532135,
-0.524340033531189,
0.30435797572135925,
-0.11180932819843292,
-0.557294487953186,
-0.7208247780799866,
1.0897976160049438,
0.24197883903980255,
0.6143420934677124,
0.05287518352270126,
0.5735934972763062,
0.47848665714263916,
0.6346726417541504,
-0.6401748061180115,
0.41299745440483093,
0.1731763780117035,
-1.207599401473999,
-0.14740604162216187,
-0.22716359794139862,
-0.5297818779945374,
-0.36531925201416016,
0.22573411464691162,
-0.3437963128089905,
0.30742591619491577,
0.19063952565193176,
-0.40676581859588623,
-0.06886280328035355,
-0.6108952760696411,
1.1951490640640259,
-0.10353266447782516,
-0.2860093414783478,
-0.4700681269168854,
-0.4367438852787018,
0.4749441146850586,
-0.20391757786273956,
0.1986507773399353,
0.09880391508340836,
0.07014574110507965,
0.6577545404434204,
-0.3613957166671753,
0.9004596471786499,
-0.17176680266857147,
0.020535700023174286,
0.7031922340393066,
0.01207697857171297,
0.3553237020969391,
0.15782512724399567,
-0.1801280677318573,
-0.16682353615760803,
0.054574061185121536,
-0.4470345973968506,
-0.18351919949054718,
0.7563140392303467,
-0.7059305310249329,
-0.5391325354576111,
-0.5258339047431946,
-0.5199745893478394,
-0.07621660083532333,
0.6235808730125427,
-0.025393923744559288,
0.2803724706172943,
-0.6526725888252258,
0.4138498604297638,
0.5703273415565491,
0.16123536229133606,
0.2895611524581909,
0.3878421187400818,
-0.022522933781147003,
-0.0591091588139534,
0.5735210180282593,
0.3019126355648041,
0.04228711873292923,
-0.2316998690366745,
-0.02763931080698967,
-0.039264049381017685,
-0.40395551919937134,
-0.3812701106071472,
-0.13518260419368744,
-0.8646575212478638,
-0.3800220489501953,
-0.45857587456703186,
-0.27980250120162964,
-0.5321135520935059,
-0.32267358899116516,
-0.5190112590789795,
-0.2715945839881897,
-0.38565728068351746,
-0.4903774857521057,
0.43852612376213074,
0.8205702304840088,
-0.21780721843242645,
0.08331655710935593,
-0.6725367903709412,
0.21909010410308838,
0.15157662332057953,
0.3221260607242584,
-0.1303258091211319,
0.2100033462047577,
-0.17800526320934296,
0.2217010259628296,
-0.39758434891700745,
-0.7489830255508423,
0.1207084134221077,
0.04864857345819473,
0.6839359998703003,
0.25843364000320435,
0.11946877837181091,
0.7119085192680359,
-0.16538478434085846,
0.8390184044837952,
-0.11649535596370697,
-0.9028184413909912,
0.5907458066940308,
-0.5274607539176941,
-0.0433456227183342,
0.5181899070739746,
0.31863272190093994,
-0.18931926786899567,
-0.0164998397231102,
-0.8199455142021179,
-0.7852096557617188,
0.7491937875747681,
0.2567104399204254,
0.2535172998905182,
0.14647802710533142,
0.22866128385066986,
0.025104936212301254,
0.3757009208202362,
-0.6576467752456665,
0.06660213321447372,
-0.3211519420146942,
0.02231462299823761,
-0.035852354019880295,
-0.07632361352443695,
-0.6530815362930298,
-0.016200704500079155,
0.8101145029067993,
-0.10991191118955612,
0.007318238727748394,
0.16898378729820251,
-0.18411675095558167,
-0.20703047513961792,
-0.049102336168289185,
0.3927319347858429,
1.069093942642212,
-0.1591157466173172,
-0.22187671065330505,
-0.3593163788318634,
-0.8020991683006287,
-0.06628219783306122,
0.5291610956192017,
-0.378797322511673,
-0.38398125767707825,
0.30334946513175964,
0.4492143988609314,
0.3761390745639801,
-0.8083601593971252,
0.5104203224182129,
0.2752488851547241,
0.2817037105560303,
-0.42033207416534424,
0.13720662891864777,
0.2663741707801819,
0.1700168251991272,
0.1184292733669281,
0.3848330080509186,
0.38460853695869446,
-0.48136478662490845,
0.38329699635505676,
0.32666468620300293,
-0.5596613883972168,
-0.12924493849277496,
0.6522734761238098,
0.6250980496406555,
-0.280840665102005,
0.8593953251838684,
-0.12848900258541107,
-0.15337899327278137,
1.1150870323181152,
0.4071711003780365,
0.7997249960899353,
-0.17108093202114105,
0.5187807679176331,
0.11958348006010056,
0.683834969997406,
-0.26101502776145935,
0.457738995552063,
-0.033816609531641006,
-0.41513678431510925,
-0.2959801256656647,
-0.37037116289138794,
-0.39081817865371704,
0.30365389585494995,
-0.679173469543457,
0.37672895193099976,
-0.6668806672096252,
-0.13857242465019226,
0.07007108628749847,
0.2021774798631668,
-0.8939927220344543,
0.4609192907810211,
-0.2880772352218628,
1.1448948383331299,
-0.6486741304397583,
0.3742882311344147,
0.7876940369606018,
-0.681049644947052,
-0.7867766618728638,
-0.2982778549194336,
0.3750438690185547,
-0.3901737928390503,
0.3448149561882019,
0.30340635776519775,
-0.25526025891304016,
0.14734263718128204,
-0.8452188372612,
-0.8892552256584167,
1.3099404573440552,
0.5228543877601624,
-0.23333817720413208,
0.08480564504861832,
-0.146205335855484,
0.35111141204833984,
-0.35889339447021484,
0.06808124482631683,
0.5344335436820984,
0.7348809242248535,
-0.4727343022823334,
-0.8287052512168884,
-0.0063334195874631405,
-0.44236645102500916,
-0.2324337363243103,
0.13987219333648682,
-0.5535555481910706,
0.712342381477356,
-0.42842012643814087,
-0.10139695554971695,
0.08251986652612686,
0.2849932909011841,
0.44640490412712097,
0.3551621437072754,
0.0987442210316658,
0.2717301547527313,
0.5885264873504639,
0.05380775034427643,
1.0694376230239868,
-0.45207732915878296,
0.14986392855644226,
0.7681929469108582,
-0.11597421765327454,
0.6340172290802002,
0.6626283526420593,
0.19112469255924225,
0.0007944730459712446,
0.7531256675720215,
-0.1594725400209427,
0.38410744071006775,
0.061833180487155914,
0.14133039116859436,
-0.2574695646762848,
-0.5525006055831909,
-0.39177054166793823,
0.4733343720436096,
0.30575886368751526,
-0.43162497878074646,
-0.2912513017654419,
-0.15176819264888763,
0.06463325023651123,
0.1032758355140686,
-0.2644162178039551,
0.15175679326057434,
0.22537031769752502,
-0.5687940716743469,
-0.1069512739777565,
0.17077645659446716,
-0.052318647503852844,
-0.5118083953857422,
-0.32234689593315125,
-0.14350415766239166,
0.21479634940624237,
-0.2550230920314789,
-0.8051369786262512,
0.4957953691482544,
0.10284904390573502,
-0.38792282342910767,
-0.6012179255485535,
0.6045738458633423,
0.09975141286849976,
-0.6193733215332031,
0.4479491412639618,
0.5801345109939575,
-0.12320718169212341,
0.14427348971366882,
-0.7497154474258423,
0.10876264423131943,
-0.211747407913208,
-0.40335431694984436,
-0.02974359318614006,
0.25153690576553345,
-0.4520195424556732,
0.916206419467926,
0.7738913297653198,
-0.013686208054423332,
-0.08255864679813385,
-0.1298329383134842,
0.8124452233314514,
-0.5773780345916748,
-0.49743354320526123,
-0.3878719210624695,
0.8554767370223999,
-0.08883652091026306,
-0.802360475063324,
0.5048497915267944,
0.37069952487945557,
1.00821852684021,
0.054363593459129333,
0.8286781907081604,
-0.3291280269622803,
0.009992174804210663,
-0.22369502484798431,
1.0256520509719849,
-0.33919376134872437,
0.0819573625922203,
-0.22180263698101044,
-1.0304906368255615,
-0.27998086810112,
0.7660014033317566,
0.09681516140699387,
0.37819206714630127,
0.130514457821846,
0.6231495141983032,
-0.18655866384506226,
0.09672389179468155,
-0.19528819620609283,
0.19706092774868011,
0.47895362973213196,
-0.12466688454151154,
0.3491653800010681,
-0.47926315665245056,
0.4882993996143341,
-0.5084200501441956,
-0.29910027980804443,
-0.15901601314544678,
-1.2318496704101562,
-0.5902155041694641,
-0.5860813856124878,
-0.4066130816936493,
-0.16366960108280182,
0.23449403047561646,
0.5764707922935486,
1.0326663255691528,
-0.7697672843933105,
-0.21335701644420624,
-0.44900381565093994,
0.002325512934476137,
-0.34304386377334595,
-0.23261146247386932,
0.045697394758462906,
0.15811887383460999,
-0.35188305377960205,
0.49966955184936523,
0.025656472891569138,
-0.03868592530488968,
-0.9312147498130798,
-0.1467035710811615,
-0.009700596332550049,
0.003338978858664632,
0.2891998291015625,
0.44537153840065,
-0.6028002500534058,
-0.1810922622680664,
0.2429417073726654,
-0.18002325296401978,
-0.48060494661331177,
0.6770334839820862,
-0.6361128091812134,
0.5766093730926514,
0.4373537003993988,
0.5474696159362793,
0.06622036546468735,
-0.3338943123817444,
1.009068250656128,
-0.3948374092578888,
0.2906765043735504,
0.706213653087616,
0.32941457629203796,
0.6126341223716736,
-0.5591720938682556,
0.8482128381729126,
-0.17527027428150177,
-0.6542759537696838,
-1.1328362226486206,
0.33574914932250977,
-0.6105534434318542,
-0.0824703723192215,
0.7102960348129272,
-0.15528163313865662,
-0.07207345962524414,
0.06886778026819229,
-0.1042296290397644,
0.15771903097629547,
-0.3030872344970703,
0.8163092136383057,
0.8472832441329956,
0.0610964410007,
-0.1266467422246933,
-0.691892147064209,
0.7065329551696777,
0.10889244079589844,
-0.9119933843612671,
0.18435291945934296,
0.9114764928817749,
0.11264551430940628,
0.4086061716079712,
0.5081794261932373,
-0.2608256936073303,
0.5788270235061646,
0.17509792745113373,
0.13514597713947296,
-0.11252999305725098,
-0.7168037295341492,
-0.17302711308002472,
-0.2656760811805725,
-0.04711933434009552,
0.29191288352012634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16743v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16743v1 | Adversarial Contrastive Decoding: Boosting Safety Alignment of Large Language Models via Opposite Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-24T15:51:30 | 2024-06-24T15:51:30 | Zhengyue Zhao, Xiaoyun Zhang, Kaidi Xu, Xing Hu, Rui Zhang, Zidong Du, Qi Guo, Yunji Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs), it has
become a significant concern to ensure their safety and prevent harmful
responses. While current safe-alignment methods based on instruction
fine-tuning and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) can
effectively reduce harmful responses from LLMs, they often require high-quality
datasets and heavy computational overhead during model training. Another way to
align language models is to modify the logit of tokens in model outputs without
heavy training. Recent studies have shown that contrastive decoding can enhance
the performance of language models by reducing the likelihood of confused
tokens. However, these methods require the manual selection of contrastive
models or instruction templates. To this end, we propose Adversarial
Contrastive Decoding (ACD), an optimization-based framework to generate two
opposite system prompts for prompt-based contrastive decoding. ACD only needs
to apply a lightweight prompt tuning on a rather small anchor dataset (< 3 min
for each model) without training the target model. Experiments conducted on
extensive models and benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed method achieves
much better safety performance than previous model training-free decoding
methods without sacrificing its original generation ability. | [
-0.31282520294189453,
-0.8159874677658081,
0.10589839518070221,
-0.13136185705661774,
-0.4710133969783783,
-0.19583933055400848,
-0.04861483350396156,
-0.2835598289966583,
-0.03488492965698242,
0.4386301636695862,
-0.6339605450630188,
-0.43052753806114197,
-0.4485244154930115,
0.056783512234687805,
-0.28163397312164307,
1.0041568279266357,
0.1329086571931839,
0.47541582584381104,
-0.05370604246854782,
-0.2586916387081146,
-0.4127994775772095,
-0.550944983959198,
-1.1457867622375488,
-0.18655088543891907,
0.4294539988040924,
0.2466956377029419,
0.9807397723197937,
1.138205647468567,
0.3161715865135193,
0.29825010895729065,
-0.16121503710746765,
0.18715092539787292,
-0.4354649782180786,
0.16733123362064362,
-0.1405065655708313,
-0.37545645236968994,
-0.20029938220977783,
-0.17015402019023895,
0.3973623514175415,
0.4887283742427826,
0.032437343150377274,
-0.3276074230670929,
0.2584529221057892,
0.5936289429664612,
-0.8047975897789001,
-0.07714440673589706,
-0.3667793273925781,
0.022427402436733246,
0.19200514256954193,
-0.49322509765625,
-0.4003331661224365,
-0.5373955965042114,
-0.05947493761777878,
-0.6512745022773743,
0.23027735948562622,
0.2701427936553955,
0.7737137675285339,
0.40956559777259827,
-0.4190153181552887,
-0.31275609135627747,
-0.23565255105495453,
0.6884312033653259,
-0.7714908719062805,
0.10787595808506012,
0.19203777611255646,
0.08610733598470688,
-0.2527325749397278,
-0.1600525826215744,
-0.504520833492279,
-0.04229312017560005,
-0.07612242549657822,
0.053152672946453094,
-0.22564324736595154,
0.41008883714675903,
0.11294275522232056,
0.088785320520401,
-0.7467909455299377,
0.5697691440582275,
0.09524744004011154,
-0.27597784996032715,
0.4834916591644287,
0.49272620677948,
0.3938656747341156,
0.176242858171463,
-0.39030757546424866,
-0.4907851219177246,
-1.0585917234420776,
0.11324886977672577,
0.694588840007782,
0.5601838231086731,
-0.2054928094148636,
0.3443261981010437,
-0.05337024852633476,
0.6241542100906372,
0.2798644006252289,
0.20304512977600098,
-0.03968274965882301,
-0.16823486983776093,
-0.08893981575965881,
0.28108587861061096,
0.8951233625411987,
0.6086286306381226,
0.042643070220947266,
-0.20205233991146088,
-0.38147836923599243,
0.4567643702030182,
0.21321526169776917,
-0.9147937297821045,
-0.38771942257881165,
0.13715435564517975,
-0.43728604912757874,
-0.7493579983711243,
-0.2434161901473999,
-0.8714436292648315,
-0.770369827747345,
-0.2692399024963379,
0.4466271996498108,
-0.4928171634674072,
0.0726737305521965,
-0.029504762962460518,
0.0075555481016635895,
0.1785983294248581,
0.18424533307552338,
-0.9938545227050781,
0.1560491919517517,
0.693755030632019,
0.6286958456039429,
-0.13789761066436768,
-0.2411624938249588,
-1.0757633447647095,
-0.14503398537635803,
-0.644152820110321,
0.5445489287376404,
-0.43717044591903687,
-0.5102933049201965,
0.09817413240671158,
0.024951282888650894,
0.025830529630184174,
-0.2975955605506897,
0.5800343751907349,
-0.8151313066482544,
0.2610093653202057,
-0.48776882886886597,
-0.40523502230644226,
-0.15857338905334473,
0.2829749584197998,
-0.5752233266830444,
0.4266400635242462,
-0.21174262464046478,
-0.9584499001502991,
0.0020876138005405664,
-0.33259621262550354,
-0.7266857028007507,
-0.17649008333683014,
-0.25143176317214966,
-0.5699262022972107,
0.01261345949023962,
0.659440279006958,
0.09461870044469833,
-0.41959962248802185,
0.07543320208787918,
-0.35451194643974304,
-0.5203094482421875,
0.13844475150108337,
-0.6527776122093201,
0.9617237448692322,
0.4620017409324646,
-0.4854523837566376,
0.4365755021572113,
-0.6147722005844116,
-0.09164953231811523,
0.2705191969871521,
-0.28534233570098877,
-0.27503684163093567,
-0.08379310369491577,
-0.09881330281496048,
0.2204534113407135,
0.173467218875885,
-0.3668246865272522,
-0.06283780187368393,
-0.6368562579154968,
0.17324896156787872,
0.9522629380226135,
-0.026207292452454567,
0.5236290097236633,
-0.3617856800556183,
0.9085938334465027,
0.08756676316261292,
0.04123550280928612,
-0.36434170603752136,
-0.21586667001247406,
-0.7366392612457275,
-0.18378229439258575,
0.2542524039745331,
0.7631322145462036,
-0.9862985014915466,
0.6572579741477966,
0.06632814556360245,
-0.05234094336628914,
-0.784227728843689,
0.02980257198214531,
0.8961219787597656,
0.9313057065010071,
0.46179643273353577,
-0.032577335834503174,
-0.5227115750312805,
-0.7180527448654175,
-0.15072019398212433,
-0.26374897360801697,
0.18259727954864502,
0.3690105974674225,
0.0441347099840641,
-0.12371869385242462,
0.5158435702323914,
-0.4725464880466461,
-0.03375668451189995,
-0.19371506571769714,
0.08790270239114761,
0.043805450201034546,
0.5896149277687073,
0.4657343626022339,
-0.7091829180717468,
-0.39023444056510925,
-0.08139698952436447,
-0.6451773047447205,
-0.26988673210144043,
-0.12149401754140854,
-0.1834433227777481,
0.3598032593727112,
0.8486477732658386,
-0.3836590051651001,
0.18578143417835236,
0.5697940587997437,
-0.42334192991256714,
0.5114974975585938,
-0.31853070855140686,
0.23139595985412598,
-0.9899826049804688,
0.3301246166229248,
-0.23291224241256714,
-0.037850767374038696,
-0.6020339727401733,
0.3225087523460388,
0.1362852156162262,
-0.29633140563964844,
-0.32298898696899414,
0.6663619875907898,
-0.42992091178894043,
0.2286546677350998,
-0.52530837059021,
0.11688537895679474,
0.08762773126363754,
0.45211341977119446,
-0.03807121887803078,
0.8597303032875061,
0.6920770406723022,
-0.5800167918205261,
0.4894729256629944,
0.18426455557346344,
0.007351597771048546,
0.5554454922676086,
-0.5874010920524597,
0.12931306660175323,
-0.3401377201080322,
0.24821244180202484,
-1.0713435411453247,
0.007135201245546341,
0.4534502327442169,
-0.35969793796539307,
0.5402255058288574,
-0.16067388653755188,
-0.16165319085121155,
-0.1515529453754425,
-0.3847641944885254,
0.6554552912712097,
0.6137176156044006,
-0.8983002305030823,
0.301287442445755,
0.25606825947761536,
-0.21650496125221252,
-0.9490212202072144,
-0.5911420583724976,
0.14208726584911346,
-0.44168150424957275,
-0.4607292711734772,
0.06456732004880905,
-0.09540719538927078,
-0.03863554820418358,
-0.0333159863948822,
-0.0732112005352974,
0.2997322082519531,
0.3922513425350189,
0.07417593151330948,
0.5105654001235962,
-0.34520310163497925,
-0.06919946521520615,
0.01709907129406929,
-0.32748886942863464,
0.09284251928329468,
-0.2094855159521103,
0.4325118660926819,
0.01170224230736494,
-0.3827247619628906,
-0.5904747843742371,
0.4918336570262909,
0.2947615087032318,
-0.09667722135782242,
0.826026439666748,
0.48959478735923767,
-0.1872473508119583,
-0.09906838089227676,
-0.2701977491378784,
-0.4255220592021942,
-0.5208378434181213,
0.3685442805290222,
-0.19656206667423248,
-0.5797935128211975,
0.4477163851261139,
0.2967863380908966,
0.038722630590200424,
0.2208234965801239,
0.2712804079055786,
0.10693331807851791,
1.5132638216018677,
0.47468870878219604,
-0.3663610816001892,
0.6349790692329407,
0.10159208625555038,
0.1766599416732788,
-0.5457870960235596,
-0.082262322306633,
-0.7368800640106201,
-0.2492624670267105,
-0.44786250591278076,
-0.06723511964082718,
0.3079123795032501,
0.2221824824810028,
-0.33723777532577515,
0.1752004474401474,
-0.423042356967926,
0.6918607354164124,
0.5531843900680542,
0.235955610871315,
0.06467334181070328,
-0.08304303139448166,
-0.35102584958076477,
0.10207357257604599,
-0.8124815225601196,
-0.3113103210926056,
0.90478515625,
0.17077668011188507,
1.189922571182251,
0.012636697851121426,
0.6330657005310059,
0.012930403463542461,
0.03073435090482235,
-0.6932673454284668,
0.6282562613487244,
-0.40663832426071167,
-0.18325833976268768,
-0.20935028791427612,
-0.6965698003768921,
-1.009730577468872,
0.26887035369873047,
-0.28495118021965027,
-0.38179853558540344,
0.2743542194366455,
0.49665072560310364,
-0.5347627401351929,
0.19216912984848022,
-0.8082581162452698,
0.8603460788726807,
-0.30896440148353577,
-0.16169783473014832,
-0.13804064691066742,
-0.918099582195282,
0.2732605040073395,
0.24373778700828552,
0.10198364406824112,
0.36447829008102417,
-0.10085376352071762,
0.5155702829360962,
-0.3801489770412445,
0.7968254685401917,
-0.31190064549446106,
-0.30280011892318726,
0.05424469709396362,
0.1841270625591278,
1.0672212839126587,
-0.18278652429580688,
-0.029000498354434967,
-0.3705671727657318,
-0.2722645401954651,
-0.4090338945388794,
-0.5911498069763184,
0.8825744986534119,
-0.7088894844055176,
-0.6785599589347839,
-0.2544392943382263,
-0.5857555270195007,
-0.2819501757621765,
0.1920463740825653,
0.5829750895500183,
0.6829255819320679,
-0.2657882273197174,
0.05580030009150505,
0.9161954522132874,
-0.4291939437389374,
0.38085153698921204,
0.424407035112381,
0.17997314035892487,
-0.5710260272026062,
1.0063426494598389,
-0.39952346682548523,
0.28326019644737244,
0.5408952832221985,
0.1264098882675171,
-0.5281533598899841,
-0.8023061156272888,
-0.5532804727554321,
-0.03658878058195114,
-0.9238213300704956,
-0.4465554356575012,
-0.605943500995636,
-0.06422434002161026,
-0.49843576550483704,
-0.43091222643852234,
-0.18887737393379211,
-0.2953084409236908,
-0.6728751063346863,
0.07321538031101227,
0.04498538747429848,
0.3951056897640228,
-0.12584257125854492,
0.24586184322834015,
-0.708734929561615,
0.4512766897678375,
0.2141016721725464,
0.07019110769033432,
0.06703682243824005,
-0.49695518612861633,
-0.19077658653259277,
0.1244184598326683,
-0.14409366250038147,
-0.7083941698074341,
0.3336855471134186,
-0.08656339347362518,
0.4798869788646698,
0.6997949481010437,
0.5889945030212402,
0.6207919120788574,
-0.40534207224845886,
0.524651825428009,
0.44100427627563477,
-0.7187487483024597,
0.3018452525138855,
-0.2574165463447571,
0.31390440464019775,
0.4677051901817322,
0.23122932016849518,
-0.4296131134033203,
-0.20840495824813843,
-0.3017561435699463,
-0.9127147197723389,
0.9297456741333008,
-0.1947086602449417,
-0.01828388124704361,
-0.19476178288459778,
0.07373273372650146,
-0.051283400505781174,
-0.03332067281007767,
-0.44333165884017944,
-0.23560123145580292,
-0.3325705826282501,
-0.5553545355796814,
-0.2161995768547058,
-0.17337119579315186,
-0.4924214780330658,
0.42717283964157104,
0.9060142040252686,
-0.3287806808948517,
0.09164851903915405,
-0.050672538578510284,
-0.07663538306951523,
-0.27501723170280457,
0.3663669228553772,
0.6257758140563965,
-0.04179984703660011,
0.005922351963818073,
0.29773229360580444,
0.17182084918022156,
-0.1968746930360794,
0.32072943449020386,
0.34149014949798584,
-0.12283669412136078,
-0.41540277004241943,
0.21390676498413086,
0.7353333234786987,
0.07683145254850388,
-0.6851963400840759,
0.7078070044517517,
-0.223033607006073,
0.1531578004360199,
0.31768137216567993,
0.3102072775363922,
-0.14964553713798523,
0.357041597366333,
0.16415154933929443,
0.14446428418159485,
0.1071256473660469,
-0.15283341705799103,
0.14208462834358215,
0.8569081425666809,
-0.3669147193431854,
-0.15393216907978058,
0.8105378150939941,
0.4291146993637085,
-0.21624670922756195,
0.5019084215164185,
-0.22503572702407837,
-0.4639786183834076,
0.770308792591095,
0.6954362988471985,
1.0341005325317383,
-0.27926018834114075,
-0.08914196491241455,
0.29175490140914917,
0.20175965130329132,
-0.12874209880828857,
0.044526271522045135,
0.08989981561899185,
-0.671729326248169,
-0.1157987117767334,
-0.41646355390548706,
-0.3517806828022003,
0.27575260400772095,
-0.7730186581611633,
0.3667992353439331,
-0.4935261011123657,
0.13682465255260468,
-0.3337971568107605,
-0.10333216190338135,
-0.2360885888338089,
0.4273918569087982,
0.08401428908109665,
0.7031914591789246,
-0.8058784008026123,
0.645014762878418,
0.5758630633354187,
-0.035452283918857574,
-0.5001953840255737,
0.14328929781913757,
0.19346340000629425,
-0.8806341290473938,
0.2721491754055023,
0.2660360038280487,
-0.4985167980194092,
0.051592081785202026,
-0.4021303951740265,
-0.5040626525878906,
0.8080002665519714,
0.6524897813796997,
-0.6269253492355347,
-0.22695589065551758,
-0.26768237352371216,
0.4529517590999603,
-0.4339958131313324,
0.02919175662100315,
0.32544204592704773,
0.0675634890794754,
0.1267826110124588,
-0.4015287160873413,
0.5030385255813599,
-0.28396135568618774,
0.06894994527101517,
0.21622389554977417,
-0.46780672669410706,
0.6049309968948364,
-0.5221959352493286,
-0.5663905739784241,
0.4784432053565979,
0.5024257898330688,
0.26288625597953796,
0.026928167790174484,
0.4972870945930481,
0.6735435128211975,
0.5074547529220581,
0.07304590940475464,
1.0665189027786255,
-0.4784773886203766,
0.03334587439894676,
1.099281668663025,
0.007538831792771816,
0.5279139280319214,
0.33836016058921814,
0.1818798929452896,
0.11762190610170364,
0.5298866629600525,
0.12104851752519608,
0.8949829339981079,
0.01804339326918125,
-0.3125929534435272,
-0.30299511551856995,
-0.16609317064285278,
-0.6234310865402222,
0.054037876427173615,
0.2931406497955322,
-0.45713716745376587,
-0.3203021287918091,
-0.14273399114608765,
0.07639884948730469,
0.22567543387413025,
-0.30778416991233826,
0.8152766227722168,
-0.08875223994255066,
-0.890709400177002,
0.8565649390220642,
0.07327888160943985,
0.7852196097373962,
-0.4672197997570038,
0.10818646848201752,
-0.3172299861907959,
0.314571350812912,
-0.047175586223602295,
-0.48259976506233215,
0.06855928152799606,
-0.027775244787335396,
-0.07688643783330917,
-0.05897679552435875,
0.40741297602653503,
-0.5758046507835388,
-0.055312931537628174,
0.2499750256538391,
0.002540342975407839,
-0.2473982870578766,
0.24092887341976166,
-0.8178756237030029,
-0.011354590766131878,
0.062283359467983246,
-0.10596320778131485,
0.5531570911407471,
0.3047221601009369,
0.16252455115318298,
0.6379075050354004,
0.7018464207649231,
0.06655126065015793,
-0.21326233446598053,
-0.021495327353477478,
1.001813292503357,
-0.6575228571891785,
-1.0079044103622437,
-0.875060498714447,
0.22682012617588043,
0.25307226181030273,
-0.15942935645580292,
0.572044849395752,
0.34652528166770935,
0.4837789535522461,
0.06770460307598114,
0.7307072877883911,
0.29331913590431213,
0.21232788264751434,
-0.857682466506958,
0.5648856163024902,
-0.4400745630264282,
0.45817869901657104,
-0.18322430551052094,
-0.551555335521698,
-0.3275967538356781,
0.42961615324020386,
-0.1438894420862198,
0.03902870789170265,
0.525653064250946,
1.2190980911254883,
0.05943543091416359,
0.08728678524494171,
0.2555997967720032,
0.08255312591791153,
0.3810608983039856,
0.6698367595672607,
0.8051859140396118,
-0.37227150797843933,
0.902454137802124,
-0.04844743385910988,
-0.19702045619487762,
-0.43858420848846436,
-0.9040604829788208,
-1.0371036529541016,
-0.23367702960968018,
-0.29418185353279114,
-0.6655703186988831,
0.40543684363365173,
0.9607390761375427,
0.5531117916107178,
-1.0938348770141602,
0.15234766900539398,
-0.39044690132141113,
0.0801006332039833,
-0.15211154520511627,
-0.23336456716060638,
0.5249940156936646,
-0.6018034815788269,
-0.6702892780303955,
0.7119398713111877,
0.1318621039390564,
0.47654712200164795,
0.015569495968520641,
-0.4460311233997345,
0.015538912266492844,
0.1343451887369156,
0.04143235459923744,
0.561730146408081,
-0.6256828308105469,
-0.081378273665905,
-0.15878568589687347,
-0.44039806723594666,
-0.06805826723575592,
0.6822055578231812,
-0.7049477100372314,
0.49998652935028076,
0.6357030868530273,
1.0305147171020508,
-0.04924002289772034,
0.34941259026527405,
0.8029720783233643,
-0.7374628782272339,
0.22412440180778503,
0.228229820728302,
0.3647802472114563,
0.5499988198280334,
-0.6749145984649658,
0.11317173391580582,
-0.029879255220294,
-0.511009156703949,
-0.8849011659622192,
0.39686331152915955,
-0.5715029835700989,
-0.48505347967147827,
1.1612794399261475,
-0.37894701957702637,
-0.04707341641187668,
-0.19151964783668518,
-0.33653801679611206,
0.3213920593261719,
-0.5902983546257019,
0.8196476697921753,
0.4415193796157837,
-0.05452204495668411,
-0.09493637830018997,
0.2327021360397339,
0.7923886179924011,
0.6713417768478394,
-0.6334502696990967,
0.22228431701660156,
0.5924445986747742,
0.05972597375512123,
-0.02694724127650261,
0.24114538729190826,
-0.08810193091630936,
0.5408483147621155,
0.21681278944015503,
-0.3103482127189636,
-0.3483886420726776,
-0.29873818159103394,
-1.0413308143615723,
0.19063296914100647,
0.01509637851268053,
-0.44647711515426636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16732v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16732v2 | CLIMATELI: Evaluating Entity Linking on Climate Change Data | 2024-06-24T15:36:00 | 2024-06-27T14:44:51 | Shijia Zhou, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Climate Change (CC) is a pressing topic of global importance, attracting
increasing attention across research fields, from social sciences to Natural
Language Processing (NLP). CC is also discussed in various settings and
communication platforms, from academic publications to social media forums.
Understanding who and what is mentioned in such data is a first critical step
to gaining new insights into CC. We present CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking),
the first manually annotated CC dataset that links 3,087 entity spans to
Wikipedia. Using CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking), we evaluate existing
entity linking (EL) systems on the CC topic across various genres and propose
automated filtering methods for CC entities. We find that the performance of EL
models notably lags behind humans at both token and entity levels. Testing
within the scope of retaining or excluding non-nominal and/or non-CC entities
particularly impacts the models' performances. | [
-0.7034519910812378,
-0.6554086208343506,
0.2692345976829529,
0.03216330707073212,
-0.23382093012332916,
0.08789984881877899,
-0.4399213194847107,
-0.9445850253105164,
-0.003691336140036583,
0.44379177689552307,
-0.6146975755691528,
-0.5531133413314819,
-0.45577752590179443,
0.41919180750846863,
-0.5387939214706421,
0.9491565227508545,
0.23586243391036987,
-0.20017273724079132,
-0.3793899416923523,
-0.036194320768117905,
-0.14484095573425293,
0.01140299066901207,
-0.9563596844673157,
-0.27364808320999146,
0.6968027353286743,
0.5295728445053101,
0.9178641438484192,
0.4067971408367157,
0.4172535240650177,
0.29666098952293396,
-0.19788368046283722,
0.16615039110183716,
-0.622533917427063,
0.30314669013023376,
-0.4559178352355957,
-0.034894201904535294,
-0.11200767010450363,
-0.14968709647655487,
0.5627886056900024,
0.43665632605552673,
0.12661898136138916,
0.6177484393119812,
0.047381848096847534,
0.4290318787097931,
-0.7524253726005554,
0.27351558208465576,
-1.2053258419036865,
-0.355389267206192,
-0.34860479831695557,
0.0508909672498703,
-0.39941248297691345,
0.042911749333143234,
0.20673474669456482,
-0.888550877571106,
0.7658198475837708,
0.7182296514511108,
0.6633389592170715,
0.573091983795166,
-0.41935375332832336,
-0.30615484714508057,
-0.6425337195396423,
0.42327141761779785,
-0.4092670679092407,
0.647619903087616,
0.22742153704166412,
-0.12385570257902145,
-0.09805316478013992,
-0.5039400458335876,
-1.0230457782745361,
-0.3779507279396057,
-0.17215938866138458,
-0.1809510439634323,
-0.07684022188186646,
-0.21289603412151337,
0.3002888858318329,
0.24537886679172516,
-0.42409294843673706,
0.052391111850738525,
-0.5500032305717468,
-0.25529539585113525,
0.7966534495353699,
0.054116345942020416,
0.40089404582977295,
-0.5696922540664673,
-0.3920878767967224,
-0.16782183945178986,
-0.866803765296936,
-0.3278851807117462,
0.5612305402755737,
0.44470733404159546,
-0.11393465101718903,
0.4741840660572052,
0.025610480457544327,
0.4130929708480835,
-0.023830197751522064,
0.2806539535522461,
-0.15691855549812317,
-0.45695966482162476,
-0.23265425860881805,
0.31912294030189514,
0.634285032749176,
0.3519499897956848,
0.027915218845009804,
-0.22966241836547852,
0.13946697115898132,
-0.22961531579494476,
-0.07517494261264801,
-0.6988300681114197,
-0.6918826699256897,
-0.21208670735359192,
-0.1349138766527176,
-0.11861167848110199,
0.08031467348337173,
-1.1628642082214355,
-0.6678430438041687,
-0.38112637400627136,
-0.08601304888725281,
0.1105736717581749,
-0.47247225046157837,
-0.27337121963500977,
0.1050095483660698,
-0.04759756475687027,
0.2888978123664856,
-0.6582698822021484,
0.34748855233192444,
0.5776222944259644,
0.639015257358551,
-0.3642813265323639,
-0.152471125125885,
-0.2770751416683197,
0.08505529910326004,
-0.18650861084461212,
0.8928169012069702,
-0.8498921990394592,
-0.6334559917449951,
-0.3084963262081146,
0.18793803453445435,
0.032392870634794235,
-0.21315769851207733,
0.37699005007743835,
-0.76836097240448,
0.014216969721019268,
-0.5862996578216553,
-0.5969921946525574,
0.15007197856903076,
-0.17460380494594574,
-1.1683368682861328,
1.2374640703201294,
-0.2384951114654541,
-1.0570050477981567,
0.8141084909439087,
-0.8113536834716797,
-0.14459040760993958,
0.13423557579517365,
0.3215651214122772,
-0.5330871939659119,
-0.3952649235725403,
0.10652764141559601,
0.05472423508763313,
-0.7273579835891724,
0.4532127380371094,
-0.5778838992118835,
-0.13158516585826874,
-0.037186842411756516,
-0.32427263259887695,
0.7292338609695435,
0.33802416920661926,
-0.3558342158794403,
0.18232066929340363,
-0.6259280443191528,
-0.3341917097568512,
-0.08059033006429672,
0.040094487369060516,
-0.6230109930038452,
0.20369552075862885,
0.5689535140991211,
-0.016428174450993538,
0.19933244585990906,
-0.45622342824935913,
0.2695741653442383,
-0.046297162771224976,
0.4506606161594391,
0.6829150319099426,
0.2530886232852936,
0.3321551978588104,
0.03130469471216202,
0.1961958408355713,
0.0762331634759903,
0.09159503132104874,
0.10554283112287521,
-0.7627983689308167,
-0.8498156666755676,
0.21080932021141052,
0.2995178699493408,
0.4665237069129944,
-0.9343254566192627,
0.030313553288578987,
-0.22833320498466492,
-0.8994238376617432,
-0.4302905797958374,
0.28936758637428284,
0.025754472240805626,
0.5812200307846069,
0.6297080516815186,
0.22867360711097717,
-0.4711676836013794,
-0.7311512231826782,
-0.40890204906463623,
-0.6411141753196716,
0.10130225867033005,
0.2891838550567627,
0.9593446850776672,
-0.13768494129180908,
1.0026949644088745,
-0.5186356902122498,
0.2593405544757843,
0.13119763135910034,
0.11629882454872131,
-0.20451398193836212,
0.31702396273612976,
0.5447850823402405,
-1.2226263284683228,
-0.36350324749946594,
-0.13168877363204956,
-0.2344442903995514,
-0.21751029789447784,
-0.11983535438776016,
-0.20886266231536865,
0.14036434888839722,
0.3778846263885498,
-0.402726948261261,
0.5839333534240723,
0.4273696839809418,
-0.6823461651802063,
0.35487085580825806,
-0.08405230194330215,
0.6087551116943359,
-0.7808505296707153,
0.27270567417144775,
0.39419645071029663,
-0.1476098746061325,
-0.5411581993103027,
-0.08971909433603287,
-0.17603842914104462,
-0.10417066514492035,
-0.5376933217048645,
0.8070626854896545,
-0.5108928680419922,
-0.15833210945129395,
0.0172285046428442,
0.28284409642219543,
0.07078009098768234,
0.09756176918745041,
0.011795236729085445,
0.7938040494918823,
0.4741641879081726,
-0.6937137246131897,
0.3470766544342041,
0.133774995803833,
-0.19611856341362,
0.4321436583995819,
-0.3460731506347656,
0.43581798672676086,
-0.24431288242340088,
0.2856278419494629,
-0.7296644449234009,
-0.11189041286706924,
0.31869226694107056,
-0.1317089945077896,
-0.019122399389743805,
-0.06812076270580292,
-0.6582925319671631,
-0.35555362701416016,
-0.0015680019278079271,
0.4661923348903656,
-0.004281812813133001,
-0.4605685770511627,
0.36466139554977417,
0.41619113087654114,
0.17895808815956116,
-0.11770451068878174,
-0.3166225552558899,
0.3035968542098999,
-0.521996259689331,
-0.3450795114040375,
0.419270783662796,
-0.39135631918907166,
-0.45452168583869934,
0.49843987822532654,
-0.17816881835460663,
-0.34952694177627563,
0.5253868699073792,
0.3498963713645935,
0.3953815698623657,
-0.09930365532636642,
0.44375598430633545,
-0.13113175332546234,
0.16574034094810486,
0.2089141309261322,
-0.2910133898258209,
0.1637660712003708,
-0.037231676280498505,
-0.07656224071979523,
-0.35599812865257263,
0.11442500352859497,
0.5858979225158691,
-0.11039217561483383,
1.1994115114212036,
0.6086885929107666,
-0.7600111961364746,
0.14012378454208374,
-0.5711133480072021,
0.07022915035486221,
-0.36653873324394226,
0.06284092366695404,
-0.1495392918586731,
-0.8277295827865601,
0.4457356035709381,
-0.04182838276028633,
0.01834259368479252,
1.0435426235198975,
0.3414927124977112,
0.30323708057403564,
0.4392307698726654,
0.8560397028923035,
-0.36131373047828674,
0.3526688814163208,
-0.024776527658104897,
0.3950936496257782,
-0.6679032444953918,
-0.5981749296188354,
-0.8687454462051392,
0.053914882242679596,
-0.8997455835342407,
-0.4062317907810211,
0.15165214240550995,
0.15193170309066772,
-0.359591007232666,
0.6568253040313721,
-0.5480343699455261,
0.4726725220680237,
0.15721362829208374,
0.1481788605451584,
0.6112003326416016,
-0.28305962681770325,
0.3634485900402069,
-0.014403271488845348,
-0.41831403970718384,
-0.49143171310424805,
0.6667802333831787,
-0.07183127850294113,
0.5642200708389282,
0.12067219614982605,
0.1574067622423172,
0.8793332576751709,
0.7304168343544006,
-0.26501262187957764,
0.4189760386943817,
0.07836167514324188,
-0.7494068145751953,
-0.6428907513618469,
-0.3211967647075653,
-0.7452534437179565,
0.06493372470140457,
-0.5218955874443054,
-0.49001556634902954,
0.3713715076446533,
0.2520180940628052,
0.11410568654537201,
0.6857373714447021,
-0.45078471302986145,
0.7016246318817139,
0.00190162961371243,
-0.4882400631904602,
-0.35814738273620605,
-0.23244576156139374,
0.28024592995643616,
-0.2860156297683716,
0.4154563844203949,
-0.4523768723011017,
-0.1917276531457901,
0.5697471499443054,
-0.3080374002456665,
0.663791835308075,
-0.20698252320289612,
0.10600864887237549,
0.4224642217159271,
-0.1306215077638626,
0.2005729228258133,
0.5114464163780212,
-0.4542270600795746,
0.3417596220970154,
0.07165580242872238,
-0.4354935586452484,
-0.20452506840229034,
1.0458452701568604,
-0.6566879153251648,
-0.539943277835846,
-0.3371800184249878,
-0.03889065608382225,
0.021684760227799416,
0.08691748231649399,
0.3008834719657898,
-0.023220183327794075,
-0.4277523458003998,
-0.027652457356452942,
0.6871006488800049,
-0.136979341506958,
0.25010043382644653,
0.4699951708316803,
-0.05875274911522865,
-0.21164025366306305,
0.6029677987098694,
0.07959756255149841,
0.04179475083947182,
0.09409651905298233,
0.046089623123407364,
-0.10657547414302826,
-0.29864275455474854,
-0.5679152011871338,
0.008140183053910732,
-0.664595365524292,
-0.2984199821949005,
-0.547163724899292,
-0.02297852747142315,
-0.47972825169563293,
0.004667630419135094,
-0.1115087941288948,
0.10645364224910736,
-0.5563133358955383,
-0.053730934858322144,
0.6321945786476135,
0.9315728545188904,
0.16959579288959503,
-0.1781386137008667,
-0.2662041485309601,
0.20742514729499817,
0.026181096211075783,
0.1500076949596405,
-0.017530836164951324,
0.050155751407146454,
-0.22813905775547028,
0.07845499366521835,
0.02231048233807087,
-1.2172468900680542,
0.2198767513036728,
0.6379972696304321,
0.315032035112381,
0.1477992832660675,
0.3282056450843811,
0.8939339518547058,
-0.5074813365936279,
1.022963047027588,
-0.03683231770992279,
-1.3646037578582764,
0.7795907258987427,
0.08741822838783264,
0.11140093207359314,
0.5534454584121704,
0.46441230177879333,
-0.5888121128082275,
-0.3119626045227051,
-0.5825919508934021,
-1.005081295967102,
0.18059267103672028,
0.35062360763549805,
-0.05769677087664604,
-0.23186443746089935,
0.7220596075057983,
0.023663107305765152,
0.1555638462305069,
-0.41296666860580444,
-0.5242258310317993,
-0.1953289955854416,
0.21885694563388824,
-0.10158312320709229,
0.028984514996409416,
0.2377958595752716,
-0.3699266016483307,
0.8909415006637573,
-0.12634001672267914,
-0.040745824575424194,
0.5097230076789856,
-0.27340829372406006,
-0.3452506363391876,
0.19059932231903076,
0.3899449110031128,
0.528670608997345,
0.28702715039253235,
-0.09273886680603027,
0.652190089225769,
-0.2670833170413971,
-0.1280042827129364,
-0.07178805023431778,
-0.2673764228820801,
0.2097562551498413,
0.3469725549221039,
0.9556795954704285,
0.7050370573997498,
-0.4152553975582123,
0.1276237815618515,
-0.12907645106315613,
0.31359344720840454,
-0.4334036111831665,
0.13050684332847595,
-0.001565993414260447,
0.07394807785749435,
0.390237420797348,
0.09357747435569763,
0.43295592069625854,
-0.5171453356742859,
0.21022315323352814,
0.0561077818274498,
-0.33469846844673157,
-0.42855799198150635,
1.2013027667999268,
0.23974789679050446,
0.041629355400800705,
0.8356665968894958,
-0.007771349512040615,
-0.464213490486145,
0.6950151324272156,
0.28816595673561096,
0.5845228433609009,
-0.2547118365764618,
0.2384633719921112,
0.7607331275939941,
0.4570058584213257,
0.14083845913410187,
-0.21822500228881836,
-0.43493515253067017,
-0.562167227268219,
-0.2765622138977051,
-0.5833147764205933,
-0.6779546141624451,
-0.06319467723369598,
-0.7526578903198242,
0.5874976515769958,
-0.20833852887153625,
-0.14077357947826385,
0.12544798851013184,
0.17693355679512024,
-1.1032023429870605,
0.2414281964302063,
0.3457382917404175,
1.161303162574768,
-1.087431788444519,
0.8638600707054138,
0.6520842909812927,
-0.2363366186618805,
-0.5630897879600525,
0.06860755383968353,
0.18769441545009613,
-0.24797412753105164,
0.6939111351966858,
-0.02925826422870159,
-0.40609052777290344,
0.05429157614707947,
-0.889258086681366,
-0.8955856561660767,
1.2425683736801147,
0.2960056662559509,
-0.5990578532218933,
-0.07045584917068481,
-0.13386762142181396,
0.6405203342437744,
-0.4125882089138031,
0.2289116233587265,
0.6561943292617798,
0.9586376547813416,
0.047857850790023804,
-0.7724650502204895,
0.05199610814452171,
-0.3880268335342407,
0.004613830707967281,
0.30983731150627136,
-0.737942636013031,
0.3555862605571747,
-0.18234504759311676,
-0.5223426222801208,
0.004932199604809284,
1.0319360494613647,
-0.02056637592613697,
0.7021370530128479,
1.0583311319351196,
0.32283899188041687,
1.1214731931686401,
-0.263931542634964,
0.8563035130500793,
-0.5776839256286621,
0.7989709377288818,
1.048059105873108,
-0.5415074229240417,
0.8821517825126648,
0.15198412537574768,
0.06846432387828827,
0.5817245841026306,
1.0045640468597412,
-0.2964268624782562,
0.4171005189418793,
0.24926519393920898,
-0.3916556239128113,
-0.3850235939025879,
-0.38056138157844543,
-0.10558032989501953,
0.11392021924257278,
0.5339299440383911,
0.04898472875356674,
-0.10398796945810318,
0.050184398889541626,
0.21317830681800842,
-0.031640954315662384,
-0.3710043132305145,
0.609004557132721,
-0.12825840711593628,
-0.6008865833282471,
-0.07211259752511978,
-0.1302703320980072,
0.3565637767314911,
-0.03827175498008728,
-0.11298157274723053,
0.044871360063552856,
-0.5987324118614197,
-0.5203272700309753,
-0.5799567699432373,
0.5635821223258972,
0.371725469827652,
-0.25427329540252686,
-0.01949615590274334,
0.5747687816619873,
-0.684725821018219,
-0.41230490803718567,
0.47133293747901917,
0.028040854260325432,
0.16623616218566895,
0.01350395567715168,
-0.8621319532394409,
0.14362157881259918,
0.03335515409708023,
-0.33018729090690613,
-0.05754164233803749,
0.16836197674274445,
-0.24709874391555786,
0.6910708546638489,
0.9200441837310791,
0.0037552702706307173,
0.03387003019452095,
-0.16767919063568115,
0.9907432794570923,
-0.6039322018623352,
-0.16261062026023865,
-0.7473065853118896,
0.438583105802536,
-0.32792001962661743,
-0.5154629945755005,
0.5191876888275146,
0.5734120607376099,
0.8549532294273376,
0.2737175524234772,
0.4732606112957001,
-0.24834927916526794,
-0.07201952487230301,
-0.6455835700035095,
0.6908906102180481,
-0.40243494510650635,
0.4621962010860443,
-0.18073555827140808,
-1.2128965854644775,
-0.07984238862991333,
0.06728634238243103,
-0.3306283950805664,
-0.08278335630893707,
0.6898035407066345,
0.5996606349945068,
0.26809677481651306,
0.13805529475212097,
0.2705903649330139,
0.3364308178424835,
0.2667759954929352,
0.1363265961408615,
0.36952391266822815,
-0.28458312153816223,
0.379079133272171,
-0.3255648612976074,
0.2977023124694824,
0.0599675215780735,
-1.09719979763031,
-0.7905648350715637,
-0.9230431914329529,
-0.7949922680854797,
-0.2770358920097351,
0.14998158812522888,
0.846504271030426,
0.6578954458236694,
-1.0064945220947266,
0.2896216809749603,
0.08085153251886368,
0.4063795804977417,
0.2849583327770233,
-0.26289263367652893,
0.3991420269012451,
0.19543065130710602,
-0.8697209358215332,
0.38021817803382874,
0.23737169802188873,
-0.4288269877433777,
-0.6785590052604675,
0.08203167468309402,
-0.13304002583026886,
0.04487326741218567,
0.11779440194368362,
0.22736667096614838,
-0.988989531993866,
-0.5443540811538696,
-0.16064117848873138,
0.06311476230621338,
-0.21715953946113586,
0.8903078436851501,
-0.8221533298492432,
0.3747093081474304,
0.4417719841003418,
0.538366973400116,
0.45925113558769226,
-0.11097431182861328,
-0.02635870687663555,
-0.15624047815799713,
-0.12648628652095795,
-0.188706174492836,
0.4398004114627838,
0.6460950374603271,
-0.8901486992835999,
0.4854138195514679,
0.4182400703430176,
-0.785162091255188,
-0.5637352466583252,
0.019519703462719917,
-0.6703783869743347,
-0.07204856723546982,
0.7499958276748657,
-0.21362854540348053,
-0.28905367851257324,
-0.21467074751853943,
0.10058771073818207,
0.2554458677768707,
-0.5845146775245667,
0.718593418598175,
0.9687325954437256,
-0.004402633290737867,
-0.22089757025241852,
-0.610865592956543,
0.5355187058448792,
-0.117342509329319,
-0.8708464503288269,
-0.060931481420993805,
0.5178837180137634,
0.5243385434150696,
0.15959322452545166,
0.3043724000453949,
0.2979816794395447,
-0.0305876974016428,
-0.233411967754364,
0.14379768073558807,
0.24006302654743195,
-0.3737487494945526,
-0.0643027275800705,
-0.016229627653956413,
0.003935089334845543,
0.47058767080307007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16722v1 | Venturing into Uncharted Waters: The Navigation Compass from Transformer to Mamba | 2024-06-24T15:27:21 | 2024-06-24T15:27:21 | Yuchen Zou, Yineng Chen, Zuchao Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer, a deep neural network architecture, has long dominated the field
of natural language processing and beyond. Nevertheless, the recent
introduction of Mamba challenges its supremacy, sparks considerable interest
among researchers, and gives rise to a series of Mamba-based models that have
exhibited notable potential. This survey paper orchestrates a comprehensive
discussion, diving into essential research dimensions, covering: (i) the
functioning of the Mamba mechanism and its foundation on the principles of
structured state space models; (ii) the proposed improvements and the
integration of Mamba with various networks, exploring its potential as a
substitute for Transformers; (iii) the combination of Transformers and Mamba to
compensate for each other's shortcomings. We have also made efforts to
interpret Mamba and Transformer in the framework of kernel functions, allowing
for a comparison of their mathematical nature within a unified context. Our
paper encompasses the vast majority of improvements related to Mamba to date. | [
-0.5948002934455872,
-0.38390305638313293,
0.7858853340148926,
0.08344276249408722,
-0.14679650962352753,
0.2723415791988373,
-0.23634099960327148,
-0.20145262777805328,
0.15078364312648773,
0.44867920875549316,
-0.4505821764469147,
-0.17999209463596344,
-0.7292429208755493,
0.030974475666880608,
-0.451242059469223,
0.7052648663520813,
0.27693283557891846,
-0.023067129775881767,
0.06374523788690567,
-0.19743022322654724,
-0.7249544262886047,
-0.5136821866035461,
-0.4265687167644501,
-0.7786186933517456,
0.524097204208374,
0.17737731337547302,
0.964276134967804,
0.2329404056072235,
0.36829036474227905,
0.33239781856536865,
-0.3271840512752533,
0.13075266778469086,
-0.37948477268218994,
0.2825421392917633,
-0.2223643958568573,
-0.37739428877830505,
-0.2091197520494461,
-0.16396135091781616,
0.6995614767074585,
1.199400782585144,
-0.0676119476556778,
-0.1156635656952858,
0.2831052839756012,
0.8902465105056763,
-0.5556715130805969,
0.30810248851776123,
-0.4801174998283386,
0.028572268784046173,
-0.007207528222352266,
0.0762273371219635,
-0.32069945335388184,
-0.27466633915901184,
0.4282102584838867,
-0.6313280463218689,
-0.02469821833074093,
-0.043320510536432266,
0.7553441524505615,
0.34795060753822327,
-0.9065445065498352,
-0.35418251156806946,
-1.0493650436401367,
0.7459062933921814,
-0.547603964805603,
0.4437732696533203,
-0.09151466190814972,
0.562853991985321,
-0.45540404319763184,
-0.8677445650100708,
-0.4650242328643799,
-0.17416122555732727,
-0.0768437460064888,
0.18047955632209778,
-0.4436382055282593,
0.0177354346960783,
-0.22691099345684052,
0.5512790083885193,
-0.16398335993289948,
0.16751740872859955,
-0.6097878217697144,
-0.21330660581588745,
0.5143415331840515,
0.3109966516494751,
0.13391505181789398,
-0.39502784609794617,
-0.16659486293792725,
-0.13285622000694275,
-0.7302275896072388,
0.32739773392677307,
0.3110424280166626,
0.5152189135551453,
0.08204830437898636,
0.5388109087944031,
-0.1482352316379547,
0.8524612188339233,
-0.1269340217113495,
0.2769588530063629,
0.05056925117969513,
-0.16741669178009033,
-0.3847091495990753,
0.1659962385892868,
0.9193738698959351,
0.2534887492656708,
0.15659542381763458,
-0.2228136509656906,
-0.07310841232538223,
-0.09099850803613663,
0.8302538394927979,
-0.36623889207839966,
-0.382800430059433,
-0.0675630122423172,
-0.39141175150871277,
-0.37337982654571533,
0.0838046744465828,
-0.729395866394043,
-0.6687325835227966,
-0.40494304895401,
0.21616844832897186,
-0.3696848452091217,
-0.4695837199687958,
0.2386968731880188,
0.1972045600414276,
0.29725706577301025,
0.1656639575958252,
-0.8237332701683044,
0.34794825315475464,
0.9827359318733215,
0.9407325387001038,
-0.03774328902363777,
0.06300627440214157,
0.14114321768283844,
-0.233484148979187,
-0.38710278272628784,
0.8350463509559631,
-0.813694417476654,
-0.9419767260551453,
0.09824215620756149,
-0.11740511655807495,
-0.10577994585037231,
-0.19926324486732483,
0.7199190258979797,
-0.4828565716743469,
0.199745774269104,
-0.38609519600868225,
-0.2677296996116638,
-0.8392127156257629,
0.34208187460899353,
-0.9361181855201721,
0.8859968185424805,
0.021103041246533394,
-0.27211102843284607,
0.06155111640691757,
-1.0909403562545776,
-0.7527216672897339,
-0.30871543288230896,
0.1045810654759407,
-0.24365876615047455,
0.18549038469791412,
0.31831419467926025,
0.3669476807117462,
-0.6355984807014465,
0.49204280972480774,
0.1149362176656723,
-0.47269201278686523,
0.3537465035915375,
-0.3368339240550995,
0.8973939418792725,
0.32288452982902527,
-0.05289042741060257,
-0.08869962394237518,
-0.966978132724762,
-0.13834232091903687,
0.006764130666851997,
-0.4832439422607422,
-0.2977697253227234,
0.17327278852462769,
-0.31534653902053833,
-0.01976608671247959,
-0.0376550629734993,
-0.47175535559654236,
0.4403429925441742,
-0.7312455177307129,
0.8073757290840149,
0.4781321585178375,
0.16366547346115112,
1.265336036682129,
0.2494652271270752,
0.49524617195129395,
0.25979700684547424,
0.21449318528175354,
-0.5471421480178833,
-0.7179324626922607,
-0.9687138795852661,
0.2685614824295044,
0.3450690507888794,
0.4035545885562897,
-0.7389346957206726,
0.4272574186325073,
-0.3516274690628052,
-0.7360926866531372,
-0.6040432453155518,
-0.35674941539764404,
0.04630715027451515,
0.699128270149231,
0.6991878151893616,
0.011553064920008183,
-0.5427545309066772,
-0.8876621127128601,
-0.33876073360443115,
-0.08635473251342773,
-0.09847114235162735,
0.24475480616092682,
0.0941309928894043,
-0.23175372183322906,
1.0593831539154053,
-0.45913398265838623,
-0.34719157218933105,
-0.34281957149505615,
0.03175947815179825,
0.46135953068733215,
0.4852377474308014,
0.39554721117019653,
-0.908148467540741,
-0.06143540143966675,
0.047407153993844986,
-0.6388174295425415,
0.12435503304004669,
-0.29518675804138184,
0.01959722861647606,
-0.32277193665504456,
0.457986444234848,
-0.5791526436805725,
0.37667638063430786,
0.48275381326675415,
-0.01906455121934414,
-0.07710851728916168,
-0.04913787171244621,
-0.03631578013300896,
-1.0991445779800415,
0.06524566560983658,
-0.07307343930006027,
0.3806014358997345,
-1.015454888343811,
-0.06691721826791763,
-0.0008464429411105812,
-0.10004720091819763,
-0.2251756340265274,
0.17790460586547852,
-0.5844663977622986,
-0.028665844351053238,
-0.29803526401519775,
0.2685074210166931,
0.05999595299363136,
0.48494359850883484,
-0.46188709139823914,
0.5332620739936829,
0.8311563730239868,
-1.0305795669555664,
0.379245787858963,
0.30172213912010193,
-0.23175594210624695,
0.2944914996623993,
-0.6503432393074036,
0.1126859113574028,
-0.22234830260276794,
0.22081664204597473,
-1.1742808818817139,
0.32604315876960754,
0.4861990213394165,
-0.5881115794181824,
0.2708979845046997,
-0.247046560049057,
-0.14503656327724457,
-0.4039907157421112,
0.06007441505789757,
0.39135923981666565,
0.575402557849884,
-0.44985121488571167,
1.1411738395690918,
0.4751289486885071,
0.21105439960956573,
-0.675087034702301,
-0.724602997303009,
0.504453182220459,
-0.02246781997382641,
-0.44650766253471375,
0.24365843832492828,
0.5269063115119934,
-0.25336992740631104,
-0.13346219062805176,
-0.09706751257181168,
-0.06704360991716385,
0.27872300148010254,
0.59285968542099,
0.24995750188827515,
-0.5142194628715515,
0.308063268661499,
0.1463136225938797,
-0.4754880666732788,
0.3078330457210541,
-0.6652398109436035,
0.4725062847137451,
-0.4669998288154602,
-0.20395976305007935,
0.04970049113035202,
0.10277983546257019,
0.3851870000362396,
-0.5255929231643677,
0.6922286748886108,
0.24855709075927734,
-0.09784771502017975,
-0.03719419613480568,
-0.15201257169246674,
-0.03932711109519005,
-0.5463722944259644,
0.10947926342487335,
-0.37269526720046997,
-0.9190371632575989,
0.48305636644363403,
-0.5071654319763184,
0.15728022158145905,
0.6290311813354492,
0.23258057236671448,
-0.07058431208133698,
0.7546464204788208,
0.937760055065155,
0.007661331910640001,
0.08249635249376297,
-0.3384171724319458,
0.9788734316825867,
-1.116752028465271,
-0.6360399127006531,
-0.7047173976898193,
-0.7419187426567078,
-0.744266927242279,
-0.11507049947977066,
0.40250280499458313,
-0.1609743982553482,
-0.23529919981956482,
0.5757944583892822,
-0.5959619283676147,
0.2910305857658386,
0.38562142848968506,
-0.32504749298095703,
0.25859659910202026,
-0.34589383006095886,
-0.48691532015800476,
-0.08478222787380219,
-1.0184552669525146,
-0.5627723932266235,
0.9244968295097351,
0.2802295684814453,
0.7483198642730713,
0.04887884855270386,
0.2641145586967468,
-0.06494352221488953,
0.328142911195755,
-0.9788837432861328,
0.6492698192596436,
0.06930287927389145,
-0.5705448389053345,
-0.4220364987850189,
-0.14702002704143524,
-1.1948531866073608,
0.4557892382144928,
-0.35530903935432434,
-0.6515982747077942,
0.4171801209449768,
-0.02593248151242733,
-0.5678809285163879,
0.637844979763031,
-0.4637010991573334,
0.5498783588409424,
-0.15766574442386627,
0.09208475798368454,
0.09882984310388565,
-0.899375855922699,
0.44386404752731323,
0.013404101133346558,
0.1806120127439499,
0.029302140697836876,
0.00966341607272625,
0.42952239513397217,
-0.20656713843345642,
0.6850900650024414,
-0.20229914784431458,
-0.27685534954071045,
0.4054778516292572,
0.36241135001182556,
-0.0463411919772625,
-0.003564528888091445,
-0.07830976694822311,
0.4618188738822937,
-0.3823366165161133,
-0.027640393003821373,
-0.8286928534507751,
0.6470184326171875,
-0.5777153372764587,
-0.47712692618370056,
-0.35538727045059204,
-0.3962809145450592,
-0.28875502943992615,
0.4035321772098541,
0.29093441367149353,
0.4516875743865967,
-0.2182207554578781,
0.37215718626976013,
0.5721353888511658,
-0.2892579138278961,
0.718486487865448,
0.19183562695980072,
-0.3966100513935089,
-0.13671977818012238,
0.6040531992912292,
0.0687188133597374,
-0.0664902925491333,
0.5415473580360413,
0.04374786838889122,
-0.435172438621521,
-0.3819122314453125,
-0.5020331144332886,
-0.06443318724632263,
-0.8495272397994995,
-0.31004783511161804,
-0.6028329730033875,
-0.3515220284461975,
-0.028259214013814926,
-0.21432463824748993,
-0.765293538570404,
-0.458233505487442,
-0.515967071056366,
-0.1916206181049347,
0.11039742827415466,
1.1715617179870605,
0.025370487943291664,
0.5469546318054199,
-0.801990807056427,
0.030461223796010017,
0.043546997010707855,
0.25343504548072815,
0.46236518025398254,
-0.38270461559295654,
-0.205336794257164,
0.21677960455417633,
-0.3026083707809448,
-0.7847802042961121,
0.1246555969119072,
-0.10277850925922394,
0.5564627051353455,
0.3718724548816681,
-0.01244406495243311,
0.5755794644355774,
-0.7343456745147705,
1.0024710893630981,
0.3715824782848358,
-0.9886535406112671,
0.41512331366539,
-0.0691724345088005,
0.2839687168598175,
0.43804624676704407,
0.40422523021698,
-0.6086960434913635,
-0.15458881855010986,
-0.39059916138648987,
-0.7905259728431702,
0.172576442360878,
0.40738922357559204,
0.35759973526000977,
0.4002450704574585,
0.46438345313072205,
-0.11016122996807098,
0.13915517926216125,
-0.6004114747047424,
-0.3871011435985565,
-0.6322351694107056,
0.10048901289701462,
-0.23043711483478546,
0.06477190554141998,
0.12174487113952637,
-0.2934442460536957,
0.3798469305038452,
-0.12286499887704849,
0.25499311089515686,
0.1694055199623108,
-0.13481198251247406,
0.09847014397382736,
0.31469303369522095,
0.5424448251724243,
0.5635425448417664,
0.4554750621318817,
0.2369893342256546,
0.25557124614715576,
-0.44475993514060974,
0.38014039397239685,
-0.12932202219963074,
-0.2978975474834442,
0.10615017265081406,
0.15373669564723969,
0.7755971550941467,
0.7796855568885803,
-0.13190218806266785,
0.2875147759914398,
-0.022821463644504547,
-0.24135832488536835,
-0.15638774633407593,
0.3008382022380829,
0.20013660192489624,
0.38023704290390015,
0.5680632591247559,
0.5578232407569885,
0.30487772822380066,
-0.3820156157016754,
-0.13157568871974945,
0.39105018973350525,
-0.7533380389213562,
-0.3089737296104431,
0.7390182018280029,
0.2887253165245056,
-0.613453209400177,
0.7084506154060364,
0.0979229211807251,
-0.7100229263305664,
0.4662953317165375,
0.14467459917068481,
0.7566881775856018,
-0.33626696467399597,
0.234785258769989,
0.34890151023864746,
0.7781110405921936,
0.083567775785923,
-0.11176245659589767,
-0.24575936794281006,
-0.8229607939720154,
-0.38626566529273987,
-0.5748181939125061,
-0.284795343875885,
-0.1033274456858635,
-0.8100799322128296,
-0.041666220873594284,
-0.49088186025619507,
-0.42664581537246704,
-0.01513688638806343,
-0.18490415811538696,
-0.3802112638950348,
0.2336500585079193,
0.18497557938098907,
0.9046193361282349,
-0.5091915130615234,
0.7022509574890137,
0.7097460031509399,
-0.3544405400753021,
-0.7798810601234436,
0.06486363708972931,
-0.02663862705230713,
-0.5456741452217102,
0.4801205098628998,
0.16074462234973907,
-0.5864551067352295,
-0.06734266132116318,
-0.4044616222381592,
-0.9655082821846008,
1.1750380992889404,
-0.12904705107212067,
-0.5372759699821472,
-0.06023240461945534,
0.28079119324684143,
0.6919060945510864,
-0.2670198976993561,
-0.127475768327713,
0.8698734641075134,
0.6641842722892761,
0.08118317276239395,
-0.665869951248169,
-0.06916137784719467,
-0.1809983253479004,
0.35092872381210327,
0.41817137598991394,
-0.5727956891059875,
0.8358774185180664,
-0.33492526412010193,
-0.38298389315605164,
0.14600251615047455,
0.93585205078125,
-0.3146874010562897,
0.04063970223069191,
0.41830286383628845,
0.23488366603851318,
0.7176958322525024,
-0.44698643684387207,
0.8431292772293091,
-0.20764583349227905,
0.3409028947353363,
0.7386860847473145,
-0.37846046686172485,
0.5323696732521057,
0.43338239192962646,
-0.19975091516971588,
0.672691822052002,
0.38507670164108276,
-0.2443232238292694,
0.4500271677970886,
0.151494562625885,
-0.16800332069396973,
-0.1020202562212944,
0.255384624004364,
-0.31586015224456787,
0.6196918487548828,
0.41771337389945984,
-0.21155968308448792,
-0.43262070417404175,
0.21683508157730103,
0.08422685414552689,
0.17534320056438446,
-0.453548401594162,
0.6632170677185059,
0.4206273853778839,
-0.7574233412742615,
0.33710402250289917,
0.1623021513223648,
0.3924920856952667,
-0.4980534017086029,
-0.015489531680941582,
-0.22186793386936188,
0.17375564575195312,
-0.10462743788957596,
-1.0117175579071045,
0.3936866521835327,
-0.28170332312583923,
0.15405742824077606,
-0.10222256928682327,
0.9104339480400085,
-0.052285876125097275,
-0.40466228127479553,
0.3938908278942108,
0.3951064944267273,
-0.1414351612329483,
-0.07151201367378235,
-0.5595464706420898,
0.06122578680515289,
-0.07521232217550278,
-0.32664889097213745,
-0.070103220641613,
0.4347066283226013,
0.479524701833725,
0.8218863606452942,
0.7770626544952393,
-0.26878103613853455,
0.2310173660516739,
0.08816584944725037,
1.0663201808929443,
-0.7933756113052368,
-0.6678123474121094,
-0.8769519329071045,
0.6332038044929504,
0.016216067597270012,
-0.3460013270378113,
0.693479061126709,
0.4264828860759735,
0.5348630547523499,
0.11637745052576065,
0.6351189613342285,
0.2196975201368332,
0.28025537729263306,
-0.5981805920600891,
1.0085253715515137,
-0.43496572971343994,
0.30214598774909973,
-0.09203959256410599,
-1.0419851541519165,
-0.5525263547897339,
0.7297883629798889,
-0.26797717809677124,
0.10248996317386627,
0.700344443321228,
0.6290686130523682,
-0.2355380803346634,
0.44930270314216614,
0.2373645305633545,
0.1648225486278534,
0.45717471837997437,
0.6050112247467041,
0.9972267746925354,
-0.7573015093803406,
0.6847638487815857,
-0.102268286049366,
0.1692504584789276,
-0.20295068621635437,
-0.9068970680236816,
-0.7472499012947083,
-0.8898647427558899,
0.13064800202846527,
-0.2765211760997772,
-0.32726383209228516,
0.36259445548057556,
0.5844757556915283,
-0.6499733328819275,
-0.23749437928199768,
-0.12740042805671692,
0.20036505162715912,
0.0031260456889867783,
-0.12215905636548996,
-0.11301614344120026,
-0.17880284786224365,
-0.4443374574184418,
0.7418842315673828,
0.68146812915802,
0.00837271474301815,
-0.6367944478988647,
-0.15007145702838898,
-0.10584572702646255,
0.1254255622625351,
0.7319393754005432,
0.37214159965515137,
-0.5957514047622681,
-0.10079851746559143,
0.2755286693572998,
0.03107302077114582,
0.39458584785461426,
1.1778825521469116,
-0.9892639517784119,
0.25970807671546936,
0.17949579656124115,
0.9713283181190491,
0.3809082806110382,
-0.2816724181175232,
0.7488970756530762,
-0.3856452405452728,
0.0356164313852787,
0.3243696689605713,
0.45339062809944153,
0.5038906335830688,
-0.19717563688755035,
0.5113914608955383,
-0.05348828434944153,
-0.3855687975883484,
-0.7068238258361816,
0.3460003137588501,
-0.9749974012374878,
-0.3235456049442291,
0.8515008687973022,
0.19697386026382446,
-0.25478503108024597,
-0.14348000288009644,
-0.20770025253295898,
0.29213395714759827,
-0.15625038743019104,
0.5127007365226746,
0.6865082383155823,
-0.005718631204217672,
-0.13882087171077728,
-0.32618340849876404,
0.2621212601661682,
0.27965715527534485,
-0.39409512281417847,
-0.2367335706949234,
0.2588585615158081,
-0.0425858199596405,
0.5812584757804871,
0.08120445907115936,
-0.12262116372585297,
-0.09750882536172867,
-0.12245449423789978,
-0.25042641162872314,
-0.1621781438589096,
-0.6618046164512634,
-0.6782875657081604,
0.231787770986557,
-0.34079423546791077,
-0.050961531698703766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16714v1 | AutoDetect: Towards a Unified Framework for Automated Weakness Detection in Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T15:16:45 | 2024-06-24T15:16:45 | Jiale Cheng, Yida Lu, Xiaotao Gu, Pei Ke, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Hongning Wang, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Although Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly powerful,
they still exhibit significant but subtle weaknesses, such as mistakes in
instruction-following or coding tasks. As these unexpected errors could lead to
severe consequences in practical deployments, it is crucial to investigate the
limitations within LLMs systematically. Traditional benchmarking approaches
cannot thoroughly pinpoint specific model deficiencies, while manual
inspections are costly and not scalable. In this paper, we introduce a unified
framework, AutoDetect, to automatically expose weaknesses in LLMs across
various tasks. Inspired by the educational assessment process that measures
students' learning outcomes, AutoDetect consists of three LLM-powered agents:
Examiner, Questioner, and Assessor. The collaboration among these three agents
is designed to realize comprehensive and in-depth weakness identification. Our
framework demonstrates significant success in uncovering flaws, with an
identification success rate exceeding 30% in prominent models such as ChatGPT
and Claude. More importantly, these identified weaknesses can guide specific
model improvements, proving more effective than untargeted data augmentation
methods like Self-Instruct. Our approach has led to substantial enhancements in
popular LLMs, including the Llama series and Mistral-7b, boosting their
performance by over 10% across several benchmarks. Code and data are publicly
available at https://github.com/thu-coai/AutoDetect. | [
-0.34415996074676514,
-0.5959596037864685,
0.6599908471107483,
0.17373144626617432,
0.24563658237457275,
0.2302655130624771,
-0.06298179924488068,
-0.3518725335597992,
-0.05933268368244171,
0.36855846643447876,
-0.45932871103286743,
-0.42193901538848877,
-0.7144598364830017,
0.07856499403715134,
-0.6617556214332581,
0.6746357083320618,
-0.33787140250205994,
-0.17947986721992493,
-0.22481797635555267,
-0.012708275578916073,
-0.5913709998130798,
-0.4169607162475586,
-0.3886948525905609,
-0.18728768825531006,
0.070455402135849,
0.609329342842102,
0.5274149775505066,
0.6031500697135925,
0.6355789303779602,
0.4591831862926483,
0.4914175570011139,
0.07101711630821228,
-0.15627749264240265,
0.33579444885253906,
-0.2908867597579956,
-0.21043728291988373,
-0.6999548077583313,
-0.33889439702033997,
0.5589298605918884,
0.51377934217453,
0.08221706748008728,
0.12881919741630554,
0.40597033500671387,
0.4711596965789795,
-0.8026678562164307,
0.3517264127731323,
-0.7128214240074158,
-0.0009234642493538558,
-0.3099808692932129,
0.1708276867866516,
-0.11051079630851746,
-0.004519161302596331,
-0.16402676701545715,
-0.1332608163356781,
0.2631951868534088,
-0.22604329884052277,
0.7735853791236877,
0.8139517307281494,
-0.46342140436172485,
-0.09593454748392105,
-0.4638916850090027,
0.6953452229499817,
-0.737838864326477,
0.251559317111969,
0.20823664963245392,
0.408338725566864,
-0.30878201127052307,
-0.4766247272491455,
-0.47955867648124695,
-0.32760193943977356,
0.02187265455722809,
0.051745910197496414,
-0.3737076222896576,
-0.020681072026491165,
0.048315152525901794,
0.42774301767349243,
-0.832395076751709,
0.406597375869751,
0.25020337104797363,
-0.4276835322380066,
0.678769588470459,
0.371962308883667,
0.5044488310813904,
0.023135244846343994,
-0.22290754318237305,
-0.26827743649482727,
-0.6738137602806091,
-0.23403356969356537,
0.4161485731601715,
0.12446696311235428,
0.11765332520008087,
0.39689669013023376,
-0.147714763879776,
0.5010793209075928,
-0.0842680037021637,
0.08976040035486221,
0.12873199582099915,
-0.19736544787883759,
-0.18926340341567993,
-0.1972365528345108,
0.8439390659332275,
-0.03675658628344536,
0.12978753447532654,
0.0743301585316658,
-0.7098070979118347,
0.18698856234550476,
0.07384124398231506,
-0.6900085806846619,
-0.4210645854473114,
0.1500275880098343,
-0.12079431861639023,
-0.5367844700813293,
0.11173717677593231,
-0.705615222454071,
-0.5859382748603821,
-0.20335160195827484,
0.5320519804954529,
-0.2883276045322418,
-0.3668525815010071,
0.12446300685405731,
0.23157073557376862,
0.07922004908323288,
0.06977031379938126,
-0.9235801100730896,
0.3533363938331604,
0.5913958549499512,
0.5311906337738037,
-0.3113180696964264,
-0.6242213845252991,
-0.3973677456378937,
0.07677005231380463,
-0.28201547265052795,
1.0584756135940552,
-0.14595408737659454,
-0.18284019827842712,
-0.2934836745262146,
0.08903706818819046,
-0.28450143337249756,
-0.5923562049865723,
0.33290013670921326,
-0.037530284374952316,
-0.29271212220191956,
0.10763084888458252,
-0.49521172046661377,
0.21504758298397064,
0.37724214792251587,
-0.7004384398460388,
1.1015571355819702,
0.3654918670654297,
-0.7350658774375916,
-0.000056679164117667824,
-0.5335429906845093,
-0.31098034977912903,
-0.019697610288858414,
-0.25887882709503174,
-0.6968660354614258,
-0.06131810322403908,
0.42040249705314636,
0.5117985010147095,
-0.49321237206459045,
0.3061647117137909,
-0.5051590800285339,
-0.20929822325706482,
0.18452270328998566,
-0.7435088753700256,
0.76652592420578,
-0.08293364197015762,
-0.73946613073349,
0.15731924772262573,
-0.9771122336387634,
0.06306541711091995,
0.35816100239753723,
-0.14676441252231598,
-0.26991787552833557,
0.056568946689367294,
0.007551886141300201,
0.007261489983648062,
0.2871870994567871,
-0.35163187980651855,
0.15582233667373657,
-0.4331834614276886,
0.12744179368019104,
0.9500206708908081,
-0.06648987531661987,
0.20868034660816193,
-0.19454504549503326,
0.676188588142395,
0.02522893436253071,
0.41040077805519104,
-0.13695186376571655,
-0.04809926822781563,
-0.9242172837257385,
-0.23228295147418976,
0.11054955422878265,
0.6558760404586792,
-0.6056841611862183,
0.6938039064407349,
-0.04180692136287689,
-0.5075786709785461,
-0.452298641204834,
0.5526336431503296,
0.5831325650215149,
0.42028650641441345,
0.2034272402524948,
-0.46067169308662415,
-0.4611486792564392,
-0.9264405965805054,
-0.2523218095302582,
-0.4565400779247284,
-0.16232553124427795,
0.0061818817630410194,
0.5995120406150818,
-0.6747003793716431,
0.7218106985092163,
-0.3450653851032257,
-0.4885495603084564,
-0.33589884638786316,
-0.019854886457324028,
-0.1505345106124878,
0.44864422082901,
0.5428038239479065,
-0.4660990834236145,
-0.5813454389572144,
-0.06891513615846634,
-0.761722207069397,
-0.6010433435440063,
0.02049824222922325,
0.21509742736816406,
0.4460885524749756,
0.47452133893966675,
-0.14809569716453552,
0.40817990899086,
0.6976086497306824,
-0.4405386745929718,
0.6911917328834534,
-0.11472970247268677,
-0.22044432163238525,
-0.9164496064186096,
-0.1691001057624817,
-0.14504548907279968,
-0.004029134288430214,
-0.2828998863697052,
0.0006993436254560947,
0.1580040454864502,
0.17026472091674805,
-0.0024839022662490606,
0.5651838779449463,
-0.5450594425201416,
-0.1919061690568924,
-0.30468273162841797,
-0.03990430757403374,
0.09526309370994568,
0.1848325878381729,
-0.343360960483551,
0.7622721195220947,
0.7341405749320984,
-0.34994953870773315,
0.5628233551979065,
0.021495459601283073,
-0.10712109506130219,
0.6964795589447021,
-0.645191490650177,
0.09578239172697067,
0.216932013630867,
0.11486484855413437,
-0.9804314970970154,
-0.5247301459312439,
0.23046164214611053,
-0.354737251996994,
0.32690510153770447,
-0.2482861876487732,
-0.615757167339325,
-0.38813069462776184,
-0.3078250288963318,
0.24416646361351013,
-0.0002596572448965162,
-0.7916443943977356,
0.6551005840301514,
0.4084468185901642,
-0.16486595571041107,
-0.7066080570220947,
-0.3834581673145294,
0.34491947293281555,
-0.20722314715385437,
-0.651954174041748,
0.030725330114364624,
-0.29649627208709717,
-0.29831933975219727,
-0.19601072371006012,
-0.15110301971435547,
-0.2703288793563843,
0.5988735556602478,
0.4765982925891876,
0.3555026948451996,
-0.226525217294693,
0.23109276592731476,
-0.09357217699289322,
-0.3119898736476898,
0.11278127878904343,
-0.25791651010513306,
0.4205615520477295,
-0.6365838646888733,
-0.9464857578277588,
-0.2455170899629593,
0.11957713961601257,
0.6870403289794922,
-0.3072758913040161,
0.10690541565418243,
0.5261249542236328,
-0.1798727661371231,
-0.6617245674133301,
-0.6092947721481323,
-0.23394541442394257,
-0.5203461647033691,
0.4983929991722107,
-0.43234783411026,
-0.5665284991264343,
0.5128253698348999,
-0.022165808826684952,
-0.10371586680412292,
0.3449397087097168,
0.4218248426914215,
0.21687185764312744,
1.1453310251235962,
0.7950003743171692,
-0.6716441512107849,
0.20836268365383148,
-0.178953617811203,
0.1013149544596672,
-0.5311590433120728,
0.05851482227444649,
-0.38806599378585815,
0.13389012217521667,
-0.31531772017478943,
-0.10262599587440491,
0.3028327226638794,
-0.12972798943519592,
-0.2074681520462036,
0.548038125038147,
-0.448706716299057,
0.6305071711540222,
0.20733489096164703,
-0.3183593153953552,
0.35982558131217957,
-0.2325020730495453,
-0.20172546803951263,
0.0063288831152021885,
-0.6390095353126526,
-0.5919638276100159,
1.1935418844223022,
0.6277194023132324,
0.9256010055541992,
0.13315317034721375,
0.9842284917831421,
0.15613754093647003,
0.47515520453453064,
-0.7070159316062927,
0.4664492607116699,
0.1256324201822281,
-0.3813980221748352,
-0.47486647963523865,
-0.4188946783542633,
-0.8443357944488525,
0.16021810472011566,
0.13957542181015015,
-0.4673515558242798,
0.3111002743244171,
0.23307213187217712,
-0.18040934205055237,
0.36991143226623535,
-0.7659525275230408,
1.058627963066101,
-0.5392308831214905,
-0.3358803391456604,
0.22114932537078857,
-0.3619077503681183,
0.40042778849601746,
-0.5602340698242188,
0.18640059232711792,
-0.14515990018844604,
0.11188845336437225,
0.44972342252731323,
-0.5384277701377869,
1.0821856260299683,
0.026390811428427696,
-0.5398890972137451,
0.12236770987510681,
0.30094584822654724,
0.6107511520385742,
0.056356050074100494,
0.1005980372428894,
-0.08132366091012955,
0.09502509981393814,
-0.31085488200187683,
-0.5028819441795349,
0.702476978302002,
-0.4991350769996643,
-0.470814049243927,
-0.43879467248916626,
-0.5532387495040894,
-0.295043021440506,
0.2763606905937195,
0.0935479924082756,
0.31211668252944946,
-0.5482956767082214,
-0.21345095336437225,
0.5536860227584839,
-0.1629628837108612,
0.6805053353309631,
0.9284465312957764,
-0.04023876413702965,
-0.0687217116355896,
1.133918046951294,
0.030055256560444832,
0.3417225778102875,
-0.10113352537155151,
-0.0059111882001161575,
0.00210250704549253,
-0.7259269952774048,
-0.3877200782299042,
0.0055942051112651825,
-0.8527154326438904,
-0.4831937551498413,
-0.37021365761756897,
-0.23946796357631683,
-0.5834704041481018,
0.011560200713574886,
-0.7852051854133606,
-0.23555397987365723,
-0.05945606902241707,
-0.1047770082950592,
0.07171229273080826,
0.8461562395095825,
-0.32813817262649536,
0.2955244183540344,
-0.59475177526474,
0.1643262654542923,
0.5908228754997253,
0.37210336327552795,
0.027223916724324226,
-0.4682490825653076,
-0.08663755655288696,
-0.4382135272026062,
-0.4801754951477051,
-0.5645967721939087,
0.6794664263725281,
0.1532803326845169,
0.4787754714488983,
0.48644089698791504,
0.19510672986507416,
0.41745099425315857,
-0.3748694062232971,
0.3206789493560791,
-0.07067994028329849,
-0.96784907579422,
0.504824161529541,
-0.19124458730220795,
0.11635662615299225,
0.6277324557304382,
0.030662065371870995,
-0.23447668552398682,
-0.8895822167396545,
-0.7226076126098633,
-1.0518269538879395,
0.36078861355781555,
0.07562168687582016,
-0.09597570449113846,
-0.04865140840411186,
0.02596188522875309,
-0.10981681197881699,
-0.19046279788017273,
-0.8101562857627869,
-0.06486144661903381,
-0.1791403889656067,
-0.35971227288246155,
0.015368073247373104,
-0.10436101257801056,
-0.15203221142292023,
-0.11168475449085236,
0.6876983046531677,
-0.38343846797943115,
0.053596433252096176,
0.14650243520736694,
-0.6207315921783447,
-0.05580643564462662,
0.3237084150314331,
0.1356566846370697,
0.623348593711853,
-0.13810506463050842,
0.4026168882846832,
0.2487904280424118,
-0.45061683654785156,
0.32071852684020996,
0.30815595388412476,
0.02373572066426277,
0.07441854476928711,
0.6829277276992798,
0.32486721873283386,
0.2427203208208084,
-0.8701984286308289,
0.7981228828430176,
-0.03555963933467865,
0.14170688390731812,
-0.6610427498817444,
0.25072231888771057,
-0.14324884116649628,
0.4222555160522461,
0.22970488667488098,
-0.3095850646495819,
0.23233191668987274,
-0.5192190408706665,
0.45272672176361084,
0.5165548920631409,
-0.4927045702934265,
-0.2578553557395935,
0.4325159788131714,
-0.03213566169142723,
-0.1529775857925415,
0.33244583010673523,
-0.18210674822330475,
-0.7738955616950989,
1.0849934816360474,
0.4760427474975586,
1.091202735900879,
-0.7815667390823364,
0.14771777391433716,
0.1276235580444336,
0.5868843197822571,
-0.21422018110752106,
0.07187630236148834,
0.141400545835495,
-0.8330722451210022,
-0.14500722289085388,
-0.47246918082237244,
-0.4445074200630188,
0.07705733925104141,
-0.4670017957687378,
0.18397735059261322,
-0.43131864070892334,
0.15348771214485168,
-0.016292348504066467,
-0.14736153185367584,
-0.39189231395721436,
0.08963692933320999,
0.016007503494620323,
0.5068747401237488,
-1.005224585533142,
0.9372676014900208,
0.3475700318813324,
-0.5328737497329712,
-0.8813164234161377,
0.16898371279239655,
0.3433510959148407,
-0.852910041809082,
0.743254542350769,
0.10292942821979523,
-0.21294954419136047,
0.0553930401802063,
-0.44677889347076416,
-0.733643651008606,
1.1285700798034668,
0.3881305456161499,
-0.6888225078582764,
0.13501529395580292,
0.2757464647293091,
0.44961652159690857,
-0.4127287268638611,
0.33973729610443115,
0.841586709022522,
0.6425611972808838,
-0.338983952999115,
-1.0622453689575195,
0.17704206705093384,
-0.20844517648220062,
-0.2028351128101349,
0.2620031237602234,
-0.5046283006668091,
0.6904314756393433,
-0.12448224425315857,
-0.15864720940589905,
0.06110009178519249,
0.219904825091362,
0.11059873551130295,
0.38542914390563965,
0.7180014252662659,
0.5544100403785706,
0.615592360496521,
0.02654443494975567,
0.8890355229377747,
-0.20374025404453278,
0.29390373826026917,
1.1043540239334106,
-0.418560266494751,
0.5631932616233826,
0.20163479447364807,
-0.07834938168525696,
0.28471195697784424,
0.3081376552581787,
-0.3385448753833771,
0.19773165881633759,
0.34390538930892944,
-0.30000582337379456,
-0.29274609684944153,
0.220566987991333,
-0.2091926485300064,
0.489818811416626,
0.3011183738708496,
-0.20629900693893433,
-0.46001937985420227,
0.14547644555568695,
0.03179510310292244,
0.06594783812761307,
-0.1651063710451126,
0.7078649401664734,
0.12240403145551682,
-0.47596973180770874,
0.8748564720153809,
-0.03348052501678467,
0.5064680576324463,
-0.49268612265586853,
-0.0362003892660141,
-0.4687785804271698,
0.556951642036438,
-0.1643049567937851,
-0.5568571090698242,
0.31688591837882996,
-0.02398649789392948,
0.07716801762580872,
-0.1633887141942978,
0.9823170900344849,
-0.17936058342456818,
-0.4145001471042633,
0.6948482990264893,
0.4528641700744629,
0.09077100455760956,
-0.30732104182243347,
-0.7215179800987244,
0.20352239906787872,
-0.18498720228672028,
-0.174745112657547,
0.4936017096042633,
0.5602762699127197,
-0.23077687621116638,
0.8884484171867371,
0.38109099864959717,
-0.04842789098620415,
-0.17926330864429474,
0.18219146132469177,
0.9393075108528137,
-0.47215962409973145,
0.0027316338382661343,
-0.9333580732345581,
0.2877497673034668,
-0.08773083984851837,
-0.05298973619937897,
0.90056973695755,
0.4532819092273712,
0.6723208427429199,
0.05266985297203064,
0.8670908808708191,
0.17394061386585236,
0.5777907371520996,
-0.23811782896518707,
0.8056219816207886,
-0.442509263753891,
0.7952723503112793,
-0.45199301838874817,
-0.9639783501625061,
-0.38411372900009155,
0.48831093311309814,
-0.13972941040992737,
-0.18579092621803284,
0.7404947280883789,
1.1306509971618652,
-0.1837802529335022,
-0.6299063563346863,
0.3622998595237732,
0.3674522042274475,
0.3819912374019623,
0.859937846660614,
0.8971046805381775,
-0.4620254337787628,
0.8132018446922302,
-0.20076559484004974,
-0.32131442427635193,
-0.2226555049419403,
-0.7197775840759277,
-1.0185118913650513,
-0.39707523584365845,
-0.472010999917984,
-0.329446941614151,
0.1687389314174652,
0.6796364784240723,
0.3348030745983124,
-0.8785458207130432,
-0.2893272638320923,
-0.3264950215816498,
0.30537840723991394,
-0.05371253564953804,
-0.2238406389951706,
0.5075241327285767,
-0.5796019434928894,
-0.4891243577003479,
0.6987159848213196,
0.3133334219455719,
0.28354448080062866,
-0.5328801274299622,
-0.010835220105946064,
0.30615150928497314,
0.14938463270664215,
0.3101584017276764,
0.6034634113311768,
-0.43992623686790466,
-0.35800525546073914,
-0.19610576331615448,
-0.24040065705776215,
-0.18646468222141266,
0.604771077632904,
-0.5353409051895142,
0.32935360074043274,
0.2288171797990799,
0.7623836994171143,
0.1455097198486328,
-0.38399046659469604,
0.6472876071929932,
-0.5458524823188782,
0.06341984122991562,
0.2963067591190338,
0.41895341873168945,
0.35202398896217346,
-0.197340726852417,
0.6297652721405029,
0.28243473172187805,
-0.596206545829773,
-1.1515614986419678,
0.34768930077552795,
-0.6398971080780029,
-0.4004904329776764,
0.9020556807518005,
-0.22513096034526825,
-0.15178386867046356,
-0.366668164730072,
-0.012727892026305199,
-0.03972863778471947,
0.10209907591342926,
1.1790385246276855,
0.569275438785553,
0.27571260929107666,
-0.059628572314977646,
-0.7040510177612305,
0.47038695216178894,
0.5663642287254333,
-0.996235191822052,
0.2754282057285309,
0.5119170546531677,
0.5302161574363708,
-0.11378185451030731,
0.44341081380844116,
-0.21226705610752106,
0.2230524867773056,
-0.14159542322158813,
0.37585872411727905,
-0.17809300124645233,
-0.44705528020858765,
-0.6170210838317871,
-0.12497729808092117,
0.18943433463573456,
0.10514993220567703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16694v1 | Task Oriented In-Domain Data Augmentation | 2024-06-24T14:58:11 | 2024-06-24T14:58:11 | Xiao Liang, Xinyu Hu, Simiao Zuo, Yeyun Gong, Qiang Lou, Yi Liu, Shao-Lun Huang, Jian Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior performance in various
applications and fields. To achieve better performance on specialized domains
such as law and advertisement, LLMs are often continue pre-trained on in-domain
data. However, existing approaches suffer from two major issues. First,
in-domain data are scarce compared with general domain-agnostic data. Second,
data used for continual pre-training are not task-aware, such that they may not
be helpful to downstream applications. We propose TRAIT, a task-oriented
in-domain data augmentation framework. Our framework is divided into two parts:
in-domain data selection and task-oriented synthetic passage generation. The
data selection strategy identifies and selects a large amount of in-domain data
from general corpora, and thus significantly enriches domain knowledge in the
continual pre-training data. The synthetic passages contain guidance on how to
use domain knowledge to answer questions about downstream tasks. By training on
such passages, the model aligns with the need of downstream applications. We
adapt LLMs to two domains: advertisement and math. On average, TRAIT improves
LLM performance by 8% in the advertisement domain and 7.5% in the math domain. | [
-0.17795586585998535,
-0.7891323566436768,
0.6187714338302612,
0.3739875853061676,
-0.08970881998538971,
0.25698527693748474,
-0.3667805790901184,
-0.5787867903709412,
0.11357923597097397,
0.6655728816986084,
-0.7152909636497498,
-0.33879557251930237,
-0.5068500638008118,
0.0915021300315857,
-0.142670139670372,
0.9047672152519226,
0.017758993431925774,
0.18128257989883423,
-0.8234327435493469,
-0.12271783500909805,
-0.3955228626728058,
-0.8901718854904175,
-0.727273166179657,
-0.3018058240413666,
0.22521619498729706,
0.39007845520973206,
0.4511907398700714,
0.42852771282196045,
0.3219354450702667,
0.30304625630378723,
0.2515657842159271,
0.5270570516586304,
-0.6523162722587585,
0.3366566598415375,
-0.3492427170276642,
-0.35647261142730713,
-0.7526407837867737,
-0.07310406118631363,
0.551883339881897,
1.0095106363296509,
0.5145869851112366,
-0.08249958604574203,
0.215450718998909,
0.6790350079536438,
-0.3504316806793213,
0.32110530138015747,
-0.5766803622245789,
-0.2714717388153076,
-0.3624626398086548,
-0.32384946942329407,
-0.23349225521087646,
-0.34161460399627686,
0.25841817259788513,
-0.730934202671051,
0.2996285855770111,
0.10827642679214478,
0.708103597164154,
0.09672713279724121,
-0.4342136085033417,
-0.09758682548999786,
-0.5197128057479858,
0.9633968472480774,
-0.58382648229599,
0.37556102871894836,
0.6381295323371887,
-0.0120297996327281,
-0.40019455552101135,
-0.5153650045394897,
-0.5992534160614014,
-0.12840598821640015,
-0.13666798174381256,
-0.15200009942054749,
0.08054538816213608,
-0.005743933841586113,
0.17396186292171478,
0.4873906373977661,
-0.6988189816474915,
0.11848480254411697,
-0.09106770902872086,
-0.20154042541980743,
0.6879152655601501,
0.3192199468612671,
0.08007386326789856,
0.07779932022094727,
-0.2782617509365082,
-0.23765209317207336,
-1.025667667388916,
0.17678596079349518,
0.4112336337566376,
0.49568232893943787,
0.07938385009765625,
0.6110266447067261,
-0.22604167461395264,
0.89142906665802,
0.22048988938331604,
-0.09562356024980545,
0.3652378022670746,
-0.20057730376720428,
-0.24978668987751007,
-0.3718164265155792,
0.4744582772254944,
-0.03429795801639557,
0.03586404025554657,
-0.2970430552959442,
-0.3799414038658142,
0.19298216700553894,
0.3745206296443939,
-0.884333074092865,
0.07456058263778687,
0.40926679968833923,
-0.14763958752155304,
-0.1697942614555359,
-0.15613053739070892,
-0.45169544219970703,
-0.22037263214588165,
-0.6728118658065796,
0.3747420907020569,
-0.674909234046936,
-0.04866144061088562,
0.0682944729924202,
0.15701837837696075,
0.1248963251709938,
0.34190818667411804,
-0.9234347343444824,
0.2909763753414154,
0.8598910570144653,
0.45392853021621704,
-0.6128295063972473,
-0.10951854288578033,
-0.7842381596565247,
0.16740794479846954,
-0.14968588948249817,
0.7168875336647034,
-0.9248120188713074,
-0.41777586936950684,
0.062463805079460144,
0.23271621763706207,
-0.31196433305740356,
-0.6733917593955994,
0.5798438787460327,
-0.7959394454956055,
0.03423263132572174,
-0.17726747691631317,
-0.9275149703025818,
-0.22407548129558563,
0.24212424457073212,
-0.6625566482543945,
1.2075576782226562,
0.6807515621185303,
-0.31328800320625305,
0.5793176889419556,
-0.7109674215316772,
-0.8456527590751648,
0.2242063283920288,
-0.2200925052165985,
-0.47332242131233215,
0.06851238757371902,
0.3956674337387085,
0.526789128780365,
-0.3015982508659363,
0.3199285864830017,
-0.3242522180080414,
-0.36819955706596375,
0.3758698105812073,
-0.05502142757177353,
0.5705828666687012,
0.14122535288333893,
-0.1693783849477768,
-0.04445550963282585,
-0.6660717725753784,
0.008824309334158897,
-0.05758203566074371,
-0.4017854630947113,
-0.48052534461021423,
0.053118471056222916,
0.14601898193359375,
0.20595748722553253,
0.31453824043273926,
-0.7530596256256104,
0.3290887475013733,
-0.39702269434928894,
0.17547230422496796,
0.773463249206543,
-0.23476947844028473,
0.5676761865615845,
-0.43760135769844055,
0.5835059881210327,
0.08488043397665024,
0.06144918501377106,
0.12750960886478424,
-0.3834412097930908,
-0.7755007743835449,
-0.4175313711166382,
0.10103929042816162,
0.37555167078971863,
-0.952754557132721,
0.5356399416923523,
-0.5055571794509888,
-0.049205321818590164,
-0.32382988929748535,
0.3394947648048401,
0.2158244401216507,
0.45018309354782104,
0.33301693201065063,
-0.412678986787796,
-0.49360525608062744,
-0.6074039340019226,
-0.1559298038482666,
0.015750087797641754,
-0.035438165068626404,
0.4552237093448639,
0.21647454798221588,
-0.4060097336769104,
1.0577807426452637,
-0.601794958114624,
-0.3775368928909302,
-0.5348279476165771,
0.04954790323972702,
0.37181252241134644,
0.4791099429130554,
0.6093487739562988,
-0.8631748557090759,
-0.4892237186431885,
0.02378065511584282,
-0.6430266499519348,
-0.09856025129556656,
-0.0215295497328043,
-0.39174792170524597,
0.07275062799453735,
0.18783120810985565,
-0.45904913544654846,
0.16995149850845337,
0.47710302472114563,
-0.40183302760124207,
0.4792472720146179,
-0.03290992230176926,
0.1832643300294876,
-0.8532302975654602,
-0.07810097932815552,
0.1727454662322998,
-0.5304011702537537,
-0.8821157813072205,
0.04917645826935768,
0.035396233201026917,
-0.2290874719619751,
-0.23127245903015137,
0.7660031318664551,
-0.2014910876750946,
-0.026292115449905396,
-0.5337739586830139,
-0.24761152267456055,
0.21940164268016815,
0.7013612389564514,
0.28305166959762573,
0.98405921459198,
0.8451035618782043,
-0.935030996799469,
0.313558965921402,
0.5056506395339966,
-0.34764498472213745,
0.8202009797096252,
-0.27891966700553894,
0.27134737372398376,
-0.08698435127735138,
0.09737332165241241,
-0.5051668286323547,
-0.3082572817802429,
-0.0045998357236385345,
-0.3278183341026306,
0.46968773007392883,
-0.01728697121143341,
-0.4550185799598694,
-0.25169140100479126,
-0.1275249421596527,
0.4451354146003723,
0.3592199385166168,
-0.7091299295425415,
0.7244313955307007,
0.42548668384552,
-0.357295423746109,
-0.2772226333618164,
-0.5003946423530579,
-0.051822010427713394,
-0.16057492792606354,
-0.7752656936645508,
0.5701366662979126,
-0.024487994611263275,
0.04949968308210373,
0.004819904919713736,
-0.027940601110458374,
-0.21254754066467285,
-0.2948964536190033,
0.2004082202911377,
0.5125772356987,
-0.09523605555295944,
0.21298538148403168,
0.05293935164809227,
0.16941732168197632,
0.054710082709789276,
-0.5999051928520203,
0.29603177309036255,
0.29405638575553894,
-0.31890934705734253,
-0.049928534775972366,
0.49251335859298706,
0.34542176127433777,
-0.1373603641986847,
0.5486106276512146,
0.31670311093330383,
-0.005653779488056898,
-0.6108822822570801,
-0.4497933089733124,
-0.18004322052001953,
-0.5224841237068176,
0.4122966527938843,
-0.4365485906600952,
-1.1681421995162964,
0.06595427542924881,
-0.18419477343559265,
0.03005591593682766,
0.18699254095554352,
0.33760419487953186,
-0.22845378518104553,
0.787555992603302,
0.9767889380455017,
-0.2791178822517395,
0.5393004417419434,
-0.44295534491539,
0.3176555037498474,
-0.8942040801048279,
-0.0724940076470375,
-0.16746099293231964,
-0.2414645105600357,
-0.27534693479537964,
-0.736936628818512,
0.5473209619522095,
-0.26852351427078247,
-0.137797549366951,
0.49912500381469727,
-0.09041484445333481,
-0.03588652238249779,
0.33670809864997864,
0.3426748514175415,
0.1504182666540146,
0.336044043302536,
0.22431382536888123,
-0.17118437588214874,
-0.5718206167221069,
-0.3003353178501129,
1.4129817485809326,
0.1761067807674408,
0.8580402135848999,
0.02724832110106945,
0.3005194067955017,
0.4218973219394684,
0.4179529845714569,
-0.738237738609314,
0.6407490372657776,
-0.5779199600219727,
-0.4252666234970093,
-0.3587130606174469,
-0.5032134056091309,
-0.5577167272567749,
0.09519051015377045,
-0.1761355996131897,
-0.40821927785873413,
0.32947733998298645,
0.26757311820983887,
-0.15668468177318573,
0.08711566030979156,
-0.3230132460594177,
0.5645313262939453,
-0.32030394673347473,
-0.7045691609382629,
-0.25591495633125305,
-0.23716726899147034,
0.24974919855594635,
-0.4765171408653259,
0.03105710633099079,
0.007979887537658215,
0.20855988562107086,
0.40940558910369873,
-0.6676493287086487,
0.7848947644233704,
-0.17605875432491302,
-0.05848386883735657,
0.24406521022319794,
-0.1805042177438736,
1.0196337699890137,
-0.12437529116868973,
-0.28576770424842834,
-0.2783318758010864,
-0.4908246397972107,
-0.451378732919693,
-0.7496472001075745,
0.6776129007339478,
-0.5143758058547974,
-0.5791147351264954,
-0.19500499963760376,
-0.8032402992248535,
-0.9347682595252991,
-0.2777312994003296,
-0.022258730605244637,
0.6397051811218262,
-0.24023154377937317,
-0.006557616405189037,
0.7626797556877136,
-0.218505859375,
0.1608283370733261,
0.6432916522026062,
0.11633263528347015,
-0.09056849777698517,
1.1832693815231323,
-0.5134375095367432,
0.39089784026145935,
0.5214410424232483,
-0.1533898413181305,
-0.6025932431221008,
-0.40896841883659363,
-0.39767712354660034,
0.17195618152618408,
-0.625385582447052,
-0.16229303181171417,
-0.727453351020813,
-0.1754714846611023,
-0.49320322275161743,
-0.12982355058193207,
-0.07586569339036942,
-0.299980491399765,
-0.26940643787384033,
-0.016589095816016197,
0.7056156992912292,
0.4315398633480072,
0.23754461109638214,
0.3331618010997772,
-0.6355891227722168,
0.33087390661239624,
0.36013567447662354,
0.26893705129623413,
-0.35452619194984436,
-0.6157317757606506,
-0.514613151550293,
0.07515695691108704,
-0.2771835923194885,
-0.326834499835968,
0.4762086868286133,
0.5136765241622925,
0.5553364157676697,
0.26038089394569397,
-0.17330718040466309,
0.6354305148124695,
-0.3368290960788727,
0.5553317666053772,
-0.062418948858976364,
-0.7445557117462158,
0.25988417863845825,
-0.254637211561203,
0.01937856897711754,
0.4734346270561218,
0.3502560555934906,
-0.14733663201332092,
-0.6897274851799011,
-0.21801723539829254,
-0.7970730066299438,
0.6842464804649353,
0.20302455127239227,
0.33108627796173096,
0.19529572129249573,
0.27039438486099243,
0.42238518595695496,
0.36614125967025757,
-0.46763885021209717,
-0.11558936536312103,
-0.17470744252204895,
-0.11868155747652054,
-0.14205819368362427,
0.042712852358818054,
0.05441673472523689,
-0.546977698802948,
0.7956043481826782,
-0.4803032875061035,
0.2757762372493744,
-0.025318609550595284,
-0.41941457986831665,
-0.021305426955223083,
0.256657212972641,
0.19206532835960388,
0.7897290587425232,
-0.13888593018054962,
-0.185418039560318,
-0.14102527499198914,
-0.734370768070221,
0.2509274482727051,
0.27342432737350464,
-0.18777363002300262,
-0.10160685330629349,
0.21558311581611633,
1.0090274810791016,
0.08297581970691681,
-0.7279560565948486,
0.5334879159927368,
0.3843490481376648,
-0.21773141622543335,
-0.14159956574440002,
0.1321260631084442,
-0.2310357242822647,
0.2254236340522766,
0.41218575835227966,
-0.04359643906354904,
0.01987643912434578,
-0.6417568325996399,
0.2931433320045471,
0.5379996299743652,
-0.12883256375789642,
-0.3405002951622009,
0.6912527084350586,
0.22095824778079987,
0.40641871094703674,
0.43856966495513916,
-0.2563256025314331,
-0.5318798422813416,
0.44221052527427673,
0.6548686623573303,
0.8626071810722351,
-0.04410626366734505,
0.3028596043586731,
0.1720414012670517,
-0.1657671481370926,
0.06998845189809799,
0.6024284958839417,
-0.00033507440821267664,
-0.7850294709205627,
-0.8592405319213867,
-0.8473173975944519,
-0.27093204855918884,
0.4230618476867676,
-0.31172502040863037,
0.04817688465118408,
-0.14728230237960815,
-0.2564511001110077,
-0.17634285986423492,
-0.0010882050264626741,
-0.9418256878852844,
0.5361294746398926,
-0.2328256070613861,
0.723532497882843,
-0.7437945008277893,
1.1947860717773438,
0.777938187122345,
-0.1955493986606598,
-0.5837520360946655,
0.0810408890247345,
-0.3290780782699585,
-0.6927764415740967,
1.0035582780838013,
-0.15070730447769165,
-0.05165351554751396,
-0.13881945610046387,
-0.38316771388053894,
-0.7087656259536743,
0.8378955721855164,
0.3531697392463684,
-0.43124905228614807,
0.10456819832324982,
0.5723901391029358,
0.4725956618785858,
-0.7841135859489441,
-0.21872276067733765,
0.588954746723175,
0.47050708532333374,
0.20027661323547363,
-0.5287222266197205,
0.06438355147838593,
-0.21604999899864197,
0.12187366932630539,
-0.0014412618475034833,
-0.3232569098472595,
0.848653256893158,
0.005634624045342207,
-0.060461703687906265,
-0.03466521203517914,
0.7354546785354614,
0.2053816318511963,
0.15125888586044312,
0.5160351991653442,
0.5873244404792786,
0.4879676401615143,
-0.10627297312021255,
1.0790894031524658,
-0.23401160538196564,
0.02387114241719246,
0.9426374435424805,
-0.5895141363143921,
0.5629063844680786,
0.39296478033065796,
-0.30997413396835327,
0.4494749903678894,
0.5619433522224426,
0.09886277467012405,
0.610830545425415,
0.04402976855635643,
-0.6244968175888062,
-0.35507887601852417,
-0.1533547192811966,
-0.04898057505488396,
0.41454675793647766,
0.5354456901550293,
-0.25112679600715637,
0.06413786113262177,
0.21743442118167877,
-0.1476902812719345,
0.11520261317491531,
-0.38758182525634766,
0.5108967423439026,
0.04944143816828728,
-0.7457072138786316,
0.5125067234039307,
-0.03608376532793045,
0.5976778268814087,
-0.7727236747741699,
-0.05554569140076637,
-0.3796856999397278,
0.17046695947647095,
-0.14532271027565002,
-0.6341283321380615,
0.2058369666337967,
0.10221680998802185,
-0.2618728280067444,
-0.45223236083984375,
0.7371378540992737,
-0.573355495929718,
-0.49799925088882446,
0.17858533561229706,
0.5596648454666138,
-0.06987336277961731,
-0.23075459897518158,
-0.36732298135757446,
0.06245393678545952,
-0.22112540900707245,
-0.12354874610900879,
0.5594101548194885,
0.3635714054107666,
-0.2926282286643982,
0.6135436296463013,
0.7130719423294067,
0.325531542301178,
-0.12974146008491516,
0.229273721575737,
1.3255674839019775,
-0.44497036933898926,
-0.5857909917831421,
-0.3631502687931061,
0.37354397773742676,
-0.2132851928472519,
-0.030852939933538437,
0.694358229637146,
0.7337470054626465,
0.7242270112037659,
-0.26186537742614746,
1.063953161239624,
-0.1825585514307022,
0.6985084414482117,
-0.6856631636619568,
0.34713470935821533,
-0.6080278754234314,
0.218875914812088,
-0.160330668091774,
-1.0676730871200562,
0.09226386249065399,
0.2403804063796997,
-0.44730377197265625,
0.0874994546175003,
0.6820583343505859,
0.9914986491203308,
-0.3572881817817688,
-0.05643681436777115,
0.3701077997684479,
-0.0739714577794075,
0.23789744079113007,
0.7005802392959595,
0.6817806363105774,
-0.15408965945243835,
0.09413672983646393,
0.0041898866184055805,
-0.23784373700618744,
-0.13529497385025024,
-0.6807636618614197,
-0.9778549671173096,
-0.7256866097450256,
-0.1982579231262207,
-0.16770541667938232,
0.13575685024261475,
0.8129585385322571,
0.8487259745597839,
-0.8550431132316589,
-0.3172587454319,
-0.0390884168446064,
-0.23466983437538147,
-0.43285703659057617,
-0.25449857115745544,
0.38827651739120483,
-0.6474606990814209,
-0.8845497965812683,
0.8836724758148193,
0.34590664505958557,
-0.14585670828819275,
-0.28762826323509216,
-0.16867803037166595,
0.06488700211048126,
0.13597819209098816,
0.8418315052986145,
0.3115461766719818,
-0.27472928166389465,
-0.2127816379070282,
0.05482577160000801,
-0.12303511798381805,
0.09036633372306824,
1.2864832878112793,
-0.8177031874656677,
0.344820111989975,
0.3745821714401245,
0.865516185760498,
0.590783417224884,
0.18945473432540894,
0.9925009608268738,
-0.9475489854812622,
0.2758062481880188,
0.3573777377605438,
0.2187635749578476,
0.5534844398498535,
-0.6931072473526001,
0.4441487193107605,
0.24306920170783997,
-0.42498329281806946,
-0.3548622727394104,
0.3582090139389038,
-0.8829066157341003,
-0.26675233244895935,
1.1813664436340332,
-0.21708111464977264,
-0.12232787907123566,
-0.4146990478038788,
0.1958548128604889,
-0.12422996014356613,
-0.3398433327674866,
0.4532114267349243,
0.39277979731559753,
-0.27438679337501526,
0.18546289205551147,
-0.6438676118850708,
0.9190898537635803,
0.32747137546539307,
-0.9728711843490601,
0.05786051228642464,
0.6113933324813843,
0.2608790695667267,
-0.3477713167667389,
0.7695606350898743,
-0.15099003911018372,
0.08866466581821442,
-0.4110892713069916,
-0.1537317931652069,
-0.12973041832447052,
-0.2832093834877014,
-0.058405499905347824,
-0.0721663385629654,
0.05179866775870323,
-0.1809764802455902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16690v1 | Scaling Laws for Linear Complexity Language Models | 2024-06-24T14:51:31 | 2024-06-24T14:51:31 | Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Ruitao Leng, Zhen Qin, Weigao Sun, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The interest in linear complexity models for large language models is on the
rise, although their scaling capacity remains uncertain. In this study, we
present the scaling laws for linear complexity language models to establish a
foundation for their scalability. Specifically, we examine the scaling
behaviors of three efficient linear architectures. These include TNL, a linear
attention model with data-independent decay; HGRN2, a linear RNN with
data-dependent decay; and cosFormer2, a linear attention model without decay.
We also include LLaMA as a baseline architecture for softmax attention for
comparison. These models were trained with six variants, ranging from 70M to 7B
parameters on a 300B-token corpus, and evaluated with a total of 1,376
intermediate checkpoints on various downstream tasks. These tasks include
validation loss, commonsense reasoning, and information retrieval and
generation. The study reveals that existing linear complexity language models
exhibit similar scaling capabilities as conventional transformer-based models
while also demonstrating superior linguistic proficiency and knowledge
retention. | [
-0.047166574746370316,
-0.5154842734336853,
0.6275668740272522,
0.4572972357273102,
0.2477835714817047,
-0.3762906789779663,
-0.27013352513313293,
-0.37974289059638977,
-0.24343076348304749,
0.6166868209838867,
-0.3036252558231354,
0.1290830820798874,
-0.6214447617530823,
-0.12021046131849289,
-0.34675872325897217,
1.0469590425491333,
0.033999670296907425,
0.07978282123804092,
-0.16936101019382477,
-0.4713655710220337,
-0.32855483889579773,
-0.4066000282764435,
-0.6997486352920532,
-0.3970882296562195,
0.6968807578086853,
0.26607614755630493,
0.8895610570907593,
1.0018168687820435,
0.7558356523513794,
0.28533878922462463,
-0.43923038244247437,
-0.46554356813430786,
-0.867242157459259,
-0.042227715253829956,
-0.2709919810295105,
-0.43131887912750244,
-0.730205774307251,
-0.27683940529823303,
0.5867908000946045,
0.9226146936416626,
-0.055660735815763474,
0.2550652027130127,
0.047255102545022964,
0.5327895283699036,
-0.3504565954208374,
0.12798598408699036,
-0.5176050066947937,
-0.11286650598049164,
0.019440030679106712,
0.2920989394187927,
-0.571950376033783,
-0.4046679437160492,
0.17440858483314514,
-0.395803838968277,
-0.03589737415313721,
0.10704737901687622,
0.6421942114830017,
0.20917783677577972,
-0.4377615749835968,
-0.6797861456871033,
-0.7288950681686401,
1.0246760845184326,
-0.9830560088157654,
0.3685446083545685,
0.16579467058181763,
0.08503729104995728,
0.22996832430362701,
-0.9623762369155884,
-0.22140176594257355,
-0.45171594619750977,
-0.03322800621390343,
-0.44314101338386536,
-0.5462584495544434,
0.19730889797210693,
0.3908942937850952,
0.5044037103652954,
-0.5275633335113525,
0.2061781883239746,
-0.5041801929473877,
-0.13092370331287384,
0.19549791514873505,
0.31912168860435486,
0.23924502730369568,
0.040961068123579025,
-0.38014090061187744,
0.14489123225212097,
-0.5309362411499023,
-0.04736125096678734,
0.06707757711410522,
0.3637601435184479,
-0.08533749729394913,
0.5490816831588745,
0.01395457424223423,
0.5243749022483826,
0.19000035524368286,
-0.2898380160331726,
0.10535462200641632,
-0.5884085297584534,
-0.16228143870830536,
-0.4051000475883484,
0.3700118958950043,
0.020550649613142014,
0.24985486268997192,
-0.3523542582988739,
-0.4326494336128235,
-0.408711701631546,
0.4351959824562073,
-0.813199520111084,
0.032418519258499146,
0.2625291645526886,
-0.5710784196853638,
-0.229582741856575,
-0.5866561532020569,
-0.37869128584861755,
-0.3407476842403412,
-0.3881045877933502,
0.9306282997131348,
-0.24325920641422272,
-0.40045952796936035,
0.22448250651359558,
0.22945277392864227,
0.38911211490631104,
0.17146317660808563,
-0.9761068224906921,
0.5347959399223328,
0.881803572177887,
0.7662729620933533,
-0.07722532004117966,
0.03382386267185211,
-0.5081133842468262,
-0.35976046323776245,
-0.26080551743507385,
0.14600366353988647,
-0.37215790152549744,
0.3769116699695587,
0.11829551309347153,
-0.22122062742710114,
-0.05104667320847511,
-0.3986004590988159,
0.6720569729804993,
-0.7414352893829346,
-0.05877019837498665,
-0.23501905798912048,
-0.6257966160774231,
-0.18461081385612488,
0.10669805854558945,
-0.8127148747444153,
0.774276077747345,
0.1665431410074234,
-0.6356407999992371,
-0.0023361817002296448,
-0.49123507738113403,
-0.408196359872818,
0.16212709248065948,
0.1818174570798874,
-0.4659128785133362,
0.29132017493247986,
-0.2035038322210312,
0.5438295602798462,
-0.4440682530403137,
0.17390727996826172,
-0.35861554741859436,
-0.10118681192398071,
-0.10961616784334183,
-0.335507333278656,
0.7759171724319458,
0.3436022400856018,
-0.4075915217399597,
0.09482120722532272,
-0.7505495548248291,
0.09188172221183777,
0.14079242944717407,
-0.5617868304252625,
-0.1951831728219986,
0.025764524936676025,
0.1804380565881729,
0.13670019805431366,
0.49978935718536377,
-0.2424241453409195,
0.047553569078445435,
-0.3171344995498657,
0.6354202032089233,
0.5134721994400024,
-0.07168177515268326,
0.657362699508667,
-0.07704215496778488,
0.516253650188446,
-0.05180666968226433,
0.2406175285577774,
-0.23523028194904327,
-0.3358347713947296,
-1.0824787616729736,
0.06060514226555824,
0.1294955015182495,
0.36062315106391907,
-0.334113210439682,
0.06571956723928452,
-0.47549352049827576,
-0.3913829028606415,
-0.16946618258953094,
0.316840261220932,
0.6022709608078003,
0.345210462808609,
0.22487081587314606,
-0.16379977762699127,
-0.43819621205329895,
-0.8965799808502197,
-0.10236939042806625,
-0.048471275717020035,
-0.05867772176861763,
0.5548270344734192,
0.5128377079963684,
-0.14389118552207947,
0.6447670459747314,
-0.13888923823833466,
-0.010931754484772682,
-0.557952880859375,
0.04709947854280472,
0.4879254102706909,
0.26540878415107727,
0.48597830533981323,
-0.5697120428085327,
-0.23506440222263336,
0.16159288585186005,
-0.48109665513038635,
-0.151805117726326,
-0.012175432406365871,
0.370103120803833,
-0.013901219703257084,
0.7097647786140442,
-0.3547402620315552,
0.15339438617229462,
0.5102605223655701,
-0.2915602922439575,
0.20090945065021515,
-0.42694804072380066,
-0.4484288692474365,
-0.8683792352676392,
0.25685596466064453,
-0.16019076108932495,
-0.3570931851863861,
-1.272385597229004,
0.28973904252052307,
0.2943389117717743,
0.052106864750385284,
-0.42915308475494385,
0.34320545196533203,
-0.44185683131217957,
-0.33963993191719055,
-0.2881615161895752,
-0.11527680605649948,
-0.0558990053832531,
0.7862960696220398,
-0.1386430412530899,
0.5386937260627747,
0.29557448625564575,
-0.8021711111068726,
0.16325081884860992,
-0.34046483039855957,
-0.1089954674243927,
0.2537935674190521,
-1.1191658973693848,
0.16900941729545593,
-0.15245860815048218,
-0.01126778218895197,
-1.0996605157852173,
0.012100414372980595,
-0.23015323281288147,
-0.16417844593524933,
0.16096079349517822,
-0.14097239077091217,
-0.43688493967056274,
-0.3301146626472473,
-0.030786819756031036,
0.6799463629722595,
0.4268348217010498,
-0.3169095814228058,
0.6942948698997498,
0.1976785957813263,
-0.15263129770755768,
-0.446147620677948,
-0.5428627729415894,
0.07559055835008621,
-0.22697271406650543,
-0.5662466883659363,
-0.2143104076385498,
-0.205379918217659,
-0.4941999018192291,
-0.15765343606472015,
0.10897090286016464,
-0.17399923503398895,
-0.023787209764122963,
0.06050436943769455,
-0.11905685812234879,
-0.7625259160995483,
0.18822459876537323,
-0.3771149814128876,
0.12436378747224808,
0.0776500254869461,
-0.7231280207633972,
0.7917491793632507,
-0.4980047643184662,
0.010248053818941116,
-0.1590757966041565,
0.08569683879613876,
0.975559413433075,
-0.32954949140548706,
0.667580246925354,
0.44699230790138245,
-0.4214933514595032,
0.23259778320789337,
-0.6405143141746521,
0.09788182377815247,
-0.4206036627292633,
0.5736133456230164,
-0.3337807059288025,
-0.7522562146186829,
0.8232088088989258,
0.16629678010940552,
0.3214091956615448,
0.6167526841163635,
1.0038213729858398,
0.11542612314224243,
0.6878334283828735,
0.7285342812538147,
-0.23050245642662048,
0.38440290093421936,
-0.09784267097711563,
-0.09123124182224274,
-0.6319899559020996,
0.03613046556711197,
-0.5124242901802063,
-0.36550018191337585,
-0.4704129993915558,
-0.790797770023346,
0.16317428648471832,
-0.0672672688961029,
-0.4475144147872925,
0.6171731352806091,
-0.07289036363363266,
0.6065129041671753,
0.19084209203720093,
-0.11024821549654007,
0.21022602915763855,
0.02101934142410755,
-0.16287507116794586,
0.007575584575533867,
-0.6512808203697205,
-0.20232106745243073,
1.294041395187378,
0.889622688293457,
0.8388991951942444,
0.43108266592025757,
0.19810913503170013,
0.38509097695350647,
0.211347296833992,
-0.8216575384140015,
0.37062931060791016,
-0.2759193181991577,
-0.7068583965301514,
-0.6032339334487915,
-0.6447749137878418,
-0.9128746390342712,
0.1642124354839325,
0.20355647802352905,
-0.4823406934738159,
0.2779948115348816,
-0.025463946163654327,
-0.25868895649909973,
0.42247459292411804,
-0.568271279335022,
0.5419701337814331,
-0.23955132067203522,
-0.558548092842102,
-0.3877083659172058,
-0.6655043959617615,
0.2012748420238495,
-0.09257535636425018,
0.14406152069568634,
0.17420879006385803,
-0.3337048590183258,
0.5844420194625854,
-0.4053778648376465,
0.7283799052238464,
-0.06974726915359497,
-0.40890106558799744,
0.15991762280464172,
0.1294333040714264,
0.6968351006507874,
-0.1048029363155365,
-0.06058010831475258,
-0.0154821015894413,
-0.5960066318511963,
-0.5887073278427124,
-0.31073716282844543,
0.5312944650650024,
-0.769131064414978,
-0.34428855776786804,
-0.006413725670427084,
-0.8305209279060364,
-0.040769774466753006,
0.4980871081352234,
0.08707018196582794,
0.6769605278968811,
0.05917898938059807,
0.5614137649536133,
1.1657634973526,
0.014663790352642536,
0.5654863119125366,
0.5111793875694275,
-0.19498468935489655,
-0.26779210567474365,
0.776848554611206,
0.18844819068908691,
0.7960523366928101,
0.47835829854011536,
0.1976763755083084,
-0.2482454925775528,
-0.6341354250907898,
-0.25987526774406433,
0.3037312924861908,
-0.7164958715438843,
-0.04413457214832306,
-0.7449690103530884,
-0.4335542917251587,
-0.3415679633617401,
0.07612484693527222,
-0.605061948299408,
-0.6450932025909424,
-0.12085145711898804,
0.07150699943304062,
0.28549179434776306,
1.1430344581604004,
-0.03423530235886574,
0.02179807983338833,
-0.15166398882865906,
0.30785030126571655,
0.4660768210887909,
0.5688826441764832,
0.18556958436965942,
-1.1177096366882324,
-0.4578028619289398,
-0.3235151171684265,
0.013447773642838001,
-0.4534446597099304,
0.08991086483001709,
0.40095147490501404,
0.35661083459854126,
0.5108888745307922,
-0.2193811684846878,
0.29099178314208984,
-0.6789069175720215,
0.3078518211841583,
0.2011416107416153,
-0.8233607411384583,
0.17842836678028107,
-0.4467153251171112,
0.48648932576179504,
0.23927655816078186,
0.14960727095603943,
-0.4222516417503357,
-0.44273194670677185,
-0.40496575832366943,
-0.7410367131233215,
0.6593652367591858,
0.29733848571777344,
0.5997405052185059,
0.4882379472255707,
0.7397403717041016,
-0.09417329728603363,
-0.193956658244133,
-1.1098744869232178,
-0.11812469363212585,
-0.10177259892225266,
-0.2398270070552826,
-0.045794159173965454,
-0.588833212852478,
0.12507258355617523,
0.06975763291120529,
0.23477239906787872,
0.13355515897274017,
0.05062335729598999,
-0.03586068004369736,
-0.1971658170223236,
-0.04747606813907623,
0.32932326197624207,
1.0339714288711548,
0.6656238436698914,
-0.16182853281497955,
0.0614798404276371,
0.3291272521018982,
-0.7042661309242249,
0.33929112553596497,
-0.25869980454444885,
-0.186322882771492,
-0.28723058104515076,
0.3931504786014557,
1.000709056854248,
0.47441843152046204,
-0.5442420244216919,
0.4047433137893677,
-0.21292796730995178,
-0.30910608172416687,
-0.17529207468032837,
-0.046865999698638916,
0.4463214576244354,
0.32010617852211,
0.23392613232135773,
0.006627632305026054,
0.10746878385543823,
-0.22134636342525482,
0.21162289381027222,
0.07183399796485901,
-0.5757459402084351,
-0.31303131580352783,
0.8389002084732056,
0.12716776132583618,
-0.2966206967830658,
0.5361484885215759,
-0.19548490643501282,
-0.286390483379364,
0.6018834710121155,
0.565473735332489,
0.5980728268623352,
-0.19402314722537994,
-0.14491988718509674,
0.451133131980896,
0.7290199398994446,
-0.09216183423995972,
-0.045030366629362106,
0.05616390332579613,
-0.47260719537734985,
-0.3800029754638672,
-0.6220727562904358,
-0.3439675271511078,
0.3112947344779968,
-0.6791196465492249,
0.056666016578674316,
-0.6948522925376892,
-0.15102456510066986,
0.012374459765851498,
0.1140417605638504,
-0.5793461799621582,
0.23323708772659302,
0.28588587045669556,
0.7907349467277527,
-0.619015097618103,
0.7560341954231262,
0.3371078073978424,
-0.25341662764549255,
-0.6652143001556396,
-0.16410699486732483,
-0.0010292917722836137,
-0.9189338684082031,
0.7443727850914001,
0.054155219346284866,
-0.07966050505638123,
0.02438126876950264,
-0.3051123321056366,
-1.2030566930770874,
0.9952600598335266,
0.41783082485198975,
-0.6701584458351135,
-0.06911985576152802,
0.33001455664634705,
0.8526526093482971,
-0.5083140134811401,
0.26146864891052246,
0.4327824115753174,
0.07469504326581955,
0.24406224489212036,
-0.9052965044975281,
-0.10824071615934372,
-0.1409091353416443,
0.22290033102035522,
0.05045788735151291,
-0.7494485974311829,
1.2394160032272339,
-0.4915068447589874,
0.017454609274864197,
0.014353550039231777,
0.9512118697166443,
-0.001247957581654191,
0.09609183669090271,
0.676161527633667,
0.7286537885665894,
0.5974833965301514,
0.18643145263195038,
0.8740429878234863,
-0.31946688890457153,
0.4314415156841278,
1.154059886932373,
-0.24023503065109253,
0.9731761813163757,
0.2079782336950302,
-0.1750086545944214,
0.3627498745918274,
0.14512191712856293,
0.06192997843027115,
0.01003989763557911,
0.4541615843772888,
0.034699004143476486,
-0.09720519185066223,
-0.21098951995372772,
-0.16340646147727966,
0.36368435621261597,
0.4042799770832062,
-0.5647950172424316,
-0.08162175118923187,
-0.034603677690029144,
0.33509400486946106,
-0.10528573393821716,
-0.5752941966056824,
0.7315738797187805,
-0.06264853477478027,
-0.5219016075134277,
0.7261533737182617,
0.02825169451534748,
0.33364322781562805,
-0.4745219349861145,
0.41582411527633667,
-0.5250499844551086,
0.5278943777084351,
0.05586342141032219,
-0.6028028130531311,
0.07653602957725525,
0.16901235282421112,
-0.5106306076049805,
-0.3924834430217743,
0.5793707370758057,
-0.3759499192237854,
-0.6953139305114746,
0.3714298605918884,
0.1461332142353058,
0.1916460543870926,
0.13700592517852783,
-0.5048404335975647,
0.10763798654079437,
-0.006715457886457443,
-0.3965020179748535,
0.16871587932109833,
0.38295960426330566,
-0.024756915867328644,
0.970788300037384,
0.1401209831237793,
0.03825673460960388,
0.6046697497367859,
0.26539456844329834,
0.7364811897277832,
-0.3972814083099365,
-0.19816607236862183,
-0.5624813437461853,
0.1876969188451767,
0.035937681794166565,
-0.1189856305718422,
0.618567168712616,
0.5427141189575195,
0.16816595196723938,
0.06859016418457031,
0.374050498008728,
0.028018483892083168,
0.3380758762359619,
-0.3020589053630829,
0.5759614706039429,
-0.6627805233001709,
0.31442922353744507,
0.14837272465229034,
-0.7904848456382751,
-0.23123103380203247,
0.11451056599617004,
-0.18524345755577087,
0.192473366856575,
0.3481210768222809,
0.7164018154144287,
-0.126548632979393,
-0.37315601110458374,
0.49076417088508606,
0.5707347393035889,
0.3171597421169281,
0.9792882800102234,
0.12254847586154938,
-0.5547803640365601,
1.035662293434143,
0.17023710906505585,
-0.24450504779815674,
-0.4065578877925873,
-0.6310553550720215,
-0.8009467720985413,
-0.4561338722705841,
-0.20360495150089264,
-0.46358051896095276,
-0.2492763102054596,
0.48198091983795166,
0.7020214200019836,
-0.8937065601348877,
-0.42049407958984375,
-0.22549772262573242,
-0.0209202878177166,
-0.12834569811820984,
-0.18357229232788086,
0.2831532955169678,
-0.7362088561058044,
-0.4554117023944855,
0.04354899749159813,
0.6319611668586731,
0.02203897200524807,
-0.647438108921051,
-0.25039780139923096,
-0.027268193662166595,
0.6097806096076965,
0.581637978553772,
0.4790634214878082,
-0.879679262638092,
-0.11664532124996185,
0.24060764908790588,
-0.602088987827301,
-0.00033108596107922494,
0.9598919749259949,
-0.23218269646167755,
0.488353431224823,
0.658370852470398,
0.6337265372276306,
0.3328152596950531,
-0.3559182286262512,
0.5524163842201233,
-0.6785550713539124,
0.09275005012750626,
0.21215800940990448,
0.3610590696334839,
0.12211339175701141,
-0.09816838055849075,
0.3738173246383667,
-0.004084945190697908,
-0.7263215780258179,
-0.6430657505989075,
0.22590626776218414,
-0.816387951374054,
0.08823095262050629,
1.2341511249542236,
-0.17426496744155884,
-0.17667825520038605,
-0.1868518888950348,
0.0778241902589798,
-0.21989145874977112,
0.012260383926331997,
0.3572399914264679,
0.816652238368988,
0.04656616598367691,
-0.40291962027549744,
-0.7333564758300781,
0.3057877719402313,
0.6285755634307861,
-0.59637051820755,
0.40268734097480774,
0.14270800352096558,
0.2811276912689209,
0.2971176505088806,
0.5551722049713135,
-0.16146256029605865,
0.19009338319301605,
-0.005350968800485134,
-0.01762634702026844,
0.39802104234695435,
-0.08864069730043411,
-0.5985564589500427,
0.36174339056015015,
0.07120669633150101,
0.44733840227127075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16678v1 | Segment Any Text: A Universal Approach for Robust, Efficient and Adaptable Sentence Segmentation | 2024-06-24T14:36:11 | 2024-06-24T14:36:11 | Markus Frohmann, Igor Sterner, Ivan Vulić, Benjamin Minixhofer, Markus Schedl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Segmenting text into sentences plays an early and crucial role in many NLP
systems. This is commonly achieved by using rule-based or statistical methods
relying on lexical features such as punctuation. Although some recent works no
longer exclusively rely on punctuation, we find that no prior method achieves
all of (i) robustness to missing punctuation, (ii) effective adaptability to
new domains, and (iii) high efficiency. We introduce a new model - Segment any
Text (SaT) - to solve this problem. To enhance robustness, we propose a new
pretraining scheme that ensures less reliance on punctuation. To address
adaptability, we introduce an extra stage of parameter-efficient fine-tuning,
establishing state-of-the-art performance in distinct domains such as verses
from lyrics and legal documents. Along the way, we introduce architectural
modifications that result in a threefold gain in speed over the previous state
of the art and solve spurious reliance on context far in the future. Finally,
we introduce a variant of our model with fine-tuning on a diverse, multilingual
mixture of sentence-segmented data, acting as a drop-in replacement and
enhancement for existing segmentation tools. Overall, our contributions provide
a universal approach for segmenting any text. Our method outperforms all
baselines - including strong LLMs - across 8 corpora spanning diverse domains
and languages, especially in practically relevant situations where text is
poorly formatted. Our models and code, including documentation, are available
at https://huggingface.co/segment-any-text under the MIT license. | [
0.08965952694416046,
-0.944600522518158,
0.7707351446151733,
0.47962287068367004,
-0.5808874368667603,
-0.1694360375404358,
-0.047301050275564194,
-0.45066606998443604,
0.15883688628673553,
0.6675161719322205,
-0.7048758864402771,
-0.7005019783973694,
-0.4126451909542084,
0.270659863948822,
-0.5381875038146973,
0.8743226528167725,
0.24186229705810547,
-0.10257554799318314,
-0.271262526512146,
-0.3598870038986206,
-0.48134845495224,
-0.7072587609291077,
-0.32300612330436707,
-0.001739980187267065,
0.24783951044082642,
0.3920746147632599,
0.39931240677833557,
1.1266388893127441,
0.38293346762657166,
0.2815699875354767,
-0.27339357137680054,
0.2655990719795227,
-0.12021857500076294,
0.4312898814678192,
-0.09271670877933502,
-0.38342854380607605,
-0.02549040876328945,
-0.0028407813515514135,
0.7205471992492676,
0.9701772332191467,
-0.12370449304580688,
-0.3315187990665436,
-0.2502893805503845,
0.533480167388916,
-0.732272744178772,
-0.37562277913093567,
-0.9583700299263,
0.010265160351991653,
-0.2647431790828705,
-0.18341414630413055,
-0.5382237434387207,
-0.4596445560455322,
0.2416166216135025,
-0.8967060446739197,
-0.10963395237922668,
0.3966502249240875,
1.1254823207855225,
0.42459988594055176,
-0.25482282042503357,
-0.27401646971702576,
-0.2911037802696228,
0.7649893164634705,
-0.26010456681251526,
0.44108590483665466,
0.002806528238579631,
-0.18436014652252197,
0.04833341762423515,
-0.8826770782470703,
-0.08595648407936096,
-0.12051355838775635,
0.1431538164615631,
-0.016712013632059097,
-0.1459624469280243,
-0.15221399068832397,
0.10059873759746552,
0.23466219007968903,
-0.6095203161239624,
0.06529561430215836,
0.11607835441827774,
-0.22200708091259003,
0.238674134016037,
0.2262590080499649,
0.7088006734848022,
-0.2860502600669861,
-0.6169956922531128,
0.19313347339630127,
-0.7174960970878601,
0.08511769026517868,
0.2327536791563034,
0.416721910238266,
-0.08340489864349365,
0.447087824344635,
0.21388909220695496,
0.9249327182769775,
-0.2347833216190338,
-0.2058810293674469,
-0.12288541346788406,
-0.33941736817359924,
-0.3000865876674652,
-0.0687902644276619,
0.7504314184188843,
-0.08970118314027786,
0.5043832659721375,
-0.12982746958732605,
0.13332371413707733,
0.06622924655675888,
0.36852753162384033,
-0.6901416778564453,
-0.40684670209884644,
-0.24122582376003265,
-0.34566137194633484,
-0.0956946462392807,
0.08762305974960327,
-0.5037007331848145,
-0.37305137515068054,
-0.2977965474128723,
0.04269813746213913,
-1.0652565956115723,
0.27082058787345886,
0.40492865443229675,
0.011835510842502117,
0.21771596372127533,
0.20136144757270813,
-0.7192519903182983,
0.2579391300678253,
0.6930752992630005,
1.000815987586975,
-0.4642902910709381,
-0.4435828924179077,
-0.6222820281982422,
0.15487965941429138,
-0.0892508402466774,
1.2164359092712402,
-0.8435981869697571,
-0.3333272933959961,
0.1297982633113861,
0.022180764004588127,
-0.686668336391449,
-0.4709877371788025,
1.072445273399353,
-0.2653116285800934,
0.2631485164165497,
-0.11442381143569946,
-0.8927270174026489,
-0.02595442906022072,
0.3096238076686859,
-0.4831075668334961,
0.6891043782234192,
-0.03311270847916603,
-0.8099943995475769,
0.3624465763568878,
-0.915848970413208,
-0.703393816947937,
0.020459884777665138,
0.024308443069458008,
-0.5919331312179565,
0.03105444274842739,
0.5947332978248596,
0.12590236961841583,
0.021566735580563545,
-0.026265360414981842,
-0.32066842913627625,
-0.2213325798511505,
0.29213792085647583,
-0.2315630167722702,
1.0776677131652832,
0.14989498257637024,
0.16220428049564362,
0.44664862751960754,
-1.1694222688674927,
0.1918926239013672,
0.07109421491622925,
-0.2583998739719391,
-0.45226046442985535,
0.11051337420940399,
0.6145740747451782,
-0.3283717930316925,
0.05065518990159035,
-0.5118326544761658,
0.18656954169273376,
-0.5047286152839661,
0.6410791873931885,
0.648492693901062,
0.262451171875,
0.6255137324333191,
-0.09316498786211014,
0.6188727617263794,
-0.20366773009300232,
0.16024579107761383,
-0.7550832033157349,
-0.13045556843280792,
-0.7931944131851196,
-0.8048376441001892,
0.5903188586235046,
0.5559267401695251,
-0.36692535877227783,
0.8652539849281311,
-0.15319231152534485,
-0.06898454576730728,
-0.37641745805740356,
-0.049643661826848984,
0.14082767069339752,
0.37133562564849854,
0.2666631042957306,
-0.09200304001569748,
-0.9749106764793396,
-0.6265267729759216,
-0.5054706335067749,
-0.12751707434654236,
0.05710744857788086,
-0.03651188686490059,
0.35681265592575073,
0.00644207838922739,
1.0506714582443237,
-0.7786765694618225,
-0.4244658350944519,
-0.5231368541717529,
-0.1328708976507187,
-0.10408198088407516,
0.4751887321472168,
0.3806014060974121,
-0.6958640813827515,
-0.447460800409317,
-0.21814794838428497,
-0.5381975173950195,
-0.305254727602005,
-0.25426429510116577,
-0.31495556235313416,
-0.12358827888965607,
0.628778338432312,
-0.47083672881126404,
0.2614433467388153,
0.13850712776184082,
-0.6396003365516663,
0.5203938484191895,
-0.15922795236110687,
-0.2701748311519623,
-1.0341987609863281,
0.12789286673069,
-0.04938570410013199,
-0.5072760581970215,
-0.5968763828277588,
0.17037296295166016,
-0.04581586271524429,
-0.22491297125816345,
-0.3480800986289978,
0.2779371738433838,
-0.27767708897590637,
0.13999634981155396,
-0.30161336064338684,
0.2470661997795105,
0.2867997884750366,
0.03595002368092537,
-0.01293445285409689,
0.8022809624671936,
0.3729588985443115,
-0.4709358215332031,
-0.2746015787124634,
0.7847638130187988,
-0.6041290163993835,
0.8663780689239502,
-0.6077640652656555,
-0.01270502433180809,
0.04348359629511833,
0.13365621864795685,
-0.5443043112754822,
-0.19363215565681458,
0.2884921133518219,
-0.31349706649780273,
-0.15448890626430511,
0.10025034099817276,
-0.1600465029478073,
0.28604450821876526,
-0.08005423098802567,
0.17786036431789398,
0.31593090295791626,
-0.45202451944351196,
0.5083453059196472,
0.38875216245651245,
-0.16194526851177216,
-0.21486690640449524,
-0.4530457854270935,
0.11968844383955002,
-0.16701099276542664,
-0.7852606773376465,
0.5149489045143127,
-0.12473811209201813,
-0.1224016472697258,
-0.0888691321015358,
-0.27578359842300415,
-0.5383171439170837,
0.35035577416419983,
0.18331940472126007,
0.18687795102596283,
-0.1538081020116806,
-0.12744610011577606,
-0.015839209780097008,
-0.15268461406230927,
-0.1817902773618698,
-0.48794808983802795,
0.526573657989502,
0.04833759739995003,
-0.21713875234127045,
-0.3951280415058136,
0.5689699649810791,
0.31410643458366394,
-0.3994958698749542,
0.3812220096588135,
0.3430889844894409,
-0.19814901053905487,
-0.5016824007034302,
-0.30100947618484497,
0.29948270320892334,
-0.3835006654262543,
0.27771902084350586,
-0.3554765284061432,
-1.1956818103790283,
0.17691439390182495,
-0.022962581366300583,
-0.16978298127651215,
0.21033993363380432,
0.16302140057086945,
-0.08920791745185852,
0.6476581692695618,
1.2292885780334473,
0.017129097133874893,
0.6574918627738953,
0.3364720940589905,
0.3625844120979309,
-0.6875296235084534,
-0.11351267993450165,
-0.9004378318786621,
0.15534618496894836,
-0.25175750255584717,
-0.0900416150689125,
0.19235850870609283,
0.1659790724515915,
-0.16988584399223328,
0.371037095785141,
-0.5455980896949768,
0.8515439629554749,
0.4816964566707611,
-0.13531333208084106,
0.3800862431526184,
0.025220796465873718,
-0.27958083152770996,
-0.1866408884525299,
-0.7055720090866089,
-0.4494578540325165,
0.6214310526847839,
0.03848147392272949,
0.3673146069049835,
-0.5268262028694153,
0.48337316513061523,
0.2598211467266083,
0.048926498740911484,
-0.7174394726753235,
0.46256184577941895,
-0.46818727254867554,
-0.5200979709625244,
-0.10537680238485336,
-0.38698452711105347,
-0.997851550579071,
0.45500287413597107,
-0.12808968126773834,
-1.029115915298462,
0.043123215436935425,
-0.3130103051662445,
-0.6222689747810364,
0.36713874340057373,
-0.590138852596283,
1.0855809450149536,
0.012013633735477924,
0.22318001091480255,
0.48267292976379395,
-0.6699617505073547,
0.07695264369249344,
-0.16933053731918335,
0.16641558706760406,
-0.400390625,
-0.16417726874351501,
0.8016653060913086,
-0.47303032875061035,
0.47711238265037537,
0.03582090511918068,
0.1549103558063507,
0.3201278746128082,
-0.14067937433719635,
0.12323786318302155,
-0.015406059101223946,
0.13851408660411835,
-0.20613683760166168,
0.2907136082649231,
-0.3899659514427185,
-0.3929053246974945,
0.4742478132247925,
-0.6263453960418701,
-0.13232551515102386,
-0.4305717647075653,
-0.6904133558273315,
-0.2838764488697052,
0.35717931389808655,
0.3282037675380707,
0.11431414633989334,
-0.596193790435791,
0.3577615022659302,
0.45889171957969666,
-0.08332052081823349,
0.6423991322517395,
0.5449444055557251,
-0.08821643888950348,
-0.6868844628334045,
0.7182549834251404,
-0.3177238404750824,
-0.35661303997039795,
0.574207067489624,
0.025673361495137215,
-0.4324013888835907,
-0.5826619267463684,
-0.2308029979467392,
0.06900624930858612,
-0.539718747138977,
-0.10061214864253998,
-0.7827265858650208,
-0.1454344540834427,
-0.2243015468120575,
-0.44709712266921997,
-0.32716137170791626,
-0.36384594440460205,
-0.5153347253799438,
-0.006479526869952679,
0.0454661101102829,
0.42031243443489075,
0.17356988787651062,
0.7452623248100281,
-0.7412796020507812,
0.17421063780784607,
-0.1922437995672226,
0.22358642518520355,
-0.6199358701705933,
-0.45803597569465637,
-0.11137794703245163,
-0.5117478966712952,
-0.44744738936424255,
-0.7187788486480713,
0.2425975203514099,
0.5427199006080627,
0.15148623287677765,
0.5509452223777771,
0.046964388340711594,
0.6091329455375671,
-0.6740643978118896,
0.7687112092971802,
0.46371594071388245,
-1.2397023439407349,
0.43137314915657043,
-0.3553277850151062,
0.3945593535900116,
0.9558558464050293,
0.17761674523353577,
-0.685448408126831,
-0.09520593285560608,
-0.36439192295074463,
-0.8723391890525818,
0.6064082980155945,
0.3899368643760681,
-0.05523799732327461,
0.008203725330531597,
0.5152955055236816,
0.3202511668205261,
-0.029143063351511955,
-0.9398003816604614,
-0.11995287984609604,
-0.07154479622840881,
-0.2680862545967102,
0.1524040251970291,
-0.09757544100284576,
-0.011846357956528664,
-0.045756809413433075,
0.5444909334182739,
-0.03584009036421776,
-0.18731309473514557,
0.22696110606193542,
-0.4681323766708374,
0.2665257155895233,
0.5732455849647522,
0.33115917444229126,
0.7662304639816284,
-0.10513948649168015,
-0.01673293113708496,
-0.23298439383506775,
-0.5430856943130493,
0.4237430989742279,
0.2384599894285202,
-0.7642541527748108,
0.15829947590827942,
0.38668063282966614,
0.7446470856666565,
0.2822991907596588,
-0.5551632642745972,
0.5192223787307739,
-0.0820004791021347,
-0.3446257412433624,
-0.12527817487716675,
0.003479225328192115,
-0.2720837891101837,
0.0323587991297245,
0.16788487136363983,
0.3456871211528778,
-0.11316318809986115,
-0.5073674917221069,
0.3919171988964081,
0.14772562682628632,
-0.6086678504943848,
-0.3000103533267975,
0.753675639629364,
0.3081343173980713,
-0.40370795130729675,
0.44852256774902344,
-0.09863196313381195,
-0.5899721384048462,
0.256511926651001,
0.6339491605758667,
1.073094367980957,
-0.07679123431444168,
0.5137040615081787,
-0.024251241236925125,
0.3937687575817108,
0.09935294091701508,
0.2406984567642212,
0.07133245468139648,
-0.7359517812728882,
-0.750215470790863,
-0.8268859386444092,
-0.29729989171028137,
0.0002778334601316601,
-0.5311214923858643,
-0.09043451398611069,
-0.6677963733673096,
0.03134893998503685,
0.12560905516147614,
-0.2719915211200714,
-0.3750215470790863,
0.530664324760437,
0.11890850961208344,
0.9843098521232605,
-0.9129153490066528,
0.7174020409584045,
0.9961509108543396,
-0.39275166392326355,
-0.44243380427360535,
0.21075281500816345,
-0.3690878450870514,
-0.7282278537750244,
-0.03228438273072243,
0.3722044825553894,
0.12168606370687485,
-0.19643281400203705,
-0.759086549282074,
-0.7226368188858032,
0.5279990434646606,
0.49980396032333374,
-0.33021727204322815,
-0.24887028336524963,
0.317401260137558,
0.3994556963443756,
-0.7527716159820557,
-0.04474331811070442,
0.9438915252685547,
0.4752714931964874,
-0.030644813552498817,
-0.314618319272995,
0.07415556907653809,
-0.14470747113227844,
0.3035058081150055,
0.12705278396606445,
-0.3954530656337738,
0.4581190049648285,
0.08334784209728241,
-0.35462021827697754,
0.6953098773956299,
0.7081445455551147,
0.02617761678993702,
0.2558031976222992,
0.8133240342140198,
0.736152708530426,
1.012851357460022,
-0.47195303440093994,
0.9525690674781799,
-0.3755190670490265,
-0.059211261570453644,
0.9685814380645752,
-0.36409223079681396,
0.6719448566436768,
0.46413061022758484,
-0.11228916794061661,
0.5939658284187317,
0.5291063189506531,
-0.09551182389259338,
0.5147755146026611,
0.11729003489017487,
-0.10113396495580673,
-0.6504470705986023,
-0.44148215651512146,
-0.19524163007736206,
0.7696731090545654,
-0.08170092850923538,
-0.12476098537445068,
-0.10995949059724808,
0.06552664190530777,
0.19568751752376556,
0.542977511882782,
-0.10272476822137833,
0.7493312954902649,
0.16621097922325134,
-0.7015390396118164,
0.2580951452255249,
0.18251682817935944,
0.605936586856842,
-0.8759660720825195,
0.38176798820495605,
-0.20650172233581543,
0.09159679710865021,
-0.15891329944133759,
-0.2662629783153534,
0.35486212372779846,
0.17297004163265228,
-0.22557087242603302,
-0.013901111669838428,
0.7526066899299622,
-0.2719188928604126,
-0.45414894819259644,
0.11606106162071228,
0.5992457270622253,
-0.08856917917728424,
-0.40931618213653564,
-0.7617826461791992,
0.4299805164337158,
0.39319565892219543,
0.11618096381425858,
0.28237247467041016,
0.5624681115150452,
0.34633901715278625,
0.5322619080543518,
0.6285219192504883,
0.0667540580034256,
-0.020003611221909523,
0.2694128155708313,
0.7982490658760071,
-0.8010425567626953,
-0.8054448366165161,
-0.7484310269355774,
0.5593022704124451,
-0.24851736426353455,
-0.6913787126541138,
0.6877837181091309,
0.6866375207901001,
0.550263524055481,
0.1683681607246399,
0.7395129799842834,
0.07959722727537155,
0.42460504174232483,
-0.49017491936683655,
0.5197400450706482,
-0.5296606421470642,
0.08363281190395355,
-0.32961466908454895,
-1.2112832069396973,
-0.7239359617233276,
0.6364669799804688,
-0.2533206343650818,
-0.29837316274642944,
1.1149952411651611,
0.1761360764503479,
-0.048855237662792206,
0.3599596321582794,
0.3690989911556244,
0.011059518903493881,
0.25299715995788574,
0.2058694213628769,
0.819836437702179,
-0.2015174925327301,
0.981453537940979,
0.015678679570555687,
-0.07203000783920288,
0.18696752190589905,
-0.864791989326477,
-0.7027247548103333,
-0.2787802517414093,
-0.40037745237350464,
-0.05421316623687744,
0.29502126574516296,
0.7963487505912781,
0.856934130191803,
-0.712156355381012,
-0.12856820225715637,
-0.18200597167015076,
0.18607521057128906,
0.018433229997754097,
-0.183420792222023,
0.4439971446990967,
-0.8499117493629456,
-0.5209303498268127,
0.8661631941795349,
0.640199601650238,
-0.17589005827903748,
0.30749449133872986,
0.2294049859046936,
-0.4098285138607025,
0.3594614267349243,
0.5566348433494568,
0.33819928765296936,
-0.39575624465942383,
-0.24388104677200317,
0.07947047799825668,
0.19579535722732544,
0.5073773860931396,
1.0735877752304077,
-0.1663791835308075,
0.2227572649717331,
0.050404686480760574,
0.8612324595451355,
0.32545843720436096,
0.35595524311065674,
0.4196680784225464,
-0.9248221516609192,
0.18369345366954803,
0.3720386028289795,
0.5845242738723755,
0.5590982437133789,
0.16161216795444489,
0.4596426784992218,
0.4080250859260559,
-0.6668311953544617,
-0.7236678004264832,
0.4240041971206665,
-1.1465262174606323,
-0.48931053280830383,
0.9741649627685547,
-0.4588201940059662,
-0.4154641330242157,
-0.13898779451847076,
-0.4173160791397095,
-0.07322058081626892,
-0.31923380494117737,
0.5165343880653381,
0.49409013986587524,
0.061535317450761795,
0.00857385341078043,
0.2738993167877197,
0.43683308362960815,
0.7998093366622925,
-1.1641758680343628,
-0.009807156398892403,
0.6755552291870117,
0.3588401973247528,
0.00642806151881814,
0.6124374270439148,
-0.11615313589572906,
-0.00968173984438181,
0.04468020051717758,
-0.13891085982322693,
0.07664090394973755,
-0.5412759184837341,
-0.3603401780128479,
0.6912857890129089,
-0.19585026800632477,
-0.2068994790315628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16674v1 | Computational Approaches to the Detection of Lesser-Known Rhetorical Figures: A Systematic Survey and Research Challenges | 2024-06-24T14:31:34 | 2024-06-24T14:31:34 | Ramona Kühn, Jelena Mitrović, Michael Granitzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rhetorical figures play a major role in our everyday communication as they
make text more interesting, more memorable, or more persuasive. Therefore, it
is important to computationally detect rhetorical figures to fully understand
the meaning of a text. We provide a comprehensive overview of computational
approaches to lesser-known rhetorical figures. We explore the linguistic and
computational perspectives on rhetorical figures, emphasizing their
significance for the domain of Natural Language Processing. We present
different figures in detail, delving into datasets, definitions, rhetorical
functions, and detection approaches. We identified challenges such as dataset
scarcity, language limitations, and reliance on rule-based methods. | [
-0.7143539190292358,
-0.901145875453949,
0.6286747455596924,
0.032573800534009933,
-0.3842194080352783,
0.26401087641716003,
-0.11488134413957596,
-0.7757940888404846,
0.3354048728942871,
0.4146394729614258,
-0.6889024972915649,
-0.25304561853408813,
-0.7638845443725586,
0.33214449882507324,
-0.2465457022190094,
0.3083220422267914,
0.26908785104751587,
0.02104811742901802,
-0.27617165446281433,
-0.08958924561738968,
-0.3138009011745453,
-0.5873165726661682,
-0.7001848816871643,
-0.27964890003204346,
0.5147234797477722,
0.27900081872940063,
0.6252048015594482,
0.7006215453147888,
0.6271253824234009,
0.3143473267555237,
-0.24822601675987244,
-0.008670072071254253,
-0.42564302682876587,
0.3804190158843994,
-0.2819763422012329,
-0.39489638805389404,
0.22061344981193542,
-0.05331377312541008,
0.6668369770050049,
0.967594563961029,
0.1547686904668808,
-0.11048071086406708,
-0.24081160128116608,
0.736427366733551,
-0.5509619116783142,
0.2128346860408783,
-0.56554114818573,
0.11868076771497726,
-0.7807626128196716,
-0.27814579010009766,
-0.5737969875335693,
-0.6489121913909912,
0.0917452722787857,
-0.5555095076560974,
0.28704318404197693,
0.14069944620132446,
0.5375131964683533,
0.08114540576934814,
-0.48493248224258423,
-0.5255529880523682,
-0.7204961180686951,
0.8933188915252686,
-0.42875975370407104,
0.06164058670401573,
0.3773461580276489,
0.48034265637397766,
-0.2673480808734894,
-0.762127161026001,
-0.3624010682106018,
-0.1772296279668808,
-0.36372309923171997,
-0.2273711860179901,
-0.8045808672904968,
-0.007540115155279636,
0.4471651017665863,
0.2939265966415405,
-0.7150890827178955,
0.06474807858467102,
-0.26160481572151184,
-0.396548330783844,
0.5039483308792114,
0.14464904367923737,
0.5413224101066589,
-0.4414670467376709,
0.09244485199451447,
-0.10285750776529312,
-0.77744460105896,
-0.1471536010503769,
0.3350616991519928,
0.2700498402118683,
-0.07895789295434952,
0.5027117133140564,
-0.22082006931304932,
0.7909538745880127,
-0.02526148594915867,
0.2584535479545593,
-0.21010498702526093,
-0.1776055544614792,
0.08985985070466995,
0.09757594764232635,
0.670151948928833,
-0.30113932490348816,
0.523262083530426,
0.327099472284317,
0.12483412027359009,
0.02392026223242283,
0.11764989048242569,
-0.6408339142799377,
-0.39792200922966003,
-0.236395463347435,
-0.5411093235015869,
-0.1784387081861496,
-0.27860039472579956,
-0.6540822386741638,
-0.981752872467041,
-0.38794630765914917,
-0.28931140899658203,
-0.41076144576072693,
-0.20412752032279968,
-0.23670004308223724,
-0.26280760765075684,
0.1732652634382248,
0.4302554130554199,
-0.6203490495681763,
0.35787609219551086,
0.8853310942649841,
0.6975953578948975,
-0.025965586304664612,
0.10474273562431335,
-0.3466726839542389,
-0.07833059132099152,
-0.5357182621955872,
1.5125662088394165,
-1.1288912296295166,
-0.29013699293136597,
0.15499669313430786,
-0.10452244430780411,
-0.13551995158195496,
-0.5691696405410767,
0.9711344838142395,
-0.3623853027820587,
0.2078486531972885,
-0.6320359706878662,
-0.7026432156562805,
-0.27561867237091064,
0.260665625333786,
-1.0113815069198608,
0.8207699060440063,
0.13170099258422852,
-1.0113831758499146,
-0.0675746500492096,
-0.7023108601570129,
-0.5939452648162842,
0.2737285792827606,
-0.48395800590515137,
0.014588039368391037,
0.5360578298568726,
0.10313721746206284,
0.38234829902648926,
-0.6018234491348267,
0.07461997866630554,
-0.05279967561364174,
-0.26616546511650085,
0.5518691539764404,
-0.49586623907089233,
0.769638180732727,
0.3080030083656311,
-0.23543700575828552,
-0.050528038293123245,
-0.6484264135360718,
-0.05860123783349991,
0.28451964259147644,
0.2867480516433716,
-0.4757128953933716,
0.17166678607463837,
0.28437402844429016,
-0.13062553107738495,
0.09348299354314804,
-0.33481743931770325,
0.05803891643881798,
-0.5832953453063965,
0.5055911540985107,
0.4176322817802429,
0.2853289246559143,
0.1748642921447754,
-0.48962491750717163,
0.8205780982971191,
-0.3939533233642578,
-0.24815838038921356,
-0.32495537400245667,
-0.9026614427566528,
-0.2530570328235626,
-0.40272024273872375,
0.5086715817451477,
0.4654260575771332,
-0.8383967280387878,
0.0022423944901674986,
-0.10022083669900894,
-0.6185337901115417,
-0.03182261437177658,
-0.3602624833583832,
0.25699514150619507,
0.49096807837486267,
-0.02139066345989704,
0.01006912998855114,
-0.6674292683601379,
-1.131035327911377,
-0.5017206072807312,
-0.11430925875902176,
0.0138207683339715,
0.16419053077697754,
0.587400496006012,
0.4076377749443054,
0.9500200748443604,
-0.6907892823219299,
-0.1239306777715683,
-0.18047812581062317,
0.7029092311859131,
0.051871784031391144,
0.301069974899292,
0.8825260400772095,
-0.8322532176971436,
-0.5772579312324524,
0.03961769491434097,
-0.575232744216919,
-0.21083694696426392,
-0.11072967201471329,
0.1508348137140274,
-0.11771135777235031,
0.6112561821937561,
-0.7193375825881958,
0.5233943462371826,
0.03943019360303879,
0.059798598289489746,
0.5143624544143677,
0.12280154973268509,
0.4292161166667938,
-0.5657119750976562,
0.02698344923555851,
0.1458093374967575,
-0.0045464178547263145,
-0.9524688720703125,
0.0823376327753067,
-0.17734648287296295,
-0.046933479607105255,
-0.4186161160469055,
0.3825814723968506,
-0.4455668330192566,
-0.03499612957239151,
-0.46082934737205505,
0.2817738950252533,
-0.04550081491470337,
0.17355364561080933,
0.28906765580177307,
0.6456477046012878,
0.5623781681060791,
-0.4307496249675751,
0.24272574484348297,
-0.09292925149202347,
-0.40325215458869934,
1.1469035148620605,
-0.6592903137207031,
0.2848566770553589,
-0.3137529790401459,
0.3213774859905243,
-1.2892733812332153,
-0.402538537979126,
0.690162181854248,
-0.49999183416366577,
0.19197800755500793,
-0.37347832322120667,
-0.5528221130371094,
-0.1555931270122528,
-0.4813673496246338,
0.705467700958252,
0.21609829366207123,
-0.25202131271362305,
0.41468945145606995,
0.7345632910728455,
-0.4264254570007324,
-0.2987304627895355,
-0.6433375477790833,
0.21221096813678741,
-0.23342853784561157,
-0.48840567469596863,
0.37344637513160706,
0.047219567000865936,
-0.6137216091156006,
-0.1808852255344391,
0.11469168961048126,
-0.236707866191864,
-0.22702759504318237,
0.12993371486663818,
-0.08303409814834595,
-0.2750554382801056,
0.11216025799512863,
0.02312960848212242,
-0.1442278027534485,
0.10023099929094315,
-0.17342860996723175,
0.4592168629169464,
0.033312246203422546,
-0.5114161372184753,
-0.512641191482544,
0.6434342861175537,
0.4145362675189972,
0.14503569900989532,
0.2990228533744812,
0.4126068651676178,
-1.0032124519348145,
0.10148805379867554,
-0.38436055183410645,
-0.09856479614973068,
-0.48123621940612793,
0.03906213119626045,
-0.21684762835502625,
-0.6807528138160706,
0.42511749267578125,
-0.1382848471403122,
-0.25221335887908936,
0.67812579870224,
0.3927345871925354,
-0.20050202310085297,
0.8376929759979248,
0.34934502840042114,
-0.03893117234110832,
0.35342469811439514,
0.010328970849514008,
0.26054930686950684,
-0.3906228542327881,
-0.1083798035979271,
-1.2222477197647095,
-0.3135303854942322,
-0.5413402318954468,
-0.572441577911377,
0.041225116699934006,
-0.40351009368896484,
0.0013917469186708331,
0.2344011664390564,
-0.9434075951576233,
0.6559228301048279,
0.13015617430210114,
-0.39174702763557434,
0.27230751514434814,
0.3122008442878723,
-0.04892444610595703,
-0.528999924659729,
-0.43446412682533264,
-0.6052137613296509,
0.5729692578315735,
0.1982984095811844,
0.4105680584907532,
0.04958048835396767,
0.37759914994239807,
0.6342419385910034,
0.14432722330093384,
-1.0541973114013672,
0.6046250462532043,
0.05784571170806885,
-0.6657213568687439,
-0.1347270905971527,
-0.471848726272583,
-1.368654727935791,
0.20410020649433136,
0.009325231425464153,
-1.0082688331604004,
0.2721550464630127,
0.05737774819135666,
-0.03031635284423828,
0.1598328799009323,
-0.452471524477005,
0.6062499284744263,
-0.1807195544242859,
-0.031793754547834396,
-0.2686026990413666,
-0.4103167951107025,
0.1916305273771286,
0.2024344950914383,
0.685644268989563,
-0.060919083654880524,
-0.04434895142912865,
0.8563476800918579,
-0.0306797306984663,
0.8950595259666443,
-0.12083292007446289,
-0.19942861795425415,
0.74946528673172,
0.15354178845882416,
0.5793567299842834,
-0.20853208005428314,
0.048370927572250366,
0.08020748198032379,
0.11433607339859009,
-0.5121455788612366,
-0.4621567130088806,
0.6859909892082214,
-0.29187101125717163,
-0.27677685022354126,
-0.7399951815605164,
-0.3237346410751343,
-0.24646374583244324,
0.06836190819740295,
0.47857680916786194,
0.36422842741012573,
-0.5409806370735168,
0.06978704780340195,
0.6581437587738037,
-0.054016564041376114,
0.33368054032325745,
0.10263442993164062,
-0.03978264704346657,
-0.4424930810928345,
1.0770931243896484,
0.15745195746421814,
-0.14502109587192535,
0.7356882691383362,
0.27888354659080505,
-0.4222877323627472,
-0.8732866048812866,
-0.200050950050354,
0.29092004895210266,
-0.9012644290924072,
0.07512512803077698,
-0.208574578166008,
-0.03349628672003746,
-0.31755948066711426,
-0.19106587767601013,
-0.17068541049957275,
-0.7196882963180542,
-0.6080387234687805,
0.1443561613559723,
0.4995196461677551,
1.0909723043441772,
-0.0791378915309906,
0.36601078510284424,
-0.30043432116508484,
0.38180699944496155,
0.14725559949874878,
0.19678045809268951,
-0.05617714673280716,
-0.2971359193325043,
0.23173308372497559,
0.15794993937015533,
-0.16099819540977478,
-1.1559197902679443,
0.2861160933971405,
0.12256690859794617,
0.5106047987937927,
0.38670045137405396,
0.09912066161632538,
0.5359911918640137,
-0.31735488772392273,
0.8268556594848633,
0.1568610668182373,
-0.7330315113067627,
0.5856794714927673,
-0.681316077709198,
0.3522133529186249,
0.6047680377960205,
0.5830552577972412,
-0.6125658750534058,
0.029755862429738045,
-0.5346260666847229,
-0.47084951400756836,
0.6015130281448364,
0.5366637110710144,
-0.08280762284994125,
0.060452934354543686,
0.28056851029396057,
0.0003187225665897131,
0.11320590227842331,
-0.36393359303474426,
-0.27431562542915344,
-0.0016693576471880078,
-0.18253283202648163,
0.03167049214243889,
0.09992852061986923,
-0.17855669558048248,
-0.28943106532096863,
0.40846553444862366,
-0.2830080986022949,
0.22150814533233643,
0.03338347002863884,
-0.17958955466747284,
-0.04583507031202316,
0.4057772159576416,
1.1472452878952026,
0.641867995262146,
0.10319985449314117,
0.29442036151885986,
-0.028820935636758804,
-0.688819944858551,
-0.12126503139734268,
0.18144014477729797,
-0.15632683038711548,
0.25646257400512695,
0.39145833253860474,
0.4265551269054413,
0.5120610594749451,
-0.756467878818512,
0.230087548494339,
-0.27460724115371704,
-0.12378675490617752,
-0.48838865756988525,
-0.44202476739883423,
0.28707581758499146,
0.06788823008537292,
0.6549583077430725,
0.37147462368011475,
0.41307973861694336,
-0.6245946884155273,
0.15051697194576263,
0.6578776240348816,
-0.35430216789245605,
-0.41589829325675964,
0.20122197270393372,
-0.06475833803415298,
-0.5354377627372742,
-0.003910937812179327,
-0.37745168805122375,
-0.6038509011268616,
0.876599907875061,
0.4197368919849396,
0.5813060402870178,
0.2117985337972641,
0.6547583341598511,
0.08395599573850632,
0.2823949158191681,
0.030791977420449257,
0.1261136829853058,
-0.06170301139354706,
-0.31077003479003906,
-0.15638454258441925,
-0.1433471143245697,
-0.856167197227478,
0.2884135842323303,
-0.4612133502960205,
0.14940202236175537,
-0.5980508327484131,
-0.18713806569576263,
0.6432536840438843,
0.014041289687156677,
-0.4163711965084076,
-0.19381074607372284,
0.5033106207847595,
0.6127970814704895,
-0.5038573741912842,
0.3527541756629944,
0.8076876997947693,
-0.06255268305540085,
-0.38204994797706604,
-0.17342109978199005,
0.5213142037391663,
-0.43522220849990845,
0.4277503192424774,
-0.04630599543452263,
-0.519228458404541,
-0.19291308522224426,
-0.7740398049354553,
-0.7537347674369812,
0.4376012086868286,
0.7336681485176086,
-0.3172667920589447,
0.1878959834575653,
0.3901445269584656,
0.6972394585609436,
-0.5400519371032715,
0.5645707845687866,
0.5610697865486145,
0.7858192920684814,
0.4716304540634155,
-0.5814319849014282,
0.058058690279722214,
-0.31130632758140564,
-0.09655412286520004,
0.2342718094587326,
-0.28129908442497253,
0.9449441432952881,
0.21797551214694977,
-0.5008029341697693,
0.19573815166950226,
0.609982967376709,
0.5835664868354797,
0.7095506191253662,
0.2313414067029953,
0.05153902992606163,
0.9575985074043274,
-0.24815979599952698,
0.8088646531105042,
0.01309543289244175,
0.3082178235054016,
0.9385504722595215,
-0.2650563716888428,
0.641700804233551,
0.251391738653183,
-0.3296523690223694,
0.5869707465171814,
0.7805378437042236,
0.07683233916759491,
0.11938068270683289,
0.5114816427230835,
-0.2105576992034912,
-0.2874637544155121,
-0.4007418751716614,
-0.5579397678375244,
0.45738905668258667,
0.767669677734375,
-0.13267682492733002,
-0.4381351172924042,
0.02080666646361351,
-0.05542818456888199,
0.5892269611358643,
-0.23504868149757385,
0.4661279022693634,
0.10223577171564102,
-0.5844599604606628,
0.737423300743103,
-0.07323988527059555,
0.6035656332969666,
-0.3939230144023895,
-0.40391257405281067,
0.2049098163843155,
-0.1896035522222519,
-0.10846824944019318,
-0.6845338344573975,
0.4258371591567993,
0.015322519466280937,
0.05523902550339699,
-0.2683216631412506,
1.445913553237915,
0.09376844018697739,
-0.5386829972267151,
-0.14757530391216278,
0.4652199447154999,
0.26235148310661316,
-0.36156970262527466,
-0.6207032203674316,
0.2274363785982132,
-0.16201278567314148,
-0.02030712552368641,
0.32670703530311584,
0.47759443521499634,
-0.040448471903800964,
0.5877890586853027,
0.4381033182144165,
-0.07142075151205063,
0.07493613660335541,
0.0396200567483902,
0.6647337675094604,
-0.745195746421814,
-0.42134156823158264,
-0.6517112255096436,
0.08035477995872498,
-0.3247900903224945,
-0.2730165421962738,
0.555708646774292,
0.4165194630622864,
0.45322325825691223,
-0.28447088599205017,
0.8002599477767944,
-0.07874730229377747,
0.5486993193626404,
-0.3644094169139862,
0.8736823201179504,
-0.2094058096408844,
0.28644710779190063,
-0.38547810912132263,
-0.48917606472969055,
-0.3171643614768982,
0.7654773592948914,
-0.5085477828979492,
-0.07081185281276703,
0.6999504566192627,
0.44188910722732544,
0.0720878317952156,
0.7727034687995911,
0.13462182879447937,
-0.06978393346071243,
0.1484936624765396,
0.34238019585609436,
1.3219670057296753,
-0.2786751687526703,
0.591334879398346,
-0.384662002325058,
0.09192337840795517,
-0.18408334255218506,
-0.9958160519599915,
-0.9353352189064026,
-0.8714945316314697,
-0.6591275334358215,
0.3174131512641907,
-0.3145482838153839,
0.7083315253257751,
0.6908731460571289,
-0.9504094123840332,
-0.2143428921699524,
-0.2666996717453003,
0.6538429260253906,
-0.1704111248254776,
-0.2775150537490845,
0.1908155232667923,
-0.019407974556088448,
-0.6169245839118958,
0.5654566884040833,
0.3786257207393646,
0.06373287737369537,
-0.10385707765817642,
0.25827378034591675,
-0.4217182397842407,
0.5781014561653137,
0.5574632287025452,
0.7534832954406738,
-0.6544522643089294,
-0.3711531162261963,
-0.06667472422122955,
-0.04426179826259613,
0.20586195588111877,
1.5132025480270386,
-0.941898763179779,
0.06281480938196182,
0.8306966423988342,
0.41933968663215637,
0.3719955384731293,
0.002646286739036441,
0.0934549868106842,
-0.7402369976043701,
0.0928955078125,
0.681257963180542,
0.29694414138793945,
0.41123899817466736,
-0.47336697578430176,
0.42631152272224426,
0.42541566491127014,
-0.23121896386146545,
-1.034104347229004,
0.5419561862945557,
-1.2193939685821533,
-0.3951846659183502,
0.5967288017272949,
0.12959162890911102,
-0.2448635995388031,
-0.5371192097663879,
-0.4392699599266052,
-0.10761357843875885,
-0.29581713676452637,
0.3723631799221039,
0.7735209465026855,
-0.4954133927822113,
-0.3816032111644745,
-0.47004395723342896,
0.6505834460258484,
0.16224002838134766,
-1.062535285949707,
0.09978586435317993,
0.679957926273346,
0.005117179360240698,
0.5103632807731628,
0.6529420614242554,
0.003170561045408249,
0.34172412753105164,
0.058356426656246185,
-0.6247546672821045,
0.31049057841300964,
-0.2058146893978119,
-0.297016978263855,
0.7134708762168884,
0.09092588722705841,
0.19425831735134125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16672v1 | CAVE: Controllable Authorship Verification Explanations | 2024-06-24T14:27:54 | 2024-06-24T14:27:54 | Sahana Ramnath, Kartik Pandey, Elizabeth Boschee, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Authorship Verification (AV) (do two documents have the same author?) is
essential for many sensitive real-life applications. AV is often used in
proprietary domains that require a private, offline model, making SOTA online
models like ChatGPT undesirable. Other SOTA systems use methods, e.g. Siamese
Networks, that are uninterpretable, and hence cannot be trusted in high-stakes
applications. In this work, we take the first step to address the above
challenges with our model CAVE (Controllable Authorship Verification
Explanations): CAVE generates free-text AV explanations that are controlled to
be 1) structured (can be decomposed into sub-explanations with respect to
relevant linguistic features), and 2) easily verified for explanation-label
consistency (via intermediate labels in sub-explanations). In this work, we
train a Llama-3-8B as CAVE; since there are no human-written corpora for AV
explanations, we sample silver-standard explanations from GPT-4-TURBO and
distill them into a pretrained Llama-3-8B. Results on three difficult AV
datasets IMdB2, Blog-Auth, and FanFiction show that CAVE generates high quality
explanations (as measured by automatic and human evaluation) as well as
competitive task accuracies. | [
0.029316533356904984,
-0.517035961151123,
0.6193861365318298,
0.26577913761138916,
-0.3082043528556824,
-0.02934730425477028,
-0.11026035249233246,
-0.5494329929351807,
0.05876091867685318,
0.6452355980873108,
-0.6316515207290649,
-0.3955901265144348,
-0.8812746405601501,
0.40628865361213684,
-0.18238499760627747,
1.206119179725647,
-0.4776749014854431,
-0.13837531208992004,
-0.36558666825294495,
-0.16526168584823608,
-0.41705837845802307,
-0.2766575813293457,
-0.6883025169372559,
-0.3475128710269928,
0.5422238707542419,
0.11641949415206909,
0.4649636447429657,
0.7627081274986267,
0.3412621021270752,
0.2271561324596405,
0.002959091914817691,
0.2643294036388397,
-0.7271432876586914,
0.1282012015581131,
-0.15675200521945953,
-0.4645543098449707,
-0.47448065876960754,
-0.0774860605597496,
0.215001180768013,
0.2168555110692978,
0.043961066752672195,
0.12281088531017303,
-0.13563278317451477,
0.3571433126926422,
-0.5883215665817261,
0.32488200068473816,
-0.4561270475387573,
-0.03525950014591217,
-0.11534740775823593,
-0.41673046350479126,
-0.5931287407875061,
-0.5529837012290955,
0.003271980443969369,
-0.9045181274414062,
0.24817213416099548,
0.04264660179615021,
0.8610827326774597,
0.5913979411125183,
-0.46035876870155334,
-0.5641977787017822,
-0.7228858470916748,
0.623586118221283,
-0.4076595902442932,
-0.03623300418257713,
0.518788754940033,
0.40826427936553955,
-0.02463122271001339,
-0.7118558883666992,
-0.6210882067680359,
-0.07676307111978531,
-0.33669474720954895,
0.10973124951124191,
-0.08365566283464432,
-0.06591980159282684,
-0.05735073611140251,
0.19402246177196503,
-0.560834527015686,
0.10223429650068283,
-0.4126298129558563,
-0.36639076471328735,
0.8145759105682373,
-0.1410856544971466,
0.19064874947071075,
0.0961846113204956,
-0.5322434902191162,
0.054461341351270676,
-1.1881132125854492,
0.3038431406021118,
0.41857069730758667,
0.0855436846613884,
-0.013931537047028542,
0.7669315934181213,
0.10136378556489944,
0.40215107798576355,
0.11277718842029572,
0.021522201597690582,
-0.13960157334804535,
-0.16675026714801788,
-0.06171990931034088,
0.33536073565483093,
0.7080272436141968,
-0.002598137827590108,
0.34504276514053345,
-0.3229318857192993,
-0.10558512806892395,
-0.004775718320161104,
0.1270347535610199,
-0.6457626819610596,
-0.22586670517921448,
0.41834214329719543,
-0.2131466418504715,
-0.40886762738227844,
0.04007347673177719,
-0.5054677724838257,
-0.8242515325546265,
-0.15352381765842438,
0.7977604866027832,
-0.02981964871287346,
-0.39768722653388977,
0.0496729277074337,
0.015398922376334667,
0.1348235160112381,
0.5530269742012024,
-0.630033016204834,
0.2585897743701935,
0.6295093894004822,
0.615327000617981,
-0.17299608886241913,
-0.2675440311431885,
-0.9248502850532532,
0.20037896931171417,
-0.4503014385700226,
0.35322850942611694,
-0.358174592256546,
-0.017961395904421806,
-0.14557482302188873,
-0.1312873363494873,
-0.027713991701602936,
-0.2066454440355301,
-0.026908252388238907,
-0.7072736620903015,
0.2800987660884857,
-0.2704298198223114,
-0.42079129815101624,
-0.253317654132843,
0.14990603923797607,
-0.5298429727554321,
0.7063020467758179,
-0.09463917464017868,
-0.8716390132904053,
0.31591522693634033,
-0.7144415378570557,
-0.12658853828907013,
0.08944917470216751,
-0.3867886960506439,
-0.32979968190193176,
-0.28679370880126953,
0.3727596402168274,
0.5371397733688354,
-0.06369514018297195,
0.37469133734703064,
0.2237308770418167,
-0.42271533608436584,
0.15969640016555786,
0.14972738921642303,
1.0343334674835205,
0.07865285128355026,
-0.8189406394958496,
0.17681753635406494,
-0.6414309144020081,
-0.37622788548469543,
0.1926766037940979,
-0.3058791160583496,
-0.2817623019218445,
-0.09457756578922272,
-0.5314846038818359,
-0.21382762491703033,
0.4462003707885742,
-0.5851731300354004,
0.07120072841644287,
0.14594903588294983,
0.32262349128723145,
0.915788471698761,
0.04953089728951454,
0.11980099231004715,
-0.19654515385627747,
0.8236235976219177,
-0.11545824259519577,
0.05529993027448654,
-0.19892849028110504,
-0.697304368019104,
-0.3423577845096588,
-0.7407481670379639,
0.35085776448249817,
0.6575255393981934,
-0.609029233455658,
0.1450059413909912,
-0.2002173364162445,
-0.4533190429210663,
-0.5534306168556213,
0.17693288624286652,
0.7409818768501282,
0.4265224039554596,
0.3204611539840698,
-0.18832609057426453,
-0.36797231435775757,
-0.6175052523612976,
-0.46990248560905457,
-0.08850618451833725,
-0.30227130651474,
0.7177838087081909,
0.5081574320793152,
-0.26926079392433167,
1.0728353261947632,
-0.2437630593776703,
-0.30788931250572205,
-0.07042787969112396,
0.33837205171585083,
0.150096595287323,
0.46604418754577637,
0.3417779207229614,
-0.9710711240768433,
-0.30308058857917786,
-0.022536946460604668,
-1.0054295063018799,
-0.27766403555870056,
-0.22264587879180908,
-0.14685556292533875,
-0.15188096463680267,
0.7446789741516113,
-0.713194727897644,
0.5195102095603943,
0.5332067608833313,
-0.5304321646690369,
0.6362429261207581,
-0.2576407790184021,
0.09699177742004395,
-0.7759972810745239,
0.10145577788352966,
-0.20106887817382812,
-0.5668304562568665,
-0.31356412172317505,
0.3657156825065613,
-0.18816861510276794,
0.09239053726196289,
-0.3806276321411133,
0.4860905706882477,
-0.45567837357521057,
0.11192505061626434,
0.1413532793521881,
0.2904823124408722,
-0.0029788988176733255,
0.7737677693367004,
-0.12311328202486038,
0.6087786555290222,
0.7125219702720642,
-0.6106640696525574,
0.3452723026275635,
0.3823159635066986,
-0.2143493890762329,
0.3305763900279999,
-0.9184442758560181,
0.39185798168182373,
-0.33364203572273254,
0.5999365448951721,
-1.2045156955718994,
-0.48922762274742126,
0.2402370572090149,
-0.5443359017372131,
0.2624239921569824,
-0.36949634552001953,
-0.39306142926216125,
0.19542196393013,
-0.031172286719083786,
0.4482190012931824,
0.4375498592853546,
-0.6647799015045166,
0.7781035900115967,
0.21110382676124573,
-0.36937156319618225,
-0.8444689512252808,
-0.6600115895271301,
-0.056033264845609665,
-0.1783338040113449,
-0.5255816578865051,
0.12238655984401703,
-0.1366911083459854,
-0.4532487690448761,
0.08835561573505402,
-0.22031962871551514,
-0.3033740818500519,
0.10466860234737396,
0.5828125476837158,
0.24223202466964722,
-0.20988982915878296,
0.007334149908274412,
0.2332727015018463,
-0.07049967348575592,
-0.02697659842669964,
-0.07722917944192886,
-0.043204259127378464,
-0.18826644122600555,
-0.12881256639957428,
-0.5651105046272278,
0.3806488811969757,
0.6148804426193237,
-0.3616105914115906,
0.8490874767303467,
0.34491172432899475,
-0.3703090250492096,
0.014150546863675117,
-0.36263343691825867,
-0.11368479579687119,
-0.4137404263019562,
-0.31186798214912415,
-0.4458199441432953,
-1.2786282300949097,
0.6779531836509705,
-0.07678620517253876,
0.261654257774353,
0.5891966223716736,
0.5857740640640259,
0.13432519137859344,
0.93116295337677,
0.588178277015686,
0.29852405190467834,
-0.014221257530152798,
-0.2369479387998581,
0.2948419451713562,
-0.6201316714286804,
-0.46348416805267334,
-0.517909824848175,
-0.14464300870895386,
-0.5044524073600769,
-0.22485992312431335,
0.275064080953598,
0.05227060988545418,
-0.24212957918643951,
0.6352885961532593,
-0.618251621723175,
0.827575147151947,
0.5623120069503784,
0.057636428624391556,
0.5249892473220825,
-0.3559791147708893,
-0.034767996519804,
0.16123229265213013,
-0.36524486541748047,
-0.7560002207756042,
0.9875961542129517,
0.32622984051704407,
0.8075500130653381,
0.4210975170135498,
0.848052978515625,
0.6063860654830933,
0.26148897409439087,
-0.30654096603393555,
0.438500314950943,
0.025708863511681557,
-0.9823105335235596,
-0.5380106568336487,
-0.418316125869751,
-0.9764243960380554,
0.19904406368732452,
-0.14245587587356567,
-1.036342740058899,
0.20627489686012268,
0.3975740671157837,
-0.5812092423439026,
0.0810924768447876,
-0.7069059610366821,
0.639327883720398,
0.10558795928955078,
-0.43583232164382935,
-0.012124981731176376,
-0.9458177089691162,
0.5756618976593018,
-0.23731869459152222,
0.3587813079357147,
0.08101779967546463,
0.15393736958503723,
0.7193584442138672,
-0.5035603046417236,
0.9099695086479187,
-0.3927347958087921,
-0.11148333549499512,
0.22972077131271362,
0.5266387462615967,
0.7441979050636292,
0.3206673860549927,
-0.08864125609397888,
0.3128560483455658,
-0.03597429022192955,
-0.31147125363349915,
-0.3367592990398407,
0.7188271284103394,
-0.9779735207557678,
-0.5157414078712463,
-0.3100232183933258,
-0.29072028398513794,
0.08983590453863144,
0.3772628605365753,
0.5838974118232727,
0.39607495069503784,
0.03146393597126007,
0.4023761749267578,
0.8787925243377686,
-0.2040768414735794,
-0.15240100026130676,
0.19018913805484772,
0.09229087829589844,
-0.10301046818494797,
0.7115284204483032,
-0.13882610201835632,
-0.03834562376141548,
0.6113004088401794,
0.35702404379844666,
-0.25929442048072815,
-0.4473924934864044,
-0.564427375793457,
0.25900799036026,
-0.6917917728424072,
0.02517854981124401,
-0.7574605345726013,
-0.0933624878525734,
-0.2492273896932602,
-0.4455326497554779,
-0.2535374164581299,
-0.5379135608673096,
-0.27251148223876953,
-0.26950523257255554,
0.3122169077396393,
1.0288764238357544,
-0.033226098865270615,
0.49422091245651245,
-0.3110038936138153,
0.6168152093887329,
0.6450398564338684,
0.25659582018852234,
-0.256334125995636,
-0.3860698640346527,
-0.02608664147555828,
0.06810939311981201,
0.002439068630337715,
-0.9065800309181213,
-0.05356498435139656,
0.30711913108825684,
0.47313088178634644,
0.4151572585105896,
0.1398029774427414,
0.2518762946128845,
-0.360291063785553,
0.984911322593689,
-0.12588508427143097,
-0.9978115558624268,
0.5841293931007385,
-0.5014323592185974,
-0.22028139233589172,
0.5640300512313843,
0.47493985295295715,
-0.11411663144826889,
-0.6804046034812927,
-0.6871963143348694,
-0.77931809425354,
0.861535906791687,
0.5616554617881775,
-0.0627760961651802,
0.43761906027793884,
0.500575602054596,
0.6510301828384399,
0.30598461627960205,
-1.0338383913040161,
0.08564735949039459,
-0.33882054686546326,
0.004866067320108414,
-0.19626551866531372,
-0.16876263916492462,
-0.6448401212692261,
0.2501574754714966,
0.7718621492385864,
0.051938991993665695,
0.190216064453125,
0.41541340947151184,
-0.2882493734359741,
-0.15100908279418945,
-0.07131023705005646,
0.8035159707069397,
0.9734295010566711,
-0.2310718148946762,
0.46463873982429504,
-0.2144642174243927,
-0.3128601312637329,
0.07444590330123901,
-0.12138763070106506,
0.004260492045432329,
0.04825201258063316,
0.7064921855926514,
0.7513755559921265,
-0.23519636690616608,
-0.4741751551628113,
0.8878071904182434,
-0.3158854842185974,
-0.45797836780548096,
-0.25350382924079895,
0.18511620163917542,
0.11042969673871994,
0.24670585989952087,
0.27294889092445374,
0.11679691076278687,
-0.14418594539165497,
-0.15275278687477112,
-0.0906493216753006,
0.0440259724855423,
-0.3229140043258667,
-0.34332704544067383,
1.0881904363632202,
0.18020883202552795,
-0.3511340022087097,
0.43514254689216614,
-0.20168694853782654,
-0.33600351214408875,
0.7337483763694763,
0.3327765166759491,
0.8215866684913635,
-0.09508658945560455,
0.28727152943611145,
0.27201947569847107,
0.4944669008255005,
-0.06066291034221649,
0.09211672842502594,
-0.4898088872432709,
-0.5325475335121155,
-0.47914937138557434,
-0.285699725151062,
-0.8341933488845825,
0.018605554476380348,
-0.5724124908447266,
0.0016979872016236186,
-0.5553297996520996,
0.36402660608291626,
0.1086881011724472,
-0.25896915793418884,
-0.6079855561256409,
0.28792804479599,
-0.170958012342453,
0.7585631012916565,
-1.1348350048065186,
0.3025131821632385,
0.4275535047054291,
-0.2761618196964264,
-0.9999160170555115,
-0.23708750307559967,
0.2126644104719162,
-0.9869421720504761,
0.44161611795425415,
0.28944194316864014,
-0.4475957751274109,
0.13818056881427765,
-1.0386590957641602,
-0.49721407890319824,
1.2620822191238403,
0.5393500924110413,
-0.19744712114334106,
0.249592587351799,
-0.38998082280158997,
0.6325696110725403,
-0.2932903468608856,
-0.012768554501235485,
0.13727276027202606,
0.5136310458183289,
0.2567569315433502,
-0.7840323448181152,
0.2696402370929718,
-0.30882400274276733,
-0.4493364691734314,
-0.1794755458831787,
-0.44134873151779175,
0.763671875,
-0.35068368911743164,
-0.04544897750020027,
-0.026030991226434708,
0.4638284146785736,
0.6345201134681702,
0.4649915099143982,
0.7164797782897949,
0.240285262465477,
0.9258040189743042,
-0.05956995487213135,
1.1159363985061646,
-0.06411399692296982,
0.1611052304506302,
1.116351842880249,
-0.12976589798927307,
0.5083596110343933,
0.4861631393432617,
0.038475774228572845,
0.7385346293449402,
0.8582606315612793,
0.2710903584957123,
0.5490329265594482,
0.29664936661720276,
-0.15024298429489136,
-0.40398621559143066,
-0.06306673586368561,
-0.3649917244911194,
0.625749409198761,
0.025383664295077324,
-0.2531168460845947,
0.07882877439260483,
-0.15217848122119904,
0.19136540591716766,
-0.1116417944431305,
-0.13549937307834625,
0.7269441485404968,
-0.005044009070843458,
-0.9715933203697205,
0.46128493547439575,
-0.1370052844285965,
0.31338733434677124,
-0.7585331797599792,
-0.04261235520243645,
-0.21979092061519623,
0.23979441821575165,
-0.3211382031440735,
-0.4567283093929291,
0.06714479625225067,
0.426967978477478,
0.05906062573194504,
-0.42296087741851807,
0.4364759027957916,
-0.45731452107429504,
-0.1045546755194664,
-0.09889383614063263,
0.25694572925567627,
0.7610355019569397,
-0.05513791739940643,
-0.15872149169445038,
-0.18687863647937775,
-0.03459111601114273,
-0.44609639048576355,
-0.15696001052856445,
0.5896056294441223,
-0.37365245819091797,
0.7226327061653137,
0.5493496060371399,
0.1990964412689209,
0.20606446266174316,
-0.14156600832939148,
0.6225845217704773,
-0.12589384615421295,
-0.8098760843276978,
-0.7909416556358337,
0.5239694714546204,
0.11427408456802368,
-0.364520788192749,
0.493439257144928,
0.4528852105140686,
0.6533702611923218,
-0.12440662086009979,
0.886574923992157,
-0.21760067343711853,
0.32179510593414307,
-0.5657769441604614,
0.8366553783416748,
-0.7432272434234619,
0.16977426409721375,
-0.2302876114845276,
-0.7499546408653259,
-0.4409486651420593,
0.5091190934181213,
0.0894068032503128,
-0.024780413135886192,
0.7199099659919739,
0.8502540588378906,
-0.09068865329027176,
-0.10051610320806503,
-0.042386628687381744,
0.3575097918510437,
0.5384935140609741,
0.4435498118400574,
0.5825867056846619,
-0.2716433107852936,
0.6762188673019409,
0.033639222383499146,
-0.6981091499328613,
-0.46222180128097534,
-1.267635464668274,
-0.8811048865318298,
-0.59052574634552,
-0.5125132203102112,
-0.3058437705039978,
0.03647654503583908,
0.4773862659931183,
0.8464812636375427,
-0.7941393852233887,
0.0152495251968503,
-0.22496114671230316,
0.41567888855934143,
-0.5011839270591736,
-0.13804295659065247,
0.5642690658569336,
0.30830660462379456,
-0.44831305742263794,
0.4127485156059265,
0.23451897501945496,
-0.04196176305413246,
-0.2970186769962311,
-0.3439084589481354,
0.019940506666898727,
0.33412954211235046,
0.1897123157978058,
0.45666781067848206,
-0.8070636987686157,
-0.2992596924304962,
0.04373692348599434,
-0.14879700541496277,
-0.08381900936365128,
0.9338074922561646,
-0.4703455865383148,
0.8095795512199402,
0.5159899592399597,
0.5554909110069275,
0.6689504981040955,
0.19827350974082947,
0.5765368342399597,
-0.835966944694519,
-0.11502955108880997,
0.1607036292552948,
0.2315736562013626,
0.37565451860427856,
-0.9007723331451416,
0.6862578392028809,
0.0683756098151207,
-0.8109043836593628,
-0.8720957040786743,
0.09342259913682938,
-1.137559175491333,
0.0046890354715287685,
1.1071752309799194,
-0.5913063883781433,
-0.10591243207454681,
-0.1451454758644104,
-0.2920010983943939,
0.4999437630176544,
-0.13693709671497345,
1.0932472944259644,
0.797177255153656,
-0.2659556567668915,
-0.06896918267011642,
-0.2920038402080536,
0.5241626501083374,
0.11867021769285202,
-0.6614255905151367,
0.1481047421693802,
0.2045615166425705,
0.211578831076622,
0.22114644944667816,
1.0070428848266602,
-0.15153704583644867,
0.4818148612976074,
0.0507887601852417,
0.12967008352279663,
-0.5610268712043762,
-0.6516599059104919,
-0.1415022909641266,
0.007459072396159172,
-0.037954460829496384,
-0.404410719871521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16655v1 | Large Language Models Are Cross-Lingual Knowledge-Free Reasoners | 2024-06-24T14:03:04 | 2024-06-24T14:03:04 | Peng Hu, Sizhe Liu, Changjiang Gao, Xin Huang, Xue Han, Junlan Feng, Chao Deng, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models have demonstrated impressive reasoning capabilities
across multiple languages. However, the relationship between capabilities in
different languages is less explored. In this work, we decompose the process of
reasoning tasks into two separated parts: knowledge retrieval and
knowledge-free reasoning, and analyze the cross-lingual transferability of
them. With adapted and constructed knowledge-free reasoning datasets, we show
that the knowledge-free reasoning capability can be nearly perfectly
transferred across various source-target language directions despite the
secondary impact of resource in some specific target languages, while
cross-lingual knowledge retrieval significantly hinders the transfer. Moreover,
by analyzing the hidden states and feed-forward network neuron activation
during the reasoning tasks, we show that higher similarity of hidden
representations and larger overlap of activated neurons could explain the
better cross-lingual transferability of knowledge-free reasoning than knowledge
retrieval. Thus, we hypothesize that knowledge-free reasoning embeds in some
language-shared mechanism, while knowledge is stored separately in different
languages. | [
-0.20259001851081848,
-0.3338488042354584,
0.8143795728683472,
0.18703493475914001,
0.11593756079673767,
-0.16929085552692413,
-0.4928603768348694,
-0.7128595113754272,
0.12589092552661896,
0.36759325861930847,
-0.173039972782135,
0.08085038512945175,
-0.607068657875061,
-0.07491578906774521,
-0.3609693646430969,
0.6182361841201782,
-0.32378000020980835,
0.000014120393643679563,
-0.3493870794773102,
-0.2744895815849304,
-0.29293301701545715,
-0.45521146059036255,
-0.5069363117218018,
-0.684002697467804,
0.7048676013946533,
0.053977809846401215,
0.7186073660850525,
0.24894990026950836,
0.05348280444741249,
0.2090814709663391,
-0.14035098254680634,
-0.038503699004650116,
-0.18456967175006866,
0.062419578433036804,
-1.0230369567871094,
-0.688474714756012,
-0.10079535096883774,
-0.3620026111602783,
0.554831326007843,
0.7996972799301147,
0.16833403706550598,
-0.08983151614665985,
0.06794153153896332,
0.4389726221561432,
-0.5930126309394836,
0.37410980463027954,
-0.6167474985122681,
-0.14565762877464294,
0.15061312913894653,
-0.03571386635303497,
-0.4711504280567169,
-0.19305431842803955,
0.29642629623413086,
-0.7890885472297668,
0.03787549212574959,
-0.11116710305213928,
0.8265397548675537,
0.006660490296781063,
-0.4509163200855255,
-0.24082764983177185,
-0.5354422330856323,
0.7163897752761841,
-0.3807911276817322,
0.5519636869430542,
0.4998041093349457,
0.2882808446884155,
0.27640601992607117,
-0.36962515115737915,
-0.5916450619697571,
-0.26374152302742004,
-0.3659437596797943,
-0.37036874890327454,
-0.5208121538162231,
-0.188038632273674,
0.30037885904312134,
0.09685539454221725,
-0.43344685435295105,
0.021464260295033455,
-0.4129982888698578,
-0.37598133087158203,
0.6573035717010498,
-0.3861479163169861,
0.6896296143531799,
-0.14587515592575073,
-0.31852489709854126,
-0.10020247101783752,
-0.6220695376396179,
0.02757471613585949,
0.12858183681964874,
0.40182945132255554,
-0.10727310180664062,
0.48025983572006226,
-0.24755656719207764,
0.5164419412612915,
-0.2706433832645416,
0.19778883457183838,
0.05495573207736015,
-0.4550614356994629,
-0.04708630219101906,
0.053986988961696625,
0.8087624907493591,
0.13328780233860016,
0.6851481795310974,
-0.5633278489112854,
-0.14817234873771667,
-0.2570040822029114,
-0.059162821620702744,
-0.4625774323940277,
-0.11271179467439651,
-0.18843485414981842,
-0.4541805386543274,
0.29714107513427734,
-0.36634621024131775,
-0.39617374539375305,
-0.1983310431241989,
-0.27983608841896057,
0.6715150475502014,
-0.5583720803260803,
-0.6722330451011658,
0.2642209231853485,
-0.20663201808929443,
0.3362806439399719,
0.22909709811210632,
-1.0584310293197632,
0.15734712779521942,
0.7641559839248657,
0.6667260527610779,
-0.2997128367424011,
-0.4574867784976959,
-0.23427243530750275,
0.24943912029266357,
-0.5001369714736938,
0.6435143351554871,
-0.3749677538871765,
-0.016197064891457558,
-0.07631940394639969,
0.36183059215545654,
-0.5788618922233582,
-0.4634599983692169,
0.11080477386713028,
-0.7990023493766785,
0.021490730345249176,
-0.8334627151489258,
-0.32319745421409607,
-0.7751619219779968,
0.2244431972503662,
-0.7798407077789307,
0.5437880158424377,
-0.05981501191854477,
-0.7045980095863342,
0.2511672377586365,
-0.38470014929771423,
-0.7007508277893066,
-0.09789767861366272,
-0.09655795246362686,
0.42687514424324036,
0.10495851933956146,
0.23259836435317993,
0.4308772385120392,
-0.49386242032051086,
0.2838691473007202,
-0.29390740394592285,
-0.15743033587932587,
0.37654227018356323,
-0.3229609727859497,
1.1812903881072998,
0.012175817973911762,
-0.4263116419315338,
0.09635743498802185,
-0.4788709282875061,
0.19112318754196167,
0.04875964671373367,
-0.22821739315986633,
-0.7473165988922119,
-0.1930909901857376,
-0.4121713936328888,
0.4874838888645172,
0.20858922600746155,
-0.5636911988258362,
0.10177590698003769,
-0.17261956632137299,
0.4590927064418793,
0.34845614433288574,
-0.11267568916082382,
0.8060328960418701,
-0.2384413480758667,
0.2225116342306137,
0.1397707611322403,
-0.1966274082660675,
0.25168493390083313,
-0.5419833064079285,
-0.7612404227256775,
0.04021570831537247,
0.25051960349082947,
0.7990254163742065,
-1.0739065408706665,
-0.15714791417121887,
-0.49903327226638794,
-0.25962576270103455,
-0.3077300488948822,
-0.01839267835021019,
0.5158829689025879,
0.20466764271259308,
0.5005593299865723,
0.0028100761119276285,
-0.03740709275007248,
-1.098623514175415,
-0.3969368040561676,
-0.04501917585730553,
0.08400513231754303,
0.2161628156900406,
0.5819423198699951,
0.14822129905223846,
0.3833772838115692,
-0.10084831714630127,
0.057643722742795944,
-0.5632266998291016,
-0.08402359485626221,
0.06351383030414581,
0.5600832104682922,
0.6213359832763672,
-0.5265963673591614,
-0.36600980162620544,
0.549811601638794,
-0.9053512215614319,
0.034366194158792496,
-0.34141114354133606,
-0.42474693059921265,
0.2512105703353882,
0.4284942150115967,
-0.856636106967926,
0.27393683791160583,
0.4253614544868469,
-0.41729071736335754,
0.46006810665130615,
-0.289397269487381,
0.1713358461856842,
-0.7949333786964417,
0.19619816541671753,
-0.2822716236114502,
0.17253537476062775,
-0.5102075934410095,
0.16347311437129974,
0.11332254111766815,
0.07378748804330826,
-0.3843327760696411,
0.9487951397895813,
-0.6680626273155212,
-0.38896816968917847,
-0.17522740364074707,
0.13746938109397888,
0.17620566487312317,
0.5581470727920532,
0.19281497597694397,
0.5117647051811218,
0.9432472586631775,
-0.6428834199905396,
0.39937645196914673,
0.11035758256912231,
-0.5342881083488464,
0.4118456244468689,
-0.6363703012466431,
-0.11652548611164093,
0.04179741442203522,
-0.15983878076076508,
-0.6144794821739197,
0.05677885562181473,
0.1004943996667862,
-0.4339265525341034,
0.17526544630527496,
-0.18003037571907043,
-0.5313636064529419,
0.09456409513950348,
0.39687126874923706,
0.6220260262489319,
0.259308785200119,
-0.5473507046699524,
0.5944586992263794,
0.007027451880276203,
-0.12095041573047638,
-0.6582027673721313,
-1.1241244077682495,
-0.18109211325645447,
0.08121141046285629,
-0.740602970123291,
0.23138560354709625,
0.31274452805519104,
-0.4587317407131195,
0.45964884757995605,
-0.04587838426232338,
-0.19709891080856323,
-0.14755402505397797,
-0.023893430829048157,
0.1379598081111908,
-0.31362831592559814,
0.39261364936828613,
0.20925229787826538,
-0.05452915281057358,
0.20758439600467682,
-0.523341715335846,
0.3245967626571655,
0.0317402258515358,
-0.6176450848579407,
-0.1702505201101303,
0.6482449769973755,
0.7744579315185547,
-0.4428666830062866,
1.0598286390304565,
0.3568353056907654,
-0.34028324484825134,
-0.3659125864505768,
-0.2780151963233948,
-0.07900694012641907,
-0.32804086804389954,
0.2338431179523468,
-0.7233026623725891,
-0.9187850952148438,
0.7817397713661194,
0.27870261669158936,
-0.004373232368379831,
0.46284574270248413,
0.3442600965499878,
0.419141948223114,
0.8079695105552673,
0.45841264724731445,
0.15131224691867828,
0.15999585390090942,
-0.24831736087799072,
0.3761745095252991,
-0.6370327472686768,
-0.5366896390914917,
-0.36783406138420105,
-0.2777695655822754,
-0.3878033757209778,
-0.6758174300193787,
-0.18686836957931519,
0.3083078861236572,
-0.3649106025695801,
0.41488316655158997,
-0.19802892208099365,
0.47110140323638916,
0.7047460675239563,
-0.14743289351463318,
0.31586816906929016,
0.14997071027755737,
-0.621370255947113,
0.12353482842445374,
-0.8766716122627258,
0.06907950341701508,
0.6383998394012451,
0.06381651014089584,
0.6217126250267029,
0.18516182899475098,
0.2739030122756958,
-0.17323502898216248,
-0.12638014554977417,
-0.8737167716026306,
0.7135499119758606,
-0.4355399012565613,
-0.6739262938499451,
-0.18447059392929077,
-0.6061539649963379,
-0.8064970970153809,
0.5965792536735535,
-0.16721898317337036,
-0.9435033202171326,
0.39516398310661316,
-0.31033527851104736,
-0.06597427278757095,
0.9260441660881042,
-0.6995659470558167,
0.7297710180282593,
-0.4703320562839508,
-0.49178582429885864,
-0.4169013500213623,
-0.4309384822845459,
0.3532232344150543,
0.15916159749031067,
0.2100210338830948,
-0.14869771897792816,
0.22818221151828766,
0.6427491903305054,
0.03241821005940437,
0.5158481001853943,
-0.14017914235591888,
-0.29071083664894104,
0.27744004130363464,
0.6092647314071655,
0.07789107412099838,
-0.2151867002248764,
-0.16722075641155243,
0.3634082078933716,
0.03553009033203125,
-0.3638226389884949,
-0.8869131207466125,
0.7049306631088257,
-0.6943175792694092,
-0.8555996417999268,
-0.18659807741641998,
-0.942486047744751,
-0.16742771863937378,
0.4138787090778351,
0.15655192732810974,
0.18822135031223297,
0.3023822605609894,
0.22735515236854553,
0.6539121866226196,
-0.3908011019229889,
0.4101341962814331,
0.3408557176589966,
-0.5036687254905701,
-0.05587960407137871,
0.9692894220352173,
0.3597008287906647,
0.4907844364643097,
0.7459248900413513,
0.0445331372320652,
-0.2885896861553192,
-0.3019315004348755,
-0.3835480809211731,
0.4540366530418396,
-0.8621233105659485,
0.28108370304107666,
-0.5228210091590881,
-0.2786657214164734,
-0.28201085329055786,
-0.26594871282577515,
-0.3745720386505127,
-0.7311988472938538,
-0.11051594465970993,
-0.15519201755523682,
0.20891417562961578,
0.438237726688385,
-0.443534255027771,
-0.26690247654914856,
-0.9111926555633545,
0.33572256565093994,
0.586128830909729,
0.3987562954425812,
0.5003671646118164,
-0.34457847476005554,
-0.15072527527809143,
0.11359218508005142,
0.33711862564086914,
-0.9604071378707886,
0.3517917990684509,
-0.058290034532547,
1.0042680501937866,
0.16580678522586823,
-0.05261213704943657,
0.3029225766658783,
-0.18341495096683502,
0.6908378005027771,
0.2891557812690735,
-0.9682096242904663,
0.2562948167324066,
-0.21745041012763977,
0.3109683692455292,
0.15172812342643738,
0.6435551643371582,
-0.5333491563796997,
0.07402050495147705,
-0.3834134638309479,
-0.6206149458885193,
0.7654877305030823,
-0.05184440314769745,
-0.024662287905812263,
0.03982413932681084,
0.0829957127571106,
0.16967786848545074,
-0.22717233002185822,
-0.6811801791191101,
0.1762804538011551,
-0.1571778506040573,
0.39671552181243896,
0.11822618544101715,
0.03715217113494873,
-0.3271062970161438,
-0.3747878074645996,
0.5647056102752686,
-0.1822810173034668,
0.3711685240268707,
0.18004100024700165,
-0.25297829508781433,
0.11552489548921585,
0.5856003761291504,
0.2154560536146164,
0.5342710614204407,
0.3765732944011688,
0.36195772886276245,
0.25195544958114624,
-0.023468738421797752,
0.17984089255332947,
0.1660149246454239,
-0.19005542993545532,
-0.1169368326663971,
0.5598368048667908,
1.0676922798156738,
0.2625473439693451,
-0.48499783873558044,
0.44230082631111145,
0.011569547466933727,
-0.619737446308136,
0.12482789903879166,
0.035770002752542496,
0.4699774384498596,
0.674729585647583,
0.22643350064754486,
0.06050196290016174,
-0.08512292802333832,
-0.5401644706726074,
0.07446261495351791,
0.3882947266101837,
-0.31427696347236633,
-0.414115309715271,
0.5524564981460571,
-0.22588388621807098,
0.06260699033737183,
0.802826464176178,
-0.29481130838394165,
-0.6150696873664856,
0.4982985854148865,
0.6356841325759888,
0.7667707800865173,
-0.008189828135073185,
0.38359811902046204,
0.4661099910736084,
0.3499942421913147,
-0.3127645254135132,
0.37096983194351196,
-0.34468308091163635,
-1.0401487350463867,
-0.7632662653923035,
-0.4333633780479431,
-0.07124796509742737,
-0.030174870043992996,
-0.6526570916175842,
-0.31860020756721497,
-0.12383950501680374,
0.14429070055484772,
-0.028358684852719307,
-0.2916569709777832,
-0.6082890033721924,
-0.05040958896279335,
0.16463758051395416,
0.937336266040802,
-0.6767634749412537,
0.9288914799690247,
0.6797832250595093,
-0.3877308964729309,
-1.2687644958496094,
-0.13198676705360413,
-0.29387739300727844,
-0.8692702054977417,
1.0341126918792725,
0.035397134721279144,
-0.2349957525730133,
-0.3631290793418884,
-0.16029387712478638,
-1.0686700344085693,
0.8351588845252991,
0.6448395848274231,
-0.41572105884552,
-0.28549420833587646,
0.16906312108039856,
0.532019317150116,
-0.10160041600465775,
-0.09164521843194962,
0.40357089042663574,
0.401162713766098,
0.24051158130168915,
-1.420903205871582,
0.5225347280502319,
-0.2733251452445984,
-0.19876928627490997,
0.20039363205432892,
-0.4709396958351135,
1.0644617080688477,
-0.41978418827056885,
-0.2949027121067047,
-0.24572810530662537,
0.28219127655029297,
0.09123718738555908,
0.020487353205680847,
0.3194425106048584,
0.7594626545906067,
0.629461944103241,
-0.11010737717151642,
1.0770299434661865,
-0.2415648102760315,
0.05982444807887077,
0.7971257567405701,
-0.2397240698337555,
0.8513297438621521,
0.3576449453830719,
0.16486798226833344,
0.8465366959571838,
0.06583947688341141,
0.15960443019866943,
0.5138332843780518,
0.16651053726673126,
-0.2636686861515045,
-0.5875915884971619,
-0.10074665397405624,
-0.33892622590065,
0.4930424690246582,
0.4356839656829834,
-0.47378870844841003,
-0.3075226843357086,
0.08914398401975632,
0.14629629254341125,
-0.1791871190071106,
-0.5491114854812622,
0.5063948631286621,
0.2553699016571045,
-1.1431795358657837,
0.8224553465843201,
-0.357193261384964,
0.48620450496673584,
-0.4623270332813263,
-0.0050245919264853,
-0.06194698065519333,
0.18423156440258026,
-0.3018118739128113,
-1.1839962005615234,
0.5818145871162415,
-0.22805462777614594,
-0.28892359137535095,
-0.3780866861343384,
1.0698347091674805,
-0.5196623206138611,
0.0046964106149971485,
1.0048224925994873,
1.0602291822433472,
0.21153201162815094,
-0.08108700811862946,
-0.5820634365081787,
-0.41367626190185547,
0.13557639718055725,
-0.303836464881897,
0.6172713041305542,
0.6654218435287476,
-0.5222424268722534,
0.7239232659339905,
0.7125034332275391,
0.4119708836078644,
0.20605464279651642,
0.20704464614391327,
0.6477717757225037,
-0.6477707028388977,
-0.44767364859580994,
-0.5280060172080994,
0.19843070209026337,
0.17248858511447906,
0.08181676268577576,
0.6617580652236938,
0.17560546100139618,
0.9880655407905579,
-0.12468461692333221,
0.8679149150848389,
-0.3101176619529724,
0.24645699560642242,
-0.49323585629463196,
1.0492072105407715,
-0.7853994965553284,
-0.02874395065009594,
0.1914921998977661,
-0.6750107407569885,
-0.24809086322784424,
0.6279997825622559,
-0.6613719463348389,
-0.11905783414840698,
0.9151480793952942,
0.6582776308059692,
-0.13855738937854767,
0.10709253698587418,
0.43303728103637695,
0.060911569744348526,
0.016991598531603813,
1.0898162126541138,
0.803428590297699,
-0.03471294790506363,
0.686474084854126,
-0.2816813886165619,
-0.07927704602479935,
0.1966179460287094,
-0.7769106030464172,
-0.7984183430671692,
-0.6846948862075806,
-0.13824868202209473,
-0.2725760340690613,
0.016262253746390343,
0.4102301597595215,
0.7203064560890198,
-0.7281744480133057,
-0.16858503222465515,
-0.020069392397999763,
0.4567564129829407,
-0.528322696685791,
-0.23766165971755981,
0.4115484654903412,
-0.1337372213602066,
-0.40182873606681824,
0.4810705780982971,
0.0491289347410202,
-0.16631661355495453,
-0.12806673347949982,
0.07008758932352066,
-0.360881507396698,
0.04583409056067467,
0.6340438723564148,
0.556244969367981,
-0.6657065153121948,
-0.43818774819374084,
0.31891679763793945,
-0.015661537647247314,
-0.24539709091186523,
0.9281970858573914,
-0.6599596738815308,
0.35536324977874756,
1.0786603689193726,
0.7143805027008057,
0.5093078017234802,
-0.6154630780220032,
0.5429668426513672,
-0.4849945306777954,
0.04547062888741493,
-0.03228066861629486,
0.6341208219528198,
0.3705906569957733,
-0.1443435102701187,
0.24507518112659454,
0.26685044169425964,
-0.4985775947570801,
-0.4479653239250183,
0.36394748091697693,
-0.9022637009620667,
-0.6884017586708069,
1.470859169960022,
-0.4529888331890106,
-0.16269943118095398,
-0.16023676097393036,
0.217346653342247,
0.5618162155151367,
-0.06457062065601349,
0.3157312572002411,
0.8590618968009949,
-0.3911520838737488,
-0.2969692051410675,
-0.6059268116950989,
0.3510996401309967,
0.45611026883125305,
-0.6811513304710388,
0.06652950495481491,
0.31590697169303894,
0.49235790967941284,
0.5728604197502136,
0.472685843706131,
-0.28739380836486816,
0.32550591230392456,
0.34726229310035706,
-0.0434759147465229,
-0.04248977452516556,
-0.46491503715515137,
-0.1670011281967163,
0.4416852295398712,
-0.16966745257377625,
-0.07645269483327866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16635v1 | ShadowLLM: Predictor-based Contextual Sparsity for Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T13:41:08 | 2024-06-24T13:41:08 | Yash Akhauri, Ahmed F AbouElhamayed, Jordan Dotzel, Zhiru Zhang, Alexander M Rush, Safeen Huda, Mohamed S Abdelfattah | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The high power consumption and latency-sensitive deployments of large
language models (LLMs) have motivated techniques like quantization and
sparsity. Contextual sparsity, where the sparsity pattern is input-dependent,
is crucial in LLMs because the permanent removal of attention heads or neurons
from LLMs can significantly degrade accuracy. Prior work has attempted to model
contextual sparsity using neural networks trained to predict activation
magnitudes, which can be used to dynamically prune structures with low
predicted activation magnitude. In this paper, we look beyond magnitude-based
pruning criteria to assess attention head and neuron importance in LLMs. We
developed a novel predictor called ShadowLLM, which can shadow the LLM behavior
and enforce better sparsity patterns, resulting in over 15% improvement in
end-to-end accuracy without increasing latency compared to previous methods.
ShadowLLM achieves up to a 20\% speed-up over the state-of-the-art DejaVu
framework. These enhancements are validated on models with up to 30 billion
parameters. Our code is available at
\href{https://github.com/abdelfattah-lab/shadow_llm/}{ShadowLLM}. | [
-0.23917150497436523,
-1.0534453392028809,
0.49889105558395386,
0.45801395177841187,
-0.18041512370109558,
-0.10563511401414871,
-0.30898723006248474,
-0.2374720275402069,
0.24685204029083252,
0.6643690466880798,
-0.44112417101860046,
-0.3882739245891571,
-0.50654536485672,
-0.24833644926548004,
-0.4769773781299591,
0.625625491142273,
0.20024538040161133,
0.0883878618478775,
-0.4338141977787018,
-0.042384758591651917,
-0.5002245306968689,
-0.6671434044837952,
-0.5948492288589478,
-0.41275832056999207,
0.644888699054718,
0.008262514136731625,
0.6137396097183228,
0.43470311164855957,
0.4020935297012329,
0.270924836397171,
-0.4125581681728363,
-0.058892108500003815,
-0.5535348057746887,
0.20775237679481506,
0.07976645231246948,
-0.1686706244945526,
-0.8097212910652161,
-0.22969648241996765,
0.7175676226615906,
1.0431290864944458,
-0.36910906434059143,
0.10478631407022476,
0.28026726841926575,
0.5347126126289368,
-0.8439930081367493,
-0.029099827632308006,
-0.6013376712799072,
-0.10907662659883499,
-0.08857487142086029,
-0.28174644708633423,
-0.3832490146160126,
-0.05373291298747063,
-0.050917357206344604,
-0.2847754657268524,
0.1497974991798401,
0.08514206856489182,
0.48850303888320923,
0.5284745097160339,
-0.1772497296333313,
0.38909682631492615,
-0.7699809670448303,
0.8585200905799866,
-0.7746106386184692,
0.6519038677215576,
0.4063105583190918,
0.10016033798456192,
-0.2506357431411743,
-0.6165019273757935,
-0.3967086374759674,
-0.29441699385643005,
-0.1780264973640442,
0.07350107282400131,
-0.34872177243232727,
0.22233785688877106,
0.3647206127643585,
0.18055950105190277,
-0.6868727803230286,
0.08916378766298294,
-0.03801308572292328,
-0.04765737056732178,
0.24291476607322693,
0.23741388320922852,
0.012718587182462215,
0.0006080966559238732,
-0.31285104155540466,
0.16822859644889832,
-0.8078768253326416,
-0.154799684882164,
0.2545281946659088,
0.008778256364166737,
-0.030988246202468872,
0.18766628205776215,
-0.10913190990686417,
1.094969391822815,
0.34484848380088806,
-0.013494781218469143,
0.012082704342901707,
-0.10718196630477905,
-0.3085135817527771,
0.06222081556916237,
0.5876136422157288,
0.20438258349895477,
0.005117157939821482,
-0.3939184248447418,
-0.19162970781326294,
-0.19620729982852936,
0.17208744585514069,
-1.0066791772842407,
-0.14704486727714539,
0.3385221064090729,
-0.3105638027191162,
-0.4009891748428345,
-0.15914873778820038,
-0.6036413311958313,
-0.42534103989601135,
-0.23093000054359436,
0.17856983840465546,
-0.4629845917224884,
-0.48394709825515747,
0.2690151035785675,
0.3136070966720581,
0.024588918313384056,
0.4070694148540497,
-0.769754946231842,
0.43334975838661194,
0.6685081720352173,
0.7785747051239014,
-0.5696812868118286,
-0.3423643410205841,
-0.7610453963279724,
0.2746785879135132,
-0.25759294629096985,
0.44523707032203674,
-0.49806085228919983,
0.08231446146965027,
-0.16506701707839966,
-0.030142683535814285,
-0.18022653460502625,
-0.5994953513145447,
0.12294336408376694,
-0.6578189134597778,
-0.021746816113591194,
0.046627145260572433,
-0.3388860523700714,
-0.3171224594116211,
0.31196174025535583,
-0.7350538372993469,
0.9470201134681702,
0.1873633712530136,
-0.5574566721916199,
0.16483670473098755,
-0.3582130968570709,
-0.5887786746025085,
0.3806864023208618,
0.0645594671368599,
-0.3941068649291992,
0.47322383522987366,
0.05941244587302208,
0.7614830732345581,
-0.20747005939483643,
0.8100005388259888,
-0.35457080602645874,
-0.5897968411445618,
0.4789769947528839,
-0.5626019239425659,
0.5271773934364319,
-0.08094283938407898,
-0.4256122410297394,
0.1312682032585144,
-0.9677976369857788,
0.12819387018680573,
-0.16817419230937958,
-0.18319952487945557,
-0.509617030620575,
0.07013442367315292,
0.3942120373249054,
0.24437960982322693,
0.15185539424419403,
-0.05911794304847717,
0.042480144649744034,
-0.6615525484085083,
0.4011496901512146,
0.7577577233314514,
-0.15006689727306366,
0.3085978031158447,
-0.05120575428009033,
0.7244790196418762,
-0.09428185224533081,
0.028022412210702896,
-0.08585552871227264,
0.001852074172347784,
-0.7675782442092896,
-0.35449278354644775,
0.31007546186447144,
0.3323783278465271,
-0.49232301115989685,
0.7285252213478088,
-0.44166117906570435,
-0.20249532163143158,
0.06394457817077637,
0.023249225690960884,
0.4975752532482147,
0.25908055901527405,
0.2866858243942261,
-0.2923205494880676,
-0.6913498640060425,
-0.8115735650062561,
-0.03593426197767258,
-0.03255747631192207,
0.15740911662578583,
0.36948245763778687,
0.26692092418670654,
-0.2093876302242279,
0.9929482936859131,
-0.3132821321487427,
-0.29803740978240967,
-0.41111111640930176,
-0.09040958434343338,
0.14517900347709656,
0.4650876820087433,
0.37793290615081787,
-0.8239725828170776,
-0.23709805309772491,
-0.20826847851276398,
-0.574512779712677,
-0.3685443103313446,
-0.026550034061074257,
0.09134187549352646,
0.052712757140398026,
0.5783466696739197,
-0.6579439640045166,
0.27170106768608093,
0.8848994374275208,
-0.2524794042110443,
0.37612950801849365,
0.09690960496664047,
-0.02794123813509941,
-1.0967406034469604,
0.3974374532699585,
0.007675372529774904,
-0.3094616234302521,
-0.7946316599845886,
-0.19890104234218597,
0.03923478350043297,
0.05396607518196106,
-0.5121860504150391,
0.7980709075927734,
-0.6166549324989319,
-0.1744825839996338,
-0.3497459292411804,
-0.06205401569604874,
-0.1538791060447693,
0.717082679271698,
0.11676589399576187,
0.7761699557304382,
0.41251400113105774,
-0.7405713200569153,
0.16943255066871643,
-0.29030418395996094,
-0.28684747219085693,
0.4289352595806122,
-0.7162418365478516,
0.03737088665366173,
0.19512559473514557,
0.16640588641166687,
-0.7878282070159912,
-0.04590461775660515,
0.021652331575751305,
-0.32851529121398926,
0.3376319408416748,
-0.07005028426647186,
-0.4401218593120575,
-0.070904441177845,
-0.2149491161108017,
0.5249525308609009,
0.42676544189453125,
-0.39691323041915894,
0.8224563002586365,
0.42000865936279297,
-0.07229015231132507,
-0.8466501832008362,
-0.5568116903305054,
0.1775015890598297,
-0.23293498158454895,
-0.5232313871383667,
0.5905124545097351,
-0.1786428838968277,
-0.26955944299697876,
-0.058593716472387314,
-0.06707998365163803,
0.12232161313295364,
0.404244601726532,
0.7245321869850159,
0.0959358885884285,
-0.05867490544915199,
0.00947853084653616,
-0.20562611520290375,
-0.2613840699195862,
0.09744255244731903,
-0.41587066650390625,
0.9105700850486755,
0.004670950584113598,
-0.2935042977333069,
-0.1358368843793869,
-0.05192737653851509,
0.5982454419136047,
-0.04715556651353836,
0.6715475916862488,
0.5951129794120789,
-0.5277639627456665,
-0.41867968440055847,
-0.9326217174530029,
-0.38845884799957275,
-0.5121331810951233,
0.8281872272491455,
-0.14378632605075836,
-0.8685979843139648,
0.42540469765663147,
-0.11529930680990219,
-0.5189907550811768,
0.03758708015084267,
0.5727490782737732,
0.08920186012983322,
1.0297653675079346,
0.8995998501777649,
-0.22201572358608246,
0.7726694345474243,
-0.30704402923583984,
0.047141123563051224,
-1.072341799736023,
-0.04450506716966629,
-0.016754942014813423,
-0.2412233203649521,
-0.050078384578228,
-0.4165380597114563,
0.18149647116661072,
0.3906501531600952,
0.22248639166355133,
0.34197112917900085,
-0.4573245048522949,
0.5145034193992615,
0.230251744389534,
-0.07305273413658142,
0.22282670438289642,
0.31419888138771057,
-0.021764304488897324,
-0.11326983571052551,
-0.6806283593177795,
-0.40511786937713623,
0.7611740231513977,
0.21548427641391754,
0.8531297445297241,
-0.0922110453248024,
0.16949425637722015,
0.16724812984466553,
0.32953932881355286,
-0.7462042570114136,
0.8342833518981934,
-0.03274714946746826,
-0.2756825089454651,
-0.21788503229618073,
-0.45188501477241516,
-1.0066355466842651,
0.3267996907234192,
-0.003598161041736603,
-0.766726553440094,
0.010396032594144344,
0.3930593430995941,
-0.46244069933891296,
0.2582400441169739,
-0.263561487197876,
0.7919648885726929,
-0.39976081252098083,
-0.7678661942481995,
-0.31194454431533813,
-0.3180604875087738,
0.22186635434627533,
-0.004102338571101427,
-0.06596381217241287,
-0.10935338586568832,
-0.17721691727638245,
0.7389762997627258,
-0.15209606289863586,
1.0610119104385376,
-0.12170818448066711,
-0.1439845860004425,
-0.02484636940062046,
0.24031776189804077,
0.5886207222938538,
0.08519206941127777,
0.045356690883636475,
0.5615478754043579,
-0.25630274415016174,
0.028403373435139656,
-0.5971817374229431,
0.9222607612609863,
-0.4543135166168213,
-0.6127700209617615,
-0.4267379939556122,
-0.5902383327484131,
-0.294504851102829,
0.2047661393880844,
0.16498534381389618,
0.3031957149505615,
-0.3683510422706604,
0.4207345247268677,
0.7669181227684021,
-0.10449343919754028,
0.5574320554733276,
0.7117189168930054,
-0.3103087544441223,
-0.6002925038337708,
0.9280040860176086,
0.21834111213684082,
0.11114490777254105,
0.4149114489555359,
0.041160665452480316,
0.0692829117178917,
-0.9322157502174377,
-0.28042319416999817,
0.08595483750104904,
-0.3423372805118561,
-0.28800082206726074,
-0.7837151288986206,
-0.4026842415332794,
-0.3257100582122803,
-0.13586921989917755,
-0.260398805141449,
-0.3663562536239624,
-0.22426585853099823,
-0.06945792585611343,
0.2143895924091339,
0.3756774663925171,
0.1635202020406723,
0.5603105425834656,
-0.44521793723106384,
0.08470746874809265,
0.16366632282733917,
0.3729499280452728,
0.041367724537849426,
-0.4513576030731201,
-0.36622217297554016,
-0.19170895218849182,
-0.20853185653686523,
-0.6880376935005188,
0.7256776690483093,
0.038407325744628906,
0.5527330636978149,
0.22975607216358185,
-0.2212541550397873,
0.730448305606842,
-0.40309539437294006,
0.6857785582542419,
0.3004944324493408,
-0.9511821866035461,
0.5336862206459045,
-0.2316347062587738,
0.3526567816734314,
0.18966889381408691,
-0.005023573059588671,
-0.7096759676933289,
-0.3353674113750458,
-0.6729657053947449,
-0.9935870170593262,
0.8512902855873108,
0.10767195373773575,
-0.0035561365075409412,
0.28344371914863586,
0.46497392654418945,
0.08244004845619202,
0.2888142764568329,
-0.7442374229431152,
-0.20444972813129425,
0.21065931022167206,
-0.19889788329601288,
-0.2121899127960205,
-0.5564412474632263,
0.05159962922334671,
-0.04720096290111542,
0.5678989291191101,
-0.2771862745285034,
-0.07452525198459625,
-0.1339636892080307,
-0.46303150057792664,
-0.3150641918182373,
0.1577468365430832,
0.5642048716545105,
0.7714616060256958,
-0.24540291726589203,
0.2020227015018463,
0.48871055245399475,
-0.7422475814819336,
0.09056830406188965,
0.19370277225971222,
-0.5128338932991028,
-0.03608773276209831,
0.4252164661884308,
0.8837751746177673,
0.36229732632637024,
-0.6205049157142639,
0.6743963360786438,
0.058572400361299515,
-0.020427044481039047,
-0.6601192951202393,
0.1281326413154602,
-0.03432658314704895,
0.05176267400383949,
0.44468528032302856,
0.14264589548110962,
0.060457177460193634,
-0.04839697852730751,
0.12725427746772766,
0.7001166343688965,
-0.5423930883407593,
-0.5395473837852478,
0.5925204753875732,
0.22584553062915802,
-0.12822067737579346,
0.18743903934955597,
0.06601468473672867,
-0.4005082845687866,
0.7308326959609985,
0.4609258472919464,
1.0340847969055176,
-0.3089264929294586,
-0.25855907797813416,
0.3192416727542877,
0.17268787324428558,
-0.15724624693393707,
-0.09301280975341797,
-0.052580270916223526,
-0.6524383425712585,
-0.6516011357307434,
-0.7798070311546326,
-0.19853517413139343,
0.6602327227592468,
-0.4150525629520416,
0.3220738172531128,
-0.47743552923202515,
-0.3074667453765869,
-0.13399603962898254,
-0.12674497067928314,
-0.3494913876056671,
0.15453378856182098,
0.25705334544181824,
0.5115416049957275,
-0.6473863124847412,
1.0717124938964844,
0.5500112175941467,
-0.09426334500312805,
-0.3402061462402344,
0.08503631502389908,
-0.17240606248378754,
-0.5593668818473816,
0.8255436420440674,
0.4842255711555481,
-0.43159180879592896,
0.10409228503704071,
-0.5814756751060486,
-1.162811279296875,
1.1415040493011475,
0.6812525391578674,
-0.8091320991516113,
-0.026231959462165833,
-0.02225165255367756,
0.3435594141483307,
-0.2653863728046417,
0.25672441720962524,
0.3584057092666626,
0.2774820029735565,
-0.016123589128255844,
-0.6511685848236084,
0.25908154249191284,
-0.10364274680614471,
0.35924050211906433,
0.21705342829227448,
-0.5771915912628174,
0.7920124530792236,
-0.16741742193698883,
-0.3678777515888214,
0.0008499051327817142,
0.5494576692581177,
0.3219928443431854,
0.1830572485923767,
0.5562748908996582,
0.527103066444397,
0.443070650100708,
-0.2548055350780487,
0.8422587513923645,
-0.6626841425895691,
0.19935494661331177,
1.034265398979187,
-0.36063507199287415,
0.721838653087616,
0.7556596398353577,
-0.04187574237585068,
0.2882041335105896,
0.43636849522590637,
-0.05437649041414261,
0.5475030541419983,
0.3057546615600586,
-0.07754288613796234,
-0.3833766579627991,
-0.1429579108953476,
-0.37372153997421265,
0.09377724677324295,
0.45625045895576477,
-0.29605475068092346,
0.27475959062576294,
0.2226075381040573,
-0.06403063237667084,
-0.027576647698879242,
-0.25490158796310425,
0.7400277256965637,
0.10158516466617584,
-0.6660603880882263,
0.786653995513916,
0.03562602773308754,
1.0253288745880127,
-0.5671541690826416,
-0.06735344976186752,
-0.32058730721473694,
0.6473840475082397,
-0.22919334471225739,
-0.370249480009079,
0.15444287657737732,
-0.26601120829582214,
-0.3365556299686432,
-0.3174116611480713,
0.8678935170173645,
-0.5300626754760742,
-0.4693734049797058,
0.6047091484069824,
0.5812307000160217,
-0.14036144316196442,
-0.3480983376502991,
-0.6875031590461731,
0.22488638758659363,
-0.27645519375801086,
-0.6380144953727722,
0.49757975339889526,
0.14727900922298431,
-0.11762087047100067,
0.7638197541236877,
0.7332746982574463,
0.4621219336986542,
-0.14409242570400238,
0.2356957495212555,
0.8038516640663147,
-0.7187462449073792,
-0.2697482407093048,
-1.0878373384475708,
0.22331884503364563,
-0.10083671659231186,
-0.1198674887418747,
0.8524038195610046,
0.5838242769241333,
0.6369303464889526,
0.0993448868393898,
0.5183637738227844,
0.053067419677972794,
0.1816098988056183,
-0.5990567803382874,
0.781058132648468,
-0.5937798619270325,
0.38242262601852417,
-0.17952564358711243,
-0.9355996251106262,
-0.43498000502586365,
0.5694820284843445,
-0.3186799883842468,
0.3310949206352234,
0.7580439448356628,
1.063557744026184,
-0.08308271318674088,
-0.3831164538860321,
0.6288465857505798,
0.27170711755752563,
0.017709938809275627,
0.6807661652565002,
0.9795295596122742,
-0.22950205206871033,
0.6039320826530457,
-0.5071305632591248,
-0.0993451252579689,
-0.4841708242893219,
-0.8900179266929626,
-0.8994590044021606,
-0.42891234159469604,
-0.6043224334716797,
-0.4750427007675171,
0.26934880018234253,
0.6359668970108032,
1.1532564163208008,
-0.8193107843399048,
-0.2311503142118454,
-0.32336610555648804,
0.001446210197173059,
-0.6072922945022583,
-0.26162052154541016,
0.44727277755737305,
-0.09137245267629623,
-0.5233058333396912,
0.30273592472076416,
0.47211769223213196,
0.10248111933469772,
-0.4928267002105713,
-0.20799040794372559,
0.07574853301048279,
-0.1385725438594818,
0.6300663948059082,
-0.015344475395977497,
-1.0602476596832275,
0.05792626366019249,
0.05401713401079178,
-0.3795433044433594,
-0.11515836417675018,
0.8733493685722351,
-0.9538064002990723,
-0.05936252698302269,
0.27321743965148926,
0.36927345395088196,
0.510471522808075,
0.010567608289420605,
0.5762450695037842,
-0.9338545203208923,
0.39292624592781067,
0.453507661819458,
0.4176425635814667,
0.4131256341934204,
-0.6414110660552979,
0.5384365916252136,
0.26298871636390686,
-0.3420494794845581,
-0.9788196086883545,
0.015088792890310287,
-1.0471251010894775,
-0.3420052230358124,
1.5049301385879517,
0.09204483032226562,
-0.503560483455658,
0.1465430110692978,
-0.13534702360630035,
0.0036260439082980156,
-0.30428433418273926,
0.611565887928009,
0.5375937819480896,
0.18965938687324524,
-0.4495834708213806,
-0.6097169518470764,
0.5614978671073914,
0.8715300559997559,
-0.6291858553886414,
0.5512670874595642,
0.6684286594390869,
0.2580546736717224,
0.15382255613803864,
0.5892077684402466,
0.00819455273449421,
0.3103311359882355,
-0.26214033365249634,
0.37323567271232605,
-0.34763848781585693,
-0.3345907926559448,
-0.6853198409080505,
0.3761643171310425,
-0.09084080159664154,
0.12866441905498505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16620v2 | OmAgent: A Multi-modal Agent Framework for Complex Video Understanding with Task Divide-and-Conquer | 2024-06-24T13:05:39 | 2024-06-25T02:43:41 | Lu Zhang, Tiancheng Zhao, Heting Ying, Yibo Ma, Kyusong Lee | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have expanded their
capabilities to multimodal contexts, including comprehensive video
understanding. However, processing extensive videos such as 24-hour CCTV
footage or full-length films presents significant challenges due to the vast
data and processing demands. Traditional methods, like extracting key frames or
converting frames to text, often result in substantial information loss. To
address these shortcomings, we develop OmAgent, efficiently stores and
retrieves relevant video frames for specific queries, preserving the detailed
content of videos. Additionally, it features an Divide-and-Conquer Loop capable
of autonomous reasoning, dynamically invoking APIs and tools to enhance query
processing and accuracy. This approach ensures robust video understanding,
significantly reducing information loss. Experimental results affirm OmAgent's
efficacy in handling various types of videos and complex tasks. Moreover, we
have endowed it with greater autonomy and a robust tool-calling system,
enabling it to accomplish even more intricate tasks. | [
-0.4236160218715668,
-0.9529423117637634,
0.6738888025283813,
0.23959733545780182,
-0.08181142807006836,
0.2677805423736572,
-0.2578246295452118,
-0.1787322610616684,
-0.17061619460582733,
0.32810351252555847,
-0.5294376611709595,
-0.29908448457717896,
-0.6766006350517273,
-0.1914108842611313,
-0.20415671169757843,
0.5079516172409058,
-0.348706990480423,
0.30075955390930176,
0.05813954398036003,
-0.47811418771743774,
-0.3974888324737549,
-0.380012571811676,
-0.5206196308135986,
-0.3206312954425812,
0.35004812479019165,
0.5455731749534607,
0.8620678186416626,
0.796646237373352,
0.563792884349823,
0.5344856381416321,
0.33110713958740234,
0.5649526119232178,
-0.360649436712265,
0.4375568926334381,
-0.347501665353775,
-0.33091816306114197,
-0.4679579734802246,
-0.40467947721481323,
0.5219312906265259,
0.4852709174156189,
-0.11686140298843384,
0.0627879649400711,
-0.4464723467826843,
0.2704395055770874,
-1.1061745882034302,
0.20291340351104736,
-0.29243823885917664,
0.2822618782520294,
0.033307936042547226,
-0.46793118119239807,
-0.18672524392604828,
0.22814181447029114,
0.16316591203212738,
-0.5775152444839478,
0.19382448494434357,
-0.20791883766651154,
0.4422493278980255,
0.5488778352737427,
-0.5356279015541077,
0.10146242380142212,
-1.0838290452957153,
0.43466758728027344,
-0.055806271731853485,
0.5255018472671509,
0.43886587023735046,
0.6814031004905701,
-0.034695547074079514,
-0.48590952157974243,
-0.6058581471443176,
-0.07839828729629517,
0.5810452103614807,
0.16874782741069794,
-0.09133739024400711,
0.24634991586208344,
0.005807327572256327,
0.33315524458885193,
-0.4697889983654022,
0.0006447394262067974,
-0.15732333064079285,
-0.320432186126709,
0.3862378001213074,
0.4862031936645508,
0.480436772108078,
-0.1314164102077484,
-0.4375898838043213,
-0.17142556607723236,
-0.0028415119741111994,
0.2660054564476013,
0.08329109102487564,
-0.1292361170053482,
0.06441768258810043,
0.8731697797775269,
-0.2048206627368927,
0.6224819421768188,
-0.08728905767202377,
-0.4463978409767151,
0.09455633163452148,
-0.2122715264558792,
-0.8509787917137146,
0.023277755826711655,
0.671430230140686,
0.3535795509815216,
-0.12997648119926453,
0.06180864945054054,
-0.006013470236212015,
0.04012607783079147,
0.2268892377614975,
-0.9280087351799011,
-0.3245334029197693,
0.14935673773288727,
-0.27157947421073914,
0.159231036901474,
0.36827513575553894,
-0.6967340111732483,
-0.5065042972564697,
-0.6036046743392944,
0.6053682565689087,
-0.7009089589118958,
-0.1968259960412979,
0.2501031160354614,
-0.09429239481687546,
0.21274015307426453,
0.8922820687294006,
-0.23412983119487762,
0.09603285044431686,
0.2727721929550171,
0.743124783039093,
-0.22045743465423584,
-0.6600247025489807,
-1.0837589502334595,
0.3821921944618225,
-0.10906260460615158,
0.49875351786613464,
-0.4721309542655945,
0.13935159146785736,
0.23682154715061188,
0.17753145098686218,
-0.09254789352416992,
-0.2829904854297638,
0.42265477776527405,
-0.8693860173225403,
-0.04823131114244461,
-0.047962598502635956,
-0.19627848267555237,
-0.45282766222953796,
0.7191862463951111,
-0.7946760058403015,
0.4893980026245117,
-0.3186318576335907,
-0.19045326113700867,
0.2509547173976898,
-0.8321853876113892,
-0.37991493940353394,
-0.11859258264303207,
-0.2680714428424835,
-0.033800240606069565,
-0.16941538453102112,
0.26938697695732117,
0.357889860868454,
-0.2346809208393097,
0.06747674196958542,
-0.1995258778333664,
0.1949065625667572,
0.2859974205493927,
-0.8080088496208191,
0.05123152956366539,
0.2901115417480469,
-0.1826951801776886,
0.34504005312919617,
-0.6209678649902344,
-0.24025489389896393,
-0.0014394668396562338,
-0.36273977160453796,
0.038483235985040665,
0.0518193319439888,
0.09279990196228027,
0.16373173892498016,
0.07958923280239105,
-0.6820101141929626,
0.12433838844299316,
0.24773526191711426,
0.6073355078697205,
0.6786572337150574,
-0.24617493152618408,
0.6383946537971497,
0.08938682079315186,
0.7432895302772522,
0.13439428806304932,
0.3064716160297394,
-0.5206580758094788,
-0.13219793140888214,
-0.5805384516716003,
-0.4753153920173645,
-0.32811322808265686,
0.3745872974395752,
-0.8538498282432556,
-0.06282900273799896,
-0.1837150901556015,
-0.2202502340078354,
-0.3454796373844147,
0.14023073017597198,
0.29701685905456543,
0.13231830298900604,
0.347572386264801,
-0.1803877055644989,
-0.3028161823749542,
-0.587082028388977,
0.055784694850444794,
0.2621314227581024,
-0.053038157522678375,
0.32231688499450684,
0.4278390407562256,
-0.4847698211669922,
1.1138927936553955,
-0.7924555540084839,
-0.7074617147445679,
-0.23458781838417053,
0.214543417096138,
-0.12877778708934784,
0.28140658140182495,
0.2142358273267746,
-1.391283392906189,
-0.19006647169589996,
0.33571258187294006,
-0.9345017671585083,
0.37529441714286804,
-0.1557149440050125,
-0.031122520565986633,
-0.09622950851917267,
0.6795221567153931,
-0.6035458445549011,
0.5073117613792419,
0.30244264006614685,
-0.31535759568214417,
0.49987393617630005,
-0.6263784170150757,
0.6270418763160706,
-0.7779561281204224,
-0.30451589822769165,
-0.17983388900756836,
-0.6452032327651978,
-0.48084157705307007,
0.07865437120199203,
-0.2259778082370758,
-0.1514805555343628,
-0.5747637152671814,
-0.029684139415621758,
-0.4266235828399658,
-0.17380128800868988,
-0.19994112849235535,
0.2815473973751068,
0.015866218134760857,
0.5946583151817322,
0.022082431241869926,
0.6685097813606262,
0.6410996317863464,
-0.567936360836029,
0.8133893609046936,
0.19267766177654266,
-0.13052819669246674,
0.9138487577438354,
-0.3012104034423828,
-0.05726779252290726,
-0.5308618545532227,
-0.013859589584171772,
-0.9704165458679199,
-0.9068740606307983,
0.127213254570961,
-0.44679397344589233,
0.14297974109649658,
-0.23826870322227478,
-0.4753780663013458,
-0.028724461793899536,
-0.22351953387260437,
0.6937810778617859,
-0.0407477542757988,
-0.6153587102890015,
1.0775161981582642,
0.29980698227882385,
0.13708801567554474,
-0.6562379002571106,
-0.48348328471183777,
0.22789935767650604,
-0.159037783741951,
-0.8925098180770874,
0.24811455607414246,
-0.20610955357551575,
-0.20599566400051117,
0.09816741198301315,
-0.5017331838607788,
-0.6297411918640137,
-0.38671451807022095,
0.47519761323928833,
-0.05341619625687599,
-0.1425425112247467,
0.17229518294334412,
-0.21414148807525635,
0.14396525919437408,
0.023943951353430748,
-0.18260370194911957,
0.5122750401496887,
-0.24648348987102509,
-0.7195894122123718,
-0.07044752687215805,
0.6425456404685974,
1.0343058109283447,
-0.5750023126602173,
0.3593129813671112,
0.9979260563850403,
-0.3146200478076935,
-0.2831419110298157,
-0.7212061882019043,
0.21573342382907867,
-0.4889701306819916,
0.8061743974685669,
-0.6496714949607849,
-0.9721856117248535,
0.6266118288040161,
-0.013839060440659523,
-0.25846680998802185,
0.08808749169111252,
0.6827197670936584,
-0.08496739715337753,
1.16141676902771,
0.6477141976356506,
-0.04691416397690773,
0.6857126951217651,
-0.3764915466308594,
0.020877527073025703,
-0.3593817353248596,
-0.6669265627861023,
-0.06575413793325424,
-0.1356268972158432,
0.09375877678394318,
-0.7602431178092957,
0.7232838273048401,
-0.057628341019153595,
-0.5198816657066345,
0.17506711184978485,
-0.29293012619018555,
0.8083431124687195,
0.20353548228740692,
0.3708442151546478,
0.49486905336380005,
0.03571264445781708,
0.32149484753608704,
0.0772177129983902,
-0.5289114117622375,
-0.31125974655151367,
0.5588116645812988,
0.4228745996952057,
1.1977511644363403,
0.6609334349632263,
-0.09497978538274765,
0.726069986820221,
-0.3379608988761902,
-0.9124845266342163,
0.585034966468811,
0.1661294400691986,
-0.45724624395370483,
-0.35762515664100647,
-0.20665214955806732,
-0.9573777914047241,
0.5103646516799927,
0.20482231676578522,
-0.6445053815841675,
0.1492159068584442,
-0.09094876050949097,
-0.31061869859695435,
0.6349377036094666,
-0.49048587679862976,
1.0676515102386475,
-0.4628567695617676,
-0.6882277727127075,
-0.41869035363197327,
-0.8890636563301086,
0.42065054178237915,
0.1616295725107193,
0.28907689452171326,
0.13708440959453583,
-0.2676815688610077,
0.314937561750412,
-0.7614197731018066,
0.5780991315841675,
0.0355365090072155,
0.15473707020282745,
0.45571884512901306,
0.4296751022338867,
0.0576430968940258,
0.21096883714199066,
0.405222088098526,
-0.49498942494392395,
-0.11997918039560318,
-0.2625371813774109,
-0.6121224164962769,
0.5711156725883484,
-0.9768580794334412,
-0.4051479697227478,
-0.28817251324653625,
-0.6039701700210571,
0.26121777296066284,
0.16176952421665192,
0.08380428701639175,
0.5940037965774536,
-0.08083293586969376,
0.38327571749687195,
0.7788363695144653,
-0.03904902935028076,
0.6649841666221619,
0.4317200481891632,
0.01447663176804781,
-0.5958396196365356,
0.9155611991882324,
-0.1082829013466835,
0.43232569098472595,
0.4796026647090912,
-0.08944563567638397,
-0.08676258474588394,
-0.18567658960819244,
-0.5224531292915344,
-0.24103829264640808,
-1.0308504104614258,
-0.3618524968624115,
-0.6137591004371643,
0.008018222637474537,
-0.07353903353214264,
-0.2136768251657486,
-0.4208352863788605,
0.34549158811569214,
-0.12960690259933472,
-0.2904903292655945,
0.3549412190914154,
0.6557914614677429,
-0.09437181800603867,
0.3619832694530487,
-0.9119998216629028,
0.5589902400970459,
0.7658936381340027,
0.3214728534221649,
-0.18554890155792236,
-0.38660433888435364,
-0.322722852230072,
-0.22123076021671295,
-0.5299732089042664,
-1.1309176683425903,
0.46122246980667114,
0.3403240740299225,
0.46352386474609375,
0.6713597178459167,
-0.04155372828245163,
0.9063809514045715,
-0.2946247458457947,
0.8547797799110413,
0.18154442310333252,
-1.0391944646835327,
0.2749323546886444,
-0.5091342329978943,
0.22149793803691864,
0.4422142803668976,
0.27446264028549194,
-0.26764434576034546,
0.10749491304159164,
-0.3951738178730011,
-0.835954487323761,
0.9589079022407532,
0.3893093466758728,
-0.24070169031620026,
0.45001283288002014,
-0.061914291232824326,
-0.1285426765680313,
0.3913499712944031,
-0.541804313659668,
0.06595557183027267,
-0.4594345688819885,
0.15266239643096924,
0.005107206758111715,
0.09529968351125717,
-0.2632080018520355,
-0.034454766660928726,
0.12458963692188263,
-0.3230041563510895,
0.15838706493377686,
0.809441089630127,
-0.7315748929977417,
-0.32477352023124695,
0.43375062942504883,
0.6345321536064148,
0.5635035634040833,
-0.31292158365249634,
0.4670899510383606,
0.2037026733160019,
-0.5855588316917419,
0.5295647978782654,
0.0743895098567009,
0.4691143035888672,
-0.10063403099775314,
0.4255621135234833,
0.5979128479957581,
-0.06527800858020782,
-1.1897623538970947,
0.7324739098548889,
0.24137260019779205,
-0.08620468527078629,
-0.506298303604126,
-0.10243086516857147,
-0.33535438776016235,
0.5912731885910034,
0.33529534935951233,
0.3830336034297943,
0.32623738050460815,
-0.8747308850288391,
0.21846239268779755,
0.11479852348566055,
-0.47268104553222656,
-0.48210597038269043,
0.7604962587356567,
-0.0020976620726287365,
-0.45612695813179016,
0.27530938386917114,
-0.3378308415412903,
-0.7464843392372131,
0.8047384023666382,
0.0072120679542422295,
0.7413649559020996,
-0.29758474230766296,
0.34430572390556335,
-0.11590589582920074,
0.26953473687171936,
-0.18702757358551025,
0.26289263367652893,
-0.3732942044734955,
-0.7561749815940857,
-0.780877947807312,
-0.17870233952999115,
-0.3798680901527405,
0.05649536848068237,
-0.5785781145095825,
0.0006127762026153505,
-0.32855597138404846,
-0.07138462364673615,
0.07660175859928131,
-0.6264844536781311,
-0.8812752366065979,
0.34212830662727356,
0.24082158505916595,
0.7241488099098206,
-0.6515702605247498,
0.6556873321533203,
1.0645004510879517,
-0.7413459420204163,
-0.8254340291023254,
-0.4584217667579651,
0.10532649606466293,
-0.5634669661521912,
0.7259601950645447,
0.11962228268384933,
-0.4394255578517914,
-0.5034782290458679,
-0.5222588181495667,
-0.5195042490959167,
1.066846251487732,
0.4452878534793854,
-0.15198282897472382,
-0.028881777077913284,
0.31498172879219055,
0.39045459032058716,
-0.441964328289032,
0.5233591794967651,
0.6226717233657837,
0.5897966027259827,
0.48112043738365173,
-0.8467023968696594,
-0.3776983320713043,
-0.14694441854953766,
-0.5467512011528015,
0.2686678171157837,
-0.45558252930641174,
1.1044284105300903,
-0.2789953649044037,
0.20964214205741882,
-0.1401924341917038,
0.3293493092060089,
-0.13881583511829376,
0.5884483456611633,
0.6178210377693176,
0.3934008777141571,
0.23323535919189453,
0.1522175520658493,
0.6406059265136719,
0.3114335834980011,
0.21463902294635773,
1.305698037147522,
-0.08076793700456619,
0.48943838477134705,
0.33731183409690857,
-0.008254505693912506,
0.2211376279592514,
0.4066069722175598,
0.07589646428823471,
0.31514495611190796,
-0.08600632101297379,
-0.38440224528312683,
-0.950774610042572,
-0.2576344907283783,
0.059793662279844284,
0.926713764667511,
0.33010759949684143,
-0.18401943147182465,
-0.5711933374404907,
0.5319139361381531,
-0.07928931713104248,
0.24870450794696808,
-0.5423688292503357,
0.8292093276977539,
-0.29076364636421204,
-0.6158365607261658,
0.14385901391506195,
-0.06416356563568115,
0.258189857006073,
-0.6727610230445862,
-0.026020685210824013,
0.1873513013124466,
0.5371299386024475,
-0.436660498380661,
-0.8661748170852661,
0.047066591680049896,
0.046753108501434326,
-0.29315757751464844,
-0.03873220831155777,
0.647027850151062,
-0.7461559176445007,
0.06915626674890518,
0.31210848689079285,
0.4605128765106201,
0.08237642794847488,
-0.6373029351234436,
-0.4039057791233063,
0.31392771005630493,
-0.015513117425143719,
-0.17324087023735046,
0.16368749737739563,
0.7291778326034546,
-0.0472436361014843,
0.8110833168029785,
0.3929738402366638,
-0.37600773572921753,
0.11981622874736786,
0.02050822600722313,
0.9496647119522095,
-0.49459171295166016,
-0.32942506670951843,
-0.9310232996940613,
0.6968609094619751,
-0.13885124027729034,
-0.045573700219392776,
0.7195135951042175,
0.5726032853126526,
0.6457700729370117,
-0.22266268730163574,
0.7146087288856506,
-0.1590123176574707,
-0.20514105260372162,
-0.26861444115638733,
0.2193678468465805,
-0.7514907717704773,
-0.11397139728069305,
-0.34229105710983276,
-0.8097227811813354,
-0.21890485286712646,
0.42808085680007935,
-0.06874015182256699,
-0.3595898747444153,
0.4999501705169678,
0.5676554441452026,
-0.4097898006439209,
-0.020068565383553505,
0.3486430048942566,
0.19320902228355408,
0.8620611429214478,
0.5001305341720581,
1.0335924625396729,
-0.25878432393074036,
1.0235055685043335,
0.1789667159318924,
-0.24929869174957275,
-0.37875643372535706,
-0.6382436156272888,
-0.8284218907356262,
-0.4556221067905426,
-0.15424810349941254,
-0.001140556181780994,
-0.10806512087583542,
1.126278042793274,
1.0280945301055908,
-0.2973928451538086,
-0.3768647015094757,
-0.009420922957360744,
0.053410936146974564,
-0.07792476564645767,
-0.17131446301937103,
0.2507297396659851,
-0.10151512920856476,
-0.7761692404747009,
0.6661619544029236,
0.5693696737289429,
-0.25598272681236267,
-0.49253469705581665,
-0.21890398859977722,
-0.1368064135313034,
0.03227873891592026,
1.0342477560043335,
0.47606804966926575,
-0.6678069829940796,
-0.3065335750579834,
0.18991787731647491,
0.09728150814771652,
0.24570676684379578,
0.9421576261520386,
-0.5140343308448792,
1.0358455181121826,
0.7313219308853149,
0.7307185530662537,
0.6947075128555298,
0.10978714376688004,
0.5927794575691223,
-0.4698408246040344,
0.23001359403133392,
0.19048330187797546,
0.5446653962135315,
0.18831253051757812,
-0.16723529994487762,
0.4780901372432709,
0.12549157440662384,
-0.7005481719970703,
-0.679829478263855,
0.4127489924430847,
-1.5048010349273682,
-0.276326447725296,
0.8958112001419067,
-0.13190260529518127,
-0.27735117077827454,
-0.22537049651145935,
-0.7010223269462585,
0.18213124573230743,
-0.8008521795272827,
0.160136416554451,
0.2579978406429291,
-0.17914636433124542,
-0.36761564016342163,
-0.5612040162086487,
0.21139858663082123,
0.34330692887306213,
-0.6696276068687439,
-0.144568532705307,
0.6487778425216675,
0.1765364706516266,
0.44774627685546875,
0.2736126184463501,
0.14489410817623138,
0.3640136420726776,
-0.3316861689090729,
-0.018064752221107483,
-0.4324130117893219,
-0.7573398947715759,
-0.324355810880661,
0.807651162147522,
-0.227190762758255,
-0.7529130578041077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16611v1 | Evaluation of Language Models in the Medical Context Under Resource-Constrained Settings | 2024-06-24T12:52:02 | 2024-06-24T12:52:02 | Andrea Posada, Daniel Rueckert, Felix Meissen, Philip Müller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Since the emergence of the Transformer architecture, language model
development has increased, driven by their promising potential. However,
releasing these models into production requires properly understanding their
behavior, particularly in sensitive domains such as medicine. Despite this
need, the medical literature still lacks technical assessments of pre-trained
language models, which are especially valuable in resource-constrained settings
in terms of computational power or limited budget. To address this gap, we
provide a comprehensive survey of language models in the medical domain. In
addition, we selected a subset of these models for thorough evaluation,
focusing on classification and text generation tasks. Our subset encompasses 53
models, ranging from 110 million to 13 billion parameters, spanning the three
families of Transformer-based models and from diverse knowledge domains. This
study employs a series of approaches for text classification together with
zero-shot prompting instead of model training or fine-tuning, which closely
resembles the limited resource setting in which many users of language models
find themselves. Encouragingly, our findings reveal remarkable performance
across various tasks and datasets, underscoring the latent potential of certain
models to contain medical knowledge, even without domain specialization.
Consequently, our study advocates for further exploration of model applications
in medical contexts, particularly in resource-constrained settings. The code is
available on https://github.com/anpoc/Language-models-in-medicine. | [
-0.07792337983846664,
-0.41313332319259644,
0.6571694016456604,
-0.10554616898298264,
-0.04462655633687973,
-0.022848837077617645,
-0.38089317083358765,
-0.30171406269073486,
-0.2681461572647095,
0.5918357968330383,
-0.5014883875846863,
-0.2787550687789917,
-0.7505131959915161,
0.28310149908065796,
-0.3007800281047821,
1.1332205533981323,
-0.09493060410022736,
0.2726314663887024,
-0.3923199772834778,
-0.2550000548362732,
-0.5317829251289368,
-0.6342579126358032,
-0.3527851104736328,
-0.48556455969810486,
0.2672695815563202,
0.11740542203187943,
0.49703362584114075,
0.6406699419021606,
0.7512657642364502,
0.2788429856300354,
-0.19581687450408936,
-0.08975980430841446,
-0.2596467435359955,
0.18381547927856445,
-0.18018151819705963,
-0.201289564371109,
-0.3058330714702606,
0.08755702525377274,
0.42504745721817017,
0.9530918598175049,
-0.06329254806041718,
0.22702625393867493,
-0.14550967514514923,
0.32312437891960144,
-0.6147585511207581,
0.13281725347042084,
-0.4704808294773102,
0.08694109320640564,
-0.1392301768064499,
0.10903415828943253,
-0.4634408950805664,
-0.22751395404338837,
0.5433136224746704,
-0.2869352102279663,
0.3656924366950989,
0.03301669657230377,
0.9321068525314331,
0.386453241109848,
-0.4644448757171631,
-0.2478800266981125,
-0.9468375444412231,
0.8257293701171875,
-0.6048361659049988,
0.3862875699996948,
0.43271660804748535,
0.3900231719017029,
0.24095140397548676,
-0.8886733651161194,
-0.4007461667060852,
-0.4357186555862427,
-0.17877408862113953,
0.008009793236851692,
-0.45780715346336365,
0.20881563425064087,
0.16664084792137146,
0.42135801911354065,
-0.4906831979751587,
0.24689935147762299,
-0.515755832195282,
-0.1326373964548111,
0.2480221539735794,
0.345602422952652,
0.5374550819396973,
-0.4142093360424042,
0.060138702392578125,
-0.006301990710198879,
-0.42569077014923096,
-0.21896173059940338,
-0.23047558963298798,
0.1783943772315979,
-0.21802249550819397,
0.5545377731323242,
0.08024769276380539,
0.8794644474983215,
-0.2484530657529831,
-0.22378678619861603,
0.07184142619371414,
-0.5304320454597473,
-0.38615182042121887,
-0.4288936257362366,
0.9614386558532715,
0.17659565806388855,
0.1500183343887329,
-0.21092526614665985,
-0.24430575966835022,
0.2018052041530609,
0.7264991402626038,
-0.9462904334068298,
-0.14374350011348724,
0.1513155996799469,
-0.6506121158599854,
-0.35776400566101074,
-0.5158849954605103,
-0.6153751015663147,
-0.44861921668052673,
0.014654750935733318,
0.07984064519405365,
-0.5140703916549683,
-0.2577263414859772,
0.18237946927547455,
0.18222865462303162,
-0.23609840869903564,
0.0358130969107151,
-0.9077820181846619,
0.499051958322525,
0.36684033274650574,
0.8097756505012512,
-0.17326851189136505,
0.039075788110494614,
-0.010643995366990566,
-0.2824684679508209,
-0.3182327151298523,
0.7835285663604736,
-0.5880196690559387,
-0.5855274200439453,
0.04175296798348427,
-0.14943502843379974,
-0.3798774182796478,
-0.6948568820953369,
0.7563320994377136,
-0.3035873472690582,
0.32195043563842773,
0.10623054951429367,
-0.5662428736686707,
-0.13751395046710968,
0.1805838942527771,
-0.7150600552558899,
0.4206278622150421,
0.4534216523170471,
-0.6312295794487,
0.31275230646133423,
-0.7948296070098877,
-0.5147683024406433,
0.2673195004463196,
-0.41923144459724426,
-0.5699286460876465,
0.395557165145874,
0.09343712031841278,
0.6015042662620544,
-0.8263789415359497,
0.5619462728500366,
0.05481373891234398,
-0.07648360729217529,
0.43667933344841003,
-0.48871946334838867,
0.6282733082771301,
0.39522668719291687,
-0.0719846785068512,
0.11161082983016968,
-0.700644850730896,
-0.025190062820911407,
0.28666457533836365,
-0.2134285271167755,
-0.33366864919662476,
0.06307527422904968,
0.31888553500175476,
0.24558427929878235,
-0.023726627230644226,
-0.47387832403182983,
0.03314531594514847,
-0.5438551902770996,
0.5640315413475037,
0.09222788363695145,
-0.019431889057159424,
0.4882587194442749,
-0.29860174655914307,
0.8566513061523438,
-0.23670439422130585,
0.36085930466651917,
-0.24129894375801086,
-0.29758358001708984,
-0.6136943697929382,
-0.287342369556427,
0.5235669612884521,
0.4954485297203064,
-0.6878087520599365,
0.2458062320947647,
-0.45445606112480164,
-0.6354436278343201,
-0.8483703136444092,
-0.2232067734003067,
0.585504412651062,
0.68429034948349,
0.4005829095840454,
-0.11317112296819687,
-0.20644645392894745,
-0.954512894153595,
-0.0839417353272438,
-0.21726253628730774,
-0.24853633344173431,
0.7733383774757385,
0.4282342195510864,
-0.4172750413417816,
0.6933553218841553,
-0.36714640259742737,
-0.08869920670986176,
-0.5037711262702942,
-0.04996604099869728,
0.02292710728943348,
0.30775371193885803,
0.6477819681167603,
-0.7128995060920715,
-0.1286504864692688,
0.18227773904800415,
-0.6441752910614014,
-0.35114848613739014,
0.007583043538033962,
0.22036544978618622,
0.0018663585651665926,
0.1783626824617386,
-0.33025798201560974,
0.3808598518371582,
0.8701557517051697,
-0.31607556343078613,
0.37273073196411133,
-0.28516870737075806,
0.12478964030742645,
-0.9517319798469543,
0.45325151085853577,
0.10017336905002594,
-0.1587909311056137,
-1.0349644422531128,
-0.03271772339940071,
0.1633482575416565,
-0.35918527841567993,
-0.27670934796333313,
0.7269429564476013,
-0.33013078570365906,
0.3943950831890106,
-0.3854765295982361,
-0.24750396609306335,
-0.03790814429521561,
0.1594836562871933,
0.25911521911621094,
0.5424699187278748,
0.5393679141998291,
-0.5518133044242859,
-0.1114947572350502,
0.2454044073820114,
-0.44469526410102844,
0.2517286241054535,
-0.7619292140007019,
-0.1282874494791031,
0.04387136921286583,
-0.054108936339616776,
-0.5536888837814331,
-0.29351070523262024,
0.11775638908147812,
-0.20889289677143097,
0.42196083068847656,
-0.15258905291557312,
-0.35305652022361755,
-0.45148301124572754,
0.22927182912826538,
0.6585020422935486,
0.6965440511703491,
-0.1261119246482849,
0.4018581807613373,
0.5943028926849365,
-0.24489988386631012,
-0.2125997096300125,
-0.4542613625526428,
-0.15694567561149597,
0.00046462882892228663,
-0.2382514625787735,
0.42177897691726685,
-0.041766658425331116,
-0.16925208270549774,
0.019100084900856018,
-0.17752394080162048,
-0.38284412026405334,
0.13783815503120422,
0.32831066846847534,
0.4983361065387726,
-0.11546777933835983,
0.3503760099411011,
0.12087792903184891,
-0.10042732208967209,
-0.06061461195349693,
-0.05928899347782135,
0.5009027123451233,
0.006462752819061279,
-0.351806640625,
-0.3233788013458252,
0.18573002517223358,
0.7850980162620544,
-0.37349697947502136,
0.6683603525161743,
0.22674056887626648,
-0.6037437915802002,
-0.023012055084109306,
-0.5557454824447632,
-0.1511881947517395,
-0.37351518869400024,
0.6339674592018127,
-0.07513419538736343,
-0.9588167667388916,
0.2640034258365631,
-0.18749117851257324,
-0.06812514364719391,
0.5314350128173828,
0.7139573693275452,
0.2840729355812073,
0.8919553160667419,
0.755420446395874,
0.17894954979419708,
0.2739758789539337,
-0.0722658708691597,
0.27112632989883423,
-0.6583610773086548,
-0.23734238743782043,
-0.6539262533187866,
0.1671653389930725,
-0.4869959056377411,
-0.41054588556289673,
0.5756958723068237,
-0.31078457832336426,
0.032579340040683746,
0.2271629273891449,
-0.73350590467453,
0.26750075817108154,
0.08255145698785782,
-0.03613894060254097,
0.10010672360658646,
-0.2030465304851532,
-0.2663394510746002,
-0.05242380127310753,
-0.9507589340209961,
-0.6761791706085205,
1.090909719467163,
0.5189969539642334,
0.6106481552124023,
-0.40227457880973816,
0.30325737595558167,
-0.14742614328861237,
0.5723893642425537,
-0.9138036370277405,
0.2576410472393036,
-0.528173565864563,
-0.6788829565048218,
-0.0961548238992691,
-0.6052847504615784,
-0.9356814026832581,
-0.025851624086499214,
-0.3768950402736664,
-0.4666653871536255,
-0.02281375043094158,
0.1314021497964859,
-0.8067814111709595,
0.24981307983398438,
-0.6819875240325928,
1.048965334892273,
-0.2429618239402771,
0.03154014050960541,
-0.10547830164432526,
-0.5468955039978027,
0.2985037565231323,
-0.5772658586502075,
0.17203694581985474,
-0.17953018844127655,
-0.05935890972614288,
0.6392756700515747,
-0.36943262815475464,
0.757480800151825,
0.04295654222369194,
0.06761441379785538,
0.07916038483381271,
0.15304559469223022,
-0.1293441653251648,
-0.16865858435630798,
-0.12074007093906403,
0.4302610158920288,
0.16973955929279327,
-0.13133493065834045,
-0.43812012672424316,
0.35900649428367615,
-0.5996278524398804,
-0.28230398893356323,
-0.21616828441619873,
-0.5754615664482117,
-0.37013381719589233,
0.2759380340576172,
0.5988312363624573,
0.4760107696056366,
-0.3679310977458954,
0.08211226761341095,
0.4435310959815979,
-0.6440486311912537,
0.31242749094963074,
0.5827982425689697,
-0.05895008519291878,
-0.18101724982261658,
0.6536468863487244,
0.17789366841316223,
0.14215297996997833,
0.2960836887359619,
0.29322347044944763,
-0.17561298608779907,
-0.875809907913208,
-0.41663721203804016,
0.29452428221702576,
-0.18095889687538147,
-0.3699165880680084,
-0.7524469494819641,
-0.6062449812889099,
-0.2749212682247162,
-0.007498730439692736,
-0.4324984848499298,
-0.26182821393013,
-0.21868088841438293,
0.15731509029865265,
0.10854732990264893,
0.9539292454719543,
0.48376673460006714,
0.4135243892669678,
-0.9776484966278076,
0.1992097795009613,
0.05959414690732956,
0.678618311882019,
-0.05885128676891327,
-0.49840089678764343,
-0.35027220845222473,
-0.31328603625297546,
-0.2706613540649414,
-0.9237020611763,
0.5254160165786743,
0.11980212479829788,
0.5380184054374695,
0.25843507051467896,
0.03296208754181862,
0.31422412395477295,
-0.9495565295219421,
0.6254317164421082,
0.21105723083019257,
-0.8995590209960938,
0.6960530877113342,
-0.11820513755083084,
0.47066622972488403,
0.4724220931529999,
0.463118314743042,
-0.5689986944198608,
-0.4834127128124237,
-0.5696188807487488,
-0.6725082993507385,
0.7744488716125488,
0.3996858298778534,
0.2932072579860687,
-0.11082296818494797,
0.42128124833106995,
0.14489422738552094,
0.11902035772800446,
-0.6709883213043213,
-0.10326558351516724,
-0.026817290112376213,
-0.3621835708618164,
0.09305533021688461,
-0.2860465943813324,
0.007404623087495565,
-0.09876375645399094,
0.40113192796707153,
-0.040709611028432846,
0.20110946893692017,
0.13614006340503693,
-0.09797390550374985,
-0.11918549984693527,
0.4128561019897461,
0.534024178981781,
0.4766695201396942,
0.10790631920099258,
-0.15036354959011078,
0.23464296758174896,
-0.6297045946121216,
0.11334024369716644,
0.2526797950267792,
-0.14760763943195343,
0.03278934955596924,
0.49715328216552734,
0.9200938940048218,
0.20172828435897827,
-0.9485912322998047,
0.6570576429367065,
-0.3633369207382202,
0.02041706256568432,
0.18530124425888062,
0.037240613251924515,
-0.1887071430683136,
0.07350441813468933,
-0.08253709226846695,
0.3147818148136139,
0.19077977538108826,
-0.010360761545598507,
0.05318465828895569,
0.291047066450119,
-0.38306787610054016,
-0.45696938037872314,
0.7327372431755066,
0.19822950661182404,
-0.31056106090545654,
0.6597183346748352,
-0.03920360654592514,
-0.36106428503990173,
0.4229278862476349,
0.5423804521560669,
0.8706619143486023,
-0.38646480441093445,
0.17260640859603882,
0.304278165102005,
0.22718818485736847,
-0.031429473310709,
0.01804382912814617,
0.12656286358833313,
-0.7608939409255981,
-0.5496127009391785,
-0.7494508028030396,
-0.3071437180042267,
0.36671537160873413,
-0.5266895294189453,
0.18786202371120453,
-0.3835471570491791,
-0.6275746822357178,
0.21197974681854248,
-0.13545434176921844,
-0.808417797088623,
0.2029586285352707,
0.2526141107082367,
0.8318259119987488,
-0.7244321703910828,
0.8547050952911377,
0.8527265787124634,
-0.31628918647766113,
-0.5704748034477234,
0.061922818422317505,
-0.21953266859054565,
-0.7656946182250977,
0.4979651868343353,
0.06463678926229477,
0.011839909479022026,
-0.2974146604537964,
-0.21179993450641632,
-0.39813512563705444,
0.7347800731658936,
0.507476270198822,
-0.5136865973472595,
-0.3900172710418701,
0.16748261451721191,
0.9167177677154541,
-0.3529542088508606,
0.31995290517807007,
0.5469480156898499,
0.07291160523891449,
-0.15324057638645172,
-1.396910309791565,
0.026589244604110718,
-0.4202437698841095,
0.25497785210609436,
0.12422548234462738,
-0.3554512560367584,
0.7247908115386963,
-0.2913552224636078,
-0.37633830308914185,
0.21306918561458588,
0.11503838747739792,
0.07801312953233719,
0.07862042635679245,
0.42265379428863525,
0.19908277690410614,
0.6113556623458862,
-0.10263484716415405,
1.2952598333358765,
-0.5859465599060059,
0.32767751812934875,
0.6251708269119263,
-0.3001733422279358,
0.6845952868461609,
0.18323373794555664,
-0.08319608122110367,
0.25281253457069397,
0.3775458037853241,
-0.03569681942462921,
0.38303831219673157,
0.20002399384975433,
-0.3412512540817261,
-0.2311124950647354,
-0.56429523229599,
-0.1988307237625122,
0.5832725167274475,
0.4499971568584442,
-0.6906631588935852,
-0.09516234695911407,
0.24817973375320435,
0.031191721558570862,
0.12689746916294098,
-0.24863925576210022,
0.8344423770904541,
0.15175850689411163,
-0.6036463975906372,
0.5634765625,
0.055237866938114166,
0.4077245593070984,
-0.5621282458305359,
0.13448545336723328,
-0.08255048841238022,
0.007470952346920967,
0.04865875467658043,
-0.4258258640766144,
0.3760530352592468,
0.41564834117889404,
-0.2656026780605316,
-0.3837905824184418,
0.8954076766967773,
-0.25068411231040955,
-0.6000800728797913,
0.23693306744098663,
0.7620754241943359,
0.007733028382062912,
0.17605026066303253,
-0.4675658643245697,
0.027208944782614708,
-0.08626041561365128,
-0.09187664091587067,
0.19019006192684174,
0.4242817461490631,
-0.04395613074302673,
0.6563129425048828,
0.22370268404483795,
0.37100085616111755,
-0.2666402757167816,
0.15325485169887543,
0.7222592830657959,
-0.5447582006454468,
-0.26165062189102173,
-0.9428577423095703,
0.2977961599826813,
0.17686311900615692,
-0.30999287962913513,
0.2771231234073639,
0.4181537628173828,
0.5560511946678162,
-0.23288927972316742,
0.8828679919242859,
0.12063773721456528,
0.6079648733139038,
-0.2699856758117676,
1.1403131484985352,
-0.5901994705200195,
0.15475012362003326,
-0.111822210252285,
-0.27701207995414734,
-0.634319543838501,
0.5289085507392883,
-0.4159849286079407,
0.1510329395532608,
0.6285004019737244,
0.4521043300628662,
-0.01461012102663517,
-0.023049352690577507,
0.5563793182373047,
0.13783343136310577,
0.066687673330307,
0.5804364681243896,
0.7655073404312134,
-0.24546629190444946,
0.5184686779975891,
-0.3001031279563904,
-0.3207923471927643,
-0.052739620208740234,
-0.7124089598655701,
-0.9648011922836304,
-0.6281332969665527,
-0.2825322449207306,
-0.11587456613779068,
-0.10441412776708603,
0.9260031580924988,
0.9413282871246338,
-0.8134443759918213,
-0.2017526477575302,
0.11019442975521088,
-0.17697352170944214,
0.05351635813713074,
-0.08352898061275482,
0.32301682233810425,
-0.3988068699836731,
-0.6886056661605835,
0.3204006254673004,
0.34493857622146606,
0.27172523736953735,
-0.1528567522764206,
0.10933908820152283,
0.28677988052368164,
0.12028061598539352,
0.5618106722831726,
0.19982647895812988,
-0.6815076470375061,
0.1403139978647232,
0.34954896569252014,
-0.24783876538276672,
-0.11448289453983307,
1.030958652496338,
-0.8468242883682251,
0.5590354204177856,
0.24353571236133575,
0.7964157462120056,
0.059061527252197266,
-0.42556673288345337,
0.6412134766578674,
-0.6385653018951416,
-0.15210160613059998,
0.6314382553100586,
0.4664771258831024,
0.3815503418445587,
-0.1789708435535431,
0.43078750371932983,
0.052718572318553925,
-0.6207165122032166,
-0.9397753477096558,
0.1873525083065033,
-0.5963634252548218,
-0.39309176802635193,
1.0020841360092163,
-0.017983267083764076,
0.014946423470973969,
-0.009365829639136791,
-0.18403489887714386,
0.46555501222610474,
-0.01760619319975376,
0.7813636660575867,
0.5789055228233337,
-0.23973263800144196,
0.019751960411667824,
-0.8159952163696289,
0.6406069397926331,
0.39905643463134766,
-0.8973080515861511,
0.13532023131847382,
0.3923299014568329,
0.17898297309875488,
0.27815741300582886,
0.7695844173431396,
-0.3279007077217102,
0.1619732826948166,
-0.2388928085565567,
0.17169047892093658,
0.18521592020988464,
-0.36437156796455383,
-0.6038693189620972,
0.14957867562770844,
0.14157646894454956,
-0.01991385594010353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16605v1 | CLEAR: Can Language Models Really Understand Causal Graphs? | 2024-06-24T12:46:15 | 2024-06-24T12:46:15 | Sirui Chen, Mengying Xu, Kun Wang, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao, Shengjie Zhao, Chaochao Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME | Causal reasoning is a cornerstone of how humans interpret the world. To model
and reason about causality, causal graphs offer a concise yet effective
solution. Given the impressive advancements in language models, a crucial
question arises: can they really understand causal graphs? To this end, we
pioneer an investigation into language models' understanding of causal graphs.
Specifically, we develop a framework to define causal graph understanding, by
assessing language models' behaviors through four practical criteria derived
from diverse disciplines (e.g., philosophy and psychology). We then develop
CLEAR, a novel benchmark that defines three complexity levels and encompasses
20 causal graph-based tasks across these levels. Finally, based on our
framework and benchmark, we conduct extensive experiments on six leading
language models and summarize five empirical findings. Our results indicate
that while language models demonstrate a preliminary understanding of causal
graphs, significant potential for improvement remains. Our project website is
at https://github.com/OpenCausaLab/CLEAR. | [
-0.10568799823522568,
-0.9083954095840454,
0.9628021121025085,
0.28408733010292053,
-0.0007179593667387962,
-0.17591269314289093,
-0.05814708396792412,
-0.764152467250824,
-0.5222908854484558,
0.5306812524795532,
-0.5245411396026611,
-0.4835759103298187,
-0.6461663842201233,
0.025547774508595467,
-0.6179147362709045,
0.6890061497688293,
-0.10312750935554504,
0.08252217620611191,
0.01610761322081089,
-0.15550057590007782,
-0.567791759967804,
0.062106307595968246,
-0.9178316593170166,
-0.674920916557312,
0.6678086519241333,
0.254129558801651,
0.756088137626648,
0.8413369655609131,
0.38006505370140076,
0.3638828992843628,
-0.17753300070762634,
-0.06163476034998894,
-0.744586169719696,
-0.13253191113471985,
-0.6722856760025024,
-0.3703766167163849,
-0.23376739025115967,
0.08102734386920929,
0.5954521894454956,
1.4780250787734985,
0.07758898288011551,
0.1714630424976349,
-0.0023682434111833572,
0.4306718409061432,
-0.6082642674446106,
0.6129264235496521,
-0.31478598713874817,
-0.17051249742507935,
0.0283298809081316,
0.17267197370529175,
-0.8650243282318115,
-0.3337966203689575,
0.011304016225039959,
-0.7162448763847351,
0.35162031650543213,
0.22557388246059418,
1.0814683437347412,
0.16931940615177155,
-0.9995502233505249,
0.033450331538915634,
-1.0483218431472778,
0.28711411356925964,
-0.6557962894439697,
0.602131724357605,
0.23771442472934723,
0.4855186343193054,
-0.31500715017318726,
-1.1104928255081177,
-0.6318885087966919,
-0.11183170229196548,
-0.22384320199489594,
-0.0352478064596653,
-0.3549293875694275,
0.22716812789440155,
0.5207090973854065,
0.12426500767469406,
-0.6281585097312927,
0.12141678482294083,
-0.46519210934638977,
-0.20366016030311584,
0.39839285612106323,
0.21777236461639404,
0.7424615025520325,
0.008889072574675083,
-0.1537502557039261,
0.33178070187568665,
-0.6140881776809692,
-0.005651091691106558,
0.19118624925613403,
0.3841164708137512,
-0.28544995188713074,
0.23579981923103333,
-0.4421654939651489,
1.031219720840454,
-0.3487301468849182,
0.23416735231876373,
-0.25912824273109436,
-0.3392850160598755,
-0.4317559003829956,
-0.03730215132236481,
0.6345786452293396,
0.08157403022050858,
0.5472207069396973,
-0.4035544991493225,
0.234237402677536,
0.09745503216981888,
0.042441293597221375,
-0.6911595463752747,
-0.450574666261673,
0.10213655978441238,
-0.42713668942451477,
-0.012207617983222008,
-0.08969481289386749,
0.04768739640712738,
-0.7542887330055237,
-0.494167298078537,
0.16960696876049042,
-0.3151828646659851,
-0.44724443554878235,
0.6700740456581116,
-0.22630445659160614,
0.013133106753230095,
0.5295985341072083,
-0.5359504222869873,
0.4589938521385193,
0.9061124324798584,
0.5278010368347168,
0.40160948038101196,
-0.4319964647293091,
-0.27616581320762634,
0.2040490359067917,
-0.4603090286254883,
0.8593042492866516,
-0.360819011926651,
0.0903044268488884,
-0.025723254308104515,
-0.025937626138329506,
-0.21882003545761108,
-0.146448016166687,
0.8111284375190735,
-0.6627458333969116,
0.10662247240543365,
-0.4042925238609314,
-0.7003543376922607,
-0.5837836265563965,
0.07730476558208466,
-0.8112578392028809,
0.37483808398246765,
-0.32705578207969666,
-0.7074688076972961,
0.6353244781494141,
-0.228977233171463,
-0.41056278347969055,
0.0910252034664154,
-0.007602043449878693,
0.02486618235707283,
0.09884469211101532,
-0.028612907975912094,
0.26443004608154297,
-0.6766129732131958,
0.8080599308013916,
-0.574568510055542,
-0.28800082206726074,
0.3115706145763397,
-0.4030352532863617,
1.1053613424301147,
0.2373427152633667,
-0.36109209060668945,
0.27766481041908264,
-0.7145204544067383,
-0.14509588479995728,
0.09973671287298203,
0.13004596531391144,
-0.24804985523223877,
0.35796058177948,
-0.18506957590579987,
0.35773301124572754,
0.06123539060354233,
-0.4892968535423279,
-0.09526132792234421,
-0.3475489020347595,
0.4361574351787567,
0.6428236365318298,
-0.08577974140644073,
0.13751181960105896,
0.06993087381124496,
0.042825475335121155,
-0.25086918473243713,
0.25194355845451355,
-0.15632317960262299,
-0.5884149074554443,
-0.7049898505210876,
-0.17794938385486603,
-0.06357741355895996,
0.2321721762418747,
-0.20008939504623413,
0.27919527888298035,
-0.2611452043056488,
-0.4618726968765259,
-0.18174879252910614,
-0.16165809333324432,
0.6241452693939209,
1.0182509422302246,
0.2395235002040863,
-0.1314622163772583,
-0.3348412811756134,
-0.8430003523826599,
-0.6761634349822998,
-0.491747111082077,
0.10703939199447632,
0.27712902426719666,
0.6926833391189575,
-0.05138353258371353,
0.9190575480461121,
-0.8460191488265991,
0.38660064339637756,
-0.25071027874946594,
0.3912588059902191,
0.3895159065723419,
0.2328345626592636,
0.1603219360113144,
-0.6949688196182251,
-0.16297052800655365,
-0.013978144153952599,
-1.047070860862732,
-0.3087863028049469,
-0.0265196580439806,
-0.14971594512462616,
-0.5535056591033936,
0.873342752456665,
-0.23361778259277344,
0.4091964066028595,
0.24230055510997772,
-1.0433202981948853,
0.5593240261077881,
-0.2474127858877182,
0.10746191442012787,
-0.29364150762557983,
0.4596715569496155,
-0.0811816155910492,
-0.331356018781662,
-0.9587586522102356,
-0.012902488932013512,
0.08899606764316559,
-0.30257081985473633,
-0.3162694275379181,
0.7384101152420044,
-0.19606059789657593,
0.07199690490961075,
-0.09674771875143051,
0.26380664110183716,
0.15674594044685364,
0.3982326090335846,
-0.10421879589557648,
0.08684994280338287,
0.5229891538619995,
-0.5494064092636108,
0.026558255776762962,
0.0167705025523901,
-0.5836928486824036,
0.48029276728630066,
-0.8780080676078796,
-0.1585676223039627,
-0.37694984674453735,
0.2487928867340088,
-1.1902401447296143,
-0.33961644768714905,
0.25792941451072693,
-0.2674439251422882,
0.0720626711845398,
-0.138264462351799,
-0.6547219753265381,
-0.30378809571266174,
0.4806135594844818,
0.4109947085380554,
0.1863594651222229,
-0.4188672602176666,
0.3094567060470581,
0.3280949890613556,
0.23241353034973145,
-0.4267268180847168,
-0.42569252848625183,
0.023125160485506058,
0.11952076852321625,
-0.7986772656440735,
-0.004127345979213715,
-0.05155057832598686,
-0.5231571197509766,
0.1063702180981636,
-0.23307546973228455,
-0.37183547019958496,
0.39211151003837585,
0.22720572352409363,
-0.25408586859703064,
-0.11609814316034317,
0.32746416330337524,
-0.09013590216636658,
-0.3363878130912781,
0.15551669895648956,
-0.3639669120311737,
0.39409124851226807,
-0.22365553677082062,
-0.4663824141025543,
-0.6320517063140869,
-0.06740344315767288,
0.4993436336517334,
-0.3244343101978302,
0.8123807311058044,
0.3763287663459778,
-0.5774238705635071,
-0.0040343152359128,
-0.34976139664649963,
-0.010586682707071304,
-0.4265763461589813,
0.15868937969207764,
-0.3565213084220886,
-0.8298866748809814,
0.7574358582496643,
-0.3184480369091034,
-0.26898816227912903,
0.5441253781318665,
0.18805597722530365,
0.10653097182512283,
1.404821515083313,
0.6817457675933838,
0.12335178256034851,
0.3174391984939575,
0.018711348995566368,
0.3610007166862488,
-0.332724392414093,
-0.3936854898929596,
-0.8302329778671265,
0.10965310782194138,
-0.38270094990730286,
-0.052410516887903214,
0.029154004529118538,
0.6011022925376892,
-0.8514471054077148,
0.07846461236476898,
-0.18681491911411285,
0.5911514759063721,
0.07039718329906464,
0.1032133474946022,
0.4186975657939911,
-0.36035531759262085,
-0.08856676518917084,
0.291456013917923,
-0.4923446774482727,
-0.6424267292022705,
0.5509229898452759,
0.35014277696609497,
0.6069517731666565,
0.2174447476863861,
0.26975610852241516,
0.06315314024686813,
0.41842880845069885,
-0.2487923502922058,
0.6161456108093262,
0.05042193457484245,
-0.8182795643806458,
-0.32078680396080017,
-0.5249394774436951,
-1.1248279809951782,
0.32352522015571594,
0.004194261506199837,
-0.9853730797767639,
0.19427599012851715,
0.19554704427719116,
0.16602377593517303,
0.29743340611457825,
-0.7497336268424988,
1.474951148033142,
-0.011683718301355839,
-0.3723525404930115,
-0.33010321855545044,
-0.7445857524871826,
0.7640149593353271,
0.23610122501850128,
0.5824613571166992,
-0.4791806638240814,
0.29722750186920166,
0.72050541639328,
-0.5653887391090393,
1.0133839845657349,
-0.1980573832988739,
-0.17443236708641052,
0.29422077536582947,
0.19625705480575562,
0.19096875190734863,
-0.11801235377788544,
-0.18809136748313904,
0.24843406677246094,
-0.2994263172149658,
-0.5728598833084106,
-0.7615513801574707,
0.4697378873825073,
-0.6640369296073914,
-0.4348433017730713,
0.0007907424587756395,
-0.48906323313713074,
0.024492569267749786,
0.7016445994377136,
-0.1497678905725479,
0.6006128191947937,
-0.2977939248085022,
-0.35169821977615356,
0.5282189249992371,
-0.2501550018787384,
0.05433548614382744,
0.8695582747459412,
-0.2698507308959961,
0.04108728840947151,
0.7700203657150269,
-0.1916802078485489,
0.37787866592407227,
0.3408190906047821,
0.5721157789230347,
-0.20186705887317657,
-0.4988313913345337,
-0.15315653383731842,
0.5418329238891602,
-1.0917285680770874,
0.26521870493888855,
-0.4645887315273285,
0.16211144626140594,
-0.4158988296985626,
-0.11495271325111389,
0.002748129889369011,
-0.37691864371299744,
-0.0451081357896328,
-0.2081957459449768,
0.06970131397247314,
1.0672305822372437,
-0.08738362044095993,
0.33866992592811584,
-0.4680439233779907,
0.3920009732246399,
0.26024720072746277,
0.5046449303627014,
0.22547569870948792,
-0.2737903892993927,
-0.07061469554901123,
-0.04788242653012276,
0.05141836777329445,
-1.12477445602417,
0.11386521905660629,
-0.13733850419521332,
0.6025081872940063,
0.6794702410697937,
-0.14011552929878235,
0.6973208785057068,
-0.7007032036781311,
0.5743472576141357,
0.1847935914993286,
-1.2214055061340332,
0.5913839340209961,
-0.4932560324668884,
0.39424362778663635,
0.4151735305786133,
0.35316726565361023,
-0.6731343269348145,
-0.7507038712501526,
-0.623074471950531,
-0.6070506572723389,
0.6541706919670105,
0.21018142998218536,
-0.28627684712409973,
-0.00328790582716465,
0.5536088943481445,
-0.15246902406215668,
-0.027637904509902,
-0.7800010442733765,
-0.3197212517261505,
-0.0063286940567195415,
-0.22643932700157166,
-0.2208607792854309,
-0.004143732599914074,
-0.14014273881912231,
-0.20566284656524658,
0.21894121170043945,
0.0554802380502224,
-0.011880340985953808,
0.049343764781951904,
-0.3147261142730713,
-0.1106235533952713,
0.23020780086517334,
0.5229148268699646,
0.9977237582206726,
-0.1419377475976944,
0.5433691740036011,
-0.04097067192196846,
-0.21160942316055298,
-0.009827238507568836,
0.11090794950723648,
-0.17291051149368286,
-0.2779310643672943,
0.9798510074615479,
0.8429555892944336,
0.48639318346977234,
-0.6498413681983948,
0.3692997097969055,
-0.2607162594795227,
0.1482308954000473,
0.2833774983882904,
0.11259866505861282,
0.1815238893032074,
0.07071937620639801,
0.009165355935692787,
-0.10510201007127762,
0.4134189784526825,
-0.5714349746704102,
0.08463996648788452,
0.1518169492483139,
-0.6207996010780334,
-0.4538154900074005,
0.9340970516204834,
0.11411424726247787,
-0.12968601286411285,
0.622802734375,
-0.229046031832695,
-0.5239838361740112,
0.8551924228668213,
0.7207972407341003,
0.7587792873382568,
-0.11971531063318253,
0.14848364889621735,
0.5224748253822327,
0.5637926459312439,
-0.11574460566043854,
0.35332417488098145,
0.010178156197071075,
-0.8084164261817932,
-0.5778964161872864,
-0.35356464982032776,
-0.3701116740703583,
-0.22175706923007965,
-0.4699692726135254,
0.1869988888502121,
-0.2523611783981323,
0.15812154114246368,
0.3680093288421631,
-0.19342420995235443,
-0.6689399480819702,
0.4147455096244812,
-0.04283371567726135,
0.8772368431091309,
-1.2483751773834229,
0.4803744852542877,
0.2840100824832916,
-0.7324331402778625,
-0.9387369751930237,
-0.33776015043258667,
0.045460041612386703,
-0.6343921422958374,
1.124752402305603,
0.3257978856563568,
-0.3855314254760742,
-0.04618944972753525,
-0.6957370638847351,
-0.729263186454773,
0.6562350988388062,
0.6323862671852112,
-0.28198567032814026,
0.16298756003379822,
0.11822937428951263,
0.5783979296684265,
0.07331211119890213,
0.4006049335002899,
0.587440013885498,
0.6708461046218872,
-0.16505515575408936,
-0.788154125213623,
0.3929629921913147,
-0.17135176062583923,
-0.3579314649105072,
0.3179076313972473,
-0.21411798894405365,
0.8321471214294434,
-0.34093746542930603,
-0.6276458501815796,
-0.27825531363487244,
0.732701301574707,
-0.017625324428081512,
0.5034647583961487,
0.5282636284828186,
0.3797186315059662,
1.06460440158844,
-0.088563933968544,
1.2494853734970093,
-0.4069775342941284,
0.4411201775074005,
1.147592306137085,
-0.3083396852016449,
0.2712756097316742,
-0.1223413422703743,
0.013903636485338211,
0.7591407895088196,
0.373294472694397,
0.4413403570652008,
0.28790366649627686,
0.4554053246974945,
-0.16803458333015442,
-0.5923395752906799,
-0.32177913188934326,
-0.06493420153856277,
0.1943415403366089,
0.4187704920768738,
-0.13562259078025818,
-0.4608532190322876,
-0.1891331672668457,
0.27514025568962097,
0.21656998991966248,
-0.4087892770767212,
0.4399072527885437,
0.05123225599527359,
-0.7001331448554993,
0.3959662616252899,
0.11304789036512375,
-0.2395823895931244,
-0.5704823136329651,
-0.019000984728336334,
0.008073018863797188,
0.2979976534843445,
-0.25310441851615906,
-0.8859758377075195,
0.28182679414749146,
-0.07541567087173462,
-0.07489190995693207,
-0.2601947486400604,
0.831281840801239,
-0.29732900857925415,
-0.2866782248020172,
0.33945077657699585,
0.42861250042915344,
0.17956915497779846,
0.1182478591799736,
-0.49330154061317444,
0.029302166774868965,
-0.29096052050590515,
0.215018168091774,
-0.21623492240905762,
0.5083918571472168,
-0.24248871207237244,
0.8216524720191956,
0.5344611406326294,
0.010351266711950302,
-0.04365396872162819,
0.4523198902606964,
0.4987296760082245,
-0.6840295791625977,
-0.37226614356040955,
-0.9626128077507019,
0.5126872062683105,
-0.1778949350118637,
-0.2072611302137375,
0.839907705783844,
0.3965027630329132,
0.6793931126594543,
0.19509291648864746,
0.4854011833667755,
0.12855912744998932,
0.10632230341434479,
-0.36834052205085754,
0.7170689702033997,
-0.46618857979774475,
-0.00529179722070694,
-0.39699116349220276,
-0.1942445933818817,
-0.7041382789611816,
0.4378627836704254,
-0.6011168360710144,
-0.030972920358181,
0.7952634692192078,
0.5259625911712646,
-0.052189648151397705,
0.1760789453983307,
0.12352362275123596,
0.5442849397659302,
0.7404453754425049,
0.4814518690109253,
0.9238031506538391,
-0.10631725937128067,
0.4010052978992462,
0.013556993566453457,
-0.349284827709198,
0.06918551027774811,
-0.9130876064300537,
-0.766772985458374,
-0.4531204402446747,
-0.4423028826713562,
-0.22322788834571838,
0.019047921523451805,
0.011789250187575817,
0.5334171652793884,
-0.5219243764877319,
-0.3502005934715271,
-0.6694899797439575,
0.7753056287765503,
-0.3955196738243103,
-0.19287224113941193,
0.573759138584137,
-0.5177564024925232,
-0.3956134617328644,
0.29401111602783203,
0.34007909893989563,
-0.3403685390949249,
-0.07881836593151093,
0.020033355802297592,
-0.26742294430732727,
0.19126176834106445,
0.5686584711074829,
0.5349003672599792,
-0.6699256300926208,
-0.5212780833244324,
-0.25654280185699463,
-0.2506454885005951,
-0.4575294852256775,
1.1305813789367676,
-0.4935804307460785,
0.837489128112793,
0.8594039678573608,
0.019236277788877487,
0.4638500511646271,
-0.33334246277809143,
0.6592738032341003,
-0.30056071281433105,
0.1015600934624672,
-0.18180935084819794,
0.7067403197288513,
0.17351669073104858,
-0.04580727592110634,
0.5624916553497314,
0.23687660694122314,
-0.4311605393886566,
-0.9546850919723511,
0.6604308485984802,
-0.7644984722137451,
-0.6660079956054688,
0.7830502390861511,
-0.12524425983428955,
-0.039775628596544266,
-0.5846661925315857,
-0.0795527771115303,
0.6501413583755493,
0.18099908530712128,
0.4284737706184387,
0.44585007429122925,
-0.3678776025772095,
0.18775224685668945,
-0.6174356937408447,
0.31585344672203064,
0.2001810222864151,
-0.8653788566589355,
0.3393963873386383,
0.7508325576782227,
0.20474591851234436,
0.03961975872516632,
0.7623439431190491,
0.07462787628173828,
0.276801735162735,
-0.010360163636505604,
-0.0726606696844101,
0.03292231634259224,
-0.4593234956264496,
-0.33509132266044617,
0.23987866938114166,
0.26843422651290894,
0.3437293469905853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16567v1 | Data Augmentation of Multi-turn Psychological Dialogue via Knowledge-driven Progressive Thought Prompting | 2024-06-24T12:02:56 | 2024-06-24T12:02:56 | Jiyue Jiang, Liheng Chen, Sheng Wang, Lingpeng Kong, Yu Li, Chuan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing dialogue data augmentation (DA) techniques predominantly focus on
augmenting utterance-level dialogues, which makes it difficult to take dialogue
contextual information into account. The advent of large language models (LLMs)
has simplified the implementation of multi-turn dialogues. Due to absence of
professional understanding and knowledge, it remains challenging to deliver
satisfactory performance in low-resource domain, like psychological dialogue
dialogue. DA involves creating new training or prompting data based on the
existing data, which help the model better understand and generate
psychology-related responses. In this paper, we aim to address the issue of
multi-turn dialogue data augmentation for boosted performance in the psychology
domain. We propose a knowledge-driven progressive thought prompting method to
guide LLM to generate multi-turn psychology-related dialogue. This method
integrates a progressive thought generator, a psychology knowledge generator,
and a multi-turn dialogue generator. The thought generated by the progressive
thought generator serves as a prompt to prevent the generated dialogue from
having significant semantic deviations, while the psychology knowledge
generator produces psychological knowledge to serve as the dialogue history for
the LLM, guiding the dialogue generator to create multi-turn psychological
dialogue. To ensure the precision of multi-turn psychological dialogue
generation by LLM, a meticulous professional evaluation is required. Extensive
experiments conducted on three datasets related to psychological dialogue
verify the effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
-0.7392662167549133,
-1.0417497158050537,
0.8207657933235168,
0.4139866232872009,
-0.1601814180612564,
0.21506674587726593,
-0.3935627043247223,
-0.10784892737865448,
0.13762585818767548,
0.4651227295398712,
-1.394055724143982,
-0.3905855715274811,
-0.1637304574251175,
0.10575772821903229,
0.06858044862747192,
0.8364733457565308,
0.2358676791191101,
0.29082900285720825,
-0.21173769235610962,
0.06841570883989334,
-0.8771622776985168,
-0.42312172055244446,
-0.695339024066925,
-0.522637665271759,
0.1177421510219574,
0.33717232942581177,
0.6019036769866943,
-0.12284258008003235,
0.0560259148478508,
0.29896095395088196,
0.028932536020874977,
0.5740123987197876,
-0.41800814867019653,
0.48674309253692627,
-0.014311864972114563,
-0.3749825060367584,
-0.8059263825416565,
-0.11669334024190903,
0.6145872473716736,
0.5741748213768005,
-0.3277861177921295,
-0.001603462384082377,
-0.11561759561300278,
0.8246256113052368,
-0.49667248129844666,
0.19171693921089172,
-0.5717872381210327,
0.081496961414814,
0.08799505233764648,
-0.37962111830711365,
-0.37964850664138794,
-0.6319859623908997,
0.16249945759773254,
-0.5521351099014282,
0.28958603739738464,
-0.44647035002708435,
0.20661330223083496,
0.16407953202724457,
-0.14668980240821838,
-0.30909112095832825,
-0.9462302327156067,
0.555286705493927,
-0.785801351070404,
0.3133200407028198,
0.30880627036094666,
0.30145642161369324,
-0.34787893295288086,
-0.3473258912563324,
-1.039852261543274,
-0.16999278962612152,
0.2524838149547577,
0.24410215020179749,
0.06870222091674805,
0.16749243438243866,
0.4030124545097351,
0.28059956431388855,
-0.26933416724205017,
-0.15809108316898346,
0.07865826040506363,
-0.11040295660495758,
0.6199715733528137,
0.5301681160926819,
-0.12473669648170471,
0.05751662328839302,
-0.05195825546979904,
-0.23393794894218445,
-0.5699407458305359,
-0.04115700721740723,
0.5147294998168945,
0.26645568013191223,
0.133278027176857,
0.43425777554512024,
-0.5324397087097168,
0.7901062369346619,
0.5313550233840942,
-0.4224141240119934,
0.44129663705825806,
-0.631779670715332,
0.048242706805467606,
0.006166166625916958,
0.8254746794700623,
0.5462234616279602,
0.5045811533927917,
0.041821300983428955,
-0.05603785067796707,
0.086527019739151,
0.3073759973049164,
-0.6489163637161255,
-0.09854099154472351,
0.31306764483451843,
-0.1783130168914795,
-0.19808416068553925,
-0.29262539744377136,
-1.1305700540542603,
-0.5386382341384888,
-0.5099054574966431,
0.15045729279518127,
-0.7665054798126221,
-0.5290130376815796,
0.16419366002082825,
0.010395404882729053,
0.1389618068933487,
0.43493470549583435,
-0.683593213558197,
-0.1407293677330017,
0.4805606007575989,
0.629986047744751,
0.020432647317647934,
-0.03579778969287872,
-0.37858590483665466,
0.12551981210708618,
-0.25301897525787354,
0.7304942011833191,
-0.7894688844680786,
-0.5701590776443481,
0.24093805253505707,
-0.30718985199928284,
0.04719880223274231,
-0.36218884587287903,
0.42465171217918396,
-0.4590827226638794,
0.5259679555892944,
-0.07186809927225113,
-0.4921475946903229,
0.03717627003788948,
0.416456013917923,
-0.3712693452835083,
0.9833534359931946,
-0.06875662505626678,
-0.7010579705238342,
0.48105111718177795,
-0.9308031797409058,
-0.4657660722732544,
0.212990865111351,
-0.3737265467643738,
-0.2637334167957306,
-0.09931332617998123,
0.6829369068145752,
0.27001360058784485,
-0.12159951776266098,
0.539149820804596,
-0.34920644760131836,
-0.15634872019290924,
0.6311611533164978,
-0.7922449111938477,
0.412552148103714,
-0.01670932210981846,
-0.26312416791915894,
0.06842882931232452,
-0.8910396695137024,
0.29645293951034546,
-0.1948610544204712,
-0.18256452679634094,
-0.0016840280732139945,
-0.16472697257995605,
-0.37805625796318054,
0.40066665410995483,
0.17651627957820892,
-0.6280185580253601,
0.39721742272377014,
-0.3722461462020874,
0.050769202411174774,
0.9147454500198364,
0.3918013870716095,
0.25559505820274353,
-0.14644519984722137,
0.620634138584137,
-0.007278470788151026,
0.27976951003074646,
-0.24006237089633942,
-0.6574704051017761,
-0.5831629037857056,
-0.2518354654312134,
0.014253946021199226,
0.5363090634346008,
-1.0430254936218262,
0.6133089065551758,
-0.14498493075370789,
-0.40476784110069275,
-0.8251008987426758,
-0.010354788973927498,
0.07411607354879379,
0.6928269863128662,
0.3355638086795807,
-0.09337131679058075,
-0.551114559173584,
-0.6474139094352722,
-0.18635258078575134,
-0.18866018950939178,
-0.13117367029190063,
0.38424184918403625,
-0.018448099493980408,
-0.3070600926876068,
1.2213032245635986,
-0.8407489061355591,
-0.1795850545167923,
-0.37262365221977234,
0.3632251024246216,
0.3455103039741516,
0.34214118123054504,
-0.011555161327123642,
-0.5591723322868347,
-0.2719569802284241,
-0.5174683332443237,
-0.6682242751121521,
-0.082967109978199,
-0.4103267192840576,
-0.3020045757293701,
0.02289748378098011,
0.14878226816654205,
-0.8075413703918457,
0.30644652247428894,
0.18492566049098969,
-0.11953043192625046,
0.9822872281074524,
-0.10604695230722427,
0.2988480031490326,
-1.0680490732192993,
-0.13749071955680847,
0.013168581761419773,
0.11821571737527847,
-0.8962756395339966,
-0.3990412652492523,
-0.13064931333065033,
-0.06471247971057892,
-0.16538845002651215,
0.18294702470302582,
-0.1551213264465332,
0.3749600052833557,
-0.39206182956695557,
0.22959479689598083,
-0.07973115146160126,
0.5890923142433167,
0.4007730185985565,
0.8776803016662598,
0.7261571884155273,
-0.8055496215820312,
0.5069684982299805,
0.4398139715194702,
-0.40324512124061584,
0.7860396504402161,
-0.10042773187160492,
0.48377129435539246,
-0.10796108096837997,
0.5425062775611877,
-0.8923697471618652,
-0.1839589625597,
0.1119871437549591,
-0.3207665979862213,
0.24614429473876953,
0.13055221736431122,
-0.5405163168907166,
-0.5117369890213013,
-0.32140210270881653,
0.3211158812046051,
0.4631606340408325,
-0.37752363085746765,
0.5057174563407898,
0.18987718224525452,
-0.5440975427627563,
-0.4864574074745178,
-0.3728131055831909,
0.10762898623943329,
-0.2424720972776413,
-0.8826627731323242,
0.3367326855659485,
-0.33630579710006714,
-0.039039116352796555,
-0.543927013874054,
0.060165368020534515,
0.30274128913879395,
-0.4627888798713684,
0.0670742392539978,
0.522156834602356,
0.09254026412963867,
0.3234681487083435,
0.12365883588790894,
-0.06697944551706314,
0.3723759055137634,
-0.2635944187641144,
0.8926950097084045,
0.07907131314277649,
-0.503163754940033,
-0.4315764009952545,
0.3744726777076721,
0.48313507437705994,
-0.12727659940719604,
0.7200552821159363,
0.8662967085838318,
-0.05672455579042435,
0.08105381578207016,
-0.8828774690628052,
-0.5717768669128418,
-0.5261279940605164,
0.2264719307422638,
-0.3900063633918762,
-0.7037385702133179,
0.2872137129306793,
-0.48284000158309937,
0.025490108877420425,
-0.10770835727453232,
0.8762815594673157,
-0.1376459002494812,
1.5298417806625366,
0.39081090688705444,
0.07763602584600449,
0.6801329851150513,
-0.2288200408220291,
0.38306641578674316,
-1.1079198122024536,
-0.4515433609485626,
-0.027166936546564102,
-0.15877597033977509,
-0.3680936396121979,
-0.3852614462375641,
0.6259576082229614,
-0.16160468757152557,
-0.12007685005664825,
-0.22171396017074585,
-0.5006695985794067,
0.03347419202327728,
0.26370030641555786,
0.40296024084091187,
0.45172756910324097,
0.05491993576288223,
-0.13458754122257233,
-0.23276057839393616,
-0.5503761172294617,
-0.23798352479934692,
1.1127302646636963,
0.22556211054325104,
0.9500836730003357,
0.0006179983611218631,
0.6241039633750916,
0.21092936396598816,
0.22732751071453094,
-0.7889147400856018,
0.6441285610198975,
0.601026177406311,
-0.35075098276138306,
-0.31958287954330444,
-0.47365647554397583,
-0.6789303421974182,
0.04545482620596886,
-0.2967068552970886,
-0.7127825617790222,
0.20131109654903412,
0.0634567067027092,
-0.3906024992465973,
-0.10048910975456238,
-0.4860866069793701,
0.2099754363298416,
-0.2204144448041916,
-0.2536028027534485,
-0.4703255593776703,
-0.46037623286247253,
0.477726012468338,
-0.13267609477043152,
0.19357725977897644,
0.19186872243881226,
0.35927659273147583,
0.7423815727233887,
-0.4130765199661255,
0.7900866866111755,
-0.5237441062927246,
-0.41821062564849854,
0.38174471259117126,
-0.039520636200904846,
0.7892771363258362,
0.26725947856903076,
-0.06090651452541351,
-0.3855134844779968,
-0.40536317229270935,
-0.12698966264724731,
-0.7875333428382874,
0.4094129204750061,
-0.544344961643219,
-0.8758875727653503,
0.02109074778854847,
-0.7648693323135376,
-0.9812855124473572,
-0.037367962300777435,
0.25275343656539917,
0.3716326057910919,
-0.08914703875780106,
-0.21413883566856384,
0.7388235926628113,
-0.11942551285028458,
0.29627636075019836,
0.7170493006706238,
-0.12502668797969818,
-0.6212524175643921,
0.783915102481842,
-0.19843094050884247,
0.3567877411842346,
-0.05661117285490036,
0.08956797420978546,
-0.7058375477790833,
-0.36923205852508545,
-0.3876105546951294,
0.17918473482131958,
-0.6287227869033813,
-0.2567569613456726,
-0.6551216840744019,
0.0656607523560524,
-0.5927770137786865,
0.1806422919034958,
-0.16349287331104279,
-0.35618430376052856,
0.11472465097904205,
-0.20993591845035553,
0.7319717407226562,
0.4446353316307068,
0.023683488368988037,
0.32985416054725647,
-0.6573909521102905,
0.37229156494140625,
0.3659350872039795,
0.2562416195869446,
0.2550218105316162,
-0.3750062882900238,
-0.2311229556798935,
0.39907222986221313,
-0.7040736079216003,
-1.0443953275680542,
0.2616245746612549,
0.12295597046613693,
0.4858231246471405,
0.5922729969024658,
0.15351414680480957,
0.8896914124488831,
-0.3931989073753357,
0.9096575975418091,
0.41095301508903503,
-0.644076943397522,
0.9331144690513611,
-0.25884366035461426,
0.5129495859146118,
0.5468239784240723,
0.1415083110332489,
-0.44204843044281006,
-0.6501230597496033,
-0.6371026039123535,
-0.6795046329498291,
0.7128310203552246,
0.2619582414627075,
0.16192162036895752,
-0.03460366651415825,
0.21121910214424133,
0.19378072023391724,
0.46548518538475037,
-0.43180862069129944,
-0.24174579977989197,
-0.22161540389060974,
-0.09460636228322983,
0.1771688610315323,
0.16620337963104248,
-0.37009161710739136,
-0.27487167716026306,
0.662916898727417,
-0.4179798364639282,
0.45708179473876953,
0.21257156133651733,
0.16870082914829254,
-0.14381206035614014,
0.4942546784877777,
0.3961520791053772,
0.6019830703735352,
-0.17237533628940582,
-0.3829423487186432,
0.21624861657619476,
-0.5610244870185852,
0.2614842653274536,
0.010923800058662891,
-0.11960718035697937,
-0.0719025731086731,
0.09392139315605164,
0.8591602444648743,
-0.397595077753067,
-0.5540143847465515,
0.15505151450634003,
0.00941507238894701,
-0.03848268464207649,
-0.23628675937652588,
0.145394429564476,
0.11177115142345428,
0.305829793214798,
0.5130106210708618,
0.16142521798610687,
0.0951170101761818,
-0.6256313323974609,
0.055964790284633636,
0.5587242841720581,
-0.09733850508928299,
-0.03823001682758331,
0.0613979697227478,
0.25714337825775146,
-0.3955199420452118,
0.8604604601860046,
-0.16184677183628082,
-0.5739384889602661,
0.020540347322821617,
0.6281787753105164,
0.8449832797050476,
-0.1937359720468521,
0.453830748796463,
0.24668261408805847,
-0.27607741951942444,
0.023013724014163017,
0.5785018801689148,
-0.3498586118221283,
-0.9026556015014648,
-0.9757668375968933,
-0.4373187720775604,
-0.5285554528236389,
0.585186243057251,
-0.8382135629653931,
0.10537980496883392,
-0.18042494356632233,
-0.6255068182945251,
-0.32726043462753296,
-0.12192536890506744,
-0.6909912824630737,
0.1288658082485199,
0.26134955883026123,
0.9798027276992798,
-0.6422602534294128,
0.7293792366981506,
0.6068390011787415,
-0.27901190519332886,
-0.6218342781066895,
0.37890124320983887,
-0.19771060347557068,
-0.6643239855766296,
0.32130712270736694,
-0.0012826673919335008,
-0.40970197319984436,
0.008225285448133945,
-0.40880805253982544,
-0.36679279804229736,
1.0024603605270386,
0.27390462160110474,
-0.551693856716156,
-0.02577396109700203,
0.2556493282318115,
0.7130792140960693,
-0.6120743751525879,
0.42602741718292236,
0.6230753660202026,
0.6621779203414917,
0.17190127074718475,
-0.6353468298912048,
0.15568915009498596,
-0.244184672832489,
-0.1734602451324463,
0.08230769634246826,
-0.5730308294296265,
0.45441749691963196,
-0.22939568758010864,
0.013827675953507423,
-0.08401262760162354,
0.6736127734184265,
0.7617462277412415,
0.30418452620506287,
0.5219742059707642,
0.3836985230445862,
0.8966382741928101,
0.053084973245859146,
0.7384189367294312,
-0.38871315121650696,
0.04304320737719536,
1.01499605178833,
-0.4218667447566986,
0.4957403540611267,
0.47508469223976135,
-0.28286629915237427,
0.9020900726318359,
0.4919693171977997,
0.0668056532740593,
0.6743742823600769,
-0.09902168065309525,
-0.7187663912773132,
-0.43369320034980774,
-0.013888374902307987,
-0.42953968048095703,
0.1696227341890335,
0.7905206680297852,
-0.14582818746566772,
0.06380930542945862,
0.23869270086288452,
-0.20911718904972076,
-0.09807004034519196,
-0.17657126486301422,
1.1130547523498535,
-0.09132891148328781,
-1.1848589181900024,
0.7046812176704407,
-0.2726989984512329,
0.6251958012580872,
-0.5811083912849426,
-0.08098866045475006,
-0.2047327756881714,
0.21089661121368408,
-0.21470114588737488,
-1.0962198972702026,
-0.08639804273843765,
0.1577979475259781,
-0.2273738831281662,
-0.26813316345214844,
0.6900839805603027,
-0.5991162061691284,
-0.43172234296798706,
0.05863828584551811,
0.7107626795768738,
-0.02061687596142292,
-0.28919634222984314,
-0.7592880129814148,
-0.23369933664798737,
0.1806313693523407,
-0.12974877655506134,
0.36929214000701904,
0.570580005645752,
0.12732833623886108,
0.8000790476799011,
0.7645877003669739,
0.27511656284332275,
-0.14987750351428986,
0.6774526834487915,
1.1409326791763306,
-0.5143245458602905,
-0.6921272873878479,
-0.8109397292137146,
0.5471400022506714,
-0.3586335778236389,
-0.0567125603556633,
0.5700457096099854,
0.25830963253974915,
0.3059443533420563,
-0.16448865830898285,
1.0041507482528687,
0.01131459791213274,
0.3410708010196686,
-0.5673087239265442,
0.33949995040893555,
0.0068671079352498055,
0.3042713701725006,
-0.5173942446708679,
-0.9617128968238831,
0.37453779578208923,
0.6082436442375183,
-0.5384913682937622,
0.10713008046150208,
0.5091433525085449,
1.007849097251892,
0.1888471096754074,
0.4924319088459015,
0.051508061587810516,
0.031036879867315292,
0.5283174514770508,
0.5797239542007446,
1.1138828992843628,
0.00438510999083519,
0.6741399168968201,
0.00976012833416462,
-0.5236889719963074,
0.056310880929231644,
-0.7231839895248413,
-0.816112756729126,
-0.44743528962135315,
-0.3379998803138733,
-0.6035276651382446,
-0.10238396376371384,
0.8061867356300354,
0.5963178873062134,
-0.6029485464096069,
-0.016208896413445473,
-0.41893574595451355,
-0.11577162891626358,
-0.44185584783554077,
-0.375047892332077,
0.13751325011253357,
-0.5395688414573669,
-0.5842686891555786,
0.7540134191513062,
0.15115399658679962,
-0.10725979506969452,
-0.6380348801612854,
-0.3262982666492462,
-0.19389207661151886,
0.12525509297847748,
0.45690375566482544,
-0.16917593777179718,
-0.5637887716293335,
-0.05586204677820206,
-0.005294498987495899,
0.3797817826271057,
0.17091189324855804,
1.069283366203308,
-1.1685665845870972,
0.7492238879203796,
0.31298330426216125,
0.3127087950706482,
0.6583393812179565,
0.15590746700763702,
1.1273372173309326,
-1.069566011428833,
-0.061970245093107224,
0.31665316224098206,
-0.03164957836270332,
0.5201082229614258,
-0.6292397379875183,
0.2535865008831024,
0.1922253519296646,
-0.37275609374046326,
-0.7455544471740723,
0.572864294052124,
-0.6483407616615295,
0.015811046585440636,
1.015610694885254,
-0.037867043167352676,
0.3064928650856018,
-0.18322259187698364,
-0.50923752784729,
0.40847715735435486,
-0.7494383454322815,
0.9315086007118225,
0.8732799887657166,
-0.818408727645874,
-0.18792720139026642,
-0.20795725286006927,
0.7514331340789795,
0.5330771803855896,
-0.7147256135940552,
0.3458927869796753,
0.4164673686027527,
-0.10647322982549667,
0.4368663430213928,
0.6743490099906921,
-0.103666752576828,
0.2688974440097809,
-0.11945091933012009,
-0.10151218622922897,
0.011978968046605587,
-0.039528850466012955,
-0.12499111890792847,
0.13748520612716675,
-0.22700732946395874,
-0.02949468232691288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16563v2 | Are there identifiable structural parts in the sentence embedding whole? | 2024-06-24T11:58:33 | 2024-07-02T14:14:48 | Vivi Nastase, Paola Merlo | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Sentence embeddings from transformer models encode in a fixed length vector
much linguistic information. We explore the hypothesis that these embeddings
consist of overlapping layers of information that can be separated, and on
which specific types of information -- such as information about chunks and
their structural and semantic properties -- can be detected. We show that this
is the case using a dataset consisting of sentences with known chunk structure,
and two linguistic intelligence datasets, solving which relies on detecting
chunks and their grammatical number, and respectively, their semantic roles,
and through analyses of the performance on the tasks and of the internal
representations built during learning. | [
-0.18728391826152802,
-1.0703061819076538,
0.8349317908287048,
0.1664009690284729,
-0.2063911110162735,
0.20274671912193298,
-0.09238783270120621,
-0.34954559803009033,
0.48208779096603394,
0.3516671061515808,
-0.41334372758865356,
-0.0893934965133667,
-0.7147191762924194,
-0.06992796808481216,
-0.7928736805915833,
0.662933886051178,
0.03375707566738129,
-0.06928055733442307,
-0.5207992196083069,
-0.031648363918066025,
-0.5488596558570862,
-0.4286232888698578,
0.053584951907396317,
-0.15052270889282227,
0.29151538014411926,
0.29372891783714294,
0.8617731332778931,
1.1593518257141113,
0.3122072219848633,
0.3404335677623749,
-0.07419691234827042,
0.03985099866986275,
-0.06459444761276245,
0.32279279828071594,
-0.28164979815483093,
-0.8913521766662598,
0.14026515185832977,
-0.21575339138507843,
0.8709859848022461,
0.7854119539260864,
0.1338157057762146,
0.11798364669084549,
-0.03195289894938469,
0.4483541250228882,
-0.46035709977149963,
0.3669685423374176,
-0.3784668743610382,
0.20832371711730957,
-0.45722392201423645,
0.09671483933925629,
-0.40760600566864014,
0.002968842862173915,
0.02912116050720215,
-0.19129641354084015,
0.14513541758060455,
0.021073464304208755,
0.9887151718139648,
0.33668550848960876,
-0.5302461981773376,
-0.47864291071891785,
-0.6588495969772339,
0.6322454214096069,
-0.2671703100204468,
0.39773255586624146,
0.42287784814834595,
-0.11325822025537491,
-0.20791716873645782,
-0.4123501181602478,
-0.44531604647636414,
-0.00035048878635279834,
-0.6134340167045593,
-0.06943900883197784,
-0.26297369599342346,
0.0007775179110467434,
0.08072802424430847,
0.4262843132019043,
-0.39304813742637634,
0.08103868365287781,
-0.46406206488609314,
-0.27722445130348206,
0.48352354764938354,
0.06656071543693542,
0.7979196906089783,
-0.5507949590682983,
-0.17886602878570557,
-0.11267967522144318,
-0.5859542489051819,
0.13345421850681305,
0.4132270812988281,
0.11671475321054459,
-0.11874143779277802,
1.048322081565857,
0.050637129694223404,
0.6539232730865479,
-0.018560724332928658,
0.21875151991844177,
0.3380277156829834,
-0.17773430049419403,
-0.150111585855484,
0.31747639179229736,
0.589625895023346,
-0.29396718740463257,
0.40227049589157104,
-0.44394996762275696,
-0.1592881977558136,
0.2596307396888733,
0.4803932011127472,
-0.3526453971862793,
-0.15938012301921844,
0.38558050990104675,
-0.34096774458885193,
-0.08695265650749207,
0.5171716809272766,
-0.35781121253967285,
-0.07346305251121521,
-0.2054859697818756,
0.2925013601779938,
-0.6483546495437622,
-0.31148263812065125,
0.03778460994362831,
-0.504423975944519,
0.43186113238334656,
-0.3390718102455139,
-0.8298370242118835,
0.3644315004348755,
0.9602918028831482,
0.7527317404747009,
0.20621542632579803,
-0.4247766137123108,
-0.5048404335975647,
0.03680160641670227,
-0.23559251427650452,
0.8810244202613831,
-1.0050264596939087,
-0.017527034506201744,
0.14221757650375366,
0.2403230518102646,
-0.1829865276813507,
-0.4223240911960602,
0.24955718219280243,
-0.4290747344493866,
0.18048885464668274,
-0.18681032955646515,
-1.0455201864242554,
-0.236480712890625,
0.05916251242160797,
-0.9236956834793091,
1.0128127336502075,
0.19271302223205566,
-0.8647648692131042,
0.22977590560913086,
-0.3556292653083801,
-0.5330755114555359,
0.1392538845539093,
-0.5581700801849365,
-0.3668874502182007,
0.6622375845909119,
-0.00011238802835578099,
0.6141291260719299,
0.02824833244085312,
0.2783452272415161,
0.11343761533498764,
-0.28485578298568726,
0.7085413932800293,
-0.09827874600887299,
0.29948511719703674,
-0.017551172524690628,
-0.3376331329345703,
0.17324738204479218,
-0.7587053775787354,
-0.11630352586507797,
0.21598894894123077,
-0.40613853931427,
-0.5666464567184448,
0.3223593533039093,
-0.06070231646299362,
-0.006755069829523563,
0.11746098101139069,
-0.8943223357200623,
0.09970058500766754,
-0.20950043201446533,
0.7405105233192444,
0.5100752711296082,
0.041663557291030884,
0.450242817401886,
-0.3353150486946106,
0.28595447540283203,
0.6161991357803345,
-0.22116880118846893,
-0.34579068422317505,
-0.5629009008407593,
-0.9898508191108704,
-0.3526022434234619,
0.4816755950450897,
0.49563509225845337,
-0.6050914525985718,
0.751203715801239,
-0.4304838478565216,
-0.0919274166226387,
-0.744461715221405,
-0.17715196311473846,
0.36722803115844727,
-0.0693010464310646,
0.33976590633392334,
-0.03803006932139397,
-0.6357033848762512,
-1.1126761436462402,
-0.4148055911064148,
0.045165833085775375,
-0.19114629924297333,
-0.20440055429935455,
0.7768266797065735,
0.1362392157316208,
1.1614375114440918,
-0.5886080265045166,
0.07640241831541061,
-0.2805957794189453,
-0.10841790586709976,
-0.12467823177576065,
0.4197290539741516,
0.3255969285964966,
-0.9238665699958801,
-0.13891318440437317,
-0.28987202048301697,
-0.7896472215652466,
0.236174076795578,
-0.2681875228881836,
-0.13524022698402405,
-0.5433254241943359,
0.5772291421890259,
-0.5446081757545471,
0.3343603312969208,
0.2585029602050781,
-0.7634203433990479,
-0.01683952659368515,
-0.2522365152835846,
-0.20638303458690643,
-0.9224631190299988,
-0.5672738552093506,
0.0036123991012573242,
-0.392755389213562,
-0.758082926273346,
0.03307697921991348,
0.2883613705635071,
0.2649398446083069,
-0.20759089291095734,
0.08236146718263626,
-0.6517482399940491,
-0.13293404877185822,
-0.12356390804052353,
0.2884780168533325,
-0.05578120797872543,
0.42939749360084534,
-0.00898274127393961,
0.27391085028648376,
0.4570814073085785,
-0.20779642462730408,
0.17324213683605194,
0.30095741152763367,
-0.78439861536026,
0.5385280847549438,
-0.6624014377593994,
-0.048097893595695496,
-0.6472029089927673,
-0.06102748215198517,
-0.8668893575668335,
-0.5342975854873657,
-0.0052463095635175705,
-0.14109864830970764,
0.17492882907390594,
-0.17246553301811218,
-0.5353856682777405,
-0.1889345943927765,
-0.06274683028459549,
0.4003903865814209,
0.47217294573783875,
-0.29338714480400085,
0.6107959747314453,
0.5960318446159363,
-0.0004890405689366162,
-0.38095319271087646,
-0.9205150008201599,
-0.22547940909862518,
-0.13049951195716858,
-0.5996889472007751,
0.5001515746116638,
0.37706393003463745,
-0.3208072781562805,
0.6376478672027588,
-0.010160897858440876,
-0.31888478994369507,
-0.005624351091682911,
0.5921154022216797,
0.10124678909778595,
-0.40916773676872253,
0.5043929815292358,
0.0654577985405922,
0.2542761564254761,
0.03272316977381706,
-0.2555048167705536,
0.5740487575531006,
-0.0913708284497261,
-0.3662346303462982,
-0.11701346188783646,
0.4914296269416809,
0.546839714050293,
-0.3617449700832367,
0.9250853061676025,
0.29132187366485596,
-0.5232564210891724,
-0.29875147342681885,
-0.43130895495414734,
0.0870964378118515,
-0.3778480291366577,
0.5235597491264343,
-0.5481090545654297,
-1.054551124572754,
0.47614023089408875,
0.28516530990600586,
-0.25693508982658386,
0.6587314605712891,
0.32424983382225037,
-0.11582430452108383,
0.5473242402076721,
0.5794680118560791,
-0.10948703438043594,
0.5735799074172974,
-0.13466469943523407,
0.16812238097190857,
-0.8283149003982544,
-0.5602458119392395,
-0.3689071536064148,
-0.563930094242096,
-0.3940422236919403,
-0.5423324108123779,
0.011604955419898033,
0.12412021309137344,
-0.37684980034828186,
0.4407828748226166,
-0.5301644802093506,
0.7464775443077087,
0.5143061876296997,
0.277822881937027,
-0.02860036864876747,
-0.22564098238945007,
-0.20162184536457062,
0.12933622300624847,
-0.5696194171905518,
-0.30524301528930664,
0.6921589374542236,
0.4558555483818054,
0.4778948724269867,
0.03481496125459671,
0.2949802279472351,
0.35524576902389526,
-0.3597576320171356,
-0.8509936332702637,
0.27566221356391907,
-0.224564328789711,
-0.47079959511756897,
-0.0719720721244812,
-0.4239586293697357,
-0.9806983470916748,
0.30465224385261536,
-0.24608656764030457,
-0.5931610465049744,
0.2668592631816864,
-0.5133420825004578,
-0.16632047295570374,
0.3439275622367859,
-0.7247817516326904,
0.6851100921630859,
-0.24645617604255676,
0.2945403456687927,
-0.08382518589496613,
-0.6052531003952026,
0.014716670848429203,
0.18347381055355072,
0.272084504365921,
-0.2510230243206024,
0.0611080527305603,
0.9924027919769287,
-0.3365837037563324,
0.8471567034721375,
-0.04494344815611839,
0.4214150905609131,
0.46645042300224304,
-0.1040240079164505,
0.27699407935142517,
-0.32446256279945374,
0.29175078868865967,
-0.05896715819835663,
0.08976558595895767,
-0.5511260628700256,
-0.7376359701156616,
0.4060080945491791,
-0.753551185131073,
-0.33241918683052063,
-0.2938249409198761,
-0.6319209337234497,
0.06933493912220001,
0.040453024208545685,
0.11769746989011765,
0.7210569381713867,
-0.13230443000793457,
0.6848105192184448,
0.5265228748321533,
0.0028908539097756147,
0.607308030128479,
0.22231115400791168,
0.0646597295999527,
-0.019660618156194687,
0.6035919189453125,
0.2819994390010834,
0.063997782766819,
0.7394808530807495,
0.15651388466358185,
0.037938185036182404,
-0.2790380120277405,
-0.3156472444534302,
0.431066632270813,
-0.6337953805923462,
-0.06226201355457306,
-0.6279551982879639,
-0.5232793688774109,
0.025085588917136192,
0.057709235697984695,
-0.42093849182128906,
-0.5331850051879883,
-0.12205556035041809,
-0.5972554683685303,
0.36231786012649536,
1.3932758569717407,
0.35945507884025574,
0.41825300455093384,
-0.8788167834281921,
0.016120437532663345,
0.06996113061904907,
0.3018944561481476,
0.12446067482233047,
-0.240221306681633,
-0.473175048828125,
0.07684904336929321,
0.13440480828285217,
-0.8799217939376831,
0.06051244959235191,
0.18891865015029907,
0.5860368609428406,
0.3466867506504059,
-0.19338862597942352,
0.43640556931495667,
-0.6203796863555908,
0.9557930827140808,
-0.26105576753616333,
-0.969363808631897,
0.4673789441585541,
0.14822585880756378,
0.42270904779434204,
0.1786237210035324,
0.6687490344047546,
-0.47342944145202637,
-0.5785644054412842,
-0.5566772818565369,
-0.6053146719932556,
0.41200557351112366,
0.25851279497146606,
0.20593850314617157,
-0.4142061769962311,
0.42358386516571045,
-0.09634583443403244,
-0.0002820430672727525,
-0.5828847885131836,
-0.02579295076429844,
-0.21112802624702454,
-0.5426799058914185,
0.2949233949184418,
-0.6297701001167297,
-0.13732725381851196,
0.05072863772511482,
0.07551152259111404,
0.1811571717262268,
0.40417078137397766,
0.2264205515384674,
-0.5538649559020996,
0.3809622526168823,
0.4059711694717407,
0.36065325140953064,
0.3400590121746063,
0.1324446052312851,
0.4439075291156769,
-0.24624137580394745,
-0.5744352340698242,
0.12154052406549454,
-0.27183398604393005,
-0.013997466303408146,
-0.008205393329262733,
0.8722909092903137,
0.8096261620521545,
0.5129047632217407,
-0.6157751679420471,
0.6321430802345276,
0.07771984487771988,
0.03973131254315376,
-0.360476016998291,
0.07371769100427628,
0.08204086869955063,
0.5380045175552368,
0.23151779174804688,
-0.1787760853767395,
-0.18951675295829773,
-0.8489445447921753,
0.4593352675437927,
0.15618504583835602,
-0.7827752828598022,
-0.666409969329834,
0.3182108402252197,
-0.1907956898212433,
-0.2697460353374481,
1.0001996755599976,
0.0038968531880527735,
-0.7908720970153809,
0.5982064604759216,
0.4856967031955719,
0.684482216835022,
-0.099449522793293,
0.3840430676937103,
-0.13827161490917206,
0.34249281883239746,
-0.14734020829200745,
0.3368033766746521,
0.025724103674292564,
-1.0617597103118896,
-0.4143296182155609,
-0.6298196911811829,
0.053949978202581406,
-0.34941455721855164,
-0.8089632391929626,
-0.03900108113884926,
-0.14157383143901825,
0.15912452340126038,
0.32073429226875305,
-0.5265873670578003,
-0.6678435802459717,
0.14220871031284332,
0.24621613323688507,
0.7019689679145813,
-1.0927801132202148,
0.8468695282936096,
0.5766321420669556,
-0.5865024328231812,
-0.6606770157814026,
-0.08795054256916046,
-0.11671096086502075,
-0.6375691890716553,
0.706981360912323,
0.16498105227947235,
0.21743643283843994,
-0.4593084156513214,
-0.2731815576553345,
-0.8572534918785095,
0.8066622614860535,
0.14916282892227173,
-0.23955386877059937,
-0.558643102645874,
0.5137048363685608,
0.39034304022789,
-0.6038830876350403,
0.26446086168289185,
0.6257110238075256,
0.3390253782272339,
-0.042497847229242325,
-0.5315091609954834,
0.1785026490688324,
-0.2269797921180725,
-0.07823419570922852,
0.46402212977409363,
-0.4477798342704773,
1.063398838043213,
0.3276456892490387,
-0.37321317195892334,
-0.21375542879104614,
0.737526535987854,
-0.3998149335384369,
-0.344418466091156,
0.5311199426651001,
0.6469681859016418,
0.928854763507843,
-0.41849929094314575,
1.1106772422790527,
-0.2566479444503784,
0.13534271717071533,
1.024425983428955,
0.363219290971756,
0.9681900143623352,
0.17218883335590363,
-0.07650473713874817,
0.971463680267334,
0.4730924367904663,
-0.18891191482543945,
0.6206556558609009,
0.30573365092277527,
-0.01173307839781046,
-0.04440203309059143,
-0.03258460760116577,
-0.0546419695019722,
0.7596461772918701,
0.6595848202705383,
-0.483598530292511,
0.01976129785180092,
0.297414630651474,
0.23879776895046234,
0.004621732514351606,
-0.19415909051895142,
0.7054018974304199,
-0.0424114465713501,
-0.5738446712493896,
0.08294612914323807,
0.02743503451347351,
0.4875853657722473,
-0.5666097402572632,
0.031443528831005096,
-0.0321442149579525,
0.20033076405525208,
-0.4382409453392029,
-1.065210223197937,
0.7407605051994324,
-0.16737927496433258,
-0.42215511202812195,
-0.27639511227607727,
0.5569325685501099,
-0.6163573265075684,
-0.4362504780292511,
0.15088477730751038,
0.45016250014305115,
0.13357234001159668,
-0.3182690441608429,
0.02987937070429325,
0.033563416451215744,
-0.002821925561875105,
-0.18164628744125366,
0.3167146146297455,
0.7050995230674744,
-0.018705986440181732,
0.3101638853549957,
0.23701952397823334,
0.009632334113121033,
0.4776524603366852,
-0.07601574808359146,
0.8822177052497864,
-0.9504311084747314,
-0.5118081569671631,
-1.05523681640625,
0.5965273380279541,
-0.2786603271961212,
-0.23939424753189087,
0.7512171864509583,
0.6993016004562378,
0.875194787979126,
0.029854068532586098,
0.6043701767921448,
-0.11461084336042404,
0.25681596994400024,
-0.6498269438743591,
0.3825521171092987,
-0.11997956782579422,
0.021361563354730606,
0.1069415956735611,
-0.8027023673057556,
-0.21112102270126343,
0.5579543709754944,
-0.28981003165245056,
-0.43164998292922974,
0.9104642271995544,
0.3742061257362366,
-0.21210139989852905,
0.3705650866031647,
0.22426237165927887,
0.3998135030269623,
0.25310325622558594,
0.3377383053302765,
0.95667964220047,
-0.33561933040618896,
0.24766723811626434,
-0.21683654189109802,
-0.07536307722330093,
0.02480536699295044,
-0.402677983045578,
-0.8409752249717712,
-0.9845045804977417,
-0.16237567365169525,
-0.11289744079113007,
-0.2162102609872818,
0.5966752171516418,
0.5491927266120911,
-0.68597412109375,
-0.13346920907497406,
-0.03305111452937126,
0.22057248651981354,
-0.1948632448911667,
-0.23825682699680328,
0.4827631711959839,
-0.25824809074401855,
-0.4157228469848633,
0.6582310199737549,
0.40647855401039124,
-0.032175444066524506,
-0.22812898457050323,
0.5990467071533203,
-0.3646349310874939,
0.451475590467453,
0.5428691506385803,
-0.07829615473747253,
-0.6873679757118225,
-0.8085793256759644,
0.006560007110238075,
-0.0033502799924463034,
0.23530884087085724,
1.0444194078445435,
-0.6078625917434692,
0.3603379726409912,
0.6779979467391968,
0.7548021078109741,
0.5474810600280762,
0.11327837407588959,
0.5333788990974426,
-1.1193970441818237,
0.4359627366065979,
0.10596524924039841,
0.6455984711647034,
0.23050662875175476,
-0.4301053285598755,
0.42869454622268677,
-0.04933127015829086,
-0.40448489785194397,
-0.4916785657405853,
0.3209248483181,
-0.7430168986320496,
-0.45605218410491943,
0.8257941007614136,
-0.3438108563423157,
-0.5425359606742859,
-0.24269349873065948,
0.16625380516052246,
0.10705894976854324,
0.08284755796194077,
0.33706244826316833,
1.0743032693862915,
-0.23104646801948547,
-0.10431322455406189,
-0.34407147765159607,
0.12616626918315887,
0.12031622976064682,
-0.5909985303878784,
-0.2846411466598511,
0.36515793204307556,
0.30683088302612305,
0.5240612030029297,
0.04875971004366875,
-0.19703340530395508,
-0.32056865096092224,
0.3100641965866089,
-0.29273977875709534,
-0.05099794641137123,
-0.5465906262397766,
-0.05695902928709984,
0.5660282969474792,
-0.34331852197647095,
-0.5235309600830078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16562v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16562v2 | EVALALIGN: Supervised Fine-Tuning Multimodal LLMs with Human-Aligned Data for Evaluating Text-to-Image Models | 2024-06-24T11:56:15 | 2024-06-27T03:57:05 | Zhiyu Tan, Xiaomeng Yang, Luozheng Qin, Mengping Yang, Cheng Zhang, Hao Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The recent advancements in text-to-image generative models have been
remarkable. Yet, the field suffers from a lack of evaluation metrics that
accurately reflect the performance of these models, particularly lacking
fine-grained metrics that can guide the optimization of the models. In this
paper, we propose EvalAlign, a metric characterized by its accuracy, stability,
and fine granularity. Our approach leverages the capabilities of Multimodal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) pre-trained on extensive datasets. We develop
evaluation protocols that focus on two key dimensions: image faithfulness and
text-image alignment. Each protocol comprises a set of detailed, fine-grained
instructions linked to specific scoring options, enabling precise manual
scoring of the generated images. We Supervised Fine-Tune (SFT) the MLLM to
align closely with human evaluative judgments, resulting in a robust evaluation
model. Our comprehensive tests across 24 text-to-image generation models
demonstrate that EvalAlign not only provides superior metric stability but also
aligns more closely with human preferences than existing metrics, confirming
its effectiveness and utility in model assessment. | [
-0.5051143765449524,
-0.7978249788284302,
0.4677237868309021,
0.19994373619556427,
-0.2753750681877136,
0.164822518825531,
-0.3828240633010864,
-0.28772297501564026,
-0.004403469152748585,
0.4094405472278595,
-0.45138034224510193,
-0.7419441342353821,
-0.4967342019081116,
0.14590132236480713,
-0.4313370883464813,
0.8997957110404968,
-0.3550594747066498,
0.14996756613254547,
-0.6243401765823364,
-0.2809804081916809,
-0.35072144865989685,
-0.2079160362482071,
-0.5753327012062073,
-0.07775360345840454,
0.5595942735671997,
0.29437607526779175,
0.8805689811706543,
0.473660945892334,
0.7119014263153076,
0.3368699848651886,
0.31788766384124756,
0.8368583917617798,
-0.5217674374580383,
0.30635181069374084,
-0.13288673758506775,
-0.08124678581953049,
-0.48761436343193054,
-0.06703174114227295,
0.5132116079330444,
0.41895800828933716,
0.08198432624340057,
0.6570013165473938,
0.1028074324131012,
0.787929117679596,
-0.8014974594116211,
-0.08856451511383057,
-0.7436350584030151,
-0.13057422637939453,
0.015459924004971981,
-0.645388126373291,
-0.595308780670166,
-0.37107032537460327,
-0.3224097490310669,
-0.5114849209785461,
0.06900453567504883,
0.4577103853225708,
1.0895968675613403,
0.38604483008384705,
-0.4064435362815857,
-0.14797836542129517,
-0.6767134666442871,
0.8510323166847229,
-0.302567720413208,
0.48200350999832153,
0.3816281259059906,
0.25586622953414917,
0.03506489470601082,
-0.6091226935386658,
-0.36644989252090454,
-0.37706783413887024,
-0.11529594659805298,
0.20629942417144775,
-0.13900363445281982,
0.08953259885311127,
-0.14697125554084778,
0.1680482178926468,
-0.5964184999465942,
0.39405718445777893,
-0.35338088870048523,
-0.2077743262052536,
0.656485915184021,
0.4692964553833008,
0.32553333044052124,
0.01840117946267128,
-0.7884687185287476,
-0.007019792217761278,
-0.7628452777862549,
0.0955793559551239,
0.40322360396385193,
0.16726654767990112,
-0.1233339011669159,
0.7333170175552368,
0.045395463705062866,
0.5897098779678345,
0.2725283205509186,
-0.03357276692986488,
-0.023993760347366333,
-0.4491276741027832,
-0.24630871415138245,
-0.08617984503507614,
0.9825313687324524,
0.9680676460266113,
-0.01575496792793274,
-0.12829066812992096,
-0.5679941773414612,
0.18789154291152954,
0.4920016825199127,
-1.0019315481185913,
-0.09255310148000717,
0.3215148150920868,
-0.6522833108901978,
-0.42914196848869324,
0.042031772434711456,
-0.7468695640563965,
-0.2095966935157776,
-0.81354820728302,
0.5743854641914368,
-0.37226980924606323,
0.16691631078720093,
-0.07998991757631302,
0.2379380762577057,
0.022131849080324173,
0.5718172192573547,
-0.9778055548667908,
0.1842212677001953,
0.6362975835800171,
0.9671985507011414,
-0.2917667627334595,
-0.4264316260814667,
-0.6305602192878723,
-0.05173227936029434,
-0.7332081198692322,
0.9431498646736145,
-0.5182506442070007,
-0.09797206521034241,
0.06927818059921265,
-0.008009890094399452,
0.04258230701088905,
-0.3943002223968506,
0.6607443690299988,
-0.45944541692733765,
-0.006345825735479593,
0.2800145745277405,
-0.36541515588760376,
0.1159672662615776,
0.4034504294395447,
-0.5822792053222656,
1.1258211135864258,
0.20344464480876923,
-0.4226357638835907,
0.45505908131599426,
-0.509995698928833,
-0.18590505421161652,
-0.09493502229452133,
-0.13289979100227356,
-0.740683913230896,
0.4306536912918091,
0.5632444024085999,
0.7913575768470764,
-0.31544122099876404,
0.2803986072540283,
-0.25435903668403625,
-0.3839443027973175,
0.5092544555664062,
-0.8044553399085999,
0.3495327830314636,
0.22562532126903534,
0.05145640671253204,
0.4461519420146942,
-0.6703762412071228,
0.3331504762172699,
-0.15039248764514923,
-0.20885862410068512,
-0.3049622178077698,
-0.13846005499362946,
0.48508238792419434,
0.11107468605041504,
0.3114002048969269,
-0.32907211780548096,
0.15605829656124115,
-0.09773809462785721,
0.24783119559288025,
0.8357354998588562,
-0.13230712711811066,
0.6206232309341431,
-0.3729110658168793,
0.6033819913864136,
-0.31924664974212646,
0.3395463526248932,
-0.44221535325050354,
-0.1551540046930313,
-0.8893678784370422,
-0.521384596824646,
0.4588433504104614,
0.13279038667678833,
-0.5582926869392395,
0.5258881449699402,
-0.671413242816925,
-0.5954304933547974,
-0.9444786906242371,
0.3186415433883667,
0.447297602891922,
0.1574680060148239,
0.3851613998413086,
-0.5176981687545776,
-0.22639481723308563,
-1.148630976676941,
0.1539655476808548,
0.048774946480989456,
0.02381780371069908,
0.40533459186553955,
0.4244970977306366,
-0.46384793519973755,
0.7573897242546082,
-0.1649477332830429,
-0.4451519846916199,
0.21018275618553162,
0.6042090058326721,
-0.3308260142803192,
0.42180749773979187,
0.6436905860900879,
-0.5726316571235657,
-0.5125342607498169,
0.3220679461956024,
-0.5563634634017944,
-0.2177465707063675,
-0.49899056553840637,
-0.3739267587661743,
0.3345050513744354,
0.3598262369632721,
-0.565330445766449,
0.3783022165298462,
0.9656539559364319,
-0.24344009160995483,
0.7050301432609558,
-0.34550175070762634,
0.6263552904129028,
-0.9182648062705994,
0.029833663254976273,
0.14914049208164215,
-0.4660516679286957,
-0.48580652475357056,
0.18324363231658936,
0.44560396671295166,
-0.07014359533786774,
-0.48605552315711975,
0.6633527874946594,
-0.5342816114425659,
0.17577099800109863,
-0.1869501769542694,
0.079354427754879,
0.4333265423774719,
0.29391852021217346,
0.00815508607774973,
0.8827345371246338,
0.5215264558792114,
-0.38247424364089966,
0.4433267116546631,
0.15642885863780975,
-0.5963704586029053,
1.0732321739196777,
-0.4992910325527191,
0.24579915404319763,
-0.12877142429351807,
0.02295776829123497,
-0.9816645979881287,
-0.18301203846931458,
-0.12765558063983917,
-0.42712780833244324,
0.48231446743011475,
0.08737355470657349,
-0.5669397115707397,
-0.0749146044254303,
-0.5128564238548279,
0.6252427697181702,
0.21052637696266174,
-0.7326608300209045,
0.6777362823486328,
0.16901476681232452,
-0.08542248606681824,
-0.4711001515388489,
-0.3532830476760864,
0.1816524863243103,
-0.1631786823272705,
-0.6545849442481995,
0.39653828740119934,
-0.01696213148534298,
-0.18359443545341492,
-0.16536016762256622,
0.127693772315979,
0.027804823592305183,
-0.16931869089603424,
0.7069383859634399,
0.4863209128379822,
-0.2046481817960739,
0.22085095942020416,
0.18584993481636047,
-0.23842287063598633,
-0.20719686150550842,
0.07332839071750641,
0.5303205847740173,
-0.23827677965164185,
-0.691036581993103,
-0.6810283660888672,
0.24365362524986267,
0.7999424934387207,
-0.3417127728462219,
0.610510528087616,
0.8209783434867859,
-0.13489596545696259,
0.04220464453101158,
-0.6649739146232605,
-0.16743293404579163,
-0.4787798821926117,
0.5406303405761719,
-0.3135792016983032,
-0.6174494624137878,
0.16968947649002075,
-0.3279416859149933,
0.1100054681301117,
0.3341282308101654,
0.8827803134918213,
-0.4778517484664917,
1.1366149187088013,
0.4971768856048584,
0.12029348313808441,
0.23289045691490173,
-0.10517372190952301,
0.03095862828195095,
-0.8923999071121216,
-0.2920069396495819,
-0.2640303373336792,
-0.5057495832443237,
-0.23195941746234894,
-0.5398067831993103,
0.27188462018966675,
0.10302173346281052,
-0.23886337876319885,
0.2292662411928177,
-0.5264719128608704,
0.5454015135765076,
0.25157395005226135,
0.25602608919143677,
0.29511526226997375,
0.2220064401626587,
0.12888595461845398,
-0.27517592906951904,
-0.2356591373682022,
-1.0174050331115723,
1.1604244709014893,
0.45805516839027405,
1.1520826816558838,
-0.019593408331274986,
0.4913158714771271,
0.26929253339767456,
0.6118491888046265,
-0.7034807205200195,
0.34743449091911316,
-0.10184696316719055,
-0.45236465334892273,
-0.22059203684329987,
-0.20946861803531647,
-0.9576680660247803,
0.11965683102607727,
-0.5589544773101807,
-0.6765049695968628,
-0.014189697802066803,
0.26323288679122925,
-0.46089380979537964,
0.03639603778719902,
-0.8727758526802063,
0.8822197914123535,
-0.9178693294525146,
-0.6961511373519897,
-0.16087718307971954,
-0.4120825529098511,
0.24658352136611938,
-0.2987043261528015,
0.15838730335235596,
-0.3818836510181427,
-0.29489412903785706,
0.3225175142288208,
-0.18554683029651642,
0.7829339504241943,
0.217617928981781,
-0.19965337216854095,
-0.022687528282403946,
0.3118070065975189,
0.45686325430870056,
0.03457942232489586,
0.024078693240880966,
0.2561548948287964,
0.1087690219283104,
-0.13233120739459991,
-0.8045492172241211,
0.7997064590454102,
-0.7465270757675171,
-0.17614568769931793,
0.10391715168952942,
-0.4450806975364685,
-0.03848050907254219,
-0.16591523587703705,
0.19259107112884521,
0.5384848117828369,
-0.4351898729801178,
0.3166542053222656,
0.22438105940818787,
-0.0727403536438942,
0.19630329310894012,
0.21868294477462769,
-0.5082335472106934,
-0.6139822006225586,
1.0779476165771484,
-0.35562992095947266,
0.45770251750946045,
0.5276107788085938,
-0.17878961563110352,
-0.44289761781692505,
-0.40119776129722595,
-0.7313268184661865,
-0.05984535440802574,
-0.7099128365516663,
-0.6395682692527771,
-0.3055131435394287,
-0.10214745998382568,
-0.0719393789768219,
-0.5402162075042725,
-0.7300092577934265,
-0.22115743160247803,
-0.5926443338394165,
0.10373948514461517,
0.24004848301410675,
0.3981485962867737,
0.3065286874771118,
0.24370570480823517,
-0.8014171123504639,
0.3572300672531128,
0.18797510862350464,
0.3373814523220062,
-0.21712647378444672,
-0.7168467044830322,
-0.217171311378479,
-0.036186933517456055,
-0.6300363540649414,
-0.43773430585861206,
0.4663657546043396,
0.45941075682640076,
0.3055001497268677,
0.7491349577903748,
-0.05664486438035965,
0.9875163435935974,
-0.6008149981498718,
0.7432241439819336,
0.5885319709777832,
-0.8550102710723877,
0.5173634886741638,
-0.08144889026880264,
0.058868784457445145,
0.7648505568504333,
0.27923285961151123,
-0.3482591509819031,
-0.39845943450927734,
-0.3925633430480957,
-0.9694304466247559,
0.21057291328907013,
0.22596320509910583,
0.623934805393219,
0.3504734933376312,
0.14376939833164215,
0.4044519066810608,
0.007264114450663328,
-0.7347375750541687,
-0.11138103902339935,
-0.11691303551197052,
-0.5206146240234375,
0.07645202428102493,
-0.22821348905563354,
-0.35020339488983154,
-0.3836822807788849,
0.5180659890174866,
-0.296320378780365,
0.09586421400308609,
-0.2396978735923767,
-0.29319649934768677,
-0.24614226818084717,
0.21859613060951233,
0.8786380290985107,
0.7034812569618225,
-0.07693048566579819,
0.3119114935398102,
0.018651092424988747,
-0.30969923734664917,
0.3962583839893341,
-0.08780913054943085,
-0.08614929765462875,
-0.0753290057182312,
0.38263553380966187,
0.9940628409385681,
0.2612046003341675,
-0.7901695370674133,
0.6800153255462646,
-0.13722017407417297,
-0.3214395046234131,
-0.1508387327194214,
-0.003318163799121976,
-0.2855149209499359,
0.2540385127067566,
0.21505297720432281,
0.527850329875946,
-0.20799830555915833,
-0.1914801001548767,
0.09973675012588501,
0.7464446425437927,
-0.538890540599823,
-0.29454323649406433,
0.7014541625976562,
0.39378997683525085,
-0.36104536056518555,
0.4882906377315521,
-0.07918119430541992,
-0.2505919635295868,
0.4779488146305084,
0.4017908275127411,
0.8255610466003418,
0.059146698564291,
0.3362051248550415,
0.3699858784675598,
0.45616698265075684,
-0.016964498907327652,
-0.09488815814256668,
-0.0006737391231581569,
-0.6963364481925964,
-0.25288471579551697,
-0.7789087891578674,
-0.2751765549182892,
0.12665875256061554,
-0.5555243492126465,
0.5254664421081543,
-0.36660757660865784,
-0.5040203928947449,
-0.06670298427343369,
-0.3088158369064331,
-0.7677079439163208,
0.09518630057573318,
0.22906836867332458,
0.5097652673721313,
-0.9057096242904663,
0.5085987448692322,
0.678417444229126,
-0.30999746918678284,
-0.5310799479484558,
-0.21104654669761658,
-0.10600107908248901,
-0.8187254071235657,
0.7141833305358887,
0.45235341787338257,
-0.19253483414649963,
-0.024721698835492134,
-0.612160861492157,
-0.714535653591156,
1.2221242189407349,
0.5231460332870483,
-0.7300702929496765,
0.4357883930206299,
0.05198505520820618,
0.5825236439704895,
-0.5591936111450195,
0.515723466873169,
0.43603095412254333,
0.6080097556114197,
-0.08364109694957733,
-0.920613706111908,
-0.17838656902313232,
-0.2760228216648102,
0.22216196358203888,
0.1574152410030365,
-0.5348447561264038,
0.3965277373790741,
-0.32538872957229614,
-0.36343514919281006,
0.49849584698677063,
0.5974433422088623,
0.2231733798980713,
0.3663088083267212,
0.20435400307178497,
0.5774337649345398,
0.5364745855331421,
-0.2236219346523285,
0.8691938519477844,
-0.4984138607978821,
0.5800482630729675,
0.9624649882316589,
-0.10882624983787537,
1.0393987894058228,
0.7268592119216919,
-0.16507172584533691,
0.15954133868217468,
0.8230300545692444,
-0.27932778000831604,
0.5541284680366516,
-0.12781625986099243,
-0.216816708445549,
-0.4704201817512512,
-0.2905455529689789,
0.03570166230201721,
0.5728906393051147,
0.3537593483924866,
-0.7104417085647583,
-0.1269906908273697,
0.04660971835255623,
-0.3987489342689514,
0.3055865168571472,
-0.4044126272201538,
0.6213228702545166,
-0.15115095674991608,
-0.4684610366821289,
0.7719494104385376,
0.052420493215322495,
0.7263748049736023,
-0.2861625850200653,
0.08067401498556137,
-0.14886415004730225,
0.08397497981786728,
-0.37496674060821533,
-0.7868094444274902,
-0.012827690690755844,
-0.04295290634036064,
-0.11017733812332153,
-0.3397153317928314,
0.6082954406738281,
-0.6012713313102722,
-0.807670533657074,
-0.11240939050912857,
0.2523379623889923,
0.01740119233727455,
0.017352741211652756,
-0.6772816777229309,
0.3616722524166107,
-0.2689051926136017,
-0.13628777861595154,
0.253568172454834,
0.40708234906196594,
-0.07737023383378983,
0.6261280179023743,
0.5908504128456116,
0.10150540620088577,
-0.11784704774618149,
0.30276021361351013,
0.6082407832145691,
-0.17893147468566895,
0.19731584191322327,
-1.1506143808364868,
0.639049232006073,
-0.04163460433483124,
-0.4322788715362549,
0.5329192876815796,
0.8474442958831787,
0.5244147777557373,
-0.2173873633146286,
0.5219987034797668,
0.3522828221321106,
-0.10412334650754929,
-0.8353497385978699,
0.8695470094680786,
-0.746492326259613,
0.023395538330078125,
-0.25390732288360596,
-1.0547395944595337,
-0.48208746314048767,
0.54788738489151,
-0.06242819130420685,
-0.08978879451751709,
0.5833088159561157,
1.265809416770935,
-0.20559485256671906,
-0.41408830881118774,
0.5687534213066101,
-0.27482864260673523,
0.20063772797584534,
0.2953358590602875,
1.073281168937683,
-0.4364159405231476,
0.37277165055274963,
-0.20061124861240387,
-0.24850593507289886,
-0.30085813999176025,
-1.0039108991622925,
-0.9770810008049011,
-0.7619006037712097,
-0.3740555942058563,
0.03927084058523178,
-0.12680043280124664,
1.0793932676315308,
0.8599172830581665,
-0.6034185290336609,
0.05403159558773041,
0.2640821635723114,
-0.23536399006843567,
-0.19439522922039032,
-0.2069384753704071,
0.6220487952232361,
-0.35598212480545044,
-0.91363525390625,
-0.10593795776367188,
0.784600555896759,
0.21491174399852753,
-0.5573741793632507,
-0.2533503472805023,
0.34133872389793396,
0.06518415361642838,
0.8015791177749634,
-0.05806035175919533,
-0.9348365664482117,
-0.17350615561008453,
-0.11423876136541367,
-0.46656668186187744,
0.1705819070339203,
0.6536029577255249,
-0.4646631181240082,
0.6168767809867859,
0.07520521432161331,
0.7082580327987671,
0.2247726023197174,
0.4371564984321594,
0.39136800169944763,
-0.9380903840065002,
0.16824249923229218,
0.000003964054030802799,
0.3207503855228424,
0.5647027492523193,
-0.28707465529441833,
0.24497386813163757,
-0.292216420173645,
-0.6919716000556946,
-0.7593968510627747,
-0.1496843546628952,
-1.058468222618103,
-0.009717526845633984,
1.261303186416626,
0.06752071529626846,
-0.14074209332466125,
0.11384537816047668,
-0.5820025205612183,
-0.13708974421024323,
-0.4209693670272827,
1.011789083480835,
0.5517105460166931,
-0.0200120210647583,
-0.4527170956134796,
-0.6015263199806213,
0.22742347419261932,
0.2966451048851013,
-0.9132009744644165,
0.1276441067457199,
0.6722584962844849,
-0.13149814307689667,
0.2672775089740753,
0.4572385251522064,
0.06554603576660156,
0.2901346683502197,
-0.29657670855522156,
0.2137862741947174,
-0.16194358468055725,
-0.401710569858551,
-0.07158023118972778,
0.030692683532834053,
0.28457480669021606,
-0.18013237416744232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16554v1 | LLaMA-MoE: Building Mixture-of-Experts from LLaMA with Continual Pre-training | 2024-06-24T11:43:07 | 2024-06-24T11:43:07 | Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Daize Dong, Jiacheng Ruan, Jingqi Tong, Conghui He, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, training MoE
from scratch in a large-scale setting still suffers from data-hungry and
instability problems. Motivated by this limit, we investigate building MoE
models from existing dense large language models. Specifically, based on the
well-known LLaMA-2 7B model, we obtain an MoE model by: (1) Expert
Construction, which partitions the parameters of original Feed-Forward Networks
(FFNs) into multiple experts; (2) Continual Pre-training, which further trains
the transformed MoE model and additional gate networks. In this paper, we
comprehensively explore different methods for expert construction and various
data sampling strategies for continual pre-training. After these stages, our
LLaMA-MoE models could maintain language abilities and route the input tokens
to specific experts with part of the parameters activated. Empirically, by
training 200B tokens, LLaMA-MoE-3.5B models significantly outperform dense
models that contain similar activation parameters. The source codes and models
are available at https://github.com/pjlab-sys4nlp/llama-moe . | [
-0.4827425181865692,
-0.8473672866821289,
0.5641579031944275,
0.4500170946121216,
-0.22923173010349274,
0.2566484808921814,
-0.4068215489387512,
-0.43291500210762024,
0.38594523072242737,
0.7472590804100037,
-0.22027866542339325,
-0.021793676540255547,
-0.8214055895805359,
0.16450630128383636,
-0.475073903799057,
0.806344211101532,
0.044065821915864944,
0.02545028366148472,
-0.04560794308781624,
0.15856313705444336,
-0.7178676128387451,
-0.3100488483905792,
-0.5056709051132202,
-0.22859510779380798,
0.4021981656551361,
0.47755491733551025,
0.6204336285591125,
0.5610103011131287,
0.11723838001489639,
0.3780793845653534,
0.058469440788030624,
0.18005141615867615,
-0.8596789836883545,
0.21599061787128448,
-0.02158334292471409,
-0.5845730304718018,
-0.5061383843421936,
0.025136448442935944,
0.7444720268249512,
0.7499650716781616,
-0.4584439992904663,
-0.013357002288103104,
0.061396773904561996,
0.1461436003446579,
-0.472917377948761,
0.016354430466890335,
-1.235740065574646,
-0.2151751071214676,
-0.35100263357162476,
0.023237403482198715,
-0.4824495017528534,
-0.08124687522649765,
0.05200525000691414,
-0.599561333656311,
-0.07954321056604385,
0.084983229637146,
0.6899675130844116,
0.4206763803958893,
-0.4144354462623596,
-0.19039663672447205,
-0.5212070941925049,
1.0278196334838867,
-0.8427005410194397,
0.23651200532913208,
0.5410981178283691,
0.15743005275726318,
-0.567744791507721,
-0.4509929120540619,
-0.6394221782684326,
-0.3709467649459839,
0.2974900007247925,
0.014836396090686321,
0.17043523490428925,
-0.1251232773065567,
-0.16067975759506226,
0.21067224442958832,
-0.13583312928676605,
0.5103468894958496,
-0.42017433047294617,
0.02508537657558918,
0.8161206841468811,
0.04513055458664894,
0.11330720782279968,
0.18168428540229797,
-0.4102083742618561,
0.15548262000083923,
-0.9175174832344055,
-0.3603789508342743,
0.33287301659584045,
-0.013261175714433193,
0.06415846198797226,
0.5440178513526917,
-0.24728693068027496,
0.6938515305519104,
0.37794193625450134,
-0.5586262941360474,
0.12024656683206558,
-0.054719917476177216,
0.05680040270090103,
-0.036315467208623886,
0.8012163043022156,
0.017237218096852303,
0.5338191390037537,
-0.4278917610645294,
-0.4445883631706238,
-0.2245267778635025,
0.2842128574848175,
-0.649017333984375,
-0.42305684089660645,
0.12030298262834549,
-0.2253345251083374,
-0.44757458567619324,
-0.2613602578639984,
-0.38946038484573364,
-0.2344575971364975,
-0.45570051670074463,
0.4930780529975891,
-0.2483246624469757,
-0.630692720413208,
0.15132933855056763,
0.23186443746089935,
-0.020584333688020706,
0.3577575087547302,
-0.772972047328949,
0.07504720985889435,
0.4712899923324585,
0.5396058559417725,
-0.18680711090564728,
-0.5115893483161926,
-0.5624284744262695,
0.4187748432159424,
-0.5436093807220459,
0.9045011401176453,
-0.752844512462616,
-0.5301728844642639,
-0.07788006961345673,
-0.3840252459049225,
0.03917888179421425,
-0.7284600734710693,
0.03128888085484505,
-0.7434574365615845,
-0.01846330054104328,
-0.10555629432201385,
-0.4243670701980591,
-0.1817428320646286,
0.3464317321777344,
-0.4727383255958557,
1.211189866065979,
0.07786329090595245,
-0.45518720149993896,
0.2523833215236664,
-0.3468722105026245,
-0.40874427556991577,
0.09212539345026016,
-0.20266525447368622,
-0.0020407051779329777,
0.26086312532424927,
0.44662535190582275,
0.9044273495674133,
-0.2710215449333191,
0.6662989258766174,
-0.5446469783782959,
-0.1654822826385498,
0.3325692415237427,
-0.3310983180999756,
0.6941742897033691,
0.09854642301797867,
-0.13227570056915283,
-0.14673040807247162,
-0.78092360496521,
-0.4414041340351105,
0.20972314476966858,
-0.5848336219787598,
-0.23234272003173828,
0.19531750679016113,
-0.3486768305301666,
0.180883526802063,
0.5094665288925171,
-0.27788645029067993,
0.39209845662117004,
-0.1464824676513672,
0.4288477301597595,
0.9014363288879395,
0.004572989884763956,
0.3986632227897644,
-0.2945259213447571,
0.4704716205596924,
0.3030564486980438,
-0.06793008744716644,
-0.34398117661476135,
-0.6545188426971436,
-0.972377598285675,
-0.46080273389816284,
0.2323065996170044,
0.4892495572566986,
-0.9353870749473572,
0.58892822265625,
-0.6100160479545593,
-0.6383586525917053,
-0.5382575392723083,
0.6603385210037231,
0.10998385399580002,
0.5246801376342773,
0.36745116114616394,
-0.33052295446395874,
-0.2791083753108978,
-0.7486161589622498,
0.2539199888706207,
-0.25803571939468384,
0.020807761698961258,
0.04527873545885086,
0.4483537971973419,
-0.403952419757843,
1.1020270586013794,
-0.3653769791126251,
-0.009220154955983162,
-0.2871580421924591,
-0.023794781416654587,
0.2721898555755615,
0.5398532748222351,
0.6517190337181091,
-0.3395729064941406,
-0.315205454826355,
0.04873116686940193,
-0.6664761900901794,
-0.21063728630542755,
-0.07674571871757507,
-0.27403464913368225,
-0.3355451226234436,
0.37125396728515625,
-0.6267831325531006,
0.0006346997106447816,
0.5892757177352905,
0.33245065808296204,
0.6426117420196533,
0.016209855675697327,
-0.22096066176891327,
-1.3098907470703125,
-0.11526161432266235,
-0.11802789568901062,
-0.25236228108406067,
-0.6126528978347778,
0.24549756944179535,
-0.22960536181926727,
-0.012833504006266594,
-0.283610463142395,
0.7062660455703735,
-0.5051995515823364,
0.05928846076130867,
-0.4006361961364746,
-0.07260432094335556,
-0.3112174868583679,
0.6845921874046326,
0.009556280449032784,
0.6590331196784973,
0.7916078567504883,
-0.7246864438056946,
0.4571368098258972,
0.11127737909555435,
-0.3916703164577484,
0.41509509086608887,
-0.7954160571098328,
0.30488014221191406,
0.03544627130031586,
0.38638490438461304,
-0.8097913861274719,
-0.45326775312423706,
0.33545494079589844,
-0.16074906289577484,
0.41031140089035034,
-0.1879708617925644,
-0.6547108888626099,
-0.2737478017807007,
-0.06009664386510849,
0.48563092947006226,
0.5841686725616455,
-0.38423797488212585,
0.9657578468322754,
0.5732725858688354,
-0.6657275557518005,
-0.6207827925682068,
-0.6168108582496643,
0.2690885365009308,
-0.12651686370372772,
-0.6910074353218079,
0.1290806084871292,
-0.049153655767440796,
-0.22986142337322235,
0.005382288247346878,
0.09962307661771774,
-0.2244974672794342,
0.24182087182998657,
0.14031389355659485,
-0.041039999574422836,
-0.27092039585113525,
-0.005966485943645239,
0.4133338928222656,
-0.01099440362304449,
0.028094260022044182,
-0.21031364798545837,
0.7008363008499146,
0.1472497433423996,
-0.38031521439552307,
-0.29326263070106506,
0.43601351976394653,
0.40214788913726807,
-0.406135231256485,
0.673897922039032,
0.3735951781272888,
-0.08672874420881271,
-0.24420806765556335,
-1.1299620866775513,
-0.17778074741363525,
-0.47782397270202637,
0.5389913320541382,
-0.4435967206954956,
-0.8644124865531921,
0.654807984828949,
-0.14933986961841583,
0.2950478196144104,
0.3829425275325775,
0.8673521876335144,
-0.08930891007184982,
0.6815735697746277,
0.5621498823165894,
-0.4884917140007019,
0.5424802303314209,
-0.04250090941786766,
-0.1592988520860672,
-0.6806492805480957,
-0.14733575284481049,
-0.2075420767068863,
-0.35478469729423523,
0.05863157659769058,
-0.5964607000350952,
0.31571072340011597,
0.3261054456233978,
-0.21506448090076447,
0.16532957553863525,
-0.06223969906568527,
0.4235040843486786,
0.40697526931762695,
0.24771630764007568,
0.09076311439275742,
0.14756567776203156,
0.08477742224931717,
0.5905032157897949,
-0.927537739276886,
-0.4034736454486847,
1.5087791681289673,
0.5282837748527527,
0.7477124333381653,
-0.12917707860469818,
0.7898728847503662,
-0.06234200298786163,
0.7467848062515259,
-0.5989236831665039,
0.7442395091056824,
0.1115046963095665,
-0.7185378074645996,
-0.16110457479953766,
-0.3991657495498657,
-0.7519127130508423,
0.24038425087928772,
-0.26013022661209106,
-0.41241443157196045,
0.18062540888786316,
0.25042465329170227,
-0.25802162289619446,
0.2188286930322647,
-0.6907535791397095,
0.18060389161109924,
-0.43388795852661133,
-0.13934001326560974,
-0.43094637989997864,
-0.5933786630630493,
0.581721305847168,
-0.5744472146034241,
0.14861099421977997,
-0.211570143699646,
-0.16725371778011322,
0.6859161257743835,
-0.4912926256656647,
0.9893429279327393,
-0.03571799024939537,
-0.4492630660533905,
0.4522331953048706,
-0.011590489186346531,
0.5823387503623962,
0.16590891778469086,
-0.22277942299842834,
0.391578733921051,
-0.5811033844947815,
-0.689420759677887,
-0.41561728715896606,
0.4720270335674286,
-1.0525643825531006,
-0.774605393409729,
0.17425747215747833,
-0.5394097566604614,
-0.3178155720233917,
0.2043902575969696,
0.02638613060116768,
0.5028087496757507,
0.19839881360530853,
0.3844541013240814,
0.6569973230361938,
0.06423842161893845,
0.27092793583869934,
0.23686926066875458,
-0.3266240358352661,
-0.5339851379394531,
0.7991187572479248,
0.32156673073768616,
0.18173792958259583,
0.2598528563976288,
0.046144574880599976,
0.06744056195020676,
-0.7863127589225769,
-0.437629371881485,
0.24167031049728394,
-0.5116701722145081,
-0.2537551820278168,
-0.6052519083023071,
-0.0897216796875,
-0.2553192675113678,
-0.16110104322433472,
-0.5212944149971008,
0.026046058163046837,
-0.3769665062427521,
-0.006157281808555126,
0.3321996331214905,
0.8384270668029785,
0.08047576248645782,
0.8448324799537659,
-0.8884337544441223,
0.20337218046188354,
0.6021092534065247,
0.2085995227098465,
0.3748578429222107,
-0.6114180684089661,
-0.45850908756256104,
0.2583999037742615,
-0.1881914734840393,
-0.9587622284889221,
0.12873965501785278,
0.2666959762573242,
0.8784278035163879,
0.7219744324684143,
-0.2093399614095688,
0.7203919291496277,
-0.5914322137832642,
0.7747918963432312,
0.15060372650623322,
-0.6802220940589905,
0.18914803862571716,
-0.6178588271141052,
0.009485479444265366,
0.5555442571640015,
0.40664759278297424,
0.09629128873348236,
-0.5642637014389038,
-0.3237881064414978,
-0.8268904089927673,
0.48557373881340027,
0.045746829360723495,
0.422551691532135,
-0.09183400869369507,
0.48057857155799866,
0.4564002752304077,
0.3026241362094879,
-0.6314223408699036,
0.16230656206607819,
-0.2536560595035553,
-0.2703888416290283,
-0.0487879179418087,
-0.40904760360717773,
-0.0958128422498703,
-0.06677576899528503,
0.5540347099304199,
0.007128543686121702,
0.05619015172123909,
-0.34701254963874817,
-0.45237240195274353,
0.23018383979797363,
-0.13186383247375488,
0.4894865155220032,
0.7637015581130981,
-0.04781675338745117,
-0.10771669447422028,
0.35823601484298706,
-0.5852110385894775,
0.19556128978729248,
0.07101432979106903,
0.10660339146852493,
-0.2876328229904175,
0.4916369616985321,
0.751976728439331,
0.4933158755302429,
-0.6056495904922485,
0.3467000126838684,
0.2925278842449188,
-0.18640536069869995,
-0.24905015528202057,
0.2381264716386795,
0.21172790229320526,
0.17028750479221344,
0.6648057699203491,
-0.05637599900364876,
-0.3751298487186432,
-0.3869665265083313,
0.06664519757032394,
0.1610373556613922,
0.21389582753181458,
-0.423153817653656,
0.522952675819397,
0.6800093650817871,
0.05464360862970352,
0.7106158137321472,
-0.24763186275959015,
-0.5190442204475403,
0.41022834181785583,
0.46430060267448425,
0.5544929504394531,
-0.405954509973526,
-0.09419526904821396,
-0.0427459217607975,
0.2840433716773987,
-0.42437827587127686,
0.08220253884792328,
-0.20556549727916718,
-0.9681712985038757,
-0.7387629151344299,
-0.5429887175559998,
-0.3120500445365906,
-0.09940996021032333,
-0.393385112285614,
0.1848098486661911,
-0.5057387351989746,
-0.1510850042104721,
-0.5249794125556946,
-0.0995013490319252,
-0.7376970052719116,
0.2436647117137909,
0.07779715955257416,
0.6354591846466064,
-0.7804266214370728,
0.9310033917427063,
0.7033410668373108,
-0.24207422137260437,
-0.9208649396896362,
-0.08004190772771835,
-0.30953821539878845,
-1.0995336771011353,
0.6916007995605469,
0.05526129528880119,
0.028132596984505653,
0.25261542201042175,
-0.8372175693511963,
-0.9937570095062256,
1.0009677410125732,
0.39969325065612793,
-0.7962679862976074,
-0.05015786364674568,
-0.05643533170223236,
0.22180800139904022,
-0.3829297423362732,
0.20394864678382874,
0.3610881268978119,
0.2374700903892517,
0.04590114578604698,
-0.8466134667396545,
-0.16738855838775635,
-0.3199172616004944,
-0.014238402247428894,
-0.042558424174785614,
-0.6892760396003723,
0.9241182804107666,
0.03344627469778061,
0.1953500509262085,
0.1363355964422226,
1.1535139083862305,
0.6598430275917053,
-0.1856391429901123,
0.7401732802391052,
0.7427155375480652,
0.7544103860855103,
0.1745818853378296,
0.7505496740341187,
-0.5979570150375366,
-0.029409395530819893,
0.9895783066749573,
-0.3674006760120392,
1.1143430471420288,
0.3387978971004486,
-0.11536268889904022,
0.5891808867454529,
0.663876473903656,
-0.038584496825933456,
0.41772890090942383,
0.10720228403806686,
-0.14548006653785706,
-0.5394741892814636,
0.11935542523860931,
-0.6755606532096863,
0.3668982684612274,
0.5048813223838806,
0.020272521302103996,
-0.02282591350376606,
0.05715709924697876,
0.21558359265327454,
-0.3970918357372284,
-0.4128473401069641,
0.596027135848999,
0.24030010402202606,
-0.5907757878303528,
0.38264358043670654,
-0.09961818903684616,
0.9378188252449036,
-0.6778290271759033,
0.3534829914569855,
-0.4435076415538788,
-0.2830333113670349,
0.0020618578419089317,
-0.6370689868927002,
-0.227849543094635,
0.09722856432199478,
-0.13227087259292603,
-0.01581057719886303,
0.5302327275276184,
-0.585576057434082,
-0.713377833366394,
-0.016389289870858192,
0.4602895975112915,
0.26870593428611755,
-0.026248617097735405,
-0.4313357472419739,
-0.006003778427839279,
-0.22963187098503113,
-0.5450032353401184,
0.37951359152793884,
0.5640437602996826,
0.004951003473252058,
0.8397068381309509,
0.6967397928237915,
0.19895964860916138,
0.5588278770446777,
-0.13372494280338287,
1.0912421941757202,
-0.18336385488510132,
-0.4591120779514313,
-0.5844240784645081,
0.6812877058982849,
0.028695661574602127,
-0.45377805829048157,
0.5184122920036316,
0.22044149041175842,
0.8873767852783203,
-0.16934897005558014,
0.6691157817840576,
0.17569562792778015,
0.20535020530223846,
-0.6687297821044922,
0.7659162282943726,
-0.6646848917007446,
0.15463082492351532,
-0.20485660433769226,
-1.1503130197525024,
-0.016114717349410057,
0.4415951371192932,
-0.32073989510536194,
0.32321393489837646,
0.12410824745893478,
0.7890961170196533,
-0.1449405699968338,
-0.3558558523654938,
0.1700429916381836,
0.4427920877933502,
0.4549514055252075,
0.4494251012802124,
0.9712744355201721,
0.004903335589915514,
0.4654289782047272,
-0.10677282512187958,
-0.23043864965438843,
-0.5061318874359131,
-0.8461111783981323,
-0.9231205582618713,
-0.33514389395713806,
-0.26187482476234436,
0.16501492261886597,
-0.2575713098049164,
0.9812510013580322,
0.8843951225280762,
-0.5764369964599609,
-0.24156668782234192,
0.17823857069015503,
-0.021163849160075188,
0.0828625038266182,
-0.09669866412878036,
0.11924326419830322,
-0.3834454119205475,
-0.689396858215332,
0.6411313414573669,
0.2637036442756653,
-0.043883536010980606,
-0.5559563636779785,
-0.1447778344154358,
-0.07993006706237793,
0.17904037237167358,
0.6256430745124817,
0.08738639205694199,
-0.7526963353157043,
-0.09726347774267197,
-0.18449382483959198,
0.09626417607069016,
-0.13376210629940033,
0.3634489178657532,
-0.7343907952308655,
0.40295717120170593,
0.4469245672225952,
1.0909175872802734,
0.16999416053295135,
0.04598822817206383,
0.8526450991630554,
-0.6630802750587463,
0.2831355333328247,
0.06120970472693443,
0.4872051477432251,
0.2275916337966919,
-0.03530009463429451,
0.2965608537197113,
0.21829578280448914,
-0.5972886681556702,
-0.9438257813453674,
0.15088742971420288,
-1.0099254846572876,
-0.18412545323371887,
1.231290340423584,
-0.16531053185462952,
0.03413473814725876,
-0.1678755283355713,
-0.2586607038974762,
0.0672055184841156,
-0.4634157419204712,
0.7815245985984802,
0.8128070831298828,
0.23218996822834015,
-0.06552717089653015,
-0.5339085459709167,
-0.17995981872081757,
0.4910106360912323,
-0.6268741488456726,
-0.4520900845527649,
0.26362141966819763,
0.45509636402130127,
0.05051890015602112,
0.7111848592758179,
0.2207072526216507,
-0.0368427112698555,
0.12681931257247925,
0.06114060804247856,
-0.30679771304130554,
-0.5456101298332214,
0.10290221124887466,
0.18341787159442902,
0.15185436606407166,
0.04539347440004349
] |
Subsets and Splits