Datasets:

SouthernCrossAI
/

Arxiv

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Split (1)

train · 132k rows

Filename stringlengths 22 64	Paragraph stringlengths 8 5.57k
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Point spread function (PSF) methods were not used in this research as the stars were chosen to be in rel- atively isolated ﬁelds and there were signiﬁcant image quality variations across the ﬁeld of the SALTICAM data and from one frame to the next. This meant that the PSF was variable in time and position in the CCD frames making measurement and application of this technique extremely diﬃcult.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	In order to reduce the data in a way that will produce precision measurements, particular attention must be paid to the following: the sky annulus should be positioned strategically so as to avoid the inclusion of other stars and irregularities in the background that would not otherwise exist underneath the object; the inner aperture should not be too large that it extends to the place where the star appears to merge into the sky noise; and the same aperture size should be used for measuring every object.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	To be able to treat all the data as one dataset and make precise comparisons, data calibration be- tween the ﬁve telescopes is essential. To do this all the MJUO data were calibrated using F region stan- dard star observations that were obtained during var- ious observing times. Observations of F region stan- dard star (F116) were taken concurrently on the OC and B&C telescopes. Since the magnitudes of F re- gion stars are known and constant (Cousins and Stoy 1962), it is possible to calculate the magnitude of the target star with respect to them. The F116 stellar images taken from diﬀerent telescopes can be used to align all the images with a common zero-point which in turn allows the diﬀerent target magnitudes to be com- pared and treated as one dataset. Images of F116 were also reduced using the method of aperture photometry and a SIMBAD identiﬁed standard star. The F region stellar magnitudes obtained from the data collected on the OC and B&C telescopes diﬀered slightly from the published values. To eliminate the inconsistencies the average magnitude in each ﬁlter for each telescope was calculated. The diﬀerence between these values and the published value in each ﬁlter for F116 was then applied to correct the data. These same shifts were then applied to all the data obtained on the OC and B&C respectively, thus ensuring their common zero point.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Since observations of an F region standard star were not taken with SALT, an alternative approach to data calibration had to be adopted. During the data reduction process the magnitude of each standard star in a given ﬁeld is entered manually. These magnitudes are those reported by SIMBAD and once they have all been recorded by Mira AL, they are automatically varied slightly with respect to the brightness and the assigned magnitudes of the standard stars in the ﬁeld. To calibrate the SALT data the oﬀset between the magnitudes of the recently calibrated standard stars in the MJUO images, and the same standard stars in the SALT images, is calculated and applied. This op- eration yields both the data from SALT and MJUO with a common zero point.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	As previously mentioned, the OGLE data is re- ceived in a post-reduction form as stellar magnitudes. The only preparation that it requires are the V and I colour corrections. To calibrate the SALT and MJUO data with these OGLE magnitudes, several processed OGLE images were analysed in a similar manner to that described earlier. The magnitudes obtained through this reduction process were compared with the origi- nally received OGLE magnitudes. An average oﬀset was calculated and this was applied to all the cal- ibrated SALT and MJUO magnitudes that already shared a common zero-point. This allowed all the mag- nitudes analysed to become aligned with the colour corrected OGLE data zero-point. Of course, since OGLE only provides data in the V and I ﬁlters, this also limited the calibration of the SALT and MJUO data to these ﬁlters. Nonetheless, calibration across the ﬁlters is certainly an issue that will be given more attention in future anaylses.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 2 shows the seven declines that have occurred in LMC100.6 48589 during the ∼ 6,000 days over which the data were collected. Even though seven declines have been identiﬁed only certain data points (circled in black) in a decline were selected for inclusion in further recovery phase calculations. This is because during the initial decline phase the dust in the stellar environment is potentially inhomogeneously distributed and results in the rapid drop observed in magnitude. There are also strong chromospheric spectral features visible at the early decline phase that do not decay until the recovery phase (Cottrell et al. 1990). And in the re- covery phase the dust around the star is assumed to be more uniformly distributed, and it is at this time that a noticeable excess in the (U -V ), (B-V ), (V -R) and (V -I) colours becomes apparent. Since the late recovery phase is the desired component of the decline under investigation in this paper, a magnitude thresh- old was set in order to reject all data that were col- lected prior to dust homogeneity over the stellar disc. This threshold varied between individual stars and was also dependent on the depth to which a particular de- cline fell. It was generally taken as being two or three magnitudes below maximum brightness, which corre- sponds to the data points in the colour-magnitude di- agram (CMD) following an asymptotic recovery line back to maximum light (Figure 3).
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 2: The light curve (V ) for LMC100.6 48589 displaying the seven declines (separately colour- coded) in the time interval of this research. The solid black points are data obtained at maximum light, while the black circled points are the data selected for use in further decline recovery calcu- lations.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	et al. 1990), with the (V -I) becoming bluer than at maximum light. However other declines are of the ‘red- type’. As the star recovers to normal brightness the data points follow a characteristic ‘loop’ track towards the asymptotic recovery line (black line). Skuljan et al. (2003) showed that in a sample of nine galactic RCB stars observed to have a total of 26 declines over a pe- riod of 12 years this asymptotic recovery back to max- ∆(V −I) ]galactic = 3.1 ± 0.1. imum light had a slope of [ ∆V In addition, the slope of the asymptotic line does not depend on the depth or the frequency of declines and is the same for all these galactic RCB stars. At this phase in the recovery the various ﬁlter band-passes are no longer aﬀected by the emission lines that are present to a greater (‘blue’) or lesser (‘red’) extent and the process is one of dispersion of the dust cloud (see Cottrell et al 1990). The determination of the asymp- totic recovery slope for the 18 declines of the four MC RCB stars studied in this research is determined us- ing this same assumption (see Table 1), even though no detailed decline phase spectroscopic observations have yet been made to conﬁrm this in these Magel- lanic Cloud objects.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 3: CMD for LMC100.6 48589 showing the characteristic ‘loop’ decline and ‘asymptotic’ re- covery track traced by each of the seven declines (colour-coded) observed in Figure 2. The black △(V −I) = 3.33 ± 0.10) represents the asymp- line ( totic recovery path and the red and blue lines are used in the calculation of its uncertainty.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	possible calculation for the gradient of the asymptote. The gradient of this line for LMC100.6 48589 was cal- ∆(V −I) = 3.33 ± 0.10, culated as having a value of with the uncertainty computed using the red and blue lines in Figure 3. These are lines ﬁtted to the extreme maximum and minimum possible values (taking into account their uncertainty in both V and (V -I)) for the data points respectively. This method for determining the uncertainty was chosen because it not only takes into account the positional spread of the desired data, but it also includes their individual uncertainties.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 4 displays the LMC104.4 60857 data. It shows several declines of varying depth. When these data are plotted in a CMD (Figure 5), it is evident that initially each decline takes a slightly diﬀerent ‘loop’ (a ‘red-type’ according to Cottrell et al. 1990) path, but remarkably during the recovery phase all the de- cline data track along the same line. This provides more evidence to consolidate the idea that the depth of an individual decline is unrelated to the ﬁnal ap- proach to maximum light. The slope of the recovery asymptote for LMC104.4 60857 was determined to be (3.34 ± 0.02), the same, within the uncertainties to that calculated for LMC100.6 48589.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figures 6 and 7 show the light curve and CMD for LMC169.7 40649. Although declines are evident in the light curve, it looks as if the star does not return com- pletly back to maximum brightness during the time- span over which the data were collected. Instead, the data portray the star as being continuously in a de- cline, which probably accounts for the steep slope of ∆(V −I) = 5.59 ± 0.24 observed in the CMD. As a re- sult, the data from this star were not included in the combined MC slope calculation (see Figure 8).
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	share a common zero point. The shift was achieved by subtracting the average magnitude at maximum light from the photometric data (in both the V and I ﬁlters) to create new V and (V -I) values. Follow- ing this, a straight line was ﬁtted to the recovery data from these four stars in order to determine the com- bined gradient. Figure 8 shows the data after the maximum magnitude subtraction was performed. The value for the gradient calculated using this method is ∆(V −I) ]combined = 3.37 ± 0.24, with the uncertainty [ ∆V being determined in the same way as that described earlier. These two gradient values are consistent con- sidering their uncertainties. They also fall close to the ∆(V −I) ]galactic = 3.1 ± 0.1 for the 26 de- value of [ ∆V clines of nine galactic RCB stars that was previously determined by Skuljan et al. (2003).
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	The closeness of these two decline recovery gradi- ents implies that the mechanism responsible for the observed magnitude declines is common to RCB stars in both the Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds. Given that at this phase all the emission lines in the galactic RCB stars have disappeared from the spectra, one is simply looking at the scattering of light by dust. The similarity of the gradients then implies that the size of the dust particles in the stellar environment would be similar in the Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 6: The light curve for LMC169.7 40649 shows that it is probable that the star did not re- turn to maximum brightness during the time-span over which the data were collected.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Table 1: The line slopes obtained from the (V − I) vs V CMDs for four RCB stars in the MCs.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	lar dust existing along the line-of-sight in the direction towards the MCs compared with the RCB stars previ- ously studied in the Galaxy.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	The gradient calculated for the LMC RCB stars alone (excluding SMC105.6 22488), is [ ∆V ∆(V −I) ]LM C = 3.34 ± 0.21. Comparing this value with the recov- ery gradient for just the SMC, or simply SMC105.6 ∆(V −I) ]SM C = 3.21 ± 0.22), it is clear that 22488 ([ ∆V they also agree to within their associated uncertain- ties. This suggests that the physical properties of the dust forming in the RCB stellar environments in the LMC and SMC are also similar.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Examination of the data acquired in the V and I ﬁlters, resulted in the identiﬁcation of a total of 18 RCB declines occurring in four stars (three in the LMC and one in the SMC). Construction of colour- magnitude diagrams ( V vs V -I), in particular dur- ing the recovery to maximum light, were undertaken in order to study the unique colour behaviour asso- ciated with the RCB declines as a result of the dust formation in the stellar environment. The combined recovery slope for the four stars was determined to be ∆(V −I) ]combined = 3.37 ± 0.24, which is similar to [ ∆V ∆(V −I) ]galactic = 3.1 ± 0.1 calculated for the value of [ ∆V galactic RCB stars (Skuljan et al. 2003). Extending this analysis by incorporating data obtained in other ﬁlters (e.g. U , B and R) would enable the creation of a dust extinction curve, that would provide conﬁrma- tion for the validity of the results obtained using the V and I data.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	Figure 8: Declines from four RCB stars with a △V △(V −I) = 3.37 ± 0.24. The combined gradient of data from each star are colour-coded as follows: LMC100.6 48589: blue, LMC101.7 8114: red, LMC104.4 60857: green, and SMC105.6 22488: magenta.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	The work undertaken for this paper may be thought of as the pilot project for the pursuit of additional re- search in this area. During the course of this research a number of hurdles have been encountered and over- come (e.g the method for data calibration), thus out- lining a clear pathway along which signiﬁcant future discoveries relating to the fascinating RCB phenonena can be made.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	The data analysed for this paper were collected by sev- eral people at three diﬀerent observatories around the world. First, we would like to acknowledge Pam Kil- martin, Alan Gilmore and Paul Tristram for making some of the observations at Mt John University Ob- servatory during the 07/08 summer. Second, thanks to the Southern African Large Telescope astronomers, in particular Dr. Petri Vaisanen, for observing six of our candidate stars with SALT. SALT is a con- sortium consisting of the National Research Founda- tion of South Africa, Nicholas Copernicus Astronomi- cal Center of the Polish Academy of Sciences, Hobby Eberly Telescope Founding Institutions, Rutgers Uni- versity, Georg-August-Universitat Gottingen, Univer- sity of Wisconsin-Madison, Carnegie Mellon Univer- sity, University of Canterbury, United Kingdom SALT Consortium, University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill, Dartmouth College, American Museum of Nat- ural History and the Inter-University Centre for As- tronomy and Astrophysics, India.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	RCB candidates. His research provided a ﬁrm foun- dation on which the work undertaken for this paper could be based.
Processed_Photometric_analysis_of_Magellanic_Cloud_R_Coronae.txt	RMW would also like to acknowledge ﬁnancial sup- port received in the form of scholarships from the De- partment of Physics and Astronomy and the Dennis William Moore Fund. Thanks also needs to be ex- tended to the Canterbury Branch of the Royal Society of New Zealand, the Dennis William Moore Fund, the Kingdon-Tomlinson Fund administered by the Royal Astronomical Society of New Zealand, the National Astronomical Research Institute of Thailand, and the International Astronomical Union, for their respective ﬁnancial contributions that enabled RMW to partici- pate in the Astronomical Society of Australia meeting (2007) and the Pacﬁc Rim Conference on Stellar Astr- physics (2008). Finally, AU would like to acknowledge the support for the OGLE project received in the form of the Polish MNiSW grant N20303032/4275.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	SUMMARY: We present preliminary results from spectral observations of four (4) candidate radio sources co-identiﬁed with known planetary nebulae (PNe) in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). These were made using the Radcliﬀe 1.9-meter tele- scope in Sutherland, South Africa. These radio PNe were originally found in Aus- tralia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) surveys of the SMC at 1.42 and 2.37 GHz, and were further conﬁrmed by new high resolution ATCA images at 6 and 3 cm (4 and may represent a sub- population of selected radio bright objects. Nebular ionized masses of these objects may be 2.6 M⊙ or greater, supporting the existence of PNe progenitor central stars with masses up to 8 M⊙.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	these objects radiate from the X-ray to the radio, detected structures are inﬂuenced by selection eﬀects from intervening dust and gas, instrument sensitivity and distance (see Kwok (2005) for a more detailed discussion).
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Most PNe have central-star and nebular masses of only about 0.6 and 0.3 M⊙, respectively. However, detection of white dwarfs in open clusters suggests the main-sequence mass of PNe progenitors can be as high as 8 M⊙ (Kwok 1994).
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	ratio near 9:3:1. However, this can be relaxed when [N ii]6583˚A is greater than Hα. In that case, a strong [O iii] line has been often detected along with the high excitation He ii4686˚A line hardly seen in H ii regions.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Generally, the [O ii]3727˚A doublet is seen in PNe, as well as [Ne iii]3869˚A, [Ar iii]7135˚A and He i6678˚A lines. [S ii]6717, 6731˚A is usually present but not signiﬁcant when compared to Hα.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	also note that our spectral indices support the gen- eral belief that PNe are weak thermal radio emitters.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Spectral observations were conducted January 2008, using the 1.9-meter telescope and Cassegrain spectrograph at the South African Astronomical Ob- servatory (SAAO) in Sutherland. We used grating number 7 (300 lpmm) to obtain spectra between 3500 and 6200 ˚A having a resolution of 5 ˚A. For these, the slit size was 1.5′′ × 1.5′ with a spatial resolution of 0.74′′ pixel−1. Exposure times were limited to 800 s with a positional accuracy of < 1′′.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	In this paper we present optical spectra of four (4) PNe that co-identify with radio PNe candidates recently found in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). Section 2 details our spectral observations and reduc- tion methods used to calibrate the data analysed in Section 3. The paper concludes with some ﬁnal com- ments and a brief summary as presented in Section 4.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Data reduction included bias subtraction and ﬂat-ﬁeld correction using the iraf software pack- age. Extraction (task ‘extractor’), including back- ground sky subtraction, of data allowed the creation of one-dimensional spectra, wavelength calibrated using standard lines from a CuAr arc. Flux calibra- tion was applied using the spectrometric standard star EG 21. Observing conditions were not photo- metric, seeing was limited to an arcsecond at best but varied throughout the evening.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Beginning with SMC J004336-730227 and SMC J005730-723224, as described in Payne et al. (2004), 28 candidate radio PNe have been found within a few arcseconds of known optical PNe in the direction of the Magellanic Clouds (MCs; Filipovi´c et al., in preparation). This includes six (6) SMC sources from Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) observations, completed for short-spacing using Parkes data and the miriad software suite to create mosaic images at 1.42 and 2.37 GHz (see Fil- ipovi´c et al. 2002).
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Recent followup ATCA observations at 6 and 3 cm give much higher resolutions (4′′and 2′′, re- spectively) and appear to conﬁrm these objects as bright radio counterparts to within 2′′ of known op- tical PNe. The number and ﬂux densities (up to ten times greater than expected) of these candidate radio PNe are unexpected given the distance of the SMC of ∼ 60 kpc (Hilditch et al. 2005). This may well modify our current understanding of PNe, including their progenitor mass and evolution.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	We used iraf’s task splot to view and ana- lyze our spectra. Only ﬂuxes from spectral lines vi- sually distinct from the baseline rms (∼ 1.0 × 10−15 ergs cm−2 s−1 ˚A−1) were selected for inclusion in Table 2. For each PNe, Table 2 lists the relative ﬂux densities (using EG21) and 90% conﬁdence intervals of common lines within our spectral range. These lines include the [O ii]3727˚A doublet, [Ne iii]3869˚A, Hβλ4861˚A and [O iii]4363, 4959, 5007˚A. All values are shown at their rest wavelengths.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	We estimate extinction using Balmer emission lines Hβ4862˚A, Hγ4340˚A and Hδ4102˚A. Noting that our spectral range does not include Hα6563˚A, we calculate Balmer decrements as Hγ/Hβ and Hδ/Hβ. Characteristic extinction curves are presented by Os- terbrock & Ferland (2006) and expected intrinsic Balmer decrements are based on Case B recombina- tion1 Table 3 lists individual values for E(B–V) based on these decrements. We cannot accurately measure the Hδ4102˚A line for JD10, because of baseline noise (Fig. 6).
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Of the available decrements, the calculated ex- tinction for each PN are similar. These values are less than zero for JD04, JD10 and JD26, for which we were able to determine electron temperature (Te) without any correction for extinction. We cannot de- termine Te for JD28, since the [O iii]4363˚A line is too weak2.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	techniques found in the task splot for a sample number of 100 and measured rms sensitivity. This 1σ value was multiplied by 1.64 to estimate a 90% conﬁdence interval for each ﬂux density.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Table 1. Radio PN Candidates in the SMC. ∆P represents the distance between radio and optical positions. JD refers to Table 4 found in Jacoby & De Marco (2002), SMP to Sanduleak et al. (1978), J to Jacoby (1980) and N to Henize (1956). Spectral index (α) is deﬁned here as Sν ∝ να, where Sν is the ﬂux density at frequency ν.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Fig. 1. 20 cm image (beam = 7′′ × 8′′) of J004336- 730227 with 20 cm contours at 0.3 and 0.6 mJy beam−1.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Table 2. Spectral Analysis of Known Optical PNe Co-Incident with Radio Sources. Flux density is given in units of 10−14 ergs cm−2 s−1 and include 90 % conﬁdence intervals. Electron temperature (Te) and ionized mass (Mi) both assume an electron density (ne) of 103 cm−3. There is no correction for extinction.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	for the measurement of electron temperature in our case is the [O iii] forbidden line ratio3. We list elec- tron temperatures in Table 2 for each of our nebulae, based on this [O iii] ratio.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	excluded the [S ii]6717, 6731˚A lines needed to calculate electron densities, we assume a ne of 103 cm−3 for this se- lected radio sample. We base this rough value on PNe averages found in the literature (see Stanghellini & Kaler 1989) and estimate Te using the Space Telescope Science Data Analysis System task neb- ular.temden, based on an ﬁve-level atom approxi- mation from De Robertis et al. (1987).
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	where Dkpc is distance (kpc), F5 is radio ﬂux density at ∼ 5 GHz (Jy) and ne represents assumed electron density (cm−3) (Kwok 2000). Table 2 lists an ion- ized mass estimate for each PN based on the given ﬂux densities at 4.8 GHz. This implies that our se- lected radio bright objects have much higher nebular ionized mass than is typically expected.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Most observed PNe have nebular masses of only 0.3 M⊙, although the main-sequence mass of PNe progenitors can be as high as 8 M⊙ (Kwok 1994). We believe the PNe we are studying may represent a predicted “missing-mass link”, belong- ing originally to a system possessing up to an 8 M⊙ central star.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	High rates of mass loss that continue for an extended fraction of a AGB’s lifetime can allow a sig- niﬁcant fraction of the star’s mass to be accumulated. This may result in the formation of a circumstellar envelope (CSE). If the transition from the AGB to PN stage is short, then such CSEs could have a sig- niﬁcant eﬀect. Perhaps, our radio observations select for high mass PNe, since the quantity of ionized mass present appears directly related to radio ﬂux density.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Our combined observations suggest that a population of PNe in the SMC have bright radio counterparts within 2′′ of each other. These PNe have fairly typical optical spectra with the expected emission lines. Nebular electron temperatures are also within the expected range assuming an average density of 103 cm−3. Given values of radio ﬂux den- sity at ∼ 5 GHz, we suggest that the ionized nebular mass of these PNe may be 2.6 M⊙ or greater.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Figs. 5 through 8 show one-dimentional spec- tra for each PNe listed in Table 2. These spectra have fairly typically emission lines with a few excep- tions. For example, Fig. 6 shows that JD10 has a predominant [Fe iii]4881˚A line. This is unusual since the abundance of iron in PNe is scarcely studied, due to the relative faintness of observed iron emis- sion lines (Perinotto et al. 1999). Therefore, such a strong line warrants further veriﬁcation and study.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Acknowledgements – This paper uses observations made from the South African Astronomical Obser- vatory (SAAO). Travel to the SAAO was funded by Australian Government, AINSTO AMRFP proposal number 07/08-O-11. We also used the karma soft- ware package developed by the ATNF. The Australia Telescope Compact Array is part of the Australia Telescope which is funded by the Commonwealth of Australia for operation as a National Facility man- aged by CSIRO. iraf is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories, which are oper- ated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	We also note in Fig. 7 (JD26), the spectrum has a very strong emission line at 3968˚A that may represent a blend of [Ne iii] and Hǫ. In Fig. 8 (JD28), He i lines are prominent at 4026, 5876˚A in addition to a strong Balmer line at Hγ4341˚A.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Filipovi´c, M. D., Bohlsen, T., Reid, W., Staveley- Smith, L., Jones, P. A., Nohejl, K., Goldstein, G.: 2002, MNRAS, 335, 1085.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Osterbrock, D. E., Ferland, G. J.: 2006, ”Astro- physics of Gaseous Nebulae and Active Galac- tic Nuclei (second edition)”. University Sci- ence Books, Sausalito, p. 180.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Payne, J. L., Filipovi´c, M. D., Reid, W., Jones, P. A., Staveley-Smith, L, White, G. L.:2004, MN- RAS, 355, 44.
Processed_Optical_Spectra_of_Radio_Planetary_Nebulae_in_the_.txt	Perinotto, M., Bencini, C. G., Pasquali, A., Man- chado, Rodriguez Espinosa, J. M., Stanga, R.: 1999, A&A, 347, 967.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	We investigate ﬁnite-temperature transitions in SU(3) lattice gauge theories with N f = 8 and 12 staggered fermions in the fundamental representation. For both of these systems, we have observed a strongly-coupled lattice phase in which the single-site shift symmetry of the staggered action is spontaneously broken. Here we report new results for ﬁnite-temperature transitions on 243 ×12 and 323 ×16 lattice volumes, contrasting the 8- and 12-ﬂavor systems. While the N f = 12 ﬁnite-temperature transitions accumulate at the bulk transition bounding the strongly- coupled lattice phase, the N f = 8 ﬁnite-temperature transitions are able to pass through the bulk transition, and behave as expected for a QCD-like system. We discuss our current results and the work in progress to complete our investigation of the ﬁnite-temperature phase diagram.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	c(cid:13) Copyright owned by the author(s) under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Licence.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	We have since extended our investigations of the 8- and 12-ﬂavor systems through several complementary analyses, two of which (studies of the Dirac eigenmode scaling and Monte Carlo renormalization group) are discussed in other contributions to these proceedings [5, 6]. In this work we consider ﬁnite-temperature transitions in the 8- and 12-ﬂavor systems, focusing on their behav- ior around the bulk transition that separates the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase from the weak-coupling phase connected to the continuum limit. Working primarily with lattice volumes L3×Nt = 243×12 and 323×16, we observe an interesting contrast between the 8- and 12-ﬂavor systems, shown in Fig. 1. For N f = 12, the ﬁnite-temperature transitions for Nt = 12 and 16 are indistinguishable, and fall on top of the bulk transition bounding the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase. For N f = 8, the ﬁnite-temperature transitions can pass through the bulk transition, moving to weaker couplings (larger βF ) as Nt increases, in agreement with RG scaling. However, the 8-ﬂavor system behaves differently at the lightest mass we consider, m = 0.005, than at m ≥ 0.01. We discuss this situation in Section 3.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	In Section 2 we present the observables that play the most prominent role in establishing the results shown in Fig. 1. First, the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters we introduced in Ref. [1] are the most robust means to resolve the bulk transitions around the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase, for T > 0 as well as zero-temperature systems. Next, we review the validity of our procedure to improve the signal in the Polyakov loop by measuring it on RG-blocked lattices. Finally, the Dirac eigenvalue density ρ(λ ) is sensitive to the chiral properties of the system, providing additional information complementary to that from the other observables. In addition to distinguishing between chirally broken and chirally symmetric systems, we can also use ρ(λ ) to identify the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase. We conclude in Section 3 by discussing the implications of our current results, and our plans for completing this investigation.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	In these expressions (cid:3)n,µ indicates the plaquettes originating at lattice site n that include links in the µ direction; U and χ are the gauge and fermion ﬁelds, respectively; αµ (n) = (−1)∑ν<µ nν ; and the expectation value (cid:104)· · ·(cid:105)nµ even is taken only over sites whose µ component is even.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	In Ref. [1] we showed that ∆Pµ and ∆Uµ vanish in both the weak-coupling phase and the familiar chirally-broken lattice phase at strong coupling. Nonzero expectation values (in one or more directions µ) characterize the intermediate (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase where the single-site shift symmetry is spontaneously broken. Even though the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase is bounded by bulk (zero-temperature) phase transitions, we observe the same transitions in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters on the ﬁnite-temperature lattices we consider here. That is, 243×12 calculations show the same transition in ∆Pµ and ∆Uµ as do 123×24 systems, and similarly for 323×16 compared to 163×32; these results are combined in Fig. 1, labelled “L = 12/Nt = 12”, etc. Our preliminary 403×20 data reveal only the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 transition, not yet the ﬁnite-temperature transition.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Figure 2: Signals of transitions in βF with ﬁxed m = 0.01 for N f = 8 (left) and 12 (right). The solid lines correspond to 323 ×16 volumes, dotted lines to 243 ×12. The green crosses and red squares are derived from the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters sensitive to the bulk transition bounding the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase. The blue triangles are RG-blocked Polyakov loop results, one indicator of the ﬁnite-temperature deconﬁnement transition.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Polyakov loop on RG-blocked lattices. (cid:104)TrLb(cid:105) has the usual Z3 symmetry in the pure-gauge theory, and can also be thought of as an extended observable on the original, unblocked lattices.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Our RG-blocking transformation consists of two HYP smearings with α = (0.6, 0.2, 0.2), as discussed in Ref. [7]. The once-blocked (cid:104)TrL1(cid:105) is therefore equivalent to the usual Polyakov loop measured with smeared links. As the number of blocking steps increases, the effective Nt of the lattice is repeatedly halved, amplifying the signal in (cid:104)TrLb(cid:105). To check that the RG-blocked Polyakov loop behaves appropriately, we measured it on N f = 2+1 conﬁgurations made available by the HotQCD Collaboration [8]. The results in the left panel of Fig. 3 show that the RG-blocked Polyakov loop captures the same physics as the familiar observable, the only change being order- of-magnitude enhancements in the signal. At the QCD transition temperature Tc ≈ 155 MeV, the maximally-blocked Polyakov loop on these 483 ×12 lattices is (cid:104)ReTrL2(cid:105) = 0.142(1), while the unblocked value is (cid:104)ReTrL(cid:105) = 0.00188(13).
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	The right panel of Fig. 3 shows maximally-blocked Polyakov loop data for the N f = 12 system at βF = 2.7 and m = 0.01 on volumes 123×6 through 323×16. Even though the unblocked Polyakov loop on these lattices is indistinguishable from zero for Nt (cid:38) 12, the RG-blocked data indicate that the system is deconﬁned through at least Nt = 16. It is important to note that even the maximally- blocked Polyakov loop can still indicate conﬁnement: this is the case for the N f = 8 system with Nt = 16 at βF = 4.7 and m = 0.01. Fig. 2 shows that this point is on the weak-coupling side of the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase, but not yet deconﬁned.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	While investigating the 12-ﬂavor (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase in Ref. [1], we found the low-lying eigenvalues of the massless staggered Dirac operator to be a particularly striking observable. In the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase we observed a soft edge (a gap in the inﬁnite-volume extrapolation of the eigenvalue density ρ(λ )), indicating restoration of both chiral symmetry and axial U(1)A symmetry in the chiral limit. Fig. 4 shows nearly indistinguishable ρ(λ ) on four zero-temperature volumes in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase, which extrapolate to the soft edge λ0 = 0.0175(5). While a soft edge is unusual, ρ(0) = 0 also for chirally symmetric systems at high temperatures above the ﬁnite-temperature transition. Chiral symmetry breaking is characterized by ρ(0) (cid:54)= 0.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Figure 3: Left: RG-blocked Polyakov loop results from N f = 2+1 ensembles generated by the HotQCD Collaboration [8], on a log scale. The red circles are the unblocked observable, green triangles are once- blocked (i.e., smeared), and blue inverted triangles are twice-blocked. Right: Maximally-blocked Polyakov loop data for the N f = 12 system at βF = 2.7 and m = 0.01 on volumes 123×6 through 323×16.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Figure 4: The N f = 12 eigenvalue density ρ(λ ) determined from the 200 lowest-lying eigenvalues on each of four volumes in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase (βF = 2.6, m = 0.005).
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	The eigenvalue density ρ(λ ) therefore provides information about both the bulk and ﬁnite- temperature transitions. This is illustrated in Fig. 5, which presents results for the 8- and 12-ﬂavor systems with m = 0.01 on 323×16 volumes. In the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase (dotted lines), ρ(λ ) shows a steep slope for both systems, and a clear gap for N f = 12. As the coupling becomes weaker, N f = 8 moves from the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase to a chirally broken system with ρ(0) (cid:54)= 0; the transition to a chirally symmetric system only occurs at even weaker couplings around βF ≈ 4.85. For N f = 12, in contrast, we move directly from the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase to a chirally symmetric system. In both cases, ρ(λ ) agrees with the behavior of the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters and RG-blocked Polyakov loop shown in Fig. 2.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	The selected observables reviewed in the previous section are those that we ﬁnd most use- ful for identifying both the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 bulk transition (order parameters and eigenvalues) as well as the ﬁnite-temperature transitions (RG-blocked Polyakov loop and eigenvalues). The results of these investigations are shown in Fig. 1, which we now discuss in more detail.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Figure 5: Eigenvalue density ρ(λ ) for ﬁxed m = 0.01 on 323×16 volumes for N f = 8 (left) and N f = 12 (right). The dotted lines indicate βF in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	to a large value at this βF , while for N f = 8 (cid:104)TrLb(cid:105) only rises at weaker couplings. Similarly, in Fig. 5 we observe ρ(0) (cid:54)= 0 (chiral symmetry breaking) for 8-ﬂavor systems on the weak-coupling side of the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase. The 12-ﬂavor system on volumes up to 323×16 is deconﬁned and chirally symmetric (ρ(0) = 0) for all couplings weaker than the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	A puzzling feature of Fig. 1 is the different behavior of the 8-ﬂavor system at m = 0.005 compared to larger masses. For m ≥ 0.01, the change in βF between the Nt = 12 and 16 transitions is ∆βF ≈ 0.2, in rough agreement with the two-loop renormalization group prediction ∆βF ≈ 0.25. At m = 0.005 the shift is much smaller (∆βF ≈ 0.05), and the transition in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters moves the same amount instead of being volume-independent as at m ≥ 0.01.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	In Fig. 6 we show the 8-ﬂavor results at m = 0.005 for the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters, RG-blocked Polyakov loop and eigenvalue density, corresponding to that in Figs. 2 and 5 for m = 0.01. In contrast to both the 8- and 12-ﬂavor results in Fig. 2, the transition in the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters for N f = 8 at m = 0.005 moves slightly as Nt increases from 12 to 16. The rise in the RG-blocked Polyakov loop occurs at the same βF where the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameters vanish, unlike the N f = 8 panel of Fig. 2. Similarly, the m = 0.005 eigenvalue density in Fig. 6 shows no sign of chiral symmetry breaking for any βF ; it appears to move straight from the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase to a chirally symmetric system with ρ(0) ≈ 0.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	How should we interpret our N f = 8 results at m = 0.005? Fig. 1 shows that the 8-ﬂavor ﬁnite- temperature transitions occur at steadily stronger couplings as the mass decreases. At Nt = 16, for example, the transition moves from βF = 4.85 to 4.75 as the mass decreases from m = 0.015 to 0.01. We suspect that at m = 0.005, the Nt = 16 ﬁnite-temperature transition is coincidentally located close enough to the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase that it becomes entangled with the transition separating the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase from the weak-coupling phase. This seems a more modest conjecture than the alternative that the nature of the 8-ﬂavor system changes fundamentally for m ≤ 0.005 compared to m ≥ 0.01.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	We are currently generating 403×20 gauge conﬁgurations to clarify this situation, which we will discuss in a future publication. If the Nt = 16 ﬁnite-temperature transition at m = 0.005 is indeed being affected by its proximity to the (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 phase, then the corresponding Nt = 20 transition should be at weak enough coupling to scale in rough agreement with the renormalization group prediction for ∆βF , similarly to Nt = 16 at m ≥ 0.01. We are also performing 403×20 calculations for the N f = 12 system, to continue our program of directly comparing these two theories.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	Figure 6: N f = 8 results for m = 0.005. Left: (cid:0)(cid:0)S4 order parameter and RG-blocked Polyakov loop results as in Fig. 2. Right: eigenvalue density ρ(λ ) as in Fig. 5.
Processed_Bulk_and_finite-temperature_transitions_in_SU(3)_g.txt	We thank Julius Kuti for helpful comments and discussions, and are grateful to Peter Petreczky, Ron Soltz and the HotQCD Collaboration for allowing us to investigate RG-blocked observables on their gauge conﬁgurations. This research was partially supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) through Grant No. DE-FG02-04ER41290 (A. C., A. H. and D. S.) and the DOE Ofﬁce of Science Graduate Fellowship Program administered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education under Contract No. DE-AC05-06OR23100 (G. P.). Our code is based in part on the MILC Collaboration’s public lattice gauge theory software,1 and on the PReconditioned Iterative MultiMethod Eigensolver (PRIMME) package [9]. Numerical calculations were carried out on the HEP-TH and Janus clusters at the University of Colorado; at Fermilab and Jefferson Lab under the auspices of USQCD supported by the DOE SciDAC program; and at the San Diego Computing Center through XSEDE supported by National Science Foundation Grant No. OCI-1053575.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Anita Petzler,1,2 J. R. Dawson,1,2 Hiep Nguyen,3 Carl Heiles,4 M. Wardle,1 M.-Y. Lee,5,6 Claire E. Murray,7 K. L. Thompson,8 and Snežana Stanimirović9 1School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences and Research Centre in Astronomy, Astrophysics & Astrophotonics, Macquarie University, Sydney, 2109, Aus- tralia 2Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO Space & Astronomy, PO Box 76, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia 3Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, The Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2611, Australia 4Department of Astronomy, University of California, Berkeley, 601 Campbell Hall 3411, Berkeley, CA, 94720-3411, USA 5Korea Astronomy & Space Science Institute, 776 Daedeok-daero, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34055, Republic of Korea 6University of Science and Technology, 217 Gajeong-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34113, Republic of Korea 7Department of Physics & Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N. Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA, NSF Astronomy & Astrophysics Postdoc- toral Fellow 8Davidson College, Davidson, NC, 28115, USA 9Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA Author for correspondence: Anita Petzler, Email: [email protected].
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Abstract We present observations of the four 2Π3/2 J = 3/2 ground-rotational state transitions of the hydroxyl molecule (OH) along 107 lines of sight both in and out of the Galactic plane: 92 sets of observations from the Arecibo telescope and 15 sets of observations from the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA). Our Arecibo observations included oﬀ-source pointings, allowing us to measure excitation temperature (Tex) and optical depth, while our ATCA observations give optical depth only. We perform Gaussian decomposition using the Automated Molecular Excitation Bayesian line-ﬁtting Algorithm ‘AMOEBA’ (Petzler, Dawson, and Wardle 2021) ﬁtting all four transitions simultaneously with shared centroid velocity and width. We identify 109 features across 38 sightlines (including 58 detections along 27 sightlines with excitation temperature measurements). While the main lines at 1665 and 1667 MHz tend to have similar excitation temperatures (median \|∆Tex(main)\| = 0.6 K, 84% show \|∆Tex(main)\| < 2 K), large diﬀerences in the 1612 and 1720 MHz satellite line excitation temperatures show that the gas is generally not in LTE. For a selection of sightlines we compare our OH features to associated (on-sky and in velocity) HI cold gas components (CNM) identiﬁed by Nguyen et al. (2019) and ﬁnd no strong correlations. We speculate that this may indicate an eﬀective decoupling of the molecular gas from the CNM once it accumulates.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	bach 1985b, 1985a; van Dishoeck and Black 1988; Wolﬁre, Hollenbach, and McKee 2010; Glover and Mac Low 2011; Glover and Smith 2016) even when hydrogen exists primar- ily as H2because of its higher self-shielding threshold com- pared to that of H2. In the local ISM the extinction threshold for H2 to form is AV ≥ 0.14 mag, but CO requires AV ≥ 0.8 mag (Wolﬁre, Hollenbach, and McKee 2010), so CO is typically photo-dissociated by external UV radiation (Tie- lens and Hollenbach 1985b; van Dishoeck and Black 1988; Wolﬁre, Hollenbach, and McKee 2010; Glover and Mac Low 2011; Glover and Smith 2016). On the other hand, in low number density molecular environments (e.g. nH (cid:46) 10–2 cm–3 as found by Busch et al. 2019, in the region of Persius) that do contain CO, the CO may not be suﬃciently excited to be de- tectable due to its relatively high critical density.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Most OH molecules in the diﬀuse ISM are expected to be found in the 2Π3/2 J = 3/2 ground state (see Fig. 1) which is split into 4 levels via lambda doubling and hyperﬁne split- ting. There are four allowed transitions between these levels: the ‘main’ lines at 1665.402 and 1667.359 MHz, and the ‘satel- lite’ lines at 1612.231 and 1720.530 MHz (e.g. Destombes et al. 1977).
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Figure 1. Energy level diagram of the 2Π3/2, J = 3/2 ground state of hy- droxyl. The ground state is split into four levels due to Λ-doubling and hy- perﬁne splitting, with 4 allowed transitions between these levels: the ‘main’ lines at 1665.402 and 1667.359 MHZ, and the ‘satellite’ lines at 1612.231 and 1720.530 MHz. Figure from Petzler, Dawson, and Wardle (2020).
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	tive excitation into the ﬁrst-excited 2Π3/2 J = 5/2 rotational state, for instance, will tend to cascade back into the ground state into its F = 2 levels more often than its F = 1 levels, while the opposite is true for cascades from the second-excited rotational level (Elitzur, Goldreich, and Scoville 1976). In most cases these cascade mechanisms will be responsible for the majority of the divergence from equal populations seen in the levels of the ground-rotational state (M. Elitzur 1992). This implies that the ground-rotational state transitions be- tween levels with diﬀerent F quantum numbers (i.e. the satel- lite lines) will often have excitation temperatures that diﬀer widely from one another and from those of the main lines. In contrast, the main lines – which involve transitions between levels with the same F quantum numbers – will tend to have excitation temperatures similar to one another and to the ki- netic temperature.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Figure 2. Schematic of the three lowest rotational states of OH, indicating their Λ and hyperﬁne splitting. Excitations above the 2Π3/2, J = 3/2 ground state will cascade back down to it via the 2Π3/2, J = 5/2 state, or the 2Π1/2, J = 1/2 state. Allowable transitions are those where parity is changed and \|∆F\| = 1, 0; shown in blue at left and red on the schematic. The en- ergy scale is given at left in kelvin, and the wavelengths of the IR transitions are shown at centre in µm. The splittings of the Λ and hyperﬁne levels are greatly exaggerated for clarity. Figure from Petzler, Dawson, and War- dle (2020).
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	lambda-doublet by a radiation ﬁeld that diverges signiﬁcantly from a Planck distribution (i.e. from hot dust M. Elitzur 1978) or by collisional excitations from particles whose motions di- verge signiﬁcantly from a Maxwellian distribution (i.e. from particle ﬂows M. Elitzur 1979). In general, since the main lines tend to be seen in their LTE ratio more often than the satellite lines, we may therefore conclude that the conditions required to create this imbalance in cascade pathways is less common in the ISM than those responsible for the satellite-line anomalies. This, coupled with the fact that for practical reasons many researchers observe only the stronger main lines of OH (e.g. Li et al. 2018; Nguyen et al. 2018; Engelke and Allen 2018), has led researchers in the ﬁeld of diﬀuse OH studies to describe the excitation of the OH via the idea of so-called ‘main-line LTE’ – where the main lines have excitation consistent with LTE – as evidenced most often by the ratio of their optical depths (τpeak(1667)/τpeak(1665) = 1.8 in LTE) or brightness temperatures (Tb(1667)/Tb(1667) = 1.8 in the optically thin limit and = 1 in the optically thin limit in LTE). Many works (e.g. Li et al. 2018; Rugel et al. 2018; Yan et al. 2017; Ebisawa et al. 2019; Engelke and Allen 2019) then report the degree to which the main lines do or do not obey this relationship.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	It is often – though not always – the case (as these works clearly show) that the main-line optical depths or brightness temperatures have a ratio consistent with LTE within the ob- servational uncertainties, and their excitation temperatures are often very similar. However, if the satellite lines are also ob- served, it is then quite clear that they do not exhibit the same ‘LTE-like’ behaviour (e.g. Ebisawa et al. 2015; Ebisawa et al. 2019; Xu et al. 2016; Petzler, Dawson, and Wardle 2020; Dawson et al. 2014; Rugel et al. 2018; van Langevelde et al. 1995; Frayer, Seaquist, and Frail 1998). The nature of this diver- gence from LTE (i.e. the relationship between satellite-line excitation temperatures or the presence of population inver- sions) can then provide additional valuable information about the conditions of the gas that may otherwise not be appar- ent if only the main lines were considered (Petzler, Dawson, and Wardle 2020). In this work we examine all four ground- rotational transitions and explore the relationships between their optical depth ratios and diﬀerences in their excitation temperatures.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	is the Einstein-A coeﬃcient and φ(ν) is the line where Aul proﬁle. If both optical depth and excitation temperature can be determined for a given transition, we may then calculate the column densities in both the upper and lower levels of that transition. Since the four ground-rotational transitions share four levels, a minimum of two transitions are needed to fully characterise the excitation of the ground-rotational state. This excitation is a function of the local environment of the gas which may be parameterised through use of (or ref- erence to) non-LTE molecular excitation modelling (e.g. Xu et al. 2016; Ebisawa et al. 2019; Petzler, Dawson, and Wardle 2020).
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	As we will describe further in the Observations section, we have observations of this type (which we refer to as ‘on- oﬀ’ observations) from the Arecibo radio telescope toward 92 compact extragalactic continuum sources. These data include 8 spectra per sightline: one optical depth and one expected brightness temperature for each of the four ground-rotational transitions of OH.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	The degeneracy between optical depth and excitation tem- perature can also be broken by observing bright compact back- ground continuum sources with an interferometer – and thus rendering the Tex and Tbg terms in Eq. 1 insigniﬁcant. The reason for this is twofold: ﬁrst, the emission from the extended OH in the intervening cloud and the diﬀuse background con- tinuum are assumed to be smooth on the sky and large com- pared to the interference fringes of the interferometer, so that the ﬂux detected from both will be negligible. Additionally, if Tc (cid:29) \|Tex\| (which is likely to be the case if a bright compact background continuum source is targeted) then the Tc term will dominate Eq. 1, and the observed brightness tempera- –τν – 1), even if some ture will be well-described by Tb = Tc(e ﬂux from the extended cloud is detected. We have observa- tions of this type from the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) towards 15 bright compact continuum sources in the Galactic plane. These data only include 4 spectra per sightline; since the observing strategy rendered the Tex and Tbg terms in Eq. 1 insigniﬁcant we are unable to construct an expected brightness temperature spectrum, and only have optical depth spectra for each transition.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	The individual features in these OH spectra will be broad- ened by mostly Gaussian processes (turbulent or thermal broad- ening, e.g. Leung and Liszt 1976; H. Liszt 2001). Other sources of broadening that are not Gaussian also contribute to the line proﬁle (i.e. natural and collisional broadening – both Lorentzian in shape) but are assumed to have negligible con- tribution to the feature shape. A single telescope pointing will tend to detect several blended Gaussian-shaped features aris- ing from the same transition at diﬀerent line-of-sight veloci- ties. In our analysis these Gaussian-shaped proﬁles are inter- preted as individual isothermal clouds along the line of sight: each cloud may then be expected to result in a feature with the same centroid velocity and full width at half-maximum (FWHM) in all the observed spectra (8 in the case of on-oﬀ observations, 4 if only optical depth spectra are obtained).
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	state transitions. Further details about our usage of AMOEBA are given in the Method practicalities and limitations section.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	OH and HI cold neutral medium In this work we will compare our OH data with published measurements of the atomic HI gas. In pressure equilibrium, most of the HI is expected to reside in two distinct thermal phases (Field, Goldsmith, and Habing 1969; McKee and Os- triker 1977; Wolﬁre et al. 1995; Wolﬁre et al. 2003): the warm neutral medium (WNM) at temperatures of several thousand kelvin, and the cold neutral medium (CNM) at temperatures at or below ∼ 100 K for typical pressure ranges found in the Galaxy (e.g. Dickey, Salpeter, and Terzian 1978; Heiles and Troland 2003b; Jenkins and Tripp 2011; Murray et al. 2018; Nguyen et al. 2019; Murray, Peek, and Kim 2020). It is gener- ally accepted that, in cool regions of the ISM (like the CNM) molecular hydrogen forms primarily on dust grains (McCrea and McNally 1960; Gould and Salpeter 1963; Hollenbach, Werner, and Salpeter 1971), and can accumulate once it is suﬃciently shielded from dissociating UV. This is not a uni- directional process, as matter can cycle back and forth from one stable phase to another (Ostriker, McKee, and Leroy 2010), and the phases (WNM, CNM and H2) are generally mixed (Goldsmith et al. 2009). Therefore, one might expect the properties of the molecular gas (as traced here by OH) to maintain some relationship to the CNM gas from which it presumably formed.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	This work utilises two distinct sets of OH observations. The ﬁrst is a collection of observations toward 92 compact back- ground continuum sources obtained through the GNOMES (Galactic Neutral Opacity and Molecular Excitation Survey) collaboration taken by the Arecibo telescope. The second set are observations towards 15 bright, compact continuum sources in the region of the Southern Parkes Large Area Sur- vey in Hydroxyl (SPLASH, Dawson et al. 2014) made with the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA). The loca- tions of all sightlines examined in this work are shown in Fig. 3.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Figure 3. Positions of sightlines examined in this work from the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA), and from the projects a2600, a2769 and a3301 from the Arecibo telescope. Sightlines with detections are indicated by ﬁlled circles, non-detections are indicated by crosses. Sightlines excluded from analysis are indicated by triangles. The grey-scale image is CO emission (Dame, Hartmann, and Thaddeus 2001) and is included for illustrative purposes only.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Arecibo observations Our observations from the Arecibo telescope obtained through the GNOMES collaboration are comprised of data from three projects: a2600 (Thompson, Troland, and Heiles 2019), a2769 (Nguyen et al. 2019) and a3301. This data set consists of on- oﬀ spectra of the four OH ground-rotational transitions to- ward 92 sightlines in the Arecibo sky. These sightlines are listed in Table 1 along with their sensitivities in optical depth and expected brightness temperature (quantiﬁed by the rms noise of the individual spectra) for each transition. As can be seen in Fig. 3 the majority of these sightlines were out of the Galactic Plane. The angular resolution of the Arecibo tele- scope at the frequency of the OH ground-rotational transi- tions is ∼ 3(cid:48).5.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	The aim of project a2600 (PI Thompson) was to use Zee- man splitting of the OH ground-rotational state transitions to measure magnetic ﬁeld strengths in the envelopes of molec- ular clouds. The targets for this project were compact ex- tragalactic continuum sources chosen from the National Ra- dio Astronomy Observatory Very Large Array Sky Survey (NVSS Condon et al. 1998) with brightness Sν (cid:38) 0.5 Jy be- hind molecular clouds identiﬁed from CO emission maps (Dame, Hartmann, and Thaddeus 2001). This project targeted re- gions of the inner and outer Galaxy, and includes sightlines passing through molecular clouds with low-mass star forma- tion (e.g. Taurus) and high-mass star formation (e.g. Mon OB1) mostly near the Galactic plane. Observations were made both on- and oﬀ-source, allowing optical depth and expected brightness temperature spectra to be produced following the method of Heiles and Troland (2003a). The 16 oﬀ-source pointings were arranged as illustrated in Fig. 4. This pattern of oﬀ-source pointings was also used in the other projects out- lined in this section. We have observations towards 12 sight- lines from this project.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	Figure 4. Offsets (in degrees) of off-source pointings (blue circles) in RA and Dec in terms of the telescope half-power beam width (HPBW) relative to the on-source pointing (black cross). The 16 off-source pointings are placed at distances of 1 and 2 times the HPBW in the four cardinal directions and in directions rotated 45◦ from these as shown.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	galactic continuum sources in the Taurus, California, Rosette, Mon OB1 and NGC 2264 giant molecular clouds. Their con- tinuum sources were also selected from the NVSS catalog and have typical ﬂux densities of Sν (cid:38) 0.6 Jy at 1.4 GHz. Our data include observations towards 73 sightlines from this project. The aim of project a3301 (PI Petzler) was to follow up lines of sight observed in previous projects included in the GNOMES collaboration that showed ‘anomalous excitation’: this generally involved interesting patterns of emission and absorption across the available transitions. Most of these were chosen because not all four transitions had been observed in the original project. These sightlines will therefore be biased towards anomalous excitation, but due to poor data quality in some of the 1720 MHz spectra, only 6 of the 16 sightlines observed in that project were included in this work.
Processed_GNOMES_II:_Analysis_of_the_Galactic_diffuse_molecu.txt	ATCA observations Our ATCA data (taken under project code C2976) include sightlines towards 15 bright compact continuum sources se- lected from the 843 MHz Molongo Galactic Plane Survey cat- alogue (MGPS, Murphy et al. 2007), the Southern Galactic Plane Survey (SGPS, Haverkorn et al. 2006) and the NVSS 1.4 GHz continuum images. All sources were cross-checked against the recombination line measurements of Caswell and Haynes (1987) in order to discriminate between HII regions and other source types, and were also examined for evidence of HI absorption in SGPS datacubes in order to conﬁrm near- or far-side Galactic distances where relevant. Bright, compact sources (unresolved or with suﬃcient unresolved structure at a beam size of ∼ 30(cid:48)(cid:48)) were chosen, located between 332◦ < l < 8◦, \|b\| < 2.1◦ to match the region mapped in the Southern Parkes Large Area Survey of Hydroxyl (SPLASH Dawson et al. 2022). Sources with a spectral ﬂux density ∼ 1 Jy at 1.6 GHz were preferred, which would result in brightness tem- peratures of ∼ 500 K when observed with our array conﬁg- uration (ATCA 1.5D, excluding antenna 6). Distant sources were considered preferable as they probe a larger number of absorbing components along the line of sight. However, the number of extragalactic and far-side Galactic sources with suﬃcient ﬂux density and compact structure was small. There- fore the target criteria were expanded to include nearside HII re- gions with evidence for bright and compact substructure and intervening HI absorption.

Subsets and Splits

No saved queries yet

Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.