discourse_id
stringlengths
12
12
essay_id
stringlengths
12
12
discourse_text
stringlengths
4
4.1k
discourse_type
stringclasses
7 values
discourse_effectiveness
stringclasses
3 values
1718026053ef
793517BB1BB3
Third, dispose your time is the best way to live. If you can walk, you able to go to schools, so the option attend classes at home is not for you to choose, it is not benefit for you,
Claim
Adequate
aa06ef4224b3
793517BB1BB3
I am just agree with the people who not able to move or stuck of something about personal to take classes at home, in that way, they can get information and study like other people. So I think that is fair for everyone, don't just give student an option like that and it will turning them to be lazy, busy working or don't have enough time in schools.
Evidence
Adequate
e031948bce03
793517BB1BB3
If necessary, student can take online after schools to complete anything they miss.
Counterclaim
Adequate
bece63bed522
793517BB1BB3
Finally, I think we should put the option about the classes online for only the people who are not able to go any where, not for normal people. In that way we can balance between these two, and every student can study in the better way.
Claim
Ineffective
9688f791d9fc
793517BB1BB3
In conclusion, benefit or not benefit are depend on you, for me the option to take classes at home is not benefit, because I always want to come to schools everyday to get experience for myself, to get new things and meet new people. And you should go that way like me, we young and we hold our future in our hand, don't just stay passive. 
Concluding Statement
Adequate
796ac8fef755
79662DEC0A1B
Students can get benefit from being able to attend class from home
Position
Adequate
82cce0504acc
79662DEC0A1B
When they take online class they start thinking much.
Evidence
Adequate
2bfe89dc04ac
79662DEC0A1B
Students get more free time to do online class at home.
Claim
Adequate
76143c232867
79662DEC0A1B
They being prefect and smart. I prefer to take online class because it's much easier than taking school
Evidence
Adequate
dea882559721
79662DEC0A1B
When I take class in school i can not focus that much because to many students yelling at class
Claim
Adequate
a010edf16dad
79662DEC0A1B
So taking online class is better. Students develop their studying skill and more knowledge.
Claim
Adequate
3423b980bc08
79662DEC0A1B
Although, taking class in school isn't that much bad but student can't concentrate at class.
Claim
Adequate
85a82fd8930c
79662DEC0A1B
When they take in class they start taking with friends they stop focusing on class. ,Nevertheless, Being taking online class at home important to develop knowledge. Gain smart. Gain perfect. Seeking to know more. being work harder. Because, Students being focus only on online class. Nobody yell at him he can concentrate and also he can think very well. Being gain smart. And Students will have confidence on their self. I have online class thins year. I am seeking to do more than I do on class. That's makes me have confidence in myself. I can do by myself.
Evidence
Adequate
0aafb1312a59
79662DEC0A1B
To began, Taking Online class at home is help to take students time.
Claim
Adequate
134fc7f67f8f
79662DEC0A1B
They will finish early and they start doing another stuff. Students can get more opportunity to do better job. Student should have opportunity to take online class and Done with their work and have time to rest. Being happy. Being smart.
Evidence
Ineffective
7cce6faad959
79662DEC0A1B
For example, When students before taking online class they pay for it. So they will take care of about the subject.
Claim
Ineffective
a59d3f356a77
79662DEC0A1B
However, Students have time to study. When he study at home, the place is quit that can he focus in studying, then he will be smart and good thinker. When you do by yourself you will have much confidence. Being confidence by yourself. Being Good thinker. Being work harder. Being developing skill of studying and developing knowledge.
Evidence
Ineffective
1bc05cdb18dd
79662DEC0A1B
This for that, Taking online class help you get more knowledge and skills
Claim
Adequate
3ac28fa332de
79662DEC0A1B
If students study a lot they can do better. they start seeking to understand about that class. They will be focus on that and getting good grade. Some people thinking taking online class is bored but isn't bored if you try to know something about what you are studying you will be loved it. Instead of wasting time taking online class at home. That is student can get benefit.
Evidence
Adequate
f6a0ff506ecf
79662DEC0A1B
Clearly, The way of taking class at home can save your time.
Claim
Adequate
0d96ab7fa204
79662DEC0A1B
Students know what to do so, If they want to take their time, online class is one of the best way to take their time. If I start taking online class I will save my time on the other hand I develop my knowledge. Fixing The way of i'm studying before. Most students are hated studying at home. They don't want to studying at home. Instead of studying they prefer to play games. But, If they have online class they starting study and they will fix their problem. That is better way to improve skills. Students become work hard and study hard. They will get good job.
Evidence
Ineffective
a4a7d9dc0d91
79662DEC0A1B
This provide that, Being though full. Smart. genius. work hard and believe in your self. They starting believe in their self. That is make students proud. They start thinking to do more. If you study a lot on online class you will do a lot. That is the way of improve knowledge. Also you could do any test. you won't afraid any tests. To change the way to you study. Online class helps you study more and also, help to having experience.
Evidence
Ineffective
850f5930f953
79662DEC0A1B
Obviously, Online class can provide your problems
Claim
Ineffective
09c397349f0e
79662DEC0A1B
If you senor you want to graduate this year but you didn't finish your credits, So the best way is that you can take online class which is you have to take to graduate this year. Then you will graduate. Online class can save your time. Gain perfect. Being develop skill. To be a good thinker. To avoid bored of study. Also, online class can help you to fix your problems. Students become thoughtful.
Evidence
Adequate
e294442c54fd
79662DEC0A1B
In conclusion, Students can get benefit from being able to attend class from home. Improve the way of studying. Instead of playing game study online class. Students being thoughtful and work Harding. Being taking online class at home important to develop your skills of studying. When you take online class you will save your time. gain smart. Nobody can bother you when you take online class at home. you will better than that you did on class. Students will get better grade. If you study on online you will get better and you will believe in yourself.         
Concluding Statement
Adequate
2686621cc2cf
7A532625FFDC
Have you ever been so uneasy with your choice that you've even question yourself or at the most ask some one else about it. For example you've ran into a question that you couldn't exactly make your mind up, so you go to a friend or a family member and ask for their advice. Well this all ties into asking others for their opinions or helping you make a better choice then what you originally going pick or decide to go with.
Lead
Adequate
7a3860bcc7e0
7A532625FFDC
It's good to have multiple opinions,
Position
Adequate
164d0850fb09
7A532625FFDC
somethings need to be heard by other people who care and possible can lead you to the right direction from the choice that you were going to make in the first place.
Claim
Effective
cad2ea8f7755
7A532625FFDC
Some opinions can just out right be for entertainment purposes, it can also be for very important things that need to be taken very seriously like school, work places, and many more.
Claim
Adequate
71c6f4545af1
7A532625FFDC
You should always seek another persons point of view or even advice because sometimes they may have a very valid point or a reasonable opinion.
Claim
Effective
d199df2c21dc
7A532625FFDC
For example you just got a new book from Target, a lot of your friends have had the same book for a couple of months now and so has your mother. The first person you asked was your mother, you ask, "I've been wanting to read this new book for months and you're one of the best person to ask since you've just finished reading it." Your mother replies in a gloomy tone,"To be very honest with you, I did not enjoy the book that much. The plot was very confusing and I also didn't understand the theme of the book that well." The next day you go to school and you ask your best friend Generic_Name, " I need your opinion on the book Drama that I just got." Generic_Name answered with excitement, "It was a very interesting book, i'd read it a million times if I could. Every detail in the book was absolutely amazing, the pictures that were apart of the comic were brightly colored and beautiful." During lunch you ask for friend Generic_Name how she felt about the book. She politely responded with, "I didn't find that book as interesting as many people did. It had beautiful pictures but other then that it was kind of boring to be honest with you."
Evidence
Adequate
83f4ff16fcb6
7A532625FFDC
that is a slight way of how a real conversation would go if you really did need a opinion like that. Just be mindful that some people may say very ignorant things that have nothing to do with anything that you asked them about.    
Concluding Statement
Ineffective
9154f79ce211
7B751C9BE162
When you are seeking for advice, why do you often find yourself asking multiple people for their opinions? What is so beneficial about asking multiple people for their opinions on a topic they may not know much about? How does it help you make a better choice?
Lead
Adequate
6c3d2859ba93
7B751C9BE162
When seeking for advice is can be about anything, family, friends or just general decision making. Let's come up with an example, Generic_Name was friends with a group of kids since childhood, she starts to lose touch with them and realizes how much she needed them in her life but she doesn't know how to approach them or talk to them anymore. she decides to ask her older brother for advice, he tells her that she shouldn't even try but if she really wanted to then she should "just be straight up with them". Her brother only says this because he dislikes some of Generic_Name's friends and finds them annoying. She doesn't really like that idea so she decides to ask someone else for their opinion
Evidence
Effective
f07a170fb6c5
7B751C9BE162
The way everyone problem solves and views things is different, not everyone has the same mindset which is why its important to hear multiple point of views.
Claim
Effective
96fac1a4a902
7B751C9BE162
When someone knows less about a situation it is sometimes better because they see everything from an outside perspective creating a less bias opinion or neutral opinion. When you ask multiple different people for advice on one topic, you are searching for a general opinion/ idea or a pattern in what people have to say to then influence your decision. If you chose not hear from a few people one persons opinion may be bias and can heavily influence your decision in a good or bad way
Evidence
Effective
db61554e21a3
7B751C9BE162
Hearing many different sides can help you come to a better conclusion of your own because you can then weigh out the pros and cons of your situation
Claim
Effective
6aaa184d99ed
7B751C9BE162
Everyone's point of view will be different like that of your 13 year old friend who is your age and knows you very personally or of your 72 year old grandmother. Your friend may know you well but your grandmother has lived longer as has possibly experienced the same things you are currently experiencing. Each has its own benefit and can help add onto your thought process.
Evidence
Effective
6c3cd5ec0bdb
7B751C9BE162
It also imperative to look at all angles of your situation because you may not being seeing important factors that can help you problem solve that someone else may see.
Claim
Effective
306d96844402
7B751C9BE162
there are many reasons as to why should always ask more than one person when seeking for advice on an issue.
Position
Adequate
631e16234b7c
7B751C9BE162
Not only will you be building your knowledge on how to deal with those kind of situations but you are also learning how to put together ideas to form your own. Asking multiple people will push you to think more and create a well thought out plan. You also learn not rely on one specific person just in case their opinion is bias when it comes to a certain topic. That is why I believe that seeking advice from multiple people can help you make a better choice.
Concluding Statement
Effective
967370367c3e
7D5D980FD05F
Some schools offer distance learning as an option for students to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing. This allows students to learn in the comfort of their own home, without having to transport to a private, or public school. This may be convienent for parents who work on a busy schedule, allowing them to choose when and where they want their chilldren to learn. Although online schooling my be beneficial to some children, it may harm their future.
Lead
Effective
1102dccc6b70
7D5D980FD05F
With this being said, students would not benefit from being able to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing
Position
Effective
9c239e1f5c6e
7D5D980FD05F
they wouldn't develop social skills
Claim
Effective
60391b4aa2c4
7D5D980FD05F
they would have a hard time creating relationships with others
Claim
Effective
ccc73cbb1b34
7D5D980FD05F
they may struggle from lack of motivation and depression.
Claim
Effective
c9cfd337840a
7D5D980FD05F
To grow as an individual, it is essential to surround oneself with others. This is because it allows individuals to develop skills that may make or break their future. These skills are called social skills, and they should be developed as a child. Social skills are important for student development because it allows them to communicate with the people surrounding them on an every day basis
Evidence
Effective
f7700ac832e0
7D5D980FD05F
Schools were intended to bring students together, allowing communication with one another, which is why it is so important for students to learn in grow in schools that are not online.
Claim
Effective
851a4d540f09
7D5D980FD05F
Social skills may also be one of the biggest things a student can learn in school, and this is something that online schooling does not offer. Communicating with one another will allow students to work and learn together, creating relationships on the way. If students are not surrounded by others, they will have a difficult time creating relationships and friendships with others.
Evidence
Effective
0ae41abf0dd3
7D5D980FD05F
Relationships play a huge role in almost everyone's life. Whether their romantic, family oriented, or friendships, they are an important way to grow as an individual. Students who attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing may find it difficult to create relationships that are not family oriented because they are not surrounded by other students every day. While students who attend online school are in the comfort of their own home, students that attend schools outside of their home are comforted by the people surrounding them
Evidence
Effective
f5d8321e8a16
7D5D980FD05F
This is why students who attend school outside of their home have a major advantage, which is developing relationships.
Claim
Effective
420f761c32de
7D5D980FD05F
Students will also get a sense of who they are and what they like when engaging and developing relationships with other students, which students who take school online will not be able to do. Most students find joy in creating relationships with others, so they are excited to wake up every morning for school. Those who aren't able to create bonds with others may lack that motivation to get up every morning, which may take a toll on their mental health.
Evidence
Effective
1a60a22a97d2
7D5D980FD05F
Students who attend school beyond the comfort of their own household may have more motivation to get out of bed every morning than those who take school online
Claim
Effective
e8c1c8c6fe18
7D5D980FD05F
This is because the students who are enrolled in schools may look forward to getting out of the house and seeing their friends every morning, while the students who are enrolled in online schooling have to stay in, isolated from things beyond their household. This may cause harm on the mental health of the students taking school online because they may feel excluded from the world around them. Feeling excluded from the world around them may place a sense of loneless in their life, which may lead to depression. Students should be surrounded by others as they grow so they can maintain a healthy mental state, and be happy.
Evidence
Effective
deb308358aaf
7D5D980FD05F
Critics may argue that online schooling has a positive impact on students because if they learn in an enviorment that they feel most comfortable in, then they will be able to absorb more information on a daily basis. They may also say that it is more managable for busy students, and that they can work their schedules around education.
Counterclaim
Effective
e3fa33d4642c
7D5D980FD05F
However, students who learn at home all their life will suffer from a lack social skills, and will have a hard time fitting in in the real world.
Rebuttal
Effective
4d10a9815988
7D5D980FD05F
This will cause them to have a major disadvantage from the students because they will have a difficlut time communicating with the people around them, which will definately have an impact on their future.
Evidence
Adequate
6a11e0bffd39
7D5D980FD05F
Students would not benefit from being able to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing because they wouldn't develop social skills, they would have a hard time creating relationships with others, and they may struggle from lack of motivation and depression.
Concluding Statement
Effective
27f19f80c606
7E8238B5BA1C
Some people would say that it is the heavy cost of a social life to take classes online instead of going to a traditional brick and mortar school. They believe that by taking online classes, people are less equipped in dealing with face-to-face interactions in the real world when the time comes. However, these people also fail to consider that there are flaws in brick and mortar schools which can burden those who prefer an option of taking classes online instead. Although some may believe otherwise
Lead
Effective
2195e239dde9
7E8238B5BA1C
it would heavily benefit students to be able to attend classes at home
Position
Adequate
e3902b5a2e3e
7E8238B5BA1C
there are some people who prefer not being in a physical classroom
Claim
Adequate
0041edef2bdb
7E8238B5BA1C
there are less cases of missing class from emergencies
Claim
Adequate
09880c44c277
7E8238B5BA1C
there are more flexibilities given to students.
Claim
Adequate
96017ac99ce9
7E8238B5BA1C
One reason why students would benefit to attend classes from home is if they have limited social skills and they are not comfortable with vocally situating themselves in a physical classroom.
Claim
Effective
f9cf5dc41fae
7E8238B5BA1C
A personal situation which displays this is my cousin Generic_Name, who decided to take online classes starting his first year of middle school due to his severe anxiety since 4th grade which made it hard for him to interact with other students since he was younger. His anxiety also impacted him since it became more difficult with concentrating and asking for guidance from teachers, in fear of them judging him for it. However, after finishing his first year of online school, Generic_Name had claimed that by taking his courses online, he felt more comfortable in pursuing help from his teachers in courses he struggled with and concentrate without thinking about the impending presence of other students. If Generic_Name had not taken online courses for his schooling and had gone to a brick and mortar school instead, he would have felt more miserable since that was where he would have been forced to have physical interactions in order to resolve his academic problems and the stress it brought to him would also hinder his ability to learn.
Evidence
Effective
45c555d6b905
7E8238B5BA1C
Another reason why it would positively impact students to take online courses from the comfort of their homes is because there are less likely scenarios of a student missing their classes from any kind of emergency.
Claim
Effective
29917fa6ac66
7E8238B5BA1C
A case which exemplies this is from another cousin, named Generic_Name, who is currently taking his school courses online admist the epidemic of the corona virus. The corona virus, which wildly spread in his hometown of Generic_City, prompted his school district to take measures in making students continue their academic courses online without the risk of exploiting students in schools where a virus is likely to spread. By making the decision for students to continue classes through online means instead, there are less chances of Generic_Name's school district of possibly extending the school year to make up for all missed days. Without the option of being able to attend classes from home, both Alex and his school district would have been negatively affected by the epidemic from possible delays in schools to a higher chance of catching the virus.
Evidence
Effective
92006878e877
7E8238B5BA1C
Another person who illustrates why attending online courses prevents missing class for emergencies is from a situation my childhood friend Generic_Name had two years ago, when her older sister Generic_Name, who lived in Generic_City, got into a heavy car accident and Generic_Name and her single mother sponantiously made plans to go visit her since Generic_Name could not stay home alone. However, since Generic_Name had been taking her academic courses online, it did not make it hard for her to catch up on her work because all she really needed was a computer and there was no need for her to be in a physical classroom to participate. By being able to take her classes by ways of online, Generic_Name's school work did not heavily interfer with the sudden emergency and she had the flexibility of doing her work no matter where she was.
Evidence
Effective
5e6e51984b6e
7E8238B5BA1C
Lastly, it would be beneficial for students to be able to take classes online because it gives more flexability to students with a busy personal life.
Claim
Effective
fbd1ffb6ee5e
7E8238B5BA1C
For instance, Emma Chamberlain, a popular YouTuber known for her witty persona, had dicussed in a video that she decided to take her junior high school year through online classes because she wanted to focus on her rising career. Her decision to do so was very intelligible in the end, given the fact that she mainly filmed videos throughout the day and frequently traveled across the U.S. due to job opportunites and sponserships from brands. Without the flexibility given to her from online classes, Emma would not be able to do what she constantly does today which would mean having less time in being able to film her videos and seeking out her passions of being a prominent figure in YouTube.
Evidence
Effective
0314b702eecf
7E8238B5BA1C
Another person who illustrates this is my same friend Generic_Name, who had a demanding part time job at a cafe during the morning of school weekdays in order to finacially support her family. Since she took her academic courses online, she was able to have a flexible shift and work for longer hours because there was no given time that she had to be present in class. If she had not been doing school through online means, it would not have been possible for her to take on the job at an hour where most students are actively learning in school.
Evidence
Effective
5a6f7ac28088
7E8238B5BA1C
Although some people make it seem taboo that attending classes online is an option a person would rather take than a tradional school,
Counterclaim
Adequate
8d65980c1af3
7E8238B5BA1C
there are clearly a lot of positive aspects of deciding on taking one's classes online.
Rebuttal
Adequate
982d47a04058
7E8238B5BA1C
By choosing to not take a traditional school, an individual is able to focus more than just their academic life and able to take on more opportunites that most likely would not be given if it were not for this barrier. Also, attending classes online pushes a person on being more independent because it is ultimately all on them to juggle with their own academic and personal life. Although attending classes online might not be for everyone, it goes to show that there are many benefits one can take from it.
Concluding Statement
Effective
6b6550ccc6c1
7E9D8E4921CD
Do you think student would benefit from being able to attend classes from home?.
Lead
Adequate
0125213fbef8
7E9D8E4921CD
First attend classes at home they can benefit for student
Position
Adequate
1ca4cee052ec
7E9D8E4921CD
they can have fun and do thing's what they like on the free time,and doing. thing to have fun and be happy that is one benefit for students to be at home.
Claim
Adequate
76e165e22896
7E9D8E4921CD
the most thing to have fun with the family and something they can do like homework during at home or study for the test that is one thing that they can benefit for the student.
Evidence
Ineffective
dff5f7b1c30e
7E9D8E4921CD
the next they can't benefit attend at home because they must has to go every day at school and if student don't go to school they will have bad grade on class and all classes attend is the most important in the school.
Claim
Ineffective
b7d9f6b328fa
7E9D8E4921CD
attend classes from home they can't benefit at school and they can't benefit for student because tha is one of the most important rule the all school has and they must has to go to school.
Evidence
Ineffective
51e8e5969d8e
7E9D8E4921CD
Finally student would benefit from being able to attend classes from home that they can benefit like doing working on internet and also they can' benefit for student because they must has to go every day at school
Claim
Ineffective
c041287ff663
7E9D8E4921CD
that is one of the rule of school studen must being on the school,and them if the student don't go to the school they will get travel for be missin the school and they will have bad grade
Evidence
Ineffective
3e67d2a1cec8
7E9D8E4921CD
something they can benefit for student to be at home they can have fun with they family and play voideo games and they can do what they like more to be at home.
Evidence
Adequate
59b5d4fa7674
80889A79B329
I know for a fact that when I need advice for something I ask a couple members of my family so I get more advice. Have you ever needed advice? Well if you haven't good for you, but most people need advice.
Lead
Adequate
103b0c970e12
80889A79B329
It is better to hear a couple different people so you get more information than what you would get from one side.
Position
Adequate
adb3438c57fb
80889A79B329
Have you ever had a tough decision to make? Wouldn't it be better to hear both sides of the story rather than just one?
Evidence
Adequate
3d001958f205
80889A79B329
you may be getting bias information if you only take advice from one person
Claim
Adequate
ec6129142351
80889A79B329
It is better to get information from multiple people so you get a better understanding of what you are learning about.
Evidence
Adequate
0ff0c2282a9a
80889A79B329
It's just like teamwork, for example it takes more than one person to play a game of basketball or football.
Evidence
Adequate
b851546594ed
80889A79B329
The more people work together the more education people will get
Claim
Adequate
1950f537095f
80889A79B329
People who hear only one side of the story will have the same information but it is more likely to be bias since it is from only one side. For example I watched a movie the other day and it was about these kids who had to work together to get anything done, and if the didn't work together they got no work done.
Evidence
Adequate
d19e71a42ec8
80889A79B329
Everyone needs assistance every now and then. Like when you fall and someone helps you up, they are assisting you. One time I was on a board at my house and I fell off and broke my leg, but my friend was there and he carried me to the house. He assisted me by helping me to the house.
Evidence
Ineffective
b1c5d908c6e1
80889A79B329
everyone needs advice at some point in your life. You can get it from anyone including your parents, but the more people you talk to, the more information you will receive. You can always talk to people like you parents, teachers, or even the guidance councilors at your school. No matter who you ask it will be less likely to be bias as long as you ask multiple people.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
262fdb0c1bbb
81EB648B5B51
Distance learning can occur through various means and technologies, but the main purpose is the same across the board. The central focus of distance learning is to allow students to learn even when they cannot be physically present at school. Distance learning has been used before for both long and short periods of time including snow storms, illness, or a mental issue.
Lead
Adequate
f96169b43234
81EB648B5B51
Although the intentions behind distance learning have just reasoning the widespread implementation of this type of learning would have detrimental effects on students across the country.
Position
Adequate
f38c43463ab8
81EB648B5B51
Distance learning takes students away from other students their age which not only isolates them, but also hinders their communication and collaboration skills
Claim
Adequate
a8faa8218a5f
81EB648B5B51
Many times throughout a school year students are given projects to work on as a group which not only allows for the students to meet new people in their age group, but also allows for them to develop communication skills. These projects typically have some sort of reflection at the end so that the students are able to discuss who in the group put in the most effort which encourages all of the students in the group to try their hardest and collaborate with each other. Part of this collaboration involves working around each others schedules and sacrificing time to check over each others work. Sadly, the skills learned from these projects cannot be learned when utilizing distance learning. Not only are the students unable to meet up in person to discuss their project, but online schools typically shy away from giving group projects due to the difficulty to work around other students schedules. Thus, distance learners are taught to be independent when completing work which can only serve to hinder them when they enter the job force.
Evidence
Effective
3507bdc04dd5
81EB648B5B51
Many classes, especially science, complete various different types of labs throughout their course.
Claim
Effective
a8373f910483
81EB648B5B51
These can include labs with chemicals, animals, or even virtual labs. The ability to complete these labs not only allows for students to better understand the topic that they are being taught, but also allows for the students to have hands on experience in a safe setting. Unsurprisingly, the same is not true of distance learners. Due to lack of materials, teacher guidance, safety equipment, and a safe area to complete labs distance learners are unable to get the same hands on experience as those physically going to school. This absence of labs hinders the learning ability of the students and retention of the information they are being taught.
Evidence
Effective
95feeb9dd6da
81EB648B5B51
However, in extremely serious situations distance learning is able to be beneficiary for students.
Counterclaim
Effective